WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Half-Completeness from Standard Gravitational Dispersion Relations
Abstract
The completeness hypothesis states that quantum gravity realizes every representation allowed by its gauge group. Previous S-matrix arguments used the graviton pole to constrain exchanged representations, including a proof of completeness by imposing an additional high-energy bound on crossing-odd amplitudes. We investigate what follows without this assumption, using standard twice-subtracted dispersion relations, positivity, and crossing symmetry. For external massless SU(2) isospin , we prove ``half-completeness'': either massive exchanges include every isospin , or at least one is required. At , we construct an explicit amplitude with only exchanges that satisfies these conditions but violates the crossing-odd bound. This establishes that the additional high-energy assumption does not follow from the standard framework. For , however, we show that lower-only spectra cannot be realized within a class of string-inspired Euler amplitudes, leaving their existence an open question. More generally, for scalar matter transforming under any compact internal symmetry group, we prove that massive singlets of unbounded Lorentz spin must be exchanged.
Introduction
Swampland conjectures seek to distinguish low-energy theories that admit a consistent quantum-gravitational completion from those that do not [1, 2]. In this work we focus on the completeness hypothesis, which requires every representation allowed by the gauge group to be realized by physical states [3, 4, 5, 6]. We investigate how much of this spectrum follows from scattering consistency of the S-matrix bootstrap framework [7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34, 35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40, 41, 42, 43]. This approach has been previously used to test swampland conjectures [44, 45, 46, 47, 48, 49, 50, 51, 52] and even to reconstruct string amplitudes and constrain their deformations [53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59, 60, 61, 62, 63, 64, 65, 66, 67, 68, 69, 70, 71, 72, 73, 74, 75, 76, 77].
Gravity couples universally to energy and momentum, so any two particles can exchange a graviton. In elastic scattering of massless scalars, this gives a contribution proportional to , where is Newton’s constant, is the squared center-of-mass energy, and is the squared momentum transfer. The pole at obstructs positivity bounds in the forward limit, requiring different approaches such as smearing [31] and sampling [78].
The graviton pole can also be used to anchor a different type of approach relating IR consistency to constraints on the UV spectrum. Through the twice-subtracted dispersion relation, massive exchanges must reproduce the graviton pole. When considering the scattering of colored particles, this leads to powerful conditions of the irreps that must be present as UV states, even without imposing positivity or crossing null constraints [79]. Later work established completeness of the Cartan charge lattice for several nonabelian groups, leaving open whether every allowed irreducible representation must also occur; the argument remained inconclusive for SO(3) [80]. Subsequent work required every representation generated by tensor products of the seed states, assuming improved high-energy behavior of crossing-odd amplitudes uniformly near the forward limit [81].
In this work we ask the natural question: can completeness be proven using only the standard assumptions of the S-matrix bootstrap? This includes twice-subtracted dispersion relations, positivity, and crossing symmetry, without imposing improved high-energy behavior or any constraints on the spectrum. Our goal is to understand this question in the simplest non-abelian group, and if the answer is negative, perhaps understand more generally what extra constraints are required.
For tree-level scattering of massless SU(2) scalars of isospin we prove that
Our all- analysis of the graviton-pole argument [79] leaves four exceptional omissions for integer , all excluded by positivity and crossing null constraints. For half-integer , the graviton relation alone suffices.
As in [80], one could next consider the scattering of SU(2) representations that are present as exchanged states in the massless all isospin amplitude discussed above, deriving new constraints on the spectrum consistent with the graviton-pole argument, positivity and crossing null constraints. Full completeness of the SU(2) representation spectrum would follow recursively if at least one higher isospin in addition to the lower isospins was necessary for consistency. Instead we find that standard assumptions are not enough to establish this.
Whether the lower-isospin branch admits an explicit amplitude is a further question. At , we construct a crossing-symmetric amplitude with positive partial-wave residues and massive exchanges only in . This example also shows that the improved high-energy assumption used in Ref. [81] does not follow from the four-point consistency conditions imposed here.
At higher , our finite numerical tests find no obstruction to lower-only exchange. However, we show that within a class of string-inspired amplitudes, matching the singlet graviton pole requires an exchanged isospin above for every .
Whether amplitudes exist outside this class, or are excluded by the full dispersive constraints, remains open. Resolving this question would clarify how much of completeness follows from scattering consistency alone. Understanding which properties cause the string-inspired obstruction may help identify what other additional assumptions are needed to pass from half-completeness to full completeness.
Independently, we show that the same framework requires massive singlets of unbounded Lorentz spin for any compact internal symmetry group. The unbounded spin required by gravity therefore cannot be carried entirely by charged exchanges. A neutral tower must couple to the scalar pair, regardless of which charged representations are present, fixing a universal feature of the ultraviolet spectrum.
Graviton pole and color projectors
We consider identical massless Lorentz scalars of integer isospin in dimensions, with unbroken SU(2) symmetry and a nonconfining vacuum when it is gauged. We assume a tree-level ultraviolet completion with isolated massive poles above a gap . We use positive pole residues, crossing symmetry, and the standard twice-subtracted dispersion framework, including its higher-moment crossing sum rules [31]. The external pair decomposes as , where is the exchanged isospin of the UV state. We denote Lorentz spin as , so Bose symmetry requires even. The Mandelstam variables obey , and we take as the forward limit.
The amplitude carries incoming SU(2) indices and outgoing indices , called color indices. The channel pairs with , the channel pairs with , and the channel pairs with . The partial-wave expansion now involves both Lorentz spin and internal isospin [79]:
Here is the Gegenbauer polynomial normalized by , and are the partial-wave coefficients, with positive normalization factors absorbed into them.
The projector selects the two-particle states with total isospin . Thus a massive pole in describes an exchanged particle of isospin and Lorentz spin . As operators on the pair space, the projectors obey and . We call the states of a given an isospin sector. Their pole weights are defined by and are nonnegative when positivity is imposed.
For an explicit illustration, take external isospin in a real Cartesian basis, so . The singlet, triplet, and quintet projectors are
The outgoing pair is ordered as , so its identity tensor is . The three projectors extract the trace, antisymmetric, and symmetric-traceless parts of that pair.
Changing the exchanged channel changes which indices are paired. In this convention, and . Expressing the - and -channel tensors in the -channel basis lets us compare their contributions with gravity.
A -channel graviton carries no SU(2) charge. It contributes , where includes the singlet-projector normalization. Its quadratic coefficient in is therefore . After removing the constant and linear subtraction terms, the twice-subtracted dispersion relation matches this quadratic contribution to a sum over massive poles (Appendix A). The massive exchanges must therefore reproduce a pure -channel singlet.
At , we have so the direct and crossed channels enter symmetrically, and the massive-pole denominators coincide. Crossing gives these poles the same spectral weight, so the relation becomes
The function is the contribution of all massive poles of isospin to this dispersion relation:
The sum includes every mass and Lorentz spin in sector . If isospin is absent, . The remainder in Eq. (4) stays bounded as . Masses and couplings change these weights but not the projector conversion coefficients. Therefore, we have the following constraint:
If the allowed sums cannot reproduce , no regular low-energy interaction can repair the unmatched graviton pole.
Let us consider a simple example that illustrates our main result. Consider a setup with , but where the massive exchanges have only , with the higher isospin absent. The explicit projectors above give
Neither remaining tensor is purely a -channel singlet, so singlet exchange alone, or triplet exchange alone, cannot reproduce gravity. With both present, cancellation of and matching of fix
The solution is unique. On the other hand, this also implies that omitting either lower isospin requires an isospin-two contribution to reproduce the graviton singlet correctly.
The pole makes this stronger than a statement about isolated particles. Inverting the two component equations gives and . Any finite set of massive poles is regular at , so both sectors need infinitely many coupled states. Unbounded Lorentz spin will follow separately when we also impose positivity.
The all-isospin constraint
For general integer , we make the same change of projector basis: , where is the -channel isospin. This is SU(2) recoupling: the Wigner symbol gives the overlap between the two ways of pairing four SU(2) indices. The conversion coefficients are
where , , and is a Racah polynomial of degree , normalized by [82]. For example, for . The crossed conversion is , so has only even components, just as we saw for in Eq. (6). We can write these components explicitly as
The vector simply lists the coefficients of this tensor in the -channel basis. Working with these lists turns the tensor-matching problem into a finite system of linear equations.
When no higher-isospin tower is present, the singular part must be built from the lower tensors. Their coefficients are polynomials of successive degrees , evaluated at distinct values . They are therefore linearly independent, giving a unique expansion
The vector represents : its singlet coefficient is one and every nonsinglet coefficient is zero. Thus the polynomial on the left below must equal one at and vanish at :
These values determine a degree- polynomial uniquely. The product supplies its zeros and normalization, and so its expansion in the Racah basis then determines every .
Inverting the dispersion relation gives . If , omitting isospin sets and leaves an unmatched pole. In other words, an isospin sector can only be removed if its corresponding weight vanishes. Changing the masses or couplings of the remaining lower isospins cannot fill the gap, so every nonzero weight requires its own tower.
The remaining question is whether any of the vanish in the unique expansion. In Appendix B we prove that for , all are non-vanishing. For smaller , we do find precisely four cases where : . These four zeros identify the only lower-isospin omissions left by this equation. Remarkably, positivity and crossing null constraints are sufficient to remove these exceptions, proving half-completeness for integer .
Half-integer external isospin. For half-integer , the corresponding graviton-matching problem again has a unique solution, but this time with no vanishing lower-isospin coefficients. It neither channel contains massive exchanges with , the graviton relation alone therefore requires a tower of unbounded mass in every in each channel.
Details are given in Appendix B2. The accompanying Wolfram Language code also computes these weights for any specified integer or half-integer .
Positivity and crossing
In this section we explain how specially constructed null constraints can eliminate the four exceptions that appear for integer . Crossing null constraints are obtained by expanding the amplitude at low energies and matching its Taylor coefficients before and after exchanging external legs. Replacing these coefficients by their dispersive expressions gives relations among massive exchanges, which directly constrain the UV spectrum. The complete derivations are done explicitly in Appendices A and D, here we consider the case, where the above discussion allows the massive state to be absent.
Define the weighted pole sums, and for simplicity set
The mass factor comes from expanding the pole denominators, and the spin polynomials from expanding their angular dependence. Crossing requires
Bose symmetry allows even spins for even and odd spins for odd . On these allowed spins, the even-isospin weight vanishes at and is positive above them. The odd-isospin weight vanishes at and is positive above them. Positive pole residues therefore give for every isospin.
By itself, Eq. (13) would allow every moment to vanish, with all exchanged spins at most three. The graviton pole excludes this possibility. With positive residues, reproducing its singularity requires arbitrarily high Lorentz spins, even if infinitely many masses are available.
If the singlet were absent this would imply , forcing every term on the right-hand side of Eq. (13) to vanish. This contradicts the spin requirement, and so a massive singlet with must be present.
Analogous null constraints exclude the remaining omissions when all exchanges are absent: at and at . Their explicit forms and sign arguments are given in Appendix C. All four exceptions are therefore removed, completing the proof of Eq. (1).
A universal singlet tower
Gravity requires unbounded spin somewhere in the coupled spectrum. In this section we show that crossing symmetry implies something stronger. A bound on singlet spin would bound every coupled spin, even when higher isospins are present.
The example above required a massive singlet with . Continuing in , we now show that singlets of arbitrarily high spin must occur for every integer , regardless of which other isospins are exchanged.
To test any proposed bound on singlet spin, we need null constraints whose weights vanish below that bound and are positive above it. Following an argument similar to [36], Appendix D constructs such constraints for every integer . Define
where and . Crossing gives
The product removes the first allowed spins: for even isospin and for odd isospin. Every higher allowed spin has positive weight, so . At and , this reproduces Eq. (13).
Suppose singlet spin were bounded, and choose above that bound. Then , so every nonnegative term on the right must also vanish. All exchanged spins would therefore lie among the zeros of the weights, with . This contradicts the unbounded spin required by the graviton pole, implying the singlet spin cannot be bounded.
General groups The argument extends to any compact internal symmetry group . Consider real scalar components. The pair
is invariant under , so only singlet particles couple to it. The remaining pair states are either symmetric and orthogonal to , or antisymmetric.
Let sum the weighted squared couplings to , and let and sum those to the remaining symmetric and antisymmetric pairs. We use the mass factors and spin weights of Eq. (14), with even spins for , and odd spins for . All three moments are nonnegative and receive strictly positive contributions from coupled particles with . Crossing gives (Appendix D.3)
For SU(2), and the and sectors collect the even and the odd , so Eq. (16) reduces to Eq. (15). If singlet spin were bounded, choosing above that bound would give . Positivity would then force both remaining moments to vanish, excluding high-spin exchanges from every pair state. This contradicts the unbounded spin required by the graviton pole. Singlets must therefore have unbounded even spin.
Reference [81] obtains a singlet tower using an improved high-energy bound on crossing-odd amplitudes. Here it follows from the twice-subtracted graviton relation, positive residues, and higher-moment crossing sum rules, without that additional bound.
Explicit amplitudes
We realize the lower-isospin branch explicitly at with a crossing-symmetric amplitude whose massive exchanges contain only . Surprisingly, this amplitude also provides a counterexample to the improved crossing-odd high-energy bound of Ref. [81], despite having a universal graviton pole, nonnegative partial-wave residues for , and standard twice-subtracted high-energy behavior.
Set the mass scale and the massless gauge coupling to zero. Define the symmetric block
with poles at nonnegative integer values of and . In the triplet’s Cartesian basis, take , , and . Crossing permutes the three terms in
The massless residues reproduce graviton exchange,
At a massive -channel pole, only the and blocks contribute. Since and , the exchanged spectrum is . The poles lie at , , with unbounded spin in both sectors. Using the results of Ref. [83], one can verify that the amplitude has nonnegative partial-wave residues for . It also satisfies the fixed-transfer high-energy bound required for a twice-subtracted dispersion relation.
At large complex and fixed , . The remaining blocks grow no faster, giving . To examine the stronger bound, define and . For , , and fixed ,
The coefficient remains nonzero as . Consequently, no positive, -independent gives the suppression required by Ref. [81].
The planar open-string example in that reference instead fails a strengthened even-sector bound and contains no graviton exchange. Our construction demonstrates the independence of the improved crossing-odd bound within the gravitational four-point setup itself.
The obstruction at $J=2. Now take external isospin . The external indices run over five components, and the projectors resolve $2\otimes2=0\oplus1\oplus2\oplus3\oplus4$. Keep the same beta-function blocks and delta tensors, replacing the overall normalization by .
The difference from is in the antisymmetric pair states. For two triplets these have only isospin one, whereas for two isospin-two particles they contain both and . Consequently, the same delta tensors now give
Their sum still reproduces the graviton: . The problem appears at the massive poles. At the first massive -channel pole, , we have . The residues of and are respectively and . The remaining block, , has no -channel pole here. Thus
The isospin-three coefficient does not vanish as a function of scattering angle. Although the nonsinglet contributions cancel at the massless pole, their different angular factors prevent that cancellation at the massive pole. The sum therefore exchanges , rather than only .
The obstruction extends beyond this particular ansatz. Appendix E treats regular Euler integrals with analytic coefficient functions and finite polynomial momentum dependence, including arbitrarily large finite sums of polynomially dressed, integer-shifted beta functions with a common slope. Absence of forbidden poles at every mass level forces each channel-pair block to obey the isospin cutoff in both of its channels. The -channel graviton pole receives contributions only from the and blocks, whose allowed tensors for span one direction each, and their sum contains only for . Within this class a singlet graviton therefore requires a massive exchange with for every . The existence of lower-only amplitudes outside this regular Euler class remains open.
Conclusions
The graviton pole constrains the exchanged representations independently of their masses and coupling strengths. For , the lower-isospin tensors form a basis, so there is no freedom to compensate for a missing nonzero coefficient by adjusting the other exchanges. Crossing and positivity remove the four remaining omissions. This uniquely fixed lower-isospin graviton expansion gives a concrete target for further completeness tests: a condition incompatible with it would force higher isospin, although filling the remaining gaps would require further constraints.
Independently of the above results, we have also numerically tested lower-only exchange for in both and . In every case, we found positive residue sums satisfying all independent crossing nulls through total Taylor degree twelve, together with a finite set of smeared twice-subtracted relations. These finite tests find no obstruction to . The related code is included as an ancillary Wolfram Language code file.
Our explicit construction is a crossing-symmetric meromorphic four-scalar amplitude whose massless poles factorize through Einstein graviton exchange and whose massive partial-wave residues are nonnegative. It satisfies the standard twice-subtracted bound, yet exchanges only and is a counterexample to the uniform crossing-odd high-energy bound of Ref. [81]. Thus the four-point assumptions used here imply neither every representation in the external tensor product nor that additional bound, which remains an independent additional assumption on the UV behavior.
For , however, we find the regular Euler constructions studied here cannot realize a spectrum. It remains an open question whether more general meromorphic amplitudes can realize this lower-isospin branch, or whether the full bootstrap constraints exclude it.
Acknowledgments
Acknowledgments. The authors would like to thank Yu-tin Huang for discussions and collaboration on related work. The research of LL is supported by the Taiwan NSTC Grant No. 113-2811-M-002-167-MY3 and the Yushan Young Fellowship. LR is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China General Program No. 12475070 and the Beijing Natural Science Foundation International Scientist Project No. IS24014. AI tools were used to assist with the nonvanishing argument in the all- proof, ancillary verification codes, and manuscript editing.
References
Dispersion relations and forward nulls
The graviton relation and crossing nulls follow from the contour identities below. Contours are counterclockwise, and each cutoff includes complete mass levels in both crossed channels.
Conventions and light poles
For integer in a real basis, let be the ordinary orthogonal pair-space projector. Our four-leg ordering is
The reversal of the outgoing pair is only an index convention. For squared mass we use
The angular polynomial is , and the residue convention is
Positive factorization means . With the main-text conversion matrix ,
A massive pole and its crossed partner in component are
Subtract all known massless exchanges in a crossing-symmetric way, so is analytic near . For graviton and gauge exchange,
Representation normalizations are absorbed in the couplings. At fixed its polynomial part is . Thus a contour enclosing and both massless energy poles gives
This includes all three light-exchange channels, not just the Taylor series at . Additional known light poles must be treated on the same contour. Energy-independent scalar exchange gives no source for .
The graviton relation
For , put and define
The inner contour equals , because and the gauge term vanishes. At a massive pole, . Its odd parity compensates the opposite residue signs of the two poles in Eq. (A.5), giving
The standard high-energy condition on the large complex-energy contours removes the outer contour at fixed transfer,
With
the resulting relation is
The vector and any finite massive-pole sum are regular at . If denotes the isospins with unbounded coupled masses, annihilating their rows must also annihilate the graviton:
This high-energy condition is imposed on the tree amplitude itself, not inferred from a bound on the full quantum amplitude [39].
Central moments and their null constraints
Define
The same contour deformation gives
Its denominator differs from Eq. (A.9). For the source-free moments used here, and . Writing and for a rising factorial,
These are finite-cutoff identities. A degree- crossing relation therefore gives
Nonvanishing of the lower-isospin coefficients
The interpolation formula (11) fixes the lower-isospin weights uniquely. This appendix proves that none of them vanishes for integer , and for every half-integer .
The proof strategy is as follows. Crossing symmetry packages all the weights into one polynomial of degree : the weight is read off from the value of at the point , and corresponds to . The vanishing of the weights with tells us the values of at the points ; with the leading coefficient this determines . The task is then to show that exceeds one at the points , all of which lie to the left of the points where is known. The key step rewrites as a sum of simple poles with positive residues. For such a function the position of every root and the sign on every interval are immediate, and two elementary estimates reduce the whole question to three numbers, all larger than one for . The half-integer case is simpler and needs no estimate.
Integer isospin
Throughout, , , and with for . The points with are the lower nodes; the points with are the upper nodes. is the Catalan number.
Step 1: one polynomial for all weights. Applying crossing to the interpolation formula gives [82]
with a polynomial of degree . Hence if and only if , and it suffices to prove
Step 2: what is known about . At the upper nodes the weights vanish, so Eq. (B.1) gives for ; the leading term of the interpolation formula gives the coefficient of in ,
These conditions determine ; the lower weights are never computed.
Step 3: positive-residue form. The data of Step 2 describe at points where it is not needed. To transport this information to the lower nodes, divide by the polynomial whose zeros are exactly the upper nodes. The ratio of two degree- polynomials is a constant plus simple poles, and the known values become the residues:
This is the partial-fraction (barycentric) form of Lagrange interpolation; the constant accounts for the leading coefficient in Eq. (B.3). The residues are positive because the values and the derivatives alternate in the same way, so their ratio has a fixed sign; explicitly, .
Positivity of the residues is the fact that drives the rest of the proof. A sum of simple poles with positive residues decreases strictly on every interval free of poles: on from to , and on each gap from to . Consequently has exactly one root below the upper node and one in each of the gaps between them. These are all roots of : they are real and ordered as .
Step 4: the root lies strictly between and $J+1. The numbers form a probability distribution on the upper nodes with
so . If all the mass sat at the mean , this would vanish exactly at . The spread of the distribution shifts the root to the left, and elementary estimates using the mean and the variance show that it does not reach :
Hence . The open interval contains no integer and therefore no node, so is nonzero at every lower node. Equation (B.2) requires the stronger bound .
Step 5: three values control all nodes. Since all roots of are real, decreases strictly on , and by Rolle’s theorem it rises and then falls between consecutive roots, so its minimum over any closed subinterval of is attained at an endpoint. The lower nodes below satisfy ; those above satisfy . Therefore
Step 6: the three values. Since , the first two values follow from Eq. (B.6) and the elementary bound for :
The third needs no estimate: the leading coefficient of the interpolation formula gives exactly, and Eq. (B.1) turns this into
All three increase with , because the Catalan ratio outgrows the rational prefactors and . At they equal , and , so
and by Eq. (B.1) no lower weight vanishes for . For the bound is below one, and indeed occurs at the four exceptional nodes.
Example. For , Eq. (B.3) gives , and , hence and . The first root is . The lower-node values , , reproduce ; the vanishing is the case .
Half-integer isospin
Let with integer , so . The scalars form a complex multiplet, and the direct and crossed channels initially carry independent coefficients, . The odd- matching equations force a polynomial of degree at most to vanish at nodes, hence identically, so ; the even equations give
The crossing identity now carries the opposite sign, and the vanishing upper weights fix the values of at points:
A polynomial of degree is determined by values, so is the Lagrange interpolant
At a lower node every term of this sum has the same sign: each factor is negative, and counting the negative factors in the denominators gives , which the alternating prescribed values exactly compensate. Therefore
the inequality being strict because the Lagrange weights sum to one while having both signs. Hence . For , and . For , is the line through and , and , give .
Every lower-isospin coefficient is therefore nonzero for every half-integer , in both physical channels.
Crossing nulls for the exceptional representations
Assume that all massive exchanges have . Define
and
These weights are nonnegative on even, odd, and odd spins, respectively. They vanish at spins , , and , and are positive above their last zero. The main-text moments are for even and for odd .
. The coefficient requires unbounded spin in . The two degree-seven crossing nulls are
and
Both right-hand sides are strictly positive because has unbounded spin. The first identity therefore requires with . In the second, the left-hand weight vanishes at , is negative at , and is positive only for even . Hence must occur with .
. The degree-six crossing null is
Here requires unbounded spin in , so . Thus must occur with .
These three identities exclude the omissions. The remaining singlet omission is excluded by Eq. (13), even when higher isospins are present.
The singlet identity and its hierarchy
The identity (15) and the zeros of its spin weights both follow from the residue theorem applied to rational forms with poles of order at two points exchanged by crossing.
The crossing identity at every order
For integer use a real orthonormal basis of dimension , and let , Eq. (A.6), viewed as a matrix from the incoming pair to the outgoing pair , with the convention of Eq. (A.1). Define
is the -channel singlet projection, with , and is the pair-space trace, i.e. the -channel singlet projection: in -channel components , and , the sign being the exchange parity of a pair of isospin . Crossing gives and .
In the variable , a state of isospin , spin and squared mass produces the direct pole at and the crossed pole at , , Eq. (A.5). Contracting its tensor structure as in Eq. (D.1) gives, with and ,
The direct pole feeds only for a singlet, while counts every state with multiplicity ; this is what gives the singlet the opposite sign below.
The functional. Let be the coefficient of in the low-energy expansion of , zero out of range; at fixed total degree all terms share the mass denominator after the dispersive substitution. We need a crossing relation among these coefficients involving only . Restrict to the homogeneous degree- parts, set , and write , , so that and with . Crossing and homogeneity give
The reflection exchanges with , the inversion exchanges with ; high coefficients live at , and the residue theorem transports them to , where crossing acts. Introduce
The poles of order select the coefficients with : with ,
and the numerators are and , so the coefficients of at infinity are and . Hence
the sum stopping because for . The prefactors and make crossing map one form onto the other: by Eq. (D.3) the reflection leaves invariant, so , and the inversion gives , so . The residue theorem for then yields
i.e. .
Spin weights and the singlet conclusion
By Eqs. (D.2) and (A.15), the coefficient of in is , and in the same with replaced by , the sign coming from the crossed pole. Here , of Eq. (A.18) is the coefficient of in . Since throughout, becomes
with the even- and odd-order sums
where for , extracts a power-series coefficient, and the closed forms follow from . For even , with ; for odd , with . Only the singlet coefficient, , is negative. The spin weights are residues of the same type as Eq. (D.4),
Under the factor changes sign and acquires , so the form is invariant and its residues at and are equal. For the numerator has degree at most against in the denominator, so the residue at infinity vanishes and both finite residues are zero: for . Since has degree at most in , these roots and the leading coefficient of Eq. (A.16) fix it:
On the allowed spins, vanishes at the first spins and is positive above them. Altogether,
with mass denominator ; dropping the common positive factor gives Eq. (15). At and , and , recovering Eq. (13), including the unrestricted identity.
Any compact group, including complex matter
The construction used only the invariant pair and the exchange sign of a state of spin . For a real scalar representation of dimension of a compact group , let interchange the factors of and define
A compact group admits an invariant positive metric, so its action is orthogonal in this basis and is invariant. These positive projectors commute with and resolve the pair space into the singlet , the other symmetric states, and the antisymmetric states, even if is reducible or contains other invariant pairs.
With and , the crossing relations and are unchanged. At a pole with residue operator , set and . The direct and crossed weights are and , both weights are . Repeating the computation of the kernel, with for even and , for odd , gives
with the positive residue measure. For , absence of high-spin residues would force all three nonnegative moments to vanish, hence every coupled spin to lie below , contradicting the graviton relation as in the main text. For every exchange is a singlet and the bounded-spin contradiction suffices.
Factorization gives with commuting with ; since is invariant, so is , and receives contributions only from singlet components of . Complex or pseudoreal matter is included by writing and keeping the physical antiparticles: a unitary representation becomes orthogonal on its real components, and for complex dimension the invariant pair is
In this real basis the singlets couple in the neutral channel of the original multiplet. The theorem fixes neither every even spin nor a mass–spin trajectory, and need not identify the towers seen by different scalar probes.
The two-channel obstruction
Within a class of amplitudes built from Euler integrals, we show that massive exchanges confined to force every building block to obey the cutoff in both of its channels, Eq. (E.7), and that for this leaves no room for the singlet graviton pole.
The cutoff in both channels
In units where the common slope is one, so that all poles lie at nonnegative integers, write
with pole-free and
where is finite and the invariant-tensor functions are analytic. The class contains the amplitude (18), with and constant , and any finite sum of polynomially dressed beta functions with nonnegative integer shifts of their arguments. We assume that every massive pole in channel has its residue in .
Residues as Taylor coefficients. The -channel poles of come from the endpoint : a term of the rest of the integrand gives , a simple pole at . To absorb the explicit factors , which equal at this pole, integrate by parts using : each factor becomes the operator on the remaining integrand, which reproduces on . In the block first substitute and , which moves all dependence into . The result is
with polynomials in whose coefficients are analytic near and along the open integration interval. Hence the coefficient of in is
a polynomial in . The block and have no -channel poles for generic .
Separating the two blocks. Fix a forbidden isospin and let the subscript denote the component. By hypothesis for all and all , so the generating function of the residues collapses to its term,
for all and all sufficiently small , where would be the coefficient of a massless pole . At fixed the three terms are exponentials with the distinct rates , and , multiplied by polynomials in . Exponentials with distinct real rates are independent over polynomials. Hence
Conclusion. vanishes near , hence by analyticity on the whole integration interval, and likewise ; the exact representation (E.3) then gives identically, pole-free parts included. Repeating for the -channel poles (endpoint of , and ) and for the -channel poles ( and ),
Only and have a pole at , whose residue is the pure singlet at order . Each block contributes to this coefficient within its own subspace, so
The obstruction for
By Eq. (8), has -components , where is an arbitrary polynomial of degree at most . It lies in iff vanishes at , i.e. iff , the polynomial of Appendix B. Hence and are one-dimensional, spanned by
the sign being absent for because . For these are up to normalization, the tensors of Eq. (18). Writing and comparing components gives at and for , where . For this yields , the solution (7). For the conditions at give , a contradiction. Within the class (E.1)–(E.2), a graviton pole therefore requires a massive exchange with for every , whatever the coefficient functions; Eq. (22) is the instance.
References
- [1]C. Vafa, The String Landscape and the Swampland (2005), arXiv:hep-th/0509212.DOI
- [2]E. Palti, Fortsch. Phys. 67, 1900037 (2019), arXiv:1903.06239.
- [3]J. Polchinski, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 19S1, 145 (2004), arXiv:hep-th/0304042.
- [4]T. Banks and N. Seiberg, Phys. Rev. D 83, 084019 (2011), arXiv:1011.5120.
- [5]D. Harlow and H. Ooguri, Commun. Math. Phys. 383, 1669 (2021), arXiv:1810.05338.
- [6]B. Heidenreich, J. McNamara, M. Montero, M. Reece, T. Rudelius, and I. Valenzuela, JHEP 2021 (09), 203, arXiv:2104.07036.
- [7]A. Adams, N. Arkani-Hamed, S. Dubovsky, A. Nicolis, and R. Rattazzi, JHEP 2006 (10), 014, arXiv:hep-th/0602178.
- [8]N. Arkani-Hamed, T.-C. Huang, and Y.-t. Huang, JHEP 2021 (05), 259, arXiv:2012.15849.
- [9]A. J. Tolley, Z.-Y. Wang, and S.-Y. Zhou, JHEP 2021 (05), 255, arXiv:2011.02400.
- [10]S. Caron-Huot and V. Van Duong, JHEP 2021 (05), 280, arXiv:2011.02957.
- [11]A. Jenkins and D. O’Connell, The Story of O: Positivity constraints in effective field theories (2006), arXiv:hep-th/0609159.DOI
- [12]A. Nicolis, R. Rattazzi, and E. Trincherini, JHEP 2010 (05), 095, erratum: JHEP 11 (2011) 128, arXiv:0912.4258.
- [13]B. Bellazzini, J. Elias Miró, R. Rattazzi, M. Rie- bau, and F. Riva, Phys. Rev. D 104, 036006 (2021), arXiv:2011.00037.
- [14]J. Elias Miró, A. Guerrieri, and M. A. Gümüş, JHEP 2023 (05), 001, arXiv:2210.01502.
- [15]J. Elias Miró, A. Guerrieri, and M. A. Gümüş, The Phases of the Scalar S-Matrix Island (2026), arXiv:2605.06613.arxiv.org/abs/2605.06613
- [16]B. Bellazzini, C. Cheung, and G. N. Remmen, Phys. Rev. D 93, 064076 (2016), arXiv:1509.00851.
- [17]C. Cheung and G. N. Remmen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 118, 051601 (2017), arXiv:1608.02942.
- [18]S. Caron-Huot, Y.-Z. Li, J. Parra-Martinez, and D. Simmons-Duffin, JHEP 2023 (05), 122, arXiv:2201.06602.
- [19]S. Caron-Huot, Y.-Z. Li, J. Parra-Martinez, and D. Simmons-Duffin, Phys. Rev. D 108, 026007 (2023), arXiv:2205.01495.
- [20]Z. Bern, D. Kosmopoulos, and A. Zhiboedov, J. Phys. A 54, 344002 (2021), arXiv:2103.12728.
- [21]B. Bellazzini, JHEP 2017 (02), 034, arXiv:1605.06111.
- [22]C. Zhang and S.-Y. Zhou, Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 201601 (2020), arXiv:2005.03047.
- [23]T. Trott, JHEP 2021 (07), 143, arXiv:2011.10058.
- [24]X. Li, H. Xu, C. Yang, C. Zhang, and S.-Y. Zhou, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 121601 (2021), arXiv:2101.01191.
- [25]V. Chandrasekaran, G. N. Remmen, and A. Shabbarzi-Moghadam, JHEP 2018 (11), 015, arXiv:1804.03153.
- [26]B. Bellazzini, J. Berman, G. Isabella, F. Riva, M. Romano, and F. Sciotti, Positivity with Long-Range Interactions (2025), arXiv:2512.13780.arxiv.org/abs/2512.13780
- [27]C. Beadle, G. Isabella, D. Perrone, S. Ricossa, F. Riva, and F. Serra, JHEP 2025 (06), 209, arXiv:2501.18465.
- [28]C. Beadle, G. Isabella, D. Perrone, S. Ricossa, F. Riva, and F. Serra, JHEP 2025 (08), 188, arXiv:2407.02346.
- [29]C. Pasiecznik, Bootstrapping Gravity with Crossing Symmetric Dispersion Relations (2025), arXiv:2506.09884.arxiv.org/abs/2506.09884
- [30]K. Häring and A. Zhiboedov, SciPost Phys. 16, 034 (2024), arXiv:2202.08280.
- [31]S. Caron-Huot, D. Mazác, L. Rastelli, and D. Simmons-Duffin, JHEP 2021 (07), 110, arXiv:2102.08951.
- [32]B. McPeak, M. Venuti, and A. Vichi, SciPost Phys. 20, 085 (2026), arXiv:2310.06888.
- [33]C. Cheung and G. N. Remmen, Phys. Rev. D 112, 016017 (2025), arXiv:2505.05553.
- [34]C. Eckner, F. Figueroa, and P. Tourkine, Phys. Rev. D 111, 126005 (2025), arXiv:2401.08736.
- [35]X. O. Camanho, J. D. Edelstein, J. Maldacena, and A. Zhiboedov, JHEP 2016 (02), 020, arXiv:1407.0557.
- [36]L.-Y. Chiang, Y.-t. Huang, W. Li, L. Rodina, and H.-C. Weng, JHEP 2022 (03), 063, arXiv:2105.02862.
- [37]J. Berman and N. Geiser, JHEP 2025 (06), 168, arXiv:2412.17902.arxiv.org/abs/2412.17902
- [38]L. Alberte, C. de Rham, S. Jaitly, and A. J. Tolley, Phys. Rev. Lett. 128, 051602 (2022), arXiv:2111.09226.DOI
- [39]K. Häring and A. Zhiboedov, What is the graviton pole made of? (2024), arXiv:2410.21499.arxiv.org/abs/2410.21499
- [40]C. Eckner, F. Figueroa, and P. Tourkine, JHEP 2025 (02), 103, arXiv:2405.21057.DOI
- [41]C. Eckner, F. Figueroa, S. Metayer, and P. Tourkine, Regge trajectories for UV completions of graviton scattering from polynomial boundedness (2025), arXiv:2512.17828.arxiv.org/abs/2512.17828
- [42]Y.-t. Huang, S. Ricossa, F. Riva, and J.-D. Tsai, Phys. Rev. Lett. 137, 041603 (2026), arXiv:2510.07991.DOI
- [43]L. Rodina, A. Tokareva, and Y. Xu, The Real EFThe-dron: A Moment Geometry for the Nonperturbative S-Matrix (2026), arXiv:2610.12615 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2610.12615
- [44]C. Cheung and G. N. Remmen, JHEP 2014 (12), 087, arXiv:1407.7865.DOI
- [45]Y. Hamada, T. Noumi, and G. Shiu, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 051601 (2019), arXiv:1810.03637.DOI
- [46]B. Bellazzini, M. Lewandowski, and J. Serra, Phys. Rev. Lett. 123, 251103 (2019), arXiv:1902.03250.DOI
- [47]N. Arkani-Hamed, Y.-t. Huang, J.-Y. Liu, and G. N. Remmen, JHEP 2022 (03), 083, arXiv:2109.13937.
- [48]J. Henriksson, B. McPeak, F. Russo, and A. Vichi, JHEP 2022 (08), 184, arXiv:2203.08164.DOI
- [49]B. Bellazzini, A. Pomarol, M. Romano, and F. Sciotti, JHEP 2026 (03), 028, arXiv:2507.12535.arxiv.org/abs/2507.12535
- [50]A. Tokareva and Y. Xu, Phys. Rev. D 112, 085020 (2025), arXiv:2502.10375 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2502.10375
- [51]S. Caron-Huot and Y.-Z. Li, JHEP 2025 (02), 115, arXiv:2408.06440.
- [52]Y.-t. Huang and L. W. Lindwasser, Causality and the Equivalence Principle for Higher Energy Scattering (2026), arXiv:2606.27222 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2606.27222
- [53]Y.-t. Huang, J.-Y. Liu, L. Rodina, and Y. Wang, JHEP 2021 (04), 195, arXiv:2008.02293.DOI
- [54]C. Cheung, A. Hillman, and G. N. Remmen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 133, 251601 (2024), arXiv:2406.02665.DOI
- [55]C. Cheung, G. N. Remmen, F. Sciotti, and M. Tarquini, Phys. Rev. Lett. 136, 251601 (2026), arXiv:2508.09246.DOI
- [56]Y.-t. Huang, S.-L. Wan, Z.-H. Wang, and S.-Y. Zhou, Infrared Consistency and the Uniqueness of String Amplitudes (2026), arXiv:2610.02124.arxiv.org/abs/2610.02124
- [57]J. Berman, H. Elvang, and A. Herderschee, JHEP 2024 (03), 021, arXiv:2310.10729.arxiv.org/abs/2310.10729
- [58]J. Berman and H. Elvang, JHEP 2024 (09), 076, arXiv:2406.03543.arxiv.org/abs/2406.03543
- [59]Y.-t. Huang and G. N. Remmen, Phys. Rev. D 106, L021902 (2022), arXiv:2203.00696.DOI
- [60]N. Geiser and L. W. Lindwasser, JHEP 04, 031, arXiv:2210.14920 [hep-th].
- [61]C. Cheung and G. N. Remmen, JHEP 2023 (01), 122, arXiv:2210.12163.DOI
- [62]C. Cheung and G. N. Remmen, Phys. Rev. D 108, 026011 (2023), arXiv:2302.12263.DOI
- [63]C. Cheung and G. N. Remmen, Phys. Rev. D 108, 086009 (2023), arXiv:2308.03833.DOI
- [64]K. Häring and A. Zhiboedov, JHEP 2024 (10), 075, arXiv:2311.13631.DOI
- [65]N. Arkani-Hamed, L. Eberhardt, Y.-t. Huang, and S. Mizera, JHEP 2022 (02), 197, arXiv:2201.11575.
- [66]R. Bhardwaj, M. Spradlin, A. Volovich, and H.-C. Weng, Phys. Rev. D 110, 106016 (2024), arXiv:2406.04410.arxiv.org/abs/2406.04410
- [67]A. Guerrieri, J. Penedones, and P. Vieira, Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 081601 (2021), arXiv:2102.02847.DOI
- [68]J. Albert, W. Knop, and L. Rastelli, JHEP 2025 (02), 157, arXiv:2406.12959.arxiv.org/abs/2406.12959
- [69]J. Berman, H. Elvang, N. Geiser, and L. L. Lin, Bootstrapping Extremal Scalar Amplitudes With and Without Supersymmetry (2024), arXiv:2412.13368.arxiv.org/abs/2412.13368
- [70]J. Berman, H. Elvang, and C. Figueiredo, JHEP 2025 (10), 226, arXiv:2506.25238.
- [71]H. Elvang, A. Herderschee, and R. Morales, JHEP 2026 (07), 105, arXiv:2601.11705.DOI
- [72]C. Cheung, A. Hillman, and G. N. Remmen, Phys. Rev. D 111, 086034 (2025), arXiv:2408.03362.DOI
- [73]N. Arkani-Hamed, C. Cheung, C. Figueiredo, and G. N. Remmen, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132, 091601 (2024), arXiv:2312.07652.
- [74]I. Basile, G. N. Remmen, and G. Staudt, Phys. Rev. D 114, 026001 (2026), arXiv:2603.0485.
- [75]B. Bachu and A. Hillman, Stringy Completions of the Standard Model from the Bottom Up (2022), arXiv:2212.03871.arxiv.org/abs/2212.03871
- [76]S. Caron-Huot, Z. Komargodski, A. Sever, and A. Zhiboedov, JHEP 2017 (10), 026, arXiv:1607.04253.
- [77]L.-Y. Chiang, Y.-t. Huang, and H.-C. Weng, Cornering the Heterotic String (2026), arXiv:2610.12318 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2610.12318
- [78]G. Peng, L. Rodina, A. Tokareva, and Y. Xu, Sampling the Graviton Pole and Deprojecting the Swampland (2026), arXiv:2604.15235.arxiv.org/abs/2604.15235
- [79]A. Hillman, Y.-t. Huang, L. Rodina, and J. Rumbutis, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 061604 (2025), arXiv:2411.04857.DOI
- [80]F. Calisto, C. Cheung, G. N. Remmen, F. Sciotti, and M. Tarquini, Phys. Rev. D 113, 106008 (2026), arXiv:2512.11955.DOI
- [81]F. Calisto, C. Cheung, G. N. Remmen, F. Sciotti, and M. Tarquini, The Equivalence Principle at High Energies Completes the Spectrum (2026), arXiv:2605.20319.arxiv.org/abs/2605.20319
- [82]NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions, Sections 18.26, 18.38, 34.4, and 34.5: Racah polynomials and Wigner 6j identities, accessed October 14, 2026.
- [83]G. Mansfield, JHEP 07, 179, arXiv:2502.20372 [hep-th].arxiv.org/abs/2502.20372