betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Spectroscopic parameters of BcB_c meson

Abstract

We study the spectroscopy and decays of the BcB_c meson in a nonrelativistic quark model in which all observables follow from a single set of wave functions, with spin-dependent effects included directly in the bound-state equation. With parameters calibrated to the measured Bc(1S)B_c(1S) and Bc(2S)B_c(2S) masses, we predict the SS-, PP-, and DD-wave spectrum up to n=5n=5, the pseudoscalar and vector decay constants with one-loop QCD corrections, the E1 and M1 radiative widths, and the radial Regge trajectories of ten spin-parity families. The 1P1P multiplet is predicted at 6692–6746~MeV with the normal fine-structure ordering, compatible with lattice QCD and located in the region of the two structures observed by LHCb in the Bc+γB_c^+γ spectrum. The 1D1D states lie near 7008~MeV, below the BDBD threshold, and all four DD-wave families are provided. The decay constant fBc=507.1f_{B_c}=507.1~MeV is consistent with recent QCD sum-rule results and corresponds to B(Bc→τντ)≈3%\mathcal{B}(B_c\toτν_τ)\approx3\%. The E1 widths follow the expected angular weights, while their magnitudes are governed mainly by the radial overlap. The 1P→1S1P\to1S (81–112~keV) and 1D→1P1D\to1P (71–93~keV) widths suggest the 1D→1P→1S1D\to1P\to1S cascade as a promising route toward the first DD-wave BcB_c state. The Regge trajectories are nearly linear, with slopes decreasing from about 5.8~GeV2^2 for the SS-wave to 4.7–4.8~GeV2^2 for the DD-wave states. These results may guide forthcoming measurements at the LHC and future e+e−e^+e^- facilities.

Introduction

The BcB_c meson family, built from a charm quark and a bottom antiquark (cbˉc\bar{b}), is the only meson system made of two heavy quarks of different flavor. Its states cannot annihilate into gluons or photons, and the levels below the open-flavor B(∗)D(∗)B^{(*)}D^{(*)} threshold are not expected to decay strongly. They reach the pseudoscalar ground state mainly through radiative and hadronic transitions, while the ground state itself decays weakly, so the excited levels are likely to be narrow, with comparatively clean decay chains. The unequal constituent masses bring further features that are absent in quarkonium. Charge-conjugation symmetry is lost. As a result, the 1P1{}^{1}P_{1} and 3P1{}^{3}P_{1} states, and likewise the 1D2{}^{1}D_{2} and 3D2{}^{3}D_{2} states, may mix into the physical JP=1+J^P = 1^+ and 2−2^- states, and the effective charge and magnetic moment entering the E1 and M1 transitions are modified. In addition, the leptonic decay constant fBcf_{B_c} governs the rate of Bc→τντB_c \to\tau\nu_\tau. Together with the measured lifetime, this channel constrains new-physics interpretations of the b→cτνb \to c\tau\nu anomalies [1, 2], and the BcB_c decay constants also enter the unitarity bounds on b→cb \to c form factors [3]. The BcB_c system thus offers heavy-quark dynamics in a regime complementary to the ccˉc\bar{c} and bbˉb\bar{b} spectra, with a direct link to flavor physics.

CDF first observed the ground state in ppˉp\bar{p} collisions at s=1.8\sqrt{s} = 1.8 TeV [4], close to potential-model expectations [5, 6], and its properties have since been measured precisely at the LHC [7, 8]. ATLAS reported a first excited state in the Bc±π+π−B_c^\pm\pi^+\pi^- spectrum consistent with the 2S2S level [9], and CMS and LHCb later resolved the Bc+(2S)B_c^+(2S) and Bc∗+(2S)B_c^{*+}(2S) signals [10, 11]. ATLAS has since observed the Bc∗+B_c^{*+} directly in Bc∗+→Bc+γB_c^{*+} \to B_c^+\gamma, with M(Bc∗+)−M(Bc+)=64.5±1.4 (stat)−1.4+1.0 (syst)M(B_c^{*+}) - M(B_c^+) = 64.5 \pm1.4\ {\rm(stat)}^{+1.0}_{-1.4}\ {\rm(syst)} MeV [12]. In the orbital sector, LHCb has observed two peaks in the Bc+γB_c^+\gamma spectrum at 6704.8 ±\pm 5.5 ±\pm 2.8 and 6752.4 ±\pm 9.5 ±\pm 3.1 MeV [13], whose spin-parity assignments are not yet established. To our knowledge, no radiative width of an excited BcB_c state has been measured, and no DD-wave state has been reported. The high-luminosity LHC and proposed e+e−e^+e^- facilities such as FCC-ee [14] and CEPC [15] are expected to provide much larger samples, and purely leptonic BcB_c decays may become measurable at LHCb and FCC-ee [3]. Predictions that address the spectrum together with its decay observables, including the unexplored DD-wave sector, may therefore be of use to forthcoming analyses.

The BcB_c system has been studied in quark models [5, 6, 16–27], light-front approaches [28, 29], lattice QCD [30–35], QCD sum rules (QCDSR) [3, 36–46], perturbative and nonrelativistic QCD [49, 50, 51, 52, 53, 54, 55, 56] [47, 48], and other approaches [57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62]. Cornell-type potentials with Breit–Fermi spin-dependent interactions have also been applied recently to BB mesons and bqˉqqˉb\bar{q}q\bar{q} tetraquarks [63]. The low-lying masses appear broadly consistent across these approaches, presumably because they are anchored to the measured levels, whereas the decay observables show a larger spread. Predictions for fBcf_{B_c} range from about 383 to 564 MeV [64] [40]. Lattice QCD gives fBc=427(6)f_{B_c} = 427(6) MeV [34] and fBc∗/fBc=0.988(27)f_{B_c^*}/f_{B_c} = 0.988(27) [35], and a recent QCDSR analysis finds fBc=499±71f_{B_c} = 499 \pm71 MeV and fBc∗=480±49f_{B_c^*} = 480 \pm49 MeV [3]. The E1 width Γ(1 3P0→1 3S1)\Gamma(1\,{}^{3}P_{0} \to1\,{}^{3}S_{1}) varies between about 52 and 96 keV [65, 66, 67] [26]. Decay constants depend on the wave function at the origin, and radiative widths on the overlap of the initial- and final-state wave functions. Both are sensitive to the short-distance interaction, the spin-dependent forces, relativistic corrections, and the quark masses, and in radiative transitions a 10–20 MeV shift of an intermediate multiplet is further amplified by the Eγ3E_{\gamma}^{3} factor, particularly when the photon energy is small. Decay observables therefore probe the wave functions in ways that the mass spectrum alone does not. Masses and decay observables are therefore best compared when they are obtained from the same wave functions, which is not the case when the spin-dependent interactions are treated as first-order perturbations.

In this work we study the BcB_c spectrum and its leptonic and radiative decays in a nonrelativistic potential model with the Cornell interaction and the Breit–Fermi spin–spin and spin–orbit interactions, both included nonperturbatively in the radial Schrödinger equation. Each state thus has its own radial wave function, which is used for all observables. The parameters are taken from Ref. [68], where they were fixed by a fit to the measured Bc(1S)B_c(1S) and Bc(2S)B_c(2S) masses, and are applied without readjustment, so the orbitally excited levels and the decay observables are predictions. We present (i) the SS-, PP-, and DD-wave spectrum up to n=5n=5, including the 3D1{}^{3}D_{1}, 3D2{}^{3}D_{2}, 1D2{}^{1}D_{2}, and 3D3{}^{3}D_{3} levels in the LSLS basis; (ii) the pseudoscalar and vector decay constants with one-loop QCD corrections and B(Bc→τντ)\mathcal{B}(B_c\to\tau\nu_{\tau}); (iii) E1 and M1 widths with overlap integrals evaluated at finite photon momentum and the relativistic recoil factor retained; and (iv) radial Regge trajectories in the (n,M2)(n,M^{2}) plane for ten spin-parity families.

The model reproduces the Bc(1S)B_c(1S) and Bc(2S)B_c(2S) masses, with a 2S2S–1S1S excitation energy of 600 MeV close to the measured value of about 597 MeV. The predicted 1P1P multiplet lies at 6692–6746 MeV with the normal fine-structure ordering, and the 1D1D multiplet lies near 7008 MeV, below the BDBD threshold. We also state the limitations of the framework explicitly. Tensor forces and coupled-channel effects are not included, so the fine-structure splittings are approximate and levels above the BDBD threshold should be read as bare quark-model states. Moreover, the adopted parameters yield SS-wave singlet–triplet splittings of only 1–2 MeV, well below the ATLAS value. We regard this measurement as an important input for constraining the spin–spin interaction and indicate in the following sections which results depend on it.

Section II describes the theoretical framework, Section III presents and discusses the results, and Section IV summarizes our conclusions.

Theoretical Framework

Potential Model

The BcB_c meson is composed of two heavy quarks, which makes a nonrelativistic potential-model treatment a suitable starting point for its description. The cbcb system is described by a nonrelativistic Hamiltonian in the center-of-mass frame [5, 24, 26],

H=M0+p22μ+Veff(r),(1)H=M_0+\frac{\mathbf{p}^{2}}{2\mu}+V_{\mathrm{eff}}(r), \tag*{(1)}

where M0=mb+mcM_0=m_b+m_c is the quark–antiquark rest-mass sum and μ=mbmc/(mb+mc)\mu=m_bm_c/(m_b+m_c) is the reduced mass. The meson mass is MBc=M0+EnℓM_{B_c}=M_0+E_{n\ell}, where EnℓE_{n\ell} is the eigenvalue of H−M0H-M_0. The effective potential is decomposed as

Veff(r)=V(r)+VSS(r)+VLS(r),(2)V_{\mathrm{eff}}(r)=V(r)+V_{SS}(r)+V_{LS}(r), \tag*{(2)}

where V(r)V(r) is the Cornell interaction, VSS(r)V_{SS}(r) the spin–spin hyperfine interaction, and VLS(r)V_{LS}(r) the spin–orbit fine-structure interaction.

The Cornell potential combines the two dominant regimes of the quark–antiquark interaction [69, 70]:

V(r)=−καsr+br,(3)V(r)=-\frac{\kappa\alpha_s}{r}+br, \tag*{(3)}

where κ=CF=4/3\kappa=C_F=4/3 is the color factor of a quark–antiquark pair in the color-singlet channel, ⟨T1⋅T2⟩singlet=−CF\langle T_1\cdot T_2\rangle_{\mathrm{singlet}}=-C_F, αs\alpha_s is the strong coupling constant and bb is the string tension. At short distances the Coulomb-like term reflects OGE, while at large distances the linear term embodies color confinement. The string tension b=0.184 GeV2b=0.184\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2} of Table I is consistent with lattice determinations of the string tension (b≈0.18b\approx0.18–0.20 GeV20.20\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2}) [71].

All three potential contributions are treated nonperturbatively by direct inclusion in Veff(r)V_{\mathrm{eff}}(r). For VSS(r)V_{SS}(r), a perturbative treatment would force spin-singlet and spin-triplet states to share the same unperturbed wave function [16, 19]. Nonperturbative inclusion allows singlet and triplet states to acquire distinct radial wave functions, so that any difference between them is carried consistently into the decay constants and radiative widths rather than being excluded by construction. For VLS(r)V_{LS}(r), direct inclusion in the Schrödinger equation ensures that fine-structure splittings within each LL-multiplet are generated self-consistently from the same wave functions used for all other observables [72] [26].

The spin–spin (hyperfine) interaction follows from the contact term of the Breit–Fermi Hamiltonian. Using ∇2(1/r)=−4πδ(3)(r)\nabla^{2}(1/r)=-4\pi\delta^{(3)}(r) for the vector OGE part VV(r)=−καs/rV_{V}(r)=-\kappa\alpha_{s}/r of the Cornell potential [73] [5],

VSS(r)=23mcmb∇2VV(r)⟨S1⋅S2⟩=8πκαs3mcmbδ(3)(r)⟨S1⋅S2⟩.(4)V_{SS}(r)=\frac{2}{3m_{c}m_{b}}\nabla^{2}V_{V}(r)\langle\mathbf{S}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{S}_{2}\rangle=\frac{8\pi\kappa\alpha_{s}}{3m_{c}m_{b}}\delta^{(3)}(r)\langle\mathbf{S}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{S}_{2}\rangle. \tag*{(4)}

Since a contact interaction cannot be used directly in the Schrödinger equation, the delta function is replaced by a normalized Gaussian of range 1/σ1/\sigma [72] [24],

VSS(r)=8πκαs3mcmb(σπ)3e−σ2r2⟨S1⋅S2⟩,(5)V_{SS}(r)=\frac{8\pi\kappa\alpha_{s}}{3m_{c}m_{b}}\left(\frac{\sigma}{\sqrt{\pi}}\right)^{3}e^{-\sigma^{2}r^{2}}\langle\mathbf{S}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{S}_{2}\rangle, \tag*{(5)}

which reduces to Eq. (4) for σ→∞\sigma\to\infty. The spin expectation value is

⟨S1⋅S2⟩=12[S(S+1)−S1(S1+1)−S2(S2+1)]={+14,S=1,−34,S=0,(6)\langle\mathbf{S}_{1}\cdot\mathbf{S}_{2}\rangle=\frac{1}{2}\left[S(S+1)-S_{1}(S_{1}+1)-S_{2}(S_{2}+1)\right]=\begin{cases}+\frac{1}{4},&S=1,\\-\frac{3}{4},&S=0,\end{cases} \tag*{(6)}

so that VSSV_{SS} raises the spin-triplet and lowers the spin-singlet levels. The parameter σ\sigma sets both the strength and the range of the hyperfine interaction and thus controls the size of the singlet–triplet splittings.

For states with L≥1L\geq1, the spin–orbit interaction lifts the degeneracy within each LL-multiplet. For a Lorentz-vector OGE interaction VV(r)=−καs/rV_{V}(r)=-\kappa\alpha_{s}/r and a Lorentz-scalar confining interaction VS(r)=brV_{S}(r)=br, the nonrelativistic reduction of the Breit–Fermi Hamiltonian for unequal quark masses gives [73] [5, 16]

VLS(r)=CLS(r)⟨L⋅S⟩,(7)V_{LS}(r)=C_{LS}(r)\langle\mathbf{L}\cdot\mathbf{S}\rangle, \tag*{(7)}

with

CLS(r)=καs4r3(1mc2+1mb2+4mcmb)−b4r(1mc2+1mb2).(8)C_{LS}(r)=\frac{\kappa\alpha_{s}}{4r^{3}}\left(\frac{1}{m_{c}^{2}}+\frac{1}{m_{b}^{2}}+\frac{4}{m_{c}m_{b}}\right)-\frac{b}{4r}\left(\frac{1}{m_{c}^{2}}+\frac{1}{m_{b}^{2}}\right). \tag*{(8)}

In the equal-mass limit mc=mb=mm_{c}=m_{b}=m this reduces to CLS(r)=1m2(2καsr3−b2r)C_{LS}(r)=\frac{1}{m^{2}}\left(\frac{2\kappa\alpha_{s}}{r^{3}}-\frac{b}{2r}\right), the form used for charmonium in Refs. [72, 74]. The first (OGE) term is positive and favors the normal ordering M(3LJ=L+1)>M(3LJ=L−1)M({}^{3}L_{J=L+1})>M({}^{3}L_{J=L-1}), whereas the second term, arising from Thomas precession in the scalar confining potential, enters with the opposite sign and partially cancels it. The two contributions balance at

r∗=[καsb(mc−2+mb−2+4(mcmb)−1)mc−2+mb−2]1/2.(9)r^{*}=\left[\frac{\dfrac{\kappa\alpha_{s}}{b}\left(m_{c}^{-2}+m_{b}^{-2}+4(m_{c}m_{b})^{-1}\right)}{m_{c}^{-2}+m_{b}^{-2}}\right]^{1/2}. \tag*{(9)}

The tensor interaction is not included in the present analysis. It vanishes for SS-wave states and does not shift the spin-weighted centroid of an L≥1L\geq1 multiplet, but it is of the same order in 1/mq21/m_{q}^{2} as the spin–orbit term and contributes to the splittings within the 3PJ{}^{3}P_{J} and 3DJ{}^{3}D_{J} multiplets. The fine-structure splittings reported below should therefore be regarded as approximate.

Writing Ψnℓm(r)=r−1ϕnℓ(r)Yℓm(r^)\Psi_{n\ell m}(r)=r^{-1}\phi_{n\ell}(r)Y_{\ell}^{m}(\hat{r}), the Schrödinger equation reduces to the radial eigenvalue problem

[−12μd2dr2+ℓ(ℓ+1)2μr2+Veff(r)]ϕnℓ(r)=Enℓϕnℓ(r),(10)\left[-\frac{1}{2\mu}\frac{d^{2}}{dr^{2}}+\frac{\ell(\ell+1)}{2\mu r^{2}}+V_{\mathrm{eff}}(r)\right]\phi_{n\ell}(r)=E_{n\ell}\phi_{n\ell}(r), \tag*{(10)}

solved numerically using the Numerov algorithm on a uniform radial grid, subject to the regularity condition ϕnℓ(0)=0\phi_{n\ell}(0)=0 at the origin and ϕnℓ(r0)=0\phi_{n\ell}(r_{0})=0 at an outer cutoff r0r_{0} chosen large enough that the bound-state wave function is negligible at the boundary. The eigenvalues are stable to within 0.10.1 MeV for r0≳30r_{0}\gtrsim30 GeV−1^{-1}. The eigenvalue EnℓE_{n\ell} thus incorporates the Cornell interaction together with the spin–spin and spin–orbit splittings, and the meson mass follows from MBc=mb+mc+EnℓM_{B_{c}}=m_{b}+m_{c}+E_{n\ell} as defined below Eq. (1).

Decay Constants

The leptonic decay constants of the pseudoscalar (BcB_{c}) and vector (Bc∗B_{c}^{*}) states are defined through the hadronic matrix elements

⟨0∣bˉγμγ5c∣P(k)⟩=ifPkμ,(11)\langle0|\bar{b}\gamma^{\mu}\gamma_{5}c|P(k)\rangle=if_{P}k^{\mu}, \tag*{(11)}
⟨0∣bˉγμc∣V(k,ε)⟩=fVMVεμ,(12)\langle0|\bar{b}\gamma^{\mu}c|V(k,\varepsilon)\rangle=f_{V}M_{V}\varepsilon^{\mu}, \tag*{(12)}

where fPf_P (fVf_V) is the pseudoscalar (vector) decay constant, and kμk^\mu, ϵμ\epsilon^\mu, MVM_V have their standard meanings. These constants govern the weak annihilation amplitudes and enter the leptonic widths Γ(Bc+→ℓ+νℓ)∝fBc2∣Vcb∣2mℓ2MBc\Gamma(B_c^+ \to\ell^+\nu_\ell) \propto f_{B_c}^2 |V_{cb}|^2 m_\ell^2 M_{B_c} and Γ(Bc∗+→ℓ+νℓ)∝fBc∗2∣Vcb∣2MBc∗3\Gamma(B_c^{*+} \to\ell^+\nu_\ell) \propto f_{B_c^*}^2 |V_{cb}|^2 M_{B_c^*}^3.

In the nonrelativistic limit, fP/Vf_{P/V} is evaluated via the Van Royen–Weisskopf formula supplemented by the one-loop QCD radiative correction [75, 76, 77] [24, 26]:

fP/V2=3∣RnS(0)∣2πMnSCˉ2(αs),(13)f_{P/V}^{2} = \frac{3\lvert R_{nS}(0)\rvert^{2}}{\pi M_{nS}} \bar{C}^{2}(\alpha_s), \tag*{(13)}

where RnS(0)=lim⁡r→0ϕnS(r)/rR_{nS}(0) = \lim_{r \to0} \phi_{nS}(r)/r is the radial wave function at the origin and MnSM_{nS} the meson mass. Since Rnℓ(0)=0R_{n\ell}(0) = 0 for ℓ≥1\ell\ge1, this formula applies only to SS-wave states. The dependence on ∣RnS(0)∣2\lvert R_{nS}(0)\rvert^2 reflects the fact that decay constants probe the wave function at zero separation, a purely short-distance quantity controlled by the Coulombic region of the interaction; they are consequently more sensitive to αs\alpha_s and the constituent quark masses than to the string tension bb that dominates the mass eigenvalues.

The one-loop QCD correction factor Cˉ(αs)\bar{C}(\alpha_s) is [76, 77] [24]:

Cˉ(αs)=1−αsπ[δ(P,V)−mb−mcmb+mcln⁡(mbmc)],(14)\bar{C}(\alpha_s) = 1 - \frac{\alpha_s}{\pi}\left[\delta^{(P,V)} - \frac{m_b-m_c}{m_b+m_c}\ln\left(\frac{m_b}{m_c}\right)\right], \tag*{(14)}

with δ(P)=2\delta^{(P)} = 2 for pseudoscalar and δ(V)=8/3\delta^{(V)} = 8/3 for vector states [76]. The logarithmic term mb−mcmb+mcln⁡(mb/mc)\frac{m_b-m_c}{m_b+m_c}\ln(m_b/m_c) is specific to the unequal-mass BcB_c system (it vanishes identically for ccˉc\bar{c} and bbˉb\bar{b}) and arises from the one-loop vertex correction with unequal quark masses; it reduces the effective radiative correction relative to a symmetric quarkonium system. Because δ(V)>δ(P)\delta^{(V)} > \delta^{(P)}, the radiative correction suppresses the vector decay constant more strongly than the pseudoscalar, so that at one-loop order it reduces the ratio fBc∗/fBcf_{B_c^*}/f_{B_c} below unity.

Radiative Transitions

Electromagnetic transitions between BcB_c states are computed at leading order in the multipole expansion as electric-dipole (E1) and magnetic-dipole (M1) transitions, subject to the selection rules

E1:ΔS=0,ΔL=±1,(15)\mathrm{E1:}\quad\Delta S = 0,\qquad\Delta L = \pm1, \tag*{(15)}
M1:ΔS=±1,ΔL=0.(16)\mathrm{M1:}\quad\Delta S = \pm1,\qquad\Delta L = 0. \tag*{(16)}

Higher-order multipole contributions (E2, M2, etc.) are suppressed by additional powers of EγrE_\gamma r and are neglected throughout.

E1 transitions

The partial width for ni2S+1LJi→γ+nf2S+1LJfn_i^{2S+1}L_{J_i} \to\gamma+ n_f^{2S+1}L_{J_f} is [24, 26]

ΓE1=4α⟨eQ⟩23Eγ3EfMiCfi∣ϵfi∣2,(17)\Gamma_{\mathrm{E1}} = \frac{4\alpha\langle e_Q\rangle^2}{3} E_\gamma^3 \frac{E_f}{M_i} C_{fi} \lvert\epsilon_{fi}\rvert^2, \tag*{(17)}

where α\alpha is the fine-structure constant, Eγ=(Mi2−Mf2)/(2Mi)E_\gamma= (M_i^2-M_f^2)/(2M_i) the photon energy, Ef/MiE_f/M_i the relativistic recoil factor, CfiC_{fi} the angular statistical factor, and ϵfi\epsilon_{fi} the radial overlap integral. The spin-conservation constraint ΔS=0\Delta S = 0 is enforced by the choice of initial and final states. The effective charge, weighted by the reduced-mass kinematics of the unequal-mass cbˉc\bar{b} system [16, 19], is

⟨eQ⟩=mbec+mcebmb+mc,(18)\langle e_Q\rangle= \frac{m_b e_c + m_c e_b}{m_b + m_c}, \tag*{(18)}

with eb=−1/3e_b = -1/3 and ec=+2/3e_c = +2/3; numerically ⟨eQ⟩≈0.416\langle e_Q\rangle\approx0.416 for the present parameter set. The angular factor is

Cfi=max⁡(Li,Lf)(2Jf+1){LfJfSJiLi1}2.(19)C_{fi} = \max(L_i,L_f)(2J_f+1) \begin{Bmatrix} L_f & J_f & S \\ J_i & L_i & 1 \end{Bmatrix}^{2}. \tag*{(19)}

The radial overlap integral is evaluated retaining the full recoil-corrected structure rather than truncating at the long-wavelength limit. For the photon energies encountered in the BcB_c spectrum (Eγ∼100E_\gamma\sim100–10001000 MeV) and a typical meson size ⟨r⟩∼0.3\langle r\rangle\sim0.3–0.50.5 fm, the product EγrE_\gamma r is not small, so the standard long-wavelength approximation ϵfi≈⟨r⟩\epsilon_{fi} \approx\langle r\rangle is not justified. The full expression is [24, 26]

ϵfi=3Eγ∫0∞dr ϕniLi(r)ϕnfLf(r)[Eγr2j0(Eγr2)−j1(Eγr2)],(20)\epsilon_{fi} = \frac{3}{E_\gamma} \int_0^\infty dr\, \phi_{n_iL_i}(r)\phi_{n_fL_f}(r) \left[\frac{E_\gamma r}{2}j_0\left(\frac{E_\gamma r}{2}\right)-j_1\left(\frac{E_\gamma r}{2}\right)\right], \tag*{(20)}

with j0(x)=sin⁡(x)/xj_0(x)=\sin(x)/x and j1(x)=sin⁡(x)/x2−cos⁡(x)/xj_1(x)=\sin(x)/x^2-\cos(x)/x. In the limit Eγr→0E_\gamma r \to0 one recovers the long-wavelength result ϵfi→∫0∞dr ϕniLi(r)rϕnfLf(r)\epsilon_{fi}\to\int_0^\infty dr\,\phi_{n_iL_i}(r)r\phi_{n_fL_f}(r).

M1 transitions

The M1 partial width for ni2Si+1LJi→γ+nf2Sf+1LJfn_i^{2S_i+1}L_{J_i}\to\gamma+n_f^{2S_f+1}L_{J_f} is [24, 26]

ΓM1=4αμq232Jf+12L+1Eγ3EfMi∣mfi∣2,(21)\Gamma_{\mathrm{M1}}=\frac{4\alpha\mu_q^2}{3}\frac{2J_f+1}{2L+1}E_\gamma^3\frac{E_f}{M_i}|m_{fi}|^2, \tag*{(21)}

where L=Li=LfL=L_i=L_f (enforced by the M1 selection rule ΔL=0\Delta L=0). The effective magnetic dipole moment is [16, 19, 24, 26]

μq=mbec+mceb2mbmc,(22)\mu_q=\frac{m_b e_c+m_c e_b}{2m_bm_c}, \tag*{(22)}

and the M1 radial overlap integral is

mfi=∫0∞dr ϕnfL(r)ϕniL(r)j0(Eγr2).(23)m_{fi}=\int_0^\infty dr\,\phi_{n_fL}(r)\phi_{n_iL}(r)j_0\left(\frac{E_\gamma r}{2}\right). \tag*{(23)}

For allowed transitions (ni=nfn_i=n_f), mfim_{fi} is nearly maximal in the Eγ→0E_\gamma\to0 limit and the width is controlled almost entirely by Eγ3E_\gamma^3. For hindered transitions (ni≠nfn_i\ne n_f), singlet and triplet states with different radial quantum numbers would be orthogonal in the limit VSS=0V_{SS}=0 and Eγ→0E_\gamma\to0; both the Gaussian hyperfine interaction, which distorts singlet and triplet wave functions differently, and the finite photon momentum entering through j0(Eγr/2)j_0(E_\gamma r/2) break this orthogonality. The relative weight of these two effects depends on the strength of the hyperfine interaction and is discussed in Sec. III C.

Regge Trajectories

Linear confinement leads to radial level spacings that are approximately uniform in M2M^2, although for heavy quarks the Coulombic interaction produces deviations at low nn. Successive excitations within a given spin-parity family therefore trace nearly linear trajectories in the (n,M2)(n,M^2) plane. The trajectory is parametrized as

M2=β0+βn,(24)M^2=\beta_0+\beta n, \tag*{(24)}

where n=1,2,3,4,5n=1,2,3,4,5 is the radial quantum number (n=1n=1 for the ground state), β\beta is the slope in GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^2, and β0\beta_0 the intercept [22, 24, 26]. Separate trajectories are constructed for the n1S0n^1S_0 and n3S1n^3S_1 families, for n1P1n^1P_1, n3P0n^3P_0, n3P1n^3P_1, and n3P2n^3P_2, and for n1D2n^1D_2, n3D1n^3D_1, n3D2n^3D_2, and n3D3n^3D_3. For each family, the squared masses from the numerical solution of Eq. (10) are fitted by linear least squares to extract β\beta, β0\beta_0, and the coefficient of determination R2R^2. The fitted parameters provide a compact characterization of the radial spectrum and a basis for comparison with other approaches.

Results and Discussion

Mass Spectrum

The masses of the SS-, PP-, and DD-wave states are listed in Tables II–Table IV, together with the experimental data and results from quark models, lattice QCD, the Bethe–Salpeter approach, and QCDSR. The parameters of Table I were determined in Ref. [68] from a fit to the measured Bc(1S)B_c(1S) and Bc(2S)B_c(2S) masses. These two levels therefore check the calibration, and all other states are predictions. Our 1S1S and 2S2S masses differ by about 11 MeV from those of Ref. [68] because of differences in the numerical implementation. Levels above the BDBD threshold (≃7144\simeq7144 MeV) are bare quark-model states.

n2S+1LJn^{2S+1}L_JThis Work[65][66][26][78][67][22][24][61]
13D11^{3}D_170087038.37037702070236841702169987014
23D12^{3}D_173717361.87357733673277080739274037335
33D13^{3}D_176917625.7761976117573728977327762—
43D14^{3}D_179817849.37842——7478—8091—
53D15^{3}D_182518043.3———————
13D21^{3}D_27009————————
23D22^{3}D_27373————————
33D23^{3}D_27694————————
43D24^{3}D_27985————————
53D25^{3}D_28256————————
11D21^{1}D_270087053.07046703270396845702669947025
21D22^{1}D_273747375.9736573477340708474007401—
31D23^{1}D_276957639.2762776237584729377437762—
41D24^{1}D_279877862.17849——7482—8093—
51D25^{1}D_282588055.4———————
13D31^{3}D_370097041.47042703070426847702969907035
23D32^{3}D_373767371.4736473487344708774057399—
33D33^{3}D_376987638.8762776257589729677507761—
43D34^{3}D_379917864.47850——7489—8092—
53D35^{3}D_382628059.4———————

Table IV. DD-wave mass spectrum of the BcB_c meson (MeV).

mbm_b (GeV)mcm_c (GeV)αs\alpha_sbb (GeV2^2)σ\sigma (GeV)
4.6051.5370.42680.18400.2614

Table 1. Quark-model parameters adopted in the present work, taken from Ref. [68].

S-wave

The ground-state mass M(11S0)=6270M(1^{1}S_0)=6270 MeV lies about 4 MeV below the PDG value [8] and is compatible with the lattice QCD result 6276 ±\pm 7 MeV [33]. The 21S02^{1}S_0 mass of 6870 MeV agrees with the CMS and LHCb measurements [10, 11] within about 1 MeV. The resulting 2S2S–1S1S excitation energy of 600 MeV, close to the measured value of about 597 MeV, is governed mainly by the Coulombic and linear terms of the Cornell potential. Most approaches in Table II describe the 21S02^{1}S_0 level comparably, whereas Ref. [67] yields an excitation energy of about 423 MeV.

For n≥3n \ge3 our masses lie above most other predictions, by about 20–60 MeV at n=3n=3 and by up to about 200 MeV at n=5n=5. The results of Ref. [22] approach ours with increasing nn and coincide within 1 MeV for the 51S05^{1}S_0 state. This spread reflects the different treatments of confinement, to which highly excited levels are most sensitive.

The singlet–triplet splittings ΔM(nS)=M(n3S1)−M(n1S0)\Delta M(nS)=M(n^{3}S_1)-M(n^{1}S_0) are only 1–2 MeV, well below the 64.5 MeV measured by ATLAS [12]. This reflects the small hyperfine strength implied by σ\sigma, which was not constrained by spin-triplet data. Combined with the PDG BcB_c mass, the ATLAS result gives M(Bc∗)≃6339M(B_c^*) \simeq6339 MeV, close to the lattice QCD value 6331 ±\pm 7 MeV [33] and to the upper end of the 6322–6338 MeV range of most models in Table II, whereas our 13S11^{3}S_1 mass is 6272 MeV. A consistent treatment would require a joint readjustment of σ\sigma and the other parameters, which we leave for future work. The SS-wave triplet masses are therefore the least constrained part of the spectrum.

n2S+1LJn^{2S+1}L_JThis WorkExperiment [8][65][66][26][78][67][22][33][61][40]
11S01^{1}S_062706274.476275.8626962716271631862726276 ±\pm 76277—
21S02^{1}S_068706871.2 ±\pm 1.06869.868866871685567416842—6867—
31S03^{1}S_07280—7252.172617239722070147226—7228—
41S04^{1}S_07622—7545.175517540749672397585———
51S05^{1}S_07927—7785.4779078057722—7928———
13S11^{3}S_162726339 ±\pm 2a^{a}6336.1632263266338633663336331 ±\pm 763326331 ±\pm 47
23S12^{3}S_16871—6905.669076890688667476882—6911—
33S13^{3}S_17280—7278.472757252724070187258—7272—
43S14^{3}S_17623—7565.975617550751272427609———
53S15^{3}S_17928—7802.6779878137735—7947———

Table 2. SS-wave mass spectrum of the BcB_c meson (MeV). a^{a}Obtained from the PDG BcB_c mass [8] and the Bc∗−BcB_c^* - B_c splitting measured by ATLAS [12].

P-wave

The 1P1P multiplet lies at 6692–6746 MeV, in line with relativistic quark models [22], the Salpeter equation [61], QCDSR [40], and modified Godfrey–Isgur schemes [78]. The 13P01^{3}P_0 and 11P11^{1}P_1 masses are compatible within one standard deviation with the lattice QCD results 6712 ±\pm 25 and 6736 ±\pm 24 MeV of Ref. [33].

The normal ordering M(3P0)<M(3P1)<M(3P2)M(^{3}P_0)<M(^{3}P_1)<M(^{3}P_2) holds at every radial excitation. The splittings M(3P1)−M(3P0)≃17M(^{3}P_1)-M(^{3}P_0)\simeq17–18 MeV and M(3P2)−M(3P1)≃33M(^{3}P_2)-M(^{3}P_1)\simeq33–36 MeV follow the 1:21:2 ratio expected from ⟨L⋅S⟩=−2,−1,+1\langle\mathbf{L}\cdot\mathbf{S}\rangle=-2,-1,+1, and each nP1nP_1 mass lies within 2 MeV of the spin-weighted centroid of the n3PJn^{3}P_J triplet. Both relations hold at first order in the spin–orbit interaction when the PP-wave hyperfine term is negligible. Their approximate validity indicates that the higher-order effects of the nonperturbative treatment are small for the PP-wave states.

The total splitting M(13P2)−M(13P0)=54M(1^{3}P_2)-M(1^{3}P_0)=54 MeV lies below the 57–73 MeV range of Refs. [61, 65, 66, 78] [22, 26] and decreases slowly to 50 MeV for the 5P5P states. According to Eq. (9), the crossover radius r∗≈0.5r^* \approx0.5 fm is comparable to the mean interquark separation of the 1P1P states. The OGE and Thomas-precession contributions therefore partially cancel and leave a positive but moderate spin–orbit coupling. At higher radial excitation the wave function extends further into the confining region, where the Thomas-precession term gains weight. The 1P1P fine structure is thus linked to καs/b\kappa\alpha_{s}/b, and a measurement of two or more members of the multiplet would probe this ratio directly.

The two LHCb peaks at 6704.8±5.5±2.86704.8 \pm5.5 \pm2.8 and 6752.4±9.5±3.16752.4 \pm9.5 \pm3.1 MeV [13] lie in the region of the 1P1P multiplet. Only the JP=1+J^{P}=1^{+} states decay directly to BcγB_{c}\gamma, whereas transitions to Bc∗γB_{c}^{*}\gamma appear shifted down by the 1S1S hyperfine splitting, about 64.5 MeV [12], when the soft photon is not reconstructed. If both peaks are attributed to the 1+1^{+} states, the average of our 3P1{}^{3}P_{1} and 1P1{}^{1}P_{1} masses, 6718 MeV, lies within about 11 MeV of the average of the peaks, 6729 MeV. The predicted separation of 16 MeV is smaller than the observed one. Since 1P1{}^{1}P_{1}–3P1{}^{3}P_{1} mixing tends to increase this separation, our LSLS-basis masses may serve as input for mixing analyses, while a definite assignment will likely require spin-parity measurements. The 21P1{}^{2}{}^{1}P_{1} mass agrees with Refs. [61, 65, 66, 78] [22, 24, 26] within about 20 MeV, and up to n=4n=4 the PP-wave levels remain within about 50 MeV of the relativistic results of Ref. [22].

n2S+1LJn^{2S+1}L_{J}This Work[65][66][?][78][67][?][?][?][61][?]
13P0{}^{1}{}^{3}P_{0}66926703.96712671467016631669966866712±256712 \pm256705—
23P0{}^{2}{}^{3}P_{0}71197111.4711871077097691570947146—7112—
33P0{}^{3}{}^{3}P_{0}74727423.2742774207393714774747536—7408—
43P0{}^{4}{}^{3}P_{0}77847678.9768276937633735078177885———
53P0{}^{5}{}^{3}P_{0}80697896.47899————8207———
13P1{}^{1}{}^{3}P_{1}6710—————67506712—6748—
23P1{}^{2}{}^{3}P_{1}7136—————71347173—7149—
33P1{}^{3}{}^{3}P_{1}7489—————75107565—7442—
43P1{}^{4}{}^{3}P_{1}7801—————78537915———
53P1{}^{5}{}^{3}P_{1}8086——————8237———
11P1{}^{1}{}^{1}P_{1}67266751.96761677667546650675067066736±246736 \pm2467396737±566737 \pm56
21P1{}^{2}{}^{1}P_{1}71527157.9715671507133693071477168—7144—
31P1{}^{3}{}^{1}P_{1}75057467.7745874587421716275107559—7440—
41P1{}^{4}{}^{1}P_{1}78177721.4770877277656736478537908———
51P1{}^{5}{}^{1}P_{1}81027936.67921————8230———
13P2{}^{1}{}^{3}P_{2}67466772.6678367876773666567616712—6762—
23P2{}^{2}{}^{3}P_{2}71717178.4717571607148694671577173—7163—
33P2{}^{3}{}^{3}P_{2}75237487.2747674647434717675247565—7456—
43P2{}^{4}{}^{3}P_{2}78347739.6772477327667737978677915———
53P2{}^{5}{}^{3}P_{2}81197953.77936————8237———

Table 3. PP-wave mass spectrum of the BcB_{c} meson (MeV). LHCb has reported two peaks in the Bc+γB_{c}^{+}\gamma spectrum at 6704.8±5.5±2.86704.8 \pm5.5 \pm2.8 and 6752.4±9.5±3.16752.4 \pm9.5 \pm3.1 MeV [13], whose spin-parity assignments are not established (see text).

D-wave

No DD-wave BcB_{c} state has been observed, so the results in Table IV are predictions. The four 1D1D levels lie at 7008–7009 MeV, close to the results of Ref. [24] and within about 45 MeV of most other references. Lying below the BDBD threshold, they are expected to decay mainly through the radiative transitions discussed in Sec. III C.

The near degeneracy of the 1D1D levels suggests that the OGE and Thomas-precession contributions nearly cancel at the separations sampled by the 1D1D wave functions. For n≥2n \ge2 a small normal splitting develops, with M(3D3)−M(3D1)M({}^{3}D_{3})-M({}^{3}D_{1}) between 5 and 11 MeV. Since it results from a near cancellation and the tensor interaction is not included, this splitting should be regarded as approximate. Refs. [61, 65, 66, 78] [22, 26] also find small splittings of 3–21 MeV for the 1D1D multiplet, whereas Ref. [24] obtains an inverted ordering. The DD-wave fine structure thus appears to be a sensitive probe of the balance between the vector and scalar components of the interaction.

We provide all four 3D1{}^{3}D_{1}, 3D2{}^{3}D_{2}, 1D2{}^{1}D_{2}, and 3D3{}^{3}D_{3} levels for n=1n=1–5. The 3D2{}^{3}D_{2} levels are absent from the comparison references of Table IV, and the separate LSLS-basis 1D2{}^{1}D_{2} and 3D2{}^{3}D_{2} masses provide input for the physical JP=2−J^{P}=2^{-} states that arise from their mixing.

Decay Constants

Table V lists the decay constants obtained from Eq. (13). The ground-state value fBc=507.1f_{B_c}=507.1 MeV lies within the 433–564 MeV range of the model calculations [64, 65, 79, 80, 81] [24]. It is consistent, within uncertainties, with the estimate 460 ±\pm 60 MeV of Ref. [77] and with the value 499 ±\pm 71 MeV of a recent QCDSR analysis [3]. The lattice QCD result fBc=427(6)f_{B_c}=427(6) MeV [34] is about 16% lower. Many potential-model results based on the Van Royen–Weisskopf relation show a similar excess, likely related to the sensitivity of ∣RnS(0)∣2\lvert R_{nS}(0)\rvert^2 to the short-distance interaction and to sizable higher-order QCD corrections [49, 51, 55, 56]. With τBc=0.510\tau_{B_c}=0.510 ps and ∣Vcb∣=0.041\lvert V_{cb}\rvert=0.041, our value gives B(Bc→τντ)≈3%\mathcal{B}(B_c\to\tau\nu_\tau)\approx3\%.

n2S+1LJn^{2S+1}L_JThis Work[65][79][64][80][24][81][77][40]
11S01^{1}S_0507.1530.3439564.1484.4433.0465460±60460 \pm60383±27383 \pm27
21S02^{1}S_0363.1434282451.6347.2355.5361——
31S03^{1}S_0319.7388.7237410.9306.4325.7319——
41S04^{1}S_0295.9358.7—386.2284.0307.5293——
51S05^{1}S_0279.8335.5—368.7268.8294.4275——
13S11^{3}S_1449.5513.4417531.9404.9434.6435460±60460 \pm60384±32384 \pm32
23S12^{3}S_1321.8421.1297424.5303.8356.4337——
33S13^{3}S_1283.5377.4257385.5270.3326.4297——
43S14^{3}S_1262.4348.5—362.3251.5308.1273——
53S15^{3}S_1248.1326—345.6238.7295.0256——

Table V. Pseudoscalar fPf_P and vector fVf_V decay constants of the BcB_c meson (MeV).

For the vector state we obtain fBc∗=449.5f_{B_c^*}=449.5 MeV, and the ratio fBc∗/fBc≈0.89f_{B_c^*}/f_{B_c}\approx0.89 is nearly independent of nn. Because the hyperfine interaction is weak in the present parametrization, the singlet and triplet wave functions at the origin almost coincide. The ratio is then fixed mainly by the one-loop factor C‾V/C‾P≃0.887\overline{C}_V/\overline{C}_P\simeq0.887 of Eq. (14). It lies below the HPQCD result 0.988(27) [35] and should be regarded as an estimate of the one-loop effect alone.

The decay constants decrease monotonically with nn, by about 28% from 1S to 2S and by about 5% from 4S to 5S, as the radial wave function spreads away from the origin. All models of Table V that provide excited states show the same trend.

Radiative Transitions

Tables VI–IX list the E1 and M1 widths obtained from Eqs. (17) and (21). The tables include 3P13P_{1}, 3D23D_{2}, and radially excited channels for which comparison values are scarce or unavailable.

E1 transitions
Initial StateFinal StateEγE_{\gamma} (MeV)This Work[65][26][78][67][82][24][19][20][83]
21S02^{1}S_{0}11P11^{1}P_{1}142.223.30812.2156.384.47.1111.5918.6634.406.13.03
23S12^{3}S_{1}13P01^{3}P_{0}177.04.8976.6313.483.02.421.3954.7825.532.90.94
13P11^{3}P_{1}159.510.868—————11.1567.654.71.45
13P21^{3}P_{2}124.48.75310.0526.985.34.312.09216.8237.595.72.28
31S03^{1}S_{0}11P11^{1}P_{1}532.55.9781.5061.743.00.61.39938.755———
21P12^{1}P_{1}126.438.47213.37611.139.013.56—27.988———
33S13^{3}S_{1}13P01^{3}P_{0}565.01.0350.6011.730.040.0943.8776.910———
13P11^{3}P_{1}548.52.493—————17.563———
13P21^{3}P_{2}515.32.5850.9731.582.20.35161.8427.487———
23P02^{3}P_{0}159.98.3849.3875.03.84.130.6727.406———
23P12^{3}P_{1}143.118.345—————17.049———
23P22^{3}P_{2}109.314.05510.85411.897.67.091.71325.112———
41S04^{1}S_{0}11P11^{1}P_{1}843.44.2570.1921.93———————
21P12^{1}P_{1}455.517.3978.3846.31———————
31P13^{1}P_{1}116.549.59826.79913.0———————
43S14^{3}S_{1}13P01^{3}P_{0}874.20.6660.1391.3——155.86————
13P11^{3}P_{1}858.41.682—————————
13P21^{3}P_{2}826.81.9510.1121.88——648.85————
23P02^{3}P_{0}487.33.0463.5813.28——24.139————
23P12^{3}P_{1}471.37.310—————————
23P22^{3}P_{2}439.07.5125.7645.78——101.987————
33P03^{3}P_{0}149.711.14922.3686.12——0.469————
33P13^{3}P_{1}133.124.111—————————
33P23^{3}P_{2}99.717.646—————————

Table VI. E1 radiative transition widths ΓE1\Gamma_{\mathrm{E1}} (keV) and photon energies EγE_{\gamma} (MeV) for SS-wave transitions of the BcB_{c} meson.

In Table VI, the largest S→PS \to P widths belong to the adjacent-shell transitions nS→(n−1)PnS \to(n-1)P: 41S0→31P14^{1}S_{0} \to3^{1}P_{1} (49.598 keV), 31S0→21P13^{1}S_{0} \to2^{1}P_{1} (38.472 keV), 43S1→33P14^{3}S_{1} \to3^{3}P_{1} (24.111 keV), and 21S0→11P12^{1}S_{0} \to1^{1}P_{1} (23.308 keV). These channels have photon energies of only 116–142 MeV, yet exceed the transitions from the same initial states to the 1P1P multiplet, whose photon energies are four to seven times larger. Conversely, 33S1→13P03^{3}S_{1} \to1^{3}P_{0} and 43S1→13P04^{3}S_{1} \to1^{3}P_{0} have the largest photon energies but among the smallest widths (1.035 and 0.666 keV). This pattern reflects the radial overlap. The nSnS and (n−1)P(n-1)P wave functions have similar node structure and extent, whereas in cross-shell transitions the sign changes of the integrand suppress ∣ϵfi∣2|\epsilon_{fi}|^{2} more strongly than Eγ3E_{\gamma}^{3} can compensate.

For 3S1→3PJ3S_{1} \to3P_{J}, Eq. (19) gives the weights 1 : 3 : 5 for J=0,1,2J=0, 1, 2. For 23S1→13PJ2^{3}S_{1} \to1^{3}P_{J} the widths are 4.897, 10.868, and 8.753 keV. The ratio Γ(13P1)/Γ(13P0)=2.22\Gamma(1^{3}P_{1})/\Gamma(1^{3}P_{0})=2.22 is close to the value 2.19 expected from the angular factor and Eγ3E_{\gamma}^{3} alone, so the radial overlaps are nearly independent of JJ. At large photon energies, as in 43S1→13PJ4^{3}S_{1} \to1^{3}P_{J}, the ordering Γ(J=2)>Γ(J=1)>Γ(J=0)\Gamma(J=2)>\Gamma(J=1)>\Gamma(J=0) is recovered, but the ratio 1 : 2.5 : 2.9 is reduced relative to 1 : 3 : 5 by the EγE_{\gamma} dependence of the overlap integral of Eq. (20).

For the Δn=1\Delta n=1 transitions our results agree reasonably with other approaches. The 23S1→13P0,12^{3}S_{1} \to1^{3}P_{0,1} widths are close to those of Ref. [24] (4.782 and 11.156 keV) and Ref. [19] (5.53 and 7.65 keV), and the 33S1→23P0,13^{3}S_{1} \to2^{3}P_{0,1} widths are consistent with Refs. [65] [24]. The 21S0→11P12^{1}S_{0} \to1^{1}P_{1} width lies above the 3–19 keV range of the comparison references, owing to the comparatively low 11P11^{1}P_{1} mass. For transitions from n=3,4n=3,4 states to the 1P1P multiplet, the model predictions spread over more than an order of magnitude, so these channels may help discriminate among models.

In Table VII, the four 1P→1S1P \to1S channels are the largest, with widths of 81–112 keV at photon energies of 407–457 MeV: 13P0→13S11^{3}P_{0} \to1^{3}S_{1} (81.476 keV), 13P1→13S11^{3}P_{1} \to1^{3}S_{1} (90.946 keV), 11P1→11S01^{1}P_{1} \to1^{1}S_{0} (101.166 keV), and 13P2→13S11^{3}P_{2} \to1^{3}S_{1} (111.554 keV). Since Cfi=1/3C_{fi}=1/3 for all 3PJ→3S1^{3}P_{J} \to{}^{3}S_{1} transitions, these widths are ordered by the photon energy, and the ratio Γ(13P2)/Γ(13P0)=1.37\Gamma(1^{3}P_{2})/\Gamma(1^{3}P_{0})=1.37 is close to the corresponding E3E3 ratio of 1.42. The 11P11^{1}P_{1} and 13P01^{3}P_{0} widths lie within the ranges of Refs. [65, 66, 67] [26], and the 13P21^{3}P_{2} width is within 4% of the value 107.402 keV of Ref. [65]. These channels are directly relevant to the structures observed by LHCb [13].

InitialFinalEγE_\gammaThis Work[65][66][26][67]
11P11^{1}P_{1}11S01^{1}S_{0}441.1101.166128.83976.574.046.13
13P01^{3}P_{0}13S11^{3}S_{1}407.081.47668.00359.5896.052.23
13P11^{3}P_{1}13S11^{3}S_{1}423.990.946————
13P21^{3}P_{2}13S11^{3}S_{1}457.4111.554107.40290.0487.071.91
21P12^{1}P_{1}11S01^{1}S_{0}828.253.31834.32624.4244.014.64
21S02^{1}S_{0}276.864.67664.42943.036.024.67
23P02^{3}P_{0}13S11^{3}S_{1}796.946.35425.4343.1941.017.52
23S12^{3}S_{1}243.445.97632.17033.4953.027.05
23P12^{3}P_{1}13S11^{3}S_{1}812.149.710————
23S12^{3}S_{1}260.054.861————
23P22^{3}P_{2}13S11^{3}S_{1}842.556.93535.45030.3552.020.36
23S12^{3}S_{1}293.075.03468.72849.3750.044.67
31P13^{1}P_{1}11S01^{1}S_{0}1133.638.26831.18532.0——
21S02^{1}S_{0}608.146.14354.07628.0——
31S03^{1}S_{0}221.757.842104.34130.0——
33P03^{3}P_{0}13S11^{3}S_{1}1103.734.17226.83530.0——
23S12^{3}S_{1}576.337.36037.69236.0——
33S13^{3}S_{1}188.637.92747.03545.0——
33P13^{3}P_{1}13S11^{3}S_{1}1118.136.150————
23S12^{3}S_{1}592.041.551————
33S13^{3}S_{1}205.147.343————
33P23^{3}P_{2}13S11^{3}S_{1}1146.940.37334.94742.0——
23S12^{3}S_{1}623.150.91362.95439.0——
33S13^{3}S_{1}238.069.168126.17943.0——
21P12^{1}P_{1}11D21^{1}D_{2}143.317.2776.2970.96—1.05
23P02^{3}P_{0}13D11^{3}D_{1}109.87.9892.5603.245.62.4
23P12^{3}P_{1}13D11^{3}D_{1}126.73.031————
13D21^{3}D_{2}126.49.031————
23P22^{3}P_{2}13D11^{3}D_{1}160.40.2390.1710.112—0.08
13D21^{3}D_{2}160.13.564————
13D31^{3}D_{3}159.719.79913.4639.78—5.4
31P13^{1}P_{1}11D21^{1}D_{2}480.97.1350.8940.19——
21D22^{1}D_{2}130.228.39310.1430.19——
33P03^{3}P_{0}13D11^{3}D_{1}449.14.6851.1381.84——
23D12^{3}D_{1}99.713.2097.99410.93——
33P13^{3}P_{1}13D11^{3}D_{1}465.01.453————
13D21^{3}D_{2}464.74.344————
23D12^{3}D_{1}116.45.162————
23D22^{3}D_{2}114.414.748————
33P23^{3}P_{2}13D11^{3}D_{1}496.80.08710.0440.94——
13D21^{3}D_{2}496.51.302————
13D31^{3}D_{3}496.07.2553.5179.07——
23D12^{3}D_{1}149.70.4200.6340.23——
23D22^{3}D_{2}147.86.079————
23D32^{3}D_{3}144.832.19042.45322.0——

Table VII. E1 radiative widths ΓE1\Gamma_{E1} (keV) and photon energies EγE_\gamma (MeV) for PP-wave transitions of the BcB_c meson.

For the radially excited PP-wave states, same-shell transitions are comparable to or larger than cross-shell ones. For example, 23P2→23S12^{3}P_{2} \to2^{3}S_{1} (75.034 keV, Eγ=293.0E_{\gamma}=293.0 MeV) exceeds 23P2→13S12^{3}P_{2} \to1^{3}S_{1} (56.935 keV, Eγ=842.5E_{\gamma}=842.5 MeV), and 31P1→31S03^{1}P_{1} \to3^{1}S_{0} (57.842 keV) exceeds both 31P1→21S03^{1}P_{1} \to2^{1}S_{0} (46.143 keV) and 31P1→11S03^{1}P_{1} \to1^{1}S_{0} (38.268 keV). The nP→n′DnP \to n'D channels follow the statistical weights closely. For 23P2→13DJ2^{3}P_{2} \to1^{3}D_{J} the widths 0.239, 3.564, and 19.799 keV are in the ratio 1:14.9:82.81:14.9:82.8, compared with 1:15:841:15:84 from Eq. (19) at nearly equal photon energies, and 23P1→13D1,22^{3}P_{1} \to1^{3}D_{1,2} follows the expected ratio 1:31:3. The largest 2P→1D2P \to1D widths, 23P2→13D32^{3}P_{2} \to1^{3}D_{3} (19.799 keV) and 21P1→11D22^{1}P_{1} \to1^{1}D_{2} (17.277 keV), may provide a radiative feeding mechanism for the 1D1D multiplet.

In Table VIII, the four 1D→1P1D \to1P channels have widths of 71–93 keV at photon energies of 258–309 MeV: 11D2→11P11^{1}D_{2} \to1^{1}P_{1} (92.846 keV), 13D2→13P11^{3}D_{2} \to1^{3}P_{1} (81.987 keV), 13D3→13P21^{3}D_{3} \to1^{3}P_{2} (77.608 keV), and 13D1→13P01^{3}D_{1} \to1^{3}P_{0} (70.774 keV). The 13D3→13P21^{3}D_{3} \to1^{3}P_{2} width is close to the values 78.0 and 86.604 keV of Refs. [65] [20], and 13D1→13P01^{3}D_{1} \to1^{3}P_{0} is close to the 65.0 keV of Ref. [26]. For 13D1→13PJ1^{3}D_{1} \to1^{3}P_{J} the weights 20:15:120:15:1 give 70.774, 45.424, and 2.139 keV. The suppressed 13D1→13P21^{3}D_{1} \to1^{3}P_{2} width agrees with Refs. [65, 66] [24] (1.786, 2.330, and 1.74 keV), which suggests a mainly kinematic and angular origin of the suppression. Same-shell transitions again dominate: 23D3→23P22^{3}D_{3} \to2^{3}P_{2} (63.765 keV) exceeds 23D3→13P22^{3}D_{3} \to1^{3}P_{2} (34.455 keV), and 31D2→31P13^{1}D_{2} \to3^{1}P_{1} (71.275 keV) exceeds the transitions to 21P12^{1}P_{1} and 11P11^{1}P_{1}.

InitialFinalEγE_{\gamma}This Work[65][66][26][67][20][24][19]
11D21^{1}D_{2}11P11^{1}P_{1}275.792.84684.67916.341.052.2663.066.020143
13D11^{3}D_{1}13P01^{3}P_{0}309.270.77486.61052.3665.040.5555.044.783133
13P11^{3}P_{1}292.145.424—————28.73165.3
13P21^{3}P_{2}257.62.1392.3301.740.71.21.81.7863.82
13D21^{3}D_{2}13P11^{3}P_{1}292.481.987—————51.272139
13P21^{3}P_{2}257.919.310—————16.07323.6
13D31^{3}D_{3}13P21^{3}P_{2}258.377.60886.60465.9867.047.8178.060.336149
21D22^{1}D_{2}11P11^{1}P_{1}618.938.39920.6381.719.06.17———
21P12^{1}P_{1}217.977.20366.3838.429.045.81———
23D12^{3}D_{1}13P01^{3}P_{0}648.226.25920.65813.541.83.99———
13P11^{3}P_{1}631.817.581———————
13P21^{3}P_{2}599.10.9250.6310.18.130.16———
23P02^{3}P_{0}248.160.45363.19837.246.035.09———
23P12^{3}P_{1}231.537.814———————
23P22^{3}P_{2}198.11.6581.3781.290.580.95———
23D22^{3}D_{2}13P11^{3}P_{1}633.732.056———————
13P21^{3}P_{2}600.98.441———————
23P12^{3}P_{1}233.469.577———————
23P22^{3}P_{2}200.015.325———————
23D32^{3}D_{3}13P21^{3}P_{2}603.734.45524.4227.4632.06.0———
23P22^{3}P_{2}202.963.76557.04548.754.039.62———
31D23^{1}D_{2}11P11^{1}P_{1}907.524.184———————
21P12^{1}P_{1}523.249.846———————
31P13^{1}P_{1}187.471.275———————
33D13^{3}D_{1}13P01^{3}P_{0}934.015.789———————
13P11^{3}P_{1}918.310.780———————
13P21^{3}P_{2}886.90.593———————
23P02^{3}P_{0}550.534.793———————
23P12^{3}P_{1}534.622.890———————
23P22^{3}P_{2}502.61.157———————
33P03^{3}P_{0}215.956.811———————
33P13^{3}P_{1}199.434.862———————
33P23^{3}P_{2}166.31.441———————
33D23^{3}D_{2}13P11^{3}P_{1}921.019.725———————
13P21^{3}P_{2}889.65.426———————
23P12^{3}P_{1}537.442.196———————
23P22^{3}P_{2}505.410.684———————
33P13^{3}P_{1}202.465.186———————
33P23^{3}P_{2}169.313.610———————
33D33^{3}D_{3}13P21^{3}P_{2}893.722.261———————
23P22^{3}P_{2}509.744.396———————
33P23^{3}P_{2}173.858.405———————

Table VIII. E1 radiative widths ΓE1\Gamma_{E1} (keV) and photon energies EγE_{\gamma} (MeV) for DD-wave transitions of the BcB_c meson.

Since the 1D1D states lie below the BDBD threshold, the sizable 1D→1P1D \to1P widths, together with the 1P→1S1P \to1S widths of Table VII, suggest that the cascade 1D→1P→1S1D \to1P \to1S could be a promising pathway toward the observation of DD-wave BcB_{c} states. Tables VI–VIII show the same behavior in all three orbital sectors: the angular dependence follows the E1 statistical weights, while the relative size of the widths is set mainly by the radial overlap.

M1 transitions

In Table IX, the allowed transitions (n=n′n=n') have mfi≃1m_{fi}\simeq1 and photon energies equal to the hyperfine splitting ΔM(nS)\Delta M(nS), so that ΓM1∝[ΔM(nS)]3\Gamma_{M1}\propto[\Delta M(nS)]^{3}. With the present splittings of 1–2 MeV the allowed widths are below 10−210^{-2} eV. The ATLAS splitting of 64.5 MeV [12] would instead give ΓM1(13S1→11S0)≈89\Gamma_{M1}(1^{3}S_{1}\to1^{1}S_{0})\approx89 eV, within the 33–150 eV range of most comparison references. These widths should therefore be read together with Sec. III A.

InitialFinalEγE_{\gamma}This Work[65][26][78][67][20][24][19][83]
13S11^{3}S_{1}11S01^{1}S_{0}1.80.0019498.42257841508053.109332.2
21S02^{1}S_{0}13S11^{3}S_{1}572194.315145.84399321340300568.3464881092
23S12^{3}S_{1}21S02^{1}S_{0}1.10.00042020.7332.48.30.141021.119170.014
11S01^{1}S_{0}57569.967140.6181205559410600481.572428495
31S03^{1}S_{0}23S12^{3}S_{1}397121.74062.319152537060———
13S11^{3}S_{1}939288.34379.3185104442404200———
33S13^{3}S_{1}31S03^{1}S_{0}0.70.00010326.28.2270.82.20.042———
21S02^{1}S_{0}39945.09560.98535613980200———
11S01^{1}S_{0}941100.50552.8571885503570600———
41S04^{1}S_{0}33S13^{3}S_{1}334114.23336.16918616—————
23S12^{3}S_{1}714207.82741.089579114—————
13S11^{3}S_{1}1231356.15351.1191122452—————
43S14^{3}S_{1}41S04^{1}S_{0}0.50.000039120.84.1230.351.1————
31S03^{1}S_{0}33541.83435.13725262—————
21S02^{1}S_{0}71674.00427.378806151—————
11S01^{1}S_{0}1233122.69028.5962501443—————
51S05^{1}S_{0}43S14^{3}S_{1}298114.08323.3142090.6—————
33S13^{3}S_{1}620215.30826.68772046—————
23S12^{3}S_{1}986277.57330.2481260138—————
13S11^{3}S_{1}1483412.73635.4351893432—————
53S15^{3}S_{1}51S05^{1}S_{0}0.40.000020317.22.3240.180.6————
41S04^{1}S_{0}29941.14722.32721035—————
31S03^{1}S_{0}62176.63517.73467573—————
21S02^{1}S_{0}98797.15216.6351316146—————
11S01^{1}S_{0}1484141.30817.9943107390—————

Table IX. TABLE IX. M1 radiative widths ΓM1\Gamma_{M1} (eV) and photon energies EγE_{\gamma} (MeV) for SS-wave states of the BcB_c meson.

The hindered transitions (n≠n′n\ne n') are less sensitive to the hyperfine scale, since their photon energies of several hundred MeV are fixed mainly by the radial spacings. Their widths lie between about 41 and 413 eV and increase with EγE_{\gamma} for a given initial state, reaching 412.736 eV for 51S0→13S15^{1}S_{0}\to1^{3}S_{1}. Because the singlet and triplet wave functions are similar in the present framework, the hindered amplitudes arise mainly from the factor j0(Eγr/2)j_{0}(E_{\gamma}r/2) in Eq. (23), which breaks the orthogonality of states with different radial quantum numbers. Transitions connecting the same pair of radial levels then differ mainly through the factor 2Jf+12J_{f}+1. For example, Γ(21S0→13S1)/Γ(23S1→11S0)=2.78\Gamma(2^{1}S_{0}\to1^{3}S_{1})/\Gamma(2^{3}S_{1}\to1^{1}S_{0})=2.78 and Γ(41S0→13S1)/Γ(43S1→11S0)=2.90\Gamma(4^{1}S_{0}\to1^{3}S_{1})/\Gamma(4^{3}S_{1}\to1^{1}S_{0})=2.90, close to the expected value of 3. For 21S0→13S12^{1}S_{0}\to1^{3}S_{1} we obtain 194.315 eV, close to the 145.843 eV of Ref. [65] and in the lower part of the 99–1092 eV range of other approaches. The 31S0→23S13^{1}S_{0}\to2^{3}S_{1} width of 121.740 eV is comparable to the values 6319 and 152 eV of Refs. [65] [26].

Regge Trajectories

Figures 1–10 show the radial Regge trajectories obtained from the masses of Tables II–IV, and Table X lists the fitted parameters of Eq. (24). Each trajectory tests the relative spacing of five levels of one spin-parity family at once.

Familyβ0\beta_0 (GeV2^2)β\beta (GeV2^2)R2R^2
S-wave
n 1S0n\,{}^1S_034.7095.7960.9888
n 3S1n\,{}^3S_134.7345.7920.9888
P-wave
n 3P0n\,{}^3P_040.2385.0550.9971
n 3P1n\,{}^3P_140.4695.0630.9972
n 1P1n\,{}^1P_140.6825.0740.9972
n 3P2n\,{}^3P_240.9335.0790.9972
D-wave
n 3D1n\,{}^3D_144.6954.7310.9988
n 3D2n\,{}^3D_244.6874.7470.9988
n 1D2n\,{}^1D_244.6694.7580.9987
n 3D3n\,{}^3D_344.6764.7730.9987

Table X. Radial Regge trajectory parameters for the BcB_c meson in the (n,M2)(n,M^2) plane, from linear least-squares fits of M2=β0+β nM^2=\beta_0+\beta\,n [Eq. (24)] to the masses of Tables II–Table IV. The intercept β0\beta_0 and slope β\beta are in GeV2^2.

The slopes decrease with increasing orbital angular momentum, from β≈5.79 GeV2\beta\approx5.79\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2} for the SS-wave families to 5.06–5.08 GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^{2} for the PP-wave and 4.73–4.77 GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^{2} for the DD-wave families, a decrease of about 18%. The intercepts rise from β0≈34.7 GeV2\beta_{0}\approx34.7\ \mathrm{GeV}^{2} to 40.2–40.9 and 44.7 GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^{2}, reflecting the larger masses of the orbitally excited states at fixed nn. The decrease of β\beta follows from the centrifugal barrier, which shifts the wave functions to larger interquark separations. There the linear confining term dominates over the Coulombic one, and the radial excitation energies become more uniform.

Within each orbital sector the trajectories are nearly parallel. The slopes differ by less than 0.01 GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^{2} for the two SS-wave families, by 0.024 GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^{2} for the four PP-wave families, and by 0.042 GeV2\mathrm{GeV}^{2} for the four DD-wave families, i.e., by less than 1%, which reflects the dominance of the central Cornell interaction in the radial spacing. The small differences follow a regular order: in the PP-wave sector both β\beta and β0\beta_0 increase in the order 3P03P_0, 3P13P_1, 1P11P_1, 3P23P_2, and in the DD-wave sector β\beta increases in the order 3D13D_1, 3D23D_2, 1D21D_2, 3D33D_3. This ordering follows the fine-structure pattern of Sec. III A, which suggests that the spin–orbit splittings persist along the radial sequence.

The fit quality improves with LL, from R2≈0.989R^2 \approx0.989 for the SS-wave to R2≈0.997R^2 \approx0.997 for the PP-wave and R2≈0.999R^2 \approx0.999 for the DD-wave families. The deviations from linearity are mildly concave; for the n 1S0n\,^{1}S_{0} family the successive intervals in M2M^{2} are 7.88, 5.80, 5.10, and 4.74 GeV2^{2}. This curvature is strongest in the SS-wave sector, where the low-lying states are more sensitive to the Coulombic part of the potential, as also found for triply heavy baryons in the same framework [68].

The first SS-wave interval, ΔM2=7.88\Delta M^{2} = 7.88 GeV2^{2}, is close to the experimental value of 7.84 GeV2^{2}[8], as expected from the calibration, and the trajectory beyond n=2n = 2 is a prediction. The same linear fit applied to the n 1S0n\,{}^{1}S_{0} masses of Ref. [22] gives a slope of 5.77 GeV2^{2}, close to the present value, whereas Refs. [65, 66] give about 5.2 GeV2^{2}. A measurement of the 3S3S level would directly test the SS-wave slope.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n^{1}S_{0}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 1. Radial Regge trajectory for the n1S0n^{1}S_{0} BcB_c states.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n^{3}S_{1}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 2. Radial Regge trajectory for the n3S1n^{3}S_{1} BcB_c states.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n\,{}^{3}P_{0}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 3. Radial Regge trajectory for the n 3P0n\,{}^{3}P_{0} BcB_c states.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n\,{}^{3}P_{1}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 4. Radial Regge trajectory for the n 3P1n\,{}^{3}P_{1} BcB_c states.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n\,{}^{1}P_{1}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 5. Radial Regge trajectory for the n 1P1n\,{}^{1}P_{1} BcB_c states.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n\,{}^{3}P_{2}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 6. Radial Regge trajectory for the n 3P2n\,{}^{3}P_{2} BcB_c states.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n\,{}^{3}D_{1}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 7. Radial Regge trajectory for the n 3D1n\,{}^{3}D_{1} BcB_c states.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n\,{}^{3}D_{2}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 8. Radial Regge trajectory for the n 3D2n\,{}^{3}D_{2} BcB_c states.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n\,{}^{1}D_{2}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 9. Radial Regge trajectory for the n 1D2n\,{}^{1}D_{2} BcB_c states.

Radial Regge trajectory for the $n\,{}^{3}D_{3}$ $B_c$ states

Figure 10. Radial Regge trajectory for the n 3D3n\,{}^{3}D_{3} BcB_c states.

Conclusion

In this work, we have studied the mass spectrum, leptonic decay constants, E1 and M1 radiative transitions, and radial Regge trajectories of the BcB_c meson in a nonrelativistic potential model. The Cornell interaction is supplemented by the Breit–Fermi spin–spin and spin–orbit interactions, both included nonperturbatively in the radial Schrödinger equation, so that each state has its own wave function and all observables follow from the same set. The parameters, fixed in Ref. [68] by a fit to the Bc(1S)B_c(1S) and Bc(2S)B_c(2S) masses, are used without readjustment.

The calibrated 1S1S and 2S2S levels are reproduced. The 1P1P multiplet shows the normal fine-structure ordering, is compatible with lattice QCD, and follows the 1:21:2 splitting ratio and the centroid relation expected from the spin–orbit interaction. If the LHCb structures are attributed to the two 1+1^+ states, their average mass agrees with our prediction within about 11 MeV, and the larger observed separation may point to 1P1^1P_1–3P1^3P_1 mixing. The 1D1D levels are nearly degenerate below the BDBD threshold, and all four DD-wave families are given in the LSLS basis as input for 2−2^- mixing analyses.

The predicted fBcf_{B_c} of Table V is consistent with recent QCDSR results but lies above the lattice QCD value, and corresponds to B(Bc→τντ)≈3%\mathcal{B}(B_c\to\tau\nu_\tau)\approx3\%. The ratio fBc∗/fBcf_{B_c^*}/f_{B_c} follows mainly from the one-loop QCD correction.

The E1 widths behave similarly in the SS-, PP-, and DD-wave sectors: their angular dependence follows the statistical weights of the E1 operator, while their relative size is set mainly by the radial overlap. The large 1P→1S1P\to1S and 1D→1P1D\to1P widths suggest that the cascade 1D→1P→1S1D\to1P\to1S could be a promising route toward the first observation of a DD-wave BcB_c state. The hindered M1 widths are determined mainly by the radial spacings and the photon-momentum dependence of the transition operator.

The radial Regge trajectories of all ten spin-parity families are approximately linear and nearly parallel within each orbital sector. Their slopes decrease from the SS- to the DD-wave sector as linear confinement becomes dominant at larger interquark separations, and the SS-wave slope is close to that of the relativistic quark model of Ref. [22].

Several limitations of the present approach should be acknowledged. First, the tensor interaction is not included, so the fine-structure splittings, in particular the near cancellation in the DD-wave sector, are approximate. Second, the SS-wave singlet–triplet splittings of 11–22 MeV lie well below the 64.564.5 MeV measured by ATLAS. The SS-wave triplet masses and the allowed M1 widths therefore least constrained results, and a joint readjustment of σ\sigma and the other parameters to this measurement is a natural next step. Third, coupled-channel effects are neglected, so the levels above the BDBD threshold should be read as bare quark-model states. Finally, 1+1^+ and 2−2^- mixing and higher-order QCD corrections to the decay constants are left for future work.

The high-luminosity LHC and future e+e−e^+e^- facilities such as FCC-ee [14] and CEPC [15] are expected to provide much larger BcB_c samples. Measurements of the spin-parity of the 1P1P structures, the 2S2S hyperfine splitting, the 1P→1S1P\to1S and 1D→1P1D\to1P radiative branching fractions, and the decay Bc→τντB_c\to\tau\nu_\tau would test the predictions presented here.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the Scientific Research Projects Coordination Unit (BAP) of Ondokuz Mayıs University under Project No. BAP01-2025-5761.

References

References

  1. [49]A. I. Onishchenko and O. L. Veretin, Eur. Phys. J. C 50, 801 (2007), arXiv:hep-ph/0302132.
  2. [50]J. Lee, W. Sang, and S. Kim, JHEP 01, 113, arXiv:1011.2274 [hep-ph].DOI
  3. [51]L.-B. Chen and C.-F. Qiao, Phys. Lett. B 748, 443 (2015), arXiv:1503.05122 [hep-ph].DOI
  4. [52]W. Tao, R. Zhu, and Z.-J. Xiao, Phys. Rev. D 106, 114037 (2022), arXiv:2209.15521 [hep-ph].DOI
  5. [53]W. Tao, R. Zhu, and Z.-J. Xiao, Eur. Phys. J. C 83, 294 (2023), arXiv:2301.00220 [hep-ph].DOI
  6. [54]W.-L. Sang, H.-F. Zhang, and M.-Z. Zhou, Phys. Lett. B 839, 137812 (2023), arXiv:2210.02979 [hep-ph].
  7. [55]F. Feng, Y. Jia, Z. Mo, J. Pan, W.-L. Sang, and J.-Y. Zhang, (2022), arXiv:2208.04302 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2208.04302
  8. [56]W. Tao and Z.-J. Xiao, JHEP 06, 012, arXiv:2310.17500 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2310.17500
  9. [57]S. M. Ikhdair and R. Sever, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 19, 1771 (2004), arXiv:hep-ph/0310295.DOI
  10. [58]S. M. Ikhdair and R. Sever, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 21, 6699 (2006), arXiv:hep-ph/0702166.DOI
  11. [59]A. Abd El-Hady, M. A. K. Lodhi, and J. P. Vary, Phys. Rev. D 59, 094001 (1999), arXiv:hep-ph/9807225.
  12. [60]G.-L. Wang, Phys. Lett. B 650, 15 (2007), arXiv:0705.2621 [hep-ph].DOI
  13. [61]G.-L. Wang, T. Wang, Q. Li, and C.-H. Chang, JHEP 05, 006, arXiv:2201.02318 [hep-ph].DOI
  14. [62]A. M. Badalian, B. L. G. Bakker, and Y. A. Simonov, Phys. Rev. D 75, 116001 (2007), arXiv:hep-ph/0702157.DOI
  15. [63]C. Lodha, M. Parmar, and A. K. Rai, Eur. Phys. J. Plus 141, 453 (2026).
  16. [64]R. Chaturvedi and A. K. Rai, Eur. Phys. J. A 58, 228 (2022), arXiv:2211.04099 [hep-ph].DOI
  17. [65]C. A. Bokade and Bhaghyashesh, Nucl. Phys. A 1060, 123109 (2025).
  18. [66]T.-y. Li, L. Tang, Z.-y. Fang, C.-h. Wang, C.-q. Pang, and X. Liu, Phys. Rev. D 108, 034019 (2023), arXiv:2204.14258 [hep-ph].DOI
  19. [67]I. Asghar, F. Akram, B. Masud, and M. A. Sultan, Phys. Rev. D 100, 096002 (2019), arXiv:1910.02680 [hep-ph].DOI
  20. [68]Ö. Çakır and H. Mutuk, Eur. Phys. J. C 86, 678 (2026), arXiv:2604.18796 [hep-ph].
  21. [69]E. Eichten, K. Gottfried, T. Kinoshita, K. D. Lane, and T.-M. Yan, Phys. Rev. D 17, 3090 (1978), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 21, 313 (1980)].
  22. [70]W. Buchmuller and S. H. H. Tye, Phys. Rev. D 24, 132 (1981).
  23. [71]G. S. Bali, Phys. Rept. 343, 1 (2001), arXiv:hep-ph/0001312.DOI
  24. [72]T. Barnes, S. Godfrey, and E. S. Swanson, Phys. Rev. D 72, 054026 (2005), arXiv:hep-ph/0505002.
  25. [73]W. Luches, F. F. Schoberl, and D. Gromes, Phys. Rept. 200, 127 (1991).
  26. [74]V. R. Debastiani and F. S. Navarra, Chin. Phys. C 43, 013105 (2019), arXiv:1706.07553 [hep-ph].DOI
  27. [75]R. Van Royen and V. F. Weisskopf, Nuovo Cim. A 50, 617 (1967), [Erratum: Nuovo Cim. A 51, 583 (1967)].
  28. [76]E. Braaten and S. Fleming, Phys. Rev. D 52, 181 (1995), arXiv:hep-ph/9501296.DOI
  29. [77]S. S. Gershtein, V. V. Kiselev, A. K. Likhoded, and A. V. Tkabladze, Phys. Usp. 38, 1 (1995), arXiv:hep-ph/9504319.
  30. [78]X.-J. Li, Y.-S. Li, F.-L. Wang, and X. Liu, Eur. Phys. J. C 83, 1080 (2023), arXiv:2308.07206 [hep-ph].DOI
  31. [79]C. Sun, R.-H. Ni, and M. Chen, Chin. Phys. C 47, 023101 (2023), arXiv:2209.06724 [hep-ph].DOI
  32. [80]N. Akbar, (2020), arXiv:2003.08491 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2003.08491
  33. [81]B. Patel, A. Majethiya, and P. C. Vinodkumar, Pramana 72, 679 (2009), arXiv:0808.2880 [hep-ph].DOI
  34. [82]N. Akbar, F. Akram, B. Masud, and M. Atif Sultan, Eur. Phys. J. A 55, 82 (2019), arXiv:1811.07552 [hep-ph].DOI
  35. [83]N. Devlani, V. Kher, and A. K. Rai, Eur. Phys. J. A 50, 154 (2014).

Paper details

vlnc:W_6fe3jtm2
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 8

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents