betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Scherk-Schwarz Compactifications: From Circles to Strings

Abstract

This review is written with a simple question in mind: what does one need to know to enter the literature on Scherk-Schwarz compactifications? It is organized as a sequence of questions that a graduate student might naturally ask, together with the concepts, calculations, and formal tools needed to work through the literature. The discussion starts at an elementary field-theory level and gradually develops toward more advanced aspects of supergravity, orbifolds, quantum effects, and string theory. Phenomenological applications are deliberately left aside.

Introduction

The journey through these pages begins with a simple idea. Upon going once around a circle of radius RR, a field need not return to itself, but may return to its image,

Φ(y+2πR)=UΦ(y),(1)\Phi(y + 2\pi R) = U\Phi(y), \tag*{(1)}

under a transformation UU. Applied in increasingly elaborate theories, this simple idea has many ramifications, which have taken decades to explore.

Before turning to the story, let us first set the stage and introduce its main characters. The first ingredient is extra dimensions. Their use in attempts to relate gravity to other interactions goes back to the earliest developments of Kaluza–Klein theory [1, 2, 3, 4] (see also Ref. [5] for a historical discussion). Many of the explicit examples considered in this review will involve the simplest internal spaces: the circle and the interval. They are sufficient to illustrate many of the main ideas discussed below, while remaining simple enough that several calculations can be carried through explicitly.

The second ingredient is supersymmetry. Supersymmetric theories have an undeniable appeal to a high-energy theorist. Nolens volens, the question of supersymmetry breaking then imposes itself upon us: first, if such theories are ever to describe our world, and second, out of intellectual curiosity about what becomes of their remarkable structures once supersymmetry is broken.

The third ingredient is string theory, our best-developed framework for a quantum theory of gravity, in which both extra dimensions and supersymmetry arise naturally. Familiar as these ingredients have become in theoretical physics, neither has so far received experimental support. Our discussion will therefore remain deliberately theoretical. In particular, we shall largely refrain from phenomenological considerations whose details are inevitably more sensitive to the passage of time.

If UU acts differently on bosons and fermions, then Eq. (1) may break supersymmetry. But can one choose UU arbitrarily? What properties must it satisfy? How does supersymmetry breaking manifest itself, and in what sense is it spontaneous? What scalar potential does it induce? What can be said about the gravitino mass? Do all states feel supersymmetry breaking already at the classical level? If not, how is the breaking transmitted to them by radiative corrections? And is there any obstruction to embedding the whole construction into string theory?

These are among the questions this review tries to answer. The novice reader will already have guessed, from these questions and from the title of the review, that the mechanism we shall be discussing is what is commonly called Scherk–Schwarz compactification [6, 7]. In their original construction, symmetries of the higher-dimensional theory were used to generate masses through a non-trivial dimensional reduction and, when the transformation acts differently on the members of a supersymmetry multiplet, to break supersymmetry spontaneously. Early field-theoretic implementations in higher-dimensional supersymmetric theories, including matter and gauge multiplets and the resulting supersymmetry-breaking mass spectra, were developed in detail by Fayet [8, 9].

String theory adds another layer to the problem. If supersymmetry is unbroken at tree level, ordinary perturbative radiative corrections do not provide a mechanism for breaking it, as follows from the non-renormalization properties of supersymmetric string vacua [10]. At the same time, classical supersymmetric and non-supersymmetric string vacua cannot in general be connected by an arbitrarily small deformation at finite distance in moduli space [11, 12]. The alternatives are therefore sharply constrained: supersymmetry breaking must already be present in the classical string background, or arise from genuinely non-perturbative physics.

This made Scherk–Schwarz breaking particularly attractive in perturbative string theory, since it provides a tree-level and calculable realization of supersymmetry breaking through the global compactification data. Starting with the early string constructions [13, 14, 15, 16], this possibility was explored in increasingly explicit settings. At the same time, string theory made clear that the apparent freedom of the field-theory construction is reduced by microscopic consistency conditions. In particular, a small gravitino mass in perturbative string constructions is tied to a tower of light states and to a decompactification limit rather than to an arbitrary small deformation of a compact vacuum [17]. These observations will reappear later in the review in a form that separates the rigid monodromy from the physical scale associated with it.

How this review is organized

There are many ways of writing a review on a subject such as this one. I have chosen not to follow the most traditional route, in which a sequence of chapters surveys and summarizes the literature on the successive developments of the subject. Instead, I have adopted a more personal approach.

I went back to several of my own papers and asked myself which questions had led me to them, and what questions a reader would have to understand in order to grasp them in depth. I then tried to write the corresponding questions and answers in the form in which I would have liked to find them in the literature. My hope is that the result will be useful to a newcomer entering any of the subjects discussed here.

One consequence of this approach is that the review is, inevitably, rather personal. A few of my own works appear repeatedly along the way. They are not, however, the subject of the review, and the reader will quickly see that they constitute only a small fraction of the material covered. For me they have served mainly as guides: to understand them, a student has to acquire a number of notions, both explicit and implicit, and the discussion has been developed outward from there.

This choice has drawbacks. The treatment of the bibliography is necessarily partial and is biased by the way in which each question is posed. Many detours that would have made the bibliography more complete have deliberately been avoided because they would also have changed the nature of the review.

The scope of the review is similarly limited. It is neither a historical account nor an exhaustive survey of Scherk–Schwarz constructions. In particular, I shall not attempt a systematic catalogue of heterotic, type II, or orientifold constructions, nor a systematic review of flux compactifications or gauged supergravities in their own right, nor a review of supersymmetry phenomenology. Such constructions will enter only when they illuminate one of the questions addressed here. The aim is to understand the mechanism and the structures underlying it, rather than to cover every context in which it has been used.

For the same reason, the discussion is not organized around a catalogue of currently open problems. This is largely intentional. I have tried to limit discussions whose content is particularly likely to become obsolete as the subject develops, and to concentrate instead on questions and structures that I hope will remain useful for longer.

The review starts at a deliberately elementary level, but the technical detail increases as the discussion progresses and becomes, in a few places, rather specialized. Roughly the first two thirds can be read entirely within quantum field theory and supergravity, while the final third brings string theory increasingly to the foreground.

Although the questions are arranged in a definite progression, individual questions, or small groups of questions dealing with closely related issues, have been written so as to remain reasonably self-contained. A reader interested in a particular aspect of the subject should therefore be able to enter the review at several different points without having to read everything that precedes it. This partial independence is also one reason why some notation and arguments are occasionally recalled.

A certain discipline has guided the questions and answers. Every notion should first be accessible at an intuitive level. The review is intended for physicists with rather different backgrounds, although familiarity with quantum field theory, supergravity, and the basic ingredients of string theory is assumed. Concepts that are more specific to the subject are introduced and defined when they first become necessary.

Whenever possible, an abstract statement is accompanied by an explicit example or calculation. Quite often, however, the answer admits a more general formulation once the appropriate mathematical language is introduced.1 The purpose is not to pursue an elegant formalism for its own sake. The hope is rather that the formalism provides a broader view of the question and makes it easier for a newcomer to recognize the same structures in related subjects and in parts of the literature not discussed explicitly here. This choice sometimes makes the exposition heavier and introduces a certain amount of repetition; I hope that the price is worth paying.

The discussion follows a corresponding progression. We begin with fields on a circle and an interval, where the kinematics of the twist can be made fully explicit. We then ask how the same data act on supersymmetry, how they enter supergravity, and how the resulting breaking is transmitted through quantum corrections. The last part of the review asks which of these effective-field-theory constructions survive the additional consistency conditions of string theory and how the same ideas are realized when a simple classical internal geometry is no longer the most useful description.

The primary purpose of a review is not to present new calculations or new results in the same way as a research paper. I have nevertheless tried to avoid producing a catalogue of summaries and, whenever possible, to bring something original to the discussion. Sometimes this lies mainly in the way the material is organized or explained; sometimes it lies in a different way of looking at familiar physical results. Some formulations may be less familiar, and a few may not have appeared in quite this form in the literature. I make no claim of priority for these observations; their purpose is to clarify the underlying structures.

Let me end this introduction by trying to answer a more personal question: why write this review now?

The first answer is very simple: I was invited to write a review, and if one is going to write one, why not this one? I first worked on Scherk–Schwarz compactifications about thirty years ago, and in a sense I began writing this review more than twenty years ago. On several occasions I intended to write a review or a broader account, with the scope oscillating between a general introduction to theories with extra dimensions and a more focused discussion of Scherk–Schwarz compactification. None of these projects was ever completed.

Over the years, however, a number of ideas, questions, and remarks accumulated and remained, so to speak, in the drawers of my mind. Some of them resurfaced when I prepared a workshop talk in Corfu; more recently, others found their way into a paper. At that point I thought that I had enough notes, and perhaps a sufficiently broad view of the subject, to write the review. I had underestimated the challenge.

What happens to fields in higher-dimensional spaces when they move along a circle?

Essential idea

On a circle, the points labelled by yy and y+2πRy+2\pi R are not distinct: they represent the same point of the compact space. Requiring all fields to be strictly periodic is the simplest way to implement this identification, but it is not the only one. A field may instead return after one circuit of the circle to its image under a transformation UU acting on the field space. This gluing transformation is the monodromy and provides the basic geometric ingredient of a Scherk–Schwarz compactification.

Periodicity and compactification

Let us consider a field theory on a spacetime

Md×S1,(2)\mathcal{M}_d \times S^1, \tag*{(2)}

where Md\mathcal{M}_d is dd-dimensional Minkowski space and S1S^1 is a one-dimensional compact manifold. Let yy denote a coordinate on the covering space R\mathbb{R}, with the identification

y∼y+2πR.(3)y \sim y+2\pi R. \tag*{(3)}

The simplest possibility is to regard a field Φ\Phi as an ordinary single-valued function on S1S^1, taking values in a fixed vector space. Its lift to the covering line then satisfies

Φ(x,y+2πR)=Φ(x,y).(4)\Phi(x,y+2\pi R)=\Phi(x,y). \tag*{(4)}

For a scalar field this gives the Fourier expansion

Φ(x,y)=∑n∈ZΦn(x)einy/R,(5)\Phi(x,y)=\sum_{n\in\mathbb{Z}}\Phi_n(x)e^{iny/R}, \tag*{(5)}

and hence the familiar tower of compact momenta

py=nR,n∈Z.(6)p_y=\frac{n}{R},\qquad n\in\mathbb{Z}. \tag*{(6)}

Historically, Kaluza–Klein theories are distinguished by the emergence of lower-dimensional gauge interactions from higher-dimensional gravity [1, 2, 3, 4]; see also Ref. [5] for a historical discussion. Following standard usage in high-energy physics, we shall nevertheless refer loosely to the modes generated by compactification as KK states, even when gravity plays no role. Strict periodicity gives the simplest KK spectrum, with momenta separated by integer units of 1/R1/R. This result, however, already contains an additional assumption: the fibre above yy has been identified with the fibre above y+2πRy+2\pi R by the identity transformation. Compactification identifies the points of the base space, but it does not by itself require this particular identification of the field fibres.

For visualization, the value of Φ\Phi in each fibre will be represented in Figure 1 by an arrow. This should not be understood as implying that Φ\Phi is a vector field: the arrow is merely a graphical representation of an element of the fibre, on which the gluing transformation UU acts.

Compactification on a circle with trivial and non-trivial gluing

Figure 1. Compactifying on a circle identifies yy and y+2πRy + 2\pi R; the interval is only a convenient way of drawing S1S^1 (insets). The arrows representing Φ\Phi are schematic elements of the fibre, not spacetime vectors. In (a) the fibre is glued to itself by the identity, U=1U = 1, whereas in (b) it is glued by a non-trivial monodromy UU.

The more general global identification

A more general description regards a field as a section of a fibre bundle over the compact space. Imagine cutting the circle at one point and representing it as the interval 0≤y≤2πR0 \le y \le2\pi R. Reconstructing the circle requires us to identify the two endpoints, but the corresponding fibres need not be glued by the identity map. They may instead be related by a transformation UU,

Φ(x,2πR)=UΦ(x,0).(7)\Phi(x, 2\pi R) = U\Phi(x, 0). \tag*{(7)}

As we shall discuss in the next question, consistency requires UU to be an admissible symmetry transformation of the higher-dimensional theory. Unrolling the circle onto its covering space gives the equivalent condition

Φ(x,y+2πR)=UΦ(x,y).(8)\Phi(x, y + 2\pi R) = U\Phi(x, y). \tag*{(8)}

For U=1U = 1 one recovers strict periodicity. For U≠1U \ne1 the lifted field on R\mathbb{R} is no longer periodic in the naive sense, even though it defines a perfectly good global field on the compact space once the fibres are glued by UU. The relevant global datum is therefore not the periodicity of a representative on the covering line, but the monodromy specifying how the field is identified after one circuit of the circle.

This distinction between the identification of points in the base space and the gluing of the fibres above them is the elementary geometric ingredient of a Scherk–Schwarz compactification [6, 7]. Much of what follows in this review will consist of determining which transformations UU are allowed, understanding how the same UU acts in different representations, and tracing the physical consequences of that action.

Monodromy and the fundamental group

The same statement can be formulated intrinsically in terms of the fundamental group. The group π1(S1)\pi_1(S^1) consists of equivalence classes of closed loops in S1S^1, two loops being equivalent when one can be continuously deformed into the other while remaining on the circle. Composition is defined by concatenation of loops, and for the circle

π1(S1)≃Z,(9)\pi_1(S^1) \simeq\mathbb{Z}, \tag*{(9)}

where the integer labels the algebraic winding number around the circle. There is therefore a single independent generator, and specifying the monodromy associated with this generator determines the gluing around every loop.

More generally, for a compact space KK, flat monodromy data can be described by a homomorphism

ρ:π1(K)⟶G,(10)\rho: \pi_1(K) \longrightarrow G, \tag*{(10)}

where GG acts on the fibres in the representation appropriate to the field under consideration. The circle is the simplest possible example: π1(S1)\pi_1(S^1) has one generator, so the entire global datum is encoded in one transformation U=ρ(1)U = \rho(1). Which such homomorphisms define physically distinct backgrounds, and in particular the role played by conjugation in GG, will be discussed in the next question.

A familiar example of non-trivial global boundary conditions is provided by spinors. On S1S^1 there are two spin structures, corresponding to

ψ(y+2πR)=+ψ(y),(11)\psi(y + 2\pi R) = +\psi(y), \tag*{(11)}

and

ψ(y+2πR)=−ψ(y).(12)\psi(y + 2\pi R) = -\psi(y). \tag*{(12)}

This elementary example already shows that the geometry of the base space does not uniquely determine the global identification of every field. The precise relations between spin structures, spacetime fermion parity (−1)Fs(-1)^{F_s}, and genuine RR-symmetry twists are subtler and will be discussed later in the review.

Bibliographical remarks

The higher-dimensional origins of Kaluza–Klein compactification are represented here by the original works of Kaluza, Klein, and Einstein–Bergmann [1, 2, 3, 4]; Ref. [5] provides a useful modern discussion of part of this early history. The generalized dimensional-reduction construction based on a non-trivial gluing by a symmetry transformation was developed by Scherk and Schwarz [6, 7]. For the mathematical language of fibre bundles, transition functions, and gluing data, a standard reference is Husemoller [18], while spin structures and spin geometry are treated systematically by Lawson and Michelsohn [19]. We shall use these mathematical notions only to the extent needed to formulate the physical questions that arise in the compactification.

Take-home message

  • Fields on a compact space are naturally regarded as sections of fibre bundles. Identifying points of the base space does not by itself require the fibres to be identified trivially.

  • On a circle, strict periodicity corresponds to trivial gluing and gives the compact momenta py=n/Rp_y = n/R.

  • More generally, a field may return to itself up to a monodromy UU after going around a non-contractible cycle.

  • For a general compact space, flat monodromy data are encoded by the action of its fundamental group on the relevant field fibres.

This naturally leads to the next question:

Why must the twist be associated with a symmetry of the higher-dimensional theory?

Why must the twist be associated with a symmetry of the higher-dimensional theory?

Essential idea

Compactification identifies different representatives of the same point of the internal space. The gluing transformation must therefore assign the same local physics to all such representatives. In the standard field-theoretic Scherk–Schwarz construction, this requires the twist to act as a symmetry of the higher-dimensional theory.

Why is this condition necessary?

As discussed in the previous question, fields need not be strictly periodic on the covering space: one may impose

Φ(x,y+2πR)=UΦ(x,y).(13)\Phi(x,y+2\pi R)=U\Phi(x,y). \tag*{(13)}

This freedom is not unlimited. The coordinates yy and y+2πRy+2\pi R represent the same point of the compact space, and the two representatives cannot be assigned different local dynamics. The restriction becomes particularly transparent if we deliberately try to violate it.

Consider, for example, a real scalar field with Lagrangian

L=12(∂ϕ)2−a[1−cos⁡(ϕf)].(14)\mathcal{L}=\frac{1}{2}(\partial\phi)^2-a\left[1-\cos\left(\frac{\phi}{f}\right)\right]. \tag*{(14)}

where 2πf2\pi f is the periodicity of the scalar potential. Suppose that we try to impose the boundary condition

ϕ(y+2πR)=ϕ(y)+Δ.(15)\phi(y+2\pi R)=\phi(y)+\Delta. \tag*{(15)}

The kinetic term is invariant under a constant shift, but the potential transforms according to

cos⁡(ϕ+Δf)=cos⁡(ϕf+Δf).(16)\cos\left(\frac{\phi+\Delta}{f}\right)=\cos\left(\frac{\phi}{f}+\frac{\Delta}{f}\right). \tag*{(16)}

For a generic value of Δ\Delta, this is not the original potential. The two representatives of the same point would therefore be assigned different local dynamics. The gluing is consistent only when

Δ=2πkf,k∈Z,(17)\Delta=2\pi kf,\qquad k\in\mathbb{Z}, \tag*{(17)}

for which the shift is an actual symmetry of the theory. The example is elementary, but it displays the general principle: the compact identification may act non-trivially on the fields, but it cannot change the local theory as one goes around the circle.

The field-theoretic criterion

For an ordinary internal symmetry in a theory admitting a Lagrangian description, the simplest form of the condition is

L(UΦ)=L(Φ).(18)\mathcal{L}(U\Phi)=\mathcal{L}(\Phi). \tag*{(18)}

More generally, it is sufficient that the action be invariant; the Lagrangian density may change by a total derivative, provided that this change is itself compatible with the global identification and gives no contribution to the action. Equivalently, one may formulate the requirement directly in terms of the equations of motion and the physical observables: UU must map the higher-dimensional theory into itself. The boundary condition (2.1) can then identify two representatives of the same point without creating any local inconsistency.

At the quantum level, the same statement must hold for the full quantum theory. A classical transformation spoiled by an anomaly, for example, cannot in general be used as an exact Scherk–Schwarz twist. Thus the twist is not an arbitrary choice of quasi-periodic boundary condition: around a non-contractible one-cycle it is a monodromy valued in the appropriate symmetry group of the higher-dimensional theory. Which elements of that group act non-trivially on the supercharges is a separate question, to which we shall turn next.

Geometric interpretation

The geometric formulation expresses the same requirement in the language introduced in the previous question. A field is a section of a fibre bundle, and the transition functions specify how local descriptions of the fibre are related on overlapping patches. For a circle, the transition function associated with going once around the compact direction is precisely the monodromy UU. A mathematically well-defined bundle can therefore be constructed with non-trivial gluing.

Mathematical consistency of the bundle alone, however, is not enough for a physical compactification. Its transition functions must also preserve the structures that define the higher-dimensional theory: its action, equations of motion, gauge structure, and, at the quantum level, its exact operator content. In the standard Scherk–Schwarz construction this is the physical statement that the monodromy takes values in an exact symmetry group GG. On a circle one may therefore write

ρ:π1(S1)≃Z⟶G,(19)\rho:\pi_1(S^1)\simeq\mathbb{Z}\longrightarrow G, \tag*{(19)}

with U=ρ(1)U=\rho(1). The abstract homomorphism introduced in the previous question thus acquires a direct physical meaning: it specifies how an allowed symmetry of the higher-dimensional theory is used to glue the fields globally around the compact direction.

Beyond ordinary symmetries

The preceding formulation can be extended beyond transformations acting locally on a conventional set of fields. What is fundamentally required is an exact automorphism of the complete theory. This distinction becomes important in string theory, where two apparently different local descriptions may be related by an exact duality, and such a duality can itself be used as part of the gluing. This leads to duality-twisted and non-geometric compactifications, in which no globally defined higher-dimensional field configuration of the conventional kind need exist.

Those possibilities will be encountered only much later in the review. For the field-theoretic Scherk–Schwarz construction developed in the next questions, the relevant twists will be ordinary symmetries of the higher-dimensional theory. Keeping this simpler setting for the moment will allow us to separate two logically distinct issues: first, whether a twist is admissible at all, and second, whether an admissible twist actually breaks supersymmetry.

Bibliographical remarks

The requirement that the non-trivial dependence on the compact coordinates be controlled by a symmetry of the higher-dimensional theory is already explicit in the original construction of Scherk and Schwarz [6, 7]. Their generalized dimensional reduction uses precisely such a symmetry to factor the dependence on the internal coordinates and to generate masses in the reduced theory. For the underlying bundle language and the role of transition functions, we refer again to the standard treatment in Ref. [18]. More general duality-valued gluings will be discussed, with their appropriate literature, when we turn to string compactifications.

Take-home message

  • A monodromy is not automatically an admissible Scherk–Schwarz twist. Since compactification identifies different representatives of the same spacetime point, the gluing must preserve the local higher-dimensional physics.

  • In the standard field-theoretic construction, the twist therefore acts as a symmetry of the higher-dimensional theory. For a Lagrangian invariant without boundary terms, this reduces to L(UΦ)=L(Φ)\mathcal{L}(U\Phi)=\mathcal{L}(\Phi).

  • The symmetry must be exact at the level at which the compactification is defined. In particular, a classical symmetry obstructed quantum mechanically cannot in general define an exact quantum twist.

  • More generally, the gluing may be an exact automorphism of the complete theory, including suitable dualities in string theory.

This naturally leads to the next question:

Among the admissible twists, which ones break supersymmetry?

Among the admissible twists, which ones break supersymmetry?

Essential Idea

A twisted compactification preserves precisely those supersymmetry transformations whose parameters are globally compatible with the monodromy. For the flat compactifications considered here, the surviving supersymmetries are therefore the invariant subspace of the monodromy induced on the supersymmetry-parameter space.

This criterion tells us which supersymmetries survive the compactification. It does not determine whether their absence should be interpreted as spontaneous breaking. That is a separate dynamical question.

An admissible twist need not preserve all the original symmetries

The previous question determined when a twist is admissible: it must act as a symmetry, or more generally as an exact automorphism, of the higher-dimensional theory. This requirement does not imply that every symmetry of the parent theory survives after compactification. In particular, an admissible monodromy may act non-trivially on the supersymmetry generators. Admissibility and preservation are therefore two distinct questions: the first asks whether the twist can consistently be used to define the compactification, while the second asks which symmetries remain globally well defined once that twist has been imposed.

The supercharge invariant-subspace criterion

Consider a supersymmetric higher-dimensional theory with supersymmetry generators QIQ^{I} and corresponding spinorial transformation parameters ϵI\epsilon^{I}. Schematically, an infinitesimal supersymmetry transformation acts as

δϵΦ∼ϵˉI[QI,Φ],(20)\delta_{\epsilon}\Phi\sim\bar{\epsilon}_{I} [Q^{I},\Phi], \tag*{(20)}

where the bracket is understood as graded whenever appropriate. Let S\mathcal{S} denote the vector space of supersymmetry parameters. If the fields obey the twisted identification

Φ(x,y+2πR)=UΦ(x,y),(21)\Phi(x,y+2\pi R)=U\Phi(x,y), \tag*{(21)}

the same transformation induces an action on S\mathcal{S}, which we denote by Rϵ(U)R_{\epsilon}(U).

For the flat compactification considered here, a supersymmetry of the lower-dimensional theory is generated by a parameter that can be chosen independent of the compact coordinate. Compatibility with the global identification then requires

Rϵ(U) ϵ=ϵ.(22)R_{\epsilon}(U)\,\epsilon=\epsilon. \tag*{(22)}

The preserved supersymmetries are consequently

Spreserved=ker⁡(Rϵ(U)−1).(23)S_{\mathrm{preserved}} = \ker(R_{\epsilon}(U)-1). \tag*{(23)}

With several supersymmetry parameters, Rϵ(U)R_{\epsilon}(U) is simply a matrix acting on the full parameter space, and partial supersymmetry breaking corresponds to a non-zero invariant subspace of dimension smaller than dim⁡S\dim S.

This criterion isolates the global part of the problem. In a more general background, preserved supersymmetries must also satisfy the appropriate local Killing-spinor equations, and the monodromy condition alone need not be sufficient. For the flat backgrounds and flat twists that will occupy us first, however, the invariant-subspace criterion contains the relevant information.

When does a twist break supersymmetry?

If the twist acts trivially on all supersymmetry generators, then

Rϵ(U)=1,(24)R_{\epsilon}(U)=1, \tag*{(24)}

and all supersymmetries survive. Notice that this does not require the twist itself to be trivial: UU may act non-trivially on other quantum numbers and modify the Kaluza–Klein spectrum while leaving every supercharge invariant. The existence of a non-trivial monodromy and the breaking of supersymmetry are therefore logically distinct statements.

An RR-symmetry is distinguished precisely by its non-trivial action on the supersymmetry generators. For a continuous RR-symmetry twist UR(ω)U_R(\omega), let the induced action on the supersymmetry parameters be

Rϵ(UR(ω))=exp⁡(2πiωRϵ),(25)R_{\epsilon}(U_R(\omega))=\exp(2\pi i\omega R_{\epsilon}), \tag*{(25)}

where RϵR_{\epsilon} denotes the RR-symmetry generator in the representation carried by SS. In a basis in which this generator is diagonal,

Rϵ(UR(ω)) ϵA=e2πiωqAϵA,(26)R_{\epsilon}(U_R(\omega))\,\epsilon_A=e^{2\pi i\omega q_A}\epsilon_A, \tag*{(26)}

with qAq_A the corresponding RR-charge. The supersymmetry generated by ϵA\epsilon_A survives if and only if

e2πiωqA=1.(27)e^{2\pi i\omega q_A}=1. \tag*{(27)}

Depending on the spectrum of RR-charges and on the value of the twist, the compactification may therefore preserve all, part, or none of the supersymmetry of the parent theory.

Several cycles

Nothing in the invariant-subspace argument is specific to a single circle. For a compact space KK, let

ρϵ:π1(K)⟶GL(S)(28)\rho_{\epsilon}:\pi_1(K)\longrightarrow\mathrm{GL}(S) \tag*{(28)}

denote the monodromy representation induced on the supersymmetry parameters. In the absence of additional local Killing-spinor constraints, the globally preserved supersymmetries are

Spreserved={ϵ∈S∣ρϵ(γ)ϵ=ϵ for every γ∈π1(K)}.(29)S_{\mathrm{preserved}}=\{\epsilon\in S\mid\rho_{\epsilon}(\gamma)\epsilon=\epsilon\ \text{for every }\gamma\in\pi_1(K)\}. \tag*{(29)}

A supersymmetry parameter must thus belong to the common invariant subspace of all monodromies. For a torus, the generators of π1(Tn)≃Zn\pi_1(T^n) \simeq\mathbb{Z}^n commute, and so must their monodromies. For a more general compact space, the monodromies instead obey the relations of its fundamental group.

What this criterion does not tell us

The invariant-subspace criterion is kinematical. If Spreserved={0}S_{\mathrm{preserved}} = \{0\}, no global supersymmetry survives, but this alone does not determine whether the breaking is spontaneous, whether a Goldstino exists, or whether a super-Higgs mechanism occurs. Those questions require additional dynamical information and will be addressed later.

Bibliographical remarks

The use of a higher-dimensional symmetry that acts non-trivially on the supersymmetry generators is already central to the original construction of Scherk and Schwarz [6, 7]. Their first explicit supergravity example uses a chiral symmetry of the higher-dimensional theory to give mass to the gravitino while leaving the graviton massless. Applications in higher-dimensional supersymmetric theories with matter and gauge multiplets, including explicit RR-symmetry twists and the corresponding patterns of partial or complete supersymmetry breaking, were developed further by Fayet [8, 9]. We shall return to these constructions when discussing the mass spectrum, the gravitino, and the dynamical interpretation of Scherk–Schwarz breaking.

Take-home message

  • Admissibility and supersymmetry preservation are distinct questions: an allowed twist need not preserve all the symmetries of the higher-dimensional theory.

  • For the flat compactifications considered here, the preserved supersymmetries form the invariant subspace of the monodromy acting on the supersymmetry-parameter space.

  • A non-trivial twist may preserve all supersymmetries if it acts trivially on the supercharges, while an RR-symmetry twist may preserve all, part, or none of them. With several cycles, the relevant subspace is the common invariant subspace of all monodromies.

  • This criterion is kinematical: the absence of invariant supersymmetry parameters does not by itself establish spontaneous supersymmetry breaking or a super-Higgs mechanism.

This naturally leads to the next question:

How does a monodromy modify the Kaluza–Klein spectrum?

How does a monodromy modify the Kaluza–Klein spectrum?

Essential idea

A monodromy changes the global spectral problem. Fields become sections of the flat bundle defined by the monodromy, and the Kaluza–Klein masses are determined by the spectrum of the corresponding twisted internal operator. The familiar shift (n+ω)/R(n+\omega)/R is the special result obtained for a phase monodromy on a flat circle.

The twisted spectral problem

Consider a higher-dimensional spacetime locally of the form Md×K\mathcal{M}_d \times K, with KK compact. For a scalar field of higher-dimensional mass m0m_0, the Klein–Gordon operator separates into a dd-dimensional d’Alembertian and an internal Laplacian ΔK\Delta_K. Writing

−ΔKψα=λαψα(30)-\Delta_K\psi_\alpha=\lambda_\alpha\psi_\alpha \tag*{(30)}

the corresponding lower-dimensional masses are

mα2=m02+λα.(31)m_\alpha^2=m_0^2+\lambda_\alpha. \tag*{(31)}

This is the ordinary Kaluza–Klein spectral problem.

Now equip the compactification with monodromy data

References

No references were extracted for this paper.

Paper details

vlnc:W_7bztyaup
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY-SA 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents