Let M=S2×S2. We prove that there is a fixed smooth open ball U⊂M such that, for every ε>0, one can find a smooth metric gε and a closed set Sε with the following properties: secgε>0 on M∖Sε; the relative volume of Sε is less than ε; every sectional curvature on U is greater than 1; −ε<secgε≤Λ for one constant Λ independent of ε; the volume and diameter have uniform positive lower and upper bounds; and the injectivity radius has a uniform positive lower bound. In fact, U∩Sε=∅. The construction starts from the product of the unit round metrics. A small conformal factor, obtained by smoothing the absolute value of the height function on each sphere, has negative definite Hessian away from two thin equatorial bands. It makes every formerly flat mixed plane strictly positive outside a set of arbitrarily small relative volume, while the negative curvature created in the bands is only O(ε). A second conformal deformation supported in a very small region produces a core on which all sectional curvatures are greater than 1; its transition has Hessian bounded above by O(ε). Finally, a diffeomorphism compresses the fixed topological ball U into that core. Pullback preserves all intrinsic bounded-geometry estimates. The main content of this paper is generated by ChatGPT 5.6 and verified by the author.
Introduction and Statement
The main purpose of this paper is to try to produce a metric on S2×S2 with quasi-positive sectional curvature, which is not successful. We note that recently Brendle and Hung constructed metrics with positive sectional curvature on S2×S2, resolving the Hopf conjecture [1]. However, since the metrics constructed in this paper is relatively simple and explicit, we post it as a note of independent interest. Main techniques used in this paper can be found in standard textbooks like [2, 3].
Acknowledgement: the author thanks Xi’an Jiaotong-Liverpool University for providing financial and academic support. He also thanks Zipei Nie for providing access to ChatGPT and insights about AI usage. His gratitude also goes to his daughter and son who were born last year, and all of his family members who have always been supportive during his academic career.
Let h be the unit round metric on S2, and put
g0=h⊕honM=S2×S2.
An open ball below means a subset diffeomorphic to the standard open 4-ball; it is fixed as a subset of the smooth manifold and is not required to have a fixed intrinsic radius for the varying metrics.
Theorem 1.1. There exist a smooth open ball U⊂M and constants
0<v−≤v+<∞,0<d−≤d+<∞,i0>0,Λ<∞,
such that, for every ε>0, there are a smooth Riemannian metric gε on M and a closed subset Sε⊂M satisfying
secgε>0 on M∖Sε;
2.
Vol(M,gε)Vol(Sε,gε)<ε;
U∩Sε=∅, and every two-plane based at a point of U has sectional curvature greater than 1;
4.
−ε<secgε≤Λon M;
5.
v−≤Vol(M,gε)≤v+,d−≤diam(M,gε)≤d+;
inj(M,gε)≥i0.
The freedom removed from the earlier one-region formulation is crucial. The exceptional set constructed here is distributed along two thin equatorial slabs, together with one small transition annulus. Its volume tends to zero, but it is not forced to have small diameter.
The product metric and conformal curvature
For a two-plane P⊂T(x,y)M, choose a g0-orthonormal basis X=(X1,X2), Y=(Y1,Y2). The product curvature tensor gives
secg0(P)=∣X1∧Y1∣h2+∣X2∧Y2∣h2.(1)
Hence
0≤secg0≤1.(2)
The zero-curvature planes are precisely the mixed planes.
We shall repeatedly use the conformal curvature formula. If
g=e2fg
and e1,e2 are g-orthonormal vectors spanning P, then
Let z:S2→[−1,1] be the height function. For the unit round metric,
∣∇z∣2=1−z2,Hesshz=−zh.(5)
Choose once and for all an even nonnegative function β∈Cc∞((−1,1)) with ∫Rβ=1, and put
βδ(t)=δ−1β(t/δ),ψδ=∣⋅∣∗βδ,0<δ<41.
Let
Cβ=2∥β∥∞.
Lemma 3.1. The function ψδ is smooth, even and convex, and it satisfies
(i) ψδ(t)=∣t∣ whenever ∣t∣≥δ;
(ii) ∣ψδ′∣≤1, tψδ′(t)≥0, and
0≤ψδ′′(t)≤δCβ;
(iii) 0<ψδ(t)≤1+δ for ∣t∣≤1.
If ϕδ=ψδ∘z, then
Hesshϕδ=ψδ′′(z)dz⊗dz−zψδ′(z)h.(6)
Consequently, as quadratic forms,
−h≤Hesshϕδ≤δCβh,∣∇ϕδ∣≤1,(7)
and on {∣z∣>δ},
Hesshϕδ=−∣z∣h≤−δh.(8)
Proof. Convolution preserves smoothness, evenness and convexity. If t≥δ, then t−s≥0 for every s in the support of βδ, and the evenness of βδ gives
ψδ(t)=∫(t−s)βδ(s)ds=t.
The case t≤−δ is identical. Since the distributional second derivative of ∣t∣ is twice the Dirac mass at the origin,
ψδ′′=2βδ.
The remaining one-dimensional assertions follow immediately. Formula (6) follows from the chain rule and (5). Because zψδ′(z)≥0, the second term in (6) is nonpositive. The upper bound follows from dz⊗dz≤h, and the lower bound follows from ∣zψδ′(z)∣≤1. On ∣z∣>δ one has ψδ(z)=∣z∣, which gives (8). □
For Eδ={∣z∣≤δ}⊂S2, spherical coordinates give
Area(S2,h)Area(Eδ,h)=δ.(9)
Define the two equatorial slabs
Σδ=(Eδ×S2)∪(S2×Eδ).(10)
Then
Vol(M,g0)Vol(Σδ,g0)=2δ−δ2<2δ.(11)
For a>0, set
ua,δ(x,y)=a(ϕδ(x)+ϕδ(y)).(12)
Lemma 3.1 gives
−ag0≤Hessg0ua,δ≤δaCβg0,∣∇ua,δ∣2≤2a2,(13)
and, on M∖Σδ,
Hessg0ua,δ≤−aδg0.(14)
Proposition 3.2. If 0<a<δ, then the metric
gˉa,δ=e2ua,δg0
has strictly positive sectional curvature on M∖Σδ. Globally,
secgˉa,δ≥−δ2aCβ−2a2,(15)
and
secgˉa,δ≤1+2a+2a2.(16)
Proof. Apply (3) with g=g0 and f=ua,δ. On M∖Σδ, (14), (4), and (2) give
e2ua,δsecgˉa,δ(P)≥2aδ−2a2>0.
The global lower bound follows from the upper Hessian estimate in (13). For the upper bound, use
Hessua,δ≥−ag0
and
du(e1)2+du(e2)2−∣∇u∣2≤∣∇u∣2.
Finally ua,δ≥0, so the factor e−2ua,δ never enlarges a positive upper bound or a negative lower bound in the estimates above. □
A bounded-curvature positive needle
We next construct a conformal factor whose Hessian is strongly negative on a very small core, while its positive Hessian is arbitrarily small everywhere.
Lemma 4.1 (local needle). Let (N,g) be a smooth closed Riemannian manifold and let q∈N. There are constants
R∗>0,c∗>0,C∗>1,
depending only on (N,g,q), with the following property. For every 0<σ≤1 and every 0<R≤R∗ there is a smooth function w=wσ,R:N→[0,∞) such that
w=0 outside Bg(q,R) and in a neighborhood of its boundary;
−C∗g≤Hessgw≤σg;
for some ρ≥c∗σR,
Hessgw≤−3gon Bg(q,ρ);
4.
∣dw∣g≤C∗σR,0≤w≤C∗σR2.
Proof. Let r=distg(q,⋅). After decreasing R∗, geodesic polar coordinates are smooth on 0<r<R∗ and
Hessgr=r1(g−dr2)+Er,∣Er∣g≤Cr.(17)
for a fixed constant C. Equivalently, Hessg(r2/2)=g+O(r2).
We construct a one-variable function F. Put A=4. Choose smooth functions α:[0,∞)→[0,1] and γ∈Cc∞((0,1)) such that
α=1 on [0,1],α=0 on [2,∞),γ≥0,∫01γ=1.
Choose a sufficiently small fixed constant c>0 and put ℓ=cσR. Define
n(r)=−Aα(r/ℓ),D=−∫0Rn(s)ds,
and put a positive bump of total mass D in the interval (3ℓ,R−ℓ):
p(r)=R−4ℓDγ(R−4ℓr−3ℓ)
there, and p=0 elsewhere. Taking c small, independently of σ and R, ensures
0≤p≤4σ,4ℓ<R.
Set
q1=n+p,Q(r)=∫0rq1(s)ds.
The negative bump occurs before the positive one, the two total masses cancel, and therefore
Q≤0,Q=0 near R,∣Q∣≤C1σR.(18)
Moreover,
−A≤q1≤4σ,rQ(r)≥−C2A.(19)
Define
F(r)=−∫rRQ(s)ds.
Then F≥0, F′=Q, F′′=q1, and F=0 near R. On 0≤r≤ℓ one has
F(r)=F(0)−2Ar2.
The radial function w=F(r), extended by zero, is smooth at both q and ∂Bg(q,R). For r>0,
Hessgw=q1(r)dr2+Q(r)Hessgr.(20)
The main tangential term Q(r)r−1(g−dr2) is nonpositive. The error in (17) has norm at most C∣Q∣r≤CC1σR2. Decrease R∗ so that this is at most 3σ/4. Equations (19) and (20) then give Hessw≤σg, while their lower bounds give Hessw≥−C∗g for a fixed C∗. On r≤ℓ,
Hessgw=−AHessg(r2/2).
After one more decrease of R∗, this is at most −3g. Thus one may take ρ=ℓ=cσR. Finally, (18) gives
∣dw∣=∣Q∣≤C∗σR,0≤w≤Rmax∣Q∣≤C∗σR2.
Construction before the final pullback
Let N∈S2 be the north pole and set
q=(N,N)∈M.
Apply Lemma 4.1 to (M,g0,q), and retain its constants R∗,c∗,C∗. Decrease R∗ so that Bg0(q,R∗) is disjoint from Σδ for every 0<δ≤1/100.
Choose a small constant τ0∈(0,1), to be fixed below. Given ε>0, put
Thus the volume and diameter of gτ have uniform positive lower and upper bounds. We also need a uniform injectivity-radius bound.
Lemma 6.1 (injectivity from first-order control). Let N be a closed manifold and gj a family of smooth metrics. Assume that
(i) the gj are uniformly bilipschitz to one fixed smooth metric;
(ii) in one fixed finite coordinate atlas, the Christoffel symbols of the gj are uniformly bounded;
(iii) secgj≤Λ for one constant Λ.
Then inj(N,gj) has a uniform positive lower bound.
Proof. By the Rauch comparison theorem, the conjugate radius is bounded below by a positive constant depending only on Λ. If the injectivity radii tended to zero, the standard injectivity-radius lemma would therefore produce geodesic loops γj:[0,Lj]→N with Lj→0.
Uniform bilipschitz control implies that each sufficiently short loop lies in one chart of the fixed finite atlas. Parametrize by gj-arclength and write its coordinates as xj(t). Uniform ellipticity gives constants c,C>0 such that
c≤∣x˙j(t)∣≤C.
The geodesic equation and the uniform Christoffel bound give ∣x¨j(t)∣≤A for one constant A. Since xj(Lj)=xj(0),
For a conformal metric e2fg0, the Levi-Civita connections are related by
∇XY=∇X0Y+df(X)Y+df(Y)X−g0(X,Y)∇0f.(31)
Thus (24) gives a uniform Christoffel bound in a fixed atlas. Lemma 6.1, Proposition 5.1, and (30) therefore give
inj(M,gτ)≥i0>0(32)
for one constant i0 independent of τ.
It remains to place the uniformly positively curved core over one fixed open ball. Choose once and for all a small g0-geodesic ball
U=Bg0(q,rU)
whose closure is contained in a normal coordinate neighborhood of q. For every τ, there is a diffeomorphism
Fτ:M⟶M
such that
Fτ(U)⊂Bg0(q,ρ/2).(33)
Indeed, in polar coordinates about q, use a smooth increasing radial map that sends [0,rU] into [0,ρ/2] and agrees with the identity outside a slightly larger fixed coordinate ball.
For the original parameter ε, with τ as in (21), set
gε=Fτ∗gτ,Sε=Fτ−1(Sτ).(34)
The map
Fτ:(M,gε)⟶(M,gτ)
is an isometry. Therefore all sectional-curvature bounds, relative volumes, total volumes, diameters, and injectivity radii are unchanged. Equations (33) and (27) also give U∩Sε=∅, while Proposition 5.1 gives secgε>1 on U.
Taking, for example,
v−=Vol(M,g0),v+=e2/5Vol(M,g0),
d−=diam(M,g0),d+=e1/10diam(M,g0),
and using (29), (32), and Proposition 5.1, proves Theorem 1.1. Notice that when ε≥τ0, one has τ=τ0; then −τ0>−ε and the relative-volume estimate <τ0≤ε still gives the required assertions.
Why this does not produce a quasi-positively curved limit
The construction exploits two freedoms that are absent from a genuine compactness argument. First, the set Σδ is thin in volume but spread across the manifold. It intersects the closed directions that obstruct the existence of a globally strictly concave function, while its relative volume tends to zero. The positive curvature created outside it is very small, of order aδ.
Second, the region on which all sectional curvatures exceed 1 has intrinsic size tending to zero before the final pullback. The diffeomorphism Fτ places the fixed topological ball U over that shrinking core without changing any intrinsic global bound. Consequently the final metrics need not be precompact in C2 in the fixed differentiable gauge. The family therefore does not yield a quasi-positively curved limit metric on S2×S2.
References
References
[1]S. Brendle, P-K. Hung, A Metric on S^2 × S^2 with Positive Sectional Curvature, arXiv:2608.19068v1, 2026.arxiv.org/abs/2608.19068
[2]W. Klingenberg, Riemannian Geometry, second edition, de Gruyter, 1995.
[3]P. Petersen, Riemannian Geometry, third edition, Graduate Texts in Mathematics 171, Springer, 2016.