betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Highly Tunable Band Inversion in AB2X4 (A=Ge, Sn, Pb; B=As, Sb, Bi; X=Se, Te) Compounds

Abstract

Topological materials have been discovered so far largely by searching for existing compounds in crystallographic databases, but there are potentially new topological materials with desirable features that have not been synthesized. One of the desirable features is high tunability resulted from the band inversion with a very small direct band gap, which can be tuned by changes in pressure or strain to induce a topological phase transition. Using density functional theory (DFT) calculations, we have studied the septuple layered AB2X4 series compounds, where A=(Ge, Sn and Pb), B=(As, Sb and Bi) and X=(Se and Te). With the DFT thermodynamic stability validated by the already reported compounds in these series, we predict new stable Se compounds, which are not found in crystallographic database. Among them, we find that GeBi2Se4 and GeSb2Se4 having a small direct band gap at the Z point are very close to a strong topological insulator, which can be tuned by a moderate pressure to induce the band inversion. Importantly, the topological features with the small direct band gap are well isolated in both momentum and energy windows, which offers high tunability for studying the topological phase transition.

Introduction

Symmetry-protected topological states[1, 2, 3, 4] have greatly expanded our understanding of electronic band structures in condensed matter physics and materials science. With the development of new understanding in band structure topology from symmetry-based indicators and the related approaches[5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11], symmetry-protected topological features have been classified and topological materials have been tabulated in databases. Several groups have compiled catalogues[12, 13, 14, 15] of topological materials by searching crystallographic databases among existing compounds, calculating band structures and topological index. However, there are potentially new topologically non-trivial compounds that have not been synthesized or in crystallographic databases. Even more interesting is that such new compounds may bring new tunability and push the limits in topological features. One such limit is to find a topological insulator (TI) with a band gap larger than Bi2Se3\mathrm{Bi}_2\mathrm{Se}_3. But the other limit of a very small direct band gap is also interesting for the purpose of high tunability to induce topological phase transitions. ZrTe5\mathrm{ZrTe}_5 is a good example sitting near the phase boundary[16, 17] between a strong and weak TI with a critical Dirac point[18] in between, which can be tuned by pressure, strain, temperature and phonons. Weyl points and many other interesting properties[19, 20] can also be induced in ZrTe5\mathrm{ZrTe}_5. Thus, it is desirable to find more compounds sitting near the topological phase boundary to a normal insulator or another topological phase with the key features isolated in both energy and momentum windows for versatile control and manipulation.

One way to search for new topological materials is to look into the under-explored area in phase diagrams and combinations of elements. For the septuple layered AB2X4AB_2X_4 series, where A=(Ge,SnA=(\mathrm{Ge}, \mathrm{Sn} and Pb)\mathrm{Pb}) for group IV, B=(As,SbB=(\mathrm{As}, \mathrm{Sb} and Bi)\mathrm{Bi}) for group V and X=(Se,Te)X=(\mathrm{Se},\mathrm{Te}) for group VI elements, the Te compounds are well explored, while Se ones are not. Eremeev et al. (2016) have studied several 1-2-4 compounds and found most are STIs. For example, PbBi2Te4\mathrm{PbBi}_2\mathrm{Te}_4 has been reported[22] from angular-resolved photo-electron spectroscopy (ARPES) as a STI with a band inversion at the Z point of the Brillouin zone (BZ) boundary, in contrast to that at Γ\Gamma point of BZ center in the Bi2Te3\mathrm{Bi}_2\mathrm{Te}_3 series. More recently the magnetic version in this structure-type MnBi2Te4\mathrm{MnBi}_2\mathrm{Te}_4 series[23, 24, 25, 26, 27, 28, 29] have been discovered to be an intrinsic anti-ferromagnetic TI with the few layers hosting quantum anomalous Hall and axion insulator behaviors[30, 31]. In contrast, the Se compounds have been much less studied. Only very recently, MnBi2Se4\mathrm{MnBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} thin films[32] have been grown in molecular beam epitaxy. Se-Te alloyed septuple layered compounds have also been recently synthesized[33].

In this paper, using density functional theory (DFT) calculations with different exchange-correlation (XC) functionals, we systematically calculate the thermodynamic stability, electronic band structure and topological properties of both Te and Se compounds in AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4} series. Out of nine different cation combinations for Te compounds in this structure, seven have been reported, except for SnAs2Te4\mathrm{SnAs}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4} and PbAs2Te4\mathrm{PbAs}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4}, which we find are thermodynamically unstable with decomposition into two binary compounds in our DFT calculations, agreeing with experimental observations. In contrast, the only Se compounds that have been reported[34, 35] are SnBi2Se4\mathrm{SnBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} and PbBi2Se4\mathrm{PbBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}, with the latter being an alloy. Using these reported compounds to establish the predictability of the DFT calculations for phase stability, we find that eight of nine Se compounds are thermodynamically stable with respect to the decomposition into the binary compounds. Although with the modified Becke-Johnson[36] (mBJ) exchange potential to correction band gap, the band inversion in Se compounds is lifted, we find that two new stable Se compounds, GeBi2Se4\mathrm{GeBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} and GeSb2Se4\mathrm{GeSb}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}, are very close to a STI with a small direct band gap at the Z point. We predict that a moderate hydrostatic pressure, can induce the topological phase transition with the band inversion and a critical Dirac point at the Z point, such as 1.7 GPa for GeBi2Se4\mathrm{GeBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}. More importantly, these topological features are well isolated in both momentum and energy windows, which offers high tunability and clean Fermi surface for studying the topological phase transition.

Computational Methods

All density functional theory[37, 38] (DFT) calculations with spin-orbit coupling (SOC) have been performed with different XC functionals using a plane-wave basis set and projector augmented wave method, as implemented in the Vienna Ab-initio Simulation Package[39, 40] (VASP). Besides PBEsol[41], for van der Waals (vdW) interaction we have considered vdW density functional (vdW-DF) of optB86b[42]. We have also used the semi-empirical vdW parameter sets of D2[43], D3[44] and D3 with Becke-Johnson damping[45] (or D3BJ). We use a kinetic energy cutoff of 300 eV, Γ\Gamma-centered Monkhorst-Pack[46] (12×12×4)(12 \times12 \times4) kk-point mesh, and a Gaussian smearing of 0.05 eV. The ionic positions and unit cell vectors are fully relaxed with the remaining absolute force on each atom is less than 0.02 eV/Å. For a few cases with available experimental lattice parameters, ionic relaxation only has also been considered for comparison to the results from full relaxation. Using maximally localized Wannier functions[47, 48], tight-binding models have been constructed to reproduce closely the band structure including SOC within 1 eV of the Fermi level by using Group IV spsp, Group V and VI pp orbitals. The surface spectral functions have been calculated with the surface Green’s function methods[49, 50] as implemented in WannierTools[51].

Results and Discussion

Structural-energy prediction

AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4} in the rhombohedral GeAs2_{2}Te4_{4}-type (Pearson symbol hR21) crystal structure of space group 166 (R3‾mR\overline{3}m) and its first Brillouin zone (BZ) are shown in Figure 1(a), where AA=(Ge, Sn and Pb), BB=(As, Sb and Bi), and XX=(Se and Te), respectively. It has septuple layered units in the abab plane coupled weakly via vdW interaction along the (001) direction. Within each septuple unit, the stacking is XX-BB-XX-AA-XX-BB-XX, where A (group IV element) occupies the central, B (group V) and X (group VI) elements occupy the three outmost atomic layers. The two group VI sites are not equivalent. Group IV, V and VI elements have the nominal valence charge of +2, +3 and −2, respectively. Such structure belongs to a large group of rhombohedral and hexagonal vdW layered materials with charge balance for being narrow gap semiconductors, thermoelectrics and TIs.

Figure 1. (a) Crystal structure and Brillouin zone (BZ) of AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4} in the rhombohedral GeAs2_{2}Te4_{4}-type (hR21) of space group 166 (R3‾mR\overline{3}m). AA=(Ge, Sn and Pb) are in red, BB=(As, Sb and Bi) in purple and XX=(Se and Te) in brown spheres. High symmetry kk-points and those on (001) surface BZ are labeled. (b)-(f) DFT-calculated formation energy (EfE_{\mathrm{f}}) with different XC functional with SOC in eV per formula unit (f.u.) of AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4} with respect to binary AXAX and B2X3B_{2}X_{3} compounds. The dotted and dashed lines are for energy zero and that shifted to GeBi2_{2}Te4_{4} or PbSb2_{2}Te4_{4} as found stable in experiment, respectively.

The DFT-calculated formation energy (EfE_{\mathrm{f}}) in eV per formula unit (eV/f.u.) are plotted for AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4} with respect to binary AXAX and B2X3B_{2}X_{3} compounds in Figure 1(b)-(Figure 1f) for different XC functionals with SOC. The ground state crystal structures of the binary AXAX and B2X3B_{2}X_{3} compounds are listed in Table I. These binary compounds are also fully relaxed with the corresponding XC functionals for the EfE_{\mathrm{f}} calculation. Considering the deviation of DFT-calculated EfE_{\mathrm{f}} vs experimental values due to the limitation of XC functional, there is likely a shift of energy zero[52]. For example, in Figure 1(d) with D3+SOC, GeBi2_{2}Te4_{4} has EfE_{\mathrm{f}}=0.05 eV/f.u., but it was found stable in experiment. When the effective energy zero is shifted to that of GeBi2_{2}Te4_{4}, we find seven out of nine Te compounds are stable, except for PbAs2_{2}Te4_{4} and SnAs2_{2}Te4_{4}, which is in a good agreement with experimental observations. The results from the five different XC functionals in Figure 1 all agree that PbAs2_{2}Te4_{4} and SnAs2Te4\mathrm{SnAs}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4} are the two unstable ones among the nine Te compounds. Using the criteria that the rest seven Te compounds are thermodynamically stable as found in experiment, an energy shift of about Ef=0.05E_{\mathrm{f}}=0.05 eV/f.u. is needed for all five XC functionals. The almost same size of the energy zero shift indicates a systematic error in PBE-based XC functionals for these compounds.

AXAXGeSnPb
SeoP8, 62, GeSoP8, 62, GeScF8, 225, NaCl
TehR6, 160, GeTecF8, 225, NaClcF8, 225, NaCl
B2X3B_{2}X_{3}AsSbBi
SemP20, 14, As2_{2}S3_{3}oP20, 62, Sb2_{2}Se3_{3}hR15, 166, Bi2_{2}Te3_{3}
TehR15, 166, Bi2_{2}Te3_{3}hR15, 166, Bi2_{2}Te3_{3}hR15, 166, Bi2_{2}Te3_{3}

Table I. Binary AXAX and B2X3B_{2}X_{3} compounds in their ground state crystal structure as listed in the sequence of Pearson symbol, space group and structural type.

With the energy zero established, the results for Se compounds can be separated into two groups. PBEsol and D3BJ give similar results to each other that all Se compounds are stable, while D2, D3 and optB86b give all are stable except for PbAs2Se4\mathrm{PbAs}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}. The change of EfE_{\mathrm{f}} across the series is also similar for PBEsol and D3BJ, but different from the other three XC functionals. The difference among the two groups of XC functionals also reflects in the optimized lattice constants and band gaps as we will discuss later. From Figure 1, the overall trend is that Se compounds on average are more stable than the corresponding Te ones with respect to the decomposition into binaries, except for some Se compounds with D2. Another important trend for Te compounds is that, except for Ge series, the stability increases with group V element going from As to Sb to Bi. This trend is also largely true for the Se compounds with D2, D3 and optB86b. Interestingly, we find that eight out of nine Se compounds are thermodynamically stable with respect to binary compounds, except for PbAs2Se4\mathrm{PbAs}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}, as determined by most XC functionals used.

The good predictability of DFT can also be seen in the optimized lattice constants. The direct comparison between the DFT-optimized lattice constants aDFTa_{\mathrm{DFT}} and the nine available experimental aexpta_{\mathrm{expt}} with the five XC functionals are plotted in Figure 2 (a)-(e) and cDFTc_{\mathrm{DFT}} vs cexptc_{\mathrm{expt}} in Figure 2 (f)-(j), respectively. Again, PBEsol and D3BJ give very similar results of more accurate aa, but cc is largely underestimated. While both D3 and optB86b overestimate aa by similar amount, the latter give better prediction in cc. Lastly D2 slightly underestimates aa, the cc prediction is as good as optB86b. These differences are also directly reflected in the mean absolute error (MAE) and root mean squared error (RMSE) as listed in Table II. While PBEsol and D3BJ have the smallest MAE and RMSE for aa, those for cc are the largest. Even for D3+SOC, it slightly overestimates aa, while underestimates cc, but they are both within ±2%\pm2\%, the acceptable range for DFT predictability. The experimental data are mostly for Te compounds. Notably the Se data (red dot) for SnBi2Se4\mathrm{SnBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} and PbBi2Se4\mathrm{PbBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} are in line with the Te compounds, as well as the alloyed structures (open symbols).

MAE/RMSE (Å)aacc
FR-PBEsol0.014/0.0170.826/0.923
FR-D20.027/0.0300.450/0.495
FR-D30.055/0.0590.606/0.694
FR-D3BJ0.018/0.0200.821/0.935
FR-optB86b0.043/0.0460.378/0.490

Table II. Mean absolute error (MAE) and root mean squared error (RMSE) for the fully-relaxed nine compounds with different XC functionals in Figure 2. Numbers in bold highlight the minimum MAE and RMSE.

Comparison of DFT-optimized and experimental lattice constants

Figure 2. Comparison of the DFT-optimized lattice constants with experimental data for (a)-(e) aa and (f)-(j) cc using different XC functionals for nine AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4}. The blue and red are for AB2Te4AB_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4} and AB2Se4AB_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}, respectively. The open symbols are reported alloys for GeSb2Te4\mathrm{GeSb}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4}, PbSb2Te4\mathrm{PbSb}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4} and PbBi2Se4\mathrm{PbBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}.

Together with the thermodynamic stability in Figure 1, these comparison to experimental data shows the reliable predictability of DFT for structural energy of these layered compounds. There are some differences among the five XC functionals. Noticeably in contrast to D2, D3 with geometry-dependent dispersion coefficients and r−8r^{-8} besides r−6r^{-6} terms give results very close to the vdW-DF XC functional optB86b. Then interestingly, instead of the zero-damping, D3BJ for D3 with the BJ damping gives very similar results to PBEsol for these compounds.

Band-gap prediction

After establishing the reliable predictability of DFT structural energy for AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4}, we next discuss the predicted band gap, band structure and topological properties. The combination of vdW-DF XC functional and mBJ exchange potential has been shown to give good results to band gaps for vdW materials[53, 54] with the latter being a meta-GGA to add orbital-dependent correction using the converged Kohn-Sham wave functions of the vdW-DF optimized crystal structures. Here we will also combine mBJ with PBEsol XC functional to calculate the band structures, as well as other semi-empirical vdW energy corrections with the correspondingly optimized crystal structures. Among the 18 compounds, four Te compounds, GeSb2_{2}Te4_{4}, GeBi2_{2}Te4_{4}, SnSb2_{2}Te4_{4} and PbBi2_{2}Te4_{4}, have their band gap measured experimentally and were determined as STI by ARPES. For these compounds, because of the available experimental lattice constants, we will also calculate band structures with only ionic relaxations (IR), besides the full relaxation (FR) in different XC functionals without and with mBJ exchange potential. These different band gap results are listed in Table III for comparison and also plotted in Figure 3(a) and (b) for IR and FR, respectively. The open symbols are for the results with mBJ correction.

Δ\Delta (eV)GeSb2Te4\mathrm{GeSb_2Te_4}GeBi2Te4\mathrm{GeBi_2Te_4}SnSb2Te4\mathrm{SnSb_2Te_4}PbBi2Te4\mathrm{PbBi_2Te_4}
expt0.10.12, 0.20.20.23
IR-PBEsol/mBJ0.07/0.140.08/0.060.14/0.090.12/0.15
IR-D2/mBJ0.06/0.130.06/0.040.10/0.020.13/0.13
IR-D3/mBJ0.02/0.090.09/0.070.16/0.120.12/0.16
IR-D3BJ/mBJ0.00/0.070.07/0.070.16/0.120.12/0.15
IR-optB86b/mBJ0.02/0.020.09/0.070.18/0.130.12/0.16
FR-PBEsol/mBJ0.08/0.030.09/0.060.09/0.160.10/0.13
FR-D2/mBJ0.05/0.020.07/0.030.07/0.000.13/0.15
FR-D3/mBJ0.11/0.070.10/0.070.14/0.130.12/0.12
FR-D3BJ/mBJ0.07/0.030.07/0.060.10/0.160.12/0.15
FR-optB86b/mBJ0.09/0.070.07/0.080.13/0.130.13/0.14

Table III. Band gaps of the four compounds with experimental data compared to the calculated results with ionic relaxation (IR) in experimental lattice constants and fully relaxed (FR) structures using different XC functionals without and with mBJ exchange potential. The numbers in italics indicate trivial band gap, while the others are with band inversion for STI.

Comparison of experimental and calculated band gaps and band structures of GeSb₂Te₄

Figure 3. Comparison between the four available experimental band gap (Δexpt\Delta_{expt}) and the calculated ones (ΔDFT\Delta_{DFT}) using (a) ionically relaxed (IR) structures with experimental lattice constants and (b) fully relaxed (FR) with DFT-optimized lattice constants. The open symbols are mBJ results for the corresponding XC functionals. Band structure of GeSb2_2Te4_4 calculated using D3+SOC with (c) IR structure and (d) also mBJ. Those with (e) FR and (f) also mBJ. The top valence band is in blue and the green shadow stands for the projection on Te pp orbitals of the outmost layer. The high symmetry kk-points are in Figure 1(a).

As listed in Table III, for GeSb2_{2}Te4_{4}, a pp-doped STI with a small band gap of 0.1 eV as determined[55] by ARPES, IR structures give a trivial narrow-gap semiconductor with a band gap from 0.00 to 0.07 eV, except for optB86b giving it as a STI with a gap of 0.02 eV. With mBJ, the band gap for the trivial narrow-gap semiconductor increases by 0.07 eV. The band inversion for STI is removed in optB86b with mBJ, although the resulting band gap size is also 0.02 eV. All five XC functionals in IR with mBJ give GeSb2_{2}Te4_{4} as trivial. In a distinct contrast, all five XC functionals with FR structures give it as a STI agreeing with experiment and the calculated band gap ranges from 0.05 to 0.11 eV. With mBJ, the band gap for FR structures all decreases, but it remains as a STI for all five XC functionals. These opposite changes for GeSb2_2Te4_4 in IR and FR without and with mBJ can be seen as the opposite relative positions of the open and filled symbols at Δexpt=0.1\Delta_{expt}=0.1 eV for GeSb2_2Te4_4 in Figure 3(a) and (b), respectively. These differences are showcased by the bulk band structures calculated with D3+SOC in Figure 3(c)–(Figure 3f) for GeSb2_2Te4_4, for which the BZ and high symmetry kk-points are shown in Figure 1(a). The band inversion in these compounds happens near the EF_\mathrm{F} at the Z point. As shown in Figure 3(c) for IR, the small gap of 0.02 eV is a direct one without band inversion at the Z point. With mBJ in Figure 3(d), the trivial direct gap in enlarged to 0.09 eV, as the lowest conduction band at the F point is pushed to higher energy and the highest valence band along L–Z is pushed to lower energy, which are expected with mBJ. In contrast, for FR in Figure 3(e), the band gap of 0.11 eV near the Z point is inverted, clearly shown by the green shade projected on the outmost Te pp orbitals. With mBJ, the lowest conduction band at the F point is still pushed higher and the highest valence band along L–Z is pushed lower in energy aiming to increase the band gap. But because of the band inversion, the tendency of mBJ to separate valence and conduction band needs to first reduce the band inversion region, but not necessarily the band gap itself. As seen in Figure 3(f) when compared to (e), the size of the band inversion region around the Z point becomes smaller with mBJ, but as the band inversion is not lifted, the band gap between the inverted bands actually decreases, changing from 0.11 to 0.07 eV. Thus, the correction with mBJ can either increase or decrease the band gap size, depending on the presence of band inversion or not, as well as if the gap is a direct or indirect one.

For the other three experimentally measured Te compounds as STI, GeBi2_2Te4_4 was confirmed56 to have a surface Dirac point by ARPES with a bulk band gap of 0.2 eV. A later ARPES study57 put the bulk band gap at 0.12 eV. SnSb2_2Te4_4 is a heavily pp-doped STI, the ARPES study estimated58 the bulk gap to be a minimum of 0.2 eV. Our calculated band gap agrees with the previous PBEsol calculation59 of 0.12 eV. For PbBi2_2Te4_4, it has been measured22 by ARPES as a STI with a band gap of 0.23 eV. Our calculated band gap also agrees with the previous calculation22, giving an underestimated band gap around 0.12 eV. From the MAE and RMSE compiled in Table IV that are based on the limited data of the four Te compounds, the D3 emerges as the choice of XC functional for band structure calculation. D3 has the smallest MAE and its RMSE is also not far from the smallest. Thus, for topological band structures that will be discussed below, D3 will be used. The D3+SOC band structures with FR of the other three known STI Te compounds are plotted in Figure 4. It clearly shows that the band inversion region for the Bi compounds is larger than the Sb one due to the stronger SOC. The band inversion region is also reduced when using mBJ. The band gap can increase or decrease depending on if it is a direct gap near the ZZ point like GeSb2Te4\mathrm{GeSb}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4} or indirect gap like these three compounds. But for all the four Te compounds, the FR structures with five different XC functional predict they are all STI, agreeing with experiment.

MAE/RMSE (eV)IRFR
PBEsol0.059/0.0660.072/0.087
PBEsol-mBJ0.074/0.0780.068/0.071
D20.076/0.0800.082/0.089
D2-mBJ0.098/0.1130.112/0.123
D30.066/0.0740.052/0.066
D3-mBJ0.054/0.0610.066/0.073
D3BJ0.076/0.0830.072/0.080
D3BJ-mBJ0.061/0.0650.062/0.064
optB86b0.061/0.0720.058/0.066
optB86b-mBJ0.069/0.0700.059/0.063

Table IV. Mean absolute error (MAE) and root mean squared error (RMSE) for the four compounds with experimental data compared to the calculated results with structures from the ionic relaxation in experimental lattice constants and full relaxation using the different XC functionals and also mBJ as plotted in Figure 3. Numbers in bold highlight the minimum MAE and RMSE.

Band structures for GeBi₂Te₄, SnSb₂Te₄ and PbBi₂Te₄

Figure 4. (a)-(c) Band structure calculated in D3+SOC with the fully relaxed crystal structures for GeBi₂Te₄, SnSb₂Te₄ and PbBi₂Te₄, respectively. (d)-(f) The corresponding band structures with mBJ. The top valence band is in blue and the green shadow stands for the projection on Te p orbitals of the outmost layer.

Ideally more experimental data from Se compounds are needed to more effectively validate the DFT prediction of band gap. From the MAE and RMSE in Table IV, PBEsol and D3BJ give good lattice constant of aa, but the calculated band gap for FR structures are not as close to experiments as the other group of XC functionals, mostly due to the inaccurate prediction on cc, which is also important for the band inversion at the ZZ point. Although IR with experimental lattice constants for band structure calculation has been regarded as reliable most of time, here it misses the band inversion in GeSb2Te4\mathrm{GeSb}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4}. This shows the sensitivity of band inversion and band gap to the change of lattice constants besides the ionic coordinates, which makes pressure an effective knob to tune topological phase transition in these compounds.

The calculated band gap for all the compounds with different XC functionals are plotted in Figure 5. These results are with FR structures without and with mBJ potential to correct the band gap. The Te compounds mostly have an indirect gap, while the Se ones mostly have a direct band gap at the ZZ point. As shown in Figure 5, across the different compounds, the results from D3BJ are quite similar to those from PBEsol, following the same kind of similarity in the predicted lattice constants and formation energy. For Te compounds, except for D2, the mBJ band gaps are very close to the one without such correction. For Se compounds, the ones with As have the largest band gap predicted with mBJ, because they are normal semiconductors without band inversion. When there is a band inversion, the mBJ needs to first overcome the band inversion before enlarge the band gap. So for compounds with band inversion, mBJ does not necessarily increase much the band gap. In contrast for trivial systems without band inversion, mBJ can open up a significantly larger band gap, which are mostly As compounds.

DFT-calculated band gaps for AB2X4 across five computational methods

Figure 5. DFT-calculated band gap (Δ\Delta) for AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4}. The blue and red are for AB2Te4AB_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4} and AB2Se4AB_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}, respectively. The solid and open symbols are for the different XC functionals and the corresponding mBJ results, respectively.

Topological tunability

For topological classification of the band structures of AB2X4AB_{2}X_{4}, due to the inversion symmetry, the Fu-Kane[60] type Z2Z_{2} topological index based on parity eigenvalues can be calculated. The septuple structure is known for the band inversion at the ZZ point with the Fu-Kane topological index of (1;111)(1;111), in contrast to the band inversion at the Γ\Gamma point in the quintuple-layered Bi2Te3\mathrm{Bi}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{3}-type. The band inversion is between group VI pzp_{z} and group V pxp_{x} and pyp_{y} orbitals. From our calculations, most Te compounds with Sb and Bi are STI, while most As ones are not, except for SnAs2Te4\mathrm{SnAs}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4}, but it is not thermodynamically stable. These results show the importance of SOC for band inversion, because As is the lightest in group V. Without mBJ correction, most Se compounds except for the ones with As are calculated as STI and some have sizable band gap and some have a very small gap. With mBJ correction, all Se compounds calculated in D2, D3 and optB86b become topologically trivial semiconductors, but importantly these band gaps are quite small, which can be tuned by pressure.

For example, we predict two thermodynamically stable Se compounds, GeBi2Se4\mathrm{GeBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} and GeSb2Se4\mathrm{GeSb}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}, not found in crystallographic database, are narrow-gap semiconductors based on mBJ, but close to the topological phase transition to STI. Without mBJ, GeBi2Se4\mathrm{GeBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} and GeSb2Se4\mathrm{GeSb}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} are STI having a very small direct band gaps of 0.01 and 0.04 eV, and the bulk band structures are shown in Figure 6(b) and (c), respectively. With mBJ, the band inversion is lifted and the gap is increased to 0.22 and 0.26 eV (Figure 6(e) and (f)). Unlike most Te compounds having an indirect band gap, such as SnBi2Te4\mathrm{SnBi}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4} in Figure 6(a) and (d), the band gap for these Se compounds is direct at the ZZ point. Away from the ZZ point, the top valence and bottom conduction bands are well separated (Figure 6(e) and (f)), thus these two Se compounds have their tunable band inversion region isolated in both momentum and energy windows, which is a desirable feature for experimental detection and control of the topological properties. For these Se compounds, especially GeBi2Se4\mathrm{GeBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}, the small band gap means it is very close to the critical point of topological phase transition between a STI and normal insulator with a critical Dirac point at the ZZ point, which can be tuned by pressure, strain, phonon and temperature. Previously ZrTe5_5 is a prototype of such highly tunable topological material. Here we predict that GeBi2_2Se4_4 and GeSb2_2Se4_4 are also materials with high tunability in band structure topology. The sensitivity of the band dispersion to pressure here is similar to that in AECd2_2As2_2 series[61] for inducing a Dirac point.

Band structures calculated with D3+SOC and mBJ for SnBi2Te4, GeSb2Se4 and GeBi2Se4

Figure 6. (a)-(c) Band structure calculated in D3+SOC with the fully relaxed crystal structures for SnBi2Te4\mathrm{SnBi}_{2}\mathrm{Te}_{4}, GeSb2Se4\mathrm{GeSb}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} and GeBi2Se4\mathrm{GeBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4}, respectively. (d)-(f) The corresponding band structures with mBJ. The top valence band is in blue and the green shadow stands for the projection on XpX p orbitals of the outmost layer.

To demonstrate the high tunability of these narrow-gap semiconductors that are close to STI, the surface spectral functions of GeBi2_2Se4_4 (001) have been calculated with different hydrostatic pressure (PP) up to 2.0 GPa as shown in Figure 7. First, the Wannier charge center (WCC) evolution on the kz=0.5k_z=0.5 plane in Figure 7(a) shows the nontrivial band topology for GeBi2_2Se4_4 under 2.0 GPa with the band inversion at the Z point. As plotted in Figure 7(b), the spectral function has topological surface states enveloping the bulk conduction bands (see Figure 1(a) for the hexagonal surface BZ) and converging toward the Γˉ\bar{\Gamma} point, which is well isolated in both momentum and energy windows. Figure 7(c) shows the in-plane spin texture from the upper surface Dirac cone enveloping the bulk conduction bands at energy as high as EF_\mathrm{F}+0.2 eV. Because the band inversion is only at the Z point, when projected on (001), the non-trivial surface Dirac point is expected to appear at Γˉ\bar{\Gamma} point. After zoomed in Figure 7(d), indeed there is only one surface Dirac point at Γˉ\bar{\Gamma} point with a small bulk band gap. With smaller pressure, the band gap is first closed in Figure 7(e) and then reopened in Figure 7(f) showing a topological phase transition. Less than PP=1.6 GPa as in Figure 7(f), the band inversion is not present, which is confirmed by the surface states only attaching to the bulk conduction bands for a normal insulator. Importantly, at PP=1.7 GPa in Figure 7(e), a critical bulk Dirac point emerges at the Z point with both the surface states and Dirac point projection converging at the Γˉ\bar{\Gamma} point. Thus, we propose that the high tunability of the topological phase transition in GeBi2_2Se4_4 and GeSb2_2Se4_4 can potentially be explored with pressure, strain and coherent phonons as found in pump-probe experiments for ZrTe5_5. We also emphasize the need to have experimentally measured band gaps for Se compounds to validate the different DFT-calculated results.

Wannier charge center evolution, surface spectral functions, and spin texture for GeBi₂Se₄ under pressure

Figure 7. (a) Wannier charge center (WCC) evolution on kz=0.5k_z=0.5 plane, (b) (001) surface spectral function and (c) spin texture on 2D Fermi surface at EF+0.2E_{\mathrm{F}}+0.2 eV for GeBi2_2Se4_4 with the hydrostatic pressure (PP) of 2.0 GPa, showing the non-trivial topology of a STI with Z2=(1;111)Z_2=(1;111). The high symmetry kk-points are in Figure 1(a). The surface spectral function zoomed around Γˉ\bar{\Gamma} point with PP of (d) 2.0, (e) 1.7 and (f) 1.6 GPa, calculated with mBJ+SOC. The P=1.7P=1.7 GPa gives a critical bulk Dirac point.

Conclusion

In conclusion, using density functional theory (DFT) calculations, we have studied the septuple layered AB2X4AB_2X_4 series compounds with AA=(Ge, Sn and Pb), BB=(As, Sb and Bi) and XX=(Se and Te). Unlike the seven Te compounds, there are only two Se compounds been reported in these series. Using these reported compounds to validate the thermodynamic stability from DFT calculations with different exchange-correlation functionals, we predict new stable Se compounds that are not found in crystallographic database. Interestingly, we find GeBi2Se4\mathrm{GeBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} and GeSb2Se4\mathrm{GeSb}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} with a small direct band gap are close to a topological phase transition to strong topological insulators with a band inversion at the Z point, which can be induced by a moderate hydrostatic pressure. Additionally, the topological features with the small direct band gap in these compounds are well isolated in both momentum and energy windows, which offers high tunability for studying the topological phase transition. Using GeBi2Se4\mathrm{GeBi}_{2}\mathrm{Se}_{4} as the example, we show that under a small hydrostatic pressure about 1.7 GPa, the band gap can be closed and then inverted with a critical Dirac point appearing at the Z point.

Acknowledgements

This work at Ames Laboratory was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Basic Energy Sciences, Materials Sciences and Engineering Division. The Ames Laboratory is operated for the U.S. Department of Energy by Iowa State University under Contract No. DE-AC02-07CH11358.

References

  1. [1]M. Z. Hasan, C. L. Kane, Colloquium: Topological insulators. Rev Mod Phys 82, 3045 (2010).
  2. [2]X.-L. Qi, S.-C. Zhang, Topological insulators and superconductors. Rev Mod Phys 83, 1057-1110 (2011).DOI
  3. [3]A. Bansil, H. Lin, T. Das, Colloquium: Topological band theory. Rev Mod Phys 88, 021004 (2016).DOI
  4. [4]N. P. Armitage, E. J. Mele, A. Vishwanath, Weyl and Dirac semimetals in three-dimensional solids. Rev Mod Phys 90, 015001 (2018).DOI
  5. [5]H. C. Po, A. Vishwanath, H. Watanabe, Symmetry-based indicators of band topology in the 230 space groups (vol 8, 50, 2017). Nat Commun 8, 50 (2017).
  6. [6]R. J. Slager, A. Mesaros, V. Juricic, J. Zaanen, The space group classification of topological band-insulators. Nat Phys 9, 98-102 (2013).
  7. [7]J. Kruthoff, J. de Boer, J. van Wezel, C. L. Kane, R.-J. Slager, Topological Classification of Crystalline Insulators through Band Structure Combinatorics. Phys Rev X 7, 041069 (2017).DOI
  8. [8]B. Bradlyn, L. Elcoro, J. Cano, M. G. Vergniory, Z. J. Wang, C. Felser, M. I. Aroyo, B. A. Bernevig, Topological quantum chemistry. Nature 547, 298-305 (2017).
  9. [9]E. Khalaf, H. C. Po, A. Vishwanath, H. Watanabe, Symmetry Indicators and Anomalous Surface States of Topological Crystalline Insulators. Phys Rev X 8, 031070 (2018).DOI
  10. [10]Z. D. Song, T. T. Zhang, Z. Fang, C. Fang, Quantitative mappings between symmetry and topology in solids. Nat Commun 9, 3530 (2018).DOI
  11. [11]H. Watanabe, H. C. Po, A. Vishwanath, Structure and topology of band structures in the 1651 magnetic space groups. Science Advances 4, eaat8685 (2018).DOI
  12. [12]F. Tang, H. C. Po, A. Vishwanath, X. G. Wan, Comprehensive search for topological materials using symmetry indicators. Nature 566, 486-490 (2019).DOI
  13. [13]T. T. Zhang, Y. Jiang, Z. D. Song, H. Huang, Y. Q. He, Z. Fang, H. M. Weng, C. Fang, Catalogue of topological electronic materials. Nature 566, 475-479 (2019).DOI
  14. [14]M. G. Vergniory, L. Elcoro, C. Felser, N. Regnault, B. A. Bernevig, Z. J. Wang, A complete catalogue of high-quality topological materials. Nature 566, 480-485 (2019).DOI
  15. [15]Y. Xu, L. Elcoro, Z.-D. Song, B. J. Wieder, M. G. Vergniory, N. Regnault, Y. Chen, C. Felser, B. A. Bernevig, High-throughput calculations of magnetic topological materials. Nature 586, 702-707 (2020).DOI
  16. [16]H. M. Weng, X. Dai, Z. Fang, Transition-Metal Pentatelluride ZrTe5 and HfTe5: A Paradigm for Large-Gap Quantum Spin Hall Insulators. Phys Rev X 4, 011002 (2014).
  17. [17]Q. Li, D. E. Kharzeev, C. Zhang, Y. Huang, I. Pletikosić, A. V. Fedorov, R. D. Zhong, J. A. Schneeloch, G. D. Gu, T. Valla, Chiral magnetic effect in ZrTe5. Nat Phys 12, 550-555 (2016).DOI
  18. [18]C. Vaswani, L. L. Wang, D. H. Mudiyanselage, Q. Li, P. M. Lozano, G. D. Gu, D. Cheng, B. Song, L. Luo, R. H. J. Kim, C. Huang, Z. Liu, M. Mootz, I. E. Perakis, Y. Yao, K. M. Ho, J. Wang, Light-Driven Raman Coherence as a Nonthermal Route to Ultrafast Topology Switching in a Dirac Semimetal. Phys Rev X 10, 021013 (2020).DOI
  19. [19]L. Luo, D. Cheng, B. Song, L.-L. Wang, C. Vaswani, P. M. Lozano, G. Gu, C. Huang, R. H. J. Kim, Z. Liu, J.-M. Park, Y. Yao, K. Ho, I. E. Perakis, Q. Li, J. Wang, A light-induced phononic symmetry switch and giant dissipationless topological photocurrent in ZrTe5. Nat Mater 20, 329-334 (2021).DOI
  20. [20]L.-L. Wang, Expansive open Fermi arcs and connectivity changes induced by infrared phonons in ZrTe5. Phys Rev B 103, 075105 (2021).DOI
  21. [22]K. Kuroda, H. Miyahara, M. Ye, S. V. Eremeev, Y. M. Koroteev, E. E. Krasovskii, E. V. Chulkov, S. Hiramoto, C. Moriyoshi, Y. Kuroiwa, K. Miyamoto, T. Okuda, M. Arita, K. Shimada, H. Namatame, M. Taniguchi, Y. Ueda, A. Kimura, Experimental Verification of PbBi2Te4 as a 3D Topological Insulator. Phys Rev Lett 108, 206803 (2012).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23003165
  22. [23]M. M. Otrokov, I. I. Klimovskikh, H. Bentmann, D. Estyunin, A. Zeugner, Z. S. Aliev, S. Gab, A. U. B. Wolter, A. V. Koroleva, A. M. Shikin, M. Blanco-Rey, M. Hoffmann, I. P. Rusinov, A. Y. Vyazovskaya, S. V. Eremeev, Y. M. Koroteev, V. M. Kuznetsov, F. Freyse, J. Sánchez-Barriga, I. R. Amiraslanov, M. B. Babanly, N. T. Mamedov, N. A. Abdullayev, V. N. Zverev, A. Alfonson, V. Kataev, B. Büchner, E. F. Schwier, S. Kumar, A. Kimura, L. Petaccia, G. Di Santo, R. C. Vidal, S. Schatz, K. Kißner, M. Ünzelmann, C. H. Min, S. Moser, T. R. F. Peixoto, F. Reinert, A. Ernst, P. M. Echenique, A. Isaeva, E. V. Chulkov, Prediction and observation of an antiferromagnetic topological insulator. Nature 576, 416-422 (2019).DOI
  23. [24]D. Zhang, M. Shi, T. Zhu, D. Xing, H. Zhang, J. Wang, Topological Axion States in the Magnetic Insulator MnBi2Te4 with the Quantized Magnetoelectric Effect. Phys Rev Lett 122, 206401 (2019).DOI
  24. [25]P. Swatek, Y. Wu, L.-L. Wang, K. Lee, B. Schrunк, J. Yan, A. Kaminski, Gapless Dirac surface states in the antiferromagnetic topological insulator MnBi₂Te₄. Phys Rev B 101, 161109 (2020).DOI
  25. [26]N. H. Jo, L.-L. Wang, R.-J. Slager, J. Yan, Y. Wu, K. Lee, B. Schrunк, A. Vishwanath, A. Kaminski, Intrinsic axion insulating behavior in antiferromagnetic MnBi₆Te₁₀. Phys Rev B 102, 045130 (2020).
  26. [27]Y.-J. Hao, P. Liu, Y. Feng, X.-M. Ma, E. F. Schwier, M. Arita, S. Kumar, C. Hu, R. e. Lu, M. Zeng, Y. Wang, Z. Hao, H.-Y. Sun, K. Zhang, J. Mei, N. Ni, L. Wu, K. Shimada, C. Chen, Q. Liu, C. Liu, Gapless Surface Dirac Cone in Antiferromagnetic Topological Insulator MnBi₂Te₄. Phys Rev X 9, 041038 (2019).DOI
  27. [28]Y. J. Chen, L. X. Xu, J. H. Li, Y. W. Li, H. Y. Wang, C. F. Zhang, H. Li, Y. Wu, A. J. Liang, C. Chen, S. W. Jung, C. Cacho, Y. H. Mao, S. Liu, M. X. Wang, Y. F. Guo, Y. Xu, Z. K. Liu, L. X. Yang, Y. L. Chen, Topological Electronic Structure and Its Temperature Evolution in Antiferromagnetic Topological Insulator MnBi₂Te₄. Phys Rev X 9, 041040 (2019).DOI
  28. [29]H. Li, S.-Y. Gao, S.-F. Duan, Y.-F. Xu, K.-J. Zhu, S.-J. Tian, J.-C. Gao, W.-H. Fan, Z.-C. Rao, J.-R. Huang, J.-J. Li, D.-Y. Yan, Z.-T. Liu, W.-L. Liu, Y.-B. Huang, Y.-L. Li, Y. Liu, G.-B. Zhang, P. Zhang, T. Kondo, S. Shin, H.-C. Lei, Y.-G. Shi, W.-T. Zhang, H.-M. Weng, T. Qian, H. Ding, Dirac Surface States in Intrinsic Magnetic Topological Insulators EuSn₂As₂ and MnBi₂nTe₃n+1. Phys Rev X 9, 041039 (2019).DOI
  29. [30]Y. Deng, Y. Yu, Z. Shi Meng, Z. Guo, Z. Xu, J. Wang, H. Chen Xian, Y. Zhang, Quantum anomalous Hall effect in intrinsic magnetic topological insulator MnBi₂Te₄. Science 367, 895-900 (2020).DOI
  30. [31]C. Liu, Y. Wang, H. Li, Y. Wu, Y. Li, J. Li, K. He, Y. Xu, J. Zhang, Y. Wang, Robust axion insulator and Chern insulator phases in a two-dimensional antiferromagnetic topological insulator. Nat Mater 19, 522-527 (2020).DOI
  31. [32]T. Zhu, A. J. Bishop, T. Zhou, M. Zhu, D. J. O’Hara, A. A. Baker, S. Cheng, R. C. Walko, J. J. Repicky, T. Liu, J. A. Gupta, C. M. Jozwiak, E. Rotenberg, J. Hwang, I. Žutić, R. K. Kawakami, Synthesis, Magnetic Properties, and Electronic Structure of Magnetic Topological Insulator MnBi₂Se₄. Nano Lett 21, 5083-5090 (2021).DOI
  32. [33]Y. Hattori, Y. Tokumoto, K. Kimoto, K. Edagawa, Evidences of inner Se ordering in topological insulator PbBi₂Te₄-PbBi₂Se₄-PbSb₂Se₄ solid solutions. Sci Rep-Uk 10, 7957 (2020).DOI
  33. [34]A. A. Sher, I. N. Odin, A. V. Novoselova, Interaction in the system Sn-Bi-Se. Inorg. Mater. 14, 993-998 (1978).
  34. [35]K. A. Agaev, S. A. Semiletov, Electron-diffraction study of the structure of PbBi₂Se₄. Sov. Phys. Crystallogr. 13, 201-203 (1968).
  35. [36]A. D. Becke, E. R. Johnson, A simple effective potential for exchange. The Journal of Chemical Physics 124, 221101 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16784253
  36. [37]P. Hohenberg, W. Kohn, Inhomogeneous Electron Gas. Phys. Rev. 136, B864-B871 (1964).
  37. [38]W. Kohn, L. J. Sham, Self-Consistent Equations Including Exchange and Correlation Effects. Phys. Rev. 140, A1133-A1138 (1965).DOI
  38. [39]G. Kresse, J. Furthmuller, Efficiency of Ab-initio Total Energy Calculations for Metals and Semiconductors Using a Plane-Wave Basis Set. Comp Mater Sci 6, 15-50 (1996).DOI
  39. [40]G. Kresse, J. Furthmuller, Efficient Iterative Schemes for Ab initio Total-Energy Calculations Using a Plane-Wave Basis Set. Phys Rev B 54, 11169-11186 (1996).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9984901
  40. [41]J. P. Perdew, A. Ruzsinszky, G. I. Csonka, O. A. Vydrov, G. E. Scuseria, L. A. Constantin, X. Zhou, K. Burke, Restoring the Density-Gradient Expansion for Exchange in Solids and Surfaces. Phys Rev Lett 100, 136406 (2008).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18517979
  41. [42]J. Klimes, D. R. Bowler, A. Michaelides, Van der Waals density functionals applied to solids. Phys Rev B 83, 195131 (2011).
  42. [43]S. Grimme, Semiempirical GGA-type density functional constructed with a long-range dispersion correction. J Comput Chem 27, 1787-1799 (2006).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16955487
  43. [44]S. Grimme, J. Antony, S. Ehrlich, H. Krieg, A consistent and accurate ab initio parametrization of density functional dispersion correction (DFT-D) for the 94 elements H-Pu. The Journal of Chemical Physics 132, 154104 (2010).DOI
  44. [45]S. Grimme, S. Ehrlich, L. Goerigk, Effect of the damping function in dispersion corrected density functional theory. J Comput Chem 32, 1456-1465 (2011).DOI
  45. [46]H. J. Monkhorst, J. D. Pack, Special Points for Brillouin-Zone Integrations. Phys Rev B 13, 5188-5192 (1976).DOI
  46. [47]N. Marzari, D. Vanderbilt, Maximally localized generalized Wannier functions for composite energy bands. Phys Rev B 56, 12847-12865 (1997).DOI
  47. [48]I. Souza, N. Marzari, D. Vanderbilt, Maximally localized Wannier functions for entangled energy bands. Phys Rev B 65, 035109 (2001).DOI
  48. [49]M. P. L. Sancho, J. M. L. Sancho, J. Rubio, Quick Iterative Scheme for the Calculation of Transfer-Matrices - Application to Mo(100). J Phys F Met Phys 14, 1205-1215 (1984).
  49. [50]M. P. L. Sancho, J. M. L. Sancho, J. Rubio, Highly Convergent Schemes for the Calculation of Bulk and Surface Green-Functions. J Phys F Met Phys 15, 851-858 (1985).
  50. [51]Q. Wu, S. Zhang, H.-F. Song, M. Troyer, A. A. Soluyanov, WannierTools: An open-source software package for novel topological materials. Computer Physics Communications 224, 405-416 (2018).
  51. [52]H. Chen, G. Hautier, G. Ceder, Synthesis, Computed Stability, and Crystal Structure of a New Family of Inorganic Compounds: Carbonophosphates. J. Am. Chem. Soc. 134, 19619-19627 (2012).DOI
  52. [53]J. Qiao, X. Kong, Z.-X. Hu, F. Yang, W. Ji, High-mobility transport anisotropy and linear dichroism in few-layer black phosphorus. Nat Commun 5, 4475 (2014).DOI
  53. [54]K. Choudhary, Q. Zhang, A. C. E. Reid, S. Chowdhury, N. Van Nguyen, Z. Trautt, M. W. Newrock, F. Y. Congo, F. Tavazza, Computational screening of high-performance optoelectronic materials using OptB88vdW and TB-mBJ formalisms. Scientific Data 5, 180082 (2018).DOI
  54. [55]M. Nurmamat, K. Okamoto, S. Zhu, T. V. Menshchikova, I. P. Rusinov, V. O. Korostelev, K. Miyamoto, T. Okuda, T. Miyashita, X. Wang, Y. Ishida, K. Sumida, E. F. Schwier, M. Ye, Z. S. Aliev, M. B. Babany, I. R. Amiraslanov, E. V. Chulkov, K. A. Kokh, O. E. Tereshchenko, K. Shimada, S. Shin, A. Kimura, Topologically Nontrivial Phase-Change Compound GeSb2Te4. ACS Nano 14, 9059-9065 (2020).DOI
  55. [60]L. Fu, C. L. Kane, Topological insulators with inversion symmetry. Phys Rev B 76, 045302 (2007).DOI
  56. [61]J. M. DeStefano, L.-L. Wang, Pressure effect on band inversion in AECd2As2 (AE=Ca, Sr, Ba). Phys Rev B 103, 115207 (2021).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_8nss98u2
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents