WorksMathematics
Semi-exact functors and the conjecture of Coulembier and Flake
Abstract
We introduce the notion of semi-exact functors between abelian categories, which are characterised by either preserving or breaking exactness of sequences. We prove semi-exact functors are always exact with respect to a canonically determined exact structure. For a symmetric tensor category \Cs, we define a support theory by considering all -linear symmetric monoidal, semi-exact functors up to equivalence, and conjecture that it agrees with the Balmer spectrum of the stable category when is finite. We prove a weak form of this conjecture and other results for Tannakian categories and in characteristic 0. Critical to the positive characteristic case is a functor constructed by Coulembier and Flake who were interested in higher Frobenius functors. We show that their construction, which relies on the theory of abelian envelopes, gives a natural source for semi-exact functors, and at least in the Tannakian setting gives all -linear, symmetric monoidal, semi-exact functors.
Introduction: semi-exact functors
Throughout, denotes an algebraically closed field. We begin with a definition.
Definition 1.1. Let be abelian categories. We say an additive functor is semi-exact if for any short exact sequence
the following are equivalent:
the sequence
is exact;
the sequence
is exact;
the sequence
is exact.
It is clear that any exact functor is semi-exact; however, there are examples of semi-exact functors which are not exact. For example, if , where , and , then the functor is semi-exact.
The notion of semi-exact functor does not appear in the literature to the best of this author’s knowledge. The purpose of this paper is to make a study of such functors. We find that in the setting of symmetric tensor categories, semi-exact functors have remarkable properties, and a rich connection to support theory.
Conjectures and theorems
By a symmetric tensor category over we mean a symmetric monoidal, rigid, -linear, locally finite abelian category such that . If has finitely many simples and enough projectives, we additionally say that is finite.
If is a finite symmetric tensor category, then we may form its stable module category , which is a tensor triangulated category, and therefore has a Balmer spectrum consisting of all thick prime tensor ideals in . We write for the closed points of the topological space .
In the following conjecture, let denote the characteristic of our field , which is either a prime number or . If , we set , and for a prime we let denote the union ([3]). We use the abbreviation LSM functor for a -linear, symmetric monoidal functor (not necessarily exact).
Conjecture 1.2. Let be a finite symmetric tensor category. Then there is a bijection:
where on the left hand side we have if the two functors are naturally isomorphic as monoidal functors.
Let us explain where the map in Conjecture 1.2 comes from. Given a non-exact, semi-exact LSM functor , its object kernel will define a point such that if and only if lies in the support of . If we are able to identify with (which happens for Tannakian categories [4] and conjecturally always holds [23]), then we show that must be a closed point. This gives a map in one direction. However it may be surprising that this correspondence could be a bijection—we return to this shortly. In the meanwhile, here is another (perhaps more outlandish) conjecture. We will say that an LSM functor is surjective if every object in is a subquotient of an object in the image of .
Conjecture 1.3. Let be symmetric tensor categories, and additionally assume that is finite. Let be a surjective, semi-exact, LSM functor. Then is also finite.
Note that Conjecture 1.3 holds for exact functors [15 Prop. 1.8.19], but is false if we drop the semi-exactness property; indeed, semisimplification functors are a large source of counterexamples. Here is some immediate evidence for Conjectures 1.2 and 1.3.
Theorem 1.4. Conjectures 1.2 and 1.3 hold if is characteristic or is Tannakian, i.e. for a finite group scheme .
Connection with abelian envelopes
What is perhaps interesting about the proof of Theorem 1.4 is it can be done with a uniform argument that suggests how the proofs of Conjectures 1.2 and 1.3 would go in general. The key observation is that in each case, given a closed point , we can construct a nonzero additive tensor ideal with finitely many indecomposables that are all supported at the point . From this, one can turn the crank of the theory of abelian envelopes (see [8 Thm. 2.4.1], [24]) to obtain a functor
where is a certain tensor ideal in , is the abelian envelope of , and is a finite symmetric tensor category. We prove that the functor is semi-exact, and moreover in good situations any semi-exact functor on must factor through one of the form for some . Using the recent work [11] which proves the Benson-Etingof-Ostrik conjecture for finite tensor categories, along with uniqueness of fibre functors to , Theorem 1.4 follows.
The conjecture of Coulembier-Flake
While § 1.2 gives a path to proof, the very difficult part is to construct an additive tensor ideal with the prescribed properties. In characteristic 0 this is not so difficult, but in characteristic we require (a generalisation of) the ‘Saturation Conjecture’ of Coulembier-Flake [9 Conj. 5.4.2(1)]. This conjecture provides such additive tensor ideals in the case of quasi-elementary abelian groups, meaning ones isomorphic to , where denotes the th Frobenius kernel of , and is the cyclic group of order . Given such a quasi-elementary abelian group of rank , along with a generic point , [9] provides an additive tensor ideal with the desired properties, and a surjective, semi-exact LSM functor
The Saturation Conjecture of Coulembier-Flake was recently proven in [11]. We will provide a different more geometric proof which was discovered independently.
Upshot in characteristic 0 setting
The upshot of Theorem 1.4 in characteristic 0 is as follows. In this case, Deligne’s theorem [12] implies that for a supergroup of the form , where is a finite group and is an -module. From an element we obtain a Duflo-Serganova functor ([13], [19])
which is a semi-exact (by Hinich’s lemma, for the experts in superalgebras) LSM functor. Theorem 1.4 implies that any semi-exact functor on must be isomorphic to for some .
Upshot in characteristic
Let be a finite group scheme in characteristic , and write . Then every point arises as a generic closed point in , where is a quasi-elementary abelian subgroup of [18]. Using the construction of Coulembier-Flake, we obtain, by restriction to , a semi-exact LSM functor
The upshot of Theorem 1.4 is that every (non-exact) semi-exact LSM functor on arises in this way.
Connection to support theory
The bijection in Conjecture 1.2 point toward a purely abelian approach to support theory which may be useful even beyond the finite setting. For a field extension , define to be the extension of scalars of , which is once again a symmetric tensor category [16 Lem. 2.2]. If are field extensions of , and
are LSM functors, then we write if there exist a field extension of both and such that and are coequalised by the natural functors and . This defines an equivalence relation on the set of LSM functors ranging over all field extensions of . Now define
We equip with a topology by declaring a basis for the closed sets to be those of the form , where runs over all objects of . Then for , we define its semi-exact support to be
By definition is closed, and in this way defines a support theory on which can easily be shown to satisfy the tensor product property:
One advantage of is that it does not require to be quasi-Frobenius. However, if is quasi-Frobenius, then defines a support theory on .
Conjecture 1.5. If is a finite symmetric tensor category, then is homeomorphic to , and is the universal support theory for .
It is possible that Conjecture 1.5 holds for any quasi-Frobenius category, but we have not computed any examples yet.
Statement on AI usage and story
This project began when the author discovered a proof of the Coulembier-Flake Saturation Conjecture using ChatGPT Astra 6.1. While writing up this result, the author became aware that Coulembier and Flake had recently also found a proof, which can now be found in [11] (see also the proof given by ChatGPT in [6]). However the author was originally motivated by the semi-exactness property in connection with the paper [20], which led to this paper.
The author used ChatGPT Astra 6.1 to help with the proof of Theorem 1.4, whose statement evolved over the last two months of work. The author also used AI to find references, understand related works in the literature, and to check the final version. Anyone interested in a more detailed AI usage statement is welcome to write the author.
This paper has been written entirely by the author, and the author takes full responsibility for its accuracy.
Acknowledgements
The author would like to foremost thank Kevin Coulembier and Johannes Flake for their comments on an initial draft of this preprint, and for helpful discussions thereafter. The author gives a hearty thanks to Bregje Pauwels for many insightful discussions and for coining the term semi-exact. The author further thanks Jonathan Gruber for interesting conversations about this project. Finally, the author thanks OpenAI for providing a temporary ChatGPT for Academic Researchers account.
Semi-exact functors, continued
We return to the study of semi-exact functors , where are now arbitrary abelian categories. Let us begin with an example.
In particular, in characteristic the semisimplification functor , which is given by
is a semi-exact functor. (For the definition and properties of , we refer to [16].)
Remark 2.2. Example 2.1 shows that a semi-exact functor need not be middle-exact.
Here is a simple but useful lemma, whose proof we omit.
Lemma 2.3. Suppose that is semi-exact, and $0 \to X \to Y \to Z \to 0$ is a short exact sequence in .
If , then .
If , then .
Exact structure from a semi-exact functor
Let be a semi-exact functor between abelian categories. Consider the class of short exact sequences $0 \to A \to B \to C \to 0\mathcal{A} is exact.
Proposition 2.4. The set is an exact category, and is exact with respect to this exact structure.
Proof. We verify the axioms of an exact category. The only nontrivial axioms to check are that the pushout of admissible monomorphisms and the pullback of admissible epimorphisms remain admissible. We will prove it for admissible monomorphisms, with the case of admissible epimorphisms being similar. Let be a monomorphism in such that is exact. Consider a morphism giving the pushforward which fits into a short exact sequence
Because is admissible, will be a monomorphism, and thus by definition of a semi-exact functor, the following sequence is exact:
It follows that is the pushout of along . Since the pushout of a monomorphism is a monomorphism in an abelian category, is a monomorphism, implying that is an admissible monomorphism, as desired.
It is now obvious that is exact on , so this completes the proof. □
2.1.1. A further exactness property. We say that an abelian category is quasi-Frobenius if it has enough injectives, enough projectives, and injectives and projectives agree. If is quasi-Frobenius, we can consider the stable category , which is the quotient of by the ideal of morphisms factoring through a projective (equivalently, an injective) object. The category has the structure of a triangulated category, where the triangulated shift is given by
where is the injective hull of . Moreover, every exact triangle in is of the form
where $0 \to X \xrightarrow{\alpha} Y \xrightarrow{\beta} Z \to 0$ is a short exact sequence in . We do not describe the boundary map here.
Lemma 2.5. Suppose that is quasi-Frobenius, is semi-exact, and for all projectives . Let
be a short exact sequence such that . Then we have a natural isomorphism
Proof. We have an exact triangle in . Thus there exists a short exact sequence $0 \to Y \to Z \oplus I \to \Sigma(X) \to 0$ in , for some injective in . Since , the semi-exactness property implies that as desired. □
Preliminaries on symmetric monoidal categories
A symmetric pseudo-tensor category will mean a Karoubian, -linear, rigid symmetric monoidal category. We recall that a symmetric tensor category is a symmetric pseudo-tensor category which is additionally abelian and locally finite.
Given a symmetric pseudo-tensor , a tensor ideal of is an ideal of (meaning a choice of subgroups satisfying the usual closure properties) such that for all .
An additive tensor ideal of (also known as a thick tensor ideal in some places) is a collection of objects of , closed under isomorphisms and direct sum(mands), such that if and , then .
Given a tensor ideal of , we write for the collection of objects such that , which will be an additive tensor ideal.
Given an LSM functor of symmetric pseudo-tensor categories, we will write for tensor ideal of morphisms such that , and set .
Semi-exact LSM functors
If is a symmetric tensor category over which has enough projectives, then it will be quasi-Frobenius and we may define its stable module category . In this case will be a symmetric monoidal, rigid, -linear triangulated category (otherwise known as a tensor triangulated category).
The following lemma is well-known [9 Lem. 2.2.2].
Lemma 2.6. If is an LSM functor and is quasi-Frobenius, then the following are equivalent:
is exact;
for all non-zero projectives in ;
for some non-zero projective in .
Let be quasi-Frobenius, and let be a non-exact, semi-exact LSM functor. By Lemma 2.6, for all projectives in , and thus factors through a functor , which by abuse of notation we also denote . Write
Since is invertible in , is invertible in , and thus is simple. Moreover, we have
Lemma 2.7. If $0 \to X \to Y \to Z \to 0$ is a short exact sequence in such that , then we have a natural isomorphism
Proof. This follows from Lemma 2.5 and the fact that is monoidal. □
The Balmer spectrum
We refer to [1] for more details of the following construction. We continue to assume that is a quasi-Frobenius symmetric tensor category. Recall that a prime thick tensor ideal in is a proper triangulated full subcategory such that
if and , and
if , then either or .
We define the Balmer spectrum to be the topological space whose points are thick prime tensor ideals in , with a basis of closed sets given by where runs over objects of . We write for the closed points of . Recall that given an object , its support is defined to be .
Lemma 2.8. Let be a non-exact, semi-exact, LSM functor. If is quasi-Frobenius, then descends to a prime thick tensor ideal of .
Proof. If is not exact, then must contain all projective objects, so descends to an additive tensor ideal of . To show is a prime thick tensor ideal, we first observe that it clearly satisfies properties (1) and (2), so it remains to show that it is a triangulated full subcategory of . For this, it suffices to prove that if is a triangle and , then . However all triangles in arise from short exact sequences in , thus we may apply e.g. Lemma 2.3 for the result. □
Corollary 2.9. Let be a non-exact, semi-exact LSM functor. Then there exists such that for all , if and only if .
Lemma 2.8 gives a mapping:
Question 2.10. Is a bijection onto ?
Remark 2.11. Note that Conjecture 1.2 is the case of Question 2.10 when is additionally assumed to be finite. A natural first case to consider beyond the finite setting is representations of a quasi-reductive supergroup in characteristic .
The Ext-algebra
Let be symmetric tensor categories, and suppose that is quasi-Frobenius. Let denote a non-exact, semi-exact LSM functor, and write . Consider the -graded -algebra
where multiplication is defined as follows. Given , , define to be
Lemma 2.12. is a domain.
Proof. Indeed, since is simple for all , any non-zero must be an isomorphism, so any product of non-zero homogeneous elements must be non-zero. □
Now write , which is a graded-commutative -algebra [1 Prop. 3.3]. We obtain an algebra morphism
via the maps
Let denote the kernel of . Then since is a domain, is a homogeneous prime ideal of .
Let us write for the homogeneous prime spectrum of , meaning the set of homogeneous prime ideals of . For , define
Then defines a prime ideal in [1 Thm. 5.3]. Hence we obtain a map
Observe that is a subspace of . We now introduce the following assumption:
Assumption (⋆): is a homeomorphism of onto .
Note that assumption (⋆) is known to hold for finite symmetric tensor categories in characteristic 0 ([2], [21] and [14]), for representations of finite group schemes [4], and for representations of unipotent finite supergroup schemes [5]. Conjecturally it is expected to hold for all finite symmetric tensor categories [23].
Theorem 2.13. Continuing with our assumptions above, we have the following:
(1) Either is the irrelevant ideal, or is a closed point in .
(2) If assumption (⋆) holds, then under this identification , and thus is a closed point.
Proof. For part (1), suppose that is not the irrelevant ideal. Then . It follows that has Krull dimension 1, and so is a point, and will be the pullback of this point under , and thus is closed.
For part (2), we need to prove that for , if and only if . And indeed, we see that if and only if
is exact, which by semi-exactness is equivalent to
being exact. However is simple, meaning must be an isomorphism, so this is equivalent to . Now Corollary 2.9 implies this is equivalent to , as desired. □
Remark 2.14. It is possible that is the irrelevant ideal if is not finite. For example, consider the supergroup , where acts nontrivially on , and set . Then , meaning every prime ideal is irrelevant.
Saturation, abelian envelopes, and semi-exact functors
Let be a quasi-Frobenius symmetric tensor category, and let . We say that a non-zero additive tensor ideal of realises if
every nonzero object has support precisely , i.e. but for all , and
has finitely many indecomposable objects.
Suppose that is an additive tensor ideal in which realises . Let denote the largest tensor ideal of such that . By an abelian envelope of we mean a symmetric tensor category and a faithful LSM functor such that if is another symmetric tensor category then any faithful LSM functor factors uniquely through an exact LSM functor .
Theorem 2.15. There exists an abelian envelope , where is finite, such that the induced functor given by the composition
is semi-exact.
For the proof, we begin with a lemma.
Lemma 2.16. There exists an additive tensor ideal such that is the unique minimal additive tensor ideal in which contains . In other words if is another additive tensor ideal in strictly containing , then it must contain .
Proof. We take for a minimal non-zero additive thick tensor ideal in , which exists because has finitely many indecomposables. Then suppose that is an additive tensor ideal which strictly contains . Then since , there must exist which is supported at . Therefore for non-zero we must have , meaning that is a non-zero additive tensor ideal contained in . Since is minimal, it must be equal to , and therefore must contain . □
Proof of Theorem 2.15. Let be the additive tensor ideal from Lemma 2.16. Then satisfies the assumptions of [8 Thm. 2.4.1 (2)], where the minimal cover is . Thus admits an envelope , and moreover (1) restricted to is full and (2) will be the category of projectives in .
It remains to prove that is semi-exact. Let $0 \to A \to B \to C \to 0\mathcal{C} is exact. Let be non-zero. Tensoring with , we obtain an exact sequence
However is projective, and thus injective, meaning each term in the exact sequence is injective. Hence we obtain a retraction . Because is fully faithful on , there exists a map such that , where . However does not contain the identity on any object in , and thus must lie in the Jacobson radical of . Hence is invertible, implying that the triangle
is split in . Thus is exact, and since is faithful and exact, this forces to also be exact, as desired. □
Saturation conjecture of Coulembier-Flake
For this section, denotes an algebraically closed field of characteristic . In this section, we establish a generalisation of [9 Conj. 5.4.2(1)] in order to construct semi-exact functors in positive characteristic.
Let , and write
for a root subgroup with normalising Borel subgroup . For , we obtain a morphism , where denotes the cyclic group of order , given by:
Let denote the th Frobenius kernel of . For , we have a morphism
Write for the image subgroup scheme. Then is an embedding if and only if .
Putting them together, for a choice of , we obtain a map
and this map is an embedding if and only if the are linearly independent over and , and the image depends only on .
For which define an embedding, we set
which is a subgroup of .
Let denote the th Frobenius kernel of . We have natural restriction functors
Write Tilt for the category of tilting modules for . This is a pseudo-tensor category, and the tensor ideals are exactly , where (see [7]). Here denotes the th Steinberg module of . The main conjecture of [9] can be stated as follows.
Conjecture 3.1. Let . Then .
We aim to prove Conjecture 3.1 by proving the following stronger theorem.
Theorem 3.2. Let . Then .
In the case , we obtain the following as a corollary:
Corollary 3.3. Let . Then .
We now turn to the proof of Theorem 3.2. Write for the distribution algebra of , where denotes the -th divided power of a generator of . Recall that is equivalent to the category of -modules such that for [17]. Thus is the category of modules over the subalgebra . We have a natural, exact (although not monoidal) functor such that , and acts by zero on for .
First step: formulating a sufficient condition
Let . We have a commutative diagram
Here is the natural restriction functor.
Lemma 3.4. The functor is an equivalence of abelian categories.
Proof. Indeed, first observe that restricts to the free module of rank one over both and (this can be shown using the polynomial model of the Steinberg representation, see e.g. [9 §5.3] and [11 Lem. 3.2]). Moreover, by the explicit polynomial realisation of . Thus takes a free module of rank one to a free module of rank one. Since is exact and faithfully, and fully faithful on projectives, it follows it is a Morita equivalence. □
Now, let , and let be such that . Finally, let , so that and . Our goal is to prove the following.
Theorem 3.5. We have .
It is easy to see that Theorem 3.5 implies both Theorem 3.2, and thus also Conjecture 3.1 and Corollary 3.3.
Second step: studying the fibre of an induced module
Consider . This is naturally a -equivariant module over .
Lemma 3.6. is a free -module of rank .
Proof. Indeed, because is self-injective, there exists an exact sequence of -modules , where and are free. However as a module over itself, so . Applying left exactness of induction and the isomorphisms
yields short exact sequences of -modules
Because has global dimension , this implies is projective by a standard syzygy argument. □
Write for the maximal ideal of , which is -invariant. Then
will be a -module of dimension .
For the following, recall that are the divided powers of a generator of .
Lemma 3.7. We have for .
Proof. Indeed, let be the line fixed pointwise by , and let . Then is a -equivariant vector bundle on with fibre at and fibre at . For a point , we have
Thus the action of on the fibre of at is obtained by conjugating the action at by
The operators are eigenvectors for this conjugation. Since acts by on the fibre at for , these operators must act by zero on the fibre of at every nonzero . But acts trivially on the underlying space , so the operators will act -linearly on . Since is a vector bundle and these operators act trivially away from , they must act trivially everywhere, including the fibre at , completing the proof. □
In the following, write for the irreducible module of highest weight .
Corollary 3.8. If is a composition factor of , then .
Proof. Indeed, if then must act nontrivially by the Steinberg tensor product theorem. □
Corollary 3.8 and [3 Lem. 3.3] now imply:
Corollary 3.9. is a tilting module.
Now consider . It is easy to see that , which is tilting by Corollary 3.9.
Third step: producing a -equivariant splitting of
Observe that for all , we have a natural morphism of -modules
This must be an isomorphism since is a free -module. On the other hand, we have , where denotes the costandard module of highest weight . Thus has a filtration by costandard modules.
Now consider the short exact sequences:
The object has a filtration by costandard modules, and thus
for all , since is tilting. For this provides a splitting of off , and then at a splitting off , and so on.
Working inductively, for each we obtain a splitting of off , which is compatible with the splitting off . Therefore we obtain a map of vector spaces
Moreover, this map is equivariant for the natural action of .
Recall we have a short exact sequence of -equivariant -modules
If we complete this sequence with respect to it will remain exact ([25 Lem. 10.97.1]), and thus we have embeddings of -modules
This diagram is moreover a pullback. We now observe that has a nonzero map to for only finitely many , since the socle of is . Hence lands in under the composition of the bottom horizontal embeddings, and hence must land in . We may conclude:
Lemma 3.10. The map splits as a -module.
Fourth step: obtaining a global -equivariant splitting
Consider the -equivariant map induced by the -module action:
We claim this is an isomorphism. Indeed, it is an isomorphism in a neighborhood of since maps isomorphically onto the fibre there. Since the complement of is a homogeneous -space, and is -equivariant, it must be a global isomorphism.
Taking the fibre at the base point , we obtain an isomorphism of -modules
which finishes the proof of Theorem 4.2.
Recalling that , we additionally obtain the following corollary.
Corollary 3.11. Let . Then there exists , all of whose weights are -restricted, such that
Proof of Theorem 1.4
The Coulembier-Flake functor
In [9], an LSM functor is constructed (subject to the validity of Conjecture 3.1), which depends on the choice of a sufficiently generic point . We now generalise this construction to a quasi-elementary abelian group
to produce a functor
where , which will depend on the choice of . The construction we give follows the ideas from § 2.5. Let , and let denote the additive tensor ideal in generated by . Then by Theorem 3.2, realises a point which is described in [10 Cor. 4.2.7]. Thus we may apply Theorem 2.15 to obtain an abelian envelope
Thus we obtain a functor
and we know that is not killed while goes to . Thus, writing for the tensor ideal of generated by , and using the classification of tensor ideals in [7], we obtain a faithful LSM functor
which therefore factors through a tensor functor from the abelian envelope of , which is :
Lemma 4.1. The functor is an equivalence of categories.
Proof. Because is incompressible [3], it suffices to prove that is a surjective tensor functor. By the theory of abelian envelopes explained in § 2.5, the indecomposables of will make up all of the projective indecomposables of . However is in the image of the functor , and so the image of must contain all projectives in . From here it is straightforward to show that is surjective. □
We have thus constructed the desired LSM functor
Theorem 4.2. The functor is semi-exact.
Proof. Indeed, this follows from Theorem 2.15. □
Finite group schemes and quasi-elementary subgroups
Let be a finite group scheme, and let . Recall that a quasielementary group scheme is one isomorphic to for some . For every point , there exists a minimal quasi-elementary subgroup such that lies in the image of [18].
Finite supergroup schemes in characteristic 0
If is characteristic and is a finite symmetric tensor category, then by [12], for a finite group , an -module , and such that , and acts by on . We write . In this case, the works of [2], [21], and [14] give the Balmer spectrum as
Thus to a point we will associate an element , which is well-defined up to non-zero scalar and -orbit.
The proof of Theorem 1.4
We now give a proof of Theorem 1.4. Therefore we either assume that is characteristic and with as in the setup of § 4.3, or that is characteristic and for a finite group scheme .
Proof of Theorem 1.4. Let be a surjective semi-exact functor. If is exact, then must be finite by [15 Prop. 1.8.19], and thus we now assume that is not exact. Then by Theorem 2.13, determines a point .
If is characteristic , then by § 4.3, lifts to a non-zero element , and in this case we let denote the purely odd, one-dimensional supergroup generated by . Then we set , where denotes the trivial -module.
If is positive characteristic, then arises from a quasi-elementary abelian subgroup of rank such that it restricts to a generic point in . In this case, let , and set .
Lemma 4.3. The support of is exactly the point .
Proof. In characteristic we may apply [4 Prop. 9.5(2)]. In characteristic , the induced module is given by , which has support precisely the -orbit of , as desired. □
Recall that for , we have the identity
In all cases we have that generates an additive tensor ideal in with finitely many indecomposables, and thus must do the same in . Write for the additive tensor ideal generated by . Then since is supported exactly at by Lemma 4.3, realises in the sense of § 2.5. By Theorem 2.15 there exists an abelian envelope
Lemma 4.4. .
Proof. Because if and only if does not lie in the support of , it is clear that . We must prove the opposite inclusion.
Let be a morphism in . Then must lie in the categorical radical of the finite additive category . Since has finitely many indecomposables, there exists such that . We claim that . Indeed, it may be factored as
and thus by assumption is . It follows that in . But since is a tensor category, this forces , completing the proof. □
It now follows that defines a faithful symmetric monoidal functor , and thus by the universal property we obtain a surjective, exact tensor functor fitting into the following diagram:
Since is surjective and exact, and is finite, must also be finite. Since are finite, there exists exact tensor functors as above, by the main theorem of [11]. By [11 Thm. 4.7], must be isomorphic to , and thus
It follows that if , then , which proves the injectivity of the map in Conjecture 1.2. Surjectivity follows from the existence of . □
References
A.S.: School of Mathematics and Statistics, UNSW Sydney, NSW 2052, Australia
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]P. Balmer, Spectra, spectra, spectra—tensor triangular spectra versus Zariski spectra of endomorphism rings, Algebr. Geom. Topol. 10 (2010), no. 3, 1521–1563; MR2661535.DOI
- [2]B. D. Boe, J. R. Kujawa and D. K. Nakano, Tensor triangular geometry for classical Lie superalgebras, Adv. Math. 314 (2017), 228–277; MR3658717.arxiv.org/abs/1402.3732
- [3]D. J. Benson, P. I. Etingof and V. Ostrik, New incompressible symmetric tensor categories in positive characteristic, Duke Math. J. 172 (2023), no. 1, 105–200; MR4533718.DOI
- [4]D. J. Benson, S. Iyengar, H. Krause, and J. Pevtsova, Stratification for module categories of finite group schemes, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 31 (2018), no. 1, 265–302; MR3718455.arxiv.org/abs/1510.06773
- [5]D. J. Benson S. Iyengar, H. Krause, and J. Pevtsova, Stratification and duality for unipotent finite supergroup schemes, in Equivariant topology and derived algebra, 241–275, London Math. Soc. Lecture Note Ser., 474, Cambridge Univ. Press, Cambridge, ; MR4327102.
- [6]OpenAI, Fiber functors for finite symmetric tensor categories in positive characteristic.DOI
- [7]K. Coulembier, Tensor ideals, Deligne categories and invariant theory, Selecta Math. (N.S.) 24 (2018), no. 5, 4659–4710; MR3874701arxiv.org/abs/1712.06248
- [8]K. Coulembier, P. I. Etingof, and V. Ostrik, Tensor ideals of abelian type and quantum groups, arXiv preprint arXiv:2511.08859 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2511.08859
- [9]K. Coulembier and J. Flake, Towards higher Frobenius functors for symmetric tensor categories, Selecta Math. (N.S.) 32 (2026), no. 5, Paper No. 98, 54 pp.; MR5134613.arxiv.org/abs/2405.19506
- [10]K. Coulembier and J. Flake, A conjecture on the tensor ideal for an elementary p-group generated by the restriction of a Steinberg module. arXiv preprint arXiv:2507.02722.
- [11]K. Coulembier and J. Flake, The Benson–Etingof–Ostrik conjecture for finite tensor categories, arXiv preprint arXiv:2610.04096 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2610.04096
- [12]P. Deligne, Catégories tensorielles, Mosc. Math. J. 2 (2002), no. 2, 227–248; MR1944506.DOI
- [13]M. Duflo and V. Serganova, On associated variety for Lie superalgebras. arXiv preprint math/0507198.
- [14]C. M. Duprieski and J. R. Kujawa, On support varieties for Lie superalgebras and finite supergroup schemes, J. Algebra 525 (2019), 64–110; MR3909818.
- [15]P. I. Etingof et al., Tensor categories, Mathematical Surveys and Monographs, 205, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2015; MR3242743.
- [16]P. I. Etingof and V. Ostrik, On the Frobenius functor for symmetric tensor categories in positive characteristic, J. Reine Angew. Math. 773 (2021), 165–198; MR4237968.
- [17]E. M. Friedlander, Support varieties for rational representations, Compos. Math. 151 (2015), no. 4, 765–792; MR3334895.DOI
- [18]E. M. Friedlander and J. Pevtsova, Representation-theoretic support spaces for finite group schemes, Amer. J. Math. 127 (2005), no. 2, 379–420; MR2130619.DOI
- [19]M. Gorelik, C. Hoyt, V. Serganova, and A. Sherman, The Duflo–Serganova Functor, Vingt Ans Après, Journal of the Indian Institute of Science, 102(3), pp.961-1000.
- [20]C. Hone, F. Klein, B. Pauwels, A. Sherman, O. Yacobi, and V. L. Zhang, Semisimplifying categorical Heisenberg actions and periodic equivalences, arXiv preprint arXiv:2509.07377 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2509.07377
- [21]H. Huang and K. B. Vashaw, Group actions on monoidal triangulated categories and Balmer spectra, Doc. Math. 30 (2025), no. 5, 1055–1083; MR4934522.arxiv.org/abs/2311.18638
- [23]D. K. Nakano, K. B. Vashaw and M. T. Yakimov, On the spectrum and support theory of a finite tensor category, Math. Ann. 390 (2024), no. 1, 205–254; MR4800913.DOI
- [24]M. Stroiński, Identity in the presence of adjunction, Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN 2024, no. 18, 12711–12745; MR4798647.arxiv.org/abs/2401.09892
- [25]The Stacks Project Authors, Stacks Project, https://stacks.math.columbia.edu (2018).