betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Bound states at Trudinger–Moser growth: obstructions, pairing and bubbling

Abstract

We study radial solutions of the planar scalar field equation −Δu+u=λu eu2,0<λ<1, -Δu+u=λu\,e^{u^2}, \qquad 0<λ<1, whose nonlinearity has critical Trudinger–Moser growth. These solutions describe standing waves of the two-dimensional nonlinear Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations. Motivated by Tang's recent uniqueness result for radial bound states with power nonlinearities in higher dimensions, we investigate the validity of the corresponding uniqueness theory at critical exponential growth. We show that the Serrin–Tang criterion and two structural hypotheses in Tang's analysis fail in this setting. We establish a pairing principle for the shooting problem, prove that Tang's variation conditions force the nodal count to be non-decreasing, and show that any two radial ground states intersect. We also derive a second-order expansion of the Liouville bubble arising at large initial heights and compute the corresponding flux correction. These asymptotics yield formal predictions for the first zero and the nodal structure at large heights. Our results suggest that the ground state is unique, whereas nodal radial bound states, if they exist, occur in pairs, contrary to the uniqueness phenomenon for power nonlinearities.

Introduction

The nonlinear scalar field equation

Δu+g(u)=0in Rn,u∈H1(Rn),u≢0,(1)\Delta u+g(u)=0 \quad\text{in } \mathbb{R}^{n},\qquad u\in H^{1}(\mathbb{R}^{n}),\quad u\not\equiv0, \tag*{(1)}

is the stationary problem behind the standing waves ψ(t,x)=eiωtu(x)\psi(t,x)=e^{i\omega t}u(x) of the nonlinear Schrödinger and Klein–Gordon equations. It has been one of the model problems of nonlinear analysis since the work of Strauss [74] and of Berestycki and Lions [19, 20]. For n≥3n\ge3, Berestycki and Lions considered odd nonlinearities gg that are negative definite at the origin and at most Sobolev critical at infinity. They proved the existence of a positive radial ground state and of infinitely many radial solutions. The two-dimensional counterpart, in which the growth at infinity is subcritical in the exponential sense, is due to Berestycki, Gallouët and Kavian [18]. Radial solutions with any prescribed number of zeros were obtained by Jones and Küpper [50] and, by a direct argument for ordinary differential equations, by McLeod, Troy and Weissler [63].

Uniqueness is much more delicate. For the model nonlinearity g(u)=−u+∣u∣p−1ug(u)=-u+|u|^{p-1}u, the uniqueness of the positive solution was proved by Coffman [28] for n=3n=3 and p=3p=3, then by McLeod and Serrin [62] for a range of exponents, and finally by Kwong [52] for all subcritical exponents in every dimension. We also refer to Peletier and Serrin [67], Chen and Lin [26], Yanagida [81], McLeod [61], Kabeya and Tanaka [51] and Serrin and Tang [73]. The criterion of Serrin and Tang requires the function ug′(u)/g(u)u g'(u)/g(u) to be non-increasing beyond the positive zero of gg. For uniqueness and nonuniqueness results in a more general radial setting, we refer to Ni and Nussbaum [66]. Uniqueness may indeed fail. For instance, Dávila, del Pino and Guerra [33] constructed three positive ground states in R3\mathbb{R}^3 for a suitable double-power nonlinearity. Positive solutions are radial by the theorem of Gidas, Ni and Nirenberg [37]; see also Li and Ni [53]. The uniqueness of ground states is essential in dispersive theory. Indeed, it identifies the optimisers of the Gagliardo–Nirenberg inequality [79], and it underlies the modulational stability theory [80].

For sign-changing radial solutions, also called bound states or excited states, Berestycki and Lions conjectured that, at least for some classes of nonlinearities, there is exactly one radial solution with exactly kk nodes. Cortázar, García-Huidobro and Yarur [32] proved the uniqueness of the bound state with one node for nonlinearities of the form −∣u∣q−1u+∣u∣p−1u-|u|^{q-1}u+|u|^{p-1}u in low dimensions, including the plane. Ao, Wei and Yao [9] treated exponents close to the critical one. Cohen, Li and Schlag [29] proved by a computer-assisted argument the uniqueness of the first twenty excited states of −Δu+u−u3=0-\Delta u+u-u^3=0 in R3\mathbb{R}^3, a question raised by Hastings and McLeod [40]. Multiplicity results for sign-changing bound states of other nonlinearities were obtained by Cortázar, García-Huidobro and Herreros [31]. In a recent breakthrough, Tang [76] settled the conjecture for g(u)=−u+∣u∣p−1ug(u)=-u+|u|^{p-1}u with 1<p<(n+2)/(n−2)1<p<(n+2)/(n-2), in every dimension n≥3n\ge3. His proof rests on a fine analysis of the variation v=∂u/∂αv=\partial u/\partial\alpha of the solution of the radial initial value problem with respect to the initial height α\alpha. Tang’s method has since been adapted to the logarithmic Schrödinger equation in dimensions n≥2n\ge2 [54], and to sublinear equations, whose bound states have compact support [82]. For the uniqueness of positive radial solutions of mm-Laplacian equations in low dimensions, we refer to [68]. The main uniqueness results quoted above are collected in Table 1.

Nonlinearity and settingDimensionGround stateBound states
−u+u3-u+u^3 in R3\mathbb{R}^3n=3n=3Coffman [28]k≤20k\leq20: Cohen–Li–Schlag [29]
−u+∣u∣p−1u-u+\lvert u\rvert^{p-1}u, subcriticaln≥3n\geq3Kwong [52]; see also [62, 61]all kk: Tang [76]
−u+∣u∣p−1u-u+\lvert u\rvert^{p-1}u, p>1p>1n=2n=2Kwong [52]k=1k=1: [32]; all kk: [82]*
−∣u∣q−1u+∣u∣p−1u-\lvert u\rvert^{q-1}u+\lvert u\rvert^{p-1}un≥3n\geq3 (GS); 2≤n≤42\leq n\leq4 (k=1k=1)Serrin–Tang [73]k=1k=1: [32]
ulog⁡u2u\log u^2 (logarithmic)n≥2n\geq2see [54]*all kk: [54]*
u−∣u∣q−2uu-\lvert u\rvert^{q-2}u, 1<q<21<q<2 (sublinear)n≥2n\geq2see [82]*all kk: [82]*
Critical exponential growth, Dirichlet problem in a discn=2n=2[3, 75, 77]no radial nodal solution in small discs [6]
−u+λueu2-u+\lambda u e^{u^2} in R2\mathbb{R}^2, problem (PλP_\lambda)n=2n=2existence [8, 71]; uniqueness open (Conjecture 6.1)this paper: pairing (Theorem 4.8); conjectured non-uniqueness (Conjecture 6.4)

Table 1. Uniqueness of radial solutions: a selection of known results. “GS” stands for ground state and “kk-BS” for radial bound state with kk nodes. Entries marked with an asterisk are preprints.

In the plane every power p>1p>1 is subcritical. Tang conjectures in the introduction of [76] that his theorem extends to n=2n=2 and every p>1p>1, a case to which, as he points out, his proof does not apply as written.

Remark 1.1. The dimensional restriction enters the proof of [76] through the positivity of Qn=Q+nrn−1u′vQ_n=Q+nr^{n-1}u'v on the intervals [bi,ci][b_i,c_i], which is obtained in [76 Lemma 5.3] from the Pohozaev bound w(bi)>n−2w(b_i)>n-2 when n=3n=3, p≥2p\ge2 or n≥4n\ge4, and in [76 Lemma 5.4] by an additional integral estimate when n=3n=3, 1<p<21<p<2. When n=2n=2, the function QnQ_n coincides with Q2=Q+2rw′vQ_2=Q+2rw'v, and its positivity on the whole phase [ci−1,ci][c_{i-1},c_i] follows directly from the induction hypothesis [76 (5.8)]. Indeed, Q2′=2ru′v′>0Q'_2=2r u'v'>0 on (ci−1,τi)(c_{i-1},\tau_i) by [76 (5.6)], with Q2(ci−1)=Q(ci−1)>0Q_2(c_{i-1})=Q(c_{i-1})>0 (or Q2(0)=0Q_2(0)=0 when i=1i=1), while u′v>0u'v>0 on (τi,ci)(\tau_i,c_i) gives Q2>Q1>0Q_2>Q_1>0 there, and Q2=Q1>0Q_2=Q_1>0 at τi\tau_i and at cic_i. This observation, together with the modifications needed in the plane, is the subject of [82 Section 6], where the uniqueness of the kk-node bound states for n=2n=2 and every p>1p>1 is obtained as a by-product of the method of [76]. We do not use this result.

The genuinely two-dimensional question, however, concerns a different notion of criticality. In R2\mathbb{R}^2, the space H1H^1 embeds into every LqL^q with 2≤q<∞2\le q<\infty but not into L∞L^\infty, and the maximal growth compatible with a variational treatment is exponential. This is quantified by the Trudinger–Moser inequality [78, 64]. The supremum of ∫Ωeβu2\int_\Omega e^{\beta u^2} over all u∈H01(Ω)u\in H^1_0(\Omega) with ∥∇u∥2≤1\lVert\nabla u\rVert_2\le1 is finite if and only if β≤4π\beta\le4\pi, and Carleson and Chang [25] proved that it is attained when Ω\Omega is a disc. Versions on the whole plane are due to Cao [24], to

Adachi and Tanaka [1] and to Ruf [69]. We also refer to Ishiwata [48] for the existence and nonexistence of maximisers, and to Ibrahim, Masmoudi and Nakanishi [47] and Masmoudi and Sani [60] for the inequality with the exact growth condition. A nonlinearity is said to have critical exponential growth if it behaves like e4πs2e^{4\pi s^2} at infinity [34]. Elliptic problems in this regime were studied by Adimurthi [2], by Adimurthi and Yadava [5], by Cao [24] and by de Figueiredo, Miyagaki and Ruf [34]. The corresponding loss of compactness was analysed by Adimurthi and Struwe [4] and by Druet [36], and, through profile decompositions of the critical embedding, by Bahouri, Majdoub and Masmoudi [13, 14]. For the scalar field equation on the whole plane with critical exponential growth, the existence of a ground state with a mountain-pass characterisation was proved by Alves, Montenegro and Souto [8] and by Ruf and Sani [71, 72], who followed the approach of Jeanjean and Tanaka [49].

Exponential nonlinearities are equally natural in dispersive equations. The Schrödinger equation in the Sobolev space of critical order was studied by Nakamura and Ozawa [65]. Ibrahim, Majdoub and Masmoudi [42] constructed global solutions of the two-dimensional Klein–Gordon equation with a nonlinearity of type u(e4πu2−1)u(e^{4\pi u^2}-1) below the energy threshold dictated by the Trudinger–Moser inequality; see also the sharp double logarithmic inequality of [43], the analysis of the energy supercritical regime in [44] and the uniqueness results of [55]. The energy-critical Schrödinger equation in the plane was treated by Colliander, Ibrahim, Majdoub and Masmoudi [30]. Scattering for the energy-critical wave and Schrödinger equations with exponential nonlinearity was proved by Ibrahim, Majdoub, Masmoudi and Nakanishi [45, 46]. For the focusing Schrödinger equation with exponential nonlinearity, Dinh, Keraani and Majdoub [35] obtained thresholds for global existence and blow-up by variational arguments. We refer to [16, 15, 17] for weighted and time-oscillating exponential nonlinearities, and to [41, 56, 57] for heat and biharmonic heat equations with exponential growth. The profiles of the standing waves of these equations are precisely the solutions of the planar scalar field equation with critical exponential growth (see Lemma 2.1 below). Their uniqueness and nondegeneracy are therefore the natural prerequisites for any modulation analysis near the ground state.

Uniqueness results at exponential growth are scarce, and the available ones concern the Dirichlet problem in a disc with a positive nonlinearity. Adimurthi [3] proved the uniqueness of the positive solution of −Δnu=λun−1eu-\Delta_n u = \lambda u^{n-1}e^u in the unit ball, which reduces to −Δu=λueu-\Delta u = \lambda u e^u in the plane. His proof relies on the Emden–Fowler transformation used by Atkinson and Peletier [11, 12]. Tang [75] obtained uniqueness for a large class of nn-Laplacian Dirichlet problems in balls, which includes nonlinearities with exponential growth. Tarsi [77] combined the Emden–Fowler inversion with methods from the theory of sublinear equations and reached the exponents 1<ϑ≤21 < \vartheta\le2 in the nonlinearity euϑe^{u^\vartheta}, including the critical case ϑ=2\vartheta= 2. For sign-changing solutions, Adimurthi and Yadava [6] proved that the Dirichlet problem in a disc with a critical exponential nonlinearity has no radial nodal solution when the radius is small. This is a two-dimensional analogue of the nonexistence result of Atkinson, Brezis and Peletier [10] for the Brezis–Nirenberg problem [23] in low dimensions. The blow-up of nodal radial solutions was analysed by Grossi and Naimen [38], and the nonexistence of least-energy nodal solutions for autonomous critical problems on R2\mathbb{R}^2 was shown by Alves and Pereira [7].

The problem and the results

After the normalisation of Lemma 2.1, we consider

−Δu+u=λueu2in R2,u∈H1(R2),0<λ<1.(2)-\Delta u + u = \lambda u e^{u^2} \quad\text{in } \mathbb{R}^2,\qquad u \in H^1(\mathbb{R}^2),\qquad0 < \lambda< 1. \tag*{(2)}

We ask the two questions raised by Tang’s theorem in this setting. Is the ground state of (Pλ)(P_\lambda) unique and nondegenerate? For each k≥1k \ge1, does (Pλ)(P_\lambda) have exactly one radial solution with exactly kk nodes?

The contribution of this paper is fourfold, and it is summarised in Table 2. First, we show in § 3 that the Serrin–Tang criterion and two hypotheses of Tang’s analysis fail at exponential growth for a structural reason (Lemma 3.1). Second, we set up in § 4 the shooting framework for (Pλ)(P_\lambda) and prove a pairing principle (Theorem 4.8). Assume that the number N(α)\mathcal{N}(\alpha) of zeros of the radial solution with initial height α\alpha exceeds kk for some α\alpha but not for large α\alpha. Then (Pλ)(P_\lambda) has at least two distinct radial solutions, positive at the origin, with at most kk nodes. Under a natural simple-crossing property, they have exactly kk nodes, and under a transversality property the number of kk-node bound states is either even or infinite (Proposition 4.13). We also prove that Tang’s two conditions on the variation imply that N\mathcal{N} is non-decreasing (Proposition 4.16). Consequently, they must fail near the right endpoint of every interval produced by the pairing principle (Corollary 4.17). Moreover, any two radial ground states intersect (Lemma 4.14), which is the first step of a uniqueness argument by intersection. Third, we analyse in § 5 the Liouville bubble that forms at the origin as α→∞\alpha\to\infty. We prove the second-order expansion of the bubble in the core (Lemma 5.2) and compute exactly the correction of its flux (Lemma 5.1). We deduce from these facts, at a formal level, the asymptotic location ((9)) of the first zero and a mechanism which forces N(α)=1\mathcal{N}(\alpha)=1 for large α\alpha. Fourth, we formulate in § 6 precise conjectures, and we outline in § 7 a programme towards their proofs. Combined with the pairing principle, these conjectures say that N\mathcal{N} is not monotone when λ\lambda is close to 1, that kk-node bound states then occur in nested pairs, and that no nodal radial solution exists when λ\lambda is below a threshold. In the language of Schrödinger standing waves, nodal radial standing waves would exist only at low frequency, and they would never be unique. Conjectures 6.3 and 6.4 are also supported by numerical experiments, which are not reported here and are not used anywhere in the paper.

StatementStatusLocation
Failure of the Serrin–Tang criterion and of the monotonicity of g1g_1provedLemma 3.1
Semicontinuity and local constancy of the zero count N\mathcal{N}provedLemmas 4.5, 4.6
Pairing principleprovedTheorem 4.8, Corollary 4.9
Exact number of nodes of the paired solutionsproved under Hypothesis 4.10Corollary 4.11
Even number of kk-node bound statesproved under transversalityProposition 4.13
Any two radial ground states intersectprovedLemma 4.14
Tang’s conditions imply monotonicity and jumps of N\mathcal{N}, hence fail near the paired heightsprovedProposition 4.16, Corollary 4.17
Core expansion of the bubble and flux correctionprovedLemmas 5.1, 5.2
Asymptotics (9) of the first zeroformalSection 5
N(α)=1\mathcal{N}(\alpha)=1 for large α\alphaformal; Conjecture 6.2Section 5
Uniqueness and nondegeneracy of the ground stateconjectureConjecture 6.1
Threshold λc\lambda_c for nodal solutions; pairs of kk-node statesconjecturesConjectures 6.3, 6.4

Table 2. Main statements of the paper and their status.

Setting and preliminaries

Throughout the paper, 0<λ<10 < \lambda< 1 and

f(s)=−s+λses2,F(s)=∫0sf(σ) dσ=−s22+λ2(es2−1).(3)f(s)=-s+\lambda s e^{s^2},\qquad F(s)=\int_0^s f(\sigma)\,\mathrm{d}\sigma=-\frac{s^2}{2}+\frac{\lambda}{2}\left(e^{s^2}-1\right). \tag*{(3)}

so that (Pλ)(P_\lambda) reads Δu+f(u)=0\Delta u+f(u)=0. We write ζ=1−λ=−f′(0)\zeta=1-\lambda=-f'(0), and we introduce the three positive numbers

u1=log⁡(1/λ),α+=s+,uλ∗=s∗.(4)u_1=\sqrt{\log(1/\lambda)},\qquad\alpha_+=\sqrt{s_+},\qquad u_\lambda^*=\sqrt{s^*}. \tag*{(4)}

where s+>0s_+>0 is the positive root of λ(es−1)=s\lambda(e^{s}-1)=s and s∗>0s^*>0 is the root of (1+s)e−s=λ(1+s)e^{-s}=\lambda. The existence and uniqueness of s+s_+ and s∗s^* are proved in Lemma 2.3 and Lemma 3.1 respectively. These levels are illustrated in Figure 1.

Figure 1. The case λ=12\lambda=\frac{1}{2}, for which u1≈0.833u_{1}\approx0.833, α+≈1.121\alpha_{+}\approx1.121 and uλ∗≈1.296u_{\lambda}^{*}\approx1.296. Left: the nonlinearity ff and its primitive FF, which vanish at u1u_{1} and α+\alpha_{+} respectively. Right: the function g1g_{1} of Lemma 3.1(b), which increases up to uλ∗u_{\lambda}^{*} and then decreases to 0, in contrast with the power case where g1g_{1} is increasing on (0,∞)(0,\infty).

Lemma 2.1.

  1. A function uu solves (Pλ)(P_\lambda) if and only if w=u/4πw=u/\sqrt{4\pi} solves −Δw+w=λwe4πw2-\Delta w+w=\lambda w e^{4\pi w^2} in R2\mathbb{R}^2, which is the equation studied in [71, 72].

(ii) Let ω>0\omega> 0. The function ψ(t,x)=eiωtφ(x)\psi(t,x)=e^{i\omega t}\varphi(x), with φ\varphi real valued, solves the focusing Schrödinger equation i∂tψ+Δψ+(e4π∣ψ∣2−1)ψ=0i\partial_t\psi+\Delta\psi+(e^{4\pi|\psi|^2}-1)\psi=0 if and only if u(x)=4πφ(x/1+ω)u(x)=\sqrt{4\pi}\varphi(x/\sqrt{1+\omega}) solves (Pλ)(P_\lambda) with λ=1/(1+ω)\lambda=1/(1+\omega).

(iii) Let ∣ω∣<1|\omega|<1. The function ϕ(t,x)=eiωtφ(x)\phi(t,x)=e^{i\omega t}\varphi(x), with φ\varphi real valued, solves the focusing Klein–Gordon equation ∂t2ϕ−Δϕ+ϕ=(e4π∣ϕ∣2−1)ϕ\partial_t^2\phi-\Delta\phi+\phi=(e^{4\pi|\phi|^2}-1)\phi if and only if u(x)=4πφ(x/2−ω2)u(x)=\sqrt{4\pi}\varphi(x/\sqrt{2-\omega^2}) solves (Pλ)(P_\lambda) with λ=1/(2−ω2)∈[12,1)\lambda=1/(2-\omega^2)\in[\frac{1}{2},1).

Proof. For (i), the substitution u=4π wu=\sqrt{4\pi}\,w gives λueu2=4πλwe4πw2\lambda u e^{u^2}=\sqrt{4\pi}\lambda w e^{4\pi w^2}, and the claim follows after division by 4π\sqrt{4\pi}. For (ii), the time derivative of eiωtφe^{i\omega t}\varphi produces the term −ωφ-\omega\varphi, and we obtain the standing-wave equation −Δφ+(1+ω)φ=φe4πφ2-\Delta\varphi+(1+\omega)\varphi=\varphi e^{4\pi\varphi^2}. We write φ(y)=(4π)−1/2u(1+ω y)\varphi(y)=(4\pi)^{-1/2}u(\sqrt{1+\omega}\,y). Then Δyφ=(4π)−1/2(1+ω)(Δu)(1+ω y)\Delta_y\varphi=(4\pi)^{-1/2}(1+\omega)(\Delta u)(\sqrt{1+\omega}\,y) and 4πφ2=u24\pi\varphi^2=u^2, so the equation becomes (1+ω)(−Δu+u)=ueu2(1+\omega)(-\Delta u+u)=ue^{u^2}, which is (Pλ)(P_\lambda) with λ=1/(1+ω)\lambda=1/(1+\omega). The proof of (iii) is identical, since the standing-wave equation now reads −Δφ+(2−ω2)φ=φe4πφ2-\Delta\varphi+(2-\omega^2)\varphi=\varphi e^{4\pi\varphi^2}. Finally, the range of λ\lambda follows from 0≤ω2<10\le\omega^2<1. □

Remark 2.2. The ground states relevant for the Klein–Gordon equation correspond to λ∈[12,1)\lambda\in[\frac{1}{2},1), while the Schrödinger standing waves cover the whole range λ∈(0,1)\lambda\in(0,1), high frequencies corresponding to small values of λ\lambda. The Schrödinger nonlinearity in Lemma 2.1(ii) is the case μ=0\mu=0 of the family (e4π∣u∣2−1−4πμ∣u∣2)u(e^{4\pi|u|^2}-1-4\pi\mu|u|^2)u, μ∈{0,1}\mu\in\{0,1\}, studied in [35]. For μ=1\mu=1, the same computation leads to Δu+f1(u)=0\Delta u+f_1(u)=0 with f1(s)=s(−1+λ(es2−1−s2))f_1(s)=s(-1+\lambda(e^{s^2}-1-s^2)) and λ=1/ω∈(0,∞)\lambda=1/\omega\in(0,\infty). The function f1(s)/sf_1(s)/s is strictly increasing on (0,∞)(0,\infty), f1′(0)=−1f_1'(0)=-1, and F1(s)=12Φ1(s2)F_1(s)=\frac{1}{2}\Phi_1(s^2) with Φ1(σ)=λ(eσ−1−σ−σ2/2)−σ\Phi_1(\sigma)=\lambda(e^\sigma-1-\sigma-\sigma^2/2)-\sigma, which is strictly convex with Φ1(0)=0\Phi_1(0)=0 and Φ1′(0)=−1\Phi_1'(0)=-1. Hence f1f_1 satisfies the conditions (C1)–(C4) recalled in Section 4, and the rigorous results of Section 4, whose proofs use only these conditions and the monotonicity of f(s)/sf(s)/s, hold verbatim for f1f_1. We do not pursue this family further.

Lemma 2.3. The function ff is smooth and odd, and the following properties hold.

(a) f<0f<0 on (0,u1)(0,u_1), f>0f>0 on (u1,∞)(u_1,\infty), f′(0)=−ζ<0f'(0)=-\zeta<0 and f′(u1)=2u12>0f'(u_1)=2u_1^2>0.

(b) F<0F<0 on (0,α+)(0,\alpha_+) and F>0F>0 on (α+,∞)(\alpha_+,\infty), where α+\alpha_+ is well defined by (4). Moreover, α+>u1\alpha_+>u_1.

(c) sf(s)−2F(s)=λ(s2es2−es2+1)>0sf(s)-2F(s)=\lambda(s^2e^{s^2}-e^{s^2}+1)>0 for s≠0s\ne0.

(d) f′′(s)=λses2(6+4s2)>0f''(s)=\lambda s e^{s^2}(6+4s^2)>0 and sf′(s)−f(s)=2λs3es2>0sf'(s)-f(s)=2\lambda s^3e^{s^2}>0 for s>0s>0.

(e) The function s↦f(s)/s=λes2−1s\mapsto f(s)/s=\lambda e^{s^2}-1 is strictly increasing on (0,∞)(0,\infty).

Proof. Since f(s)=s(λes2−1)f(s)=s(\lambda e^{s^2}-1), the sign of ff on (0,∞)(0,\infty) is that of λes2−1\lambda e^{s^2}-1, which changes exactly at u1u_1. Moreover, f′(s)=−1+λes2(1+2s2)f'(s)=-1+\lambda e^{s^2}(1+2s^2), hence f′(0)=λ−1f'(0)=\lambda-1, and the identity λeu12=1\lambda e^{u_1^2}=1 yields f′(u1)=2u12f'(u_1)=2u_1^2. This proves (a), and (e) follows immediately from the same factorisation. For (b), we observe that F(s)=12Φ(s2)F(s)=\frac{1}{2}\Phi(s^2) with Φ(σ)=λ(eσ−1)−σ\Phi(\sigma)=\lambda(e^\sigma-1)-\sigma. The function Φ\Phi is strictly convex, vanishes at 00, satisfies Φ′(0)=λ−1<0\Phi'(0)=\lambda-1<0, and tends to +∞+\infty at infinity. We infer that Φ\Phi has exactly one positive zero s+s_+, and that it is negative on (0,s+)(0,s_+) and positive on (s+,∞)(s_+,\infty). Since Φ′(σ)=λeσ−1<0\Phi'(\sigma)=\lambda e^\sigma-1<0 on (0,log⁡(1/λ))(0,\log(1/\lambda)), the function Φ\Phi is negative on (0,log⁡(1/λ))(0,\log(1/\lambda)), and we conclude that s+>log⁡(1/λ)s_+>\log(1/\lambda), that is, α+>u1\alpha_+>u_1. For (c), a direct computation gives sf(s)−2F(s)=λχ(s2)sf(s)-2F(s)=\lambda\chi(s^2) with χ(σ)=σeσ−eσ+1\chi(\sigma)=\sigma e^\sigma-e^\sigma+1. As χ(0)=0\chi(0)=0 and χ′(σ)=σeσ>0\chi'(\sigma)=\sigma e^\sigma>0 for σ>0\sigma>0, the expression is positive for s≠0s\ne0. Finally, (d) follows by differentiating f′f' once more, and from the identity sf′(s)=f(s)+2λs3es2sf'(s)=f(s)+2\lambda s^3e^{s^2}. □

Remark 2.4. In dimension two, the Pohozaev function of the radial equation degenerates. We use the notation of [76], where the nonlinearity is normalised so that its positive zero equals 1 (see the paragraph before Proposition 4.3). The functions entering conditions (C5) and (C7) of [76] are h(s)=2nF(s)−(n−2)sf(s)h(s) = 2nF(s) - (n - 2)sf(s) and h2(s)=(n+2)f(s)−(n−2)sf′(s)h_{2}(s) = (n + 2)f(s) - (n - 2)sf'(s). When n=2n = 2, we get h=4Fh = 4F and h2=4fh_{2} = 4f. Consequently, condition (C5) holds with threshold equal to the positive zero of FF (in our normalisation, α+\alpha_{+}), whereas for n≥3n \ge3 the threshold in (C5) is strictly larger than the positive zero of FF. Likewise, condition (C7) holds with threshold equal to the positive zero of ff (in our normalisation, u1u_{1}). In addition, the Pohozaev function P(r)=r2(u′(r)2+2F(u(r)))P(r) = r^{2}(u'(r)^{2} + 2F(u(r))) used in Lemma 4.4 below reduces to P(r)=2r2E(r)P(r) = 2r^{2}E(r), where EE is the energy (6).

Structural obstructions

Let K(s)=sf′(s)/f(s)K(s) = sf'(s)/f(s) for s>u1s > u_{1}. The uniqueness criterion of Serrin and Tang [73] requires KK to be non-increasing on (u1,∞)(u_{1},\infty). Condition (C8) of [76] requires f/(sf′)=1/Kf/(sf') = 1/K to be increasing on (u1,∞)(u_{1},\infty); when f′>0f' > 0 there, this is equivalent to the Serrin–Tang condition. In the analysis of the first phase in [76 Lemma 4.2], the function

g1(s)=2f(s)sf′(s)−f(s)g_{1}(s) = \frac{2f(s)}{sf'(s) - f(s)}

is assumed to satisfy g1′>0g_{1}' > 0 on (0,∞)(0,\infty). The functions KK, 1/K1/K and g1g_{1} are invariant under the normalisation w=u/u1w = u/u_{1} of § 4, in the sense that the corresponding functions of f~(w)=f(u1w)/u1\widetilde{f}(w) = f(u_{1}w)/u_{1} are obtained by evaluating them at s=u1ws = u_{1}w. We may therefore state all conditions directly for ff.

Lemma 3.1.

(a) For every s>u1s > u_{1} one has K(s)>1+2s2K(s) > 1 + 2s^{2}. In particular, KK is unbounded, it is not non-increasing on any half-line (b,∞)(b,\infty), and 1/K1/K is not increasing on (u1,∞)(u_{1},\infty).

(b) For $s > 0,

g1(s)=λes2−1λs2es2,g1′(s)=2s3((1+s2)e−s2λ−1).g_{1}(s) = \frac{\lambda e^{s^{2}} - 1}{\lambda s^{2}e^{s^{2}}}, \qquad g_{1}'(s) = \frac{2}{s^{3}}\left(\frac{(1+s^{2})e^{-s^{2}}}{\lambda} - 1\right).

Hence g1g_{1} is strictly increasing on (0,uλ∗](0,u_{\lambda}^{*}] and strictly decreasing on [uλ∗,∞)[u_{\lambda}^{*},\infty), where uλ∗u_{\lambda}^{*} is well defined by (4). Moreover, α+<uλ∗\alpha_{+} < u_{\lambda}^{*}.

Proof. Let s>u1s > u_{1}. By Lemma 2.3(d), sf′(s)=f(s)+2λs3es2sf'(s) = f(s) + 2\lambda s^{3}e^{s^{2}}, and f(s)=s(λes2−1)>0f(s) = s(\lambda e^{s^{2}} - 1) > 0. We obtain

K(s)=1+2s2λes2λes2−1>1+2s2,K(s) = 1 + \frac{2s^{2}\lambda e^{s^{2}}}{\lambda e^{s^{2}} - 1} > 1 + 2s^{2},

because λes2>λes2−1>0\lambda e^{s^{2}} > \lambda e^{s^{2}} - 1 > 0. A function which is non-increasing on (b,∞)(b,\infty) is bounded above there by its value at any point of that interval, and this is incompatible with K(s)→∞K(s) \to\infty as s→∞s \to\infty. Likewise, the positive function 1/K1/K tends to 00 at infinity, and therefore it cannot be increasing on (u1,∞)(u_{1},\infty). This proves (a).

For (b), the formula for g1g_{1} follows from Lemma 2.3(d). Writing g1(s)=s−2−λ−1s−2e−s2g_{1}(s) = s^{-2} - \lambda^{-1}s^{-2}e^{-s^{2}}, we find

g1′(s)=−2s3+1λ(2s3+2s)e−s2=2s3((1+s2)e−s2λ−1).g_{1}'(s) = -\frac{2}{s^{3}} + \frac{1}{\lambda}\left(\frac{2}{s^{3}} + \frac{2}{s}\right)e^{-s^{2}} = \frac{2}{s^{3}}\left(\frac{(1+s^{2})e^{-s^{2}}}{\lambda} - 1\right).

The function σ↦(1+σ)e−σ\sigma\mapsto(1+\sigma)e^{-\sigma} has derivative −σe−σ<0-\sigma e^{-\sigma} < 0 on (0,∞)(0,\infty), and it decreases from 11 to 00. Since 0<λ<10 < \lambda< 1, it takes the value λ\lambda exactly once, at s∗s^{*}, and it is larger than λ\lambda on (0,s∗)(0,s^{*}) and smaller on (s∗,∞)(s^{*},\infty). The sign of g1′g_1' is therefore as stated. Finally, the definition of s+s_{+} gives λes+=s++λ\lambda e^{s_{+}}=s_{+}+\lambda, so that

(1+s+)e−s+=λ(1+s+)s++λ>λ,(1+s_{+})e^{-s_{+}}=\frac{\lambda(1+s_{+})}{s_{+}+\lambda}>\lambda,

since λ<1\lambda<1. By the monotonicity just established, we deduce that s+<s∗s_{+}<s^{*}, that is, α+<uλ∗\alpha_{+}<u_{\lambda}^{*}.

Remark 3.2. Lemma 3.1(a) is the precise sense in which the Serrin–Tang approach, designed for nonlinearities of at most power growth, does not reach Trudinger–Moser growth. By part (b), the monotonicity of g1g_{1} required in [76 Lemma 4.2] fails on (uλ∗,∞)(u_{\lambda}^{*},\infty), and it holds on the range (0,α](0,\alpha] of a positive solution only if α≤uλ∗\alpha\leq u_{\lambda}^{*}. In the proof of [76 Lemma 4.2], the derivative g1′g_{1}' only enters through the identity T1′(r)=−g1′(u(r))u′(r)M(r)T_{1}'(r)=-g_{1}'(u(r))u'(r)M(r), and it is evaluated at the values u(r)∈(0,α)u(r)\in(0,\alpha) taken for 0<r<z10<r<z_{1} (or for all r>0r>0 in the case of a ground state). The remaining hypotheses of that lemma, namely (C1), (C3), (C5), (C6), (C9) and the positivity of sf′(s)−f(s)sf'(s)-f(s), hold for our ff in dimension two by Lemma 2.3 and Remark 2.4. Since [76 Sections 2 and 4] are written for a real dimension n>1n>1, we infer that the conclusions of [76 Lemma 4.2] hold for every ground state or nodal solution of (5) whose initial height satisfies α≤uλ∗\alpha\leq u_{\lambda}^{*}. Every positive solution which decays at infinity has α>α+\alpha>\alpha_{+} (Proposition 4.3(ii)), and α+<uλ∗\alpha_{+}<u_{\lambda}^{*}, so the condition α≤uλ∗\alpha\leq u_{\lambda}^{*} is not excluded a priori. However, a uniqueness proof must handle all ground states simultaneously, and the condition α≤uλ∗\alpha\leq u_{\lambda}^{*} cannot be verified for an unknown second ground state.

Table 3 compares the structural conditions of [76] for the power nonlinearity and for the nonlinearity of (Pλ)(P_{\lambda}).

The shooting framework and rigorous results

Radial solutions u(x)=u(r)u(x)=u(r), r=∣x∣r=|x|, of (Pλ)(P_{\lambda}) are obtained from the initial value problem

u′′+1ru′+f(u)=0,r>0,u(0)=α>0,u′(0)=0.(5)u''+\frac{1}{r}u'+f(u)=0,\qquad r>0,\qquad u(0)=\alpha>0,\qquad u'(0)=0. \tag*{(5)}

Problem (5) is equivalent to the Volterra integral equation

u(r)=α−∫0rτlog⁡(rτ)f(u(τ)) dτu(r)=\alpha-\int_0^r \tau\log\left(\frac{r}{\tau}\right)f(u(\tau))\,\mathrm{d}\tau

whose kernel is bounded on {0≤τ≤r≤R}\{0\le\tau\le r\le R\}. Since ff is smooth, a contraction argument gives a unique local solution u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha). Moreover, the solution depends smoothly on α\alpha in C1([0,R])C^1([0,R]) for every RR for which it exists [21, 39, 76]. The energy

E(r)=12u′(r)2+F(u(r)),E′(r)=−u′(r)2r,(6)E(r)=\frac{1}{2}u'(r)^2+F(u(r)),\qquad E'(r)=-\frac{u'(r)^2}{r}, \tag*{(6)}

is non-increasing. As FF is even and coercive, the inequality F(u(r))≤E(r)≤F(α)F(u(r))\le E(r)\le F(\alpha) bounds uu on the interval of existence. Then 12u′(r)2≤F(α)−min⁡F\frac{1}{2}u'(r)^2\le F(\alpha)-\min F bounds u′u', and we conclude that the solution is global. The variation v=∂u/∂αv=\partial u/\partial\alpha is well defined for all r≥0r\ge0, and it solves

v′′+1rv′+f′(u)v=0,v(0)=1,v′(0)=0.v''+\frac{1}{r}v'+f'(u)v=0,\qquad v(0)=1,\quad v'(0)=0.

Remark 4.1. Every solution u∈H1(R2)u\in H^1(\mathbb{R}^2) of (Pλ)(P_\lambda) is smooth, bounded, and tends to zero at infinity. Indeed, ∫R2(eβu2−1)<∞\int_{\mathbb{R}^2}(e^{\beta u^2}-1)<\infty for every β>0\beta>0 by [24, 69]. Hence, for every q<∞q<\infty, the integral ∫B1(x)equ2\int_{B_1(x)}e^{qu^2} is bounded independently of x∈R2x\in\mathbb{R}^2. Since ∣s∣≤es2|s|\le e^{s^2}, the function −u+λueu2-u+\lambda u e^{u^2} is bounded in Lq(B1(x))L^q(B_1(x)) independently of xx. The interior LqL^q estimates then show that uu is bounded in W2,q(B1/2(x))W^{2,q}(B_{1/2}(x)) independently of xx. We infer that uu is bounded and uniformly continuous on R2\mathbb{R}^2, and a bootstrap argument shows that uu is smooth. As u∈L2(R2)u\in L^2(\mathbb{R}^2) is uniformly continuous, it tends to zero at infinity. In particular, every radial solution in H1(R2)H^1(\mathbb{R}^2) with u(0)=α>0u(0)=\alpha>0 coincides with u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha). Moreover, every positive solution is radially symmetric about some point by [37, 53], since f(s)=−ζs+O(s3)f(s)=-\zeta s+O(s^3) as s→0s\to0. These facts are not used below.

Definition 4.2. The solution u=u(⋅,α)u=u(\cdot,\alpha) of (5) is called a ground state if u>0u>0 and u(r)→0u(r)\to0 as r→∞r\to\infty. It is called a kk-node bound state if it has exactly k≥1k\ge1 zeros in (0,∞)(0,\infty) and u(r)→0u(r)\to0 as r→∞r\to\infty. It is called oscillatory if E(r)≤0E(r)\le0 for some r≥0r\ge0. We denote by N(α)\mathcal{N}(\alpha) the number of zeros of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) in (0,∞)(0,\infty), and by G\mathcal{G} the set of all α>0\alpha>0 for which u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) is a ground state or a bound state.

The following proposition collects results of Tang [76 Propositions 2.1–2.4]; see also [21, 67]. They are proved in [76] for a general nonlinearity satisfying conditions (C1)–(C4) there, namely: f∈C1(R)f\in C^{1}(\mathbb{R}) is odd, f<0f<0 on (0,1)(0,1) and f>0f>0 on (1,∞)(1,\infty); FF has a positive zero α∗>1\alpha^{*}>1; f′(0)<0f'(0)<0; and f′(1)>0f'(1)>0. In [76 Section 2], the dimension nn appearing in the radial equation is treated as a real parameter in (1,∞)(1,\infty), so these results apply when n=2n=2. Tang normalises the positive zero of ff to be 1, and this is inessential. Indeed, w=u/u1w=u/u_{1} solves w′′+w′/r+f~(w)=0w''+w'/r+\widetilde{f}(w)=0 with f~(w)=f(u1w)/u1\widetilde{f}(w)=f(u_{1}w)/u_{1}. By Lemma 2.3(a)–(b), the function f~\widetilde{f} satisfies (C1)–(C4), with f~′(0)=−ζ\widetilde{f}'(0)=-\zeta, f~′(1)=2u12\widetilde{f}'(1)=2u_{1}^{2} and α∗=α+/u1\alpha^{*}=\alpha_{+}/u_{1}.

Proposition 4.3 ([76]). Let u=u(⋅,α)u=u(\cdot,\alpha) with α>0\alpha>0 and α≠u1\alpha\ne u_{1} (for α=u1\alpha=u_{1} we have u≡u1u\equiv u_{1}).

(i) EE is strictly decreasing on (0,∞)(0,\infty). If α>u1\alpha>u_{1}, then ∥u∥∞=α\|u\|_{\infty}=\alpha.

(ii) If uu is a ground state or has a zero, then α>α+\alpha>\alpha_{+}. If α≤α+\alpha\le\alpha_{+}, then u>0u>0 and uu is oscillatory.

(iii) Assume that uu has zeros z1<z2<⋯z_{1}<z_{2}<\cdots. Then uu has exactly one critical point ci∈(zi,zi+1)c_{i}\in(z_{i},z_{i+1}) between two consecutive zeros, ∣u(ci)∣>α+|u(c_{i})|>\alpha_{+}, and α>∣u(c1)∣>∣u(c2)∣>⋯\alpha>|u(c_{1})|>|u(c_{2})|>\cdots. Moreover, N(α)<∞\mathcal{N}(\alpha)<\infty.

(iv) Exactly one of the following occurs: uu is a ground state, uu is a bound state, or uu is oscillatory. Ground states and bound states satisfy E>0E>0 on (0,∞)(0,\infty) and u′(r)/u(r)→−ζu'(r)/u(r)\to-\sqrt{\zeta} as r→∞r\to\infty. Moreover, lim sup⁡r→∞∣u(r)∣e(ζ−ε)r<∞\limsup_{r\to\infty}|u(r)|e^{(\sqrt{\zeta}-\varepsilon)r}<\infty for every ε∈(0,ζ)\varepsilon\in(0,\sqrt{\zeta}), and the same exponential decay holds for u′u'. An oscillatory solution satisfies E(r)<0E(r)<0 for all large rr, has no zero beyond the first rr at which E(r)≤0E(r)\le0, and oscillates about u1u_{1} or −u1-u_{1}.

Several parts of Proposition 4.3 are elementary consequences of (6). For instance, at a zero zz of uu we have E(z)=12u′(z)2>0E(z)=\frac{1}{2}u'(z)^{2}>0, the zero being simple by uniqueness for (5). Since EE is strictly decreasing, we get F(α)=E(0)>E(z)>0F(\alpha)=E(0)>E(z)>0, and Lemma 2.3(b) yields α>α+\alpha>\alpha_{+}. In particular, every α∈G\alpha\in\mathcal{G} yields a classical, exponentially decaying, and hence finite-energy solution of (Pλ)(P_{\lambda}).

Lemma 4.4 (Pohozaev identity in the plane). If α∈G\alpha\in\mathcal{G}, then ∫0∞rF(u(r,α)) dr=0\int_{0}^{\infty}rF(u(r,\alpha))\,\mathrm{d}r=0.

Proof. Let P(r)=r2(u′2+2F(u))=2r2E(r)P(r)=r^{2}(u'^{2}+2F(u))=2r^{2}E(r). Using (6), we get P′(r)=4rE(r)−2ru′(r)2=4rF(u(r))P'(r)=4rE(r)-2ru'(r)^{2}=4rF(u(r)). We have P(0)=0P(0)=0. Moreover, P(r)→0P(r)\to0 as r→∞r\to\infty by the exponential decay of uu and u′u', since F(s)=O(s2)F(s)=O(s^{2}) as s→0s\to0. Integrating over (0,∞)(0,\infty), we obtain the claim. □

Semicontinuity and local constancy of the zero count

Lemma 4.5. Let α>0\alpha>0.

(a) There is δ>0\delta>0 such that N(β)≥N(α)\mathcal{N}(\beta)\ge\mathcal{N}(\alpha) for ∣β−α∣<δ|\beta-\alpha|<\delta.

(b) If α∉G\alpha\notin\mathcal{G}, there is δ>0\delta>0 such that N(β)=N(α)\mathcal{N}(\beta)=\mathcal{N}(\alpha) for ∣β−α∣<δ|\beta-\alpha|<\delta.

Proof. Every zero z>0z>0 of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) is simple. Indeed, u(z)=u′(z)=0u(z)=u'(z)=0 would force u≡0u\equiv0 on (0,∞)(0,\infty) by uniqueness for (5) away from the origin, and then u(0)=0u(0)=0 by continuity, which contradicts u(0)=α>0u(0)=\alpha>0. For (a), we may assume N(α)≥1\mathcal{N}(\alpha)\geq1; recall that N(α)\mathcal{N}(\alpha) is finite by Proposition 4.3(iii). We choose RR larger than the last zero of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha), so that u(R,α)≠0u(R,\alpha)\neq0. As β→α\beta\to\alpha, we have u(⋅,β)→u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\beta)\to u(\cdot,\alpha) in C1([0,R])C^1([0,R]). Since u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) changes sign at each of its zeros, the intermediate value theorem gives a zero of u(⋅,β)u(\cdot,\beta) near each zero of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) in (0,R)(0,R). We conclude that u(⋅,β)u(\cdot,\beta) has at least N(α)\mathcal{N}(\alpha) zeros when β\beta is close to α\alpha.

For (b), suppose first that α=u1\alpha=u_1. Then E(0)=F(u1)<0E(0)=F(u_1)<0 by Lemma 2.3(b), so that F(β)<0F(\beta)<0 for β\beta close to u1u_1. Since the energy is non-increasing, the solution u(⋅,β)u(\cdot,\beta) satisfies E≤F(β)<0E\leq F(\beta)<0 on [0,∞)[0,\infty). As E=12u′2≥0E=\frac{1}{2}u'^2\geq0 at any zero, it follows that u(⋅,β)u(\cdot,\beta) has no zero, and N≡0\mathcal{N}\equiv0 near u1u_1.

Suppose now that α≠u1\alpha\neq u_1 and α∉G\alpha\notin\mathcal{G}. By Proposition 4.3(iv), u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) is oscillatory, and the strict monotonicity of EE gives some rˉ>0\bar{r}>0 with E(rˉ)<0E(\bar{r})<0. Then u(rˉ,α)≠0u(\bar{r},\alpha)\neq0, and all zeros of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) lie in (0,rˉ)(0,\bar{r}). Let z1<⋯<zmz_1<\cdots<z_m be these zeros, with m=N(α)m=\mathcal{N}(\alpha). Since u′(zi,α)≠0u'(z_i,\alpha)\neq0, we may choose disjoint closed intervals Ii⊂(0,rˉ)I_i\subset(0,\bar{r}) centred at ziz_i on which ∣u′(⋅,α)∣\lvert u'(\cdot,\alpha)\rvert is bounded below by a positive constant. Then ∣u(⋅,α)∣\lvert u(\cdot,\alpha)\rvert is bounded below by a positive constant on the compact set [0,rˉ]∖⋃iint⁡(Ii)[0,\bar{r}]\setminus\bigcup_i\operatorname{int}(I_i). By the C1C^1 convergence on [0,rˉ][0,\bar{r}], for β\beta close to α\alpha the function u(⋅,β)u(\cdot,\beta) does not vanish on this set, it is strictly monotone on each IiI_i, and it changes sign on each IiI_i. We infer that u(⋅,β)u(\cdot,\beta) has exactly one zero in each IiI_i, hence exactly mm zeros in (0,rˉ](0,\bar{r}]. Moreover, its energy at rˉ\bar{r} is still negative, by continuity. Since the energy is non-increasing, u(⋅,β)u(\cdot,\beta) has no zero in [rˉ,∞)[\bar{r},\infty), and we conclude that N(β)=N(α)\mathcal{N}(\beta)=\mathcal{N}(\alpha).

Lemma 4.6. N(β)=0\mathcal{N}(\beta)=0 for every β∈(0,α+]\beta\in(0,\alpha_+], and there is δ0>0\delta_0>0 such that N=0\mathcal{N}=0 on (0,α++δ0)(0,\alpha_++\delta_0).

Proof. For β∈(0,α+]\beta\in(0,\alpha_+] with β≠u1\beta\neq u_1, Proposition 4.3(ii) gives u(⋅,β)>0u(\cdot,\beta)>0, and for β=u1\beta=u_1 the solution is constant. Moreover, α+∉G\alpha_+\notin\mathcal{G}, because ground states and bound states require α>α+\alpha>\alpha_+ by Proposition 4.3(ii). Applying Lemma 4.5(b) at α=α+\alpha=\alpha_+, we obtain δ0\delta_0.

The pairing principle

For k≥0k\geq0 we set

Uk={α>0:N(α)≥k+1}.U_k=\{\alpha>0:\mathcal{N}(\alpha)\geq k+1\}.

Proposition 4.7. For every k≥0k\geq0, the set UkU_k is open and contained in [α++δ0,∞)[\alpha_++\delta_0,\infty). Every boundary point α^∈(0,∞)\hat{\alpha}\in(0,\infty) of UkU_k belongs to G\mathcal{G} and satisfies N(α^)≤k\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha})\leq k.

Proof. Openness follows from Lemma 4.5(a), and the inclusion follows from Lemma 4.6. Let α^∈(0,∞)\hat{\alpha}\in(0,\infty) be a boundary point of UkU_k. Since UkU_k is open, α^∉Uk\hat{\alpha}\notin U_k, that is, N(α^)≤k\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha})\leq k. If α^\hat{\alpha} did not belong to G\mathcal{G}, Lemma 4.5(b) would provide a neighbourhood of α^\hat{\alpha} on which N≡N(α^)≤k\mathcal{N}\equiv\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha})\leq k. This neighbourhood would not meet UkU_k, which contradicts the fact that α^\hat{\alpha} lies in the closure of UkU_k.

Theorem 4.8 (Pairing principle). Let k≥0k\geq0, and assume that there are β1<β2\beta_1<\beta_2 such that N(β1)≥k+1\mathcal{N}(\beta_1)\geq k+1 and N(α)≤k\mathcal{N}(\alpha)\leq k for every α≥β2\alpha\geq\beta_2. Let (a,b)(a,b) be the connected component of UkU_k containing β1\beta_1. Then α+<a<β1<b≤β2\alpha_+<a<\beta_1<b\leq\beta_2, both aa and bb belong to G\mathcal{G}, N(a)≤k\mathcal{N}(a)\leq k and N(b)≤k\mathcal{N}(b)\leq k, while N≥k+1\mathcal{N}\geq k+1 on (a,b)(a,b). In particular, (Pλ)(P_\lambda) possesses two distinct radial solutions u(⋅,a)u(\cdot,a) and u(⋅,b)u(\cdot,b), positive at the origin, each of which is a ground state or a bound state with at most kk nodes. Moreover, these two solutions are not related by a translation or by a change of sign.

Proof. By Proposition 4.7, UkU_k is an open subset of (0,∞)(0,\infty) containing β1\beta_1, so its connected component containing β1\beta_1 is an open interval (a,b)(a,b). The inclusion Uk⊂[α++δ0,∞)U_k\subset[\alpha_++\delta_0,\infty) gives a≥α++δ0>α+a\geq\alpha_++\delta_0>\alpha_+. Since N≤k\mathcal{N}\leq k on [β2,∞)[\beta_2,\infty), the interval (a,b)(a,b) does not meet [β2,∞)[\beta_2,\infty), and we get b≤β2b \le\beta_2. Both aa and bb are finite and positive. As endpoints of a connected component of an open set, they do not belong to UkU_k but lie in its closure. Hence they are boundary points of UkU_k, and Proposition 4.7 shows that they lie in G\mathcal{G} and have at most kk zeros. Finally, the two solutions take the distinct positive values a<ba<b at the origin, so they are distinct radial solutions centred at the origin. A nontrivial translate of u(⋅,a)u(\cdot,a) is not radially symmetric about the origin, and −u(⋅,a)-u(\cdot,a) is negative at the origin. We conclude that neither of them coincides with u(⋅,b)u(\cdot,b).

Corollary 4.9. Let Nmax⁡=sup⁡α>0N(α)N_{\max}=\sup_{\alpha>0}\mathcal{N}(\alpha) and N∞=lim sup⁡α→∞N(α)N_{\infty}=\limsup_{\alpha\to\infty}\mathcal{N}(\alpha), and suppose that N∞<∞N_{\infty}<\infty. Then, for every integer kk with N∞≤k<Nmax⁡N_{\infty}\le k<N_{\max}, there are two distinct radial solutions of (Pλ)(P_\lambda), positive at the origin, with at most kk nodes, each of which is a ground state or a bound state.

Proof. Since N\mathcal{N} is integer valued and N∞≤kN_{\infty}\le k, there is β2\beta_2 such that N(α)≤k\mathcal{N}(\alpha)\le k for all α≥β2\alpha\ge\beta_2. Since k<Nmax⁡k<N_{\max}, there is β1\beta_1 with N(β1)≥k+1\mathcal{N}(\beta_1)\ge k+1, and necessarily β1<β2\beta_1<\beta_2. Theorem 4.8 applies. □

In order to identify exactly the number of nodes of the two solutions, we need a simple-crossing property. Lemma 4.5(a) already gives the corresponding lower bound unconditionally.

Hypothesis 4.10 (Simple crossing). For every α^∈G\hat{\alpha}\in\mathcal{G}, there is δ>0\delta>0 such that N(β)≤N(α^)+1\mathcal{N}(\beta)\le\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha})+1 for ∣β−α^∣<δ|\beta-\hat{\alpha}|<\delta.

Corollary 4.11. Under the assumptions of Theorem 4.8, if Hypothesis 4.10 holds at aa and at bb, then N(a)=N(b)=k\mathcal{N}(a)=\mathcal{N}(b)=k. Consequently, if k≥1k\ge1, equation (Pλ)(P_\lambda) has at least two distinct kk-node radial bound states positive at the origin, and if k=0k=0, it has at least two distinct radial ground states.

Proof. Points of (a,b)(a,b) arbitrarily close to aa satisfy N≥k+1\mathcal{N}\ge k+1, while Hypothesis 4.10 gives N≤N(a)+1\mathcal{N}\le\mathcal{N}(a)+1 near aa. We deduce that N(a)≥k\mathcal{N}(a)\ge k, and N(a)≤k\mathcal{N}(a)\le k by Theorem 4.8. The same argument applies at bb. □

Remark 4.12. Heuristically, Hypothesis 4.10 holds for the following reason. Let α^∈G\hat{\alpha}\in\mathcal{G} and let β\beta be close to α^\hat{\alpha}. The solution u(⋅,β)u(\cdot,\beta) follows the exponentially decaying tail of u(⋅,α^)u(\cdot,\hat{\alpha}) up to a large radius RR, at which the deviation, which grows like eζre^{\sqrt{\zeta}r}, becomes comparable to e−ζre^{-\sqrt{\zeta}r}. If the solution then crosses zero, its energy at the crossing is of order e−2ζRe^{-2\sqrt{\zeta}R}. A further zero requires an excursion to ∣u∣>α+|u|>\alpha_+ and back, close to the homoclinic orbit of the autonomous equation u′′+f(u)=0u''+f(u)=0. During this excursion, the energy decreases by an amount of order R−1R^{-1}, which is much larger than e−2ζRe^{-2\sqrt{\zeta}R}. The energy therefore becomes negative, and the solution is trapped. Making this argument quantitative requires a careful perturbative analysis near the saddle point (0,0)(0,0), which has not been carried out.

A stronger property than Hypothesis 4.10 gives the parity of the number of bound states. We say that α^∈G\hat{\alpha}\in\mathcal{G} is transversal if there is δ>0\delta>0 such that N\mathcal{N} is equal to N(α^)\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha}) on one of the intervals (α^−δ,α^)(\hat{\alpha}-\delta,\hat{\alpha}), (α^,α^+δ)(\hat{\alpha},\hat{\alpha}+\delta), and to N(α^)+1\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha})+1 on the other. A transversal point clearly satisfies Hypothesis 4.10.

Proposition 4.13. Let k≥0k\ge0. Assume that there is β2\beta_2 such that N(α)≤k\mathcal{N}(\alpha)\le k for all α≥β2\alpha\ge\beta_2, and that every α^∈G\hat{\alpha}\in\mathcal{G} with N(α^)≤k\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha})\le k is transversal. Then every connected component of UkU_k is a bounded interval (a,b)(a,b) with α+<a<b≤β2\alpha_+<a<b\le\beta_2 and N(a)=N(b)=k\mathcal{N}(a)=\mathcal{N}(b)=k. Moreover,

every α^∈G\hat{\alpha} \in G with N(α^)=k\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha}) = k is an endpoint of exactly one connected component of UkU_k. Consequently, the set of initial heights of the radial solutions of (Pλ)(P_\lambda) that are ground states (if k=0k = 0) or kk-node bound states (if k≥1k \ge1) is either infinite or has an even number of elements.

Proof. Let (a,b)(a,b) be a connected component of UkU_k. As in the proof of Theorem 4.8, we have α+<a<b≤β2\alpha_+ < a < b \le\beta_2, and aa, bb are points of GG with N(a)≤k\mathcal{N}(a) \le k and N(b)≤k\mathcal{N}(b) \le k. The point aa is transversal, and N≥k+1>N(a)\mathcal{N} \ge k+1 > \mathcal{N}(a) on (a,b)(a,b). Hence N=N(a)+1\mathcal{N} = \mathcal{N}(a)+1 on a right neighbourhood of aa, and we obtain N(a)+1≥k+1\mathcal{N}(a)+1 \ge k+1, that is, N(a)=k\mathcal{N}(a) = k. The same argument gives N(b)=k\mathcal{N}(b) = k.

Let now α^∈G\hat{\alpha} \in G with N(α^)=k\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha}) = k. By transversality, N=k\mathcal{N} = k on one side of α^\hat{\alpha} and N=k+1\mathcal{N} = k+1 on the other. Suppose, for instance, that N=k+1\mathcal{N} = k+1 on (α^,α^+δ)(\hat{\alpha},\hat{\alpha}+\delta) and N=k\mathcal{N} = k on (α^−δ,α^)(\hat{\alpha}-\delta,\hat{\alpha}). Then (α^,α^+δ)⊂Uk(\hat{\alpha},\hat{\alpha}+\delta) \subset U_k while α^∉Uk\hat{\alpha} \notin U_k, so α^\hat{\alpha} is the left endpoint of the component containing (α^,α^+δ)(\hat{\alpha},\hat{\alpha}+\delta). On the other hand, α^\hat{\alpha} is not the right endpoint of any component, since (α^−δ,α^)(\hat{\alpha}-\delta,\hat{\alpha}) does not meet UkU_k. The other case is symmetric. Therefore, the map which sends a component (a,b)(a,b) to the pair {a,b}\{a,b\} yields a partition of the set of heights in question into pairs, and the last assertion follows. □

Intersection of ground states

Lemma 4.14. Let UU and WW be two distinct radial ground states of (Pλ)(P_\lambda), both centred at the origin. Then there is r>0r > 0 with U(r)=W(r)U(r) = W(r).

Proof. Two radial solutions of (5) with the same initial height coincide, so we may assume that U(0)<W(0)U(0) < W(0). Suppose, by contradiction, that the graphs do not meet on (0,∞)(0,\infty). Then 0<U<W0 < U < W on [0,∞)[0,\infty). We consider the Wronskian ϖ(r)=r(U′(r)W(r)−U(r)W′(r))\varpi(r) = r(U'(r)W(r) - U(r)W'(r)). Since (rU′)′=−rf(U)(rU')' = -rf(U) and (rW′)′=−rf(W)(rW')' = -rf(W), we have

ϖ′(r)=−rf(U)W+rf(W)U=rUW(f(W)W−f(U)U)>0\varpi'(r) = -rf(U)W + rf(W)U = rUW\left(\frac{f(W)}{W} - \frac{f(U)}{U}\right) > 0

for r>0r > 0, by Lemma 2.3(e). It follows that ϖ\varpi is strictly increasing, with ϖ(0)=0\varpi(0) = 0, so that ϖ(r)≥ϖ(1)>0\varpi(r) \ge\varpi(1) > 0 for all r≥1r \ge1. On the other hand, UU, U′U', WW and W′W' decay exponentially by Proposition 4.3(iv), hence ϖ(r)→0\varpi(r) \to0 as r→∞r \to\infty. This is a contradiction. □

Tang’s reduction in the plane

Remark 4.15. Let v=∂u/∂αv = \partial u/\partial\alpha. If z(α)z(\alpha) is a zero of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha), the implicit function theorem shows that zz depends smoothly on α\alpha, with z′(α)=−v(z,α)/u′(z,α)z'(\alpha) = -v(z,\alpha)/u'(z,\alpha). Tang reduces the uniqueness of bound states to two conditions on vv [76 Lemma 3.1]. In our setting they read as follows, for a given α>α+\alpha> \alpha_+.

(a) If u=u(⋅,α)u = u(\cdot,\alpha) has exactly k≥1k \ge1 zeros z1<⋯<zkz_1 < \cdots< z_k, then vv has exactly kk zeros τ1<⋯<τk\tau_1 < \cdots< \tau_k in [0,zk][0,z_k], with τ1∈(0,z1)\tau_1 \in(0,z_1) and τi∈(zi−1,zi)\tau_i \in(z_{i-1},z_i) for 2≤i≤k2 \le i \le k. Moreover, u′v′>0u'v' > 0 whenever v=0v = 0.

(b) If uu is a ground state, then vv has exactly one zero in (0,∞)(0,\infty). If uu is a kk-node bound state, then vv has exactly one zero in [zk,∞)[z_k,\infty), and it lies beyond the last critical point of uu. In either case, vv is strictly monotone for large rr and ∣v(r)∣→∞|v(r)| \to\infty as r→∞r \to\infty.

For the power nonlinearity in dimension n≥3n \ge3, Tang verifies (a) and (b) in [76 Sections 4 and 5]. This verification uses the structural conditions of Table 3 and, in the transition between phases, identities that are specific to the power nonlinearity [76 Appendix A.4]. By contrast, the deduction of uniqueness from (a) and (b) is robust, as the following proposition shows. Its proof follows the argument of [76 proof of Lemma 3.1], which goes back to McLeod [61].

ConditionPower, n≥3n \ge3ff of (Pλ)(P_\lambda), n=2n=2Justification for ff
(C1)–(C4): sign, primitive, f′(0)<0f'(0)<0, f′>0f'>0 at the zero✓✓Lemma 2.3(a)–(b)
(C5): sign of h=2nF−(n−2)sfh=2nF-(n-2)sf✓✓h=4Fh=4F, Remark 2.4
(C6): sf−2F≥0sf-2F\ge0✓✓Lemma 2.3(c)
(C7): sign of h2=(n+2)f−(n−2)sf′h_2=(n+2)f-(n-2)sf'✓✓h2=4fh_2=4f, Remark 2.4
(C8): f/(sf′)f/(sf') increasing (Serrin–Tang)✓×Lemma 3.1(a)
(C9): f′′>0f''>0 beyond the zero of ff✓✓Lemma 2.3(d)
sf′−f>0sf'-f>0 on (0,∞)(0,\infty)✓✓Lemma 2.3(d)
g1′>0g_1'>0 on (0,∞)(0,\infty)✓× (only on (0,u∗))(0,u_*))Lemma 3.1(b)
Connection identities [76 Appendix A.4]✓not availablespecific to the power case

Table 3. Structural conditions of [76] for the power nonlinearity −u+∣u∣p−1u-u+|u|^{p-1}u in Rn\mathbb{R}^n, n≥3n\ge3, and for the nonlinearity ff of (Pλ)(P_\lambda) in R2\mathbb{R}^2. All conditions are stated after normalising the positive zero of the nonlinearity.

Proposition 4.16.

(i) Let 0<α1<α20 < \alpha_1 < \alpha_2, and assume that condition (a) of Remark 4.15 holds at every α∈[α1,α2]\alpha\in[\alpha_1,\alpha_2]. Then N(α1)≤N(α2)\mathcal{N}(\alpha_1) \le\mathcal{N}(\alpha_2).

(ii) Let α^∈G\widehat{\alpha} \in\mathcal{G}, and assume that conditions (a) and (b) hold at α^\widehat{\alpha}. Then there is δ>0\delta> 0 such that N(β)≥N(α^)+1\mathcal{N}(\beta) \ge\mathcal{N}(\widehat{\alpha}) + 1 for every β∈(α^,α^+δ)\beta\in(\widehat{\alpha},\widehat{\alpha} + \delta).

(iii) Assume that (a) holds at every α>α+\alpha> \alpha_+ and that (b) holds at every α∈G\alpha\in\mathcal{G}. Then (Pλ)(P_\lambda) has at most one radial ground state centred at the origin and, for every k≥1k \ge1, at most one kk-node radial bound state positive at the origin.

Proof. We first show that (a) at α\alpha implies u′v>0u'v > 0 at every zero of u=u(⋅,α)u = u(\cdot,\alpha). The zeros of vv are simple. Indeed, v(τ)=v′(τ)=0v(\tau) = v'(\tau) = 0 at some τ>0\tau> 0 would force v≡0v \equiv0 by uniqueness for the linear equation of vv, which contradicts v(0)=1v(0) = 1. Hence vv changes sign at each τi\tau_i, and vv has the sign (−1)i(-1)^i on (τi,τi+1)∩[0,zk](\tau_i,\tau_{i+1}) \cap[0,z_k], where τ0=0\tau_0 = 0 and τk+1=∞\tau_{k+1} = \infty. Since zi∈(τi,τi+1)z_i \in(\tau_i,\tau_{i+1}), we get that v(zi)v(z_i) has the sign (−1)i(-1)^i. On the other hand, u>0u > 0 on [0,z1)[0,z_1), the zeros of uu are simple, and therefore u′(zi)u'(z_i) also has the sign (−1)i(-1)^i. We conclude that u′v>0u'v > 0 at each ziz_i.

(i) We may assume that m=N(α1)≥1m = \mathcal{N}(\alpha_1) \ge1. Let z1<⋯<zmz_1 < \cdots< z_m be the zeros of u(⋅,α1)u(\cdot,\alpha_1). By continuity of uu on [0,1]×[α1,α2][0,1] \times[\alpha_1,\alpha_2] and u(0,α)=α≥α1u(0,\alpha) = \alpha\ge\alpha_1, there is r0>0r_0 > 0 such that u(r,α)>0u(r,\alpha) > 0 for r∈[0,r0]r \in[0,r_0] and α∈[α1,α2]\alpha\in[\alpha_1,\alpha_2]. By the implicit function theorem, each zjz_j is the starting point of a C1C^1 curve α↦ζj(α)\alpha\mapsto\zeta_j(\alpha) of zeros of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha), with ζj′=−v/u′<0\zeta_j' = -v/u' < 0 by the first step. Let α♯\alpha^\sharp be the supremum of those β∈[α1,α2]\beta\in[\alpha_1,\alpha_2] such that the mm curves are defined on [α1,β][\alpha_1,\beta]. Each ζj\zeta_j is decreasing and takes values in [r0,zj][r_0,z_j], so it has a limit as α↑α♯\alpha\uparrow\alpha^\sharp, which is a zero of u(⋅,α♯)u(\cdot,\alpha^\sharp) by continuity. These limits are distinct. Indeed, near a simple zero of u(⋅,α♯)u(\cdot,\alpha^\sharp) the zero set of uu is a single C1C^1 curve, so two of the curves cannot converge to the same point. If α♯<α2\alpha^\sharp< \alpha_2, the implicit function theorem extends the curves beyond α♯\alpha^\sharp, which contradicts the definition of α♯\alpha^\sharp. Hence the curves are defined on [α1,α2][\alpha_1,\alpha_2], and u(⋅,α2)u(\cdot,\alpha_2) has at least mm zeros.

(ii) Let j=N(α^)j = \mathcal{N}(\widehat{\alpha}), u^=u(⋅,α^)\widehat{u} = u(\cdot,\widehat{\alpha}) and v^=v(⋅,α^)\widehat{v} = v(\cdot,\widehat{\alpha}). We assume that jj is odd; the case of even jj, including j=0j = 0, follows by reflection. Then u^<0\widehat{u} < 0 eventually, and u^\widehat{u} increases to 00 beyond its last critical point. By (a) and (b), v^\widehat{v} has exactly j+1j + 1 zeros, all simple, so that v^>0\widehat{v} > 0 eventually. Since v^\widehat{v} is eventually monotone and ∣v^∣→∞|\widehat{v}| \to\infty, we deduce that v^,v^′>0\widehat{v},\widehat{v}' > 0 for large rr. Let s0>0s_0 > 0 be such that f′<0f' < 0 on (−s0,s0)(-s_0,s_0), which is possible since f′(0)<0f'(0) < 0. We fix rˉ\bar{r} beyond the last zero and the last critical point of u^\widehat{u}, such that v^(rˉ)>0\widehat{v}(\bar{r}) > 0, v^′(rˉ)>0\widehat{v}'(\bar{r}) > 0 and ∣u^∣<s0|\widehat{u}| < s_0 on [rˉ,∞)[\bar{r},\infty). Let β>α^\beta> \widehat{\alpha}, let uβ=u(⋅,β)u_\beta= u(\cdot,\beta) and w=uβ−u^w = u_\beta- \widehat{u}. Since

w(rˉ)=∫α^βv(rˉ,s) dsw(\bar{r}) = \int_{\widehat{\alpha}}^\beta v(\bar{r},s)\,ds

and

w′(rˉ)=∫α^βv′(rˉ,s) ds,w'(\bar{r}) = \int_{\widehat{\alpha}}^\beta v'(\bar{r},s)\,ds,

the continuity of vv and v′v' gives w(rˉ)>0w(\bar{r}) > 0 and w′(rˉ)>0w'(\bar{r}) > 0 for β\beta close to α^\widehat{\alpha}. Arguing as in the proof of Lemma 4.5(b), we also see that uβu_\beta has exactly jj zeros in (0,rˉ)(0,\bar{r}) and uβ(rˉ)<0u_\beta(\bar{r}) < 0 for such β\beta. Suppose that uβu_\beta has no zero in (rˉ,∞)(\bar{r},\infty). If β∈G\beta\in\mathcal{G}, then w(r)→0w(r) \to0 as r→∞r \to\infty. Otherwise, uβu_\beta is oscillatory and negative on (rˉ,∞)(\bar{r},\infty), so it oscillates about −u1-u_1 by Proposition 4.3(iv), and it takes values below −u1-u_1 at arbitrarily large radii, while u^(r)→0\widehat{u}(r) \to0. In this case, ww takes negative values at arbitrarily large radii. In both cases, since w(rˉ)>0w(\bar{r}) > 0 and w′(rˉ)>0w'(\bar{r}) > 0, the function ww attains a positive local maximum at some rˉ>rˉ\bar{r} > \bar{r}, where w′(rˉ)=0w'(\bar{r}) = 0 and w′′(rˉ)≤0w''(\bar{r}) \le0. Now ww solves

w′′+1rw′+c(r)w=0,c(r)=∫01f′(u^(r)+θw(r)) dθ.w'' + \frac{1}{r}w' + c(r)w = 0, \qquad c(r) = \int_0^1 f'\bigl(\widehat{u}(r) + \theta w(r)\bigr)\,d\theta.

At r^\hat r we have u^(r^)<u~(r^)+θw(r^)≤uβ(r^)<0\hat u(\hat r)<\tilde u(\hat r)+\theta w(\hat r)\le u_\beta(\hat r)<0 and ∣u^(r^)∣<s0|\hat u(\hat r)|<s_0, so that c(r^)<0c(\hat r)<0. We infer that w′′(r^)=−c(r^)w(r^)>0w''(\hat r)=-c(\hat r)w(\hat r)>0, a contradiction. Hence uβu_\beta has a zero in (rˉ,∞)(\bar r,\infty), and N(β)≥j+1\mathcal{N}(\beta)\ge j+1.

(iii) Suppose that α^<α^′\hat\alpha<\hat\alpha' are two points of G\mathcal{G} with N(α^)=N(α^′)=k\mathcal{N}(\hat\alpha)=\mathcal{N}(\hat\alpha')=k. By (ii), there is β∈(α^,α^′)\beta\in(\hat\alpha,\hat\alpha') with N(β)≥k+1\mathcal{N}(\beta)\ge k+1. By (i), applied on [β,α^′]⊂(α+,∞)[\beta,\hat\alpha']\subset(\alpha_+,\infty), we get N(α^′)≥N(β)≥k+1\mathcal{N}(\hat\alpha')\ge\mathcal{N}(\beta)\ge k+1, a contradiction. □

Corollary 4.17. Under the assumptions of Theorem 4.8, let (a,b)(a,b) be the interval given there. Then, for every δ∈(0,b−a)\delta\in(0,b-a), condition (a) of Remark 4.15 fails at some α∈[b−δ,b]\alpha\in[b-\delta,b].

Proof. We have N(b−δ)≥k+1>k≥N(b)\mathcal{N}(b-\delta)\ge k+1>k\ge\mathcal{N}(b), and Proposition 4.16(i) applies on [b−δ,b][b-\delta,b]. □

In particular, if (Pλ)(P_\lambda) has two distinct kk-node bound states for some k≥1k\ge1, then Tang’s conditions cannot hold for all initial heights. The mechanism is illustrated in Figure 2.

Figure 2. Schematic graph of N\mathcal{N} for λ\lambda close to 1, as predicted by Conjectures 6.2 and 6.4; it is not computed. Filled dots are the values of N\mathcal{N} at points of G\mathcal{G}. The endpoints of each component of UkU_k are radial solutions with at most kk nodes (Theorem 4.8), here kk-node bound states, so that bound states come in nested pairs αk−<αk+\alpha_k^-<\alpha_k^+. Tang’s conditions force N\mathcal{N} to be non-decreasing, and therefore they must fail near α1+\alpha_1^+ and α2+\alpha_2^+ (Corollary 4.17).

Bubbling as the initial height tends to infinity

In this section, we describe the behaviour of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) as α→∞\alpha\to\infty. Lemmas 5.1 and 5.2 are rigorous, while the matched asymptotics built on them in Subsections 5.3 and 5.4 are formal and are labelled as such.

The rescaled equation

Let α>0\alpha>0, and define the scale εα\varepsilon_\alpha and the rescaled function wαw_\alpha by

εα=(2λα2eα2)−1/2,u(εαs,α)=α+wα(s)2α.\varepsilon_\alpha=\left(2\lambda\alpha^2e^{\alpha^2}\right)^{-1/2},\qquad u(\varepsilon_\alpha s,\alpha)=\alpha+\frac{w_\alpha(s)}{2\alpha}.

Then u2=α2+wα+wα2/(4α2)u^2=\alpha^2+w_\alpha+w_\alpha^2/(4\alpha^2). Since 2α2εα2=λ−1e−α22\alpha^2\varepsilon_\alpha^2=\lambda^{-1}e^{-\alpha^2}, a direct computation shows that (5) becomes

−Δswα=(1+wα2α2)(ewα+wα2/(4α2)−e−α2λ),wα(0)=0,wα′(0)=0.(7)-\Delta_s w_\alpha=\left(1+\frac{w_\alpha}{2\alpha^2}\right)\left(e^{w_\alpha+w_\alpha^2/(4\alpha^2)}-\frac{e^{-\alpha^2}}{\lambda}\right),\qquad w_\alpha(0)=0,\quad w_\alpha'(0)=0. \tag*{(7)}

The linear term −u-u of the original equation contributes only the term of order e−α2e^{-\alpha^{2}}. Expanding the right-hand side of (7) in powers of α−2\alpha^{-2}, we are led to the expansion wα=w0+α−2w1+o(α−2)w_{\alpha}=w_{0}+\alpha^{-2}w_{1}+o(\alpha^{-2}), which is justified on compact sets in Lemma 5.2 below. Here

−Δw0=ew0,−Δw1−ew0w1=ew0(w024+w02).-\Delta w_{0}=e^{w_{0}}, \qquad-\Delta w_{1}-e^{w_{0}}w_{1}=e^{w_{0}}\left(\frac{w_{0}^{2}}{4}+\frac{w_{0}}{2}\right).

with zero initial data at s=0s=0. The first equation gives w0(s)=−2log⁡(1+s2/8)w_{0}(s)=-2\log(1+s^{2}/8). This is the radial solution of the Liouville equation −Δw=ew-\Delta w=e^{w} with w(0)=0w(0)=0, and it satisfies ∫R2ew0=8π\int_{\mathbb{R}^{2}}e^{w_{0}}=8\pi. All solutions of the Liouville equation with ew∈L1(R2)e^{w}\in L^{1}(\mathbb{R}^{2}) were classified by Chen and Li [27]. We refer to Brezis and Merle [22] for the general blow-up theory of Liouville-type equations, and to [4, 36, 58, 59, 38] for bubbling at Trudinger–Moser criticality.

The second-order correction

The asymptotic flux lim⁡s→∞sw′(s)\lim_{s\to\infty}sw'(s) of the profile governs the behaviour of uu in the neck region. For w0w_{0} it equals −4-4, by the explicit formula. The next lemma computes exactly the correction of order α−2\alpha^{-2}.

Lemma 5.1. Let w0(s)=−2log⁡(1+s2/8)w_{0}(s)=-2\log(1+s^{2}/8) and let w1w_{1} be the solution of

w1′′+1sw1′+ew0w1=−ew0(w024+w02),s>0,w1(0)=w1′(0)=0.(8)w_{1}''+\frac{1}{s}w_{1}'+e^{w_{0}}w_{1}=-e^{w_{0}}\left(\frac{w_{0}^{2}}{4}+\frac{w_{0}}{2}\right), \qquad s>0, \qquad w_{1}(0)=w_{1}'(0)=0. \tag*{(8)}

Then w1(s)=O(log⁡s)w_{1}(s)=O(\log s) as s→∞s\to\infty, and lim⁡s→∞sw1′(s)=−4\lim_{s\to\infty}sw_{1}'(s)=-4.

Proof. We set g=ew0(w02/4+w0/2)g=e^{w_{0}}(w_{0}^{2}/4+w_{0}/2) and t=s2/8t=s^{2}/8, so that ew0=(1+t)−2e^{w_{0}}=(1+t)^{-2} and g=(1+t)−2(ℓ2−ℓ)g=(1+t)^{-2}(\ell^{2}-\ell) with ℓ=log⁡(1+t)\ell=\log(1+t). Equation (8) is linear with smooth coefficients, and its regular singular point at s=0s=0 is handled exactly as in (5). Hence it has a unique global solution. In the variable τ=log⁡s\tau=\log s, the function y(τ)=w1(eτ)y(\tau)=w_{1}(e^{\tau}) satisfies y′′=−e2τ(ew0y+g)y''=-e^{2\tau}(e^{w_{0}}y+g). For τ≥0\tau\geq0 we have e2τew0≤64e−2τe^{2\tau}e^{w_{0}}\leq64e^{-2\tau} and e2τ∣g∣≤C(1+τ2)e−2τe^{2\tau}|g|\leq C(1+\tau^{2})e^{-2\tau}. Integrating twice, we obtain for τ≥0\tau\geq0

∣y(τ)∣≤∣y(0)∣+τ∣y′(0)∣+∫0τ(τ−σ)(64e−2σ∣y(σ)∣+C(1+σ2)e−2σ) dσ.|y(\tau)|\leq|y(0)|+\tau|y'(0)|+\int_{0}^{\tau}(\tau-\sigma)\left(64e^{-2\sigma}|y(\sigma)|+C(1+\sigma^{2})e^{-2\sigma}\right)\,d\sigma.

Since (τ−σ)/(1+τ)≤1(\tau-\sigma)/(1+\tau)\leq1 for 0≤σ≤τ0\leq\sigma\leq\tau, the function q(τ)=∣y(τ)∣/(1+τ)q(\tau)=|y(\tau)|/(1+\tau) satisfies q(τ)≤C′+∫0τ64(1+σ)e−2σq(σ) dσq(\tau)\leq C'+\int_{0}^{\tau}64(1+\sigma)e^{-2\sigma}q(\sigma)\,d\sigma. By Gronwall’s lemma, qq is bounded, that is, w1(s)=O(log⁡s)w_{1}(s)=O(\log s). We infer that y′′y'' is integrable on (0,∞)(0,\infty), and therefore m1=lim⁡s→∞sw1′(s)=lim⁡τ→∞y′(τ)m_{1}=\lim_{s\to\infty}sw_{1}'(s)=\lim_{\tau\to\infty}y'(\tau) exists.

To compute m1m_{1}, we use the function φ0=2+sw0′(s)=2(8−s2)/(8+s2)\varphi_{0}=2+sw_{0}'(s)=2(8-s^{2})/(8+s^{2}). It is the derivative at μ=1\mu=1 of the family w0(μs)+2log⁡μw_{0}(\mu s)+2\log\mu of solutions of the Liouville equation, hence φ0′′+φ0′/s+ew0φ0=0\varphi_{0}''+\varphi_{0}'/s+e^{w_{0}}\varphi_{0}=0. We multiply (8) by sφ0s\varphi_{0}, subtract the equation of φ0\varphi_{0} multiplied by sw1sw_{1}, and integrate over (0,S)(0,S). We get

S(φ0(S)w1′(S)−w1(S)φ0′(S))=−∫0Ssφ0(s)g(s) ds.S\left(\varphi_{0}(S)w_{1}'(S)-w_{1}(S)\varphi_{0}'(S)\right)=-\int_{0}^{S}s\varphi_{0}(s)g(s)\,ds.

As S→∞S\to\infty, we have φ0(S)→−2\varphi_{0}(S)\to-2, Sφ0′(S)=O(S−2)S\varphi_{0}'(S)=O(S^{-2}) and w1(S)=O(log⁡S)w_{1}(S)=O(\log S). Passing to the limit, we deduce that −2m1=−∫0∞sφ0g ds-2m_{1}=-\int_{0}^{\infty}s\varphi_{0}g\,ds. In the variable tt, we have s ds=4 dts\,ds=4\,dt and φ0=2(1−t)/(1+t)\varphi_{0}=2(1-t)/(1+t), so that

m1=12∫0∞sφ0g ds=4∫0∞1−t(1+t)3(ℓ2−ℓ) dt=4∫1∞2−xx3(log⁡2x−log⁡x) dx.m_{1}=\frac{1}{2}\int_{0}^{\infty}s\varphi_{0}g\,ds=4\int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{1-t}{(1+t)^{3}}(\ell^{2}-\ell)\,dt=4\int_{1}^{\infty}\frac{2-x}{x^{3}}(\log^{2}x-\log x)\,dx.

Using ∫1∞x−klog⁡jx dx=j!/(k−1)j+1\int_1^\infty x^{-k}\log^j x\,dx=j!/(k-1)^{j+1} for k>1k>1, we find

∫1∞2−xx3log⁡2x dx=12−2=−32,∫1∞2−xx3log⁡x dx=12−1=−12.\int_1^\infty\frac{2-x}{x^3}\log^2 x\,dx=\frac{1}{2}-2=-\frac{3}{2},\qquad\int_1^\infty\frac{2-x}{x^3}\log x\,dx=\frac{1}{2}-1=-\frac{1}{2}.

We conclude that m1=4(−32+12)=−4m_1=4\left(-\frac{3}{2}+\frac{1}{2}\right)=-4.

The expansion of wαw_\alpha is rigorous on compact sets of the core variable.

Lemma 5.2. Let S>0S>0. There is αS>0\alpha_S>0 such that, for every α≥αS\alpha\geq\alpha_S, the solution u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) is positive on [0,Sεα][0,S\varepsilon_\alpha]. Moreover, as α→∞\alpha\to\infty,

wα=w0+α−2w1+o(α−2)in C1([0,S]).w_\alpha=w_0+\alpha^{-2}w_1+o(\alpha^{-2})\qquad\text{in }C^1([0,S]).

In particular, z1(α)/εα→∞z_1(\alpha)/\varepsilon_\alpha\to\infty as α→∞\alpha\to\infty for the first zero z1(α)z_1(\alpha) of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha), whenever it exists.

Proof. We set η=α−2\eta=\alpha^{-2} and, for w∈Rw\in\mathbb{R} and η≥0\eta\geq0,

G(w,η)=(1+ηw2)(ew+ηw2/4−e−1/ηλ)(η>0),G(w,0)=ew.G(w,\eta)=\left(1+\frac{\eta w}{2}\right)\left(e^{w+\eta w^2/4}-\frac{e^{-1/\eta}}{\lambda}\right)\quad(\eta>0),\qquad G(w,0)=e^w.

For η<0\eta<0 we set G(w,η)=(1+ηw/2)ew+ηw2/4G(w,\eta)=(1+\eta w/2)e^{w+\eta w^2/4}. Since η↦e−1/η\eta\mapsto e^{-1/\eta}, extended by zero for η≤0\eta\leq0, is smooth on R\mathbb{R} with all derivatives vanishing at 00, the function GG is of class C1C^1 on R2\mathbb{R}^2. Moreover, Gw(w,0)=ewG_w(w,0)=e^w and Gη(w,0)=ew(w/2+w2/4)G_\eta(w,0)=e^w(w/2+w^2/4). Let X=C([0,S])X=C([0,S]) and let K\mathcal{K} be the Volterra operator (Kh)(s)=∫0sτlog⁡(s/τ)h(τ) dτ(\mathcal{K}h)(s)=\int_0^s\tau\log(s/\tau)h(\tau)\,d\tau, whose kernel is bounded on {0≤τ≤s≤S}\{0\leq\tau\leq s\leq S\}. By (7), wαw_\alpha is the unique solution in XX of Φ(W,α−2)=0\Phi(W,\alpha^{-2})=0, where

Φ(W,η)=W+K(G(W,η)),(W,η)∈X×R.\Phi(W,\eta)=W+\mathcal{K}(G(W,\eta)),\qquad(W,\eta)\in X\times\mathbb{R}.

Uniqueness holds because GG is locally Lipschitz and K\mathcal{K} has a bounded kernel, so that Gronwall’s lemma applies. The map Φ\Phi is of class C1C^1, since GG is, and Φ(w0,0)=0\Phi(w_0,0)=0. Its partial differential DWΦ(w0,0)=I+K(ew0⋅)D_W\Phi(w_0,0)=I+\mathcal{K}(e^{w_0}\cdot) is the identity plus a Volterra operator with bounded kernel, hence it is invertible on XX. By the implicit function theorem, there are η0>0\eta_0>0 and a C1C^1 map η↦W(⋅,η)∈X\eta\mapsto W(\cdot,\eta)\in X on (−η0,η0)(-\eta_0,\eta_0) with W(⋅,0)=w0W(\cdot,0)=w_0 and Φ(W(⋅,η),η)=0\Phi(W(\cdot,\eta),\eta)=0. By uniqueness, wα=W(⋅,α−2)w_\alpha=W(\cdot,\alpha^{-2}) on [0,S][0,S] for α−2<η0\alpha^{-2}<\eta_0. Differentiating Φ(W(⋅,η),η)=0\Phi(W(\cdot,\eta),\eta)=0 at η=0\eta=0, we find that Y=∂ηW(⋅,0)Y=\partial_\eta W(\cdot,0) solves Y+K(ew0Y+ew0(w0/2+w02/4))=0Y+\mathcal{K}(e^{w_0}Y+e^{w_0}(w_0/2+w_0^2/4))=0, which is the integral form of (8). Hence Y=w1Y=w_1, and wα=w0+α−2w1+o(α−2)w_\alpha=w_0+\alpha^{-2}w_1+o(\alpha^{-2}) in XX. Finally, W′(s)=−s−1∫0sτG(W(τ),η) dτW'(s)=-s^{-1}\int_0^s\tau G(W(\tau),\eta)\,d\tau, and the map h↦s−1∫0sτh dτh\mapsto s^{-1}\int_0^s\tau h\,d\tau is bounded on XX. We conclude that the expansion also holds in C1([0,S])C^1([0,S]). In particular, ∣wα∣≤CS|w_\alpha|\leq C_S on [0,S][0,S] for α\alpha large, so that u(εαs,α)≥α−CS/(2α)>0u(\varepsilon_\alpha s,\alpha)\geq\alpha-C_S/(2\alpha)>0 for s∈[0,S]s\in[0,S] and α\alpha large. Since SS is arbitrary, it follows that z1(α)/εα→∞z_1(\alpha)/\varepsilon_\alpha\to\infty. □\square

Formal asymptotics of the first zero

The arguments of this subsection and of the next one are formal. By Lemmas 5.1 and 5.2, the expected asymptotic flux of wαw_\alpha is −4−4α−2+O(α−4)-4-4\alpha^{-2}+O(\alpha^{-4}). In terms of uu, this means that ru′(r)=−2α(1+α−2+O(α−4))ru'(r)=-\frac{2}{\alpha}(1+\alpha^{-2}+O(\alpha^{-4})) in the neck region εα≪r≪α−1\varepsilon_\alpha\ll r\ll\alpha^{-1}. In this region, the right-hand side of (7), multiplied by s2s^2, is of order exp⁡{−2log⁡s(1−2log⁡s/α2)}\exp\{-2\log s(1-2\log s/\alpha^2)\}. It is therefore exponentially small in the interior of the neck, whose length in the variable log⁡r\log r is close to α2/2\alpha^2/2, so that the flux is essentially conserved there. The function uu is then almost harmonic in log⁡r\log r. We use log⁡(1/εα)=α22+12log⁡(2λα2)\log(1/\varepsilon_\alpha)=\frac{\alpha^2}{2}+\frac{1}{2}\log(2\lambda\alpha^2) together with w0(s)=−4log⁡s+2log⁡8+o(1)w_0(s)=-4\log s+2\log8+o(1), and we obtain

u(r,α)=1α(−2log⁡r−log⁡(2λα2)+log⁡8−1)+o(α−1)u(r,\alpha)=\frac{1}{\alpha}\left(-2\log r-\log(2\lambda\alpha^2)+\log8-1\right)+o(\alpha^{-1})

up to rr of order α−1\alpha^{-1}. The constant −1-1 comes from the product of the correction −4α−2-4\alpha^{-2} of the flux with the length α2/2\alpha^2/2 of the neck. Without this correction, one would obtain the leading-order prediction z1≈8/(α2λ)z_1 \approx\sqrt{8}/(\alpha\sqrt{2\lambda}). The linear term of the equation modifies the flux by a relative amount O(α−2log⁡α)O(\alpha^{-2}\log\alpha) only, over a range of log⁡r\log r of length O(1)O(1). Taking the correction into account, we are led to

lim⁡α→∞α2λ z1(α)=8e−1/2,(9)\lim_{\alpha\to\infty}\alpha\sqrt{2\lambda}\,z_1(\alpha)=\sqrt{8}e^{-1/2}, \tag*{(9)}

independently of λ∈(0,1)\lambda\in(0,1).

A formal mechanism for a bounded zero count

Beyond the first zero, in the range z1≪r≪1z_1\ll r\ll1, the formal expansion above gives u(r)≈−2αlog⁡(r/z1)u(r)\approx-\frac{2}{\alpha}\log(r/z_1) and u′(r)≈−2αru'(r)\approx-\frac{2}{\alpha r}, while F(u)=−ζ2u2+O(u4)F(u)=-\frac{\zeta}{2}u^2+O(u^4). Hence

E(r)≈2α2(1r2−ζlog⁡2rz1).E(r)\approx\frac{2}{\alpha^2}\left(\frac{1}{r^2}-\zeta\log^2\frac{r}{z_1}\right).

The energy therefore vanishes at a radius rαr_\alpha with rαζlog⁡(rα/z1)=1r_\alpha\sqrt{\zeta}\log(r_\alpha/z_1)=1, that is, rα∼(ζlog⁡α)−1r_\alpha\sim(\sqrt{\zeta}\log\alpha)^{-1}. This is consistent with the approximations used, provided that ζlog⁡α≫1\sqrt{\zeta}\log\alpha\gg1. Indeed, ∣u(rα)∣\lvert u(r_\alpha)\rvert is then of order α−1log⁡α\alpha^{-1}\log\alpha, and the contribution of the linear term to the flux on (z1,rα)(z_1,r_\alpha) is of relative order (log⁡α)−1(\log\alpha)^{-1}. Since EE is decreasing and positive at every zero, the solution has no zero beyond rαr_\alpha. This suggests that N(α)=1N(\alpha)=1 for all sufficiently large α\alpha, for every λ∈(0,1)\lambda\in(0,1). It also suggests that the large-height regime sets in only when log⁡α≫(1−λ)−1/2\log\alpha\gg(1-\lambda)^{-1/2}, which leaves room for many oscillations at moderate heights when λ\lambda is close to 11.

The three regions involved in this description are sketched in Figure 3.

Figure 3. Schematic structure of u(r,α)u(r,\alpha) for large α\alpha, plotted against log⁡r\log r (not to scale). In the core r≲εαr\lesssim\varepsilon_\alpha, the solution is a Liouville bubble (Lemmas 5.1 and 5.2, rigorous). In the neck, uu is almost linear in log⁡r\log r with the slope indicated, and it vanishes for the first time near z1≈8e−1/2/(α2λ)z_1\approx\sqrt{8}e^{-1/2}/(\alpha\sqrt{2\lambda}). Beyond rα∼(ζlog⁡α)−1r_\alpha\sim(\sqrt{\zeta}\log\alpha)^{-1}, the energy is negative, no further zero can occur, and the solution eventually oscillates about −u1-u_1 (Proposition 4.3(iv)). The neck and transition regions are described only formally.

Conjectures

The following statements are not proved. They are motivated by the results of Sections 4 and 5, by the analogy with the Dirichlet problem in a disc discussed in the introduction and, for Conjectures 6.3 and 6.4, by numerical experiments that are not reported here.

Conjecture 6.1 (Ground state). For every λ∈(0,1)\lambda\in(0,1), equation (Pλ)(P_\lambda) has exactly one positive solution up to translation, and this solution is nondegenerate: the kernel in L2(R2)L^2(\mathbb{R}^2) of the linearised operator Δ+f′(u)=Δ−1+λeu2(1+2u2)\Delta+ f'(u) = \Delta- 1 + \lambda e^{u^2}(1 + 2u^2) is spanned by ∂1u\partial_1u and ∂2u\partial_2u.

Conjecture 6.2 (Large heights). For every λ∈(0,1)\lambda\in(0,1), one has N(α)=1\mathcal{N}(\alpha) = 1 for all sufficiently large α\alpha. Moreover, (9) holds.

Conjecture 6.3 (Threshold). There is λc∈(0,1)\lambda_c \in(0,1) such that (Pλ)(P_\lambda) has no radial sign-changing solution in H1(R2)H^1(\mathbb{R}^2) when 0<λ≤λc0 < \lambda\le\lambda_c, and has radial bound states when λc<λ<1\lambda_c < \lambda< 1. Moreover, the maximal number of nodes of a radial bound state tends to infinity as λ→1\lambda\to1.

Conjecture 6.4 (Failure of the Berestycki–Lions uniqueness). Let λc<λ<1\lambda_c < \lambda< 1 and k≥1k \ge1. The number of kk-node radial bound states of (Pλ)(P_\lambda) that are positive at the origin is even (possibly zero), and all of them are nondegenerate. More precisely, their initial heights form nested pairs αk−<αk+\alpha_k^- < \alpha_k^+: the zero count N\mathcal{N} jumps from kk to k+1k+1 at αk−\alpha_k^- and from k+1k+1 to kk at αk+\alpha_k^+. Tang’s conditions (a) and (b) of Remark 4.15 hold at αk−\alpha_k^-. In particular, the uniqueness of kk-node bound states fails whenever they exist.

Several parts of Conjecture 6.4 reduce to the other conjectures and to the rigorous results of § 4. First, Conjecture 6.2 gives N∞=1≤k\mathcal{N}_\infty= 1 \le k. Hence, by Corollaries 4.9 and 4.11, the existence of two kk-node bound states would follow from Conjecture 6.2, Hypothesis 4.10 and the existence of a height β1\beta_1 with N(β1)≥k+1\mathcal{N}(\beta_1) \ge k+1. Second, by Proposition 4.13, the parity statement would follow from Conjecture 6.2 and the transversality of every point α^∈G\hat{\alpha} \in\mathcal{G} with N(α^)≤k\mathcal{N}(\hat{\alpha}) \le k. We expect transversality to follow from the nondegeneracy of all bound states, but this implication has not been proved. Third, if the structure described in Conjecture 6.4 holds, then N=k\mathcal{N} = k on a right neighbourhood of αk+\alpha_k^+. By Proposition 4.16(ii), conditions (a) and (b) cannot both hold at αk+\alpha_k^+.

Towards proofs

Large heights

The core of the programme is Conjecture 6.2. The tools are the blow-up analysis for Trudinger–Moser critical equations [4, 36, 58, 59, 38], the classification of the limiting Liouville profile [27] and the quantisation of the blow-up mass [22, 36]. One has to establish a precise expansion of u(⋅,α)u(\cdot,\alpha) in three regions. The first is the core r≲εαr \lesssim\varepsilon_\alpha, where Lemma 5.2 already gives the expansion on compact sets of the rescaled variable. The second is the neck εα≪r≲α−1\varepsilon_\alpha\ll r \lesssim\alpha^{-1}, where the solution is almost harmonic in log⁡r\log r. The third is the region α−1≲r≲(log⁡α)−1\alpha^{-1} \lesssim r \lesssim(\log\alpha)^{-1}, where the solution is small and the energy changes sign. The expansion must be accurate enough to show that E(rα)<0E(r_\alpha) < 0 at a radius rαr_\alpha beyond the first zero, as in the formal argument of § 5. Lemma 5.1 identifies the second-order term of the core expansion, and the factor e−1/2e^{-1/2} in (9) is a useful test of any such expansion. Once Conjecture 6.2 is known, Corollary 4.9 produces, for every λ\lambda with Nmax⁡≥2N_{\max} \ge2, two distinct radial solutions with at most one node.

Finite heights and validated numerics

The remaining hypothesis of Theorem 4.8, namely the existence of β1\beta_1 with N(β1)≥k+1\mathcal{N}(\beta_1) \ge k + 1, concerns a single solution on a compact interval. It is therefore accessible to rigorous computer-assisted proofs in the spirit of Cohen, Li and Schlag [29]. Indeed, it suffices to enclose u(⋅,β1)u(\cdot,\beta_1) on an interval [0,R][0,R] containing k+1k + 1 zeros. Combined with a proof of Conjecture 6.2, this would give, for the corresponding value of λ\lambda, a rigorous proof that (Pλ)(P_\lambda) has two distinct radial solutions with at most kk nodes. Under Hypothesis 4.10, these would be two distinct kk-node bound states.

Uniqueness of the ground state

Lemma 3.1 rules out a direct use of the Serrin–Tang criterion and of Tang’s first-phase lemma, and two features of the problem suggest a hybrid strategy. In the core, where the exponential growth dominates, the change of variables r=2e−t/2r = 2e^{-t/2} transforms the radial equation u′′+u′/r+f(u)=0u'' + u'/r + f(u) = 0 into utt+e−tf(u)=0u_{tt} + e^{-t}f(u) = 0. This is the Emden–Fowler form used by Atkinson and Peletier [11, 12], on which the uniqueness proofs of Adimurthi [3] and Tarsi [77] for the Dirichlet problem in a disc are based. Lemma 4.14 is the whole-plane version of the first step of an intersection argument. A natural next step would be to show that two ground states intersect exactly once, and that a suitable comparison quantity is monotone beyond the intersection point, in the spirit of the separation method of Peletier and Serrin [67]. In the tail, where f(s)=−(1−λ)s+O(s3)f(s) = -(1-\lambda)s + O(s^3), the variation analysis of [76] is a natural candidate. Matching the two regimes is the main difficulty, and we have not attempted it.

Further questions

The same questions arise for general nonlinearities with critical exponential growth satisfying the hypotheses of [34, 8, 71], for the nonlinearity (e4πu2−1−4πu2)u(e^{4\pi u^2} - 1 - 4\pi u^2)u of [35] (see Remark 2.2), for the NN-Laplacian in RN\mathbb{R}^N, and for the biharmonic equation in R4\mathbb{R}^4 with critical growth in the sense of Adams [70, 72]. Once the stationary picture is established, the dispersive consequences become natural directions of research. Examples are the orbital instability of the bound states and the role of a second 1-node bound state in the dynamics above the ground-state threshold of [35].

Declarations

Funding. This research received no funding.

Conflict of interest. The author declares no conflict of interest.

Data availability. Data sharing is not applicable to this article, as no datasets were generated or analysed.

References

Basic and Applied Scientific Research Center, Imam Abdulrahman Bin Faisal University, P.O. Box 1982, Dammam 31441, Saudi Arabia

Email address: [email protected]

Email address: [email protected]

Email address: [email protected]

URL: https://orcid.org/0000-0001-6038-1069

References

  1. [1]S. Adachi and K. Tanaka, Trudinger type inequalities in ℝ^N and their best exponents, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 128 (2000), 2051–2057.
  2. [2]Adimurthi, Existence of positive solutions of the semilinear Dirichlet problem with critical growth for the n-Laplacian, Ann. Sc. Norm. Super. Pisa Cl. Sci. (4) 17 (1990), 393–413.
  3. [3]Adimurthi, Uniqueness of positive solutions of a quasilinear Dirichlet problem with exponential nonlinearity, Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh Sect. A 128 (1998), 895–906.DOI
  4. [4]Adimurthi and M. Struwe, Global compactness properties of semilinear elliptic equations with critical exponential growth, J. Funct. Anal. 175 (2000), 125–167.DOI
  5. [5]Adimurthi and S. L. Yadava, Multiplicity results for semilinear elliptic equations in a bounded domain of ℝ² involving critical exponents, Ann. Sc. Norm. Super. Pisa Cl. Sci. (4) 17 (1990), 481–504.
  6. [6]Adimurthi and S. L. Yadava, Nonexistence of nodal solutions of elliptic equations with critical growth in ℝ², Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 332 (1992), 449–458.
  7. [7]C. O. Alves and D. S. Pereira, Existence and nonexistence of least energy nodal solution for a class of elliptic problem in ℝ², Topol. Methods Nonlinear Anal. 46 (2015), 867–892.arxiv.org/abs/1404.7649
  8. [8]C. O. Alves, M. Montenegro and M. A. S. Souto, Existence of a ground state solution for a nonlinear scalar field equation with critical growth, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 43 (2012), 537–554.DOI
  9. [9]W. Ao, J. Wei and W. Yao, Uniqueness and nondegeneracy of sign-changing radial solutions to an almost critical elliptic problem, Adv. Differential Equations 21 (2016), 1049–1084.arxiv.org/abs/1510.04678
  10. [10]F. V. Atkinson, H. Brezis and L. A. Peletier, Nodal solutions of elliptic equations with critical Sobolev exponents, J. Differential Equations 85 (1990), 151–170.DOI
  11. [11]F. V. Atkinson and L. A. Peletier, Ground states and Dirichlet problems for −Δu = f(u) in ℝ², Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 96 (1986), 147–165.
  12. [12]F. V. Atkinson and L. A. Peletier, Emden–Fowler equations involving critical exponents, Nonlinear Anal. 10 (1986), 755–776.DOI
  13. [13]H. Bahouri, M. Majdoub and N. Masmoudi, On the lack of compactness in the 2D critical Sobolev embedding, J. Funct. Anal. 260 (2011), 208–252.arxiv.org/abs/1003.2562
  14. [14]H. Bahouri, M. Majdoub and N. Masmoudi, Lack of compactness in the 2D critical Sobolev embedding, the general case, J. Math. Pures Appl. (9) 101 (2014), 415–457.
  15. [15]A. Bensouilah, D. Draouil and M. Majdoub, A 2D Schrödinger equation with time-oscillating exponential nonlinearity, Dyn. Partial Differ. Equ. 17 (2020), 307–327.arxiv.org/abs/1812.06005
  16. [16]A. Bensouilah, D. Draouil and M. Majdoub, Energy critical Schrödinger equation with weighted exponential nonlinearity: local and global well-posedness, J. Hyperbolic Differ. Equ. 15 (2018), 599–621.arxiv.org/abs/1710.06477
  17. [17]A. Bensouilah, V. D. Dinh and M. Majdoub, Scattering in the weighted L²-space for a 2D nonlinear Schrödinger equation with inhomogeneous exponential nonlinearity, Commun. Pure Appl. Anal. 18 (2019), 2735–2755.
  18. [18]H. Berestycki, T. Gallouët and O. Kavian, Équations de champs scalaires euclidiens non linéaires dans le plan, C. R. Acad. Sci. Paris Sér. I Math. 297 (1983), 307–310.
  19. [19]H. Berestycki and P.-L. Lions, Nonlinear scalar field equations. I. Existence of a ground state, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 82 (1983), 313–345.DOI
  20. [20]H. Berestycki and P.-L. Lions, Nonlinear scalar field equations. II. Existence of infinitely many solutions, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 82 (1983), 347–375.DOI
  21. [21]H. Berestycki, P.-L. Lions and L. A. Peletier, An ODE approach to the existence of positive solutions for semilinear problems in ℝᴺ, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 30 (1981), 141–157.
  22. [22]H. Brezis and F. Merle, Uniform estimates and blow-up behavior for solutions of −Δu = V(x)eᵘ in two dimensions, Comm. Partial Differential Equations 16 (1991), 1223–1253.DOI
  23. [23]H. Brezis and L. Nirenberg, Positive solutions of nonlinear elliptic equations involving critical Sobolev exponents, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 36 (1983), 437–477.DOI
  24. [24]D. M. Cao, Nontrivial solution of semilinear elliptic equation with critical exponent in ℝ², Comm. Partial Differential Equations 17 (1992), 407–435.
  25. [25]L. Carlson and S.-Y. A. Chang, On the existence of an extremal function for an inequality of J. Moser, Bull. Sci. Math. (2) 110 (1986), 113–127.
  26. [26]C.-C. Chen and C.-S. Lin, Uniqueness of the ground state solution of Δu + f(u) = 0 in ℝⁿ, n ≥ 3, Comm. Partial Differential Equations 16 (1991), 1549–1572.DOI
  27. [27]W. Chen and C. Li, Classification of solutions of some nonlinear elliptic equations, Duke Math. J. 63 (1991), 615–622.DOI
  28. [28]C. V. Coffman, Uniqueness of the ground state solution for Δu − u + u³ = 0 and a variational characterization of other solutions, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 46 (1972), 81–95.DOI
  29. [29]A. Cohen, Z. Li and W. Schlag, Uniqueness of excited states −Δu + u − u³ = 0 in three dimensions, Anal. PDE 17 (2024), 1887–1906.DOI
  30. [30]J. Colliander, S. Ibrahim, M. Majdoub and N. Masmoudi, Energy critical NLS in two space dimensions, J. Hyperbolic Differ. Equ. 6 (2009), 549–575.arxiv.org/abs/0806.2979
  31. [31]C. Cortázar, M. García-Huidobro and P. Herreros, Multiplicity results for sign changing bound state solutions of a semilinear equation, J. Differential Equations 259 (2015), 7108–7134.arxiv.org/abs/1505.07132
  32. [32]C. Cortázar, M. García-Huidobro and C. S. Yarur, On the uniqueness of sign changing bound state solutions of a semilinear equation, Ann. Inst. H. Poincaré Anal. Non Linéaire 28 (2011), 599–621.DOI
  33. [33]J. Dávila, M. del Pino and I. Guerra, Non-uniqueness of positive ground states of non-linear Schrödinger equations, Proc. Lond. Math. Soc. (3) 106 (2013), 318–344.
  34. [34]D. G. de Figueiredo, O. H. Miyagaki and B. Ruf, Elliptic equations in ℝ² with nonlinearities in the critical growth range, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 3 (1995), 139–153.
  35. [35]V. D. Dinh, S. Keraani and M. Majdoub, Long time dynamics for the focusing nonlinear Schrödinger equation with exponential nonlinearities, Dyn. Partial Differ. Equ. 17 (2020), 329–360.arxiv.org/abs/2006.08279
  36. [36]O. Druet, Multibumps analysis in dimension 2: quantification of blow-up levels, Duke Math. J. 132 (2006), 217–269.DOI
  37. [37]B. Gidas, W.-M. Ni and L. Nirenberg, Symmetry of positive solutions of nonlinear elliptic equations in ℝⁿ, in: Mathematical Analysis and Applications, Part A, Adv. Math. Suppl. Stud. 7a, Academic Press, New York, 1981, 369–402.
  38. [38]M. Grossi and D. Naimen, Blow-up analysis for nodal radial solutions in Moser–Trudinger critical equations in ℝ², Ann. Sc. Norm. Super. Pisa Cl. Sci. (5) 20 (2020), 797–825.
  39. [39]P. Hartman, Ordinary Differential Equations, 2nd ed., Classics Appl. Math. 38, SIAM, Philadelphia, PA, 2002.
  40. [40]S. P. Hastings and J. B. McLeod, Classical Methods in Ordinary Differential Equations, Grad. Stud. Math. 129, Amer. Math. Soc., Providence, RI, 2012.DOI
  41. [41]S. Ibrahim, R. Jrad and M. Majdoub, Local well posedness of a 2D semilinear heat equation, Bull. Belg. Math. Soc. Simon Stevin 21 (2014), 535–551.DOI
  42. [42]S. Ibrahim, M. Majdoub and N. Masmoudi, Global solutions for a semilinear, two-dimensional Klein–Gordon equation with exponential-type nonlinearity, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 59 (2006), 1639–1658.DOI
  43. [43]S. Ibrahim, M. Majdoub and N. Masmoudi, Double logarithmic inequality with a sharp constant, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 135 (2007), 87–97.DOI
  44. [44]S. Ibrahim, M. Majdoub and N. Masmoudi, Well- and ill-posedness issues for energy supercritical waves, Anal. PDE 4 (2011), 341–367.arxiv.org/abs/0906.3092
  45. [45]S. Ibrahim, M. Majdoub, N. Masmoudi and K. Nakanishi, Scattering for the two-dimensional energy-critical wave equation, Duke Math. J. 150 (2009), 287–329.DOI
  46. [46]S. Ibrahim, M. Majdoub, N. Masmoudi and K. Nakanishi, Scattering for the two-dimensional NLS with exponential nonlinearity, Nonlinearity 25 (2012), 1843–1849.DOI
  47. [47]S. Ibrahim, N. Masmoudi and K. Nakanishi, Trudinger–Moser inequality on the whole plane with the exact growth condition, J. Eur. Math. Soc. 17 (2015), 819–835.arxiv.org/abs/1110.1712
  48. [48]M. Ishiwata, Existence and nonexistence of maximizers for variational problems associated with Trudinger–Moser type inequalities in ℝᴺ, Math. Ann. 351 (2011), 781–804.DOI
  49. [49]L. Jeanjean and K. Tanaka, A remark on least energy solutions in ℝᴺ, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 131 (2003), 2399–2408.
  50. [50]C. Jones and T. Küpper, On the infinitely many solutions of a semilinear elliptic equation, SIAM J. Math. Anal. 17 (1986), 803–835.DOI
  51. [51]Y. Kabeya and K. Tanaka, Uniqueness of positive radial solutions of semilinear elliptic equations in ℝᴺ and Séré’s non-degeneracy condition, Comm. Partial Differential Equations 24 (1999), 563–598.DOI
  52. [52]M. K. Kwong, Uniqueness of positive solutions of Δu − u + uᵖ = 0 in ℝⁿ, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 105 (1989), 243–266.DOI
  53. [53]Y. Li and W.-M. Ni, Radial symmetry of positive solutions of nonlinear elliptic equations in ℝⁿ, Comm. Partial Differential Equations 18 (1993), 1043–1054.DOI
  54. [54]T. Liu, X. Sun and W. Zou, Uniqueness of bound states to the logarithmic Schrödinger equation, preprint, arXiv:2606.19077 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2606.19077
  55. [55]M. Majdoub and N. Masmoudi, On uniqueness for supercritical nonlinear wave and Schrödinger equations, Int. Math. Res. Not. IMRN 2015 (2015), 2386–2405.arxiv.org/abs/1301.4835
  56. [56]M. Majdoub, S. Otsmane and S. Tayachi, Local well-posedness and global existence for the biharmonic heat equation with exponential nonlinearity, Adv. Differential Equations 23 (2018), 489–522.arxiv.org/abs/1606.07320
  57. [57]M. Majdoub and S. Tayachi, Global existence and decay estimates for the heat equation with exponential nonlinearity, Funkcial. Ekvac. 64 (2021), 237–259.arxiv.org/abs/1912.06490
  58. [58]A. Malchiodi and L. Martinazzi, Critical points of the Moser–Trudinger functional on a disk, J. Eur. Math. Soc. 16 (2014), 893–908.DOI
  59. [59]G. Mancini and L. Martinazzi, The Moser–Trudinger inequality and its extremals on a disk via energy estimates, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 56 (2017), Paper No. 94.arxiv.org/abs/1608.07169
  60. [60]N. Masmoudi and F. Sani, Trudinger–Moser inequalities with the exact growth condition in ℝ^N and applications, Comm. Partial Differential Equations 40 (2015), 1408–1440.DOI
  61. [61]K. McLeod, Uniqueness of positive radial solutions of Δu + f(u) = 0 in ℝⁿ. II, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 339 (1993), 495–505.
  62. [62]K. McLeod and J. Serrin, Uniqueness of positive radial solutions of Δu + f(u) = 0 in ℝⁿ, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 99 (1987), 115–145.DOI
  63. [63]K. McLeod, W. C. Troy and F. B. Weissler, Radial solutions of Δu + f(u) = 0 with prescribed numbers of zeros, J. Differential Equations 83 (1990), 368–378.DOI
  64. [64]J. Moser, A sharp form of an inequality by N. Trudinger, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 20 (1971), 1077–1092.
  65. [65]M. Nakamura and T. Ozawa, Nonlinear Schrödinger equations in the Sobolev space of critical order, J. Funct. Anal. 155 (1998), 364–380.DOI
  66. [66]W.-M. Ni and R. D. Nussbaum, Uniqueness and nonuniqueness for positive radial solutions of Δu + f(u, r) = 0, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 38 (1985), 67–108.DOI
  67. [67]L. A. Peletier and J. Serrin, Uniqueness of positive solutions of semilinear equations in ℝⁿ, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 81 (1983), 181–197.DOI
  68. [68]P. Pucci, J. Zhang and X. Zhong, Uniqueness of radial solutions for m-Laplacian equations in low dimensions, preprint, arXiv:2511.16129 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2511.16129
  69. [69]B. Ruf, A sharp Trudinger–Moser type inequality for unbounded domains in ℝ², J. Funct. Anal. 219 (2005), 340–367.
  70. [70]B. Ruf and F. Sani, Sharp Adams-type inequalities in ℝⁿ, Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 365 (2013), 645–670.DOI
  71. [71]B. Ruf and F. Sani, Ground states for elliptic equations in ℝ² with exponential critical growth, in: R. Magnanini, S. Sakaguchi and A. Alvino (eds.), Geometric Properties for Parabolic and Elliptic PDE’s, Springer INdAM Ser. 2, Springer, Milan, 2013, 251–267.DOI
  72. [72]F. Sani, Exponential-type inequalities in ℝⁿ and applications to elliptic and biharmonic equations, Ph.D. Thesis, Università degli Studi di Milano, Ledizioni, Milano, 2013.
  73. [73]J. Serrin and M. Tang, Uniqueness of ground states for quasilinear elliptic equations, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 49 (2000), 897–923.DOI
  74. [74]W. A. Strauss, Existence of solitary waves in higher dimensions, Comm. Math. Phys. 55 (1977), 149–162.DOI
  75. [75]M. Tang, Uniqueness of positive radial solutions for n-Laplacian Dirichlet problems, Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh Sect. A 130 (2000), 1405–1416.DOI
  76. [76]M. Tang, Uniqueness of bound states to Δu − u + |u|ᵖ⁻¹u = 0 in ℝⁿ, n ≥ 3, Invent. Math. 243 (2026), 245–291, doi:10.1007/s00222-025-01379-0.
  77. [77]C. Tarsi, Uniqueness of positive solutions of nonlinear elliptic equations with exponential growth, Proc. Roy. Soc. Edinburgh Sect. A 133 (2003), 1409–1420.DOI
  78. [78]N. S. Trudinger, On imbeddings into Orlicz spaces and some applications, J. Math. Mech. 17 (1967), 473–483.DOI
  79. [79]M. I. Weinstein, Nonlinear Schrödinger equations and sharp interpolation estimates, Comm. Math. Phys. 87 (1983), 567–576.
  80. [80]M. I. Weinstein, Modulational stability of ground states of nonlinear Schrödinger equations, SIAM J. Math. Anal. 16 (1985), 472–491.DOI
  81. [81]E. Yanagida, Uniqueness of positive radial solutions of Δu + g(r)u + h(r)uᵖ = 0 in ℝⁿ, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 115 (1991), 257–274.DOI
  82. [82]C. Zhang and X. Zhang, Uniqueness of bound states for sublinear elliptic equations, preprint, arXiv:2606.17840 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2606.17840

Paper details

vlnc:W_7j5kxthg
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents