betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Does the inverse distance ladder rule out late-time solutions to the Hubble tension? A model-independent test using DES-Dovekie supernovae and DESI DR2 BAO

Abstract

It has been argued that the inverse distance ladder disfavours late-time solutions to the Hubble tension. We test this with a cosmographic expansion where HH is a fourth-order polynomial in 1−a1 - a. We combine the uncalibrated DES-Dovekie SNIa with DESI~DR2 BAO, assuming a standard sound horizon rd=147.05±0.30r_{\rm d} = 147.05 \pm 0.30~Mpc. Using only DES SNIa yields H0=76.25±2.87H_0 = 76.25 \pm 2.87 km/s/Mpc, which is 3.1σ3.1σ above the CMB-calibrated ΛΛCDM prediction but consistent with SH0ES (1.0σ1.0σ). Adding the legacy SNIa decreases H0H_0 to 67.98±0.6967.98 \pm 0.69 km/s/Mpc, 4.7σ4.7σ below SH0ES. The 8.278.27 km/s/Mpc drop in H0H_0 upon including the legacy SNIa cannot be attributed to expected sample variance: under a fiducial ΛCDMΛ\text{CDM} model, only 1.24%1.24\% of 10410^4 mock realisations exhibit such a large H0H_0 shift due to the changed redshift sampling. This points to a systematic tension between DES and legacy SNIa datasets. We next add local H0H_0 anchors (the bright siren, SNII, TRGB + SBF) and test a parametrisation where the ΛΛCDM H(z)H(z) is enhanced by ΔH(z)=Aexp⁡(−z/z1)ΔH(z) = A \exp (-z/z_1). We recover H0=70.00−0.98+4.78H_0 = 70.00^{+4.78}_{-0.98} km/s/Mpc and z1<0.086z_1 < 0.086 at 1σ1σ confidence using DES SNIa, but H0=67.66±1.01H_0 = 67.66 \pm 1.01 km/s/Mpc and z1z_1 is unconstrained using DES + legacy. Late-time solutions are thus viable with the homogeneous DES catalogue, but not with the legacy SNIa as published. Allowing them to be arbitrarily recalibrated relative to the main DES sample yields an inferred offset of ΔM_\rm{legacy} = 0.0646 \pm 0.0391~mag, raising the predicted H0H_0 to 71.03±1.9971.03 \pm 1.99 km/s/Mpc. Ongoing SNIa surveys like DEBASS will provide a homogeneous sample of SNIa down to redshifts accessible via the distance ladder, assessing the validity of the current legacy samples and hence the feasibility of late-time solutions to the Hubble tension.

Introduction

One of the most challenging problems in modern cosmology is the tension between different estimates of the present expansion rate H0H_0. This Hubble tension describes the discrepancy between the expansion rate of the Universe inferred through local distance measurements (e.g. H0SH0ES=73.17±0.86H_0^{\mathrm{SH0ES}} = 73.17 \pm0.86 km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1} from SH0ES; Breval et al. 2024) and the predicted expansion rate based on calibrating the parameters of the Lambda cold dark matter (Λ\LambdaCDM) standard cosmological paradigm (Efstathiou, Sutherland & Maddox 1990; Ostriker & Steinhardt 1995) using the Cosmic Microwave Background (CMB), which gives a far lower value (e.g. SPT-3G + ACT DR6 + Planck obtained that H0SPA=67.19±0.38H_0^{\mathrm{SPA}} = 67.19 \pm0.38 km s−1^{-1} Mpc−1^{-1}; SPT-3G Collaboration [107]). These results are in a 6.4σ6.4\sigma tension with each other. An even higher tension has recently been claimed by the Local Distance Network based on combining several popular local determinations and taking into account their covariance (H0DN Collaboration 2026). However, this does not properly model selection effects or distance priors (Desmond et al. 2026; Stiskalek et al. 2026). The three possible explanations for the tension are unaccounted-for systematics in the distance ladder, statistical inadequacy of the inferences (e.g. Becker et al. 2015; Feeney et al. 2018; Desmond et al. 2026; Percival 2026; Stiskalek et al. 2026; Stiskalek & Desmond 2026), and new physics beyond the standard Λ\LambdaCDM model (e.g. Valentino et al. 2025, and references therein). New physics could primarily affect the Universe prior to recombination or have little impact until more recent epochs, leading to a distinction between early-time and late-time solutions.

A useful expansion probe is provided by supernovae (SNe) of Type Ia (SNIa). These thermonuclear explosions occur when a carbon–oxygen white dwarf in a binary system reaches a mass close to 1.2 M⊙1.2\,M_{\odot}, as predicted by models like the dynamically driven double-degenerate double-detonation (D6^{6}) scenario (Shen et al. 2018a,b; Bauer et al. 2021). Since SNIa occur at nearly the same mass, they are good standardisable candles, i.e., the peak absolute magnitude MBM_B in the BB band can be estimated independently of the redshift zz (Phillips 1993; Tripp 1998; Phillips et al. 1999). Due to the known H0H_0–MBM_B degeneracy (Cai & Wang 2026; Wang & Wang 2026), SNIa require an absolute calibration to measure H0H_0. Since SNIa are very luminous (MB∼−19.3M_B \sim-19.3), they can be detected out to z≈2z \approx2 (Scolnic et al. 2022). However, it is difficult to access all of this redshift range using just one survey. Modern SNIa catalogues like Pantheon+ (Scolnic et al. 2022), Union3 (Rubin et al. 2025), and Unite (Camilleri et al. 2026) typically combine different surveys. This may create problems due to the use of different filters, selection functions, and relative calibration offsets (Betoule et al. 2014; Scolnic et al. 2014, 2015; Efstathiou 2025). A homogeneous catalogue with only one survey and one selection function would be far preferable for cosmological inference.

This is provided by the Dark Energy Survey (DES; DES Collaboration 2016) through its Dovekie catalogue (Popovic et al. 2026). This single-instrument dataset with a single filter system is typically complemented by legacy SNIa from older surveys to improve the leverage on the shape of the expansion history at z≲0.2z \lesssim0.2, where there are very few SNIa in DES (though it has SNIa down to z=0.073z = 0.073; DES Collaboration 2024). However, including the legacy SNIa risks the aforementioned problems with combining surveys, and assessing this legacy sample relative to the DES sample is a main aim of this paper. Our baseline analysis involves only SNIa in the DES data, which we label simply DES. We also consider an extension including the legacy SNIa (DES + legacy), which corresponds to what other authors typically mean by “DES” (e.g. DESI Collaboration 2025). This distinguishes our work from similar studies (most notably Popovic & Sullivan 2026), which generally do not distinguish between legacy and DES SNIa.

Our main motivation is the presently open discussion on whether the legacy SNIa have been correctly recalibrated onto the DES photometric filter system, something which cannot be directly verified through further observations given the transient nature of SNIa (Efstathiou 2025; Huang et al. 2025; Ormondroyd et al. 2026). Since the legacy SNIa lie in z∈[0.025,0.087]z \in[0.025, 0.087], they provide a critical lever on the value of H0H_0, making it crucial that they be unbiased. This motivates further analyses where we calculate the possible offset between the legacy SNIa and the main DES sample. This is also a crucial issue for the evidence for evolving dark energy, which is largely driven by the legacy SNIa; allowing an offset provides a better fit to the data in a Bayesian sense than allowing a time-variation in the equation of state of dark energy (Ormondroyd et al. 2026). In § 4.5, we explore the extent to which the legacy SNIa affect the evidence for evolving dark energy.

There are two main routes to determine the absolute SNIa magnitude MSNIaM_{\mathrm{SNIa}}. The first route is through the cosmic distance ladder, usually with three rungs. The first rung involves geometry to calibrate distance indicators like Cepheid variable stars (Leavitt & Pickering 1912; Riess et al. 2022; Breuval et al. 2024), the tip of the red giant branch (TRGB; Lee et al. 1993; Madore & Freedman 1995; Freedman et al. 2019; Hoyt et al. 2024), or the J-region Asymptotic Giant Branch (JAGB; Madore & Freedman 2020; Lee et al. 2025). The second rung is where the MBM_B calibration happens using SNIa host galaxies near enough to contain a first rung indicator. The third rung contains SNIa in the Hubble flow at z≳0.023z \gtrsim0.023, where peculiar velocities are not important in Λ\LambdaCDM, allowing a determination of H0H_0 from the slope of the Hubble diagram. Using this approach, the SH0ES collaboration derived a value of MB=−19.253±0.027M_B = -19.253 \pm0.027 (Riess et al. 2022; Scolnic et al. 2022).

The second route to MSNIaM_{\mathrm{SNIa}} is through the inverse distance ladder (IDL). This involves anchoring MSNIaM_{\mathrm{SNIa}} using our understanding of the early Universe to set the baryon acoustic oscillation (BAO) comoving sound horizon rdr_d at the end of the baryon drag epoch (zd≈1060z_d \approx1060; Hu & Sugiyama 1996; Eisenstein & Hu 1998) and then propagating this to intermediate redshifts using the BAO evident from galaxy clustering, which nowadays is typically obtained from the Dark Energy Spectroscopic Instrument (DESI) Data Release 2 (DR2; [33]). One common assumption which we follow is to adopt the Planck constraint of rd=147.05±0.30r_d = 147.05 \pm0.30 comoving Mpc (cMpc) from Planck Collaboration VI [100] (hereafter Planck [100]). This explicitly adopts Λ\LambdaCDM at early times, so the IDL approach implicitly assumes that the Hubble tension, if due to new physics, must be solved at late times. Under this assumption, MSNIa≃−19.30M_{\mathrm{SNIa}} \simeq-19.30 to −19.40-19.40 (Camilleri et al. 2025; Popovic & Sullivan 2026), which is significantly lower than suggested by the local distance ladder. This is because a lower H0H_0 value requires SNIa to be more distant at a given zz, which for given apparent magnitude requires the SNIa to be brighter. The discrepancy with the locally determined MBM_B leads to the usual conclusion that a successful solution to the Hubble tension requires a smaller rdr_d, which is possible only through new pre-recombination physics (Cai & Wang 2026; Sabogal et al. 2026; Tiwari et al. 2026).

Although the expansion history is nowadays mainly probed through the distance–redshift relation, it is possible to bypass distances altogether by instead focusing on the lookback time. The elapsed time between any two redshifts can be found using the cosmic chronometer (CC) technique, which involves comparing massive passive elliptical galaxies at those redshifts to determine the relative age (Jimenez & Loeb 2002; Moresco et al. 2012; Moresco 2015; Moresco et al. 2016, 2022; Moresco 2024). Since we can relate distance and lookback time using the speed of light, we can use CC datasets to calibrate MBM_B without assuming any value for rdr_d, thereby obtaining an estimate for H0H_0 (Cogato et al. 2024; Guo et al. 2025).

Early-time solutions to the Hubble tension seek to resolve it by decreasing rdr_d, which requires modifying the redshift dependence of the sound horizon and/or the redshift of recombination (Mirpoor​ian et al. 2025). Since BAO measurements are most sensitive to the product H0rdH_0r_d, reducing rdr_d allows for an increased H0H_0. However, these solutions face at least seven problems (Vagnozzi 2023). One of these is that they would imply a significantly reduced age of the Universe (Vagnozzi et al. 2022). This prediction is in significant tension with the observed ages of the oldest Galactic stars and globular clusters (Montalbán et al. 2021; Valcin et al. 2020, 2021; Cimatti & Moresco 2023; Souza et al. 2024; Valcin et al. 2025, 2026; Banik et al. 2026b). These features cannot be explained through a simple change to rdr_d. Moreover, currently known early-time solutions struggle with Big Bang nucleosynthesis (BBN) due to their need for a generically higher baryon density to match the CMB anisotropies, which affects primordial light element abundances (Giovanetti 2026; Launders et al. 2026; Poulin et al. 2026). More generally, the success of Λ\LambdaCDM in fitting the CMB anisotropies by now limits the scope for substantial modifications prior to recombination ([107] (Planck 2020; Calabrese et al. 2025)), including in models where electron density fluctuations cause inhomogeneous recombination (Lynch et al. 2026).

Late-time solutions to the Hubble tension avoid these problems by assuming standard pre-recombination physics, but such models have their own problems at z≲1z \lesssim1 (Krishnan et al. 2021a). In particular, Bansal & Huterer 2026 find that a model modifying only the late-time expansion history cannot simultaneously fit H0SH0ESH_0^{\mathrm{SH0ES}}, the DESI BAO data, and relative SNIa distances. A fit is possible only if MSNIaM_{\mathrm{SNIa}} takes a sharp step at very low redshift (z≲0.01z \lesssim0.01) or the distance-duality relation is broken. Both escapes are trivial since they decouple the calibrated SNIa from the remaining data. Importantly, their analysis rests on the Pantheon+ catalogue. A step in MBM_B at low redshift is degenerate with precisely the relative calibration offsets between surveys described above, given the difficulty of covering a very wide redshift range using the same survey. Their most successful late-time magnitude step model has a transition in the redshift range where a heterogeneous compilation is least able to separate new physics from filter-related changes to the zero point. This motivates the test we present here. We note that astrophysically it is difficult to understand why SNIa might abruptly change in intrinsic brightness, with terrestrial data placing strong constraints on models with a sharp change in GG in the geologically recent past (Banik, Desmond & Samaras 2025). Such models also face difficulties with the mass–radius relation of red dwarf stars due to their long thermal timescales (Sakstein & Desmond 2026).

Our main goal is to assess if the IDL can accommodate a late-time solution to the Hubble tension, i.e., if the assumption of standard pre-recombination physics is compatible with the high H0H_0 required to match various local constraints (Di Valentino et al. 2025; H0DN Collaboration 2026). The observational data we use for this purpose are described in § 2. We then explain the IDL, our Bayesian model comparison of late-time solutions to the Hubble tension, and consistency tests (§ 3). We go on to present our results (§ 4) and discuss their implications (§ 5). We conclude in § 6. In Appendix A, we present the Alcock–Paczynski (AP) consistency test between DESI DR2 BAO and DES-Dovekie SNIa. Appendix B reports how the inferred cosmological parameters depend on the polynomial order. Appendix C contains all the posteriors from our analyses. In Appendix D, we use ΛCDM mocks to better understand how our analysis is affected by the limited DES coverage at low redshift.

Observational data

DES-Dovekie SNIa

The DES-Dovekie compilation of SNe provides 1820 spectroscopically and photometrically classified events with their full statistical plus systematic covariance (Popovic et al. 2026). The intrinsic scatter contribution to this covariance is calibrated so that ΛCDM yields an acceptable fit to the Hubble diagram. This is because we currently lack sufficiently large samples of SNIa with redshift-independent distances from which the intrinsic scatter can be inferred, as is usually done with other indicators like Cepheids. The total SNIa uncertainties are therefore scaled to a reference cosmology, which means that an acceptable χ2\chi^2 under ΛCDM in SNIa-dominated analyses like ours does not by itself demonstrate that ΛCDM is an adequate description of the data. We consider two SN samples, which we label DES and DES + legacy throughout this paper. Our baseline is the DES sample, which uses the 1623 DES SNe alone (IDSURVEY = 10), leading to a redshift range of z∈[0.073,1.14]z \in[0.073, 1.14] – though in practice there is limited constraining power at z≲0.2z \lesssim0.2 (see figures 3 and 4 of DES Collaboration 2024). We select the SNe with magnitude uncertainty σm<1\sigma_m < 1, removing 82 SNe as these are likely contaminants (e.g. other types of SN) given they are down-weighted by the Bayesian Estimation Applied to Multiple Species (BEAMS) analysis (Kunz et al. 2007). They carry ≈10−5\approx10^{-5} of the total statistical weight, so removing them does not significantly change the results.

The DES + legacy sample adds an external low-redshift anchor from legacy surveys, which contribute a further 197 spectroscopically confirmed SNIa with z∈[0.025,0.087]z \in[0.025, 0.087], lowering the redshift floor from z≈0.073→0.025z \approx0.073 \to0.025. It is important to stress that both DES and legacy SNIa are uncalibrated as there is no independent determination of their absolute magnitude in the DES filters. We denote this absolute magnitude MDESM_{\rm DES} rather than MBM_B to differentiate it from the rest-frame Johnson BB-band in which the SH0ES MBM_B is defined. The reported distance modulus μ(z)=m(z)−MDES\mu(z) = m(z)-M_{\rm DES} assumes a fiducial MDES=−19.327M_{\rm DES} = -19.327, but this can be arbitrarily varied. We infer MDESM_{\rm DES} jointly with the other parameters, which implicitly imposes a calibration via the IDL. The predicted μ=25+5log⁡10DL/Mpc\mu= 25 + 5\log_{10}D_L/{\rm Mpc}, with the luminosity distance DLD_L found as follows:

DL=(1+zhel)DM(zHD),(1)D_L = (1+z_{\rm hel})D_M(z_{\rm HD}), \tag*{(1)}
DM(z)=c∫0zdz~H(z~),(2)D_M(z) = c\int_0^z \frac{\mathrm{d}\tilde{z}}{H(\tilde{z})}, \tag*{(2)}

where DMD_M is the comoving distance, zhelz_{\rm hel} is the heliocentric redshift of each SNIa, and zHDz_{\rm HD} is its “Hubble diagram” redshift obtained after corrections for peculiar velocities.

To study possible differences between the main DES sample and the legacy SNIa, we also consider adding a systematic offset of ΔMlegacy\Delta M_{\rm legacy} to the absolute magnitude of the legacy SNIa. This measures possible systematics when correcting the legacy SNIa for survey completeness effects or converting the observed legacy magnitudes to what would have been measured in the DES filters – despite the lack of direct measurements in those filters. We label this as DES + legacy (ΔMlegacy\Delta M_{\rm legacy}) and explain it further in § 3.6.

DESI DR2 BAO

The BAO is a statistical standard ruler arising from matter fluctuations in the primordial Universe (Eisenstein & Hu 1998). We consider the latest DESI data release (DESI DR2; DESI Collaboration 2025). They report six measurements of DM/rdD_M/r_d, six of DH/rdD_H/r_d at the same redshifts, and one of DV/rdD_V/r_d at a lower redshift:

DH(z)=cH(z),(3)D_H(z) = \frac{c}{H(z)}, \tag*{(3)}
DV(z)=[zDM2(z)DH(z)]1/3,(4)D_V(z) = \left[zD_M^2(z)D_H(z)\right]^{1/3}, \tag*{(4)}
rd=∫zd∞cs(z~)H(z~) dz~,(5)r_d = \int_{z_d}^{\infty}\frac{c_s(\tilde{z})}{H(\tilde{z})}\,\mathrm{d}\tilde{z}, \tag*{(5)}

where csc_s is the sound speed in the baryon–photon plasma. We use the full DESI covariance matrix, which has a block-diagonal form because measurements at different redshifts use different galaxies, making them independent.

CC

We use 15 CC measurements to constrain the expansion history without assumptions about MDESM_{\rm DES} or rdr_d (Moresco et al. 2012; Moresco 2015; Moresco et al. 2016). CC measurements constrain the Hubble–Lemaître parameter via the following relation

H(z)=−z˙1+z,(6)H(z) = -\frac{\dot{z}}{1+z}, \tag*{(6)}

where an overdot denotes a time derivative. z˙\dot{z} is measured through the differential age evolution of early-type galaxies (Jimenez & Loeb 2002). We use the full covariance reported in Moresco et al. (2020). The errors quoted in CC compilations like Moresco et al. (2022) omit the stellar-population modelling systematic. We find that this is crucial as it can significantly change the cosmological parameter posteriors. In particular, the error on rdr_d roughly doubles when considering the full covariance rather than only the diagonal terms. Since the covariance with other CC measurements is not known, we do not use the other 18 of the 33 available CC measurements (Moresco et al. 2020; Wang et al. 2026).

We use the CC data for an extended analysis in which a direct comparison between differential age H(z)H(z) measurements and DH/rdD_H/r_d BAO measurements can independently calibrate rdr_d (§ 4.3). This affords an IDL independent of the CMB.

Methodology

Model setup

The cosmic expansion history a(t)a(t) can be approximated as a Taylor series around the present epoch, where aa is the cosmic scale factor normalised to unity today and tt is the time since the Big Bang. The use of a Taylor series minimises assumptions about the expansion history, making the results model-independent. The series expansion is commonly based on redshift, but since we consider data out to z=2.33z = 2.33, we instead expand in the lookback scale factor a~=1−a\tilde{a} = 1 - a, limiting the range to 0–1. We therefore use the following series expansion:

E(a~)=1+∑k=1kmax⁡Cka~k,a~=z1+z=1−a,(7)E(\tilde{a}) = 1 + \sum_{k=1}^{k_{\max}} C_k \tilde{a}^{k}, \qquad\tilde{a} = \frac{z}{1+z} = 1-a, \tag*{(7)}

where E(a~)≡H(a~)/H0E(\tilde{a}) \equiv H(\tilde{a})/H_0 is the normalised expansion rate and kmax⁡k_{\max} is the order of the polynomial with coefficients CkC_k. Using the lookback scale factor a~\tilde{a} instead of zz leads to a narrower range because a~<1 ∀z\tilde{a} < 1\ \forall z. This is important here because DESI reaches out to z=2.33z = 2.33, which is too large for a convergent Taylor series since it converges only for ∣z∣<1|z| < 1 (Cattoën & Visser 2007). This means that expanding in powers of zz and fitting the model with data at z>1z > 1 is not a cosmographic expansion but rather a polynomial fit, which is clearly model-dependent (e.g. with fixed asymptotic behaviour). In this case, the parameters H0H_0, q0q_0, j0j_0, . . . do not represent the standard cosmographic parameters but rather are parameters of the polynomial model. This problem does not arise in our setup because a~≤0.70\tilde{a} \le0.70. Since the z≪1z \ll1 correspondence is a~=z−z2+O(z3)\tilde{a} = z-z^2+O(z^3), the deceleration parameter can be found from q0=C1−1q_0 = C_1-1.

A crucial aspect for a cosmographic analysis is the prior on the polynomial coefficients CkC_k, but it is difficult to estimate an appropriate prior range. Instead of directly bounding each CkC_k separately, we set a prior on the shape of the expansion history by requiring the following:

0≤E(a~)≤2+7a~,0≤a~≤a~max⁡,(8)0 \le E(\tilde{a}) \le2 + 7\tilde{a}, \qquad0 \le\tilde{a} \le\tilde{a}_{\max}, \tag*{(8)}

References

  1. [33]DESI Collaboration 2025, Physical Review D, 112, 083515
  2. [39]Etherington I. M. H., 1933, Philosophical Magazine, 15, 761
  3. [100]Planck Collaboration VI 2020, A&A, 641, A6
  4. [107]SPT-3G Collaboration 2026, Physical Review D, 113, 083504
  5. [136]Virgo & LIGO Collaborations 2017, Physical Review Letters, 119, 161101

Paper details

vlnc:W_6kjhxmye
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents