WorksMathematics
Exact multiplicity for a Minkowski-curvature Neumann problem with a step weight
Abstract
The DEG1 challenge asks whether positive solutions of a super-exponential Minkowski-curvature equation are unique for step weights with a single sign change and negative mean. In this paper, we give a Neumann counterexample by studying with , where on and on , with . Using the shooting method, we prove that the positive solution curve has exactly two nondegenerate folds for in a nonempty open region. As increases through the corresponding critical values, the number of positive solutions is successively , , , , and .
Introduction and main result
The DEG1 challenge [1] asks whether the equation
has a unique positive solution under Neumann or periodic boundary conditions when is a step function with one sign change and negative mean. Boscaggin, Feltrin, and Zanolin [2 Corollary 2.1] proved existence for both boundary conditions under hypotheses that cover these weights. They also noted that numerical experiments suggested uniqueness in the super-exponential case [3 Section 4.2].
We give a Neumann counterexample with and two steps of equal length. Consider
where , , and
A positive solution is a function with and on , whose flux is absolutely continuous and which satisfies (1) almost everywhere. We denote the number of distinct positive solutions by .
Multiplicity results for indefinite Minkowski-curvature equations include pairs of positive radial Neumann solutions for power nonlinearities [4] and positive periodic and subharmonic solutions [5]. Shooting methods have also been used to study multiplicity for radial Neumann problems [6].
Ma, Su, and Zhao [7] studied the Neumann problem
with an integrable weight allowed to change sign. Under suitable growth conditions on , they obtained at least two positive solutions for sufficiently large . For the same form of equation on , Su, Ma, and Yang [8] fixed a continuous sign-changing weight and used bifurcation methods to establish the existence of -shaped connected components of positive solutions as the overall multiplier varies. In (1) we fix the positive coefficient and vary the negative one through the ratio . This lets us study how the number of positive solutions changes with the balance between the two steps.
In the semilinear setting, Feltrin and Sovrano [9 Theorem 1.1] used shooting to obtain at least three positive Neumann solutions for under their assumptions. Feltrin, Sovrano, and Tellini [10 Section 1] studied solution counts for with Neumann conditions and a step weight having two positive intervals separated by a negative one. Exact multiplicity and bifurcation curves for autonomous Minkowski-curvature Dirichlet problems were studied in [11, 12]. In particular, Huang and Wang [13 Theorem 4] studied the autonomous perturbed Gelfand problem
They used a time map relating the maximum of a positive solution to the half-length to classify the shape of the curve as and vary. In particular, the curve has exactly two turning points when is above a threshold and is sufficiently large. For nonautonomous Dirichlet problems, -shaped connected components and more complicated bifurcation curves have been obtained in [14, 15].
For in the open region of Theorem 1.1, matching the trajectories across the jump in the weight gives exactly one for each initial value . The resulting graph parametrizes all positive solutions of (1.1). A uniform expansion on bounded amplitude intervals gives two nondegenerate folds. A variational estimate proves strict monotonicity at large amplitudes, excluding further folds on the unbounded part of the graph. Counting intersections with the lines of constant then gives the exact number of positive solutions for every in this regime.
Theorem 1.1. There exist constants and such that, for every
there are unique critical values such that, for every ,
The functions and are smooth on . For each fixed , the set of positive solutions is a single smooth curve parametrized by . Its projection onto the -axis has exactly two critical points, both nondegenerate. At each critical value precisely one solution is degenerate, with a one-dimensional kernel for the linearized Neumann problem. Every other positive solution is nondegenerate.
For any and , the weight has one sign change and integral . The three positive solutions therefore disprove uniqueness in the Neumann part of the DEG1 challenge. Uniqueness is recovered for .
Section 2 constructs the global shooting curve. Section 3 analyzes its shape and proves the main theorem. Section 4 derives the critical-value asymptotics and illustrates the curve numerically.
The global shooting curve
Throughout the paper, set
Thus and . With , problem (1.1) becomes
For each finite initial condition, bounds on , and the equation for then bounds . Thus neither state variable can escape to infinity in finite time. Applying the continuation criterion [16 Corollary 2.16] to each autonomous system gives existence throughout by concatenation at . Both vector fields are smooth, so their flows depend smoothly on the initial data and parameters by [16 Theorem 2.11]. The composition preserves this smooth dependence.
Lemma 2.1. Every positive solution of (1.1) satisfies
Moreover,
Proof. The sign assertions in (7) follow from [3 Section 2.1, Eqs. (2.5)–(2.6)] with , , and . Integrating the equation for gives the ratio in (8). It is greater than one because is strictly increasing and for . □
We now fix . The following condition ensures that every positive initial value can be used for shooting:
Lemma 2.2. Assume (9). For every , the solution of the first-half system in (2.2) with and is positive on . In particular,
Proof. If , then for , since . Suppose that and that has a first zero in . Before this zero, and . Consequently,
which is impossible at the first zero. □
Proposition 2.3. Assume (9). For each , there is exactly one for which the solution of (2.2) with is positive and satisfies . The function is smooth, and its graph parametrizes all positive solutions.
For fixed , let
where the dependence on is suppressed. At every positive solution,
Proof. Fix and use (10) as initial data for the second half of the trajectory. In this proof only, time on that half is measured from zero. We use the energy identity and time quadrature for the negative step from [3 Section 2.1, Eqs. (2.7)–(2.8)]. In our notation, the conserved quantity is
A positive stopping point therefore satisfies
Such a point exists precisely when
In that case it is unique and belongs to . The trajectory has and before reaching . Solving (13) for gives its stopping time:
The singularity at is of order , so this time is finite. The stopping event is transverse because .
To prove strict monotonicity in , write on the second half-interval. Then and , with . The derivatives and satisfy
On the positive trajectory, this is a cooperative linear system with a strictly positive forcing in its second equation. Hence and for . Differentiating yields
As , equation (14) gives . The integrand in (16), extended by zero to , converges pointwise on to
Since at zero, this limit is asymptotic to a positive constant times . Fatou’s lemma gives . As , we have , and integration of gives . Thus there is exactly one with . The resulting solution is positive on the whole interval, and Lemma 2.1 shows that . Conversely, every positive Neumann solution must stop in this way.
At a matched trajectory, (17), evaluated at the fixed right-hand time , gives . The ordinary implicit function theorem therefore gives smooth dependence of on , and also on as long as (9) holds. Uniqueness identifies the local implicit functions with the global curve just constructed.
Lemma 2.4. Under (9),
Proof. For , the first half of the trajectory satisfies and , where . It follows that
For all sufficiently large , this gives . On we have , whereas on we have . Applying (8), we obtain
The last limit follows from .
Proof of the main theorem
By Proposition 2.3, for fixed and , counting positive solutions amounts to counting the initial values for which . We first analyze the leading term of the shooting curve on bounded intervals. We then prove that the two critical points persist and that the curve is strictly increasing for , so these are its only turning points. The two endpoint limits and the three monotone branches give the exact count, and the linearized shooting equation identifies the degenerate solutions.
The reduced shooting curve
A uniform expansion on bounded amplitude intervals
Define, for and ,
and set . An integral representation that will be useful below is
The reduced shooting function is
Proposition 3.1. Let and let be a compact interval. For sufficiently small , uniformly for , the shooting function extends smoothly to , with . There is a constant such that
Here has a smooth extension to , and
The function itself extends smoothly to , where its value is .
Proof. Put and write and . For , the normalized equations are
where on and on . Let for , with the smooth positive extension . The identities
remove the apparent singularities at . Thus the two vector fields in (26) are smooth in near the compact parameter set under consideration.
At the solution is
Smooth dependence [16 Theorem 2.11], applied successively on the two half-intervals, provides a common neighborhood of in which the flow exists up to and depends smoothly on all parameters. For its terminal value , we have
The implicit function theorem and compactness therefore yield a single smooth function , defined for , , and small, with . At , equations (26)–(27) give for every such , and hence . For and small positive , the normalized solution has . After also imposing (2.5), Proposition 2.3 identifies with .
We compute the derivative with respect to at zero. Fix and put . Along the implicit branch, let and , where the subscript denotes the parameter, not differentiation. At ,
Since , its parameter derivative satisfies
Rescaling (2.4) to and differentiating gives
The second equality follows by changing the order of integration on each half-interval.
The quotient extends smoothly to zero and . Writing proves smooth extendibility at and (3.5). Taylor’s formula now gives
where
is smooth on a neighborhood of the compact set. Its first two -derivatives are uniformly bounded, proving (3.4). Equation (3.10) also proves the final assertion.
Two critical points of the reduced curve
We first record the one-variable identities underlying the shape of . Set
with and .
Lemma 3.2. The function is smooth at zero and strictly decreasing on . It satisfies
and
In particular, there is a unique such that , and .
Proof. Differentiating (22) yields
This is a weighted average of , which proves the strict inequalities in (32). The formula for also gives
Taking a logarithmic derivative of proves (33); its right-hand side is negative. The expansion of at zero proves smoothness and . Finally, dominated convergence in (22) gives as . Equation (34) then implies .
The equation
has exactly one positive root, and . Indeed, is strictly convex, vanishes at zero, has negative derivative there, and changes sign between 1 and 2. Consequently,
A direct differentiation of gives
Combining this identity with (23) yields
Proposition 3.3. There exists such that, for every , the function has exactly two critical points
They are nondegenerate, with
The functions and are smooth on .
Proof. By (38), the critical points correspond to the positive zeros of
There are no zeros for , by (36).
Choose so small that and
Next choose , and set . By Lemma 3.2, we can choose a fixed with .
For the first zero, use the coordinate and consider
As ,
The limit has exactly one zero, , and its derivative there is negative. To see that the same exact count holds for , choose a closed interval around on which is bounded above by a negative constant. Outside this interval, has a positive lower bound. The convergence gives one strictly decreasing zero inside the interval and no zeros outside. For sufficiently large , the whole range corresponds to . If but , then
Thus there is exactly one zero in , and its sign change is from positive to negative.
On , the function has a positive minimum, while uniformly. Hence throughout this interval for large $L.
On , differentiation and (33) give, with ,
The right-hand side tends uniformly to zero. Together with (41), this implies for all sufficiently large . We already know that , whereas . There is therefore exactly one zero in this last interval, with sign change from negative to positive.
These intervals cover , and both zeros are simple. Since the prefactor in (38) is positive for , the conclusions in (39) follow. Smoothness of the two critical points is a consequence of the implicit function theorem and their uniqueness.
The two folds of the shooting curve
Strict monotonicity at large amplitudes
The preceding expansion controls only bounded intervals of . We next establish a uniform estimate on the remaining half-line.
Proposition 3.4. Let . There exists such that, for and , the global shooting curve is defined and
Proof. Choose small enough that (2.5) holds for every . Fix and write for the positive solution on the shooting curve. Since ,
The logarithmic derivative satisfies
because in this range.
We differentiate along the shooting curve, keeping fixed:
On the first half-interval these are also the fixed- derivatives, since the left equation does not involve . They satisfy
Before a first possible zero of , we have and . Moreover, and (47) give , hence . On this half-interval , so
The constant
is finite: the ratio is continuous and tends to zero at infinity. Since and , we have . Decrease so that . Estimate (50) then excludes a first zero of and gives
Set
Since on the first half-interval,
Suppose, by contradiction, that , and put . On the second half-interval the total derivatives in (48) satisfy
On any interval starting at on which , the function is decreasing. If , then and (47) give . If , the same inequality follows from . Thus as long as remains positive. Because , (55) gives . Integrating yields
Here (54) and are used. By continuity, this estimate excludes a first zero of on . At , it gives . But the identity implies . The contradiction proves (45).
Persistence of the two critical points
Lemma 3.5. Let be as in Proposition 3.3, and let be a compact interval. For all sufficiently small , uniformly for , the function has exactly two critical points on , denoted by
They are nondegenerate, and
Furthermore,
uniformly for .
Proof. Define
using the local extension from Proposition 3.1 when . This function is smooth on a neighborhood of , and
The functions are continuous on , are separated from each other and from the endpoints , and satisfy the strict second-derivative inequalities in (3.19). Compactness therefore gives such that the intervals
are disjoint and contained in , and
for every . On the compact complement of the interiors of these two moving intervals, has a positive lower bound. By (3.39), the derivative has the same sign as on this complement, is strictly decreasing on , and is strictly increasing on , once is small. The endpoint signs on each interval are opposite. Thus has exactly one zero in each interval and no other zeros in . Both zeros are simple.
Proposition 3.4 excludes every further critical point for , after decreasing the upper bound for if necessary. This proves (3.37) and nondegeneracy. The implicit function theorem applied to gives smooth dependence of the critical points on up to . Their -derivatives are uniformly bounded on a smaller compact parameter neighborhood, which proves (3.38).
Exact multiplicity and nondegeneracy
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Choose and apply Lemma 3.5 with . Take small enough for that lemma, Propositions 3.1 and 3.4, and condition (2.5) to hold uniformly on . For , set and define
The first point is a strict local maximum and the second a strict local minimum. By (2.4) and (3.37),
Proposition 3.1 and Lemma 2.4 give
The three strictly monotone pieces of the shooting curve consequently have ranges
when their turning-point endpoints are omitted. Counting intersections with a horizontal line, and counting a turning point only once, yields (4). Proposition 2.3 ensures that these intersections account for all positive solutions. The same description proves uniqueness of the pair . Smoothness of the critical values follows from the smooth critical-point functions and the change of variables .
It remains to relate the turning points to the linearized boundary value problem. For fixed , use the shooting function from (11). On the positive solution curve,
The linearized equation at a positive solution is
It is understood with continuous and across . Since is continuous and strictly positive, this is equivalent to continuity of . Every solution of the linearized equation satisfying the left Neumann condition is a scalar multiple of the fixed- initial-value variation with . For this variation,
since and . Thus the linearized Neumann problem has a nonzero solution if and only if , or equivalently . At either critical point its kernel is one-dimensional; elsewhere it is trivial.
Let be one of the two critical initial values and let . Differentiating the shooting identity twice at gives
Equivalently, the local solution curve has the form
where . The smooth local coordinate therefore puts the projection into the normal form
This is a nondegenerate fold. The parameterization by is regular as a curve of functions because its derivative has value at . At each critical value, the other solution lies on a strictly monotone part of the curve and is nondegenerate.
Critical-value asymptotics and numerical illustration
The reduced function also gives the first-order locations of the two critical parameter values.
Corollary 4.1. Let be a compact interval. For and sufficiently small , define the critical values by (3.40), using Lemma 3.5. Uniformly for , as ,
In particular,
Proof. Substitute (3.38) into (3.4). The functions and their first derivatives are uniformly bounded on . This gives (4.1), and subtraction gives (4.2).
Proposition 4.2. Let and be defined by and (3.15), respectively. The reduced critical points satisfy
Their critical values satisfy
Proof. In the first part of the proof of Proposition 3.3, the zero converges to . Thus . For the second zero, belongs to a fixed neighborhood of and satisfies . Since is the only zero of in that neighborhood, . Now as , so
For the second value, , and
This proves (4.4).
Remark 4.3. The two limiting procedures above are distinct. Corollary 4.1 is uniform for in a fixed compact interval, whereas Proposition 4.2 concerns the reduced function as . A joint limit in which is unbounded and would require additional uniform estimates.
For numerical illustration, Figure 1 shows a portion of the shooting curve for .
Figure 1. Numerical shooting curve for (1.1) with . The markers and indicate the local minimum and maximum, respectively, of as a function of .
For each sampled , we solve numerically for using the shooting function (11). OpenAI Codex assisted in writing the code for this computation and the plot. The curve was computed with SciPy and plotted with Matplotlib. The two turning points of the computed curve lie at and .
Declaration of generative AI use
The author used OpenAI Codex to assist with the organization and English-language editing of the manuscript, the review of references and mathematical derivations, and the preparation of the numerical shooting and plotting code for Figure 1. The author reviewed and revised the material prepared with this assistance and takes full responsibility for the content of the article.
References
- [1]DEG1, DEG1 challenges, entry on uniqueness for a super-exponential Minkowski-curvature equation. https://deg1.uniud.it/challenges.html.
- [2]A. Boscaggin, G. Feltrin, and F. Zanol in, Positive solutions for a Minkowski-curvature equation with indefinite weight and super-exponential nonlinearity, Commun. Contemp. Math. 25 (2023), no. 4, Paper No. 2250005, 20 pp. doi:10.1142/S0219199722500055.DOI
- [3]A. Boscaggin, G. Feltrin, and F. Zanol in, Uniqueness of positive solutions for boundary value problems associated with indefinite φ-Laplacian-type equations, Open Math. 19 (2021), no. 1, 163–183. doi:10.1515/math-2021-0003.
- [4]A. Boscaggin and G. Feltrin, Pairs of positive radial solutions for a Minkowski-curvature Neumann problem with indefinite weight, Nonlinear Anal. 196 (2020), Paper No. 111807, 14 pp. doi:10.1016/j.na.2020.111807.DOI
- [5]A. Boscaggin and G. Feltrin, Positive periodic solutions to an indefinite Minkowski-curvature equation, J. Differential Equations 269 (2020), no. 7, 5595–5645. doi:10.1016/j.jde.2020.04.009.DOI
- [6]A. Boscaggin, F. Colasuonno, and B. Noris, Positive radial solutions for the Minkowski-curvature equation with Neumann boundary conditions, Discrete Contin. Dyn. Syst. Ser. S 13 (2020), no. 7, 1921–1933. doi:10.3934/dcdss.2020150.DOI
- [7]R. Ma, X. Su, and Z. Zhao, Global structure of positive solutions for a Neumann problem with indefinite weight in Minkowski space, J. Fixed Point Theory Appl. 25 (2023), no. 2, Paper No. 43. doi:10.1007/s11784-023-01047-x.DOI
- [8]X. Su, R. Ma, and W. Yang, S-shaped connected components of positive solutions for Minkowski-curvature Neumann problems with indefinite weight, J. Math. Phys. 66 (2025), no. 7, Paper No. 071510. doi:10.1063/5.0239395.DOI
- [9]G. Feltrin and E. Sovrano, Three positive solutions to an indefinite Neumann problem: a shooting method, Nonlinear Anal. 166 (2018), 87–101. doi:10.1016/j.na.2017.10.006.DOI
- [10]G. Feltrin, E. Sovrano, and A. Tellini, On the number of positive solutions to an indefinite parameter-dependent Neumann problem, Discrete Contin. Dyn. Syst. 42 (2022), no. 1, 21–71. doi:10.3934/dcds.2021107.
- [11]S.-Y. Huang, Exact multiplicity and bifurcation curves of positive solutions of a one-dimensional Minkowski-curvature problem and its application, Commun. Pure Appl. Anal. 17 (2018), no. 3, 1271–1294. doi:10.3934/cpaa.2018061.DOI
- [12]S.-Y. Huang, Global bifurcation and exact multiplicity of positive solutions for the one-dimensional Minkowski-curvature problem with sign-changing nonlinearity, Commun. Pure Appl. Anal. 18 (2019), no. 6, 3267–3284. doi:10.3934/cpaa.2019147.DOI
- [13]S.-Y. Huang and S.-H. Wang, Bifurcation curves for the one-dimensional perturbed Gelfand problem with the Minkowski-curvature operator, J. Differential Equations 416 (2025), 700–726. doi:10.1016/j.jde.2024.10.002.DOI
- [14]R. Ma and M. Xu, S-shaped connected component for a nonlinear Dirichlet problem involving mean curvature operator in one-dimension Minkowski space, Bull. Korean Math. Soc. 55 (2018), no. 6, 1891–1908. KCI record.
- [15]Y.-H. Lee, I. Sim, and R. Yang, Repeated S-shaped and Σ-shaped bifurcation curves for the one-dimensional non-autonomous Minkowski-curvature problem, J. Math. Anal. Appl. 539 (2024), no. 2, Paper No. 128548. doi:10.1016/j.jmaa.2024.128548.DOI
- [16]G. Teschl, Ordinary Differential Equations and Dynamical Systems, Graduate Studies in Mathematics, vol. 140, American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 2012. doi:10.1090/gsm/140.DOI
