In this paper
AbstractIntroductionRigidity for exterior domains of bounded obstaclesThe planar caseThe higher-dimensional caseRigidity for noncompact connected boundariesReferencesWorksMathematics
Overdetermined boundary problems for maximal graphs
Abstract
We study overdetermined boundary problems for the maximal surface equation with zero Dirichlet data and constant nonzero Neumann data . For the exterior of a bounded domain with connected boundary in , , we prove that such domain must be the complement of a ball and the solution is radial. In dimension two, we also show that a positive solution on a domain bounded by a properly embedded noncompact connected curve forces the domain to be a half-plane and the solution to be affine. The proofs combine the divergence structure of the equation with the induced geometry of maximal graphs.
Introduction
Let denote the Lorentz–Minkowski space endowed with the metric
The graph of a function is spacelike if , and its mean curvature with respect to the Lorentz metric vanishes precisely when satisfies the maximal surface equation
This equation is the Euler–Lagrange equation of the Lorentzian area functional
under compactly supported variations of the graph. The strict spacelikeness condition ensures that the induced metric is Riemannian and that the equation is elliptic. Unlike minimal graphs in Euclidean space, spacelike solutions of (1.1) locally maximize the Lorentzian area among spacelike graph variations with fixed boundary values, owing to the strict concavity of the area integrand . This variational property explains the terminology maximal.
The classical Bernstein theorem of Calabi and Cheng–Yau asserts that every smooth entire spacelike maximal graph must be a hyperplane [5, 6]. For domains with boundary, the geometry of the boundary and the prescribed boundary data allow a much richer family of solutions; see, for example, Bartnik–Simon [3].
On a bounded region , the functional
differs from the negative Lorentzian area by a constant, and its Euler–Lagrange equation is (1.1).
We orient by the unit outward normal . To describe domain variations without assuming that is finite, fix a large ball and consider deformations supported strictly inside . Let
where solves the maximal surface equation, vanishes on the moving boundary, and has fixed Dirichlet data on the outer boundary. For a smooth family of spacelike solutions, the shape derivative is
The first variation of the enclosed volume is
Thus, critical point under volume-preserving deformations implies there exists a Lagrange multiplier such that
Hence we are led to the overdetermined problem
where and denotes the unit normal pointing into . Geometrically, the graph has boundary in the horizontal hyperplane and meets that hyperplane at a constant hyperbolic angle.
The study of overdetermined elliptic problems originates in Serrin’s symmetry theorem [20], which establishes spherical symmetry for positive solutions of a broad class of elliptic equations on bounded domains with constant Dirichlet and Neumann data. For exterior domains, Reichel [14, 15] developed a version of the moving plane method adapted to the unbounded setting. Sirakov [22] subsequently extended this theory, allowing, in particular, different constant boundary data on different components of a bounded obstacle. These results show that suitable overdetermined data, together with appropriate conditions at infinity, force the obstacle to be a ball.
For the corresponding Euclidean mean curvature equation, the planar problem admits a particularly strong classification. Cui [7] proved that a positive minimal graph with connected boundary, zero Dirichlet data, and constant normal derivative must be a half-plane or a portion of a vertical catenoid. Equivalently, its domain is a half-plane or the exterior of a disk. The proof uses analytic reflection and classification results for complete minimal surfaces.
Our first main result investigates (2) on an exterior domain of a bounded set.
Theorem 1.1. Let and let be a bounded domain with connected boundary, where . Suppose that is connected. Let satisfy the overdetermined problem (2). Then there exist and such that and
An important analytic input for this theorem is the asymptotic expansion of solutions to the maximal surface equation on exterior domains obtained by Hong and Yuan [10]. Let be as above, and let be a smooth strictly spacelike solution of the maximal surface equation in . The divergence structure implies that the quantity
is independent of whenever . Following the terminology of Hong and Yuan, the normalization quantity is called the residue of , where
Set
the asymptotic expansion of Hong–Yuan asserts that there exists , and such that
for every integer . Here the notation means that, for every multi-index with ,
for all sufficiently large .
In dimension two, we have absorbed the explicit correction term of order in Hong–Yuan’s expansion into the remainder. When , their sharper expansion gives
We next turn to domains with noncompact boundary. The geometry of overdetermined problems in this setting is substantially richer. A central question was formulated by Berestycki, Caffarelli, and Nirenberg [4], who conjectured that a smooth domain with connected complement admitting a bounded positive solution of
for a Lipschitz nonlinearity , must be a ball, a half-space, a generalized cylinder, or the complement of one of these domains. The BCN conjecture is false in general. Sicbaldi [21] constructed counterexamples in dimensions by perturbing straight cylinders periodically. Ros, Ruiz, and Sicbaldi [18] subsequently constructed nonradial exterior domains supporting bounded positive solutions for suitable nonlinearities in every dimension , thereby also disproving the conjecture in the plane.
For complements of unbounded obstacles, nontrivial examples exist even in the harmonic case . Fall, Minlend, and Weth [8] constructed exceptional domains in as complements of nontrivial periodic perturbations of a straight cylinder. Minlend, Weth, and Wu [12] obtained analogous constructions in every dimension . These domains have connected noncompact boundary and support positive harmonic functions with zero Dirichlet data and constant nonzero Neumann data. The corresponding functions have logarithmic growth in the three-dimensional construction and are bounded in dimensions . Thus, in higher dimensions, connectedness of the boundary does not force even a harmonic overdetermined domain to be a half-space or the complement of a straight circular cylinder. These examples also suggest that a similarly unrestricted classification for maximal graphs should not be expected, although they do not themselves provide counterexamples for the maximal surface equation.
In dimension two, however, strong rigidity results remain available when the boundary is connected and noncompact. Ros, Ruiz, and Sicbaldi [19] proved that a planar domain with unbounded connected boundary supporting a bounded positive solution of the semilinear overdetermined problem above must be a half-plane, and the solution is one-dimensional.
Several rigidity results are also available for geometric quasilinear equations in dimension two. In addition to the aforementioned result of Cui [7], a recent contribution is due to Lian and Sicbaldi [11], who studied the capillary overdetermined problem
For planar domains with unbounded connected boundary, they obtained half-plane rigidity and one-dimensionality of the solution under boundedness of both and , provided that admits a nonpositive primitive satisfying .
Our second result establishes a rigidity statement in the setting of noncompact domains with connected unbounded boundary in dimension two.
Theorem 1.2. Let be a properly embedded curve diffeomorphic to , where , and let be one of the two connected components of . Let be a constant. Suppose that satisfies the overdetermined problem (1.2), then, after a rigid motion, , and .
The proofs of both theorems combine the divergence structure of the equation with the geometry of maximal graphs, making essential use of the induced Riemannian metric. For Theorem 1.1, integral identities and geometric inequalities lead to rigidity through their equality cases. This strategy is reminiscent of Weinberger’s approach to Serrin’s problem [23] and of the integral methods underlying Alexandrov-type rigidity results [16, 17]. For Theorem 1.2, a key step is to establish the uniform spacelikeness (), which allows us to exploit global conformal coordinates and reduce the rigidity argument to the analysis of harmonic functions.
We present the proof of Theorem 1.1 in Section 2 and the proof of Theorem 1.2 in Section 3.
Rigidity for exterior domains of bounded obstacles
Throughout this section, we write
and orient by the unit normal pointing from into . We denote the Euclidean area of by , the volume of by . The mean curvature is the sum of principal curvatures with respect to , so that on . denotes the unit outward normal of .
In view of the maximal surface equation (2), the divergence theorem in gives
For simplicity, we set
The first step is to show that the overdetermined boundary conditions eliminate the linear part allowed by the general exterior asymptotic expansion (3).
Lemma 2.1. Under the assumptions of Theorem 1.1, the asymptotic slope of in the expansion (3) vanishes.
If , there exists such that
In this case, in .
If , there exists such that
In this case, in . The expansions hold for every nonnegative integer .
Proof. Define
Each row of has zero divergence, since
On ,
The divergence theorem yields
By Hong and Yuan’s asymptotic expansion (3), there exists , , such that
Write
Thus , and
Using
we obtain
Choose a smooth function on which agrees with outside a fixed large ball, using a cutoff near . For each , the vector field is divergence free. Since on for large , it follows that each row of is also divergence free, and consequently
Integrating (2.5) against and using (2.1), (2.4) and (2.6), we find
Consequently,
Letting and using , we conclude that .
The expansions (2.2) and (2.3) now follow from (1.3).
For , positivity of the residue implies as . The maximum principle on bounded truncations, followed by the strong maximum principle, gives in .
For , suppose that . Since on and at infinity, the maximum principle on bounded truncations would give in . This contradicts on . Hence , and the maximum principle gives throughout . □
Next, we shall utilize the geometric property of the maximal surface equation. We equip with the metric induced by the maximal graph, . We will reserve for Euclidean derivative, and all notions with a subscript such as are taken with respect to .
We list several geometric identities needed below.
Setting , therefore
From the maximal surface equation, it is easy to see that is harmonic with respect to :
With the convention for the second fundamental form in Lorentzian space, the Christoffel symbols and the Hessian of the height function are
Since the graph is maximal, . The Gauss equation therefore gives
where is any -orthonormal frame.
For later use, let be a regular level set of , oriented by the Euclidean unit normal . Its -unit normal pointing toward increasing is . If denotes the sum of the Euclidean principal curvatures of , then its mean curvature in , with the same trace convention, is
Consequently, (10) implies
Therefore, we have
Lemma 2.2. For , define
Plugging , then on ,
If , equality holds in (13). If , setting gives a continuous weakly subharmonic function on . If , for every , the function , assigned the value at , is weakly subharmonic on .
Moreover, along every regular level set of ,
Proof. We first work on . Since and , equation (2.8) gives
Applying the Bochner formula to the harmonic function , we obtain
For both definitions of ,
The chain rule thus yields
By the refined Kato inequality, the term in the parentheses is nonnegative. When , it vanishes.
To handle critical points, suppose first that . The defining integral converges at zero, and as . For every , the function is locally constant near and weakly subharmonic on . It is therefore weakly subharmonic throughout . Letting , with locally uniform convergence, proves the assertion for . For , the same argument applies directly to , since as .
Finally, using (12) and , we find
□
Proof of Theorem 1.1. We divide the proof into two cases.
The planar case
Assume . By Lemma 2.1,
It follows that and hence
Thus is bounded near infinity and equals on .
We claim that
Indeed fix . Since and is bounded near infinity, on every sufficiently large sphere. On , the same expression is zero.
To justify the comparison at critical points, fix such a sphere and choose large enough that the truncation agrees with on both boundary components of . This is possible because on and on sufficiently large spheres. By Lemma 2.2,
is weakly subharmonic. The maximum principle gives the desired comparison on . Exhausting and then letting proves (2.12).
It follows from (14) that
Since and ,
The connected boundary is a simple closed curve, so the turning-angle formula gives
Equality must therefore hold everywhere in (16). Thus has constant positive curvature and is a disk.
The higher-dimensional case
Assume and abbreviate
By Lemma 2.1, and at infinity.
The function is weakly subharmonic, vanishes on , and tends to zero at infinity. The maximum principle on an exhaustion gives
Taking the inward derivative on yields
Consequently,
The asymptotic expansion implies that
Multiplying the maximal surface equation by and integrating over , we find
Letting gives
Consider the divergence-free tensor
Its trace is
On ,
Moreover, at infinity, so
Applying the divergence theorem to and using (2.16), we obtain
Define
The function is decreasing. For almost every , the level set is smooth and compact. The divergence theorem gives
Since
the Euclidean coarea formula yields
The critical set causes no additional contribution, because wherever . For , define by
The comparison (2.14) implies on . Using the monotonicity of and (2.18), we obtain
The elementary identity
follows by differentiating both sides with respect to and observing that both sides tend to zero as . Combining (2.17), (2.19), and (2.20), we find
Since , cancellation gives
The curvature bound (2.15) makes strictly mean convex. The Euclidean Heintze–Karcher inequality[9] states that
Together with (2.15) and (2.21), this gives
All inequalities above are therefore equalities, and is a ball. Finally we show that is radial about . For an orthogonal transformation , set
The functions and solve the same equation and have the same zero boundary data. By Lemma 2.1,
In dimension two, this follows from the common logarithmic coefficient and constant term; in higher dimensions, both functions tend to . The comparison principle on bounded exhaustions therefore gives . Thus .
The radial equation is
Since , its first integral is
Solving for and using , we obtain
This is the asserted formula and completes the proof. □
Rigidity for noncompact connected boundaries
In this section we prove Theorem 1.2. In the bounded-obstacle case considered above, the gradient vanishes at infinity; although such decay is unavailable in the present setting, the following lemma shows that the uniform spacelikeness still follows from the boundary conditions.
Lemma 3.1. Let be a properly embedded curve diffeomorphic to , and let be one of the two components of . Let be a constant and we assume that satisfies (1.2), then
Proof. Put
Notice that . On the set , put . The two-dimensional identity in Lemma 2.2 gives , where
Thus and
The function is throughout . At every critical point of , attains its minimum value zero, so there as well. Therefore is subharmonic on all of .
Note
We shall show that throughout .
To this end, we need a superharmonic barrier as follows. For every , choose a nearest boundary point . Since the segment lies in , the conditions and give
Choose and such that , and write . Then , and consequently
Consider the translated graph immersion into Lorentz–Minkowski space, so that . Let be its future-directed unit timelike normal. Maximality gives , and hence
Since
we obtain
It follows that
Thus the function is nonnegative and superharmonic. Moreover, (3.1) implies that as in .
For , define . It follows that
The maximum principle, applied on sufficiently large bounded truncations of , gives
Letting at each fixed point, we conclude that in . Since the function
is strictly increasing on , this implies .
This uniform spackelikeness enables one to build up a global conformal parametrization that respects the noncompact boundary.
Lemma 3.2. Under the assumptions of Theorem 1.2, there exists a conformal diffeomorphism
where , which extends to a homeomorphism in the spherical topology, with , and . At every finite boundary point, extends locally as a diffeomorphism up to the boundary.
Proof. Since is a properly embedded curve diffeomorphic to , the component of other than contains a closed ball. The boundary conditions give on . Thus Lemma 3.1 yields
and consequently . The conformal structure determined by has a Beltrami coefficient satisfying
Extend measurably to by setting it equal to zero outside . By the measurable Riemann mapping theorem [1], there exists a quasiconformal homeomorphism
whose restriction to is an isothermal coordinate map for .
Properness of implies that is a Jordan curve in . Therefore is also a Jordan curve, and is one of its complementary domains. The Riemann mapping theorem and the Carathéodory boundary extension theorem [13] provide a conformal map
which extends homeomorphically to the closures in . After precomposing with an automorphism of , we may arrange that . Hence has the asserted conformal and topological properties.
It remains to verify regularity at finite boundary points. This is a local issue. Fix . Since and on , the metric admits a positive definite extension to a neighborhood of . Local isothermal coordinates for this extension may be chosen of class for some . In these coordinates, becomes a boundary arc, and becomes an ordinary conformal map.
The local boundary regularity theorem of Kellogg–Warschawski [13] then implies that this conformal map extends to the boundary arc, with nonvanishing derivative. Transforming back to the original coordinates shows that extends locally as a diffeomorphism up to . □
We also record a standard consequence of the representation of positive harmonic functions on the upper half-plane.
Lemma 3.3. Let be a nonnegative harmonic function on , continuous on . If
where is constant, then for some .
Proof. The conclusion is immediate if . Otherwise, the strong maximum principle gives in . By the representation theorem for positive harmonic functions on the upper half-space [2 Theorem 7.26], there exist and a positive Borel measure on such that
The approximate identity property of the Poisson kernel, together with this integrability condition, implies that
More precisely, for every ,
On the other hand, continuity of on and the boundary condition imply that uniformly on each compact interval as . Therefore
for every , and hence .
Substituting this into the representation formula and using
we obtain , with .
Now we are ready to complete the proof.
Proof of Theorem 1.2. Let be the conformal parametrization given by Lemma 3.2, and write
Since is -harmonic, the function is harmonic on . It is positive in and continuous with zero boundary values on the entire real axis. Lemma 3.3 therefore gives
In particular,
Thus has no critical points.
Lemma 2.2 now applies without truncation and yields
Since for , the function is positive and harmonic on . The boundary conditions imply
Hence extends continuously to the real axis with the constant boundary value . A second application of Lemma 3.3 gives
Combining this identity with (26), we obtain . Since is onto,
Let denote the signed Euclidean curvature of , with the convention . Thus a circle has positive curvature when points toward its exterior. The inward unit conormal in the graph metric is , On we have . The boundary identity (14), specialized to dimension two, gives . Taking the inward derivative of (27) therefore yields
In particular, has constant curvature.
A properly embedded curve in is complete in its induced Euclidean metric. A complete connected plane curve with constant nonzero curvature is a circle, whereas a complete connected curve with zero curvature is a line. Since is noncompact and diffeomorphic to , the circle case is excluded. Thus . Because , equation (28) implies . Consequently,
The function is strictly increasing, so , and .
We finally show that is affine. Differentiating gives . The nondivergence form of the maximal surface equation is
and therefore . The Euclidean Bochner identity gives
Hence and is affine.
We already know that is a line, and is one of its complementary half-planes. After a Euclidean rigid motion we may write
The boundary conditions and then identify the affine function as . □
References
SCHOOL OF MATHEMATICAL SCIENCES, SHANGHAI JIAO TONG UNIVERSITY, SHANGHAI 200240, CHINA
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]L. V. Ahlfors, Lectures on Quasiconformal Mappings, 2nd ed., University Lecture Series, vol. 38, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2006.DOI
- [2]S. Axler, P. Bourdon, and W. Ramey, Harmonic Function Theory, 2nd ed., Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 137, Springer-Verlag, New York, 2001.
- [3]R. Bartnik and L. Simon, Spacelike hypersurfaces with prescribed boundary values and mean curvature, Comm. Math. Phys. 87 (1982), no. 1, 131–152.DOI
- [4]H. Berestycki, L. A. Caffarelli, and L. Nirenberg, Monotonicity for elliptic equations in unbounded Lipschitz domains, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 50 (1997), no. 11, 1089–1111.doi.org/10.1002/(sici)1097-0312(199711)50:11<1089::aid-cpa2>3.0.co;2-6
- [5]E. Calabi, Examples of Bernstein problems for some nonlinear equations, in Global Analysis, Proceedings of Symposia in Pure Mathematics, vol. 15, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1970, 223–230.DOI
- [6]S.-Y. Cheng and S.-T. Yau, Maximal space-like hypersurfaces in the Lorentz–Minkowski spaces, Ann. of Math. (2) 104 (1976), no. 3, 407–419.DOI
- [7]Q. Cui, A note on an overdetermined problem for minimal surface equation, Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 150 (2022), no. 12, 5403–5409.DOI
- [8]M. M. Fall, I. A. Minlend, and T. Weth, On an electrostatic problem and a new class of exceptional subdomains of ℝ³, SIAM J. Math. Anal. 55 (2023), no. 3, 2347–2376. doi:10.1137/22M1487540.DOI
- [9]E. Heintze and H. Karcher, A general comparison theorem with applications to volume estimates for submanifolds, Ann. Sci. École Norm. Sup. (4) 11 (1978), no. 4, 451–470.DOI
- [10]G. Hong and Y. Yuan, Maximal hypersurfaces over exterior domains, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 74 (2021), no. 3, 589–614.arxiv.org/abs/1903.00787
- [11]Y. Lian and P. Sicbaldi, Rigidity results for the capillary overdetermined problem, preprint, arXiv:2503.14215, 2025.arxiv.org/abs/2503.14215
- [12]I. A. Minlend, T. Weth, and J. Wu, Exceptional domains in higher dimensions, J. Geom. Anal. 36 (2026), Paper No. 6. doi:10.1007/s12220-025-02243-6.DOI
- [13]Ch. Pommerenke, Boundary Behaviour of Conformal Maps, Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, vol. 299, Springer-Verlag, Berlin, 1992.DOI
- [14]W. Reichel, Radial symmetry for an electrostatic, a capillarity and some fully nonlinear overdetermined problems on exterior domains, Z. Anal. Anwendungen 15 (1996), no. 3, 619–635.DOI
- [15]W. Reichel, Radial symmetry for elliptic boundary-value problems on exterior domains, Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 137 (1997), no. 4, 381–394.DOI
- [16]R. C. Reilly, Applications of the Hessian operator in a Riemannian manifold, Indiana Univ. Math. J. 26 (1977), no. 3, 459–472.
- [17]A. Ros, Compact hypersurfaces with constant higher order mean curvatures, Rev. Mat. Iberoamericana 3 (1987), 447–453.
- [18]A. Ros, D. Ruiz, and P. Sicbaldi, Solutions to overdetermined elliptic problems in nontrivial exterior domains, J. Eur. Math. Soc. (JEMS) 22 (2020), no. 1, 253–281. doi:10.4171/JEMS/921.
- [19]A. Ros, D. Ruiz, and P. Sicbaldi, A rigidity result for overdetermined elliptic problems in the plane, Comm. Pure Appl. Math. 70 (2017), no. 7, 1223–1252. doi:10.1002/cpa.21696.
- [20]J. Serrin, A symmetry problem in potential theory, Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 43 (1971), 304–318.DOI
- [21]P. Sicbaldi, New extremal domains for the first eigenvalue of the Laplacian in flat tori, Calc. Var. Partial Differential Equations 37 (2010), nos. 3–4, 329–344. doi:10.1007/s00526-009-0264-z.DOI
- [22]B. Sirakov, Symmetry for exterior elliptic problems and two conjectures in potential theory, Ann. Inst. H. Poincaré C Anal. Non Linéaire 18 (2001), no. 2, 135–156.DOI
- [23]H. F. Weinberger, Remark on the preceding paper of Serrin, Arch. Rational Mech. Anal. 43 (1971), 319–320.DOI