betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The renormalization of the shell-model neutrinoless double-beta decay operator starting from effective field theory at leading order

Abstract

In this work, we approach for the first time the task to perform a shell-model calculation of the matrix element for the neutrinoless double-beta decay, within a fully-consistent framework where the expressions of the nuclear Hamiltonian and of the decay operators have been derived through chiral perturbation theory. More precisely, the effective shell-model Hamiltonian and all transition operators have been constructed by way of the many-body perturbation theory, and then employed to calculate both spectroscopic properties of the nuclei involved in the decays under our consideration - namely 48Ca, 76Ge, and 82Se -, as well as the nuclear matrix elements of the electromagnetic and neutrinoless double-beta decays. We also present a study of the convergence properties of the calculated matrix elements in order to provide the elements for an estimate of the theoretical uncertainty.

Introduction

During the first decades of this century, the nuclear structure community has seen the rise and consolidation of an innovative approach to the description of atomic nuclei, namely the application of the principles of effective field theory (EFT) to the dynamics ruling the interaction of nucleons in the nuclear environment.

The seeds of such a revolution were planted in a few papers by Steven Weinberg, where it was suggested that nuclei, as low-energy systems, could be studied in terms of pions and nucleons within the framework of EFT [1, 2, 3]. In such an approach, the long-range component of the nuclear force should be ruled by the symmetries of low-energy QCD – and in particular the spontaneously broken chiral symmetry – and the short-range dynamics is taken into account by a complete set of contact terms, which are proportional to low-energy constants (LECs) that have to be fitted to data.

Chiral perturbation theory (ChPT) has then provided a powerful tool to construct nuclear Hamiltonians with a direct link to the underlying theory for the strong force among hadrons (QCD), and to expand nuclear forces in a consistent structure of two- and many-body components [4, 5].

Moreover, also electroweak currents can be consistently constructed through ChPT, since this framework accounts for the composite nature of hadrons through the symmetries of QCD. As a matter of fact, during the last decade the ChPT expansion of the Gamow-Teller (GT) decay operator has been applied to study standard β\beta-decay processes in different mass regions [6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12], and has contributed substantially to the understanding of the nature of the well-known problem of the quenching of the axial coupling constant gAg_A.

In recent years, EFT has been also applied to construct electroweak currents corresponding to the neutrinoless double-β\beta (0νββ0\nu\beta\beta) decay, performing a ChPT expansion of the two-body current up to next-to-next-to-leading order (N2^{2}LO) [13]. A relevant feature of the derivation of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay operator within EFT – within the light Majorana-neutrino exchange scenario – is the emergence at the leading order (LO) of a contact operator, that is required to guarantee the renormalizability of the process [13, 14]. Such a short-range component does not appear in the standard expression of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta operator, that is characterized only by a long-range component [15, 16], and also introduces a new LEC that has to be renormalized by evaluating the nn→ppe−e−nn \to pp e^{-}e^{-} amplitude [17].

In this paper, we present the results of shell-model (SM) calculations which aim to calculate the nuclear matrix element of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay M0νM^{0\nu} for a few nuclei of interest – 48^{48}Ca, 76^{76}Ca, and 82^{82}Se – in terms of effective SM Hamiltonians and decay operators that have been derived from nuclear potentials and 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta currents which have been constructed through ChPT.

Our present work is a natural extension of a previous one [12], where we investigated GT transitions involving the same nuclear systems to assess the role of both two-body electroweak currents and many-body correlations as the causes of the well-known issue of the quenching of the axial coupling constant gAg_A [18]. In fact, as in Ref. [12], we employ effective SM Hamiltonians (HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s) derived by way of the many-body perturbation theory [19, 20, 21, 22], starting from the well-known two-nucleon potential constructed by Entem and Machleidt through a chiral perturbative expansion up to N3^{3}LO [5, 23], and paired by a three-body component that is consistently built at N2^{2}LO in ChPT.

Consistently with the construction of HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s, we derive effective SM decay operators from two-body current operators at LO in ChPT, by way of the same many-body approach we have followed in our previous study [24], where the calculations were performed starting from the high-precision CD-Bonn nucleon-nucleon (2NF) potential. tential [25], whose repulsive high-momentum components were renormalized through the Vlow−kV_{\mathrm{low-k}} procedure [26]. We also confront the outcome of our study with the results reported in a recent paper of Castillo et al., where the authors performed the calculation of 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta nuclear matrix elements by way of the nuclear shell model and proton-neutron quasiparticle random-phase approximation (pn-QRPA), using two-body decay currents up to N2LON^{2}\mathrm{LO} in ChPT, but employing phenomenological HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s [27].

This work is organized as follows. In the upcoming Section II, we report a few details about the expression of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay operator according to the ChPT expansion [13], and highlight the procedure we have followed to derive the effective SM Hamiltonian as well as the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta operator, starting from the chiral 2NF N3LON^{3}\mathrm{LO} potential constructed by Entem and Machleidt [23] and juxtaposed by a three-body component at N2LON^{2}\mathrm{LO} in ChPT [5].

The results of the SM calculations are then presented in Sec. III, where first we report the results of low-energy spectroscopic properties of the nuclei involved in the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}, to support the reliability of our approach to the SM calculation of electroweak transitions by way of effective Hamiltonians and operators, and validate the nuclear wave functions of the initial and final states. Then, we report the calculated nuclear matrix elements M0νM^{0\nu}’s, as well as a study of the perturbative behavior of those theoretical values to estimate the theoretical uncertainties that originate from our approach.

The conclusions of this study are drawn in Sec. IV, together with the perspectives of our current project.

Theoretical Framework

ChPT Hamiltonian and 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay operators

As mentioned in the Introduction, during the end of 1990s and the dawn of 2000s the application of EFT to low-energy nuclear systems, especially within the ChPT approach, has provided a valuable tool to tackle the problem of generating hadronic interactions in a low-energy regime [4, 5]. The relevant feature of pursuing this approach to the construction of nuclear forces is the link with their underlying theory – the quantum chromodynamics –, that is obtained through the fundamental requirement that any nuclear effective Hamiltonian has to obey to the relevant symmetries of QCD [1].

This framework is based on identifying a separation of the scales between hadronic systems that are characterized by well-defined energy regimes [28]. For finite nuclei the so-called “hard scale” is set at Λχ∼mρ∼1\Lambda_{\chi} \sim m_{\rho} \sim1 GeV and the soft scale is then identified with the pion mass – Q∼mπQ \sim m_{\pi} –, known also as the chiral-symmetry breaking scale. This represents the building block of the low-energy ChPT expansion, which is arranged in terms of the soft scale over the hard scale, (Q/Λχ)ν(Q/\Lambda_{\chi})^{\nu}, QQ being an external momentum or a pion mass, while the degrees of freedom of the nuclear Hamiltonian are pions and nucleons and, in some cases, (Δ)(\Delta) resonances.

As previously reported, for the present study, we have considered a nuclear Hamiltonian consisting of a two-(2NF) and a three-nucleon (3NF) component of the nuclear force. As regards the 2NF component, we choose the high-precision potential developed by Entem and Machleidt through a perturbative expansion at N3LON^{3}\mathrm{LO} [23], that is characterized by a regulator function whose cutoff parameter is Λ=500\Lambda= 500 MeV. This potential exhibits a smooth behavior in the high-momentum regime and can be profitably employed for a perturbative derivation of HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}, as was shown in Refs. [21, 29]. Consistently, the 2NF potential is paired by a 3NF one, derived at N2LON^{2}\mathrm{LO} in ChPT, and consisting of three topologies: the two-pion exchange (2PE), one-pion exchange (1PE), and three-nucleon-contact interactions [5]. These terms are specified by a set of LECs that already appear in the 2NF components, but they also contain a new LEC cDc_{D} – associated to the 1PE contribution –, while another new one, cEc_{E}, enters in the 3NF contact potential. These LECs, cDc_{D} and cEc_{E}, should be fixed to reproduce the observables of the A=3A = 3 system, and we have adopted the same values as in Refs. [12, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33], namely cD=−1c_{D} = -1 and cE=−0.34c_{E} = -0.34. This choice traces back to a study performed within the no-core shell model (NCSM), where the authors first constrained the relation of cDc_{D}-cEc_{E}, and then investigated a set of observables in light pp-shell nuclei to obtain a second constraint [34].

As pointed out in the Introduction, another key feature of ChPT is to provide a tool to construct also electroweak currents consistently with the derivation of the nuclear Hamiltonian, routing the structure of these decay operators in the symmetries of the QCD and also accounting for the composite structure of nucleons and pions [35, 37, 38, 39, 40] [36]. This approach has been extensively applied to study GT transitions in light nuclear systems [6, 7, 8, 9, 10], in a few medium-mass nuclei through abab initioinitio methods [11], and also by way of the realistic shell model [12]. The application of ChPT to the study of β\beta decay has represented a turning point in the understanding of the mechanism of the renormalization of electroweak operators in nuclear systems, and overcoming the so-called “quenching problem” of the axial coupling constant gAg_{A} [41, 42, 43].

ChPT has been also employed to construct the expression of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay operator induced by the light Majorana-neutrino exchange, shifting the physics of such a process from the energy scale of the lepton-number violation ΛLNV=1−100\Lambda_{\mathrm{LNV}} = 1 - 100 TeV down the one of low-energy nuclear systems, namely the chiral-symmetry breaking scale [13].

In recent years, the expansion of two- and three-body currents of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta operator has been carried out in ChPT [13, 44, 45], and a few studies on the impact of this novel approach to the definition of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta operator has been already conducted by calculating the nuclear matrix elements M0νM^{0\nu}’s for nuclei that are currently of experimental interest [27, 46, 47, 48].

As a matter of fact, one of the most relevant features of the definition of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay operator in ChPT is the emergence of a short-range contact operator which is not present in the standard formulation of the theory of 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay [15, 16]. In the earliest formulation of the EFT approach to defining the light-neutrino exchange mechanism of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay, this contact term appeared as a contribution at N2^{2}LO of the ChPT expansion [13]. Then, in a following study it has been shown that this contribution had to be promoted at LO of the expansion, to accomplish the need to introduce a counterterm to absorb the ultraviolet (UV) divergences that appear in the calculation of the amplitude of the nn→ppe−e−nn \to ppe^{-}e^{-} process for 1S0→1S0{}^{1}S_{0} \to{}^{1}S_{0} transitions [14].

As a counterterm, this contribution is regulated by a LEC, dubbed gνNNg_{\nu}^{NN}, and the only way to fix it would be by reproducing the data of lepton-number-violation (LNV) processes, data that are not available at present.

In Ref. [14], the authors suggested to estimate the magnitude of the contact term by considering the coefficients of the charge-independence breaking (CIB) contact interaction. For the Entem-Machleidt N3^{3}LO potential this leads to gνNN=−0.47 fm2g_{\nu}^{NN} = -0.47\ \mathrm{fm}^{2}, that is the value we have employed in this work. It is worth pointing out that Jokiniemi et al. have followed the same considerations in Ref. [47].

As can be seen in the following, these considerations about the contact term, that is intimately connected with the renormalization mechanism of ChPT approach, are very important in the definition of the nuclear matrix element M0νM^{0\nu}.

It should be recalled that the expression of the half-life of a 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay, assuming the exchange of a light Majorana neutrino, is:

[T1/20ν]−1=G0νgA4∣M0ν∣2∣⟨mν⟩me∣2(1)\left[T_{1/2}^{0\nu}\right]^{-1}=G^{0\nu}g_{A}^{4}\left|M^{0\nu}\right|^{2}\left|\frac{\langle m_{\nu}\rangle}{m_{e}}\right|^{2} \tag*{(1)}

where G0νG^{0\nu} is the phase-space factor [49, 50], M0νM^{0\nu} is the nuclear matrix element directly related to the wave functions of the parent and grand-daughter nuclei, gAg_{A} is the axial coupling constant, mem_{e} is the electron mass, and ⟨mν⟩=∑i(Uei)2mi\langle m_{\nu}\rangle=\sum_{i}(U_{ei})^{2}m_{i} is the effective neutrino mass, as expressed in terms of the neutrino masses mim_{i} and their mixing matrix elements UeiU_{ei}.

At LO in ChPT, M0νM^{0\nu} is expressed as the sum of a long- and short-range components [13]:

M0ν=ML0ν+MS0ν(2)M^{0\nu}=M_{L}^{0\nu}+M_{S}^{0\nu} \tag*{(2)}

In turn, the formal expression of the LO long-range component ML0νM_{L}^{0\nu} is expressed in terms of the two-body transition-density matrix elements ⟨f∣ap†anap′†an′∣i⟩\langle f|a_{p}^{\dagger}a_{n}a_{p'}^{\dagger}a_{n'}|i\rangle, between the initial (ii) and final (ff) nuclear wave functions, as:

MLα0ν=∑jnjn′jpjp′⟨f∣ap†anap′†an′∣i⟩⟨jpjp′∣ΘLα∣jnjn′⟩(3)M_{L\alpha}^{0\nu}=\sum_{j_{n}j_{n'}j_{p}j_{p'}}\langle f|a_{p}^{\dagger}a_{n}a_{p'}^{\dagger}a_{n'}|i\rangle\left\langle j_{p}j_{p'}\left|\Theta_{L\alpha}\right|j_{n}j_{n'}\right\rangle \tag*{(3)}

where α\alpha stands for Fermi (FF), Gamow-Teller (GTGT), or tensor (TT) decay channels, and the operators ΘLα\Theta_{L\alpha} are [51]:

ΘGT=[τ1⋅τ2(σ1⋅σ2)HGT(r)],(4)\Theta_{GT}=\left[\boldsymbol{\tau}_{1}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_{2}\left(\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{1}\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{2}\right)H_{GT}(r)\right], \tag*{(4)}
ΘF=τ1⋅τ2HF(r),(5)\Theta_{F}=\boldsymbol{\tau}_{1}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_{2}H_{F}(r), \tag*{(5)}
ΘT=[τ1⋅τ2(3(σ1⋅r^)(σ2⋅r^)−σ1⋅σ2)HT(r)],(6)\Theta_{T}=\left[\boldsymbol{\tau}_{1}\cdot\boldsymbol{\tau}_{2}\left(3\left(\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{1}\cdot\hat{r}\right)\left(\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{2}\cdot\hat{r}\right)-\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{1}\cdot\boldsymbol{\sigma}_{2}\right)H_{T}(r)\right], \tag*{(6)}

The neutrino potentials are expressed as [13]:

Hα(r)=2Rπ∫0∞jnα(qr)hα(q2)q dq(7)H_{\alpha}(r)=\frac{2R}{\pi}\int_{0}^{\infty}j_{n_{\alpha}}(qr)h_{\alpha}(q^{2})q\,dq \tag*{(7)}

It should be pointed out that at LO the expression of ML0νM_{L}^{0\nu}, as well as the one of the neutrino potentials in Eq. (7), is the same as the one in the standard formulation [15, 16] when resorting to the closure approximation [51], but setting the closure energy equal to zero [13].

Coming back to Eq. (7), the nuclear radius RR is defined as R=1.2A1/3 fmR=1.2A^{1/3}\ \mathrm{fm}, jnα(qr)j_{n_{\alpha}}(qr) is the spherical Bessel function, nα=0n_{\alpha}=0 for Fermi and Gamow-Teller components, while nα=2n_{\alpha}=2 for the tensor component.

In the following, we also report the explicit expressions of neutrino form functions, hα(q)h_{\alpha}(q), for light-neutrino exchange at LO [13]:

hF(q2)=gV2,h_{F}(q^{2})=g_{V}^{2},
hGT(q2)=[1−23q2q2+mπ2+13(q2q2+mπ2)2]+23gM2gA2q24mp2,h_{GT}(q^{2})=\left[1-\frac{2}{3}\frac{q^{2}}{q^{2}+m_{\pi}^{2}}+\frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{q^{2}}{q^{2}+m_{\pi}^{2}}\right)^{2}\right]+\frac{2}{3}\frac{g_{M}^{2}}{g_{A}^{2}}\frac{q^{2}}{4m_{p}^{2}},
hT(q2)=[23q2q2+mπ2−13(q2q2+mπ2)2]+13gM2gA2q24mp2(8)h_{T}(q^{2})=\left[\frac{2}{3}\frac{q^{2}}{q^{2}+m_{\pi}^{2}}-\frac{1}{3}\left(\frac{q^{2}}{q^{2}+m_{\pi}^{2}}\right)^{2}\right]+\frac{1}{3}\frac{g_{M}^{2}}{g_{A}^{2}}\frac{q^{2}}{4m_{p}^{2}} \tag*{(8)}

where gV=1g_{V}=1, gA≡gAfree=1.2723g_{A}\equiv g_{A}^{free}=1.2723, gM=(μp−μn)gVg_{M}=(\mu_{p}-\mu_{n})g_{V}, and (μp−μn)=4.7(\mu_{p}-\mu_{n})=4.7.

Then, the full expression of the long-range term (at LO) of the nuclear matrix element M0νM^{0\nu} is written as

ML0ν=MGT0ν−gV2gA2MF0ν+MT0ν.(9)M_{L}^{0\nu}=M_{GT}^{0\nu}-\frac{g_{V}^{2}}{g_{A}^{2}}M_{F}^{0\nu}+M_{T}^{0\nu}. \tag*{(9)}

As regards the short-range contact term, its expression is the same as in Eq. 3

MS0ν=∑jnjn′jpjp′⟨f∣ap†anap′†an′∣i⟩⟨jpjp′∣ΘS∣jnjn′⟩(10)M_{S}^{0\nu}=\sum_{j_nj_n'j_pj_p'}\langle f|a_{p}^{\dagger}a_{n}a_{p'}^{\dagger}a_{n'}|i\rangle \langle j_pj_{p'}|\Theta_{S}|j_nj_{n'}\rangle \tag*{(10)}

where ΘS\Theta_{S} is:

ΘS=τ1−τ2−HS(r),(11)\Theta_{S}=\tau_{1}^{-}\tau_{2}^{-}H_{S}(r), \tag*{(11)}

and the neutrino potential is:

HS(r)=2Rπ∫0∞j0(qr)hS(q2)q2dq,(12)H_{S}(r)=\frac{2R}{\pi}\int_{0}^{\infty}j_{0}(qr)h_{S}(q^{2})q^{2}dq, \tag*{(12)}

where we choose to regularize the contact term with a Gaussian regulator as in Refs. [27, 47]:

hS(q2)=−2(gνNN/gA2)e−q2/(2Λ2).(13)h_{S}(q^{2})=-2\left(g_{\nu}^{NN}/g_{A}^{2}\right)e^{-q^{2}/(2\Lambda^{2})}. \tag*{(13)}

Effective SM Hamiltonian and transition operators

In this section we are going to sketch out briefly our approach to the derivation of the effective SM operators that are necessary to construct the nuclear wave functions – namely, the effective SM Hamiltonian HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} –, and then calculate the nuclear matrix elements that are needed to extract the half-lives of electromagnetic and β\beta decays, the effective SM decay operators Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}}’s.

A more detailed presentation of our approach to the derivation of effective SM Hamiltonians and transition operators by way of the many-body perturbation theory, and starting from realistic nuclear forces, can be found in Refs. [21, 22, 52].

As mentioned in the Introduction, we construct the two HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s, for 0f1p0f1p and 0f5/21p0g9/20f_{5/2}1p0g_{9/2} model spaces, respectively, starting from the ChPT nuclear Hamiltonian as described in § 2 A.

It is also worth noting that the Coulomb potential is explicitly included in the proton-proton channel of the nuclear Hamiltonian.

The procedure to derive HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} starts from the SM nuclear Hamiltonian HH for AA interacting nucleons, which, by introducing an auxiliary potential UU, is split into a one-body term H0H_{0}, whose eigenvectors provide the unperturbed SM basis, and an interaction component H1H_{1}:

H=T+V2NF+V3NF=(T+U)+(V2NF+V3NF−U)=H0+H1,(14)\begin{aligned} H &= T+V_{2\mathrm{NF}}+V_{3\mathrm{NF}}=(T+U)+(V_{2\mathrm{NF}}+V_{3\mathrm{NF}}-U)\\ &=H_{0}+H_{1}, \tag*{(14)} \end{aligned}

where the auxiliary potential UU is chosen to be the harmonic-oscillator (HO) one, with a value according to the Blomqvist-Molinari formula ℏω=45A−1/3−25A−2/3\hbar\omega=45A^{-1/3}-25A^{-2/3} MeV [53], namely ℏω=11\hbar\omega=11 and 1010 MeV for 40Ca{}^{40}\mathrm{Ca} and 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} cores, respectively.

Since the eigenvalue problem of HH for a many-body system, and within an infinite Hilbert-space of H0H_{0} eigenvectors, cannot be solved, there is the need to construct an effective Hamiltonian by way of a similarity transformation [54, 55] to project the eigenvalue problem into a truncated model space. In our case, we study the double-β\beta decay of 48Ca{}^{48}\mathrm{Ca} considering the model space by four proton and neutron orbitals 0f7/20f_{7/2}, 0f5/20f_{5/2}, 1p3/21p_{3/2}, 1p1/21p_{1/2}, outside 40Ca{}^{40}\mathrm{Ca} doubly-closed core. As regards the decays of 76Ge{}^{76}\mathrm{Ge} and 82Se{}^{82}\mathrm{Se}, the model space is spanned by the four HO orbitals 0f5/20f_{5/2}, 1p3/21p_{3/2}, 1p1/21p_{1/2}, 0g9/20g_{9/2}, now considering 56Ni{}^{56}\mathrm{Ni} as reference nucleus.

These are the same model spaces as in Ref. [12], where we have performed a study of single- and double-β\beta decays of the same isotopes.

The HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s for these model spaces are derived by way of the time-dependent perturbation theory, namely performing the Kuo-Lee-Ratcliff folded-diagram expansion in terms of the Q^\hat{Q}-box vertex function [21, 56, 57]:

H1eff(ω)=Q^(ϵ0)−PH1Q1ϵ0−QHQQH1eff(ω),(15)H_{1}^{\mathrm{eff}}(\omega)=\hat{Q}(\epsilon_{0})-PH_{1}Q\frac{1}{\epsilon_{0}-QHQ}QH_{1}^{\mathrm{eff}}(\omega), \tag*{(15)}

where ω\omega is the wave operator decoupling the model space PP and its complement QQ, and ϵ0\epsilon_{0} is the eigenvalue of the unperturbed degenerate HO Hamiltonian H0H_{0}.

We recall that Q^\hat{Q} box operator is defined as

Q^(ϵ)=PH1P+PH1Q1ϵ−QHQQH1P,(16)\hat{Q}(\epsilon)=PH_{1}P+PH_{1}Q\frac{1}{\epsilon-QHQ}QH_{1}P, \tag*{(16)}

and ϵ\epsilon is an energy parameter called the “starting energy”.

Computationally, it is impossible to perform an exact calculation of the Q^\hat{Q} box, then the term 1/(ϵ−QHQ)1/(\epsilon-QHQ) is expanded as a power series

1ϵ−QHQ=∑n=0∞1ϵ−QH0Q(QH1Qϵ−QH0Q)n.(17)\frac{1}{\epsilon-QHQ}=\sum_{n=0}^{\infty}\frac{1}{\epsilon-QH_{0}Q}\left(\frac{QH_{1}Q}{\epsilon-QH_{0}Q}\right)^{n}. \tag*{(17)}

In all our applications of the many-body perturbation theory to derive HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}, we expand the Q^\hat{Q} box up to the third order in perturbation theory (n=1) [22], and the set of two-body configurations belonging to the subspace QQ is truncated to those which correspond to an excitation energy smaller than Emax⁡=Nmax⁡ℏωE_{\max}=N_{\max}\hbar\omega [21]. In the present paper, we employ the same HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s as in Ref. [12], where all effective SM operators and Hamiltonians have been calculated through Nmax⁡=18N_{\max}=18.

It should be pointed out that we have performed previous studies [29, 58], where it was verified that such a value of Nmax⁡N_{\max} is large enough to obtain convergent values of the single-particle (SP) energies and two-body matrix elements of the residual interaction (TBMEs), that is the basic requirement for stable values of the excitation spectra and transition strengths, with a fixed decay operator.

After the Q^\hat{Q} box is calculated perturbatively, the nonlinear matrix equation (15) can be solved by way of iterative techniques [54, 59], or graphical non-iterative methods [60].

Usually, SM calculations are performed by a number of valence nucleons that are larger than two, then we include also contributions from induced three-body forces in the calculation of the Q^\hat{Q} box, namely involving also three valence nucleons, and then resort to a normal-ordering decomposition of the 3NF induced-force contributions arising at second order in perturbation theory. More details of such a method are reported in Refs. [22, 31], but it is worth pointing out that the chosen reference state is the ground state of the nucleus under study, and we consider a fractional filling of model-space orbitals, a procedure that is performed also for the application of the valence-space in-medium similarity transformation group (VS-IMSRG) approach within the “target” normal ordering [61].

We have adopted the normal-ordering decomposition also calculating the contributions at first order in many-body perturbation theory for the calculation of the Q^\hat{Q} box of the N2^{2}LO 3NF component of the ChPT Hamiltonian [30].

The SM parameters of the HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s that have been employed to study the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay of 48^{48}Ca, 76^{76}Ge, and 82^{82}Se – namely the SP energies and the TBMEs of the residual interaction – are included in the Supplemental Material in Ref. [12].

Now, we turn our attention to the derivation of effective SM decay operators Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}}’s.

The need to build effective operators is due to the issue that the diagonalization of the HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} does not lead to the true nuclear wave-functions, but to their projections onto the model space PP. This means that, consistently with the construction of HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}, any decay operator Θ\Theta has to be renormalized, so that Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} accounts for the neglected degrees of freedom belonging to the subspace Q=1−PQ=1-P.

As in our previous studies of double-β\beta decay processes [12, 24, 62, 63, 64], the construction of the effective SM 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta operators has been carried out by way of the approach that has been introduced by Suzuki and Okamoto [20], that is consistent with the derivation of HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}.

As for HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}, the derivation of Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} is grounded on the perturbative expansion of a vertex function, the so-called Θ^\hat{\Theta} box, which is the counterpart of the Q^\hat{Q} box that has been previously defined in Eq. (16). The details of the procedure can be found in Refs. [20, 22], here we are only going to outline the structure of the derivation of any effective SM decay operators Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} by way of many-body perturbation theory.

As previously mentioned, the perturbative calculation of Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} starts from introducing two energy-dependent vertex functions:

Θ^(ϵ)=PΘP+PΘQ1ϵ−QHQQH1P ,\hat{\Theta}(\epsilon)=P\Theta P+P\Theta Q\frac{1}{\epsilon-QHQ}QH_{1}P \, ,
Θ^(ϵ1;ϵ2)=PH1Q1ϵ1−QHQQΘQ1ϵ2−QHQQH1P ,\hat{\Theta}(\epsilon_{1};\epsilon_{2})=PH_{1}Q\frac{1}{\epsilon_{1}-QHQ}Q\Theta Q\frac{1}{\epsilon_{2}-QHQ}QH_{1}P \, ,

and of their derivatives calculated in ϵ=ϵ0\epsilon=\epsilon_{0}, ϵ0\epsilon_{0} being the eigenvalue of the degenerate unperturbed Hamiltonian H0H_{0}:

Θ^m=1m!dmΘ^(ϵ)dϵm∣ϵ=ϵ0 ,\hat{\Theta}_{m}=\left.\frac{1}{m!}\frac{d^{m}\hat{\Theta}(\epsilon)}{d\epsilon^{m}}\right|_{\epsilon=\epsilon_{0}} \, ,
Θ^mn=1m!n!dmdϵ1mdndϵ2nΘ^(ϵ1;ϵ2)∣ϵ1=ϵ0,ϵ2=ϵ0 .\hat{\Theta}_{mn}=\left.\frac{1}{m!n!}\frac{d^{m}}{d\epsilon_{1}^{m}}\frac{d^{n}}{d\epsilon_{2}^{n}}\hat{\Theta}(\epsilon_{1};\epsilon_{2})\right|_{\epsilon_{1}=\epsilon_{0},\epsilon_{2}=\epsilon_{0}} \, .

Then, a series of operators χn\chi_{n} is calculated:

χ0=(Θ^0+h.c.)+Θ^00 ,(18)\chi_{0}=(\hat{\Theta}_{0}+h.c.)+\hat{\Theta}_{00} \, , \tag*{(18)}
χ1=(Θ^1Q^+h.c.)+(Θ^01Q^+h.c.) ,(19)\chi_{1}=(\hat{\Theta}_{1}\hat{Q}+h.c.)+(\hat{\Theta}_{01}\hat{Q}+h.c.) \, , \tag*{(19)}
χ2=(Θ^1Q^1Q^+h.c.)+(Θ^2Q^Q^+h.c.)+(Θ^02Q^Q^+h.c.)+Q^Θ^11Q^ ,(20)\chi_{2}=(\hat{\Theta}_{1}\hat{Q}_{1}\hat{Q}+h.c.)+(\hat{\Theta}_{2}\hat{Q}\hat{Q}+h.c.)+(\hat{\Theta}_{02}\hat{Q}\hat{Q}+h.c.)+\hat{Q}\hat{\Theta}_{11}\hat{Q} \, , \tag*{(20)}

⋯\cdots

where Q^=Q^(ϵ)\hat{Q}=\hat{Q}(\epsilon).

Finally, Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} is expressed in the following form:

Θeff=HeffQ^−1(χ0+χ1+χ2+⋯ ) .(21)\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}}=H_{\mathrm{eff}}\hat{Q}^{-1}(\chi_{0}+\chi_{1}+\chi_{2}+\cdots) \, . \tag*{(21)}

where the Θ^\hat{\Theta} function is expanded up to third order in perturbation theory, consistently with the perturbative calculation of the Q^\hat{Q} box.

It should be noticed that, since the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay operator owns a two-body structure and we are considering nuclear systems with a number of valence nucleons far larger than two, we have included in the Θ^\hat{\Theta} box expansion also leading-order three-body contributions, namely the second-order three-body diagrams that can be found in Refs. [22, 24]. In Ref. [24] we have also discussed the impact of these three-body contributions to the definition of Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} for the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay.

In Refs. [24, 58, 63] there are reported studies of the convergence of the χn\chi_{n} series and of the perturbative properties of the Θ^\hat{\Theta} box, in order to support the robustness of the expansion of Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}}.

It is worth pointing out that one of the themes of discussion of the results in Sec. III will be the evaluation of theoretical uncertainties associated to our calculated M0νM^{0\nu}’s of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decays of 48^{48}Ca, 76^{76}Ge, and 82^{82}Se, uncertainties that originate from the perturbative expansion of HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} and Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}}.

Results

In this section we present the results of our SM calculations, that are obtained by employing HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s and Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}}’s from ChPT. First, it is worth considering the quality of the agreement between calculated and experimental spectroscopic properties of the nuclei which are the focus of our study, aiming to assess the quality of the nuclear wave functions we employ to calculate M0νM^{0\nu}’s. The results of such a study have already been reported in Ref. [12], and in § 3 A we will report a study of the perturbative properties of HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s and decay Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}}’s.

Then, in § 3 B we report the results of the calculation of M0νM^{0\nu}’s for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} decays, considering the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay operator at the LO in ChPT expansion. We will present an analysis of the perturbative properties of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} to ascertain an uncertainty estimate of the calculated M0νM^{0\nu}’s, and compare the results with those we obtained in a similar study, in which we have derived HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s and Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}}’s from the meson-theoretic CD-Bonn 2NF potential [24].

Theoretical results vs. experimental quantities

As already pointed out in the previous sections, our SM calculations are carried out employing theoretical SP energies, TBMEs, and effective transition operators as reported in § 2 B, whose details can be found in Ref. [22].

We start considering the nuclei involved in the double-β\beta decay of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, namely the latter and 48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ti}. In Figure 1, we show the experimental [65] and calculated low-energy spectra of both nuclei, obtained within the full fpfp shell, namely the proton and neutron 0f7/20f_{7/2}, 0f5/20f_{5/2}, 1p3/21p_{3/2}, and 1p1/21p_{1/2} orbitals. The arrow widths are proportional to the B(E2)B(E2) strengths, and next to them we report also the theoretical and experimental values in e2fm4e^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{4} [65].

Experimental and calculated spectra of 48Ca and 48Ti

Figure 1. Experimental and calculated spectra of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} and 48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ti}. B(E2)B(E2) strengths (in e2fm4e^{2}\mathrm{fm}^{4}) are also reported (see text for details).

Since we want to evaluate the perturbative behavior of the calculated SM effective Hamiltonian, we compare the low-lying excitation spectra obtained with HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s derived at first-, second-, and third-order in many-body perturbation theory. A similar study, performed for one- and

two-valence nuclei, was reported in Ref. [29], and here we want to extend it to many-valence nucleon systems.

It should be noticed that in the present study we have employed the same effective E2E2 transition operator, the one derived at third order in perturbation theory, to calculate B(E2)B(E2)’s with HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s that are calculated at different order. In such a way, the focus is spotted on the quality of the shell-model wave functions at each order in perturbation theory, so to recover these information when the attention will be turned to the calculation of 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta matrix elements.

As can be seen, the observed shell closure of the neutron 0f7/20f_{7/2} orbital in 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} is reproduced at all orders, a feature that traces back to the contribution of the three-body component of the nuclear Hamiltonian [29]. The perturbative behavior of the results obtained with second- and third-order HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s is satisfactory, as well as the agreement with experiment. First-order results exhibit some overestimate of the shell closure, that is testified also by the smaller B(E2;21+→01+)B(E2;2_{1}^{+}\rightarrow0_{1}^{+}) with respect to second- and third-order ones.

As regards 48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ti}, the strength of the proton-neutron interaction induces a larger collectivity in its low-energy excitation spectrum, also evidenced by larger B(E2)B(E2)’s. Second- and third-order HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s reproduce quite well these experimental features, while first-order HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} is characterized by smaller B(E2)B(E2)’s, despite the compressed energy spectrum which usually leads to a larger collectivity.

The calculation of low-energy spectra and wave functions of 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, 76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se}, 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}, and 82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Kr} has been carried out by employing the four proton and neutron orbitals 0f5/20f_{5/2}, 1p3/21p_{3/2}, 1p1/21p_{1/2} and 0g9/20g_{9/2}, outside 56Ni^{56}\mathrm{Ni} closed core, as model space.

Figure 2 reports the experimental [65] and calculated low-energy spectra of 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} an 76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se}, as well as the electric quadrupole transition strengths, following the same scheme of analysis as for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} and 48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ti}. It is worth pointing out that the reproduction of the observable characterizing low-energy states in these nuclides is far more challenging for a microscopic nuclear structure model, owing to the experimental evidence of the 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} rigid triaxial deformation [66].

Experimental and calculated spectra of 76Ge and 76Se

Figure 2. Same as in Fig. 1, but for 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} and 76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se} (see text for details).

First, we observe that there is quite a satisfactory perturbative behavior between second- and third-order HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s, as regards the spectroscopic properties of low-energy states. As regards the agreement with experiment, we have already noticed in Ref. [12] that the agreement between the experimental and calculated spectra and B(E2)B(E2)’s for 76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se} is very satisfactory, but this is not the same for 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}. We have also shown that this traces back to the monopole component of the HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}, especially when comparing with the results obtained in our earlier study where HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}} was derived from a Vlow−kV_{\mathrm{low-k}} potential obtained from the CD-Bonn potential [63].

In Figure 3 we report the results for 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} and 82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Kr} low-energy spectra, and compare them with the experimental ones. As can be seen, we have obtained both a good perturbative behavior of the HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s, and a quantitative agreement with observables.

Energy spectra for $^{82}\mathrm{Se}$ and $^{82}\mathrm{Kr}$

Figure 3. Same as in Fig. 1, but for 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} and 82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Kr} (see text for details).

Now, we shift our attention to the results of the matrix elements M2νM^{2\nu}’s for the two-neutrino double-β\beta decay of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}. The SM effective operator has been constructed by way of ChPT, namely the one- and two-body matrix elements of the axial currents JAJ_{A} are derived through a chiral expansion up to N3^{3}LO, and the LECs appearing in their expression are consistent with those of the nuclear potential. The details about the derivation of the SM effective decay operator are reported in Ref. [12], here we have employed the same one – calculated at third order in many-body perturbation theory –, but diagonalizing the SM Hamiltonian with first-, second-, and third-order HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s.

As for the calculation of the B(E2)B(E2)’s, our intent is to focus to the perturbative behavior of the SM wave functions, as well as their reliability to reproduce data, within the perspective of the prediction of 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta nuclear matrix elements.

Table I reports the calculated M2νM^{2\nu}’s, obtained with the different HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s, for the 2νββ2\nu\beta\beta decays 48Ca→48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ca}\to{}^{48}\mathrm{Ti}, 76Ge→76Se^{76}\mathrm{Ge}\to{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}, 82Se→82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Se}\to{}^{82}\mathrm{Kr} (ground state to ground state).

As can be observed, the perturbative behavior is very good for the theoretical M2νM^{2\nu}’s of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}, and less satisfactory for 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, in line with the results for the electric-quadrupole B(E2)B(E2)’s. The agreement with experiment is very good considering the third-order HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}, as already pointed out in Ref. [12].

The outcome of the study of the perturbative behavior of the calculated HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s, and most importantly of the calculated SM wave functions, makes us confident that the HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s calculated at third-order in many-body perturbation theory are the best starting point to study the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}. Then, in the following section the calculation of M0νM^{0\nu}’s will be performed by way of third-order HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s to concentrate the attention to the perturbative properties of the SM effective 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay operator, and the related uncertainty estimate of the nuclear matrix elements M0νM^{0\nu}’s.

Neutrinoless double-β\beta decay of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}

As introduced in § 2 A, in the present work the calculation of M0νM^{0\nu} accounts for the light-neutrino exchange mechanism, the total nuclear matrix element being expressed as in Eq. (2) and calculated accordingly to Eqs. (4),(5),(6),(11),(3),(10),(7),(12).

As in our previous studies of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay [24, 64], we have carried out the perturbative expansion of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta effective operator Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} including in the Θ^\hat{\Theta} box diagrams up to the third order (see § 2 B), and a number of intermediate states which corresponds to oscillator quanta up to Nmax⁡=18N_{\max}=18. In fact, this value corresponds to a number of intermediate states that is large enough to guarantee a substantial convergence of the calculated M0νM^{0\nu}’s.

In Figure 4 the calculated values of M0νM^{0\nu} for the 48Ca→48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ca}\to{}^{48}\mathrm{Ti} decay are reported as a function of Nmax⁡N_{\max}, and, as can be observed, results are substantially convergent from Nmax⁡=14N_{\max}=14 on.

Figure 4. M0νM^{0\nu} for the 48Ca→48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ca}\rightarrow{}^{48}\mathrm{Ti} decay as a function of Nmax⁡N_{\max}.

This convergent behavior appears also for the M0νM^{0\nu}’s calculated for the 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} decays, as reported in Table II.

Now, we shift the focus on the results of the order-by-order convergence, that are the starting point for discussing the uncertainties related to our calculated M0νM^{0\nu}’s.

First, we consider the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay between the ground states of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} and 48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ti}. In Figure 5 we have reported the calculated values of M0νM^{0\nu}, MGT0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{GT}}, MF0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{F}}, MT0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{T}}, and MS0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{S}} from first- up to third-order in perturbation theory. We have decided to report also the value of their Padé approximant [2∣1][2|1], as an indicator of the quality of the perturbative behavior of the calculated M0νM^{0\nu} [68].

Figure 5. M0νM^{0\nu} for the decay of the 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} ground state to the 48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ti} one, as a function of the perturbative order. The green triangles correspond to MF0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{F}}, the blue squares to MGT0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{GT}}, the purple diamonds to MT0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{T}}, the brown lower triangles to MS0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{S}}, and the black dots to the full M0νM^{0\nu}.

DecayNmax⁡=14N_{\max}=14Nmax⁡=16N_{\max}=16Nmax⁡=18N_{\max}=18
76Ge→76Se^{76}\mathrm{Ge}\rightarrow{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}1.6981.6581.661
82Se→82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Se}\rightarrow{}^{82}\mathrm{Kr}1.2841.2501.253

Table II. M0νM^{0\nu}'s for 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay between their ground states, calculated for Nmax⁡=14N_{\max}=14, 16, and 18.

As can be seen in Figure 5, the perturbative behavior is driven by the Gamow-Teller component, since LO contact term is rather flat between second- and third-order, and both Fermi and tensor matrix elements MF0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{F}}, MT0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{T}} are weakly affected by the renormalization procedure.

A more refined analysis of our results and of the perturbative behavior may be obtained performing a decomposition of M0νM^{0\nu}'s in terms of the contributions from the decaying pair of neutrons coupled to a given angular momentum and parity JπJ^\pi. This decomposition for 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} is reported in Figure 6, comparing the contributions obtained by employing the SM effective 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay operator Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} as calculated at first-, second-, and third-order in many-body perturbation theory.

Figure 6. Contributions from pairs of decaying neutrons with given JπJ^\pi to M0νM^{0\nu} for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay. The bars filled in blue, dashed red, and filled in red correspond to the results obtained with Θeff\Theta_{\mathrm{eff}} calculated at first-, second-, and third-order in perturbation theory, respectively.

There are two remarks that we point out from the inspection of Figure 6: first, the main contributions, at all orders, are provided by Jπ=0+,2+J^\pi=0^+,2^+ components and they are always of opposite sign, and this fact is mainly responsible for the particularly small M0νM^{0\nu} for the decay of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, a feature that is common to almost all calculations for this doubly-closed nuclear system [24, 69, 70, 71, 72]. Second, we note that the perturbative behavior of each component is much better than the total M0νM^{0\nu}, as observed in Figure 5, and that it is the cancellation between the two main components which contributes largely to the increase of the uncertainty of the calculated M0νM^{0\nu}, with respect to the one that characterizes each term of the decomposition.

Very similar observations can be drawn also for the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay of the ground states of 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} to the ones of 76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se}, 82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Kr}, from the inspection of Figure 7,Figure 8 which report the calculated values of M0νM^{0\nu}, MGT0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{GT}}, MF0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{F}}, MT0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{T}}, and MS0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{S}} from first- up to third-order in perturbation theory, as well as the value of their Padé approximant [2∣1][2|1].

Figure 7. Same as in Fig. 5, but for the decay of the 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} ground state to the 76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se} one.

Figure 8. Same as in Fig. 5, but for the decay of the 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} ground state to the 82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Kr} one.

For these decays too, the decomposition of M0νM^{0\nu}'s in terms of the contributions of the decaying pair of neutrons coupled to a given angular momentum and parity ity JπJ^\pi provides a useful insight on the main sources of the uncertainties related to the perturbative expansion of 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta Θeff\Theta_{\rm eff}’s.

From the inspection of Figure 9,Figure 10, we observe that the most relevant contributions come by the Jπ=0+,2+J^\pi= 0^+, 2^+ components and they are always of opposite sign, as for the decay of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, but their respective intensities differ more substantially, and lead to larger M0νM^{0\nu}’s with respect to the 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} decay.

Positive- and negative-parity contributions for the $^{76}\mathrm{Ge}\to{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}$ decay

Figure 9. Same as in Fig. 6, but for the decay of the 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} ground state to the 76Se^{76}\mathrm{Se} one.

Bar plots of the effective matrix elements for the decay of the $^{82}\mathrm{Se}$ ground state to the $^{82}\mathrm{Kr}$ ground state

Figure 10. Same as in Figure 6, but for the decay of the 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} ground state to the 82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Kr} one.

The perturbative behavior is dominated by the Jπ=0+J^\pi= 0^+ component, that is characterized by a larger difference between second- and third-order calculations.

This exposition of our results leads to an analysis of our evaluation of M0νM^{0\nu}’s for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decays, as well as an estimate of the corresponding theoretical uncertainties.

It should be stressed that a calculation that is grounded on many-body perturbation theory is not a size-extensive approach as for ab initio methods, then

a proper theoretical error cannot be evaluated. Then, we rely on the theory of Padé approximant as an instrument to obtain the best approximation of the sum of a perturbative expansion from a truncated power series [68]. Moreover, here we refer only to the many-body perturbation theory as a source of uncertainties, while a complete treatment should involve also a study of the perturbativity of the ChPT expansion of the nuclear Hamiltonian and electroweak currents, the latter defining the decay operators.

On the above grounds, we have reported in Table III the values of M0νM^{0\nu}’s as obtained at third order in many-body perturbation theory, and the Padé approximant [2|1] which accounts for the perturbative behavior up to third-order. In the last column, we have reported the absolute value of the difference between these two values Δ=∣M3rd0ν−MPadeˊ0ν∣\Delta= \left|M^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{3rd}} - M^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{Pad\acute{e}}}\right|, that we propose as the estimate of the uncertainties associated to our calculated M0νM^{0\nu}’s.

DecayM3rd0νM^{0\nu}_{3\mathrm{rd}}MPadeˊ0νM^{0\nu}_{\mathrm{Padé}}Δ\Delta
48Ca→48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ca}\to{}^{48}\mathrm{Ti}0.890.800.09
76Ge→76Se^{76}\mathrm{Ge}\to{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}1.661.460.20
82Se→82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Se}\to{}^{82}\mathrm{Kr}1.251.120.13

Table III. Calculated values of M0νM^{0\nu} for all decays under investigation. The first column corresponds to the results obtained employing the SM effective 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay operator at third-order in perturbation theory, the second one is the corresponding Padé approximant [2|1]. In the third column the absolute value of the difference of results in columns one and two (Δ\Delta) are reported.

To support such a choice, the quantities in Table IV provide an additional check of the perturbative behavior of the effective double-β\beta decay operators. As can be seen, the M2νM^{2\nu} values obtained with the third-order effective operator (which are also reported in Table I) are very close to the corresponding Padé [2|1] approximants, with differences that are negligible on the scale of the matrix elements. It should be stressed that, although the 2νββ2\nu\beta\beta and 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decays involve different transition operators, both calculations rely on the same many-body perturbative construction of effective shell-model operators.

Finally, it is worth to compare our results with those reported in recent papers, where the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay for intermediate- and heavy-mass systems has been investigated within EFT electroweak operators.

DecayM3rd2νM^{2\nu}_{\mathrm{3rd}}MPadeˊ2νM^{2\nu}_{\mathrm{Pad\acute{e}}}Δ\DeltaExpt
48Ca→48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ca}\rightarrow{}^{48}\mathrm{Ti}0.0190.0190.00.042±0.0040.042 \pm0.004
76Ge→76Se^{76}\mathrm{Ge}\rightarrow{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}0.1180.1140.0040.129±0.0040.129 \pm0.004
82Se→82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Se}\rightarrow{}^{82}\mathrm{Kr}0.0950.0930.0020.103±0.0010.103 \pm0.001

Table 4. Same as in Table III, but for M2νM^{2\nu}’s and including the corresponding experimental values.

In [48], the authors carried out a comprehensive ab initio uncertainty quantification of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay of 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, employing nuclear Hamiltonians and electroweak operators derived within ChPT. 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} M0νM^{0\nu} was calculated with recently developed many-body emulators, and their numerical result is M0ν=2.60−1.36+1.28M^{0\nu} = 2.60^{+1.28}_{-1.36}.

The latter is greater than the value reported in Table III – M0ν=1.46M^{0\nu} = 1.46 –, but both M0νM^{0\nu}’s are consistent within the theoretical error in Ref. [48] and our estimated uncertainty.

The authors of the study in Ref. [27] evaluated the M0νM^{0\nu}’s for several 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decays, employing 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay operators derived up to N2^{2}LO in ChPT, and employing both pnQRPA and nuclear shell model, but with empirical effective Hamiltonians. The SM results reported there in Table 1 evidence values for M0νM^{0\nu}’s of 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}, for the LO long- and short-range components of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay operator, larger than those reported in Table III.

Decay1st order2nd order3rd orderExpt
48Ca→48Ti^{48}\mathrm{Ca}\to{}^{48}\mathrm{Ti}0.0550.0140.0190.042 ±\pm 0.004
76Ge→76Se^{76}\mathrm{Ge}\to{}^{76}\mathrm{Se}0.0220.0560.1180.129 ±\pm 0.004
82Se→82Kr^{82}\mathrm{Se}\to{}^{82}\mathrm{Kr}0.0420.0990.0950.103 ±\pm 0.001

Table 1. Experimental [67] and calculated M2νM^{2\nu}’s (in MeV−1^{-1}) for 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} 2νββ2\nu\beta\beta decay (ground state to ground state).

Note that with empirical HeffH_{\mathrm{eff}}’s, as in Ref. [27], it is not possible to construct consistent SM effective decay operators. Therefore, their results need to be compared with our results obtained with our 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta OeffO_{\mathrm{eff}} at first order in many-body perturbation theory.

For 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca} decay, our first-order long-range ML0ν=0.83M^{0\nu}_{L} = 0.83, the short-range component being MS0ν=0.25M^{0\nu}_{S} = 0.25 at first order. Considering 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge} and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se} decays, our first-order values are ML0ν=3.05,2.70M^{0\nu}_{L} = 3.05, 2.70 and MS0ν=0.49,0.44M^{0\nu}_{S} = 0.49, 0.44, respectively, which are in a much closer agreement with the central values of Ref. [27], considering the ranges reported there in Table 1.

Summary and Outlook

In this work, for the first time, we have carried out a shell-model calculation of the matrix elements for the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay 48Ca^{48}\mathrm{Ca}, 76Ge^{76}\mathrm{Ge}, and 82Se^{82}\mathrm{Se}, employing consistent effective Hamiltonians and decay operators derived within the ChPT. In particular, we have started from the nuclear Hamiltonian which has been constructed including two-body contributions up to N3^{3}LO and three-body ones up to N2^{2}LO, and the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta-decay operator included only the leading-order (LO) contribution for the light-neutrino exchange.

The derivation of the SM effective operators has been performed through many-body perturbation theory, including all contributions up to third order. The reliability of such an approach has been tested in a previous work [12], comparing spectroscopic observables and experimental GT matrix elements with the theoretical ones. Here we have also added a discussion about the convergence properties of calculated low-energy spectra and 2νββ2\nu\beta\beta-decay matrix elements for the nuclei under scrutiny, aiming to establish the soundness of the many-body perturbative expansion.

Next, the focus of the perturbativity was on the calculated M0νM^{0\nu}’s, since one of our interests has been to estimate the uncertainties associated to them because of the perturbative approach. Since we employ a many-body perturbative approach to carry out the shell-model calculations, the evaluation of the uncertainties related to M0νM^{0\nu}’s has been grounded on the theory of Padé approximants, and does not account for the theoretical errors that are associated to the construction of the nuclear Hamiltonian and electroweak decay operators within the chiral perturbation theory, and that is also tackled in other recent works [48].

The outlook of our study of calculating M0νM^{0\nu}’s– and in general electroweak decay observables that may be related to such a rare process – is to shift our efforts in considering higher-order contributions of the ChPT expansion of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta currents, namely including in the SM effective decay operator terms up to N2^{2}LO, and then investigating also the perturbative properties of approaching the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay within EFT.

Moreover, we plan to apply this framework to study also the double-β\beta decay of 100^{100}Mo, a nuclear system that is currently a candidate to the detection of the 0νββ0\nu\beta\beta decay, but that is very challenging from the point of view of a shell-model calculation.

Acknowledgments

The calculations were made possible by grants of computing time from the Italian National Supercomputing Center CINECA, under the CINECA-INFN agreement.

References

  1. [1]S. Weinberg, Physica 96A, 327 (1979).
  2. [2]S. Weinberg, Phys. Lett. B 251, 288 (1990).
  3. [3]S. Weinberg, Nucl. Phys. B 363, 3 (1991).
  4. [4]E. Epelbaum, H.-W. Hammer, and U.-G. Meißner, Rev. Mod. Phys. 81, 1773 (2009).
  5. [5]R. Machleidt and D. R. Entem, Phys. Rep. 503, 1 (2011).
  6. [6]G. B. King, L. Andreoli, S. Pastore, M. Piarulli, R. Schiavilla, R. B. Wiringa, J. Carlson, and S. Gandolfi, Phys. Rev. C 102, 025501 (2020).
  7. [7]A. Baroni, G. B. King, and S. Pastore, Few-Body Syst. 62, 114 (2021).
  8. [8]A. Gnech, L. E. Marcucci, R. Schiavilla, and M. Viviani, Phys. Rev. C 104, 035501 (2021).
  9. [9]A. Gnech and R. Schiavilla, Phys. Rev. C 106, 044001 (2022).
  10. [10]G. B. King, A. Baroni, V. Cirigliano, S. Gandolfi, L. Haven, E. Mereghetti, S. Pastore, and M. Piarulli, Phys. Rev. C 107, 015503 (2023).
  11. [11]P. Gysbers, G. Hagen, J. D. Holt, G. R. Jansen, T. D. Morris, P. Navrátil, T. Papenbrock, S. Quaglioni, A. Schwenk, S. R. Stroberg, et al., Nature Phys. 15, 428 (2019).
  12. [12]L. Coraggio, N. Itaco, G. De Gregorio, A. Gargano, Z. H. Cheng, Y. Z. Ma, F. R. Xu, and M. Viviani, Phys. Rev. C 109, 014301 (2024).
  13. [13]V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, E. Mereghetti, and A. Walker-Loud, Phys. Rev. C 97, 065501 (2018).
  14. [14]V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, J. de Vries, M. L. Graesser, E. Mereghetti, S. Pastore, M. Piarulli, U. van Kolck, and R. B. Wiringa, Phys. Rev. C 100, 055504 (2019).
  15. [15]T. Tomoda, Rep. Prog. Phys. 54, 53 (1991).
  16. [16]J. D. Vergados, H. Ejiri, and F. Šimkovic, Rep. Prog. Phys. 75, 106301 (2012).
  17. [17]V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, J. de Vries, M. Hoferichter, and E. Mereghetti, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 172002 (2021).
  18. [18]J. T. Suhonen, Frontiers in Physics 5, 55 (2017).
  19. [19]T. T. S. Kuo, J. Shurpin, K. C. Tam, E. Osnes, and P. J. Ellis, Ann. Phys. (NY) 132, 237 (1981).
  20. [20]K. Suzuki and R. Okamoto, Prog. Theor. Phys. 93, 905 (1995).
  21. [21]L. Coraggio, A. Covello, A. Gargano, N. Itaco, and T. T. S. Kuo, Ann. Phys. (NY) 327, 2125 (2012).
  22. [22]L. Coraggio and N. Itaco, Frontiers in Physics 8, 345 (2020).
  23. [23]D. R. Entem and R. Machleidt, Phys. Rev. C 68, 041001(R) (2003).
  24. [24]L. Coraggio, A. Gargano, N. Itaco, R. Mancino, and F. Nowacki, Phys. Rev. C 101, 044315 (2020).
  25. [25]R. Machleidt, Phys. Rev. C 63, 024001 (2001).
  26. [26]S. Bogner, T. T. S. Kuo, L. Coraggio, A. Covello, and N. Itaco, Phys. Rev. C 65, 051301(R) (2002).
  27. [27]D. Castillo, L. Jokiniemi, P. Soriano, and J. Menéndez, Physics Letters B 860, 139181 (2025), ISSN 0370-2693.
  28. [28]U. van Kolck, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 43, 337 (1999).
  29. [29]Y. Z. Ma, L. Coraggio, L. De Angelis, T. Fukui, A. Gargano, N. Itaco, and F. R. Xu, Phys. Rev. C 100, 034324 (2019).
  30. [30]T. Fukui, L. De Angelis, Y. Z. Ma, L. Coraggio, A. Gargano, N. Itaco, and F. R. Xu, Phys. Rev. C 98, 044305 (2018).
  31. [31]L. Coraggio, G. De Gregorio, A. Gargano, N. Itaco, T. Fukui, Y. Z. Ma, and F. R. Xu, Phys. Rev. C 102, 054326 (2020).
  32. [32]L. Coraggio, G. De Gregorio, A. Gargano, N. Itaco, T. Fukui, Y. Z. Ma, and F. R. Xu, Phys. Rev. C 104, 054304 (2021).
  33. [33]S. L. Lyu, G. De Gregorio, T. Fukui, N. Itaco, and L. Coraggio, Phys. Rev. C 112, 054314 (2025).
  34. [34]P. Navrátil, V. G. Gueorguiev, J. P. Vary, W. E. Ormand, and A. Nogga, Phys. Rev. Lett. 99, 042501 (2007).
  35. [35]T. S. Park, D. P. Min, and M. Rho, Phys. Rep. 233, 341 (1993). [36] S. Pastore, L. Girlanda, R. Schiavilla, M. Viviani, and R. B. Wiringa, Phys. Rev. C 80, 034004 (2009).
  36. [37]S. Kölling, E. Epelbaum, H. Krebs, and U. G. Meißner, Phys. Rev. C 80, 045502 (2009).
  37. [38]A. Baroni, L. Girlanda, S. Pastore, R. Schiavilla, and M. Viviani, Phys. Rev. C 93, 015501 (2016).
  38. [39]H. Krebs, E. Epelbaum, and U.-G. Meißner, Annals of Physics 378, 317 (2017).
  39. [40]H. Krebs, Eur. Phys. J. A 56, 234 (2020).
  40. [41]H. Hyuga and A. Arima, J. Phys. Soc. Jpn. Suppl. 34, 538 (1973).
  41. [42]I. S. Towner and K. F. C. Khanna, Nucl. Phys. A 399, 334 (1983).
  42. [43]G. Martínez-Pinedo, A. Poves, E. Caurier, and A. P. Zuker, Phys. Rev. C 53, R2602 (1996).
  43. [44]V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, J. de Vries, M. L. Graesser, E. Mereghetti, S. Pastore, and U. van Kolck, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 202001 (2018).
  44. [45]G. Chambers-Wall, J. Lieffers, G. B. King, E. Mereghetti, S. Pastore, M. Piarulli, and R. B. Wiringa, Phys. Rev. C 113, 025502 (2026).
  45. [46]R. Wirth, J. M. Yao, and H. Hergert, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 242502 (2021).
  46. [47]L. Jokiniemi, P. Soriano, and J. Menéndez, Physics Letters B 823, 136720 (2021), ISSN 0370-2693.
  47. [48]A. Belley, J. M. Yao, B. Bally, J. Pitcher, J. Engel, H. Hergert, J. D. Holt, T. Miyagi, T. R. Rodríguez, A. M. Romero, et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 182502 (2024).
  48. [49]J. Kotila and F. Iachello, Phys. Rev. C 85, 034316 (2012).
  49. [50]J. Kotila and F. Iachello, Phys. Rev. C 87, 024313 (2013).
  50. [51]J. Engel and J. Menéndez, Rep. Prog. Phys. 80, 046301 (2017).
  51. [52]L. Coraggio, G. De Gregorio, T. Fukui, A. Gargano, Y. Ma, Z. Cheng, and F. Xu, Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics 134, 104079 (2024).
  52. [53]J. Blomqvist and A. Molinari, Nucl. Phys. A 106, 545 (1968).
  53. [54]K. Suzuki and S. Y. Lee, Prog. Theor. Phys. 64, 2091 (1980).
  54. [55]R. S. Stroberg, H. Heiko, S. K. Bogner, and J. D. Holt, Annu. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 69, 307 (2019).
  55. [56]T. T. S. Kuo and E. Osnes, Lecture Notes in Physics, vol. 364 (Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1990).
  56. [57]M. Hjorth-Jensen, T. T. S. Kuo, and E. Osnes, Phys. Rep. 261, 125 (1995).
  57. [58]L. Coraggio, L. De Angelis, T. Fukui, A. Gargano, and N. Itaco, J. Phys. Conf. Ser. 1056, 012012 (2018).
  58. [59]E. M. Krenciglowa and T. T. S. Kuo, Nucl. Phys. A 235, 171 (1974).
  59. [60]K. Suzuki, R. Okamoto, H. Kumagai, and S. Fujii, Phys. Rev. C 83, 024304 (2011).
  60. [61]S. R. Stroberg, A. Calci, H. Hergert, J. D. Holt, S. K. Bogner, R. Roth, and A. Schwenk, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 032502 (2017).
  61. [62]L. Coraggio, L. De Angelis, T. Fukui, A. Gargano, and N. Itaco, Phys. Rev. C 95, 064324 (2017).
  62. [63]L. Coraggio, L. De Angelis, T. Fukui, A. Gargano, N. Itaco, and F. Nowacki, Phys. Rev. C 100, 014316 (2019).
  63. [64]L. Coraggio, N. Itaco, G. De Gregorio, A. Gargano, R. Mancino, and F. Nowacki, Phys. Rev. C 105, 034312 (2022).
  64. [65]Data extracted using the NNDC On-line Data Service from the ENSDF database., URL https://www.nndc.bnl.gov/ensdf.
  65. [66]Y. Toh, C. J. Chiara, E. A. McCutchan, W. B. Walters, R. V. F. Janssens, M. P. Carpenter, S. Zhu, R. Broda, B. Fornal, B. P. Kay, et al., Phys. Rev. C 87, 041304 (2013).
  66. [67]A. Barabash, Universe 6, 159 (2020).
  67. [68]G. A. Baker and J. L. Gammel, The Padé Approximant in Theoretical Physics, vol. 71 of Mathematics in Science and Engineering (Academic Press, New York, 1970).
  68. [69]R. A. Sen’kov and M. Horoi, Phys. Rev. C 88, 064312 (2013).
  69. [70]R. A. Sen’kov and M. Horoi, Phys. Rev. C 93, 044334 (2016).
  70. [71]R. A. Sen’kov, M. Horoi, and B. A. Brown, Phys. Rev. C 89, 054304 (2014).
  71. [72]C. F. Jiao, M. Horoi, and A. Neacsu, Phys. Rev. C 98, 064324 (2018).

Paper details

vlnc:W_7ch7ngwb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 10

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents