betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Alloying effects on the interface cohesion of grain boundaries in the Ni–Fe–Cr system

Abstract

Grain boundaries (GBs) in polycrystalline Ni-based alloys strongly influence mechanical strength and fracture behavior, yet the effect of alloying elements such as Fe and Cr on GB cohesion remains difficult to quantify systematically. Using density functional theory (DFT), we compute rigid-body separation (RBS) curves for six symmetric-tilt Ni GBs, extracting the work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and maximum traction σmax⁡σ_{\max} via the universal binding energy relation (UBER). We find that substitution of Cr or Fe into the GB plane increases both quantities relative to pure Ni GBs. To overcome the size limitations of DFT, we compare several machine-learning interatomic potential (MLIP) foundation models against the DFT dataset and identify a model achieving quantitative agreement with DFT for WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡σ_{\max}. This MLIP enables systematic sampling of alloying configurations at finer concentration steps. We show that alloying-induced changes in GB cohesion depend on both, element type and local structures, revealing trends that are inaccessible with DFT alone. Extending the analysis to a ternary Ni56Fe20Cr24\mathrm{Ni}_{56}\mathrm{Fe}_{20}\mathrm{Cr}_{24} composition, inspired by the principal constituents of the widely used commercial Alloy 718, shows that the binary trends provide a useful basis for interpreting the combined effect of both substitutes, while explicit ternary calculations are required to capture their interplay quantitatively. Together, these results provide a validated workflow for quantifying the effect of alloying elements on GB cohesion in multicomponent alloys. The resulting values may serve as input for continuum-scale fracture models, paving the way toward atomistically informed multiscale modeling.

Introduction

Nickel-based alloys are a cornerstone of modern high-performance materials, owing to their ability to maintain mechanical integrity and chemical stability under extreme operating conditions [1, 2]. They are widely deployed in energy conversion systems, chemical processing, and aerospace applications, where high temperatures, complex stress states, and aggressive environments are routinely encountered [3, 4]. These multicomponent Ni-based alloys provide an ideal platform for investigating the interplay between chemistry, microstructure, and mechanical response. In particular, ternary Ni–Fe–Cr alloys are frequently used as model systems for oxidation- and corrosion-resistant materials and serve as a simplified representation of more complex commercial alloys, such as Alloy 718 [5, 6, 7, 8]. The Ni–Fe–Cr system is employed here as a representative, technologically relevant test case for developing and validating atomistic methodologies applicable to complex alloys and their interface mechanics.

A key microstructural feature governing the performance of Ni-based alloys is their grain boundaries (GBs). GBs strongly influence mechanical strength, fracture behavior, and environmental degradation, often acting as preferential sites for crack initiation and accelerated transport of detrimental species [9, 10, 11, 12]. Accordingly, a quantitative understanding of GB cohesion and separation is essential for establishing physically grounded links between atomistic interfacial mechanisms and continuum-scale models of damage evolution and macroscopic failure [13, 14].

At the atomistic scale, GB fracture can be studied using rigid-body separation (RBS) simulations, in which the total energy of a simulation cell containing the GB is evaluated as the two adjoining grains are incrementally and rigidly displaced normal to the interface, ultimately forming two free surfaces [15, 16]. The resulting energy–separation data can be described using the universal binding energy relation (UBER), a general framework for modeling the energy as a function of displacement between two atomic planes [17, 18, 19]. In the following, all energies entering the UBER expression are normalized by the interface area AA. For a relative displacement dd of the two grains normal to the interface, measured from the initial relaxed configuration,

E(d)=E∞+Eb(1+d−d0L)exp⁡[−d−d0L].(1)E(d) = E_{\infty} + E_b \left(1 + \frac{d-d_0}{L}\right) \exp\left[-\frac{d-d_0}{L}\right]. \tag*{(1)}

Here, E∞E_{\infty} is the energy of the fully separated system, i.e., two independent free surfaces (d→∞d \to\infty), d0d_0 is the equilibrium separation, EbE_b is the binding energy, i.e., the energy at the minimum of the curve relative to the fully separated state, and LL is a characteristic length scale controlling the curvature of the energy–displacement curve. Throughout the remainder of this paper, we report the work of separation Wsep=−EbW_{\mathrm{sep}}=-E_b, i.e., the energy per unit area required to separate the two grains into two free surfaces, so that larger values indicate stronger cohesion. The corresponding traction, which quantifies the interfacial force per unit area as a function of separation, is obtained by differentiating the energy with respect to dd:

σ(d)=dEdd=WsepLd−d0Lexp⁡[−d−d0L].(2)\sigma(d)=\frac{\mathrm{d}E}{\mathrm{d}d}=\frac{W_{\mathrm{sep}}}{L}\frac{d-d_0}{L}\exp\left[-\frac{d-d_0}{L}\right]. \tag*{(2)}

The maximum of σ(d)\sigma(d) represents the maximum cohesive traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} of the interface, i.e., the ideal de-cohesion strength under rigid separation. It occurs at d=d0+Ld=d_0+L and is given by

σmax⁡=WsepeL.(3)\sigma_{\max}=\frac{W_{\mathrm{sep}}}{eL}. \tag*{(3)}

Thus, the maximum traction depends on both the work of separation and the characteristic length LL. Figure 1 shows the result of a typical RBS simulation. The upper panel shows the energy–separation data, to which Eq. (1) is fitted, with energies referenced to the energy at the largest separation. The depth of the minimum of this curve corresponds to WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}}, with a separation of 6 Å taken to represent two fully separated, free surfaces. The lower plot shows the derivative of the fitted curve, and the maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} is indicated. The quantities obtained from this procedure, such as WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max}, can be used to inform traction–separation laws for cohesive-zone models in finite-element method (FEM) simulations [20, 21].

Figure 1. Universal binding energy relation curve for the Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10][\bar{1}10] Ni grain boundary. Top: energy as a function of separation distance, with DFT data points (open circles) and the corresponding UBER fit (solid line), referenced to the energy at the largest separation (6 Å). Bottom: the associated traction, obtained as the derivative of the fitted energy curve, with the maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} indicated by the dashed vertical line.

Density functional theory (DFT) provides a reliable description of interfacial cohesion at the electronic-structure level and, as a first-principles method, is not restricted to a specific chemical subspace, making it a powerful tool for describing multicomponent materials and complex local structural motifs [22, 23]. However, its computational cost severely restricts the accessible system size and configurational sampling. This limitation is especially problematic for multicomponent alloys, where realistic grain boundaries exhibit chemical disorder, segregation, and structural complexity that require large simulation cells far beyond what is feasible with DFT.

To address these challenges, we employ a machine-learning interatomic potential (MLIP) based on the Graph Atomic Cluster Expansion (GRACE) framework [24]. Within this framework, several foundation models are available, which have been trained on large datasets of DFT calculations, such as OMAT [25] or Alexandria [26], and which differ in complexity and the training dataset used [27]. Using our own DFT reference data, we select the foundation model that achieves the best agreement with the DFT results. The resulting MLIP enables an accuracy comparable to DFT while allowing simulations of large, chemically complex GB structures. By combining GRACE with RBS calculations, we demonstrate how MLIPs can be used to systematically study GB cohesion in multicomponent alloys at scales inaccessible to first-principles methods. The workflow presented here, which includes calculating DFT reference data, performing large-scale GB separation simulations with a MLIP, and extracting energy–separation data, is fully transferable to a wide range of alloy systems and establishes a framework for linking atomistic modeling to continuum-scale fracture simulations.

The remainder of this paper is organized as follows: Sec. II describes the construction of the grain boundary structures and the computational details of the DFT and MLIP calculations. Sec. III presents the results and discussion, beginning with the properties of the Ni grain boundaries (Sec. III A), followed by the DFT-based chemical effects of Cr and Fe substitution (Sec. III B) and the comparison of GRACE foundation models to DFT data (Sec. III C). Using the selected MLIP, we then analyze the configurational effects of binary Cr and Fe substitution in large simulation cells (Sec. III D) and extend this analysis to a ternary Ni56_{56}Fe20_{20}Cr24_{24} composition (Sec. III E). Finally, Sec. IV summarizes our findings.

Theoretical approach

Grain boundary structures

First, an energy–volume curve was computed and fitted to determine the equilibrium lattice constant of ferromagnetic Ni, yielding a value of 3.518 Å, in good agreement with the literature [28, 29]. Using this lattice constant, symmetric-tilt grain boundary structures were constructed with the atomsk software [33]. For each grain boundary, face-centered cubic (fcc) Ni was oriented with the tilt axis along xx and the grain boundary normal along zz. Following the approach reported by Zheng et al. [34], pairs of Ni atoms separated by less than 1.5 Å were replaced by a single Ni atom at their midpoint. The resulting simulation cells contained two grain boundaries, located at fractional coordinates z=0z = 0 and z=0.5z = 0.5. The height of the two grains was chosen such that the kk-point density used for the entire cell (see Sec. II B) resulted in a single kk-point along the grain boundary normal (c>42c > 42 Å). This procedure was applied to all six investigated grain boundaries: Σ3 (111) [1ˉ\bar{1}10], Σ3 (112) [1ˉ\bar{1}10], Σ5 (012) [100], Σ5 (013) [100], Σ9 (221) [1ˉ\bar{1}10], and Σ11 (113) [1ˉ\bar{1}10], whose structures are shown in Figure 2. The dimensions of the supercells are reported in Table I. These GBs cover a wide range of GB energies, which are defined as:

Grain boundary structures for six grain boundaries

Figure 2. Grain boundary structures are shown with the corresponding tilt axis oriented perpendicular to the plane of the page. For clarity, the repeating structural motifs of the grain boundaries are highlighted. Atoms depicted in darker shading are located within the grain boundary plane.

γGB=EGB−NGBEbulk(at)2A(4)\gamma_{\mathrm{GB}} = \frac{E_{\mathrm{GB}} - N_{\mathrm{GB}} E_{\mathrm{bulk}}^{(\mathrm{at})}}{2A} \tag*{(4)}

where EGBE_{\mathrm{GB}} is the total energy of the relaxed grain boundary supercell, NGBN_{\mathrm{GB}} is the number of atoms in that supercell, Ebulk(at)E_{\mathrm{bulk}}^{(\mathrm{at})} is the reference energy per atom of the undisturbed fcc-Ni bulk crystal, AA is the cross-sectional area of the grain boundary plane, and the factor of 2 accounts for the two equivalent grain boundaries contained in the periodic slab cell.

Grain boundaryaa (Å)bb (Å)cc (Å)α\alpha (°)β\beta (°)γ\gamma (°)NN
Σ3 (111) [1ˉ\bar{1}10]2.492.4948.7590906024
Σ3 (112) [1ˉ\bar{1}10]2.496.0942.8590909058
Σ5 (012) [100]4.314.3147.21909048.1960
Σ5 (013) [100]3.525.5643.9690909078
Σ9 (221) [1ˉ\bar{1}10]2.497.4642.2290909070
Σ11 (113) [1ˉ\bar{1}10]4.314.3146.68909033.5644

Table 1. Lattice parameters aa, bb, cc, angles α\alpha, β\beta, γ\gamma, and number of atoms NN of the initial GB supercells used in the DFT calculations.

For each grain boundary plane orientation, a corresponding simulation cell was oriented such that separation of bulk Ni along the normal to this plane could be computed analogously to the GB RBS calculations.

Three chemical configurations were considered for each GB in the DFT calculations: the pure Ni GB and two substituted GBs with either Cr (Cr@GB) or Fe (Fe@GB) replacing all Ni atoms in one of the two GB planes of the simulation cell. For the calculations with the GRACE MLIP, supercells were constructed by replicating the DFT simulation cells five times along both in-plane directions, resulting in cells containing 600–2000 atoms. In these larger cells, Ni atoms were substituted randomly not only within the GB plane but also in the adjacent layers, either by a single species (Cr or Fe) or simultaneously by both species to obtain a ternary composition, as described in Secs. III D and III E, respectively.

Computational details

Electronic structure calculations were performed using the Vienna ab initio simulation package (VASP) [35]. The interactions between valence electrons and ionic cores were treated using the projector-augmented wave method [36, 37] within the generalized gradient approximation (GGA), employing the Perdew–Burke–Ernzerhof (PBE) exchange-correlation functional. The Ni 3d3d and 4s4s, Fe 3d3d and 4s4s, and Cr 3p3p, 3d3d and 4s4s electrons were treated as valence states. A plane-wave energy cutoff of 600 eV was used. The Brillouin zone was sampled using Monkhorst–Pack [38] kk-point meshes chosen to maintain a reciprocal-space sampling density equivalent to that of a 12×12×1212 \times12 \times12 mesh for the fcc Ni unit cell. Gaussian smearing with a width of 0.1 eV was applied for the Brillouin-zone integrations [39]. The electronic self-consistency loop was converged to 1×10−61 \times10^{-6} eV, and ionic relaxations were continued until all interatomic forces were below 1×10−21 \times10^{-2} eV/Å.

Spin polarization was used to account for local magnetic moments. As for bulk fcc Ni, a ferromagnetic (FM) ordering was found to be more stable than antiferromagnetic (AFM) ordering for all the considered pure Ni GBs. For the Cr@GB and Fe@GB structures, several configurations with the local magnetic moments oriented parallel or antiparallel to the Ni moments were considered, and the lowest-energy configuration found in each case was selected for further investigation. The results are described in detail in App. A.

We introduced the separation above the GB plane by shifting all atoms on one side of the plane upward and elongating the simulation cell by the same amount. Energies were calculated at the following separations: {−0.2,−0.1,0,0.1,0.2,0.4,0.5,0.6,0.7,0.8,1,6}\{-0.2, -0.1, 0, 0.1, 0.2, 0.4, 0.5, 0.6, 0.7, 0.8, 1, 6\} Å, generating energy–separation data. The separations were chosen to thoroughly sample both the region around the equilibrium distance and the region where the maximum traction occurs. Equation (1) is fitted to these data points, and the work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} is extracted. The maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} is subsequently obtained from Eq. (2).

To assess the performance of the GRACE foundation models, we performed the same RBS calculations, as done with DFT. Since the models may have different equilibrium lattice constants for pure nickel due to training, we proceeded similarly to the DFT approach: The lattice parameters in the xyxy plane were fixed according to the model’s equilibrium bulk lattice parameter, and the cell and atoms were relaxed along the zz axis prior to the RBS calculations until the relative energy change between two consecutive iterations in LAMMPS [40] was below 10−810^{-8}. Subsequently, the energy was calculated for the same separations as described above, and Eq. (1) was fitted to the energy–separation data. The resulting values for the work of separation and maximum traction were compared with the DFT values using a combined metric that quantifies the mean relative error (MRE) averaged over both target quantities,

MRE‾=12N∑i=1N[∣Wsep,iGRACE−Wsep,iDFT∣Wsep,iDFT+∣σmax⁡,iGRACE−σmax⁡,iDFT∣σmax⁡,iDFT](5)\overline{\mathrm{MRE}} = \frac{1}{2N}\sum_{i=1}^{N}\left[\frac{\left|W_{\mathrm{sep},i}^{\mathrm{GRACE}}-W_{\mathrm{sep},i}^{\mathrm{DFT}}\right|}{W_{\mathrm{sep},i}^{\mathrm{DFT}}}+\frac{\left|\sigma_{\max,i}^{\mathrm{GRACE}}-\sigma_{\max,i}^{\mathrm{DFT}}\right|}{\sigma_{\max,i}^{\mathrm{DFT}}}\right] \tag*{(5)}

where NN is the number of RBS calculations, which in this work is 24. Normalizing by the DFT reference value makes both error terms dimensionless, so work of separation and maximum traction contribute equally to the combined score.

Results and Discussion

Structural and energetic properties of Ni grain boundaries

Prior to the RBS calculations, the Ni grain boundaries were structurally relaxed and subsequently characterized in terms of their geometric widening and grain boundary energy. Atomic positions were allowed to move along zz, i.e., along the GB normal, and the cc-lattice parameter was adjusted accordingly, while the in-plane Ni bulk lattice constant was kept fixed. This approximates the situation in which the two grains are large enough to recover bulk-like values away from the interface.

We define the geometric GB excess volume as

δGB=VGB−NGBVbulk(at)2A,(6)\delta_{\mathrm{GB}} = \frac{V_{\mathrm{GB}}-N_{\mathrm{GB}}V_{\mathrm{bulk}}^{(\mathrm{at})}}{2A}, \tag*{(6)}

where VGBV_{\mathrm{GB}} is the total volume of the relaxed grain boundary supercell, NGBN_{\mathrm{GB}} is the number of atoms in that supercell, Vbulk(at)V_{\mathrm{bulk}}^{(\mathrm{at})} is the reference volume per atom of the undisturbed fcc-Ni bulk crystal, AA is the cross-sectional area of the grain boundary plane, and the factor of 2 accounts for the two equivalent grain boundaries contained in the periodic slab cell. Table II lists the resulting excess volumes and GB energies for the six pure Ni structures, together with GB energies from the literature. The calculated GB energies are generally in good agreement with the DFT literature values. The deviations may partly arise from differences in structural relaxation procedures. For example, in Refs. [34, 41], all atomic positions and lattice parameters of the simulation cell were relaxed.

Grain boundaryγGB\gamma_{\mathrm{GB}} (J/m2^2) This workγGB\gamma_{\mathrm{GB}} (J/m2^2) Ref.δGB\delta_{\mathrm{GB}} (Å)
Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [11ˉ01\bar{1}0]0.070.06 [42]0.01
Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [11ˉ01\bar{1}0]0.940.84 [41]0.15
Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [?]1.281.31 [43]0.34
Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [?]1.251.26 [34]0.30
Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [11ˉ01\bar{1}0]1.181.16 [34]0.31
Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [11ˉ01\bar{1}0]0.440.43 [42]0.13

Table II. Grain boundary energies γGB\gamma_{\mathrm{GB}} compared to DFT values from the literature, together with the excess volumes δGB\delta_{\mathrm{GB}} for the investigated Ni GB structures.

Figure 3 shows the interlayer distances in the Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100] GB for pure Ni, as well as for structures containing Fe or Cr. While Cr and Fe substitutions do have an effect, the main difference compared to the interlayer distances in the bulk is attributable to the geometric properties of the grain boundaries. Between the two GB planes of the simulation cell, the interlayer spacings can be seen to approach the bulk value (within 0.01 Å), supporting the assumption stated above. This behavior was verified for all six GB structures investigated in this work.

Figure 3. Interlayer spacing along the grain boundary normal for the Σ5 (013) [100] GB, comparing pure Ni (Ni GB) with Cr- and Fe-substituted grain boundaries (Cr@GB, Fe@GB). The dashed horizontal line marks the bulk Ni interlayer spacing as reference. Distances are reported relative to the GB plane, located at fractional z=0.5z = 0.5. The region around ±0.01\pm0.01 Å of the bulk interlayer distance is shaded in grey.

Chemical effect of substitutes at the GB

For each of the six GBs, four RBS calculations were performed: one reference calculation on the corresponding bulk cell (where the separation is applied normal to the plane, which is the GB plane in the GB structures), and three calculations on the GB structures, namely the pure Ni GB and the two substituted configurations, Cr@GB and Fe@GB. The absolute values for all structures are reported in Table III, and Figure 4 shows the

Relative change in work of separation and maximum traction

Figure 4. Relative change in work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (a) and maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (b) for the pure Ni GB and the Cr@GB and Fe@GB structures, relative to the pure Ni bulk value.

GBNi bulk crystalNi GBCr@GBFe@GB
WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m2^2)σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m2^2)σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m2^2)σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m2^2)σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)
Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]3.9130.383.7929.075.1137.074.4432.48
Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]4.6330.394.0227.364.8931.564.3528.28
Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [100]5.0330.633.9425.394.1325.984.1125.94
Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100]5.0530.944.0726.644.4027.244.2426.72
Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]4.4530.203.5624.664.3228.133.9325.55
Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]4.8730.414.4228.405.1532.624.6929.29

Table III. Work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} for the considered grain boundary structures (pure Ni GB and with Fe or Cr as substitutional element at the GB plane). Values for the rigid body separation of a Ni bulk crystal along the same lattice plane are given as reference.

relative deviation of the work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and the maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} with respect to bulk Ni. These relative deviations are defined as

ΔWsep=WsepGB−WsepbulkWsepbulk,(7)\Delta W_{\mathrm{sep}} = \frac{W_{\mathrm{sep}}^{\mathrm{GB}} - W_{\mathrm{sep}}^{\mathrm{bulk}}}{W_{\mathrm{sep}}^{\mathrm{bulk}}}, \tag*{(7)}

and

Δσmax⁡=σmax⁡GB−σmax⁡bulkσmax⁡bulk,(8)\Delta\sigma_{\max} = \frac{\sigma_{\max}^{\mathrm{GB}} - \sigma_{\max}^{\mathrm{bulk}}}{\sigma_{\max}^{\mathrm{bulk}}}, \tag*{(8)}

where WsepGBW_{\mathrm{sep}}^{\mathrm{GB}} and σmax⁡GB\sigma_{\max}^{\mathrm{GB}} denote the values for the pure Ni GB, Cr@GB, or Fe@GB configuration, and WsepbulkW_{\mathrm{sep}}^{\mathrm{bulk}} and σmax⁡bulk\sigma_{\max}^{\mathrm{bulk}} are the corresponding bulk reference values.

For all tested GBs, the pure Ni GBs exhibit lower values for WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} than the corresponding bulk structures. This can be explained by the non-equilibrium atomic distances and different coordination environments compared to bulk Ni, resulting from the local geometries at the GBs [44, 45]. However, the quantitative reduction varies between grain boundaries. While the values for the Σ3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10] GB, which has a low GB energy, are close to the bulk values, for grain boundaries with higher GB energies, the values are much lower compared to the bulk (up to approx. −20-20 % for Σ5 (012) [100] or Σ9 (221) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]).

The work of separation values agree well with the values for unrelaxed surfaces reported by Sesták et al. [42] for the Σ3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10] and Σ11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10] GBs (3.78 and 4.35 J/m2^2). For the Σ5 (012) [100] GB, Černý et al. [46] reported 3.94 J/m2^2 and 25.3 GPa for WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max}, respectively, which match our values almost exactly.

Chen and Dongare [47] reported maximum tensile stresses of 28.06, 24.89, 23.55, and 27.51 GPa for the pristine Σ3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10], Σ5 (012) [100], Σ5 (013) [100], and

Σ11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10] GBs, respectively. For Σ3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10], Σ5 (012) [100], and Σ11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10], these agree with our values of 29.07, 25.39, and 28.40 GPa within the variation expected due to differences in the computational details. For Σ5 (013) [100], however, our value of 26.64 GPa is substantially higher than their 23.55 GPa. We attribute this to the GB structure: in our construction, two closely spaced Ni atoms were merged into one site (Sec. II A), whereas Chen and Dongare retain both, resulting in a significantly higher GB energy of 1.91 J/m2^2 compared to our 1.25 J/m2^2.

There is an approximately linear trend between GB energy and the reduction in WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (with a Pearson correlation coefficient [48] between the magnitude of the reduction in WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and GB energy of r=0.98r = 0.98, and between the magnitude of the reduction in σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} and GB energy of r=0.93r = 0.93), where deviations from a perfect correlation can be explained by the fact that the RBS calculations primarily capture the modified local bonding environments along the direction of separation, while the grain boundary energy captures the spatially averaged effect of the local geometry across the interface.

Replacing Ni atoms with Fe or Cr in the grain boundary plane increases both the work of separation and the maximum traction. This is consistent with thermodynamic calculations for the ternary fcc system, which show that mixed Fe–Ni and Cr–Ni bonds are more energetically favorable than the corresponding pure bonds [49].

The effective interaction between Cr and Ni in ternary Ni–Fe–Cr alloys is significantly stronger than that between Fe and Ni, which is consistent with the observation that the increase in the quantities in Figure 4 caused by Cr is greater than that caused by Fe. However, the extent of the increase varies strongly and does not follow any easily discernible trend, which can be explained by the different local geometric environments of the various grain boundaries.

GRACE foundation models

In order to overcome the size limitations implied by the computational cost of DFT simulations, we use the DFT data described in the previous section as a reference to evaluate the performance of various MLIPs and subsequently select one for larger and more numerous simulations. The comparison to DFT constitutes a particularly stringent test for the MLIPs, as they require an accurate description not only of bulk properties, but also of surface energies (at large separations), the local structural motifs at the grain boundaries, and the stretching of bonds across the full range of separations. We evaluated 26 GRACE foundation models against the DFT reference data using the combined mean relative error MRE defined in Eq. (5). Most of the models yield similar results, with 17 of the 26 reaching MRE < 3 %. The five models with the lowest MRE (1.17–1.79 %) differ in architecture and size, but share the same training data: they are all trained on OMAT [25], Alexandria [26], and Materials Project (MP) [50] datasets (-ft-AM). The GRACE-2L-OMAT-large-ft-AM model achieved the lowest MRE value and was therefore chosen as the model for further investigations. The values of MAE and MRE for all models are summarized in App. B.

The comparison between the values obtained by DFT and the GRACE-2L-OMAT-large-ft-AM model is presented in Figure 5. The figure shows that the model exhibits excellent agreement with the DFT data for the Ni bulk and Ni GB systems (mean absolute error (MAE) of WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}}: 0.023 J/m2^2 and 0.024 J/m2^2, respectively). For the Fe@GB structures, MAE(WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}}) = 0.057 J/m2^2. The Cr@GB structures show the largest deviations with

Parity plots comparing the work of separation and maximum traction

Figure 5. Parity plots comparing the work of separation (a) and maximum traction (b), obtained with the GRACE-2L-OMAT-large-ft-AM foundation model against DFT reference values. The mean absolute error (MAE), the mean relative error (MRE) and the Pearson correlation coefficient rr [48] are reported in the legends of each quantity.

MAE(WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}}) = 0.072 J/m2^2. This is likely due, in part, to the magnetic degrees of freedom, which are not taken into account explicitly in the MLIP. For Fe@GB, the FM arrangements were the most energetically favorable for all systems (see App. A), essentially reducing this degree of freedom. In contrast, the preferred magnetic arrangement for Cr@GB depends on the GB structure. The largest deviation in WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} occurs for the Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100] Cr@GB structure, where the two Cr atoms carry large magnetic moments of opposite sign (−1.81-1.81 and +2.56 μB+2.56\,\mu_{\mathrm{B}}). The absence of explicit magnetic degrees of freedom in the MLIP likely contribute to the larger deviations observed for Cr@GB.

Configurational effects of binary substitution at the GB

To achieve a more realistic description of the material, larger simulation cells are needed in which, for example, grain boundaries with larger structural motifs can be realized, extending all the way to general grain boundaries [51]. Here, we aim to use the GRACE MLIP to describe the alloying effect of Cr and Fe at the grain boundaries more realistically. To do this, we use simulation cells that are five times larger within the grain boundary plane in both directions, reaching sizes of 600–2000 atoms.

The MLIP not only allows us to calculate many different arrangements of the alloying elements but also, due to the larger simulation cells, enables finer gradations in element concentrations. In the DFT analysis, we considered only substitutions within the grain boundary plane to keep the number of possible structures and the associated magnetic arrangements manageable. In the following, we extend the analysis beyond substitution solely within the grain boundary plane by also substituting atoms in the layers above and below it, while the separation during the RBS calculations is still performed directly above the GB plane. We first examined how many alloyed layers need to be considered before the results no longer change significantly. Distributing the substitute atoms over several layers, rather than placing them exclusively in the GB plane, gives a more realistic picture and approaches a randomly mixed alloy without preferential segregation to the GB. This is shown exemplarily in Figure 6 for the Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10][\bar{1}10] GB. Subfigure (a) in Figure 6 shows the increasing number of layers considered for substitution.

Effect of alloying species on GB cohesion

Figure 6. Effect of alloying species on GB cohesion. (a): The Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10][\bar{1}10] GB structure, with the GB plane indicated by darker shaded atoms. From left to right, the increasing number of Ni layers nn considered for substitution is highlighted. The horizontal dashed line indicates the plane where the separation is introduced. (b) and (c): Mean work of separation obtained from UBER fits to RBS calculations performed with the GRACE MLIP for different concentrations of the substitute elements Cr and Fe, respectively, and different numbers of layers nn. (d) and (e): Mean maximum traction derived from the same RBS calculations.

For each concentration and number of layers considered, 50 random arrangements of Cr or Fe were generated. This means that out of all Ni atoms located within the considered layers, the atoms to be substituted by Cr or Fe were selected randomly. For each number of layers, the maximum number of substituted atoms was limited to the number corresponding to a concentration of 100 % when substitution is restricted to the GB plane alone. Higher concentrations for a larger number of layers would otherwise correspond to an overall higher concentration of Cr or Fe atoms. This is particularly relevant because the in-plane lattice parameters are kept fixed to simulate bulk Ni between the GBs, such that a high concentration of substitute atoms could give rise to additional, confounding effects. Using the GRACE potential, each of these simulation cells was relaxed along the GB normal (cf. also Sec. III A), RBS calculations were performed, and Eq. (1) was fitted to these data. Figure 6 (b) and (c) show the mean work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} as a function of concentration for the different numbers of layers considered, for the Cr@GB and Fe@GB systems, respectively. Subfigures (d) and (e) in Figure 6 show the values for σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} in the same manner.

For the case where only substitution within the GB plane was considered, both WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} increase linearly with increasing concentration. The deviations from the DFT data are the same ones visible in Figure 5, i.e., they reflect the differences between DFT and the chosen GRACE potential. This linear trend is consistent with the interpretation that, as the concentration increases, more Cr–Ni and Fe–Ni bonds are broken during separation, as discussed in Sec. III B.

In contrast, substituting Ni atoms in additional layers leads to two qualitatively different phenomena: For the Cr@GB systems (subfigures (b) and (d) in Figure 6), we continue to observe an approximately linear trend in both quantities, with the slope increasing as more layers are included.

are included. This suggests that Cr–Cr bonds also contribute to strengthening the interfacial cohesion. This increase in slope appears to converge for four layers, with only minor deviations in both WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} when a fifth layer is substituted. This is plausible, since substitutions in layers further away from the GB plane are expected to have a progressively smaller effect on the interface cohesion. The Fe@GB systems exhibit different effects. While Fe–Ni bonds increase WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (see Figure 6 (c) and (e)), albeit to a lesser extent than Cr–Ni bonds, Fe–Fe bonds being stretched across the separation plane lead to different behavior. As with the Cr@GB systems, WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} increases with higher concentrations, though not as linearly as when substitution is confined to the GB plane alone. The maximum traction, on the other hand, only increases for small Fe concentrations when more layers are considered, then remains approximately constant and even decreases at high Fe concentrations. Within the UBER description, the simultaneous increase in WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and decrease in σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} implies that the characteristic length LL increases with Fe concentration by a larger relative amount than WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}}, see Eq. (3). The resulting broader traction–separation curve therefore has a lower peak traction despite the greater total energy required for separation. Again, the results vary only slightly between four and five layers considered, and we therefore chose to investigate substitution for this GB structure using four layers.

The same procedure was applied to the other GBs studied here, and the layers considered for substitution are marked in the top row of Figure 7. The middle and bottom subfigures show the resulting values for the work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and the maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max}, respectively. We calculated both quantities for all GBs up to concentrations of 50 %. Beyond this point, as described above, confounding effects arising from high overall concentrations of Cr or Fe in the simulation cells are expected. The results shown are the minimum, maximum, and mean values for 100 random arrangements.

Layers considered for substitution and plots of work of separation and maximum traction for six grain boundaries

Figure 7. Top: Layers considered for the substitution of Ni atoms with Cr or Fe in the six grain boundaries studied. Only atoms located entirely within the shaded region were considered for substitution. The darker-shaded atoms are located within the grain boundary plane. Middle: Work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} obtained from MLIP-based RBS calculations. Circles show the mean values over 100 random binary substitution configurations per concentration, and shaded bands span the minimum and maximum values. Black diamonds represent the ternary composition Ni₅₆Fe₂₀Cr₂₄, with bars indicating the minimum and maximum values. Bottom: Maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max}, plotted in the same manner.

In order to check the convergence of the mean values, 10 additional random arrangements were generated for each GB, substitutional element, and concentration, and the corresponding RBS calculations were performed. In all cases, the mean values changed by at most 0.1 %. While a larger number of calculations might reveal even lower minimum or higher maximum values, the small change in the mean values indicates that the mean provides a statistically reliable estimate of the expected value, under the assumption that the substitutional elements are randomly distributed.

For the Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10][\bar{1}10], Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [100], Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100], and Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ10][\bar{1}10] GBs, the trends with increasing Cr or Fe concentration follow the same qualitative behavior we have already discussed for Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10][\bar{1}10]. In the Cr@GB systems, both WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} increase approximately linearly with Cr concentration, while in the Fe@GB systems WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} follows the same trend (although for Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100] it is nearly constant), but σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} decreases with increasing Fe content. For Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ10][\bar{1}10], the same trends hold, with one exception: here, σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} in the Fe@GB systems does not decrease with increasing Fe content but instead remains essentially constant across the entire concentration range. All absolute values are reported in App. § 2.2.1.

GB cohesion for a ternary composition

While the binary substitutions allow the effects of Fe and Cr to be examined separately, technologically relevant Ni-based alloys contain both elements simultaneously. As a first step toward such multicomponent systems, we therefore extended the calculations to a ternary composition of Ni56_{56}Fe20_{20}Cr24_{24} (at.%), inspired by the principal constituents of Alloy 718 [52]. Within the substitution regions shown in Figure 7, Ni atoms were randomly replaced by Fe and Cr to obtain the prescribed composition, corresponding to a total substitution concentration of 44 %. For each GB structure, 100 random configurations were generated. The resulting mean values of WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} are included in Figure 7, and the numerical values are reported in Table IV.

GBWsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m2^2)σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)
Σ\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ\bar{1}10]4.37 ±\pm 0.0630.32 ±\pm 0.30
Σ\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ\bar{1}10]4.52 ±\pm 0.0228.82 ±\pm 0.18
Σ\Sigma5 (012) [100]4.30 ±\pm 0.0225.84 ±\pm 0.19
Σ\Sigma5 (013) [100]4.45 ±\pm 0.0226.73 ±\pm 0.16
Σ\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ\bar{1}10]3.95 ±\pm 0.0225.33 ±\pm 0.19
Σ\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ\bar{1}10]4.91 ±\pm 0.0429.74 ±\pm 0.21

Table IV. Work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} for Ni grain boundaries with Ni atoms randomly replaced by Fe and Cr within the substitution regions shown in Figure 7, yielding a local composition of Ni56_{56}Fe20_{20}Cr24_{24}, inspired by the principal constituents of Alloy 718. Values are reported as mean ±\pm standard deviation over 100 configurations.

For both quantities, the ternary results lie between the corresponding binary Cr@GB and Fe@GB values at the same total substitution concentration, consistent with a balance between the individual effects of the two substitutes. However, this intermediate response is not necessarily captured by a linear interpolation of the binary results. For the Σ\Sigma5 (012) [100] and Σ\Sigma5 (013) [100] GBs, for example, the ternary σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} lies closer to the Fe@GB curve despite the comparable Fe and Cr fractions, suggesting a disproportionate influence of Fe on the maximum traction. The binary calculations therefore provide a useful basis for interpreting the ternary response, but explicit ternary calculations are needed to assess the combined solute effects quantitatively.

Taken together, the GB-dependent binary trends and the effects observed in the ternary model highlight the need to resolve both boundary structure and local alloy composition when assessing GB cohesion. A systematic investigation of these dependencies across many GBs, alloying elements, and configurations would be impractical with DFT alone at the scale considered here. It is precisely this limitation that underlines the value of the GRACE MLIP. Beyond identifying qualitative trends, its good quantitative agreement with DFT (see Sec. III C) enables the calculation of statistically well-founded values for WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max}. Accounting for Fe and Cr simultaneously, the ternary calculations extend the binary analysis to more realistic chemical environments and represent a first step toward multicomponent alloys. The resulting cohesive properties can be used, for example, to parameterize cohesive-zone models in FEM simulations [20], providing a route toward atomistically informed multiscale modeling of such alloys.

Summary

In this work, we investigated the influence of Cr and Fe alloying on the cohesive properties of Ni grain boundaries by combining DFT-based rigid-body separation calculations with a machine-learning interatomic potential based on the GRACE framework. DFT calculations across six symmetric-tilt GBs showed that substitution of Cr or Fe at the GB plane consistently increases both the work of separation and the maximum traction relative to pure Ni GBs. However, the magnitude of this effect varies substantially between GB structures, reflecting the distinct local geometric environments at each interface, and precludes a simple, transferable trend across GB types.

To extend this analysis beyond the size and configurational limitations of DFT, we compared 26 GRACE foundation models and identified one achieving good quantitative agreement with the DFT reference data for both WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max}. Using this MLIP, we performed large-scale RBS calculations for several thousand random alloying configurations at fine concentration resolution, a level of configurational sampling beyond what is feasible with DFT. This revealed distinct concentration-dependent trends for Cr and Fe, which arise from differences in their respective bonding contributions to GB cohesion. For a ternary Ni56_{56}Fe20_{20}Cr24_{24} composition, both WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} lie between the corresponding binary results, but the relative contributions of Fe and Cr vary with the GB structure. Thus, the binary results aid interpretation, while a quantitative description requires explicit multicomponent calculations.

These results demonstrate that DFT-validated MLIPs provide a practical and reliable route to capture configurational and chemical alloying effects at grain boundaries that would otherwise remain inaccessible due to the computational cost of first-principles methods. The statistically well-founded values for WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} obtained here, together with the general workflow presented, are readily transferable to other multicomponent alloy systems and provide a solid foundation for parameterizing continuum-scale cohesive-zone models of grain boundary fracture.

Acknowledgments

This work was funded by the German Research Foundation (DFG) under project number 526257118. Crystallographic drawings were created with the software VESTA [53].

References

Magnetic ground states of Cr@GB and Fe@GB

To test various magnetic configurations for the Cr@GB and Fe@GB structures, the Ni atoms were initialized in an FM configuration, and each GB atom (Cr or Fe) was assigned an initial magnetic moment of ±1\pm1 or ±5 μB\pm5\,\mu_{\mathrm{B}}, where the sign denotes the orientation relative to the Ni magnetic moments. When more than one Cr or Fe atom was present at the GB, all combinations of ±\pm orientations across these atoms were enumerated for each moment magnitude. In addition, a non-magnetic (NM) configuration was included for comparison.

Across all six GBs, the lowest-energy Fe@GB configurations found exhibit Fe moments aligned parallel to the Ni magnetization and, where applicable, to the other Fe moments. The local Fe moments range from approximately 2.5 to 3.0 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}}, and neighboring Ni moments remain essentially unperturbed (μNi≈0.58\mu_{\mathrm{Ni}} \approx0.58–0.66 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}}). For Cr@GB, the preferred local magnetic configuration depends on the GB structure. The Cr moments are essentially quenched in Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10], Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10], and Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10], with ∣μCr∣<0.2 μB|\mu_{\mathrm{Cr}}| < 0.2\,\mu_{\mathrm{B}}. For Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100] and Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10], the two Cr atoms carry oppositely oriented moments of unequal magnitude. For Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [100], the Cr moment is −2.60 μB-2.60\,\mu_{\mathrm{B}} and is antiparallel to the Ni magnetization. This Cr-induced quenching and frustration is also reflected in the neighboring Ni moments, which are locally suppressed to 0.13–0.30 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}} in the Cr@GB structures, in stark contrast to the Fe@GB cases. These results are qualitatively consistent with the preference for antiparallel Cr alignment and parallel Fe alignment reported for bulk Ni–Fe–Cr alloys using magnetic cluster expansion [54].

Grain boundaryCr moments (μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}})Fe moments (μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}})
Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]+0.04+2.53
Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]+0.17, −0.01+2.59, +2.74
Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [100]−2.60+2.97
Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100]−1.81, +2.56+2.75, +2.99
Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]−0.46, +0.74+2.64, +2.81
Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]−0.02+2.78

Table V. Local magnetic moments of the Cr and Fe substitute atoms in the lowest-energy configuration for each GB. The sign refers to the orientation of the moments with respect to the Ni atoms.

Comparison metrics for all GRACE models versus DFT data

Table VI reports the mean absolute error between the GRACE foundation models and the DFT data obtained from RBS calculations for the work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and the maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max}. Models are ordered by ascending combined mean relative error MRE (Eq. (5)), which is listed in the rightmost column and used to select the model for further calculations.

ModelBulk Ni MAE WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m²)Bulk Ni MAE σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)Ni GB MAE WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m²)Ni GB MAE σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)Cr@GB MAE WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m²)Cr@GB MAE σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)Fe@GB MAE WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m²)Fe@GB MAE σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)MRE (%)
GRACE-2L-OMAT-large-ft-AM0.020.080.020.400.070.710.060.321.17
GRACE-2L-OMAT-medium-ft-AM0.040.210.030.270.100.750.100.281.39
GRACE-1L-OMAT-large-ft-AM0.030.290.020.220.160.970.100.481.65
GRACE-1L-OMAT-medium-ft-AM0.070.340.050.220.111.020.090.391.71
GRACE-3L-OMAT-large-ft-AM0.040.120.050.740.121.030.060.411.79
GRACE-FS-OMAT0.110.920.040.450.170.610.060.472.08
GRACE-3L-OMAT-large0.020.140.040.870.171.490.050.662.18
GRACE-2L-SMAX-OMAT-medium0.080.150.040.670.101.440.090.712.19
GRACE-1L-SMAX-OMAT-large0.030.270.040.770.151.310.080.872.32
GRACE-1L-OMAT0.140.140.100.410.161.140.120.332.34
GRACE-2L-OMAT-large-ft-E0.040.490.040.840.141.740.060.692.44
GRACE-1L-OMAT-medium-ft-E0.160.350.140.430.071.370.080.422.44
GRACE-2L-SMAX-OMAT-large0.030.370.020.810.201.640.100.922.60
GRACE-1L-OMAT-large-base0.030.670.021.100.161.620.100.752.72
GRACE-2L-SMAX-medium0.190.620.130.170.131.040.130.682.73
GRACE-1L-OMAT-large-ft-E0.100.450.080.860.171.690.120.512.85
GRACE-2L-SMAX-large0.220.920.160.480.150.640.110.542.95
GRACE-1L-OAM0.060.310.070.710.231.360.220.873.02
GRACE-2L-OMAT-medium-ft-E0.060.670.091.110.161.570.110.873.07
GRACE-2L-OAM0.100.570.120.770.110.890.281.253.27
GRACE-1L-SMAX-large0.280.770.230.390.070.860.170.793.36
GRACE-2L-OMAT0.120.760.151.110.201.440.110.743.44
GRACE-1L-OMAT-medium-base0.061.000.071.300.201.270.161.053.45
GRACE-2L-OMAT-large-base0.080.800.111.250.221.710.120.943.54
GRACE-2L-OMAT-medium-base0.150.830.181.390.211.640.171.254.32
GRACE-FS-OAM0.342.210.230.670.192.730.221.835.96

Table VI. Mean absolute errors of the predicted work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} relative to the DFT reference values, grouped by structural category. The final column gives the overall combined mean relative error MRE (%). Models are ordered by ascending MRE.

Values obtained from the UBER fits to the MLIP RBS calculations

Table VII presents the mean values and standard deviations of WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} for the 100 configurations calculated per element and concentration.

GBConcentration (%)Cr@GB WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m²)Cr@GB σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)Fe@GB WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} (J/m²)Fe@GB σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} (GPa)
Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]10.03.99 ± 0.0730.02 ± 0.393.90 ± 0.0429.52 ± 0.20
Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]20.04.19 ± 0.0930.63 ± 0.533.95 ± 0.0429.28 ± 0.23
Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]30.04.39 ± 0.1131.23 ± 0.654.03 ± 0.0429.18 ± 0.21
Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]40.04.55 ± 0.1331.73 ± 0.794.09 ± 0.0429.01 ± 0.22
Σ3\Sigma3 (111) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]50.04.71 ± 0.1132.29 ± 0.664.16 ± 0.0428.90 ± 0.19
Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]10.04.19 ± 0.0128.32 ± 0.064.10 ± 0.0127.89 ± 0.05
Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]20.04.38 ± 0.0228.95 ± 0.114.16 ± 0.0127.92 ± 0.08
Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]30.04.58 ± 0.0229.67 ± 0.154.22 ± 0.0127.85 ± 0.10
Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]40.04.76 ± 0.0230.26 ± 0.174.27 ± 0.0127.82 ± 0.11
Σ3\Sigma3 (112) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]50.04.94 ± 0.0230.81 ± 0.234.30 ± 0.0127.68 ± 0.13
Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [100]10.04.10 ± 0.0126.23 ± 0.124.04 ± 0.0126.08 ± 0.05
Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [100]20.04.22 ± 0.0226.42 ± 0.164.08 ± 0.0125.93 ± 0.09
Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [100]30.04.34 ± 0.0326.60 ± 0.184.11 ± 0.0225.77 ± 0.13
Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [100]40.04.46 ± 0.0226.83 ± 0.184.14 ± 0.0225.58 ± 0.14
Σ5\Sigma5 (012) [100]50.04.59 ± 0.0227.11 ± 0.174.16 ± 0.0225.38 ± 0.13
Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100]10.04.26 ± 0.0127.14 ± 0.054.18 ± 0.0126.81 ± 0.07
Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100]20.04.39 ± 0.0127.43 ± 0.094.21 ± 0.0126.62 ± 0.11
Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100]30.04.53 ± 0.0127.75 ± 0.104.23 ± 0.0126.36 ± 0.11
Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100]40.04.66 ± 0.0128.05 ± 0.104.23 ± 0.0226.08 ± 0.16
Σ5\Sigma5 (013) [100]50.04.79 ± 0.0128.42 ± 0.114.23 ± 0.0225.72 ± 0.15
Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]10.03.69 ± 0.0125.31 ± 0.073.62 ± 0.0124.92 ± 0.06
Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]20.03.83 ± 0.0125.66 ± 0.123.65 ± 0.0124.70 ± 0.11
Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]30.03.97 ± 0.0126.04 ± 0.123.69 ± 0.0124.48 ± 0.12
Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]40.04.10 ± 0.0126.38 ± 0.133.70 ± 0.0124.18 ± 0.14
Σ9\Sigma9 (221) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]50.04.23 ± 0.0226.69 ± 0.133.71 ± 0.0123.87 ± 0.15
Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]10.04.57 ± 0.0229.43 ± 0.094.49 ± 0.0129.07 ± 0.06
Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]20.04.76 ± 0.0230.03 ± 0.144.55 ± 0.0229.05 ± 0.10
Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]30.04.95 ± 0.0430.65 ± 0.204.62 ± 0.0229.05 ± 0.11
Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]40.05.14 ± 0.0431.35 ± 0.254.67 ± 0.0229.00 ± 0.12
Σ11\Sigma11 (113) [1ˉ10\bar{1}10]50.05.34 ± 0.0432.06 ± 0.264.72 ± 0.0228.96 ± 0.12

Table VII. Work of separation WsepW_{\mathrm{sep}} and maximum traction σmax⁡\sigma_{\max} for each grain boundary, element and concentration (mean ± standard deviation over 100 configurations per concentration).

References

  1. [1]J. Liu, H.-Y. Yang, X.-M. Zhong, B.-X. Dong, Z.-Y. Li, J.-B. Chen, L. Liu, S.-L. Shu, F. Qiu, and Q.-C. Jiang, Journal of Materials Research and Technology 40, 2930 (2025).
  2. [2]J. Moverare, R. J. Lancaster, J. Jones, S. Stekovic, and M. T. Whittaker, Metall Mater Trans A 56, 1115 (2025).
  3. [3]G. Gudivada and A. K. Pandey, Journal of Alloys and Compounds 963, 171128 (2023).
  4. [4]B. Saleh, R. Fathi, and L. Zhao, Applied Materials Today 48, 103051 (2026).
  5. [5]Y. Kang, X. Leng, L. Zhao, B. Bai, X. Wang, and H. Chen, Crystals 13, 725 (2023).
  6. [6]R. Karimighighi and M. Naghizadeh, Materials and Corrosion 74, 1246 (2023).
  7. [7]A. N. Singh, S. K. Swain, A. Meena, M. Islam, and K.-W. Nam, Ceramics 7, 1928 (2024).
  8. [8]E. Hosseini and V. A. Popovich, Additive Manufacturing 30, 100877 (2019).
  9. [9]G. Dehm and J. Cairney, MRS Bulletin 47, 800 (2022).
  10. [10]A. R. Krause, P. R. Cantwell, C. J. Marvel, C. Comp­son, J. M. Rieckman, and M. P. Harmer, Journal of the American Ceramic Society 102, 778 (2019).
  11. [11]R. Janisch and C. Elsässer, Phys. Rev. B 67, 224101 (2003).
  12. [12]U. Krupp, International Materials Reviews 50, 83 (2005).
  13. [13]M. Liu, Z. Wang, Y. Zhao, Y. Chen, H. Lu, X. Wei, S. Liu, D. Pang, A. Li, L. Wang, and X. Han, npj Mater Degrad 9, 162 (2025).
  14. [14]H. Uruchida, Y. Tsukada, Y. Matsuoka, and T. Koyama, Sci Rep 14, 12996 (2024).
  15. [15]A. M. Tahir, R. Janisch, and A. Hartmaier, Materials Science and Engineering: A 612, 462 (2014).
  16. [16]H. L. Mai, X.-Y. Cui, T. Hickel, J. Neugebauer, and S. P. Ringer, Acta Materialia 297, 121288 (2025).
  17. [17]J. H. Rose, J. Ferrante, and J. R. Smith, Phys. Rev. Lett. 47, 675 (1981).
  18. [18]A. Banerjea and J. R. Smith, Phys. Rev. B 37, 6632 (1988).
  19. [19]R. Janisch, N. Ahmed, and A. Hartmaier, Phys. Rev. B 81, 184108 (2010).
  20. [20]J. J. Möller, E. Bitzek, R. Janisch, H. Ul Hassan, and A. Hartmaier, J. Mater. Res. 33, 3750 (2018).
  21. [21]A. M. Tahir, R. Janisch, and A. Hartmaier, Modelling Simul. Mater. Sci. Eng. 21, 075005 (2013).
  22. [22]V. I. Razumovskiy, A. Y. Lozovoi, and I. M. Razumovskii, Acta Materialia 82, 369 (2015).
  23. [23]R. Janisch and C. Elsässer, International Journal of Materials Research 100, 1488 (2009).
  24. [24]A. Boch karev, Y. Lysogorskiy, and R. Drautz, Phys. Rev. X 14, 021036 (2024).
  25. [25]L. Barros-Luque, M. Shuaibi, X. Fu, B. M. Wood, M. Dzamba, M. Gao, A. Rizvi, M. Uyttendaele, C. L. Zitnick, and Z. W. Ulissi, Nat Comput Sci 6, 642 (2026).
  26. [26]T. Cavignac, J. Schmidt, P.-P. De Breuck, A. Loew, T. F. T. Cerqueira, H.-C. Wang, A. Bochkarev, Y. Lyso­gorskiy, A. H. Romero, R. Drautz, S. Botti, and M. A. L. Marques, J. Phys. Mater. 9, 025014 (2026).
  27. [27]Y. Lysogorskiy, A. Bochkarev, and R. Drautz, npj Comput Mater 12, 114 (2026).
  28. [28]F. Birch, Phys. Rev. 71, 809 (1947).
  29. [29]F. D. Murnaghan, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America 30, 244 (1944).
  30. [33]P. Hirel, Computer Physics Communications 197, 212 (2015).
  31. [34]H. Zheng, X.-G. Li, R. Tran, C. Chen, M. Horton, D. Winston, K. A. Persson, and S. P. Ong, Acta Materialia 186, 40 (2020).
  32. [35]G. Kresse and J. Furthmüller, Phys. Rev. B 54, 11169 (1996).
  33. [36]P. E. Blöchl, Phys. Rev. B 50, 17953 (1994).
  34. [37]G. Kresse and D. Joubert, Phys. Rev. B 59, 1758 (1999).
  35. [38]H. J. Monkhorst and J. Pack, Physical Review B 13, 5188 (1976).
  36. [39]C. Elsässer, M. Fähnle, C. T. Chan, and K.-M. Ho, Physical Review B 49, 13975 (1994).
  37. [40]A. P. Thompson, H. M. Aktulga, R. Berger, D. S. Bolintineanu, W. M. Brown, P. S. Crozier, P. J. in ’t Veld, A. Kohlmeyer, S. G. Moore, T. D. Nguyen, R. Shan, M. J. Stevens, J. Tranchida, C. Trott, and S. J. Plimpton, Computer Physics Communications 271, 108171 (2022).
  38. [41]J. J. Bean and K. P. McKenna, Acta Materialia 110, 246 (2016).
  39. [42]P. Šesták, M. Černý, Z. Zhang, and J. Pokluda, Crystals 10, 590 (2020).
  40. [43]M. Mazalová, M. Všianská, J. Pavlů, and M. Šob, Nanomaterials 10, 691 (2020).
  41. [44]D. Wolf and S. Yip, Materials Interfaces (Chapman and Hall, London, 1992).
  42. [45]A. P. Sutton and R. W. Balluffi, Interfaces in Crystalline Materials, Oxford Classic Texts in the Physical Sciences (Oxford University Press, Oxford, New York, 2006).
  43. [46]M. Černý, P. Šesták, P. Řehák, M. Všianská, and M. Šob, Materials Science and Engineering: A 669, 218 (2016).
  44. [47]J. Chen and A. M. Dongare, J Mater Sci 52, 30 (2017).
  45. [48]K. Pearson, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. 58, 240 (1895).
  46. [49]J. S. Wróbel, D. Nguyen-Manh, M. Y. Lavrentiev, M. Muzyk, and S. L. Dudarev, Phys. Rev. B 91, 024108 (2015).
  47. [50]A. Jain, S. P. Ong, G. Hautier, W. Chen, W. D. Richards, S. Dacek, S. Cholia, D. Gunter, D. Skinner, G. Ceder, and K. A. Persson, APL Mater. 1, 011002 (2013).
  48. [51]K. Ito, T. Yokoi, K. Hyodo, and H. Mori, npj Comput Mater 10, 255 (2024).
  49. [52]Y. Zhao, Q. Song, H. Ji, W. Cai, Z. Liu, and Y. Cai, Materials & Design 221, 110998 (2022).
  50. [53]K. Momma and F. Izumi, J Appl Cryst 44, 1272 (2011).
  51. [54]T. Su, B. J. Blankenau, N. Kim, J. A. Krogstad, and E. Ertekin, Acta Materialia 276, 120088 (2024).

Paper details

vlnc:W_7724mpwf
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 5

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents