In this work, we are interested in the decomposition of trilinear forms. We associate this decomposition with the decomposition into irreducible subspaces of the group algebra associated with the symmetric group. We have a correspondence between a ternary form and a symmetric trilinear form, in the same way that we have the correspondence between a quadratic form and a symmetric quadratic form. We are then interested in the decomposition of ternary forms into a sum of cubes of linear forms and as an application we find the Tartaglia formulae on the expression of the roots of equations of degree 3.
Introduction
The decomposition of a bilinear form into a sum of a symmetric form and a skew-symmetric form is actually based on the decomposition into irreducible subspaces of the associative group algebra defined by the symmetric group Σ2 of degree 2. Starting from this remark, we propose a decomposition of trilinear forms by describing a decomposition of the group algebra associated with the symmetric group Σ3 of degree 3. Recall that if G is a finite group, the group algebra A(G) defined by G is the finite dimensional vector space generated by G and this space is naturally endowed with an associative algebra structure and a G-module structure.
We extend this result to trilinear applications with values in a vector space. This is the case, for example, of the associator of a multiplication of a non-associative algebra. This makes it possible to highlight particular classes of such algebras.
To complete this work, we are interested in ternary forms (also called cubic forms) associated with symmetric trilinear forms. We show under which conditions these ternary forms on a two-dimensional K-vector space E can be decomposed into a sum of two cubes of linear forms. As a direct consequence, we find again the Tartaglia formulae giving the expressions of roots of real equations of degree 3.
We briefly touch upon finding solutions to degree 5 equations using this method.
The trilinear forms and more generally the multilinear forms occur in different mathematical areas and subject such as cryptography (see [2]) and also in the study of properties of algebra laws (see [1]).
Definition
Trilinear forms
Let E be a K-vector space where K=R or C. A map
f:E3→K
is a trilinear form if f is a linear form with respect to each of its arguments. If dimE=n and if {e1,⋯,en} is a basis of E, then the writing of f in this basis is an homogeneous algebraic expression of degree 3. The constants
aijk=f(ei,ej,ek)
are the structure constants (or coefficients) of f with respect to this basis. The formulae of change of basis are the classical formulae corresponding to f∈(E⊗E⊗E)∗.
Definition 1. Let f be a trilinear form on E. Then
(1) f is symmetric if for every x1,x2,x3∈E,
∀σ∈Σ3,f(xσ(1),xσ(2),xσ(3))=f(x1,x2,x3),
(2) f is alternating if it vanishes when two inputs are the same.
A trilinear form on E is antisymmetric (skew-symmetric) if
f(xσ(1),xσ(2),xσ(3))=−f(x1,x2,x3)
for every transposition σ∈Σ3 and for every x1,x2,x3∈E. But, since we assume that the characteristic of K is 0, the notions of antisymmetric and alternating trilinear forms coincide.
A p-linear form f:Ep→K is defined in the same way as a linear form with respect to each of its p arguments.
Symmetrization-alternatization
Let f be a trilinear form on E. The trilinear form fs defined by
fs(x1,x2,x3)=σ∈Σ3∑f(xσ(1),xσ(2),xσ(3))
is symmetric. It is called the symmetrization of f.
is alternating. It is called the alternatization of f.
Remark : casep=2. It is well known, that for bilinear forms we have a converse to this construction. Given a symmetric bilinear form f1 and an alternating bilinear form f2, there is a unique bilinear form f such that
fs=f1,fa=f2.
This form is given by
f=2fs+fa
(recall that we assume that Char(K)=0).
In the next section, we will give an interpretation of this decomposition in terms of representations of Σ3 to extend it to the trilinear case.
The group algebra K[Σp]
Generalities
If Σp is the symmetric group of degree p, then the group algebra K[Σp] is the associative algebra over K whose underlying K-module is the free module over K on the underlying set of Σp and whose multiplication is given on basis elements by the group operation. An element of K[Σp] is a formal combination
v=σ∈Σp∑aσσ
The action of Σp on K[Σp] is defined by
(σ,v=i∑aiσi)⟶σv=i∑aiσ−1∘σi.
For each v∈K[Σp], we denote by O(v) the corresponding orbit and by Fv=K(O(v)) the linear subspace of K[Σp] generated by O(v). A subspace F is called invariant if for every σ∈Σp, we have σF⊂F. In particular the subspaces Fv are invariant.
Examples. We denote by τi,j the transposition between i and j.
(1) p=2. We have
Σ2={Id,τ1,2}
and
K[Σ2]={a1Id+a2τ1,2,ai∈K}.
If v=a1Id+a2τ1,2, then O(v)={v,a2Id+a1τ1,2}. We deduce that dimFv=2 except if a1−a2=0.
Proposition 2.Assume that v=0. Then dimFv=2 except if v=a1(Id−τ1,2) or v=a1(Id+τ1,2). In these last cases, if a1=0, dimFv=1
If we denote by
V2=Id−τ1,2,W2=Id+τ1,2
then FV2 and FW2 are the only one-dimensional invariant subspaces of K[Σ2] and we have the classical decomposition
K[Σ2]=FV2⊕FW2.
(2) p=3. We have
Σ3={Id,τ1,2,τ1,3,τ2,3,c,c2}
where c is the cycle (2,3,1) and c2=c∘c. If we denote by V3 and W3 the vectors
then dimFV3=dimFW3=1 and these spaces are the only one-dimensional invariant subspaces of K[Σ3].
Irreducible subspaces of dimension 2 for p=3
An invariant subspace F of K[Σ3] is called irreducible if any invariant subspace of F is trivial. The only one-dimensional irreducible subspaces are FV3 and FW3.
Assume now that F is a 2-dimensional irreducible subspace of K[Σ3]. For any v=0∈F, {σv,σ∈Σ3} is a generating family of F and there exists σ∈Σ3, such as {v,σv} is a basis of F.
Let v=a1Id+a2τ12+a3τ13+a4τ23+a5c1+a6c2 be in K[Σ3].
The family {v,τ1,2v} is linearly dependent
The hypothesis implies τ1,2v=λv. Solving this linear system, we obtain λ=±1 and v=(a1,a1,a3,a4,a4,a3) or (a1,−a1,a3,a4,−a4,−a3). Since dimFv=2, then there exists σ∈Σ3 such that {v,σv} is a basis of Fv. If we also have that τ1,3v=λv, then v=V3 or W3 and Fv is not irreducible. Then we can assume that {v,τ1,3v} is a basis of Fv.
In the first case, that is v=(a1,a1,a3,a4,a4,a3), we have
v+τ1,3v+τ2,3v=(a1+a3+a4)W3.
If a1+a3+a4=0, W3∈Fv and this subspace is not irreducible. Then a1+a3+a4=0 and
v=(a1,a1,a3,−a1−a3,−a1−a3,a3).
In the second case, that is v=(a1,−a1,a3,a4,−a4,−a3), we have
v−τ1,3v−τ2,3v=(a1−a3−a4)V3
This implies a4=a1−a3 and
v=(a1,−a1,a3,a1−a3,−a1+a3,−a3).
The family {v,τ1,2v} is a basis of Fv
In this case we consider the vector u=v+τ1,2v. This vector is in Fv then Fu is a subspace of Fv. If dimFu=1, then Fu=FV3 or FW3 and Fv is not irreducible. Then Fu=Fv. But {u,τ1,2u} is linearly dependent. So we return to the previous case.
Proposition 3. Let us consider the vectors
u1=(1,1,0,−1,−1,0),u2=(1,1,−1,0,0,−1).
and
u3=(1,−1,0,1,−1,0),u4=(1,−1,1,0,0,−1).
Then the subspaces Fui are 2-dimensional irreducible subspaces.
Theorem 4. We have the following direct decomposition of K[Σ3] in irreducible subspaces
K[Σ3]=FV3⊕FW3⊕Fui⊕Fuj,i=j.
In fact the vectors V3,W3,ui,τ13ui,uj,τ13uj,(i=j) are linearly independent.
Decomposition of a trilinear form
Let φ be a p-linear form on E and v=∑aiσi∈K[Σp]. We define the p-linear form φv by
φv(x1,…,xp)=∑aiφ(xσi(1),…,xσi(p)).
For example, the symmetric and alternating part of φ correspond to
φs=φVp,φa=φWp.
In particular, if φ is a bilinear form, the decomposition in symmetric and alternating part corresponds to
φ=21(φV2+φW2)
and it is associated with the decomposition
R[Σ2]=FV2⊕FW2
in irreducible subspaces. We generalize this remark to the trilinear case.
is identified with an homogeneous polynomial expression Pφ of degree 3 in the variables xji.
If φ=φs is symmetric, then Pφ is a symmetric polynomial. But any symmetric polynomial in n3 variables x11,x12,⋯,x1n,x21,x22,⋯,x2n,x31,x32,⋯,x3n is representable in a unique way as a polynomial in the elementary symmetric polynomials. But Pφ is homogeneous of degree 3. The previous decomposition is quite trivial but we can refine this decomposition.
Nonassociative algebras. A decomposition of the associator
The multiplication μ of an algebra A over K is given by a bilinear map
μ:A×A→A.
Its associator Aμ is the trilinear map given by Aμ(x,y,z)=μ(μ(x,y),z)−μ(x,μ(y,z)). For simplification, we will denote xy instead of μ(x,y) and refer to the associator as A. The algebra (A,μ) is associative when A=0. It is nonassociative if A is null or not null. As with trilinear forms, for any vector v=∑aiσi∈K[Σ3], we define the trilinear map Av by
This decomposition highlights the following classes of nonassociative algebras:
Totally symmetric algebras. The associator AV3 satisfies the relations
AV3(x,y,z)=AV3(y,x,z)=AV3(z,y,x).
If (A,μ) is a nonassociative algebra whose associator corresponds to AV3, it satisfies the previous symmetric relations and it is a nonassociative totally symmetric algebra.
Remark: If we consider a nonassociative algebra whose associator A satisfies
Alternative algebras. The associator AW3 satisfies the relations
AW3(x,y,z)=−AW3(y,x,z)=−AW3(z,y,x).
If (A,μ) is a nonassociative algebra whose associator corresponds to AW3, it satisfies the previous symmetric relations and it is an alternative algebra.
Remark: If we consider a nonassociative algebra whose associator A satisfies
An algebra A whose associator A satisfies the first relation is left symmetric which implies that it is also Lie-admissible and it is 3-power associative from the second relation.
Remark. Let us consider the class of nonassociative algebras whose associator A satisfies
This class does not seem to have been the subject of particular studies. However, let us note that this class contains the class of right-symmetric algebras.
The first relation shows that the algebra is left-alternative which implies that it is 3-power-associative. The second identity implies that this algebra is Lie-admissible.
Remark. If we consider a nonassociave algebra whose associator A satisfies
This class of nonassociative algebras contains the class of right-alternative algebras that is satisfying
A(x1,x2,x3)+A(x1,x3,x2).
On the reduction of cubic forms
Symmetric trilinear forms and cubic forms
The decomposition of a trilinear form focuses on the study of antisymmetric, symmetric forms and those defined by vectors u1 and u2. Let E be a finite-dimensional K-vector space. The classification of alternating trilinear forms is already presented in [3]. The study of bilinear symmetric forms is associated with the study of quadratic forms.
Recall that a quadratic form is a map q:E→K such that q(av)=a2q(v) for all a∈K, v∈E and the function f:E×E→K defined by f(u,v)=21(q(u+v)−q(u)−q(v)) is a bilinear form on E. Such a map can be identified to a homogeneous polynomial of degree 2 in n variables with coefficients in K. A major result specifies that any quadratic form can be written as a linear combination of squares of linearly independent linear forms. What about the cubic forms? We assume now that K=C. The problem that naturally arises is that of the decomposition of cubic forms.
A cubic form is a homogeneous polynomial of degree 3 in n variables: For example
If φ is a trilinear form on the K vector space E, the associated cubic form is
qφ(u)=φ(u,u,u).
It is clear that if φ is skewsymmetric then qφ=0. But from Proposition 7, it is the same if φ=φui for i∈{1,2,3,4}. We deduce that the cubic forms are in a one-to-one correspondence with the symmetric trilinear forms.
The next section concerns the reduction of binary cubic forms, that is when E is 2-dimensional.
Decomposition of a binary cubic form
In this paragraph, we are interested in the decomposition of a binary cubic form into a sum of cubes of linear forms.
Proposition 11.There are binary cubic forms that cannot be written as a sum of cubes of independent linear forms.
Since there are binary cubic forms that are the sum of cubes of linear forms, we can wonder about the structure of such forms that are written in this way. Let q(x,y)=ax3+bx2y+cxy2+dy3 a binary cubic form. When a=0, a classical change of variables x=X−3aby leads to aX3+pXy2+qy3 with p=c−3ab2, q=d−3abc+27a22b3 so allows to reduce the problem for a=0 to write as the sum of cubes of linear forms the binary cubic forms
If c=0 then q is trivially a sum of linear forms. If one of the coefficients αi,βi is zero, then c=0 and q is indeed a sum of cubes of independent linear forms (two cubes if d=0). Then we assume that α1α2β1β2=0. Then
And we find again the expression of ρ and the equation β13+β23=d is satisfied.
Theorem 12. Let q(x,y)=ax3+cxy2+dy3 be a ternary form with a=0.
If c=0, the binary cubic form q(x,y)=ax3+dy3 writes trivially as a sum of two linear forms.
If c=0 we can write q as a sum of the cube of two linear forms if and only if
δ=4c3+27ad2=0
and we have
q(x,y)=(α1x+β1y)3+(α2x+β2y)3
with
α2=u,β1=vu,α1=3acuv2,β2=−9a2c2uv3
and
u=3c(a2(aΔ−dΔ)2)31,v=c3a(−2ad+2Δ)31
with Δ=27a3δ.
It remains to examine the case q(x,y)=bx2y+cxy2+dy3, that is a=0 in the initial case. If d=0 the study is similar to the previous case exchanging the role of x and y. We can therefore only study the particular case
q(x,y)=bx2y+cxy2.
If bc=0, then q cannot be written as a sum of the cube of linear forms. Assume bc=0. Since α13+α23=β13+β23=0, we can choose α1=k1α2,β1=k2β2 with k13=k23=−1 and 1+k12k2=0 and 1+k1k22=0. Let’s take, for example, k1=−1,k2=−j. In this case 1+k12k2=1−j and 1+k1k22=2+j. We deduce
To find the roots of an equation of degree 3, we have only to consider the case a=0. Using the previous decompositions, we can also consider b=0, that is, ax3+cx+d=0. If c(4c3+27ad2)=0, the roots are easy to find. If c(4c3+27ad2)=0, we have
q(x,1)=ax3+cx+d=(α1x+β1)3+(α2x+β2)3
with
α2=u,β1=vu,α1=3acuv2,β2=−9a2c2uv3.
and
u=3c(a2(aΔ−dΔ)2)31,v=c3a(−2ad+2Δ)31
We deduce that
x1=−α1+α2β1+β2
is a root of the equation ax3+cx+d=0.
Theorem 16. (Tartaglia’s roots) If c(4c3+27ad2)=0 and a=0 then
x1=−v1+3acv
with
v=c3a(2a−d+Δ)31
is a root of ax3+cx+d=0.
Proof.
q(x,y)=(α1x+β1)3+(α2x+β2)3
with α2=u, β1=vu, α1=3acuv2, β2=−9a2c2uv3. We have a root
x1=−α1+α2β1+β2=−v1+3acv.
▢
Remarks. If Δ>0, then v∈R. We have seen that
v3=2c327a3(−ad±Δ)
To find a root of ax3+cx+d=0 we have considered that ±=+. If v1 corresponds to: ±=+ and v2 to ±=−, then we have 3acv2=−v11 and we find the same root.
If Δ<0 and x1∈R, then we find again the previous conditions. If x1∈C−R, then we find the conjugate root.
On the equations of degree 5
In the same vein, we conclude this work by examining what this degree 3 method can induce for degree 5 equations.
Let us consider a binary pentatic form
f(x,y)=ax5+bx4y+cx3y2+dx2y3+exy4+fy5.
As for the binary cubic case, if a=0, we can always consider that b=0. We moreover assume that e=0, that is
If (c,d)=(0,0) it is trivial that f is the sum of two 5-power linear equations. If (c,d)=(0,0), we have α1α2β1β2=0. The second equation is equivalent to