betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Healing of topological defects while crystallizing nanocrystals

Abstract

Understanding the role of confinement while crystallizing nanocrystals is very relevant for predicting their structure and physical properties. With this aim we perform Langevin dynamics simulations of nanocrystals of the model system of few hundred vortices nucleated in micron-sized superconductors. We study the crystallization dynamics and the low-temperature structural properties of vortex nanocrystals nucleated in field-cooling conditions when changing vortex density or elasticity of the system and physical size of the samples. The low-temperature snapshots obtained in simulations present a healing effect at the edges that is in quantitative agreement with experimental data in Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+δ micron-sized samples. We show that the low-temperature radial distribution of topological defects is a stationary profile frozen at a temperature below the melting line tuned by intrinsic properties of the vortex structure and on the confinement effect. These findings on the dynamics and spatial profile of topological defects can be applied to describe the physical properties of confined soft condensed matter nanocrystals in general.

Introduction

The spatial distribution and dynamics of topological defects in crystallization processes following a particular thermal and deformation history constrains the physical properties of a material and their potential applications. [1] While systems at equilibrium forget their thermal and deformation history, crystallizing systems in a substrate with disorder generates plastic deformations and since the material is not in global equilibrium its properties depend on history. [1, 2] Thermal history is tuned by cooling or warming at different temperature rates; deformation history can be controlled by introducing stress either with an external field or by the edges of the material. For systems in the nanoscale, namely composed by only few thousands of components, the deformation effect introduced by the confinement produced by the edges of the sample becomes relevant. [3]

The kinetic process of crystallization is governed by the transport of topological defects. For example, the density and nature of topological defects can control the occurrence of phase transitions, [4] and the dynamics of interfaces composed of topological defects control the nucleation and size of grains in polycrystalline solids [5, 6, 7, 8, 9], which in turn affects the mechanical properties of the material. [10, 11, 12] Topological defects are nucleated in real materials when crystallization occurs on experimental time scales since the system quenches from the disordered high-temperature phase into the ordered low-temperature state. [13, 14] These defects are unavoidably nucleated if the order is also frustrated by boundary conditions and/or the disorder of the host media. [15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22] For instance, the former is particularly relevant in the case of nanocrystalline matter since the edge of the system induces strong confinement effects. [17, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28]

Finite assemblies of interacting particles confined to disk-like geometries—such as colloids in circular traps [29] and Wigner molecules in quantum dots [30]—exhibit universal features, including shell formation, boundary-induced defects, and a crossover towards bulk crystalline order. In this context, vortex nanocrystals provide a tunable and experimentally accessible platform to investigate these generic aspects of crystallization under confinement. Therefore, to elucidate the role of topological defects in the crystallization dynamics of nanocrystals, vortex matter in type-II superconductors confined to micron-sized samples serves as an ideal model system. [31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36] The density of vortices can be readily tuned by varying the applied magnetic field, since the average intervortex spacing scales as $a \propto \sqrt{B}$, where $B$ is the magnetic induction. {citep}[37] The interaction between vortices can be controlled by the choice of superconducting material and by the applied field. {citep}[37] In addition, the quench dynamics can be systematically modified by tuning the strength of disorder (pinning) in the sample. {citep}[22, 38] Finally, confinement effects can be adjusted by varying the sample size and geometry. {citep}[34, 39, 40]`

In nanocrystals a depletion of the total binding energy of the system occurs when decreasing the size down to few thousands components due to an enhancement of the surface-to-volume ratio in the number of components. For vortex nanocrystals, this reduction on the number of components produces a depletion of the entropy-jump in the first-order solidification transition. [36] In addition, the structural order of vortex nanocrystals is worsened with respect to macroscopic vortex crystals. [41] Direct imaging with individual vortex resolution reveals a sudden increase in the density of topological defects near the edges of the samples. This excess of topological defects in vortex nanocrystals induced by confinement might be at the origin of the depletion of the entropy-jump entailed at the first-order solidification transition. [41] Close to the sample edge vortex rows have a tendency to bend, an effect that heals on going towards the core of the nanocrystal where an ordered phase is nucleated. This effect is more pronounced on decreasing the size of the nanocrystal and on decreasing the inter-vortex interaction by lowering BB. All these observations have been revealed in static experimental conditions after following a field-cooling quenching history from the liquid vortex phase down the solid quasi-crystalline Bragg glass phase.

Controlling the physical properties of the vortex nanocrystals resulting from cooling from a high temperature phase requires to gain insight on the dynamics of the formation of the belt of topological defects crowding the edge of the sample and on the mostly isolated dislocations populating the core of the nanocrystal. Here we get insight on this issue by performing Langevin dynamics simulations to study the crystallization of vortex nanocrystals while field-cooling in micron-sized samples with weak point disorder distributed at random. The choice of cooling protocol, disorder type, and sample geometry considered in the simulations is driven by experimental results revealing snapshots of nanocrystals of few thousands of vortices crystallized in micron-sized Bi2_2Sr2_2CaCu2_2O8+δ_{8+\delta} samples after following a field-cooling protocol at low applied fields. [40, 41] As already known from data in macroscopic samples, the vortex structure observed at the end of the cooling protocol corresponds to a configuration frozen at a characteristic temperature located below the melting temperature. [40, 42] At this temperature the dynamics of the vortex system at length scales of the lattice spacing is appreciably slowed down due to the viscous effect of the unavoidable disorder present in real samples. We employ an effective two-dimensional model of interacting vortices to describe the quenched configurations observed in magnetic decoration experiments on Bi2_2Sr2_2CaCu2_2O8+δ_{8+\delta}. This description is phenomenological and not intended as a microscopic model of the full three-dimensional vortex lines.

Using this model we present a systematic study of the dynamics of the formation of the belt of topological defects crowding the edge of the sample and of the mostly isolated dislocations populating the core of the nanocrystal, as a function of the number of vortices in the nanocrystal. The number of vortices is tuned either by the physical size of the disk-like samples with diameter DD or by the vortex density controlled by the magnetic induction BB. Changes in BB also modify the elasticity of the structure: The smaller (larger) BB the softer (stiffer) the vortex nanocrystal. We find that this phenomenological study quantitatively describes the experimental data available in Bi2_2Sr2_2CaCu2_2O8+δ_{8+\delta} nanocrystals. In particular, it allows us to disentangle the intrinsic effect of elasticity and disorder from the effects of confinement controlled by the perimeter-to-area ratio. We find that the dynamics of crystallization presents a characteristic crossover freezing temperature, smaller than the melting one, below which the radial density of topological defects reaches a stationary profile. This freezing temperature is sensitive to both, intrinsic and confinement effects: Increases on raising field and the perimeter-to-area ratio. The stationary profile of defects is characterized by a healing length at the edge of the nanocrystal that quantitatively agrees with experimental observations. Also in accordance with experiments, the density of defects at the core of the nanocrystal after the field-cooling crystallization is mainly governed by the elasticity of the structure and the disorder of the host media. In contrast, we find that the characteristic healing length in units of aa depends mainly on DD, increasing when the perimeter-to-area ratio decreases. Namely, the number of lattice spacings at the edge of the nanocrystal where the excess of defects is healed is independent of the elasticity of the vortex structure.

Methods

We perform two-dimensional Langevin dynamics simulations mimicking the interaction between rigid three-dimensional vortices [43] in micron-sized samples with weak point disorder. We focus on the crystallization of vortex nanocrystals during a field-cooling process from a high-temperature disordered vortex structure to a low-temperature state, for various vortex densities in disk-like thin samples with diameters DD. For selected temperatures while cooling, we quantify the proliferation of topological defects, mostly dislocations, by considering their radial density ρ(r)=Ndef(r)/Nv(r)\rho(r)=N_{\rm def}(r)/N_{\rm v}(r). Here Ndef(r)N_{\rm def}(r) is the number of non-sixfold coordinated vortices and Nv(r)N_{\rm v}(r) the total number of vortices in a circular shell with radius rr centered at the sample center. We denote ρT\rho_{\rm T} as the total density of defects in the nanocrystal at a given temperature TT.

For each vortex located at ri\mathbf{r}_i, with neighbors at rj\mathbf{r}_j, the equation of motion for its overdamped Langevin dynamics reads

η∂ri∂t=∑j≠iϵ0λabK1(∣ri−rj∣λab)ri−rj∣ri−rj∣−∇Vp(ri)−∇Vd(ri)+fi(t)(1)\eta\frac{\partial\mathbf{r}_i}{\partial t}=\sum_{j\ne i}\frac{\epsilon_0}{\lambda_{ab}}K_1\left(\frac{\lvert\mathbf{r}_i-\mathbf{r}_j\rvert}{\lambda_{ab}}\right)\frac{\mathbf{r}_i-\mathbf{r}_j}{\lvert\mathbf{r}_i-\mathbf{r}_j\rvert}-\nabla V_{\rm p}(\mathbf{r}_i)-\nabla V_{\rm d}(\mathbf{r}_i)+\mathbf{f}_i(t) \tag*{(1)}

where η\eta is an effective viscosity proportional to the Bardeen-Stephen viscosity, ϵ0\epsilon_0 is the vortex line tension, λab\lambda_{ab} the superconducting penetration depth and K1K_1 is the first-order modified Bessel function. The term fi\mathbf{f}_i is a random force accounting for thermal fluctuations and satisfying ⟨fi(t)⟩=0\langle\mathbf{f}_i(t)\rangle=0 and ⟨fi(t)fj(t′)⟩=2ηkBTδijδ(t−t′)\langle f_i(t)f_j(t')\rangle=2\eta k_{\rm B}T\delta_{ij}\delta(t-t') with ⟨…⟩\langle\ldots\rangle an ensemble average. We consider the pinning potential

Vp(r)=∑nVpexp⁡[−∣r−rnp∣2/2ξ2](2)V_{\rm p}(\mathbf{r})=\sum_n V_{\rm p}\exp\left[-\lvert\mathbf{r}-\mathbf{r}_n^{\rm p}\rvert^2/2\xi^2\right] \tag*{(2)}

that emulates the disorder generated by a random and dense spatial distribution of weak point pins located at rpr_p, all with equal magnitude VpV_p, and present in the samples with a density ρp\rho_p. The confinement potential is modeled as a truncated parabola

Vd(r)=ϵ02λab2r2Θ(λab−∣Rr^−r∣)(3)V_d(\mathbf{r}) = \frac{\epsilon_0}{2\lambda_{ab}^{2}}r^2\Theta\left(\lambda_{ab}-\left|R\hat{\mathbf{r}}-\mathbf{r}\right|\right) \tag*{(3)}

with r=0\mathbf{r}=0 the center of the disk of radius R=D/2R=D/2. The equations of motion (1) are integrated using an explicit Euler scheme, and the computation of the short-range vortex–vortex and vortex–pin interactions is optimized using a double cell-list method. [44]

We perform simulations for disks with diameter D=30D=30, 4040 and 5050 μ\mum and for vortex densities of 1616, 3232 and 5050 G. The vortex density is controlled by the average separation between vortices, a=1.075Φ0/Ba=1.075\sqrt{\Phi_0/B} with Φ0=2.07⋅10−7\Phi_0=2.07\cdot10^{-7} G·cm2^2 the flux quantum. The pinning parameters ρp\rho_p, VpV_p and ξ\xi, are chosen as to obtain in our simulations a density of topological defects in macroscopic samples similar to those observed in experiments. [36, 40, 41] We consider the value of λab\lambda_{ab} as equal to that of Bi2_2Sr2_2CaCu2_2O8+δ_{8+\delta} at the irreversibility temperature. [36, 45] All magnitudes in the simulations are dimensionless since we measure distance in units of λab\lambda_{ab}, time in units of ηλab2/ϵ0\eta\lambda_{ab}^{2}/\epsilon_0, energy per unit length in units of ϵ0λab\epsilon_0\lambda_{ab}, and temperature in units of ϵ0λab/kB\epsilon_0\lambda_{ab}/k_B per unit length, with kBk_B the Boltzmann constant. In what follows we refer exclusively to dimensionless variables.

We simulate field-cooling protocols resembling the thermal history followed in experiments. First we emulate the liquid vortex phase by starting at a high temperature Ti=0.01T_i=0.01 with a configuration of vortices distributed at random inside of the disks. The system is equilibrated at TiT_i during a time teq=105t_{\mathrm{eq}}=10^5. Second, the system is cooled down Tf=0.0001T_f=0.0001 following a linear decrease of temperature during a ramp time trunt_{\mathrm{run}}.

temperature during a ramp time trunt_{\mathrm{run}}. Figure 1 shows a schematic representation of one particular cooling protocol performed in the simulations. We vary the sweep rate of the temperature ramp, vsweep=(Ti−Tf)/trunv_{\mathrm{sweep}}=(T_i-T_f)/t_{\mathrm{run}}, by changing the value of trunt_{\mathrm{run}} in the range of 10310^3 to 10710^7 simulation steps for the fastest and slowest ramps, respectively. As discussed in the next section, during this temperature-ramps the vortex nanocrystals transform at the melting temperature TmT_m from a liquid at high temperatures to a solid state at TfT_f.

Figure 1. Typical temperature-history protocol used in our simulations emulating field-cooling experimental conditions followed in magnetic decoration experiments. The equilibration and ramp times, teqt_{\mathrm{eq}} and trunt_{\mathrm{run}}, as well as the initial TiT_i, final TfT_f, and melting TmT_m temperatures are indicated.

For each studied vortex density BB and sample size DD we perform five independent simulations of field-cooling processes starting at TiT_i, finishing at TfT_f, and following the same sweep rate while cooling. The five independent simulations are performed by starting with five different initial vortex distributions at high temperature, with different Langevin noise realizations. All the magnitudes reported in the next section are averaged over these 5 simulation runs and the error bars in the data represent the standard deviation in this average.

Results

We study the dynamics of topological defects in nanocrystals while cooling by, computing the density of topological defects as a function of temperature, ρT\rho_T. We study different vortex densities and sample sizes comparable to available experimental data. [41] In order to obtain ρ\rho we start considering snapshots of the nanocrystals as, for instance the one shown in Figure 2 (a) for the smallest nanocrystal studied. By means of a Delaunay triangulation algorithm [46] we identify sixfold and non-sixfold coordinated vortices, indicated as black and red vortices in the figure. The density of defects is computed inside the nanocrystal, without considering the vortices located at its very edge, see blue vortices in Figure 2 (a). ρ\rho is estimated as the ratio between the non-sixfold to the total number of vortices.

Figure 2. (a) Example of a snapshot of a nanocrystal with ∼400\sim400 vortices crystallized at TfT_{\mathrm{f}} after the field-cooling protocol followed in our simulations. Results correspond to the smallest magnetic field studied of 16 G and for a disk with 30 μ\mum diameter. Sixfold-coordinated vortices are shown in black while disclinations (vortices with 5 or 7 neighbors) are highlighted in red. The blue vortices at the edge of the nanocrystal are not considered for the calculation of the defect densities presented in this work. (b) Delaunay triangulation of the vortex nanocrystal with topological defects highlighted in gray. The Burgers vector of one isolated dislocation, b\mathbf{b}, is indicated.

Inside of the nanocrystal, most of non-sixfold coordinated vortices have 5 and 7 neighbors, topological defects known as disclinations. They are generally paired forming edge dislocations, see gray-highlighted triangles in the Delaunay triangulation of Figure 2 (b). The region close to the edge of the nanocrystal is highly crowded with dislocations since the vortex arrangement close to the edge mimics the circular shape of the disk. On going towards the center of the nanocrystal most dislocations are located in grain boundaries separating small crystallites with different orientations. Isolated dislocations are not excessively frequent, particularly in the smallest nanocrystals, though they generally appear close to the center of the sample. The topological charge of dislocations known as Burgers vectors, [47] see for example arrow in Figure 2 (b), are related to the number of extra planes of vortices crossed when encircling the dislocation. Some pairs of Burgers vectors annihilate in close-by dislocations and some pairs annihilate in far apart dislocations.

We first start by studying how changes in the temperature sweep-rate of the simulations alter the total density of defects at the final temperature, ρTf\rho_{T_{\mathrm{f}}}. Figure 3 shows ρTf\rho_{T_{\mathrm{f}}} for simulations performed at various sweep-rates, vsweepv_{\mathrm{sweep}}, at a fixed vortex density of 16 G for disks with 30, 40 and 50 μ\mum diameters. ρTf\rho_{T_{\mathrm{f}}} enhances with increasing vsweepv_{\mathrm{sweep}} presenting two characteristic behaviors

Total density of defects versus temperature sweep-rate

Figure 3. Total density of defects in the vortex nanocrystal at the final temperature, ρTf\rho_{T_{\mathrm{f}}}, as a function of the temperature sweep-rate followed while cooling, vsweepv_{\mathrm{sweep}}. Data for a vortex density of 16 G and disk samples with diameters D=30D = 30, 40 and 50 μ\mum. Blue dotted lines are fits to the data with a constant for the slow vsweepv_{\mathrm{sweep}} regime whereas red dotted lines are algebraic growth fits for the fast sweep-rates.

within the error of the data: For large sweep-rates grows algebraically whereas for vsweep<10−5v_{\mathrm{sweep}} < 10^{-5} display a tendency to saturation. We observe this phenomenology when performing simulations spanning changes in the cooling rate of up to four orders of magnitude. The ρTf\rho_{T_{\mathrm{f}}} presents a clear tendency to saturation for the four slowest cooling rates studied. A similar phenomenology is observed for the other vortex densities studied in this work. Thus, in order to avoid spurious effects in the total density of defects due to fast cooling ramps, in what follows we perform slow simulations considering vsweep=10−7v_{\mathrm{sweep}} = 10^{-7}.

Figure 4 shows examples of the simulated vortex positions obtained at TfT_{\mathrm{f}} after following a field-cooling protocol at the slowest sweep-rate. This figure presents Delaunay triangulations highlighting the topological defects for vortex densities of 16, 32 and 50 G, and samples with diameters D=30D = 30, 40, 50 μ\mum. These images show that for a fixed vortex density, confinement effects enhance on decreasing the size of the nanocrystals, see for instance the saturation values of ρTf\rho_{T_{\mathrm{f}}} in Figure 3. Data for samples with a given diameter DD and different number of vortices controlled by BB indicate that, at a fixed r/ar/a value, the radial density of defects ρTf(r)\rho_{T_{\mathrm{f}}}(r) is larger for nanocrystals with a lesser number of vortices. For example, Figure 5 (a) shows the case of D=50D = 50 μ\mum and vortex nanocrystals with 1300 (16 G), 2800 (32 G), and 4700 (50 G) vortices. This radial density is obtained by computing the ratio between the number of non-sixfold coordinated vortices and the total number of vortices located in a circular belt of radius rr and width Δr=±0.5a\Delta r = \pm0.5a. Figure 5 (b) also puts in evidence this confinement effect from another set of data: ρTf(r)\rho_{T_{\mathrm{f}}}(r) is, for a given distance r/ar/a from the center of the nanocrystal, larger for smaller disks.

Figure 4. Examples of Delaunay triangulations of the snapshots of vortex nanocrystals obtained at the lowest temperature, TfT_f, after following field-cooling protocols at the slowest sweep-rate of vsweep=10−7v_{\mathrm{sweep}} = 10^{-7}. Columns present data at fixed vortex densities of 16, 32 and 50 G whereas rows show data at fixed sample sizes with diameters D=30D = 30, 40, 50 μ\mum. Sixfold-coordinated vortices are shown in blue while disclinations (vortices with 5 or 7 neighbors) are highlighted in grey with vortices in red. Vortices at the edge of the nanocrystal are not considered for the calculation of the Delaunay triangulation and defect density.

Radial density of defects in the vortex nanocrystal as a function of normalized radius

Figure 5. Radial density of defects in the vortex nanocrystal at the final temperature, ρTf(r)\rho_{T_f}(r), as a function of the radius normalized by the average vortex separation, r/ar/a. (a) Data for a given diameter DD of nanocrystals with different number of vortices between 1300 and 4700 tuned by changing the induction BB in the range between 16 and 50 G. (b) Data for a vortex density of 16 G and disk samples with diameters D=30D = 30, 40 and 50 μ\mum. Dotted lines are fits to the data with a function that considers a saturation value plus an exponential growth on going towards the edge of the nanocrystals.

For all the studied vortex densities and nanocrystal sizes, the density of defects at TfT_f presents a roughly constant value at around the center of the nanocrystal, see horizontal dotted blue line in Figure 5 (b), and enhances on going towards the edges of the samples. ρTf(r)\rho_{T_f}(r) remains constant up to a larger rr when increasing the diameter of the nanocrystal DD for a given vortex density. This saturation value is roughly the same for a given vortex density irrespective of the diameter of the nanocrystal. The enhancement of ρTf(r)\rho_{T_f}(r) at the edge of the vortex nanocrystals follows a sudden growth.

This stagnation and growth phenomenology on going towards the edge of the nanocrystals was observed experimentally, [41] and the distance in which the density of defects decreases on going towards the center of the nanocrystal was interpreted as a healing length. In order to describe this phenomenology, we follow the lead of the previous experimental work and fit

ρTf(r)≈ρbulk+Aexp⁡((r−D/2)/(α⋅a)),(4)\rho_{T_f}(r) \approx\rho_{\mathrm{bulk}} + A \exp\left((r-D/2)/(\alpha\cdot a)\right), \tag*{(4)}

with ρbulk\rho_{\mathrm{bulk}} the density of topological defects in macroscopic crystals found experimentally for the same vortex density, and α⋅a\alpha\cdot a the healing length. The fits, shown with color dotted lines in the two panels of Figure 5, reasonably follow the simulation data within the error.

The phenomenological healing-length parameter α⋅a\alpha\cdot a is a measure of the confinement effect introduced by the edge of the sample that bends the lanes of vortices close to the edge by inducing topological defects. Towards the center of the sample, the vortex lattice recovers a hexagonal symmetry with mostly parallel lanes of vortices and the density of topological defects is similar to both, the central density of defects observed in experiments in disks and in large macroscopic samples for the same vortex density. This coincidence is the result of conveniently choosing the magnitude of the point pinning potential parameters VpV_p, ρp\rho_p, ξ\xi, as to quantitatively reproduce the experimental density of defects at the center of the disks. Figure 6 presents the variation of α⋅a\alpha\cdot a with DD and shows

Dependence of the phenomenological healing length on the diameter of the vortex nanocrystal

Figure 6. Dependence of the phenomenological healing length α⋅a\alpha\cdot a with the diameter DD of the vortex nanocrystal for vortex densities of (a) 16, (b) 32 and (c) 50 G. Simulation results (open dots) are compared with experimental data (full dots) from Ref. 41. Insert: Parameter α\alpha obtained in the simulations for all the studied vortex densities and sample sizes.

that the simulation data agrees quantitatively well with the experiments within the error. Both in simulations and experiments the healing length increases on growing DD at a given vortex density. [41] In addition, for a given size of the sample α\alpha is almost independent of the vortex density, see insert to Figure 6. Then, the characteristic healing length in units of aa depends primarily on DD such that enhances when the perimeter-to-area ratio diminishes.

In order to study the dynamics of this healing process, we start by considering the density of defects at the center of the sample for a given temperature TT while field cooling, namely ρT(r=0)\rho_T(r = 0). Figure 7 presents the variation with temperature of the average of this magnitude over 5 independent runs for all the simulated vortex densities and sample sizes. For every vortex density studied, the curves for different sample diameters roughly overlap within the error. Irrespective of vortex density, at TiT_i when the field cooling starts, ρT(r=0)∼0.7\rho_T(r = 0) \sim0.7, as expected for a very disordered liquid vortex structure. On starting cooling, ρT(r=0)\rho_T(r = 0) decreases significantly and at an intermediate temperature displays a tendency to saturation before reaching TfT_f. This characteristic temperature depends on vortex density, being lower for softer vortex structures nucleated at smaller BB. For a given vortex density, no clear dependence of this saturation phenomena with DD is detected in our simulations. These phenomenology indicates that the dynamics of crystallization of the nanocrystals gets frozen at an intermediate temperature that depends primarily on the system elastic properties: On increasing the stiffness of the nanocrystal it gets frozen at a higher temperature.

Central density of topological defects as a function of temperature

Figure 7. Central density of topological defects as a function of temperature, ρT(r=0)\rho_T(r = 0) during the field-cooling process starting at Ti=0.01T_i = 0.01 and finishing at Tf=0.0001T_f = 0.0001. Data for different disk diameters DD and vortex densities of (a) 16, (b) 32 and (c) 50 G. The melting temperature TmT_m of each vortex density is indicated with vertical lines. Inset: Example of the determination of TmT_m from the abrupt jump in the diffusion coefficient of the vortex structure for the case of B=16B = 16 G.

This freezing temperature is, in all cases studied, smaller than the field-dependent melting temperature of the nanocrystals, TmT_m, see dotted vertical lines in Figure 7. The insert to this figure shows an example on how we determine the melting transition in our simulations from the sudden jump on the diffusion coefficient DD of vortices on cooling. Data on the temperature-dependent D(T)D(T) are obtained from a different set of simulations where the vortex structure is cooled at the slowest sweep rate down to a given temperature TT at which the system is allowed to evolve for a long time t0t_0. After that time we compute the mean-square displacement of vortex positions that is proportional to t−t0t-t_0 via the diffusion coefficient, namely Δ2(T)/a2=D(T)(t−t0)\Delta^2(T)/a^2 = D(T)(t-t_0) for sufficiently large t0t_0 and t−t0t-t_0, according to the Einstein-Smolochuwski relation. [48] Here we consider the melting temperature as that where DD starts to register a sudden jump on cooling, see vertical dotted line in the insert to Figure 7.

The saturation of the central defect density ρT(r=0)\rho_T(r = 0) at an intermediate temperature smaller than TmT_m is also consistent with the evolution with temperature of the radial density of defects for a given temperature TT, ρT(r)\rho_T(r). Figure 8 shows for example the changes on this radial magnitude on cooling a vortex nanocrystal with a density of 16 G nucleated in a sample with D=40 μmD = 40\ \mu\mathrm{m}. As in all the studied cases, the density of defects at the center of the sample decreases on cooling and stagnates at an intermediate temperature, in this case around 0.7Tm0.7T_m. In addition, all the curves at different temperatures presented, the ρT(r)\rho_T(r) curves roughly overlap in most of the r/ar/a range, suggesting the dynamics of crystallization and thus the healing process of the nanocrystal is already frozen at all lengthscales. A similar qualitative behavior on the temperature evolution of the radial density of defects is observed for all studied cases.

Radial density of topological defects as a function of distance from the center of the nanocrystal

Figure 8. Radial density of topological defects as a function of distance from the center of the nanocrystal, ρT(r)\rho_{\mathrm{T}}(r) for various temperatures while field-cooling through the vortex melting transition at TmT_{\mathrm{m}}. Data for a disk with D=40 μmD = 40\ \mu\mathrm{m} and a vortex density of 16 G. The dashed black line is a fit to the data at the lowest temperature of T/Tm=0.14T/T_{\mathrm{m}} = 0.14 with a function ρbulk+Aexp⁡((r−D/2)/(α⋅a))\rho_{\mathrm{bulk}} + A\exp\left((r-D/2)/(\alpha\cdot a)\right), with ρbulk\rho_{\mathrm{bulk}} the density of topological defects in macroscopic crystals found experimentally for the same vortex density (see dotted horizontal line).

The freezing process spans in a finite temperature range below the melting transition and as we discuss now it is a crossover process that occurs at different temperatures in different locations of the sample. In order to show this, consider for instance the case of the vortex structure nucleated at 16 G in a 40 μm\mu\mathrm{m} diameter disk. Panel (a) of Figure 7 indicates that at the center of the sample the density of topological defects is still significantly varying at T=0.004∼0.55TmT = 0.004 \sim0.55T_{\mathrm{m}}. In contrast, Figure 8 shows that at this temperature, for r/a>12r/a > 12 the density of defects is similar to values found at lower temperatures. Similarly, for T=0.005∼0.69TmT = 0.005 \sim0.69T_{\mathrm{m}}, ρT(r)\rho_{\mathrm{T}}(r) at distances r/a<12r/a < 12 is larger than for smaller temperatures but register similar values for r/a>12r/a > 12. This phenomenology suggests that the freezing process is still underway at the center of the sample whereas at its outskirt the nanocrystal gets frozen at higher temperatures in a highly disordered structure. This temperature-delay in the freezing process when going towards the center of the sample has been observed in all the studied cases.

With the aim of following a unique criteria for determining a characteristic freezing temperature for vortex nanocrystals with given size and density, we thus consider a global magnitude. We recall that it is important to keep in mind that the freezing is a crossover and not an abrupt process that spans in a temperature range rather than at a clearly defined temperature, with this temperature range also depending on the location of the sample. One possible global criteria could be based on the temperature-evolution of the total density of defects in the nanocrystal. We thus compute the total density of defects in the studied nanocrystals at a given temperature TT, ρT\rho_{\mathrm{T}}, and plot it as a function of temperature on cooling, see Figure 9.

Figure 9. Variation with temperature of the total density of defects ρT\rho_{\mathrm{T}} while field cooling vortex nanocrystals with densities of (a) 16, (b) 32 and (c) 50 G. Data for nanocrystals of different sizes with D=30,40,50 μmD = 30, 40, 50\ \mu\mathrm{m}. Horizontal lines correspond to the saturation value of the total density of defects once the vortex structure is frozen. The characteristic freezing temperature for the larger disks is indicated with arrows.

In all studied cases ρT\rho_{\mathrm{T}} shows a tendency to remain constant below a field-dependent temperature, see arrows indicating this temperature for the largest studied disks. We consider this stagnation in ρT\rho_{\mathrm{T}} as a global indication that the vortex nanocrystal is frozen and thus consider this temperature TT as the freezing temperature TfreezT_{\mathrm{freez}}. The value of TfreezT_{\mathrm{freez}} moderately decreases on increasing DD, namely on reducing the perimeter-to-area ratio, and has a clear dependence on vortex density being smaller for softer nanocrystals (smaller BB). This behavior is summarized in the insert to Figure 9 that shows the ratio of TfreezT_{\mathrm{freez}} to TmT_{\mathrm{m}} as a function of vortex density for all the studied DD.

Sequence of snapshots of a vortex nanocrystal while field-cooling

Figure 10. Sequence of snapshots while field-cooling a vortex nanocrystal nucleated at 16 G in a sample with 50 μ\mum diameter for the different T/TmT/T_{\mathrm{m}} temperatures indicated in black. The Delaunay triangulations show sixfold (non-sixfold) coordinated vortices in blue (red). Some defects have been highlighted in different colors in order to follow their dynamics on cooling: A turquoise twisted bond located at the edge of the nanocrystal from intermediate to low temperatures, a yellow edge dislocation located at the center and rather static from intermediate and low temperatures, and a pink isolated edge dislocation at the center that seems to detach from a more complex defect at T/Tm∼0.34T/T_{\mathrm{m}} \sim0.34.

Since our simulation results agree quantitatively well with experimental data, we feel confident to study the vortex freezing dynamics with this method. Experimental field-cooling magnetic decorations do not provide information of nanocrystal freezing dynamics since the observed vortex patterns are snapshots of the structure frozen at a given TfreezT_{\mathrm{freez}} of the order or smaller than the temperature at which pinning sets in. [46, 49] On the contrary, our simulation results can provide valuable information on the freezing dynamics while cooling nanocrystals in micron-sized samples with weak and dense point pinning disorder.

Figure 10 shows a sequence of snapshots of the vortex nanocrystal while field-cooling from high to low temperatures $0.04 < T/T_{\mathrm{m}} < 0.9$ for the example of a 16 G vortex structure nucleated in a disk with 50 μ\mum diameter. The sequence highlights the main results already presented: i) A global decrease in the density of defects is produced on cooling; ii) the edge of the sample introduces a confinement effect that tends to bend the structure generating a greater density of topological defects at the outskirt of the nanocrystal; iii) at an intermediate temperature TfreezT_{\mathrm{freez}}} \sim (0.44 - 0.34)T_{\mathrm{m}}$ in this case) the nanocrystal gets globally frozen presenting an outer belt of defects and an almost healed ordered structure at the center of the nanocrystal; iv) this freezing process is actually location-dependent since at temperatures slightly below the defined global freezing temperature TfreezT_{\mathrm{freez}} (∼0.38Tm\sim0.38T_{\mathrm{m}} in this case) the defects located at the central part of the nanocrystal still present a certain degree of dynamics, see for instance the dislocation indicated in pink that appears at T/Tm=0.34T/T_{\mathrm{m}}=0.34.

Conclusions

We show that the crystallization of vortex nanocrystals is strongly controlled by the area-to-perimeter ratio, as well as by the elasticity of the system and the disorder in the samples. These factors determine both the total density of defects and its spatial profile at different temperatures, which can be characterized by a healing length and a core value within the nanocrystal. In our study, the profiles of topological defects obtained in low-temperature simulations agree quantitatively well with experimental data, despite we consider a phenomenological model that does not capture the layered nature of the vortex system.

In our simulations, the temperature dependence of the total defect density indicates a change in the nucleation behavior upon cooling at a characteristic temperature, TfreezT_{\mathrm{freez}}. The dependence of Tfreez/TmT_{\mathrm{freez}}/T_{\mathrm{m}} on vortex density and sample size suggests that the freezing temperature is influenced by both, intrinsic and confinement effects.

In contrast, the systematic increase of the healing length (in units of aa) with the nanocrystal size at fixed density, in agreement with experimental observations, indicates that confinement effects dominate the structural properties of the frozen nanocrystal. This behavior is consistent with a more prominent role of edge-induced bending as the surface-to-volume vortex ratio decreases. Therefore, elasticity and system size play distinct roles in the freezing dynamics of vortex nanocrystals formed upon cooling.

Our results are largely independent of the microscopic specifics of vortex matter, and should therefore capture general features of crystallization in confined interacting particle systems, including colloids in circular traps and Wigner molecules in quantum dots.

Acknowledgments

We acknowledge M. Schwerter for stimulating discussions. Work partially supported by the National Council of Scientific and Technical Research of Argentina (CONICET) through grants No. PIP 2021-1848, No. PIP 112-202001-01294-CO, and PIET-R IA-CoNSoFi, by the Universidad Nacional de Cuyo Research Grant No. 06/80020240100305UN, and by Universidad Nacional de San Luis Research Grant PROICO 03-2220 .

References

  1. [1]J. P. Sethna, M. K. Bierbaum, K. A. Dahmen, C. P. Goodrich, J. R. Greer, L. X. Hayden, J. P. Kent-Dobias, E. Lee, D. B. Liarté, X. Ni, K. N. Quinn, A. Raju, D. Z. Rocklin, A. Shekhawat, and S. Zapperi, Annual Review Materials Research 47, 217 (2017).
  2. [2]V. J. Anderson and H. N. W. Lekkerkerker, Nature 416, 811 (2002).
  3. [3]A. Taloni, M. Vodret, G. Costantini, and S. Zapperi, Nature Reviews Materials 3, 211–224 (2018).
  4. [4]D. R. Nelson, Defects and geometry in condensed matter Physics, 1st ed. (Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, United Kingdom, 2002).
  5. [5]M. Hillert, Acta Metallographica 13, 227–238 (1965).
  6. [6]P. Moretti, M.-C. Miguel, and S. Zapperi, Phys. Rev. B 72, 014005 (2005).
  7. [7]M. Salvalaggio, R. Backofen, K. R. Elder, and A. Voigt, Phys. Rev. Mater. 2, 053804 (2018).
  8. [8]M. Salvalaggio, A. Voigt, and K. R. Elder, npj Computational Materials 5, 48 (2019).
  9. [9]C. Qiu, M. Punke, Y. Tian, Y. Han, S. Wang, Y. Su, M. Salvalaggio, X. Pan, D. J. Srolovitz, and J. Han, Science 385, 980 (2024).
  10. [10]N. J. Petch, J. Iron Steel Res. Int. 19, 25 (1953).
  11. [11]E. O. Hall, Proc. Phys. Soc., Sec. B 64, 747 (1954).
  12. [12]L. Benoît–Maréchal, I. Nitschke, A. Voigt, and M. Salvalaggio, Mechanics of Materials 198, 105114 (2024).
  13. [13]P. Rudolph, AIP Conference Proceedings 916 (2007).
  14. [14]C. Reichhardt and C. J. Olson Reichhardt, Rep. Prog. Phys. 80, 026501 (2017).
  15. [15]P. M. Chaikin and T. C. Lubensky, Principles of Condensed Matter Physics (Cambridge University Press, 1995).
  16. [16]M. Menghini, Y. Fasano, and F. de la Cruz, Phys. Rev. B 65, 064510 (2002).
  17. [17]F. Peeters, B. Baelus, and M. Milošević, Physica E: Low-dimensional Systems and Nanostructures 18, 312 (2003), 23rd International Conference on Low Temperature Physics (LT23).
  18. [18]M. Baus and C. F. Tejero, eds., Topological defects, in Equilibrium Statistical Physics:Phases of Matter and Phase Transitions (Springer Berlin Heidelberg, Berlin, Heidelberg, 2008) pp. 307–313.DOI
  19. [19]C. van der Beek, S. Demirdis, M. Konczykowski, Y. Fasano, N. Cejas Bolecek, H. Pastoriza, D. Colson, and F. Rullier-Albenque, Physica B: Condensed Matter 407, 1746 (2012), proceedings of the International Workshop on Electronic Crystals (ECRYS-2011).
  20. [20]J. B. Llorens, L. Embon, A. Correa, J. D. González, E. Herrera, I. Guillamón, R. F. Luccas, J. Azpeitia, F. J. Mompéan, M. García-Hernández, C. Munuera, J. A. Sánchez, Y. Fasano, M. V. Milošević, H. Suderow, and Y. Anahory, Phys. Rev. Res. 2, 013329 (2020).
  21. [21]J. A. Sánchez, R. C. Maldonado, M. L. Amigó, G. Nieva, A. Kolton, and Y. Fasano, Phys. Rev. B 107, 094508 (2023).
  22. [22]J. Puig, J. A. Sánchez, E. Herrera, I. Guillamón, Z. Pribulová, J. Kacmarcik, H. Suderow, A. B. Kolton, and Y. Fasano, Phys. Rev. B 110, 024108 (2024).
  23. [23]G. R. Berdiyorov, B. J. Baelus, M. V. Milošević, and F. M. Peeters, Phys. Rev. B 68, 174521 (2003).
  24. [24]I. V. Grigorieva, W. Escoffier, J. Richardson, L. Y. Vinnikov, S. Dubonos, and V. Obnoznov, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 077005 (2006).
  25. [25]H. J. Zhao, V. R. Misko, F. M. Peeters, V. Oboznov, S. V. Dubonos, and I. V. Grigorieva, Phys. Rev. B 78, 104517 (2008).
  26. [26]V. Turlo and T. Rupert, Acta Materialia 151 (2017).
  27. [27]J. D. González, O. J. Gaona, and J. Barba-Ortega, Journal of Low Temperature Physics 198, 123 (2020).
  28. [28]A. O. Haridy, A. A. Sheekhoon, and V. V. Kresin, Phys. Rev. B 113, L041404 (2026).
  29. [29]R. Bubeck, C. Bechinger, S. Neser, and P. Leiderer, Phys. Rev. Lett. 82, 3364 (1999).
  30. [31]V. Moschalkov, L. Gielen, C. Strunk, R. Jonckheere, X. Qiu, C. Haesendonck, and Y. Bruynseraede, Nature 373, 319 (1995).
  31. [32]A. Geim, I. Grigorieva, S. Dubonos, J. Lok, J. Maan, A. Filippov, and F. M. Peeters, Nature 390, 259 (1997).
  32. [33]J. J. Palacios, Phys. Rev. B 58, R5948 (1998).
  33. [34]V. A. Schweigert, F. M. Peeters, and P. S. Deo, Phys. Rev. Lett. 81, 2783 (1998).
  34. [35]Y. M. Wang, M. S. Fuhrer, A. Zettl, S. Ooi, and T. Tamegai, Phys. Rev. Lett. 86, 3626 (2001).
  35. [36]M. I. Dolz, Y. Fasano, N. R. Cejas Bolecek, H. Pastoriza, V. Mosser, M. Li, and M. Konczykowski, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 137003 (2015).
  36. [37]G. Blatter, M. V. Feigel’man, V. B. Geshkenbein, A. I. Larkin, and V. M. Vinokur, Rev. Mod. Phys. 66, 1125 (1994).
  37. [38]J. Puig, F. Elías, J. A. Sánchez, R. C. Maldonado, G. Rumi, G. Nieva, P. Pedrazzini, A. B. Kolton, and Y. Fasano, Communications Materials 3, 32 (2022).
  38. [39]Y. M. Wang, A. Zettl, S. Ooi, and T. Tamegai, Phys. Rev. B 65, 184506 (2002).
  39. [40]N. R. Cejas Bolecek, M. I. Dolz, A. Kolton, H. Pastoriza, C. J. v. d. Beek, M. M. Konczykowski, M. Menghini, G. Nieva, and Y. Fasano, Journal of Low Temperature Physics 179, 35 (2015).
  40. [41]N. R. C. Bolecek, M. I. Dolz, H. Pastoriza, M. Konczykowski, C. J. van der Beek, A. B. Kolton, and Y. Fasano, Phys. Rev. B 96, 024507 (2017).
  41. [42]M. Dolz, Y. Fasano, H. Pastoriza, V. Mosser, M. Li, and M. Konczykowski, Physical Review B 90, 144507 (2014).
  42. [43]C. Reichhardt, J. Groth, C. J. Olson, S. B. Field, and F. Nori, Phys. Rev. B 54, 16108 (1996).
  43. [44]M. P. Allen and D. J. Tildesley, Computer Simulation of Liquids, 2nd ed. (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2017).
  44. [45]Y. Fasano, M. De Seta, M. Menghini, H. Pastoriza, and F. de la Cruz, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 102, 3898 (2005).
  45. [46]Y. Fasano, M. De Seta, M. Menghini, H. Pastoriza, and F. de la Cruz, Solid State Communications 128, 51 (2003).
  46. [47]D. Hull and D. J. Bacon, Introduction to dislocations, 5th ed. (Butterworth-Heinemann, Elsevier, Oxford, 2011).
  47. [48]A. Cruz-García, J. Puig, R. M. Besana, A. B. Kolton, and Y. Fasano, Phys. Rev. B 113, 024112 (2026).
  48. [49]Y. Fasano, J. Herbsommer, and F. de la Cruz, Physica Status Solidi (b) 215, 563 (1999).

Paper details

vlnc:W_73crmkug
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents