betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Resonances in 12^{12}C and 24^{24}Mg: what do we learn from a microscopic cluster theory?

Abstract

We discuss resonance properties in three-body systems, with examples on 12C^{12}{\rm C} and 24Mg^{24}{\rm Mg}. We use a microscopic cluster model, where the generator coordinate is defined in the hyperspherical formalism. The 12C^{12}{\rm C} nucleus is described by an α+α+αα+α+α structure, whereas 24Mg^{24}{\rm Mg} is considered as an 16O+α+α^{16}{\rm O}+α+α system. We essentially pay attention to resonances. We review various techniques which may extend variational methods to resonances. We consider 0+0^+ and 2+2^+ states in 12C^{12}{\rm C} and 24Mg^{24}{\rm Mg}. We show that the r.m.s. radius of a resonance is strongly sensitive to the variational basis. This has consequences for the Hoyle state (02+0^+_2 state in 12C^{12}{\rm C}) whose radius has been calculated or measured in several works. In 24Mg^{24}{\rm Mg}, we identify two 0+0^+ resonances slightly below the three-body threshold.

Introduction

Clustering is a well established phenomenon in light nuclei (see Refs. [1, 2, 3] for recent reviews). In nuclear physics, most cluster states involve the α\alpha particle. Due to its large binding energy, the α\alpha particle tends to keep its own identity, which leads to the α\alpha cluster structure [4, 5]. The cluster structure in α\alpha nuclei (i.e. with nucleon numbers A=4kA=4k, where kk is an integer number) was clarified by Ikeda et al. [6] who proposed a diagram which identifies situations where a cluster structure can be observed. The α\alpha cluster structure is essentially found for nuclei near N=ZN=Z. The α\alpha model and its extensions were utilized by many authors to investigate the properties of α\alpha-particle nuclei such as 8Be^{8}\mathrm{Be}, 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}, 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}, etc. In particular, the interest for α\alpha-cluster models was recently revived by the hypothesis of a new form of nuclear matter, in analogy with the Bose-Einstein condensates [7, 8].

Nuclear models are essentially divided in two categories: (1) in non-microscopic models, the internal structure of the clusters is neglected, and they interact by a nucleus-nucleus potential; (2) in microscopic models, the wave functions depend on the AA nucleons of the system, and the Hamiltonian involves a nucleon-nucleon interaction. Recent developments in nuclear models [9, 10, 11] aim to find exact solutions of the AA-body problem, but they present strong difficulties when the nucleon number increases. To simplify the problem, cluster models assume that the nucleons are grouped in clusters. The simplest variant is a two-cluster model and is being developed since more than 40 years [12, 13]. Multicluster microscopic models are more recent (see, for example, Ref. [3]). They allow to extend the range of applications.

In the present paper, we focus on two α\alpha nuclei: 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} and 24Mg^{24}\mathrm{Mg}, which are described by three-body structures (3α3\alpha and 16O+α+α^{16}\mathrm{O}+\alpha+\alpha, respectively). Over the last 20 years, there was a strong interest on 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}, and in particular on the 02+0^+_2 resonance, known as the Hoyle state [14]. The unbound nature, however, make theoretical studies delicate.

With 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} and 24Mg^{24}\mathrm{Mg} as typical examples, we discuss more specifically the determination of resonance properties in cluster models. As resonances are unbound, a rigorous treatment would require a scattering model, with scattering boundary conditions. There are, however, various techniques aimed at complementing the much simpler variational method which is, strictly speaking, valid for bound states only. In a variational method, negative energies are associated with physical bound states. The positive eigenvalues correspond to approximations of the continuum. For narrow resonances, a single eigenvalue is in general a fair approximation. We show, however, that the calculation of physical quantities, such as the r.m.s. radius, should be treated carefully.

The paper is organized as follows. In Sec. 2, we present the microscopic three-body model, using hyperspherical coordinates. Section 3 is devoted to a brief discussion of different techniques dealing with resonances. The 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} and 24Mg^{24}\mathrm{Mg} nuclei are presented in Sects. 4 and 5, respectively. Concluding remarks are given in Sect. 6.

The Microscopic three-cluster model

Hamiltonian and wave functions

In a microscopic model, the Hamiltonian of a AA-nucleon system is given by

H=∑i=1ATi+∑i<j=1A(VijN+VijC),(1)H = \sum_{i=1}^{A} T_i + \sum_{i<j=1}^{A} \left(V_{ij}^{N}+V_{ij}^{C}\right), \tag*{(1)}

where TiT_i is the kinetic energy of nucleon ii, and VijNV_{ij}^{N} and VijCV_{ij}^{C} are the nuclear and Coulomb interactions between nucleons ii and jj.

In a partial wave JπJ^\pi, the wave function ΨJMπ\Psi^{JM\pi} is a solution of the Schrödinger equation

HΨJMπ=EΨJMπ.(2)H\Psi^{JM\pi}=E\Psi^{JM\pi}. \tag*{(2)}

Recent ab initio models [9, 10] aim at determining exact solutions of Eq. (2). For instance, the No-Core Shell Model (NCSM) is based on large one-center harmonic-oscillator (HO) bases and effective interactions [15], derived from realistic forces such as Argonne [16] or CD-Bonn [17]. These interactions are adapted for finite model spaces through a particular unitary transformation. Wave functions are then expected to be accurate, but states presenting a strong clustering remain difficult to describe with this approach.

In cluster models, the nucleon-nucleon interaction VijNV_{ij}^{N} must account for the cluster approximation of the wave function. This leads to effective interactions, adapted to harmonic-oscillator orbitals. For example, using 0s0s orbitals for the α\alpha particle makes all matrix elements of non-central forces equal to zero. The effect of non-central components is simulated by an appropriate choice of the central effective interaction. Typical effective interactions are the Minnesota [18] or the Volkov potentials [19]. These central forces simulate the effects of the missing tensor interaction. They include an adjustable parameter, which can be slightly modified without changing the basic properties of the force. This parameter is typically used to reproduce the energy of the ground state or of a resonance.

In the present model, Eq. (2) is solved by using the cluster approximation, i.e. the nucleus is seen as a three-body system, where each cluster is represented by a shell-model wave function. This leads to the Resonating Group Method (RGM, see Refs. [13, 3]) which was initially developed for two-cluster systems, but more recently extended to three-body nuclei [20].

The three-body system is illustrated in Figure 1. Coordinate r\mathbf{r} is associated with the external clusters, whereas R\mathbf{R} is the relative coordinate between the core and the two-body subsystem. Scaled Jacobi coordinates x\mathbf{x} and y\mathbf{y} [21, 20] are obtained from

Coordinates in the microscopic three-cluster system

Figure 1. Coordinates in the microscopic three-cluster system.

x=A1A2A1+A2r,\mathbf{x}=\sqrt{\frac{A_1A_2}{A_1+A_2}}\mathbf{r},
y=Ac(A1+A2)Ac+A1+A2R,(3)\mathbf{y}=\sqrt{\frac{A_c(A_1+A_2)}{A_c+A_1+A_2}}\mathbf{R}, \tag*{(3)}

where AcA_c is the mass of the core and (A1,A2)(A_1,A_2) the masses of the external clusters. We use the hyperspherical formalism

where the hyperradius ρ\rho and the hyperangle α\alpha are defined as

ρ2=x2+y2\rho^2=\mathbf{x}^2+\mathbf{y}^2
α=arctan⁡(y/x).(4)\alpha=\arctan(y/x). \tag*{(4)}

The hyperspherical formalism is well known in non-microscopic three-body systems [22, 21], where the structure of the nuclei is neglected. This formalism makes use of five angles Ω5=(Ωx,Ωy,α)\Omega^5=(\Omega_x,\Omega_y,\alpha) and of an hypermomentum KK which generalizes the concept of angular momentum in two-body systems. The hyperspherical functions are [23]

YKLMℓxℓy(Ω5)=ϕKℓxℓy(α)[Yℓx(Ωx)⊗Yℓy(Ωy)]LM,(5)\mathcal{Y}_{KLM}^{\ell_x\ell_y}(\Omega^5)=\phi_K^{\ell_x\ell_y}(\alpha)\left[Y_{\ell_x}(\Omega_x)\otimes Y_{\ell_y}(\Omega_y)\right]^{LM}, \tag*{(5)}

where ℓx\ell_x and ℓy\ell_y are angular momenta associated with the Jacobi coordinates x\mathbf{x} and y\mathbf{y}. Functions ϕKℓxℓy\phi_K^{\ell_x\ell_y} are given by

ϕKℓxℓy(α)=NKℓxℓy(cos⁡α)ℓx(sin⁡α)ℓyPnℓy+12,ℓx+12(cos⁡2α).(6)\phi_K^{\ell_x\ell_y}(\alpha)=\mathcal{N}_K^{\ell_x\ell_y}(\cos\alpha)^{\ell_x}(\sin\alpha)^{\ell_y}P_n^{\ell_y+\frac{1}{2},\ell_x+\frac{1}{2}}(\cos2\alpha). \tag*{(6)}

In these definition, Pnα,β(x)P_n^{\alpha,\beta}(x) is a Jacobi polynomial, NKℓxℓy\mathcal{N}_K^{\ell_x\ell_y} is a normalization factor, and n=(K−ℓx−ℓy)/2n=(K-\ell_x-\ell_y)/2 is a positive integer.

For the sake of clarity, we limit the presentation to clusters with spin 0 (a generalization can be found in Ref. [24]). The total wave function of the system is written as

ΨJMπ=∑ℓxℓy∑K=0∞Aϕ1ϕ2ϕ3YKJMℓxℓy(Ω5)χℓxℓyKJπ(ρ),(7)\Psi^{JM\pi}=\sum_{\ell_x\ell_y}\sum_{K=0}^{\infty}\mathcal{A}\phi_1\phi_2\phi_3\mathcal{Y}_{KJM}^{\ell_x\ell_y}(\Omega^5)\chi_{\ell_x\ell_yK}^{J\pi}(\rho), \tag*{(7)}

where A\mathcal{A} is the AA-nucleon antisymmetrizer, and ϕi\phi_i are the cluster wave functions, defined in the shell-model. For the α\alpha particle, the internal wave function ϕ\phi is a Slater determinant involving four 0s0s orbitals. Definition (7), however, is valid in a broader context where ϕ\phi is a linear combination of several Salter determinants. A recent example [24] is the 11Li{}^{11}\mathrm{Li} nucleus described by a 9Li+n+n{}^{9}\mathrm{Li}+n+n structure, where the shell-model description of 9Li{}^{9}\mathrm{Li} involves all Slater determinants (90) which can be built in the pp shell. The oscillator parameter bb is taken identical for the three clusters. Going beyond this approximation raises enormous difficulties due to center-of-mass problems, even in two-cluster calculations [25]. In Eq. (7), the hypermomentum KK ваҡытта runs from zero to infinity. In practice a truncation value Kmax⁡K_{\max} is adopted. The hyperradial functions χℓxℓyKJπ(ρ)\chi_{\ell_x\ell_y K}^{J\pi}(\rho) are to be determined from the Schrödinger equation (2).

As for two-cluster systems, the RGM definition clearly displays the physical interpretation of the cluster approximation. In practice, however, using the Generator Coordinate Method (GCM) wave functions is equivalent, and is more appropriate to systematic numerical calculations [3]. In the GCM, the wave function (7) is equivalently written as

ΨJMπ=∑γ∫dR fγJπ(R)ΦγJMπ(R),(8)\Psi^{JM\pi}=\sum_{\gamma}\int dR\,f_{\gamma}^{J\pi}(R)\Phi_{\gamma}^{JM\pi}(R), \tag*{(8)}

where we use label γ=(ℓx,ℓy,K)\gamma=(\ell_x,\ell_y,K). In this equation, RR is the generator coordinate, ΦγJMπ(R)\Phi_{\gamma}^{JM\pi}(R) are projected Slater determinants, and fγJπ(R)f_{\gamma}^{J\pi}(R) are the generator functions (see Ref. [3] for more detail). In practice, the integral is replaced by a sum over a finite set of RR values (typically 10-15 values are chosen, up to R≈10−12R\approx10-12 fm).

After discretization of (8), the generator functions are obtained from the eigenvalue problem, known as the Hill-Wheeler equation,

∑γ′n′[Hγ,γ′Jπ(Rn,Rn′)−EkJπNγ,γ′Jπ(Rn,Rn′)]fγ′Jπ(Rn)=0,(9)\sum_{\gamma'n'}\left[H_{\gamma,\gamma'}^{J\pi}(R_n,R_{n'})-E_k^{J\pi}N_{\gamma,\gamma'}^{J\pi}(R_n,R_{n'})\right]f_{\gamma'}^{J\pi}(R_n)=0, \tag*{(9)}

where kk denotes the excitation level. The Hamiltonian and overlap kernels are obtained from 7-dimension integrals involving matrix elements between Slater determinants (see Refs. [20, 3] for detail). They are given by

Nγ,γ′Jπ(R,R′)=⟨ΦγJMπ(R)∣Φγ′JMπ(R′)⟩,Hγ,γ′Jπ(R,R′)=⟨ΦγJMπ(R)∣H∣Φγ′JMπ(R′)⟩.(10)\begin{aligned} N_{\gamma,\gamma'}^{J\pi}(R,R')&=\langle\Phi_{\gamma}^{JM\pi}(R)|\Phi_{\gamma'}^{JM\pi}(R')\rangle,\\ H_{\gamma,\gamma'}^{J\pi}(R,R')&=\langle\Phi_{\gamma}^{JM\pi}(R)|H|\Phi_{\gamma'}^{JM\pi}(R')\rangle. \tag*{(10)} \end{aligned}

The non-projected matrix elements are computed with Brink’s formula [4], and the main part of the numerical calculations is devoted to the two-body interaction which involves quadruple sums over the orbitals. The projection over angular momentum, which requires multidimension integrals, makes the calculation very demanding. A more detailed description is provided in Ref. [24].

Radii and energy curves

From the wave function (7,8), various properties can be computed. We discuss more specifically the r.m.s. radius, defined as

⟨r2⟩=1A⟨ΨJMπ∣∑i=1A(ri−Rc.m.)2∣ΨJMπ⟩,(11)\langle r^2\rangle=\frac{1}{A}\langle\Psi^{JM\pi}|\sum_{i=1}^{A}(\boldsymbol{r}_i-\boldsymbol{R}_{\mathrm{c.m.}})^2|\Psi^{JM\pi}\rangle, \tag*{(11)}

which, in the GCM is determined from

⟨r2⟩=∑γn∑γ′n′fγJπ(Rn)fγ′Jπ(Rn′)×⟨ΦγJMπ(Rn)∣1A∑i=1A(ri−Rc.m.)2∣Φγ′JMπ(Rn′)⟩.(12)\begin{aligned} \langle r^2\rangle={}&\sum_{\gamma n}\sum_{\gamma'n'}f_{\gamma}^{J\pi}(R_n)f_{\gamma'}^{J\pi}(R_{n'})\\ &\times\langle\Phi_{\gamma}^{JM\pi}(R_n)|\frac{1}{A}\sum_{i=1}^{A}(\boldsymbol{r}_i-\boldsymbol{R}_{\mathrm{c.m.}})^2|\Phi_{\gamma'}^{JM\pi}(R_{n'})\rangle. \tag*{(12)} \end{aligned}

The matrix elements between Slater determinants are obtained as in Eqs. (10). Notice that these calculations are rigorous for bound states, i.e. states with energy EkJπE_k^{J\pi} lower than the three-cluster breakup threshold ET=E1+E2+E3E_T=E_1+E_2+E_3, EiE_i being the internal energy of cluster ii, computed consistently with the same Hamiltonian. In this case, the relative functions χγJπ(ρ)\chi_{\gamma}^{J\pi}(\rho) [see Eq. (7)] tend rapidly to zero, and the sum over (n,n′)(n,n') in (12) converges. For resonances (EkJπ>ETE_k^{J\pi}>E_T), the convergence of (12) is not guaranteed. We discuss this issue in more detail in Sect. 3.

The energies and r.m.s. radii discussed in the previous subsection involve all generator coordinates. It is, however, useful to analyze the energies of the system for a single RR value. This quantity is referred to as the energy curves. Two variants can be considered. In the former, only the diagonal matrix elements of the Hamiltonian are used, and the energy curves are defined as

EγJπ(R)=Hγ,γJπ(R,R)Nγ,γJπ(R,R)−ET.(13)E_{\gamma}^{J\pi}(R)=\frac{H_{\gamma,\gamma}^{J\pi}(R,R)}{N_{\gamma,\gamma}^{J\pi}(R,R)}-E_T. \tag*{(13)}

This definition ignores the couplings between the channels. At large distances, they tend to

EγJπ(R)⟶Zγe2R+ℏ22mN(K+3/2)(K+5/2)R2+14ℏω,(14)E_{\gamma}^{J\pi}(R)\longrightarrow\frac{Z_{\gamma}e^2}{R}+\frac{\hbar^2}{2m_N}\frac{(K+3/2)(K+5/2)}{R^2}+\frac{1}{4}\hbar\omega, \tag*{(14)}

where Zγe2Z_{\gamma}e^2 is a diagonal element of the Coulomb three-body interaction (see, for example, Ref. [26]), mNm_N is the nucleon mass, and 14ℏω\frac{1}{4}\hbar\omega is the residual energy associated with the harmonic oscillator functions (ℏω=ℏ2/mNb2\hbar\omega=\hbar^2/m_Nb^2).

In the alternative approach, the energy curves stem from a diagonalization of the Hamiltonian for a fixed RR value. They are given by the eigenvalue problem

∑γ′[Hγ,γ′Jπ(R,R)−EkJπ(R)Nγ,γ′Jπ(R,R)]cγ′Jπ(R)=0.(15)\sum_{\gamma'}\left[H_{\gamma,\gamma'}^{J\pi}(R,R)-E_k^{J\pi}(R)N_{\gamma,\gamma'}^{J\pi}(R,R)\right]c_{\gamma'}^{J\pi}(R)=0. \tag*{(15)}

At large distances, the coupling elements (γ≠γ′\gamma\ne\gamma') tend to zero and both definitions (13) and (15) are equivalent. In three-body systems, however, the couplings are known to extend to large distances, even for short-range interactions (see, for example, Refs. [27, 26, 28]).

The energy curves cannot be considered as genuine potentials. However, they provide various informations, such as the existence of bound states or of narrow resonances, the level ordering, the cluster structure, etc.

Discussion of resonances

The eigenvalue problem (9) is, strictly speaking, valid for bound states only. The variational principle guarantees that an upper limit of the exact solution is found, and that the wave function tends exponentially to zero. The situation, however, is different for positive-energy states. In that case, the lowest energy is zero, i.e. the optimal solution, according to the variational principle, corresponds to a system where the clusters are at infinite distance from each other.

For narrow resonances, the bound-state approximation (BSA), which is a direct extension of (9), usually provides a fair approximation of the energy, even with finite bases. If the width is small, the energy is fairly stable when the basis changes. The situation is different for the wave function. The long-range part may be sensitive to the choice of the basis, and matrix elements using these wave functions may be unstable. A typical example will be shown with the 02+0_2^+ resonance of 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C}.

For broad resonances, there are various techniques which complement the variational method. The idea is to avoid scattering calculations, such as in the RR-matrix theory [29], where resonance properties are derived from an analysis of the phase shifts (or scattering matrices). The complementary methods have solid mathematical foundations, and are, in principle, relatively simple to implement in variational calculations. We briefly summarize below some of them.

  • The complex scaling method (CSM) is based on the rotation of the space and momentum coordinates [30, 31, 32]. In other words, the space coordinate r\mathbf{r} and momentum p\mathbf{p} of each particle are transformed as

U(θ)rU−1(θ)=rexp⁡(iθ),U(\theta)\mathbf{r}U^{-1}(\theta)=\mathbf{r}\exp(i\theta),
U(θ)pU−1(θ)=pexp⁡(−iθ),(16)U(\theta)\mathbf{p}U^{-1}(\theta)=\mathbf{p}\exp(-i\theta), \tag*{(16)}

where θ\theta is the rotation angle. Under this transformation, the Schrödinger equation reads

H(θ)Ψ(θ)=U(θ)HU−1(θ)Ψ(θ)=E(θ)Ψ(θ),(17)H(\theta)\Psi(\theta)=U(\theta)HU^{-1}(\theta)\Psi(\theta)=E(\theta)\Psi(\theta), \tag*{(17)}

and the solutions Ψ(θ)\Psi(\theta) are square-integrable provided that θ\theta is properly chosen [32]. They can be expanded over a finite basis, after rotation of the Hamiltonian. Of course the potential should be available in an analytic form to apply transformation (16).

The ABC theorem [31] shows that the eigenvalues Ek(θ)E_k(\theta) are located on a straight line in the complex plane, rotated by an angle 2θ2\theta. Resonant states are not affected by this angle and correspond to stable eigenvalues

Ek(θ)=ER−iΓ/2,(18)E_k(\theta)=E_R-i\Gamma/2, \tag*{(18)}

where ERE_R is the energy and Γ\Gamma the width of the resonance.

Recently, the CSM has been extended to the calculation of level densities [33, 34] and to dipole strength distributions [32]. Of course the resonance properties (18) derived from the CSM should also be consistent with those derived from a phase-shift analysis.

  • In the complex absorbing potential (CAP) method, an imaginary potential is added to the Hamiltonian kernel. The first applications were developed in atomic physics [35] and in non-microscopic nuclear models [36]. Ito and Yabana Ito and Yabana [37] have extended the method to microscopic cluster calculations within the GCM. The Hamiltonian kernel (10) is replaced by

H(R,R′)⟶H(R,R′)−iηW(R)δ(R−R′),(19)H(R,R')\longrightarrow H(R,R')-i\eta W(R)\delta(R-R'), \tag*{(19)}

where η\eta is a positive real number. The absorbing potential is usually taken as

W(R)=θ(R−R0)(R−R0)β,(20)W(R)=\theta(R-R_0)(R-R_0)^\beta, \tag*{(20)}

where R0R_0 is an arbitrary radius, larger than the range of the nuclear force and θ\theta is the step function. In most calculations, β\beta is taken as β=4\beta=4. This method provides the energy and widths of resonances as in (18), even for broader states. In Ref. [37], it was shown, however, that the method needs many generator coordinates. In their microscopic study of α+6He\alpha+{}^{6}\mathrm{He} scattering, Ito and Yabana use 100 generator coordinates, up to R=50R=50 fm. For computational reasons, this method is difficult to apply to three-body systems, owing to the strong couplings between the channels, and to the long range of the potentials.

  • The analytic continuation in a coupling constant (ACCC) method has been proposed by Kukulin et al. [38] to evaluate the energy and width of a resonance. The main advantage is that the ACCC method only requires bound-state calculations, much simpler than scattering calculations involving boundary conditions. Some applications to a microscopic description of two- and three-cluster models can be found in Ref. [39]. The method has been applied to a non-microscopic description of 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} in Ref. [40].

To apply the ACCC method, one assumes that the Hamiltonian can be written as

H(u)=H0+uH1,(21)H(u)=H_0+uH_1, \tag*{(21)}

where uu is a linear parameter. The linear part H1H_1 is supposed to be attractive so that, for increasing uu values, the system becomes bound. For u=u0u=u_0, the energy is zero, and we have E(u0)=0E(u_0)=0.

The problem is to determine the resonance properties for the physical value u<u0u<u_0. In the bound-state regime (u>u0u>u_0), the wave number kk is imaginary, and is parametrized by a Padé approximant as

k(x)=ic0+c1x+⋯+cMxM1+d1x+⋯+dNxN,(22)k(x)=i\frac{c_0+c_1x+\cdots+c_Mx^M}{1+d_1x+\cdots+d_Nx^N}, \tag*{(22)}

where x=u−u0x=\sqrt{u-u_0}, and (M,N)(M,N) define the degree of the Padé approximant. The (M+N+1)(M+N+1) coefficients cic_i and djd_j are calculated in the bound-state region by using uiu_i values such that E(ui)<0E(u_i)<0. Going to the physical value uu (u<u0u<u_0, imaginary), one determines kk from (22). The energy ERE_R and width Γ\Gamma are obtained from

E=ℏ2k22m=ER−iΓ/2.(23)E=\frac{\hbar^2k^2}{2m}=E_R-i\Gamma/2. \tag*{(23)}

The ACCC is, in principle, a simple extension of the variational method. However, it was pointed out [38, 39] that this method requires a high accuracy in the numerical calculation. In particular, the u0u_0 value must be determined with several digits. It is therefore not realistic for microscopic three-body systems.

  • The box method [41] can be used for narrow resonances. This method has been applied essentially in atomic physics. The idea is to search for positive eigenvalues of the Schrödinger equation (2) inside a box. Then, looking at the eigenvalues as a function of the box size, a narrow resonance appears at a stable energy (see, for example, Figure 1 of Ref. [41]). This method is simpler than other approximate techniques and, therefore, permits the use of large bases. The method has been recently extended to the determination of resonance widths [42]. However, it requires the numerical calculation of the first and second derivatives, which means that, in practice, many generator coordinates must be used for a good accuracy of the resonance parameters.

Application to 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}

The 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} nucleus has attracted much attention in recent years, in particular for the 02+0_2^+ resonance, known as the Hoyle state (see Ref. [14] for a recent review). The Hoyle state, located just above the 3α3\alpha threshold (ER=0.36E_R = 0.36 MeV), is quite important in nuclear astrophysics since its properties determine the triple-α\alpha reaction rate. Its existence was predicted by Hoyle [43] on the basis of the observed abundance of 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}.

There is an impressive literature about the Hoyle state, and we refer to Refs. [14, 8] for an overview. One of its characteristics is to present a marked α+8Be\alpha+{}^{8}\mathrm{Be} cluster structure [44]. This α\alpha clustering is well established in many light nuclei, such as 7Li^{7}\mathrm{Li}, 7,8,9,10Be^{7,8,9,10}\mathrm{Be}, 16,17,18O^{16,17,18}\mathrm{O}, 18,19,20Ne^{18,19,20}\mathrm{Ne} [5]. The specificity of the 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} nucleus is that the second cluster 8Be^{8}\mathrm{Be} also presents an α\alpha cluster structure. As in all excited states located near a breakup threshold, the Hoyle state presents an extended density, which means that the density at short distances is decreased if compared to well bound states. This natural property, common to all nuclei, lead some authors to refer to the concept of ”dilute gas” [45, 46] and of Bose-Einstein Condensates [7, 8].

Our aim here is not to perform new calculations on the 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} nucleus. The first microscopic 3α3\alpha calculation was performed by Uegaki et al. in 1977 [47], and improved in different ways [48, 44, 7, 49, 45, 50]. The ab initio calculation of Ref. [49] works rather well for the ground state, but needs the introduction of specific 3α3\alpha configurations to reproduce the Hoyle state. One of the frequent issues about the Hoyle state is the determination of its r.m.s. radius, which is expected to be large (see references in Ref. [14]).

We adopt the same microscopic 3α3\alpha model as in Ref. [50], where the Minnesota nucleon-nucleon interaction [18] with u=0.9487u = 0.9487 was used. For the generator coordinates, we use a large basis: 12 values from 1.5 to 18 fm with a step of 1.5 fm, and 3 additional values at 20, 22 and 24 fm. This basis is unusually large, but permits a reliable discussion concerning the properties of resonances.

In Figure 2, we display the energy curves (13) for J=0+J = 0^+ and for different KK values. Note that in 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}, a full symmetrization of the wave functions for α\alpha exchange leads to the cancellation of the K=2K = 2 component (see, for example, Ref. [26]). The dashed line illustrates the asymptotic behaviour (14) with Z00=28.81Z_{00} = 28.81 [26]. The energy curves for K=0,4,6K = 0, 4, 6 present a minimum around R=4R = 4 fm. At short distances, the antisymmetrization between the nucleons makes these curves equivalent. This is not true at large distances, where the effective three-body Coulomb interaction is different, and where the centrifugal term plays a role.

Figure 2. Energy curves (13) for J=0+J = 0^+ in 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}. The curves are labeled by the KK values. The dashed line represents the asymptotic behaviour (14) for K=0K = 0.

Figure 3 presents the binding energy (with respect to the 3α3\alpha threshold) of the 01+0_1^+ and 02+0_2^+ states for increasing size of the basis. We define Rmax⁡R_{\max} as the maximum RR value included in the basis. The upper and lower panels present the energy and r.m.s. radius, respectively. As expected for a bound state, the 01+0_1^+ energy and r.m.s. radius converge rapidly. With Rmax⁡≃6R_{\max} \simeq6 fm, a fair convergence is reached. The corresponding radius ⟨r2⟩=2.21\sqrt{\langle r^2\rangle} = 2.21 fm is too small compared to experiment (2.48 fm [51]) but this difference is due to the overbinding of the theoretical state.

More interesting results are obtained for the 02+0_2^+ state. If the energy remains almost constant above Rmax⁡≃15R_{\max} \simeq15 fm, the r.m.s. radius significantly increases with larger bases. We go here up to Rmax⁡=24R_{\max} = 24 fm, which represents a huge value, much larger than in standard calculations (see, for example, Ref. [50]). This is, however, necessary to illustrate convergence issues. As we may expect from the unbound nature of the 02+0_2^+ state, the r.m.s. radius diverges. Any (large) value can be obtained, provided that the basis is large enough. This explains why calculations in the literature are quite different [14].

The same quantities are plotted in Figure 4 for J=2+J = 2^+. The existence of a 22+2_2^+ resonance, second state of a band based on the Hoyle state, is well established [48, 44], but this state should be broad. Even the energy is not stable, and does not present a plateau with Rmax⁡R_{\max}. The corresponding r.m.s. radius strongly diverges. Notice that a microscopic 3α3\alpha model does not predict any 03+0^+_3 or 23+2^+_3 resonance.

Total energy and r.m.s. radius for $J=2^+$

Figure 4. See caption to Figure 3 for J=2+J=2^+.

Total energy and r.m.s. radius of the $0^+_1$ and $0^+_2$ states in $^{12}\mathrm{C}$

Figure 3. Total energy (top) and r.m.s. radius (bottom) of the 01+0^+_1 and 02+0^+_2 states in 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}. Energies are given with respect to the 3α3\alpha threshold.

Let us briefly comment on non-microscopic descriptions of the 3α3\alpha system. Two α+α\alpha+\alpha potentials, the shallow Ali-Bodmer potential [52] and the deep Buck potential [53] reproduce very well the experimental α+α\alpha+\alpha phase shifts up to 20 MeV. When applied to NαN\alpha systems (N>2N>2), however, none of these potentials provides satisfactory results. With the Ali-Bodmer potential, the 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} ground state is strongly underbound [54], and the 02+0^+_2 resonance is far above the 3α3\alpha threshold, in contradiction with experiment. This problem may be partly addressed by adding a phenomenological 3-body force, but this technique introduces spurious 3α3\alpha resonances [26].

The deep Buck potential raises the question of the two-body forbidden states which should be removed in the 3α3\alpha model. This is usually done by using a projection technique but, here also, several problems remain (see the discussions in Refs. [55, 26]). An efficient alternative would be to use non-local α+α\alpha+\alpha potentials [50], but the simplicity of non-microscopic models is lost. A fully satisfactory description of the 3α3\alpha system within non-microscopic models remains an open issue.

Application to 24Mg^{24}\mathrm{Mg}

The 16O+α+α^{16}\mathrm{O}+\alpha+\alpha system is more complex than 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} since the level density is much higher. The 24Mg^{24}\mathrm{Mg} nucleus was studied within an α+20Ne\alpha+^{20}\mathrm{Ne} multicluster model in Ref. [56], where 20Ne^{20}\mathrm{Ne} is described by an α+16O\alpha+^{16}\mathrm{O} structure. In Ref. [57] the authors use a microscopic 16O+α+α^{16}\mathrm{O}+\alpha+\alpha model to search for 0+0^+ resonances in a stochastic approach. The basis, however, is more limited since a fixed geometry is adopted. The present work contains a more extended basis, owing to the use of the hyperspherical coordinates.

The oscillator parameter is chosen as b=1.65b=1.65 fm, which represents a compromise between the optimal values of α\alpha and of 16O^{16}\mathrm{O}. We use the Volkov force V2 [19] with a Majorana exchange parameter M=0.624M=0.624. This value reproduces the binding energy of the ground state with respect to the 16O+α+α^{16}\mathrm{O}+\alpha+\alpha threshold (−14.05-14.05 MeV).

The calculations of the matrix elements are much longer than for 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}. Since most of the computer time is devoted to the quadruple sums involved in the two-body interaction, the ratio between the computer times is approximately given by 64/34=166^4/3^4=16, since 24Mg^{24}\mathrm{Mg} involves 6 orbitals (ss and pp), whereas 12C^{12}\mathrm{C} involves 3 orbitals (ss only).

As for 12C^{12}\mathrm{C}, we use a large basis with 10 RR-values from 1.2 fm to 12 fm, complemented by larger values R=13.5R=13.5, 15, 17, 19 fm. In Figure 5, we present the binding energies and r.m.s. radii of J=0+J=0^+ states as a function of Rmax⁡R_{\max}, the maximum RR value included in the basis.

Figure 5. Energies with respect to the 16O+α+α^{16}\mathrm{O}+\alpha+\alpha threshold (top) and r.m.s. radii (bottom) of J=0+J=0^+ states in 24Mg^{24}\mathrm{Mg} for different sizes of the basis. The color schemes are identical in both panels. In the upper panel, the right side shows experimental energies. In the lower panel, the r.m.s. radii for the third and fourth eigenvalues are almost superimposed.

The upper panel shows that four states are bound with respect to the 16O+α+α^{16}\mathrm{O}+\alpha+\alpha decay, two of which are above the α+20Ne\alpha+^{20}\mathrm{Ne} threshold (−4.7-4.7 MeV), and are therefore not rigorously bound. This is confirmed by the r.m.s. radii (lower panel). The two lowest states converge rapidly to <r2>≈8<r^2>\approx8 fm2^2, whereas the 03+0^+_3 and 04+0^+_4 radii present a slower convergence and a larger radius <r2>≈10<r^2>\approx10 fm2^2. The radii corresponding to the four negative-energy curves are linked by solid lines.

The right side of the upper panel shows the experimental 0+0^+ states. The ground-state energy is adjusted by the nucleon-nucleon interaction. The 02+0^+_2 energy is in fair agreement with experiment. In the high-energy part of the spectrum, several 0+0^+ experimental states are present.

Figure 5 suggests two important properties. Around E≈5E\approx5 MeV, there is a plateau in the energy curves, and the corresponding radii are rather insensitive to the size of the basis. This is consistent with a high-energy (Ex≈19E_x\approx19 MeV) resonance in the 24^{24}Mg spectrum. As Rmax⁡R_{\max} increases, the label of the eigenvalue varies. The radii corresponding to the plateau therefore show up as individual points around ⟨r2⟩≈7.5\langle r^2\rangle\approx7.5 fm2^2. The dip near Rmax⁡=5R_{\max}=5 fm is due to a crossing between the energy curves. The second information concerns the radii. The lower panel of Figure 5 shows a clear distinction between physical states and approximations of the continuum. The former present a stable radius, whereas the latter are characterized by diverging radii. A careful study of the radii, and in particular of their stability against the extension of the basis, is therefore an efficient way to make a distinction between physical states and pseudostates.

Figure 6 displays the energy curves for J=2+J=2^+. The level density is still higher than for J=0+J=0^+ and it is difficult to make a clear link between theory and experiment. The 21+2_1^+ and 23+2_3^+ energies are in fair agreement, but the GCM 22+2_2^+ energy is too low by about 2 MeV. This is probably due to the lack of a spin-orbit force in a 16^{16}O +α+α+\alpha+\alpha model. The model predicts seven states below the 16^{16}O +α+α+\alpha+\alpha threshold. The r.m.s. radii are not presented as they qualitatively follow those of J=0+J=0^+. The converged radii for the 21+2_1^+ and 22+2_2^+ states are around ⟨r2⟩≈8.2\langle r^2\rangle\approx8.2 fm2^2, which is close to the radius of the ground state.

Energy curves for $J=2^+$

Figure 6. See caption to Fig. 5 for J=2+J=2^+. Only energies are displayed.

Conclusion

The goal of the present work is to illustrate the calculation of resonance properties in cluster models, and more especially in multicluster models. A rigorous treatment of the resonances would require a scattering theory, with exact boundary conditions. If this approach is fairly simple in two-cluster models, it raises strong difficulties when more than two clusters are involved. The bound-state approximation is commonly used owing to its simplicity. We have shown, however, that positive-energy eigenvalues should be treated carefully, and that, even for narrow resonances, the wave function may be sensitive to the basis. A direct consequence is that some properties, such as the r.m.s. radius, are unstable. The stability against the basis should be assessed.

Several method exist to complement the bound-state approximation, such as the CSM or the ACCC. They permit to determine the energy and width of a resonance. In practice, however, they are difficult to apply to microscopic calculations since they usually need very large bases. We have used an alternative of the box method, where the number of basis functions is progressively increased. We have shown that a stability of the energy can be obtained, but the corresponding r.m.s. radii are unstable. The application to the Hoyle state in 12^{12}C is an excellent example which explains the variety of the values in the literature.

Acknowledgments

This work was supported by the Fonds de la Recherche Scientifique - FNRS under Grant Numbers 4.45.10.08 and J.0049.19. It benefited from computational resources made available on the Tier-1 supercomputer of the Fédération Wallonie-Bruxelles, infrastructure funded by the Walloon Region under the grant agreement No. 1117545.

References

  1. [1]M. Freer, H. Horiuchi, Y. Kanada-En’yo, D. Lee, U.G. Meißner, Rev. Mod. Phys. 90, 035004 (2018)
  2. [2]H. Horiuchi, K. Ikeda, K. Katō, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 192, 1 (2012)
  3. [3]P. Descouvemont, M. Dufour, Clusters in Nuclei, Vol. 2 (Springer, 2012)
  4. [4]D. Brink, Proceedings of the International School of Physics "Enrico Fermi", Course XXXVI, Varenna, 1965, Academic Press, New-York p. 247 (1966)
  5. [5]Y. Fujiwara, H. Horiuchi, K. Ikeda, M. Kamimura, K. Katō, Y. Suzuki, E. Uegaki, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 68, 29 (1980)
  6. [6]K. Ikeda, N. Takigawa, H. Horiuchi, Prog. Theo. Phys. Suppl., Extra Number p. 464 (1968)
  7. [7]A. Tohsaki, H. Horiuchi, P. Schuck, G. Röpke, Phys. Rev. Lett. 87, 192501 (2001)
  8. [8]B. Zhou, Y. Funaki, H. Horiuchi, A. Tohsaki, Frontiers of Physics 15 (2020)
  9. [9]T. Neff, H. Feldmeier, Eur. Phys. J. Special Topics 156, 69 (2008)
  10. [10]P. Navrátil, S. Quaglioni, I. Stetcu, B.R. Barrett, J. Phys. G 36, 083101 (2009)
  11. [11]H. Hergert, Frontiers in Physics 8, 379 (2020)
  12. [12]K. Wildermuth, Y.C. Tang, A Unified Theory of the Nucleus (Vieweg, Braunschweig, 1977)
  13. [13]H. Horiuchi, Prog. Theor. Phys. Suppl. 62, 90 (1977)
  14. [14]M. Freer, H. Fynbo, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 78, 1 (2014)
  15. [15]P. Navrátil, G.P. Kamuntavičius, B.R. Barrett, Phys. Rev. C 61, 044001 (2000)
  16. [16]R.B. Wiringa, V.G.J. Stoks, R. Schiavilla, Phys. Rev. C 51, 38 (1995)
  17. [17]R. Machleidt, Phys. Rev. C 63, 024001 (2001)
  18. [18]D.R. Thompson, M. LeMere, Y.C. Tang, Nucl. Phys. A 286, 53 (1977)
  19. [19]A.B. Volkov, Nucl. Phys. 74, 33 (1965)
  20. [20]S. Korenov, P. Descouvemont, Nucl. Phys. A 740, 249 (2004)
  21. [21]M.V. Zhukov, B.V. Danilin, D.V. Fedorov, J.M. Bang, I.J. Thompson, J.S. Vaagen, Phys. Rep. 231, 151 (1993)
  22. [22]A. Kievsky, S. Rosati, M. Viviani, L.E. Marcucci, L. Girlanda, J. Phys. G 35, 063101 (2008)
  23. [23]J. Raynal, J. Revai, Nuovo Cim. A 39, 612 (1970)
  24. [24]P. Descouvemont, Phys. Rev. C 99, 064308 (2019)
  25. [25]D. Baye, M. Kruglanski, Phys. Rev. C 45, 1321 (1992)
  26. [26]P. Descouvemont, J. Phys. G 37, 064010 (2010)
  27. [27]P. Descouvemont, E.M. Tursunov, D. Baye, Nucl. Phys. A 765, 370 (2006)
  28. [28]A. Damman, P. Descouvemont, Phys. Rev. C 80, 044310 (2009)
  29. [29]P. Descouvemont, D. Baye, Rep. Prog. Phys. 73, 036301 (2010)
  30. [30]Y.K. Ho, Phys. Rep. 99, 1 (1983)
  31. [31]J. Aguilar, J.M. Combes, Commun. Math. Phys. 22, 269 (1971)
  32. [32]S. Aoyama, T. Myo, K. Katō, K. Ikeda, Prog. Theor. Phys. 116, 1 (2006)
  33. [33]R. Suzuki, T. Myo, K. Katō, Prog. Theor. Phys. 113, 1273 (2005)
  34. [34]R. Suzuki, A.T. Kruppa, B.G. Giraud, K. Katō, Prog. Theor. Phys. 119, 949 (2008)
  35. [35]U.V. Riss, H.D. Meyer, J. Phys. B 26, 4503 (1993)
  36. [36]Y. Takenaka, R. Otani, M. Iwasaki, K. Mimura, M. Ito, Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2014 (2014)
  37. [37]M. Ito, K. Yabana, Prog. Theor. Phys. 113, 1047 (2005)
  38. [38]V.I. Kukulin, V.M. Krasnopol’sky, J. Horáček, Theory of Resonances, Principles and Applications (Kluwer Academic, 1989)
  39. [39]N. Tanaka, Y. Suzuki, K. Varga, R.G. Lovas, Phys. Rev. C 59, 1391 (1999)
  40. [40]C. Kurokawa, K. Katō, Phys. Rev. C 71, 021301 (2005)
  41. [41]C.H. Maier, L.S. Cederbaum, W. Domcke, J. Phys. B 13, L119 (1980)
  42. [42]S.G. Zhou, J. Meng, E.G. Zhao, J. Phys. B 42, 245001 (2009)
  43. [43]F. Hoyle, Astrophys. J. Suppl. 1, 121 (1954)
  44. [44]P. Descouvemont, D. Baye, Phys. Rev. C 36, 54 (1987)
  45. [45]Y. Kanada-En’yo, Prog. Theor. Phys. 117, 655 (2007)
  46. [46]Y. Funaki, Phys. Rev. C 92, 021302 (2015)
  47. [47]E. Uegaki, S. Okabe, Y. Abe, H. Tanaka, Prog. Theor. Phys. 57, 1262 (1977)
  48. [48]M. Kamimura, Nucl. Phys. A 351, 456 (1981)
  49. [49]M. Chernykh, H. Feldmeier, T. Neff, P. von Neumann-Cosel, A. Richter, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98, 032501 (2007)
  50. [50]Y. Suzuki, H. Matsumura, M. Orabi, Y. Fujiwara, P. Descouvemont, M. Theeten, D. Baye, Phys. Lett. B 659, 160 (2008)
  51. [51]J.H. Kelley, J.E. Purcell, C.G. Sheu, Nucl. Phys. A 968, 71 (2017)
  52. [52]S. Ali, A.R. Bodmer, Nucl. Phys. 80, 99 (1966)
  53. [53]B. Buck, H. Friedrich, C. Wheatley, Nucl. Phys. A 275, 246 (1977)
  54. [54]E.M. Tursunov, D. Baye, P. Descouvemont, Nucl. Phys. A 723, 365 (2003)
  55. [55]Y. Fujiwara, K. Miyagawa, M. Kohno, Y. Suzuki, D. Baye, J.M. Sparenberg, Phys. Rev. C 70, 024002 (2004)
  56. [56]P. Descouvemont, D. Baye, Phys. Lett. B 228, 6 (1989)
  57. [57]T. Ichikawa, N. Itagaki, T. Kawabata, T. Kokalova, W. von Oertzen, Phys. Rev. C 83, 061301 (2011)

Paper details

vlnc:W_6gjuczmj
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents