WorksMathematics
Geometric Rigidity of Manifolds Admitting -Modified Conformal Vector Fields
Abstract
We establish certain integral inequalities for -modified conformal vector fields on compact Riemannian manifolds and derive corresponding triviality and rigidity results. We further obtain integrability conditions for such vector fields and establish an extended Bourguignon-Ezin identity. We then prove that a compact Riemannian manifold admitting a non-trivial closed -modified conformal vector field is isometric to a round sphere under either a constant scalar curvature and positive Ricci curvature assumption or a suitable bound on the Ricci curvature involving the first nonzero eigenvalue of the Laplace operator. As a consequence, we obtain an extension of a classical sphere characterization result of Yano and Nagano to the corresponding result for a non trivial -modified conformal vector field assumed closed. Finally, we consider a complete Kähler manifold admitting a closed -modified conformal vector field , and show that is -modified Killing and around a non-zero point of the manifold splits as the product of the complex Euclidean plane and a complete Kähler manifold.
2020 Mathematics Subject Classifications: 53C21, 53C25
Introduction
A Riemannian manifold is said to be a Ricci soliton if it satisfies the equation
where denotes the Lie-derivative operator, is a smooth vector field on , is the Riemannian metric, is the Ricci tensor of , and is a real constant. If is the gradient of a smooth function , i.e., , then is called a gradient Ricci soliton. As a natural generalization of Einstein metrics and gradient Ricci solitons, Catino [4] introduced the notion of a generalized quasi-Einstein manifold. More precisely, an -dimensional Riemannian manifold is said to be generalized quasi-Einstein if it satisfies
where is a constant and is a smooth function on . Catino [4] showed that a complete generalized quasi-Einstein manifold with harmonic Weyl tensor and zero radial Weyl curvature is locally a warped product with an -dimensional Einstein fiber. In particular, taking
equation (2) becomes
The tensor
is referred to as the -Bakry-Émery Ricci tensor. When is constant, equation (3) defines an -quasi-Einstein manifold; see Case, Shu and Wei [3] and He, Petersen and Wylie [8]. A vector-field analogue of (3) was subsequently considered by Limoncu [9] and Barros and Ribeiro, Jr. [1]. More precisely, if denotes the 1-form metrically dual to the vector field , they considered
where is a constant. Moreover, in the limiting case , equation (4) reduces to the classical Ricci soliton equation (1). For a Riemannian manifold , it is interesting to know what happens when is both Einstein and -quasi Einstein. In this case, there exists a vector field on such that
where is a constant. Zhang and Chen [15] generalized the above setting by replacing the constant with a smooth function , thereby introducing the following definition.
Definition: A vector field on a Riemannian manifold is called an -modified conformal vector field if
where is a positive constant and .
When is constant and , a vector field satisfying (1.5) is called an -modified homothetic vector field; in the special case , it is called an -modified Killing vector field. is said to be trivial when . In the limiting case , equation (1.5) reduces to: , and hence recovers the usual notion of a conformal vector field. Zhang and Chen [15] established several rigidity results for -modified conformal vector fields. In particular, they proved that a connected compact Riemannian manifold of dimension at least 2 admits no -modified conformal vector field of constant length. They further showed in Riemannian case that, for Lie groups admitting left-invariant -modified conformal vector fields, the metric is Einstein and non-trivial -quasi-Einstein. Moreover, such Lie groups are solvable and isometric to a real hyperbolic space. In the compact setting, Poddar and Sharma [10] investigated -modified conformal vector fields and established several rigidity results. In particular, they proved that:
a compact Riemannian manifold admits no non-trivial -modified homothetic vector field; and
if is an -modified conformal vector field, with , on a compact Riemannian manifold satisfying
then is trivial.
More recently, Deshmukh et al. [6] obtained further triviality results for -modified conformal vector fields in both compact and non-compact settings. They also constructed an example of an -modified conformal vector field on a round sphere.
m-Modified Conformal Vector Fields On Compact Riemannian Manifolds
First, we establish the following generalization of the result (i) of [10] stated earlier.
Theorem 2.1 If is an -modified conformal vector field on a compact (without boundary) Riemannian manifold , then , equality holds when is Killing for , and vanishes for .
Remark 2.1 For constant, this theorem reduces to the result (i) of [10].
Proof. First, tracing equation (5) gives
Equation (5) can also be exhibited as
The exterior derivative of the 1-form is given by
As is skew-symmetric, we define a tensor field of type given by
Evidently, is skew self-adjoint, i.e., . Thus, (9) assumes the form
Adding equations (2.2 and (10) side by side, and factoring out gives
Now, we compute the covariant derivative of the squared -norm of using (11) as follows
Using this we compute
Next, multiplying both sides of (6) with , gives . Integrating it over the compact , using divergence theorem, and the identity: , we obtain
where is the -volume elemment of . Substituting for in (12) we have
Using this equation, along with the identity: , in equation (13) provides
Eliminating between (6) and (16) shows that
Now using (2.1) in the above, and simplifying we find that
Integrating it over compact provides
Going back to equation (14), using (2.10) and (2.1) we have that
At this point, multiplying the above equation with , and (2.12) with , and subsequently subtracting the resulting equations we obtain
The assertions of the theorem follow from equation (2.14). This completes the proof.
We turn our attention back to the result (ii) of [10] that provides a generalization of the following result [12] of Yano “If a compact Riemannian manifold admits a conformal vector field satisfying , then is parallel, and if the Ricci curvature is negative definite, then the conformal vector field is zero”. Improving this result further and extending the aforementioned result of Yano to the case of an -modified vector field, we prove the following result.
Theorem 2.2 Let be a compact Riemannian manifold admitting an -modified conformal vector field . If , then is parallel if , and vanishes identically if .
Proof. Recalling (2.6) and using it we compute
where denotes the curvature tensor of type for , defined by: for arbitrary . Contracting equation (20) at we have
Next, substituting for in the above equation gives
Through the computation:
and its trace at we obtain
where we have used (2.6) and the skew self adjointness of . Integrating the preceding equation over the compact , we have
Integrating equation (21) over the compact and making use of equations (22) and (2.14) we obtain the formula
The conclusions of the theorem follow immediately from this consequence, completing the proof.
Integrability Conditions for -Modified Conformal Vector Field
In this section, we derive integrability conditions for an -modified conformal vector field on a Riemannian manifold . By definition, the equation (5) is written in local co-ordinates as
Lie-differentiating the relation: along gives
Using (24) in it, and taking inner product with yields that
At this point we denote by and hence . Then we have
Use of the formula (Yano [13]):
in (25) provides
where denote the connection coefficients of . Now combined use of the formula [13]: and equation (26), gives
where and are components of an arbitrary vector field . Contracting (3.4) with respect to and we get
where are the components of the Ricci tensor of . Finally, we compute using (3.2) and (3.5) and thus obtain
Equations (3.3), (3.4), (3.5), (3.6) provide the evolutions of the connection coefficients, curvature tensor, Ricci tensor and scalar curvature along an -modified conformal vector field .
Extended Bourguignon-Ezin Identity and Scalar Curvature Constraints
Here we assume compact and admitting an -modified vector field . Integrating (3.6) over the compact we find that
Using the equation (2.1) and the identity: in (4.1) we obtain
We note that this reduces to the Bourguignon-Ezin identity [2] for a conformal vector field (for which ) on a compact Riemannian manifold. We state the above consequence as the following result.
Theorem 4.1 For an -modified conformal vector field on a compact Riemannian manifold of dimension , we have the extended Bourguignon-Ezin identity given by (4.2).
Remark 4.1 (31) is trivially satisfied by a compact Einstein manifold.
We close this section with the scalar curvature constraint. Using equation (23) in (31) and simplifying gives the following constraint on the scalar curvature :
It follows immediately from the above equation that
In particular, if is constant, and is non-zero and non-conformal, then the in-equality (33) shows that , because is not conformal, i.e., . However, if , then (32) implies that , , and hence from (6) we get , a contradiction. Consequently, . Hence we have proved the following result.
Proposition 4.1 If a compact Riemannian manifold of dimension has constant scalar curvature , and admits a non-zero non-conformal -modified conformal vector field, then is bounded below by the positive constant .
Closed -modified Conformal Vector Fields On Compact Riemannian Manifolds
We begin this section by recalling the following rigidity theorems for conformal vector fields on compact Riemannian manifolds.
Theorem 5.1 (Yano [13]) Let be an -dimensional closed Riemannian manifold with constant scalar curvature admitting a nontrivial gradient conformal vector field, then is isometric to a round sphere.
Theorem 5.2 (Deshmukh and Al-Solamy [5]) Let be an -dimensional compact Riemannian manifold whose Ricci curvature satisfies
where is a constant and denotes the first nonzero eigenvalue of the Laplace operator. If admits a nonzero conformal gradient vector field, then is isometric to the sphere .
Motivated by the aforementioned results, we now establish the corresponding rigidity result (a generalization of Theorem 5.2) for closed -modified conformal vector fields.
Theorem 5.3 Let be a compact Riemannian manifold with positive Ricci curvature admitting a non-trivial closed -modified conformal vector field. Then is isometric to a round sphere if one of the following conditions is satisfied:
(i) has constant scalar curvature and .
(ii) The Ricci curvature satisfies
where is a constant and denotes the first nonzero eigenvalue of the Laplace operator.
Proof. Let be a non-trivial closed -modified conformal vector field on , and let denote its metrically dual 1-form. Since is compact, the Hodge decomposition gives
where and is a 1-form such that . We are going to show that the harmonic component in (34) vanishes under our hypothesis. Since is closed, its dual 1-form is closed, and hence
On the other hand, the Hodge decomposition gives
Thus
so that is harmonic. The Bochner formula for a harmonic 1-form yields
where denotes the vector field metrically dual to . Integrating (35) over the compact manifold and applying the divergence theorem, we obtain
Since Ric is positive definite, both terms in the integrand are non-negative and
whenever . Consequently, (5.3) implies
It follows from (5.1) that
and hence
We next exploit the -modified conformal equation. As , equation (1.5) becomes
Let us define: . Then
and a direct computation gives
Using (5.5) in (5.6), we obtain
Therefore,
Thus is a gradient conformal vector field. It remains to verify that is non-trivial. Suppose, to the contrary, that . Then integrating equation (2.1) and using the divergence theorem would imply , a contradiction to the nontriviality of . Therefore, is a non-zero function on . Hence admits a non-trivial gradient conformal vector field. To prove part (i), we assume that has constant scalar curvature. Since , Theorem 5.1 applies and yields that is isometric to a round sphere. This completes the proof of part (i).
For part (ii), the positivity of the Ricci curvature, together with the assumed upper bound on the Ricci curvature, allows us to apply Theorem 5.2. Consequently, is isometric to a round sphere. This completes the proof.
Corollary 5.1 Let be an -dimensional compact Riemannian manifold, whose Ricci curvature satisfies
for a constant , where is the first nonzero eigenvalue of the Laplace operator. If admits a non-trivial closed conformal vector field, then is isometric to a round sphere.
Proof. The result follows immediately by letting in (1.5) and applying Theorem 5.3 (ii).
Corollary 5.2 Let , , be a compact Einstein manifold admitting a non-trivial closed -modified conformal vector field (). Then is isometric to a round sphere.
Proof. The result follows directly from Theorem 5.3 (i) and Proposition 4.1 (here non-conformal means ()), together with the fact that an Einstein manifold has constant scalar curvature for , as a consequence of Schur’s lemma.
Remark 5.1 Corollary 5.2 raises the following question “What can we say about a compact Einstein manifold admitting a non-trivial non-closed -modified conformal vector field ()?” For ( conformal) we know, by a classical result of Yano and Nagano [14], that a compact Einstein manifold admitting a non-Killing conformal vector field is isometric to a Euclidean sphere (this result was proved more generally in [14], for a complete under the condition that is complete. For compact, is automatically complete.)
Closed -modified Conformal Vector Fields On Kähler Manifolds
An almost Hermitian manifold is a real -dimensional smooth manifold with a tensor field and a Riemannian metric such that and for arbitrary vector fields on . If is integrable, i.e., the Nijenhuis tensor defined by vanishes, then is a Hermitian manifold. An almost Hermitian manifold is said to be an almost Kähler manifold if the fundamental 2-form defined by is closed i.e., ( is the exterior derivative operator). An almost Kähler manifold whose underlying almost complex structure is integrable i.e., the Nijenhuis tensor of vanishes on , is known as a Kähler manifold. It is known that for a Kähler manifold , where is the Riemannian connection of . Conformal vector fields on Kähler manifolds are known to exhibit strong rigidity phenomena. A classical result of Goldberg [7] says that a closed conformal vector field (i.e., the metrically equivalent 1-form is closed) on a Kähler manifold is necessarily homothetic. In this section, we examine the impact of the existence of a non-zero closed -modified conformal vector field on a Kähler manifold, and prove the following result.
Theorem 6.1 If a complete Kähler manifold of real dimension admits a real non-trivial -modified () closed conformal vector field , then reduces to -modified () Killing vector field, and around any non-zero of , splits as the product , where is the Euclidean complex plane and is a complete Kähler manifold of real dimension .
Proof. The -modified equation can be written in view (2.6) and (2.4) as
for arbitrary , because is closed, i.e. and hence . Operating (6.1) by the complex structure tensor we have
Next, substituting for in (6.1) we also have
Before proceeding ahead, we denote the 1-form metrically equivalent to by , i.e., . Using (6.2) and (6.3) we find that
The use of equation (6.2) in the above equation entails
where is the exterior derivative operator and arbitrary vector fields on . Skew-symmetrizing it with respect to shows that
Operating (6.5) with gives
where we used the co-boundary formula: , , and the property: for and forms respectively. Expanding (6.6) for arbitrary we have
Using (6.4) in the foregoing equation and factoring out provides
Contracting it with respect to we get
because , by hypothesis. Now, using (6.1) we compute and find that
Contracting it at and using (6.7) we find that
where we have denoted the Ricci tensor of type also by . As commutes with on a Kähler manifold, the foregoing equation implies that
Going back to (6.8), operating by and using the Kähler property: for all , and then contracting at gives
Comparing equations (6.9) and (6.10) and noting that and by hypothesis, shows that
Using this in (6.7) at once implies that is constant. Therefore, as , (6.11) implies that . Hence (6.1) reduces to
Now, as is Hermitian, , we have for arbitrary vector fields . So , and hence is orthogonal to . On an open dense subset of , let , and denote the 2-dimensional distribution spanned by and . To show that is integrable, it suffices to show that . For this, , where we used (6.12). Now, for real functions on , computing
shows that is totally geodesic in . Next we consider the distribution orthogonal to and complementary in the tangent bundle on . Let , i.e., , for any , i.e. , for arbitrary real functions on . Then we have and . Subtracting them and using (6.12), we get . Thus . Finally, to show that is totally geodesic in , we compute
because are to . Also, from (6.8) and the consequence , we have [and hence ] for any . Thus the leaves of the foliation are flat. We also note that a totally geodesic submanifold in Kähler of codimension 2 is also Kähler. Summing up, we have shown that around any non-zero of , splits locally as where is a complete -dimensional Kähler manifold. This completes the proof.
Statements and Declarations
Competing Interests: On behalf of all the authors, the corresponding author states that there is no conflict of interest.
Data Availability: Data sharing is not applicable to this article as no datasets were generated or analysed during the current study.
No Use Of Artificial Intelligence: No Artificial Intelligence has been used in the preparation of this article.
References
- [1]Barros, A. and Ribeiro, E. Integral formulae on quasi-Einstein manifolds and applications. Glasgow Math. J. 54 (2012), 213-223.DOI
- [2]Bourguignon, J.-P. and Ezin, J.-P. Scalar curvature functions in a conformal class of metrics and conformal transformations. A.M.S. 301 (1987), 723-736.
- [3]Case, J., Shu, Y. and Wei, G. Rigidity of quasi-Einstein metrics. Diff. Geom. Appln. 29 (2011), 93-100.arxiv.org/abs/0805.3132
- [4]Catino, G. Generalized quasi-Einstein manifolds with harmonic Weyl tensor. Math. Z. 271 (2012), 751-756.
- [5]Deshmukh, S. and Al-Solamy, F. Conformal gradient vector fields on a compact Riemannian manifold. Colloq. Math. 114 (2009), 71-80.DOI
- [6]Deshmukh, S., Turki, N. B., Chen, B-Y. and Fatima, T. Properties of m-modified conformal vector fields on a Riemannian manifold. Mathematics. 11(9) (2026), 29774-29795.DOI
- [7]Goldberg, S.I.: Curvature and Homology, Academic Press, N.Y. 1964.
- [8]He, C., Petersen, P. and Wylie, W. On the classification of warped product Einstein metrics. Comm. Anal. Geom. 20 (2012), 271-311.arxiv.org/abs/1010.5488
- [9]Limoncu, M. Modifications of the Ricci tensor and applications. Arch. Math. 95 (2010)DOI
- [10]Poddar, R. and Sharma, R. On the triviality of m-modified conformal vector fields. Indag. Math. (2025)arxiv.org/abs/2409.07607
- [12]Yano, K. On harmonic and Killing vector fields. Ann. Math. 55 (1952), 38-46.
- [13]Yano, K. Integral formulas in Riemannian geometry, Marcel Dekker, 1970.
- [14]Yano, K. and Nagano, T. Einstein spaces admitting a one-parameter group of conformal transformations. Ann. Math. 69 (1959), 451-461.
- [15]Zhang, H. and Chen, Z. On m-Modified Conformal Vector Fields. J. Geom. Anal. 33 (2023), 258.DOI