WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Flavour decomposition of the chiral-odd form factors of the nucleon
Abstract
We compute the chiral-odd form factors , and of the nucleon within light-cone QCD sum rules, separately for the and quarks, over GeV, and organise their values at into the tensor monopole, dipole and quadrupole moments , and . The flavour components of the quadrupole moment and the isoscalar channel have not previously been obtained in this framework. The form factors are read from a basis of Lorentz structures that becomes independent only after a canonical ordering of the Dirac strings, and three of the eight surviving structures give the three form factors separately. Two statements follow from the analytic expressions. The -quark contributions to and are equal and opposite in the chiral limit, the breaking being proportional to the quark mass and to the twist-six amplitude . At the level of the least suppressed momentum-fraction integral, the isoscalar tensor charge receives no leading-twist contribution, the twist-three terms of the two flavours cancelling. Neither statement is visible without resolving the flavours. At GeV we obtain, for the two distribution-amplitude sets, and , and , and , and , and , and and . The mean-field relation holds in sign and in order of magnitude, the ratio being and . In the impact-parameter plane the two flavour distributions are displaced in opposite transverse directions by nearly equal amounts, and fm, and both are elongated across the polarisation axis, the quark some five to six times more strongly than the quark.
Introduction
The internal structure of the nucleon is encoded in the matrix elements of local QCD operators. Those of the vector and axial-vector currents have been mapped in detail; the third leading-twist structure, the one probed by the tensor current, remains the least constrained. It measures how quarks are polarised transversely to the nucleon spin, and both the experimental and the theoretical determinations of it are still sparse. The present work computes the tensor form factors of the nucleon within QCD light-cone sum rules, resolved into - and -quark contributions, and organises them into the three multipole moments that carry the physical content: the tensor charge, the anomalous tensor magnetic moment and the tensor quadrupole moment. Resolving the flavours is not a refinement here but the substance of the calculation, since each of the structural results reported below lives in one flavour channel or in the interplay of the two.
The tensor current is odd under charge conjugation, so its forward matrix element, the tensor charge , measures the difference between the transverse polarisation of quarks and that of antiquarks: sea quark–antiquark pairs cancel in it to the extent that quarks and antiquarks are equally polarised, and is in this sense a valence quantity rather than a measure of the full quark content of the nucleon [1, 2]. The axial-vector current behaves in the opposite way: it is C-even, sea-quark helicities survive, and the singlet axial charge is correspondingly difficult to interpret. The tensor charge is the first moment of the transversity distribution , the last of the three leading-twist collinear distributions to be mapped [1, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7]: being chiral-odd, decouples from inclusive deep inelastic scattering and must be paired with a second chiral-odd object, which has restricted its extraction to semi-inclusive processes and to dihadron production, and it is constrained from above by the Soffer inequality [8]. Interest in the tensor charge is not confined to hadron structure. The flavour-diagonal tensor charges are precisely the matrix elements that convert a quark electric dipole moment into a neutron one [9, 10, 11], so a bound on the neutron electric dipole moment translates into a bound on CP-violating physics beyond the Standard Model only to the accuracy with which is known [12, 13]. The same matrix elements control the sensitivity of precision -decay measurements to BSM tensor interactions [14]. Experimentally, transversity and the tensor charge have been extracted from Collins asymmetries in semi-inclusive deep inelastic scattering measured by HERMES [15] and COMPASS [16], combined with data from Belle [17], and from dihadron production [18, 19]; global analyses of increasing scope have followed [20, 21, 22, 23]. The precision remains well below that of the helicity sector, and improving it is among the goals of the Electron-Ion Collider [24, 25]. On the theory side the tensor charge has been computed in lattice QCD [26, 27, 28, 29, 30], in the chiral quark-soliton model [31, 32, 33, 34], in the bag model [35], in light-front and covariant quark models [36, 37, 38, 39], in Dyson–Schwinger approaches [11, 40], and in QCD sum rules [41, 42, 43]. The tensor form factors of other hadronic systems have also been studied [44, 45, 46, 47, 48].
At leading twist the matrix element of the tensor current between spin- states is parametrised by three form factors, , and , the first Mellin moments of the chiral-odd generalised parton distributions [49, 50]. As such they are the natural variables in momentum space, but for the spatial interpretation the physical content is carried by particular combinations of them. Expanding the matrix element in irreducible tensors built from the momentum transfer separates a monopole, a dipole and a quadrupole term, an enumeration carried out systematically for the chiral-odd operator in Ref. [51], where the quadrupole structure was identified as a term that earlier analyses had omitted. The monopole is the tensor charge. The dipole moment measures the shift of the average transverse position of quarks polarised in the transverse direction, in an unpolarised target [52]. That distortion, combined with final-state interactions, has been argued to generate the Boer–Mulders function [52], so that the sign of carries a phenomenological consequence; the chiral-odd distributions moreover allow the quark angular momentum to be decomposed with respect to quarks of definite transversity, giving access to the correlation between quark spin and orbital angular momentum in an unpolarised nucleon [52]. The quadrupole moment characterises the deformation of the corresponding distribution when the nucleon is transversely polarised as well, and is peculiar to the chiral-odd sector: at leading twist the chiral-odd operator carries , and combined with the rank-two tensor the quadrupole is the highest structure that can be formed, whereas the chiral-even operator has and cannot reach it at all [50]. The chiral-odd generalised parton distributions themselves have been studied on the lattice [53] and in a range of models [35, 37, 39, 54]. Their measurement meets the same obstacle as that of , a second chiral-odd object being required, and exclusive processes in which this role is played by the distribution amplitude of a transversely polarised meson have been proposed, in the diffractive electroproduction of two vector mesons [55] and in the photoproduction of a pair at large invariant mass [56].
Within light-cone QCD sum rules the coverage is uneven. The isovector form factors were obtained in Ref. [42]; Ref. [43] derived the sum rules for both isovector and isoscalar currents using the general interpolating field, but quoted no numbers, having found that the form factors change sign with the mixing parameter. Neither study formed the multipole combinations. The isovector value of is implied by the of Ref. [42], and we construct it for the comparison of Sec. IV, but the quadrupole moment is not discussed there, and neither its flavour components nor its isoscalar combination have been obtained in this framework. The present work differs from these studies in four respects. The form factors are computed separately for the and quarks, and both isospin combinations are evaluated, the isoscalar one included. The flavour resolution requires no new technique, each flavour component of the tensor current being inserted into the correlator separately; what makes it informative is that, with the Ioffe current written with the two quarks adjacent, the - and -quark contractions draw in the chiral limit on disjoint sets of distribution amplitudes, and the two structural results of Secs. IV A and IV B follow from that separation. The three multipole moments, the quadrupole included, are formed in every flavour channel. The form factors are read from a basis of Lorentz structures that is independent only after a canonical ordering of the Dirac strings; before ordering the structures are linearly related, so the coefficient assigned to any one of them depends on how the expression happens to have been written. And the results are used to test a relation derived in the mean-field picture, from a framework that makes no assumption about . The moments are finally carried to the impact-parameter plane, where the three of them fix the displacement and the deformation of the transverse quark distribution.
The paper is organised as follows. Section II sets up the multipole decomposition, fixes the independent basis and derives the sum rules. Section III describes the input, the working region of the auxiliary parameters and the extraction procedure. Section IV presents the results and discusses them. § 1.4 summarises. The QCD-side expressions are collected in the Appendix.
Formalism
Form factors
The matrix element of the tensor current between nucleon states is parametrised by three form factors,
with , and ; is the momentum flowing into the tensor current, so that . A fourth structure is allowed by Lorentz covariance, but the corresponding form factor vanishes by T-invariance [43, 49]. The three are the first Mellin moments of the chiral-odd generalised parton distributions.
Multipole structure
As first Mellin moments of the chiral-odd generalised parton distributions the three form factors are the natural variables in momentum space, but they do not coincide one by one with the multipoles of the transverse spatial distribution: enters both the dipole and the quadrupole, and enters the dipole only in combination with it. The multipole content is exposed by expanding the matrix element in irreducible tensors built from the momentum transfer, which separates a monopole, a dipole and a quadrupole term. Expanding in the transverse plane at fixed light-front time, which is where the density interpretation is available, gives [51]
The monopole is the tensor charge, the net number of transversely polarised quarks in a transversely polarised nucleon. The dipole measures the shift of the average transverse position of quarks polarised along a fixed transverse direction, in an unpolarised target [52] — the one multipole that survives when the nucleon polarisation is averaged over; it plays for the tensor current the role that the anomalous magnetic moment plays for the vector one. The quadrupole characterises the deformation of the transverse distribution when the nucleon is polarised as well [50], a configuration developed in Sec. IV D. A second, three-dimensional expansion in the Breit frame is also in use [34]; the two sets do not coincide, differing by terms of order , and every result below refers to Eq. (2).
The expansion stops at the quadrupole. At leading twist the chiral-odd operator carries ; combined with the rank-two tensor built from the momentum transfer, the quadrupole is the highest structure that can be formed. The chiral-even operator has and cannot reach the quadrupole at all, so this term is peculiar to the chiral-odd sector.
Light-cone QCD sum rules
The starting point is
The interpolating field is not unique: the general local three-quark operator with the quantum numbers of the nucleon carries a free mixing parameter, and the resulting form factors depend on it. We fix it to the Ioffe value throughout, so that
Three reasons. First, this is the choice for which the coupling of the current to the nucleon ground state is largest relative to the continuum in the two-point function, the criterion originally proposed in Ref. [57]. Second, it is the current adopted in the analysis from which the distribution amplitudes used here are taken [58], so that the current and its nonperturbative input are matched. Third, and specific to the present calculation, only at this value can the current be written with the like-flavour pair adjacent, as in the second form of Eq. (4), and it is in that form that the selection rule derived below becomes manifest.
The two earlier light-cone QCD sum rule studies of the tensor form factors work at other values of the mixing parameter. Writing it as , the Ioffe current corresponds to , whereas Ref. [42] reports stability near and Ref. [43] works in the window .
In the second writing of Eq. (4) the two Dirac indices sit on the same object and the distribution amplitude carries them together, so the chain closes and each contraction is a Dirac trace multiplying an open string. The tensor current can be contracted with either of the two quarks of the diquark , which gives the contractions labelled (A) and (B) below, or with the quark, which gives (C); in (B) the contracted field is the transposed one, which is why the conjugated propagator appears there. Using , and with , every factor of cancels and
where is the diquark Dirac structure of the amplitude , the structure carrying the third quark index, and for the , and amplitudes and for and . In the term of the propagator flips sign while the mass term does not, so the two must be kept as separate objects once .
The -quark contraction (C) contains , four times the vector component of , which vanishes unless is , or . Only the six amplitudes therefore contribute to the -quark channel; , , and drop out. This selection rule is used in Secs. IV A and IV B.
The light-quark propagator is kept with its mass term,
the condensate pieces being removed by the Borel transformation and the gluon pieces feeding four- and five-particle amplitudes, which are small [58, 59] and are neglected. The nonperturbative input is the three-quark matrix element, whose decomposition into distribution amplitudes of definite twist we take unchanged from Refs. [58, 60]; we follow their notation throughout.
On the hadronic side the nucleon contribution is isolated by inserting a complete set of states and keeping the ground-state pole,
with and the decomposition of Eq. (1).
The two sides are now matched structure by structure, and this is where a choice has to be made that is usually left implicit. The Dirac strings generated by the operator product are not independent as they stand; the Clifford algebra relates them, for instance
so that , and cannot be treated as three separate objects. The coefficient one assigns to any one of them therefore depends on how the expression happens to have been written, not only on its content, and the same ambiguity affects , , and . A projection performed before the strings are brought to a common arrangement is thus not well defined, whichever side of the sum rule it is applied to.
We remove the ambiguity by reducing every string to the canonical arrangement
through repeated use of
applied so as to move , then , then successively to the left, each substitution generating a scalar product and a reordered string, and eliminating through . What remains is a set of eight mutually irreducible antisymmetric structures with scalar coefficients built from , , , and . Applying the same reduction to the right-hand side of Eq. (9) gives
Of the eight structures, does not appear at all and mixes, receiving and so giving access to the dipole moment rather than to either form factor separately. The other six are clean, but four of them return ; the three that give one form factor each are
and these are the structures we project onto. Of the four that return alone we read it from , which carries the lowest Dirac structure of the four; the remaining three are available as a consistency check.
Earlier light-cone QCD sum rule work extracts from [42, 43], which by Eq. (10) is not one of the eight. We do not claim this leads to an incorrect result — both pieces on the right of Eq. (10) happen to carry alone — but the assignment of a QCD-side term to that structure is not unique before ordering, and the basis used here is therefore different from theirs, independently of the interpolating current or the fit range. This is one of the differences to bear in mind when the results are compared in Sec. IV.
Equating the two representations, Borel transforming in and subtracting the continuum with the standard substitution rules [58] then gives
where denotes the Borel transformation together with the continuum subtraction and is the coefficient of the corresponding structure of Eq. (14) on the QCD side, given in Appendix A. The prefactors follow directly from Eq. (14) and are independent of ; every sign in Eq. (15) follows from the convention , and with the opposite choice the three would be reversed.
Numerical analysis
Input parameters
We use GeV, MeV and MeV [61], which enter the expressions of Appendix A through the ratios . The residue is taken from the two-point sum rule [42].
Unlike the vector and axial-vector currents the tensor current is renormalisation-scale dependent already at one loop. The distribution amplitudes are normalised at GeV and all results are quoted at that scale; results obtained elsewhere are evolved using [6]
with
GeV.
We use two distribution-amplitude parameter sets, listed in Table I: Set I, in which all eight nonperturbative parameters are estimated from QCD sum rules, and Set II, the asymptotic set in which the higher conformal-spin contributions are required to vanish [58, 62]. The spread between them is carried in the error budget as the distribution-amplitude systematic.
| Parameter | Set-I | Set-II |
Table I. Nonperturbative parameters entering the nucleon DAs [58]. The normalisation constants , and are common to the two sets.
The three amplitudes , and carry additive mass-correction partners of twist five, and likewise for and , with the same Dirac structures [58]. These are included throughout. Switching them off changes nothing in and , which do not receive contributions from the Lorentz structures these amplitudes reach, and changes by 0.2%. They are therefore not a source of uncertainty here.
Auxiliary parameters
The results depend on the Borel mass and the continuum threshold , and must be insensitive to both. The working regions are fixed before any form factor is extracted, so that the criteria do not depend on the values they produce. The upper limit of follows from requiring convergence of the light-cone expansion, that is, that the highest-twist terms retained remain a small fraction of the total; the lower limit follows from requiring that the highest power of does not dominate, which is equivalent to demanding a sufficiently large pole contribution. The threshold is set from the mass of the first excitation and varied within a physically motivated interval. This gives
Across this window the pole contribution, defined as the ratio of the ground-state term to the total, lies between 0.55 and 0.74, while the highest-twist terms retained in the expansion enter below the 0.2% level, so both criteria are met comfortably. The dependence on the Borel mass is shown in Figure 1–Figure 2. Within the window the results are stable to the point that the variation is negligible against the other sources, and we do not carry it in the error budget; the uncertainty is dominated by the variation and by the spread between the two distribution-amplitude sets.
Figure 1. Dependence of the isoscalar chiral-odd form factors on the Borel mass, shown over GeV so that the approach to the plateau is visible; the working window of Eq. (18) is the subinterval GeV. The curves are at GeV and for the three values of the continuum threshold , 2.25 and 2.5 GeV. Rows, from top to bottom: , and . Left column: Set I distribution amplitudes; right column: Set II. The flatness across the working window is what justifies neglecting the Borel-mass systematic in the error budget; the spread between the three curves is the uncertainty quoted in Table II.
Figure 2. Same as Figure 1, but for the isovector chiral-odd form factors.
Extraction of the moments
The sum rules are reliable for , so the moments at are obtained by extrapolation with
in which the exponent is left free rather than fixed to a monopole or dipole form, so that the mass scale and the fall-off are determined separately by the computed points rather than tied to one another by the choice of ansatz. The fit range is fixed by the region in which the sum rules are valid and is not varied: narrowing it discards valid data rather than probing a systematic, and the sensitivity it would expose is already carried by the variation.
The extrapolation is performed separately at each of the three continuum thresholds, and the spread of the resulting is quoted as the uncertainty. Treating that spread instead as a point-by-point error would understate it, since the three curves shift coherently rather than fluctuating independently. The distribution-amplitude systematic is not folded into that number but displayed by quoting both parameter sets throughout, and the dependence is negligible as noted above.
The dipole moment requires a choice that the other two do not. Both and are a single form factor times a constant, so forming the combination before or after the extrapolation is the same operation. For it is not: one may extrapolate and separately and add the static limits, or form pointwise in and extrapolate that. The two target the same number at and differ only in which object the multipole ansatz is applied to. We take the second. The combination is not an arbitrary sum: as Eq. (13) shows, it is the coefficient of a single structure of the ordered basis, , so within this calculation it is as much a form factor of the correlator as and are individually. A further practical gain is that the dependence cancels between the two before the fit rather than after it, which roughly halves the uncertainty.
The two routes agree. Summing the static limits of Table II instead gives and for Set I and and for Set II, the uncertainties of and being added in quadrature. These uncertainties are about twice those of the combination fit because the quadrature sum treats the two static limits as independent, whereas their variations are correlated and partly cancel when is formed pointwise. Compared with the values of Table III, the differences are about and for Set I and and for Set II. The agreement is closest in the channel, where the fitted combination returns to four digits in both sets, exactly as Eq. (25) requires; this confirms the identity of Eq. (24) at the level of the dependence rather than of the moment alone.
| Set I | ||||
| Set II | ||||
Table II. Chiral-odd form factors at and GeV.
| Set I | ||||
| Set II | ||||
Table III. Tensor multipole moments, Eq. (2). The entries come from the combination fit of Sec. III C, the entries from of Table II; the two therefore differ in the channel by the reconstruction systematic discussed in the text.
The flavour components are obtained directly from their own sum rules and the isospin combinations are constructed from them, for all three moments alike. Fitting the isospin combinations directly instead gives and for Set I and and for Set II, which reproduce the entries of Table III to better than in all four cases.
An entry is quoted as a number only if the fitted shape parameter is stable against and lies in a physically sensible range and the total uncertainty is small compared with the central value; entries failing these conditions are reported together with the reason rather than omitted.
Results and discussion
Figure 3 shows the dependence of the three form factors over the region in which the sum rules apply. These curves are the direct output of the calculation, and the two structural results of Secs. IV A and IV B are properties of the sum rules themselves, holding at every in that region; the values at , which Table II collects for both distribution-amplitude sets, and the moments built from them rely in addition on the extrapolation of Sec. III C. For and the flavour entries are the direct sum-rule fits and the isospin combinations are derived from them; for the reverse, because the direct fit does not meet the quotability conditions of Sec. III C while both isospin combinations do.
Figure 3. dependence of the chiral-odd form factors of the nucleon over the interval GeV, the region in which the sum rules are reliable. Rows, from top to bottom: , and . Left column: Set I distribution amplitudes; right column: Set II. Each panel shows the - and -quark contributions together with the isoscalar and isovector combinations and , with bands from the variation.
That reversal makes the -quark entry a check on the extrapolation itself. Equation (24) makes exact on the QCD side, so reconstructing from the two isospin fits ought to return 1.56 and 1.37; it returns 1.70 and 1.44, a departure of 9% and 5%. This is the price of extrapolating the two isospin combinations independently rather than the channel itself, and it sets the size of the extraction systematic carried by every and entry in Tables II and III. It is also why in Table III is 3.40 rather than the that the identity would give: comes from the combination fit of Sec. III C and therefore respects the identity exactly, while inherits the reconstruction systematic just quoted.
Table IV places the results next to the other determinations, all at a common scale. For the isovector tensor charge most of the other determinations cluster tightly. Four independent lattice calculations give 1.00–1.11 once brought to a common scale, the external-field QCD sum rule of Ref. [41] gives 1.00(71) at the scale we work at, and the quark-model average of Ref. [35] gives 1.20(24). The earlier light-cone QCD sum rule is the exception: it spans 1.15–2.11 across the three fit regions quoted there, a factor of two, which already indicates how sensitive the extrapolation to is in this channel. Set II, at 1.08(6), falls inside the lattice band, and Set I, at 1.27(7), lies just above it while agreeing with the quark-model average; both sit in the lower part of the earlier sum-rule range. The global fit of Ref. [23] gives 0.56(13) from data alone and 0.99(2) once lattice input is imposed as a prior, so the phenomenological determination is the one entry lying clearly below the lattice band; that tension is between data and lattice rather than with the present work.
The isoscalar tensor charge is where we are clearly low. Our 0.38–0.39 is to be compared with 0.59–0.61 from two lattice calculations and 0.55(2) from the lattice-constrained global fit, three determinations that agree among themselves; the same shows up in the scale-independent ratio , for which we obtain 0.53 and 0.48 against 0.30 in the chiral quark-soliton model, 0.25 in the bag model and 0.28 in the lattice-constrained global fit. These are one statement, not two, and the reason is structural: as shown in Sec. IV A, the isoscalar tensor charge receives no leading-twist contribution at the level of the least suppressed integral.
The contrast between the two isovector columns is worth noting on its own. The tensor charge has been computed four times on the lattice with a total spread of about 10% and is further constrained by a global fit to data, whereas the anomalous tensor magnetic moment has been computed on the lattice once, has no phenomenological determination at all, and the theoretical values for it range over a factor of four and a half.
The isovector dipole moment shows the widest spread of any entry in the table: 0.85 in the bag model, 1.14 on the lattice, 1.17 for the quark-model average, 1.52 and 1.66 in the two soliton calculations, 1.72 in the mean-field calculation with corrections, 1.82–3.86 across the three fit regions of the earlier sum-rule work, and 1.35–1.58 here. Our values sit in the middle of that spread, between the lattice and quark-model determinations on the one side and the soliton results on the other. The reason the spread is so wide is structural rather than numerical: as discussed in Sec. IV C, is the residual of a cancellation between two much larger quantities, enforced to two powers of , so it inherits both their uncertainties and is intrinsically the least well-determined of the three moments in any approach. The width of the literature spread is itself evidence of that.
For the isoscalar dipole our 4.32–4.47 falls just below the two soliton values, 4.72 and 4.86, and well below the bag model. For and we agree in sign and in order of magnitude with the mean-field calculation while disagreeing in sign with the only other sum-rule determination. That determination also violates the large- relation of Sec. IV C in sign rather than magnitude. The extraction basis is one difference to bear in mind here: there and are read from structures which, as shown in Sec. II C, are not part of the independent set once the Dirac strings are ordered. In the flavour decomposition both components of the dipole moment come out positive, and for Set I, as they do on the lattice and in the soliton models; this is the sign pattern required by the connection between the transverse distortion and the Boer–Mulders function [52].
The comparison with the soliton calculations also raises the role of sea quarks. In the chiral quark-soliton model the matrix elements are the sum of a contribution from the discrete valence level and one from the polarised Dirac continuum, and the latter has been found to be important for the tensor dipole structure [34]. Being odd under charge conjugation, the tensor current measures the difference between quark and antiquark contributions, so that quark–antiquark pairs from the sea enter only to the extent that the quark and the antiquark differ in transverse polarisation or in transverse position. The separation of the soliton model into valence level and Dirac continuum is moreover not the same as the partonic separation into valence and sea quarks, the continuum contributing to antiquark as well as to quark distributions. On the side of the method, the nucleon enters the sum rules only through its three-quark distribution amplitudes up to twist six, and Fock components with an additional quark–antiquark pair are not included, so a valence–sea decomposition analogous to that of the soliton model has no counterpart here. Whether the residual difference between our dipole moments and the soliton values reflects such components, the different treatment of , or the truncation of the sum rule cannot be decided from the present comparison.
Finally, the quadrupole columns are sparsely populated. Apart from the present work, only the leading-order mean-field calculation in Table IV reports as such; the isovector entry of the earlier sum-rule work is our construction from the quoted there, and differs from ours in sign, as discussed above. None of the determinations compared gives the isoscalar quadrupole.
Table IV. Comparison with other determinations. Every entry, including its renormalisation scale, is taken from the original reference rather than from a compilation. The column gives that scale in GeV; every row is then brought to GeV with Eq. (16), errors scaling with the same factor. The factors are 0.871 from , 0.876 from 0.36, 0.925 from 0.49 and 1.085 from 4.0. Lattice results are in the MS scheme at 2 GeV. For Refs. [33, 34] the scale is not displayed in the expressions but is fixed by the inverse average instanton size, GeV; for Ref. [35] the initial scale is GeV, and the range 0.5–0.9 GeV explored there moves the evolution factor by up to 15% downward and 6% upward, so that row carries an extra normalisation uncertainty of that size. For Ref. [42] the range spans the three fit regions quoted there, and GeV. Where a reference resolves the flavours, the isospin combinations are constructed from them. Errors are in the last digits; means the quantity is not given in that reference.
One caveat on the comparison itself. Reference [34] defines the computed isovector mean-field quantity as in its Eq. (38b), yet quotes the resulting number as . If the tensor charge were not subtracted, the corresponding would be smaller by . We quote the value as published.
Why the isoscalar tensor charge carries no leading twist
With the Ioffe current the two flavour channels draw on disjoint sets of distribution amplitudes. In the chiral limit the channel is fed by , and alone — every amplitude reaches it only through the mass term of the propagator, and so carries a factor — while the channel, by the selection rule of Sec. II C, is fed by , and alone. No amplitude contributes to both.
Order the contributions by the momentum-fraction integral they carry. The least suppressed is of Eq. (32), whose coefficient is
the entry carrying the isospin factor that distinguishes the two combinations. Of these, and are of twist three and , of twist four. The nucleon distribution amplitudes obey [58]
and in the asymptotic limit vanishes while is symmetric, so that . The two twist-three terms in Eq. (20) are then equal in magnitude and opposite in sign: they cancel in the isoscalar combination and add in the isovector one.
The consequence is that has no leading-twist contribution at the level of and is built from twist four and above, together with whatever residue the departure of from leaves behind, whereas receives twice the leading-twist piece. Both channels retain a substantial higher-twist content: switching off and , which reach the channel only through , removes about two thirds of at , so the channel is by no means saturated by its leading-twist amplitude either.
Two independent observations support the picture. First, the isoscalar charge is almost unchanged between the two distribution-amplitude sets, 0.39 against 0.38, while the isovector charge moves from 1.27 to 1.08: the two sets differ in the higher conformal-spin parameters that shape the twist-three amplitudes, but share , and , so a quantity built purely from twist four and above is expected to be the stable one. Second, and more directly, rescaling the normalisation of the twist-three amplitudes moves the isovector charge while leaving the isoscalar charge unchanged at the 0.01% level, which is the cancellation of Eq. (20) seen in the output rather than in the coefficients.
This also explains why the isoscalar entry is the least reliable in Table IV. A quantity with no leading-twist contribution is precisely the one for which a sum rule evaluated at leading order in , with the light-cone expansion truncated at twist six, is weakest.
An identity in the d-quark channel
Only the six amplitudes reach the -quark channel, by the selection rule of Sec. II C, and their contributions organise themselves into the calligraphic amplitudes of Ref. [58], and :
in the notation of Eqs. (32) and (A3), the full expressions being Eqs. (38) and (A9) of Appendix A. Hence
The -quark contributions to and are exactly equal and opposite in the chiral limit. The breaking is triply suppressed — by the quark mass, by being of twist six, and by the higher power of the denominator — and is numerically a effect: at we obtain against , and setting gives to every digit. It follows that
so the -quark sector carries a single independent function. The identity holds to this accuracy on the QCD side, at every in the working region; what degrades it in Table III is the extrapolation, as quantified at the start of this section. Because Eq. (24) isolates multiplied by the quark mass, it also offers a direct window on the size of the twist-six contribution in the tensor channel.
Test of the large- relation
In the mean-field picture and are both while their combination is , so the cancellation is enforced to two powers of [33]. Light-cone QCD sum rules make no assumption about , so our results provide an independent test. Using Eq. (24) the relation reduces to , so any deviation resides entirely in the channel.
We find
against the value of unity that the relation predicts. The sign and the order of magnitude come out right, with the central values lying about a third below unity, and the deviation is in both sets. The two sets agree with each other to within three per cent, so whatever is responsible is systematic rather than a fit artefact; but at , and with the quoted uncertainties covering the spread alone, this is a mild tension rather than a violation. It is worth reading together with the fact that a sum rule evaluated at leading order in and truncated at twist six is itself least reliable for combinations in which a cancellation occurs, which is exactly the situation here.
Expressed through the channel with the help of Eq. (24), the relation requires and for the two sets, against the and we obtain, a difference in both cases; the channel satisfies its part exactly, by construction. Those two values are the isospin reconstruction of Table II; fixing from Eq. (24) instead would shift them to and , well inside the quoted uncertainty, so the conclusion does not depend on which route is taken. Whatever the status of the relation, the resulting flavour asymmetry is pronounced and comfortably survives the uncertainties: is unity for the quark, exactly, and and for the quark in the two sets, more than fifteen standard deviations away from unity. This is the direct reason the tensor quadrupole moment sits almost entirely on the quark, as Table III shows.
Impact-parameter shapes
The multipole moments of Table III have a direct interpretation in the impact-parameter plane. Fourier transforming the matrix element of the tensor current with respect to the transverse momentum transfer,
gives the transverse distribution of quarks of a definite transverse polarisation in a nucleon of transverse polarisation . Here are light-cone components, is a transverse index, so that is the average light-cone momentum, is the transverse momentum transfer with , and denotes the matrix element of Eq. (1) with the tensor indices taken as . Both polarisations are needed. In the two-dimensional multipole expansion of Ref. [51] the monopole and the quadrupole sit on nucleon spin operators and the dipole on the unit operator, so in an unpolarised nucleon only the dipole survives; that limit is the Burkardt distortion [52] and it carries alone. To display all three moments we therefore take the nucleon polarised as well, along the same axis as the quarks.
Contracting the transverse index of the operator with the quark polarisation and taking , the three structures of [51] reduce to an isotropic term, a term odd in , and a term, so that
with measured from the polarisation axis. No higher harmonics occur, since the expansion stops at the quadrupole (Sec. II B). The radial profiles , and require the form factors at all and are not determined here. Two moments of the distribution are determined, however, and they depend on the profiles only through integrals. With , the angular integrations in Eq. (28) give
so that the displacement is fixed by alone and the deformation by alone. The same moments follow directly from Eq. (27): weighting with or with and integrating over the plane amounts to differentiating the matrix element once or twice with respect to at , where only the form factors at survive. The normalisation is set by the monopole, the first derivative picks out the dipole term and the traceless part of the second the quadrupole term, so that
independently of the profiles. The first is the displacement of the centroid perpendicular to the polarisation axis, the light-front analogue of the shift generated by the anomalous magnetic moment in the vector channel; the second is the quadrupole deformation, positive when the distribution is elongated along the polarisation axis and negative when it is elongated across it. The monopole sets the normalisation and appears in both denominators, so it is the relative, not the absolute, size of and that shapes the distribution.
With the moments of Table III we obtain
Figure 4 shows the corresponding distributions. For display we take a Gaussian isotropic profile, , and the lowest profiles compatible with regularity at the origin, and : for the density to be smooth at , the and terms must vanish there as and , respectively. Equation (29) then fixes and , so that the displayed distributions reproduce the moments of Eq. (31) exactly, whatever the value of . We take , of the order of the transverse size of the nucleon. The width affects the appearance of the figure, but neither the moments nor the conclusions drawn from them below, which rest on Eq. (30) alone.
Figure 4. Impact-parameter distributions of (left) and (right) quarks polarised along in a nucleon polarised along the same direction, from Eq. (28) with the moments of Eq. (31), a Gaussian profile of width fm and the profiles and described in the text. Top row: Set I; bottom row: Set II. The colour map shows the density on a common scale, the grey curves are isodensity contours, the dashed circle is the undisplaced, undeformed reference and the arrow marks in fm. The two flavours are displaced in opposite directions by nearly equal amounts, while both distributions are elongated across the polarisation axis, the quark some five to six times more strongly. The overall normalisation of each panel is set by , which is negative for the quark, and is not displayed; only the shapes are compared. The density is shown within fm. Beyond fm the linearly and quadratically rising profiles and , which are a display choice, begin to outweigh the isotropic term, and the displayed density would no longer be positive.
The two flavours are displaced in opposite directions by nearly equal amounts. This follows from the ratios , which come out 3.5 and 4.0 for the quark in the two sets and and for the quark: is negative while is positive, and it is that sign mismatch, rather than any difference in the magnitude of the distortion, that reverses the shift. The deformations, in contrast, have the same sign for both flavours, both distributions being elongated across the polarisation axis, but they differ by a factor of five to six: is and for the quark against and for the quark. This is the impact-parameter form of the flavour hierarchy of Sec. IV C, where is unity for the quark and an order of magnitude smaller for the quark. The two distribution-amplitude sets give the same picture throughout.
Summary
The tensor current is odd under charge conjugation, so the quantities it defines measure the difference between quark and antiquark contributions, and its three chiral-odd form factors organise themselves into a monopole, a dipole and a quadrupole. We have computed all three for the nucleon within light-cone QCD sum rules, resolved by flavour, over , and assembled the corresponding multipole moments from their values at . The flavour components of the quadrupole moment and the isoscalar channel had not previously been obtained in this framework.
Three results stand apart from the numbers themselves. The first is methodological. The Lorentz structures generated by the operator product are not independent until the Dirac strings are brought to a canonical order. Eight independent antisymmetric structures survive the reduction; one of them does not appear on the hadronic side at all, one mixes two form factors, and of the six that are clean, four return the tensor charge, so that exactly three suffice to give the three form factors separately. The structure from which the tensor charge has usually been extracted is not among the eight. Before ordering the structures are linearly related, so the coefficient assigned to any one of them is not fixed by the content of the expression alone; the basis used here is therefore different from that of earlier sum-rule work, independently of the interpolating current or the fit range.
The second is an identity. Only the vector distribution amplitudes reach the -quark channel with the Ioffe current, and their contributions to and are equal and opposite in the chiral limit, the breaking being proportional to the quark mass and to the twist-six amplitude . Numerically the breaking is a effect, and setting the quark mass to zero reproduces the cancellation to every digit. The -quark sector therefore carries a single independent function, and , on the QCD side, up to the quark mass. The extraction confirms this: fitting as a function of returns to four digits in both distribution-amplitude sets. The 9% and 5% by which the quoted departs from is not a failure of the identity but the cost of reaching through the two isospin combinations, and it sets the extraction systematic on the and entries.
The third concerns the isoscalar channel. The two flavour channels draw on disjoint sets of distribution amplitudes, and their leading-twist contributions to the tensor charge are equal and opposite, so that they cancel in the isoscalar combination and add in the isovector one. The isoscalar tensor charge thus has no leading-twist contribution at the level of the least suppressed integral. That explains both why it comes out small and why it is the least reliable entry in the comparison: a quantity built essentially from twist four and above is precisely the one for which a sum rule evaluated at leading order in , with the light-cone expansion truncated at twist six, is weakest. Two independent checks support the mechanism, the stability of the isoscalar charge against the choice of distribution-amplitude set and its insensitivity to the twist-three normalisation. None of these three would have been visible without resolving the flavours: each is a statement about one channel, or about the relation between the two.
The same is true of the picture the moments produce. Carried to the impact-parameter plane, and taken with the quark and the nucleon polarised along the same transverse axis, they displace the two flavour distributions in opposite directions by nearly equal amounts, and fm, and elongate both across that axis, the quark some five to six times more strongly. The opposite displacements do not come from a difference in the distortion itself but from the sign of , which is negative for the quark while is positive for both; and the disparity in the deformations is the impact-parameter form of the flavour asymmetry in , which is unity for the quark and an order of magnitude smaller for the quark. Both distribution-amplitude sets give the same picture.
Against the other determinations the isovector tensor charge sits inside the existing band and the isovector dipole moment in the middle of it, while the isoscalar charge lies below for the reason just given and the isoscalar dipole falls just under the two soliton values. The dipole moment shows the widest spread of any quantity in the comparison, which is itself a consequence of its being the residual of a cancellation enforced to two powers of ; it has been computed once on the lattice and has no phenomenological determination at all. Among the determinations compared, only the mean-field calculation gives the quadrupole moment as such, and none gives the isoscalar quadrupole, so this is the entry that would benefit most from an independent calculation. Tested against our results, the mean-field relation holds in sign and in order of magnitude, the ratio coming out 0.64(16) and 0.67(15) against the predicted unity, a deviation that resides entirely in the channel.
QCD-side results
The invariant functions multiplying the independent structures of Eq. (14), before the Borel transformation and the continuum subtraction, are collected here. It is convenient to abbreviate the momentum-fraction integrals as
the weight being , , or . The factor is included so that all three carry the same mass dimension; with this normalisation, and writing , every term below is an integer multiple of times one of them. The distribution amplitudes are those of Refs. [58, 60], and the quark masses enter only through the mass term of the light-quark propagator, Eq. (8). The -channel amplitudes are evaluated at and the -channel ones at , as required by the slot structure of Sec. II C; the arguments are suppressed below. The isoscalar and isovector combinations are obtained by adding the two channels with a relative sign and respectively.
Tensor form factor
Two features of Eqs. (35) and (A5) are used in Sec. IV A. The channel receives the amplitudes only through , so in the chiral limit it is fed by and alone, while the channel is fed by alone. And the coefficients of the least suppressed integral are in the channel against in the channel.
Tensor form factor
Tensor form factor
The identity of Sec. IV B can now be read off directly. Both and the mass-independent part of are proportional to with the same prefactor and opposite sign, so they cancel term by term. What survives is the mass term of , whose amplitude combination is , giving Eq. (24).
The same combination appears in , with the opposite overall sign and with in place of . In the isospin limit the two therefore cancel in the isoscalar combination and add in the isovector one, although the effect is numerically negligible, being both mass-suppressed and of twist six.
References
- [1]R. L. Jaffe, X.-D. Ji, Chiral odd parton distributions and polarized Drell-Yan, Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 552–555. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.67.552.DOI
- [2]R. L. Jaffe, X.-D. Ji, Chiral odd parton distributions and Drell-Yan processes, Nucl. Phys. B 375 (1992) 527–560. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(92)90110-W.DOI
- [3]J. P. Ralston, D. E. Soper, Production of Dimuons from High-Energy Polarized Proton Proton Collisions, Nucl. Phys. B 152 (1979) 109. doi:10.1016/0550-3213(79)90082-8.DOI
- [4]X. Artru, M. Mekhfi, Transversely Polarized Parton Densities, their Evolution and their Measurement, Z. Phys. C 45 (1990) 669. doi:10.1007/BF01556280.DOI
- [5]J. L. Cortes, B. Pire, J. P. Ralston, Measuring the transverse polarization of quarks in the proton, Z. Phys. C 55 (1992) 409–416. doi:10.1007/BF01565099.DOI
- [6]V. Barone, A. Drago, P. G. Ratcliffe, Transverse polarisation of quarks in hadrons, Phys. Rept. 359 (2002) 1–168. arXiv:hep-ph/0104283, doi:10.1016/S0370-1573(01)00051-5.DOI
- [7]V. Barone, F. Bradamante, A. Martin, Transverse-spin and transverse-momentum effects in high-energy processes, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 65 (2010) 267–333. arXiv:1011.0909, doi:10.1016/j.ppnp.2010.07.003.DOI
- [8]J. Soffer, Positivity constraints for spin dependent parton distributions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 74 (1995) 1292–1294. arXiv:hep-ph/9409254, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.74.1292.DOI
- [9]M. Pospelov, A. Ritz, Electric dipole moments as probes of new physics, Annals Phys. 318 (2005) 119–169. arXiv:hep-ph/0504231, doi:10.1016/j.aop.2005.04.002.DOI
- [10]T. Bhattacharya, V. Cirigliano, R. Gupta, H.-W. Lin, B. Yoon, Neutron Electric Dipole Moment and Tensor Charges from Lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115 (21) (2015) 212002. arXiv:1506.04196, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.212002.DOI
- [11]M. Pitschmann, C.-Y. Seng, C. D. Roberts, S. M. Schmidt, Nucleon tensor charges and electric dipole moments, Phys. Rev. D 91 (2015) 074004. arXiv:1411.2052, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.91.074004.DOI
- [12]T. Liu, Z. Zhao, H. Gao, Experimental constraint on quark electric dipole moments, Phys. Rev. D 97 (7) (2018) 074018. arXiv:1704.00113, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.97.074018.DOI
- [13]A. Courtoy, S. Baßler, M. González-Alonso, S. Lüti, Beyond-Standard-Model Tensor Interaction and Hadron Phenomenology, Phys. Rev. Lett. 115 (2015) 162001. arXiv:1503.06814, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.115.162001.DOI
- [14]T. Bhattacharya, V. Cirigliano, S. D. Cohen, A. Filipuzzi, M. Gonzalez-Alonso, M. L. Graesser, R. Gupta, H.-W. Lin, Probing Novel Scalar and Tensor Interactions from (Ultra)Cold Neutrons to the LHC, Phys. Rev. D 85 (2012) 054512. arXiv:1110.6448, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.85.054512.DOI
- [15]A. Arapietian, et al., Effects of transversity in deep-inelastic scattering by polarized protons, Phys. Lett. B 693 (2010) 11–16. arXiv:1006.4221, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2010.08.012.
- [16]C. Adolph, et al., Experimental investigation of transverse spin asymmetries in muon-p SIDIS processes: Collins asymmetries, Phys. Lett. B 717 (2012) 376–382. arXiv:1205.5121, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2012.09.055.DOI
- [17]A. Vossen, et al., Observation of transverse polarization asymmetries of charged pion pairs in e+e− annihilation near √s = 10.58 GeV, Phys. Rev. Lett. 107 (2011) 072004. arXiv:1104.2425, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.107.072004.DOI
- [18]A. Bacchetta, A. Courtoy, M. Radici, First extraction of valence transversities in a collinear framework, JHEP 03 (2013) 119. arXiv:1212.3568, doi:10.1007/JHEP03(2013)119.DOI
- [19]M. Radici, A. Courtoy, A. Bacchetta, M. Guagnelli, Improved extraction of valence transversity distributions from inclusive dihadron production, JHEP 05 (2015) 123. arXiv:1503.03495, doi:10.1007/JHEP05(2015)123.DOI
- [20]M. Anselmino, M. Boglione, U. D’Alesio, S. Melis, F. Murgia, A. Prokudin, Simultaneous extraction of transversity and Collins functions from new SIDIS and e+e− data, Phys. Rev. D 87 (2013) 094019. arXiv:1303.3822, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.87.094019.DOI
- [21]Z.-B. Kang, A. Prokudin, P. Sun, F. Yuan, Extraction of Quark Transversity Distribution and Collins Fragmentation Functions with QCD Evolution, Phys. Rev. D 93 (1) (2016) 014009. arXiv:1505.05589, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.93.014009.DOI
- [22]H.-W. Lin, W. Melnitchouk, A. Prokudin, N. Sato, H. Shows, First Monte Carlo Global Analysis of Nucleon Transversity with Lattice QCD Constraints, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120 (15) (2018) 152502. arXiv:1710.09858, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.120.152502.DOI
- [23]C. Cocuzza, A. Metz, D. Pitonyak, A. Prokudin, N. Sato, R. Seidl, Transversity Distributions and Tensor Charges of the Nucleon: Extraction from DiHadron Production and Their Universal Nature, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 (9) (2024) 091901. arXiv:2306.12998, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.132.091901.DOI
- [24]A. Accardi, et al., Electron Ion Collider: The Next QCD Frontier: Understanding the glue that binds us all, Eur. Phys. J. A 52 (9) (2016) 268. arXiv:1212.1701, doi:10.1140/epja/i2016-16268-9.
- [25]R. Abdul Khalek, et al., Science Requirements and Detector Concepts for the Electron-Ion Collider: EIC Yellow Report, Nucl. Phys. A 1026 (2022) 122447. arXiv:2103.05419, doi:10.1016/j.nuclphysa.2022.122447.DOI
- [26]M. Gockeler, P. Hagler, R. Horsley, D. Pleiter, P. E. L. Rakow, A. Schaefer, G. Schierholz, J. M. Zanotti, Quark helicity flip generalized parton distributions from two-flavor lattice QCD, Phys. Lett. B 627 (2005) 113–123. arXiv:hep-lat/0507001, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2005.09.002.DOI
- [27]T. Bhattacharya, V. Cirigliano, S. Cohen, R. Gupta, A. Joseph, H.-W. Lin, B. Yoon, Iso-vector and Iso-scalar Tensor Charges of the Nucleon from Lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. D 92 (9) (2015) 094511. arXiv:1506.06411, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.92.094511.DOI
- [28]R. Gupta, B. Yoon, T. Bhattacharya, V. Cirigliano, Y.-C. Jang, H.-W. Lin, Flavor diagonal tensor charges of the nucleon from (2+1+1)-flavor lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. D 98 (9) (2018) 091501. arXiv:1808.07597, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.98.091501.DOI
- [29]C. Alexandrou, S. Bacchio, M. Constantinou, J. Finkenrath, K. Hadjiyiannakou, K. Jansen, G. Koutsou, A. Vaquero Aviles-Casco, Nucleon axial, tensor, and scalar charges and σ-terms in lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. D 102 (5) (2020) 054517. arXiv:1909.00485, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.102.054517.DOI
- [30]C. Alexandrou, et al., Moments of the nucleon transverse quark spin densities using lattice QCD, Phys. Rev. D 107 (5) (2023) 054504. arXiv:2202.09871, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.107.054504.DOI
- [31]T. Ledwig, A. Silva, H.-C. Kim, Tensor charges and form factors of SU(3) baryons in the self-consistent SU(3) chiral quark-soliton model, Phys. Rev. D 82 (2010) 034022. arXiv:1004.3612, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.82.034022.DOI
- [32]T. Ledwig, A. Silva, H.-C. Kim, Anomalous tensor moments and form factors of the proton in the self-consistent chiral quark-soliton model, Phys. Rev. D 82 (2010) 054014. arXiv:1007.1355, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.82.054014.DOI
- [33]N.-Y. Ghim, H.-Y. Won, J.-Y. Kim, H.-C. Kim, Nucleon tensor form factors at large Nc, Phys. Rev. D 111 (7) (2025) 074024. arXiv:2501.12241, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.111.074024.DOI
- [34]N.-Y. Ghim, H.-Y. Won, J.-Y. Kim, H.-C. Kim, Multipole structure of nucleon tensor form factors, Phys. Rev. D 114 (3) (2026) 034016. arXiv:2605.24435, doi:10.1103/wtdr-92yh.DOI
- [35]K. Tezgin, B. Maynard, P. Schweitzer, Chiral-odd GPDs in the bag model, Phys. Rev. D 110 (5) (2024) 054028. arXiv:2404.11563, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.110.054028.
- [36]I. Schmidt, J. Soffer, Melosh rotation and the nucleon tensor charge, Phys. Lett. B 407 (1997) 331–334. arXiv:hep-ph/9703411, doi:10.1016/S0370-2693(97)00737-5.DOI
- [37]B. Pasquini, M. Pincetti, S. Boffi, Chiral-odd generalized parton distributions in constituent quark models, Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005) 094029. arXiv:hep-ph/0510376, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.72.094029.DOI
- [38]I. C. Cloet, W. Bentz, A. W. Thomas, Transversity quark distributions in a covariant quark-diquark model, Phys. Lett. B 659 (2008) 214–220. arXiv:0708.3246, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2007.09.071.
- [39]T. Maji, D. Chakrabarti, Transverse structure of a proton in a light-front quark-diquark model, Phys. Rev. D 95 (7) (2017) 074009. arXiv:1702.04557, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.95.074009.DOI
- [40]S.-X. Xu, C. Chen, I. C. Cloet, C. D. Roberts, J. Segovia, H.-S. Zong, Contact-interaction Faddeev equation and, inter alia, proton tensor charges, Phys. Rev. D 92 (11) (2015) 114034. arXiv:1509.03311, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.92.114034.DOI
- [41]H.-x. He, X.-D. Ji, The Nucleon’s tensor charge, Phys. Rev. D 52 (1995) 2960–2963. arXiv:hep-ph/9412235, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.52.2960.DOI
- [42]G. Erkol, A. Ozpineci, Tensor form factors of nucleon in QCD, Phys. Lett. B 704 (2011) 551–558. arXiv:1107.4584, doi:10.1016/j.physletb.2011.09.089.DOI
- [43]T. M. Aliev, K. Azizi, M. Savci, Nucleon tensor form factors induced by isovector and isoscalar currents in QCD, Phys. Rev. D 84 (2011) 076005. arXiv:1108.2019, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.84.076005.
- [44]U. Özdem, Isovector and isoscalar tensor form factors of N(1535) → N transition in light-cone QCD, Phys. Rev. D 102 (1) (2020) 014001. arXiv:2004.12312, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.102.014001.DOI
- [45]U. Özdem, Tensor form factors of N(1535) state via light-cone QCD, Chin. J. Phys. 72 (2021) 93–99. doi:10.1016/j.cjph.2021.04.018.DOI
- [46]A. kucukarslan, U. Ozdem, A. Ozpineci, Tensor form factors of the octet hyperons in QCD, Phys. Rev. D 94 (9) (2016) 094010. arXiv:1610.08358, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.94.094010.DOI
- [47]Z. Asmaee, N. Hajirasouliha, K. Azizi, Tensor form factors of the Δ+ baryon induced by isovector and isoscalar currents in QCD, Phys. Rev. D 113 (5) (2026) 054002. arXiv:2511.12360, doi:10.1103/mlt1-gvnw.DOI
- [48]Z. Asmaee, K. Azizi, Tensor form factors of decuplet hyperons in QCD, Phys. Rev. D 113 (9) (2026) 094020. arXiv:2601.17948, doi:10.1103/zwcs-5qx3.DOI
- [49]M. Diehl, Generalized parton distributions with helicity flip, Eur. Phys. J. C 19 (2001) 485–492. arXiv:hep-ph/0101335, doi:10.1007/s100520100635.DOI
- [50]M. Diehl, P. Hägler, Spin densities in the transverse plane and generalized transversity distributions, Eur. Phys. J. C 44 (2005) 87–101. arXiv:hep-ph/0504175, doi:10.1140/epjc/s2005-02342-6.DOI
- [51]J.-Y. Kim, C. Weiss, Chiral-odd generalized parton distributions in the large-Nc limit of QCD: Spin-flavor structure, polynomiality, and sum rules, Phys. Rev. D 111 (7) (2025) 074007. arXiv:2411.17634, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.111.074007.
- [52]M. Burkardt, Transverse deformation of parton distributions and transversity decomposition of angular momentum, Phys. Rev. D 72 (2005) 094020. arXiv:hep-ph/0505189, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.72.094020.DOI
- [53]M. Göckeler, P. Hägler, R. Horsley, Y. Nakamura, D. Pleiter, P. E. L. Rakow, A. Schäfer, G. Schierholz, H. Stüben, J. M. Zanotti, Transverse spin structure of the nucleon from lattice QCD simulations, Phys. Rev. Lett. 98 (2007) 222001. arXiv:hep-lat/0612032, doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.98.222001.DOI
- [54]S. Kaur, S. Xu, C. Mondal, X. Zhao, J. P. Vary, Spatial imaging of proton via leading-twist non-skewed GPDs with basis light-front quantization, Phys. Rev. D 109 (1) (2024) 014015. arXiv:2307.09869, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.109.014015.DOI
- [55]D. Y. Ivanov, B. Pire, L. Szymanowski, O. V. Teryaev, Probing chiral odd GPD’s in diffractive electroproduction of two vector mesons, Phys. Lett. B 550 (2002) 65–76. arXiv:hep-ph/0209300, doi:10.1016/S0370-2693(02)02856-3.
- [56]R. Boussarie, B. Pire, L. Szymanowski, S. Wallon, Exclusive photoproduction of a γ ρ pair with a large invariant mass, JHEP 02 (2017) 054, [Erratum: JHEP 10, 029 (2018)]. arXiv:1609.03830, doi:10.1007/JHEP02(2017)054.DOI
- [58]V. M. Braun, A. Lenz, M. Wittmann, Nucleon Form Factors in QCD, Phys. Rev. D 73 (2006) 094019. arXiv:hep-ph/0604050, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.73.094019.DOI
- [59]M. Diehl, T. Feldmann, R. Jakob, P. Kroll, Linking parton distributions to form-factors and Compton scattering, Eur. Phys. J. C 8 (1999) 409–434. arXiv:hep-ph/9811253, doi:10.1007/s100529901100.DOI
- [60]V. Braun, R. J. Fries, N. Mahnke, E. Stein, Higher twist distribution amplitudes of the nucleon in QCD, Nucl. Phys. B 589 (2000) 381–409, [Erratum: Nucl.Phys.B 607, 433–433 (2001)]. arXiv:hep-ph/0007279, doi:10.1016/S0550-3213(00)00516-2.DOI
- [61]S. Navas, et al., Review of particle physics, Phys. Rev. D 110 (3) (2024) 030001. doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.110.030001.DOI
- [62]A. Lenz, M. Gockeler, T. Kaltenbrunner, N. Warkentin, The Nucleon Distribution Amplitudes and their application to nucleon form factors and the N → Δ transition at intermediate values of Q², Phys. Rev. D 79 (2009) 093007. arXiv:0903.1723, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.79.093007.DOI



