betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Theoretical modeling of approximate universality of tidally deformed neutron stars

Abstract

Quasi-universal relations are known to exist among various neutron star observables that do not depend sensitively on the underlying nuclear matter equations of state. For example, some of these relations imply that the tidally induced multipole moments are approximately characterized by the electric-type quadrupolar tidal deformability. Such relations can be used to reduce the number of independent tidal parameters in gravitational-waveform modeling, thereby allowing us to infer extreme nuclear matter properties more accurately and test General Relativity in an insensitive manner to uncertainties in nuclear physics. We present a comprehensive theoretical investigation into approximate universality of neutron stars. Our approach employs a semi-analytic relativistic stellar interior model, which extends the Tolman VII solution, thereby enabling a refined exploration of the tidal properties of nonrotating stars within a semi-analytic framework. The derived power-law relations among various tidal deformabilities – referred to as the universal Love relations – agree well with expressions in previous work found empirically. We elucidate how the equation-of-state dependence is suppressed in a particular combination of macroscopic physical parameters induced by perturbations and demonstrate that the relation between the moment of inertia and electric-type quadrupolar tidal deformability (I-Love relation) rests on the same underlying mechanism. Our findings indicate that the approximate universality of neutron stars can be attributed to low compressibility, consistent with some of the previous studies on the possible origin of the universality.

Introduction and summary

Neutron star physics

Neutron stars (NSs) exhibit a variety of observable phenomena, including gravitational waves (GWs), neutrino emissions, and electromagnetic waves in the broad frequency band. With their rich information channels, NSs serve as powerful probes for addressing outstanding questions in astrophysics, nuclear physics, and fundamental physics. The first detection of GWs from the binary NS merger, GW170817 [1, 2], was accompanied by electromagnetic counterparts, ushering us into the era of multi-messenger astronomy [3]. This event provided evidence that binary NS mergers can be a source of heavy rr-process elements [4] and main engines of short gamma-ray bursts [3].

NSs are the densest objects in the Universe, offering a unique opportunity to explore the properties of matter at supranuclear densities [5, 6, 7]. The central density is a few times the nuclear saturation density ρnuc=2.8×1014 g cm−3\rho_{\mathrm{nuc}} = 2.8 \times10^{14}\ \mathrm{g\ cm}^{-3}, a regime that cannot yet be accessed from the first principles. Determining the equation of state (EoS) of nuclear matter in an extreme environment is one of the outstanding goals in nuclear physics. The NS mass-radius relation is in one-to-one correspondence with the EoS. Therefore, independent accurate measurements of the NS mass and radius with multifaceted observations allow us to determine the EoS. NS masses have been accurately measured through the Shapiro time delay (and other post-Keplerian parameters) in the arrival times of radio pulses emitted by millisecond pulsars [8, 9, 10]. NS radii, together with masses, are determined by the NICER mission using X-ray that is emitted from hot spots on the surfaces of millisecond pulsars [11, 12, 13, 14]. GW observations of binary NSs allow us to constrain the EoS and radii by measuring the stellar tidal deformability [1, 2, 15, 16].

NSs, in the context of fundamental physics, serve as natural laboratories for strong-field tests of gravity [17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22]. In the weak-field regime,1 the first observational experiment using NSs was unexpectedly conducted by measuring the decay rate of the orbital period of the Hulse-Taylor binary radio pulsar [23], which is consistent with the theoretical predictions of GW emission in General Relativity (GR), thereby providing empirical support for the theory. The compactness of NSs typically ranges from 0.1 to 0.3, and hence, their structure lies in the strong-field regime. Alternative theories of gravity may provide different descriptions of the coupling between gravity and matter from GR. Consequently, the mass-radius relation differs from that within GR for a given EoS, and in turn, their observational signature is also modified from the predictions by GR [24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30] (see also [31, 32, 33, 34] for the NS mass-radius relation in non-GR theories that do not alter the matter-gravity coupling from GR but modify the field equations).

The aforementioned properties of NS structures and observational outcomes suggest that NSs are ideal laboratories for studying fundamental interactions among physical degrees of freedom in extremely dense and strong-gravity environments, including not only known components, but also hypothetical sectors. However, there are uncertainties in both the EoS and the underlying gravitational theory in the NS interiors. The achievement of the determination of the fundamental interactions thus requires breaking the degeneracies within the two types of uncertainties (nuclear and gravitational physics).

Approximate universality for neutron stars

Spinning and tidally-deformed NSs exhibit approximate universality known as the “I-Love-QQ” relations, which link the moment of inertia (II), tidal deformability (Love), and spin induced mass quadrupole moment (QQ) in an EoS insensitive way [35, 36, 37].2 For instance, the I-QQ curve for NSs across various EoSs, including realistic EoS models proposed from nuclear physics, remains nearly indistinguishable, allowing us to approximately express “I” as a function of “Q” independently of EoSs, and vice versa. Consequently, once one of these parameters is determined, the others can be inferred, thereby breaking the degeneracies among the parameters used in the theoretical modeling of X-ray light curves from hot spots on NS surfaces [41]. The I-Love-QQ relation provides an unprecedented avenue for determining NS parameters by combining independent observations with GWs and electromagnetic waves. A similar approximate universality extends to other stellar parameters. The multipole Love relations discovered in Ref. [42] connect tidal parameters at different post-Newtonian (PN) orders in the GW phase in a manner insensitive to EoSs. Furthermore, for cold and old NSs with realistic EoSs, the I-Love-C relation for the stellar compactness CC is also insensitive to the EoSs within a relative error ≲2%\lesssim2\% [37, 43]. Other extensions include the relation between the ff-mode frequency and the tidal deformability [44] (further extensions involving the first pp and ww modes are studied in [45]), three-hair relations among various multipole moments [40, 46], for different stellar configurations with pressure anisotropy [47], non-barotropic fluids [48], differential rotation [49], and magnetars [50, 51].

The universal Love relations, which refer to the empirical power-law relations found in Ref. [42], connect approximately (conservative) tidal deformabilities in an EoS insensitive manner, thereby reducing the number of independent parameters in GW data analysis. With the third-generation detector [52], neglecting the magnetic-type quadrupolar tidal deformability in the waveform template may lead to a small bias in the parameter estimation [53]. Given recent advance of waveform modeling up to higher PN-order tidal corrections [42, 53, 54, 55, 56, 57, 58, 59], it is beneficial to investigate these empirical relations in greater depth by rederiving the theoretical expressions in a (semi-)analytic manner.

It is natural to ask what is the physical origin of the approximate universality found in NSs. At present, there is no decisive answer, although some evidence exist – such as the approximate self-similarity of isodensity contours in stellar interiors [60], the incompressible limit as a stationary point of the relative change of rate of the I-Love relation for different EoSs [61], and the monotonic behavior exhibited by certain perturbation variables in their radial profiles [62]. A deeper exploration of the underlying structure of the universality will illuminate unexplored aspects of how stellar characters – originally governed by a number of parameters – tend to be lost as stellar configurations evolve along the sequence from non-relativistic to relativistic stars in a phase space [60], where the extreme limit is a black hole with the no-hair property.

Summary of this work

We conduct a comprehensive, theoretical study on the approximate universality of NSs. Our approach employs a semi-analytic relativistic stellar interior model, referred to as a modified Tolman VII model [68, 69], and solves the tidal perturbations based on the post-Minkowskian expansion. We semi-analytically derive the universal Love relations among the tidal deformabilities of nonrotating NSs by solving tidal perturbations on the Tolman VII solution [70], which is a particular case of the modified Tolman VII model:

σˉ2=−0.0135394λˉ24/5(1+3.06615λˉ21/5+3.69338λˉ22/5+1.98439λˉ23/5+0.343307λˉ24/5+0.0875811λˉ2),(1)\bar{\sigma}_2=-0.0135394\bar{\lambda}_2^{4/5}\left(1+\frac{3.06615}{\bar{\lambda}_2^{1/5}}+\frac{3.69338}{\bar{\lambda}_2^{2/5}}+\frac{1.98439}{\bar{\lambda}_2^{3/5}}+\frac{0.343307}{\bar{\lambda}_2^{4/5}}+\frac{0.0875811}{\bar{\lambda}_2}\right), \tag*{(1)}

and

λˉ3=0.155283λˉ27/5(1+0.342365λˉ21/5+0.300941λˉ22/5+0.085495λˉ23/5+0.142828λˉ24/5+0.0435432λˉ2),(2)\bar{\lambda}_3 = 0.155283\bar{\lambda}_2^{7/5}\left(1+\frac{0.342365}{\bar{\lambda}_2^{1/5}}+\frac{0.300941}{\bar{\lambda}_2^{2/5}}+\frac{0.085495}{\bar{\lambda}_2^{3/5}}+\frac{0.142828}{\bar{\lambda}_2^{4/5}}+\frac{0.0435432}{\bar{\lambda}_2}\right), \tag*{(2)}

where λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_\ell and σˉℓ\bar{\sigma}_\ell are the ℓ\ellth electric-type and magnetic-type tidal deformabilities, respectively.3 These relations agree well with the empirical expressions in Ref. [42] that were obtained by fitting against numerical data. Figure 1 presents the λˉ2−σˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2-\bar{\sigma}_2 and λˉ2−λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_2-\bar{\lambda}_3 relations with the power-law expressions in Eqs. (1) and (2), demonstrating the approximate universality for tidally deformed NSs with realistic EoSs. Following Ref. [42], we consider the following EoSs: Akmal, Pandharipande, and Ravenhall (APR) [63], Skyrme-Lyon (SLy) [64], Lattimer-Swesty with nuclear incompressibility of 220MeV (LS220) [65], and Shen [66, 67].

Figure 1. (Top) Approximately universal λˉ2−σˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2-\bar{\sigma}_2 (left) and λˉ2−λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_2-\bar{\lambda}_3 (right) relations. The black lines in the left and right panels are the power-law relations (1) and (2), respectively. The colored circles denote a set of (λˉ2,σˉˉ2)(\bar{\lambda}_2,\bar{\bar{\sigma}}_2) and (λˉ2,λˉ3)(\bar{\lambda}_2,\bar{\lambda}_3) that were computed numerically for realistic EoS models (APR [63], SLy [64], LS220 [65], and Shen [66, 67]). Observe that the relations with different EoSs are indistinguishable. (Bottom) The fractional difference of the relations for realistic EoSs from the power-law expressions (1) and (2).

The tidally induced multipole moments of NSs are approximately characterized by λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2. Consequently, higher-PN-order tidal deformabilities in waveform models can be analytically expressed in terms of λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2, reducing the number of independent parameters in GW data analysis, thereby improving the measurement accuracy of the leading tidal parameter. Furthermore, these relations impose theoretical constraints among the tidal deformabilities of NSs within GR, allowing us for strong-field tests of gravity in a manner insensitive to uncertainties in the EoSs.

We reveal the suppression mechanism of the EoS dependence in the universal relations in a particular combination of tidal Love numbers (TLNs). This mechanism essentially relies on the macroscopic property of tidally deformed NSs: stiffer EoSs lead to stronger tidal deformation. The I-Love relation is based on a similar suppression mechanism between the moment of inertia and the TLN, in which stiffer EoSs lead to a higher moment of inertia. The shared EoS dependence among linear responses results in suppression of the EoS dependence. We speculate that NSs perturbed by arbitrary processes exhibit, more or less, a similar suppression mechanism in particular combinations among macroscopic physical parameters induced by perturbations.

The suppression mechanism is continuously reinforced as the local adiabatic index increases. Our findings suggest that the approximate universality of perturbed NSs can be attributed to low compressibility. Indeed, we find that stellar configurations in equilibrium tend to become insensitive to variations in EoSs as the local adiabatic index increases. These observations suggest the following picture: incompressible stars correspond to a restricted subset of equilibrium stellar configurations in the phase space spanned by physical degrees of freedom, as the energy density remains constant throughout the entire interior. Linear perturbations to such incompressible stars induce the strongest possible responses, setting upper bounds on their magnitudes. Stars deviate from this limit by decreasing the adiabatic index. For NSs, stellar configurations remain insensitive to variations in the EoSs due to low compressibility. A decrease in the adiabatic index reduces the magnitudes of the responses in a manner shared among the perturbations, leading to approximate universality. Eventually, as the adiabatic index decreases further, the degrees of freedom associated with an EoS expand, and in turn, the similarity of the responses is lost, resulting in the loss of universality.

Organization and convention

In Section II, we introduce a semi-analytic model for relativistic stellar interiors. In Section III, we present the analytic, approximate universal relations among the tidal deformabilities of NSs. In Section IV, we discuss the potential origin of these universal Love relations and unveil how EoS dependence is suppressed in a particular combination of TLNs. Section V is devoted to discussing our findings and mentioning possible future extensions. Appendix A introduces semi-analytic and fully analytic NS interior models used in this work. In Appendix B, we summarize the linear perturbation theory of relativistic spherical stars within a perfect-fluid approximation. In Appendix C, we demonstrate that the I-Love relation results from the same suppression mechanism of the EoS dependence as the universal Love relations. We adopt the geometric units with c=G=1c = G = 1.

Semi-analytic model of neutron star interior

We consider a static and spherically symmetric relativistic star in isolation. In static coordinates (t,r,θ,φ)(t,r,\theta,\varphi), the line element takes the form,

gμνdxμdxν=−eνdt2+eλdr2+r2dΩ2,(3)g_{\mu\nu}dx^\mu dx^\nu= -e^\nu dt^2 + e^\lambda dr^2 + r^2d\Omega^2, \tag*{(3)}

where ν=ν(r)\nu=\nu(r), λ=λ(r)\lambda=\lambda(r), and dΩ2:=dθ2+sin⁡2θdφ2d\Omega^2 := d\theta^2+\sin^2\theta d\varphi^2. We model a NS by a sphere occupied by an isotropic fluid in static equilibrium. The star should satisfy Einstein’s equations,

Gμν=8πTμν,(4)G_{\mu\nu}=8\pi T_{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(4)}

with the Einstein tensor GμνG_{\mu\nu} and the stress-energy tensor of a perfect fluid,

Tμν=(p+ρ)uμuν+pgμν.(5)T_{\mu\nu}=(p+\rho)u_\mu u_\nu+pg_{\mu\nu}. \tag*{(5)}

Here, p=p(r)p=p(r) and ρ=ρ(r)\rho=\rho(r) are the pressure and energy density, respectively. The vector uμu^\mu is the four-velocity of the fluid, normalized by gμνuμuν=−1g_{\mu\nu}u^\mu u^\nu=-1, and hence, uμ=(e−ν/2,0,0,0)u^\mu=(e^{-\nu/2},0,0,0).

Einstein’s equations (4) reduce to a set of the following three equations:

m′=4πr2ρ,ν′=2m+4πr3pr(r−2m),p′=−(p+ρ)m+4πr3pr(r−2m).(6)\begin{aligned} m'&=4\pi r^2\rho,\qquad\nu'=2\frac{m+4\pi r^3p}{r(r-2m)},\\ p'&=-(p+\rho)\frac{m+4\pi r^3p}{r(r-2m)}. \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

where the prime denotes a differentiation with respect to rr. Here, we have introduced a radial mass function m=m(r)m=m(r) defined by m:=(r/2)(1−e−ν)m:=(r/2)(1-e^{-\nu}). To close (6), an EoS p=p(ρ)p=p(\rho) connecting the internal matter degrees of freedom is necessary. The exterior solution to (6), where ρ=p=0\rho=p=0, must be the Schwarzschild metric by virtue of Birkoff’s theorem,

eν=e−λ=1−2Mr,(7)e^\nu=e^{-\lambda}=1-\frac{2M}{r}, \tag*{(7)}

where MM is the gravitational mass. In general, solving (6) requires numerical calculations.

Since this work aims to understand the tidal property of NSs semi-analytically, we follow the idea of a (semi-)analytic model for NS interiors, an extension of a Tolman VII solution [70] by introducing an additional parameter α\alpha, proposed in Refs. [69]. The parameter α\alpha controls the internal relation between energy density and pressure, and hence, corresponds to the degree of freedom of an EoS. The energy density profile is given by

ρ=ρc[1−αξ2+(α−1)ξ4].(8)\rho=\rho_c\left[1-\alpha\xi^2+(\alpha-1)\xi^4\right]. \tag*{(8)}

Here, ρc\rho_c is the central energy density and is related to MM and α\alpha (see Eq. (A4)); ξ:=r/R\xi:=r/R is a dimensionless radial coordinate normalized by the radius RR. Given ρ\rho in Eq. (8), one can determine mm fully analytically, while ν\nu and pp are obtained by solving Eq. (6) numerically, thereby constructing a semi-analytic NS interior model [68]. The functions, mm, ν\nu, and pp, are provided in Appendix A. We refer to this semi-analytic solution as a modified Tolman VII solution. The fully analytic model proposed by Ref. [69] provides a good approximation to this numerical solution, except for pp in the outer layers [68], despite not being an exact solution to Eq. (6). We provide the expressions for mm, ν\nu, and pp of the fully analytic model in Appendix A.

The modified Tolman VII solution has three independent parameters, MM, RR, and α\alpha. The stellar configuration for 0.4≲α≲1.40.4 \lesssim\alpha\lesssim1.4 can model NSs well with various realistic EoSs in a wide range of compactness [69, 72]. In this work, we assume 0≤α≤1.40 \leq\alpha\leq1.4, as our purpose involves obtaining insights into the potential origin of the approximate universality for NSs. Taking α→1\alpha\to1, the modified Tolman VII solution reduces to the Tolman VII solution, originally derived in Ref. [70]. The quadratic energy density profile is a good approximation for stellar models with various realistic EoSs in a large portion of the interior (see, e.g., Figure 4 in Ref. [61] and Figure 9 in Ref. [69]).

Figure 4. (Top panel) The λˉ2−σˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2-\bar{\sigma}_2 relation. The black line is the power-law relation (1). The magenta dashed line is the empirical fit for realistic EoSs in [42]. The colored circles denote a set of (λˉ2,σˉ2)(\bar{\lambda}_2,\bar{\sigma}_2) numerically computed for various α\alpha in the modified Tolman VII model without relying on the PM expansion, given discrete compactness. Observe that the variation of the results with respect to α\alpha is indistinguishable. (Bottom panel) The fractional difference between the numerical values represented by the circles and the theoretical power-law relation (1) (solid curves). The black dashed curve denotes the fractional difference between the theoretical and fitting expressions. Note that the theoretical relation is approximately derived for the Tolman VII solution (α=1\alpha=1) within the PM expansion, leading to the smallest fractional difference in a wide range of λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2.

Figure 9. The mass function profile of the modified Tolman VII solution.

To see the role of α\alpha, we briefly discuss the energy density profile (8), presented in Figure 2. Notice that ρc\rho_{\mathrm{c}} tends to be lower with decreasing α\alpha and fixed compactness C(:=M/R)C( := M/R). A plateau exists near the stellar origin and extends as α\alpha decreases, suggesting that smaller α\alpha corresponds to a stiffer EoS. The local stiffness of an EoS can be measured through the local adiabatic index defined by

Energy density profiles for various $\alpha$

Figure 2. The energy density profile in Eq. (8) for various α\alpha with C=0.1C = 0.1. Observe that the plateau near the stellar origin extends further as α\alpha decreases.

Γ:=(1+pρ)dln⁡pdln⁡ρ.(9)\Gamma:= \left(1 + \frac{p}{\rho}\right)\frac{d\ln p}{d\ln\rho}. \tag*{(9)}

Figure 3 shows that smaller α\alpha leads to larger Γ\Gamma. Note that the curves with different α\alpha do not intersect. This implies that smaller α\alpha corresponds to stiffer EoSs. In the limit

Figure 3. The local adiabatic index (9) for C=0.1C = 0.1 with various α\alpha. Observe that smaller α\alpha yields larger Γ\Gamma. This behavior is qualitatively independent of the choice of CC. The blue curve (α=0\alpha= 0) diverges at the origin, being locally incompressible.

of α→0\alpha\to0, Γ\Gamma blows up in the inner core, corresponding to a locally incompressible limit.

Now, the dependence of ρ\rho on α\alpha in Figure 2 can be interpreted from a physical point of view. Smaller α\alpha leads to lower compressible configurations in the entire interior, meaning that matter resists gravitational attraction more effectively, even at lower densities. Consequently, a lower central density is sufficient to generate the necessary pressure gradient to maintain equilibrium.

Universal Love relations

Tidal deformability

Let us consider a star, initially spherically symmetric, immersed in a tidal environment created by other gravitational sources, such as a binary companion. The external source exerts tidal forces on the star, and in turn, the gravitational potential of the star receives anisotropic corrections, inducing higher-order multipole moments in its multipole expansion. If the external force is sufficiently weak and varies slowly in time compared to the timescale for the star settling down to equilibrium, the tidal interaction can be regarded as static tides, and thus, the analysis boils down to a stationary linear response problem for the star within the framework of relativistic perturbation theory.

The tidal perturbation is decomposed into the electric-type and magnetic-type sectors, subject to the parity transformation [73, 74, 75]. With harmonic decomposition, the tidal deformation of the star is quantified by a set of the dimensionless ℓ\ellth electric-type and magnetic-type tidal deformabilities λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_{\ell} and σˉℓ\bar{\sigma}_{\ell} [42, 74],

λˉℓ:=2(2ℓ−1)!!C−2ℓ−1kℓ.(10)\bar{\lambda}_{\ell} := \frac{2}{(2\ell- 1)!!} C^{-2\ell-1} k_{\ell}. \tag*{(10)}
σˉℓ:=ℓ−14(ℓ+2)(2ℓ−1)!!C−2ℓ−1jℓ.(11)\bar{\sigma}_{\ell} := \frac{\ell- 1}{4(\ell+ 2)(2\ell- 1)!!} C^{-2\ell-1} j_{\ell}. \tag*{(11)}

Here, kℓk_{\ell} and jℓj_{\ell} are the ℓ\ellth electric-type and magnetic-type (dimensionless) TLNs, respectively.4 The TLNs can be read off from the large-distance expansion of the tidally deformed metric. Note that λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_{\ell} and σˉℓ\bar{\sigma}_{\ell} are dimensionless quantities and are identical to coefficients Λℓ\Lambda_{\ell} and Σℓ\Sigma_{\ell} commonly used in the context of GW astronomy [57, 59, 71].5 The coefficients λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_{\ell} and σˉℓ\bar{\sigma}_{\ell} directly enter in the GW phase at (2ℓ+1)(2\ell+1) and 3ℓ3\ell PN order, respectively, relative to the point-particle approximation [42, 81].

Power-law relations

We here provide the analytic power-law expressions representing approximate universal relations among the tidal deformabilities. The perturbation equations to determine λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_{\ell} and σˉℓ\bar{\sigma}_{\ell} are derived in Appendix B. In Section IV, we discuss the underlying structure of these relations in detail.

Even–Odd Love relations

Figure 4 presents the λˉ2−σˉ2\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{\sigma}_{2} relation, demonstrating the insensitivity of the results with respect to variation in α\alpha and the excellent agreement of the power-law expression (1) with the previous empirical finding by Ref. [42].6 Note that the colored circles denote a set of (λˉ2,σˉ2)(\bar{\lambda}_{2},\bar{\sigma}_{2}) numerically computed for various α\alpha on the background described by the modified Tolman VII solution.

The theoretical relation (1) is derived in the following manner. First, we consider tidal perturbations in the fully analytic model of the modified Tolman VII solution,

jℓ=2(ℓ+2)(ℓ+1)ℓ(ℓ−1)κℓ−.(12)j_{\ell} = \frac{2(\ell+ 2)(\ell+ 1)}{\ell(\ell- 1)}\kappa_{\ell}^{-}. \tag*{(12)}

Here, jℓj_{\ell} and κℓ−\kappa_{\ell}^{-} are the magnetic-type TLNs in the current work and in the literature, respectively.

Theoretical and empirical relations between $\bar{\lambda}_2$ and $\bar{\lambda}_3$

Figure 5. Similar to Fig. 4 but for the λˉ2−λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_2-\bar{\lambda}_3 relation.

Figure 12. (Top panel) The electric-type quadrupolar tidal deformability λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2 computed by Eq. (58). Note that the PM expansion is truncated at (jmax⁡,kmax⁡)=(6,15)(j_{\max}, k_{\max})=(6,15) in Eq. (55). (Bottom panel) The relative error between their values and numerical results on the modified Tolman VII background for various α\alpha.

Figure 13. (Top panel) The magnetic-type quadrupolar tidal deformability σˉ2\bar{\sigma}_2 computed by Eq. (B42). Note that the PM expansion is truncated at jmax⁡=5j_{\max}=5 in Eq. (B40). (Bottom panel) The relative error between their values and numerical results on the modified Tolman VII background for various α\alpha.

Figure 14. Similar to Figure 4 but for the I-Love relation.

provided in Appendix A. One then obtains the analytic expressions for λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_{\ell} and σˉℓ\bar{\sigma}_{\ell} as a function of CC for fixed α\alpha by solving tidal perturbation equations within the post-Minkowskian (PM) expansion, i.e., an expansion in terms of CC. The technical details are provided in Appendix B. The tidal deformabilities, λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_{\ell} and σˉℓ\bar{\sigma}_{\ell}, are expressed in the form of polynomials of CC. We re-sum those with the Padé approximant to improve their accuracy, thereby obtaining

λˉℓ=2(2ℓ−1)!!C−2ℓ−1pℓ,0++pℓ,1+C+pℓ,2+C2+pℓ,3+C3qℓ,0++qℓ,1+C+qℓ,2+C2+qℓ,3+C3.(13)\bar{\lambda}_{\ell} = \frac{2}{(2\ell- 1)!!} C^{-2\ell-1} \frac{p_{\ell,0}^{+}+p_{\ell,1}^{+}C+p_{\ell,2}^{+}C^{2}+p_{\ell,3}^{+}C^{3}}{q_{\ell,0}^{+}+q_{\ell,1}^{+}C+q_{\ell,2}^{+}C^{2}+q_{\ell,3}^{+}C^{3}}. \tag*{(13)}

and

σˉℓ=ℓ−14(ℓ+2)(2ℓ−1)!!C−2ℓpˉℓ,0±+pˉℓ,1±C+pˉℓ,2±C2qˉℓ,0±+qˉℓ,1±C+qˉℓ,2±C2(14)\bar{\sigma}_{\ell}=\frac{\ell-1}{4(\ell+2)(2\ell-1)!!}C^{-2\ell}\frac{\bar{p}_{\ell,0}^{\pm}+\bar{p}_{\ell,1}^{\pm}C+\bar{p}_{\ell,2}^{\pm}C^{2}}{\bar{q}_{\ell,0}^{\pm}+\bar{q}_{\ell,1}^{\pm}C+\bar{q}_{\ell,2}^{\pm}C^{2}} \tag*{(14)}

where pˉℓ,i±=pˉℓ,i±(α)\bar{p}_{\ell,i}^{\pm}=\bar{p}_{\ell,i}^{\pm}(\alpha) and qˉℓ,i±=qˉℓ,i±(α)\bar{q}_{\ell,i}^{\pm}=\bar{q}_{\ell,i}^{\pm}(\alpha). The explicit forms of pˉℓ,i±\bar{p}_{\ell,i}^{\pm} and qˉℓ,i±\bar{q}_{\ell,i}^{\pm} are provided in online [82]. Equations (13) and (14) agree with values computed numerically in a wide range of compactness, as presented in Appendix B (see Figure 12 and Figure 13).

We now derive the power-law expression (1). Since the dependence of the λˉ2−σˉ2\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{\sigma}_{2} relation on α\alpha is weak, we fix α=1\alpha=1 without losing much generality. This choice corresponds to specifying the background using the original Tolman VII solution [70], allowing us to derive the power-law relation in a fully analytic manner consistent with Einstein’s equations (6). Setting α=1\alpha=1 and ℓ=2\ell=2, and solving Eq. (13) about CC inversely, we express CC as a polynomial of 1/λˉ21/51/\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{1/5}:

C=∑j=18βjλˉ2j/5(15)C=\sum_{j=1}^{8}\frac{\beta_j}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{j/5}} \tag*{(15)}

where βj\beta_j are numbers given in Eq. (59). Substituting this into Eq. (14) with ℓ=2\ell=2 and expanding it about 1/λˉ21/51/\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{1/5}, one can express σˉ2\bar{\sigma}_{2} in the form of a power-law series of λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_{2}, which is Eq. (1).

We now assess the α\alpha dependence of the power-law relation. Again, expressing CC in terms of λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_{2} without fixing α\alpha, substituting this into Eq. (14) with ℓ=2\ell=2, and expanding it about 1/λˉ21/51/\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{1/5}, we obtain

σˉ2=−λˉ24/5[C0σˉ2λˉ2+C1σˉ2λˉ2λˉ21/5+O(1λˉ22/5)](16)\bar{\sigma}_{2}=-\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{4/5}\left[C_{0}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}+\frac{C_{1}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{1/5}}+O\left(\frac{1}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{2/5}}\right)\right] \tag*{(16)}

where C0σˉ2λˉ2=C0σˉ2λˉ2(α)C_{0}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}=C_{0}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}(\alpha) and C1σˉ2λˉ2=C1σˉ2λˉ2(α)C_{1}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}=C_{1}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}(\alpha). The approximate universality arises from the insensitivity of the power-law coefficients to the α\alpha-variation. Indeed, the Taylor expansion of C0σˉ2λˉ2C_{0}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}} and C1σˉ2λˉ2C_{1}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}} around α=1\alpha=1 shows

C0σˉ2λˉ2=0.014[1+0.028(α−1)+O((α−1)2)],C_{0}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}=0.014\left[1+0.028(\alpha-1)+O\left((\alpha-1)^2\right)\right],
C1σˉ2λˉ2=0.041[1+0.038(α−1)+O((α−1)2)].(17)C_{1}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}=0.041\left[1+0.038(\alpha-1)+O\left((\alpha-1)^2\right)\right]. \tag*{(17)}

Notice that the coefficient in front of (α−1)(\alpha-1) is less than 4% of the leading-order one, showing the weak α\alpha dependence. The universality is assessed by

C0σˉ2λˉ2∣α=0C0σˉ2λˉ2∣α=1.4≃0.96,(18)\frac{C_{0}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}\big|_{\alpha=0}}{C_{0}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}\big|_{\alpha=1.4}}\simeq0.96, \tag*{(18)}

which indicates that the deviation of the λˉ2−σˉ2\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{\sigma}_{2} relation in the range of α\alpha under consideration is only 4%. This is much smaller than the deviation between polytropes with 0≤n≤10\leq n\leq1, which was found to be 11% [42].

Multipole Love relations

Figure 5 presents the λˉ2−λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_2-\bar{\lambda}_3 relation, showing the weak α\alpha dependence and agreement of the power-law relation (2) with the fit found in Ref. [42]. Notice that the colored circles denote a set of (λˉ2,λˉ3)(\bar{\lambda}_2,\bar{\lambda}_3) numerically computed for various α\alpha on the modified Tolman VII background. The theoretical expression (2) is derived by substituting Eq. (15) into Eq. (13) with ℓ=2\ell=2 and α=1\alpha=1, and by expanding it about 1/λˉ21/51/\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{1/5}.

Let us discuss the insensitivity of the relation to variation in α\alpha. Substituting the expansion of CC in λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2 into Eq. (13) with ℓ=3\ell=3 without fixing α\alpha, one finds

λˉ3=λˉ27/5[C0λˉ3λˉ2+C1λˉ3λˉ2λˉ21/5+O(1λˉ22/5)](19)\bar{\lambda}_{3}=\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{7/5}\left[C_{0}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}+\frac{C_{1}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{1/5}}+O\left(\frac{1}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{2/5}}\right)\right] \tag*{(19)}

where C0λˉ3λˉ2=C0λˉ3λˉ2(α)C_{0}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}=C_{0}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}(\alpha) and C1λˉ3λˉ2=C1λˉ3λˉ2(α)C_{1}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}=C_{1}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}(\alpha). The Taylor expansion of C0λˉ3λˉ2C_{0}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}} and C1λˉ3λˉ2C_{1}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}} around α=1\alpha=1 leads

C0λˉ3λˉ2=0.16[1+0.066(α−1)+O((α−1)2)],C_{0}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}=0.16\left[1+0.066(\alpha-1)+O\left((\alpha-1)^2\right)\right],
C1λˉ3λˉ2=6.6[1+0.19(α−1)+O((α−1)2)].(20)C_{1}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}=6.6\left[1+0.19(\alpha-1)+O\left((\alpha-1)^2\right)\right]. \tag*{(20)}

For the leading-order contribution, the first-order coefficient in the expansion is less than 10% of the zeroth-order coefficient, indicating the weak α\alpha dependence. We assess the universality by

Cˉ0λˉ3λˉ2∣α=0Cˉ0λˉ3λˉ2∣α=1.4≃0.92.(21)\frac{\left.\bar{C}_{0}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}\right|_{\alpha=0}}{\left.\bar{C}_{0}^{\bar{\lambda}_{3}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}\right|_{\alpha=1.4}} \simeq0.92. \tag*{(21)}

This means the deviation of the λˉ2−λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{\lambda}_{3} relation in the range of α\alpha under consideration is 8%, which is, once again, much smaller than the deviation between polytropes with 0≤n≤10 \le n \le1, found as 20% [42].

Potential origin of the approximate universality

The power-law relations are characterized by the following two key aspects: the independence of the power-law exponent from the details of microscopic physics and the weak dependence of the power-law coefficients on these details. In the following, we discuss these one by one, by focusing on the leading-order contribution of the PM expansion, which sufficiently captures the approximate universal behavior. After that, we argue that the stellar structures with low compressibility appear to play a crucial role in universality.

EoS independence of the power-law exponent

Equations (13) and (14) imply that λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_{\ell} and σˉℓ\bar{\sigma}_{\ell} scale as C−2ℓ−1C^{-2\ell-1} and C−2ℓC^{-2\ell}, respectively, to leading order of the PM expansion. A comparison by eliminating CC from them reveals the scaling relation, σˉℓ∝λˉℓ2ℓ/(2ℓ+1)\bar{\sigma}_{\ell} \propto\bar{\lambda}_{\ell}^{2\ell/(2\ell+1)}, which determines the exponent in Eq. (16) for ℓ=2\ell=2. Similarly, one finds λˉℓ′∝λˉℓ(2ℓ′+1)/(2ℓ+1)\bar{\lambda}_{\ell^{\prime}} \propto\bar{\lambda}_{\ell}^{(2\ell^{\prime}+1)/(2\ell+1)} for ℓ′≠ℓ\ell^{\prime} \ne\ell, explaining the exponent in Eq. (19) for (ℓ,ℓ′)=(2,3)(\ell,\ell^{\prime})=(2,3). The exponent is thus determined by the scaling law of the tidal deformabilities with respect to CC, which is independent of the underlying microphysics.

Suppression of EoS dependence of the power-law coefficients

We here mainly discuss the Even-Odd Love relation (1), as it shares fundamentally same structures with the multipole Love relation (2). Eliminating CC from Eqs. (10) and (11) (noting jℓ=O(C1)j_{\ell}=\mathcal{O}(C^{1})) at leading order of the PM expansion with ℓ=2\ell=2, we obtain

σˉ2∝j2(1PM)(k2(N))4/5λˉ24/5,(22)\bar{\sigma}_{2} \propto\frac{j_{2}^{(1\mathrm{PM})}}{\left(k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})}\right)^{4/5}}\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{4/5}, \tag*{(22)}

where k2(N)k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})} and j2(1PM)j_{2}^{(1\mathrm{PM})} are the Newtonian quadrupolar TLN and 1PM-order magnetic-type quadrupolar TLN, respectively. The factor in front of λˉ24/5\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{4/5} on the right-hand side shares the α\alpha dependence with Cˉ0σˉ2λˉ2\bar{C}_{0}^{\bar{\sigma}_{2}\bar{\lambda}_{2}} in Eq. (16); the only difference is an irrelevant numerical factor.

Let us first discuss the α\alpha dependence of k2(N)k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})} and j2(1PM)j_{2}^{(1\mathrm{PM})}. We expand them around α=α0(∈[0,1.4])\alpha=\alpha_{0}(\in[0,1.4]), obtaining

k2(N)=Ck2(0)[1−Ck2(1)(α−α0)+O((α−α0)2)],(23)k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})}=C_{k_{2}}^{(0)}\left[1-C_{k_{2}}^{(1)}(\alpha-\alpha_{0})+\mathcal{O}\left((\alpha-\alpha_{0})^{2}\right)\right], \tag*{(23)}
j2(1PM)=−Cj2(0)[1−Cj2(1)(α−α0)+O((α−α0)2)],(24)j_{2}^{(1\mathrm{PM})}=-C_{j_{2}}^{(0)}\left[1-C_{j_{2}}^{(1)}(\alpha-\alpha_{0})+\mathcal{O}\left((\alpha-\alpha_{0})^{2}\right)\right], \tag*{(24)}

where Ck2(i)C_{k_{2}}^{(i)} and Cj2(i)C_{j_{2}}^{(i)} are positive numbers. It is worth mentioning that the relative change rates of k2(N)k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})} and j2(1PM)j_{2}^{(1\mathrm{PM})} with respect to α\alpha, i.e., −Ck2(1)-C_{k_{2}}^{(1)} and −Cj2(1)-C_{j_{2}}^{(1)}, are negative. Physically, this implies that smaller α\alpha (stiffer EoS) leads to stronger tidal deformation. The magnitude of Ck2(1)C_{k_{2}}^{(1)} and Cj2(1)C_{j_{2}}^{(1)} quantifies the α\alpha dependence of k2(N)k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})} and j2(1PM)j_{2}^{(1\mathrm{PM})}, respectively. For example, (Ck2(1),Cj2(1))≃(0.31,0.21)(C_{k_{2}}^{(1)},C_{j_{2}}^{(1)})\simeq(0.31,0.21) for α0=1\alpha_{0}=1. We found 0.2≲Ck2(1)≲0.50.2\lesssim C_{k_{2}}^{(1)}\lesssim0.5 and Cj2(1)≃0.68Ck2(1)C_{j_{2}}^{(1)}\simeq0.68C_{k_{2}}^{(1)} (the latter to be explained below) for 0≤α≤1.40\le\alpha\le1.4, implying that the α\alpha dependence of k2(N)k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})} and j2(1PM)j_{2}^{(1\mathrm{PM})} is not significant but slightly stronger than that in the universal Love relations derived in Section III. On the other hand, the α\alpha dependence of the ratio,7

rλˉ2−σˉ2(1)(α)=Cj2(1)(α)Ck2(1)(α),(25)r_{\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{\sigma}_{2}}^{(1)}(\alpha)=\frac{C_{j_{2}}^{(1)}(\alpha)}{C_{k_{2}}^{(1)}(\alpha)}, \tag*{(25)}

in 0≤α≤1.40\le\alpha\le1.4 is evaluated as

rλˉ2−σˉ2(1)(0)rλˉ2−σˉ2(1)(1.4)≃0.97,(26)\frac{r_{\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{\sigma}_{2}}^{(1)}(0)}{r_{\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{\sigma}_{2}}^{(1)}(1.4)}\simeq0.97, \tag*{(26)}

which shows the insensitivity to α\alpha. The ratio, Cj2(1)/Ck2(1)≃0.68C_{j_{2}}^{(1)}/C_{k_{2}}^{(1)}\simeq0.68, thus approximately holds in $0\le\alpha\le1.4. We have also confirmed that the ratio deviates from 0.68 as α\alpha further increases. Physically, Eq. (26) implies the similarity of the α\alpha dependence of k2(N)k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})} and j2(1PM)j_{2}^{(1\mathrm{PM})} in 0≤α≤1.40\le\alpha\le1.4. Another intriguing finding is that the ratio is close to the value of the power-law exponent, 4/5(=0.8)4/5 (=0.8), which appears to play a certain role in suppressing the α\alpha dependence as will be seen below.

The similar structure can be found in other universal Love relations as well, which is summarized in tbl:I, and even in the I-Love relation as discussed in Appendix C. The physical origin of these structures remains unclear; we discuss it again at the end of this section.

Let us now discuss the combination of TLNs. Equation (22) shows that k2(N)k_2^{(\mathrm{N})} contributes to the power-law coefficient with an inverse power. This means that the α\alpha-dependent contribution arising from k2(N)k_2^{(\mathrm{N})} has the opposite sign to that from j2(1PM)j_2^{(1\mathrm{PM})} in the combination, and thus, the total α\alpha dependence in the coefficient is diminishing with each other. Indeed, one can derive

j2(1PM)(k2(N))4/5∝1−(Cj2(1)−45Ck2(1))(α−α0)+O((α−α0)2).(27)\frac{j_2^{(1\mathrm{PM})}}{\left(k_2^{(\mathrm{N})}\right)^{4/5}}\propto1-\left(C_{j_2}^{(1)}-\frac{4}{5}C_{k_2}^{(1)}\right)(\alpha-\alpha_0)+O\left((\alpha-\alpha_0)^2\right). \tag*{(27)}

Since Cj2(1)≃0.68Ck2(1)C_{j_2}^{(1)}\simeq0.68C_{k_2}^{(1)} and Ck2(1)=O(10−1)C_{k_2}^{(1)}=O(10^{-1}) as mentioned previously, the factor in front of (α−α0)(\alpha-\alpha_0) on the right-hand side is of O(10−2)O(10^{-2}), implying that the α\alpha variation in the power-law coefficient in Eq. (22) is of order of 1%, as demonstrated in Figure 6. Thus, the particular combination of TLNs suppresses their EoS dependence, leading to approximate universality. Interestingly, Figure 6 shows that the α\alpha dependence tends to weaken as α\alpha decreases, reaching a minimum at α=0\alpha=0. This implies that (i) Cσˉ02λˉ2C_{\bar{\sigma}_0^2\bar{\lambda}_2} in Eq. (16) is a monotonically increasing function of α\alpha, explaining why the ratio in Eq. (18) is smaller than unity; (ii) the universality is continuously reinforced as the local adiabatic index in the entire interior increases. The multipole Love relation (19) can also be understood in the same way.

Figure 6. The relative change rate of Cσˉ02λˉ2C_{\bar{\sigma}_0^2\bar{\lambda}_2} in Eq. (16) with respect to α\alpha, which corresponds to the ratio of the first-order coefficient to the zeroth-order one in the expansion (27). Observe that the rate is less than 5% in 0≤α≤1.40\leq\alpha\leq1.4, indicating approximate universality between λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2 and σˉ2\bar{\sigma}_2.

An intriguing observation in the suppression mechanism is that the ratio of the relative change rates of TLNs with respect to α\alpha is a similar value to the power-law exponent in the power-law relations, as presented in Table I. In Appendix C, we find the same structure in the I-Love relation as well (see Table II therein). This structure plays a certain role in universality, as the ratio deviates from those values as α\alpha further increases, which is consistent with Figure 6. Again, the insensitivity of the rate to α\alpha suggests the similarity of the α\alpha dependence of TLNs. The origin of the number of the ratio still remains unclear; we leave further considerations about the physical origin for future work.

In summary, the approximate universal Love relations rely on the suppression of the EoS dependence in a particular combination of TLNs. This suppression mechanism essentially rests on the macroscopic property of tidally deformed NSs: the absolute values of TLNs increase for stiffer EoSs, implying that stiffer EoSs lead to stronger tidal deformation. Note that the modest EoS dependence of TLNs is not generically a necessary condition for the universal Love relations despite being closely related to their assessment, as argued in the next section.

Modest EoS dependence of TLNs

One might expect that the suppression mechanism previously discussed relies on the modest EoS dependence of kℓk_\ell and jℓj_\ell. We now argue that this is not a necessary condition for the universal Love relations despite being closely related to their assessment. Figure 7 implies that the variation in kℓk_\ell with respect to α\alpha in 0≤α≤1.40\leq\alpha\leq1.4 is small, compared to polytropes with 0≤n≤10\leq n\leq1 (see, e.g., Figure 2 in [83]). Indeed, the EoS dependence is assessed by

The $k_2$-$j_2$-$C$ relation

Figure 7. The k2k_2-j2j_2-CC relation. For a given EoS, a set of TLNs form a curve as a function of CC. The incompressible limit (black curves) corresponds to the outer edge of the region covered by a set of EoS curves in the parameter space that keeps pressure finite. Observe that, for larger α\alpha (softer EoS), the region surrounded by the curves shrinks.

k2(N)∣α=0k2(N)∣α=1.4≃1.4,j2(1PM)∣α=0j2(1PM)∣α=1.4≃1.3,(28)\frac{k_2^{(\mathrm{N})}\big|_{\alpha=0}}{k_2^{(\mathrm{N})}\big|_{\alpha=1.4}}\simeq1.4,\qquad \frac{j_2^{(1\mathrm{PM})}\big|_{\alpha=0}}{j_2^{(1\mathrm{PM})}\big|_{\alpha=1.4}}\simeq1.3, \tag*{(28)}

and

k2(N)∣n=0k2(N)∣n=1≃2.9,j2(1PM)∣n=0j2(1PM)∣n=1≃2.1.(29)\frac{k_2^{(\mathrm{N})}|_{n=0}}{k_2^{(\mathrm{N})}|_{n=1}} \simeq2.9,\qquad\frac{j_2^{(1\mathrm{PM})}|_{n=0}}{j_2^{(1\mathrm{PM})}|_{n=1}} \simeq2.1. \tag*{(29)}

The former deviation is of O(10)%\mathcal{O}(10)\%, while the latter is of O(102)%\mathcal{O}(10^2)\%. On the one hand, the modest α\alpha dependence in the modified Tolman VII solution may be related to the Love-CC relation, discovered in NSs with realistic EoSs [37, 43] as well as the fully analytic model of the modified Tolman VII solution [72]. On the other hand, tidal deformabilities (and TLNs) for polytropes with 0≤n≤10 \le n \le1 sensitively depend on nn but follow the universal Love relations due to the suppression mechanism in a weaker manner than both the modified Tolman VII solution and realistic EoSs [42].

The universal Love relations hold more robustly than the kℓ−Ck_\ell-C and jℓ−Cj_\ell-C relations due to the suppression mechanism that works among macroscopic physical parameters induced by perturbations. It is important to note that the kℓ−Ck_\ell-C and jℓ−Cj_\ell-C relations do not underlie the universal Love relations, nor vice versa; rather, they should be regarded as mutually correlated in a non-hierarchical manner. The kℓ−Ck_\ell-C and jℓ−Cj_\ell-C relations appear to originate from an approximate quadratic energy density profile shared by NSs with realistic EoSs and the modified Tolman VII solution [35, 72]. This is consistent with the fact that TLNs for polytropes with 0≤n≤10 \le n \le1 strongly depend on nn. However, the universal Love relations still hold even for the polytropes, suggesting that the suppression mechanism arises from different structures from the similarity of the energy density profile. This is more evident in the I-Love relation, as seen in Appendix C.

Universality from low compressibility

Figure 6 suggests that smaller α\alpha (stiffer EoS) reinforces universality. This seems to be consistent with the fact that universality becomes less tight as one continuously increases the polytropic index in the regime n>1n > 1. Therefore, it is natural to expect that universality may arise from stellar structures associated with low compressibility.

We find that the trend in the α\alpha dependence of the power-law coefficients is inherited from that of the equilibrium stellar configuration, i.e., the modified Tolman VII solution. Figure 8 presents the fractional difference in the energy density profiles (8) for similar values of α\alpha with a fixed λˉ2=1000\bar{\lambda}_2=1000, showing that the difference is typically less than 10%10\% in a large portion of the interior and increases for larger α\alpha. Similar behavior can be found in other background quantities, such as pp, ν\nu, and mm. In other words, the stellar configuration in equilibrium tends to become insensitive to α\alpha variations as α\alpha approaches zero. The “valley” observed in Figure 8 originates from the crossing of the energy-density profiles for different values of α\alpha around ξ=0.6\xi=0.6, as shown in Figure 2.

The fractional difference in density profiles

Figure 8. The fractional difference in ρ\rho given by Eq. (8) for similar values of α\alpha with λˉ2=1000\bar{\lambda}_2=1000, as a function of ξ(=r/R)\xi(=r/R). Observe that, for larger α\alpha, the fractional difference increases in a large portion of the interior.

Building upon the above considerations, we expect that low compressibility of stellar configurations in the entire interior region plays a crucial role in approximate universality for NSs. These observations suggest the following picture: incompressible stars correspond to a restricted subset of equilibrium stellar configurations in the phase space spanned by physical degrees of freedom, as the energy density remains constant throughout the entire interior. Linear perturbations to such incompressible stars induce the strongest possible responses, setting upper bounds on their magnitudes. Compressible stars deviate from this limit by decreasing the adiabatic index. For NSs, stellar configurations remain insensitive to variations in the EoS due to low compressibility. A decrease in the adiabatic index reduces the magnitudes of the responses in a manner commonly shared among various tidal perturbations, leading to approximate universality. Eventually, as the adiabatic index decreases further, the degrees of freedom associated with an EoS expand, and in turn, the similarity of the responses is lost, resulting in the loss of universality.

Comparison with previous findings

Let us discuss consistencies with findings from previous studies. Reference [61] demonstrated that the I-Love relation is most strongly reinforced around the incompressible limit (polytrope with n=0n = 0) using an exact solution to Eq. (6), called a generalized Tolman VII model. It is worth noting that this model serves as a good approximation for quark stars rather than NSs, except in the Tolman VII-solution limit as the density is generally discontinuous at the stellar surface. Within this framework, the incompressible limit corresponds to a stationary point of the I-Love relation, in the sense that the relative change rate of the coefficient in the power-law relation becomes exactly zero (see Figure 5 in the reference). In Appendix C, we demonstrate that the rate for the I-Love relation within our framework reaches a minimum in the locally incompressible limit in a similar manner to the universal Love relations.

The proposal by Ref. [61] is that the I-Love-Q relation can be attributed to the incompressible limit; the high stiffness of EoSs causes approximate universality of NSs. Establishing this statement requires addressing a question regarding the difference in the profile of the local adiabatic index in the generalized Tolman VII model from that of realistic EoSs for NSs, particularly in the outer region. In the previous section, we found the strongest reinforcement of the universal Love relations (as well as the I-Love relation, as discussed in Appendix C) around the locally incompressible limit in the inner core, which is consistent with this statement. Therefore, our findings support and complement the claim in Ref. [61] by providing a comprehensive perspective on the approximate universality of NSs, based on an analytic model for realistic NSs, instead of quark stars.

Reference [60] found that the isodensity contours of rotating NSs with realistic EoSs can be approximated by self-similar ellipsoids and relaxing this assumption in stellar modeling destroys the three hair relations discovered by Ref. [46]. These results suggest that the self-similarity of elliptical stellar isodensity surfaces is responsible for the approximate universality. Figure 17 in Ref. [60] demonstrates that the spatial variation in stellar eccentricity of Newtonian polytropes tends to weaken as the polytropic index nn decreases, and vanishes in the incompressible fluid case (n=0n = 0). This suggests that, for stiffer EoSs, the energy density profile is better approximated by a sequence of self-similar surfaces with constant stellar eccentricity. Notably, this approximation becomes exact when n=0n = 0. On the other hand, softer EoSs tend to break this self-similar condition, resulting in the loss of universality. These findings further highlight the importance of stiffness of EoSs in approximate universality, which is consistent with our results.

Discussion and extensions

We have conducted a comprehensive theoretical investigation of approximate universality of NSs using a semi-analytic approach. Our analysis relies on the semi-analytic NS interior model proposed in Ref. [68] and fully analytic NS interior model proposed in Ref. [69], both of which approximately recover static equilibrium configurations of NSs with realistic EoSs in a wide range of compactnesses. The derived power-law relations among tidal deformabilities agree well with the empirical fit in Ref. [42].

In general, magnetic-type tidal deformabilities are expected to be difficult to measure, even in third generation GW observations due to their small magnitude compared to the even-parity tidal deformabilities. However, their sign depends on the fluid state in the NS interior [84, 85], which may leave detectable imprints in the GW phase [53]. Our analysis of the odd-parity stellar perturbations assumes an irrotational state that permits internal motions, leading to negative-valued magnetic-type tidal deformabilities, while assuming a strictly static state results in positive values [75]. The universal Love relations derived in this work can be used to infer the fluid state inside realistic NSs within GR.

A potential extension of the present work involves incorporating the effect of NS rotation, even though NSs in a binary system are generically expected to rotate slowly. The perturbative framework in Refs. [86, 87] about a small spin parameter shows that the coupling between NS spin and a tidal environment gives rise to a new class of tidal coefficients, dubbed rotational TLNs. Notably, it has been suggested that slowly spinning NSs do not exhibit the I-Love relations with respect to the rotational TLNs [88]. Exploring the breakdown of universality due to the spin-tidal coupling would provide a deeper insight into the fundamental physical origin of universality. Alternatively, it is beneficial to study whether universality with respect to rotational TLNs is preserved under a different construction of relevant dimensionless quantities, as the strength of universality appears to depend on normalization of physical parameters [89].

From a practical perspective, if the universal Love relations hold even for rotational TLNs, they could provide a powerful tool for waveform modeling. This is because the leading-order rotational TLN enters at 6.5PN order, which is lower than the ℓ≥3\ell\ge3rd electric-type and magnetic-type tidal deformabilities [53]. Furthermore, neglecting the spin-tidal coupling may introduce a significant bias in parameter estimation for NSs with dimensionless spin of χ∼0.1\chi\sim0.1 with third-generation detectors [53, 58]. Establishing an EoS insensitive connection between the rotational TLN and the quadrupolar electric-type tidal deformability could enhance the ability to infer the EoS at supernuclear densities and test GR in the strong-field regime.

This work focuses on NSs within GR. Modifying the theory of gravity can alter the description of the coupling between gravity and matter, leading to deviations in tidal deformabilities from their GR values. It is not obvious whether NSs in modified theories of gravity exhibit approximate universality among various tidal deformabilities. If universal Love relations hold even for non-GR theories, the power-law relations would differ from those in GR. The EoS insensitive property provides a novel approach to test strong gravity through tidal effects in GW observations.

The approximate universality of tidally deformed NSs is reminiscent of a hidden symmetry underlying the vanishing TLNs of black holes [90, 91, 92] in the sense that Schwarzschild black holes have identical (zero) TLNs at any multipole orders in both the even-parity and odd-parity sectors. Since the exterior region of a nonspinning NS is uniquely described by the Schwarzschild spacetime, one could interpret that the compact stellar interior region weakly breaks the symmetry, leading to nonzero TLNs, whose values increase as the stellar compactness decreases. Although there is no stationary continuous sequence from a NS to a black hole within a perfect-fluid approximation due to the Buchdahl limit [93], the approximate universal Love relations could be understood in this context. We leave further consideration for future study.

Acknowledgments

We are indebted to Zexin Hu and Lijing Shao for their valuable comments and insights. T.K. and G.R.M. acknowledge support from the Villum Investigator program supported by the VILLUM Foundation (grant no. VIL37766) and the DNRF Chair program (grant no. DNRF162) by the Danish National Research Foundation. This work has received funding from the European Union’s Horizon 2020 research and innovation programme under the Marie Sklodowska-Curie grant agreement No 101131233. The Center of Gravity is a Center of Excellence funded by the Danish National Research Foundation under grant No. 184. K.Y. acknowledges support from NSF Grant No. PHY-2309066, No. PHYS-2339969, and the Owens Family Foundation.

Modified Tolman VII model

Semi-analytic model

We provide the modified Tolman VII solution in Figure 9–Figure 11 with C=0.1\mathcal{C}=0.1. The energy density profile is given by Eq. (8) and is depicted in Figure 2.

Figure 11. The lapse function profile of the modified Tolman VII solution.

Figure 10. The pressure profile of the modified Tolman VII solution.

Fully analytic model

The explicit form of the fully analytic model of the modified Tolman VII solution is given by [69]

eν=C1cos⁡2ϕ,(30)e^\nu=C_1\cos^2\phi, \tag*{(30)}
e−λ=1−8πρcR2ξ2(13−α5ξ2+α−17ξ4),e^{-\lambda}=1-8\pi\rho_cR^2\xi^2\left(\frac{1}{3}-\frac{\alpha}{5}\xi^2+\frac{\alpha-1}{7}\xi^4\right),

with

ϕ=C2−12ln⁡(ξ2−56+5e−λ∣α=18πρcR2),\phi=C_2-\frac{1}{2}\ln\left(\xi^2-\frac{5}{6}+\sqrt{\frac{5e^{-\lambda}|_{\alpha=1}}{8\pi\rho_cR^2}}\right),
C1=(1−2MR)×{1+8πρcR2(10−3α)2(15−16πρcR2)3[105+16πρcR2(3α−10)]2},(31)C_1=\left(1-\frac{2M}{R}\right)\times\left\{1+\frac{8\pi\rho_cR^2(10-3\alpha)^2(15-16\pi\rho_cR^2)}{3[105+16\pi\rho_cR^2(3\alpha-10)]^2}\right\}, \tag*{(31)}
C2=arctan⁡[−2(10−3α)R6πρc(15−16πρcR2)48πρc(10−3α)R2−315]+12ln⁡(16+58πρcR2−23),C_2=\arctan\left[-\frac{2(10-3\alpha)R\sqrt{6\pi\rho_c(15-16\pi\rho_cR^2)}}{48\pi\rho_c(10-3\alpha)R^2-315}\right]+\frac{1}{2}\ln\left(\frac{1}{6}+\sqrt{\frac{5}{8\pi\rho_cR^2}}-\frac{2}{3}\right),

and

p=tan⁡ϕRρc10π[1−8πρcR215ξ2(5−3ξ2)]−ρc15(5−3ξ2)+6(1−α)ρc16πρcR2(10−3α)−105.(32)p=\frac{\tan\phi}{R}\sqrt{\frac{\rho_c}{10\pi}\left[1-\frac{8\pi\rho_cR^2}{15}\xi^2(5-3\xi^2)\right]-\frac{\rho_c}{15}(5-3\xi^2)+\frac{6(1-\alpha)\rho_c}{16\pi\rho_cR^2(10-3\alpha)-105}}. \tag*{(32)}

Here, ρc\rho_c is the energy density at the stellar origin, related to the total mass MM via

ρc=105M8πR3(10−3α).(33)\rho_c=\frac{105M}{8\pi R^3(10-3\alpha)}. \tag*{(33)}

This model satisfies boundary conditions eν(R)=e−λ(R)=1−2M/Re^{\nu(R)}=e^{-\lambda(R)}=1-2M/R and p(R)=ρ(R)=0p(R)=\rho(R)=0 with m(R)=Mm(R)=M.

Linear perturbations for relativistic stars

In this appendix, we describe linear perturbations for relativistic stars. We explain even-parity and odd-parity sectors separately.

Even-parity sector

Stellar perturbations

We first briefly introduce the general framework of frequency-dependent linear perturbations of relativistic stars. In the Regge-Wheeler gauge [94], the even-parity sector of metric perturbations with harmonic decomposition takes the form,

hμν+dxμdxν=(eνHℓmdt2+2H1ℓmdtdr+eλH2ℓmdr2+r2KℓmdΩ2)e−iωtYℓm.(34)h^+_{\mu\nu}dx^\mu dx^\nu=\left(e^\nu H^{\ell m}dt^2+2H^{\ell m}_1dtdr+e^\lambda H^{\ell m}_2dr^2+r^2K^{\ell m}d\Omega^2\right)e^{-i\omega t}Y_{\ell m}. \tag*{(34)}

Here, Hℓm=Hℓm(r)H^{\ell m}=H^{\ell m}(r), H1ℓm=H1ℓm(r)H^{\ell m}_1=H^{\ell m}_1(r), H2ℓm=H2ℓm(r)H^{\ell m}_2=H^{\ell m}_2(r), Kℓm=Kℓm(r)K^{\ell m}=K^{\ell m}(r); Yℓm=Yℓm(θ,ϕ)Y_{\ell m}=Y_{\ell m}(\theta,\phi) are spherical harmonics. Henceforth, we drop the superscript ℓm\ell m.

The even-parity metric perturbation induces the displacement of ρ\rho, pp, and the four velocity. We parametrize the Lagrangian displacement of the fluid variables by two functions, W=W(r)W=W(r) and V=V(r)V=V(r), so that the components of the displacement vector ξμ\xi^\mu are expressed by [95]

ξr=rℓ−1e−λ/2We−iωtYℓm,ξA=−rℓVe−iωtEAℓm,(35)\xi^r=r^{\ell-1}e^{-\lambda/2}We^{-i\omega t}Y_{\ell m},\qquad\xi_A=-r^\ell Ve^{-i\omega t}E^{\ell m}_A, \tag*{(35)}

where EAℓm:=(0,0,∂θYℓm,∂ϕYℓm)E^{\ell m}_A:=(0,0,\partial_\theta Y_{\ell m},\partial_\phi Y_{\ell m}) are even-parity vector spherical harmonics. We assume uμξμ=0u_\mu\xi^\mu=0 by using the gauge degrees of freedom. One can express the Eulerian perturbation of the four velocity, δuμ\delta u^\mu, in terms of WW and VV as follows. First, for the Lagrangian variation Δ\Delta, using the normalization condition (gμν+Δgμν)(uμ+Δuμ)(uν+Δuν)≃−1(g_{\mu\nu}+\Delta g_{\mu\nu})(u^\mu+\Delta u^\mu)(u^\nu+\Delta u^\nu)\simeq-1 to linear order, and noticing that Δuμ\Delta u^\mu should be proportional to uμu^\mu linearly, one obtains the expression for Δuμ\Delta u^\mu by [96]

Δuμ=12uμuαuβΔgαβ.(36)\Delta u^\mu=\frac{1}{2}u^\mu u^\alpha u^\beta\Delta g_{\alpha\beta}. \tag*{(36)}

Next, using the relation that relates the Lagrangian variation Δ\Delta with the Eulerian variation δ\delta through Δ=δ+Lξ\Delta=\delta+\mathcal{L}_{\xi}, where Lξ\mathcal{L}_{\xi} is the Lie derivative along ξ\xi, one obtains

δut=12e−ν/2He−iωtYℓm,δur=−iωe−ν/2ξr,δuA=−iωe−ν/2ξA.(37)\begin{aligned} \delta u^t &= \frac{1}{2}e^{-\nu/2}H e^{-i\omega t}Y_{\ell m},\\ \delta u^r &= -i\omega e^{-\nu/2}\xi^r,\qquad\delta u^A = -i\omega e^{-\nu/2}\xi^A. \tag*{(37)} \end{aligned}

The Eulerian variation of the density and pressure at linear order is related to the change of the baryon number density as follows. First, we assume that the baryon number of each fluid element in the perturbed configuration is conserved:

Δ[∇μ(nuμ)]=0,(38)\Delta\left[\nabla_{\mu}\left(nu^{\mu}\right)\right]=0, \tag*{(38)}

where nn is the baryon number density; Δn\Delta n is its Lagrangian displacement. Using Eq. (36), Eq. (38) at linear order leads to the fractional change of the baryon number density,

Δnn=−12(gμν+uμuν)Δgμν,(39)\frac{\Delta n}{n}=-\frac{1}{2}\left(g^{\mu\nu}+u^{\mu}u^{\nu}\right)\Delta g_{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(39)}

which reads

Δnn=−e−iωtYℓm[H22+K+ℓ(ℓ+1)rℓ−2V+e−λ/2rℓ−2{(ℓ+1)W+rW′}].(40)\frac{\Delta n}{n}=-e^{-i\omega t}Y_{\ell m} \left[ \frac{H_2}{2}+K+\ell(\ell+1)r^{\ell-2}V +e^{-\lambda/2}r^{\ell-2}\left\{(\ell+1)W+rW'\right\} \right]. \tag*{(40)}

Now, we assume that the perturbation is isentropic (s=const.s=\mathrm{const.} everywhere), Δs=0\Delta s=0 for the entropy ss per baryon.8 Then, the first law of thermodynamics implies

Δρ=(ρ+p)Δnn.(41)\Delta\rho=(\rho+p)\frac{\Delta n}{n}. \tag*{(41)}

This is compatible with the baryon conservation, ∇μ(nuμ)=0\nabla_{\mu}(nu^{\mu})=0, and the projection of ∇μTμν=0\nabla_{\mu}T^{\mu\nu}=0 along the four velocity of the fluid.

The EoS links the pressure and energy density at the background level. In general, the Lagrangian perturbation to pressure, Δp\Delta p, depends on the EoS in equilibrium configurations and on chemical reactions during the dynamical process, which correlates with the entropy per baryon and the change in the fractional abundance of nuclear species inside the NS. If the relaxation timescale of perturbed configurations toward equilibrium is much shorter than the orbital period, the reactions may maintain equilibrium even in perturbed configurations in the

adiabatic manner. The fractional abundance of nuclear species then shifts continuously while maintaining equilibrium, and hence, the variation in pressure with respect to that in density in perturbations approximately follows the same relation as in equilibrium configurations. In such a situation, the EoS for the background also holds for perturbed configurations. The connection between density and pressure perturbations is provided by γ=γ(ρ)\gamma=\gamma(\rho) through

Δpp=γΔnn.(42)\frac{\Delta p}{p}=\gamma\frac{\Delta n}{n}. \tag*{(42)}

With these, one can obtain the Eulerian variation of the pressure and energy density via

δρ=Δρ−ξrρ′,δp=Δp−ξrp′.(43)\delta\rho=\Delta\rho-\xi^r\rho',\qquad\delta p=\Delta p-\xi^r p'. \tag*{(43)}
Perturbation equations

Now, let us linearize Einstein’s equations and the matter conservation law, δGμν=8πδTμν\delta G_{\mu\nu}=8\pi\delta T_{\mu\nu}, and δ(∇μTμν)=0\delta(\nabla_{\mu}T^{\mu\nu})=0. Combining various components in these equations, we derive a set of perturbation equations for HH, WW, and VV as follows.

We begin with the perturbed Einstein’s equations. First, δG θθ−δG φφ=8π(δT θθ−δT φφ)\delta G^{\theta}_{\ \theta}-\delta G^{\varphi}_{\ \varphi}=8\pi(\delta T^{\theta}_{\ \theta}-\delta T^{\varphi}_{\ \varphi}) allows us to express H2H_2 in terms of HH. With this, δG rθ=8πδT rθ\delta G^{\theta}_{\ r}=8\pi\delta T^{\theta}_{\ r} yields H1=H1(H,K,H′,K′)H_1=H_1(H,K,H',K'); δG θθ=8πδT θθ\delta G^{\theta}_{\ \theta}=8\pi\delta T^{\theta}_{\ \theta} leads to H1′=H1′(H,K,V,H′,K′)H'_1=H'_1(H,K,V,H',K'). Eliminating H2H_2, H1′H'_1, and H1H_1 from δG rr=8πδT rr\delta G^{r}_{\ r}=8\pi\delta T^{r}_{\ r} and δG tr=8πδT tr\delta G^{r}_{\ t}=8\pi\delta T^{r}_{\ t}, one obtains KK and K′K' in the form of a combination of (H,W,V,H′,W′,V′)(H,W,V,H',W',V'). One can then express H′′H'' in terms of (H,W,V,H′,W′,V′)(H,W,V,H',W',V') using δG tt=8πδT tt\delta G^{t}_{\ t}=8\pi\delta T^{t}_{\ t}.

Next, we look at the perturbed stress-energy conservation equation. From δ(∇μT θμ)=0\delta(\nabla_{\mu}T^{\mu}_{\ \theta})=0, one derives the expression for W′W' in terms of (H,W,V,H′,V′)(H,W,V,H',V'), leading to δ(∇μT rμ)=0\delta(\nabla_{\mu}T^{\mu}_{\ r})=0. Next, δ(∇μT rμ)=0\delta(\nabla_{\mu}T^{\mu}_{\ r})=0 gives V′V' in terms of (H,W,V,H′)(H,W,V,H'), thereby allowing one to eliminate V′V' from W′W' and H′′H''.

Thus, the perturbation equations to be solved are summarized into a set of the following three equations in the form of

H′′=αH,H′H′+αH,HH+αH,WW+αH,VV,(44)H''=\alpha_{H,H'}H'+\alpha_{H,H}H+\alpha_{H,W}W+\alpha_{H,V}V, \tag*{(44)}

and

W′=αW,H′H′+αW,HH+αW,WW+αW,VV,(45)W'=\alpha_{W,H'}H'+\alpha_{W,H}H+\alpha_{W,W}W+\alpha_{W,V}V, \tag*{(45)}

with

V′=αV,H′H′+αV,HH+αV,WW+αV,VV.(46)V'=\alpha_{V,H'}H'+\alpha_{V,H}H+\alpha_{V,W}W+\alpha_{V,V}V. \tag*{(46)}

Here, αq,i\alpha_{q,i} are functions of the background quantities. We provide their expression in online [82].

Static tidal perturbations

Taking the stationary limit ω→0\omega\to0, Eq. (45) leads to an algebraic equation for WW, allowing one to express it in terms of HH. Then, Eq. (46) connects VV with HH. One can now show Δn/n=O(ω)\Delta n/n = O(\omega). In other words, the fractional volumetric change per baryon is zero at the leading order of small ω\omega expansion. This leads to δρ=cs2δp\delta\rho= c_s^2 \delta p for the speed of sound in unperturbed configurations, cs:=(dp/dρ)1/2c_s := (dp/d\rho)^{1/2}, which is the assumption often used in the literature. Equation (B11) thus results in a single second-order ordinary differential equation for HH:

H′′+P1H′−P2H=0,(47)H^{\prime\prime} + P_1 H^\prime- P_2 H = 0, \tag*{(47)}

with

P1=2r+eλ[2mr2+4πr(p−ρ)],(48)P_1 = \frac{2}{r} + e^\lambda\left[\frac{2m}{r^2} + 4\pi r(p-\rho)\right], \tag*{(48)}
P2=eλ[ℓ(ℓ+1)r2−4πp+ρcs2−4π(5ρ+9p)]+ν′2.P_2 = e^\lambda\left[\frac{\ell(\ell+1)}{r^2} - 4\pi\frac{p+\rho}{c_s^2} - 4\pi(5\rho+9p)\right] + \nu^{\prime2}.

Equation (B14) is consistent with Eq. (15) of Ref. [73] and Eq. (27) of Ref. [74].

The tidal deformabilities, λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2 and λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_3, in Figure 4, Figure 5, and Figure 14 are derived by solving Eq. (47) with the background being the modified Tolman VII solution, provided in Appendix A. In what follows, we solve Eq. (47) in the stellar exterior and interior on the fully analytic background, provided in Appendix A, in an analytic manner. We then match the logarithmic derivatives of the solutions at the stellar surface, thereby describing the static tidal response.

External problem

The exterior solution, HextH_{\mathrm{ext}}, corresponds to tidal perturbations in the Schwarzschild spacetime (7), and thus obeys

Hext′′+2(r−M)r2fHext′−1r2f[ℓ(ℓ+1)+4M2r2f]Hext=0,(49)H_{\mathrm{ext}}^{\prime\prime} + \frac{2(r-M)}{r^2 f}H_{\mathrm{ext}}^\prime- \frac{1}{r^2 f}\left[\ell(\ell+1)+\frac{4M^2}{r^2 f}\right]H_{\mathrm{ext}}=0, \tag*{(49)}

where f:=1−2M/rf := 1-2M/r. The general solution is [78, 79]

Hext=EHHT+IHHR,(50)H_{\mathrm{ext}}=E_H H_T+I_H H_R, \tag*{(50)}

where EHE_H and IHI_H are integration constants with

HT:=f(rM)ℓ2F1(−ℓ+2,−ℓ;−2ℓ;2Mr),(51)H_T := f\left(\frac{r}{M}\right)^\ell{}_2F_1\left(-\ell+2,-\ell;-2\ell;\frac{2M}{r}\right), \tag*{(51)}
HR:=f(Mr)ℓ+12F1(ℓ+1,ℓ+3;2ℓ+2;2Mr).H_R := f\left(\frac{M}{r}\right)^{\ell+1}{}_2F_1\left(\ell+1,\ell+3;2\ell+2;\frac{2M}{r}\right).

Here, 2F1(a,b;c;2M/r){}_2F_1(a,b;c;2M/r) are Gaussian hypergeometric functions [97]. Following a “standard” definition [75, 79, 98] arising from the analytical properties of the hypergeometric functions, one can relate EHE_H and IHI_H to the electric-type tidal moment and mass multipole moment, thereby obtaining the expression for the electric-type TLNs,

kℓ=12C2ℓ+1IHEH.(52)k_\ell=\frac{1}{2}C^{2\ell+1}\frac{I_H}{E_H}. \tag*{(52)}

The integration constants are determined by matching the exterior solution with an interior solution, derived in the subsequent section, at the stellar surface.

Internal problem

We first introduce a new variable yin+=rHin′/Hiny_{\mathrm{in}}^+ = rH_{\mathrm{in}}^\prime/H_{\mathrm{in}} for the interior solution HinH_{\mathrm{in}} for later convenience. (47) reduces to

ryin+′+(yin+)2+F+yin+−Q+=0,(53)r y_{\mathrm{in}}^{+\prime}+(y_{\mathrm{in}}^+)^2+F^+y_{\mathrm{in}}^+-Q^+=0, \tag*{(53)}

with

F+=eλ[1+4πr2(p−ρ)],(54)F^+=e^\lambda\left[1+4\pi r^2(p-\rho)\right], \tag*{(54)}
Q+=ℓ(ℓ+1)eλ−4πr2{eλ[5ρ+9p+ρ+pcs2]−ν′24π}.Q^+=\ell(\ell+1)e^\lambda-4\pi r^2\left\{e^\lambda\left[5\rho+9p+\frac{\rho+p}{c_s^2}\right]-\frac{\nu^{\prime2}}{4\pi}\right\}.

The regularity condition for HH at the stellar origin translates into yin+∣r=0=ℓy_{\mathrm{in}}^+|_{r=0}=\ell.

To solve Eq. (53) analytically, we first use a PM expansion for yin+y_{\mathrm{in}}^+ in terms of C\mathcal{C}, following Refs. [72, 99, 100],

yin+=∑j=0jmax⁡Cjyj+(r).(55)y_{\mathrm{in}}^+=\sum_{j=0}^{j_{\max}} C^j y_j^+(r). \tag*{(55)}

(53) is then reduced into a set of equations for yj+y_j^+. We further Taylor-expand yj+y_j^+ around the origin,

yj+=∑k=0kmax⁡cj,2k+r2k.(56)y_j^+=\sum_{k=0}^{k_{\max}}c_{j,2k}^+r^{2k}. \tag*{(56)}

The resulting equations form recurrence relations about cj,2k+c_{j,2k}^+. Solving them under yin+∣r=0=ℓy_{\mathrm{in}}^+|_{r=0}=\ell, we derive the analytic expression for yin+y_{\mathrm{in}}^+, thereby obtaining yin+∣r=Ry_{\mathrm{in}}^+|_{r=R}. Note that (jmax⁡,kmax⁡)(j_{\max},k_{\max}) is not specified at the current stage; the best set is determined by comparing analytically computed λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_\ell with numerical results for various sets.

Electric-type tidal deformability

The following matching, rHext′/Hext∣r=R=yin+∣r=RrH_{\mathrm{ext}}^\prime/H_{\mathrm{ext}}|_{r=R}=y_{\mathrm{in}}^+|_{r=R}, allows us to obtain kℓk_\ell in Eq. (52) in the form of the expansion about C\mathcal{C} via

IHEH=−RHT′−yin+HTRHR′−yin+HR∣r=R.(57)\frac{I_H}{E_H}=-\left.\frac{RH_T^\prime-y_{\mathrm{in}}^+H_T}{RH_R^\prime-y_{\mathrm{in}}^+H_R}\right|_{r=R}. \tag*{(57)}

Note that IH/EHI_H/E_H scales as O(C−2ℓ−1)\mathcal{O}(C^{-2\ell-1}), implying kℓ=O(C0)k_\ell=\mathcal{O}(C^0). This is consistent with previous findings by Refs. [74, 75] showing that the electric-type TLNs for stars are generically nonvanishing in the Newtonian limit.

We thus obtain the expression for λˉℓ\bar{\lambda}_\ell in Eq. (10) in the form of a polynomial of CC. To improve its accuracy further, we re-sum the polynomial with the Padé approximant, thereby obtaining

λˉℓ=2(2ℓ−1)!! C2ℓ+1pℓ,0++pℓ,1+C+pℓ,2+C2+pℓ,3+C3qℓ,0++qℓ,1+C+qℓ,2+C2+qℓ,3+C3(58)\bar{\lambda}_\ell=\frac{2}{(2\ell-1)!!\,C^{2\ell+1}}\frac{p_{\ell,0}^{+}+p_{\ell,1}^{+}C+p_{\ell,2}^{+}C^2+p_{\ell,3}^{+}C^3}{q_{\ell,0}^{+}+q_{\ell,1}^{+}C+q_{\ell,2}^{+}C^2+q_{\ell,3}^{+}C^3} \tag*{(58)}

where pℓ,i+=pℓ,i+(α)p_{\ell,i}^{+}=p_{\ell,i}^{+}(\alpha) and qℓ,i+=qℓ,i+(α)q_{\ell,i}^{+}=q_{\ell,i}^{+}(\alpha) (with the modified Tolman α\alpha) for $i=0,1,2,3. The explicit forms of pℓ,i+p_{\ell,i}^{+} and qℓ,i+q_{\ell,i}^{+} are provided in online [82]. (58) is identical to Eq. (13).

Figure 12 compares λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2 computed from Eq. (58) with the values computed numerically, showing good agreement across various α\alpha in the low-compactness regime. The agreement between the analytical and numerical solutions for λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2 and λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_3 follows the same trend. In the regime of low compactness, the values found analytically exhibit excellent agreement with the numerical results, with the relative error decreasing until reaching a minimum at a certain value of compactness. Beyond this point, the error begins to increase again and eventually diverges rapidly as CC increases. The main effect of varying the truncation order of CC seems to shift the location of this minimum: a higher truncation order of CC moves this minimum towards a higher value of compactness. This, in turn, extends the regime over which the analytic expressions for λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2 or λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_3 remain accurate. One can further reduce the error by employing higher order Padé approximants. Nevertheless, for the purposes of the present work, it is sufficient to consider the Padé approximants up to [3/3][3/3] order. Truncating the PM expansion at O(C6)\mathcal{O}(C^6) is sufficient for the Padé approximation at [3/3][3/3] order, as proceeding to even higher orders in CC yields only negligible improvements in the accuracy of both λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2 and λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_3.

Furthermore, we compared our results with the analytical expression derived in Ref. [69] for λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2. We find that our expression yields a more accurate λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2 over the entire range of compactness by expanding yin+y_{\mathrm{in}}^{+} to higher order about CC and ξ\xi, thereby improving the previous results.

Compactness in terms of λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2

Here, we provide the expressions for βj\beta_j in Eq. (15):

β1=0.735783…,β2=−0.692724…,β3=0.502849…,β4=−0.313895…,β5=0.164826…,β6=−0.0694865…,β7=0.0223008…,β8=−0.00777183….(59)\begin{aligned} \beta_1&=0.735783\ldots,\\ \beta_2&=-0.692724\ldots,\\ \beta_3&=0.502849\ldots,\\ \beta_4&=-0.313895\ldots,\\ \beta_5&=0.164826\ldots,\\ \beta_6&=-0.0694865\ldots,\\ \beta_7&=0.0223008\ldots,\\ \beta_8&=-0.00777183\ldots. \tag*{(59)} \end{aligned}

Here, …\ldots denotes higher-order decimal digits. In the actual derivation of the power-law expressions (1) and (2), we have used fractions, which have arbitrary precision. We only present numerical values above because the exact expressions are too lengthy. The precise values of βj\beta_j are provided in online [82].

Odd-parity sector

Stellar perturbation equations

We next present stellar perturbations in the odd-parity sector. In the Regge-Wheeler gauge, the odd-parity sector of metric perturbations with harmonic decomposition takes the form,

hμνℓmdxμdxν=(2hℓmSθℓmdtdθ+2hℓmSϕℓmdtdφ+2h1ℓmSθℓmdrdθ+2h1ℓmSϕℓmdrdφ)e−iωt.(60)h_{\mu\nu}^{\ell m}dx^\mu dx^\nu= \left(2h^{\ell m}S_\theta^{\ell m}dtd\theta+ 2h^{\ell m}S_\phi^{\ell m}dtd\varphi+ 2h_1^{\ell m}S_\theta^{\ell m}drd\theta+ 2h_1^{\ell m}S_\phi^{\ell m}drd\varphi\right)e^{-i\omega t}. \tag*{(60)}

Here, hℓm=hℓm(r)h^{\ell m}=h^{\ell m}(r), h1ℓm=h1ℓm(r)h_1^{\ell m}=h_1^{\ell m}(r); (Sθℓm,Sϕℓm):=(−∂φYℓm/sin⁡θ,sin⁡θ∂θYℓm)(S_\theta^{\ell m},S_\phi^{\ell m}):=(-\partial_\varphi Y_{\ell m}/\sin\theta,\sin\theta\partial_\theta Y_{\ell m}). Henceforth, we drop the superscript ℓm\ell m.

In the odd-parity sector, the metric perturbation is not coupled to the pressure and density perturbations but induces the displacement of the four velocity. The Eulerian perturbation of the four velocity is parametrized by a function U=U(r)U=U(r) [85, 88, 101]

δut=0,δur=0,(61)\delta u^t=0,\quad\delta u^r=0, \tag*{(61)}
δuA=Ueν/24πr2(ρ+p)(Sθℓm,Sφℓmsin⁡2θ)e−iωt.(62)\delta u^A=\frac{Ue^{\nu/2}}{4\pi r^2(\rho+p)}\left(S_\theta^{\ell m},\frac{S_\varphi^{\ell m}}{\sin^2\theta}\right)e^{-i\omega t}. \tag*{(62)}

Now, linearizing Einstein’s equations and the matter conservation law, we derive a set of perturbation equations. First, δGθθ=8πδTθθ\delta G^\theta_\theta=8\pi\delta T^\theta_\theta allows us to express h1′h_1' in terms of hh and h1h_1, Then, δGrθ=8πδTrθ\delta G^\theta_r=8\pi\delta T^\theta_r leads to

h1=iωrrh′−2hω2r2−eν(ℓ2+ℓ−2).(63)h_1=i\omega r\frac{rh'-2h}{\omega^2r^2-e^\nu(\ell^2+\ell-2)}. \tag*{(63)}

One finds from δ(∇μTθμ)=0\delta(\nabla_\mu T^\mu_\theta)=0 that

U=−4πe−νh(ρ+p).(64)U=-4\pi e^{-\nu}h(\rho+p). \tag*{(64)}

With these, δGtθ=8πδTtθ\delta G^\theta_t=8\pi\delta T^\theta_t yields a second-order differential equation for hh:

h′′=αh,h′h′+αh,hh,(65)h''=\alpha_{h,h'}h'+\alpha_{h,h}h, \tag*{(65)}

where αh,i\alpha_{h,i} are functions of the background quantities. We provide their expression in online [82].

Static tidal perturbation

Taking the stationary limit of Eq. (65) leads to9

h′′−4πreλ(ρ+p)h′−eλ[ℓ(ℓ+1)r2−4mr3−8π(ρ+p)]h=0.(66)h''-4\pi r e^\lambda(\rho+p)h'-e^\lambda\left[\frac{\ell(\ell+1)}{r^2}-\frac{4m}{r^3}-8\pi(\rho+p)\right]h=0. \tag*{(66)}

Equation (B33) is consistent with the stationary limit of Eq. (11) in Eq. (11) in Ref. [85], Eq. (5.6) in Ref. [84], and Eq. (31) in Ref. [74].

The tidal deformability σˉ2\bar{\sigma}_2 is derived by solving Eq. (66) numerically under the modified Tolman VII background solution. Here, similar to the even-parity case, we solve Eq. (66) in the stellar exterior and interior on the analytic background in a fully analytic manner and then match their logarithmic derivatives of the solutions at the stellar surface, thereby evaluating the static tidal response.

External problem

(66) reduces to a master equation for tidal perturbations, hexth_{\mathrm{ext}}, in the Schwarzschild spacetime (7),

hext′′−1r2f[ℓ(ℓ+1)−4Mr]hext=0.(67)h_{\mathrm{ext}}''-\frac{1}{r^2f}\left[\ell(\ell+1)-\frac{4M}{r}\right]h_{\mathrm{ext}}=0. \tag*{(67)}

The general solution is found in closed form [78, 79]

hext=EhhT+IhhR,(68)h_{\mathrm{ext}}=E_hh_T+I_hh_R, \tag*{(68)}

where EhE_h and IhI_h are integration constants with

hT:=(rM)ℓ+12F1(−ℓ+1,−ℓ−2;−2ℓ;2M/r),(69)h_T:=\left(\frac{r}{M}\right)^{\ell+1}{}_2F_1(-\ell+1,-\ell-2;-2\ell;2M/r), \tag*{(69)}
hR:=(Mr)ℓ2F1(ℓ−1,ℓ+2;2ℓ+2;2M/r).h_R:=\left(\frac{M}{r}\right)^\ell{}_2F_1(\ell-1,\ell+2;2\ell+2;2M/r).

Following a “standard” definition [75, 79, 98], one can identify the integration constants with the magnetic-type tidal moment and the current multipole moment, thus obtaining

jℓ=−ℓ+2ℓ−1C2ℓ+1IhEh.(70)j_\ell=-\frac{\ell+2}{\ell-1}C_{2\ell+1}\frac{I_h}{E_h}. \tag*{(70)}

Similar to the even-sector case, the integration constants are determined by matching the exterior solution with an interior solution derived in the next section.

Internal problem

Introducing a new variable yin=rhin′/hiny_{\mathrm{in}}=rh'_{\mathrm{in}}/h_{\mathrm{in}} for convenience, Eq. (B33) is cast into

ryin′+(yin)2+F−yin−Q−=0,(71)ry'_{\mathrm{in}}+(y_{\mathrm{in}})^2+F^{-}y_{\mathrm{in}}-Q^{-}=0, \tag*{(71)}

with

F−=−1−4πr2eλ(ρ+p),(72)F^{-}=-1-4\pi r^2e^\lambda(\rho+p), \tag*{(72)}
Q−=−eλ{4mr−[ℓ(ℓ+1)−8πr2(ρ+p)]}.Q^{-}=-e^\lambda\left\{\frac{4m}{r}-\left[\ell(\ell+1)-8\pi r^2(\rho+p)\right]\right\}.

The regularity condition for hh at the stellar origin translates to yin∣r=0=ℓ+1y_{\mathrm{in}}|_{r=0}=\ell+1.

Similar to the even-parity case, we expand yiny_{\mathrm{in}} in terms of C\mathcal{C},

yin=∑j=0jmax⁡Cjyj−(r).(73)y_{\mathrm{in}}=\sum_{j=0}^{j_{\max}} \mathcal{C}^{j}y_j^{-}(r). \tag*{(73)}

Substituting this into Eq. (B38), we derive differential equations for yj−y_j^{-}. We solve them order by order and impose yin∣r=0=ℓ+1y_{\mathrm{in}}|_{r=0}=\ell+1, thereby deriving yin∣r=Ry_{\mathrm{in}}|_{r=R} approximately. Notably, the construction of yiny_{\mathrm{in}} does not require a Taylor expansion around the origin, unlike to the even-parity case as in Eq. (B23).

Magnetic-type tidal deformability

The matching condition, rhint′/hint∣r=R=yext∣r=Rrh'_{\mathrm{int}}/h_{\mathrm{int}}|_{r=R}=y_{\mathrm{ext}}|_{r=R}, leads to the expression for jℓj_\ell in Eq. (B37) in the form of the expansion of C\mathcal{C} through

IhEh=−RhT′−yinhTRhR′−yinhR∣r=R.(74)\frac{I_h}{E_h}=-\left.\frac{Rh'_T-y_{\mathrm{in}}h_T}{Rh'_R-y_{\mathrm{in}}h_R}\right|_{r=R}. \tag*{(74)}

Note that Ih/EhI_h/E_h scales as O(C−2ℓ)O(\mathcal{C}^{-2\ell}), implying jℓ=O(C1)j_\ell=O(\mathcal{C}^{1}). The magnetic-type TLNs have no Newtonian analogue, as shown in Refs. [74, 75].

We thus obtain σˉℓ\bar{\sigma}_\ell in Eq. (11) in the form of a polynomial of C\mathcal{C}. The Padé approximant of the polynomial provides more accurate expressions,

σˉℓ=ℓ−14(ℓ+2)(2ℓ−1)!!pˉℓ,0+pˉℓ,1C+pˉℓ,2C2C2ℓ(qˉℓ,0+qˉℓ,1C+qˉℓ,2C2).(75)\bar{\sigma}_\ell=\frac{\ell-1}{4(\ell+2)(2\ell-1)!!}\frac{\bar{p}_{\ell,0}+\bar{p}_{\ell,1}\mathcal{C}+\bar{p}_{\ell,2}\mathcal{C}^{2}}{\mathcal{C}^{2\ell}\left(\bar{q}_{\ell,0}+\bar{q}_{\ell,1}\mathcal{C}+\bar{q}_{\ell,2}\mathcal{C}^{2}\right)}. \tag*{(75)}

where pˉℓ,i=pˉℓ,i(α)\bar{p}_{\ell,i}=\bar{p}_{\ell,i}(\alpha) and qℓ,i=qℓ,i(α)q_{\ell,i}=q_{\ell,i}(\alpha) for i=0,1,2i=0,1,2. Equation (B42) is identical to Eq. (14). The explicit forms of pˉℓ,i\bar{p}_{\ell,i} and qℓ,iq_{\ell,i} are provided in online [82].

Figure 13 compares σˉ2\bar{\sigma}_2 computed from Eq. (B42) with the values computed numerically, showing their excellent agreement across various α\alpha.

I-Love relation from low compressibility

The moment of inertia quantifies how rapid an object can rotate for a given angular momentum and is related to the current dipole moment of the object. One can extract the (normalized) moment of inertia, Iˉ\bar{I}, from the asymptotic expansion of the tϕt\phi component of the metric of spinning stars at large distances. In this work, we utilize the analytic expression for Iˉ\bar{I} of the fully analytic modified Tolman VII model, derived in Ref. [72]. The expression for Iˉ\bar{I} can be found in Ref. [102]. Substituting C\mathcal{C} in Eq. (15) into this expression with α=1\alpha=1, and expanding it about 1/λˉ21/51/\bar{\lambda}_2^{1/5}, we obtain the theoretical power-law I-Love relation,

Iˉ=0.527755λˉ22/5(1+2.71536λˉ21/5+2.95181λˉ22/5+1.51947λˉ23/5+0.298088λˉ24/5+0.0295906λˉ2).(76)\bar{I}=0.527755\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{2/5}\left(1+\frac{2.71536}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{1/5}}+\frac{2.95181}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{2/5}}+\frac{1.51947}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{3/5}}+\frac{0.298088}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{4/5}}+\frac{0.0295906}{\bar{\lambda}_{2}}\right). \tag*{(76)}

Figure 14 presents the I-Love relation in the modified Tolman VII solution, showing that the power-law relation (C1) agrees well with the empirical fit in Refs. [35, 36].

We discuss the underlying structure of the I-Love relation. Let us focus on the Newtonian-order contribution. Noting that Iˉ\bar{I} scales as O(C−2)O(C^{-2}), one can obtain

Iˉ∝Iˉ(N)(k2(N))2/5λˉ22/5,(77)\bar{I}\propto\frac{\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})}}{\left(k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})}\right)^{2/5}}\bar{\lambda}_{2}^{2/5}, \tag*{(77)}

where Iˉ(N)\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})} is the leading-order coefficient of the PM expansion of Iˉ\bar{I} [72]. Here, notice that the power-law exponent of λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_{2}, 2/52/5, is independent of any microphysics, and is determined by the scaling law of Iˉ\bar{I} and λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_{2} with respect to CC, as in Eq. (22). Now, similar to Eq. (23), we expand Iˉ(N)\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})} around α=α0\alpha=\alpha_{0}, obtaining

Iˉ(N)=CI(0)[1−CI(1)(α−α0)+O((α−α0)2)],(78)\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})}=C_{I}^{(0)}\left[1-C_{I}^{(1)}(\alpha-\alpha_{0})+O\left((\alpha-\alpha_{0})^{2}\right)\right], \tag*{(78)}

where CI(i)C_{I}^{(i)} are positive numbers. For example, (CI(0),CI(1))=(0.29,0.11)(C_{I}^{(0)},C_{I}^{(1)})=(0.29,0.11) for α0=1\alpha_{0}=1. Notice that the

λˉ2−Iˉ\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{I}rλˉ2−Iˉ(1)r_{\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{I}}^{(1)}Exponent nˉ\bar{n}Ratio rλˉ2−Iˉ(1)(0)/rλˉ2−Iˉ(1)(1.4)r_{\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{I}}^{(1)}(0)/r_{\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{I}}^{(1)}(1.4)
λˉ2−Iˉ\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{I}0.352/51.1

caption: Similar to Table 1 but for the I-Love relation.

x−yx-y relationRatio rx−y(1)(1)r^{(1)}_{x-y}(1)Exponent nˉ\bar{n}Ratio rx−y(1)(0)/rx−y(1)(1.4)r^{(1)}_{x-y}(0)/r^{(1)}_{x-y}(1.4)
λˉ2−σˉ2\bar{\lambda}_2-\bar{\sigma}_20.684/5 (=0.8)4/5\ (=0.8)0.97
λˉ2−λˉ3\bar{\lambda}_2-\bar{\lambda}_31.17/5 (=1.4)7/5\ (=1.4)1.1
σˉ2−σˉ3\bar{\sigma}_2-\bar{\sigma}_31.23/2 (=1.5)3/2\ (=1.5)0.94

Table 1. The ratio of the relative change rates of TLNs, defined in the same manner as Eq. (25), the power-law exponent nˉ\bar{n} of each universal relation defined as y∝xnˉy\propto x^{\bar{n}} to leading order in the PM expansion, and the assessment of the insensitivity of the ratio to α\alpha, similar to Eq. (26). Observe that the ratio rx−y(1)(1)r^{(1)}_{x-y}(1) takes a value similar to the power-law exponent. Note that the ratio deviates from those values as α\alpha further increases.

:::

The ratio of the coefficient at first order in the expansion to that at zeroth order is negative as the expansion of k2k_{2} is in Eq. (23). Physically, for stiffer EoSs, the mass distribution in the stellar interior peaks further outward, making rotation more difficult for a given angular momentum. Also note 0.05≲CI(1)≲0.160.05\lesssim C_{I}^{(1)}\lesssim0.16 and CI(1)≃0.35Ck2(1)C_{I}^{(1)}\simeq0.35C_{k_{2}}^{(1)} for 0≤α0≤1.40\leq\alpha_{0}\leq1.4, indicating the modest α\alpha dependence. Indeed, there exists the so-called I-C relation [37], which is assessed by

Iˉ(N)Iˉ(N)∣α=0α=1.4≃1.1.(79)\left.\frac{\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})}}{\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})}}\right|_{\alpha=0}^{\alpha=1.4}\simeq1.1. \tag*{(79)}

For comparison, the ratio for polytropes with 0≤n≤10\leq n\leq1 is [35, 36]

Iˉ(N)Iˉ(N)∣n=0n=1≃1.5.(80)\left.\frac{\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})}}{\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})}}\right|_{n=0}^{n=1}\simeq1.5. \tag*{(80)}

The I-C relation has weaker universality compared to the I-Love relation (∼0.2%\sim0.2\% difference between polytropes with 0≤n≤10\leq n\leq1) [35, 36]. The ratio,

rλˉ2−Iˉ(1)(α)≡CI(1)(α)Ck2(1)(α)≃0.35(81)r_{\bar{\lambda}_{2}-\bar{I}}^{(1)}(\alpha)\equiv\frac{C_{I}^{(1)}(\alpha)}{C_{k_{2}}^{(1)}(\alpha)}\simeq0.35 \tag*{(81)}

approximately holds for the range of α\alpha studied in this paper and is close to the power-law exponent of the I-Love relation, 2/52/5, as presented in tbl:2. As α\alpha further increases, the ratio deviates from this value.

Equation (C2) shows that k2k_{2} enters in the denominator of the coefficient of the power-law relation in the same way as in Eq. (22). The α\alpha dependence coming from k2(N)k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})} contributes to the coefficient in the opposite way to that from Iˉ(N)\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})} in the combination. One finds

Iˉ(N)(k2(N))2/5∝1−(CI(1)−25Ck2(1))(α−α0)+O((α−α0)2).(82)\frac{\bar{I}^{(\mathrm{N})}}{\left(k_{2}^{(\mathrm{N})}\right)^{2/5}}\propto1-\left(C_{I}^{(1)}-\frac{2}{5}C_{k_{2}}^{(1)}\right)(\alpha-\alpha_{0})+O\left((\alpha-\alpha_{0})^{2}\right). \tag*{(82)}

Recalling that CI(1)≃0.35Ck2(1)C_{I}^{(1)}\simeq0.35C_{k_{2}}^{(1)} and Ck2=O(10−1)C_{k_{2}}=O(10^{-1}), the factor in front of (α−α0)(\alpha-\alpha_{0}) is of O(10−2)O(10^{-2}), indicating approximate universality. This is the same mechanism as the universal Love relations studied in Section IV. A key observation is that Iˉ\bar{I} shares the α\alpha dependence with λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_{2}.

We assess the universality by

C0Iˉλˉ2∣α=0C0Iˉλˉ2∣α=1.4≃0.98,C0Iˉλˉ2:=Iˉ(N)(k2(N))2/5.(83)\frac{\left.C_{0}^{\bar{I}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}\right|_{\alpha=0}}{\left.C_{0}^{\bar{I}\bar{\lambda}_{2}}\right|_{\alpha=1.4}} \simeq0.98,\qquad C_{0}^{\bar{I}\bar{\lambda}_{2}} := \frac{\bar{I}^{(N)}}{\left(k_{2}^{(N)}\right)^{2/5}}. \tag*{(83)}

This is slightly larger than the one for polytropes with 0≤n≤10 \le n \le1, which is 0.2% [35, 36]. In contrast to the I-C relation, the polytropes follow the I-Love relation more robustly compared to the modified Tolman VII solution with 0≤α≤1.40 \le\alpha\le1.4. This implies that the I-C relation does not necessarily underlie the I-Love relation, but is rather mutually correlated with the I-Love relation in a non-hierarchical manner. The suppression mechanism of the EoS dependence in the latter arises from different structures as the I-C relation, which appears to originate from an approximate quadratic energy density profile [72]. We speculate the similarity of the EoS dependence of TLNs and the moment of inertia (CI(1)/Ck2(1)≃0.35C_{I}^{(1)}/C_{k_{2}}^{(1)} \simeq0.35 in the current case) plays a certain role in the degree of the I-Love relation.

Figure 15 presents the relative change rate of C0Iˉλˉ2C_{0}^{\bar{I}\bar{\lambda}_{2}} in Eq. (83) with respect to α\alpha, showing that the α\alpha dependence of the power-law coefficient is weak, becomes weaker as α\alpha decreases, and reaches a minimum at α=0\alpha= 0. This implies that the I-Love relation can also be attributed to low compressibility in the entire interior region.

Figure 15. The relative change rate of C0Iˉλˉ2C_{0}^{\bar{I}\bar{\lambda}_{2}} in Eq. (83) with respect to α\alpha, indicating approximate universality between Iˉ\bar{I} and λˉ2\bar{\lambda}_{2}.

References

References

  1. [1]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 161101 (2017), arXiv:1710.05832 [gr-qc].
  2. [2]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Phys. Rev. X 9, 011001 (2019), arXiv:1805.11579 [gr-qc].DOI
  3. [3]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo, Fermi GBM, INTEGRAL, IceCube, AstroSat Cadmium Zinc Telluride Imager Team, IPN, Insight-Hxmt, ANTARES, Swift, AGILE Team, 1M2H Team, Dark Energy Camera GW-EM, DES, DLT40, GRAWITA, Fermi-LAT, ATCA, ASKAP, Las Cumbres Observatory Group, OzGrav, DWF (Deeper Wider Faster Program), AST3, CAASTRO, VINROUGE, MASTER, J-GEM, GROWTH, JAGWAR, CaltechNRAO, TTU-NRAO, NuSTAR, Pan-STARRS, MAXI Team, TZAC Consortium, KU, Nordic Optical Telescope, ePESSTO, GROND, Texas Tech University, SALT Group, TOROS, BOOTES, MWA, CALET, IKI-GW Follow-up, H.E.S.S., LOFAR, LWA, HAWC, Pierre Auger, ALMA, Euro VLBI Team, Pi of Sky, Chandra Team at McGill University, DFn, ATLAS Telescopes, High Time Resolution Universe Survey, RIMAS, RATTIR, SKA South Africa/MeerKAT), Astrophys. J. Lett. 848, L12 (2017), arXiv:1710.05833 [astro-ph.HE].
  4. [4]D. Kasen, B. Metzger, J. Barnes, E. Quataert, and E. Ramirez-Ruiz, Nature 551, 80 (2017), arXiv:1710.05463 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
  5. [5]J. M. Lattimer and M. Prakash, Phys. Rept. 621, 127 (2016), arXiv:1512.07820 [astro-ph.SR].DOI
  6. [6]F. Özel and P. Freire, Ann. Rev. Astron. Astrophys. 54, 401 (2016), arXiv:1603.02698 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
  7. [7]G. F. Burgio, H. J. Schulze, I. Vidana, and J. B. Wei, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 120, 103879 (2021), arXiv:2105.03747 [nucl-th].DOI
  8. [8]B. A. Jacoby, A. Hotan, M. Bailes, S. Ord, and S. R. Kulkarni, Astrophys. J. Lett. 629, L113 (2005), arXiv:astro-ph/0507420.DOI
  9. [9]J. P. W. Verbiest, M. Bailes, W. van Straten, G. B. Hobbs, R. T. Edwards, R. N. Manchester, N. D. R. Bhat, J. M. Sarkissian, B. A. Jacoby, and S. R. Kulk arni, Astrophys. J. 679, 675 (2008), arXiv:0801.2589 [astro-ph].DOI
  10. [10]P. Demorest, T. Pennucci, S. Ransom, M. Roberts, and J. Hessels, Nature 467, 1081 (2010), arXiv:1010.5788 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
  11. [11]T. E. Riley, A. L. Watts, S. Bogdanov, P. S. Ray, R. M. Ludlam, S. Guillot, Z. Arzoumanian, C. L. Baker, A. V. Bilous, D. Chakrabarty, K. C. Gendreau, A. K. Harding, W. C. G. Ho, J. M. Lattimer, S. M. Morsink, and T. E. Strohmayer, The Astrophysical Journal Letters 887, L21 (2019).
  12. [12]M. C. Miller, F. K. Lamb, A. J. Dittmann, S. Bogdanov, Z. Arzoumanian, K. C. Gendreau, S. Guillot, A. K. Harding, W. C. G. Ho, J. M. Lattimer, R. M. Ludlam, S. Mahmoodifar, S. M. Morsink, P. S. Ray, T. E. Strohmayer, K. S. Wood, T. Enoto, R. Foster, T. Okajima, G. Prigozhin, and Y. Soong, The Astrophysical Journal Letters 887, L24 (2019).
  13. [13]M. C. Miller, F. K. Lamb, A. J. Dittmann, S. Bogdanov, Z. Arzoumanian, K. C. Gendreau, S. Guillot, W. C. G. Ho, J. M. Lattimer, M. Loewenstein, S. M. Morsink, P. S. Ray, M. T. Wolff, C. L. Baker, T. Cazeau, S. Manthripragada, C. B. Markwardt, T. Okajima, S. Pollard, I. Cognard, H. T. Cromartie, E. Fonseca, L. Guillemot, M. Kerr, A. Parthasarathy, T. T. Pennucci, S. Ransom, and I. Stairs, The Astrophysical Journal Letters 918, L28 (2021).
  14. [14]D. Choudhury, T. Salmi, S. Vinciguerra, T. E. Riley, Y. Kini, A. L. Watts, B. Dorsman, S. Bogdanov, S. Guillot, P. S. Ray, D. J. Reardon, R. A. Remillard, A. V. Bilous, D. Huppenkothen, J. M. Lattimer, N. Rutherford, Z. Arzoumanian, K. C. Gendreau, S. M. Morsink, and W. C. G. Ho, The Astrophysical Journal Letters 971, L20 (2024).
  15. [15]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 161101 (2018), arXiv:1805.11581 [gr-qc].DOI
  16. [16]B. P. Abbott et al. (LIGO Scientific, Virgo), Astrophys. J. Lett. 892, L3 (2020), arXiv:2001.01761 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
  17. [17]C. M. Will, Living Rev. Rel. 9, 3 (2006), arXiv:gr-qc/0510072.DOI
  18. [18]E. Berti et al., Class. Quant. Grav. 32, 243001 (2015), arXiv:1501.07274 [gr-qc].DOI
  19. [19]V. Cardoso, F. Franzin, A. Maselli, P. Pani, and G. Raposo, Phys. Rev. D 95, 084014 (2017), [Addendum: Phys.Rev.D 95, 089901 (2017)], arXiv:1701.01116 [gr-qc].DOI
  20. [20]M. Kramer et al., Phys. Rev. X 11, 041050 (2021), arXiv:2112.06795 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
  21. [21]L. Shao and K. Yagi, Sci. Bull. 67, 1946 (2022), arXiv:2209.03351 [gr-qc].DOI
  22. [22]N. Yunes, X. Siemens, and K. Yagi, (2024), arXiv:2408.05240 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2408.05240
  23. [23]R. A. Hulse and J. H. Taylor, Astrophys. J. Lett. 195, L51 (1975).
  24. [24]P. Pani, E. Berti, V. Cardoso, and J. Read, Phys. Rev. D 84, 104035 (2011), arXiv:1109.0928 [gr-qc].DOI
  25. [25]P. Pani and E. Berti, Phys. Rev. D 90, 024025 (2014), arXiv:1405.4547 [gr-qc].DOI
  26. [26]K. Yagi and M. Stepaniczka, Phys. Rev. D 104, 044017 (2021), arXiv:2105.01614 [gr-qc].DOI
  27. [27]G. Creci, T. Hinderer, and J. Steinhoff, Phys. Rev. D 108, 124073 (2023), arXiv:2308.11323 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2308.11323
  28. [28]I. van Gemeren, B. Shiraliou, and T. Hinderer, Phys. Rev. D 108, 024026 (2023), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 109, 089901 (2024)], arXiv:2302.08480 [gr-qc].DOI
  29. [29]G. Creci, I. van Gemeren, T. Hinderer, and J. Steinhoff, (2024), arXiv:2412.06620 [gr-qc].DOI
  30. [30]R. F. Diedrichs, S. Tsujikawa, and K. Yagi, (2025), arXiv:2501.07998 [gr-qc].DOI
  31. [31]K. Yagi, D. Blas, N. Yunes, and E. Barausse, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 161101 (2014), arXiv:1307.6219 [gr-qc].DOI
  32. [32]K. Yagi, D. Blas, E. Barausse, and N. Yunes, Phys. Rev. D 89, 084067 (2014), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 90, 069902 (2014), Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 90, 069901 (2014)], arXiv:1311.7144 [gr-qc].DOI
  33. [33]K. Yagi, L. C. Stein, N. Yunes, and T. Tanaka, Phys. Rev. D 87, 084058 (2013), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 93, 089909 (2016)], arXiv:1302.1918 [gr-qc].DOI
  34. [34]A. Saffer and K. Yagi, Phys. Rev. D 104, 124052 (2021), arXiv:2110.02997 [gr-qc].DOI
  35. [35]K. Yagi and N. Yunes, Science 341, 365 (2013), arXiv:1302.4499 [gr-qc].DOI
  36. [36]K. Yagi and N. Yunes, Phys. Rev. D 88, 023009 (2013), arXiv:1303.1528 [gr-qc].DOI
  37. [37]K. Yagi and N. Yunes, Phys. Rept. 681, 1 (2017), arXiv:1608.02582 [gr-qc].DOI
  38. [38]G. Pappas and T. A. Apostolatos, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 121101 (2014), arXiv:1311.5508 [gr-qc].DOI
  39. [39]S. Chakrabarti, T. Delsate, N. Güllebeck, and J. Steinhoff, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 201102 (2014), arXiv:1311.6509 [gr-qc].DOI
  40. [40]K. Yagi, K. Kyutoku, G. Pappas, N. Yunes, and T. A. Apostolatos, Phys. Rev. D 89, 124013 (2014), arXiv:1403.6243 [gr-qc].DOI
  41. [41]M. Bauböck, E. Berti, D. Psaltis, and F. Özel, Astrophys. J. 777, 68 (2013), arXiv:1306.0569 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
  42. [42]K. Yagi, Phys. Rev. D 89, 043011 (2014), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 96, 129904 (2017), Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 97, 129901 (2018)], arXiv:1311.0872 [gr-qc].DOI
  43. [43]A. Maselli, V. Cardoso, V. Ferrari, L. Gualtieri, and P. Pani, Phys. Rev. D 88, 023007 (2013), arXiv:1304.2052 [gr-qc].DOI
  44. [44]T. K. Chan, Y. H. Sham, P. T. Leung, and L. M. Lin, Phys. Rev. D 90, 124023 (2014), arXiv:1408.3789 [gr-qc].DOI
  45. [45]H. Sotani and B. Kumar, Phys. Rev. D 104, 123002 (2021), arXiv:2109.08145 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2109.08145
  46. [46]L. C. Stein, K. Yagi, and N. Yunes, Astrophys. J. 788, 15 (2014), arXiv:1312.4532 [gr-qc].DOI
  47. [47]K. Yagi and N. Yunes, Phys. Rev. D 91, 123008 (2015), arXiv:1503.02726 [gr-qc].DOI
  48. [48]G. Martinon, A. Maselli, L. Gualtieri, and V. Ferrari, Phys. Rev. D 90, 064026 (2014), arXiv:1406.7661 [gr-qc].DOI
  49. [49]J. Bretz, K. Yagi, and N. Yunes, Phys. Rev. D 92, 083009 (2015), arXiv:1507.02278 [gr-qc].DOI
  50. [50]B. Haskell, R. Ciolfi, F. Pannarale, and L. Rezzolla, Mon. Not. Roy. Astron. Soc. 438, L71 (2014), arXiv:1309.3885 [astro-ph.SR].DOI
  51. [51]Z. Zhu, A. Li, and L. Rezzolla, Phys. Rev. D 102, 084058 (2020), arXiv:2005.02677 [astro-ph.HE].DOI
  52. [52]M. Punturo et al., Class. Quant. Grav. 27, 194002 (2010).
  53. [53]X. Jiménez Forteza, T. Abdelsalhin, P. Pani, and L. Gualtieri, Phys. Rev. D 98, 124014 (2018), arXiv:1807.08016 [gr-qc].DOI
  54. [54]T. Abdelsalhin, L. Gualtieri, and P. Pani, Phys. Rev. D 98, 104046 (2018), arXiv:1805.01487 [gr-qc].DOI
  55. [55]B. Banihashemi and J. Vines, Phys. Rev. D 101, 064003 (2020), arXiv:1805.07266 [gr-qc].DOI
  56. [56]P. Landry, (2018), arXiv:1805.01882 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/1805.01882
  57. [57]Q. Henry, G. Faye, and L. Blanchet, Phys. Rev. D 102, 044033 (2020), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 108, 089901 (2023), Erratum: Phys.Rev.D 111, 029901 (2025)], arXiv:2005.13367 [gr-qc].DOI
  58. [58]G. Castro, L. Gualtieri, A. Maselli, and P. Pani, Phys. Rev. D 106, 024011 (2022), arXiv:2204.12510 [gr-qc].
  59. [59]T. Narikawa, Phys. Rev. D 108, 063029 (2023), arXiv:2307.02033 [gr-qc].DOI
  60. [60]K. Yagi, L. C. Stein, G. Pappas, N. Yunes, and T. A. Apostolatos, Phys. Rev. D 90, 063010 (2014), arXiv:1406.7587 [gr-qc].DOI
  61. [61]Y. H. Sham, T. K. Chan, L. M. Lin, and P. T. Leung, Astrophys. J. 798, 121 (2015), arXiv:1410.8271 [gr-qc].DOI
  62. [62]K. Kyutoku, (2025), arXiv:2503.00098 [gr-qc].DOI
  63. [63]A. Akmal, V. R. Pandharipande, and D. G. Ravenhall, Phys. Rev. C 58, 1804 (1998), arXiv:nucl-th/9804027.DOI
  64. [64]F. Douchin and P. Haensel, Astron. Astrophys. 380, 151 (2001), arXiv:astro-ph/0111092.
  65. [65]J. M. Lattimer and F. D. Swesty, Nucl. Phys. A 535, 331 (1991).
  66. [66]H. Shen, H. Toki, K. Oyamatsu, and K. Sumiyoshi, Nucl. Phys. A 637, 435 (1998), arXiv:nucl-th/9805035.DOI
  67. [67]H. Shen, H. Toki, K. Oyamatsu, and K. Sumiyoshi, Prog. Theor. Phys. 100, 1013 (1998), arXiv:nucl-th/9806095.DOI
  68. [68]C. Posada, J. Hladík, and Z. Stuchlík, Phys. Rev. D 105, 104020 (2022), arXiv:2201.05209 [gr-qc].DOI
  69. [69]N. Jiang and K. Yagi, Phys. Rev. D 99, 124029 (2019), arXiv:1904.05954 [gr-qc].DOI
  70. [70]R. C. Tolman, Phys. Rev. 55, 364 (1939).
  71. [71]M. Favata, Phys. Rev. Lett. 112, 101101 (2014), arXiv:1310.8288 [gr-qc].DOI
  72. [72]N. Jiang and K. Yagi, Phys. Rev. D 101, 124006 (2020), arXiv:2003.10498 [gr-qc].DOI
  73. [73]T. Hinderer, Astrophys. J. 677, 1216 (2008), [Erratum: Astrophys.J. 697, 964 (2009)], arXiv:0711.2420 [astro-ph].DOI
  74. [74]T. Damour and A. Nagar, Phys. Rev. D 80, 084035 (2009), arXiv:0906.0096 [gr-qc].DOI
  75. [75]T. Binnington and E. Poisson, Phys. Rev. D 80, 084018 (2009), arXiv:0906.1366 [gr-qc].DOI
  76. [76]T. Katagiri, T. Ikeda, and V. Cardoso, Phys. Rev. D 109, 044067 (2024), arXiv:2310.19705 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2310.19705
  77. [77]T. Katagiri, H. Nakano, and K. Omukai, Phys. Rev. D 108, 084049 (2023), arXiv:2304.04551 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2304.04551
  78. [78]T. Katagiri, V. Cardoso, T. Ikeda, and K. Yagi, Phys. Rev. D 111, 084081 (2025), arXiv:2410.02531 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2410.02531
  79. [79]T. Katagiri, K. Yagi, and V. Cardoso, Phys. Rev. D 111, 084080 (2025), arXiv:2409.18034 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/2409.18034
  80. [80]T. Damour, A. Nagar, and L. Villain, Phys. Rev. D 85, 123007 (2012), arXiv:1203.4352 [gr-qc].DOI
  81. [81]E. E. Flanagan and T. Hinderer, Phys. Rev. D 77, 021502 (2008), arXiv:0709.1915 [astro-ph].DOI
  82. [82]https://github.com/TakuyaKatagiri/Theory_universal_Love_
  83. [83]S. Postnikov, M. Prakash, and J. M. Lattimer, Phys. Rev. D 82, 024016 (2010), arXiv:1004.5098 [astro-ph.SR].DOI
  84. [84]P. Landry and E. Poisson, Phys. Rev. D 91, 104026 (2015), arXiv:1504.06606 [gr-qc].DOI
  85. [85]P. Pani, L. Gualtieri, T. Abdelsalhin, and X. Jiménez-Forteza, Phys. Rev. D 98, 124023 (2018), arXiv:1810.01094 [gr-qc].DOI
  86. [86]P. Pani, L. Gualtieri, A. Maselli, and V. Ferrari, Phys. Rev. D 92, 024010 (2015), arXiv:1503.07365 [gr-qc].arxiv.org/abs/1503.07365
  87. [87]P. Landry and E. Poisson, Phys. Rev. D 91, 104018 (2015), arXiv:1503.07366 [gr-qc].DOI
  88. [88]P. Pani, L. Gualtieri, and V. Ferrari, Phys. Rev. D 92, 124003 (2015), arXiv:1509.02171 [gr-qc].DOI
  89. [89]B. Majumder, K. Yagi, and N. Yunes, Phys. Rev. D 92, 024020 (2015), arXiv:1504.02506 [gr-qc].DOI
  90. [90]L. Hui, A. Joyce, R. Penco, L. Santoni, and A. R. Solomon, JCAP 01, 032 (2022), arXiv:2105.01069 [hep-th].DOI
  91. [91]T. Katagiri, M. Kimura, H. Nakano, and K. Omukai, Phys. Rev. D 107, 124030 (2023), arXiv:2209.10469 [gr-qc].DOI
  92. [92]P. Charalambous, S. Dubovsky, and M. M. Ivanov, JHEP 10, 175 (2022), arXiv:2209.02091 [hep-th].DOI
  93. [93]H. A. Buchdahl, Phys. Rev. 116, 1027 (1959).
  94. [94]T. Regge and J. A. Wheeler, Phys. Rev. 108, 1063 (1957).
  95. [95]L. Lindblom and S. L. Detweiler, Astrophys. J. 53, 73 (1983).
  96. [96]J. L. Friedman, Commun. Math. Phys. 62, 247 (1978).
  97. [97]DLMF, “NIST Digital Library of Mathematical Functions,” https://dlmf.nist.gov/, Release 1.2.0 of 2024-03-15, f. W. J. Olver, A. B. Olde Daalhuis, D. W. Lozier, B. I. Schneider, R. F. Boisvert, C. W. Clark, B. R. Miller, B. V. Saunders, H. S. Cohl, and M. A. McClain, eds.
  98. [98]E. Poisson, Phys. Rev. D 103, 064023 (2021), arXiv:2012.10184 [gr-qc].DOI
  99. [99]T. K. Chan, A. P. O. Chan, and P. T. Leung, Phys. Rev. D 91, 044017 (2015), arXiv:1411.7141 [astro-ph.SR].DOI
  100. [100]T. Lowrey, K. Yagi, and N. Yunes, Phys. Rev. D 111, 024075 (2025), arXiv:2410.06358 [gr-qc].DOI
  101. [101]R. Price and K. S. Thorne, Astrophys. J. 155, 163 (1969).
  102. [102]https://github.com/nj2nu/I-C_Love-C_6thorderSeriesExpansion_Coefficients.

Paper details

vlnc:W_85dampwh
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents