WorksMathematics
Minimal quasisections of circle bundles
Abstract
Let be an oriented circle bundle over an oriented closed surface, and let denote its Euler number. A quasisection is a smooth surface , possibly with boundary, together with a generic smooth map such that . The local formula expresses the Euler number of a bundle as a sum of the weights of the singular vertices of a quasisection. In the present paper determine the minimal number of singular vertices for closed and for bordered quasisections for a given circle bundle. For bordered quasisections, For closed quasisections, If is even, If is odd, We also provide examples of quasisections that realize these minimal values.
Introduction
Let be an oriented circle bundle, that is, an oriented locally trivial fiber bundle with fiber over a closed oriented surface [2]. Such bundles are classified by their Euler classes, or, equivalently in this setting, by their Euler numbers.
Definition 1. A closed quasisection of a circle bundle is a pair , where is a closed smooth surface and is a smooth map such that . A bordered quasisection is defined in the same way, for a compact smooth surface possibly with boundary. In both cases, is not required to be connected.
Throughout the paper, the maps and are assumed to be generic, or stable, in the sense of Whitney singularity theory [1]. Thus the image of may have curves of transverse self-intersection, isolated triple points, and Whitney umbrellas. At regular points of , the only singularities of are folds and pleats. The additional genericity assumptions used below are listed in § 2.1.
Given a quasisection, Theorems 4 and 5, taken from [4], express the Euler number of the bundle as the sum of the weights of certain singularities of the quasisection. This singularities are called singular vertices, see section 2.1–2.3 for definition.
Definition 2. The number of singularities is the number of all singular vertices of . We define two numbers:
Clearly, and are functions of .
A closed (respectively, bordered) quasisection is minimal in its class if its number of singular vertices equals (respectively, ).
In this paper, we establish the values of and and provide examples of quasisections that realize these minimal values.
Theorem 1. For a circle bundle with Euler number ,
Preliminaries
We recall the main constructions and definitions, referring the reader to [4] for further details, figures, and examples.
Singular vertices of a closed quasisection
We first recall the constructions for closed quasisections: the singular curve, the portraits of singular vertices, their weights, and the local formula. Throughout Sections 2.1–2.3, the quasisection is assumed to be closed. In Section 2.4 we then describe precisely what changes when the quasisection is allowed to have boundary.
Let be a closed quasisection of a circle bundle .

Figure 1. A regular sheet crosses a fold.
The singular curve of is the closure in of the union of the following sets:
the image under of the self-intersection locus of ;
the image under of the fold locus.
We refer to the second set as the projection of the folds. In particular, the images under of Whitney umbrellas and pleat points belong to the singular curve; we call them the projections of Whitney umbrellas and the projections of pleats, respectively.
A singular vertex is a point of one of the following types:
A self-intersection of the singular curve.
The projection of a Whitney umbrella.
The projection of a pleat.
We assume that all singular vertices are stable, that is, that they persist under sufficiently small perturbations of . The precise genericity conditions are listed in [4].
Portraits of singular vertices of a closed quasisection
Let be a closed quasisection and let . Choose a small positively oriented circle around . Equip a neighborhood of and its preimage with product metrics for which is locally an orthogonal projection and all fibers have the same length. Then is a flat torus. Cut this torus along a circle transverse to the fibers and depict it as an annulus whose inner and outer boundary circles are identified. Orient the fibers inward, from the outer boundary circle to the inner one, and mark the non-empty union of curves .
This picture is called the portrait of . Two portraits are considered equal if they differ by an orientation-preserving fiberwise diffeomorphism of the torus.
Lemma 2. (1) The portrait of an intersection of two projected folds is as in the left-hand part of Figure 2, up to adding or removing simple circles. At least one simple circle is present because . Such a singular vertex is called type I.
(2) The portrait of a projected pleat is, up to reflection, as in the center of Figure 2. The number of simple circles may vary. Such a vertex is called type II, right if its portrait is the one shown in the figure, and type II, left if its portrait is its reflection.
(3) The portrait of the projection of an intersection between a fold and a regular sheet is, up to reflection, as in the right-hand part of Figure 2. Such a vertex is called type III, right if its portrait is the one shown in the figure, and type III, left if its portrait is its reflection, in both cases up to adding simple circles.

Figure 2. The non-symmetric portraits. Left: type , with two fold curves and one simple circle; at least one simple circle must be present. Center: type , with a pleat and no simple circles. Right: type , with a simple circle crossing a fold curve.
Singular vertices of types , , and are called essential vertices.
Closed quasisection and the local formula
In this subsection is again a generic closed quasisection.
Let be a singular vertex of type .
Move a point counterclockwise along , starting in a sector with no projected fold curves, equivalently, in a sector where has the minimum number of points. Order the two fold curves according to when they are first encountered by .
Let be the number of simple circles between the first and second fold curves, counted from the first fold curve in the direction of the fiber. Similarly, let be the number of simple circles between the two fold curves, counted from the second fold curve in the direction of the fiber.
Lemma 3. (1) The portrait of an essential vertex of type is determined by the two non-negative integers and defined above. Their sum is non-zero.
(2) The portrait of an essential vertex of type is determined by, and determines, its side (right or left) and the number of simple circles.
(3) The portrait of an essential vertex of type is determined by, and determines, its side (right or left) and the number of simple circles.
In [4], weights are assigned to the essential singular vertices:
Definition 3. (1) For an essential vertex of type , set
(2) For a right essential vertex of type , set
For a left essential vertex of type , set
(3) For a right essential vertex of type , set
For a left essential vertex of type , set
Theorem 4 (The local formula for closed quasisections, [4]). The Euler number of a circle bundle with a generic closed quasisection is equal to the sum of the weights of its essential singular vertices:
Bordered quasisections and the local formula
Now is a generic quasisection whose boundary may be non-empty. In this setting the singular curve contains also the projection of . The definitions of the three interior types , , and remain unchanged. Four additional types of essential vertices can occur:
: a transverse intersection of two projected boundary curves;
: a transverse intersection of a projected boundary curve and a projected fold;
: the projection of an intersection of a boundary curve with a regular sheet;
: the projection of a point at which a fold terminates on the boundary of (a -point).
The types , , and have right and left versions, distinguished by reflection of their local portraits. For and , the numbers and count the simple circles between the two ordered curves in the two directions along the fiber, as for type ; in particular, . For types and , is the number of simple circles in the portrait. The right–left conventions are those of Section 6 of [4].
The weights of the new types of singular vertices are
The weights of types , , and remain unchanged.
Theorem 5 (The local formula for possibly bordered quasisections, [4]). For a generic bordered quasisection of , the Euler number is equal to the sum of weights:
Clearly, if , the four boundary terms vanish and the formula reduces to Theorem 4.
Proof of Theorem 1: Lower bounds for the number of singular vertices
Let be a generic (possibly bordered) quasisection. The definition of the weights implies immediately:
Consequently, the weight of every singular vertex satisfies
and we have
Since is an integer, we have
The same is true for closed quasisections:
but this is not yet the desired formula from item 2 of Theorem 1 for odd , so we need a further analysis.
Assuming that is closed, recall that the degree of the quasisection, denoted by , is either the integral degree or the degree modulo 2 of the map .
It is proven in [4 Theorem 12] that
(1) if is orientable and , the integral degree vanishes; (2) if is non-orientable and is odd, its degree modulo 2 is zero.
If is odd, then for each regular point of the base, the number of points in the preimage is even, and therefore all essential vertices have absolute weight at most . This follows from the definitions of the weights and from
Thus the local formula gives for every closed quasisection when is odd, that is,
Thus we have proved all the lower bounds in Theorem 1.
Proof of Theorem 1: Examples realizing the equalities
It remains to construct examples of quasisections with the desired numbers of singular vertices. We first construct examples for Euler numbers 2 and 1, and then combine these basic examples for a bundle with arbitrary Euler number.
A quasisection with the smallest possible number of singular vertices for
A quasisection with the smallest possible number of singular vertices for . Assume that . Choose a small1 disk in the base . Take two trivializations of the bundle, one over and the other one over .
Each of the trivializations gives a diffeomorphism of the gluing torus
with the standard torus . The restrictions of the two trivializations to the boundary differ (up to homotopy) by the square of the Dehn twist with respect to the fiber.
Now choose a constant section over . Its graph is some bordered surface whose boundary lies on the gluing torus .
Let and be the standard generators of . In the coordinates induced by the trivialization over , the curve is homotopic to . In Figure 3, it is visualized as a curve spiraling on . To build a quasisection, we construct inside a surface whose boundary equals . Then gluing and along their boundaries yields a closed quasisection.
Figure 3. The construction for . Left: the smooth Möbius band, its fold curve, and the ambient solid torus . Right: the projection of the fold curve to ; its three cusps are the three vertices of type .
Identify with the unit disk and write the circle fibers as . So a point of has coordinates , where and is taken modulo .
Consider the Möbius band
For , set
Set also
Let us comment on this formula. For fixed , the map parameterizes a chord of the disk . The unit vector is the normal to this chord, is the signed distance of the chord from the origin, and gives its direction. The value corresponds to its midpoint, while and correspond to its endpoints. The endpoints lie on .
The image is a smooth Möbius band in the solid torus . Geometrically, imagine a moving horizontal segment in the solid torus whose projection is a chord of tangent to the three-cusped curve shown in Figure 3. The union of these segments is . The homotopy class of its boundary is , hence can be glued to along their boundaries.
We arrive at a closed quasisection. To find the critical curve, write the first component of as
Since and , we have
Consequently, and are linearly dependent exactly when . Since and , this value lies in the interior of the chord. Substitution gives the critical curve
Since
and ranges from to , the critical curve has exactly three cusps that correspond to three pleats. They are singular vertices of type with , have the same sign, and each has weight . The glued surface is therefore a closed quasisection of with exactly three singular vertices; see Figure 3.
Clearly, the same number of vertices is realized in the bordered class. For instance, one may add an embedded regular disk whose image lies over a region already covered by the closed quasisection. This creates a non-empty boundary but no new singular vertices.
A quasisection with the smallest possible number of singular vertices for
Assume that . Again, choose a small disk , set , and take trivializations of the bundle over and over . This time their restrictions to differ (up to homotopy) by one positive Dehn twist with respect to the fiber.
We use the same notation as above:
. Choose a constant section over and denote its graph by . In the coordinates induced by the trivialization over , its boundary is homotopic to , since the Dehn twist adds one copy of the fiber class to .
Let and choose a constant section disk over . Its boundary represents the class . Consequently, and have algebraic intersection one. Without loss of generality, we choose these curves to intersect transversely at exactly one point.
Extend by attaching a narrow collar across , and modify the surface near the attaching curve so that the resulting disk, still denoted by , is smooth and satisfies
The collar may be chosen in general position so that is one transverse arc joining to . Its two endpoints project to two right vertices of type with . This construction is shown on the left-hand side of Figure 4.

Figure 4. Local constructions for . Left: the bordered construction formed by two disks and the normal strip produced by the twist. Right: the closed construction formed by the boundaries of two tubular neighborhoods. The gluing torus and the relevant intersections are indicated in both pictures, which are shown in the coordinates induced by the trivialization over .
The construction has only two singular vertices, each of weight
so their total weight is 1. This gives the required example of a bordered quasisection with the smallest possible number of singular vertices for .
For the closed construction, start with the two embedded surfaces and from the bordered construction and take the boundaries of sufficiently small tubular neighborhoods of the two surfaces separately. After a small generic perturbation, the two resulting closed surfaces form a closed quasisection with exactly four singular vertices, all of type with and weight . This construction is shown on the right-hand side of Figure 4.
One can go even further and, using an appropriate surgery, eliminate the self-intersections of the quasisection. The surgery can be visualized through the portraits of singularities; see Figure 5.

Figure 5. Eliminating self-intersections by surgery, as seen in the portraits of singularities. Left: before the surgery. Right: after the surgery.
The general case
Choose pairwise disjoint disks in . The bundle is trivial over their complement, and its Euler number is the sum of the degrees of the clutching twists around the disks. We may therefore insert independent copies of the - and - constructions from § 4.1 and § 4.2 and attach them to a common partial section over the complement. Since their supports are disjoint, the numbers of their singular vertices add up. For negative , use negative powers or simply reverse the orientation of the base.
For bordered quasisections, write or . Use copies of the construction in § 4.1 and, in the odd case, one bordered copy of the construction in § 4.2. This gives or
vertices, respectively. For , a section together with an embedded regular disk is a bordered quasisection without singular vertices. Together with (1), these constructions prove item 1 of Theorem 1.
For closed quasisections with , use copies of the closed construction in § 4.1; the result has vertices. If is odd, use disjoint copies of the closed Euler-number-one construction from § 4.2; the result has vertices. Finally, for a global section has no singular vertices. These examples attain (2) and (3), and complete the proof of Theorem 1.
Acknowledgement. This work is supported by the Russian Science Foundation (project 25-11-00058).
AI Usage Declaration. We hereby declare that no AI was used in the completion of this research.
References
G. Panina: St. Petersburg Department of Steklov Mathematical Institute; [email protected]; I. Kiselev: St. Petersburg State University,[email protected]; Timur Shamazov: St. Petersburg Department of Steklov Mathematical Institute; [email protected]
References
- [1]V. I. Arnold, S. Gusein-Zade, A. Varchenko, Singularities of Differentiable Maps, vol. I, Monographs in Mathematics, vol. 82, Birkhäuser, 1985.
- [2]S. Chern, Circle bundles, Lecture Notes in Mathematics, vol. 597, 1977, 114–131.DOI
- [4]G. Panina, M. Turevskii, T. Shamazov, Quasisections of circle bundles and Euler class, arXiv:2410.22453.arxiv.org/abs/2410.22453
