betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Different Stories: European Astronomy as a Tool of Colonization in the Americas and Hawai'i

Abstract

The history of Western astronomy is frequently told as a story of discovery, technological innovation, and human progress. Yet the astronomical knowledge, instruments, and techniques associated with these achievements also contributed to European colonial expansion. Through four material and visual examples - a marine chronometer, an astronomical surveying quadrant, the Nautical Almanac, and contemporary observatories on Maunakea - we invite reconsideration of astronomy's relationships with navigation, territorial mapping, colonial authority, and Indigenous lands. How might these histories be told differently when considered through Indigenous Knowledges and Perspectives? What might such reconsideration reveal about the continuing relationships between astronomy, colonialism, and place?

Different stories

The stories we tell are important. The history of Western science is often presented as a triumph of light over darkness, in which science and scientists are situated as noble figures working in the service of progress. Consider familiar accounts of Copernicus and Galileo challenging established cosmologies, Newton discovering universal gravitation, or Marie Curie’s investigations of radioactivity. Such stories foreground intellectual courage, ingenuity, and discovery. They can also encourage us to imagine science as an enterprise separate from the political and social conditions in which it develops.

But telling the story of astronomy’s ideas and instruments during the European so-called “Age of Discovery” and its aftermath—including the invasion and colonization of territories now known as the United States—produces a different account. Astronomical knowledge was not merely carried along on voyages of exploration. It helped make those voyages possible, made distant territories more readily measurable and representable, and contributed to the infrastructures through which colonial powers asserted authority over lands and peoples. These relationships deserve particular attention in the context of the 250th anniversary of the founding of the United States, an event that can be understood quite differently when viewed alongside the ongoing dispossession of Indigenous peoples.

Our poster invites the viewer to consider four images (Figure 1) and to imagine how the stories prompted by them might differ, in fundamental ways, from the perspectives of scientists and colonized peoples. We do not suggest that the objects possess a single meaning, or that a single account can represent diverse Indigenous perspectives. Rather, we use them to pose questions about astronomy’s material, institutional, and political histories.

Marine chronometer K1

(a) Marine chronometer K1, carried aboard Cook’s Resolution, 1772–1775. National Maritime Museum, Greenwich. Photo: Authors.

Quadrant

(b) Quadrant associated with surveys in Lower Canada, ca. 1780–1820; attributed to Peter and John Dollond. Photo: Board of Trustees, Science Museum, London.

Title page of the Nautical Almanac for 1767

(c) Title page of the Nautical Almanac for 1767. Smithsonian Institution Libraries.

Subaru and Keck observatories on Maunakea

(d) Subaru and Keck observatories on Maunakea, 2019. Photo: A. Franceschini/Corbis News.

Figure 1. Four objects and images used in the Different Stories poster. The captions preserve the poster’s source attributions; museum provenance and reproduction permissions should be confirmed before publication.

Instruments, measurement, and colonial power

The first object is the marine chronometer K1, carried aboard James Cook’s Resolution during his second Pacific voyage (1772–1775). Accurate timekeeping, together with celestial observations, provided a means to determine longitude at sea and thereby improved the reliability of navigation and chart-making. Cook reportedly called K1 “our trusty friend” and “never-failing guide.” In a conventional history of science, the chronometer exemplifies the extraordinary achievements of precision instrument making. Another story asks what the capacity to navigate, return to, and map distant places meant for the peoples already living there. Scientific achievement and colonial consequence were not mutually exclusive: the same instrument could be celebrated for its accuracy and examined for its role within imperial maritime expansion.

The second object is a quadrant attributed on the poster to Peter and John Dollond and associated with surveying in Lower Canada between approximately 1780 and 1820. Astronomical and geodetic observations supplied positions and bearings that could be incorporated into surveys and maps. Such practices made land legible within European systems of property, administration, and territorial jurisdiction. The act of measurement did not itself establish legitimate ownership. Yet mapping and surveying could be mobilized within colonial processes that displaced Indigenous relationships with lands and waters and replaced them with imposed boundaries, titles, and jurisdictions. The instrument therefore prompts questions not only about how land was measured, but also who authorized the measurement, whose understandings of place were recognized, and to what ends the resulting representations were put.

The third object is the title page of the Nautical Almanac and Astronomical Ephemeris for 1767, published by order of the Commissioners of Longitude. The almanac made predictions of celestial positions and other astronomical information available in standardized tabular form, notably supporting the lunar-distance method for determining longitude. Its significance lay not in a single instrument or observer but in a network of observations, mathematical calculations, publishing, and maritime practice. The production and circulation of such knowledge helped translate astronomical science into repeatable techniques useful to navigators and surveyors. It reminds us that colonial power depended not only on individual explorers, but also on institutions and systems of expertise that supported their activities.

Together, these three objects illustrate distinct but connected aspects of the application of astronomy to colonial projects: navigating across oceans, locating and mapping territories, and institutionalizing the knowledge needed to do both. Their histories should not be reduced to a claim that astronomical science inevitably produced colonization. Rather, they demonstrate how scientific capabilities were developed, funded, and deployed within specific imperial circumstances, with consequences that were not equally experienced by all peoples.

Space, place, and scientific authority

The fourth image brings the conversation into the present. It shows the Subaru and Keck observatories on Maunakea, Hawaiʻi, in 2019, with a stone offering or marker in the foreground. Maunakea is a place of profound cultural and spiritual significance for many Native Hawaiians, as well as a site of internationally important astronomical research. Disputes surrounding telescope development and stewardship have raised questions about consent, governance, cultural responsibilities, and the authority to determine how a place should be used.

This example is not offered as a simple continuation of eighteenth-century exploration. Its political and historical circumstances are different. Nevertheless, it invites us to examine a recurring assumption: that the scientific value of a place can be defined independently of the people whose histories, responsibilities, and relationships are rooted there. The image asks us to look beyond the telescopes as technical achievements and to consider the mountain as a place with meanings that cannot be captured by astronomical site assessments alone.

Attention to Indigenous Knowledges and Perspectives can challenge the apparent neutrality of scientific representations of space. A chart, a survey, a coordinate, and a telescope site each make certain relationships visible while potentially obscuring others. Asking what such representations leave out is not a rejection of astronomical knowledge. It is an invitation to understand its situated uses and consequences, and to recognize that other knowledge traditions and relationships to place possess their own authority ([2, 1]).

Reconsidering the stories we tell

We began with a question: how were the instruments and techniques of astronomy implicated in the production of colonial knowledge, authority, and territorial control in the Americas and the Pacific? The objects presented here do not provide a complete answer. Instead, they offer points of entry into a broader inquiry at the intersection of the history of science, material culture, colonial history, and Indigenous scholarship.

The familiar story of a chronometer, quadrant, or almanac emphasizes precision, ingenuity, and the expansion of geographical knowledge. Different stories may foreground the invasion of Indigenous territories, the displacement of existing systems of knowledge and governance, and the use of measurement to support colonial claims. Similarly, the story of an astronomical observatory can be one of scientific discovery while also being a story about Indigenous sovereignty and responsibilities to place.

These stories need not be treated as interchangeable, nor should their differences be erased in a single narrative of progress. By examining what astronomical instruments made possible, for whom, and at whose expense, we can begin to tell more complete histories of astronomy. We hope these images encourage reflection on how the colonial legacies of astronomical practice continue to shape conversations within our discipline today.

Images from the conference poster

References

  1. [1]Kame‘eleihiwa, L. 1992, Native Land and Foreign Desires: Pehea Lā E Pono Ai? (Honolulu: Bishop Museum Press)
  2. [2]Smith, L. T. 2012, Decolonizing Methodologies: Research and Indigenous Peoples, 2nd ed. (London: Zed Books)

Paper details

vlnc:W_7gts3v2c
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 8

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents