The complex formations exhibited by schooling fish have long been the object of fascination for biologists and physicists. However, the physical and sensory mechanisms leading to organized collective behavior remain elusive. On the physical side in particular, it is unknown how the flows generated by individual fish influence the collective patterns that emerge in large schools. To address this question, we here present a continuum theory for a school of swimmers in an inline formation. The swimmers are modeled as flapping wings that interact through temporally nonlocal hydrodynamic forces, as arise when one swimmer moves through the lingering vortex wakes shed by the others, leading to a system of time-delay-differential equations. Through coarse-graining, we derive a system of partial differential equations for the evolution of swimmer density and collective vorticity-induced hydrodynamic force. Linear stability analysis of the governing equations shows that there is a range of swimmer densities for which the uniform (constant-density) state is unstable to perturbations. Numerical simulations {in periodic domains} reveal families of stable traveling wave solutions, where a uniform school destabilizes into a collection of densely populated "sub-schools" separated by relatively sparse regions that move as a propagating wave. We find that distinct propagating waves may be stable for the same set of kinematic parameters. We also find that finite schools can evolve into packets of coarsening traveling waves whose overall spreading is described by a rarefaction fan moving upstream and a terminating downstream shock. Generally, our results show that temporally nonlocal hydrodynamic interactions can lead to rich collective behavior in schools of swimmers.
Introduction
The complex dynamics of animal collectives such as fish schools offers a beautiful visualization of non-equilibrium collective behavior [1]. A fish school is an archetype of an active matter system, as the individual organisms consume energy in order to self-propel and interact with each other [2]. The mechanisms by which large groups of fish generate and sustain organized collective locomotion has long fascinated scientists [3, 4], one goal being to uncover their fundamental underlying biological principles and use them towards potential engineering applications, for example designing swarms of biomimetic underwater vehicles [5].
Much of the prior research has focused on the behavioral mechanisms by which fish interact with each other while schooling [6, 7]. Experimental studies of different fish species in controlled environments have sought to uncover interaction rules that govern how fish move and orient themselves with respect to each other [8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13].
These studies are complemented by a variety of theoretical models that seek to capture the collective phenomena observed in biological systems. Discrete models, such as the seminal Viscek model [14] and variants thereof (e.g. [15, 16, 17]), posit equations of motion for the coupled positional and orientational dynamics of interacting agents that sense each other and respond accordingly while being perturbed by stochastic noise. Continuum models have the advantage of being more amenable to analysis, and are biologically relevant when a collective contains a large number of individuals. For example, the celebrated Toner-Tu continuum partial differential equation (PDE) theory [18, 19, 20] is a coarse-graining of the Viscek model, and has motivated other more sophisticated theories (e.g. [21, 22]). Partial integro-differential equations have been used to model spatially nonlocal sensory interactions [23, 24, 25, 26], wherein the constituents sense and thus interact with each other over long ranges. Despite their successes, these spatially nonlocal models do not account for temporally nonlocal interactions between constituents. Specifically, swimming fish generate flow structures that persist over spatial and temporal scales relevant to physical interactions within a school [27], yet modeling these interactions remains challenging due to the inherently non-local and non-instantaneous nature of these flows.
A substantial body of research has demonstrated that hydrodynamic interactions are important in mediating schooling behavior [28]. For example, studies have demonstrated that fish exert less energy while swimming in a school than they do in isolation [29, 30, 31], especially in the turbulent flow conditions characteristic of relatively fast-moving schools [32]. Hydrodynamic considerations have been used to rationalize the emergence of particular schooling formations over others in a water tank [33]. In order to isolate hydrodynamic effects, recent experiments have been performed in which fish are replaced by freely-swimming wings, whose vertical (periodic) flapping motion is prescribed but horizontal motion is determined by the balance of hydrodynamic thrust and drag forces. These experiments have shown that a linear periodic array of flapping wings can move faster than a single wing [34], and that pairs of wings in an in-line [35] or staggered [36, 37] formation spontaneously adopt steady “schooling modes,” wherein the pair translates at constant velocity while maintaining a fixed separation distance. Such modes persist even if the wings’ flapping amplitudes and frequencies are incommensurate [38]. Groups of more wings in an in-line formation exhibit flow-induced instabilities, wherein disturbances to the leader wing progressively amplify as they propagate downstream and can cause collisions between the trailing wings [39].
Theoretical models have been developed to describe hydrodynamic interactions between schooling swimmers in relatively high-Reynolds number flows. Models that account for far-field hydrodynamic effects, wherein each swimmer is modeled as a dipole [40, 41], have been used to demonstrate that swimmers adopt different schooling modes due to hydrodynamic interactions [42], and that swimming collectives undergo phase transitions when in confinement [43]. Near-field hydrodynamic interactions, which are due to the vortices generated by fish as they swim [27], have been modeled using a generalized thin-airfoil theory [44, 45], wherein the periodic wake generated by a flapping plate is assumed to be flat [35, 46]. The vortices shed by fish have been modeled explicitly using point-vortex models, first in Refs. [47, 48] and later generalized in Ref. [49], which were used to compare the hydrodynamic thrust and efficiency of different schooling formations. Numerical simulations using a vortex sheet method have been used to assess the hydrodynamic interactions between pairs [50, 51] and larger collectives [52, 53] of flapping plates in the limit of infinite Reynolds number.
However, there is currently no continuum description of swimmers that generate and interact through a relatively high-Reynolds number flow, a necessary step towards simulating the large fish schools observed in nature. The difficulty is that the hydrodynamic interactions between swimming fish are temporally nonlocal: while small-scale objects such as bacteria [54] or cilia [55] generate a low-Reynolds number (Stokes) flow that can be readily incorporated into continuum models because the interactions between constituents are instantaneous, fish swim at higher Reynolds number and thus generate vortical flow structures that persist over a timescale τ that is often comparable to the timescale d/u0 over which fish interact, d and u0 being the typical distance between and velocity of the fish, respectively.
We here explicitly account for this temporal nonlocality by using a system of nonlinear delay-differential equations to model the swimmers’ dynamics [34, 38, 39]. The predictions of the model have been shown to exhibit favorable agreement with experiments on flapping wings in a water tank, and with both CFD and vortex sheet simulations of flapping wings [52]. While Viscek-type models with constant time-delay have been studied previously [56, 57], this model differs crucially in that the time-delays are state-dependent [34, 38, 39], which accounts for the fact that the swimmers interact with each other through a fluid-mediated memory. Another key feature of the model is that the interactions are non-reciprocal, in that a given swimmer is affected by the flow generated by the swimmers ahead of it. We make two simplifying assumptions: (1) we consider a kinematic model [34], in which the swimmers’ inertia is neglected so hydrodynamic forces directly determine the swimmers’ velocities; and (2) we analyze the model in 1D, thus modeling a linear chain which is perhaps the simplest formation in which fish have been observed to school [58]. By introducing new field variables that account for the persistent vortical flow generated by the swimmers, we show that this model coarse-grains naturally and thus obtain a continuum PDE description of schooling swimmers with temporally-nonlocal interactions. We show that, in certain parameter regimes, a uniform-density school of swimmers is unstable to perturbations. These perturbations give rise to traveling waves, which consist of densely populated “sub-schools” of swimmers separated by relatively sparse regions. Lastly, we numerically investigate the evolution of a compactly supported school.
Derivation of the continuum PDE model
We present a derivation of the continuum PDE model, the details of which are given in Supplemental Material §I. We consider a collection of N flapping swimmers with positions xi(t) that self-propel while maintaining an in-line formation (Fig. 1). The swimmers are assumed to flap in-phase with the same flapping angular frequency ω and amplitude, and are assumed to move to the left, so x˙i<0. The time-evolution of their positions is governed by a system of nonlinear delay-differential equations, versions of which have been proposed previously to model the hydrodynamic interactions between flapping swimmers in high-Reynolds number flows [34, 38, 39]. The equations are
x˙i=−u0−u1j=1∑NK(t−tj(xi)),(1)
where tj(x)={argtxj(t)=x+∞if ∃t such that xj(t)=x,otherwise;
K(t)=−H(t)e−t/τcosωt;(2)
the constants u0 and u1 are positive; and H(t) is the Heaviside step function. We have assumed that the swimmers’ inertia is negligible and thus the hydrodynamic forces on the swimmers directly determine their velocities.
What do these equations assume and encapsulate? In Eq. (1a), each swimmer is assumed to self-propel in isolation with a speed u0, as determined by the balance between hydrodynamic thrust and drag forces on it. The swimmers interact through the term proportional to u1, the physical interpretation being that each swimmer experiences hydrodynamic forces due to the vortical wakes shed upstream of it. Following [38], we employ a simplified description of the vortical wakes: the combined wake is given by a linear superposition of the wakes generated by each swimmer, and the vertical wake speed generated by a given swimmer as it swims by is equal to its instantaneous vertical flapping velocity. This wake speed oscillates in time with frequency ω and decays exponentially over a timescale τ [Eq. (1c)], the latter modeling the turbulent dissipation of flows at high Reynolds number [35, 38, 59, 60]. The force on swimmer i is determined by its own vertical velocity y˙i relative to the local vertical velocity vi of the fluid flow generated by the other swimmers. Specifically, the force is proportional to −⟨(y˙i−vi)2⟩≈T0+T1, where T0=−⟨y˙i2⟩, T1=2⟨y˙ivi⟩ and ⟨⋅⟩ denotes a time average over the flapping period, where we have assumed that ∣vi∣≪∣y˙i∣. The free swimming speed u0 is determined by the thrust on an isolated swimmer T0, and the interaction force (proportional to u1 in Eq. (1a)) is determined by $T_1 ({xref}Supplemental Material §I). From the form of $T_1$, it is evident that a swimmer experiences a thrust (drag) if it moves up (down) into a downflow or down (up) into an upflow. Equivalently, this force is determined by the swimmer’s flapping phase relative to that of the other swimmers in the past. This relative phase is accounted for through the time-delays $t_j(x_i)$ defined in {xref}Eq. (1b), which specify the time in the past at which swimmer $j$ was in the current position of swimmer $i$. The non-reciprocal and causal nature of the interactions between swimmers is imposed by the Heaviside function $H(t)$, which ensures that a given swimmer is affected only by the wakes generated upstream of it. That is, if swimmer $i$ remains ahead of swimmer $j$ for all time ($x_i(t)<x_j(t)$), it will never be affected by swimmer $j$, as $H(t-t_j(x_i(t)))=0$ and the corresponding interaction term in {xref}Eq. (1a)` would vanish. However, note that even if swimmer i is ahead of swimmer j at some instant t (xi(t)<xj(t)), it would have been influenced by swimmer j if it was behind swimmer j at some earlier time t′<t (xi(t′)>xj(t′)). Taken together, the vorticity-induced hydrodynamic interactions between flapping swimmers in high-Reynolds number flows are reduced to the non-reciprocal interactions of particles through memory: each particle leaves behind a signal, which oscillates and decays in time, and this signal is read by downstream particles as they pass by.
We convert the system of delay-differential equations (1) into a system of ordinary differential equations by introducing the fields
C(x,t)=i=1∑NK(t−ti(x))
and
S(x,t)=i=1∑NK(t−ti(x)),(3)
where K(t)=−H(t)e−t/τsinωt.
We also make the equations dimensionless via t→t/τ and x→x/(u0τ), which introduces two dimensionless parameters: the strength of the hydrodynamic interactions r=u1/u0, and the dimensionless flapping frequency α=ωτ. Note that
dtdH(t−ti(x))=δ(t−ti(x))=δ(x−xi(t))∣x˙i∣,(4)
where the second equality follows from the fact that δ(g(z))=∑iδ(z−zi)/∣g′(zi)∣ for smooth functions g(z) with roots at z=zi, and the definition ti(xi(t))=t. Since x˙i<0, we can rewrite Eq. (1) as the system
x˙i=−1−rC(xi,t),(5)
∂tC=i=1∑Nδ(x−xi(t))x˙i−C−αS,(6)
∂tS=−S+αC.(7)
The rewriting of Eq. (1) as Eq. (4) is very convenient mathematically, as the temporally-nonlocal hydrodynamic interactions between swimmers (through the time delay functions tj(x) are replaced by spatial interactions through the aggregated field C(x,t) generated by the swimmers. The oscillatory and decaying nature of the fields C and S (Figure 1) is evident through the relationship between them in Eqs. (4b)–(4c). As an example, for a single swimmer (N=1) starting at the origin and moving at constant speed to the left, x1(t)=−Ut, we have C(x,t)=−cos[α(t+x/U)]exp[−(t+x/U)] and S(x,t)=−sin[α(t+x/U)]exp[−(t+x/U)] if −Ut<x<0, and zero otherwise. That is, the fields are supported on the interval [−Ut,0], where they exhibit decaying oscillations.
Figure 1. Schematic of the model (1) for a linear school of flapping swimmers in a fluid. The swimmers are modeled as particles (dots), which are constrained to move in a line to the left. Each swimmer generates a wake whose vertical velocity (curves and arrows) oscillates and decays. These wakes induce horizontal forces on the downstream swimmers, in that a swimmer experiences a horizontal thrust (drag) if it moves up (down) into a downflow or down (up) into an upflow. The interactions between the swimmers are non-reciprocal, as each swimmer is influenced by the wakes shed upstream of it.
We now seek the continuum limit of Eq. (4), since we expect that the empirical density ∑i=1Nδ(x−xi(t)) converges to a smooth density ρ(x,t) as N→∞. We expect that ρ satisfies the continuity equation ∂tρ+∂x(ρU0)=0[61, 62], where we define the mean-field swimmer velocity U0(x,t)=−1−rC(x,t). Substituting Eq. (4a) into Eq. (4b) and using the fact that δ(x−x~)g(x~)=δ(x−x~)g(x), Eq. (4b) may be rewritten as
∂tC=ρU0−C−αS.(8)
The resulting hyperbolic PDEs admit discontinuous solutions with shocks, so we regularize the equations by replacing U0→Uν=U0−ν∂x(logρ), where ν>0 is an effective diffusivity. This additional term modifies the swimmers’ velocities to decrease in the presence of a local increase in swimmer density. We thus obtain the equations
References
[1]D. S. Pavlov and A. O. Kasumyan. Patterns and mechanisms of schooling behavior in fish: A review. J. Ichthyology, 40:S163–S231, 2000.
[2]M. C. Marchetti, J. F. Joanny, S. Ramaswamy, T. B. Liverpool, J. Prost, M. Rao, and R. A. Simha. Hydrodynamics of soft active matter. Reviews of Modern Physics, 85(1143), 2013.DOI
[3]E. Shaw. The schooling of fishes. Scientific American, 206(6):128–141, 1962.DOI
[4]B. L. Partridge. The structure and function of fish schools. Scientific American, 246(6):114–123, 1982.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/7201674
[5]J. D. Geder, R. Ramamurti, D. Edwards, T. Young, and M. Preussner. Development of an unmanned hybrid vehicle using artificial pectoral fins. Marine Technology Society Journal, 51(56), 2017.DOI
[6]J. K. Parrish, S. V. Viscido, and D. Grünbaum. Self-organized fish schools: An examination of emergent properties. The Biological Bulletin, 202(3):296–305, 2002.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12087003
[7]U. Lopez, J. Gautrais, I. D. Couzin, and G. Theraulaz. From behavioural analyses to models of collective motion in fish schools. Interface Focus, 218:1–11, 2012.DOI
[8]J. W. Jolles, N. J. Boogert, V. H. Sridhar, I. D. Couzin, and A. Manica. Consistent individual differences drive collective behavior and group functioning of schooling fish. Current Biology, 27:2862–2868, 2017.DOI
[9]K. Tunstrøm, Y. Katz, C. C. Ioannou, C. Huepe, M. J. Lutz, and I. D. Couzin. Collective states, multistability and transitional behavior in schooling fish. PLOS Computational Biology, 9(2):e1002915, 2013.DOI
[10]J. Gautrais, F. Ginelli, R. Fournier, S. Blanco, M. Soria, H. Chaté, and G. Theraulaz. Deciphering interactions in moving animal groups. PLOS Computational Biology, 8(9):1–11, 09 2012.DOI
[11]Y. Katz, K. Tunstrøm, C. C. Ioannou, C. Huepe, and I. D. Couzin. Inferring the structure and dynamics of interactions in schooling fish. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108(46):18720–18725, 2011.DOI
[12]J. E. Herbert-Read, A. Perna, R. P. Mann, T. M. Schaerf, D. J. T. Sumpter, and A. J. W. Ward. Inferring the rules of interaction of schooling fish. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 108(46):18726–18731, 2011.
[13]Y. Yang, F. Turci, E. Kague, C. L. Hammond, J. Russo, and C. P. Royall. Dominating lengthscales of zebrafish collective behaviour. PLOS Computational Biology, 18(1):1–14, 01 2022.DOI
[14]T. Vicsek, A. Czirók, E. Ben-Jacob, I. Cohen, and O. Shochet. Novel type of phase transition in a system of self-driven particles. Physical Review Letters, 75(6), 1995.
[15]A. Huth and C. Wissel. The simulation of the movement of fish schools. Journal of Theoretical Biology, 156:365–385, 1992.DOI
[16]H. Chaté, F. Ginelli, G. Grégoire, F. Peruani, and F. Raynaud. Modeling collective motion: variations on the Vicsek model. Eur. Phys. J. B, 64:451–456, 2008.DOI
[17]D. S. Calovi, U. Lopez, P. Schuhmacher, H. Chaté, C. Sire, and G. Theraulaz. Collective response to perturbations in a data-driven fish school model. J. R. Soc. Interface, 12, 2015.DOI
[18]J. Toner and Y. Tu. Flocks, herds and schools: A quantitative theory of flocking. Phys. Rev. E, 58(4828), 1998.DOI
[19]J. Toner and Y. Tu. Long-range order in a two-dimensional dynamical XY model: How birds fly together. Physical Review Letters, 75(23), 1995.
[20]J. Toner. Reanalysis of the hydrodynamic theory of fluid, polar-ordered flocks. Physical Review E, 86(031918), 2012.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23030955
[21]A. Cavagna, I. Giardina, T. S. Grigera, A. Jelić, D. Levine, S. Ramaswamy, and M. Viale. Silent flocks: Constraints on signal propagation across biological groups. Physical Review Letters, 114(218101), 2015.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/26066459
[22]X. Yang and M. C. Marchetti. Hydrodynamics of turning flocks. Physical Review Letters, 115(258101), 2015.DOI
[23]A. Mogilner and L. Edelstein-Keshet. A nonlocal model for a swarm. Journal of Mathematical Biology, 38:534–570, 1999.
[24]C. M. Topaz and A. L. Bertozzi. Swarming patterns in a two-dimensional kinematic model for biological groups. SIAM Journal of Applied Mathematics, 65(1):152–174, 2004.
[25]J. A. Carrillo, S. Martin, and V. Panferov. A new interaction potential for swarming models. Physica D, 260:112–126, 2013.DOI
[26]A. J. Leverentz, C. M. Topaz, and A. J. Bernoff. Asymptotic dynamics of attractive-repulsive swarms. SIAM Journal on Applied Dynamical Systems, 8(3):880–908, 2009.DOI
[27]M. S. Triantafyllou, G. S. Triantafyllou, and D. K. P. Yue. Hydrodynamics of fishlike swimming. Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics, 32:33–53, 2000.
[28]M. Ligman, J. Lund, and M. Fürth. A comprehensive review of hydrodynamic studies on fish schooling. Bioinspiration & Biomimetics, 19(1):011002, 2023.DOI
[29]S. Marras, S. S. Killen, J. Lindström, D. J. McKenzie, J. F. Steffensen, and P. Domenici. Fish swimming in schools save energy regardless of their spatial position. Behavioral Ecology and Sociobiology, 69:219–226, 2015.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25620833
[30]J. Herskin and J. F. Steffensen. Energy savings in sea bass swimming in a school: measurements of tail beat frequency and oxygen consumption at different swimming speeds. Journal of Fish Biology, 53:366–376, 1998.
[31]Y. Zhang and G. V. Lauder. Energy conservation by collective movement in schooling fish. eLife, 12(RP90352), 2024.
[32]Y. Zhang, H. Ko, M. A. Calicchia, R. Ni, and G. V. Lauder. Collective movement of schooling fish reduces the costs of locomotion in turbulent conditions. PLOS Biology, 22(6):1–28, 06 2024.DOI
[33]I. Ashraf, H. Bradshaw, T.-T. Ha, J. Halloy, R. Godoy-Diana, and B. Thiria. Simple phalanx pattern leads to energy saving in cohesive fish schooling. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 114(36):9599–9604, 2017.DOI
[34]A. D. Becker, H. Masoud, J. W. Newbolt, M. Shelley, and L. Ristroph. Hydrodynamic schooling of flapping swimmers. Nat. Commun., 6(8514), 2015.DOI
[35]S. Ramananarivo, F. Fang, A. Oza, J. Zhang, and L. Ristroph. Flow interactions lead to orderly formations of flapping wings in forward flight. Phys. Rev. Fluids, 1(071201(R)), 2016.DOI
[36]J. W. Newbolt, J. Zhang, and L. Ristroph. Lateral flow interactions enhance speed and stabilize formations of flapping swimmers. Phys. Rev. Fluids, 7:L061101, 2022.DOI
[37]P. C. Ormonde, M. Kurt, A. Mivehchi, and K. W. Moored. Two-dimensionally stable self-organisation arises in simple schooling swimmers through hydrodynamic interactions. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 1000:A90, 2024.DOI
[38]J. W. Newbolt, J. Zhang, and L. Ristroph. Flow interactions between uncoordinated flapping swimmers give rise to group cohesion. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA, 116(9):2419–2424, 2019.DOI
[39]J. W. Newbolt, N. Lewis, M. Bleu, J. Wu, C. Mavroyiakoumou, S. Ramananarivo, and L. Ristroph. Flow interactions lead to self-organized flight formations disrupted by self-amplifying waves. Nature Communications, 15:3462, 2024.DOI
[40]A. C. H. Tsang and E. Kanso. Dipole interactions in doubly periodic domains. Journal of Nonlinear Science, 23(6):971–991, 2013.arxiv.org/abs/1304.6795
[41]M. Gazzola, A. A. Tchieu, D. Alexeev, A. de Brauer, and P. Koumoutsakos. Learning to school in the presence of hydrodynamic interactions. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 789:726–749, 2016.
[42]A. Filella, F. Nadal, C. Sire, E. Kanso, and C. Eloy. Model of collective fish behavior with hydrodynamic interactions. Physical Review Letters, 120(198101), 2018.DOI
[43]C. Huang, F. Ling, and E. Kanso. Collective phase transitions in confined fish schools. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 121(44):e2406293211, 2024.DOI
[44]T. Y. Wu. Swimming of a waving plate. J. Fluid Mech., 10(03):321–344, 1961.DOI
[45]T. Y. Wu and A. T. Chwang. Extraction of flow energy by fish and birds in a wavy stream. In T. Y. Wu, C. J. Brokaw, and C. Brennen, editors, Swimming and flying in nature, vol. 2, pages 687–702. Springer, 1975.DOI
[46]P. J. Paddock, N. J. Moore, A. U. Oza, and D. G. Crowdy. Generalization of waving-plate theory to multiple interacting swimmers. Communications on Pure and Applied Mathematics, 76(12):3811–3851, 2023.
[47]D. Weihs. Hydromechanics of fish schooling. Nature, 241, 1973.DOI
[48]D. Weihs. Some hydrodynamical aspects of fish schooling. In T. Y. Wu, C. J. Brokaw, and C. Brennen, editors, Swimming and Flying in Nature, vol. 2, pages 703–718. Springer, 1975.
[49]A. U. Oza, L. Ristroph, and M. J. Shelley. Lattices of hydrodynamically interacting flapping swimmers. Physical Review X, 9(041024), 2019.DOI
[50]S. Heydari and E. Kanso. School cohesion, speed and efficiency are modulated by the swimmers flapping motion. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 922:A27, 2021.DOI
[51]F. Fang, C. Mavroyiakoumou, L. Ristroph, and M. J. Shelley. Flow interactions and forward flight dynamics of tandem flapping wings. arXiv, 2505.13149, 2025.DOI
[52]S. Heydari, H. Hang, and E. Kanso. Mapping spatial patterns to energetic benefits in groups of flow-coupled swimmers. eLife, 13(RP96129), 2024.
[53]M. Nitsche, A. U. Oza, and M. J. Siegel. On the stability of an in-line formation of hydrodynamically interacting flapping plates. Journal of Fluid Mechanics, 1013:A14, 2025.DOI
[54]D. Saintillan and M. Shelley. Emergence of coherent structures and large-scale flows in motile suspensions. J. R. Soc. Interface, 9(68):571–585, 2011.DOI
[55]R. Golestanian, J. M. Yeomans, and N. Uchida. Hydrodynamic synchronization at low Reynolds number. Soft Matter, 7:3074–3082, 2011.DOI
[56]E. Forgoston and I. B. Schwartz. Delay-induced instabilities in self-propelling swarms. Phys. Rev. E, 77:035203, Mar 2008.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18517450
[57]V. Holubec, D. Geiss, S. A. M. Loos, K. Kroy, and F. Cichos. Finite-size scaling at the edge of disorder in a time-delay Vicsek model. Phys. Rev. Lett., 127:258001, 2021.DOI
[58]E. W. Gudger. Fishes that swim heads to tails in single file. Copeia, 1944(3):152–154, 1944.DOI
[59]J. J. L. Higdon and S. Corrsin. Induced drag of a bird flock. The American Naturalist, 112(986):727–744, 1978.DOI
[60]M. Daghooghi and I. Borazjani. The hydrodynamic advantages of synchronized swimming in a rectangular pattern. Bioinspiration and Biomimetics, 10(056018), 2015.DOI
[61]F. Golse. On the dynamics of large particle systems in the mean field limit. In A. Muntean, J. Rademacher, and A. Zagaris, editors, Macroscopic and Large Scale Phenomena: Coarse Graining, Mean Field Limits and Ergodicity, pages 1–144. Springer International Publishing, Cham, 2016.DOI
[62]P.-E. Jabin and Z. Wang. Mean field limit for stochastic particle systems. In N. Bellomo, P. Degond, and E. Tadmor, editors, Active Particles, Volume 1: Advances in Theory, Models, and Applications, pages 379–402. Springer International Publishing, Cham, 2017.DOI
[63]G. Grégoire and H. Chaté. Onset of collective and cohesive motion. Phys. Rev. Lett., 92:025702, 2004.DOI
[64]A. P. Solon, H. Chaté, and J. Tailleur. From phase to microphase separation in flocking models: The essential role of nonequilibrium fluctuations. Phys. Rev. Lett., 114:068101, 2015.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25723246
[65]J.-B. Caussin, A. Solon, A. Peshkov, H. Chaté, T. Dauxois, J. Tailleur, V. Vitelli, and D. Bartolo. Emergent spatial structures in flocking models: A dynamical system insight. Phys. Rev. Lett., 112:148102, 2014.
[66]M. E. Cates and J. Tailleur. Motility-induced phase separation. Annual Review of Condensed Matter Physics, 6(Volume 6, 2015):219–244, 2015.DOI
[67]H. Zhao, A. Kösmrlj, and S. S. Datta. Chemotactic motility-induced phase separation. Phys. Rev. Lett., 131:118301, Sep 2023.arxiv.org/abs/2301.12345
[68]P. A. Milewski and X. Yang. A simple model for biolog- ical aggregation with asymmetric sensing. Communications in Mathematical Sciences, 6(2), 2008.
[69]A. C. H. Tsang and E. Kanso. Density shock waves in confined microswimmers. Phys. Rev. Lett., 116:048101, Jan 2016.DOI
[70]A. C. H. Tsang, M. J. Shelley, and E. Kanso. Activity-induced instability of phonons in 1D microfluidic crystals. Soft Matter, 14:945–950, 2018.DOI
[71]C. Wollin and H. Stark. Metachronal waves in a chain of rowers with hydrodynamic interactions. The European Physical Journal E, 34(4):42, 2011.DOI
[72]F. Meng, R. R. Bennett, N. Uchida, and R. Golestanian. Conditions for metachronal coordination in arrays of model cilia. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 118(32):e2102828118, 2021.DOI
[73]A. V. Kanale, F. Ling, H. Guo, S. Fürthauer, and E. Kanso. Spontaneous phase coordination and fluid pumping in model ciliary carpets. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119(45):e2214413119, 2022.DOI
[74]B. Chakrabarti, S. Fürthauer, and M. J. Shelley. A multiscale biophysical model gives quantized metachronal waves in a lattice of beating cilia. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, 119(4):e2113539119, 2022.
[75]D. R. Brumley, M. Polin, T. J. Pedley, and R. E. Goldstein. Hydrodynamic synchronization and metachronal waves on the surface of the colonial alga volvox carteri. Phys. Rev. Lett., 109:268102, Dec 2012.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23368623
[76]D. R. Brumley, M. Polin, T. J. Pedley, and R. E. Goldstein. Metachronal waves in the flagellar beating of volvox and their hydrodynamic origin. Journal of The Royal Society Interface, 12(108):20141358, 2015.DOI
[77]A. C. Quillen, A. Peshkov, E. Wright, and S. McGaffigan. Metachronal waves in concentrations of swimming turbartrix aceti nematodes and an oscillator chain model for their coordinated motions. Phys. Rev. E, 104:014412, Jul 2021.DOI
[78]A. Peshkov, S. McGaffigan, and A. C. Quillen. Synchronized oscillations in swarms of nematode turbartrix aceti. Soft Matter, 18:1174–1182, 2022.DOI
[79]W. K. Potts. The chorus-line hypothesis of manoeuvre coordination in avian flocks. Nature, 309(5966):344–345, 1984.DOI
[80]A. Pertzelan, G. Ariel, and M. Kiflawi. Schooling of light reflecting fish. PLOS ONE, 18(7):1–20, 07 2023.DOI
[81]J. E. Herbert-Read, C. Buhl, F. Hu, A. J. W. Ward, and D. J. T. Sumpter. Initiation and spread of escape waves within animal groups. R. Soc. Open Sci., 2:140355, 2015.
[82]W. Poel, B. C. Daniels, M. M. G. Sosna, C. R. Twomey, S. P. Leblanc, I. D. Couzin, and P. Romanczuk. Sub-critical escape waves in schooling fish. Science Advances, 8(25):eabm6385, 2022.
[83]J. C. Liao. A review of fish swimming mechanics and behaviour in altered flows. Phil. Trans. R. Soc. B, 362:1973–1993, 2007.DOI
[84]L. Ristroph, J. C. Liao, and J. Zhang. Lateral line layout correlates with the differential hydrodynamic pressure on swimming fish. Physical Review Letters, 114(018102), 2015.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25615505
[85]A. Attanasi, A. Cavagna, L. D. Castello, I. Giardina, T. S. Grigera, A. Jelić, S. Melillo, L. Parisi, O. Pohl, E. Shen, and M. Viale. Information transfer and behavioural inertia in starling flocks. Nature Physics, 10:691–696, 2014.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/25264452
[86]A. Cavagna, L. D. Castello, I. Giardina, T. S. Grigera, A. Jelić, S. Melillo, L. Parisi, and M. Viale. Flocking and turning: a new model for self-organized collective motion. Journal of Statistical Physics, 158(3):601–627, 2015.DOI
[87]A. Cavagna, D. Conti, C. Creato, L. D. Castello, I. Giardina, T. S. Grigera, S. Melillo, L. Parisi, and M. Viale. Dynamic scaling in natural swarms. Nature Physics, 13(9):914–918, 2017.
[88]H. Löwen. Inertial effects of self-propelled particles: From active Brownian to active Langevin motion. The Journal of Chemical Physics, 152(4):040901, 2020.DOI