betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Three New Phases in the Two-Dimensional Potts Model at Complex Temperature

Abstract

The complex-temperature phase structure of the two-dimensional Potts model has remained largely unresolved despite decades of study. Here we determine the complex-temperature phase diagram of the 3-state Potts model, and uncover three gapless phases beyond the familiar ferromagnetic and paramagnetic phases. This is done by combining tensor-network free energies with the Poisson equation to compute the Fisher zero density in the thermodynamic limit. The resulting zero distribution unifies and revises long-standing conjectures on the zero loci, and outlines each phase. One is a non-conformal gapless phase, with an exponentially growing number of low-lying transfer-matrix levels distributed across all momentum sectors. The other two are Luttinger-liquid phases with complex-valued Luttinger parameters related by the Kramers-Wannier duality. At the antiferromagnetic critical point, the Luttinger parameter equals 3, while its limit from the adjacent Luttinger-liquid phase is 6. These findings reveal rich phase structures and unconventional critical behavior in a classical textbook model.

Introduction

The two-dimensional Potts model has been a versatile cornerstone of statistical mechanics [1]. It provides a unified setting for continuous and first-order phase transitions [2] and a testing ground of various theories and algorithms, connecting to gas adsorption [3, 4, 5], percolation and graph coloring [6]. Beyond its well-established real-temperature criticality, decades of study have revealed additional structures in the complex-temperature regime, including the antiferromagnetic (AFM) critical point [7] and its dual point [8, 9], the Berker–Kadanoff (BK) fixed point [10], and critical points described by complex conformal field theories (CFTs) [11, 12, 13, 14]. These findings suggest a rich phase structure at complex temperature. Yet even for the 3-state model without external field, the complex-temperature phase diagram is still unsettled [15, 16]. Whether a third phase exists beyond the ferromagnetic (FM) and paramagnetic (PM) ones has remained an open question.

The Yang–Lee theory provides a universal framework to study systems with complex variables [17, 18, 19]. It relates phases and phase transitions to the partition-function zeros on the complex plane, which typically coalesce into curves that delineate phase boundaries in the thermodynamic limit. These zeros can be observed experimentally [20, 21, 22, 23]. Their distribution not only encodes transition orders and critical exponents [24, 25, 26], but also connects to dynamical quantum phase transitions [27], quantum many-body scars [28], and the fermion sign problem [29]. However, computing these zeros for generic interacting models remains challenging, with exact calculations often limited to small lattices [16, 30, 31, 32].

For Fisher zeros, i.e., partition function zeros on the complex-temperature plane, this challenge is further compounded, since they often form exotic topologies and even dense areas in the absence of the Lee–Yang circle theorem [33, 34, 35, 36]. In this field, the square-lattice Potts model is a paradigmatic system, whose intricate Fisher zero distribution has attracted persisting interest and motivated numerous conjectures [15, 16, 32, 37, 38]. However, strong finite-size effects obscure which structures will survive in the thermodynamic limit [16].

In this Letter, we combine tensor-network free energies with the Poisson equation to compute the global Fisher zero density of the 3-state Potts model. This approach works directly in the thermodynamic limit and requires no a priori knowledge of the zero loci. The resulting zero distribution unifies and revises long-standing conjectures, identifies the BK fixed point as a triple point, and reveals a complex-temperature phase diagram featuring three gapless phases. One is non-conformal, with a number of low-lying transfer-matrix levels that grows exponentially with LL in every momentum sector. The other two belong to the Luttinger-liquid (LL) universality class described by c=1c=1 compact-boson CFT. Their complex-valued Luttinger parameters and phase-diagram regions are related by the Kramers–Wannier (KW) duality. We also find that at the AFM critical point, an imaginary thermal perturbation drives the renormalization-group (RG) flow away from the LL fixed line and back to it at a distant fixed point, yielding a sharp discontinuity in the Luttinger parameter.

Model and Methods

The energy of the classical Potts model is defined as E({σj})=−J∑⟨jk⟩δσjσkE(\{\sigma_j\}) = -J \sum_{\langle jk\rangle} \delta_{\sigma_j\sigma_k}, where σj∈{1,…,q}\sigma_j \in\{1,\ldots,q\} is the integer-valued spin. When q=2q = 2, it reduces to the Ising model. Here, we focus on the q=3q = 3 case on the square lattice. Using the conventional variable z≡eβJz \equiv e^{\beta J}, the partition function

Z(z)=∑{σj}e−βE({σj})=∑{σj}∏⟨jk⟩zδσjσk(1)Z(z) = \sum_{\{\sigma_j\}} e^{-\beta E(\{\sigma_j\})} = \sum_{\{\sigma_j\}} \prod_{\langle jk\rangle} z^{\delta_{\sigma_j\sigma_k}} \tag*{(1)}

is a polynomial of zz. The number of its zeros on the complex zz-plane is proportional to the number of lattice sites NN. In the thermodynamic limit, the normalized zero density ρ(z)\rho(z) satisfies the Poisson equation [35, 39, 40, 41]

ρ(z)=−12π∇2Re⁡f(z),(2)\rho(z) = -\frac{1}{2\pi}\nabla^2 \operatorname{Re} f(z), \tag*{(2)}

where f(z)≡−lim⁡N→∞1Nln⁡Z(z)f(z) \equiv-\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{N}\ln Z(z) is the dimensionless free energy per site. The KW duality implies that f(z⋆)=f(z)+2ln⁡(z−1)−ln⁡3f(z^\star) = f(z) + 2\ln(z-1) - \ln3, where z⋆≡1+3/(z−1)z^\star\equiv1 + 3/(z-1) is the KW dual of zz [1]. The zero density thus satisfies ρ(z⋆)=∣z−1∣4ρ(z)/9\rho(z^\star) = |z-1|^4\rho(z)/9, which we exploit to identify and suppress numerical artifacts [42].

Tensor network methods provide a powerful route to access complex partition functions in the thermodynamic limit [43, 44]. Here, we use a synergistic framework of four complementary algorithms. The bond-weighted tensor renormalization group (BWTRG) [45] is adopted to compute Re⁡f(z)\operatorname{Re} f(z) on a dense zz-grid, yielding ρ(z)\rho(z) via the discrete Laplacian. We also use the infinite density matrix renormalization group (iDMRG) [46, 47, 48] to compare free energies of different phases. To characterize each phase, we use the Loop-TNR algorithm [49] to extract CFT data [50, 51, 52] and the exact diagonalization (ED) method to compute transfer-matrix spectra at finite lattice widths. All numerical implementations are based on the Julia QuantumKitHub ecosystem [53, 54, 55, 56, 57].

Fisher Zeros

Baxter’s exact results have identified the FM critical point zFM=1+3z_{\mathrm{FM}} = 1 + \sqrt{3}, the AFM critical point zAFM=0z_{\mathrm{AFM}} = 0, and its KW dual zAFM⋆=−2z^\star_{\mathrm{AFM}} = -2 [2, 8]. According to the Yang–Lee theory, they must be accumulation points of zeros. Chen, Hu, and Wu conjectured that all zeros with Re⁡(z)>1\operatorname{Re}(z) > 1 lie on the self-dual circle ∣z−1∣=3|z - 1| = \sqrt{3} in the thermodynamic limit, which is strongly supported by finite-size calculations [37]. In the remaining region, the zero distribution is elusive. Jacobsen, Richard, and Salas (JRS) conjectured that zero curves pass through or close to the BK fixed point zBK≡1−3z_{\mathrm{BK}} \equiv1 - \sqrt{3}, and pass through zJRS≡(−1±3i)/2z_{\mathrm{JRS}} \equiv(-1 \pm\sqrt{3}i)/2 [15]. Matveev and Shrock (MS) identified a singularity at zMS≈−1.71±1.46iz_{\mathrm{MS}} \approx-1.71 \pm1.46i via the low-temperature series expansion, and conjectured from finite-size zeros that zMSz_{\mathrm{MS}} is an endpoint of a zero arc [38]. These zz points are summarized in Figure 1(a), with Fisher zeros for 12×1212 \times12 lattices in Figure 1(b) for comparison. One cannot infer how many zero curves will intersect the real zz-axis, and whether the zeros will coalesce into curves or areas.

Complex $z$ points, Fisher zeros, zero density, and free-energy competition

Figure 1. (a) Complex zz points relevant to established results and conjectures. (b) Fisher zeros obtained from finite-size partition functions. (c) Zero density ρ(z)\rho(z) computed by BWTRG. Regions with ρ(z)<10−2\rho(z) < 10^{-2} are colored in black for simplicity. The inset shows the Re⁡f(z)\operatorname{Re} f(z) landscape. (d) ρ(z)\rho(z) and Im⁡f(z)\operatorname{Im} f(z) near zBKz_{\mathrm{BK}} computed by iDMRG. (e) Free-energy competition among the three phases near zBKz_{\mathrm{BK}} along Im⁡(z)=0.03\operatorname{Im}(z) = 0.03. Phase boundaries remain almost unchanged as χ\chi increases.

To directly compute the zero distribution in the thermodynamic limit, we use BWTRG with bond dimension χ=72\chi= 72. The resulting ρ(z)\rho(z) reproduces the self-dual circle, and exhibits a “butterfly” pattern on the left Figure 1(c). Three pairs of zero curves intersect at zBKz_{\mathrm{BK}}, zAFMz_{\mathrm{AFM}}, and zAFM⋆z^\star_{\mathrm{AFM}}, respectively, forming three X-shaped structures. Away from the real zz-axis, they converge at zJRSz_{\mathrm{JRS}}. These features are robust under different χ\chi and algorithms, strongly supporting the JRS conjectures on zBKz_{\mathrm{BK}} and zJRSz_{\mathrm{JRS}}.

While the zeros coalesce into curves, they also form areal density on the “wing tips” of the butterfly. Note that zMSz_{\mathrm{MS}} lies in the interior of a dense-zero area, rather than the previously conjectured endpoint. Why the paradox? Our explanation is that the series expansion only describes the analytic behavior of a single phase, but zero curves are generally determined by two or more adjacent phases [58]. A singularity of the continued phase may occur where the phase is metastable. In such a case, it need not appear in f(z)f(z) and ρ(z)\rho(z).

Intuitively, one may doubt that the two zero curves connecting zBKz_{\mathrm{BK}} and zJRSz_{\mathrm{JRS}} seem too close. Do they truly sandwich a phase, or will they merge into a single curve on the self-dual circle as χ→∞\chi\to\infty? To answer this question, we compute f(z)f(z) near zBKz_{\mathrm{BK}} using iDMRG. The resulting ρ(z)\rho(z) and Im⁡f(z)\operatorname{Im} f(z) show that zBKz_{\mathrm{BK}} is indeed a triple point Figure 1(d). We further compare the three competing free-energy branches from z=−0.76+0.03iz=-0.76+0.03\mathrm{i} to −0.70+0.03i-0.70+0.03\mathrm{i} with increasing χ\chi Figure 1(e). At each zz, the branch with the smallest Re⁡f(z)\operatorname{Re} f(z) is stable and dominates the partition function [58]. Our results show that the sandwiched phase remains stable in a finite interval, which does not narrow as χ\chi increases.

Phase Diagram

The zero curves and areas partition the complex zz-plane into zero-free regions. Each of them represents a phase, in which f(z)f(z) varies analytically. For instance, the two regions containing zFM−z_{\mathrm{FM}}^{-} and zFM+z_{\mathrm{FM}}^{+} represent the well-studied PM and FM phases, respectively. Next, we will identify two gapped phases, a non-conformal gapless (NCG) phase, and two conformal gapless phases of the LL universality class, as summarized in Figure 2(a). Here “gap” refers to the radial structure of the transfer-matrix spectrum {λα}\{\lambda_\alpha\}. We say the system is gapless if infinitely many eigenvalues satisfy ln⁡∣λ0/λα∣→0\ln|\lambda_0/\lambda_\alpha| \to0 as L→∞L \to\infty, where λ0\lambda_0 denotes the dominant eigenvalue. It is useful to define the “level”, i.e., the rescaled transfer-matrix gap

Figure 2. (a) Complex-temperature phase diagram of the 3-state Potts model. (b) Transfer-matrix levels DD, effective central charges cc, and Luttinger parameters KfitK_{\mathrm{fit}} computed via Loop-TNR. Real parts of Eq. (4) are labeled as (n,m)(n,m), whose descendants are indicated by orange arrows. (c) Transfer-matrix spectrum {λα}\{\lambda_\alpha\} computed by ED (L=12L=12) at representative zz points. Black solid lines denote the unit circle. The NCG phase exhibits a “snowflake” spectrum distinct from both the gapped phases and the LL phases.

Dα=L2πln⁡∣λ0λα∣.(3)D_\alpha= \frac{L}{2\pi}\ln\left|\frac{\lambda_0}{\lambda_\alpha}\right|. \tag*{(3)}

In a gapped system, a finite number of Dα→0D_\alpha\to0 while others go to infinity. In a system described by a CFT, low-lying levels satisfy Dα→Re⁡(Δα−Δ0)D_\alpha\to\operatorname{Re}(\Delta_\alpha-\Delta_0), where Δα\Delta_\alpha is the operator scaling dimension [59, 60].

We run the Loop-TNR algorithm with χ=30\chi=30 at different zz points. In the yellow (gray) regions of Figure 2(a), Loop-TNR converges to the high (low)-temperature trivial fixed point, where all transfer-matrix eigenvalues collapse to 0 except for a nondegenerate (threefold degenerate) λ0\lambda_0, signifying a PM (FM) gapped phase. In the cyan and purple regions, the RG flow is attracted to nontrivial fixed points, where the low-lying {ln⁡(λ0/λα)}\{\ln(\lambda_0/\lambda_\alpha)\} exhibit integer ratios and descendant structures Figure 2(b) and Figure S1. Their values and symmetry are consistent with the LL (c=1c=1 compact-boson) universality class [61], whose vertex primary operators have scaling dimensions [62]

Figure S1. (a)(b) Complex transfer-matrix levels D~α(τ)\widetilde{D}_{\alpha}^{(\tau)} extracted from Loop-TNR results. They exhibit integer ratios (solid gray lines), descendant structures (dashed gray lines), and parallelogram patterns. Theoretically, the spectra of {Dα(1)}\{D_{\alpha}^{(1)}\} and {Dα(−1)}\{D_{\alpha}^{(-1)}\} are identical by virtue of the σj↦−σj\sigma_j \mapsto-\sigma_j symmetry, and so are the Q=±1Q=\pm1 sectors. However, they differ when Loop-TNR fails to capture higher scaling dimensions due to the finiteness of χ\chi. For τ=0\tau=0, there is a family of Dα(τ)∝n2D_{\alpha}^{(\tau)} \propto n^2 and Q=n mod 3Q=n \bmod3. For the Q=0Q=0 sector, there is also a family of Dα(τ)∝m2D_{\alpha}^{(\tau)} \propto m^2 and τ=m mod 3\tau=m \bmod3. (c)(d) Complex scaling dimensions Δnm(τ)\Delta_{nm}^{(\tau)} (red circles) of the LL predicted by Eq. (9) and their descendants (yellow circles). They are consistent with the low-lying Dα(τ)D_{\alpha}^{(\tau)} (purple dots) obtained via Loop-TNR.

Δnm=n22K+m2K2(n,m∈Z),(4)\Delta_{nm}=\frac{n^2}{2K}+\frac{m^2K}{2}\qquad(n,m\in\mathbb{Z}), \tag*{(4)}

where K∈CK\in\mathbb{C} is the Luttinger parameter. We identify nn mod 3 with the global Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 charge, and mm with the winding number. Under the convention Re⁡(β)>0\operatorname{Re}(\beta)>0, the cyan and purple regions satisfy J>0J>0 and J<0J<0, respectively. We therefore refer to them as the “FM-LL” and “AFM-LL” phases. These two regions are mapped to each other under the KW duality, and their Luttinger parameters satisfy K(z)K(z∗)=9K(z)K(z^*)=9, as derived in End Matter.

In the sandwiched pink region, Loop-TNR fails due to an extremely dense singular-value spectrum. We resort to ED to compute finite-width (L=12L=12) spectra at representative zz points Figure 2(c). In the gapped phases, the degeneracy of λ0\lambda_0 is consistent with the Loop-TNR spectra. In the LL phases, near-dominant eigenvalues scatter sparsely, corresponding to scaling operators. Remarkably, the sandwiched phase exhibits a “snowflake” spectrum distinct from both behaviors. At z=−0.7−0.3iz=-0.7-0.3\mathrm{i}, there are LL dominant eigenvalues with evenly spaced arguments, each accompanied by a dense cluster of near-dominant eigenvalues. The spectrum at zJRSz_{\mathrm{JRS}} is more exotic, with all eigenvalues lying on the dominant circle. This exact equimodularity has been noticed by JRS [15], and is rigorously proved here for arbitrary LL and any boundary condition (see End Matter). Consequently, the system at zJRSz_{\mathrm{JRS}} is NCG, since all Dα=0D_\alpha=0 is incompatible with the essential descendant structure in any CFT. In the following, we will demonstrate numerically that the sandwiched phase is also NCG.

Non-Conformal Gaplessness

We study the finite-size behavior of {Dα}\{D_\alpha\} at z=−0.7−0.3iz=-0.7-0.3\mathrm{i}. Figure 3(a) shows that for the LL phases, the total number of eigenvalues satisfying Dα<1.5D_\alpha<1.5 has an upper bound, which is the expected behavior of compact CFTs. In stark contrast, this number increases exponentially with LL at z=−0.7−0.3iz=-0.7-0.3\mathrm{i}. Although non-compact CFTs can have continuous scaling-dimension spectra and densifying {Dα}\{D_\alpha\}, e.g., Dα∼(ln⁡L)−2D_\alpha\sim(\ln L)^{-2} [63], it is still difficult to explain the exponential densification of {Dα}\{D_\alpha\}.

Figure 3. (a) The number of transfer-matrix eigenvalues with Dα<1.5D_\alpha<1.5. At the representative NCG point z=−0.7−0.3iz=-0.7-0.3\mathrm{i}, only near-dominant eigenvalues are numerically accessible for L>12L>12, so the corresponding counts are not shown. (b) Transfer-matrix levels evaluated at z=−0.3iz=-0.3\mathrm{i}. Low-lying DαD_\alpha stabilize to their corresponding Re⁡(Δα)\operatorname{Re}(\Delta_\alpha), and the momentum distribution concentrates to P=0P=0 and π\pi. (c) The proportion of momentum sectors in which at least one eigenvalue satisfies Dα<0.1D_\alpha<0.1. (d) Transfer-matrix levels evaluated at z=−0.7−0.3iz=-0.7-0.3\mathrm{i}. Panels for L≥14L\geq14 are vertically zoomed in for clarity. No size-independent level structure emerges, and the momentum distribution does not concentrate to one or more centers.

We further resolve the transfer-matrix spectrum into LL momentum sectors. We say that a transfer-matrix eigenvector has momentum pp if its eigenvalue under circumferential translation is eip\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}p}, which satisfies eipL=1\mathrm{e}^{\mathrm{i}pL}=1. If the system is described by a CFT in the continuum limit, the distribution of {(Dα,pα)}\{(D_\alpha,p_\alpha)\} is anchored by the conformal spectrum {(Δα,sα)}\{(\Delta_\alpha,s_\alpha)\} as pα=P+2πsα/L+o(L−1)p_\alpha=P+2\pi s_\alpha/L+o(L^{-1}), where sαs_\alpha is the conformal spin and PP is the momentum offset [60]. For instance, the AFM-LL phase has P=0P=0 and π\pi, with {(Dα,pα)}\{(D_\alpha,p_\alpha)\} concentrating to them [Fig. 3(b)]. Let γ0.1\gamma_{0.1} denote the proportion of momentum sectors in which at least one eigenvalue satisfies Dα<0.1D_\alpha<0.1. As shown in Figure 3(c), we have γ0.1→0\gamma_{0.1}\to0 in the LL phases, while γ0.1=1\gamma_{0.1}=1 holds for every accessible LL at z=−0.7−0.3iz=-0.7-0.3\mathrm{i}. Figure 3(d) further shows that this behavior is likely to persist as LL increases. A CFT interpretation would therefore require an infinite number of primary operators satisfying Re⁡(Δα−Δ0)<0.1\operatorname{Re}(\Delta_\alpha-\Delta_0)<0.1, and either their {sα}\{s_\alpha\} is unbounded or their {P}\{P\} is dense throughout the Brillouin zone. To our knowledge, no concrete CFT has such spectral features. Together with the absence of a clear Casimir scaling of λ0\lambda_0, these results provide strong evidence for an NCG phase.

Discontinuity at the AFM Point

Having identified the AFM-LL phase, we now examine how it meets the AFM critical point. Previous studies have shown that zAFM=0z_{\mathrm{AFM}}=0 also belongs to the LL universality class with K(0)=3K(0)=3 [64], and that two scaling operators are excited under the thermal perturbation [65]: one is a relevant vortex operator with RG eigenvalue yt=1/2y_t=1/2, and the other is strictly marginal. At positive temperature, the relevant operator prevents the RG flow from staying on the fixed line, so that zAFMz_{\mathrm{AFM}} does not extend to an LL phase.

Surprisingly, we find that under an imaginary perturbation, the RG flow initially leaves the LL fixed line but then returns to it at a distinct fixed point. At z=0.02iz=0.02\mathrm{i}, the Loop-TNR spectra remain close to K=3K=3 at first, and then cross over to K≈6K\approx6 [Fig. 4(a)]. By interpolating DαD_\alpha between RG steps, we extract the crossover step and corresponding lattice size L×L_\times at different zz points within the AFM-LL phase [Fig. 4(b)]. They scale as L×∼∣z∣−2L_\times\sim|z|^{-2}, consistent with yt=1/2y_t=1/2 and implying that the crossover will eventually occur for arbitrarily small Im⁡(z)>0\operatorname{Im}(z)>0. This establishes a twofold discontinuity K(i0+)=2K(0)=6K(\mathrm{i}0^+)=2K(0)=6, reflecting the noncommutativity of the thermodynamic limit and z→i0+z\to\mathrm{i}0^+. Similar phenomena occur at the KW dual point zAFM∗=−2z^*_{\mathrm{AFM}}=-2 where K(−2+i0+)=12K(−2)=1.5K(-2+\mathrm{i}0^+)=\frac{1}{2}K(-2)=1.5.

This jump can be understood from two known results.

First, the thermal perturbation at zAFMz_{\mathrm{AFM}} is described by a cosine potential added to the free-boson action, yielding the sine-Gordon model [66]. Second, for the sine-Gordon model, when the coefficient of the cosine potential is imaginary, the massless RG flow takes the Gaussian coupling from gUVg_{\mathrm{UV}} to gIR=2−gUVg_{\mathrm{IR}} = 2 - g_{\mathrm{UV}} [67]. Using our convention K=4/gK = 4/g, this corresponds to a flow from KUV=3K_{\mathrm{UV}} = 3 to KIR=6K_{\mathrm{IR}} = 6. In the K≈6K \approx6 regime, the aforementioned vortex operator becomes irrelevant and the LL phase is stabilized.

Implications and Outlook

By resolving the global Fisher zero distribution, our results unify and revise long-standing conjectures and establish a phase diagram featuring both conformal and non-conformal gapless phases. The two LL phases provide a concrete realization of the KW duality relating extended critical phases, beyond its familiar role in relating ordered and disordered phases. Recent studies have also shown that complex-temperature phases may represent metastable phases at real temperature, which are encoded in the partition function but absent from the real-temperature equilibrium phase diagram [68]. This motivates asking whether the AFM-LL phase has a metastable continuation to real temperature, and whether it can be stabilized by introducing suitable real-valued couplings. The rich phase structure also offers targets for quantum experiments. Quantum circuit protocols for measuring complex-temperature partition functions explicitly apply to two-dimensional Ising and Potts models [69]. It has been demonstrated that dense Fisher zeros of the anisotropic Ising model correspond to a spatially or temporally modulated phase [70]. Given recent measurements of Fisher zeros on quantum hardware [22, 23], we expect this route to enable experimental realizations of the complex-temperature Potts model and its gapless phases.

Acknowledgments

We thank Yi-Hua Dong, Ling Liu, Jia-Cheng Gao, Qing-Yang Zheng, and Wuji Han for helpful discussions. We are supported by the Science Challenge Project under Grant No. TZ02052013, the National Science Foundation of China under Grants No. 123B2048, 12522410, 12550005, 12234001, 12474215, 62321004, and the National Key Laboratory of Computational Physics under Grant No. SYSM-2026-WDZC-04. The computational resources were provided by the supercomputer center at Peking University, China.

End Matter

Transfer Matrix

Throughout the appendices, addition involving spins σj\sigma_j should be understood modulo 33. Denote the configuration of a lattice row by σ≡(σ1,…,σL)\boldsymbol{\sigma} \equiv(\sigma_1,\ldots,\sigma_L) and the transfer matrix by T(τ)\mathcal{T}^{(\tau)}, where τ∈{0,1,−1}\tau\in\{0,1,-1\} defines the twisted boundary condition σL+1=σ1+τ\sigma_{L+1} = \sigma_1 + \tau. The transfer-matrix element is determined by the energy change of adding a new row σ\boldsymbol{\sigma} adjacent to σ′\boldsymbol{\sigma}', as

⟨σ∣T(τ)∣σ′⟩≡e−β[−JU(τ)(σ)−JV(σ,σ′)](5)\langle\sigma|\mathcal{T}^{(\tau)}|\sigma'\rangle\equiv e^{-\beta[-J U^{(\tau)}(\sigma)-JV(\sigma,\sigma')]} \tag*{(5)}

where

U(τ)(σ)≡∑j=1Lδσjσj+1,V(σ,σ′)≡∑j=1Lδσjσj′(6)U^{(\tau)}(\boldsymbol{\sigma}) \equiv\sum_{j=1}^{L}\delta_{\sigma_j\sigma_{j+1}}, \qquad V(\boldsymbol{\sigma},\boldsymbol{\sigma}') \equiv\sum_{j=1}^{L}\delta_{\sigma_j\sigma'_j} \tag*{(6)}

are the numbers of satisfied bonds within a single row and between two adjacent rows, respectively. The spectra shown in Figure 2–Figure 4 are computed using the periodic boundary condition (τ=0)(\tau= 0). Note that T(0)\mathcal{T}^{(0)} commutes with the circumferential translation J\mathcal{J} and the cyclic spin-shift G\mathcal{G}, which are defined as

Figure 4. (a) Starting from z=0z=0 and 0.02i0.02\mathrm{i}, the RG flow terminates at LL fixed points with K=3K=3 and K≈6K\approx6, respectively. The transfer-matrix levels DnmD_{nm} corresponding to Δnm\Delta_{nm} are highlighted in blue, which undergo a crossover at z=0.02iz=0.02\mathrm{i}. (b) As zz becomes closer to 00, the crossover occurs at larger RG steps. (c) The RG step at which D10D_{10} and D20D_{20} intersect 0.1250.125 and 0.50.5, respectively. The crossover lengths extracted from both gaps scale as L×∼∣z∣−2L_\times\sim|z|^{-2}.

J∣σ⟩=∣(σL,σ1,⋯ ,σL−1)⟩(7)\mathcal{J}|\sigma\rangle= |(\sigma_L,\sigma_1,\cdots,\sigma_{L-1})\rangle \tag*{(7)}
G∣σ⟩=∣(σ1+1,σ2+1,⋯ ,σL+1)⟩.(8)\mathcal{G}|\sigma\rangle= |(\sigma_1+1,\sigma_2+1,\cdots,\sigma_L+1)\rangle. \tag*{(8)}

They satisfy JL=G3=I\mathcal{J}^{L} = \mathcal{G}^{3} = \mathcal{I}, where I\mathcal{I} is the identity matrix. Therefore, the eigenvalues of T(0)\mathcal{T}^{(0)} can be grouped into L×3L \times3 sectors labeled by (p,Q)(p,Q), where pp is the momentum and Q∈{0,1,−1}Q \in\{0,1,-1\} is the global Z3\mathbb{Z}_3 charge. As for T(±1)\mathcal{T}^{(\pm1)}, they also commute with G\mathcal{G} so that QQ is still well-defined. Figure S1 shows the charge-resolved spectra of T(τ)\mathcal{T}^{(\tau)} computed via Loop-TNR. The low-lying levels are consistent with

Δnm(τ)=n22K+K2(m+τ3)2(n,m∈Z),(9)\Delta_{nm}^{(\tau)} = \frac{n^2}{2K} + \frac{K}{2}\left(m+\frac{\tau}{3}\right)^2 \qquad(n,m \in\mathbb{Z}), \tag*{(9)}

identifying the quantum number mm as the integer winding. They also satisfy Q=n mod 3Q = n \bmod3, implying that the spin-shift G\mathcal{G} acts as a shift on the compact boson by one third of its compactification period.

The KW Duality

Given two plane graphs GG and G∗G^* that are dual graphs of each other, the KW duality refers to the exact relation [1]

ZG(z)=3N(G)−b(G)−1(z−1)b(G)ZG∗(z∗)(10)Z_G(z) = 3^{N(G)-b(G)-1}(z-1)^{b(G)}Z_{G^*}(z^*) \tag*{(10)}

where ZGZ_G is the partition function of the 3-state Potts model defined on GG, N(G)N(G) is the number of vertices, and b(G)b(G) is the number of edges. The infinite-size square lattice is a self-dual graph, so that

f(z)=−lim⁡N→∞1Nln⁡Z(z)(11)f(z)=-\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{N}\ln Z(z) \tag*{(11)}
=−lim⁡N→∞1Nln⁡[3−N−1(z−1)2NZ(z⋆)](12)=-\lim_{N\to\infty}\frac{1}{N}\ln\left[3^{-N-1}(z-1)^{2N}Z(z^\star)\right] \tag*{(12)}
=f(z⋆)−2ln⁡(z−1)+ln⁡3.(13)=f(z^\star)-2\ln(z-1)+\ln3. \tag*{(13)}

The KW duality applies not only to Z(z)Z(z), but also to transfer matrices. Since T(τ)\mathcal{T}^{(\tau)} commutes with G\mathcal{G}, it can be decomposed into three blocks as T(τ)=⨁QT(τ,Q)\mathcal{T}^{(\tau)}=\bigoplus_Q\mathcal{T}^{(\tau,Q)}. Based on the isomorphism proposed by Han and Honecker [71], we can prove that for any z≠1z\ne1,

T(τ,Q)(z⋆)≃3L(z−1)−2LT(Q,τ)(z),(14)\mathcal{T}^{(\tau,Q)}(z^\star)\simeq3^L(z-1)^{-2L}\mathcal{T}^{(Q,\tau)}(z), \tag*{(14)}

where ≃\simeq denotes the matrix similarity. Therefore, the respective dominant eigenvalues of T(0,0)(z)\mathcal{T}^{(0,0)}(z), T(0,0)(z⋆)\mathcal{T}^{(0,0)}(z^\star), T(1,0)(z)\mathcal{T}^{(1,0)}(z), and T(0,1)(z⋆)\mathcal{T}^{(0,1)}(z^\star) satisfy

λ0(0,0)(z⋆)=3L(z−1)−2Lλ0(0,0)(z),(15)\lambda_0^{(0,0)}(z^\star)=3^L(z-1)^{-2L}\lambda_0^{(0,0)}(z), \tag*{(15)}
λ0(0,1)(z⋆)=3L(z−1)−2Lλ0(1,0)(z).(16)\lambda_0^{(0,1)}(z^\star)=3^L(z-1)^{-2L}\lambda_0^{(1,0)}(z). \tag*{(16)}

Combining Eqs. (9)(15)(16) and taking L→∞L\to\infty yields

Δ10(0)(z⋆)=Δ00(1)(z)=12K(z⋆)=K(z)18,(17)\Delta_{10}^{(0)}(z^\star)=\Delta_{00}^{(1)}(z)=\frac{1}{2K(z^\star)}=\frac{K(z)}{18}, \tag*{(17)}

and hence K(z)K(z⋆)=9K(z)K(z^\star)=9.

The JRS Point

The transfer matrix defined in Eq. (5) can be written as T(τ)=U(τ)V\mathcal{T}^{(\tau)}=\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)}\mathcal{V}, where

U(τ)∣σ⟩=zU(τ)(σ)∣σ⟩(18)\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)}|\sigma\rangle=z^{U^{(\tau)}(\sigma)}|\sigma\rangle \tag*{(18)}

is diagonal, and

V=[z111z111z]⊗L.(19)\mathcal{V}=\begin{bmatrix}z&1&1\\1&z&1\\1&1&z\end{bmatrix}^{\otimes L}. \tag*{(19)}

Note that zJRS=(−1±3i)/2z_{\mathrm{JRS}}=(-1\pm\sqrt{3}i)/2 is a primitive cube root of unity, which we denote by ω\omega for simplicity. At z=ωz=\omega, we have U(τ)†U(τ)=I\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)\dagger}\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)}=\mathcal{I}, since

z‾U(τ)(σ)zU(τ)(σ)=(ω‾ω)U(τ)(σ)=1,(20)\overline{z}^{U^{(\tau)}(\sigma)}z^{U^{(\tau)}(\sigma)}=(\overline{\omega}\omega)^{U^{(\tau)}(\sigma)}=1, \tag*{(20)}

and V†V=3LI\mathcal{V}^\dagger\mathcal{V}=3^L\mathcal{I}, since

\begin{bmatrix}\omega&1&1\\1&\omega&1\\1&1&\omega\end{bmatrix}^{\dagger} \begin{bmatrix}\omega&1&1\\1&\omega&1\\1&1&\omega\end{bmatrix} = \begin{bmatrix}3&0&0\\0&3&0\\0&0&3\end{bmatrix}. \tag*{(21)}\end{bmatrix}

Consequently, 3−L/2T(τ)3^{-L/2}\mathcal{T}^{(\tau)} is unitary, so that its all eigenvalues lie on the unit circle. So far, we have proved that at z=zJRSz=z_{\mathrm{JRS}}, all transfer-matrix eigenvalues satisfy ∣λα∣=3L/2|\lambda_\alpha|=3^{L/2} regardless of LL and τ\tau. In fact, this property holds for any boundary conditions (e.g., the open boundary condition), since they only affect U(τ)(σ)\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)}(\sigma) which remains real.

References

supp.pdf

Supplemental Material for ``Three New Phases in the Two-Dimensional Potts Model at Complex Temperature''

Extracting complex scaling dimensions from Loop-TNR results

Using Loop-TNR results, we construct the transfer matrix via the configuration depicted in Fig. 3(g) of Ref. [49]. When the RG step ℓ\ell is even, this transfer matrix equals the LL-th power of the single-row transfer matrix T(τ)T^{(\tau)}, where

L=2ℓ/2L=2^{\ell/2}. We use its eigenvalues {(λα(τ))L}\{(\lambda_{\alpha}^{(\tau)})^{L}\} to compute the complex-valued level

D~α(τ)≡12πln⁡(λ0(0))Le−iPL(λα(τ))L(22)\widetilde{D}_{\alpha}^{(\tau)} \equiv\frac{1}{2\pi}\ln\frac{(\lambda_{0}^{(0)})^{L}}{e^{-iPL}(\lambda_{\alpha}^{(\tau)})^{L}} \tag*{(22)}

where the momentum offset PP can be determined from momentum-resolved ED spectra. In the two LL phases, we have P∈{0,π}P\in\{0,\pi\}, so that e−iPL=1e^{-iPL}=1 holds for all ℓ=2,4,6,⋯\ell=2,4,6,\cdots. After choosing the right branch of the logarithm, we expect D~α(τ)→Δα(τ)−Δ0(0)\widetilde{D}_{\alpha}^{(\tau)}\to\Delta_{\alpha}^{(\tau)}-\Delta_{0}^{(0)} as L→∞L\to\infty. However, since the bond dimension χ\chi is finite, D~α(τ)\widetilde{D}_{\alpha}^{(\tau)} must be computed at a moderate RG step ℓ\ell, not as large as possible [72]. Figure S1 shows the low-lying {D~α(τ)}\{\widetilde{D}_{\alpha}^{(\tau)}\} computed at representative points z=−2.0+0.3iz=-2.0+0.3i and z=0.15iz=0.15i with ℓ=20\ell=20, and the {Δnm(τ)}\{\Delta_{nm}^{(\tau)}\} predicted by Eq. (9) for comparison. Their consistency strongly supports the LL description, and the quantum numbers nn and mm are related to QQ and τ\tau, respectively. The Luttinger parameter KfitK_{\mathrm{fit}} is determined using the twelve D~α(τ)\widetilde{D}_{\alpha}^{(\tau)} with smallest real parts.

The limiting value of the Luttinger parameter K(i0+)K(i0^{+}) is extrapolated using Kfit(iζ)K_{\mathrm{fit}}(i\zeta) from ζ=0.020\zeta=0.020 to 0.0400.040, fitted from low-lying {D~α(0)}\{\widetilde{D}_{\alpha}^{(0)}\} at ℓ=28\ell=28 [Figure S2]. The resulting Kfitext(0)≈5.99+0.02iK_{\mathrm{fit}}^{\mathrm{ext}}(0)\approx5.99+0.02i is close to 2K(0)=62K(0)=6. We can also see that increasing ζ\zeta mainly contributes to Im⁡(K)\operatorname{Im}(K) rather than Re⁡(K)\operatorname{Re}(K).

Figure S2. Luttinger parameters (blue dots) fitted from Loop-TNR results and the extrapolated value at ζ=0\zeta=0 (red crosses).

Identifying and suppressing finite-entanglement artifacts of BWTRG

The zero density ρ(z)\rho(z) in Figure 1(c) is computed via the following procedure. We define a square grid on the region {z∈C:−3≤Re⁡(z)≤3, 0≤Im⁡(z)≤2}\{z\in\mathbb{C}:-3\leq\operatorname{Re}(z)\leq3,\ 0\leq\operatorname{Im}(z)\leq2\} with grid spacing h=0.01h=0.01. For each zz point in the grid, we invoke BWTRG twice. On the one hand, we construct the initial local tensor A(z)A(z) of BWTRG, which directly yields the free energy fdirect(z)f_{\mathrm{direct}}(z). On the other hand, we construct the initial local tensor A(z∗)A(z^{*}), yielding fdirect(z∗)f_{\mathrm{direct}}(z^{*}) and

fdual(z)≡fdirect(z∗)−2ln⁡(z−1)+ln⁡q.(23)f_{\mathrm{dual}}(z)\equiv f_{\mathrm{direct}}(z^{*})-2\ln(z-1)+\ln q. \tag*{(23)}

According to Eq. (13), we have fdirect=fdualf_{\mathrm{direct}}=f_{\mathrm{dual}} theoretically, but they are numerically different since χ\chi is finite. We use them to compute ρdirect\rho_{\mathrm{direct}} and ρdual\rho_{\mathrm{dual}}, respectively, via the discrete Laplacian

ρ(z)=−12π∇2Re⁡f(z)≈12πRe⁡4f(z)−f(z+h)−f(z−h)−f(z+ih)−f(z−ih)h2.(24)\rho(z)=-\frac{1}{2\pi}\nabla^{2}\operatorname{Re}f(z)\approx\frac{1}{2\pi}\operatorname{Re}\frac{4f(z)-f(z+h)-f(z-h)-f(z+ih)-f(z-ih)}{h^{2}}. \tag*{(24)}

Figure S3 shows the results with χ=54,60,72\chi=54,60,72. We distinguish true Fisher zero structures from finite-entanglement artifacts by three criteria: (i) they satisfy ρ≥0\rho\geq0, (ii) they are stable under increasing χ\chi, and (iii) they should appear in both ρdirect\rho_{\mathrm{direct}} and ρdual\rho_{\mathrm{dual}}. Using these criteria, we find that finite-entanglement artifacts mainly appear around zRSz_{\mathrm{RS}} as ringing artifacts, i.e., adjacent positive-negative pairs.

Figure S3. ρdirect\rho_{\mathrm{direct}} and ρdual\rho_{\mathrm{dual}} computed by BWTRG at (a) χ=54\chi=54, (b) χ=60\chi=60, and (c) χ=72\chi=72. One can see that most finite-entanglement artifacts are not self-dual and appear as adjacent positive-negative pairs.

To suppress the ringing artifacts, we apply a nonlinear filter to ρdirect\rho_{\mathrm{direct}} and ρdual\rho_{\mathrm{dual}}, respectively. We define the credibility of each zz point in the grid as

κ(z;w)≡∑j,ke−(j2+k2)h2/2w2ρ(z+jh+ikh)∑j,ke−(j2+k2)h2/2w2∣ρ(z+jh+ikh)∣.(25)\kappa(z;w)\equiv\frac{\sum_{j,k}e^{-(j^{2}+k^{2})h^{2}/2w^{2}}\rho(z+jh+ikh)}{\sum_{j,k}e^{-(j^{2}+k^{2})h^{2}/2w^{2}}\lvert\rho(z+jh+ikh)\rvert}. \tag*{(25)}

where w>0w>0 is the standard deviation of the Gaussian filter. The denominator of Eq. (25) quantifies the average ∣ρ∣|\rho| near zz, while the numerator reflects the net zero density. When ρ≥0\rho\geq0, we have κ(z)=1\kappa(z)=1. Near the ringing artifacts, if ww is sufficiently large to cover the positive-negative pattern, the terms in the numerator of Eq. (25) will cancel and we expect κ(z)≈0\kappa(z)\approx0. Therefore, we define

ρ^(z;w)={κ(z;w)ρ(z)if κ(z;w)>0 and ρ(z)>0,0otherwise.(26)\hat{\rho}(z;w)= \begin{cases} \kappa(z;w)\rho(z) & \text{if }\kappa(z;w)>0\text{ and }\rho(z)>0,\\ 0 & \text{otherwise.} \end{cases} \tag*{(26)}

As shown in Figure S4, using w=0.02w=0.02 suppresses most ringing artifacts, and preserves the stable features in Figure S3. In the main text, Figure 1(c) actually shows (ρ^direct+ρ^dual)/2(\hat{\rho}_{\mathrm{direct}}+\hat{\rho}_{\mathrm{dual}})/2 with w=0.02w=0.02.

Figure S4. ρ^direct\hat{\rho}_{\mathrm{direct}} computed at χ=72\chi=72 and filtered using different ww values. Most ringing artifacts are suppressed when w=0.02w=0.02.

Figure S6. ρdirect\rho_{\mathrm{direct}} computed by HOTRG at (a) χ=30\chi= 30, (b) χ=40\chi= 40, (c) χ=50\chi= 50, and (d) χ=60\chi= 60.

Figure S7. ρdirect\rho_{\mathrm{direct}}, Im⁡f\operatorname{Im} f, and the Galerkin error ε\varepsilon computed by iDMRG with 2000 iteration steps at (a) χ=100\chi= 100 and (b) χ=200\chi= 200. Since iDMRG relies on the random initial tensor, it may converge to wrong branches and yield discontinuous f(z)f(z), especially in gapless phases and dense-zero areas. However, ε(z)\varepsilon(z) exhibits a rather stable “phase diagram” pattern.

Fisher zero density obtained with different methods

We have shown ρ(z)\rho(z) computed by BWTRG in Figure 1(c), Figure S3, and Figure S4. Now, we present ρ(z)\rho(z) obtained from iDMRG, Loop-TNR, and higher-order tensor renormalization group (HOTRG) [73] with zz-grid spacing h=0.025h=0.025. Similar to BWTRG, Loop-TNR and HOTRG are robust and directly produce Re⁡f(z)\operatorname{Re} f(z). We also obtain Im⁡f(z)\operatorname{Im} f(z) via iDMRG which produces e−f(z)e^{-f(z)}, but it is hard to converge in the gapless phases—the well-converged result in Figure 1(d) is obtained using ∼104\sim10^4 iteration steps, smaller χ\chi, and multiple trial initial tensors. Moreover, we use ED to compute λ0(z)\lambda_0(z) with zz-grid spacing h=0.02h=0.02, and use −1Lln⁡∣λ0(z)∣-\frac{1}{L}\ln|\lambda_0(z)| to approximate Re⁡f(z)\operatorname{Re} f(z) since [50]

−ln⁡∣λ0(z)∣={LRe⁡f(z)+O(e−L/ξ)if the system is gapped,LRe⁡f(z)−π6LRe⁡(c)+o(L−1)if the system is conformal gapless.(27)-\ln|\lambda_0(z)| = \begin{cases} L\operatorname{Re} f(z)+O(e^{-L/\xi}) & \text{if the system is gapped},\\ L\operatorname{Re} f(z)-\frac{\pi}{6L}\operatorname{Re}(c)+o(L^{-1}) & \text{if the system is conformal gapless}. \end{cases} \tag*{(27)}

where cc is the effective central charge. Figure S5–Figure S8 show ρ(z)\rho(z) obtained by these four methods, respectively. They are consistent with the phase diagram in Figure 2(a). The ringing artifacts seems to be a common trait of tensor network renormalization methods (BWTRG, Loop-TNR, and HOTRG), while the finite-size artifact in Figure S8(Figure S8) are mostly nonnegative. We also notice that the Galerkin error ε(z)\varepsilon(z) of iDMRG clearly distinguishes the gapped phase, the gapless phase, and the dense-zero area.

Figure S5. ρdirect\rho_{\mathrm{direct}} computed by Loop-TNR at (a) χ=12\chi= 12 and (b) χ=18\chi= 18.

Figure S8. ρdirect\rho_{\mathrm{direct}} computed by −1Lln⁡∣λ0(z)∣≈Re⁡f(z)-\frac{1}{L}\ln|\lambda_0(z)|\approx\operatorname{Re} f(z) at (a) L=10L=10 and (b) L=12L=12. The argument of the dominant eigenvalue are shown below, which approximates −LIm⁡f(z) mod 2π-L\operatorname{Im} f(z)\bmod2\pi.

Finite-size scaling of the dominant transfer-matrix eigenvalue

If the NCG phase has a CFT description, the dominant eigenvalue λ0\lambda_0 should have the Casimir scaling in Eq. (27). Figure S9 shows 1Lln⁡∣λ0∣\frac{1}{L}\ln|\lambda_0| for L≤18L \le18 at representative zz points. For the LL phases, the untwisted sector (τ=0\tau= 0) is realized at even LL with c=1c = 1. For the gapped phases, the finite-size effect vanishes rapidly, exhibiting the c=0c = 0 behavior. The NCG phase is different from both cases. If we manage to fit a value of Re⁡(c)\operatorname{Re}(c), it will lie substantially below 1, which usually suggests a compact CFT. However, the compact-CFT description is challenged in the main text since they cannot account for the exponentially densifying transfer-matrix levels with Dα<1.5D_\alpha< 1.5.

Figure S9. Finite-size scaling of ∣λ0∣|\lambda_0| evaluated at representative zz points. Solid and hollow symbols represent even and odd LL, respectively. Dashed lines with slopes Re⁡(c)=1\operatorname{Re}(c)=1 and 00 are only used for reference. Panels (a) and (e) shows the conformal behavior of the LL phases, while (b) and (d) shows the gapped behavior of the FM and PM phases. In Panel (c), we cannot identify a conformal subsequence with a steady slope. Even if such slope exists, it seems to have Re⁡(c)\operatorname{Re}(c) strictly less than 1.

Proof for the KW duality of transfer matrices

In this section, we will prove the statement in Eq. (14) that T(τ,Q)(z∗)T^{(\tau,Q)}(z^*) is similar to 3L(z−1)−2LT(Q,τ)(z)3^L(z-1)^{-2L}T^{(Q,\tau)}(z) for any L∈Z+L \in\mathbb{Z}_+ and z≠1z \ne1, basically rephrasing the work of Han and Honecker [71] in the language of classical 3-state Potts model. Let us define the local spin-shift matrix Xj\mathcal{X}_j and the spin-difference matrix Bj(τ)\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j as

Xj∣σ⟩≡∣σ1,⋯ ,σj−1,σj+1,σj+1,⋯ ,σL⟩,(28)\mathcal{X}_j|\sigma\rangle\equiv|\sigma_1,\cdots,\sigma_{j-1},\sigma_j+1,\sigma_{j+1},\cdots,\sigma_L\rangle, \tag*{(28)}
Bj(τ)∣σ⟩≡ωσj+1−σj∣σ⟩,(29)\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j|\sigma\rangle\equiv\omega^{\sigma_{j+1}-\sigma_j}|\sigma\rangle, \tag*{(29)}

where ω≡e2πi/3\omega\equiv e^{2\pi i/3}, j∈{1,⋯ ,L}j \in\{1,\cdots,L\}, and Bj(τ)\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j depends on τ\tau only when j=Lj=L. Note that they satisfy

(I+Bj(τ)+(Bj(τ))2)∣σ⟩=3δσjσj+1∣σ⟩,(30)\left(\mathcal{I}+\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j+(\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j)^2\right)|\sigma\rangle= 3\delta_{\sigma_j\sigma_{j+1}}|\sigma\rangle, \tag*{(30)}
I+Xj+Xj2=I1⊗(j−1)⊗[111111111]⊗I1⊗(L−j),(31)\mathcal{I}+\mathcal{X}_j+\mathcal{X}_j^2=\mathcal{I}_1^{\otimes(j-1)}\otimes \begin{bmatrix} 1 & 1 & 1\\ 1 & 1 & 1\\ 1 & 1 & 1 \end{bmatrix} \otimes\mathcal{I}_1^{\otimes(L-j)}, \tag*{(31)}

where I1\mathcal{I}_1 denotes the 3×33 \times3 identity matrix. The matrices U(τ)(z)\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)}(z) and V(z)\mathcal{V}(z) defined in Eqs. (18) and (19) can be rewritten as

U(τ)(z)=∏j=1L[I+z−13(I+Bj(τ)+(Bj(τ))2)],(32)\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)}(z)=\prod_{j=1}^{L}\left[\mathcal{I}+\frac{z-1}{3}\left(\mathcal{I}+\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j+(\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j)^2\right)\right], \tag*{(32)}
V(z)=∏j=1L(I1⊗(j−1)⊗[z111z111z]⊗I1⊗(L−j))=∏j=1L[(I+Xj+Xj2)+(z−1)I].(33)\mathcal{V}(z)=\prod_{j=1}^{L}\left(\mathcal{I}_1^{\otimes(j-1)}\otimes \begin{bmatrix} z & 1 & 1\\ 1 & z & 1\\ 1 & 1 & z \end{bmatrix} \otimes\mathcal{I}_1^{\otimes(L-j)}\right) =\prod_{j=1}^{L}\left[(\mathcal{I}+\mathcal{X}_j+\mathcal{X}_j^2)+(z-1)\mathcal{I}\right]. \tag*{(33)}

Now consider the eigenspaces of G=∏j=1LXj\mathcal{G}=\prod_{j=1}^{L}\mathcal{X}_j, denoted as HQ\mathcal{H}_Q, where Q∈{0,1,−1}Q \in\{0,1,-1\}. Define the linear map

MQ→Q′:13∑s=13ω−sQ∣s,t2+s,⋯ ,tL+s⟩ ↦ 13L∑σ1,⋯ ,σL=13ω∑j=1L(tj−tj+1)σj∣σ⟩,(34)\mathcal{M}_{Q\to Q'}:\quad\frac{1}{\sqrt{3}}\sum_{s=1}^{3}\omega^{-sQ}|s,t_2+s,\cdots,t_L+s\rangle \ \mapsto\ \frac{1}{\sqrt{3^L}}\sum_{\sigma_1,\cdots,\sigma_L=1}^{3}\omega^{\sum_{j=1}^{L}(t_j-t_{j+1})\sigma_j}|\sigma\rangle, \tag*{(34)}

where t1≡0t_1\equiv0 and tL+1≡Q′t_{L+1}\equiv Q' are fixed, and t2,⋯ ,tL∈{0,1,2}t_2,\cdots,t_L\in\{0,1,2\}. One can verify that taking all 3L−13^{L-1} values of (t2,⋯ ,tL)(t_2,\cdots,t_L), the left hand side of Eq. (34) forms an orthonormal basis of HQ\mathcal{H}_Q, and the right hand side forms an orthonormal basis of HQ′\mathcal{H}_{Q'}. Therefore, MQ→Q′\mathcal{M}_{Q\to Q'} is an isometry from HQ\mathcal{H}_Q to HQ′\mathcal{H}_{Q'}. Next, we will show that MQ→τ\mathcal{M}_{Q\to\tau} connects T(τ,Q)≡T(τ)∣HQT^{(\tau,Q)}\equiv T^{(\tau)}|_{\mathcal{H}_Q} and T(Q,τ)≡T(Q)∣HτT^{(Q,\tau)}\equiv T^{(Q)}|_{\mathcal{H}_\tau}, and denote MQ→τ\mathcal{M}_{Q\to\tau} as M\mathcal{M} for simplicity.

Note that the left hand side of Eq. (34) is an eigenvector of Bj(τ)\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j while the right hand side is an eigenvector of Xj\mathcal{X}_j, and both their eigenvalues equal ωtj+1−tj\omega^{t_{j+1}-t_j}. Hence, we have MBj(τ)∣HQ=XjM\mathcal{M}\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j|_{\mathcal{H}_Q}=\mathcal{X}_j\mathcal{M}. Also, note that applying Xj\mathcal{X}_j on the left will multiply each term on the right by ωσj−σj−1\omega^{\sigma_j-\sigma_{j-1}} if j>1j>1, and by ωQ+σ1−σL\omega^{Q+\sigma_1-\sigma_L} if j=1j=1. This is equivalent to applying Bj−1(Q)\mathcal{B}^{(Q)}_{j-1} on the right (define B0(Q)≡BL(Q)\mathcal{B}^{(Q)}_0\equiv\mathcal{B}^{(Q)}_L), implying that MXj∣HQ=Bj−1(Q)M\mathcal{M}\mathcal{X}_j|_{\mathcal{H}_Q}=\mathcal{B}^{(Q)}_{j-1}\mathcal{M}. So far, we can see that M\mathcal{M} transforms the matrices on HQ\mathcal{H}_Q to matrices on Hτ\mathcal{H}_\tau as

M(Bj(τ)∣HQ)M−1=Xj∣Hτ,(35)\mathcal{M}\left(\mathcal{B}^{(\tau)}_j|_{\mathcal{H}_Q}\right)\mathcal{M}^{-1}=\mathcal{X}_j|_{\mathcal{H}_\tau}, \tag*{(35)}
M(Xj∣HQ)M−1=Bj−1(Q)∣Hτ.(36)\mathcal{M}\left(\mathcal{X}_j|_{\mathcal{H}_Q}\right)\mathcal{M}^{-1}=\mathcal{B}^{(Q)}_{j-1}|_{\mathcal{H}_\tau}. \tag*{(36)}

Consequently, Eqs. (32) and (33) are transformed as

M[U(τ)(z)∣HQ]M−1=∏j=1L[I+z−13(τ+Xj+Xj2)]Hτ=(z−13)LV(z∗)∣Hτ.(37)\mathcal{M}\left[\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)}(z)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_Q}\right]\mathcal{M}^{-1}=\prod_{j=1}^{L}\left[\mathcal{I}+\frac{z-1}{3}\left(\tau+\mathcal{X}_j+\mathcal{X}_j^2\right)\right]_{\mathcal{H}_\tau}=\left(\frac{z-1}{3}\right)^L\mathcal{V}(z^*)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_\tau}. \tag*{(37)}
M[V(z)∣HQ]M−1=∏j=1L[I+Bj−1(Q)+(Bj−1(Q))2+(z−1)I]Hτ=(z−1)LU(Q)(z∗)∣Hτ.(38)\mathcal{M}\left[\mathcal{V}(z)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_Q}\right]\mathcal{M}^{-1}=\prod_{j=1}^{L}\left[\mathcal{I}+\mathcal{B}_{j-1}^{(Q)}+\left(\mathcal{B}_{j-1}^{(Q)}\right)^2+(z-1)\mathcal{I}\right]_{\mathcal{H}_\tau}=(z-1)^L\mathcal{U}^{(Q)}(z^*)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_\tau}. \tag*{(38)}

Together, we have T(τ,Q)(z)=U(τ)(z)V(z)∣HQ\mathcal{T}^{(\tau,Q)}(z)=\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)}(z)\mathcal{V}(z)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_Q} similar to

M(U(τ)(z)V(z)∣HQ)M−1=3−L(z−1)2LV(z∗)U(Q)(z∗)∣Hτ.(39)\mathcal{M}\left(\mathcal{U}^{(\tau)}(z)\mathcal{V}(z)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_Q}\right)\mathcal{M}^{-1}=3^{-L}(z-1)^{2L}\mathcal{V}(z^*)\mathcal{U}^{(Q)}(z^*)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_\tau}. \tag*{(39)}

For any complex zz, at least one of V(z∗)∣Hτ\mathcal{V}(z^*)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_\tau} and U(Q)(z∗)∣Hτ\mathcal{U}^{(Q)}(z^*)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_\tau} is invertible, so that their product is always similar to T(Q,τ)(z∗)=U(Q)(z∗)V(z∗)∣Hτ\mathcal{T}^{(Q,\tau)}(z^*)=\mathcal{U}^{(Q)}(z^*)\mathcal{V}(z^*)\vert_{\mathcal{H}_\tau}.

References

[49] S. Yang, Z.-C. Gu, and X.-G. Wen, Loop optimization for tensor network renormalization, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 110504 (2017).

[72] S.-H. Chan and P. Chen, Extracting conformal data from finite-size tensor-network flow in critical two-dimensional classical models, Phys. Rev. Research 8, 033297 (2026).

[73] Z.-Y. Xie, J. Chen, M.-P. Qin, J. W. Zhu, L.-P. Yang, and T. Xiang, Coarse-graining renormalization by higher-order singular value decomposition, Phys. Rev. B 86, 045139 (2012).

[50] H. W. Blöte, J. L. Cardy, and M. P. Nightingale, Conformal invariance, the central charge, and universal finite-size amplitudes at criticality, Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 742 (1986).

[71] N. Han and A. Honecker, Low-temperature expansions and correlation functions of the Z₃-chiral potts model, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 27, 9 (1994).

References

  1. [1]F.-Y. Wu, The potts model, Rev. Mod. Phys. 54, 235 (1982).
  2. [2]R. J. Baxter, Potts model at the critical temperature, J. Phys. C: Solid State Phys. 6, L445 (1973).DOI
  3. [3]S. Alexander, Lattice gas transition with cubic terms, Phys. Lett. A 54, 353 (1975).
  4. [4]A. N. Berker, S. Ostlund, and F. A. Putnam, Renormalization-group treatment of a potts lattice gas for krypton adsorbed onto graphite, Phys. Rev. B 17, 3650 (1978).DOI
  5. [5]E. Domany, M. Schick, J. S. Walker, and R. B. Griffiths, Classification of continuous order-disorder transitions in adsorbed monolayers, Phys. Rev. B 18, 2209 (1978).DOI
  6. [6]A. D. Sokal, Bounds on the complex zeros of (d i) chromatic polynomials and potts-model partition functions, Combinatorics, Probability and Computing 10, 41 (2001).DOI
  7. [7]The AFM critical point and its dual are z = −1±√(4−q). The real-temperature regime is z ≥ 0. Hence, the AFM critical temperature is complex for q > 3, while its dual temperature is complex for all q.
  8. [8]R. J. Baxter, Critical antiferromagnetic square-lattice potts model, Proc. R. Soc. London, Ser. A 383, 43 (1982).DOI
  9. [9]J. L. Jacobsen and H. Saleur, The antiferromagnetic transition for the square-lattice potts model, Nucl. Phys. B 743, 207 (2006).DOI
  10. [10]H. Saleur, The antiferromagnetic potts model in two dimensions: Berker-kadanoff phase, antiferromagnetic transition, and the role of beraha numbers, Nucl. Phys. B 360, 219 (1991).DOI
  11. [11]V. Gorbenko, S. Rychkov, and B. Zan, Walking, weak first-order transitions, and complex cfts, J. High Energy Phys. 2018 (10), 1.DOI
  12. [12]V. Gorbenko, S. Rychkov, and B. Zan, Walking, weak first-order transitions, and complex cfts in two-dimensional potts model at Q > 4, SciPost Phys. 5, 050 (2018).
  13. [13]J. L. Jacobsen and K. J. Wiese, Lattice realization of complex conformal field theories: Two-dimensional potts model with Q > 4 states, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 077101 (2024).DOI
  14. [14]Y. Tang, H. Ma, Q. Tang, Y.-C. He, and W. Zhu, Reclaiming the lost conformality in a non-hermitian quantum 5-state potts model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 076504 (2024).DOI
  15. [15]J. L. Jacobsen, J.-F. Richard, and J. Salas, Complex-temperature phase diagram of potts and rsos models, Nucl. Phys. B 743, 153 (2006).DOI
  16. [16]P. P. Martin and S. F. Dawes, Zeros of the 3-state potts model partition function for the square lattice revisited, J. Stat. Mech.: Theory Exp. 2019 (8), 084003.DOI
  17. [17]C.-N. Yang and T.-D. Lee, Statistical theory of equations of state and phase transitions. i. theory of condensation, Phys. Rev. 87, 404 (1952).
  18. [18]T.-D. Lee and C.-N. Yang, Statistical theory of equations of state and phase transitions. ii. lattice gas and ising model, Phys. Rev. 87, 410 (1952).
  19. [19]M. E. Fisher, The nature of critical points (University of Colorado Press, 1965).
  20. [20]X. Peng, H. Zhou, B.-B. Wei, J. Cui, J. Du, and R.-B. Liu, Experimental observation of lee-yang zeros, Phys. Rev. Lett. 114, 010601 (2015).
  21. [21]H. Gao, K. Wang, L. Xiao, M. Nakagawa, N. Matsumoto, D. Qu, H. Lin, M. Ueda, and P. Xue, Experimental observation of the yang-lee quantum criticality in open quantum systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 176601 (2024).
  22. [22]H. Laba and V. Tkachuk, Quantum computation of fisher zeros for the ising model, Phys. Lett. A 534, 130251 (2025).
  23. [23]A. Kuzmak and V. Tkachuk, Detecting the purely imaginary fisher zeros of an ising spin system on a quantum computer, Sci. Rep. 15, 32854 (2025).
  24. [24]I. Bena, M. Droz, and A. Lipowski, Statistical mechanics of equilibrium and nonequilibrium phase transitions: the yang-lee formalism, Int. J. Mod. Phys. B 19, 4269 (2005).
  25. [25]R. Abe, Note on the critical behavior of ising ferromagnets, Prog. Theor. Phys. 38, 72 (1967).DOI
  26. [26]R. Kenna, D. Johnston, and W. Janke, Scaling relations for logarithmic corrections, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 115701 (2006).
  27. [27]M. Heyl, A. Polkovnikov, and S. Kehrein, Dynamical quantum phase transitions in the transverse-field ising model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 135704 (2013).
  28. [28]Y. Meng, S. Lv, Y. Liu, Z. Tan, E. Zhao, and H. Zou, Detecting many-body scars from fisher zeros, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 070402 (2025).
  29. [29]R.-C. He, J.-X. Zeng, S. Yang, C. Wang, Q.-J. Ye, and X.-Z. Li, Fermion sign problem and the structure of lee-yang zeros: The form of the partition function for indistinguishable particles and its zeros at 0 k, Phys. Rev. E 113, 024115 (2026).
  30. [30]R. B. Pearson, Partition function of the ising model on the periodic 4 × 4 × 4 lattice, Phys. Rev. B 26, 6285 (1982).
  31. [31]S.-Y. Kim, Yang-lee zeros of the antiferromagnetic ising model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 93, 130604 (2004).
  32. [32]S.-Y. Kim, Density of the fisher zeros for the three-state and four-state potts models, Phys. Rev. E 70, 016110 (2004).
  33. [33]S. Lv, Y. Liu, E. Zhao, H. Zou, and T. Xiang, Giant bubbles of fisher zeros in the quantum xy chain, Phys. Rev. B 113, L241117 (2026).
  34. [34]W. van Saarloos and D. A. Kurtze, Location of zeros in the complex temperature plane: Absence of lee-yang theorem, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 17, 1301 (1984).
  35. [35]B. Derrida, The zeros of the partition function of the random energy model, Physica A 177, 31 (1991).
  36. [36]W. Janke, D. A. Johnston, and R. Kenna, Phase transition strength through densities of general distributions of zeros, Nucl. Phys. B 682, 618 (2004).
  37. [37]C.-N. Chen, C.-K. Hu, and F. Wu, Partition function zeros of the square lattice potts model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 169 (1996).
  38. [38]V. Matveev and R. Shrock, Complex-temperature singularities in potts models on the square lattice, Phys. Rev. E 54, 6174 (1996).
  39. [39]R. Blythe and M. Evans, Lee-yang zeros and phase transitions in nonequilibrium steady states, Phys. Rev. Lett. 89, 080601 (2002).
  40. [40]X.-Y. Ouyang, Q.-J. Ye, and X.-Z. Li, Complex phase diagram and supercritical matter, Phys. Rev. E 109, 024118 (2024).
  41. [41]M. Abdelshafy and M. Sedik, Yang-lee zeros of two-dimensional nearest-neighbor antiferromagnetic ising models: A numerical linked cluster expansion study, Phys. Rev. B 112, 054445 (2025).
  42. [42]See Supplemental Material, at http://xxx, for details and additional discussions, where Refs. [72, 73] are also cited.
  43. [43]A. Denbleyker, Y. Liu, Y. Meurice, M. Qin, T. Xiang, Z. Xie, J. Yu, and H. Zou, Controlling sign problems in spin models using tensor renormalization, Phys. Rev. D 89, 016008 (2014).
  44. [44]A. García-Saez and T.-C. Wei, Density of yang-lee zeros in the thermodynamic limit from tensor network methods, Phys. Rev. B 92, 125132 (2015).
  45. [45]D. Adachi, T. Okubo, and S. Todo, Bond-weighted tensor renormalization group, Phys. Rev. B 105, L060402 (2022).DOI
  46. [46]S. R. White, Density matrix formulation for quantum renormalization groups, Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 2863 (1992).
  47. [47]T. Nishino, Density matrix renormalization group method for 2d classical models, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. 64, 3598 (1995).
  48. [48]I. P. McCulloch, Infinite size density matrix renormalization group, revisited, arXiv preprint arXiv:0804.2509 (2008).
  49. [49]S. Yang, Z.-C. Gu, and X.-G. Wen, Loop optimization for tensor network renormalization, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 110504 (2017).
  50. [50]H. W. Blöte, J. L. Cardy, and M. P. Nightingale, Conformal invariance, the central charge, and universal finite-size amplitudes at criticality, Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 742 (1986).
  51. [51]I. Affleck, Universal term in the free energy at a critical point and the conformal anomaly, in Current Physics–Sources and Comments, Vol. 2 (Elsevier, 1988) pp. 347–349.
  52. [52]Z.-C. Gu and X.-G. Wen, Tensor-entanglement-filtering renormalization approach and symmetry-protected topological order, Phys. Rev. B 80, 155131 (2009).
  53. [53]L. Devos and J. Haegeman, TensorKit.jl: A julia package for large-scale tensor computations, with a hint of category theory, arXiv preprint arXiv:2508.10076 (2025).
  54. [54]V. Vanthilt, A. Naravane, C. Meng, and A. Ueda, A practical introduction to tensor network renormalization with tn rkit.jl, SciPost Phys. Codebases , 077 (2026).
  55. [55]V. Vanthilt, A. Naravane, and A. Ueda, TNRKit (version 0.1.4), Zenodo (2025).
  56. [56]L. Devos, M. Van Damme, and J. Haegeman, MPSKit (version 0.13.11), Zenodo (2026).
  57. [57]J. Haegeman, KrylovKit (version 0.7.0), Zenodo (2024).
  58. [58]M. Biskup, C. Borgs, J. T. Chayes, L. J. Kleinwaks, and R. Kotecký, General theory of lee-yang zeros in models with first-order phase transitions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 84, 4794 (2000).
  59. [59]J. L. Cardy, Conformal invariance and universality in finite-size scaling, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 17, L385 (1984).
  60. [60]J. Cardy, Conformal field theory and statistical mechanics, Exact Methods in Low-Dimensional Statistical Physics and Quantum Computing (Oxford University Press, Oxford, 2010) , 65 (2010).
  61. [61]J. Voit, One-dimensional fermi liquids, Rep. Prog. Phys. 58, 977 (1995).DOI
  62. [62]K. Nomura and A. Kitazawa, SU(2)/Z₂ symmetry of the BKT transition and twisted boundary condition, arXiv preprint cond-mat/9711294 (1997).
  63. [63]Y. Ikhlef, J. Jacobsen, and H. Saleur, A staggered six-vertex model with non-compact continuum limit, Nucl. Phys. B 789, 438 (2008).
  64. [64]J. Salas and A. D. Sokal, The three-state square-lattice Potts antiferromagnet at zero temperature, J. Stat. Phys. 92, 729 (1998).DOI
  65. [65]J. Cardy, J. L. Jacobsen, and A. D. Sokal, Unusual corrections to scaling in the 3-state potts antiferromagnet on a square lattice, J. Stat. Phys. 105, 25 (2001).DOI
  66. [66]G. Delfino, Sine-gordon description of the scaling three-state potts antiferromagnet on the square lattice, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 34, L311 (2001).DOI
  67. [67]P. Fendley, H. Saleur, and A. B. Zamolodchikov, Massless flows i: the sine-gordon and o (n) models, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 8, 5717 (1993).DOI
  68. [68]Y.-H. Dong, L. Liu, F.-C. Wang, Q.-J. Ye, and X.-Z. Li, Tracking metastable phases by complex lee-yang zeros, arXiv preprint arXiv:2606.08004 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2606.08004
  69. [69]A. Krishnan, M. Schmitt, R. Moessner, and M. Heyl, Measuring complex-partition-function zeros of ising models in quantum simulators, Phys. Rev. A 100, 022125 (2019).DOI
  70. [70]S. Basu, D. P. Arovas, S. Gopalakrishnan, C. A. Hooley, and V. Oganesyan, Fisher zeros and persistent temporal oscillations in nonunitary quantum circuits, Phys. Rev. Research 4, 013018 (2022).DOI
  71. [71]N. Han and A. Honecker, Low-temperature expansions and correlation functions of the Z₃-chiral potts model, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 27, 9 (1994).DOI
  72. [72]S.-H. Chan and P. Chen, Extracting conformal data from finite-size tensor-network flow in critical two-dimensional classical models, Phys. Rev. Research 8, 033297 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2604.15749
  73. [73]Z.-Y. Xie, J. Chen, M.-P. Qin, J. W. Zhu, L.-P. Yang, and T. Xiang, Coarse-graining renormalization by higher-order singular value decomposition, Phys. Rev. B 86, 045139 (2012).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_7atdt9g4
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 7

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents