betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Sedimentation of spheroids in Newtonian fluids with spatially varying viscosity

Abstract

This paper examines the rigid body motion of a spheroid sedimenting in a Newtonian fluid with a spatially varying viscosity field. The fluid is at zero Reynolds number, and the viscosity varies linearly in space in an arbitrary direction with respect to the external force. First, we obtain the correction to the spheroid's rigid body motion in the limit of small viscosity gradients, using a perturbation expansion combined with the reciprocal theorem. Next, we determine the general form of the particle's mobility tensor relating its rigid body motion to an external force and torque. The viscosity gradient does not alter the force/translation and torque/rotation relationships, but introduces new force/rotation and torque/translation couplings that are determined for a wide range of particle aspect ratios. Finally, we discuss results for the spheroid's rotation and center-of-mass trajectory during sedimentation. Depending on the viscosity gradient direction and particle shape, a steady orientation may arise at long times or the particle may tumble continuously. These results are significantly different from the case when no viscosity gradient is present, where the particle stays at its initial orientation for all times. The particle's center of mass trajectory can also be altered depending on the particle's orientation behavior, for example giving rise to diagonal motion or zig-zagging motion. We summarize the observations for prolate and oblate spheroids for different viscosity gradient directions and provide phase plots delineating different dynamical regimes. We also provide guidelines to extend the analysis when the viscosity gradient exhibits a more complicated spatial behavior.

Introduction

Fluids with inhomogeneous viscosity fields are ubiquitous around us. For example, certain biological fluids like mucus and extracellular microbial polymers are mixtures of fluids with different viscosities (Howard Berg 2004), and therefore exhibit variable viscosity, either with [16] or without sharp viscosity gradients (Du et al. 2012). Similarly, gradients in temperature, salinity, or concentration may induce spatial variation in viscosity, most commonly observed in marine ecosystems [3]. Finally, suspensions of particles in Newtonian fluids (both active and passive) may be treated at the continuum level as fluids with viscosity varying with local volume fraction [22, 51].

In this manuscript, we will examine an idealized problem of a single spheroid sedimenting in a spatially varying viscosity field. We will discuss the dynamics that are observed, and how they differ from other situations studied in the literature. By now, it is well-known that in Stokes flow, a spheroid in gravity does not change its orientation due to the particle symmetry and the reversibility of the Stokes equations. If the orientation starts out neither parallel or perpendicular to the gravity direction, the particle will move in a straight diagonal line, the direction of which is determined by the resistances parallel and perpendicular to the particle’s orientation vector (Figure 1a). These dynamics will change only when symmetry breaking is present in the system. One way in which symmetry breaking occurs is if fluid inertia is present [5, 7, 27], or if the suspending fluid has normal stresses due to the presence of polymers [18, 19, 28]. For example, small fluid inertia generates a torque that orients the spheroid’s longest axis perpendicular to the external force – the so-called “broad side on” configuration [8]. Conversely, fluid viscoelasticity orients the spheroid such that its longest axis is along the force direction – i.e., an “edge wise” configuration [8, 28]. These effects markedly change the particle trajectory as well as the sedimentation speed (Figure 1), since the particle’s drag coefficient is a function of orientation and is minimized when the longest axis is along the force direction.

Illustration of spheroid orientation and trajectory during sedimentation

Figure 1. Illustration of spheroid orientation and trajectory during sedimentation in (a) Stokes flow (zero Reynolds number), (b) fluid with finite inertia, and (c) polymeric fluid with normal stresses (large Elasticity number). This paper investigates the behavior when viscosity stratification is present – i.e., case (d)

Another way in which symmetry breaking could occur is if there is a stratified fluid – i.e., variations in density, viscosity, or other fluid properties that alter the force and torque on the particle [42]. This area of research is relatively modern, and most of the efforts have examined the effect of density stratification on particle dynamics including both solid particles [2, 13] and liquid droplets [40]. When density increases along the gravity direction, it is found that the drag on a sphere is enhanced as confirmed by theory [41], experiments [39, 63] and simulations [21, 43]. The buoyancy force also leads to continuous deceleration and absence of a terminal velocity [13]. For anisotropic particles like spheroids, there has been some research to understand their settling behavior in density stratified fluids. Using a reciprocal theorem based approach, Varanasi and Subramanian (Varanasi & Subramanian [59] showed that the hydrostatic torque due to buoyancy originating from density stratification tends to rotate the particle in a broad side on configuration (similar to inertia), which had earlier been also shown by Dandekar et al. (Dandekar et al. [10]. In the cited papers, it was assumed that the fluid density is not altered by the presence of the particle, and gives rise to a so-called “hydrostatic torque”. However, the particle itself can alter the density field, and this additional effect can modify the particle torque [43, 59]. For example, density is often linked to a scalar field like temperature, which depends on a convection-diffusion equation. Depending on the Peclet number, the density around the particle may or may not be coupled with the fluid flow. In the low Peclet number limit, this additional torque is opposite the hydrostatic torque [43, 59].

Despite the advances in understanding microhydrodynamics of particles in density stratified fluids, there is a relative lack of literature examining viscosity stratified fluids, even though there is recent evidence suggesting that these effects would be more important than those due to variations in density in a variety of applications [25] (Dandekar & Ardekani 2020). For example, viscosity gradients are present in the swimming of micro-organisms, and it is of much interest to biologists to understand how organisms move in such complex environments [22, 38, 51, 52, 56], as well as roboticists who design microrobots in such fluids [4, 30, 45, 49, 64] (Li et al. 2017a). Some questions that arise are: how does a spatially varying fluid viscosity affect the common swimming speed, propulsion, and efficiency [17]? Do microswimmers orient themselves in preferable positions in response to the viscosity gradients [58]? The common approach is to leverage a prototypical swimmer model (squirmers [12, 53], swimming sheet [9, 15], Purcell’s swimmer [50], cilia [4, 49]) and then couple it to the Stokes flow field with a variable viscosity.

Currently, work has been performed on the motion of a single sphere in a viscosity varying fluid [12], but the effect of particle shape has yet to be considered. We note that the authors in the cited paper found that viscosity gradients give rise to force/rotation and torque/translation coupling for the sphere’s motion, which would otherwise not exist if the viscosity gradient were absent. This type of coupling is likely to give rise to unique rotational dynamics for orientable particles, which we will investigate in this paper. We note that similar to the case of density stratified flows, the motion of the particle may induce changes in viscosity in the fluid around the particle that could lead to novel hydrodynamic phenomena. For the case of spheres, as shown by [53], the changes in viscosity induced by particle motion do not lead to qualitative changes in the particle dynamics. Thus, in our paper, we do not account for changes in viscosity induced by the motion of the particle and only consider a spatially varying, time invariant viscosity field. However, later in § 5.7, we expound the probable strategy to incorporate the changes in viscosity due to particle motion, in the low Peclet number (PePe) limit.

With this motivation in mind, this manuscript will examine a problem of a single spheroid sedimenting in a Newtonian fluid with a spatially varying viscosity field. The viscosity field varies linearly in space, and its gradient points in an arbitrary direction with respect to the direction of sedimentation (external force). § 2 outlines the particle geometry and equations of motion. § 3 numerically solves for the particle’s rigid body motion in the limit of weak viscosity gradient using the reciprocal theorem. Sec. 4 uses the principles of symmetry to obtain a general expression for the particle mobility tensor relating the particle’s rigid body motion with the force and torque on the spheroid. The force/translation and torque/rotation relationships are unaltered due to the presence of a viscosity gradient, but the viscosity gradient gives rise to new force/rotation and torque/translation coupling terms that depend on three undetermined coefficients. We determine the values of these coefficients numerically, and thus are able to solve the rigid body problem for arbitrary set of forcing, viscosity gradient direction, and particle geometry. § 5 discusses some illustrative examples, wherein the orientations and trajectories of settling spheroids are analysed for different directions of the viscosity gradient. We find that depending on the viscosity gradient direction, particle shape (prolate vs. oblate spheroid), and particle aspect ratio, the spheroid can take on different steady orientation angles. The section concludes on how to extend the analysis to more complicated situations, followed by Sec. 6 which summarizes all results.

We note that although this work primarily focuses on passive particles in viscosity stratified fluids, the results here will likely be important in a variety of contexts beyond this work. For example, scientists are interested in quantifying the swimming of particles in viscosity varying fluids, and the mobility relationships developed here can be used for such applications. Furthermore, understanding the rotation behavior and velocity field from a single, orientable particle can help understand their far-field hydrodynamic interactions in a dilute suspension, which is important in understanding concentration instabilities that arise in fibrous suspensions [6, 23, 31, 32, 33, 46, 54, 55, 60]. The force/rotation and torque/translation couplings shown in our paper has also been very recently shown in sedimentation of spheroids with non-uniform density, where the center of mass of the particle does not match its gravitational center [47] and therefore we expect that the theory developed in this paper may also aid in the understanding of the sedimentation of such mass polar spheroids as well. We will not comment on this point further, noting that the work acts as a stepping stone for these more complicated problems when viscosity gradients are present.

Problem Statement

Problem Geometry

The schematic of our system is shown in Figure 2 and Figure 3. We consider a torque-free spheroid under an external force F\mathbf{F} in a Newtonian fluid with a constant viscosity gradient ∇η\nabla\eta. The force is in the positive 3-direction. The viscosity gradient ∇η\nabla\eta can be co-linear with the force (Figure 2, where ∇η\nabla\eta is in the ±3\pm3-direction) or perpendicular to the force (Figure 3, where ∇η\nabla\eta is in the +1+1-direction). The spheroid has three semi-major axes of lengths (a,b,c)(a,b,c), with a≠b=ca \ne b = c. The initial center of mass of the spheroid is (x01,x02,x03)=(0,0,0)(x_{01},x_{02},x_{03})=(0,0,0).

Schematic of a prolate and oblate spheroid falling under an external force

Figure 2. Schematic of a prolate and oblate spheroid falling under an external force acting in the 3-direction. The viscosity gradient is along the 3-direction (parallel or anti-parallel). The particle’s orientation vector p\mathbf{p} makes a polar angle α∈[0,π]\alpha\in[0,\pi] with respect to the sedimentation direction.

Schematic of a prolate and oblate spheroid

Figure 3. Schematic of a prolate and oblate spheroid falling under an external force FF acting in the 3-direction, while the viscosity varies spatially in the 1-direction. The particle’s orientation p\boldsymbol{p} makes a polar angle α∈[0,π]\alpha\in[0,\pi] with respect to the 3-direction, and makes an azimuthal angle ϕ∈[0,2π)\phi\in[0,2\pi) in the 1-2 plane.

We will define the spheroid’s orientation vector p\mathbf{p} as the direction along its unequal axis (i.e., the aa-axis). Two different cases arise. A prolate spheroid has p\mathbf{p} along its longest axis, while an oblate spheroid has p\mathbf{p} along its shortest axis. Another way to parameterize the particle shape is through an aspect ratio parameter ARA_R and equivalent radius RR. Here, ARA_R is the ratio a/ba/b, while RR is the radius of an equivalent sphere with the same volume.

AR=abR=(abc)1/3(1)A_R = \frac{a}{b} \qquad R = (abc)^{1/3} \tag*{(1)}

The two systems of parameterization are connected by the following relationship:

a=RAR2/3,b=c=RAR−1/3(2)a = R A_R^{2/3}, \qquad b = c = R A_R^{-1/3} \tag*{(2)}

Evidently, a prolate particle has its aspect ratio parameter AR>1A_R > 1, while an oblate particle has its aspect ratio parameter AR<1A_R < 1. Figure 2 and Figure 3 describe the polar and azimuthal angles α∈[0,π]\alpha\in[0,\pi] and ϕ∈[0,2π)\phi\in[0,2\pi) for the particle orientation. The next section discusses the equations of motion and the rheology of the fluid.

Equations of motion and fluid rheology

The fluid surrounding the particle is incompressible and Newtonian. The fluid also has negligible inertia – in other words, the Reynolds number based on the particle’s largest length scale Re=(ρfULmax⁡)/η0≈0Re = (\rho_f U L_{\max})/\eta_0 \approx0. Here, ρf\rho_f is the density of the fluid surrounding the particle, UU is the translation speed of the particle, Lmax⁡=max⁡(a,b)L_{\max} = \max(a,b) is the largest axis of the particle, and η0\eta_0 is fluid’s viscosity at the origin if the particle were absent.

When these conditions hold, the momentum and mass balance equations in the fluid are given as:

∂σij∂xj=0;∂vi∂xi=0(3)\frac{\partial\sigma_{ij}}{\partial x_j} = 0; \qquad\frac{\partial v_i}{\partial x_i} = 0 \tag*{(3)}

where σij\sigma_{ij} is the stress tensor and viv_i is the velocity field. Einstein summation convention is assumed – i.e., repeated indices are summed. The stress tensor takes the following form:

σij=−pδij+η(x)γ˙ij(4)\sigma_{ij} = -p\delta_{ij} + \eta(\boldsymbol{x})\dot{\gamma}_{ij} \tag*{(4)}

where pp is the pressure, γ˙ij=∂vi∂xj+∂vj∂xi\dot{\gamma}_{ij} = \frac{\partial v_i}{\partial x_j} + \frac{\partial v_j}{\partial x_i} is twice the strain rate tensor, and η\eta is the viscosity of the medium. In this problem, the viscosity is independent of the strain rate but exhibits a spatial dependence. The viscosity field is:

η(x)=η0(1+βRd^⋅x)(5)\eta(\boldsymbol{x}) = \eta_0\left(1 + \frac{\beta}{R}\hat{\boldsymbol{d}}\cdot\boldsymbol{x}\right) \tag*{(5)}

In the above equation, η0\eta_0 is the viscosity at the origin and ∇η=η0Rβd^\nabla\eta= \frac{\eta_0}{R}\beta\hat{\boldsymbol{d}} is a constant viscosity gradient with dimensionless magnitude β\beta and unit direction d^\hat{\boldsymbol{d}}.

The goal of the problem is to solve Eqs. (3), (4), and (5) for the stress and velocity around the particle. The equations have to be solved with the following boundary conditions:

vi→0,∣xi∣→∞(6)v_i \to0,\qquad|x_i| \to\infty \tag*{(6)}
vi=Ui+ϵijkωj(xk−xkcm),xi∈Sp(7)v_i = U_i + \epsilon_{ijk}\omega_j\left(x_k-x_k^{\mathrm{cm}}\right),\qquad x_i\in S_p \tag*{(7)}

where (Ui,ωi)(U_i,\omega_i) are the rigid body velocities of the particle, SpS_p is the particle surface, xkcmx_k^{\mathrm{cm}} is the center of mass, and ϵijk\epsilon_{ijk} is the Levi-Civita symbol. An additional constraint is that the particle’s external force and torque are specified. These are:

Fi=−∫Spσijnj dS,Ti=−∫Spϵikl(xk−xkcm)σljnj dS(8)F_i=-\int_{S_p}\sigma_{ij}n_j\,\mathrm{d}S,\qquad T_i=-\int_{S_p}\epsilon_{ikl}\left(x_k-x_k^{\mathrm{cm}}\right)\sigma_{lj}n_j\,\mathrm{d}S \tag*{(8)}

where nin_i is the outward-pointing vector on the particle surface. For this problem, Ti=0T_i=0.

In this problem, we specify the viscosity field to have a constant gradient, while for other problems the viscosity field is often found by solving a scalar quantity like temperature or concentration that is a solution to a convection-diffusion equation around the particle. For such problems in the limit of small Peclet number (one-way coupling), the results will be very similar to the problem formulated here, albeit with minor quantitative differences. A more detailed discussion will be provided at the end of the manuscript (§ 5.7).

Non dimensionalization, dimensionless numbers and perturbation expansion

Unless otherwise noted, all quantities from here on out will be written in non-dimensional form. Lengths will be scaled by the average particle size RR, forces by its magnitude FF, and viscosities by its value at the origin η0\eta_0. Velocities will be scaled by the Newtonian sedimentation velocity U=F6πη0RU=\frac{F}{6\pi\eta_0R}, times by tc=R/Ut_c=R/U, strain rates and rotational velocities by γ˙c=1/tc\dot{\gamma}_c=1/t_c, stresses and pressures by η0γ˙c\eta_0\dot{\gamma}_c, and torques (if present) by FRFR.

The dynamics of the spheroid will depend on the following dimensionless quantities – the particle aspect ratio parameter ARA_R, the particle orientation p\boldsymbol{p} (characterized by angles α\alpha and ϕ\phi), and the non-dimensional viscosity gradient ∇η\nabla\eta (characterized by magnitude β\beta and direction d^\hat{\boldsymbol{d}}):

AR=ba;p=[sin⁡αcos⁡ϕ,sin⁡αsin⁡ϕ,cos⁡α];∇η=βd^(9)A_R=\frac{b}{a};\qquad\boldsymbol{p}=[\sin\alpha\cos\phi,\sin\alpha\sin\phi,\cos\alpha];\qquad\nabla\eta=\beta\hat{\boldsymbol{d}} \tag*{(9)}

In dimensionless form, the viscosity of the fluid in Figure 2 and Figure 3 is the following:

η=1±βx3η=1+βx1(10)\eta=1\pm\beta x_3\qquad\eta=1+\beta x_1 \tag*{(10)}

where the first equation namely, η=1±βx3\eta=1\pm\beta x_3 corresponds to the situation where the viscosity gradient is parallel (+3+3 direction) or anti-parallel (−3-3 direction) to the external force, and the second equation namely, η=1+βx1\eta=1+\beta x_1 corresponds to the case where the viscosity gradient is perpendicular to the external force. For a general viscosity gradient ∇η\nabla\eta, the particle motion will be a superposition of the solutions for the two cases listed above. We will examine particle dynamics in the limit of small viscosity gradient:

Re≪β≪1(11)Re \ll\beta\ll1 \tag*{(11)}

The above condition indicates that one can neglect fluid inertia and perform a regular perturbation expansion in β\beta. We will solve for the rigid body motion up to O(β)O(\beta), both numerically and semi-analytically using symmetry arguments listed in the next sections.

Numerical solution to particle dynamics

Reciprocal theorem

We will determine the rigid body motion of the spheroid by performing a perturbation expansion in the non-dimensional viscosity gradient β≪1\beta\ll1. We perturb the dependent variables as follows:

{vi,p,σij,γ˙ij,Fi,Ui,ωi}={vi(0),p(0),σij(0),γ˙ij(0),Fi(0),Ui(0),ωi(0)}+β{ui(1),p(1),τij(1),γ˙ij(1),Fi(1),Ui(1),ωi(1)}+⋯(12)\{v_i,p,\sigma_{ij},\dot{\gamma}_{ij},F_i,U_i,\omega_i\} = \left\{v_i^{(0)},p^{(0)},\sigma_{ij}^{(0)},\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(0)},F_i^{(0)},U_i^{(0)},\omega_i^{(0)}\right\} + \beta\left\{u_i^{(1)},p^{(1)},\tau_{ij}^{(1)},\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(1)},F_i^{(1)},U_i^{(1)},\omega_i^{(1)}\right\}+\cdots \tag*{(12)}

and solve for the momentum and mass balances Eqs. (2.3) - (2.7) at each order in β\beta. At leading order, the spheroid sediments in a zero Reynolds number fluid with a constant, non-dimensional viscosity η=1\eta=1 and a non-dimensional external force F=1F=1:

∂2vi(0)∂xk∂xk−∂p(0)∂xi=0;∂vi(0)∂xi=0;Fi=δi3;Ti=0(13)\frac{\partial^2 v_i^{(0)}}{\partial x_k\partial x_k}-\frac{\partial p^{(0)}}{\partial x_i}=0;\qquad\frac{\partial v_i^{(0)}}{\partial x_i}=0;\qquad F_i=\delta_{i3};\qquad T_i=0 \tag*{(13)}

The solution to the above problem is given in many classical texts (for example see [29]). The velocity field is presented in Appendix A, while the rigid body motion satisfies the classical resistance relationship:

(RFURFωRTURTω)⋅(U(0)ω(0))=(FT)(14)\begin{pmatrix} R^{FU} & R^{F\omega}\\ R^{TU} & R^{T\omega} \end{pmatrix} \cdot \begin{pmatrix} U^{(0)}\\ \omega^{(0)} \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} F\\ T \tag*{(14)} \end{pmatrix}

In this equation, (RFU,RFω,RTU,RTω)(R^{FU},R^{F\omega},R^{TU},R^{T\omega}) are the resistance tensors for a spheroid, which are given in Appendix B. The external force and torque are given in (13).

At the next order of approximation O(β)O(\beta), the momentum and mass balance equations become Stokes flow with an extra fluid body force bib_i:

∂2vi(1)∂xk∂xk−∂p(1)∂xi+bi=0;∂vi(1)∂xi=0(15)\frac{\partial^2 v_i^{(1)}}{\partial x_k\partial x_k}-\frac{\partial p^{(1)}}{\partial x_i}+b_i=0;\qquad\frac{\partial v_i^{(1)}}{\partial x_i}=0 \tag*{(15)}

Here the body force is due to the spatially varying viscosity field:

bi=∂τijex∂xj;τijex=(d^⋅x)γ˙ij(0)(16)b_i=\frac{\partial\tau_{ij}^{ex}}{\partial x_j};\qquad\tau_{ij}^{ex}=(\hat{d}\cdot x)\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(0)} \tag*{(16)}

In the above (16), τijex\tau_{ij}^{ex} is the extra stress tensor, and γ˙ij(0)\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(0)} is twice the rate of strain tensor from the leading order velocity field.

We employ the reciprocal theorem to solve for the translational and rotational velocity for the O(β)O(\beta) problem. This theorem has a storied history in the Stokes flow community, as is often used to solve for the rigid body motion of particles in Stokes flow with a fluid body force. The derivation is stated in Appendix C and we present the main results below. In brief, the translational and rotational velocities follow a resistance relationship similar to Eq. (14), except the forces and torques are replaced by an effective viscosity-stratified force and torque:

(RFURFωRTURTω)⋅(U(1)(1)ω(1)(1))=(FvsTvs)(17)\begin{pmatrix} R^{FU} & R^{F\omega} \\ R^{TU} & R^{T\omega} \end{pmatrix} \cdot\begin{pmatrix} U_{(1)}^{(1)} \\ \omega_{(1)}^{(1)} \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} F^{vs} \\ T^{vs} \tag*{(17)} \end{pmatrix}

The viscosity-stratified force and torque are given as follows:

Fivs=−∫Vout∂vkitrans∂xjτkjex dV;Tivs=−∫Vout∂vkirot∂xjτkjex dV(18)F_i^{vs}=-\int_{V_{\mathrm{out}}}\frac{\partial v_{ki}^{\mathrm{trans}}}{\partial x_j}\tau_{kj}^{\mathrm{ex}}\,\mathrm{d}V;\qquad T_i^{vs}=-\int_{V_{\mathrm{out}}}\frac{\partial v_{ki}^{\mathrm{rot}}}{\partial x_j}\tau_{kj}^{\mathrm{ex}}\,\mathrm{d}V \tag*{(18)}

where the integrals are evaluated over the volume VoutV_{\mathrm{out}} outside the particle. The quantities vkitransv_{ki}^{\mathrm{trans}} and vkirotv_{ki}^{\mathrm{rot}} are the Stokes flow velocity fields around a spheroid in the kk direction due to unit translation or unit rotation in the ii direction. These quantities are derived from the same velocity fields listed in Appendix A.

Numerical implementation:

The volume integrals in the Eq. (18) are difficult to evaluate analytically. A custom-made MATLAB code was written to calculate the spheroid’s rigid body motion. This code is similar to the approach used in our prior papers to investigate the motion of ellipsoids in weakly viscoelastic fluids [61], except that here the extra stress is modified to account for the viscosity gradient. First, we transform from the laboratory frame to the particle frame of reference where that the origin is at the particle’s center of mass and the Cartesian coordinate axes align with the particle’s principle axes. We then evaluate the volume integrals in Eq. (18) for the viscosity-stratified force and torque, using an elliptical coordinate system and performing Gaussian quadrature via Legendre polynomials. A mesh convergence study showed that 60 elements in the radial direction, 80 elements in the polar direction and 100 elements in the azimuthal direction yielded a sufficiently accurate mesh for our analysis. We then solve the matrix equations Eq. (14) and Eq. (17) for the rigid body motions at O(1)O(1) and O(β)O(\beta), and transform back to the laboratory frame. The particle’s center of mass and orientation are evolved by solving the rigid body dynamics:

dxcmdt=U;dpdt=ω×p(19)\frac{\mathrm{d}x^{cm}}{\mathrm{d}t}=U;\qquad\frac{\mathrm{d}p}{\mathrm{d}t}=\omega\times p \tag*{(19)}

We use a forward Euler scheme with Δt=0.01\Delta t=0.01. More details are found in our prior publications [1, 61].

Verification of code

For the case of a sphere sedimenting in a linear, imposed viscosity gradient, we refer to the work by Datt & Elfring [12]. Specifically, Eqs. (7, 8) in Datt & Elfring [12] are the resistance relationships for the external force FF and torque TT on a sphere of radius aa in a fluid with a constant viscosity gradient ∇η\nabla\eta, with translational velocity UU and rotational velocity ω\omega. For convenience, these equations are reproduced in dimensional form here:

F=6πη0aU−2πa3∇η×ωF=6\pi\eta_0 a U-2\pi a^3\nabla\eta\times\omega
T=2πa3∇η×U+8πη0a3ωT=2\pi a^3\nabla\eta\times U+8\pi\eta_0a^3\omega

(i) Spatial variation in yy direction: For a torque-free (T=0T=0) sphere sedimenting in the xx-direction where the dimensional viscosity gradient is along the yy-direction ∇η=\nabla\eta= βη0ay^\beta\frac{\eta_0}{a}\hat{\boldsymbol{y}}, the above equations give us:

Ux=Fxπaη0(6−0.5β2);Uy=Uz=0(20)U_x=\frac{F_x}{\pi a\eta_0(6-0.5\beta^2)};\qquad U_y=U_z=0 \tag*{(20)}
ωx=ωy=0ωz=0.25βFxπη0a2(6−0.5β2)(21)\omega_x=\omega_y=0\qquad\omega_z=0.25\beta\frac{F_x}{\pi\eta_0a^2(6-0.5\beta^2)} \tag*{(21)}

The analytical result for ωz\omega_z in Eq. (21) is compared against the results of the numerical simulation and the comparison is shown in Figure 4(a) showing an accurate match.

Code validation for a sphere sedimenting in a fluid with a prescribed viscosity gradient

Figure 4. Code validation for a sphere sedimenting in a fluid with a prescribed viscosity gradient in the (a) yy-direction and (b) xx-direction. For all the cases, the external force is a unit vector along the xx-direction, while the external torque is T=0\boldsymbol{T}=0. The radius and fluid viscosity are a=1a=1 and η0=1\eta_0=1, respectively. The results of the theory are from [12], expanded in § 3.2.1.

(ii) Spatial variation in xx direction: Similarly, for a torque-free sphere sedimenting in the xx-direction where the dimensional viscosity gradient is along the xx-direction ∇η=βη0ax^\boldsymbol{\nabla}\eta=\beta\frac{\eta_0}{a}\hat{\boldsymbol{x}}, the above equations give:

Ux=Fx6πaη0;Uy=Uz=0(22)U_x=\frac{F_x}{6\pi a\eta_0};\qquad U_y=U_z=0 \tag*{(22)}
ωx=ωy=ωz=0(23)\omega_x=\omega_y=\omega_z=0 \tag*{(23)}

We compare the results of the simulation against Eq. (22) in Figure 4(b) where a good match is seen. The relative error in the simulation with respect to the simulation results is <1%<1\%

Semi analytical theory

Introduction and motivation

The simulations described in the previous section solve the rigid body motion of the particle, but are computationally intensive. At each timestep, one has to evaluate six volume integrals in Eq. (18) to obtain the viscosity-stratified force and torque. Furthermore, a new time sweep has to be performed if one examines a different viscosity gradient direction and magnitude.

An alternative approach to obtain the same dynamics is to develop a semi-analytical theory based on the symmetry of the problem. Such a theory will give the general form of the particle’s motion in terms of three undetermined constants, which in turn can be found by performing simulations at three specific configurations. The result of this analysis is that one can cheaply obtain the particle’s motion for an arbitrary set of particle orientations, forcing, and viscosity gradients.

What we are doing is essentially finding the general form of the mobility tensor when a viscosity gradient is present. Thus, the analysis below will not only give general information about the force-rotation coupling of these orientable particles, but can also give results for the case when a torque is applied – for example, the torque-translation coupling. A description is below.

General form of mobility tensor

The governing momentum and continuity Eqns. (3) - (8) are linear in the external force and torque (F,T)(F,T). Thus, the translational and rotational velocities (U,ω)(U,\omega) are also linear in these quantities and obey the following relationship:

(Uω)=(ABBTD)⋅(FT)(24)\begin{pmatrix} U \\ \omega\end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} A & B \\ B^{T} & D \end{pmatrix} \cdot \begin{pmatrix} F \\ T \tag*{(24)} \end{pmatrix}

Here, (A,B,D)(A,B,D) are mobility tensors that are non-dimensionalized by (UF,UFR,UFR2)=(16πη0R,16πη0R2,16πη0R3)\left(\frac{U}{F},\frac{U}{FR},\frac{U}{FR^{2}}\right)=\left(\frac{1}{6\pi\eta_{0}R},\frac{1}{6\pi\eta_{0}R^{2}},\frac{1}{6\pi\eta_{0}R^{3}}\right), respectively . In a constant viscosity fluid, these tensors are only a function of the particle shape and orientation, characterised by the aspect ratio parameter ARA_{R} and the orientation vector p\mathbf{p}. If a viscosity gradient is present, the tensors will also be a function of the non-dimensional viscosity gradient ∇η=βd^\nabla\eta=\beta\hat{\mathbf{d}}. Note: the off-diagonal terms of the matrix in Eq. (24) are transposes of each other as can be proved by the reciprocal theorem (not shown here).Additionally, the mobility tensors (A,D)(A,D) are symmetric for arbitrary shaped particle in viscosity stratified fluid, as has been shown with due rigor with aid of reciprocal theorem earlier in literature [48]

In the limit of β≪1\beta\ll1, we expand the mobility tensors in a Taylor series as follows:

{Aij,Bij,Dij}={Aij(0),Bij(0),Dij(0)}+β{Aij(1),Bij(1),Dij(1)}(25)\left\{A_{ij},B_{ij},D_{ij}\right\} = \left\{A_{ij}^{(0)},B_{ij}^{(0)},D_{ij}^{(0)}\right\} +\beta\left\{A_{ij}^{(1)},B_{ij}^{(1)},D_{ij}^{(1)}\right\} \tag*{(25)}

At leading order (O(1))(O(1)), the tensors are the same as those for the particle in a constant viscosity fluid. These quantities are well-characterized and formulas are given in Appendix B for a general ellipsoid. Specifically, for the case where the particle has an orientation vector p\mathbf{p}, they take the form:

Aij(0)=c1(δij−pipj)+c2pipj(26)A_{ij}^{(0)}=c_{1}\left(\delta_{ij}-p_{i}p_{j}\right)+c_{2}p_{i}p_{j} \tag*{(26)}
Dij(0)=c3(δij−pipj)+c4pipj(27)D_{ij}^{(0)}=c_{3}\left(\delta_{ij}-p_{i}p_{j}\right)+c_{4}p_{i}p_{j} \tag*{(27)}
Bij(0)=0(28)B_{ij}^{(0)}=0 \tag*{(28)}

where c1c_{1}, c2c_{2}, c3c_{3} and c4c_{4} are functions of the aspect ratio parameter and are given in Appendix B.

At O(β)O(\beta), the motion will be linear in ∇η\nabla\eta. Thus, in non-dimensional form, the mobility tensors take the following structure:

Aij(1)=αijkd^k(29)A^{(1)}_{ij}=\alpha_{ijk}\hat{d}_k \tag*{(29)}
Dij(1)=βijkd^k(30)D^{(1)}_{ij}=\beta_{ijk}\hat{d}_k \tag*{(30)}
Bji(1)=Mikjd^k(31)B^{(1)}_{ji}=M_{ikj}\hat{d}_k \tag*{(31)}

where d^k\hat{d}_k is the direction of the viscosity gradient. Therefore the problem of finding the mobility matrices (Aij(1),Bij(1),Dij(1))(A^{(1)}_{ij},B^{(1)}_{ij},D^{(1)}_{ij}) reduces to the problem of finding αijk,βijk\alpha_{ijk},\beta_{ijk} and MijkM_{ijk}. For a spheroid, these third order tensors depend on the orientation product pipjp_i p_j, since fore-aft symmetry dictates that changing pip_i to −pi-p_i will not alter the results. Noting that (αijk,βijk)(\alpha_{ijk},\beta_{ijk}) are third order true tensors, and such tensors cannot be formed from pipjp_i p_j, we obtain the result:

αijk=βijk=0(32)\alpha_{ijk}=\beta_{ijk}=0 \tag*{(32)}

The above relationship means that at O(β)O(\beta), the force-velocity coupling and torque-angular velocity coupling are unchanged. However, as we will see next, the force-rotation coupling and torque-velocity coupling will change. BjiB_{ji} is a pseudo tensor since it connects a pseudo vector (angular velocity) with a true vector (force). Therefore, MikjM_{ikj} is a third order pseudo tensor, which depends on the orientation product pipjp_i p_j. The general form of MijkM_{ijk} is given below as:

Mijk=λ1ϵijk+λ2piϵjkqpq+λ3pjϵikqpq+λ4pkϵijqpq(33)M_{ijk}=\lambda_1\epsilon_{ijk}+\lambda_2p_i\epsilon_{jkq}p_q+\lambda_3p_j\epsilon_{ikq}p_q+\lambda_4p_k\epsilon_{ijq}p_q \tag*{(33)}

where λ1,λ2,λ3,λ4\lambda_1,\lambda_2,\lambda_3,\lambda_4 are dimensionless coefficients that depend only on the aspect ratio parameter ARAR. One can show that without loss of generality λ2=0\lambda_2=0 (see Appendix D) and therefore the problem reduces to finding the coefficients λ1,λ3,λ4\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4. In other words, Eq. (33) reduces to

Mijk=λ1ϵijk+λ3pjϵikqpq+λ4pkϵijqpq(34)M_{ijk}=\lambda_1\epsilon_{ijk}+\lambda_3p_j\epsilon_{ikq}p_q+\lambda_4p_k\epsilon_{ijq}p_q \tag*{(34)}

We note that at the time of this article being prepared for publication, another manuscript solving a similar problem, arrived at a similar formulation for the mobility tensor (see Eq. 27 in Gong et al. [20]).

In summary, the mobility relationships up to O(β)O(\beta) reduce to:

Ui=Aij(0)Fj+βMjkid^kTj(35)U_i=A^{(0)}_{ij}F_j+\beta M_{jki}\hat{d}_kT_j \tag*{(35)}
ωi=βMikjd^kFj+Dij(0)Tj(36)\omega_i=\beta M_{ikj}\hat{d}_kF_j+D^{(0)}_{ij}T_j \tag*{(36)}

where Aij(0),Dij(0)A^{(0)}_{ij},D^{(0)}_{ij} are the known mobility tensors for a spheroid without a viscosity gradient, given by Eq. (4.3), while MijkM_{ijk} is the cross-coupling term given by Eq. (34). The unknown coefficients for the tensor MijkM_{ijk} are (λ1,λ3,λ4)(\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4), which are functions of the aspect ratio parameter ARAR for the spheroid. We also note, from Eq. (34) in conjunction with Eq. (4.4c), that λ1,λ3,λ4\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4 are related to the eigenvalues of BB, and in some cases of the orientation of the viscosity gradient vector, are exactly equal to the eigenvalues of BB. For a more detailed discussion on this interpretation, please refer to Witten & Diamant [62]. The next section discusses how we determine these coefficients.

Determining coefficients λ1,λ3,λ4\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4 for the mobility matrix MijkM_{ijk} (force-rotation and torque-translation coupling)

Fig 5 outlines the simulations we perform to obtain the coefficients (λ1,λ3,λ4)(\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4) for MijkM_{ijk} in Eq. (34). We examine a torque-free particle (Ti=0T_i=0) and quantify its angular velocity ωi\omega_i for the three specific geometries listed below. We note that the angular velocity can cause two effects – it can change the spheroid’s orientation or it can keep the orientation the same but spin it along its axis. The rate of change of the orientation is given by:

dpidt=ϵijkωjpk(37)\frac{d p_i}{d t}=\epsilon_{ijk}\omega_j p_k \tag*{(37)}

while the rate of spinning is:

Ω=ωipi(38)\Omega=\omega_i p_i \tag*{(38)}

These quantities are computed for the cases below:

(i) Case A: ∇η×F=0\nabla\eta\times\boldsymbol{F}=0: Here, we examine the situation in Figure 5a where the external force and viscosity gradient are in the same direction – i.e., F=d^=z^\boldsymbol{F}=\hat{\boldsymbol{d}}=\hat{\boldsymbol{z}}. The particle has its orientation in the x−zx-z plane with an angle α\alpha with respect to the force direction – i.e., p=[sin⁡α,0,cos⁡α]\boldsymbol{p}=[\sin\alpha,0,\cos\alpha]. Using Eqs. (34), (4.8b), and (37), one finds the angular velocity to be:

Simulations carried out for three specific geometries

Figure 5. Simulations carried out to estimate the parameters (λ1,λ3,λ4)(\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4) in the third order pseudo tensor MijkM_{ijk} given by Eq. (34). The orientation angles (α,ϕ)(\alpha,\phi) are defined in Figure 2 and Figure 3 respectively.

ω2=dαdt=12β(λ3+λ4)sin⁡(2α)(39)\omega_2=\frac{d\alpha}{d t}=\frac{1}{2}\beta(\lambda_3+\lambda_4)\sin(2\alpha) \tag*{(39)}

Thus, performing one simulation at a specific polar angle and viscosity gradient magnitude (say α=π/4,β=0.1\alpha=\pi/4,\beta=0.1) allows us to obtain (λ3+λ4)(\lambda_3+\lambda_4). To test this theory, we carried out simulations of prolate spheroids undergoing sedimentation at aspect ratio AR=3AR=3 and AR=5AR=5. The simulations were performed for many different values of angles α\alpha and non-dimensional viscosity gradient β=0.1\beta=0.1, and they found that for a given aspect ratio, the quantity 2βsin⁡(2α)dαdt\frac{2}{\beta\sin(2\alpha)}\frac{d\alpha}{d t} was constant for all values of α\alpha (equal to 0.0649 for AR=3AR=3 and 0.0656 for AR=5AR=5). This behavior is consistent with the expression listed above.

(ii) Case B: ∇η⋅F=0,p×F=0\nabla\eta\cdot\boldsymbol{F}=0,\boldsymbol{p}\times\boldsymbol{F}=0. We examine the situation in Figure 5b where the external force and viscosity gradient are perpendicular to each other – i.e., F=z^\mathbf{F}=\hat{\mathbf{z}}, d^=x^\hat{\mathbf{d}}=\hat{\mathbf{x}}. The particle has its orientation along the force direction – i.e., p=[0,0,1]\mathbf{p}=[0,0,1] – which corresponds to the polar and azimuthal angles of α=ϕ=0\alpha=\phi=0 in Figure 3. Using Eqs. (34), (4.8b), and (37), one finds the angular velocity to be:

ω2=dαdt∣α=ϕ=0∘=−β(λ1+λ4)(40)\omega_{2}=\left.\frac{\mathrm{d}\alpha}{\mathrm{d}t}\right|_{\alpha=\phi=0^\circ}=-\beta(\lambda_{1}+\lambda_{4}) \tag*{(40)}

Performing one simulation at a specific value of β\beta (e.g., β=0.1\beta=0.1) allows us to obtain (λ1+λ4)(\lambda_{1}+\lambda_{4}).

(iii) Case C: ∇η⊥F⊥p\nabla\eta\perp\mathbf{F} \perp\mathbf{p}: We examine case in Fig 5c where the orientation, viscosity gradient, and force are all perpendicular to each other – i.e., F=z^\mathbf{F}=\hat{\mathbf{z}}, d^=x^\hat{\mathbf{d}}=\hat{\mathbf{x}}, p=y^\mathbf{p}=\hat{\mathbf{y}}. Here, the particle will spin but not change orientation. Using Eqs. (34), (4.8b), and (38), we find the spinning rate to be:

Ω=ω2=−βλ1(41)\Omega=\omega_{2}=-\beta\lambda_{1} \tag*{(41)}

Performing one simulation at a specific value of β\beta (e.g., β=0.1\beta=0.1) allows us to obtain λ1\lambda_{1}.

The three simulations listed above yield a linear system of equations for the coefficients (λ1,λ3,λ4)(\lambda_{1},\lambda_{3},\lambda_{4}) that can be solved. Fig 6 shows the values of the coefficients for different values of the aspect ratio parameter ARA_R, for both prolate and oblate spheroids. For comparison, we have also plotted the λ\lambda’s from Kamal & Lauga [26], who invoked the slender body theory to solve the problem of sedimenting slender bodies in inertialess flows of Newtonian fluids with spatially varying viscosity. As can be seen from our plots, a good match is observed between our results for prolate spheroids at high ARA_R and that given by Kamal & Lauga [26].

Once these coefficients are tabulated, one has a general form for the rigid body motion (Eq. (4.8)) for spheroids that can be solved for arbitrary viscosity gradient, orientation, aspect ratio, and external force/torque.

Results and illustrative examples

In Sec. 4, we developed a theory to describe the rigid body motion of a spheroid in a spatially varying viscosity field. In the limit of weak or linearly varying viscosity field, the general form of the translational and rotational velocities is given in Eq. (4.8), where Aij(0)A_{ij}^{(0)} and Dij(0)D_{ij}^{(0)} are the standard mobility tensors for force/translation and torque/rotation in Stokes flow, and MijkM_{ijk} is a newly introduced coupling tensor between force/rotation and torque/translation that arises due to viscosity gradients. The tensor MijkM_{ijk} is given in Eq. (34) in terms of three coefficients (λ1,λ3,λ4)(\lambda_{1},\lambda_{3},\lambda_{4}) that are only functions of the spheroid aspect ratio parameter ARA_R. These coefficients are estimated numerically using the reciprocal theorem (see § 3 and Figure 6).

Computed values of $(\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4)$ for prolate and oblate spheroids

Figure 6. Computed values of (λ1,λ3,λ4)(\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4) for prolate and oblate spheroids for different values of aspect ratio ARA_R. The empty symbols denote the results derived in this paper, while the filled symbols, for prolate spheroids, denote the results from Kamal & Lauga [26], who used the slender body theory to derive their results

In this section, we investigate the spheroid’s dynamics for some special cases and discuss the physics that arise. Details are below. Please note that all the results and examples are valid only up to the first order in β\beta deviation from the constant viscosity, unless otherwise mentioned.

Viscosity gradient is along or opposite the force direction

Governing equations

Let us examine the situation in Figure 2 where the external force is in the positive zz-direction, and the viscosity gradient is either parallel to the force (positive zz-direction) or anti-parallel to the force (negative zz-direction). In this case, the particle orientation only has one degree of freedom, namely the polar angle α\alpha measured from the zz-axis. Without loss of generality, we will state that p\mathbf{p} lies in the xx–zz plane, and thus p=[sin⁡α,0,cos⁡α]\mathbf{p}=[\sin\alpha,0,\cos\alpha].

From our theory (Eqs. (34), (4.8b), and (37)), the orientation angle obeys the following equation:

dαdt=±12β(λ3+λ4)sin⁡(2α)(42)\frac{d\alpha}{dt} = \pm\frac{1}{2}\beta(\lambda_3+\lambda_4)\sin(2\alpha) \tag*{(42)}
⇒∣tan⁡(α)∣=∣tan⁡(α0)∣eβ(λ3+λ4)(t−t0)(43)\Rightarrow\left|\tan(\alpha)\right| = \left|\tan(\alpha_0)\right|e^{\beta(\lambda_3+\lambda_4)(t-t_0)} \tag*{(43)}

where ±\pm illustrates the cases where the viscosity gradient is parallel (++) or anti-parallel (−-) to the force and α0\alpha_0 is the initial angle at t=t0t=t_0. The translational motion of the particle obeys:

dxdt=12(c2−c1)sin⁡(2α);dzdt=c1sin⁡2α+c2cos⁡2α(44)\frac{dx}{dt} = \frac{1}{2}(c_2-c_1)\sin(2\alpha); \qquad\frac{dz}{dt} = c_1\sin^2\alpha+c_2\cos^2\alpha \tag*{(44)}

where c1c_1 and c2c_2 are the mobility coefficients for spheroid translation in Stokes flow (given in Appendix B in dimensional form). Major conclusions are given below.

Particle takes a stable orientation depending on its shape and viscosity gradient direction

Figure 7 plots the evolution of α\alpha with respect to time for prolate and oblate spheroids, for the cases when the force F\mathbf{F} and viscosity gradient ∇η\nabla\eta are parallel and anti-parallel to each other. For each set of conditions, two curves are given – one arising from the symmetry based theory (dashed curve, Eq. (5.1a)), and another from full numerical simulations where the reciprocal theorem is used at every time step (solid curve). The overlap is indistinguishable, thereby validating our theory. The second observation we make is that that irrespective of the initial orientation and viscosity gradient direction (parallel or anti parallel), both prolate and oblate spheroids evolve to a steady configuration of α\alpha. This observation is very different than what is observed in Stokes flow where the orientation stays at its initial angle at all times [35].

Orientation angle plots for prolate and oblate spheroids

Figure 7. Orientation angle α\alpha vs. time for prolate and oblate spheroids when the external force F\mathbf{F} and viscosity gradient ∇η\nabla\eta are parallel or anti-parallel to each other. The left figures (a,c) correspond to prolate spheroids with AR=5A_R = 5, while those the right figures (b,d) correspond to oblate spheroids with AR=1/5A_R = 1/5. The top row (a,b) is the case when the F\mathbf{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta are in the same direction, while the bottom row (b,d) is the case when they are in opposite directions. The solid curves are from full numerical simulations based on the reciprocal theorem, while the dashed curves are from the symmetry based theory (solving Eq. (5.1a)). The dimensionless viscosity gradient is β=0.1\beta= 0.1.

Figure 8 summarizes the steady orientations observed for different particle shapes and viscosity gradient directions. When the external force and the viscosity gradient are parallel to each other, the prolate spheroid adopts a stable configuration where the projector is perpendicular to external force, while the oblate spheroid orients itself such the projector is along the same direction as the external force. In both of these cases, the spheroid (whether prolate or oblate) has its shortest axis oriented along the direction of the viscosity gradient. On the other hand, when the spheroid is falling in the direction of decreasing viscosity (i.e., F\mathbf{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta are anti-parallel), the prolate spheroid attains a stable configuration where the projector is oriented along the force direction, whilst the oblate spheroid orients the projector perpendicular to the force direction. In both these cases, the longest axis of the particle (whether prolate and oblate) will be along the force direction.

Steady configurations of prolate and oblate spheroids for co-linear force and viscosity gradient

Figure 8. Steady configurations attained by (a) prolate and (b) oblate spheroids when the external force FF and viscosity gradient ∇η\nabla\eta are co-linear. The top row is for the case when the external force and the viscosity gradient are in the same direction, while the bottom row is when they are in the opposite direction.

To provide a physical understanding of this behavior, we refer to Figure 9. Here, as observed from the reference frame of the particle, the flow around the prolate spheroid bifurcates into two parts about the stagnation point and engenders both a clockwise and counter-clockwise hydrodynamic torque. Figure 9(a) illustrates the magnitude of the torques for the case when the viscosity gradient is in the same direction as the force, while Figure 9(b) illustrates the case when the viscosity gradient is in the opposite direction. The pictures illustrate that the the unequal torques push the particle toward the stable orientations discussed above.

Unequal torques on a prolate spheroid for parallel and anti-parallel force and viscosity gradient

Figure 9. Illustration of unequal torques created on a prolate spheroid when the force and viscosity gradient are co-linear. The left figure (a) is when the viscosity gradient and force are in the same direction, while the right figure (b) is when they are in opposite directions.This schematic is shown in particle’s frame of reference.

Lastly, we note that Figure 8 summarizes the unstable, steady orientations that can occur for different combinations of viscosity gradient and particle shape. These orientations only exist if the initial condition is at a specific angle, and can only be observed in exceptionally rare cases.

Particle translation is different than in Stokes flow

Beyond orientational kinematics, we are also interested in the translation of the spheroid. In a constant viscosity fluid with zero inertia, it is well-known that the particle stays at its initial orientation [35]. If the initial angle is α=0\alpha= 0, π2\frac{\pi}{2}, or π\pi, the particle will sediment vertically, while if α\alpha is not these values, the particle will drift in a straight, diagonal path. The direction in which the particle sediments is dictated by the resistances parallel and perpendicular to its orientation vector p\mathbf{p}.

When a viscosity gradient is present, the translational velocity UU obeys the same differential equation as the Stokes flow case (Eq. (44)), since we found that the viscosity gradient does not alter the force/translation coupling (see Eq. (4.8)). Thus, on the surface, it appears that the particle trajectory may seem unchanged due to the presence of a spatially varying viscosity field. However, upon closer inspection, we see that the differential equation (Eq. (4.8)) depends on the particle’s orientation angle α\alpha, which itself is altered due to the viscosity gradient as discussed in the previous section. Thus, the viscosity gradient plays an indirect role in altering the translational dynamics.

Fig. 10 plots the trajectories of oblate and prolate spheroids for different values of the initial orientation angle α0\alpha_0. For α0≠0\alpha_0 \ne0, π2\frac{\pi}{2}, and π\pi, we observe motion in the sedimentation direction (3-direction) as well as a cross stream drift (1-direction). For the case when no viscosity gradient is present, the particle moves in a straight, diagonal path. When a viscosity gradient is present, the trajectory is no longer a straight line. The cross-stream drift eventually stops when the spheroid reaches a stable orientation, beyond which the spheroid sediments vertically in the 3-direction. Since the spheroid ceases to drift once the stable orientation is reached, a spheroid whose initial orientation is further away from its stable orientation will drift further than a spheroid whose initial orientation is closer to its stable orientation. Therefore, for a prolate spheroid, a particle with initial orientation α0=π/4\alpha_0=\pi/4 will drift further than one with α0=π/3\alpha_0=\pi/3, since the stable orientation is α=π/2\alpha=\pi/2 (see Figure 10(a)). Conversely, for an oblate spheroid, the particle with an initial orientation α0=π/3\alpha_0=\pi/3 will drift further than one with α0=π/4\alpha_0=\pi/4, since the stable orientation is at α=0\alpha=0.

Particle trajectories for prolate and oblate spheroids

Figure 10. Particle trajectories for (a) prolate and (b) oblate spheroids when the external force and viscosity gradient are in the same direction (F=z^\mathbf{F}=\hat{\mathbf{z}}, ∇η=βz^\nabla\eta=\beta\hat{\mathbf{z}}). The dashed curves correspond to when no viscosity gradient is present (β=0\beta=0), while the solid curve is when a viscosity gradient is present (β=0.1\beta=0.1). Different colors and symbols correspond to different initial starting angles α0\alpha_0. The prolate spheroid has AR=5A_R=5 while the oblate spheroid has AR=1/5A_R=1/5.

Viscosity gradient is perpendicular to the external force

Governing equations

We will now examine the situation in Figure 3 where the external force is in the positive zz-direction (F=z^\mathbf{F}=\hat{\mathbf{z}}), and the viscosity gradient is perpendicular to the force (∇η=βx^\nabla\eta=\beta\hat{\mathbf{x}}). The spheroid’s orientation can point in any direction, and we state it takes the form p=[sin⁡αcos⁡ϕ,sin⁡αsin⁡ϕ,cos⁡α]\mathbf{p}=[\sin\alpha\cos\phi,\sin\alpha\sin\phi,\cos\alpha], where α\alpha and ϕ\phi are the polar and azimuthal angles, respectively. From our theory (Eqs. (34), (4.8b), and (37)), the orientation angles evolve as follows:

dαdt=−β(λ1−λ3sin⁡2α+λ4cos⁡2α)cos⁡ϕ(45)\frac{d\alpha}{dt}=-\beta\left(\lambda_1-\lambda_3\sin^2\alpha+\lambda_4\cos^2\alpha\right)\cos\phi \tag*{(45)}
dϕdt=β(λ1+λ4)cot⁡αsin⁡ϕ(46)\frac{d\phi}{dt}=\beta(\lambda_1+\lambda_4)\cot\alpha\sin\phi \tag*{(46)}

where λ1\lambda_1, λ3\lambda_3, and λ4\lambda_4 are the force-rotation mobility coefficients determined in Sec. 4. The translation of the particle obeys the following:

dxdt=12(c2−c1)sin⁡(2α)cos⁡ϕ;dydt=12(c2−c1)sin⁡(2α)sin⁡ϕ;dzdt=c1sin⁡2α+c2cos⁡2α(47)\frac{dx}{dt}=\frac{1}{2}(c_2-c_1)\sin(2\alpha)\cos\phi;\qquad \frac{dy}{dt}=\frac{1}{2}(c_2-c_1)\sin(2\alpha)\sin\phi;\qquad \frac{dz}{dt}=c_1\sin^2\alpha+c_2\cos^2\alpha \tag*{(47)}

where c1c_1 and c2c_2 are the mobility coefficients for particle translation in Stokes flow (given in Appendix B in dimensional form). Major conclusions are given below.

Particle can take a steady orientation different than the force and viscosity gradient directions

We will first discuss the case when the particle starts in the same plane as F\mathbf{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta – in other words ϕ0=0\phi_0 = 0. From Eq. (5.3b), we see that dϕ/dt=0d\phi/dt = 0 for this angle, so the particle stays at ϕ=0\phi= 0 and only the polar angle α\alpha will change. Figure 11 plots α\alpha versus time for both prolate and oblate spheroids, for the specific case of AR=5A_R = 5 and AR=−1/5A_R = -1/5, respectively. First of all, we note that the results from the symmetry based theory (solid curve, Eq. (5.3)) are virtually indistinguishable from the full numerical simulation (dashed curve), indicating the validity of our theory. Secondly, for all starting conditions, we observe the particle converges to one steady orientation. However, this steady orientation is not α=0\alpha= 0, α=π\alpha= \pi, or α=π/2\alpha= \pi/2, which was the case when the force and viscosity gradient vectors were co-linear.

Orientation angle versus time for prolate and oblate spheroids

Figure 11. Orientation angle α\alpha vs. time for prolate (AR=5A_R = 5) and oblate (AR=1/5A_R = 1/5) spheroids when the external force and viscosity gradient are perpendicular (F=z^\mathbf{F} = \hat{\mathbf{z}}, ∇η=x^\nabla\eta= \hat{\mathbf{x}}). The dimensionless viscosity gradient is β=0.1\beta= 0.1, and the particle initially starts in the plane of F\mathbf{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta (i.e., ϕ0=0\phi_0 = 0). Solid curves are from full numerical simulations based on the reciprocal theorem, while the dashed curves are from the symmetry based theory (solving Eq. (5.3)).

We elucidate this point more clearly in Figure 12. Here, we observe that neither α=0\alpha= 0, π/2\pi/2, or π\pi are steady configurations because the counter-clockwise torque is different than the clockwise torque at these specific angles. Some general trends are described below for prolate and oblate particles:

Schematic explaining the absence of steady orientations

Figure 12. Schematic explaining the absence of steady orientations at α=0\alpha= 0 and α=π/2\alpha= \pi/2 for (a) prolate and (b) oblate spheroids when the external force and viscosity gradient are perpendicular. This schematic is shown in the particle’s frame of reference.

  • Prolate spheroids: For prolate spheroids, we observe from Figure 12 that the difference between the counter-clockwise and clockwise torques is smaller for α=0\alpha= 0 and π\pi (where the long axis is along the force direction) compared to α=π/2\alpha= \pi/2 (where the long axis is along the viscosity gradient direction). Therefore, the steady orientation is closer to α=0\alpha= 0 and π\pi than to α=π/2\alpha= \pi/2, and continues to approach α=0\alpha= 0 or π\pi as the aspect ratio increases. In the limiting case of needle like particles where AR→∞AR \to\infty the steady orientation reaches α=nπ\alpha= n\pi. Between the two configurations of α=0+Δ\alpha= 0 + \Delta and α=π−Δ\alpha= \pi- \Delta (where Δ\Delta is a positive constant depending on aspect ratio), α=π−Δ\alpha= \pi- \Delta is the stable configuration, while α=0+Δ\alpha= 0 + \Delta is unstable (see Figure 11(a)).

  • Oblate spheroids: For oblate spheroids, the difference in hydrodynamic torques is larger at α=0\alpha= 0 compared to α=π/2\alpha= \pi/2, because in the former case the longer axis is oriented along the viscosity gradient direction. Therefore, for oblate spheroids, the equilibrium orientation configuration is closer to α=π/2\alpha= \pi/2 than to α=0\alpha= 0. In the limiting case of a thin disc where AR→0AR \to0, the stable orientation is at α=π/2\alpha= \pi/2. Between the two configurations of α=π/2±ξ\alpha= \pi/2 \pm\xi (where ξ\xi is a positive constant depending on the aspect ratio), α=π/2−ξ\alpha= \pi/2 - \xi is the stable orientation, while α=π/2+ξ\alpha= \pi/2 + \xi is an unstable orientation (see Figure 11(b)).

The results discussed above illustrate the dynamics when the initial particle orientation is co-planar with F\mathbf{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta – i.e., ϕ0=0\phi_0 = 0 or ϕ=π\phi= \pi. Figure 13 plots the orientation angles ϕ\phi and α\alpha over time when the starting angle is no longer co-planar with F\mathbf{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta – i.e., ϕ0≠0\phi_0 \ne0 or π\pi. We see that at long times, the angle ϕ→0\phi\to0 or π\pi – i.e., the orientation ends up in the same plane as F\mathbf{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta. The angle α\alpha also converges to the same result as before. Thus, we conclude that the steady orientation angles discussed previously are stable to out of plane perturbations.

Orientation angles for prolate and oblate spheroids

Figure 13. Orientation angles α(t)\alpha(t) and ϕ(t)\phi(t) for prolate and oblate spheroids when the external force and viscosity gradient are perpendicular (F=z^\mathbf{F} = \hat{\mathbf{z}}, ∇η=βx^\nabla\eta= \beta\hat{\mathbf{x}}). The dashed curves show the evolution of ϕ\phi, while the solid curves show the evolution of α\alpha. For all cases, the initial orientation is given by the ordered pair (ϕ0,α0)=(π/3,π/4)(\phi_0,\alpha_0) = (\pi/3,\pi/4) and the dimensionless viscosity gradient is β=0.1\beta= 0.1. The results show that ϕ→0\phi\to0 or π\pi, and hence the particle becomes co-planar with F\mathbf{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta.

Stable orientation for different aspect ratios

Figure 14 plots the steady orientation angles for prolate and oblate spheroids for different aspect ratio parameters. The steady orientations occur when dαdt=0\frac{d\alpha}{dt} = 0 and dϕdt=0\frac{d\phi}{dt} = 0 in Eq.

Stable orientations for prolate and oblate spheroids

Figure 14. (a) Prolate \quad (b) Oblate. Stable orientations αse\alpha_{se} for prolate and oblate spheroids of different aspect ratio parameters ARA_R when the external force and viscosity gradient are perpendicular to each other (F=z^\mathbf{F}=\hat{\mathbf{z}}}, ∇η=βx^\nabla\eta=\beta\hat{\mathbf{x}}, β=0.1\beta=0.1).

(5.3), which corresponds to the criterion:

ϕ=nπλ1−λ3sin⁡2α+λ4cos⁡2α=0⇒sin⁡2α=λ4+λ1λ3+λ4(48)\phi=n\pi\qquad\lambda_1-\lambda_3\sin^2\alpha+\lambda_4\cos^2\alpha=0\Rightarrow\sin^2\alpha=\frac{\lambda_4+\lambda_1}{\lambda_3+\lambda_4} \tag*{(48)}
0<λ4+λ1λ3+λ4<1(49)0<\frac{\lambda_4+\lambda_1}{\lambda_3+\lambda_4}<1 \tag*{(49)}

In the above equation, (λ1,λ3,λ4)(\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4) are the mobility coefficients for force-rotation coupling that were calculated in Sec. 4, which are only functions of the aspect ratio parameter ARA_R. Figure 14 show that for a wide range of ARA_R, the above criterion is satisfied and a steady angle αse\alpha_{se} exists. The stable orientation αse\alpha_{se} for a prolate spheroid is closer to π\pi compared to an oblate spheroid, while the oblate spheroid has a stable angle closer to π/2\pi/2.

Translation dynamics

Figure 15 shows the spheroid’s translation trajectories for the case when the force and viscosity gradient are perpendicular to each other for both prolate and oblate spheroids. For both these spheroids, when the particle has a stable orientation (AR=5A_R=5), the particle at long times will move in a straight, diagonal line – i.e., sediment downwards and also have a component along the viscosity gradient direction. This diagonal motion qualitatively looks similar to the motion when the spheroid is in a constant viscosity fluid [35]. However, in a constant viscosity fluid, the angle of motion is determined by the particle’s initial angle, whereas in this case, all particles will eventually move with the same trajectory, regardless of starting angle.

Particle trajectories for prolate and oblate spheroids

Figure 15. (a) Prolate AR=5A_R=5 \quad (b) Oblate 1/AR=51/A_R=5. Particle trajectories for spheroids with (a) AR=5A_R=5 and (b) 1/AR=51/A_R=5 when the external force and viscosity gradient are perpendicular (F=z^\mathbf{F}=\hat{\mathbf{z}}, ∇η=βx^\nabla\eta=\beta\hat{\mathbf{x}}). The dashed curves correspond to when no viscosity gradient is present (β=0\beta=0), while the solid curve is when a viscosity gradient is present (β=0.1\beta=0.1). Different color curves correspond to different initial starting angles α0\alpha_0.

General case: general direction for viscosity gradient

Governing equations

We now consider the most general case where F\boldsymbol{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta are neither parallel or orthogonal to each other, but are inclined at an angle θ\theta to each other. The external force points in the positive zz-direction F=z^\boldsymbol{F} = \hat{\boldsymbol{z}}, while the viscosity gradient is as follows:

∇η=βd^=βcos⁡θz^+βsin⁡θx^(50)\nabla\eta= \beta\hat{\boldsymbol{d}} = \beta\cos\theta\hat{\boldsymbol{z}} + \beta\sin\theta\hat{\boldsymbol{x}} \tag*{(50)}

Similar to before, the orientation vector is p=[sin⁡αcos⁡ϕ,sin⁡αcos⁡ϕ,cos⁡α]\boldsymbol{p} = [\sin\alpha\cos\phi, \sin\alpha\cos\phi, \cos\alpha], where α\alpha and ϕ\phi are the polar and azimuthal angles. To determine how these angles evolve over time, we note that the dynamics are a linear superposition of the cases described previously. In other words,

dαdt=dαdt∣∥cos⁡θ+dαdt∣⊥sin⁡θ(51)\frac{d\alpha}{dt} = \left.\frac{d\alpha}{dt}\right|_{\parallel}\cos\theta+ \left.\frac{d\alpha}{dt}\right|_{\perp}\sin\theta \tag*{(51)}
dϕdt=dϕdt∣∥cos⁡θ+dϕdt∣⊥sin⁡θ(52)\frac{d\phi}{dt} = \left.\frac{d\phi}{dt}\right|_{\parallel}\cos\theta+ \left.\frac{d\phi}{dt}\right|_{\perp}\sin\theta \tag*{(52)}

where dαdt∣∥\left.\frac{d\alpha}{dt}\right|_{\parallel} and dαdt∣⊥\left.\frac{d\alpha}{dt}\right|_{\perp} are the variations in the polar angle from viscosity gradients parallel and perpendicular to the external force, given by Eq. (5.1a) (using the positive sign) and Eq. (5.3a), respectively. The corresponding terms dϕdt∣∥\left.\frac{d\phi}{dt}\right|_{\parallel} and dϕdt∣⊥\left.\frac{d\phi}{dt}\right|_{\perp} are the same quantities for the azimuthal angle, which is zero for dϕdt∣∥\left.\frac{d\phi}{dt}\right|_{\parallel} and Eq. (5.3b) for dϕdt∣⊥\left.\frac{d\phi}{dt}\right|_{\perp}. The equation for particle translation is the same as Eq. (47).

Steady orientation angles

If a steady orientation angle exists, it will be in the plane spanned by F\boldsymbol{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta as discussed previously – i.e., ϕ=0\phi= 0. We set ϕ=0\phi= 0 and determine the conditions under which dαdt=0\frac{d\alpha}{dt} = 0 in Eq. (5.7a). The criterion for a steady orientation angle is:

12(λ3+λ4)sin⁡(2α)cos⁡θ−(λ1−λ3sin⁡2α+λ4cos⁡2α)sin⁡θ=0.(53)\frac{1}{2}(\lambda_3+\lambda_4)\sin(2\alpha)\cos\theta-\left(\lambda_1-\lambda_3\sin^2\alpha+\lambda_4\cos^2\alpha\right)\sin\theta=0. \tag*{(53)}

For illustration, Figure 16 plots the steady orientation angles αse\alpha_{se} for different values of the angle θ\theta between the external force F\mathbf{F} and ∇η\nabla\eta. The results are plotted for prolate and oblate spheroids with aspect ratio parameter AR=5AR = 5 and AR=1/5AR = 1/5, respectively. We observe that αse\alpha_{se} varies between π/2\pi/2 and π\pi for prolate spheroids and between 00 and π/2\pi/2 for oblate spheroids. As discussed in the previous sections, these limits are the stable orientations for very high aspect ratio spheroids when the viscosity gradients are parallel and perpendicular to external force. For example, as θ→0\theta\to0, we see αse→π/2\alpha_{se} \to\pi/2 for prolate spheroids and 00 for oblate spheroids, which are the stable orientation for these particles when the viscosity gradient is parallel to the external force.

Stable orientation angles for prolate spheroids

(a) Prolate spheroid

Stable orientation angles for oblate spheroids

(b) Oblate spheroid

Figure 16. Stable orientation angles αse\alpha_{\mathrm{se}} for prolate and oblate spheroids when the viscosity gradient ∇η\nabla\eta and the external force F\boldsymbol{F} are inclined at an angle θ\theta to each other.

Discussion of applicability of model and incorporating disturbance viscosity

In this paper, we assumed the viscosity field around the particle is a linear function of space and is independent of the flow and the particle geometry. In reality, however, the viscosity field has a more complicated spatial dependence, as it is linked to a scalar field like temperature or concentration that depends on the aforementioned quantities (see [48] for the related problem of a hot sphere in a temperature coupled viscosity field). In this section, we make suggestions on how to incorporate these effects into the analysis and what changes can be expected to the main results.

For illustrative purposes, let us consider a particle in a fluid subject to a temperature gradient ∇T\nabla T far away from the particle. The fluid’s viscosity depends linearly on temperature – i.e., η−η0=dηdT(T−T0)\eta-\eta_0 = \frac{d\eta}{dT}(T-T_0), and thus the viscosity field also varies spatially around the particle. If the thermal Peclet number is small and the temperature profile is steady, the temperature field will satisfy Laplace’s equation inside and outside the particle: (see [11] for details):

∇2Tout=0;∇2Tin=0;(54)\nabla^2 T^{out}=0; \qquad\nabla^2 T^{in}=0; \tag*{(54)}

This equation is subject to the following boundary conditions: (a) Tout→T0+∇T⋅xT^{out} \to T_0 + \nabla T \cdot\mathbf{x} far away from the particle (∣x∣→∞|\mathbf{x}| \to\infty), and (b) on the particle surface, the temperatures and fluxes are continuous – i.e., Tin=ToutT^{in}=T^{out} and (n⋅∇Tout)=kr(n⋅∇Tin)(\mathbf{n}\cdot\nabla T^{out})=k_r(\mathbf{n}\cdot\nabla T^{in}), where krk_r is the conductivity ratio between the particle and fluid phase. Once one solves the temperature profile, one can obtain the viscosity field η(x)\eta(\mathbf{x}) and then solve for the particle motion in this field. The rigid body motion will still follow the same procedure discussed earlier in the paper – i.e., one performs a perturbation expansion for the viscosity and finds the correction to the rigid body motion via the reciprocal theorem using an extra stress tensor τijex=(η(x)−η0)γ˙ij(0)\tau_{ij}^{ex}=(\eta(\mathbf{x})-\eta_0)\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(0)}. The mobility tensors described in Sec. 4 will take the same form, except that the numerical values for the force/rotation mobility coefficients (λ1,λ3,λ4)(\lambda_1,\lambda_3,\lambda_4) will be different. For the special cases when one neglects the presence of the particle in the transport equation, or if the conductivity ratio is kr=1k_r=1, the viscosity field will be linear everywhere, and we will recover the results described earlier in the manuscript. Otherwise, and in general, the viscosity field will have a more complicated spatial and even temporal dependence, emanating from the motion of the particle. Such a viscosity field, which is coupled with the particle motion, posits at least a theoretical possibility of a more complicated orientational dynamics than that has been presented in this paper. However, based on the work carried out previously by Shaik & Elfring [53] for spheres, we speculate that such a motion-coupled viscosity field will not introduce any novel effects but only bolster the trends in orientational dynamics discussed in our paper. Of course, this hypothesis will need to be tested, via a full fledged analysis. The outlines of such an analysis have been presented in this subsection already. A key mathematical ingredient of such an analysis, if taken up later in a different paper, will include the solution to Laplace’s equation around an ellipsoidal particle. In Appendix E, we outline how one solves Laplace’s equation around an ellipsoidal particle.

Conclusion

In this paper, we study a spheroid sedimenting in Newtonian fluid with a viscosity field that varies linearly in space. We employ the principles of linearity, reversibility, symmetry to delineate the mobility relationships for this problem. In the limit of small viscosity gradients, we find that the force/velocity and torque/rotation couplings remain unchanged from the Stokes flow limit. However, the viscosity gradient gives rise to an additional force/rotation and torque/velocity coupling, which is characterized by a third order tensor MijkM_{ijk}. The reduced analytical form of this tensor is given by Eq. (34), up to three undetermined coefficients. The values of these coefficients are determined numerically, under the aegis of a reciprocal theorem-based simulation, for a wide range of particle aspect ratios.

Illustrative examples and specific results of our theory are discussed next. Unlike in Stokes flow where the particle orientation stays at its initial orientation during sedimentation, we find that viscosity gradients alter the orientation over time. When the viscosity gradient is along the external force direction, both prolate and oblate spheroids reach a stable orientation where the longest axis is perpendicular to the viscosity gradient. When the viscosity gradient is opposite the external force, the spheroids reach a stable orientation where the longest axis is along to the viscosity gradient. We also show that for most initial orientation angles, the spheroid acquires a drift in a direction transverse to its (main) sedimentation direction until its orientation stabilizes, at which point it moves downward.

When the viscosity gradient and the external force are perpendicular, the plane defined by the viscosity gradient and force is a plane of stability, and the spheroid, irrespective of its initial orientation, will eventually become co-planar with the force and the viscosity gradient. For the limiting case of a needle-like particle, the prolate spheroid will orient its projector in the direction of the force, while conversely, for the limiting case of a flat disk, the oblate spheroid will orient its projector in the direction of the viscosity gradient. Finally, we note in the general case when the viscosity gradient and external force are neither parallel or perpendicular to each other, the dynamics of the particle is a linear combination of the cases discussed above.

Throughout the analysis, we have neglected the coupling between the viscosity field and the flow or particle motion. Guidelines for incorporating this coupling are presented, using ellipsoidal harmonics to solve the Laplace equation in low PePe limit. However, based on previous literature [53] we believe that such an analysis may not yield any novel results not yet accounted for.

We have taken a perturbative approach to solving this problem, where only the terms first order in viscosity gradient are accounted for. Due to the limitation of the perturbative approach , the analysis here is valid for the following two cases: a) when the viscosity gradient is weak , so that the terms of O(β2)O(\beta^2) can be neglected. b) when the viscosity gradient is linear, but not necessarily weak, so that the terms of O(β2)O(\beta^2) are identically zero. For this second case, where the viscosity gradient is linear, but not weak, we expect that the steady state behavior – namely the stable orientation of the spheroids – will remain unchanged. Stronger, but still linear, viscosity gradients will change the rate at which the stable orientation is attained, but not the value of the steady orientation per se. Additionally, a spheroid is a typical axisymmetric particle with no isotropy but fore-aft symmetry. The mechanisms of hydrodynamic torque acting on the spheroid and the resultant stable orientation as discussed in this paper may therefore prove useful in understanding the dynamics of other orientable particles, which are common in nature and in the industry. The current problem may also be a stepping stone towards the analysis of more complex systems, for instance flows with linear and quadratic components, or with density (in addition to viscosity) stratification, among others. Lastly, we have shown the existence of torque-translation coupling, in addition to the force-rotation coupling, due to the linear viscosity gradient. This coupling opens the exciting possibility of controlling the motion (translation) of the spheroid by subjecting it to external torque, say via a rotating magnetic field [44] (Li et al. 2017b).

Acknowledgment

The authors would like to acknowledge support from the American Chemical Society Petroleum Research Fund (DNI-ACS PRF 61266-DNI9), as well as support from the Michael and Carolyn Ott Endowment at Purdue University.

The authors would also like to thank Prof. Gwynn Elfring and his team (specifically Dr. Vaseem Shaik and Mr. Jiahao Gong) at University of British Columbia for constructive feedback and discussion on this manuscript.

Declaration of Interests

The authors report no conflict of interest.

Appendix

Appendix A – Disturbance velocity for an ellipsoid in Stokes flow

Consider a reference frame at an ellipsoid’s center of mass with axes aligned along the particle’s principle axes. From [29 pg. 55], the Stokes velocity field around the ellipsoid from external force and torque is the following:

vi=116πη0∑j=13Fj[δijG0−xj∂G0∂xi+aj22∂2G1∂xi∂xj](55)v_i = \frac{1}{16\pi\eta_0}\sum_{j=1}^{3} F_j \left[\delta_{ij}G_0 - x_j\frac{\partial G_0}{\partial x_i} + \frac{a_j^2}{2}\frac{\partial^2 G_1}{\partial x_i\partial x_j}\right] \tag*{(55)}
vi=364πη0∑j=13(T×∇)j[δijG1−xj∂G1∂xi+aj24∂2G2∂xi∂xj](56)v_i = \frac{3}{64\pi\eta_0}\sum_{j=1}^{3}(\mathbf{T}\times\nabla)_j \left[\delta_{ij}G_1 - x_j\frac{\partial G_1}{\partial x_i} + \frac{a_j^2}{4}\frac{\partial^2 G_2}{\partial x_i\partial x_j}\right] \tag*{(56)}

In these formulas, no summation is assumed for repeated indices unless explicitly stated. To obtain formulas for vkitransv_{ki}^{trans} and vkirv_{ki}^{r} in the reciprocal theorem, we substitute into Eq. (7.1) the force and torque that comes from unit translation and rotation, respectively.

In the above expressions, the expression for GnG_n is:

Gn(x,y,z)=∫λ∞(x2a2+t+y2b2+t+z2c2+t−1)ndtΔ(t)(57)G_n(x,y,z)=\int_{\lambda}^{\infty}\left(\frac{x^2}{a^2+t}+\frac{y^2}{b^2+t}+\frac{z^2}{c^2+t}-1\right)^n\frac{\mathrm{d}t}{\Delta(t)} \tag*{(57)}

with Δ(t)=(a2+t)(b2+t)(c2+t)\Delta(t)=\sqrt{(a^2+t)(b^2+t)(c^2+t)} and λ(x,y,z)\lambda(x,y,z) being the positive root of

x2a2+t+y2b2+t+z2c2+t=1(58)\frac{x^2}{a^2+t}+\frac{y^2}{b^2+t}+\frac{z^2}{c^2+t}=1 \tag*{(58)}

Appendix B – Resistance formulae for an ellipsoid in Stokes flow

Let us consider a reference frame with the origin at the center of mass of an ellipsoid and the Cartesian axes aligned along the principle axes.

We denote the ellipsoid’s semi-axes as (a1,a2,a3)=(a,b,c)(a_1,a_2,a_3)=(a,b,c). In dimensional form, the resistance tensors RFUR^{FU} and RTωR^{T\omega} are diagonal, while the cross-coupling term RFω=RTU=0R^{F\omega}=R^{TU}=0. The diagonal elements are:

R11FU=12η0Vχ0+α1a12,R11Tω=4η0V(a22+a32)α2a22+α3a32(59)R_{11}^{FU}=\frac{12\eta_0 V}{\chi_0+\alpha_1a_1^2},\qquad R_{11}^{T\omega}=\frac{4\eta_0 V\left(a_2^2+a_3^2\right)}{\alpha_2a_2^2+\alpha_3a_3^2} \tag*{(59)}

where V=4π3a1a2a3V=\frac{4\pi}{3}a_1a_2a_3 is the particle volume, and (χ0,α1,α2α3)(\chi_0,\alpha_1,\alpha_2\alpha_3) are elliptic integrals defined below:

χ0=34πV∫0∞dtΔ(t)\chi_0=\frac{3}{4\pi}V\int_0^\infty\frac{\mathrm{d}t}{\Delta(t)}
αi=34πV∫0∞dt(ai2+t)Δ(t)\alpha_i=\frac{3}{4\pi}V\int_0^\infty\frac{\mathrm{d}t}{(a_i^2+t)\Delta(t)}
Δ(t)=(a12+t)(a22+t)(a32+t)\Delta(t)=\sqrt{(a_1^2+t)(a_2^2+t)(a_3^2+t)}

The other elements of the diagonal tensors are obtained by index cycling.

The mobility matrix is the inverse of the resistance matrix, and hence given by the inverse of the diagonal elements above. For the special case when the particle is a spheroid with a1≠a2=a3a_1\ne a_2=a_3, the coefficients c1−c4c_1-c_4 for the mobility matrix in Eq. (4.3a) and Eq. (4.3b) are:

c1=1R22FU;c2=1R11FU;c3=1R22Tω;c4=1R11Tωc_1=\frac{1}{R_{22}^{FU}};\qquad c_2=\frac{1}{R_{11}^{FU}};\qquad c_3=\frac{1}{R_{22}^{T\omega}};\qquad c_4=\frac{1}{R_{11}^{T\omega}}

These coefficients have analytical formulae (see pgs 64 and 68 in Kim and Karilla). Using the notation in this paper, we obtain for prolate and oblate spheroids:

  • Prolate spheroids

c1=16πη0a1YA;YA=163e3[2e+(3e2−1)L]−1(60)c_1=\frac{1}{6\pi\eta_0a}\frac{1}{Y_A};\qquad Y_A=\frac{16}{3}e^3\left[2e+(3e^2-1)L\right]^{-1} \tag*{(60)}
c2=16πη0a1XA;XA=83e3[−2e+(1+e2)L]−1(61)c_2=\frac{1}{6\pi\eta_0a}\frac{1}{X_A};\qquad X_A=\frac{8}{3}e^3\left[-2e+(1+e^2)L\right]^{-1} \tag*{(61)}
c3=18πη0a31YC;YC=43e3(2−e2)[−2e+(1+e2)L]−1(62)c_3=\frac{1}{8\pi\eta_0a^3}\frac{1}{Y_C};\qquad Y_C=\frac{4}{3}e^3(2-e^2)\left[-2e+(1+e^2)L\right]^{-1} \tag*{(62)}
c4=18πη0a31XC;XC=43e3(1−e2)[2e−(1−e2)L]−1(63)c_4=\frac{1}{8\pi\eta_0a^3}\frac{1}{X_C};\qquad X_C=\frac{4}{3}e^3(1-e^2)\left[2e-(1-e^2)L\right]^{-1} \tag*{(63)}

where e=1−b2a2e=\sqrt{1-\frac{b^2}{a^2}} is the spheroid’s eccentricity and L=ln⁡(1+e1−e)L=\ln\left(\frac{1+e}{1-e}\right). To get the non-dimensional form used in the manuscript, we multiply c1c_1 and c2c_2 by 6πη0R=6πη0(ab2)1/36\pi\eta_0R=6\pi\eta_0(ab^2)^{1/3}, and multiply c3c_3 and c4c_4 by 6πη0R3=6πη0ab26\pi\eta_0R^3=6\pi\eta_0ab^2.

  • Oblate spheroids

c1=16πη0b1YA,YA=83e3[(2e2+1)C−e1−e2]−1(64)c_1 = \frac{1}{6\pi\eta_0 b}\frac{1}{Y_A}, \qquad Y_A = \frac{8}{3}e^3\left[(2e^2+1)C-e\sqrt{1-e^2}\right]^{-1} \tag*{(64)}
c2=16πη0b1XA,XA=43e3[(2e2−1)C+e1−e2]−1(65)c_2 = \frac{1}{6\pi\eta_0 b}\frac{1}{X_A}, \qquad X_A = \frac{4}{3}e^3\left[(2e^2-1)C+e\sqrt{1-e^2}\right]^{-1} \tag*{(65)}
c3=18πη0b31YC,YC=23e3(2−e2)[e1−e2−(1−2e2)C]−1(66)c_3 = \frac{1}{8\pi\eta_0 b^3}\frac{1}{Y_C}, \qquad Y_C = \frac{2}{3}e^3(2-e^2)\left[e\sqrt{1-e^2}-(1-2e^2)C\right]^{-1} \tag*{(66)}
c4=18πη0b31XC,XC=23e3[C−e1−e2]−1(67)c_4 = \frac{1}{8\pi\eta_0 b^3}\frac{1}{X_C}, \qquad X_C = \frac{2}{3}e^3\left[C-e\sqrt{1-e^2}\right]^{-1} \tag*{(67)}

where e=1−a2b2e=\sqrt{1-\frac{a^2}{b^2}} is the spheroid’s eccentricity and C=cot⁡−1(1−e2e)C=\cot^{-1}\left(\frac{\sqrt{1-e^2}}{e}\right). To get the non-dimensional form used in the manuscript, we multiply c1c_1 and c2c_2 by 6πη0R=6πη0(ab2)1/36\pi\eta_0R=6\pi\eta_0(ab^2)^{1/3}, and multiply c3c_3 and c4c_4 by 6πη0R3=6πη0ab26\pi\eta_0R^3=6\pi\eta_0ab^2.

Appendix C – Reciprocal theorem and O(β\beta) solution

To delineate the O(β)O(\beta) correction to the particle kinematics – i.e., obtain the solution for (Ui(1),ωi(1))(U_i^{(1)},\omega_i^{(1)}) – there are two approaches possible. The brute force approach is to solve the velocity and stress field around the particle, and then integrate the stress on the particle’s surface to find the viscosity-stratified force and torque. However, this approach is tedious and analytically intractable for complicated geometries. Instead, we circumvent the calculation of the velocity and the stress field around the particle and directly obtain the viscosity-stratified force and torque using the reciprocal theorem [34].

First, we note that the fluid stress field at O(β)O(\beta) has two parts:

σij(1)=γ˙ij(1)−p(1)δij+τijex.(68)\sigma_{ij}^{(1)}=\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(1)}-p^{(1)}\delta_{ij}+\tau_{ij}^{ex}. \tag*{(68)}

One is the Newtonian part given by γ˙ij(1)−p(1)δij\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(1)}-p^{(1)}\delta_{ij}. The other part is viscosity-stratified, denoted as τijex\tau_{ij}^{ex} and given by:

τijex=(d^kxk)γ˙ij(0)(69)\tau_{ij}^{ex}=(\hat{d}_k x_k)\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(0)} \tag*{(69)}

We note the important observation that the viscosity-stratified stress at O(β)O(\beta) depends on the strain rate at leading order.

In the spirit of the reciprocal theorem, we define an auxiliary problem wherein the same particle, at the same location and same orientation, is sedimenting in a Newtonian fluid with a constant (spatially invariant) viscosity. The quantities pertaining to the auxiliary problem are denoted by the aux superscript. Therefore, the external force and the torque acting on the particle in the auxiliary problem is given by Fiaux,TiauxF_i^{aux},T_i^{aux} and its rigid body motion is given by Uiaux,ωiauxU_i^{aux},\omega_i^{aux}. The flow field around the particle is viauxv_i^{aux}, while the stress field is σijaux\sigma_{ij}^{aux}, expressed as:

σijaux=γ˙ijaux−pauxδij(70)\sigma_{ij}^{aux}=\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{aux}-p^{aux}\delta_{ij} \tag*{(70)}

Since the stress field of the auxiliary problem and that of the O(β)O(\beta) problem are divergence free:

∂σijaux∂xj=∂σij(1)∂xj=0,(71)\frac{\partial\sigma_{ij}^{aux}}{\partial x_j}=\frac{\partial\sigma_{ij}^{(1)}}{\partial x_j}=0, \tag*{(71)}

or,

vi(1)∂σijaux∂xj=viaux∂σij(1)∂xj=0,(72)v_i^{(1)}\frac{\partial\sigma_{ij}^{aux}}{\partial x_j}=v_i^{aux}\frac{\partial\sigma_{ij}^{(1)}}{\partial x_j}=0, \tag*{(72)}

Using the product rule, the above equation reduces to:

∂vi(1)σijaux∂xj−∂viauxσij(1)∂xj=σijaux∂vi(1)∂xj−σij(1)∂viaux∂xj(73)\frac{\partial v_i^{(1)}\sigma_{ij}^{aux}}{\partial x_j}-\frac{\partial v_i^{aux}\sigma_{ij}^{(1)}}{\partial x_j}=\sigma_{ij}^{aux}\frac{\partial v_i^{(1)}}{\partial x_j}-\sigma_{ij}^{(1)}\frac{\partial v_i^{aux}}{\partial x_j} \tag*{(73)}

We now substitute the expressions σijaux=γ˙ijaux−pauxδij\sigma_{ij}^{aux}=\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{aux}-p^{aux}\delta_{ij} and σij(1)=γ˙ij(1)−p(1)δij+τijex,(0)\sigma_{ij}^{(1)}=\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(1)}-p^{(1)}\delta_{ij}+\tau_{ij}^{ex,(0)} to the right hand side. Using the identities ∂vi∂xi=∂viaux∂xi=0\frac{\partial v_i}{\partial x_i}=\frac{\partial v_i^{aux}}{\partial x_i}=0 and γ˙ij(1)∂viaux∂xj=γ˙ijaux∂vi(1)∂xj\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{(1)}\frac{\partial v_i^{aux}}{\partial x_j}=\dot{\gamma}_{ij}^{aux}\frac{\partial v_i^{(1)}}{\partial x_j}, we obtain:

∂vi(1)σijaux∂xj−∂viauxσij(1)∂xj=−τijex,(0)∂viaux∂xj(74)\frac{\partial v_i^{(1)}\sigma_{ij}^{aux}}{\partial x_j}-\frac{\partial v_i^{aux}\sigma_{ij}^{(1)}}{\partial x_j}=-\tau_{ij}^{ex,(0)}\frac{\partial v_i^{aux}}{\partial x_j} \tag*{(74)}

Next, we integrate the above equation over the volume outside the particle and use the divergence theorem. This procedure yields:

∫Snjvi(1)σijaux dS=∫Snjviauxσij(1) dS+∫Vτijex,(0)∂viaux∂xj dV(75)\int_S n_jv_i^{(1)}\sigma_{ij}^{aux}\,\mathrm{d}S=\int_S n_jv_i^{aux}\sigma_{ij}^{(1)}\,\mathrm{d}S+\int_V\tau_{ij}^{ex,(0)}\frac{\partial v_i^{aux}}{\partial x_j}\,\mathrm{d}V \tag*{(75)}

where SS is the surface of the particle and njn_j is the normal to the particle surface pointing inside the fluid. On particle surface, vi(1)v_i^{(1)} and viauxv_i^{aux} are rigid body motion – i.e., vi(1)=Ui(1)+ϵijkωj(1)xkv_i^{(1)}=U_i^{(1)}+\epsilon_{ijk}\omega_j^{(1)}x_k and viaux=Uiaux+ϵijkωjauxxkv_i^{aux}=U_i^{aux}+\epsilon_{ijk}\omega_j^{aux}x_k. Substituting these expressions into the surface integrals yield:

−FiauxUi(1)−Tiauxωi(1)=∫Vτijex,(0)∂viaux∂xj dV(76)-F_i^{aux}U_i^{(1)}-T_i^{aux}\omega_i^{(1)}=\int_V\tau_{ij}^{ex,(0)}\frac{\partial v_i^{aux}}{\partial x_j}\,\mathrm{d}V \tag*{(76)}

Note when deriving the above expression, we made use of the fact that the force and torque acting on the particle at O(β)O(\beta) is zero (Fi(1)=Ti(1)=0F_i^{(1)}=T_i^{(1)}=0). Lastly, let us write the auxillary force and torque as a linear combination of the rigid body velocities using the resistance tensors for the particle:

Fiaux=RijFUUjaux+RijFωωjauxTiaux=RijTUUjaux+RijTωωjaux(77)\begin{aligned} F_i^{aux}&=R_{ij}^{FU}U_j^{aux}+R_{ij}^{F\omega}\omega_j^{aux}\\ T_i^{aux}&=R_{ij}^{TU}U_j^{aux}+R_{ij}^{T\omega}\omega_j^{aux} \tag*{(77)} \end{aligned}

where in the above equation, the resistance tensors satisfy the following symmetry relationships: RFU=(RFU)TR^{FU}=(R^{FU})^{T}, RTω=(RTω)TR^{T\omega}=(R^{T\omega})^{T}, and RFω=(RTU)TR^{F\omega}=(R^{TU})^{T}. We will also write the auxillary velocity field in the volume integral for Eq. (76) as a linear combination of the rigid body motions:

viaux=viktransUkaux+vikrotωkaux(78)v_i^{aux}=v_{ik}^{trans}U_k^{aux}+v_{ik}^{rot}\omega_k^{aux} \tag*{(78)}

where vikrotv_{ik}^{rot} and vikrotv_{ik}^{rot} are the velocity fields in the ii direction induced by unit translation or rotation in the kk direction. Substituting Eqs. (77) and (78) into (76) and eliminating UiauxU_i^{aux} and ωiaux\omega_i^{aux} yields the final result (Eq. (17)) stated in the manuscript.

Appendix D – Simplification of mobility tensor Mijk

Here, we show that Eq. (33) is equivalent to Eq. (34). To that end, we re-write Eq. (33) as:

Mijk=λ1ϵijk+λ2piϵjkqpq+λ3pjϵikqpq+λ4pkϵijqpq(79)M_{ijk}=\lambda_1\epsilon_{ijk}+\lambda_2p_i\epsilon_{jkq}p_q+\lambda_3p_j\epsilon_{ikq}p_q+\lambda_4p_k\epsilon_{ijq}p_q \tag*{(79)}

Without any loss of generality, we assume a particular orientation of the projection vector pip_i namely pi=δi1p_i = \delta_{i1} (and so on). Therefore, Eq. (80) may be written as:

Mijk=λ1ϵijk⏟Term 1+λ2δi1ϵjk1⏟Term 2+λ3δj1ϵik1⏟Term 3+λ4δk1ϵij1⏟Term 4(80)M_{ijk} = \lambda_1 \underbrace{\epsilon_{ijk}}_{\text{Term 1}} + \lambda_2 \underbrace{\delta_{i1}\epsilon_{jk1}}_{\text{Term 2}} + \lambda_3 \underbrace{\delta_{j1}\epsilon_{ik1}}_{\text{Term 3}} + \lambda_4 \underbrace{\delta_{k1}\epsilon_{ij1}}_{\text{Term 4}} \tag*{(80)}

Say,

Mijk(1)=Term 1=ϵijk(81)M_{ijk}^{(1)} = \text{Term 1} = \epsilon_{ijk} \tag*{(81)}
Mijk(2)=Term 2=δi1ϵjk1(82)M_{ijk}^{(2)} = \text{Term 2} = \delta_{i1}\epsilon_{jk1} \tag*{(82)}
Mijk(3)=Term 3=δj1ϵik1(83)M_{ijk}^{(3)} = \text{Term 3} = \delta_{j1}\epsilon_{ik1} \tag*{(83)}
Mijk(4)=Term 4=δk1ϵij1(84)M_{ijk}^{(4)} = \text{Term 4} = \delta_{k1}\epsilon_{ij1} \tag*{(84)}

To expand the different tensors, term by term, we find that the only nonzero terms in Mijk(1)M_{ijk}^{(1)} are:

M123(1)=M312(1)=M231(1)=1(85)M_{123}^{(1)} = M_{312}^{(1)} = M_{231}^{(1)} = 1 \tag*{(85)}
M132(1)=M321(1)=M213(1)=−1(86)M_{132}^{(1)} = M_{321}^{(1)} = M_{213}^{(1)} = -1 \tag*{(86)}

Similarly, the nonzero terms in Mijk(2)M_{ijk}^{(2)} are given as:

M123(2)=1(87)M_{123}^{(2)} = 1 \tag*{(87)}
M132(2)=−1(88)M_{132}^{(2)} = -1 \tag*{(88)}

and the nonzero terms in Mijk(3)M_{ijk}^{(3)} are given as:

M213(3)=−1(89)M_{213}^{(3)} = -1 \tag*{(89)}
M312(3)=1(90)M_{312}^{(3)} = 1 \tag*{(90)}

whilst, the nonzero terms in Mijk(4)M_{ijk}^{(4)} are given as:

M231(4)=1(91)M_{231}^{(4)} = 1 \tag*{(91)}
M321(4)=−1(92)M_{321}^{(4)} = -1 \tag*{(92)}

From the visual inspection of Eqs. (7.21), (7.22), (7.23), (7.24), we obtain the following relationship:

Mijk(1)=Mijk(2)+Mijk(3)+Mijk(4),(93)M_{ijk}^{(1)} = M_{ijk}^{(2)} + M_{ijk}^{(3)} + M_{ijk}^{(4)}, \tag*{(93)}

which means out of the four terms Mijk(1),Mijk(2),Mijk(3)M_{ijk}^{(1)},M_{ijk}^{(2)},M_{ijk}^{(3)} and Mijk(4)M_{ijk}^{(4)}, only 3 are linearly independent, and therefore, without loss of generality, we can remove Mijk(2)M_{ijk}^{(2)} (= Term2) from Eq. (80) (or Eq. (33)), which leads to, with slight change in notation, Eq. (34).

Appendix E – Solving Laplace equation around an ellipsoid with a far field temperature gradient

Here we outline how to solve Laplace’s equation around an ellipsoidal particle. We will use ellipsoidal harmonics, a technique is widely used in electrostatics, and the results in papers [57] directly apply here. Let us consider a frame of reference where the Cartesian coordinate system (x,y,z)(x, y, z) aligns with the semi-major axes (a,b,c)(a, b, c) of the ellipsoid, with a≥b≥ca \ge b \ge c. If the far-field temperature is:

T∞(x)=T0+∂T∂xx+∂T∂yy+∂T∂zz(94)T^{\infty}(\boldsymbol{x}) = T_0 + \frac{\partial T}{\partial x}x + \frac{\partial T}{\partial y}y + \frac{\partial T}{\partial z}z \tag*{(94)}

the solution outside the ellipsoid takes the following form:

T(x)=T∞(x)+∑p=13B1pF1p(x)(95)T(\boldsymbol{x}) = T^{\infty}(\boldsymbol{x}) + \sum_{p=1}^{3} B_{1p}\mathcal{F}_{1}^{p}(\boldsymbol{x}) \tag*{(95)}

In the above equation, F1p(x)=F1p(ξ)E1p(μ)E1p(ν)\mathcal{F}_{1}^{p}(\boldsymbol{x}) = F_{1}^{p}(\xi)E_{1}^{p}(\mu)E_{1}^{p}(\nu) are decaying ellipsoidal harmonics using the ellipsoidal coordinate system (ξ,μ,ν)(\xi, \mu, \nu), where ξ=a\xi= a denotes the surface of the ellipsoid. The functions E1pE_{1}^{p} and F1pF_{1}^{p} are Lame functions of the first and second kind, defined in publication [57]. In Eq. (95), the coefficients B1pB_{1p} are the following:

B11=abc31kh(1−kr)1+L11(a)(kr−1)∂T∂x(96)B_{11} = \frac{abc}{3}\frac{1}{kh}\frac{(1-k_r)}{1+L_{1}^{1}(a)(k_r-1)}\frac{\partial T}{\partial x} \tag*{(96)}
B12=abc31hk2−h2(1−kr)1+L12(a)(kr−1)∂T∂y(97)B_{12} = \frac{abc}{3}\frac{1}{h\sqrt{k^2-h^2}}\frac{(1-k_r)}{1+L_{1}^{2}(a)(k_r-1)}\frac{\partial T}{\partial y} \tag*{(97)}
B13=abc31kk2−h2(1−kr)1+L13(a)(kr−1)∂T∂z(98)B_{13} = \frac{abc}{3}\frac{1}{k\sqrt{k^2-h^2}}\frac{(1-k_r)}{1+L_{1}^{3}(a)(k_r-1)}\frac{\partial T}{\partial z} \tag*{(98)}

where k=a2−c2k = \sqrt{a^2-c^2} and h=a2−b2h = \sqrt{a^2-b^2}. The geometric factors L11,2,3(a)L_{1}^{1,2,3}(a) take the following form [57]:

L11,2,3(a)=abc∫a∞dξ′[E11,2,3(ξ′)]2(ξ′2−h2)(ξ′2−k2)(99)L_{1}^{1,2,3}(a) = abc \int_{a}^{\infty} \frac{d\xi'}{\left[E_{1}^{1,2,3}(\xi')\right]^2\sqrt{(\xi'^2-h^2)(\xi'^2-k^2)}} \tag*{(99)}

This figure "Alpha_SE_Oblate.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Alpha_SE_Prolate.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Oblate_Alpha_Phi_Perpendicular_AR.png" is available in "png" format

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Oblate_Lambdas_NonFilled3.png" is available in "png" format from: http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Oblate_Translation_Perpendicular.png" is available in "png" format from

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Oblate_X_Epsilon_Positive_Analytical_NL.png" is available in "png"

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Oblate_X_Negative_Scaled_NL.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Oblate_Y_Positive_Analytical2_ScaledNL.png" is available in "png" fo

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Prolate_Alpha_Phi_Perpendicular_AR.png" is available in "png" format

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Prolate_Y_Positive_Analytical2_ScaledNL.png" is available in "png" format.

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Prolate_Lambda_Lauga3.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Prolate_X_Epsilon_Negative_Analytical_ScaledNL.png" is available in

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Prolate_X_Epsilon_Positive_Analytical_scaledNL.png" is available in "

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Stable_Oblate_Random.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Stable_Prolate_Random.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Translate_X_Obalte.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

This figure "Translate_X_Prolate.png" is available in "png" format from:

http://arxiv.org/ps/2305.00285v2

References

  1. [1]Anand, Vishal & Narsimhan, Vivek 2023 Dynamics of spheroids in pressure driven flows of shear thinning fluids.arxiv.org/abs/2303.06251
  2. [2]Ardekani, Arezoo M., Doostmohammadi, Amin & Desai, Nikhil 2017 Transport of particles, drops, and small organisms in density stratified fluids. Physical Review Fluids 2 (10), 100503.DOI
  3. [3]Arrigo, Kevin R., Robinson, Dale H, Worthen, Denise L, Dunbar, Robert B, DiTullio, Giacomo R, VanWoert, Michael & Lizotte, Michael P 1999 Phytoplankton Community Structure and the Drawdown of Nutrients and CO₂ in the Southern Ocean. Science 283 (5400), 365–367.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9888847
  4. [4]Asghar, Zeeshan, Javid, Khurram, Waqas, Muhammad, Ghaffari, Abuzar & Khan, Waqar Azeem 2020 Cilia-driven fluid flow in a curved channel: effects of complex wave and porous medium. Fluid Dynamics Research 52 (1), 015514.DOI
  5. [5]Auguste, Franck, Magnaudet, Jacques & Fabre, David 2013 Falling styles of disks. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 719, 388–405.
  6. [6]Butler, Jason E. & Shaqfeh, Eric S.G. 2002 Dynamic simulations of the inhomogeneous sedimentation of rigid fibres. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 468, 205–237.DOI
  7. [7]Cox, R. G. 1965 The steady motion of a particle of arbitrary shape at small Reynolds numbers. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 23 (4), 625–643.DOI
  8. [8]Dabade, Vivekanand, Marath, Marath, Navaneeth K. & Subramanian, Ganesh 2015 Effects of inertia and viscoelasticity on sedimenting anisotropic particles. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 778, 133–188.DOI
  9. [9]Dandekar, Rajat & Ardekani, Arezoo M. 2020 Swimming sheet in a viscosity-stratified fluid. Journal of Fluid Mechanics.DOI
  10. [10]Dandekar, Rajat, Shaik, Vaseem A. & Ardekani, Arezoo M. 2020 Motion of an arbitrarily shaped particle in a density stratified fluid. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 890, A16.DOI
  11. [11]Dassios, George 2012 Ellipsoidal Harmonics: Theory and Applications. Ellipsoidal Harmonics
  12. [12]Datt, Charu & Elfring, Gwynn J. 2019 Active Particles in Viscosity Gradients. Physical Review Letters 123 (15).
  13. [13]Doostmohammadi, A., Dabiri, S. & Ardekani, A. M. 2014 A numerical study of the dynamics of a particle settling at moderate Reynolds numbers in a linearly stratified fluid. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 750, 5–32.DOI
  14. [15]Eastham, Patrick S. & Shoele, Kourosh 2020 Axisymmetric squirmers in Stokes fluid with nonuniform viscosity. Physical Review Fluids 5 (6).DOI
  15. [16]Esparza López, Christian, Gonzalez-Gutierrez, Jorge, Solorio-Ordaz, Francisco, Lauga, Eric & Zenit, Roberto 2021 Dynamics of a helical swimmer crossing viscosity gradients. Physical Review Fluids 6 (8).DOI
  16. [17]Gagnon, D. A. & Arratia, P. E. 2016 The cost of swimming in generalized Newtonian fluids: experiments with C. elegans. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 800, 753–765.DOI
  17. [18]Galdi, Giovanni P. 2000 Slow steady fall of rigid bodies in a second-order fluid. Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics 90 (1), 81–89.DOI
  18. [19]Galdi, Giovanni P., Vaidya, Ashwin, Pokorný, Milan, Joseph, Daniel D. & Feng, Jimmy 2011 Orientation of symmetric bodies falling in a second-order liquid at nonzero Reynolds number. Mathematical Models and Methods in Applied Sciences 12 (11), 1653–1690.
  19. [20]Gong, J iahao, Shaik, Vaseem A. & Elfring, Gwynn J. 2023 Active spheroids in viscosity gradients.DOI
  20. [21]Hanazaki, H., Konishi, K. & Okamura, T. 2009 Schmidt-number effects on the flow past a sphere moving vertically in a stratified diffusive fluid. Physics of Fluids 21 (2), 026602.DOI
  21. [22]Hatwalne, Yashodhan, Ramaswamy, Sr ira m, Rao, Madan & Simha, R. Ad it 2004 Rheology of Active-Particle Suspensions. Physical Review Letters 92 (11), 118101.
  22. [23]Herzhaft, Benjamin & Guazzelli, Elisabeth 1999 Experimental study of the sedimentation of dilute and semi-dilute suspensions of fibres. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 384, 133–158.
  23. [25]Jacquemin, J., Husson, P., Padua, A. A.H. & Majer, V. 2006 Density and viscosity of several pure and water-saturated ionic liquids. Green Chemistry 8 (2), 172–180.DOI
  24. [26]Kamal, Catherine & Lauga, Eric 2023 Resistive-force theory of slender bodies in viscosity gradients. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 963, A24.DOI
  25. [27]Khayat, R. E. & Cox, R. G. 1989 Inertia effects on the motion of long slender bodies. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 209, 435–462.DOI
  26. [28]Kim, Sangtae 1986 THE MOTION OF ELLIPSOIDS IN A SECOND ORDER FLUID. Journal of Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics 21, 255–269.
  27. [29]Kim, Sangtae & Karilla, Seppo 2005 Microhydrodynamics: Principles and Selected Application, 2nd edn. Mineola, New York: Dover Publications.
  28. [30]Kim, Sangwon, Lee, Seungmin, Lee, Jeonghun, Nelson, Bradley J., Zhang, Li & Choi, Hongsoo 2016 Fabrication and manipulation of ciliary microrobots with non-reciprocal magnetic actuation. Scientific Reports 6.DOI
  29. [31]Koch, Donald L. & Shaqfeh, Eric S. G. 1989 The instability of a dispersion of sedimenting spheroids. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 209, 521–542.DOI
  30. [32]Koch, Donald L. & Shaqfeh, E. S. G. 1991 Screening in sedimenting suspensions. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 224, 275–303.DOI
  31. [33]Kuusela, E., Lahtinen, J. M. & Ala-Nissila, T. 2003 Collective Effects in Settling of Spheroids under Steady-State Sedimentation. Physical Review Letters 90 (9), 4.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12689226
  32. [34]Leal, L G 1980 Particle motions in a viscous fluid. Ann. Rev. Fluid Mech 12, 435–76.DOI
  33. [35]Leal, L Gary 2007 Advanced transport phenomena: fluid mechanics and convective transport processes, vol. 7. Cambridge University Press.
  34. [38]Liebchen, Benno, Monderkamp, Paul, ten Hagen, Borge & Löwen, Hartmut 2018 Vicotaxis: Microswimmer Navigation in Viscosity Gradients. Physical Review Letters 120 (20), 208002.DOI
  35. [39]Lofquist, Karl E. B. & Purtell, L. Patrick 1984 Drag on a sphere moving horizontally through a stratified liquid. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 148, 271–284.DOI
  36. [40]Mandel, Tracy L., Zhou, De Zhen, Waldrop, Lindsay, Theillard, Maxime, Kleckner, Dustin & Khatri, Shilpa 2020 Retention of rising droplets in density stratification. Physical Review Fluids 5 (12), 124803.DOI
  37. [41]Mehaddi, R., Candelier, F. & Mehlig, B. 2018 Inertial drag on a sphere settling in a stratified fluid. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 855, 1074–1087.DOI
  38. [42]More, Rishabh V & Ardekani, Arezoo M 2022 Annual Review of Fluid Mechanics Motion in Stratified Fluids. Annu. Rev. Fluid Mech. 2023 55, 157–192.
  39. [43]More, Rishabh V., Ardekani, Mehdi N., Brandt, Luca & Ardekani, Arezoo M. 2021 Orientation instability of settling spheroids in a linearly density-stratified fluid. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 929.DOI
  40. [44]Morozov, Konstantin I. & Leshansky, Alexander M. 2014 The chiral magnetic nanomotors. Nanoscale 6 (3), 1580–1588.DOI
  41. [45]Nelson, Bradley J., Kaliakatsos, Ioannis K. & Abbott, Jake J. 2010 Microrobots for minimally invasive medicine.DOI
  42. [46]Nicolai, H., Herzhaft, B., Hinch, E. J., Oger, L. & Guazzelli, E. 1998 Particle velocity fluctuations and hydrodynamic self-diffusion of sedimenting non-Brownian spheres. Physics of Fluids 7 (1), 12.
  43. [47]Nissanka, Kavinda, Ma, Xiaolei & Burton, Justin C 2023 Dynamics of mass polar spheroids during sedimentation. J. Fluid Mech 956, 28.DOI
  44. [48]Oppenheimer, Naomi, Navardi, Shahin & Stone, Howard A. 2016 Motion of a hot particle in viscous fluids. Physical Review Fluids 1 (1).DOI
  45. [49]Palagi, Stefano, Jager, Edwin WH, Mazzolai, Barbara & Beccai, Lucia 2013 Propulsion of swimming microrobots inspired by metachronal waves in ciliates: from biology to material specifications. Bioinspiration & Biomimetics 8 (4), 046004.DOI
  46. [50]Qin, Ke & Pak, On Shun 2023 Purcell’s swimmer in a shear-thinning fluid. Phys. Rev. Fluids 8 (3), 33301.DOI
  47. [51]Rafaï, Salima, Jibuti, Levan & Peyla, Philippe 2010 Effective Viscosity of Microswimmer Suspensions. Physical Review Letters 104 (9), 098102.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/20367014
  48. [52]Sengupta, Anupam, Carrara, Francesco & Stocker, Roman 2017 Phytoplankton can actively diversify their migration strategy in response to turbulent cues. Nature 543 (7646), 555–558.DOI
  49. [53]Shaik, Vaseem A. & Elfring, Gwynn J. 2021 On the hydrodynamics of active particles in viscosity gradients. Physical Review of Fluids .arxiv.org/abs/2107.03518
  50. [54]Shin, Mansoo, Koch, Donald L. & Subramanian, Ganesh 2006 A pseudospectral method to evaluate the fluid velocity produced by an array of translating slender fibers. Physics of Fluids 18 (6), 063301.DOI
  51. [55]Shin, Mansoo, Koch, Donald L. & Subramanian, Ganesh 2009 Structure and dynamics of dilute suspensions of finite-Reynolds-number settling fibers. Physics of Fluids 21 (12), 123304.DOI
  52. [56]Sokolov, Andrey & Aranson, Igor S. 2009 Reduction of Viscosity in Suspension of Swimming Bacteria. Physical Review Letters 103 (14), 148101.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19905604
  53. [57]Sten, Johan C.-E. 2006 Ellipsoidal harmonics and their application in electrostatics. Journal of Electrostatics 64 (10), 647–654.DOI
  54. [58]Takabe, Kyosuke, Tahara, Hajime, Islam, Md Shafiqul, Affroze, Samia, Kudo, Seishi & Nakamura, Shuichi 2017 Viscosity-dependent variations in the cell shape and swimming manner of Leptospira. Microbiology (United Kingdom) 163 (2), 153–160.DOI
  55. [59]Varanasi, Arun Kumar & Subramanian, Ganesh 2022 Motion of a sphere in a viscous density stratified fluid. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 949, A29.DOI
  56. [60]Vishnampet, Ramanathan & Saintillan, David 2012 Concentration instability of sedimenting spheres in a second-order fluid. Physics of Fluids 24 (7), 073302.DOI
  57. [61]Wang, Shiyan, Tai, Cheng Wei & Narsimhan, Vivek 2020 Dynamics of spheroids in an unbound quadratic flow of a general second-order fluid. Physics of Fluids 32 (11).DOI
  58. [62]Witten, Thomas A. & Diamant, Haim 2020 A review of shaped colloidal particles in fluids: anisotropy and chirality. Reports on Progress in Physics 83 (11), 116601.DOI
  59. [63]Yick, King Yeung, Torres, Carlos R., Peacock, Thomas & Stocker, Roman 2009 Enhanced drag of a sphere settling in a stratified fluid at small Reynolds numbers. Journal of Fluid Mechanics 632, 49–68.DOI
  60. [64]Zhuang, Jiang, Park, Byung Wook & Sitti, Metin 2017 Propulsion and Chemotaxis in Bacteria-Driven Microswimmers. Advanced Science 4 (9).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_8dw7andv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents