betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Low-mass dark sector searches with deuteron photodisintegration

Abstract

Recent years have seen much activity in searches for dark-sector messenger particles in the 10-100 MeV mass range, especially in view of a potential new light boson conjectured by the ATOMKI collaboration, X17. Under the assumption that the messenger particle has definite parity and either zero or unit spin, quite stringent bounds already exist on its coupling to electrons and protons. Equally stringent bounds on the neutron coupling do not exist yet, but are nonetheless desirable. We explore how measurements of deuteron photodisintegration with a quasi-free neutron can yield bounds on the neutron coupling, and compute projections for a potential measurement at the lowenergy high-intensity electron scattering experiment MAGIX@MESA. The projected bounds are found to be competitive for an axial-vector or pseudoscalar scenario, but not for a vector or scalar scenario.

Introduction

In recent years, the main paradigm for dark-matter searches has been shifting. With heavier candidate particles, such as WIMPs, either excluded or experimentally out of reach [1, 2], a vigorous effort is presently underway to search for light dark-sector particles in the MeV–GeV mass range [3, 4]. In this context a new boson XX is often posited to be a messenger particle connecting the known visible sector to a hidden dark sector [5, 6, 7, 8].

The mass of the mediator XX determines its decay. It may either decay invisibly into particles of the hidden dark sector, or it may decay visibly into particles of the Standard Model. Herein we deal with visible decays of the mediator XX to an electron-positron pair, where one typically searches for XX by directing a high-intensity, O(100 MeVO(100\ \mathrm{MeV}–few GeV) electron beam at a fixed gas-jet target [9, 10, 11]. If present, a potential signal will appear as a narrow resonance on top of a large, but well-known QED background.

Using these techniques robust exclusion limits on the coupling of XX to an electron-positron pair have been established, with reactions such as e−p→e−p(X→e+e−)e^-p \to e^-p(X \to e^+e^-), or e−Z→e−Z(X→e+e−)e^-Z \to e^-Z(X \to e^+e^-), where ZZ denotes a heavy target nucleus [6]. Likewise, results from the NA48/2 experiment, using π0→γ(X→e+e−)\pi^0 \to\gamma(X \to e^+e^-), have put strict bounds on the coupling of XX to the proton [12]. And, under the assumption that XX is a pseudoscalar, results from the SINDRUM collaboration [13], which measured π+→e+νe(X→e+e−)\pi^+ \to e^+\nu_e(X \to e^+e^-), limit the isovector nucleon coupling of XX.

Unlike the effective electron and proton couplings of XX, the effective neutron coupling is not as strongly tested in the region mX∼10m_X \sim10–100 MeV/c2100\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2. The reason is simple: in the lab, no free, high-density neutron target exists. Any extractions of the neutron coupling have to be made by proxy, which is why the current strongest constraints come from neutron star phenomenology [2, 14, 15] or isotope shift spectroscopy [16, 17]. Unfortunately, these bounds fall short of covering the MeV-to-GeV mass range of interest.

Nevertheless, for several reasons it is desirable to have better limits on the neutron coupling in this region as well. First, taken with the existing constraints on the proton coupling, constraints on the neutron coupling can be directly translated into limits on the quark couplings of XX, i.e. gu=(2gp−gn)/3g_u = (2g_p - g_n)/3 and gd=(2gn−gp)/3g_d = (2g_n - g_p)/3. In turn, these limits directly tell us what new physics models are permissible. As a specific example consider the dark photon which, through kinetic mixing with an ordinary photon, necessarily couples to the quarks in a manner proportional to their charges, gu=2gp/3g_u = 2g_p/3 and gd=−gp/3g_d = -g_p/3, implying gn=0g_n = 0 [18]. Any deviation from this value already rules out the dark photon scenario. Another more immediate reason is connected to the potential discovery of a narrow resonance around 17 MeV by the ATOMKI collaboration—dubbed X17—in the e+e−e^+e^- decay spectrum of excited states of 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}, 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} and 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} [19, 20, 21]. Limits on the coupling of X17 to the nucleon, which can be derived individually from each of the observed nuclear decays, appear to be in tension with each other [22, 23, 24]. Better constraints on the neutron coupling would help resolve this apparent conflict.

The problem, which involves determining the XX coupling to the neutron, is mirrored in the program to measure the neutron polarizabilities [25, 26]. There, a successful strategy is to measure deuteron photodisintegration under specific kinematic conditions where the bound neutron behaves as though it were free [27]. One can then access the polarizabilities indirectly, using the ‘quasi-free’ bound neutron [28]. The purpose of this paper is to explore the use of a similar approach, a measurement of γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^+e^-pn in quasi-free neutron kinematics, to extract limits on the neutron coupling of XX.

To make our analysis concrete, our work will be centered around the forthcoming experiment at MAGIX@MESA [29], though it may be readily adapted to meet the constraints provided by other electron scattering facilities. MESA is an electron accelerator (presently under construction) that will be capable of producing a low-energy, high-intensity electron beam (up to 105105 MeV in its energy-recovering mode). With a gas-jet target, luminosities around 1035 cm−2s−110^{35}\ {\rm cm}^{-2}{\rm s}^{-1} will be reached [30]. The MAGIX experiment consists of two high-resolution electron-positron spectrometers with a relative momentum resolution of δp/p<10−4\delta p/p < 10^{-4} and an angular resolution of δθ<3\delta\theta< 3 mrad [29, 30]. Accordingly, the expected electron-positron invariant-mass resolution is δmee≈0.1 MeV/c2\delta m_{ee} \approx0.1\ {\rm MeV}/c^2 or better [10]. Note that earlier dark-photon searches have already achieved a resolution of 0.2 MeV/c20.2\ {\rm MeV}/c^2 [31, 32].

In this paper we will investigate which limits on the neutron coupling to a dark-sector messenger particle XX can be obtained with the MAGIX@MESA setup using γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^+e^-pn. Our paper is structured as follows: in Sec. II we start by specifying the kinematics of the γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^+e^-pn process and derive an expression for the differential cross section. In Sec. III we subsequently describe the plane-wave impulse approximation, and outline the kinematic regime in which the scattering on a quasi-free neutron is valid. In Sec. IV we specify the QED background and XX-boson signal, respectively. In Sec. V we derive projections for the reach at MAGIX@MESA, and in Sec. VI we apply our framework to the specific case of the conjectured X17. We conclude with a brief outlook in Sec. VII.

Kinematics and cross section of e+e−pne^+e^-pn

We begin our calculation with the kinematics of the γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^+e^-pn process. We work within the rest frame of the deuteron and set up our coordinate system such that the zz-axis is along the direction of the incoming photon’s three-momentum, and the neutron and photon three-momenta span the xx-zz plane. We have,

γ(q,λ)d(pd,M)→e+(p+,s+)e−(p−,s−)\gamma(q,\lambda)d(p_d,M)\to e^+(p_+,s_+)e^-(p_-,s_-)
p(pp,sp)n(pn,sn),p(p_p,s_p)n(p_n,s_n),

where λ\lambda is the polarization of the incoming photon, s±s_\pm are the e±e^\pm helicities, and MM, sps_p and sns_n are the deuteron, proton and neutron spin projection along the zz-axis. In the lab frame, the four-momenta are given by

pdμ=(md,0,0,0),qμ=(Eγ,0,0,Eγ),p_d^\mu=(m_d,0,0,0),\qquad q^\mu=(E_\gamma,0,0,E_\gamma),
piμ=(Ei,∣pi∣p^i),for i=±,n,p_i^\mu=(E_i,|\mathbf p_i|\hat{\mathbf p}_i),\qquad\text{for }i=\pm,n,
ppμ=(Ep,pp),p_p^\mu=(E_p,\mathbf p_p),

where

p^i=(sin⁡θicos⁡ϕi,sin⁡θisin⁡ϕi,cos⁡θi),for i=±,n,(1)\hat{\mathbf p}_i=(\sin\theta_i\cos\phi_i,\sin\theta_i\sin\phi_i,\cos\theta_i),\qquad\text{for }i=\pm,n, \tag*{(1)}
pp=q−p−−p+−pn.(2)\mathbf p_p=\mathbf q-\mathbf p_--\mathbf p_+-\mathbf p_n. \tag*{(2)}

We denote the masses of the nucleons, leptons and deuteron as mNm_N, mem_e and mdm_d, respectively. It is also

useful to introduce the four-momentum q′=p++p−q'=p_++p_- and the squared invariant mass of the dilepton system, q′2=mee2q'^2=m_{ee}^2.

We choose our kinematic variables as EγE_\gamma, ∣p±∣|\mathbf p_\pm|, the polar angles θ±\theta_\pm and θn\theta_n, and the azimuthal angles ϕ±\phi_\pm and ϕn\phi_n. It follows that the magnitude of the neutron three-momentum is given by,

∣pn∣=12a[b±b2−4ac],(3)|\mathbf p_n|=\frac{1}{2a}\left[b\pm\sqrt{b^2-4ac}\right], \tag*{(3)}

where

a=(Eγ+md−q′0)2−∣q−q′∣2cos⁡2θγγ′>0,(4)a=(E_\gamma+m_d-q'^0)^2-|\mathbf q-\mathbf q'|^2\cos^2\theta_{\gamma\gamma'}>0, \tag*{(4)}
b=(q+pd−q′)2∣q−q′∣cos⁡θγγ′,(5)b=(q+p_d-q')^2|\mathbf q-\mathbf q'|\cos\theta_{\gamma\gamma'}, \tag*{(5)}
c=mN2(Eγ+md−q′0)2−14(q+pd−q′)4>0,(6)c=m_N^2(E_\gamma+m_d-q'^0)^2-\frac{1}{4}(q+p_d-q')^4>0, \tag*{(6)}

with

∣q−q′∣cos⁡θγγ′=p^n⋅(q−q′).(7)|\mathbf q-\mathbf q'|\cos\theta_{\gamma\gamma'}=\hat{\mathbf p}_n\cdot(\mathbf q-\mathbf q'). \tag*{(7)}

For our kinematic regime of interest the positive solution of Eq. (3) corresponds to physical values of the neutron three-momentum.

Lastly, the differential cross section is given by

dσdΠ=K⟨∣M∣2⟩,(8)\frac{d\sigma}{d\Pi}=K\langle|\mathcal M|^2\rangle, \tag*{(8)}

with

K=164(2π)8mdEγ∣p+∣2∣p−∣2E+E−×∣pn∣2∣pn∣(md+Eγ−q′0)−En∣q−q′∣cos⁡θγγ′,(9)K=\frac{1}{64(2\pi)^8m_dE_\gamma}\frac{|\mathbf p_+|^2|\mathbf p_-|^2}{E_+E_-}\times\frac{|\mathbf p_n|^2}{|\mathbf p_n|(m_d+E_\gamma-q'^0)-E_n|\mathbf q-\mathbf q'|\cos\theta_{\gamma\gamma'}}, \tag*{(9)}

where dΠd\Pi is shorthand for d∣p+∣d∣p−∣dΩ+dΩ−dΩnd|\mathbf p_+|d|\mathbf p_-|d\Omega_+d\Omega_-d\Omega_n. Furthermore, in Eq. (8) ∣M∣2|\mathcal M|^2 is the squared Feynman amplitude and ⟨⋅⟩\langle\cdot\rangle denotes the average over initial helicities or spin projections and sum over final helicities or spin projections.

The plane-wave impulse approximation

As a first step, to calculate the matrix element M\mathcal M we work within the plane-wave impulse approximation (PWIA) [28]. In this approximation, shown in Figure 1, we can separate the process γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn into two parts: a part where the proton is a spectator and a part where the neutron is a spectator. By doing so we disregard meson exchange currents and final state interactions. However, in our kinematic regime of interest the meson exchange currents are estimated to give corrections of approximately 5%, meaning they can be safely neglected.

Figure 1. In the plane-wave impulse approximation we can factorize the process γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^+e^-pn into a process on a quasi-free neutron, n~\tilde n, and a process on a quasi-free proton, p~\tilde p.

Likewise, for a first approximation, the final state interactions can be omitted (see Figure 5 and its discussion in Ref. [28]). As we are interested in the low-energy regime (Eγ∼100E_{\gamma} \sim100 MeV) where relativistic corrections are expected to be small, we use a non-relativistic framework to implement the PWIA. We start by inserting a complete set of two-particle states [33],

Figure 5. The differential signal cross section (blue) assuming an axial-vector scenario and the differential QED background cross sections (red) with uncertainties due to the neutron polarizabilities. We fix Eγ=105 MeVE_\gamma= 105\ \mathrm{MeV}, mX=17 MeV/c2m_X = 17\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2, δmee=0.1 MeV/c2\delta m_{ee} = 0.1\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2 and gAn=7×10−5g_A^n = 7 \times10^{-5}. The bands correspond to the range gAn=(5g_A^n = (5–9)×10−59) \times10^{-5}. A further specification of the kinematics is given in the body of the text.

MIA(γd→e+e−pn)=∑s1,s2∫d3p(2π)3⟨e+e−,pp sp,pn sn∣MIA∣γ,12pd+p s1,12pd−p s2⟩(2md)1/2(2E~p)1/2(2E~n)1/2 NR⟨p;s1s2∣d(1,M)⟩NR,(10)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{IA}}(\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn) = \sum_{s_{1},s_{2}} \int\frac{\mathrm{d}^{3}\mathbf{p}}{(2\pi)^{3}} \langle e^{+}e^{-}, \mathbf{p}_{p}\,s_{p}, \mathbf{p}_{n}\,s_{n} | \mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{IA}} | \gamma, \tfrac{1}{2}\mathbf{p}_{d}+\mathbf{p}\,s_{1}, \tfrac{1}{2}\mathbf{p}_{d}-\mathbf{p}\,s_{2}\rangle\frac{(2m_{d})^{1/2}}{(2\widetilde{E}_{p})^{1/2}(2\widetilde{E}_{n})^{1/2}}\,{}_{\mathrm{NR}}\langle\mathbf{p};s_{1}s_{2}|d(1,M)\rangle_{\mathrm{NR}}, \tag*{(10)}

where ‘NR’ indicates the baryon states are normalized non-relativistically and no subscript refers to covariant normalization,

∣p,s⟩=(2Ep)1/2∣p,s⟩NR,|\mathbf{p},s\rangle= (2E_{p})^{1/2}|\mathbf{p},s\rangle_{\mathrm{NR}},
⟨p,s∣p′,s′⟩=(2Ep)(2π)3δ(3)(p−p′)δss′.\langle\mathbf{p},s|\mathbf{p}',s'\rangle= (2E_{p})(2\pi)^{3}\delta^{(3)}(\mathbf{p}-\mathbf{p}')\delta_{ss'}.

In the second line of Eq. (10) we can identify the components of the relative deuteron wave function in momentum space, Ψ~s1s2M(p)=NR⟨p;s1s2∣d(1,M)⟩NR\widetilde{\Psi}^{M}_{s_{1}s_{2}}(\mathbf{p})={}_{\mathrm{NR}}\langle\mathbf{p};s_{1}s_{2}|d(1,M)\rangle_{\mathrm{NR}}. They are given by

Ψ~s1s2M(p)=(2π)3/2[ψ~0(p)Y00(p^)⟨12s1;12s2∣1M⟩−ψ~2(p)∑MsY2M−Ms(p^)⟨1Ms;2M−Ms∣1M⟩×⟨12s1;12s2∣1Ms⟩],(11)\widetilde{\Psi}^{M}_{s_{1}s_{2}}(\mathbf{p})=(2\pi)^{3/2}\left[\widetilde{\psi}_{0}(p)Y^{0}_{0}(\hat{\mathbf{p}})\langle\tfrac{1}{2}s_{1};\tfrac{1}{2}s_{2}|1M\rangle-\widetilde{\psi}_{2}(p)\sum_{M_{s}}Y^{M-M_{s}}_{2}(\hat{\mathbf{p}})\langle1M_{s};2M-M_{s}|1M\rangle\times\langle\tfrac{1}{2}s_{1};\tfrac{1}{2}s_{2}|1M_{s}\rangle\right], \tag*{(11)}

where p=∣p∣p=|\mathbf{p}|, ⟨j1m1;j2m2∣jm⟩\langle j_{1}m_{1};j_{2}m_{2}|jm\rangle are Clebsch-Gordan coefficients and YlmY^{m}_{l} are the spherical harmonics. For our numerical estimates we use the CD-Bonn parametrization [34] for the s- and d-wave functions. Note that we use a different convention for the Fourier transform as compared to Ref. [34], which gives rise to the different factors of 2π2\pi. Also note that the relative sign between the s- and d-wave functions is absorbed into the CD-Bonn parametrization of Ref. [34]. That is, ψ~0(p)=ψ~0Bonn(p)\widetilde{\psi}_{0}(p)=\widetilde{\psi}^{\mathrm{Bonn}}_{0}(p) and ψ~2(p)=−ψ~2Bonn(p)\widetilde{\psi}_{2}(p)=-\widetilde{\psi}^{\mathrm{Bonn}}_{2}(p). The wave function is normalized as

1=∫d3p(2π)3∣Ψ~M(p)∣2=∫0∞dp p2[ψ~02(p)+ψ~22(p)].(12)1=\int\frac{\mathrm{d}^{3}\mathbf{p}}{(2\pi)^{3}}|\widetilde{\Psi}^{M}(\mathbf{p})|^{2}=\int_{0}^{\infty}\mathrm{d}p\,p^{2}\left[\widetilde{\psi}_{0}^{2}(p)+\widetilde{\psi}_{2}^{2}(p)\right]. \tag*{(12)}

In this work we will restrict ourselves to kinematics inside the neutron quasi-free peak (NQFP) [28]. Qualitatively, this means we only consider configurations in which the bound proton is a spectator, i.e. has low momentum. As a consequence the incoming photon primarily scatters off the bound neutron n~\widetilde{n}, and contributions to the cross section from processes involving the bound proton are negligible.

A more quantitative definition of the NQFP may be derived using the relative and total momenta of the bound neutron and bound proton. In the lab frame the total momentum is just the deuteron momentum, pd=0\mathbf{p}_{d}=0, and the relative momentum is the negative of the outgoing proton, p=pp=−pn~\mathbf{p}=\mathbf{p}_{p}=-\mathbf{p}_{\widetilde{n}}. Near the NQFP ∣p∣→0|\mathbf{p}|\to0, meaning we approach the singularity of the deuteron wave function,

1md−Ep−E~n=12mN−Δ−2Ep,\frac{1}{m_{d}-E_{p}-\widetilde{E}_{n}}=\frac{1}{2m_{N}-\Delta-2E_{p}},

where Δ≈2.2\Delta\approx2.2 MeV is the deuteron binding energy. Close to this singularity, n~\widetilde{n} is ‘nearly on shell’, and so we define the NQFP by [28]

Ep≲mN+Δ2⟹∣pp∣≲mNΔ≈45.7 MeV/c.(13)E_{p}\lesssim m_{N}+\frac{\Delta}{2}\Longrightarrow|\mathbf{p}_{p}|\lesssim\sqrt{m_{N}\Delta}\approx45.7\ \mathrm{MeV}/c. \tag*{(13)}

Expanding Ψ~M\widetilde{\Psi}^{M} in Eq. (10) in the NQFP region gives

MIA(γd→e+e−pn)≈MIAn(γd→e+e−pn),(14)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{IA}}(\gamma d\to e^{+}e^{-}pn)\approx\mathcal{M}^{n}_{\mathrm{IA}}(\gamma d\to e^{+}e^{-}pn), \tag*{(14)}

with

MIAn(γd→e+e−pn)=(2md)1/2(EpE~n)1/2×∑sn~Ψ~spsn~M(pp)M(γn~→e+e−n),(15)\mathcal{M}^{n}_{\mathrm{IA}}(\gamma d\to e^{+}e^{-}pn)=(2m_{d})^{1/2}\left(\frac{E_{p}}{\widetilde{E}_{n}}\right)^{1/2}\times\sum_{s_{\widetilde{n}}}\widetilde{\Psi}^{M}_{s_{p}s_{\widetilde{n}}}(\mathbf{p}_{p})\mathcal{M}(\gamma\widetilde{n}\to e^{+}e^{-}n), \tag*{(15)}

where the quasi-free neutron has momentum and spin projection −pp-\mathbf{p}_{p} and sn~s_{\widetilde{n}}, respectively. We have explicitly checked the size of the proton contribution to the cross section and found it to be negligible in the kinematic region corresponding with Eq. (13), validating Eq. (14). Note that in the NQFP kinematic region of interest here any off-shell effects are small, and can be safely neglected.

QED background processes and signal processes

Having related the amplitude of γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn to the amplitude of γn~→e+e−n\gamma\widetilde{n} \to e^{+}e^{-}n, we turn to the calculation of M(γn~→e+e−n)\mathcal{M}(\gamma\widetilde{n} \to e^{+}e^{-}n). This calculation is composed of two steps, the calculation of the QED background amplitude and the subsequent computation of the signal amplitude.

QED background amplitudes

For photon energies around 100 MeV, i.e. below the pion production threshold, the QED background may be parameterized by a combination of the Bethe-Heitler process and Compton scattering process. The latter is described by the Born process, the π0\pi^0 t-channel exchange process and the non-Born contributions parameterized by the neutron electric (αE\alpha_E) and magnetic (βM\beta_M) polarizabilities. These are all shown in Fig. 2, where we have omitted the crossed diagrams for the Bethe-Heitler and Born contributions. All diagrams in Fig. 2 are embedded in the quasi-free neutron blob of Fig. 1. Technical details of the calculation of the QED background have been relegated to Appendix A and a comparison of our calculated QED background and previous calculations is given in Appendix B.

Signal amplitudes

The XX signal process is identical to Fig. 2b, with XX replacing the virtual photon. In principle, XX may also contribute via the Bethe-Heitler process. However, to extract limits on the neutron coupling from γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn, we are only interested in processes where XX is on resonance (that is, mee2=mX2m_{ee}^{2}=m_{X}^{2}). Consequently, any Bethe-Heitler contributions stemming from virtual XX exchange are negligibly small and may be safely omitted.

We assume that XX is either scalar, pseudoscalar, vector or axial vector (S, P, V or A, respectively) and that it couples to the fermions ff, where ff may be a neutron, proton or electron (f=nf=n, pp or ee, respectively). We can then generically parameterize its interaction using the effective interactions,

Li=∑fgfifˉΓif⋅X,for i=S,P,V,A,(16)\mathcal{L}_i=\sum_f g_f^i\bar{f}\Gamma_i f\cdot X,\quad\text{for }i=S,P,V,A, \tag*{(16)}

where ΓS=1\Gamma_S=1, ΓP=iγ5\Gamma_P=i\gamma_5, ΓVμ=γμ\Gamma_V^\mu=\gamma^\mu and ΓAμ=γμγ5\Gamma_A^\mu=\gamma^\mu\gamma_5. The dot in Eq. (16) indicates all Lorentz indices, should they be present, are to be contracted. In this approach we remain agnostic to any models describing XX; constraints on the effective couplings gfig_f^i can always be matched to constraints on couplings from a UV-complete model by integrating out the corresponding degrees of freedom of the microscopic theory.

Using Eq. (16) we find that the signal amplitude is given by

Mi=Bimee2−mX2+imXΓX,for i=S,P,V,A,(17)\mathcal{M}_i=\frac{B_i}{m_{ee}^{2}-m_X^{2}+im_X\Gamma_X},\quad\text{for }i=S,P,V,A, \tag*{(17)}

where Bi=ε(q,λ)⋅Hi⋅Ci⋅LiB_i=\varepsilon(\mathbf{q},\lambda)\cdot H_i\cdot C_i\cdot L_i, with

Ci(μν)=−egiegin[δSi+δPi−gμνδVi−(gμν−q′μq′νmX2)δAi],(18)C_i^{(\mu\nu)}=-eg_i^e g_i^n\left[\delta S_i+\delta P_i-g^{\mu\nu}\delta V_i-\left(g^{\mu\nu}-\frac{q'^\mu q'^\nu}{m_X^2}\right)\delta A_i\right], \tag*{(18)}
Li(μ)=uˉ(p−,s−)Γi(μ)v(p+,s+),(19)L_i^{(\mu)}=\bar{u}(p_-,s_-)\Gamma_i^{(\mu)}v(p_+,s_+), \tag*{(19)}
H_i^{\mu(\nu)}=\bar{u}(p_n,s_n)\left\{\Gamma_i^{(\nu)}\frac{\slashed{p}_{\widetilde n}+\slashed{q}+m_N}{(p_{\widetilde n}+q)^2-m_N^2}\Gamma_q^\mu+\Gamma_q^\mu\frac{\slashed{p}_{\widetilde n}-\slashed{q'}+m_N}{(p_{\widetilde n}-q')^2-m_N^2}\Gamma_i^{(\nu)}\right\}u(p_{\widetilde n},s_{\widetilde n}). \tag*{(20)}

The photon nucleon vertex Γqμ\Gamma_q^\mu is described in Eq. (A10), with e>0e>0.

Signal averaged over a single invariant lepton-mass bin

As can be seen from Eq. (17), the final cross section around the NQFP with mee=mXm_{ee}=m_X will generally depend on the coupling of XX to the neutron and electron, as well as the (narrow) width of XX, ΓX\Gamma_X. In an experiment we would not be able to set mee=mXm_{ee}=m_X exactly—instead, we will collect all events falling in [mee−δmee/2,mee+δmee/2][m_{ee} - \delta m_{ee}/2, m_{ee} + \delta m_{ee}/2]. If δmee\delta m_{ee} is sufficiently narrow, ∼O(0.1 MeV/c2)\sim O(0.1\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2), the QED background will remain nearly constant across this bin and, given that ΓX≪δmee\Gamma_X \ll\delta m_{ee}, this is also the only bin in which the signal will reside.

To calculate the signal averaged over a single bin we start by fixing δmee=0.1 MeV/c2\delta m_{ee} = 0.1\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2 (bin widths achievable by MAGIX@MESA). Moreover, on resonance we may safely neglect any interference terms between the QED background and the XX-boson signal due to the narrowness of the resonance,

dσdΠ≈(dσdΠ)QED+(dσi‾dΠ)X,for i=S,P,V,A,(21)\frac{d\sigma}{d\Pi} \approx\left(\frac{d\sigma}{d\Pi}\right)_{\mathrm{QED}} + \left(\frac{d\overline{\sigma_i}}{d\Pi}\right)_X,\qquad\text{for }i=S,P,V,A, \tag*{(21)}

where

(dσi‾dΠ)X:=1δmee∫mX−δmee/2mX+δmee/2dmee(dσidΠ)X,(22)\left(\frac{d\overline{\sigma_i}}{d\Pi}\right)_X := \frac{1}{\delta m_{ee}}\int_{m_X-\delta m_{ee}/2}^{m_X+\delta m_{ee}/2}dm_{ee}\left(\frac{d\sigma_i}{d\Pi}\right)_X, \tag*{(22)}

is the signal averaged over a bin. We assume that mX≫ΓXm_X \gg\Gamma_X, so that in Eq. (22) we may replace,

∣1mee2−mX2+imXΓX∣2→πmXΓXδ(mee2−mX2).(23)\left|\frac{1}{m_{ee}^2-m_X^2+im_X\Gamma_X}\right|^2 \to\frac{\pi}{m_X\Gamma_X}\delta(m_{ee}^2-m_X^2). \tag*{(23)}

This gives

(dσi‾dΠ)X=1δmeeπ2mX2ΓX(K∣Bi∣2)∣mee2=mX2,(24)\left(\frac{d\overline{\sigma_i}}{d\Pi}\right)_X = \frac{1}{\delta m_{ee}}\frac{\pi}{2m_X^2\Gamma_X}\left(K\lvert B_i\rvert^2\right)\bigg|_{m_{ee}^2=m_X^2}, \tag*{(24)}

where KK is given in Eq. (9) and BiB_i is given in Eq. (17).

We can rewrite ΓX\Gamma_X using

B(X→e+e−)=Γ(X→e+e−)ΓX.\mathcal{B}(X\to e^+e^-) = \frac{\Gamma(X\to e^+e^-)}{\Gamma_X}.

A short calculation gives

Γi(X→e+e−)=(gei)2π[(δPi+δVi)pcm+(δSi+δAi)pcm3mX2]βi,(25)\Gamma_i(X\to e^+e^-) = \frac{(g_e^i)^2}{\pi}\left[(\delta_{P i}+\delta_{V i})p_{\mathrm{cm}}+(\delta_{S i}+\delta_{A i})\frac{p_{\mathrm{cm}}^3}{m_X^2}\right]\beta_i, \tag*{(25)}

where βS=1\beta_S=1, βP=1/4\beta_P=1/4, βV=(1+2me2/mX2)/6\beta_V=(1+2m_e^2/m_X^2)/6 and βA=2/3\beta_A=2/3, with pcm=mX2−4me2/2p_{\mathrm{cm}}=\sqrt{m_X^2-4m_e^2}/2.

Using the above, dσ‾/dΠd\overline{\sigma}/d\Pi no longer directly depends on ΓX\Gamma_X and geig_e^i, and only depends on the electronic branching fraction, which appears as an overall scaling factor. Throughout this work we set B(X→e+e−)=1\mathcal{B}(X\to e^+e^-)=1. If the branching fraction is not equal to unity, any result can be easily rescaled by a simple multiplication.

Neutron-coupling reach for MAGIX@MESA

Next, we present projections for the reach of the neutron couplings for an experiment at MAGIX@MESA. We consider a signal significant if it is nσn_\sigma standard deviations over the QED background. Then, the reach at the nσn_\sigma confidence level is given by [11]

∣gnreach∣=[σQEDσX∣gn=1nσL×σQED]1/2,(26)\left|g_n^{\mathrm{reach}}\right| = \left[\frac{\sigma_{\mathrm{QED}}}{\sigma_X|_{g_n=1}}\frac{n_\sigma}{\sqrt{\mathcal{L}\times\sigma_{\mathrm{QED}}}}\right]^{1/2}, \tag*{(26)}

where σi\sigma_i are the integrated signal and background cross sections and we denote the integrated luminosity by L=∫dt LL=\int dt\,\mathcal{L}, with L\mathcal{L} the luminosity. Equation (26) implies an approximate scaling of the reach with the bin width like δmee\sqrt{\delta m_{ee}}.

The range over which we can integrate the signal and background cross sections is restricted by: a) the quasi-free neutron condition (13), b) the requirement that meem_{ee} falls into the correct bin (with width δmee=0.1 MeV/c2\delta m_{ee}=0.1\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2), and c) geometric constraints from MAGIX@MESA [30]. The latter limit ∣θ±∣≤165∘\lvert\theta_\pm\rvert\leq165^\circ and ∣θn∣≥5∘\lvert\theta_n\rvert\geq5^\circ. Even with these constraints the accessible phase space is much larger than can be realistically measured in a single run. To that end, we consider several more restrictive detector settings. Across all settings we fix

∣p±∣∈[10.0,100.0] MeV/c,\lvert\mathbf{p}_\pm\rvert\in[10.0,100.0]\ \mathrm{MeV}/c,
ϕ+∈[150.0∘,210.0∘],\phi_+\in[150.0^\circ,210.0^\circ],
ϕ−∈[−30.0∘,30.0∘],\phi_-\in[-30.0^\circ,30.0^\circ],
θn∈[−30.0∘,−5.0∘]∪[5.0∘,30.0∘],\theta_n\in[-30.0^\circ,-5.0^\circ]\cup[5.0^\circ,30.0^\circ],

and vary the other kinematic variables as outlined in Table I.

In all settings we only consider backward lepton kinematics because the signal-to-background ratio is considerably more favorable as compared to forward lepton kinematics. This is because in forward lepton kinematics the Bethe-Heitler part of the QED background increases, thereby significantly worsening the signal-to-background ratio.

We stress that the integration limits we provide are estimates. Naturally, they are to be refined once the parameters for the MAGIX@MESA setup are established. However, projections in Ref. [30] suggest our estimates are likely to be realistic. Furthermore, should there be any significant changes then our analysis can easily be repeated. Finally, note that in practice the lepton spectrometers are restricted to in-plane kinematics only [30]. To cover a larger range of ϕ±\phi_\pm one can equivalently measure the neutron at an out-of-plane angle.

We perform the integration using Monte Carlo integration with 10,000 integration points, at which results converge to within 1–2% of each other, which we deem to be sufficiently accurate for our purposes here. We use rejection sampling to implement the NQFP condition (13) and to ensure all events fall within the desired meem_{ee} bin [39].

The reach, assuming nσ=2n_\sigma=2, is shown in Figure 3, for a scalar (a), pseudoscalar (b), vector (c) and axial-vector (d) XX scenario. To calculate the reach we have taken the projected luminosity of MAGIX@MESA’s gas-jet target,

Figure 3. 2σ2\sigma reach plots for the effective neutron coupling assuming a scalar (a), pseudoscalar (b), vector (c) or axial-vector (d) boson, where any signal in the shaded yellow, orange, blue or cyan regions would be detectable. In all plots the bin width δmee=0.1\delta m_{ee} = 0.1 MeV/c2c^2 and the integrated luminosity L=7.2×108L = 7.2 \times10^8 nb−1^{-1}. Results may be easily rescaled using Eq. (26). The detector settings are given in Table I. Existing bounds from neutron-lead scattering [22, 35] are shown in gray, while bounds from the ATOMKI experiments at 17 MeV/c2c^2 are shown in purple. The latter are discussed in detail in Sec. VI and Figure 7. We note that for all scenarios there exist several bounds on either the difference of the neutron coupling and an (unbounded) proton coupling, and many bounds on parameters other than the neutron coupling. Both cannot be directly shown in the above figure. For further discussion regarding constraints on parameters other than the neutron coupling, see § 1.4 and, for instance, Refs. [2, 22, 23, 24, 36, 37, 38] and references therein.

SettingEγE_\gamma (MeV)θ±\theta_{\pm} (deg)meem_{ee} range (MeV/c2c^2)
1a55135.0–165.010.0–35.0
1b85135.0–165.015.0–50.0
1c105135.0–165.020.0–65.0
2105105.0–135.045.0–90.0

Table 1. The detector settings considered in this work, consistent with the projected values for MAGIX@MESA [30]. The meem_{ee} range follows immediately from mee2=(p++p−)2m_{ee}^{2} = (p_{+} + p_{-})^{2}, where we have rounded the range to the nearest multiple of 5 MeV/c2c^2. Note that limits similar to setting 2 but with a lower photon energy are fully covered by settings 1b and 1c.

L=1035L = 10^{35} cm−2^{-2} s−1^{-1} [30], together with a beam time of 2000 h, giving an integrated luminosity L=7.2×108L = 7.2 \times10^8 nb−1^{-1}. Of course, results in Figure 3 can easily be rescaled using Eq. (26) to account for different luminosities.

It is evident that a higher EγE_\gamma correlates with an improved reach, and the best (lowest) reach is obtained in the 20–85 MeV/c2c^2 range with Eγ=105E_\gamma= 105 MeV. To access masses ≲20\lesssim20 MeV/c2c^2 at Eγ=105E_\gamma= 105 MeV requires measurements in which the leptonic polar angles θ±\theta_{\pm} are further backwards than is geometrically feasible for the MAGIX@MESA setup. To access the lower mass region, one instead has to lower EγE_\gamma. As can be seen by comparing settings 1a–c, this unfortunately worsens the reach for the lower masses.

To further explore the relation between the reach and our kinematic variables, in Figure 4 we show several projections of the phase space (sampled 10,000 times) assuming a vector-like scenario for setting 1c, with δmee=0.1\delta m_{ee}=0.1 MeV/c2c^2 and mee=25m_{ee}=25, 4040 and 5555 MeV/c2c^2. In Figure 4 we have, at each kinematic point, taken the inverse of Eq. (26) using the differential cross section instead of the integrated cross section, yielding ∣reach∣−1|\mathrm{reach}|^{-1}. In addition, we have normalized each point to the maximum value of ∣reach∣−1|\mathrm{reach}|^{-1} out of the 10,000 sampled points, denoted by max⁡∣reach∣−1\max|\mathrm{reach}|^{-1}. We have checked, and broadly our conclusions also hold for other parity assignments, bin sizes and settings.

Projections of the phase space for detector setting 1c and $m_{ee}=25$, $40$ and $55$ MeV/$c^2$

Figure 4. Projections of the phase space from 10,000 uniformly sampled points specified by detector setting 1c (see Table I) for mee=25m_{ee}=25, 4040 and 5555 MeV/c2c^2 (left to right, respectively) and δmee=0.1\delta m_{ee}=0.1 MeV/c2c^2, assuming a vector-like scenario. The color code shows the inverse reach normalized to its maximum value of the considered sample (see Eq. (26)).

In Figure 4a one sees that a smaller meem_{ee} corresponds to more backward leptonic polar angles θ±\theta_{\pm}. This is because meem_{ee} is proportional to the relative angle between three-momentum of the lepton pair, meaning if meem_{ee} is small, this relative angle has to be small as well. It is also evident that backward lepton kinematics give a better reach than forward kinematics. The reason for this is, as previously mentioned, that in the forward regime the Bethe-Heitler contribution is enhanced, thus washing away the signal.

In Figure 4b we have plotted the lepton momenta ∣p±∣|\mathbf{p}_{\pm}|. Here one sees that higher momenta generally correlate to a better reach. In passing, let us also mention that projections in ϕ±\phi_{\pm} (not shown) are fairly evenly distributed.

Finally, in Figure 4c we have plotted the proton momentum ∣pp∣|\mathbf{p}_{p}| against the neutron angle θn\theta_{n}. For all meem_{ee} a clear pattern is visible: a lower protonic three-momentum corresponds to a better reach, which is not surprising. From Eq. (26) we see that the reach is determined by the signal-to-background ratio as well as the absolute size of the integrated QED cross section. The absolute value of the proton three-momenta enters the cross section in Ψ~M(pp)\widetilde{\Psi}_{M}(p_{p}). The most prominent contribution there, the deuteron s-wave function, is peaked at small momenta values. Thus, one obtains a larger cross section for small ∣pp∣|\mathbf{p}_{p}|, which is exactly reflected in Figure 4.

As an aside, we remark that a cut on small ∣pp∣|\mathbf{p}_{p}| would not be advantageous. We have checked that the gain in signal-to-background (the first fraction in Eq. (26)) is smaller than the loss in phase space (the second fraction in Eq. (26)) after placing the cut. Therefore, the net result is a worse reach. We discuss this further in Appendix C.

In Figure 5 we have plotted the differential cross section of the background and signal as a function of θn\theta_{n}. Here we assumed an axial-vector XX scenario with mX=17m_{X}=17 MeV/c2c^2, though similar conclusions hold for other parity assignments and masses as well. We fixed Eγ=105E_{\gamma}=105 MeV, δmee=0.1\delta m_{ee}=0.1 MeV/c2c^2 and the other kinematic variables to,

∣p+∣=65.7 MeV/c2,θ+=165.0∘,ϕ+=−180.0∘,|\mathbf{p}_{+}|=65.7\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2,\quad\theta_{+}=165.0^\circ,\quad\phi_{+}=-180.0^\circ,
∣p−∣=20.1 MeV/c2,θ−=165.0∘,ϕ−=0.0∘,|\mathbf{p}_{-}|=20.1\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2,\quad\theta_{-}=165.0^\circ,\quad\phi_{-}=0.0^\circ,
ϕn=0.0∘.\phi_{n}=0.0^\circ.

The QED background is shown in red. In the above kinematics mee=mXm_{ee}=m_{X}, leading to the enhanced signal shown in blue. For the blue curve, gnA=7×10−5g_{n}^{A}=7\times10^{-5}, while the light blue bands correspond to the range gnA=(5g_{n}^{A}=(5–9)×10−59)\times10^{-5}. The angular dependence shown in Figure 5 is typical for kinematics on the NQFP. The maximum of the peaked cross section corresponds approximately to the angle θn\theta_{n} at which ∣pp∣|\mathbf{p}_{p}| reaches its minimum, assuming all other kinematic variables are kept fixed.

Lastly, in Figure 6 we have plotted the integrated background and signal cross section for an axial-vector XX scenario as a function of meem_{ee}, with mX=30m_{X}=30 MeV/c2c^2 and δmee=0.1\delta m_{ee}=0.1 MeV/c2c^2 using detector setting 1c. Analogous results hold for different values of mXm_{X}, the bin width, and different parity assignments. The signal height is proportional to ∣gnA∣2|g_{n}^{A}|^2; for illustrative purposes only we have chosen gnA=10−5g_{n}^{A}=10^{-5}. In an experiment, the strongly-enhanced signal would clearly be visible inside a single bin.

Figure 6. The integrated signal (blue) and QED background (red) with uncertainties due to the neutron polarizabilities for mX=30 MeV/c2m_X = 30\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2, δmee=0.1 MeV/c2\delta m_{ee} = 0.1\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2 and gAn=10−5g_A^n = 10^{-5} using detector setting 1c (see Table I). A hypothetical axial-vector boson, XX, would show up inside a single bin where mee=mXm_{ee} = m_X.

We may compare the obtained reach with some available limits in the literature. As can be seen in Figure 3a, for the scalar scenario limits from Ref. [35],

∣gnS∣×(mX MeV/c2)−2≲2.1×10−5,(27)|g_{n}^{S}|\times(m_{X}\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2)^{-2}\lesssim2.1\times10^{-5}, \tag*{(27)}

already exclude the accessible parameter space.

Similarly, for a vector-like XX we have constraints from 208Pb{}^{208}\mathrm{Pb}-nn scattering [22], limiting

∣gnV∣×∣126208gnV+82208gpV∣×(mX MeV/c2)−4≲4.3×10−10.(28)\lvert g_n^V\rvert\times\left\lvert\frac{126}{208}g_n^V+\frac{82}{208}g_p^V\right\rvert\times(m_X\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2)^{-4} \lesssim4.3 \times10^{-10}. \tag*{(28)}

The intensive search program for the dark photon has yielded strong bounds on the proton coupling [12], which we may reinterpret as bounds on a more general vector XX [40],

∣gpV∣≲2.5×10−4.(29)\lvert g_p^V\rvert\lesssim2.5 \times10^{-4}. \tag*{(29)}

Combining both constraints implies

∣gnV∣×(mX MeV/c2)−2≲4.3×10−6,(30)\lvert g_n^V\rvert\times(m_X\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2)^{-2} \lesssim4.3 \times10^{-6}, \tag*{(30)}

which also already excludes the accessible parameter space, as can be seen in Figure 3c.

For a pseudoscalar XX current limits on the nucleon coupling are given in terms of the isovector coupling [36],

∣gpP−gnP∣≲1.2×10−3.(31)\lvert g_p^P-g_n^P\rvert\lesssim1.2 \times10^{-3}. \tag*{(31)}

Such an inequality may be easily satisfied if the proton and neutron coupling are of a similar order, so the purely-neutron exclusion limits one gets from γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^+e^-pn become relevant again.

A similar situation arises for an axial-vector XX, where, out of all parity assignments, the couplings are least constrained. The strictest bounds comes from the KTeV anomaly [22, 41],

1.3×10−10≤(gpA−gnA)geA(mX MeV/c2)2≤5.2×10−10,(32)1.3 \times10^{-10} \le\frac{(g_p^A-g_n^A)g_e^A}{(m_X\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2)^2} \le5.2 \times10^{-10}, \tag*{(32)}

where the upper and lower bounds are given in units of (MeV/c2)−2(\mathrm{MeV}/c^2)^{-2}. The electron coupling can be estimated to be

geA=±(1.52±0.31)×10−4,(33)g_e^A = \pm(1.52 \pm0.31) \times10^{-4}, \tag*{(33)}

which gives two possible bands in which the neutron coupling may fall (see Figure 7 in Sec. VI and Figure 5 of Refs. [22, 24]). Moreover, just as the pseudoscalar coupling, one can fine-tune the proton and neutron couplings to largely evade the bound on their difference. Therefore, bounds solely on the neutron coupling would be a very welcome complement to the constraints given above.

Allowed parameter space for vector and axial-vector X17

Figure 7. The 1σ1\sigma (dark) and 2σ2\sigma (light) allowed parameter space for a vector (a) or axial-vector (b) X17. Projections from γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn from Figure 3 are shown in yellow. As can also be seen in Figure 3, for the vector case, this constraint is subdominant to other constraints. The 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}, 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} and 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C}-derived constraints are given in orange, red and pink, respectively, where we use the isospin mixing angle θ1+=0.35(8)∘\theta_{1+} = 0.35(8)^\circ for the 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be} states (see Sec. VI). A different mixing angle rotates the 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be} bands around the origin. For the vector scenario additional constraints from NA48/2 [12] and lead-neutron scattering [35] are shown in green and gray, respectively. Pion decay constraints [24] are shown in blue, where the upper and lower bands correspond to a positive and negative electron coupling, respectively. For the axial-vector scenario additional constraints from the KTeV anomaly [41] and pion decay [24] are shown in green and blue respectively, where the upper bands corresponds to a positive electron coupling and the lower bands to a negative electron coupling.

On the other hand, one should also consider recent results from the isotope-shift analysis of Xenon [17] (and similar systems [16, 42]). At low energies both a pseudoscalar and an axial-vector interaction are described by a Yukawa potential in position space [43]. When included in isotope shift analyses, one obtains bounds on the product of the electron and neutron couplings. These bounds typically go up to 1 MeV/c21\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2 and are of O(10−11)\mathcal{O}(10^{-11}). If we extrapolate them to our energy range, we get an order-of-magnitude estimate for ∣gegn∣≲O(10−9)\lvert g_e g_n\rvert\lesssim\mathcal{O}(10^{-9}). Current bounds on the electron coupling are O(10−4)\mathcal{O}(10^{-4}) [36], which would mean the isotope-shift analyses would give limits on the neutron coupling of O(10−5)\mathcal{O}(10^{-5}), much stricter than the ones we get in Figure 3b and d. Of course, it remains an open question whether atomic methods can be improved enough to access the 1010–100 MeV/c2100\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2 mass range any time soon.

Next, we discuss how one may further improve the bounds in Figure 3. A possible approach would be to decrease δmee\delta m_{ee}. However, given that halving δmee\delta m_{ee} to 0.05 MeV/c20.05\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^2 only gives an improvement of the reach with a factor ∼1/2\sim1/\sqrt{2}, significant improvements from this area are unlikely. As previously stated and demonstrated in Appendix § 1.3.3, the reach can also be enhanced by increasing the measured phase space. Given that the ranges given in Table I already represent (roughly) the largest ranges that would be realistically possible for MAGIX@MESA to measure, the only remaining variable is the integrated luminosity. As we already consider a fairly long experiment given our choice of 2000 hours, we turn to the luminosity. It is unlikely that L\mathcal{L} of the gas-jet target with a deuteron gas can be increased enough at MAGIX@MESA to make up the difference, as the luminosity enters as L−1/4\mathcal{L}^{-1/4} into the reach. However, the gas-jet target does allow for different gases with more neutrons—for example Xenon, with around 80 neutrons. One naively expects the luminosity (and by extension the reach) to scale with the number of available neutrons. To that end, interesting further research would be to investigate the coupling limits around the NQFP of a more neutron-rich system.

In sum, deuteron photodisintegration gives competitive limits on the neutron coupling for a pseudoscalar or axial vector XX, though it is likely that in the future methods such as isotope-shift spectroscopy will yield improved limits. That being said, whereas other methods give limits on the product of gng_n with another coupling, an extraction using γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn gives limits directly on gng_n. Moreover, it is expected that by replacing the deuteron with a more neutron-rich system the reach can be improved further.

As mentioned in the introduction, recent results of the ATOMKI collaboration have garnered significant theoretical and experimental interest; in a series of experiments [19, 20, 21, 44] the collaboration claims to have found evidence of a new, light boson dubbed X17.

The ATOMKI collaboration looked at internal pair creation in decays of excited 8Be^{8}\mathrm{Be}, 4He^{4}\mathrm{He} and, recently, 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} nuclei. In all three cases, an anomalous bump was found in the distribution of the emitted electron-positron pair’s relative angle, with a statistical significance consistently exceeding 6σ6\sigma (see Ref. [45] for a review). Working with members of the ATOMKI collaboration, researchers at VNU University of Science claim to have independently verified the original 8Be^{8}\mathrm{Be} measurements [46].

In the Standard Model, nuclear transitions in which an e+e−e^{+}e^{-} pair is emitted are mediated by electromagnetic interactions and are well understood. They are sensitive to new physics appearing at the MeV scale, and thus the ATOMKI collaboration attributes their anomaly to the as-of-yet unseen X17, with a reported averaged mass around 17.02(10) MeV/c217.02(10)\ \mathrm{MeV}/c^{2} [19, 20, 21]. Assuming definite parity, the beryllium results indicate X17 can be a pseudoscalar, vector or axial-vector particle [47], while the carbon results point to a scalar, vector or axial-vector particle [22]. Theoretically, based on the 8Be^{8}\mathrm{Be} decays, models for X17 have been developed for the pseudoscalar, vector and axial-vector cases [36, 37, 40, 48, 49] that attempt to explain the ATOMKI anomalies while conforming to existing exclusion bounds. In particular, according to the vector model put forward by Feng et al. [40, 50] X17 additionally must be protophobic (couple weakly to protons) to meet existing bounds from the NA48/2 experiment [12]. Experimentally, a global effort is underway to scrutinize the results of the ATOMKI anomaly, with new experiments at facilities such as C2PAC [51], MEG II at the PSI [52], JLAB [53], New JEDI [54], among many others [45].

We investigate how the neutron-coupling limits from deuteron photodisintegration discussed above can be of added value in the current search for X17. To estimate the coupling of X17 to the nucleon we compare models by Alves and Weiner [36] for the pseudoscalar case, by Feng et al. [40] for the vector case and by Kozaczuk et al. [37] for the axial-vector case. To match their notation with ours we have

gXNN(0)=(gpP+gnP)/2,gXNN(1)=(gpP−gnP)/2,g_{XNN}^{(0)} = (g_p^P + g_n^P)/2,\qquad g_{XNN}^{(1)} = (g_p^P - g_n^P)/2,
ϵf=gfV/e,\epsilon_f = g_f^V/e,
af=gfA,a_f = g_f^A,

for f=pf=p, nn and ee.

We can constrain X17’s couplings by using the branching fractions of the 8Be^{8}\mathrm{Be} and 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} decays reported by the ATOMKI collaboration [19, 21],

ΓXΓγ∣8Be(18.15)=6(1)×10−6,(34)\left.\frac{\Gamma_X}{\Gamma_\gamma}\right|_{^{8}\mathrm{Be}(18.15)} = 6(1)\times10^{-6}, \tag*{(34)}
ΓXΓγ∣12C(17.23)=3.6(3)×10−6.(35)\left.\frac{\Gamma_X}{\Gamma_\gamma}\right|_{^{12}\mathrm{C}(17.23)} = 3.6(3)\times10^{-6}. \tag*{(35)}

as well as from the branching fraction of 4He^{4}\mathrm{He} decays. The latter are more complicated with furthers details given in Refs. [20, 22, 55]. Because the couplings of X17 have been extensively discussed in other works we shall only give a brief summary. For more details we refer the reader to the relevant papers.

The 8Be(18.15)^{8}\mathrm{Be}(18.15) state, which is predominately isoscalar, is isospin mixed with the 8Be(17.64)^{8}\mathrm{Be}(17.64) state, which is predominately isovector. In our analysis we parameterize this isospin mixing with an isospin-mixing angle, θ1+\theta_{1+}, and an isospin-breaking parameter, κ\kappa [40]. Following Ref. [36], we take θ1+=0.35(8)∘\theta_{1+}=0.35(8)^{\circ}, whence κ=0.681\kappa=0.681 [40].

For a pseudoscalar X17 scenario, results from the SINDRUM collaboration [13] put a strong bound on the isovector coupling,

∣gXNN(1)∣≤0.6×10−3.(36)\left|g_{XNN}^{(1)}\right| \leq0.6\times10^{-3}. \tag*{(36)}

By following the procedure described in Ref. [36] we derive bounds on the isoscalar coupling from Eq. (34). This gives

∣gXNN(0)∣=(2.0–5.4)×10−3,∣gXNN(1)∣=(0.0–0.6)×10−3.\left|g_{XNN}^{(0)}\right|=(2.0\text{--}5.4)\times10^{-3},\qquad\left|g_{XNN}^{(1)}\right|=(0.0\text{--}0.6)\times10^{-3}.

Clearly, from Figure 3b our projected limits from deuteron photodisintegration for a pseudoscalar X17 are not competitive.

For a vector X17 scenario the constraint provided by the NA48/2 experiment [12] leads to the protophobia condition (the green band in Figure 7a),

∣εp∣≤1.2×10−3.(37)|\varepsilon_p| \le1.2 \times10^{-3}. \tag*{(37)}

We derive the remaining neutron coupling from the 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be} data as outlined in Ref. [40], and from the 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} data using [22]

ΓXΓγ∣12C(17.23)=kΔE(1+mX22ΔE2)∣εp−εn∣2,(38)\frac{\Gamma_X}{\Gamma_\gamma}\bigg|_{{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(17.23)} = \frac{k}{\Delta E}\left(1+\frac{m_X^2}{2\Delta E^2}\right)|\varepsilon_p-\varepsilon_n|^2, \tag*{(38)}

where k=ΔE2−mX2k = \sqrt{\Delta E^2-m_X^2}. We find

8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}: ∣εn∣=(1.1−1.7)×10−2|\varepsilon_n| = (1.1-1.7) \times10^{-2}

12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C}: ∣εn∣=(2.6−5.3)×10−3|\varepsilon_n| = (2.6-5.3) \times10^{-3}

The projected limits from γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn, shown in Figure 3, would have to be improved by at least a factor of two to test these couplings. This is also visible in Figure 7a, where the γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn projections span the entire parameter space.

In passing, we remark that like Refs. [22, 23, 24], we find some tension between the carbon, beryllium and helium results for a vector-like X17. The neutron couplings only overlap when the uncertainty of the 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be} results is increased to around 3σ3\sigma (see the orange, red and pink bands in Figure 7a). In view of this there is an ongoing discussion in the literature surrounding X17’s couplings. There is a general consensus that, as it stands, one cannot explain the 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}, 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} and 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} anomalies simultaneously without introducing some form of tension (see Refs. [23, 24] for more discussion thereon. From pion decays, the blue bands in Figure 7a, one may obtain additional constraints which increase the tension even more). Our carbon-derived neutron couplings agree with Ref. [23], which would indicate that one should critically re-examine the beryllium data; a similar finding is echoed in Ref. [24]. A possible resolution of the discrepancy would be if X17 simply is not a vector particle. If X17 exists, and if it were in truth an axial vector, then interpreting its axial couplings as vector couplings would, naturally, lead to erroneous results.

To derive couplings for the scenario of an axial-vector X17 we need its nuclear matrix elements. For the beryllium transition we take the matrix elements as calculated in Ref. [37],

⟨8Be(g.s.)∥σ^(p)∥8Be(18.15)⟩=(−0.38±2.19)×10−2,\langle{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}(\mathrm{g.s.})\Vert\hat{\sigma}^{(p)}\Vert{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}(18.15)\rangle= (-0.38 \pm2.19) \times10^{-2},
⟨8Be(g.s.)∥σ^(n)∥8Be(18.15)⟩=(−10±2.6)×10−2,\langle{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}(\mathrm{g.s.})\Vert\hat{\sigma}^{(n)}\Vert{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}(18.15)\rangle= (-10 \pm2.6) \times10^{-2},

which may be used in [22]

ΓX∣8Be(18.15)=kX18π[2+(ΔE/mX)2]×∣⟨8Be(g.s.)∥apσ^(p)+anσ^(n)∥8Be(18.15)⟩∣2.(39)\Gamma_{X\vert{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}(18.15)} = \frac{k_X}{18\pi}\left[2+\left(\Delta E/m_X\right)^2\right] \times\left\lvert\langle{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}(\mathrm{g.s.})\Vert a_p\hat{\sigma}^{(p)}+a_n\hat{\sigma}^{(n)}\Vert{}^{8}\mathrm{Be}(18.15)\rangle\right\rvert^2. \tag*{(39)}

Because there are no bounds on the proton coupling or neutron coupling individually, the axial vector coupling is only loosely constrained. Even taking into account the additional KTeV anomaly (32) (the green bands in Figure 7b) still leaves a large part of the parameter space accessible.

Unlike the beryllium decay, the required axial carbon matrix element, ⟨12C(g.s.)∥D^σ3∥12C(17.23)⟩\langle{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(\mathrm{g.s.})\Vert\hat{D}_{\sigma}^{3}\Vert{}^{12}\mathrm{C}(17.23)\rangle, with D^σ3\hat{D}_{\sigma}^{3} the corresponding spin dipole operator, is not known [22]. This relates back to the aforementioned tension. We view the computation of ⟨D^σ3⟩\langle\hat{D}_{\sigma}^{3}\rangle as a pressing open problem. Its resolution would immediately tell us whether one has a true discrepancy between the carbon and beryllium results—there would be no overlap between the carbon and beryllium measurements in the parameter space of the axial-vector couplings—or whether one has merely misinterpreted the data. Order-of-magnitude estimates suggest that the 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be} and 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} data could be harmonized using an axial vector X17 [22].

Following the analyses in Refs. [22, 24] we summarize the aforementioned constraints in Figure 7 for the two most promising X17 scenarios, vector and axial-vector, with projected limits from Figure 3 overlaid on top. Note that, unlike in Figure 3, here the shaded regions indicate allowed regions of the parameter space. Our 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be} limits differ slightly from Refs. [22, 24] as we use a different mixing angle θ1+\theta_{1+}. We have checked that when using their mixing angle we recover the their results. The actual value of the mixing angle has not been pinned down exactly (for example Refs. [36, 37, 40] use different values, see also the discussion in Ref. [23]), meaning the available parameter space may be slightly larger than shown in Figure 7. For both the vector and axial-vector scenarios, changing the mixing angle effectively rotates the 8Be{}^{8}\mathrm{Be} bands around the origin. Especially for the axial-vector scenario limits from γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn would constrain to what extent this rotation is permissible.

In summary, if a calculation of the axial transition matrix element of 12C(17.23){}^{12}\mathrm{C}(17.23) to the ground state remains outstanding, constraints from γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn would be subdominant for a vector X17 scenario, but for what is at present the most likely X17 scenario, an axial vector, helpful to limit the available coupling range.

Summary and outlook

Low-mass dark sector searches are a very active area of research, fueled further by possible sightings of a new 17 MeV/c2c^2 boson, X17. Compared to the electron and proton couplings, the coupling of a new boson in the 10–100 MeV/c2c^2 mass range to the neutron is poorly constrained. To that end, we studied the efficacy of the deuteron photodisintegration process γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn at MAGIX@MESA in limiting the effective coupling of a new scalar, pseudoscalar, vector or axial-vector boson in the 10–100 MeV/c2c^2 mass range, using kinematics corresponding to quasi-free production on a neutron. It turns out that for a scalar or vector scenario other methods yield better constraints on the neutron coupling. However, for a pseudoscalar and axial vector scenario current bounds only limit the difference between the proton and neutron coupling. In this case, deuteron photodisintegration has the potential to yield limits directly on the neutron coupling. Specifically, for the axial vector scenario our projections from γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn yield competitive constraints for the neutron coupling in light of X17.

Furthermore, besides providing exclusion limits on the neutron, via the reaction γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn one can also study the neutron polarizabilities, as has been previously done using γd→γpn\gamma d \to\gamma pn [27, 28]. Such a study would be a worthwhile extension of the present work.

Acknowledgments

The authors thank S. Schlimme, D. Barducci and C. Toni for helpful communications. This work was supported by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation), in part through the Research Unit [Photon-photon interactions in the Standard Model and beyond, Projekt­nummer 458854507 - FOR 5327], and in part through the Cluster of Excellence [Precision Physics, Fundamental Interactions, and Structure of Matter] (PRISMA+ EXC 2118/1) within the German Excellence Strategy (Project ID 39083149).

Calculation of the QED background

Conventions

Our computation of the QED background starts with the QED vertex following from the QED interaction Lagrangian. In our convention,

LQED=−JμAμ=eψˉγμψAμ,(40)\mathcal{L}_{\mathrm{QED}}=-J_{\mu}A^{\mu}=e\bar{\psi}\gamma^{\mu}\psi A_{\mu}, \tag*{(40)}

The photon nucleon vertex Γqμ\Gamma^\mu_q is defined as

⟨N(p′)∣Jμ(0)∣N(p)⟩=−euˉ(p′)Γqμu(p)=−euˉ(p′)[F1(q2)γμ+i2mNF2(q2)σμνqν]u(p),(41)\begin{aligned} \langle N(p') \mid J^\mu(0) \mid N(p) \rangle= -e\bar{u}(p')\Gamma^\mu_q u(p) \\ &= -e\bar{u}(p')\left[F_1(q^2)\gamma^\mu+\frac{i}{2m_N}F_2(q^2)\sigma^{\mu\nu}q_\nu\right]u(p), \tag*{(41)} \end{aligned}

where N=p,nN=p,n and Jμ(x)J^\mu(x) is the electromagnetic current operator, with q=p′−pq=p'-p. For the Dirac and Pauli form factors, F1F_1 and F2F_2 respectively, we use the parametrization given in Ref. [56].

Bethe-Heitler amplitude

The tree-level diagram for the Bethe-Heitler process is shown in Figure 2a. The amplitude is given by

Figure 2. Below the pion production threshold the reaction γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^{+}e^{-}pn is described by the Bethe-Heitler process (a), the Born process (b), π0\pi^0 t-channel exchange (c) and non-Born neutron scalar polarizability contributions (d). Crossed diagrams for the Bethe-Heitler and Born processes are not shown explicitly. All diagrams are embedded in the quasi-free neutron blob in Fig. 1.

MBH=ie3(q−q′)2ϵμ(q,λ)LBHμνHBHνBHν,(42)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{BH}}=\frac{ie^3}{(q-q')^2}\epsilon_\mu(q,\lambda)L_{\mathrm{BH}}^{\mu\nu}H_{\mathrm{BH}\nu}^{\phantom{\mathrm{BH}\nu}}, \tag*{(42)}

where ϵμ\epsilon^\mu is the photon polarization vector, with

LBHμν=uˉ(p−,s−){γμ(̸p−−q̸+me−2p−⋅q)γν+γν(q̸−̸p++me−2p+⋅q)γμ}v(p+,s+),(43)L_{\mathrm{BH}}^{\mu\nu}=\bar{u}(p_-,s_-)\left\{\gamma^\mu\left(\frac{\not{p}_--\not{q}+m_e}{-2p_-\cdot q}\right)\gamma^\nu+\gamma^\nu\left(\frac{\not{q}-\not{p}_++m_e}{-2p_+\cdot q}\right)\gamma^\mu\right\}v(p_+,s_+), \tag*{(43)}
HBHν=uˉ(pn,sn)Γq−q′νu(p~n,s~n).(44)H_{\mathrm{BH}}^\nu=\bar{u}(p_n,s_n)\Gamma^\nu_{q-q'}u(\widetilde{p}_n,\widetilde{s}_n). \tag*{(44)}

Born amplitude

The tree-level Born amplitude is shown in Figure 2b, and its amplitude is given by

MBorn=−ie3q2ϵμ(q,λ)LBornBornHBornμν,(45)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{Born}}=-\frac{ie^3}{q^2}\epsilon_\mu(q,\lambda)L_{\mathrm{Born}}^{\mathrm{Born}}H_{\mathrm{Born}}^{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(45)}

where

LBornν=uˉ(p−,s−)γνv(p+,s+),(46)L_{\mathrm{Born}}^\nu=\bar{u}(p_-,s_-)\gamma^\nu v(p_+,s_+), \tag*{(46)}
HBornμν=uˉ(pn,sn){Γq−q′ν̸p~n+q̸+mN(p~n+q)2−mN2Γqμ+Γqμ̸p~n−̸q′+mN(p~n−q′)2−mN2Γ−q′ν}u(p~n,s~n),(47)H_{\mathrm{Born}}^{\mu\nu}=\bar{u}(p_n,s_n)\left\{\Gamma^\nu_{q-q'}\frac{\not{\widetilde{p}}_n+\not{q}+m_N}{(\widetilde{p}_n+q)^2-m_N^2}\Gamma^\mu_q+\Gamma^\mu_q\frac{\not{\widetilde{p}}_n-\not{q}'+m_N}{(\widetilde{p}_n-q')^2-m_N^2}\Gamma^\nu_{-q'}\right\}u(\widetilde{p}_n,\widetilde{s}_n), \tag*{(47)}

with Γqμ\Gamma^\mu_q given in Eq. (41).

Pion-pole amplitude

For the pion-pole contribution we need the pion-photon and pion-nucleon vertices. The pion-photon vertex follows from

Lπ0γγ=e24Fπ0γγFμνF~μνπ0,(48)\mathcal{L}_{\pi^0\gamma\gamma}=\frac{e^2}{4}F_{\pi^0\gamma\gamma}F^{\mu\nu}\widetilde{F}_{\mu\nu}\pi^0, \tag*{(48)}

where F~μν=12ϵμναβFαβ\widetilde{F}_{\mu\nu}=\frac{1}{2}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}F^{\alpha\beta} and Fπ0γγ(0)=1/(4π2fπ)F_{\pi^0\gamma\gamma}(0)=1/(4\pi^2f_\pi), with FμνF^{\mu\nu} the photon field strength and fπ≈92.4 MeVf_\pi\approx92.4\ \mathrm{MeV} the pion decay constant. Our convention is ϵ0123=+1\epsilon_{0123}=+1. The photon-nucleon vertex follows from

LπNN=gπNNNˉπaτaiγ5N,(49)\mathcal{L}_{\pi NN}=g_{\pi NN}\bar{N}\pi^a\tau^a i\gamma_5N, \tag*{(49)}

where τa\tau^a are the Pauli matrices, N=(p,n)N=(p,n) and gπNN=gAmN/fπg_{\pi NN}=g_Am_N/f_\pi, with the axial-vector coupling from nuclear β\beta-decay gA=1.27g_A=1.27. The pion-pole amplitude is shown in Figure 2c, and is given by

Mπ0=−Fπ0γγgπNNie3q′2ϵμ(q,λ)Lπ0νHμνπ0,(50)\mathcal{M}_{\pi^0}=-F_{\pi^0\gamma\gamma}g_{\pi NN}\frac{ie^3}{q'^2}\epsilon^\mu(q,\lambda)L_{\pi^0}^\nu H_{\mu\nu}^{\pi^0}, \tag*{(50)}

where

Lπ0ν=uˉ(p−,s−)γνv(p+,s+),(51)L_{\pi^0}^\nu=\bar{u}(p_-,s_-)\gamma^\nu v(p_+,s_+), \tag*{(51)}
Hμνπ0=i(q−q′)2−mπ2ϵμναβq′βuˉ(pn,sn)γ5u(p~n,s~n).(52)H_{\mu\nu}^{\pi^0}=\frac{i}{(q-q')^2-m_\pi^2}\epsilon_{\mu\nu\alpha\beta}q'^\beta\bar{u}(p_n,s_n)\gamma_5u(\widetilde{p}_n,\widetilde{s}_n). \tag*{(52)}

Non-Born neutron polarizability amplitude

Lastly, we account for nucleon polarizability contributions following the formalism in Ref. [57]. In short, one may parameterize the unpolarized Compton process, N(k)γ(q)→N(k′)γ(q′)N(k)\gamma(q)\to N(k')\gamma(q'), often subtracting the Born and pion exchange contribution, with 18 independent tensors TiμνT_i^{\mu\nu} and their corresponding coefficients Bi(q2,q′2,q⋅q′,q⋅P)B_i(q^2,q'^2,q\cdot q',q\cdot P), where P=12(k+k′)P=\frac{1}{2}(k+k'). For unpolarized real Compton scattering only two tensors contribute (see Appendix § 1.3.1 in Ref. [57]),

MRCS,spin avg.μν=B1(0,0,q⋅q′,q⋅P)T1μν+B2(0,0,q⋅q′,q⋅P)T2μν,(53)M_{\mathrm{RCS,spin\ avg.}}^{\mu\nu}=B_1(0,0,q\cdot q',q\cdot P)T_1^{\mu\nu}+B_2(0,0,q\cdot q',q\cdot P)T_2^{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(53)}

where

T1μν=−(q⋅q′)gμν+q′μqν,(54)T_1^{\mu\nu}=-(q\cdot q')g^{\mu\nu}+q'^\mu q^\nu, \tag*{(54)}
T2μν=(2mNν)2(−gμν+q′μqνk⋅q)(55)T_2^{\mu\nu}=(2m_N\nu)^2\left(-g^{\mu\nu}+\frac{q'^\mu q^\nu}{k\cdot q}\right) \tag*{(55)}
−4(q⋅q′)(Pμ−q⋅Pq⋅q′q′μ)(Pν−q⋅Pq⋅q′q′ν),(56)-4(q\cdot q')\left(P^\mu-\frac{q\cdot P}{q\cdot q'}q'^\mu\right)\left(P^\nu-\frac{q\cdot P}{q\cdot q'}q'^\nu\right), \tag*{(56)}

with ν=(q⋅P)/mN\nu=(q\cdot P)/m_N. The low-energy expansions for B1B_1 and B2B_2 are given by

B1(0,0,q⋅q′,q⋅P)=1αβM1,(57)B_1(0,0,q\cdot q',q\cdot P)=\frac{1}{\alpha}\beta_{M1}, \tag*{(57)}
B2(0,0,q⋅q′,q⋅P)=−1α1(2mN)2(αE1+βM1),(58)B_2(0,0,q\cdot q',q\cdot P)=-\frac{1}{\alpha}\frac{1}{(2m_N)^2}(\alpha_{E1}+\beta_{M1}), \tag*{(58)}

where the values for the neutron polarizabilities are [2]

βM1n=(3.7±1.2)×10−4 fm3,\beta_{M1}^n=(3.7\pm1.2)\times10^{-4}\ \mathrm{fm}^3,
αE1n+βM1n=(15.2±0.5)×10−4 fm3.\alpha_{E1}^n+\beta_{M1}^n=(15.2\pm0.5)\times10^{-4}\ \mathrm{fm}^3.

The polarizability amplitude is illustrated in Figure 2d and given by

MPol.=−ie3q′2εμ(q,λ)LPol.νHμνPol.,(59)\mathcal{M}_{\mathrm{Pol.}}=-\frac{\mathrm{i}e^3}{q'^2}\varepsilon^\mu(q,\lambda)L_{\mathrm{Pol.}}^\nu H_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{Pol.}}, \tag*{(59)}

with

LPol.ν=uˉ(p−,s−)γνv(p+,s+)(60)L_{\mathrm{Pol.}}^\nu=\bar{u}(p_-,s_-)\gamma^\nu v(p_+,s_+) \tag*{(60)}
HμνPol.=uˉ(pn,sn)MμνRCS, spin avg.u(pn~,sn~).(61)H_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{Pol.}}=\bar{u}(p_n,s_n)M_{\mu\nu}^{\mathrm{RCS,\ spin\ avg.}}u(p_{\widetilde{n}},s_{\widetilde{n}}). \tag*{(61)}

where the blob in Figure 1 indicates the polarizability contribution. Note that in our case q′2≪1\sqrt{q'^2}\ll1 GeV, so using the real Compton amplitude in place of the single-virtual Compton amplitude is a very good approximation.

Verification of the QED background

In general, there is no calculation of the QED background of γd→e+e−pn\gamma d \to e^+e^-pn that we can directly compare to. However, there has been a calculation of the QED background in γd→γpn\gamma d \to\gamma pn [28]. Up to phase-space factors this is, in principle, identical to our calculation with the Bethe–Heitler contribution removed. Therefore, it can serve as a useful intermediate cross check. Of course, the methods used in Ref. [28] are not identical to our methods, so we cannot expect a completely identical result. Nevertheless, our results should agree to at least the same order of magnitude.

To that end, we have repeated the PWIA calculation of Ref. [28]. Using their notation, we have computed the in-plane differential cross section dσ/dΩγ′dΩnTnd\sigma/d\Omega_{\gamma'}d\Omega_nT_n as a function of TnT_n, where TnT_n is the kinetic energy of the outgoing neutron and Ωγ′\Omega_{\gamma'} and Ωn\Omega_n are the solid angles of the outgoing photon and neutron, respectively (see Ref. [28] for details of the calculation). This is shown in Figure 8 and should be compared to the dotted line in Fig. 5a of Ref. [28]. As can be seen, both calculations agree, giving a useful cross check of our QED background.

Figure 8. The in-plane differential cross section of γd→γpn\gamma d \to\gamma pn as a function of the neutron kinetic energy, TnT_n. We fix Eγ=100E_\gamma= 100 MeV, θγ′=135∘\theta_{\gamma}' = 135^\circ and θn=−20∘\theta_n = -20^\circ.

Dependence reach of neutron coupling on integration range

From Eq. (26) it is clear that the reach of the coupling of XX to the neutron depends on the size of the phase space we integrate over. Given that the detector settings in Table I are estimates, it is important to see to what degree changing the accessible phase space influences the reach. The ranges of ∣p±∣|\mathbf{p}_\pm| are unlikely to change in the final MAGIX@MESA setup, and cutting the range of θn\theta_n has little influence on the reach (see Sec. V). Therefore, we focus on the influence of θ±\theta_\pm, ϕ±\phi_\pm and EγE_\gamma.

The general trend is that increasing the available phase space improves the reach, albeit with diminishing returns. This is illustrated in Figure 9. Here, we take detector setting 2 (with mX=65m_X = 65 MeV/c2c^2 and δmX=0.1\delta m_X = 0.1 MeV/c2c^2) and either increase the integration range of ϕ±\phi_\pm or θ±\theta_\pm symmetrically,

Figure 9. The dependence of the reach on the size of the integrated phase space for a vector-like XX normalized to its value at the start of the xx-axis. Here we vary (a) EγE_\gamma, (b) ϕ±\phi_\pm or (c) θ±\theta_\pm while keeping the rest of the kinematic variables fixed to detector setting 2 (see text). We set mX=65m_X = 65 MeV/c2c^2 and δmX=0.1\delta m_X = 0.1 MeV/c2c^2.

ϕ+∈[180∘−Δϕ±,180∘+Δϕ±],\phi_+ \in[180^\circ-\Delta\phi_\pm,180^\circ+\Delta\phi_\pm],
ϕ−∈[−Δϕ±,Δϕ±],\phi_- \in[-\Delta\phi_\pm,\Delta\phi_\pm],

or

θ±∈[120∘−Δθ±,120∘+Δθ±],(62)\theta_\pm\in[120^\circ-\Delta\theta_\pm,120^\circ+\Delta\theta_\pm], \tag*{(62)}

respectively, keeping the other parameters fixed. We have assumed a vector-like scenario, however we have checked that the same conclusions hold for the other parity assignments.

In Figure 9a we see that, as a function of EγE_{\gamma}, the reach has an optimum. The reason here is that shifting the energy roughly corresponds to translating the exclusion limits in Figure 3—at a certain point one hits the kinematic boundaries.

In Figure 9b we see that increasing the integration range to be more out of plane quickly increases the reach, before flattening out. A similar trend is visible in Figure 9c, when one increases the range of the polar angles. So, if one integrates over a very small part of the phase space, it is worthwhile to try to access more. If one already can integrate over a large area of phase space, increasing the phase space further is not as useful.

References

References

  1. [1]E. Aprile et al. (XENON), Dark matter search results from a one ton-year exposure of XENON1T, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 111302 (2018), arXiv:1805.12562 [astro-ph.CO].DOI
  2. [2]R. L. Workman et al. (Particle Data Group), Review of particle physics, PTEP 2022, 083C01 (2022).
  3. [3]J. Beacham et al., Physics beyond colliders at CERN: beyond the Standard Model Working Group report, J. Phys. G 47, 010501 (2020).DOI
  4. [4]P. Agrawal et al., Feebly-interacting particles: FIPs 2020 workshop report, Eur. Phys. J. C 81, 1015 (2021).
  5. [5]N. Arkani-Hamed, D. P. Finkbeiner, T. R. Slatyer, and N. Weiner, A theory of dark matter, Phys. Rev. D 79, 015014 (2009), arXiv:0810.0713 [hep-ph].
  6. [6]R. Essig et al., Working group report: new light weakly coupled particles, in Snowmass 2013: Snowmass on the Mississippi (2013) arXiv:1311.0029 [hep-ph].
  7. [7]J. Alexander et al., Dark Sectors 2016 Workshop: community report (2016) arXiv:1608.08632 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/1608.08632
  8. [8]G. Lanfranchi, M. Pospelov, and P. Schuster, The Search for feebly interacting particles, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 71, 279 (2021), arXiv:2011.02157 [hep-ph].DOI
  9. [9]M. Freytsis, G. Ovanesyan, and J. Thaler, Dark force detection in low energy e-p collisions, JHEP 01, 111, arXiv:0909.2862 [hep-ph].
  10. [10]R. Essig, P. Schuster, N. Toro, and B. Wojtsekhow​ski, An electron fixed target experiment to search for a new vector boson A′ decaying to e+e−, JHEP 02, 009, arXiv:1001.2557 [hep-ph].
  11. [11]T. Beranek, H. Merkel, and M. Vanderhaeghen, Theoretical framework to analyze searches for hidden light gauge bosons in electron scattering fixed target experiments, Phys. Rev. D 88, 015032 (2013), arXiv:1303.2540 [hep-ph].DOI
  12. [12]J. R. Batley et al. (NA48/2), Search for the dark photon in π0 decays, Phys. Lett. B 746, 178 (2015).
  13. [13]R. Eichler et al. (SINDRUM), Limits for short-lived neutral particles emitted in μ+ or π+ decay, Phys. Lett. B 175, 101 (1986).DOI
  14. [14]E. Rrapaj and S. Reddy, Nucleon-nucleon bremsstrahlung of dark gauge bosons and revised supernova constraints, Phys. Rev. C 94, 045805 (2016), arXiv:1511.09136 [nucl-th].
  15. [15]J. M. Berryman, S. Gardner, and M. Zakeri, Neutron stars with baryon number violation, probing dark sectors, Symmetry 14, 518 (2022), arXiv:2201.02637 [hep-ph].DOI
  16. [16]J. C. Berengut, C. Delaunay, A. Geddes, and Y. Soreq, Generalized King linearity and new physics searches with isotope shifts, Phys. Rev. Res. 2, 043444 (2020), arXiv:2005.06144 [hep-ph].DOI
  17. [17]N.-H. Rehbehn, M. K. Rosner, J. C. Berengut, P. O. Schmidt, T. Pfeifer, M. F. Gu, and J. R. Crespo López-Urrutia, Narrow and ultranarrow transitions in highly charged Xe ions as probes of fifth forces, Phys. Rev. Lett. 131, 161803 (2023), arXiv:2309.17141 [physics.atom-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2309.17141
  18. [18]B. Holdom, Two U(1)’s and epsilon charge shifts, Phys. Lett. B 166, 196 (1986).DOI
  19. [19]A. J. Krasznahorkay et al., Observation of anomalous internal pair creation in 8Be : a possible indication of a light, neutral boson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 042501 (2016), arXiv:1504.01527 [nucl-ex].DOI
  20. [20]A. J. Krasznahorkay, M. Csátiős, L. Csige, J. Gulyás, A. Krasznahorkay, B. M. Nyakó, I. Rajta, J. Timár, I. Vajda, and N. J. Sas, New anomaly observed in 4He supports the existence of the hypothetical X17 particle, Phys. Rev. C 104, 044003 (2021).
  21. [21]A. J. Krasznahorkay et al., New anomaly observed in 12C supports the existence and the vector character of the hypothetical X17 boson, Phys. Rev. C 106, L061601 (2022).DOI
  22. [22]D. Barducci and C. Toni, An updated view on the ATOMKI nuclear anomalies, J. High Energy Phys. 02, 154 (2023).DOI
  23. [23]P. B. Denton and J. Gehrlein, Neutrino constraints and the ATOMKI X17 anomaly, Phys. Rev. D 108, 015009 (2023), arXiv:2304.09877 [hep-ph].DOI
  24. [24]M. Hostert and M. Pospelov, Pion decay constraints on exotic 17 MeV vector bosons, Phys. Rev. D 108, 055011 (2023), arXiv:2306.15077 [hep-ph].arxiv.org/abs/2306.15077
  25. [25]H. W. Griesshammer, J. A. McGovern, D. R. Phillips, and G. Feldman, Using effective field theory to analyse low-energy Compton scattering data from protons and light nuclei, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 67, 841 (2012), arXiv:1203.6834 [nucl-th].DOI
  26. [26]V. Lensky, J. McGovern, and V. Pascalutsa, Predictions of covariant chiral perturbation theory for nucleon polarizabilities and polarised Compton scattering, Eur. Phys. J. C 75, 604 (2015), arXiv:1510.02794 [hep-ph].DOI
  27. [27]E. Mornacchi et al. (A2 Collaboration at MAMI), Measurement of Compton scattering at MAMI for the extraction of the electric and magnetic polarizabilities of the proton, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 132503 (2022), arXiv:2110.15691 [nucl-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2110.15691
  28. [28]M. I. Levchuk, A. I. L’vov, and V. A. Petrunkin, Photon scattering on quasi-free neutrons in the reaction γd → γ′np and neutron polarizabilities, Few Body Syst. 16, 101 (1994).DOI
  29. [29]L. Doria, P. Achenbach, M. Christmann, A. Denig, and H. Merkel, Dark matter at the intensity frontier: the new MESA electron accelerator facility, PoS ALPS2019, 022 (2020), arXiv:1908.07921 [hep-ex].arxiv.org/abs/1908.07921
  30. [30]B. S. Schlimme et al. (A1, MAGIX), Operation and characterization of a windowless gas jet target in high-intensity electron beams, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. A 1013, 165668 (2021), arXiv:2104.13503 [physics.ins-det].DOI
  31. [31]H. Merkel et al., Search at the Mainz Microtron for light massive gauge bosons relevant for the muon g-2 anomaly, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 221802 (2014), arXiv:1404.5502 [hep-ex].
  32. [32]J. Backens and M. Vanderhaeghen, X17 discovery potential in the γN → e+e−N process at electron scattering facilities, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 091802 (2022).DOI
  33. [33]We do not need to include a label for isospin, as a potential isospin factor of 1/√2 is already included in the CB-Bonn wave function [34].
  34. [34]R. Machleidt, The high precision, charge dependent Bonn nucleon-nucleon potential (CD-Bonn), Phys. Rev. C 63, 024001 (2001).DOI
  35. [35]R. Barbieri and T. E. O. Ericson, Evidence against the existence of a low mass scalar boson from neutron-nucleus scattering, Phys. Lett. B 57, 270 (1975).
  36. [36]D. S. M. Alves and N. Weiner, A viable QCD axion in the MeV mass range, J. High Energy Phys. 07, 092 (2018).DOI
  37. [37]J. Kozaczuk, D. E. Morrissey, and S. R. Stroberg, Light axial vector bosons, nuclear transitions, and the 8Be anomaly, Phys. Rev. D 95, 115024 (2017).
  38. [38]Y. Kahn, G. Krnjaic, S. Mishra-Sharma, and T. M. P. Tait, Light weakly coupled axial forces: models, constraints, and projections, JHEP 05, 002, arXiv:1609.09072 [hep-ph].DOI
  39. [39]P. Shirley, Ii.7 - nonuniform random point sets via warping, in Graphics Gems III (IBM Version), edited by D. Kirk (Morgan Kaufmann, San Francisco, 1992) pp. 80–83.DOI
  40. [40]J. L. Feng, B. Fornal, I. Galon, S. Gardner, J. Smolinsky, T. M. P. Tait, and P. Tanedo, Particle physics models for the 17 MeV anomaly in beryllium nuclear decays, Phys. Rev. D 95, 035017 (2017).DOI
  41. [41]E. Abouzaid et al. (KTeV), Measurement of the rare decay π0 → e+e−, Phys. Rev. D 75, 012004 (2007), arXiv:hep-ex/0610072.DOI
  42. [42]H. Leeb and J. Schmiedmayer, Constraint on hypothetical light interacting bosons from low-energy neutron experiments, Phys. Rev. Lett. 68, 1472 (1992).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10045140
  43. [43]P. Fadeev, Y. V. Stadnik, F. Ficek, M. G. Kozlov, V. V. Flambaum, and D. Budker, Revisiting spin-dependent forces mediated by new bosons: potentials in the coordinate-space representation for macroscopic and atomic-scale experiments, Phys. Rev. A 99, 022113 (2020), arXiv:1908.07921 [hep-ex].
  44. [44]A. J. Krasznahorkay, A. Krasznahorkay, M. Csatlós, L. Csige, J. Timár, M. Begala, A. Krakó, I. Rajta, and I. Vajda, Observation of the X17 anomaly in the decay of the Giant Dipole Resonance of 8Be, (to be published) (2023), arXiv:2308.06473 [nucl-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2308.06473
  45. [45]D. S. M. Alves et al., Shedding light on X17: community report, Eur. Phys. J. C 83, 230 (2023).DOI
  46. [46]T. T. Anh et al., Checking the 8Be anomaly with a two-arm electron positron pair spectrometer, in 52nd International Symposium on Multiparticle Dynamics (2024) arXiv:2401.11676 [nucl-ex].DOI
  47. [47]A. J. Krasznahorkay et al., Observation of anomalous internal pair creation in 8Be, Acta Phys. Polon. Supp. 8, 597 (2015).DOI
  48. [48]U. Ellwanger and S. Moretti, Possible explanation of the electron positron anomaly at 17 MeV in 8Be transitions through a light pseudoscalar, J. High Energy Phys. 11, 039 (2016).arxiv.org/abs/1609.01669
  49. [49]M. Viviani, E. Filandri, L. Girlanda, C. Gustavino, A. Kievsky, L. E. Marcucci, and R. Schiavilla, X17 boson and the 3H(p,e+e−)4He and 3He(n,e+e−)4He processes: A theoretical analysis, Phys. Rev. C 105, 014001 (2022).
  50. [50]J. L. Feng, B. Fornal, I. Galon, S. Gardner, J. Smolinsky, T. M. P. Tait, and P. Tanedo, Protophobic fifth-force interpretation of the observed anomaly in 8Be nuclear transitions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 071803 (2016).DOI
  51. [51]G. Azuelos et al., Status of the X17 search in Montreal, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 2391, 012008 (2022).DOI
  52. [52]A. M. Baldini et al. (MEG II), The design of the MEG II experiment, Eur. Phys. J. C 78, 380 (2018).DOI
  53. [53]D. Dutta et al., A new direct detection electron scattering experiment to search for the X17 particle, preprint (2023), arXiv:2301.08768 [nucl-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2301.08768
  54. [54]B. Bastin et al., Investigation of a light dark boson existence: the New JEDI project, EPJ Web Conf. 275, 01012 (2023).DOI
  55. [55]J. L. Feng, T. M. P. Tait, and C. B. Verhaaren, Dynamical evidence for a fifth force explanation of the ATOMKI nuclear anomalies, Phys. Rev. D 102, 036016 (2020), arXiv:2006.01151 [hep-ph].DOI
  56. [56]R. Bradford, A. Bodek, H. S. Budd, and J. Arrington, A New parameterization of the nucleon elastic form-factors, Nucl. Phys. B Proc. Suppl. 159, 127 (2006), arXiv:hep-ex/0602017.DOI
  57. [57]V. Lensky, F. Hagelstein, V. Pascalutsa, and M. Vanderhaeghen, Sum rules across the unpolarized Compton processes involving generalized polarizabilities and moments of nucleon structure functions, Phys. Rev. D 97, 074012 (2018).

Paper details

vlnc:W_6g24dhup
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents