betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Galois conjugation, droplet growth, and the differential transcendence of the Ising model in nonzero field

Abstract

The square-lattice Ising model is exactly solvable in zero magnetic field, but the scope of exact solutions at nonzero field remains unresolved. We show that, at every fixed dimensionless field H=h/(kBT)≠0H=h/(k_BT)\ne 0, its free energy and magnetization obey no algebraic differential equation in the coupling K=J/(kBT)K=J/(k_BT). This excludes Onsager-type formulas and broad classes of special-function expressions. Previous work left open a countable set of fields with algebraic-integer fugacities. We eliminate these exceptions using Galois conjugation and the large-order growth of droplets of reversed spins. At conjugate fugacities outside the unit circle, nearly square droplets produce coefficient growth incompatible with an algebraic differential equation. We prove that cancellations cannot remove this growth in the full pressure series. The free-energy result also holds for the Lieb lattice and square lattices with equal-length chain decorations and uniform coupling and field. In every dimension d≥2d\ge2, we additionally resolve fields for which e−2∣H∣e^{-2|H|} has a real algebraic conjugate greater than one.

Introduction

It is a long-standing question whether the free energy of the Ising model in a magnetic field can be written in closed form. The model in a field is the simplest system in which to study how integrable models relate to the generic, nonintegrable models that describe experiments [1]. The expected natural boundary of the zero-field susceptibility [2, 3, 4, 5] and the zeros of the partition function in a field [6] suggest that a closed form is very hard to find, if it exists at all.

In a sharp form of the question we ask whether the free energy obeys an algebraic differential equation in the coupling, because the familiar forms of exact solutions all do [1, 5, 7, 8, 9]. We write K=J/(kBT)K = J/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T) for the dimensionless coupling and H=h/(kBT)H = h/(k_{\mathrm{B}}T) for the dimensionless field, and we vary KK at fixed HH. A cooling path at fixed JJ and hh instead keeps H/K=h/JH/K = h/J fixed. Closed forms built by arithmetic operations and composition from elliptic, hypergeometric, or Painlevé functions with fixed parameters, with arguments that are differentially algebraic in KK, obey such equations as well [7, 10, 11].

It was recently shown that the free energy in a field obeys no algebraic differential equation in KK, at every fixed HH outside a countable set and in every dimension d≥2d \ge2 [12]. The obstruction comes from droplets of reversed spins. On the square lattice an r×rr \times r droplet contributes u2rzr2u^{2r}z^{r^2} to the low-temperature series in u=e−4Ku = e^{-4K}, where z=e−2Hz = e^{-2H} is the fugacity. At a rational fugacity z=A/Bz = A/B these droplets force the coefficient of u2ru^{2r} to have a denominator divisible by Br2B^{r^2}, which grows too fast for a solution of an algebraic differential equation [13, 14, 15, 16].

The exceptional set consists of the fields whose fugacity is an algebraic integer, a root of a monic polynomial with integer coefficients. At such a fugacity the droplets produce no denominators, and the argument of [12] cannot be applied. Hence a closed form at a nonzero real field could occur only at such a fugacity. The set is countable, but it is dense in (0,1)(0,1) and contains, for instance, the golden-ratio fugacity z=(5−1)/2z = (\sqrt{5} - 1)/2. In this work we focus on these exceptions.

We resolve them completely on the square lattice and on decorated square lattices, and partially in every dimension. To do so we evaluate the low-temperature series at the Galois conjugates of the fugacity, the other roots of its minimal polynomial. Our results are the following.

  1. On the square lattice, at every fixed nonzero real field, the free energy and the magnetization obey no algebraic differential equation on any interval of the coupling. Solutions of Onsager’s type [12] and closed forms in elliptic, hypergeometric, or Painlevé functions with fixed parameters are therefore impossible at every nonzero field.

  1. The free energies of the Lieb lattice and of every square lattice whose bonds are replaced by chains of equal length, with uniform coupling and field, obey no algebraic differential equation at any nonzero real field either. In zero field these free energies follow from Onsager’s solution [17]. In a nonzero field their effective fugacity varies with the temperature, so the square-lattice results do not apply to them, and we prove the result at every nonzero real field, including the fields whose fugacity is not an algebraic integer.

  1. In every dimension d≥2d \ge2, we use a positivity argument to show that the formal low-temperature series at every real fugacity z>1z > 1, where the field favors minus spins, obeys no algebraic differential equation. Consequently, the free energy on Zd\mathbb{Z}^d obeys no algebraic differential equation at every algebraic fugacity with a real conjugate larger than one, a dense set of fields.

We use the same square droplets as at rational fugacities, but we measure their weights with a different absolute value. Besides the ordinary absolute value, a number has an ℓ\ell-adic absolute value for each prime ℓ\ell, which is large when a high power of ℓ\ell divides its denominator [18]. A nonzero algebraic number that is not a root of unity has either an ℓ\ell-adic absolute value larger than one or a Galois conjugate of modulus larger than one [18, 19]. The first case gives the denominators of [12]. At an algebraic integer α∈(0,1)\alpha\in(0,1) all ℓ\ell-adic absolute values are at most one, but some conjugate β\beta obeys ∣β∣>1|\beta| > 1. A power series with coefficients in the field Q(α)\mathbb{Q}(\alpha) that obeys an algebraic differential equation obeys one with coefficients in that field [20], and Galois conjugation maps it to an equation for the conjugated series. By Maillet’s theorem, the coefficients of every power-series solution of such an equation are bounded by a power of a factorial [21, 22]. The conjugated series has the coefficients of the low-temperature series evaluated at the fugacity β\beta, where the weight β∣S∣\beta^{|S|} of a droplet SS grows with its area. For real β>1\beta> 1 it is the formal low-temperature expansion of the plus phase in a field that favors minus spins, in which large droplets dominate, as in the nucleation of a metastable phase [23]. It is shown in [24, 25] that at low temperature large droplets make the kkth derivative of the free energy with respect to the field grow like (k!)d/(d−1)(k!)^{d/(d-1)} at H=0H = 0, so that the free energy has no analytic continuation across H=0H = 0.

Prellberg and Owczarek [26] showed that, for every fixed (q>1)(q > 1), near-square convex polygons determine the leading large-perimeter asymptotics of the sum over all square-lattice self-avoiding polygons weighted by (qarea)(q^{\mathrm{area}}). This ensemble models inflated lattice vesicles [27]. The same pattern is observed in [28] for the low-temperature expansion of the Ising model in a field. We show that it holds exactly for the full free energy, in which droplets with holes and all Mayer clusters also contribute, and that all other droplets and clusters are negligible at every complex fugacity outside the unit circle, not only at real q>1q > 1, where the argument of [26] uses the positivity of the weights. The generating function of the near-square droplets is a theta function times the fourth power of the partition generating function [26], and by Jacobi’s triple product it has no zeros in the unit disk [10]. Hence the near-square droplets cannot cancel at any conjugate, and the coefficients of the conjugated series grow like ∣β∣r2|\beta|^{r^2}, too fast for Maillet’s bound.

Combining this argument with [12], we find that the formal low-temperature series of the square lattice obeys no algebraic differential equation at any complex fugacity other than zero and the roots of unity. The only real roots of unity are z=1z = 1 and z=−1z = -1, the two fugacities at which the free energy is known [17, 29]. In Sec. II we recall the argument of [12] and explain why it fails at algebraic integers. In Sec. III we prove our result at algebraic-integer fugacities on the square lattice. In Sec. IV we treat real conjugates in every dimension and coupled layers, in Sec. V we treat decorated lattices, and in Sec. VI we discuss the physical meaning of our results and the open questions.

Droplets and denominators

In this section we summarize the argument of [12] for fugacities that are not algebraic integers. We consider the Ising model on the square lattice Z2\mathbb{Z}^2, with spins σi=±1\sigma_i = \pm1 and Hamiltonian

H=−J∑⟨ij⟩σiσj−h∑iσi,J>0,(1)\mathcal{H}=-J\sum_{\langle ij\rangle}\sigma_i\sigma_j-h\sum_i\sigma_i,\qquad J>0, \tag*{(1)}

where ⟨ij⟩\langle ij\rangle runs over the nearest-neighbor bonds. Spin reversal maps hh to −h-h, so we take h>0h > 0. The dimensionless pressure p(K,H)=lim⁡N→∞N−2log⁡ZNp(K,H)=\lim_{N\to\infty}N^{-2}\log Z_N of N×NN\times N boxes, which gives the free energy per site f=−kBTpf=-k_{\mathrm B}Tp, has the low-temperature expansion [30]

p=2K+H+Φ(u,z),Φ(u,z)=∑m≥2Lm(z)um,(2)p=2K+H+\Phi(u,z),\qquad\Phi(u,z)=\sum_{m\geq2}L_m(z)u^m, \tag*{(2)}

where 2K+H2K+H is the pressure of the fully aligned state. Relative to that state, a set SS of reversed spins with ∣∂S∣|\partial S| boundary bonds has the Boltzmann weight um(S)z∣S∣u^{m(S)}z^{|S|} with m(S)=∣∂S∣/2m(S)=|\partial S|/2 [31], so uu is the weight of two broken bonds and zz that of one reversed spin. A single reversed spin has ∣∂S∣=4|\partial S|=4, and every nonempty SS has ∣∂S∣≥4|\partial S|\geq4, since its leftmost, rightmost, lowest, and highest sites each have a boundary bond pointing out of SS. Hence m(S)≥2m(S)\geq2, and the sum in (2) starts at m=2m=2. For every ∣z∣<1|z|<1 the series (2) converges near u=0u=0 to the physical Φ\Phi, and its sum is analytic in (u,z)(u,z) jointly, which was shown with the Lee–Yang circle theorem [12, 29].

A function Φ(u)\Phi(u) is differentially algebraic if it obeys

∑μ,νcμ,νuμ∏j=0s(∂ujΦ)νj=0(3)\sum_{\mu,\nu}c_{\mu,\nu}u^\mu\prod_{j=0}^{s}\left(\partial_u^j\Phi\right)^{\nu_j}=0 \tag*{(3)}

for some order ss, with finitely many nonnegative integer exponents μ\mu and ν=(ν0,…,νs)\nu=(\nu_0,\ldots,\nu_s) and complex coefficients cμ,νc_{\mu,\nu}, not all zero. Otherwise Φ\Phi is differentially transcendental [32]. Differentially algebraic functions are closed under arithmetic operations and composition [11], so differential algebraicity in uu and in KK are equivalent. The pressure is real analytic in (K,H)(K,H) jointly for K>0K>0 and H≠0H\ne0 [33], so at fixed H≠0H\ne0 an equation (3) on a short interval of KK extends to all K>0K>0, and then to the series (2) near u=0u=0 [12]. It therefore suffices to show that, at fixed zz, the series (2) obeys no equation (3).

To describe the coefficients LmL_m, we call the connected components of SS its droplets. In an a×ba\times b box Λa,b\Lambda_{a,b} with plus boundary spins,

Pa,b(u,z)=∑S⊆Λa,bum(S)z∣S∣∈Z[u,z],Pa,b(0,z)=1,(4)P_{a,b}(u,z)=\sum_{S\subseteq\Lambda_{a,b}}u^{m(S)}z^{|S|}\in\mathbb{Z}[u,z],\qquad P_{a,b}(0,z)=1, \tag*{(4)}

is the partition function of a gas of droplets with hard-core exclusion, because the droplets of one configuration neither overlap nor touch [34]. Its logarithm is the Mayer expansion [35, 36, 37]

log⁡Pa,b=∑k≥11k!∑γ1,…,γkφT(γ1,…,γk)∏i=1kum(γi)z∣γi∣.(5)\log P_{a,b}=\sum_{k\geq1}\frac{1}{k!}\sum_{\gamma_1,\ldots,\gamma_k}\varphi^T(\gamma_1,\ldots,\gamma_k)\prod_{i=1}^{k}u^{m(\gamma_i)}z^{|\gamma_i|}. \tag*{(5)}

Two droplets are incompatible when they share a site or contain neighboring sites, and every droplet is incompatible with itself. The truncated function φT\varphi^T is the sum of (−1)∣E(G)∣(-1)^{|E(G)|} over the connected graphs GG on the labels 1,…,k1,\ldots,k whose edges join incompatible droplets. A list of droplets with φT≠0\varphi^T\ne0 is a Mayer cluster. Repeats are allowed, and a single droplet is a Mayer cluster with φT=1\varphi^T=1. Counting the translates of Mayer clusters in the box, we have [12]

Lm(z)=∑c1k!φT(γ1,…,γk)z∑i∣γi∣,(6)L_m(z)=\sum_c\frac{1}{k!}\varphi^T(\gamma_1,\ldots,\gamma_k)z^{\sum_i|\gamma_i|}, \tag*{(6)}

where cc runs over the finitely many classes of Mayer clusters with ∑im(γi)=m\sum_i m(\gamma_i)=m under translations. Since Pa,bP_{a,b} has integer coefficients and Pa,b(0,z)=1P_{a,b}(0,z)=1, the logarithmic derivative u∂ulog⁡Pa,bu\partial_u\log P_{a,b} has integer coefficients, so m[um]log⁡Pa,b∈Z[z]m[u^m]\log P_{a,b}\in\mathbb{Z}[z]. The union of the droplets of each class in (6) has a bounding box w×hw\times h with w,h≤mw,h\leq m, which has (a−w+1)(b−h+1)(a-w+1)(b-h+1) translates in Λa,b\Lambda_{a,b}. For a,b≥ma,b\geq m the coefficient [um]log⁡Pa,b[u^m]\log P_{a,b} is therefore a polynomial of degree one in each of aa and bb, with the coefficient LmL_m of abab, and with Δaf(a)=f(a+1)−f(a)\Delta_a f(a)=f(a+1)-f(a) we obtain [12]

mLm=ΔaΔb(m[um]log⁡Pa,b)∈Z[z].(7)mL_m=\Delta_a\Delta_b\left(m[u^m]\log P_{a,b}\right)\in\mathbb{Z}[z]. \tag*{(7)}

References

  1. [1]B. M. McCoy and J.-M. Maillard, The importance of the Ising model, Prog. Theor. Phys. 127, 791 (2012), arXiv:1203.1456.DOI
  2. [2]A. J. Guttmann and I. G. Enting, Solvability of some statistical mechanical systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 76, 344 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10061433
  3. [3]B. G. Nickel, On the singularity structure of the 2D Ising model susceptibility, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 32, 3889 (1999).DOI
  4. [4]B. G. Nickel, Addendum to “On the singularity structure of the 2D Ising model susceptibility”, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 33, 1693 (2000).DOI
  5. [5]W. P. Orrick, B. G. Nickel, A. J. Guttmann, and J. H. H. Perk, The susceptibility of the square lattice Ising model: New developments, J. Stat. Phys. 102, 795 (2001), arXiv:cond-mat/0103074.DOI
  6. [6]M. Assis, J. L. Jacobsen, I. Jensen, J.-M. Maillard, and B. M. McCoy, Analyticity of the Ising susceptibility: an interpretation, J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 50, 365203 (2017), arXiv:1705.02541.
  7. [7]T. T. Wu, B. M. McCoy, C. A. Tracy, and E. Barouch, Spin-spin correlation functions for the two-dimensional Ising model: Exact theory in the scaling region, Phys. Rev. B 13, 316 (1976).
  8. [8]M. Jimbo and T. Miwa, Studies on holonomic quantum fields, XVII, Proc. Japan Acad. Ser. A Math. Sci. 56, 405 (1980).
  9. [9]A. J. Guttmann, I. Jensen, J.-M. Maillard, and J. Pantone, Is the full susceptibility of the square-lattice Ising model a differentially algebraic function?, J. Phys. A: Math. Theor. 49, 504002 (2016), arXiv:1607.04168 [math-ph].DOI
  10. [10]DLMF, NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions, https://dlmf.nist.gov/ (2026), release 1.2.8 of 2026-09-15, edited by F. W. J. Olver, A. B. Olde Daalhuis, D. W. Lozier, B. I. Schneider, R. F. Boisvert, C. W. Clark, B. R. Miller, B. V. Saunders, H. S. Cohl, and M. A. McClain.
  11. [11]R. Ait El Manssour, A.-L. Sattelberger, and B. Teguia Tabuguia, D-algebraic functions, J. Symbolic Comput. 128, 102377 (2025), arXiv:2301.02512 [math.AG].
  12. [12]R. Luo and J. Tian, Droplets obstruct Onsager-type solutions of the Ising model in a magnetic field (2026), arXiv:2610.20569.arxiv.org/abs/2610.20569
  13. [13]G. Pólya, Über das Anwachsen von ganzen Funktionen, die einer Differentialgleichung genügen, Vierteljahrsschr. Naturforsch. Ges. Zürich 61, 531 (1916).
  14. [14]J. Popken, Über arithmetische Eigenschaften analytischer Funktionen, Ph.D. thesis, Rijksuniversiteit Groningen (1935).
  15. [15]Y. Sibuya and S. Sperber, Arithmetic properties of power series solutions of algebraic differential equations, Ann. Math. 113, 111 (1981).DOI
  16. [16]C. Krattenthaler and T. Rivoal, Arithmetic properties of the Taylor coefficients of differentially algebraic power series, Ann. Fac. Sci. Toulouse Math. 35, 617 (2026), arXiv:2502.09259.arxiv.org/abs/2502.09259
  17. [17]L. Onsager, Crystal statistics. I. A two-dimensional model with an order-disorder transition, Phys. Rev. 65, 117 (1944).
  18. [18]J. Neukirch, Algebraic Number Theory, Grundlehren der mathematischen Wissenschaften, Vol. 322 (Springer, Berlin, 1999).
  19. [19]L. Kronecker, Zwei Sätze über Gleichungen mit ganzzahligen Coefficienten, J. Reine Angew. Math. 53, 173 (1857).DOI
  20. [20]K. Mahler, Lectures on Transcendental Numbers, Lecture Notes in Mathematics, Vol. 546 (Springer, Berlin, 1976).
  21. [21]E. Maillet, Sur les séries divergentes et les équations différentielles, Ann. Sci. Éc. Norm. Supér. 20, 487 (1903).DOI
  22. [22]B. Malgrange, Sur le théorème de Maillet, Asymptotic Anal. 2, 1 (1989).DOI
  23. [23]J. S. Langer, Theory of the condensation point, Ann. Phys. (N.Y.) 41, 108 (1967).
  24. [24]S. N. Isakov, Nonanalytic features of the first order phase transition in the Ising model, Commun. Math. Phys. 95, 427 (1984).DOI
  25. [25]S. Friedli and C.-E. Pfister, On the singularity of the free energy at a first order phase transition, Commun. Math. Phys. 245, 69 (2004).
  26. [26]T. Prellberg and A. L. Owczarek, On the asymptotics of the finite-perimeter partition function of two-dimensional lattice vesicles, Commun. Math. Phys. 201, 493 (1999), arXiv:cond-mat/9809156.DOI
  27. [27]M. E. Fisher, A. J. Guttmann, and S. G. Whittington, Two-dimensional lattice vesicles and polygons, J. Phys. A: Math. Gen. 24, 3095 (1991).DOI
  28. [28]K. A. Meissner, D. Ircha, W. Olszewski, J. Ruta, and A. Słapek, Ising model with a magnetic field, J. Stat. Phys. 190, 152 (2023), arXiv:2303.12453 [cond-mat.stat-mech].arxiv.org/abs/2303.12453
  29. [29]T. D. Lee and C. N. Yang, Statistical theory of equations of state and phase transitions. II. Lattice gas and Ising model, Phys. Rev. 87, 410 (1952).
  30. [30]M. F. Sykes, J. W. Essam, and D. S. Gaunt, Derivation of low-temperature expansions for the Ising model of a ferromagnet and an antiferromagnet, J. Math. Phys. 6, 283 (1965).DOI
  31. [31]I. G. Enting, Some algebraic techniques for obtaining low-temperature series expansions, Aust. J. Phys. 31, 515 (1978).DOI
  32. [32]L. A. Rubel, A survey of transcendentally transcendental functions, Amer. Math. Monthly 96, 777 (1989).DOI
  33. [33]S. Ott, Weak mixing and analyticity of the pressure in the Ising model, Commun. Math. Phys. 377, 675 (2020), arXiv:1905.12928 [math.PR].DOI
  34. [34]C. Gruber and H. Kunz, General properties of polymer systems, Commun. Math. Phys. 22, 133 (1971).DOI
  35. [35]J. E. Mayer, The statistical mechanics of condensing systems. I, J. Chem. Phys. 5, 67 (1937).DOI
  36. [36]D. C. Brydges, A short course on cluster expansions, in Critical Phenomena, Random Systems, Gauge Theories (Les Houches, Session XLIII, 1984), edited by K. Osterwalder and R. Stora (North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1986) pp. 129–183.
  37. [37]R. Bissacot, R. Fernández, and A. Procacci, On the convergence of cluster expansions for polymer gases, J. Stat. Phys. 139, 598 (2010), arXiv:1002.3261 [math-ph].DOI
  38. [38]E. R. Kolchin, Differential Algebra and Algebraic Groups (Academic Press, New York, 1973).
  39. [39]R. R. Gontsov and I. V. Goryuchkina, The Maillet–Malgrange type theorem for generalized power series, Manuscripta Math. 156, 171 (2018), arXiv:1601.05778.arxiv.org/abs/1601.05778
  40. [40]O. Penrose, Convergence of fugacity expansions for classical systems, in Statistical Mechanics: Foundations and Applications, edited by T. A. Bak (Benjamin, New York, 1967).
  41. [41]R. Fernández and A. Procacci, Cluster expansion for abstract polymer models. New bounds from an old approach, Commun. Math. Phys. 274, 123 (2007), arXiv:math-ph/0605041.
  42. [42]B. Adamczewski, T. Dreyfus, and C. Hardouin, Hypertranscendence and linear difference equations, J. Amer. Math. Soc. 34, 475 (2021), arXiv:1910.01874.DOI
  43. [43]P. Butera and M. Pernici, Ising low-temperature polynomials and hard-sphere gases on cubic lattices of general dimension, Physica A 444, 220 (2016), arXiv:1510.06172.arxiv.org/abs/1510.06172
  44. [44]D. Ellis, E. Friedgut, G. Kindler, and A. Yehudayoff, Geometric stability via information theory, Discrete Anal. 2016, 10 (2016), arXiv:1510.00258.arxiv.org/abs/1510.00258
  45. [45]M. E. Fisher, Lattice statistics in a magnetic field. I. A two-dimensional super-exchange antiferromagnet, Proc. R. Soc. Lond. A 254, 66 (1960).DOI
  46. [46]J. Strečka and K. Karlová, Thermal phase transitions in a mixed-spin Ising model on the Lieb lattice: Exact results beyond zero magnetic field (2026), arXiv:2607.11661.arxiv.org/abs/2607.11661
  47. [47]E. H. Lieb, Two theorems on the Hubbard model, Phys. Rev. Lett. 62, 1201 (1989).
  48. [48]M. E. Fisher, Transformations of Ising models, Phys. Rev. 113, 969 (1959).DOI
  49. [49]R. Luo and J. Tian, Corner Young diagrams and the differential transcendence of the Ising free energy in a magnetic field (2026), in preparation.

Paper details

vlnc:W_82h7u24p
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 13

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents