betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Unraveling effects of electron correlation in two-dimensional Fen_{n}GeTe2_{2} (n=3, 4, 5) by dynamical mean field theory

Abstract

The Fen_{n}GeTe2_{2} systems are newly discovered two-dimensional van-der-Waals materials, exhibiting magnetism at room temperature. The sub-systems belonging to Fen_{n}GeTe2_{2} class are special because they show site-dependent magnetic behavior. We focus on the critical evaluation of magnetic properties and electron correlation effects in Fen_{n}GeTe2_{2} (nn= 3, 4, 5) (FGT) systems performing first-principles calculations. Three different ab-initio approaches have been used, viz., i) standard density functional theory (DFT), ii) incorporating static electron correlation (DFT+U) and iii) inclusion of dynamic electron correlation effect (DFT+DMFT). Our results show that DFT+DMFT is the most accurate technique to correctly reproduce the magnetic interactions and experimentally observed transition temperatures. The inaccurate values of structural parameters, magnetic moments and exchange interactions obtained from DFT+U make this method inapplicable for the FGT family. Correct determination of magnetic properties for this class of materials is important since they are promising candidates for spin transport and spintronic applications at room temperature.

Introduction

Magnetism and spintronics have been the topic of interest for fundamental studies as well as technological applications. Two-dimensional (2D) van der Waals (vdW) materials have recently developed increasing attention, as they show a new direction to explore magnetism in low-dimension. Since the discovery of graphene [1], the world of two-dimensional (2D) materials is rapidly expanding to an enormous variety of systems due to their interesting properties. The discovery of intrinsic long-range magnetic order is one of the most exciting recent developments in 2D materials [2, 3]. The newly discovered 2D van-der-Waals (vdW) materials offer a new means to study magnetism in low-dimension, where spin fluctuations are expected to be strongly enhanced at finite temperature destroying long-range magnetic order according to Mermin-Wagner theorem [4]. Magnetic anisotropy reduces spin fluctuations and results in finite Curie temperature below which a magnetic order in 2D can survive and thereby lifting the restrictions imposed by Mermin-Wagner theorem [5, 6]. Magnetism in 2D has started a new era in the field of energy-efficient device fabrication due to its tunability under small or moderate-scale external perturbations [7].

The 2D magnets play a crucial role in the development of efficient spintronic devices [8] not only by size reduction but also by introducing novel physics stemming from 2D confinement. Prior to 2016, doping by magnetic impurities was the main strategy to induce magnetism in 2D materials, which has failed to materialize 2D magnets with high Curie temperature [9]. The exfoliation of 2D insulating ferromagnet CrI3\mathrm{CrI}_{3} [10] and Cr2Ge2Te6\mathrm{Cr}_{2}\mathrm{Ge}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{6} [11], in 2016, opened the doors to the application of 2D magnets in semiconducting devices.

However, the relatively low transition temperature (TC≈60KT_{\mathrm{C}} \approx60\mathrm{K}) intrinsic to the 2D magnetic insulators and/or semiconductors limits their utilization. On the other hand, metals exhibiting 2D magnetism are more promising for practical applications due to their high transition temperature. The most significant advantage of the metallic ferromagnets is that their conducting nature enables an interplay between spin and charge degrees of freedom, which lies at the heart of spintronics [12, 13, 14]. There are recent studies on ferromagnetic metals, such as CrTex\mathrm{CrTe}_{x}, Cr2BC\mathrm{Cr}_{2}\mathrm{BC}, FeSe2\mathrm{FeSe}_{2}, FeTe\mathrm{FeTe}, MnSe\mathrm{MnSe}, and FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{n}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2}, reporting high TCT_{\mathrm{C}} (130–846K) [15, 16, 17, 18, 19]. The newly discovered 2D metallic Fe–Ge–Te ternary compounds or popularly known as ‘FGT’ systems exhibit TCT_{\mathrm{C}} close to room temperature and gain tremendous attention due to their interesting magnetic properties.

Each member belonging to the FGT family exhibits a plethora of interesting physical properties, and among them, Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{5}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2} is the most complicated system. Recent experimental studies have found anomalous magnetic behavior in bulk Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{5}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2} at temperature <100< 100 K, which is speculated as a result of magnetostructural effects [20, 21, 22]. Recently, Liu et al., using the DFT+U approach, proposed that a competition between ferromagnetic (FM) and antiferromagnetic (AFM) coupling can give rise to a transition below 200 K in Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{5}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2}, and they show the net magnetization reduces with a decrease in temperature similar to the experimental reports. However, they failed to capture the traces of this transition in Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{4}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2} [23]. Though the study by Liu et al. can reproduce the magnetization vs. temperature behavior of Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{5}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2}, as observed in experiments, the moments of Fe atoms reported in their study are hugely overestimated (by ∼1 μB\sim1\ \mu_{\mathrm{B}}). This suggests that the DFT+U technique cannot correctly predict the magnetic moments of Fe sublattices present in FGT systems. Similarly, other first principles studies also revealed that DFT+U is not a good approximation for the FGT systems to produce the correct lattice parameters and magnetic moments [24, 25].

Electrons occupying the ss and pp orbitals are strongly itinerant and their kinetic energies are dominant over the Coulomb repulsion. Therefore, a static mean field approximation (like DFT) should be suitable enough to study these weakly correlated electrons. On the other hand, due to significant Coulomb interactions between electrons in the dd and ff orbitals, strongly correlated electrons become localized on their atomic sites. In this regime, DFT is no longer a proper approach and can yield inaccurate results. The possible solutions are DFT+U in the static mean field approximation, mostly applicable for Mott insulators and dynamical mean field theory with frequency-dependent self-energy for strongly correlated metals. The presence of itinerant electrons is the cause of spontaneous magnetism in 2D metals, which can be explained by the Stoner model [26]. However, in the case of metallic FGT systems, some studies show the evidence of non-Stoner magnetism where the local moments may play crucial role in the electronic and magnetic properties [27, 28]. These results hint towards the possibility that the FGT systems could be an admixture of localized and itinerant electrons, exhibiting moderate electron correlation. Hence, the use of DMFT will be more justified.

The main peculiarity related to all the FGT systems is their site-dependent magnetic and electronic properties [21]. In other words, based on the magnetic moments associated with different Fe sublattices, electrons belonging to some Fe atoms are expected to have more itinerant character than others. All these complications combined together have made the proper treatment of electronic structure and magnetic behavior in FGT systems a controversial issue. Up to this date, researchers have used DFT [24, 25, 29], DFT+U [23] or DMFT [30, 31] approaches, leaving behind the most crucial question unanswered i.e. which method is the most reliable one to correctly treat the FGT systems. In this paper, we perform a systematic study, comparing different aspects of electronic and magnetic properties of Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2}, Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{4}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2}, and Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{5}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2}, mostly in their 2D form (except Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2}), via DFT, DFT+U, and DFT+DMFT approaches. We put forward a detailed comparative study to analyse the outcomes of these different computational techniques and their compatibility with experimental results. Since atomically thin films or monolayers of FGT systems are not experimentally studied yet, we considered the well-studied bulk Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{GeTe}_{2} as our reference to examine the accuracy of our calculations, and bridge between 3D and 2D regimes.

Results and Discussion

Systems

Here we focus on the Fen_nGeTe2_2 monolayers, where n=3,4n = 3, 4 and 55, to investigate the magnetic properties of FGT systems using different first-principles techniques, e.g., standard density functional theory (DFT), DFT with the inclusion of dynamic and static electron correlation effects.

In this section, we discuss the structural properties of the monolayers. In the case of Fe5_5GeTe2_2, we study both without and with the Fe1-Ge split sites, see Ref 32 for details. Figure 1 shows the side view of the Fen_nGeTe2_2 monolayers, (a) n=3n = 3, (b) n=4n = 4, (c) n=5n = 5 in UUU and (d) UDU configurations, we label each Fe atom present in the unit cell of Fen_nGeTe2_2 monolayers. The space-groups (and in-plane lattice parameters) for Fe3_3GeTe2_2, Fe4_4GeTe2_2, Fe5_5GeTe2_2 UUU and UDU monolayers are P6ˉ\bar{6}m2 (a=4.05a=4.05 Å), P3ˉ\bar{3}m1 (a=3.97a= 3.97 Å), P3m1 (a=3.99a= 3.99 Å) and P31m (a=7.00a=7.00Å), respectively. From the type of space-groups possessed by Fen_nGeTe2_2 monolayers, it is clear that Fe5_5GeTe2_2 possesses lower symmetry operations, and hence less symmetric compared to n=3n =3 and 4.

Schematic side views of Fe₃GeTe₂, Fe₄GeTe₂, UUU Fe₅GeTe₂, and UDU Fe₅GeTe₂ monolayers

Figure 1. The schematic side views of (a) Fe3_3GeTe2_2, (b) Fe4_4GeTe2_2, (c) UUU Fe5_5GeTe2_2, and (d) UDU Fe5_5GeTe2_2 monolayers, where orange, yellow, and blue circles represent Fe, Te, and Ge atoms, respectively. Direction of the arrows shown inside Fe atoms, indicates the easy axis of magnetization obtained from our DFT+DMFT calculations. The half-colored circles in Figure 1(d) show the Fe1-Ge split sites present in the UDU configuration. The green arrow drawn in each system shows the pair of Fe atoms exhibiting the strongest isotropic symmetric exchange interaction between each other.

Each Fen_nGeTe2_2 system contains different Fe sublattices based on their structural arrangements. This sublattice classification is reflected on the electronic and magnetic properties [32, 33]. In the case of Fe3_3GeTe2_2, Fe1 and Fe2 sublattices are equivalent, while Fe3 is different. Similarly, for Fe4_4GeTe2_2, Fe1 and Fe4 species belong to the same category, whereas Fe2 and Fe3 are similar.

The structural configuration for Fe5_5GeTe2_2 is more complex. Based on the previous experimental and theoretical studies, the Fe1 species can occupy two possible sites either above or below Ge, giving rise to Fe1-Ge split-sites [20, 21, 32]. Also, depending on the thermal history during the synthesis process, this system may show the absence of Fe1-Ge splitting [21, 34]. To incorporate the Fe1-Ge splitting, a 3×3\sqrt{3} \times\sqrt{3} cell of Fe5_5GeTe2_2 monolayer is constructed, where two (one) Fe1 are (is) situated above (below) Ge, this structure is referred to as ‘UDU’ configuration. In the absence of Fe1-Ge splitting, the Fe1 species is placed at top of the Ge atom, this structure is named as ‘UUU’ configuration. From our previous first-principles study, we found that the UDU configuration is energetically favored over the UUU configuration [32], resulting in the 3×3\sqrt{3} \times\sqrt{3} superstructure, as already discussed by previous experimental studies [20, 21, 22, 32, 34]. Hence, in the following sections, we mainly focus on the UDU configuration of Fe5_5GeTe2_2 monolayer. All the five Fe atoms present in the unit cell of UUU configuration are different, hence this configuration is the least symmetric. In the case of UDU, we find the Fe atoms can be roughly (not strictly) categorized into four sublattices in UDU configuration: i) Fe2, Fe5, ii) Fe3, Fe4, iii) Fe1U and iv) Fe1D. The sublattice classification in Fen_nGeTe2_2 systems has a direct consequence on the exchange interactions present in these systems and also the magnetization vs. temperature behavior as reported in Ref. 32. The black arrows drawn in Figure 1(a)-(Figure 1d) show the direction of the easy axis of magnetization for different Fen_nGeTe2_2 monolayers obtained from our DMFT studies, which we discuss in § 2.3.

From Figure 1, one can see that the chemical environment, coordination number and relative position of each Fe atom w.r.t. the other Fe and Ge atoms present in the Fen_nGeTe2_2 monolayers change with nn. For example, in the case of Fe3_3GeTe2_2, the Fe1 and Fe2 atoms are situated symmetrically relative to the Ge atom with Fe1(Fe2)-Ge distance of 2.65 Å. While the Fe3 species is placed in the same zz plane as Ge with a distance 2.34 Å along the xyxy-plane. The first nearest neighbor (NN) Fe1-Fe2 and Fe1-Fe3 distances are 2.47 and 2.65 Å, respectively. Due to this small first NN distance between Fe1 and Fe2, the strongest isotropic symmetric exchange interaction exists between the first NN of these two species, shown by the green arrow in Figure 1(a). The scenario is quite different for Fe4_4GeTe2_2, where the Ge atom is placed between Fe2 and Fe3 (shifted along the diagonal direction). The first NN Fe1-Fe2 (Fe4-Fe3) and Fe1-Fe3 (Fe4-Fe2) distances are 2.55 Å and 2.49 Å, respectively. The first NN Fe2-Ge (or Fe3-Ge) and Fe1-Ge (or Fe4-Ge) distances are 2.40 Å and 2.92 Å, respectively. Although the shortest first NN distance exists between Fe1 and Fe3 (Fe4 and Fe2), the highest isotropic symmetric exchange interaction takes place between Fe1 and Fe2, instead of between Fe1 and Fe3. The position of Ge atom relative to the Fe atoms is responsible for such an unexpected feature. In the case of Fe5_5GeTe2_2 monolayer in both UUU and UDU configurations, the most significant symmetric exchange interactions take place between the first NN Fe5 and Fe4. The exchange interactions present in different FGT monolayers are discussed in more detail in section 2.4.1.

Effective Hubbard parameters

As already mentioned in § 2.1, the FGT systems possess site-dependent electronic and magnetic properties. In our previous first-principles study on Fe5_5GeTe2_2 monolayer, we have found that though the structural properties and magnetic moments obtained using the standard DFT technique are in good agreement with the experimental reports, the calculated Curie temperature (using Monte Carlo simulations solving the Spin-Hamiltonian) is almost twice of the experimental value reported for this system [32]. This hints toward the fact that one needs to go beyond the standard DFT formalism to correctly capture the magnetic interactions. One possibility to solve such discrepancy in Curie temperature is to include the electron correlation effect in first-principles calculations which might be able to reproduce the experimental results. Here, we consider both the dynamic and static electron correlation effects and finally compare the results obtained using DFT, DFT+DMFT and DFT+U techniques.

As the choice of Hubbard UU parameter is always ambiguous to some extent, we have calculated the effective Hubbard UU parameter (UeffU_{\mathrm{eff}}) for each Fe species in its magnetic ground state (as obtained from standard DFT) using the constrained linear response (cLR) method proposed by Cococcioni et al [35]. This method is focused on the main effect associated with the on-site Coulomb repulsion UU, neglecting the secondary effects related to the higher-multipolar terms in the Coulomb interaction. The effects of Hund’s exchange interaction (JHJ_{\mathrm{H}}) are incorporated by redefining the Hubbard UU as Ueff=U−JHU_{\mathrm{eff}} = U-J_{\mathrm{H}} (see § 4.5 for further details). The site-dependent UeffU_{\mathrm{eff}} values obtained using cLR for each Fe species belonging to different FGT monolayers are reported in Table 1.

SystemAtomUeffU_{\mathrm{eff}} (eV)
Fe3_3GeTe2_2Fe14.8
Fe3_3GeTe2_2Fe24.8
Fe3_3GeTe2_2Fe33.9
Fe4_4GeTe2_2Fe14.5
Fe4_4GeTe2_2Fe24.0
Fe4_4GeTe2_2Fe34.0
Fe4_4GeTe2_2Fe44.5
Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (UDU)Fe1U3.7
Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (UDU)Fe1D4.0
Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (UDU)Fe24.6
Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (UDU)Fe34.1
Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (UDU)Fe44. 1
Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (UDU)Fe54.6

Table 1. Effective Hubbard UU parameter for Fe atoms in Fen_nGeTe2_2 systems obtained from constrained linear response technique.

There are previous reports in literature where the Fen_nGeTe2_2 systems are studied considering (mostly) the static electron correlation effect, where the site-dependence of Hubbard UU is not considered [31, 36], except by Zhu et al. , where U=5.5U=5.5 eV and 5.0 eV with the common JH=0.8J_{\mathrm{H}}=0.8 eV are considered for two different Fe sublattices present in Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} [30]. To the best of our knowledge, apart from our work, so far, there is no other first-principles study reporting site-dependent UU value computed from either constrained linear response or any other standard computational technique (e.g., constrained random phase approximation or cRPA) generally followed for such calculations. It should be noted that the average value of UeffU_{\mathrm{eff}} considered by the previous authors to study any FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{n}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} system falls in the range from 4 to 4.5 eV [30, 31, 36], which is close to our calculated UeffavgU_{\mathrm{eff}}^{\mathrm{avg}} values for the FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{n}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} monolayers. Nevertheless, it is worth mentioning that Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{5}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} shows a much larger variation of site-dependent UU values.

It is known that the size of the magnetic moment is inversely proportional to the width of the electronic density of states. The width of electronic density of states of FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{n}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} system is ∼8\sim8 eV (see Figs. S1 and S2 in SI), and with Ueff∼4U_{\mathrm{eff}}\sim4 eV, U/W∼0.5U/W\sim0.5. Therefore, due to the existence of broad enough Fe-dd bands, the Fe-dd electrons are quite delocalized and the applicability of Hubbard UU correction within the DFT+U formalism is questionable.

In FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{n}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} systems, the Fe sublattices can be classified into different categories based on their magnetic properties. For example, Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} contains two types of Fe sublattices with different magnetic moments [30, 37, 38], e.g., 2.18 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}} and 1.80 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}} based on the data obtained from neutron powder diffraction experiments [37]. From our DFT calculations, we find the moment of two Fe sublattices present in Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} to be 2.49 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}} and 1.50 μB\mu_{\mathrm{B}}. This implies that the electronic nature or localization of Fe-dd states must be different for these two sublattices (see Fig. S1 in SI). Using the cLR method we find the Fe species with larger moment has Ueff=4.8U_{\mathrm{eff}}=4.8 eV, while for the other Fe sublattice Ueff=3.9U_{\mathrm{eff}}=3.9 eV, supporting the relationship between the degree of localization of electronic state and magnetic moment. Similarly, Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{4}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} and Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{5}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} systems also exhibit site dependent magnetic properties [21, 31], and this feature is reflected in our calculated UeffU_{\mathrm{eff}}, see Table 1.

Role of electron correlation effect: comparison between DMFT, DFT and DFT+U approaches

Within the framework of standard density functional theory, the exchange-correlation functionals (LDA and GGA) are derived in the limit of a nearly uniform electron density, which can not correctly describe the electronic and magnetic properties of localized electronic states with strong Coulomb interactions. In some systems, the on-site Coulomb interaction (UU) is quite significant and becomes much larger than the band width (WW). When U/W≪1U/W\ll1 the system is weakly correlated and well described by LDA/GGA. In the case of strongly correlated regime U/W≫1U/W\gg1, which gives atomic-like behavior (e.g., Hubbard bands, Mott insulators). The most interesting case is when U/W∼1U/W \sim1, which is a mixture of both band-like and atomic-like behavior, this can give rise to exotic phenomena like Kondo behavior, materials with heavy fermions etc.

DFT+U deals with on-site Coulomb interaction which is applicable only in the limit of U/W≫1U/W \gg1. While the dynamical mean field or DMFT covers the entire range of the parameter U/WU/W, i.e., from uncorrelated metal to Mott insulator. Since the Fen_nGeTe2_2 systems are metallic in nature, inclusion of static electron correlation or DFT+U is not supposed to be a good choice. To check the applicability of DMFT vs. DFT+U we calculate and compare the magnetic moments, exchange interactions, magnetic anisotropies and finally the Curie temperatures.

The concept of dynamical mean-field theory is to replace a lattice model with many degrees of freedom by an effective single-site model coupled to a self-consistent bath [42]. The primary quantity of DMFT is the local Green’s function GR(z)G_R(z), defined as the one-electron Green’s function projected to the correlated states at site RR:

GR(z)=PRG(z)PRG_R(z) = P_R G(z) P_R, where PRP_R is the projection operator. G(z)G(z) is the one-electron Green’s function, which is given by:

G(z)=[z+μ−Heff−Σ(z)]−1(1)G(z) = [z + \mu- H_{\mathrm{eff}} - \Sigma(z)]^{-1} \tag*{(1)}

where μ\mu is the chemical potential, the term HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} is the effective Hamiltonian which includes the Hartree, exchange and correlation terms on the level of the generalized-gradient approximation (GGA). Σ(z)\Sigma(z) is the self-energy, which goes beyond GGA and includes dynamical electronic correlations and z=iωnz = i\omega_n where ωn\omega_n is the Matsubara frequency. The approximation of DMFT assumes the locality of one-electron self-energy, which can be written as the sum of local self-energies for all Bravais lattice sites. In DMFT, the problem of a lattice is substituted by the impurity problem, popularly known as the effective Anderson model, where a single correlated site in the self-consistent bath is described by the bath Green’s function G0(R,z)\mathcal{G}_0(R,z) defined as:

G0−1(R,z)=GR−1(z)+ΣR(z)(2)\mathcal{G}_0^{-1}(R,z)=G_R^{-1}(z)+\Sigma_R(z) \tag*{(2)}

Here, we perform fully charge self-consistent DFT combined with DMFT [42] by spin-polarized T-matrix combined with fluctuating exchange approximation or SPTF solver [43], which is a perturbative solver, best suited for weak correlations, computationally less expensive, applicable for spin-polarized case treating crystal field and spin–orbit effects correctly, and gives accurate DOS and spectral densities [44]. We use site-dependent Hubbard UeffU_{\rm eff} parameter for DMFT and DFT+U calculations obtained from the constrained linear response method, as reported in Table 1.

In principle, DMFT is based on a mapping of lattice models onto quantum impurity models and for correlated electrons, this mapping is exact in the limit of infinite dimensions [45]. However, in recent days, DMFT has been proven to be a reliable and well-controlled approximation to study correlation effects in bulk solids as well as for two-dimensional systems [46]. Recent studies on 2D or layered materials reported that DFT+DMFT technique describes the electronic and magnetic properties more accurately than DFT+U or standard DFT [47, 48, 49].

First, we focus on the magnetic moments calculated using DMFT, DFT and DFT+U techniques. Table 2 reports the magnetic moment of each Fe sublattice for Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2, Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_4\mathrm{GeTe}_2 and Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 (UDU configuration) monolayers (moments of Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 in UUU configuration are reported in Table S1 in SI). As mentioned in section 2.1, the influence of structural symmetry on the electronic/magnetic properties of FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_n\mathrm{GeTe}_2 systems is reflected in the magnetic moments reported in Table 2. We find the values of magnetic moment obtained using DMFT and DFT are quite similar, except for the Fe1U sublattice for Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 in UDU configuration. It is known from previous studies that this species exhibits fluctuating moment and is mainly responsible for magnetic anomaly observed in Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 at low temperature [20, 21, 32, 34]. The magnetic moments of the UUU configuration are reported in Table S2 in Supplementary Information (SI). More interestingly, both the DFT+DMFT and DFT moments are close in magnitude to the moments obtained from neutron powder diffraction experiments, as we see in Table 2. There is a small discrepancy between the experimental and DMFT/DFT results which arises because the DMFT or DFT moments are calculated at 0K whereas the neutron powder diffraction experiments are performed at finite temperatures (∼2−5\sim2 - 5 K) [21, 37, 38].

SystemspeciesDMFT (μB\mu_B)DFT (μB\mu_B)DFT+U (μB\mu_B)Expt. (μB\mu_B)
Fe3_3GeTe2_2Fe12.522.493.192.18 [37], 1.95 [38]
Fe22.522.493.192.18 [37], 1.95 [38]
Fe31.311.502.501.54 [37], 1.56 [38]
average2.122.162.961.60 [39], 1.70 [30]
Fe4_4GeTe2_2Fe12.612.573.33
Fe21.581.752.62
Fe31.581.752.62
Fe42.612.573.33
average2.102.162.981.80 [31]
Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (UDU)Fe1U-0.451.2302.77ranges from
Fe1D1.761.7133.000.8 to 2.5 [21]
Fe22.552.5112.97
Fe31.922.0842.85
Fe41.851.9792.64
Fe52.632.5672.97
average1.852.112.851.95 [40], 1.80 [41]

Table 2. Magnetic moments associated with each Fe atom in Fen_nGeTe2_2 monolayer (computed with different techniques).

In the case of DFT+U, a large deviation between the computed and experimental moments is observed. Moreover, the lattice parameters of FGT monolayers get hugely deviated from the experimental measurements. Previous DFT+U studies on FGT systems also report significant discrepancy in structural and electronic properties of FGT systems compared to experimental results [23, 24, 25, 36, 50]. Note, in the DFT+U calculations we use the fully-localized limit as the double counting (DC) correction to study the electronic and magnetic properties. We perform further calculations using the around mean field (AMF) as the DC correction using exactly the same site-dependent UeffU_{\mathrm{eff}} values. In that case also we find that the magnetic moments have hugely deviated from the experimental moments. This implies that DFT+U fails to reproduce the correct ground state properties of FGT systems.

Value of the highest $J_{ij}$ interaction, magnetic anisotropy energy, and Curie temperature for Fe$_{n}$GeTe$_2$ monolayers

Figure 2. (a)–(d) Value of the highest JijJ_{ij} interaction for (a) Fe3_3GeTe2_2, Fe4_4GeTe2_2 and Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (in both UUU and UDU configurations) monolayers obtained using DMFT, DFT and DFT+U. (e)–(h) Magnetic anisotropy energy (MAE=E⊥−E∥E_{\perp}-E_{\parallel}) Fe3_3GeTe2_2, Fe4_4GeTe2_2 and Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (in both UUU and UDU configurations) monolayers obtained using DMFT, DFT and DFT+U. (i)–(l) Curie temperature TCT_{\mathrm{C}} for Fe3_3GeTe2_2, Fe4_4GeTe2_2 and Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (in both UUU and UDU configurations) monolayers obtained using DMFT, DFT and DFT+U.

Fen_nGeTe2_2 systems are metallic with conducting electrons and therefore, to correctly describe the electronic properties and magnetic behavior of such metallic systems inclusion of DFT+U, i.e., consideration of on-site Coulomb repulsion is not the proper approach [24]. Instead, the dynamical electron correlation effect or DMFT may be a better choice to capture the correct electronic structure and magnetic behavior, which can properly describe the site-dependent magnetic behavior present in these systems [20, 30, 31]. There are recent studies on Fe3_3GeTe2_2 which have mentioned the existence of heavy Fermion states due to intriguing interplay between localized magnetic moments and itinerant electrons [51, 52]. Also, Zhang et al. have proposed the existence of itinerant ferromagnetism in Fe5_5GeTe2_2. [20] These reports hint toward the fact that the electronic nature of Fe-3d states is sublattice specific. Such findings and prediction have motivated us to consider the electron correlation effect in FGT systems incorporating site-dependent UeffU_{eff}. There are a few first-principles reports on FGT systems where the dynamical electron correlation effect is considered [30, 31], but those studies do not explain why DMFT should be considered as a better technique compared to other first-principles methods, for the correct description of FGT systems. In our study, we show the importance of the dynamic electron correlation effect for the FGT systems by calculating the exchange interactions, magnetic anisotropy and more importantly the Curie temperature of these systems.

Monte Carlo simulations are performed to calculate TCT_{\mathrm{C}} using the following spin Hamiltonian:

H=−∑i≠jJije⃗i⋅e⃗j−∑i≠jD⃗ij⋅(e⃗i×e⃗j)−∑i≠jKi(eiz)2,(3)H=-\sum_{i\ne j}J_{ij}\vec{e}_{i}\cdot\vec{e}_{j}-\sum_{i\ne j}\vec{D}_{ij}\cdot(\vec{e}_{i}\times\vec{e}_{j})-\sum_{i\ne j}K_{i}(e_{i}^{z})^{2}, \tag*{(3)}

where JijJ_{ij} and D⃗ij\vec{D}_{ij} are the symmetric and antisymmetric exchange interactions, respectively between the iith and jjth sites. According to eq. 3, positive (negative) sign of JijJ_{ij} implies ferromagnetic (antiferromagnetic) interaction. KiK_i is the single-ion anisotropy for the iith site. We first check how the JijJ_{ij} and KiK_i values obtained using DFT, DMFT and DFT+U are different from each other to influence the value of TCT_{\mathrm{C}}. Here we neglect the term DijD_{ij} since we find that the magnitude of Dzyaloshinkii-Moriya interaction (DMI) are quite small compared to the JijJ_{ij} and MAE values, therefore the DMI is expected to have negligible influence on TCT_{\mathrm{C}}.

In Fig. 2.3 the histogram plots show (a)-(d) the strongest isotropic symmetric exchange interaction (JijJ_{ij}), (e)-(h) magnetic anisotropy energy (MAE) and (i)-(l) Curie temperature (TCT_{\mathrm{C}}) for Fen_nGeTe2_2 (n=3,4,5n=3,4,5) systems obtained using DMFT, DFT and DFT+U techniques. From Figs. 2.3(a)-(d) we see that the sign of the highest JijJ_{ij} interactions computed using these different methods remain unaltered but their magnitudes differ significantly. In the case of Fe3_3GeTe2_2 and Fe5_5GeTe2_2, we find the value of the strongest JijJ_{ij} interaction obtained using DMFT is almost half of the DFT value, while this difference is even more (DMFT ∼4 times smaller than DFT) for Fe4_4GeTe2_2. The strongest JijJ_{ij} value using DFT+U for n=3n=3, 4, and 5 is overestimated by 6%, 71%, 43% (UUU) and 26% (UDU), respectively, w.r.t. the standard DFT results for the corresponding systems.

Magnetic anisotropy energy MAE=E⊥−E∥E_{\perp}-E_{\parallel} calculated using different computational techniques are plotted in Figs. 2.3(e)-(h), positive (negative) sign indicates in-plane (out-of-plane) easy axis. The standard DFT results show that the easy axis of magnetization is strongly along the out-of-plane and in-plane directions for Fe3_3GeTe2_2 and Fe5_5GeTe2_2 monolayers, respectively, while for Fe5_5GeTe2_2 monolayer, MAE is weakly out-of-plane (in-plane) for the UDU (UUU) configuration. The DFT MAE results for Fe3_3GeTe2_2, Fe4_4GeTe2_2 and Fe5_5GeTe2_2 (UUU configuration) monolayers are in excellent agreement with previous DFT results [32, 32, 33, 53].

Next we investigate how the DFT computed MAE results get modified by the inclusion of dynamical electronic correlations. The direction of easy axis obtained using DMFT and DFT remains same for any FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_n\mathrm{GeTe}_2 monolayer, except for Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 in UDU configuration. The DFT result shows weak out-of-plane anisotropy while DMFT produces small in-plane anisotropy value. The DMFT (DFT) computed MAE for Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2, Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_4\mathrm{GeTe}_2, Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 in UUU and UDU configurations are: -1.51 (-1.22), 0.77 (1.01), 0.05 (0.11) and 0.02 (-0.03) meV/Fe, respectively.

It is important to note that the direction of easy axis for the Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2 and Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_4\mathrm{GeTe}_2 monolayers evaluated using DMFT and DFT is in good agreement with the experimental results reported for the corresponding bulk systems [31]. In the case of bulk Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 the scenario is not so straightforward because some studies report weak in-plane easy axis [20], while some mentions canted out-of-plane [21] configuration. This can be attributed to the complexity related to the structural properties and chemical composition of Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2. Our previous first-principles study on Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 monolayer reported that both the direction and magnitude of MAE vary depending on the concentration of Fe vacancy and the presence of Fe1-Ge split sites [32]. Since the strength of MAE for this system is quite weak, small structural changes or weak perturbations can easily tune this property.

Figs. 2.3 (i)-(l) show the value of TCT_\mathrm{C} computed using different techniques for different FGT monolayers. It is quite evident from Figs. 2.3(i)-(l) that TCT_\mathrm{C} obtained from DFT is overestimated compared with DMFT. TCT_\mathrm{C} obtained using DFT is almost twice of the DMFT value for Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2 and Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2, while this difference increases in the case of Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_4\mathrm{GeTe}_2. The MM vs. TT behavior for different Fe sublattices present in the FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_n\mathrm{GeTe}_2 monolayers are plotted in SI.

Carefully examining Figs. 2.3(a)-(d) and (i)-(l), one can see there is a direct correlation between the DFT and DMFT computed JijJ_{ij} and TCT_\mathrm{C}. For example, in the case of Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2, the value of the strongest JijJ_{ij} coupling using DMFT and DFT are 36.52 meV/Fe and 65.32 meV/Fe, respectively. Similarly, TCT_\mathrm{C} changes from 270 K (DMFT) to 480 K (DFT). This implies TCT_\mathrm{C} is dominated by the first term JijJ_{ij} in eq. (3). However, no such relationship between JijJ_{ij} and TCT_\mathrm{C} is observed for DFT+U results.

It is important to note that, the value of TCT_\mathrm{C} for FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_n\mathrm{GeTe}_2 monolayers obtained using DMFT fall in the same range as reported in the experiments on few-layer thick or bulk FGT systems. Since in the bulk FGT systems different formula units are stacked together via weak vdW forces, the monolayer could be considered as a good representative of the bulk, though the interlayer interactions are absent in this case. Therefore, TCT_\mathrm{C} obtained for monolayers should be compatible with their bulk counterpart. TCT_\mathrm{C} for monolayer (bulk) Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2, Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_4\mathrm{GeTe}_2 and Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 systems obtained from DFT+DMFT (experiments) are the following: 260 K (220 K [30, 31]), 250 K (270 K [31]) and 275 K (275–310 K [20, 21, 54]), respectively. From these values of TCT_\mathrm{C} we see there is no linear relationship as a function of nn for different FGT monolayers, while the TCT_\mathrm{C} values reported in experiments show the linear trend for bulk FGT systems [20]. Even in the case of DFT+DMFT, there is still some overestimation of TCT_\mathrm{C} obtained for monolayer Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2 compared to the experimental values (130 K - 150 K) reported for this system [37, 55]. Such mismatch may arise due to the presence of Fe-vacancies or defects in the real sample, which can alter the exchange interactions and hence the TCT_{\mathrm{C}} [56]. For example, studies on bulk Fe3_3GeTe2_2 show TCT_{\mathrm{C}} can vary from 220 K to 160 K depending on the concentration of Fe (as well as Ge and Te) atoms present in the sample [37, 57]

Therefore, one may conclude that the standard DFT technique gives reasonable results for magnetic moment and MAE, but overestimates the exchange interactions, especially the isotropic symmetric exchange, hence, leads to high values of the Curie temperature TCT_{\mathrm{C}}. While the magnetic moments, magnetic anisotropy energy and Curie temperature computed using DMFT are in a good agreement with the experimental studies reported in literature. The outcome from DFT+U calculations, for example, the magnetic moment, MAE and TCT_{\mathrm{C}} are not at all compatible with experimental results. Therefore, the consideration of static electron correlation (in the limit of U/W≫1U/W \gg1) can not be a reasonable choice for the correct description of the electronic and magnetic properties of FGT systems.

Interatomic exchange interactions

Based on our results discussed in section 2.3, we find that DMFT produces a reasonable outcome in terms of the magnetic properties of FGT monolayers. In this section, we discuss the isotropic symmetric and antisymmetric exchange interactions computed with the inclusion of dynamical electronic correlation effects. We focus on the exchange interactions obtained using DMFT, because, as discussed in section 2.3, this technique captures the physical (electronic and magnetic) properties of FGT systems more accurately than other methods.

Isotropic symmetric exchange parameters

The isotropic symmetric exchange interactions JijJ_{ij} within the DFT+DMFT framework is given by [58]:

Jij=T4∑nTr⁡[Δi(iωn)Gij†(iωn)Δj(iωn)Gji†(iωn)],(4)J_{ij} = \frac{T}{4} \sum_n \operatorname{Tr}\left[\Delta_i(i\omega_n)G_{ij}^{\dagger}(i\omega_n)\Delta_j(i\omega_n)G_{ji}^{\dagger}(i\omega_n)\right], \tag*{(4)}

where the trace is over the orbital degrees of freedom, TT is the temperature, and ωn\omega_n is the nnth Matsubara frequency, GijG_{ij} is the intersite Green’s function between sites ii and jj. Therefore, according to eq. 4, the exchange interactions JijJ_{ij} depend on the onsite exchange splitting Δi\Delta_i and intersite Green’s function GijG_{ij}.

The onsite exchange splitting term Δi\Delta_i which includes the self-energy is given by:

Δi(iωn)=HKS↑+Σi↑(iωn)−HKS↓−Σi↓(iωn),(5)\Delta_i(i\omega_n) = H_{\mathrm{KS}}^{\uparrow} + \Sigma_i^{\uparrow}(i\omega_n) - H_{\mathrm{KS}}^{\downarrow} - \Sigma_i^{\downarrow}(i\omega_n), \tag*{(5)}

where, HKSH_{\mathrm{KS}} and Σi\Sigma_i are the Kohn-Sham Hamiltonian and site-dependent self-energy. The self-energy is obtained by solving the DMFT equations. In DMFT calculations, the self-energy is frequency-dependent, which is also true for the exchange splitting. Though the self-energy Σ\Sigma is a single-site quantity, it affects the intersite Green’s function according to eq. 1 [58]. JijJ_{ij} parameters for each Fe sublattice in Fen_nGeTe2_2 (n=3,4,5n = 3, 4, 5) systems obtained using DMFT are plotted in Figure 3.

Isotropic symmetric exchange parameters $J_{ij}$ as a function of neighbouring distance $R_{ij}$ for Fe$_3$GeTe$_2$, Fe$_4$GeTe$_2$ and Fe$_5$GeTe$_2$ monolayers

Figure 3. Isotropic symmetric exchange parameters JijJ_{ij} as a function of neighbouring distance RijR_{ij} for (a)-(b) Fe3_3GeTe2_2, (c)-(d) Fe4_4GeTe2_2 and (e)-(j) Fe5_5GeTe2_2 monolayer, obtained using DMFT. The JijJ_{ij} values reported here are multiplied by the corresponding coordination numbers.

Figure 3 (a) and (Figure 3b) show the JijJ_{ij} interactions when i=Fe1i=\mathrm{Fe1} and Fe3\mathrm{Fe3} for Fe3_3GeTe2_2 monolayer as a function of the nearest neighbor distance RijR_{ij} (normalized by the lattice parameter aa) obtained using DFT+DMFT. The dominating exchange interaction is ferromagnetic (FM) between different types of Fe species, i.e., when i≠ji \ne j while for i=ji = j, the first NN interaction is antiferromagnetic (AFM) irrespective of the type of Fe sublattice. As already mentioned in § 2.1, the first NN distance between Fe1 and Fe2 is smaller than the first NN Fe1-Fe3 distance, therefore, as expected, the strongest FM JijJ_{ij} interaction takes place between the first NN Fe1-Fe2 pair, see Figure 3(a) and (Figure 3b). From the orbital decomposition of JijJ_{ij} interactions (see Table S1 in SI), we find the dominating contribution to the first nearest neighbor (NN) J12J_{12} interaction comes from the dz2d_{z^2} orbital of the vertically aligned Fe1 and Fe2 atoms, see Figure 1(a).

The JijJ_{ij} values calculated using standard DFT, DFT+DMFT and DFT+U techniques for Fe3_3GeTe2_2 monolayer are plotted in Fig.S3 SI. This comparison clearly shows that, although the sign of JijJ_{ij} interactions remains unchanged, their magnitude differs drastically, which in turn modifies the TCT_{\mathrm{C}}. We check the robustness of DFT+DMFT method with respect to the correlation strength by calculating the JijJ_{ij} interactions for different Ueff=U−JU_{\mathrm{eff}} = U - J values using DFT+DMFT, for example, U=5.0U = 5.0 eV and JH=1.2J_{\mathrm{H}} = 1.2 eV, Seo et. al. considered these values in their studies on Fen_nGeTe2_2 systems [31]. Our results show the maximum deviation in the largest JijJ_{ij} value is ∼8%\sim8\% between the site-dependent UeffU_{\mathrm{eff}} values (calculated from cLR method) and U=5.0U = 5.0, JH=1.2J_{\mathrm{H}} = 1.2 eV, for Fe3_3GeTe2_2 monolayer, see Fig.S4 SI.

The JijJ_{ij} interactions obtained using DFT+DMFT for i=Fe1i = \mathrm{Fe1} and Fe2\mathrm{Fe2} of Fe4_4GeTe2_2 monolayer are plotted in Figure 3(c) and (Figure 3d), respectively. Fig. S5 shows the isotropic exchange interactions of Fe4_4GeTe2_2 computed using DFT, DFT+DMFT and DFT+U. In the case of Fe4_4GeTe2_2 as well, the sign of JijJ_{ij} couplings remain unchanged irrespective of the type of computational technique. The JijJ_{ij} interactions are mostly FM in this system and dominating FM interaction takes place between Fe1-Fe2 and Fe3-Fe4.

The nature of JijJ_{ij} interactions is relatively complicated in the case of Fe5_5GeTe2_2. The dominating exchange interaction between different Fe sublattices is FM for i=2,3,4i = 2, 3, 4 and 55, while a small AFM coupling exists between the same Fe species, see Figure 3(g)–(Figure 3j). This scenario is quite different for i=1i = 1U and 1D, where significant AFM interactions are present even for i≠ji \ne j, i.e., between 1U or 1D and other Fe species, see Figure 3(e) and (Figure 3f). The presence of such non-negligible AFM coupling implies the existence of exchange frustration in Fe5_5GeTe2_2. Fig. S6 shows how the absence and presence of electron correlation affect the JijJ_{ij} interactions present in Fe5_5GeTe2_2 for the UDU configuration. The JijJ_{ij} interactions computed using DFT and DFT+U in the UDU configuration are plotted in Fig. S7 in SI.

Using the DMFT computed JijJ_{ij} values we calculate exchange stiffness constant AA for the FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_n\mathrm{GeTe}_2 monolayers, which is given by:

A=12Vlim⁡κ→0∑i≠jJijRij2e−κRij(6)A = \frac{1}{2V}\lim_{\kappa\to0}\sum_{i\ne j}J_{ij}R_{ij}^{2}e^{-\kappa R_{ij}} \tag*{(6)}

where VV is the unit cell volume per magnetic site and κ\kappa is the damping parameter. The term e−κRije^{-\kappa R_{ij}} is introduced to improve the convergence of AA with the cutoff radii or RijR_{ij} [59]. We check the dependence of AA as a function of κ\kappa for different RijR_{ij} varying κ\kappa from 0 to 2 and we find for κ≥0.5\kappa\ge0.5 different curves coincide. Using those results we fit the exponential function f(κ)=ae−bκ+cf(\kappa)=ae^{-b\kappa}+c and calculated f(0)f(0) at the κ=0\kappa=0 limit. The stiffness constant AA is estimated this way.

Since we are interested in monolayer FGT systems, eq. (7) is modified in the following way:

A=12Slim⁡κ→0∑i≠jJijRij2e−κRij(7)A = \frac{1}{2S}\lim_{\kappa\to0}\sum_{i\ne j}J_{ij}R_{ij}^{2}e^{-\kappa R_{ij}} \tag*{(7)}

where SS is the unit cell area.

The exchange stiffness constants AA for FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_n\mathrm{GeTe}_2 monolayers calculated using eq. (7) are given by: 4.63 meV (n=3n=3), 4.30 meV (n=4n=4), 3.24 meV (n=5n=5, UUU) and 13.88 meV (n=5n=5, UDU).

Antisymmetric exchange interactions

Next, we study the antisymmetric exchange (DijD_{ij}) interactions. The DijD_{ij} interactions are calculated using the relativistic generalization of the Lichtenstein-Katsnelson-Antropov-Gubanov (LKAG) formula [60]. In the fully relativistic limit, the magnetic exchange parameters are (3×3)(3 \times3) tensors, with the isotropic exchange terms JijJ_{ij} as the diagonal components and the antisymmetric DM and the symmetric anisotropic exchange interactions in the off-diagonal components.

Figure 4 shows the antisymmetric exchange interactions or Dzyaloshinkii-Moriya interaction (DMI) Dij=(Dijx)2+(Dijy)2+(Dijz)2D_{ij} = \sqrt{(D_{ij}^{x})^{2}+(D_{ij}^{y})^{2}+(D_{ij}^{z})^{2}} between different ii and jj in FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_n\mathrm{GeTe}_2 monolayers, computed using DMFT, where, Dijz=12(Jijxy−Jijyx)D_{ij}^{z}=\frac{1}{2}(J_{ij}^{xy}-J_{ij}^{yx}). The DM interactions for the two different Fe sublattices (Fe1 and Fe3) of Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2 are plotted in Figure 4(a) and (Figure 4b). The strongest DijD_{ij} interaction takes place between Fe1-Fe1, i.e., Fe atoms situated in the same zz plane, as we see in Figure 4(a) the first nearest neighbor D11D_{11} interaction is ∼10\sim10 meV. Figure 4(c) shows the side view of the first nearest neighbor D11D_{11} acting between Fe1-Fe1 and the dominating contribution comes from the DzD_z component. The next significant DM interaction takes place between the first nearest neighbors Fe1 and Fe3. Figure 4(d) shows the top view of the DM interaction vectors between Fe1 and Fe3 sites, which have mainly the in-plane components (DxD_x and DyD_y). It is important to note that the D11zD_{11}^{z} as well as the D13xD_{13}^{x} and D13yD_{13}^{y} vectors present in the unit cell almost cancel each other due to the structural symmetry of this system. More interestingly, the first nearest neighbour (NN) D13D_{13} interaction is essentially zero, this happens because the NN Fe1 and Fe2 atoms are inversion symmetric partners with respect to the zz axis, see Figure 1(a). Comparing between the magnitudes of the highest DijD_{ij} and JijJ_{ij} values of

Antisymmetric exchange parameters for Fe₃GeTe₂, Fe₄GeTe₂, and Fe₅GeTe₂ monolayers

Figure 4. Antisymmetric exchange parameters Dij=Dxij2+Dyij2+Dzij2D_{ij} = \sqrt{D_{xij}^{2} + D_{yij}^{2} + D_{zij}^{2}} as a function of neighbouring distance RijR_{ij} for (a)-(b) Fe₃GeTe₂, (e)-(f) Fe₄GeTe₂ and (i)-(n) Fe₅GeTe₂ monolayer, obtained using DMFT. (c), (d), (g), (h), (o) and (p) show the first neighbor DM interactions between different iith and jjth pairs. The DijD_{ij} values are multiplied by the corresponding coordination numbers.

Antisymmetric exchange interactions

Fe3_3GeTe2_2 monolayer, we see the DM interaction is ∼3\sim3 times smaller than the isotropic symmetric exchange interactions. Fig. S9 in SI shows the DM interactions present in Fe3_3GeTe2_2 obtained using DFT and DFT+DMFT.

The DijD_{ij} interactions for different Fe sublattices of Fe4_4GeTe2_2 are plotted in Figure 4(e) and (f). Similar to Fe3_3GeTe2_2, in this case also the first NN D11D_{11} interaction (between Fe1 and Fe1) has the highest contribution to DMI in Fe4_4GeTe2_2 with DzD_z as the dominating component, see Figure 4(g). The next dominating DM interaction takes place between the first NN Fe2-Fe2 pair, and the direction of D22D_{22} is mainly along zz. There exists non-zero DMI between Fe1-Fe2 or Fe3-Fe4 where the in-plane components dominate, see Figure 4(h). The first nearest neighbor D13D_{13} or D24D_{24} interaction is zero, while the long-range D13D_{13} (or D24D_{24}) are non-zero. More interestingly, DM interactions do not exist between Fe1 and Fe4 (Fe2 and Fe3), these are the inversion symmetric partners, see Figure 1(b). The DM interaction vectors between different Fe-sublattices of Fe4_4GeTe2_2 are plotted in Figure 4(g) and (Figure 4h). Fig. S10 shows the DM interactions present in Fe4_4GeTe2_2 obtained using DFT and DFT+DMFT.

Figure 4(i)-(Figure 4n) show the DM interactions for different Fe sublattices of Fe5_5GeTe2_2 in UDU configuration. The DijD_{ij} interactions are quite complex in this case compared to the Fe3_3GeTe2_2 and Fe4_4GeTe2_2 monolayers, because this system is less symmetric than the first two FGT systems. Figure 4(o) and (Figure 4p) show the DM vectors between Fe1U-Fe4 and Fe4-Fe5 pairs in Fe5_5GeTe2_2. Fig. S11 shows the DM interactions present in Fe5_5GeTe2_2 monolayer in UUU configuration computed using DFT and DFT+DMFT.

Though the scalar form of DijD_{ij} interactions plotted in Figure 4 shows a non-zero contribution for some of the site neighbors, the net DMI for all the nearest neighbors of a given site ii is quite small due to the structural symmetries present in the pristine FGT monolayers. Using the computed D⃗ij\vec{D}_{ij} values we calculate the spiralization constant DD for the Fen_nGeTe2_2 monolayers defined as:

D=1Slim⁡κ→0∑i≠jD⃗ij⊗R⃗ije−κRij(8)D = \frac{1}{S}\lim_{\kappa\to0}\sum_{i \ne j}\vec{D}_{ij}\otimes\vec{R}_{ij}e^{-\kappa R_{ij}} \tag*{(8)}

In this case DD is 3×33 \times3 tensor. Since our system of interest is 2D FGT systems, we divide eq. 8 by the unit cell area SS (same as eq. 7).

The spiralization constants calculated from the DM vectors are negligible in the case of Fe3_3GeTe2_2 and Fe4_4GeTe2_2, because the net DM vector acting between any sites ii and jj gets significantly cancelled out due to the structural symmetries, as we see in Figure 4(c), (Figure 4d), (Figure 4g) and (Figure 4h). In the case of Fe5_5GeTe2_2 in UUU and UDU configurations, the diagonal terms in eq. 8 are very small but there are some non-negligible off-diagonal terms. The highest off-diagonal term of the spiralization tensor for UUU and UDU configurations are 0.04 meV Å−1^{-1} and 0.031 meV Å−1^{-1}, respectively. Due to the existence of such small DM interactions in Fen_nGeTe2_2 monolayers, there is a negligible contribution to TCT_{\mathrm{C}} from the antisymmetric exchange interactions.

Electronic structure

In order to investigate how electron correlation effect modifies the electronic structure we compare the DFT band structure and kk-resolved spectral density obtained from DMFT, along the high symmetry directions. We also discuss the difference in density of states for these two cases.

The DMFT expressions for spectral density A(k,ϵ)A(\mathbf{k},\epsilon) and density of states (DOS) D(ϵ)D(\epsilon) are given by:

A(k,ϵ)=−1π∑χ⟨k,χ∣Im⁡G(ϵ+i0)∣k,χ⟩,(9)A(\mathbf{k},\epsilon)=-\frac{1}{\pi}\sum_{\chi}\langle\mathbf{k},\chi|\operatorname{Im}G(\epsilon+i0)|\mathbf{k},\chi\rangle, \tag*{(9)}
D(ϵ)=−1πTr⁡[Im⁡G(ϵ+i0)],(10)D(\epsilon)=-\frac{1}{\pi}\operatorname{Tr}[\operatorname{Im}G(\epsilon+i0)], \tag*{(10)}

Among the three Fen_nGeTe2_2 systems, n=3n=3 is the simplest one and the JijJ_{ij} interactions present in this system are less complicated. Hence, we focus only on Fe3_3GeTe2_2, to see the change in electronic structure due to dynamical electronic correlations. Here we focus on Fe1-dz2d_{z^2} state since from the orbital resolved analysis of JijJ_{ij} interactions we see this particular orbital of Fe1 (and/or Fe2) has dominating contribution to the isotropic symmetric exchange interaction J12J_{12} (between Fe1 and Fe2), as reported in section 2.4.1 and Table S1 in SI. Figure 5 shows the comparison of electronic structures of Fe3_3GeTe2_2 monolayer obtained without and with dynamical correlations.

Band structures and projected densities of states for Fe$_1$ and Fe$_2$

Figure 5. Band structure projecting on both spin channels of dz2d_{z^2} orbital for Fe1 (Fe2) in Fe3_3GeTe2_2 using (a), (d) DFT and (b), (e) DMFT. (c) and (f) show the DFT (black) vs. DFT+DMFT (red) density of states projected on dz2d_{z^2} orbital of Fe1(Fe2) for both spin channels. Insets in (c) and (f) show the real (red solid) and imaginary (green dashed) parts of the self-energy Σ\Sigma for both spin channels.

The spin-polarized DFT and DFT+DMFT band structures for Fe1 (or Fe2) sublattice of Fe3_3GeTe2_2 projecting on dz2d_{z^2} orbital are plotted along the high-symmetry directions in Figure 5(a)-(b) (up spin) and (d)-(e) (down spin), respectively. The DFT band structure contains sharp energy bands, while the DMFT bands are smeared out due to the finite quasiparticle lifetime [44] induced by a non-zero imaginary part of the self-energy. Furthermore, the energy levels are shifted towards the Fermi level, which is attributed to the real part of the self-energy, and become more flat due to correlations. Correlations also reduce the bandwidth in the momentum-resolved spectral function A(k,ϵ)A(\mathbf{k},\epsilon). In Figure 3(a) we see the first NN J12J_{12}, i.e., the isotropic symmetric exchange interaction between Fe1 and Fe2, is the strongest among all JijJ_{ij} interactions present in this system. The orbital decomposed results show the first NN Fe1 and Fe2 atoms interact mainly via their dz2d_{z^2} orbitals. Due to this reason, here we focus on the dz2d_{z^2} orbital of one of these Fe species, and compare its electronic nature using DFT and DFT+DMFT. Comparing between the DFT and DMFT band structures we find the narrowing or shift of bands towards the Fermi energy is quite significant along Γ−K\Gamma-K and Γ−M\Gamma-M directions for the spin-up and down channels, respectively.

The DFT (black) and DFT+DMFT (red) density of states D(ϵ)D(\epsilon) projecting on Fe1 (or Fe2) dz2d_{z^2} orbital for both spin channels are plotted in Figure 5(c) and (f). It follows from Figure 5(c) and (f) that DMFT causes noticeable renormalization of Fe1-3dz2d_{z^2} projected density of states (PDOS). In the case of spin-up channel of the DMFT PDOS (red curve), the first peak is situated closer to the Fermi energy compared to the DFT PDOS, see Figure 5(c). Similarly, for the spin-down channel the electronic states are also shifted toward the Fermi level for DMFT PDOS, see Figure 5(f).

Even though the integration of spin-polarized DOS up to the Fermi energy remains almost the same for both DFT and DMFT, (which causes similar value of magnetic moments for DFT and DMFT), the electronic spectra gets modified upon the inclusion of dynamical electronic correlations. These modifications in the PDOS can be understood by analyzing the real (red solid) and imaginary (green dashed) parts of the self-energy Σ\Sigma, displayed as the insets in Figure 5(c) and (Figure 5f), for the up and down spin channels, respectively. According to eq. (10) the DMFT DOS contains imaginary part of the Green’s function, and the self energy term Σ\Sigma is included in the denominator of Green’s function, see eq. (1). The quasiparticle energies are renormalized by the real part of the self-energy which shifts the positions of the peaks in the DMFT spectrum. The high and positive value of the self-energy for the up and down spin channels within the energy range between 0 and -5 eV shifts the spectrum toward the Fermi level. The imaginary part of the self-energy causes broadening of the peaks present in PDOS, leading to an effective decrease of their intensities. Note, the imaginary part of the self energy is ∼0 at and close to the Fermi energy, implying the quasi-particles have longer lifetimes, according to Fermi liquid theory.

The difference in electronic structure between DFT and DMFT, displayed in Figure 5, is responsible to modify the isotropic symmetric exchange interactions present in Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} monolayer, which in turn changes the Curie temperature. The band structure plot along high-symmetry directions shows that the energy levels get more localized in the case of DMFT than DFT, thus the dynamical correlations reduce the electron hopping amplitude between different sites and consequently the intersite Green’s-function GijG_{ij} in eq. (4). Therefore, the isotropic symmetric exchange interactions present in FGT systems get significantly reduced in DMFT leading to smaller values of TCT_{\mathrm{C}}.

Discussion on Bulk FGT systems

TCT_{\mathrm{C}} obtained from our Monte Carlo simulations for Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2}, Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{4}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} and Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{5}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} (UDU configuration) monolayers are 275 K, 220 K and 280 K, respectively. From these results one can see that TCT_{\mathrm{C}} does not increase linearly as a function of n(=3,4, and 5)n(= 3, 4, \text{ and } 5), which is in contrast to previous studies on bulk FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{n}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} systems [20, 31]. This implies some important features must be missing in the case of FGT monolayers compared to the bulk FGT systems. Due to the lack of those features, the expected TCT_{\mathrm{C}} vs. nn relationship is not observed.

To understand the real scenario present in bulk FGT systems we focus on bulk Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} since this is the simplest member. Based on our (DFT and DFT+DMFT) results we find (as mentioned in section 2.3) that the value of TCT_{\mathrm{C}} primarily depends on JijJ_{ij}. Therefore, the sign and magnitude of JijJ_{ij} interactions present in bulk Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_{3}\mathrm{Ge}\mathrm{Te}_{2} should be the main features to tune the TCT_{\mathrm{C}} from monolayer to bulk (or vice versa). We calculate the magnetic exchange interactions and TCT_\mathrm{C} for bulk Fe3_3GeTe2_2. Our results show both the strength and magnitude of intralayer JijJ_{ij} interactions remain almost the same for monolayer and bulk, see Fig. S12 in SI. Therefore the intralayer JijJ_{ij} interactions do not play any role in modifying the TCT_\mathrm{C} for this system.

Next, we focus on the interlayer symmetric exchange interactions and our DFT+DMFT results show that significant antiferromagnetic (AFM) couplings exist in bulk Fe3_3GeTe2_2, as already discussed in the literature [61, 62, 63]. Figure 6(a) and (b), (c) show the side view of bulk Fe3_3GeTe2_2 and the interlayer symmetric exchange interactions JijJ_{ij} for i=1i = 1 and i=3i = 3, respectively. Bulk Fe3_3GeTe2_2 has the vdW gap of 3.47 Å and the out-of-plane lattice constant is 16.33 Å. Note, the unit cell of bulk Fe4_4GeTe2_2 and Fe5_5GeTe2_2 contain three formula units along zz direction with thickness 29.08 and 29.20 Å, respectively [21, 31]. Figure 6(b) and (c) significant interlayer AFM interactions are present in bulk Fe3_3GeTe2_2. Though these interlayer JijJ_{ij} interactions are weaker than the intralayer interactions, such exchange couplings are enough to tune the TCT_\mathrm{C}. As a result, the Curie temperature changes from 260 K (monolayer) to 205 K (bulk), and this value of TCT_\mathrm{C} for the pristine bulk Fe3_3GeTe2_2 is in excellent agreement with the previously reported experimental findings [31, 37, 38, 52, 57, 64] and computed values of TCT_\mathrm{C} [31, 65]. Note, from standard DFT calculations the value of TCT_\mathrm{C} for bulk Fe3_3GeTe2_2 is found to be 410 K, which is hugely overestimated compared to DFT+DMFT and also w.r.t. the experimental reports. fig:S13 shows the comparison in magnetization (MM) vs. temperature (TT) behavior for bulk Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2 between DFT and DFT+DMFT.

Side view of bulk Fe3GeTe2 and interlayer symmetric exchange couplings

Figure 6. (a) Side view of bulk Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2, the sublattices highlighted in white show the strongest AFM interaction. Interlayer symmetric exchange couplings JijJ_{ij} as a function of neighbouring distance RijR_{ij} for Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2 bulk for the iith site as (b) Fe1 and (c) Fe3. These results are obtained using DFT+DMFT. The second nearest neighbor J14J_{14} (or J36J_{36}) interaction shows significant AFM coupling. The exchange parameters are multiplied by the corresponding coordination numbers. The blue dashed line in (a) between Fe1 and Fe4 shows the Fe sublattices taking part into the highest AFM interaction, highlighted by the blue circle in (b).

Similar to Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2, if we compute TCT_{\mathrm{C}} of bulk Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_4\mathrm{GeTe}_2 and Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 (UDU configuration), then we should in principle obtain the linear relationship between TCT_{\mathrm{C}} and nn (n=3,4,5n = 3, 4, 5). Since we have already discussed in this study that DFT+DMFT describes the physical properties of FGT systems more accurately than standard DFT or DFT+U, therefore one has to perform DFT+DMFT calculations for bulk Fe4GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_4\mathrm{GeTe}_2 and Fe5GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_5\mathrm{GeTe}_2 to get compatible results with experiment. But these DMFT calculations are computationally expensive due to a large number of atoms. Therefore, in this study, we have limited ourselves to DFT+DMFT calculations only for bulk Fe3GeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_3\mathrm{GeTe}_2. Based on our results and physical interpretation we expect that the interlayer exchange interactions present in other bulk FGT systems would modify the corresponding TCT_{\mathrm{C}} w.r.t. the monolayer and one can probably expect a linear trend for TCT_{\mathrm{C}} vs. nn similar to experiment.

Conclusion

In this study, we have performed a systematic investigation of the electronic structure and magnetic properties of FenGeTe4\mathrm{Fe}_n\mathrm{GeTe}_4 (n=3,4,n = 3, 4, and 55) systems by DFT, DFT+U and DMFT methods. By using the computed parameters in the spin Hamiltonian, the Curie temperature for each FGT monolayer was determined. Based on our results, it is quite evident that, among these three methodologies, DFT+U with static electronic correlations is not applicable for these systems, since it produces values of magnetic moments and Curie temperature that do not agree with the experiment. We find that the magnetic moments obtained using standard DFT are compatible with the experimental results, but the Curie temperature is overestimated. Upon the inclusion of dynamical electronic correlations within the DFT+DMFT approach, the magnetic moments remain almost unchanged, while the exchange interactions, especially the isotropic symmetric exchange parameters get significantly modified to decrease the Curie temperature substantially. The latter is in a good agreement with experimental reports for all FGT systems. This implies that consideration of dynamical correlations is necessary to capture the correct electronic structure and magnetic behavior of the FGT systems.

Methods and Computational Details

Density functional theory (DFT) based calculations are performed to study the structural, electronic, and magnetic properties of FenGeTe2\mathrm{Fe}_n\mathrm{GeTe}_2 (FGT family) systems. Structural optimizations are performed using Vienna Ab initio Simulation Package (VASP) [66, 67], where the exchange-correlation potential has been treated with the generalized gradient approximation (GGA), with the Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof (PBE) functional [68]. We use 18×18×118 \times18 \times1 Monkhorst-Pack kk-point mesh in our calculations for Brillouin zone (BZ) integration. [69] To model isolated 2D monolayers, the interaction between periodic images of the supercell along the zz-axis was reduced by adding a 20 Å vacuum region perpendicular to the surface of monolayers. The lattice constants and atomic coordinates were optimized by minimizing energy based on the conjugate gradient method with a force component tolerance of 0.01 eV/Å on each atom. The energy cutoff for the plane-wave basis set was set to 500 eV.

To have more accurate prediction of localized magnetic properties, we used the full-potential linear muffin-tin orbital (FP-LMTO) method, implemented in the RSPt code [44, 70]. The kk-point grids with dimensions 21×21×121 \times21 \times1 and 36×36×136 \times36 \times1 were constructed for calculating the magnetic exchange interactions (JijJ_{ij}) and magnetic anisotropy energy (MAE), respectively. Within the scope of FP-LMTO, we studied the electronic and magnetic properties of FGT systems using different computational approaches: DFT, dynamical mean-field theory (DMFT) and DFT+UU.

DMFT methodology

The key concept of DMFT is that the Hubbard model is mapped locally to an effective Anderson impurity model, where the problem of an entire lattice is converted into the simple problem of an atom embedded in an electronic bath. Each lattice-site is coupled with the bath which represents rest of the crystal and electron on the single site could be created or annihilated by coupling with the electronic bath [42]. The Hamiltonian of the Anderson impurity model can be written as:

HAIM=Hatom+∑ν,σϵνaνσ†aνσ+∑νσ(Vνc0σ†aνσ+h.c.)+Un0↑n0↓,(11)H_{AIM} = H_{atom} + \sum_{\nu,\sigma} \epsilon_{\nu} a_{\nu\sigma}^{\dagger} a_{\nu\sigma} + \sum_{\nu\sigma} \left(V_{\nu} c_{0\sigma}^{\dagger} a_{\nu\sigma} + \mathrm{h.c.}\right) + U n_{0\uparrow} n_{0\downarrow}, \tag*{(11)}

where HatomH_{\mathrm{atom}} includes the single site interactions and ϵν\epsilon_{\nu} is the energy associated with the bath electrons. The first two terms can be considered as the non-interaction energy terms. While the third term describes the coupling between the bath electrons and the electron on the single atom site, where VνV_{\nu} is the strength of this coupling. (c0,σ†,c0,σ)(c^{\dagger}_{0,\sigma}, c_{0,\sigma}) and (aν,σ†,aν,σ)(a^{\dagger}_{\nu,\sigma}, a_{\nu,\sigma}) are the degrees of freedom for the on-site and bath electrons, respectively. The last term describes the local Coulomb interaction UU.

The converged DFT calculations are the starting point to perform our DMFT calculations as implemented in RSPt [44, 71]. The first step of the DFT+DMFT or DMFT method is to identify a set of local orbitals, which are not properly described by the standard DFT technique. The Hamiltonian written in eq. (11) can be solved through DMFT, and convergence should be achieved for both the local self-energy and the full electron density. To solve the effective impurity problem arising in the DMFT cycle we use the spin polarized T-matrix fluctuation-exchange (SPTF) solver [44]. SPTF solver is chosen for our calculations due to its efficiency and accuracy for the moderately correlated systems [72, 73]. The double counting correction HDCH_{\mathrm{DC}} is considered as the orbitally averaged static part of the self-energy, which is usually done for the SPTF solver [72, 74]. In our calculations we use full-potential muffin-tin orbitals as implemented in the RSPt code. The Fermi smearing is used for the electronic occupations for the FGT systems, with the smearing temperature 155 K. The effective Hubbard parameter UeffU_{\mathrm{eff}} used in our calculations are obtained from the constrained linear response method, as described in § 2.3.

Methodology for JijJ_{ij} calculations

The isotropic symmetric exchange interactions JijJ_{ij} are calculated within the full-potential linearized muffin-tin orbital (FPLMTO) basis implemented in the RSPt code. From the LMTO basis, one can construct the Bloch sums to solve the DFT eigenvalue problem and subsequently for the one-electron Green’s function. We have considered Löwdin orthonormalized LMTO basis functions, which are not very localized due to their long decaying tail, and are more physical for metallic systems like Fe5_5GeTe2_2. For a detailed description of the shape of various local orbitals used in RSPt, please see Ref. 58. The Löwdin orbitals used in our calculations have been constructed from the original LMTO basis functions performing a k-point-wise orthonormalization [58].

JijJ_{ij} can be extracted from the Green’s function obtained from the LMTO basis. The generalized expression for the intersite exchange parameters is given by:

Jij=T4∑n[Δi(iωn)G^ijσ(iωn)Δj(iωn)G^jiσ],(12)J_{ij} = \frac{T}{4} \sum_n \left[\Delta_i(i\omega_n)\widehat{G}^{\sigma}_{ij}(i\omega_n)\Delta_j(i\omega_n)\widehat{G}^{\sigma}_{ji}\right], \tag*{(12)}

The most important quantities in this expression are the onsite spin splitting Δi\Delta_i and the spin-dependent intersite Green’s function G^ij\widehat{G}_{ij}. The trace in eq. (12) is taken over the orbital degrees of freedom. TT and ωn=2πT(2n+1)\omega_n = 2\pi T(2n+1) are the temperature and the nnth fermionic Matsubara frequency respectively. G^ijσ\widehat{G}^{\sigma}_{ij} is the intersite Green’s function between sites ii and jj and projected over a given spin σ\sigma. The term Δi\Delta_i gives the exchange splitting at site ii, obtained using spin and site-projected Kohn-Sham Hamiltonian. In the presence of dynamical electronic correlations, eq. (12) gets modified and in DMFT the JijJ_{ij} parameters are calculated using eq. (4) as mentioned in section 2.4.1.

Methodology for DijD_{ij} calculations

In order to obtain information on more complex magnetic interactions, one has to generalize this approach to the relativistic case, which has been done already within the Korringa-Kohn-Rostoker (KKR) Green-function method [75]. The details concerning the implementation of antisymmetric exchange interactions in RSPt and the calculation results for different correlated systems are discussed in refs. 75 and 76.

Monte Carlo simulations

To estimate the magnetic ordering temperatures, we performed classical Monte Carlo (MC) simulations via UppASD code [77], where the calculated magnetic parameters are implemented in the Hamiltonian introduced in eq. (3). Here, identical KiK_i was assumed for all Fe sites by averaging the total MAE/cell by the number of Fe atoms present in the unit cell. To achieve properly averaged properties, calculations were done for three ensembles in supercell with sizes varying between 40×40×140 \times40 \times1, 50×50×150 \times50 \times1, and 60×60×160 \times60 \times1, where periodic boundary conditions were imposed along xx and yy axes, and the transition temperatures were estimated by monitoring the cross sections of fourth-order cumulants of magnetization.

Constrained Linear Response Method

We computed the Hubbard UU parameter by means of constrained-density-functional calculations. The Hubbard UU was computed by varying the electron occupation of a single site by constructing a supercell where the periodically repeated sites are perturbed coherently. In this supercell approach, the occupation of one representative site in a large cell is changed leaving all other site occupations unchanged.

The effective interaction parameter UU associated to site ii in terms of the response function χ\chi is given by:

U=(χ0−1−χ−1)iiU = \left(\chi_{0}^{-1} - \chi^{-1}\right)_{ii}

We performed a well converged self-consistent field DFT calculation for the unperturbed system for all sites in the supercell. Then starting from its self-consistent potential, small positive and negative potential shifts were added to each nonequivalent “Hubbard” site jj and the variation of the occupations for all the ii sites present in the supercell was computed in two steps: i) re-adjusting the Kohn-Sham potential of the system self-consistently to optimally screen the localized perturbation, and ii) without allowing this screening. This latter result is nothing but the variation computed from the first iteration in the self-consistent cycle leading eventually to the former (screened) results. The site-occupation derivatives calculated according to i) and ii) produce the matrices χij\chi_{ij} and χij0\chi^{0}_{ij}, respectively. The difference between these matrices gives the value of the Hubbard parameter UU.

This scheme is rotationally invariant, therefore the Hund’s exchange JHJ_{\mathrm{H}}, describing these effects can be considered as zero, or the effect of JHJ_{\mathrm{H}} can be mimicked by redefining the UU parameter as Ueff=U−JU_{\mathrm{eff}} = U - J, which is known as Dudarev scheme in literature [78].

Supplementary information Supporting Information accompanies this article which is available free of charge.

Acknowledgments B.S. and S.G. acknowledge a postdoctoral grant from Carl Tryggers Stiftelse (CTS 20:378). The computations were enabled in project SNIC 2021/3-38 by resources provided by the Swedish National Infrastructure for Computing (SNIC) at NSC, PDC, and HPC2N partially funded by the Swedish Research Council (Grant No. 2018-05973). B.S. acknowledges allocation of supercomputing hours by PRACE DECI-17 project ‘Q2Dtopomat’ in Eagle supercomputer in Poland and EuroHPC resources in Karolina supercomputer in Czech Republic.

Author contributions S.G. and S.E. carried out the calculations. All authors discussed the results and co-wrote the paper.

Correspondence Correspondence to Biplab Sanyal.

Competing interests The authors declare no competing interests.

Data availability The data supporting the findings of this study are available from the corresponding authors upon request.

Code availability The structural optimizations are performed using VASP. The full-potential LMTO code RSPt was used to compute the magnetic and electronic properties. The Monte Carlo simulations are performed using the UppASD code. All these packages or codes are commercially available.

References

References

  1. [1]Geim A K and Novoselov K S 2007 Nat. Mater. 6(3) 183–191
  2. [2]Mak K F, Shan J and Ralph D C 2019 Nat. Rev. Phys. 1(11) 646–661
  3. [3]Gong C, Li L, Li Z, Ji H, Stern A, Xia Y, Cao T, Bao W, Wang C, Wang Y, Qiu Z Q, Cava R J, Louise S G, Xia J and Zhang X 2017 Nature 546(7657) 265–269
  4. [4]Mermin N D and Wagner H 1966 Phys. Rev. Lett. 17 1133
  5. [5]Huang B, Clark G, Navarro-Moratalla E, Klein D R, Cheng R, Seyler K L, Zhong D, Schmidgall E, McGuire M A, Cobden D H, Yao W, Xiao D, Jarillo-Herrero P and Xu X 2017 Nature 546(7657) 270–273
  6. [6]Xu C, Feng J, Xiang H and Bellaiche L 2018 npj. Comput. Mater. 4(1) 57
  7. [7]Cortie D L, Causer G L, Rule K C, Fritzsche H, Kreuzpaintner W and Klose F 2020 Adv. Funct. Mater. 30 1901414
  8. [8]Žutić I, Fabian J and Sarma S D 2004 Rev. Mod. Phys. 76 323
  9. [9]Cortie D L, Causer G L, Rule K C, Fritzsche H, Kreuzpaintner W and Klose F 2020 Adv. Funct. Mater. 30 1901414
  10. [10]Gong C, Li L, Li Z, Ji H, Stern A, Xia Y, Cao T, Bao W, Wang C, Wang Y et al. 2017 Nature 546 265–269
  11. [11]Huang B, Clark G, Navarro-Moratalla E, Klein D R, Cheng R, Seyler K L, Zhong D, Schmidgall E, McGuire M A, Cobden D H et al. 2017 Nature 546 270–273
  12. [12]Bhatti S, Sbiaa R, Hirohata A, Ohno H, Fukami S and Piramanayagam S 2017 Mater. Today 20 530–548 ISSN 1369-7021
  13. [13]Li X, Lü J T, Zhang J, You L, Su Y and Tsymbal E Y 2019 Nano Lett. 19(8) 5133–5139
  14. [14]Huang K, Shao D F and Tsymbal E Y 2022 Nano Lett. 22(8) 3349–3355
  15. [15]Zhang Y, Chu J, Yin L, Shifa T A, Cheng Z, Cheng R, Wang F, Wen Y, Zhan X, Wang Z and He J 2019 Adv. Mater. 31 1900056
  16. [16]Kang L, Ye C, Zhao X, Zhou X, Hu J, Li Q, Liu D, Das C M, Yang J, Hu D, Chen J, Cao X, Zhang Y, Xu M, Di J, Tian D, Song P, Kutty G, Zeng Q, Fu Q, Deng Y, Zhou J, Ariando A, Miao F, Hong G, Huang Y, Pennycook S J, Yong K T, Ji W and Renshaw Wang X 2020 Nat. Commun. 11 3729
  17. [17]Abdullahi Y Z, Vatansever Z D, Ersan F, Akinci U, Akturk O U and Akturk E 2021 Phys. Chem. Chem. Phys. 23(10) 6107–6115
  18. [18]Wu H, Zhang W, Yang L, Wang J, Li J, Li L, Gao Y, Zhang L, Du J, Shu H and Chang H 2021 Nat. Commun. 12(1) 5688
  19. [19]Meng L, Zhou Z, Xu M, Yang S, Si K, Liu L, Wang X, Jiang H, Li B, Qin P, Zhang P, Wang J, Liu Z, Tang P, Ye Y, Zhou W, Bao L, Gao H J and Gong Y 2021 Nat. Commun. 12(1) 809
  20. [20]Zhang H, Chen R, Zhai K, Chen X, Caretta L, Huang X, Chopedkder R V, Cao J, Sun J, Yao J, Birgeneau R and Ramesh R 2020 Phys. Rev. B 102(6) 064417
  21. [21]May A F, Ovchinnikov D, Zheng Q, Hermann R, Calder S, Huang B, Fei Z, Liu Y, Xu X and McGuire M A 2019 ACS nano 13 4436–4442
  22. [22]Ly T T, Park J, Kim K, Ahn H B, Lee N J, Kim K, Park T E, Duvjir G, Lam N H, Jang K et al. 2021 Adv. Funct. Mater. 31 2009758
  23. [23]Liu Q, Xing J, Jiang Z, Guo Y, Jiang X, Qi Y and Zhao J 2022 Commun. Phys. 5 1–10
  24. [24]Joe M, Yang U and Lee C 2019 N. Mater. Sci. 1 299–303 ISSN 2589-9651
  25. [25]Zhuang H L, Kent P R C and Hennig R G 2016 Phys. Rev. B 93(13) 134407
  26. [26]Clifton S E 1938 Proc. R. Soc. Lond. Ser. A. Math. Phys. Sci. 165 372–414
  27. [27]Wang H, Xu R, Liu C, Wang L, Zhang Z, Su H, Wang S, Zhao Y, Liu Z, Yu D, Mei J W, Zou X and Dai J F 2020 J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 11(17) 7313–7319
  28. [28]Xu X, Li Y W, Duan S R, Zhang S L, Chen Y J, Kang L, Liang A J, Chen C, Xia W, Xu Y, Malinowski P, Xu X D, Chu J H, Li G, Guo Y F, Liu Z K, Yang L X and Chen Y L 2020 Phys. Rev. B 101(20) 201104
  29. [29]Schmidt M, Denneulin T, Kovács A, Saunderson T G, Rüßmann P, Shahee A, Scholz T, Tavabi A, Gradhаnd M, Mavropoulos P, Lotsch B, Dunin-Borkowski R, Mokrousov Y, Blügel S and Kläui M 2022 Skyrmionic spin structures in layered Fe₅GeTe₂ up to room temperature
  30. [30]Zhu J X, Janoschek M, Chaves D S, Cezar J C, Durakiewicz T, Rønning F, Sassa Y, Månsson M, Scott B L, Wakeham N, Bauer E D and Thompson J D 2016 Phys. Rev. B 93(14) 144404
  31. [31]Seo J, Kim D Y, An E S, Kim K, Kim G Y, Hwang S Y, Kim D W, Jang B G, Kim H, Eom G, Seo S Y, Stania R, Muentywiler M, Lee J, Watanabe K, Taniguchi T, Jo Y J, Lee J, Min B I, Jo M H, Yeom H W, Choi S Y, Shim J H and Kim J S 2020 Sci. Adv. 6 8912
  32. [32]Ershadrad S, Ghosh S, Wang D, Kvashnin Y and Sanyal B 2022 J. Phys. Chem. Lett. 13 4877–4883
  33. [33]Kim D, Lee C, Jang B G, Kim K and Shim J H 2021 Sci. Rep. 11(1) 17567
  34. [34]May A F, Du M H, Cooper V R and McGuire M A 2020 Phys. Rev. Mater. 4 074008
  35. [35]Cococcioni M and de Gironcoli S 2005 Phys. Rev. B 71(3) 035105
  36. [36]Shen Z X, Bo X, Cao K, Wan X and He L 2021 Phys. Rev. B 103(8) 085102
  37. [37]May A F, Calder S, Cantoni C, Cao H and McGuire M A 2016 Phys. Rev. B 93(1) 014411
  38. [38]Verchenko V Y, Tsirlin A A, Sobolev A V, Presniakov I A and Shelkov A V 2015 Inorg. Chem. 54(17) 8598–8607
  39. [39]Chen B, Yang J, Wang H, Imai M, Ohta H, Michioka C, Yoshimura K and Fang M 2013 Journal of the Physical Society of Japan 82 124711
  40. [40]Ribeiro M, Gentile G, Marty A, Dosenovic D, Okuno H, Vergnaud C, Jacquot J F, Jalabert D, Longo D, Ohresser P, Hallal A, Chshiev M, Boulle O, Bonell F and Jamet M 2022 npj 2D Mater. and Appl. 6(1) 10
  41. [41]Deng Y, Yu Y, Song Y, Zhang J, Wang N Z, Sun Z, Yi Y, Wu Y Z, Wu S, Zhu J, Wang J, Chen X H and Zhang Y 2018 Nature 563(67729) 94–99
  42. [42]Georges A, Kotliar G, Krauth W and Rozenberg M J 1996 Rev. Mod. Phys. 68(1) 13–125
  43. [43]Pourovsskii L V, Katsnelson M I and Lichtenstein A I 2005 Phys. Rev. B 72(11) 115106
  44. [44]Wills J, Eriksson O, Alouani M and Price D 2000 Full-Potential LMTO Total Energy and Force Calculations (Berlin, Heidelberg: Springer Berlin Heidelberg)
  45. [45]Georges A, Kotliar G, Krauth W and Rozenberg M J 1996 Rev. Mod. Phys. 68(1) 13–125
  46. [46]Turkowski V, Kabir A, Nayyar N and Rahman T S 2012 J. Chem. Phys. 136 114108
  47. [47]Kim T J, Ryee S, Han M J and Choi S 2020 2D Materials 7 035023
  48. [48]Zhou Z, Pandey S K and Feng J 2021 Phys. Rev. B 103(3) 035137
  49. [49]Kvashnin Y O, Rudenko A N, Thunström P, Rösner M and Katsnelson M I 2022 Phys. Rev. B 105(20) 205124
  50. [50]Hu X, Zhao Y, Shen X, Krasheninnikov A V and Chen Zhongfang andSun L 2020 ACS Appl. Mater. Interfaces 12(23) 26367–26373
  51. [51]Zhao M, Chen B B, Xi Y, Zhao Y, Xu H, Zhang H, Cheng N, Feng H, Zhuang J, Pan F, Xu X, Hao W, Li W, Zhou S, Dou S X and Du Y 2021 Nano Lett. 21(14) 6117–6123
  52. [52]Zhang Y, Lu H, Zhu X, Tan S, Feng W, Liu Q, Zhang W, Chen Q, Liu Y, Luo X, Xie D, Luo L, Zhang Z and Lai X 2018 Sci. Adv. 4 eaao6791
  53. [53]Yang X, Zhou X, Feng W and Yao Y 2021 Phys. Rev. B 104(10) 104427
  54. [54]Li Z, Xia W, Su H, Yu Z, Fu Y, Chen L, Wang X, Yu N, Zou Z and Guo Y 2020 Sci. Reports 10(1) 15345
  55. [55]Fei Z, Huang B, Malinowski P, Wang W, Song T, Sanchez J, Yao W, Xiao D, Zhu X, May A F, Wu W, Cobden D H, Chu J H and Xu X 2018 Nat. Mater. 17(9) 778–782
  56. [56]Chakraborty A, Srivastava A K, Sharma A K, Gopi A K, Mohseni K, Ernst A, Deniz H, Hazra B K, Das S, Sessi P, Kostanovskiy I, Ma T, Meyerheim H L and Parkin S S P 2022 Adv. Mater. 34 2108637
  57. [57]Mayoh D A, Wood G D A, Holt S J R, Beckett G, Dekker E J L, Lees M R and Balakrishnan G 2021 Cryst. Growth Des. 21(12) 6786–6792
  58. [58]Kvashnin Y O, Grånäs O, Di Marco I, Katsnelson M I, Lichtenstein A I and Eriksson O 2015 Phys. Rev. B 91(12) 125133
  59. [59]Borisov V, Xu Q, Ntallis N, Clulow R, Shtender V, Cedervall J, Sahlberg M, Wikfeldt K T, Thonig D, Pereiro M, Bergman A, Delin A and Eriksson O 2022 Phys. Rev. Materials 6(8) 084401
  60. [60]1987 Journal of Magnetism and Magnetic Materials 67 65–74
  61. [61]Yi J, Zhuang H, Zou Q, Wu Z, Cao G, Tang S, Calder S A, Kent P R C, Mandrus D and Gai Z 2016 2D Mater. 4 011005
  62. [62]Kim D, Park S, Lee J, Yoon J, Joo S, Kim T, Joon Min K, Park S Y, Kim C, Moon K W, Lee C, Hong J and Hwang C 2019 Nanotechnology 30 245701
  63. [63]Jang S W, Yoon H, Jeong M Y, Ryee S, Kim H S and Han M J 2020 Nanoscale 12(25) 13501–13506
  64. [64]Roemer R, Liu C and Zou K 2020 npj 2D Mater. Appl. 4(1) 2397–7132
  65. [65]Zhu M, You Y, Xu G, Tang J, Gong Y and Xu F 2021 Intermetallics 131 107085
  66. [66]Kresse G and Joubert D 1999 Phys. Rev. B 59 1758
  67. [67]Kresse G and Hafner J 1994 J. Phys. Condens. Matter 6 8245
  68. [68]Perdew J P, Burke K and Ernzerhof M 1996 Phys. Rev. Lett. 77 3865
  69. [69]Monkhorst H J and Pack J D 1976 Phys. Rev. B 13 5188
  70. [70]Wills J M and Cooper B R 1987 Phys. Rev. B 36(7) 3809–3823
  71. [71]Grånäs O, Di Marco I, Thunström P, Nordström L, Eriksson O, Björkman T and Wills J 2012 Comput. Mater. Sci. 55 295–302 ISSN 0927-0256
  72. [72]Grechnev A, Di Marco I, Katsnelson M I, Lichtenstein A I, Wills J and Eriksson O 2007 Phys. Rev. B 76(3) 035107
  73. [73]Pourovsskii L V, Katsnelson M I and Lichtenstein A I 2005 Phys. Rev. B 72(11) 115106
  74. [74]Lichtenstein A I, Katsnelson M I and Kotliar G 2001 Phys. Rev. Lett. 87(6) 067205
  75. [75]Kvashnin Y O, Bergman A, Lichtenstein A I and Katsnelson M I 2020 Phys. Rev. B 102(11) 115162
  76. [77]Eriksson O, Bergman A, Bergqvist L and Hellsvik J 2017 Atomistic Spin Dynamics: Foundations and Applications (Oxford university press)
  77. [78]Dudarev S L, Botton G A, Savrasov S Y, Humphreys C J and Sutton A P 1998 Phys. Rev. B 57(3) 1505–1509

Paper details

vlnc:W_78wdct5w
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents