betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

An analytical solution for horizontal velocity profiles in the hurricane boundary layer

Abstract

Theoretical analyses of the hurricane boundary layer have traditionally relied on slab models, which provide a limited description of wind profiles. Literature on height-resolving methods is typically based on linear analyses, which may fall short of capturing the full sensitivity of the solution to variations in input parameters. This work proposes an approximate analytical solution of a nonlinear single-column model for horizontal winds based on a constant eddy viscosity assumption and valid outside the eyewall. Building on literature that uses a linearized system of equations, we account for the nonlinearities through a series expansion approach. We find that a first order correction is sufficient for most practical cases. This solution helps provide a simplified understanding of the sensitivity of the radial and tangential wind profiles to input parameters such as the distance from the hurricane eye and the Coriolis force.

Introduction

The vertical structure of mean wind in hurricane boundary layers (HBLs) is of relevance for a wide range of engineering applications, including hurricane forecasting, damage modeling, and risk assessment for coastal infrastructure.

Practical difficulties in obtaining wind speed and flux measurements in the HBL have traditionally limited the amount of available observational data. Advances over the past two decades in observational capabilities [5] have provided significant insight into HBL processes and informed the development of empirical wind profiles such as those presented in Vickery et al. (2009), which have proved useful for operational use. Additionally, recent developments in turbulence-resolving HBL simulations (e.g., Bryan et al. [1]; Worsnop et al. (2017); Momen et al. (2021); Chen et al. [4]; Ma and Sun [12]), have opened the doors for a more mechanistic understanding of HBL dynamics.

Simplified theoretical analyses are also being explored that build on these advancements and enhance our understanding of the wind variation seen in numerical and observational studies. Theoretical analyses of the HBL are typically performed using slab models (Kepert [10]; Smith and Montgomery (2023)) which average out or prescribe the vertical dynamical structure. Height-resolving analyses, with a focus on the velocity profiles, gained traction towards the last quarter of the 20th century (Rosenthal (1962); Smith (1968); Eliassen and Lystad [6]; Meng et al. (1995)). A summary of these contributions is presented in Chang et al. [3].

An influential paper by Kepert [9] incorporated much of the work in these previous studies and established the system of linear equations used in height-resolving models. These equations are the radial and tangential momentum balance that use the gradient wind balance to model the radial pressure gradient, and neglect second and higher order products of velocities. In the limit of large radial distance from the storm center, the solution to these equations converges to the classic Ekman layer solution. More recent publications built on this work to include vertically varying eddy viscosity (Vickery et al. (2009)), non-axisymmetric gradient wind (Snaiki and Wu (2017a)) and the vertical advection in the eyewall (Yang et al. (2021)). These works have provided insight into the vertical structure of the mean wind in the HBL but are based on a linearized formulation of the problem. While there is some literature that discusses the drawbacks of neglecting nonlinearities (Kepert and Wang [11]; Foster [8]; Vogl and Smith (2009)), these analyses have relied on a numerical approach to solve the differential equations. There remains a need for an analytical formula for the variation of mean speed that is backed by nonlinear theory, matches realistic hurricane wind profiles, and is sufficiently simple for use in engineering practice. Such a solution would also help elucidate dependencies between flow features and make these easier to interpret.

This work proposes an analytical solution of the nonlinear HBL equations valid outside the eyewall, using a single column model with constant eddy-viscosity. Building on Kepert [9], which analyses the linearised version of the same model, we use a series expansion to account for the nonlinearities. We first discuss the governing equations, boundary conditions and the physical validity of the solutions to these equations in Sect. 2 and 3. This is followed by the description of the series solution, of the nonlinear equations and a comparison against the numerical solution in Sect. 4. The analytical solution allows for a simple analysis of sensitivity to the various parameters. This is explored in Sect. 5. A simpler alternative solution for the velocity magnitude is proposed in Sect. 6, which is informed by the analysis in Sect. 4 and 5. Conclusions are drawn in Sect. 7.

Governing Equations and Non-Dimensionalization

The governing equations for the mean velocity profiles in the stationary and axisymmetric HBL far from the eyewall are

ddz(Kdu‾rdz)=(Vg2R+fVg)−u‾θ2R−u‾r2R−fu‾θ(1)\frac{d}{dz}\left(K\frac{d\overline{u}_r}{dz}\right)=\left(\frac{V_g^2}{R}+fV_g\right)-\frac{\overline{u}_\theta^2}{R}-\frac{\overline{u}_r^2}{R}-f\overline{u}_\theta \tag*{(1)}
ddz(Kdu‾θdz)=u‾ru‾θR+fu‾r−nu‾rVgR(2)\frac{d}{dz}\left(K\frac{d\overline{u}_\theta}{dz}\right)=\frac{\overline{u}_r\overline{u}_\theta}{R}+f\overline{u}_r-n\overline{u}_r\frac{V_g}{R} \tag*{(2)}

where u‾r\overline{u}_r is the radial velocity, u‾θ\overline{u}_\theta is the tangential velocity, VgV_g is the gradient wind speed, ff is the Coriolis frequency, RR is the radial distance from the axis of rotation, nn is the non-dimensional radial derivative of gradient wind and KK is the sum of the molecular and turbulent viscosities, which we treat in this analysis to be constant. A detailed derivation is provided in Appendix 9.1. We have used the modelling choices ∂u‾r/∂r=−u‾r/R\partial\overline{u}_r/\partial r=-\overline{u}_r/R and ∂u‾θ/∂r=−nVg/R\partial\overline{u}_\theta/\partial r=-nV_g/R which restrict the equations to the region outside the eyewall.

We start by considering a constant gradient wind Vg=GV_g=G. A linearly varying gradient wind is considered in Appendix 9.3. For a constant gradient wind, (1) and (2) is solved with the boundary conditions

u‾r(0)=u‾r(∞)=u‾θ(0)=0,u‾θ(∞)=G(3)\overline{u}_r(0)=\overline{u}_r(\infty)=\overline{u}_\theta(0)=0,\qquad\overline{u}_\theta(\infty)=G \tag*{(3)}

Consider the coordinate transformation u^=u‾r\hat{u}=\overline{u}_r and v^=u‾θ−G\hat{v}=\overline{u}_\theta-G. Next, introduce non-dimensional height ξ=z/H\xi=z/H and non-dimensional velocity variables u=u^/Gu=\hat{u}/G and v=v^/Gv=\hat{v}/G. A depth scale similar to the Ekman layer depth H=2K/IH=\sqrt{2K/I} can be constructed to normalize zz, where,

I=(f+2GR)(f+(1−n)GR)(4)I=\sqrt{\left(f+\frac{2G}{R}\right)\left(f+(1-n)\frac{G}{R}\right)} \tag*{(4)}

is the inertial stability, as defined in Kepert [9]. Substituting the transformations into (1) and (2), one obtains

d2udξ2=H2GKR[−(1Ro+2)v−(u2+v2)](5)\frac{d^2u}{d\xi^2}=\frac{H^2G}{KR}\left[-\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+2\right)v-(u^2+v^2)\right] \tag*{(5)}
d2vdξ2=H2GKR[(1Ro+(1−n))u+uv](6)\frac{d^2v}{d\xi^2}=\frac{H^2G}{KR}\left[\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+(1-n)\right)u+uv\right] \tag*{(6)}

where Ro=G/(fR)Ro=G/(fR) is a Rossby number based on the gradient wind speed GG and the radial distance RR at which the velocity profiles are to be determined. Substituting for HH, the equations become

d2udξ2=−α~v−γ~(u2+v2)(7)\frac{d^2u}{d\xi^2}=-\widetilde{\alpha}v-\widetilde{\gamma}(u^2+v^2) \tag*{(7)}
d2vdξ2=β~u+γ~uv(8)\frac{d^2v}{d\xi^2}=\widetilde{\beta}u+\widetilde{\gamma}uv \tag*{(8)}
nnα~\tilde{\alpha}β~\tilde{\beta}γ~\tilde{\gamma}
Case 10.303.371.191.67
Case 20.453.791.061.89
Case 30.604.430.902.20

caption: Three cases analysing the effect of nn (with Ro=100Ro = 100).

where

α~=2(1Ro+2)(1Ro+(1−n)),β~=2(1Ro+(1−n))(1Ro+2),\tilde{\alpha} = 2\sqrt{\frac{\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+2\right)}{\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+(1-n)\right)}}, \qquad\tilde{\beta} = 2\sqrt{\frac{\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+(1-n)\right)}{\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+2\right)}},
γ~=2(1Ro+2)(1Ro+(1−n)).(9)\tilde{\gamma} = \frac{2}{\sqrt{\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+2\right)\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+(1-n)\right)}}. \tag*{(9)}

Note that {α~,β~,γ~}=2H2{α,β,γ}\{\tilde{\alpha}, \tilde{\beta}, \tilde{\gamma}\} = 2H^2\{\alpha, \beta, \gamma\} where α\alpha, β\beta and γ\gamma are defined in Equation (8) of Kepert [9]. Normalized boundary conditions for (7) and (8) are

u(0)=u(∞)=v(∞)=0,v(0)=−1.(10)u(0) = u(\infty) = v(\infty) = 0,\qquad v(0) = -1. \tag*{(10)}

We emphasize here that the non-dimensional problem depends only on two parameters, namely nn and the non-dimensional Coriolis frequency 1/Ro1/Ro.

Physical validity of governing equation

Hurricanes occur in the Northern Hemisphere roughly in the latitudes 8∘8^\circN to 40∘40^\circN and with gradient wind speeds from about 20 to 80 m/s. “Outside the eyewall” could be considered to be R∈[20,200]R \in[20, 200] km. These values correspond to Ro∈[1,200]Ro \in[1, 200]. The only other parameter in the non-dimensional equations is nn. From Mallen et al. [13], n∈[0.04,0.67]n \in[0.04, 0.67].

Consider three cases of nn, as tabulated in Table 1. Equations (7) and (8) with boundary conditions (10) are solved over a finite but sufficiently large domain numerically for cases 1 and 3 and are shown in Figure 2.

Analytical and numerical solutions for cases 1 and 2

Figure 2. Analytical and numerical solution for cases 1 and 2 of Table 1.

We expect velocity profiles to resemble those of the classical Ekman layer solution. uu should feature a jet with negative peak velocity near the surface and decay further aloft; 1+v1+v should be positive and be characterized by an elevated maximum and asymptote to a value of 1 aloft to match the gradient wind.

We see that the expected behaviour is followed in Case 1 but not Case 3. For Case 3, 1+v1+v does not tend to 1 aloft. The stable numerical solution for 1+v1+v appears like a mirror image about 0 of what we would have expected based on the Ekman layer solution.

We find that there is a switch in the stable numerical solution from a form similar to Case 1 (Figure 1,a) where vv has a positive slope near the ground, to that seen in Case 3 (Figure 1,b) where vv has a negative slope near the ground. Through some trial and error, we find that this switch occurs at n≈0.5n \approx0.5, with a mild sensitivity to RoRo. (Note that a Neumann boundary condition du/dξ=dv/dξ=0du/d\xi= dv/d\xi= 0 is used for Case 3. Using a Dirichlet condition instead would have caused a sharp change in vv aloft to match the boundary condition.) The effect on the profiles upon changing RoRo is minimal (not shown).

Numerical solution for Cases 1 and 3 of Table 1

Figure 1. Numerical solution for Cases 1 and 3 of Table 1.

To analyse possible solutions to (7) and (8) aloft, we set d2u/dξ2=d2v/dξ2=0\mathrm{d}^{2}u/\mathrm{d}\xi^{2}=\mathrm{d}^{2}v/\mathrm{d}\xi^{2}=0 (the effects of curvature in the velocity profiles should only be present close to the ground). We get two algebraic equations

u2+v2+(2+1Ro)v=0,uv+u((1−n)+1Ro)=0.(11)u^{2}+v^{2}+\left(2+\frac{1}{Ro}\right)v=0,\qquad uv+u\left((1-n)+\frac{1}{Ro}\right)=0. \tag*{(11)}

There are four solutions to this system of algebraic equations, which are

u=0, v=0,u=0, v=−(2+1Ro),u=±((1−n)+1Ro)(1+n), v=−((1−n)+1Ro).(12)\begin{aligned} u&=0,\ v=0,\qquad u=0,\ v=-\left(2+\frac{1}{Ro}\right),\\ u&=\pm\sqrt{\left((1-n)+\frac{1}{Ro}\right)(1+n)},\ v=-\left((1-n)+\frac{1}{Ro}\right). \tag*{(12)} \end{aligned}

In Figure 1(b), we see that the u→0u\to0 and (1+v)→−(1+1/Ro)(1+v)\to-(1+1/Ro). This is consistent with a possible solution in (12), and therefore appears to be a mathematically valid tendency. But this is clearly not physical, since the velocity should approach that of the gradient wind aloft.

One simple reason for this switch could be the increasing dominance of the nonlinear terms as nn becomes larger. This is seen clearly from (5) and (6). For even a moderately large RoRo (say, Ro>10Ro>10), the effect of 1/Ro1/Ro can be neglected. Focusing on nn, we see that as nn becomes larger, the coefficient attached to uu in (6) is much smaller than that attached to uvuv, and hence the nonlinear behaviour dominates the linear.

Details of the numerical solver are given in Appendix § 9.2 and a qualitative mechanism for this flip is described. Additionally, in Appendix § 9.2, we plot velocity profiles with a vertically varying eddy viscosity (Figure 10,a). Even with the variable eddy viscosity, the switch of solution behaviour is seen. However, the nn at which this switch occurs appears to be pushed to a higher value (n≈0.67n\approx0.67 for the chosen eddy viscosity profile).

Image not extracted

Figure 10. Numerical solution for n=0.6n=0.6 with (a) variable eddy viscosity (b) a slip boundary condition. Dot-dashed lines are the radial velocity and solid lines are the tangential velocity.

Meng et al. (1995), Kepert [9] and other subsequent work (Snaiki and Wu, 2017b; Fang et al., 2018; Yang et al., 2021) consider a slip condition instead at the bottom boundary. The switch in solution behaviour for large nn is observed with this boundary condition as well. For example, using C=0.002C = 0.002 and K=50 m2s−1K = 50\,\mathrm{m}^{2}\mathrm{s}^{-1} as in Kepert [9], the switch is observed at n≈0.69n \approx0.69 (Figure 10,b). Raising CC to a larger value, such as 0.02, causes the switch to occur at a lower n≈0.55n \approx0.55.

The observed behaviour limits the physical validity of the governing equations and suggests that care must be taken when using large values of nn to ensure that the solution to the equations retains physical tendencies.

Approximate analytical solution

Acknowledging the above limitations of the governing equations, we constrain the study in this section to n∈[0,0.45]n \in[0, 0.45]. Increases in the parameters RoRo and nn make the solution increasingly dependent on the nonlinear terms. In all the cases considered, the coefficient attached to the nonlinear terms are of the same order of magnitude as those of the linear terms, and therefore nonlinear terms cannot be neglected.

We follow Lyapunov’s artificial small parameter method (Nayfeh, 2008). Attaching an artificial small parameter δ\delta to the nonlinear terms, the equations are

d2udξ2=−α~v−δγ~(u2+v2),(13)\frac{\mathrm{d}^{2}u}{\mathrm{d}\xi^{2}}=-\tilde{\alpha}v-\delta\tilde{\gamma}(u^{2}+v^{2}), \tag*{(13)}
d2vdξ2=β~u+δγ~uv.(14)\frac{\mathrm{d}^{2}v}{\mathrm{d}\xi^{2}}=\tilde{\beta}u+\delta\tilde{\gamma}uv. \tag*{(14)}

Consider a series expansion of the form

u(ξ)=u0(ξ)+δu1(ξ)+δ2u2(ξ)+⋯ ,(15)u(\xi)=u_{0}(\xi)+\delta u_{1}(\xi)+\delta^{2}u_{2}(\xi)+\cdots, \tag*{(15)}
v(ξ)=v0(ξ)+δv1(ξ)+δ2v2(ξ)+⋯ .(16)v(\xi)=v_{0}(\xi)+\delta v_{1}(\xi)+\delta^{2}v_{2}(\xi)+\cdots. \tag*{(16)}

Substituting the series and collecting orders of δ\delta, we obtain the following systems of equations at the first few orders. The leading order equations read

∂2u0∂ξ2=−α~v0,(17)\frac{\partial^{2}u_{0}}{\partial\xi^{2}}=-\tilde{\alpha}v_{0}, \tag*{(17)}
∂2v0∂ξ2=β~u0,(18)\frac{\partial^{2}v_{0}}{\partial\xi^{2}}=\tilde{\beta}u_{0}, \tag*{(18)}

with boundary conditions u0(0)=u0(∞)=v0(∞)=0u_{0}(0)=u_{0}(\infty)=v_{0}(\infty)=0, v0(0)=−1v_{0}(0)=-1. Similarly, the first order correction reads

∂2u1∂ξ2=−α~v1−γ~(u02+v02),(19)\frac{\partial^{2}u_{1}}{\partial\xi^{2}}=-\tilde{\alpha}v_{1}-\tilde{\gamma}(u_{0}^{2}+v_{0}^{2}), \tag*{(19)}
∂2v1∂ξ2=β~u1+γ~(u0v0).(20)\frac{\partial^{2}v_{1}}{\partial\xi^{2}}=\tilde{\beta}u_{1}+\tilde{\gamma}(u_{0}v_{0}). \tag*{(20)}

with boundary conditions u1(0)=u1(∞)=v1(0)=v1(∞)=0u_1(0)=u_1(\infty)=v_1(0)=v_1(\infty)=0. The second order correction is

∂2u2∂ξ2=−α~v2−γ~(2u0u1+2v0v1),(21)\frac{\partial^2 u_2}{\partial\xi^2}=-\tilde{\alpha}v_2-\tilde{\gamma}(2u_0u_1+2v_0v_1), \tag*{(21)}
∂2v2∂ξ2=β~u2+γ~(u0v1+u1v0),(22)\frac{\partial^2 v_2}{\partial\xi^2}=\tilde{\beta}u_2+\tilde{\gamma}(u_0v_1+u_1v_0), \tag*{(22)}

with the same boundary conditions as for the first order problem.

Note that we have used the no-slip boundary condition instead of a slip condition. This choice is made to come up with a sufficiently simple form of the solution including nonlinear effects that can represent the various trends seen in more complicated analyses. Future versions of this analysis that include a varying eddy viscosity or a higher fidelity boundary condition would likely match realistic velocity profiles even more closely.

The solution to the equations at the leading order is simply that of the Ekman layer, namely

u0=−α~2e−ξsin⁡(ξ),(23)u_0=-\frac{\tilde{\alpha}}{2}e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi), \tag*{(23)}
v0=−e−ξcos⁡(ξ).(24)v_0=-e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi). \tag*{(24)}

To obtain the first-order correction, substitute for u0u_0 and v0v_0 from Eqns. (23) and (24) into (20) and (19), and then substitute u1u_1 from (20) in (19). The resulting equation can be solved by considering an ansatz which is a linear combination of terms in the following product of sets

{1,e−ξ,e−2ξ}×{1,cos⁡(ξ),sin⁡(ξ),cos⁡(2ξ),sin⁡(2ξ)}.(25)\left\{1,e^{-\xi},e^{-2\xi}\right\}\times\left\{1,\cos(\xi),\sin(\xi),\cos(2\xi),\sin(2\xi)\right\}. \tag*{(25)}

Substituting the ansatz, comparing terms and solving for the coefficients, we obtain

u1(ξ)=γ~10(α~24+1)e−ξcos⁡(ξ)+γ~30e−ξsin⁡(ξ)−γ~10(α~24+1)e−2ξ+γ~30(−38α~2+2)e−2ξsin⁡(2ξ),(26)\begin{aligned} u_1(\xi)={}&\frac{\tilde{\gamma}}{10}\left(\frac{\tilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi)+\frac{\tilde{\gamma}}{30}e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi)\\ &-\frac{\tilde{\gamma}}{10}\left(\frac{\tilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-2\xi}+\frac{\tilde{\gamma}}{30}\left(-\frac{3}{8}\tilde{\alpha}^2+2\right)e^{-2\xi}\sin(2\xi), \tag*{(26)} \end{aligned}
v1(ξ)=γ~15α~e−ξcos⁡(ξ)−γ~5α~(α~24+1)e−ξsin⁡(ξ)−γ~10α~(α~24+1)e−2ξ+γ~30α~(3α~24+1)e−2ξcos⁡(2ξ).(27)\begin{aligned} v_1(\xi)={}&\frac{\tilde{\gamma}}{15\tilde{\alpha}}e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi)-\frac{\tilde{\gamma}}{5\tilde{\alpha}}\left(\frac{\tilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi)\\ &-\frac{\tilde{\gamma}}{10\tilde{\alpha}}\left(\frac{\tilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-2\xi}+\frac{\tilde{\gamma}}{30\tilde{\alpha}}\left(\frac{3\tilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-2\xi}\cos(2\xi). \tag*{(27)} \end{aligned}

The solutions beyond the first order become increasingly unwieldy and difficult to interpret conceptually. Further, as elaborated below, the first-order solution already represents a noticeable enhancement in accuracy compared to the linear leading-order solution, and is also sufficiently close to the numerical solution. This work will therefore focus primarily on the first-order solution. Appendix 9.4 presents the second order correction for the interested reader.

Noting that the gradient wind vector is seldom constant with height in the HBL, Appendix § 10 generalizes the above solution to linearly decreasing gradient winds.

Comparison with numerical solution

Leading and first order solutions are contrasted against the numerical solution in Figure 2 for cases 1 and 2 of Table 1. Case 1 has a small n=0.3n = 0.3 that falls well within the solution’s region of validity. Based on the figure, it is apparent that a first-order correction is sufficient to closely match the numerical solution. The corrections modulate the inflow, yielding slightly more diffused inflow and tangential velocity profiles. Case 2 is characterized by a relatively larger n=0.45n = 0.45, which is close to the bordering n≈0.5n \approx0.5 beyond which the switch in stable solution was observed (§ 3). The solution features a slower convergence rate, requiring a larger number of terms to obtain an adequate approximation. However, these higher order solutions are required only when nn becomes quite close to (say, within 0.050.05 of) the critical value, and a first order solution remains sufficient for smaller nn. For n≈0.5n \approx0.5, the analytical solution diverges.

The correction term v1v_1 is negative near the ground (upto ξ≈3\xi\approx3) and u1u_1 has an S-like shape where it is positive at the ground and negative above. Both the u1u_1 and v1v_1 terms thus have a tendency to reduce the magnitudes of the peak radial and tangential velocities respectively.

The role of the corrections in moderating the gradient of the velocity near the ground is also interesting. The derivative of v1v_1 is negative upto ξ≈1\xi\approx1, and thus decreases the slope of tangential velocity at the ground. As nn increases, the strength of this reduction in the slope of v0v_0 by v1v_1 also increases. This may be connected to the switch in solution behaviour, and is elaborated in Appendix § 9.2. Overall, the proposed corrections offer improvements to the linear (leading-order) solution and additional insight into the nonlinear effects.

Sensitivity Analysis

To characterize the role of the input parameters, we analyse here the sensitivity of the normalized solutions to their variations. A discussion on sensitivities is also presented for the solutions in the more intuitive dimensional form.

Figure 3(a) shows the sensitivity to RoRo for n=0.3n = 0.3. For a given latitude, a small RoRo means either that GG is small or that RR is large. Thus, small RoRo is not a very interesting case. When RoRo becomes large, we expect the effect of the latitude to be negligibly small. Wind profiles should get closer to each other as RoRo increases. This is reflected in Figure 3(a), with the curve for Ro=10Ro = 10 appearing almost superimposed on the curve for Ro=100Ro = 100. Figure 3(b) plots the sensitivity to nn for Ro=100Ro = 100. As nn increases, so does the strength of the inflow. The sensitivity to nn for 1+v1 + v is, however, far less pronounced than for uu.

Sensitivity of the first order accurate solutions in normalized form to $Ro$ and $n$

Figure 3. Sensitivity of the first order accurate solutions in normalized form to RoRo and nn.

Sensitivities of the solutions in dimensional form are discussed next. Solutions are dimensionalized based on parameter values listed in Table 2, with the exception of the parameter that is being varied. Figure 4(a) shows the sensitivity to GG. As is expected, GG has a strong impact on the shape and magnitude of the velocity components. As GG increases, the u‾θ\overline{u}_{\theta} profiles feature a strengthened jet with a more pronounced nose moving closer to the surface. A similar behavior characterizes the u‾r\overline{u}_{r} profile. The sensitivity to variations in nn is shown in Figure 4(b). As was seen in the non-dimensional analysis in Figure 3(b), despite its importance in determining the convergence of the analytical solution, this parameter only modulates the u‾r\overline{u}_{r} profile with a modest impact on u‾θ\overline{u}_{\theta}. The sensitivity to KK is shown in Figure 5(a). As KK increases, there is increased mixing, causing the jet to become wider. With larger KK, the peak of this more diffuse jet also tends to become higher. The role of KK here is similar to that in the Ekman layer. The effect of increasing RR (Figure 5(b)) is quite similar to that of increasing KK. As RR increases, the jet becomes less pronounced and thicker, and its elevation above the surface level increases. This is consistent with the intuition that as we move farther away from the eye of the hurricane, the effect of the centrifugal force term in the gradient wind forcing becomes smaller, and the wind profile tends to that due to a geostrophic forcing. The mild decrease in the peak magnitudes of uˉr\bar{u}_r and uˉθ\bar{u}_\theta with increasing RR is due to the change in RoRo and this effect is negligible as seen in the figure.

GG40 m s−1^{-1}nn0.25
KK50 m2^{2}s−1^{-1}RR50 km
ff5×10−55 \times10^{-5} s−1^{-1}GzG_z0 s−1^{-1}

Table 2. Dimensional values of parameters used to plot Figures 4 to 6.

Sensitivity to $K$ and $R$

Figure 5. Sensitivity to KK and RR.

These sensitivities can be further analysed quantitatively using the analytical solution. For example, we examine the peak magnitude and height of the inflow and use the leading order solution for the radial velocity for simplicity. Differentiating 23 and setting to zero, one obtains ξuˉrpeak=π/4\xi^{\mathrm{peak}}_{\bar{u}_r}=\pi/4, corresponding to

uˉrpeak=1.11KRG((1Ro+2)(1Ro+(1−n)))−0.25≈0.93KRG1−n(28)\bar{u}_r^{\mathrm{peak}}=1.11\sqrt{\frac{KR}{G}}\left(\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+2\right)\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+(1-n)\right)\right)^{-0.25}\approx0.93\sqrt{\frac{KR}{G\sqrt{1-n}}} \tag*{(28)}

where in the last step we have use 1/Ro≈01/Ro\approx0. From this formula we see that, to the leading order, RR and KK have the same effect on the height of the inflow peak. This was also observed in the two parts of Figure 5. From the formula, as GG and nn increase, the height of the peak decreases, which is also seen in Figure 4. Substituting in 23, the magnitude of peak inflow is

Sensitivity of the first order accurate solution to $G$ and $n$

Figure 4. Sensitivity of the first order accurate solution in dimensional form to GG and nn. zz is in metres and the velocity components in metres per second.

uˉrpeak=0.32G1Ro+21Ro+(1−n)≈0.46G1−n.(29)\bar{u}_r^{\mathrm{peak}} = 0.32G\sqrt{\frac{\frac{1}{Ro}+2}{\frac{1}{Ro}+(1-n)}} \approx0.46\frac{G}{\sqrt{1-n}}. \tag*{(29)}

This formula shows that as nn increases, the magnitude of peak inflow increases. This is seen in Figure 4(b). Figure 6(a) shows the sensitivity to ff. Coriolis frequency has a small impact for this radius, since the centrifugal term dominates the Coriolis term. The impact of ff is slightly more visible for a larger radius of, say R=200R = 200 km (not shown). But for cases of interest, i.e., for small RR and large GG, the effect due to ff is negligible.

Sensitivity to f and G_z

Figure 6. Sensitivity to ff and GzG_z.

The sensitivity to variations in GzG_z is shown in Figure 6(b). As apparent, this parameter mainly affects the slope of uˉθ\bar{u}_\theta away from the surface, with minimal impact on the uˉr\bar{u}_r profiles.

Although (30) was derived using the linear solution (23), we can extend this to the nonlinear solution using the fact the solution is insensitive to RoRo (see Figure 3,a). Neglecting 1/Ro1/Ro, the solution to (7) and (8) is only a function of ξ\xi and nn. For a fixed nn, the non-dimensional peak is a constant value. In a dimensional setting, this thus means that even the nonlinear solution features

zuˉrpeak,zuˉθpeak∝KRGf(n).(30)z_{\bar{u}_r}^{\mathrm{peak}}, z_{\bar{u}_\theta}^{\mathrm{peak}} \propto\sqrt{\frac{KR}{G}}f(n). \tag*{(30)}

If we vary only GG (or, alternatively, KK or RR) holding the other constants fixed, then height of the peak velocity values for the leading and first order analytical and numerical solutions are simply multiples of each other. We demonstrate this in Figure 7, where normalized variations of peak heights for a range of parameter sweeps are shown. Normalized peak heights are defined as

Normalized variations of peak heights for the tangential and radial velocities against variations of selected dimensional parameters

Figure 7. Normalized variations of peak heights for the tangential and radial velocities against variations of selected dimensional parameters.

SˉG=zuˉipeak(G,q0)−zuˉipeak(G0,q0)zuˉipeak(G0,q0).(31)\bar{S}_G = \frac{z_{\bar{u}_i}^{\mathrm{peak}}(G,q_0)-z_{\bar{u}_i}^{\mathrm{peak}}(G_0,q_0)}{z_{\bar{u}_i}^{\mathrm{peak}}(G_0,q_0)}. \tag*{(31)}

where uˉi\bar{u}_i denotes either uˉr\bar{u}_r or uˉθ\bar{u}_\theta, and q0\mathbf{q}_0 refers to the other dimensional parameters that we hold fixed. We see that the six curves overlap for variations in GG, RR and KK. The overlap is weaker for larger GG and RR, due to the small effect from RoRo.

The above reasoning does not however hold for nn, and this is confirmed by Figure 7(b) where no collapse is observed. We also note that the numerical solution shows a faster growth of peak height with nn than the linear solution. The first order analytical solution is an improvement to the linear solution but fails to match the numerical solution as nn increases. The figure also shows that, for the numerical and first order solutions, the rate of growth of the peak height is higher for tangential velocity than radial velocity. This is not captured by the linear solution, for which the dashed curve overlaps the solid one.

Velocity Magnitude

Figure 8(a) plots the numerical solution for the velocity magnitude uˉ2+(1+v)2\sqrt{\bar{u}^{2}+(1+v)^{2}}, for a range of representative RoRo and nn values. As apparent from the figure, the solution is insensitive to both of these parameters. This is surprising, especially when considering the role of nn in controlling the convergence of the analytical solution.

Numerical, analytical, and curve-fit velocity profiles

Figure 8. Left: Numerical solution for the velocity magnitude in normalized form, for various nn and RoRo. Figure also includes the analytical solution 32, 33 and the curve fit 34. Right: Numerical, analytical and curve fit solutions in dimensional form. The curves from left to right are cases 1 to 4 of Table 3 respectively.

If one is interested only in the magnitude of velocity, then this finding presents an alternative strategy to obtain the velocity profile for larger nn. We had noted in Sect. 4 that for small nn, the analytical solution with first order correction is indistinguishable from the numerical solution. We can therefore consider the case when Ro→∞Ro \to\infty and n=0n = 0 for the first order analytical solution. In this limit, the coefficients are constant numerical values. Substituting 1/Ro=n=01/Ro = n = 0 in (23), (24), (26) and (27), we obtain

u0+u1=−1.37e−ξsin⁡(ξ)+0.42e−ξcos⁡(ξ)−0.42e−2ξ−0.05e−2ξsin⁡(2ξ)(32)u_0 + u_1 = -1.37e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi) + 0.42e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi) -0.42e^{-2\xi} - 0.05e^{-2\xi}\sin(2\xi) \tag*{(32)}
1+v0+v1=1−0.97e−ξcos⁡(ξ)−0.30e−ξsin⁡(ξ)−0.15e−2ξ+0.12e−2ξcos⁡(2ξ)(33)1 + v_0 + v_1 = 1 - 0.97e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi) - 0.30e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi) -0.15e^{-2\xi} + 0.12e^{-2\xi}\cos(2\xi) \tag*{(33)}

Since the coefficients are just numerical values (and not functions of RoRo or nn), an even simpler strategy could be to perform a curve fit. A simple fit C(ξ)C(\xi) of the velocity magnitude yields

C(ξ)=1−0.88e−ξcos⁡(ξ)−0.28e−ξsin⁡(ξ)−0.13e−2ξcos⁡(2ξ)+0.31e−2ξsin⁡(2ξ)(34)C(\xi) = 1 - 0.88e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi) - 0.28e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi) -0.13e^{-2\xi}\cos(2\xi) + 0.31e^{-2\xi}\sin(2\xi) \tag*{(34)}

Figure 8(a) also includes (u0+u1)2+(1+v0+v1)2\sqrt{(u_0 + u_1)^2 + (1 + v_0 + v_1)^2} from (32) and (33), and the curve fit C(ξ)C(\xi) in (34). We see that both of these are quite close to the other four curves. This solution can also be tested for robustness in a dimensional setting. We consider four curves, with various values of the dimensional parameters listed in Table 3. The black symbols in Figure 8(b) are obtained by solving the dimensional equations (1) and (2) numerically with boundary conditions (3). The purple curves labelled “analytical” are

G (m s−1^{-1})R (km)f (s−1^{-1})nK (m2^{2} s−1^{-1})
Case 120502.5×10−52.5 \times10^{-5}0.110
Case 2301005×10−55 \times10^{-5}0.220
Case 3401507.5×10−57.5 \times10^{-5}0.330
Case 45020010×10−510 \times10^{-5}0.440

Table 3. Parameters used in the four curves of Figure 8(b).

G(u0(zH)+u1(zH))2+(1+v0(zH)+v1(zH))2(35)G\sqrt{\left(u_0\left(\frac{z}{H}\right) + u_1\left(\frac{z}{H}\right)\right)^2 + \left(1 + v_0\left(\frac{z}{H}\right) + v_1\left(\frac{z}{H}\right)\right)^2} \tag*{(35)}

where u0+u1u_0 + u_1 are 1 + v0+v1v_0 + v_1 are from (32) and (33). The green curves are GC(z/H)GC(z/H) where C(ξ)C(\xi) is from (34). We see that curves from the analytical solution and the curve fit are able to match the numerical solution very closely. The curve fit shows a slight deviation for larger nn (see rightmost curve), but the analytical solution superposes the numerical solution almost exactly. This proves further that the simpler strategies derived in this section are robust alternatives to the series expansion from Sect.4, when considering the velocity magnitude.

Using this new analytical solution, we can now obtain the depth and peak value of the velocity magnitude by differentiating (u0+u1)2+(1+v0+v1)2\sqrt{(u_0 + u_1)^2 + (1 + v_0 + v_1)^2} and setting to 0.

ξpeak=2.56  ⟹  zpeak=3.62KRG((1Ro+2)(1Ro+(1−n)))−0.25.(36)\xi_{\mathrm{peak}} = 2.56 \;\Longrightarrow\; z_{\mathrm{peak}} = 3.62\sqrt{\frac{KR}{G}}\left(\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+2\right)\left(\frac{1}{Ro}+(1-n)\right)\right)^{-0.25}. \tag*{(36)}

For large Rossby number, this simplifies further to

zpeak=3.04KRG1−n.(37)z_{\mathrm{peak}} = 3.04\sqrt{\frac{KR}{G\sqrt{1-n}}}. \tag*{(37)}

The dependence of the height of the peak from 37 is also seen in Figure 4 and Figure 5. As KK and RR increase, the height of the peak tangential velocity increases. Whereas as GG increases, the height of the peak decreases slightly. The sensitivity of the depth appears to be greater for KK and RR because they have a much broader range of physical values than does GG. The coefficient 3.04 is larger than the coefficient 0.93 obtained earlier, indicating that the peak inflow occurs at a lower height than that of the velocity magnitude. This is consistent with the solution to the Ekman layer.

Substituting 37 in 35 gives us a maximum dimensional velocity magnitude of 1.0528 GG. Notice that this value depends only on the gradient wind magnitude. Thus, while the height at which the peak occurs is dependent on the viscosity, radius etc., the percentage supergradient predicted by this analysis, i.e. 5.28%, is a constant. The existing literature largely focuses on the radius of maximum wind (RMW) within the eyewall, where much higher supergradient values are reported (e.g., Kepert and Wang, [11]). We emphasize that our analysis is constrained to the region outside the eyewall. Despite this different focus, the value we obtain, 5.28%, still falls within the range of supergradient values reported in some of these studies (e.g., Yang et al., 2021).

Summary and Conclusions

This work has presented approximate solutions to the nonlinear equations describing the vertical structure of the horizontal velocity profiles in the HBL under constant and linearly varying gradient wind. The formulation is based on a series-expansion approach and it has been shown that including a first-order correction to the linear leading order solution increases the accuracy of the model while retaining a relatively simple form. The solution has been compared against a linear counterpart and a corresponding “exact” numerical solution across a range of realistic values of the input parameters in both normalized and dimensional form. Velocities were scaled with gradient wind speed GG and vertical coordinate zz was scaled with 2K/I\sqrt{2K/I}, following Kepert [9]. We found that 2K/I\sqrt{2K/I} remains a robust choice of scaling for zz even when accounting for the nonlinear terms in the governing equations, further corroborating findings from the numerical study of Foster [8].

It was shown that nonlinear terms cause a switch in the stable solution from a physical one, where uˉθ→G\bar{u}_\theta\to G aloft, to a nonphysical one where uˉθ→−G(1+1/Ro)\bar{u}_\theta\to-G(1 + 1/Ro). Thus, care must be taken when prescribing nn, so that the solution to the equations retains physical tendencies. This also prompts a closer look at the modeling assumption ∂v/∂r≈−nVg/R\partial v/\partial r \approx-nV_g/R. A better approximation to this radial derivative as a function of zz (for example, ∂v/∂r≈−nv/R\partial v/\partial r \approx-nv/R) instead of a constant or linear function throughout the height of the boundary layer could yield an approximation that is closer to reality.

From a wind profiles perspective, the non-dimensional first order solution exhibits a reduced peak velocity magnitude and more elevated jets when compared to its leading-order counterpart. In normalized form, the parameter RoRo was found to have a negligible impact on the velocity profiles. In dimensional form, the solution was found, as expected, to be sensitive to variations in GG, RR and KK and insensitive to variations in ff. These were used to show that both the height of inflow and tangential velocity peak in both the linear and nonlinear solutions follow a KR/G\sqrt{KR/G} dependence. The parameter nn, along with its role in controlling the convergence of the analytical solution, was found to primarily control the inflow profile. It however does not have a significant effect on the tangential velocity and velocity magnitude. Building on this lack of sensitivity to variations in RoRo and nn, a simple alternative expression was proposed to describe the velocity magnitude profile. This simplified expression provides insight into the dependence of the jet height and magnitude on the various parameters and shows that the peak jet magnitude is 5.28% supergradient.

In summary, the proposed series solution provides a nuanced yet still conceptually simple description of velocity profiles in the HBL and associated sensitivities, accounting for the impact of non-linear terms. Although valid only away from the eyewall and under the assumption of constant eddy viscosity, this formulation serves as a foundation for developing operational models that capture the correct sensitivities of the hurricane boundary layer profile.

Acknowledgements

This research was funded by the National Institute of Standards and Technology (ror.org/05xpvk416) under Grant No. 70NANB22H057. A special thanks to Dr. Jaeyoung Jung, Postdoctoral Scholar, Columbia University for his help with the numerical ODE solver.

Appendices

Governing Equations

The Navier Stokes equations in cylindrical coordinates, in a reference frame rotating with the Earth and moving with the hurricane are

∂ur∂t+ur∂ur∂r+uθr∂ur∂θ+uz∂ur∂z−uθ2r=−1ρ∂P∂r+fuθ+Dνm,r(38)\frac{\partial u_r}{\partial t}+u_r\frac{\partial u_r}{\partial r}+\frac{u_\theta}{r}\frac{\partial u_r}{\partial\theta}+u_z\frac{\partial u_r}{\partial z}-\frac{u_\theta^2}{r}=-\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial P}{\partial r}+fu_\theta+D_{\nu m,r} \tag*{(38)}
∂uθ∂t+ur∂uθ∂r+uθr∂uθ∂θ+uz∂uθ∂z+uruθr=−1rρ∂P∂θ−fur+Dνm,θ(39)\frac{\partial u_\theta}{\partial t}+u_r\frac{\partial u_\theta}{\partial r}+\frac{u_\theta}{r}\frac{\partial u_\theta}{\partial\theta}+u_z\frac{\partial u_\theta}{\partial z}+\frac{u_ru_\theta}{r}=-\frac{1}{r\rho}\frac{\partial P}{\partial\theta}-fu_r+D_{\nu m,\theta} \tag*{(39)}
∂uz∂t+ur∂uz∂r+uθr∂uz∂θ+uz∂uz∂z=−1ρ∂P∂z+Dνm,z(40)\frac{\partial u_z}{\partial t}+u_r\frac{\partial u_z}{\partial r}+\frac{u_\theta}{r}\frac{\partial u_z}{\partial\theta}+u_z\frac{\partial u_z}{\partial z}=-\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial P}{\partial z}+D_{\nu m,z} \tag*{(40)}

where the terms DνmD_{\nu m} represent molecular diffusion.

The continuity equation in cylindrical coordinates is

∂ur∂r+urr+1r∂uθ∂θ+∂uz∂z=0.(41)\frac{\partial u_r}{\partial r}+\frac{u_r}{r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial u_\theta}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial u_z}{\partial z}=0 . \tag*{(41)}

Multiplying the continuity equation (41) by uru_r and adding to the radial momentum equation (38)}, by $u_\theta$ and adding to (39)}, and by uzu_z and adding to (40)}, we obtain

∂ur∂t+∂(urur)∂r+1r∂(uruθ)∂θ+∂(uruz)∂z+ur2r=−1ρ∂P∂r+uθ2r+fuθ+Dνm,r,(42)\frac{\partial u_r}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial(u_ru_r)}{\partial r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial(u_ru_\theta)}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial(u_ru_z)}{\partial z}+\frac{u_r^2}{r}=-\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial P}{\partial r}+\frac{u_\theta^2}{r}+fu_\theta+D_{\nu m,r}, \tag*{(42)}
∂uθ∂t+∂(uruθ)∂r+1r∂(uθuθ)∂θ+∂(uzuθ)∂z+uruθr=−1rρ∂P∂θ−uruθr−fur+Dνm,θ,(43)\frac{\partial u_\theta}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial(u_ru_\theta)}{\partial r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial(u_\theta u_\theta)}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial(u_zu_\theta)}{\partial z}+\frac{u_ru_\theta}{r}=-\frac{1}{r\rho}\frac{\partial P}{\partial\theta}-\frac{u_ru_\theta}{r}-fu_r+D_{\nu m,\theta}, \tag*{(43)}
∂uz∂t+∂(uruz)∂r+1r∂(uθuz)∂θ+∂(uzuz)∂z+uruzr=−1ρ∂P∂z+Dνm,z.(44)\frac{\partial u_z}{\partial t}+\frac{\partial(u_ru_z)}{\partial r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial(u_\theta u_z)}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial(u_zu_z)}{\partial z}+\frac{u_ru_z}{r}=-\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial P}{\partial z}+D_{\nu m,z}. \tag*{(44)}

Taking the time-average, we have

∂(urur‾)∂r+1r∂(uruθ‾)∂θ+∂(uruz‾)∂z+ur2‾r=−1ρ∂P‾∂r+uθ2‾r+fuθ‾+Dνm,r,(45)\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_r})}{\partial r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_\theta})}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_z})}{\partial z}+\frac{\overline{u_r^2}}{r}=-\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial\overline{P}}{\partial r}+\frac{\overline{u_\theta^2}}{r}+f\overline{u_\theta}+D_{\nu m,r}, \tag*{(45)}
∂(uruθ‾)∂r+1r∂(uθuθ‾)∂θ+∂(uzuθ‾)∂z+uruθ‾r=−1rρ∂P‾∂θ−uruθ‾r−fur‾+Dνm,θ,(46)\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_\theta})}{\partial r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial(\overline{u_\theta u_\theta})}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial(\overline{u_zu_\theta})}{\partial z}+\frac{\overline{u_ru_\theta}}{r}=-\frac{1}{r\rho}\frac{\partial\overline{P}}{\partial\theta}-\frac{\overline{u_ru_\theta}}{r}-f\overline{u_r}+D_{\nu m,\theta}, \tag*{(46)}
∂(uruz‾)∂r+1r∂(uθuz‾)∂θ+∂(uzuz‾)∂z+uruz‾r=−1ρ∂P‾∂z+Dνm,z.(47)\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_z})}{\partial r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial(\overline{u_\theta u_z})}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial(\overline{u_zu_z})}{\partial z}+\frac{\overline{u_ru_z}}{r}=-\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial\overline{P}}{\partial z}+D_{\nu m,z}. \tag*{(47)}

The vertical momentum equation does not hold much physical significance far from the eyewall, so it can be ignored for this analysis.

The gradient wind balance is expected to hold in the radial direction. Also, no average pressure gradient is expected in the azimuthal direction. That is,

1ρ∂P‾∂r=Vg2r+fVg,(48)\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial\overline{P}}{\partial r}=\frac{V_g^2}{r}+fV_g, \tag*{(48)}
1ρ∂P‾∂θ=0.(49)\frac{1}{\rho}\frac{\partial\overline{P}}{\partial\theta}=0 . \tag*{(49)}

Substituting, we get

∂(urur‾)∂r+1r∂(uruθ‾)∂θ+∂(uruz‾)∂z+ur2‾r=−(Vg2r+fVg)+uθ2‾r+fuθ‾+Dνm,r,(50)\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_r})}{\partial r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_\theta})}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_z})}{\partial z}+\frac{\overline{u_r^2}}{r}=-\left(\frac{V_g^2}{r}+fV_g\right)+\frac{\overline{u_\theta^2}}{r}+f\overline{u_\theta}+D_{\nu m,r}, \tag*{(50)}
∂(uruθ‾)∂r+1r∂(uθuθ‾)∂θ+∂(uzuθ‾)∂z+uruθ‾r=−uruθ‾r−fur‾+Dνm,θ.(51)\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_\theta})}{\partial r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial(\overline{u_\theta u_\theta})}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial(\overline{u_zu_\theta})}{\partial z}+\frac{\overline{u_ru_\theta}}{r}=-\frac{\overline{u_ru_\theta}}{r}-f\overline{u_r}+D_{\nu m,\theta}. \tag*{(51)}

The azimuthal direction can be considered statistically homogeneous. Hence

∂(urur‾)∂r+∂(uruz‾)∂z+ur2‾r=−(Vg2r+fVg)+uθ2‾r+fuθ‾+Dνm,r,(52)\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_r})}{\partial r}+\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_z})}{\partial z}+\frac{\overline{u_r^2}}{r}=-\left(\frac{V_g^2}{r}+fV_g\right)+\frac{\overline{u_\theta^2}}{r}+f\overline{u_\theta}+D_{\nu m,r}, \tag*{(52)}
∂(uruθ‾)∂r+∂(uzuθ‾)∂z+uruθ‾r=−uruθ‾r−fur‾+Dνm,θ.(53)\frac{\partial(\overline{u_ru_\theta})}{\partial r}+\frac{\partial(\overline{u_zu_\theta})}{\partial z}+\frac{\overline{u_ru_\theta}}{r}=-\frac{\overline{u_ru_\theta}}{r}-f\overline{u_r}+D_{\nu m,\theta}. \tag*{(53)}

Far from the eyewall, the average vertical velocity uz‾≈0\overline{u_z} \approx0. Thus

uruz‾≈ur′uz′‾,uθuz‾≈uθ′uz′‾.(54)\overline{u_r u_z} \approx\overline{u'_r u'_z}, \qquad\overline{u_\theta u_z} \approx\overline{u'_\theta u'_z}. \tag*{(54)}

Additionally, the following assumption is made

urur‾≈ur‾ur‾,uθur‾≈uθ‾ur‾,uθuθ‾≈uθ‾uθ‾.(55)\overline{u_r u_r} \approx\overline{u_r}\overline{u_r}, \qquad\overline{u_\theta u_r} \approx\overline{u_\theta}\overline{u_r}, \qquad\overline{u_\theta u_\theta} \approx\overline{u_\theta}\overline{u_\theta}. \tag*{(55)}

This assumption might break down close to the surface. But close to the surface (and sufficiently far from the eyewall) it is also known that the velocity profiles follow the log-law (Powell et al., 2003; Smith and Montgomery, 2014). Future versions of this procedure that account for variable-eddy viscosity could simply adjust the eddy viscosity so that the velocity follows the log-law near the wall. The equations become

2ur‾∂ur‾∂r+∂ur′uz′‾∂z+ur‾ 2r=−(Vg 2r+fVg)+uθ‾ 2r+fuθ‾+Dνm,r,(56)2\overline{u_r}\frac{\partial\overline{u_r}}{\partial r}+\frac{\partial\overline{u'_r u'_z}}{\partial z}+\frac{\overline{u_r}^{\,2}}{r}=-\left(\frac{V_g^{\,2}}{r}+fV_g\right)+\frac{\overline{u_\theta}^{\,2}}{r}+f\overline{u_\theta}+D_{\nu_m,r}, \tag*{(56)}
uθ‾∂ur‾∂r+ur‾∂uθ‾∂r+∂ur′uθ′‾∂z+2ur‾uθ‾r=−fur‾+Dνm,θ.(57)\overline{u_\theta}\frac{\partial\overline{u_r}}{\partial r}+\overline{u_r}\frac{\partial\overline{u_\theta}}{\partial r}+\frac{\partial\overline{u'_r u'_\theta}}{\partial z}+2\frac{\overline{u_r}\overline{u_\theta}}{r}=-f\overline{u_r}+D_{\nu_m,\theta}. \tag*{(57)}

We now require modelling assumptions for ∂uθ‾/∂r\partial\overline{u_\theta}/\partial r and ∂ur‾/∂r\partial\overline{u_r}/\partial r. We follow Bryan et al. [2] here. Assume that, far aloft, the tangential velocity varies radially through a power law

uθ‾(r)=Vmax⁡(rrmax⁡)−n,(58)\overline{u_\theta}(r)=V_{\max}\left(\frac{r}{r_{\max}}\right)^{-n}, \tag*{(58)}

where Vmax⁡V_{\max} and rmax⁡r_{\max} correspond to a tangential velocity and radial distance within the eyewall. Differentiating, we get

duθ‾dr(r)=−nVmax⁡r(rrmax⁡)−n.(59)\frac{\mathrm{d}\overline{u_\theta}}{\mathrm{d}r}(r)=-\frac{nV_{\max}}{r}\left(\frac{r}{r_{\max}}\right)^{-n}. \tag*{(59)}

Far aloft, uθ‾(r)=Vg\overline{u_\theta}(r)=V_g. If it is assumed that this radial variation holds throughout the depth of the HBL, then

∂uθ‾∂r(r,z)≈−nVgr.(60)\frac{\partial\overline{u_\theta}}{\partial r}(r,z)\approx-n\frac{V_g}{r}. \tag*{(60)}

To model the term ∂ur‾/∂r\partial\overline{u_r}/\partial r, take the time-average of the continuity equation.

∂ur‾∂r+ur‾r+1r∂uθ‾∂θ+∂uz‾∂z=0.(61)\frac{\partial\overline{u_r}}{\partial r}+\frac{\overline{u_r}}{r}+\frac{1}{r}\frac{\partial\overline{u_\theta}}{\partial\theta}+\frac{\partial\overline{u_z}}{\partial z}=0. \tag*{(61)}

By statistical homogeneity, ∂uθ‾/∂θ=0\partial\overline{u_\theta}/\partial\theta=0. Far from the eyewall, the effect of vertical velocity can also be neglected. Hence

∂ur‾∂r=−ur‾r.(62)\frac{\partial\overline{u_r}}{\partial r}=-\frac{\overline{u_r}}{r}. \tag*{(62)}

Substituting for ∂uθ‾/∂r\partial\overline{u_\theta}/\partial r and ∂ur‾/∂r\partial\overline{u_r}/\partial r, we have

∂ur′uz′‾∂z=−(Vg 2r+fVg)+uθ‾ 2r+ur‾ 2r+fuθ‾+Dνm,r,(63)\frac{\partial\overline{u'_r u'_z}}{\partial z}=-\left(\frac{V_g^{\,2}}{r}+fV_g\right)+\frac{\overline{u_\theta}^{\,2}}{r}+\frac{\overline{u_r}^{\,2}}{r}+f\overline{u_\theta}+D_{\nu_m,r}, \tag*{(63)}
∂ur′uθ′‾∂z=−uruθ‾r−fur‾+nur‾Vgr+Dνm,θ.(64)\frac{\partial\overline{u'_r u'_\theta}}{\partial z}=-\frac{\overline{u_r u_\theta}}{r}-f\overline{u_r}+n\overline{u_r}\frac{V_g}{r}+D_{\nu m,\theta}. \tag*{(64)}

Model the turbulent stresses using a Boussinesq assumption (and absorb the viscous stresses into these). At a specific radial distance r=Rr=R

∂∂z(K∂ur‾∂z)=(Vg2R+fVg)−uθ2‾R−ur2‾R−fuθ‾,(65)\frac{\partial}{\partial z}\left(K\frac{\partial\overline{u_r}}{\partial z}\right)=\left(\frac{V_g^2}{R}+fV_g\right)-\frac{\overline{u_\theta^2}}{R}-\frac{\overline{u_r^2}}{R}-f\overline{u_\theta}, \tag*{(65)}
∂∂z(K∂uθ‾∂z)=uruθ‾R+fur‾−nur‾VgR.(66)\frac{\partial}{\partial z}\left(K\frac{\partial\overline{u_\theta}}{\partial z}\right)=\frac{\overline{u_r u_\theta}}{R}+f\overline{u_r}-n\overline{u_r}\frac{V_g}{R}. \tag*{(66)}

This is a system of two equations has two unknowns ur‾\overline{u_r} and uθ‾\overline{u_\theta}, which are functions only of the vertical coordinate zz. The equations to be solved are thus

ddz(Kdur‾dz)=(Vg2R+fVg)−uθ2‾R−ur2‾R−fuθ‾(67)\frac{d}{dz}\left(K\frac{d\overline{u_r}}{dz}\right)=\left(\frac{V_g^2}{R}+fV_g\right)-\frac{\overline{u_\theta^2}}{R}-\frac{\overline{u_r^2}}{R}-f\overline{u_\theta} \tag*{(67)}
ddz(Kduθ‾dz)=uruθ‾R+fur‾−nur‾VgR(68)\frac{d}{dz}\left(K\frac{d\overline{u_\theta}}{dz}\right)=\frac{\overline{u_r u_\theta}}{R}+f\overline{u_r}-n\overline{u_r}\frac{V_g}{R} \tag*{(68)}

Numerical solver

To solve the system of ordinary differential equations numerically, we use a finite difference based solver. A pseudo-time term is added and time marching is performed with a 3rd3^{\mathrm{rd}} order Runge-Kutta method. We use a domain size from ξ=0\xi=0 to ξ=10\xi=10 and 200 grid points to discretize the domain. The initial condition is set to be the linear solution

uinitial=−α~2e−ξsin⁡(ξ),(69)u_{\mathrm{initial}}=-\frac{\tilde{\alpha}}{2}e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi), \tag*{(69)}
vinitial=−e−ξcos⁡(ξ)+G‾zξ.(70)v_{\mathrm{initial}}=-e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi)+\overline{G}_z\xi. \tag*{(70)}

First and second derivatives are based on 5th5^{\mathrm{th}} and 6th6^{\mathrm{th}} order WENO schemes respectively. The WENO based derivatives are capable of capturing sharp gradients and offers greater numerical stability compared to simpler finite differences based derivatives. This is especially useful here since there is a significant deviation of the steady state solution for large nn from the initial condition, which caused a divergence of the solution when the simpler finite differences based derivatives were used.

Figure 9 shows snapshots at every 2750 steps of pseudo-time of the solution of case 3 of Table 1. We notice that, first, the nonlinearities tend to make the gradient of the tangential velocity near the bottom boundary less steep. Once the curve becomes approximately perpendicular to the boundary (Figure 9c), there is a sharp switch of the tangential velocity curve to the other stable solution (cf. (11)). This behaviour where the nonlinearities tend to make the gradient of the tangential velocity near the ground smaller is also seen in cases without a switch of solution (Figure 2). This also suggests that the critical value of nn could be that for which the slope of the tangential velocity solution is exactly zero at the ground.

Snapshots from the pseudo-time evolution of the numerical solution

Figure 9. Snapshots from the pseudo-time evolution of the numerical solution of case 3 of Table 1. Dot-dashed lines are uu and solid lines are 1+v1+v.

The nn for which the switch in solution is seen can be postponed if the velocity gradient near the ground is forced to be larger. This could be due, for example, to a variable eddy viscosity or a slip boundary condition. Consider the eddy viscosity profile

K(z)=0.4z(1−zL)4.(71)K(z) = 0.4z\left(1-\frac{z}{L}\right)^4 . \tag*{(71)}

Figure 10(a) shows the numerical solution to (1) and (2) with n=0.6n=0.6 and using K(ξ)K(\xi) from (71) (with L=3000L=3000 m) instead of a constant value. The values of the other constants are those specified in Table 2. We see that even for n=0.6n=0.6, the profiles continue to be physical. If we push to a larger value of nn, the switch in solution is seen again, through a similar mechanism as in Figure 9. By trial and error, the transitional value of n≈0.67n\approx0.67. Figure 10(b) plots the numerical solution to (1)

and (2) again with n=0.6n=0.6, but using a slip boundary condition at the ground instead of a no-slip condition, as in Kepert [9]. Once again the profiles remain physical. The switch occurs for n≳0.69n\gtrsim0.69. If we choose a larger value of C=0.02C=0.02, the switch is seen at a smaller value of n≈0.55n\approx0.55.

Appendix 3: Extension to linearly varying gradient wind

Consider a linearly varying gradient wind

Vg=G+zGz(72)V_g = G + zG_z \tag*{(72)}

where Gz<0G_z < 0. To incorporate the tendency of vv to VgV_g above the inflow layer, we change the boundary conditions to

uˉr(z=0)=0,uˉθ(z=0)=0,duˉrdz∣z→∞=0,duˉθdz∣z→∞=Gz.(73)\bar{u}_r(z=0)=0,\qquad\bar{u}_\theta(z=0)=0,\qquad\left.\frac{d\bar{u}_r}{dz}\right|_{z\to\infty}=0,\qquad\left.\frac{d\bar{u}_\theta}{dz}\right|_{z\to\infty}=G_z. \tag*{(73)}

Substituting (72) in (1) and (2), and following the same steps for variable changes and non-dimensionalization, the equations become

∂2u∂ξ2=−α~v−γ~(u2+v2)+(α~G~z)ξ+(γ~G~z2)ξ2,(74)\frac{\partial^2u}{\partial\xi^2}=-\tilde{\alpha}v-\tilde{\gamma}(u^2+v^2)+(\tilde{\alpha}\tilde{G}_z)\xi+(\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{G}_z^2)\xi^2, \tag*{(74)}
∂2v∂ξ2=β~u+γ~uv−(γ~G~zn)uξ,(75)\frac{\partial^2v}{\partial\xi^2}=\tilde{\beta}u+\tilde{\gamma}uv-(\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{G}_z n)u\xi, \tag*{(75)}

and the boundary conditions become

u(ξ=0)=0,v(ξ=0)=−1,dudξ∣ξ→∞=0,dvdξ∣ξ→∞=G~z(76)u(\xi=0)=0,\qquad v(\xi=0)=-1,\qquad\left.\frac{du}{d\xi}\right|_{\xi\to\infty}=0,\qquad\left.\frac{dv}{d\xi}\right|_{\xi\to\infty}=\tilde{G}_z \tag*{(76)}

where G~z=GzH/G\tilde{G}_z=G_zH/G is the non-dimensional slope of gradient wind. G~z\tilde{G}_z is now an additional non-dimensional parameter in the governing equations.

Including the artificial small parameter δ\delta as in § 4, the governing equations become

∂2u∂ξ2=−α~v+(α~G~z)ξ−δ(γ~(u2+v2)−(γ~G~z2)ξ2),(77)\frac{\partial^2u}{\partial\xi^2}=-\tilde{\alpha}v+(\tilde{\alpha}\tilde{G}_z)\xi-\delta\left(\tilde{\gamma}(u^2+v^2)-(\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{G}_z^2)\xi^2\right), \tag*{(77)}
∂2v∂ξ2=β~u+δ(γ~uv−(γ~G~zn)uξ).(78)\frac{\partial^2v}{\partial\xi^2}=\tilde{\beta}u+\delta\left(\tilde{\gamma}uv-(\tilde{\gamma}\tilde{G}_z n)u\xi\right). \tag*{(78)}

Expanding the solution using the asymptotic series 15 results in the following systems of equations at the first few orders. The leading order reads

∂2u0∂ξ2=−α~v0+(α~G~z)ξ,(79)\frac{\partial^2u_0}{\partial\xi^2}=-\tilde{\alpha}v_0+(\tilde{\alpha}\tilde{G}_z)\xi, \tag*{(79)}
∂2v0∂ξ2=β~u0,(80)\frac{\partial^2v_0}{\partial\xi^2}=\tilde{\beta}u_0, \tag*{(80)}

with boundary conditions u0(0)=u0′(∞)=0u_0(0)=u'_0(\infty)=0, v0(0)=−1v_0(0)=-1, v0′(∞)=G~zv'_0(\infty)=\tilde{G}_z. The first order correction is

∂2u1∂ξ2=−α~v1−γ~(u02+v02−G~z2ξ2),(81)\frac{\partial^2u_1}{\partial\xi^2}=-\tilde{\alpha}v_1-\tilde{\gamma}\left(u_0^2+v_0^2-\tilde{G}_z^2\xi^2\right), \tag*{(81)}
∂2v1∂ξ2=β~u1+γ~(u0v0−G~znξu0).(82)\frac{\partial^2v_1}{\partial\xi^2}=\tilde{\beta}u_1+\tilde{\gamma}\left(u_0v_0-\tilde{G}_z n\xi u_0\right). \tag*{(82)}

with boundary conditions u1(0)=u1′(∞)=v1(0)=v1′(∞)=0u_1(0)=u'_1(\infty)=v_1(0)=v'_1(\infty)=0. The second order correction reads

∂2u2∂ξ2=−α~v2−γ~(2u0u1+2v0v1),(83)\frac{\partial^2 u_2}{\partial\xi^2}=-\widetilde{\alpha}v_2-\widetilde{\gamma}(2u_0u_1+2v_0v_1), \tag*{(83)}
∂2v2∂ξ2=β~u2+γ~(u0v1+u1v0−G~znξu1),(84)\frac{\partial^2 v_2}{\partial\xi^2}=\widetilde{\beta}u_2+\widetilde{\gamma}(u_0v_1+u_1v_0-\widetilde{G}_z n\xi u_1), \tag*{(84)}

with the same boundary conditions as for the first order problem. These equations contain additional non-homogeneous terms which are products of polynomial terms {ξ,ξ2,…}\{\xi,\xi^2,\ldots\} and the terms {exp⁡(−ξ)cos⁡(ξ),exp⁡(−ξ)sin⁡(ξ),…}\{\exp(-\xi)\cos(\xi),\exp(-\xi)\sin(\xi),\ldots\}. This calls for a larger set of basis functions in our ansatz, namely

{1,ξ,ξ2}×{1,e−ξ,e−2ξ}×{1,cos⁡(ξ),sin⁡(ξ),cos⁡(2ξ),sin⁡(2ξ)}.(85)\{1,\xi,\xi^2\}\times\{1,e^{-\xi},e^{-2\xi}\}\times\{1,\cos(\xi),\sin(\xi),\cos(2\xi),\sin(2\xi)\}. \tag*{(85)}

Substituting the ansatz and solving for the coefficients readily results in the following leading-order solution

u0=−α~2e−ξsin⁡(ξ),(86)u_0=-\frac{\widetilde{\alpha}}{2}e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi), \tag*{(86)}
v0=−e−ξcos⁡(ξ)+G~zξ,(87)v_0=-e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi)+\widetilde{G}_z\xi, \tag*{(87)}

and first-order correction

u1(ξ)=γ~10(α~24+1)e−ξcos⁡(ξ)+γ~30e−ξsin⁡(ξ)−γ~10(α~24+1)e−2ξ+γ~30(−38α~2+2)e−2ξsin⁡(2ξ)+G~zγ~α~28(1−n)ξe−ξsin⁡(ξ),(88)\begin{aligned} u_1(\xi)={}&\frac{\widetilde{\gamma}}{10}\left(\frac{\widetilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi)+\frac{\widetilde{\gamma}}{30}e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi)\\ &-\frac{\widetilde{\gamma}}{10}\left(\frac{\widetilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-2\xi}+\frac{\widetilde{\gamma}}{30}\left(-\frac{3}{8}\widetilde{\alpha}^2+2\right)e^{-2\xi}\sin(2\xi)\\ &+\frac{\widetilde{G}_z\widetilde{\gamma}\widetilde{\alpha}^2}{8}(1-n)\xi e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi), \tag*{(88)} \end{aligned}
v1(ξ)=γ~15α~e−ξcos⁡(ξ)−γ~5α~(α~24+1)e−ξsin⁡(ξ)−γ~10α~(α~24+1)e−2ξ+γ~30α~(3α~24+1)e−2ξcos⁡(2ξ).(89)\begin{aligned} v_1(\xi)={}&\frac{\widetilde{\gamma}}{15\widetilde{\alpha}}e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi)-\frac{\widetilde{\gamma}}{5\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(\frac{\widetilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi)\\ &-\frac{\widetilde{\gamma}}{10\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(\frac{\widetilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-2\xi}+\frac{\widetilde{\gamma}}{30\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(\frac{3\widetilde{\alpha}^2}{4}+1\right)e^{-2\xi}\cos(2\xi). \tag*{(89)} \end{aligned}

Higher order solutions can similarly be obtained. We observe that there is no term involving G~z\widetilde{G}_z in v1v_1. Even the term involving G~z\widetilde{G}_z in u1u_1 is quite small compared to the other terms and almost no difference is seen in a plot where the term is ignored (not shown). Hence one can sufficiently incorporate the effect of G~z\widetilde{G}_z with just the term G~zξ\widetilde{G}_z\xi in v0v_0 and safely ignore its presence in the corrections.

Due to limited observational data, there are very few numerical values reported in the literature for GzG_z. Here, we choose a representative value to be that used in Bryan et al. [2], i.e., a decrease of the gradient wind speed of 40 m s−1^{-1} over 18 km. Assuming this GzG_z is for R=50R=50 km and K=50K=50 m2^2 s−1^{-1} gives H=250H=250 m. Hence G~z=250/18000=0.014\widetilde{G}_z=250/18000=0.014.

Figure 11 shows the comparison between the numerical and analytical solutions for Cases 2 and 4 in Table 2, and with G~z=0.014\widetilde{G}_z=0.014. We observe, as before, that the solution converges well for relatively smaller nn, whereas the convergence is slower as nn approaches the limiting value n≈0.5n\approx0.5. The solution again diverges for larger nn, with the limit n≈0.5n\approx0.5 not appearing to be affected by the specific value of G~z\widetilde{G}_z (not shown).

Image not extracted

Figure 11. Cases 1 and 2 from Table 1, with G~z=0.014\widetilde{G}_z = 0.014.

Appendix 4: Higher order approximation solution forms

The second order corrections are

u2(ξ)=γ~2(e−ξcos⁡(ξ)25600α~(25α~4+98α~2+688)−e−ξsin⁡(ξ)115200α~(135α~4+210α~2+368)+e−2ξ300α~(α~2+4)+e−2ξcos⁡(2ξ)240α~(3α~4−4α~2−64)+e−2ξsin⁡(2ξ)1800α~(3α~2−16)−e−3ξcos⁡(ξ)76800α~(171α~4+422α~2+1040)−e−3ξsin⁡(ξ)25600α~(39α~4+198α~2+240)−e−3ξsin⁡(3ξ)76800α~(27α~4−26α~2+144)),(90)u_2(\xi)=\widetilde{\gamma}^{2}\left(\frac{e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi)}{25600\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(25\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}+98\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+688\right)-\frac{e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi)}{115200\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(135\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}+210\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+368\right) +\frac{e^{-2\xi}}{300\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+4\right)+\frac{e^{-2\xi}\cos(2\xi)}{240\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(3\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}-4\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}-64\right)+\frac{e^{-2\xi}\sin(2\xi)}{1800\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(3\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}-16\right) -\frac{e^{-3\xi}\cos(\xi)}{76800\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(171\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}+422\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+1040\right)-\frac{e^{-3\xi}\sin(\xi)}{25600\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(39\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}+198\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+240\right) -\frac{e^{-3\xi}\sin(3\xi)}{76800\widetilde{\alpha}}\left(27\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}-26\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+144\right)\right), \tag*{(90)}
v2(ξ)=γ~2(e−ξcos⁡(ξ)115200α~2(270α~4+420α~2+736)+e−ξsin⁡(ξ)25600α~2(50α~4+196α~2+1376)+e−2ξ300α~2(α~2+4)−e−2ξcos⁡(2ξ)900α~2(3α~2+4)+e−2ξsin⁡(2ξ)1200α~2(3α~4+16α~2+16)−e−3ξcos⁡(ξ)76800α~2(186α~4+452α~2−160)−e−3ξsin⁡(ξ)25600α~2(14α~4−132α~2+160)−e−3ξcos⁡(3ξ)76800α~2(6α~4+172α~2+32)).(91)v_2(\xi)=\widetilde{\gamma}^{2}\left(\frac{e^{-\xi}\cos(\xi)}{115200\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}}\left(270\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}+420\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+736\right)+\frac{e^{-\xi}\sin(\xi)}{25600\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}}\left(50\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}+196\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+1376\right) +\frac{e^{-2\xi}}{300\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}}\left(\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+4\right)-\frac{e^{-2\xi}\cos(2\xi)}{900\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}}\left(3\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+4\right)+\frac{e^{-2\xi}\sin(2\xi)}{1200\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}}\left(3\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}+16\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+16\right) -\frac{e^{-3\xi}\cos(\xi)}{76800\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}}\left(186\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}+452\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}-160\right)-\frac{e^{-3\xi}\sin(\xi)}{25600\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}}\left(14\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}-132\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+160\right) -\frac{e^{-3\xi}\cos(3\xi)}{76800\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}}\left(6\widetilde{\alpha}^{4}+172\widetilde{\alpha}^{2}+32\right)\right). \tag*{(91)}

Higher order corrections are similarly obtained, but involve many more cross terms.

References

  1. [1]Bryan GH, Dahl NA, Nolan DS, Rotunno R (2017a) An eddy injection method for large-eddy simulations of tornado-like vortices. Monthly Weather Review 145:1937–1961
  2. [2]Bryan GH, Worsnop RP, Lundquist JK, Zhang JA (2017b) A simple method for simulating wind profiles in the boundary layer of tropical cyclones. Boundary-Layer Meteorology 162:475–502DOI
  3. [3]Chang Y, Wang J, Li S, Chan P (2024) A comprehensive review on the modeling of tropical cyclone boundary layer wind field. Physics of Fluids 36DOI
  4. [4]Chen X, Bryan GH, Zhang JA, Cione JJ, Marks FD (2021) A framework for simulating the tropical cyclone boundary layer using large-eddy simulation and its use in evaluating pbl parameterizations. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences 78:3559–3574DOI
  5. [5]Cione JJ, Bryan GH, Dobosy R, Zhang JA, de Boer G, Aksoy A, Wadler JB, Kalina EA, Dahl BA, Ryan K, et al. (2020) Eye of the storm: Observing hurricanes with a small unmanned aircraft system. Bulletin of the American Meteorological Society 101:E186–E205DOI
  6. [6]Eliassen A, Lystad M (1977) The ekman layer of a circular vortex-a numerical and theoretical study. Geophysica Norvegica 31:1–16
  7. [8]Foster RC (2009) Boundary-layer similarity under an axisymmetric, gradient wind vortex. Boundary-Layer Meteorology 131:321–344DOI
  8. [9]Kepert J (2001) The dynamics of boundary layer jets within the tropical cyclone core. part i: Linear theory. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences 58:2469–2484doi.org/10.1175/1520-0469(2001)058<2469:tdoblj>2.0.co;2
  9. [10]Kepert J (2010) Slab-and height-resolving models of the tropical cyclone boundary layer. part i: Comparing the simulations. Quarterly Journal of the Royal Meteorological Society 136:1686–1699DOI
  10. [11]Kepert J, Wang Y (2001) The dynamics of boundary layer jets within the tropical cyclone core. part ii: Nonlinear enhancement. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences 58:2485–2501doi.org/10.1175/1520-0469(2001)058<2485:tdoblj>2.0.co;2
  11. [12]Ma T, Sun C (2021) Large eddy simulation of hurricane boundary layer turbulence and its application for power transmission system. Journal of Wind Engineering and Industrial Aerodynamics 210:104,520DOI
  12. [13]Mallen KJ, Montgomery MT, Wang B (2005) Reexamining the near-core radial structure of the tropical cyclone primary circulation: Implications for vortex resiliency. Journal of the Atmospheric Sciences 62:408–425DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_8n7tu3h5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents