WorksPhysics and Astronomy
"Inevitable'' nonstrange tetraquark states and interaction
Abstract
Investigation of the interaction between two mesons with and is conducted systematically in the framework of the quark delocalization color screening model. The results show that there is a strong attractive potential between two mesons, which makes it easier for these two mesons to form bound states. The largest binding energies occur for and with values over a hundred MeV, while the state is the least bound and has a binding energy of only a few MeV. Moreover, the results of intercluster distances favor a molecular interpretation of these states. The interaction analysis reveals that the and interactions share certain similarities. Drawing inspiration from the dibaryon prediction and from decay-property analyses, we suggest that the with may be the most promising candidate of the ``inevitable'' nonstrange tetraquark state, which deserves experimental search.
Introduction
The study of tetraquark dates back to Jaffe in 1977, where he pointed out that certain known mesons (, , , ) are not conventional states but rather the lightest cryptoexotic nonet [1, 2]. The renewed interest in tetraquark systems was triggered in 2003 by the successive discoveries of several charmed tetraquarks, such as the observed by the Belle Collaboration in [3], the reported by the BaBar Collaboration in the invariant mass spectrum [4], the charged charmoniumlike state reported by BESIII in [5], and the open-charm exotic structures and observed by LHCb in [6].
While much of the interest has focused on charmed tetraquarks, fully light tetraquarks exist as well and have likewise been the subject of extensive study. Using a dispersive analysis of Roy equations, Caprini et al. obtained the pole at MeV, establishing its resonant nature, and determined the pole within the same framework [7]. Ruiz de Elvira et al. subsequently performed a dispersive analysis of scattering data with once-subtracted Roy equations, obtaining the pole positions of both the and [8], which have since served as benchmark inputs for later theoretical studies. Agaev et al. discussed the structure, mixing angle, and coupling constants of and within QCD sum rules [9], with results consistent with a tetraquark-dominated picture, while Weinstein and Isgur interpreted and as weakly bound molecular states in a nonrelativistic potential model [10]. In 1995, the Crystal Barrel Collaboration confirmed in annihilation at rest from LEAR [11]. A prominent
signal of was later seen by the BESII Collaboration in and the resonance was confirmed by the STAR Collaboration in the invariant mass spectrum in collisions at GeV [12, 13]. Its branching ratios, however, remain undetermined, its experimental Breit-Wigner width lies between 200 and 500 MeV [14], and its internal structure is still under considerable debate. Large- QCD study suggests a possible interpretation in which , , and form the lowest tetraquark nonet [15].
Our group has also carried out a systematic study of the interactions between light mesons within the quark delocalization color screening model (QDCSM). We found that, for most physical channels, the interaction between two pseudoscalar mesons is repulsive; the one between a pseudoscalar meson and a vector meson is repulsive or weakly attractive; and the one between two vector mesons is attractive [16]. The greater likelihood of the attraction between two vector mesons indicates a higher possibility of forming bound states, which is of particular importance for tetraquark studies.
Additionally, a similar behavior of the interaction properties has been found in hexaquark systems. In Ref. [17], dibaryon candidates in the , and flavor sectors were systematically investigated within the QDCSM, and the results showed that octet-octet interactions are mostly repulsive or weakly attractive, decuplet-octet interactions are always weakly attractive and decuplet-decuplet interactions are always strongly attractive. One of the most representative examples of the decuplet-decuplet interactions is the with predicted by T. Goldman et al. in 1989. They called the state a nonstrange “inevitable” state and named it [18]. Other groups have also investigated the interaction and found it to be attractive. The binding energies have been calculated in several works, with values ranging from a few MeV to several hundred MeV [19, 20, 21, 22, 23, 24, 25]. Experimentally, a pronounced resonance structure was observed in the cross section with the resonance mass GeV and the width MeV by the CELSIUS-WASA Collaboration [26] and WASA-at-COSY Collaboration [27, 28].
Motivated by the similarity between the interaction properties of tetraquarks and hexaquarks, we wonder whether a -like resonance, well established in decuplet-decuplet systems, also exists in vector-vector meson systems. Since our previous work revealed a deep attraction between two mesons [16], the central aim of present work is to determine whether can form such a nonstrange “inevitable” tetraquark state.
The structure of this paper is as follows. The information of the quark model and the calculation methods are given in § 2. The numerical results and corresponding discussion are presented in Section III. The last section is a summary.
Quark Model and Calculation Methods
The quark delocalization color screening model (QDCSM)
In this work, we employ the quark delocalization color screening model (QDCSM), which has been explored in detail in the Refs. [29, 30]. The explicit form of the Hamiltonian is given as follows.
Where , and denote the confinement potential, the one-gluon exchange potential and the Goldstone boson exchange potential, respectively. represents the kinetic energy of the center of mass; is the quark-gluon coupling constant; and are standard Yukawa functions; is quark tensor operator, which gives no contribution here as only -wave states are involved in this work. The coupling constant for the chiral field is determined from the coupling constant through
The color screening parameter , which is fixed by fitting to the deuteron properties, phase shifts and scattering phase shifts, takes the value . Other symbols in the above expressions have their usual meanings. In this work, we use the model parameters determined by fitting the meson spectrum, as taken from our previous study on the tetraquark states [31].
The calculation methods
The resonating group method (RGM) is employed here to study a bound state or a scattering problem. We express the wave function of the tetraquark state as
where the symbol is the anti-symmetrization operator, with the SU(3) symmetry written as . gives the total color symmetry, represents isospin quantum number and refers to the spin quantum number. is the relative motion wave function of the two clusters, with being the relative coordinate between them; denotes the center-of-mass wave function. and are the cluster wave functions,
The is obtained by solving the Schrödinger equation within the variational approach:
After performing the variation, the RGM equation is as follows
where and are Hamiltonian and norm kernels.
Then the energy and the wave function can be obtained by solving the RGM equation. In practice, however, direct implementation of the RGM expression is computationally inconvenient. To recast the differential-integral equation of RGM into an algebraic form that can be readily solved numerically, we expand the relative-motion wave function as a series of known Gaussian wave functions:
where is the generating coordinate in the model, denoting the separation of two reference centers. The center of mass motion wave function is
As for the orbital wave functions, and are the single-particle orbital wave functions with different reference centers:
Then equation (9) can be written as
The RGM expression is finally given as follows
where and are the overlaps and Hamiltonian matrix elements, respectively. In this work, only -wave systems are explored. By solving Eq. (18), the energies and wave functions of tetraquark states can be obtained.
The Result and Discussion
In this work, we first calculate the binding energies of the -wave states with all possible combinations of isospin and total angular momentum . The results are listed in Table I. The binding energy is given by , where represents the single channel energy, and is the corresponding theoretical threshold.
| (MeV) | (MeV) | (MeV) | |
| 00 | 1544.93 | 1437.87 | |
| 02 | 1544.93 | 1429.95 | |
| 11 | 1544.93 | 1475.29 | |
| 20 | 1544.93 | 1542.82 | |
| 22 | 1544.93 | 1454.51 |
Table I. The binding energies of the -wave states.
It is evident from Table I that sustains bound states with all allowed numbers and the binding energies vary significantly with different . The largest binding energy is observed with , reaching MeV, closely followed by and , with the values of MeV and MeV, respectively. A significant reduction in binding is observed for , which gives only MeV, whereas the channel is found to be the weakest bound, with a value as small as MeV. Notably, studies based on chiral effective field theory have employed the state with to account for the observed [32, 33, 34]. Reference [35] employed an improved unitarization method to study the interactions between vector mesons and pointed out that the state with is significant to form the scalar meson or . In present work, the single channel energy of is 1437.87 MeV, which is closer to 1500 MeV and may be used to explain the . Besides, some studies associate the state with the observed [32, 33], while others suggest that it is unbound [34, 35]. To determine whether these states can account for the observed or states, the channel coupling effects should be taken into account and the studies of the properties of the resonance states as well as the decay widths are needed.
The variation in binding energy among these channels is consistent with the behavior of the interaction explored in Ref. [16], with the effective potential for and being the deepest and that for the shallowest. In addition, Table I shows that, for a given angular momentum , the binding energy is larger with a smaller isospin . For example, when , the binding energy with is larger than that with ; the same trend persists with . Conversely, for a fixed isospin , a larger angular momentum tends to give a larger binding energy. For instance, the binding energy with is larger than that with for both and . In general, a larger binding energy can be observed in the states with smaller isospin and larger total angular momentum.
The distance between the two clusters is calculated to further explore the structure of the . For , , , and the distances are 1.323 fm, 1.305 fm, 1.344 fm, 1.720 fm and 1.315 fm, respectively. The assumed radius of a single cluster is 0.518 fm. From the above data, it is clear that the distance between the two clusters exceeds ( fm), so we assume that tends to form molecular states for all channels under consideration.
To understand why can form bound states, we investigate the contribution of each interaction term to the system with different . The results are shown in Figure 1, where the kinetic energy (), the confinement (), the one-gluon exchange (), and the one-boson exchange (, , ) terms are presented. It should be noted that makes no contribution to studied here, hence, only and are included in Figure 1.
Figure 1. Figure (a) to (e) are the contributions to the effective potential of interactions with different .
The total effective potential is attractive for all possible , with and showing a visibly larger attraction and the weakest. This is consistent with the magnitude of the binding energies given in Table I. The kinetic energy provides the dominant intermediate-range attraction, which is related to the QDCSM employed here. In the QDCSM model, the quark delocalization effect permits quarks to move between two clusters, reducing the total kinetic energy of the system and thereby allowing the kinetic energy to contribute attraction. The delocalization parameter is determined by the dynamics of the system and the results are shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2. The delocalization parameter for .
The delocalization parameters for both and are close to 1 when the distance is less than 0.9 fm, while those for and become close to 1 when fm and fm, respectively. This indicates that the quarks tend to move between two clusters, giving rise to an attractive interaction. For , however, the delocalization parameter approaches to 1 only when fm and it approaches to 0 quickly as the distance increases. Although this also reduces the kinetic energy, the reduction is much smaller than that in other states, accounting for the weakest attraction of the state.
Back to Figure 1, the confinement potential is attractive at short distances but gives a repulsive contribution in the intermediate distance region for all states. As for the OGE potential, it is purely repulsive only for and attractive in other channels. Besides the contribution of other items is small.
To further investigate the origin of the attraction or repulsion from the effective potentials, especially the OGE potential, we calculate the matrix elements in spin-flavorcolor space. The definitions are given as follows:
Where and represent the -th and -th quarks, respectively. The subscript means the direct matrix elements and denotes the exchange matrix elements. According to the anti-symmetrization operator (), there are three exchange terms labeled by the subscripts 1, 2 and 3 in matrix elements , and . The matrix elements represent the color-related factor of the interaction, including the confinement term and the Coulomb part of the one-gluon exchange interaction. The matrix elements mainly describe the spin-color factor associated with the chromomagnetic part of the OGE potential. The calculated matrix elements for all channels are listed in Table II-Table VI.
| 12 | ||||||||
| 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 14 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 23 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 24 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 34 |
Table II. The matrix elements in spin-flavor-color-isospin spaces of with .
| 12 | ||||||||
| 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 14 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 23 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 24 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 34 |
Table VI. The matrix elements in spin-flavor-color-isospin spaces of with .
The matrix elements between the two clusters are zero as presented in Table II-Table VI. This is because both meson clusters are color-singlets, and do not contribute to the meson-meson interaction. The behavior of the matrix elements is consistent with the variation of the effective potential, as illustrated by the two notable cases and . For , the exchange matrix elements and are all positive; when the negative sign of the color-magnetic term in the is considered, the resulting values are negative,
| 12 | ||||||||
| 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 14 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 23 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 24 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 34 |
Table III. The matrix elements in spin-flavor-color-isospin spaces of with .
| 12 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 14 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 23 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 24 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
| 34 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 |
Table IV. The matrix elements in spin-flavor-color-isospin spaces of with .
| 12 | ||||||||
| 13 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 14 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 23 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 24 | 0 | 0 | 0 | 0 | ||||
| 34 |
Table V. The matrix elements in spin-flavor-color-isospin spaces of with .
which confirms the deep attraction of the OGE potential. In case of , the exchange matrix elements and are all negative. With the sign taken into account, the results become positive, corresponding to the repulsive effect of the OGE potential shown in Figure 1.
In addition, to further explore the similarities between the vector-vector meson interaction and the decuplet-decuplet baryon interaction, the interaction between two decuplet baryons is examined. Taking as an example, a previous study conducted in the QDCSM shows that the state has the binding energy of MeV, while the state with is weakly bound with the value of only MeV [24]. To reveal the underlying dynamics, the contributions to the effective potential of interaction with and are shown in Figure 3.
Figure 3. The contributions to the effective potential of interactions with and .
Figure 4. The delocalization parameter for .
For both states, the attraction originates mainly from the kinetic energy term, while the meson exchange potential are repulsive, similar to the behavior found for states. The delocalization parameter for approaches to 1 when the distance is less than 0.5 fm, while that for is close to 1 when fm and it quickly approaches to 0. This accounts for the relatively weaker kinetic attraction in compared with . At short range, the confinement potential is attractive, whereas at intermediate range it becomes repulsive. The OGE potential provides attraction for , while it is repulsive for . As a result, the total attraction for is larger than that for . The properties of the interaction between two mesons are similar to those of the interaction between two baryons. Since the dibaryon with composed of two s has been predicted as an “inevitable” nonstrange state [18] and confirmed by experiments [26, 27, 28], it is natural to consider whether the states can likewise be identified as “inevitable” nonstrange tetraquark states.
Given the deep binding energies of the states with and obtained in this work, these two states seem to be the promising candidates of the “inevitable” tetraquark states. For the state, it decays mainly into the -wave channel through the central-force coupling. Because this coupling is relatively strong, two possible cases may arise. In one case, the coupling may push the energy of the state above the threshold, turning it into a scattering state. In the other case, may become a resonance after coupling, but with a large decay width that makes the resonance very broad and highly unstable. This is analogous to the coupling of the () to the . As studied in Ref. [36], the with has a relatively deep binding energy of 258 MeV. However, after coupling to the -wave channel, its energy is pushed above the threshold, causing the resonance to disappear. In contrast, the state with can only decay into -wave via the tensor-force coupling. In general, the tensor-force coupling is weaker than the central-force coupling, and thus the state is less affected by channel coupling. This is similar to the state with , which can only decay to -wave . After the consideration of channel coupling, the state appears as a resonance state in the -wave scattering process and the energy shifts from 2365 MeV to 2368 MeV [36]. Based on the above analyse, the state with might turn into a scattering state through the -wave channel, whereas the state with is likely to appear as a resonance in the -wave scattering. Therefore, we tend to consider that with may be the “inevitable” nonstrange tetraquark state.
Summary
In this work, we systematically investigate the -wave states with and in the framework of the QDCSM by the RGM. To confirm the existence of bound states, we calculate the binding energies for all states. The distance between the two clusters is also calculated to explore the structure of states. In order to study the origin of interaction, we investigate the contributions to the effective potential from varies terms of interaction and calculate the matrix elements in spin-flavor-color space.
The numerical results show that all channels can form bound states, with binding energies of MeV, MeV, MeV, MeV, and MeV for , , , and , respectively. Notably, the binding energies for and are much larger than those for other states, whereas the binding energy for is the smallest. In addition, we find that tends to form a deeper bound state for a smaller isospin and a larger total angular momentum. Based on the calculated distance between the two clusters, we assume that tend to form molecular states.
The study of the contribution of each interaction term shows that the total attraction of comes mainly from the kinetic energy, which is related to the intermediate-range attraction mechanism in the QDCSM. As the delocalization parameters approaches to 1, the quarks tend to move more strongly between two clusters. This delocalization reduces the total kinetic energy of the system. The confinement potential provides an attractive contribution at short distances but a repulsive contribution in the intermediate-range for all states. The OGE potential is attractive, except for , where its contribution is repulsive. The contribution of other terms is small. The matrix element calculations show that the behavior of the matrix elements is consistent with the variation of the effective potential.
Additionally, to explore the analogy between the vector-vector meson interaction and the decuplet-decuplet baryon interaction, we take as an example to explore the interaction between two decuplet baryons. The total attraction for is larger than that for . The behavior of the interaction with different quantum numbers resembles that of the . According to the discussion of the channel coupling effects, we tend to predict that with is an “inevitable” nonstrange tetraquark state, which is worthy of the attention from both theoretical and experimental studies. In future work, we will systematically investigate the scattering processes to confirm whether the states are resonances or not.
Acknowledgments
This work is supported partly by the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Contracts Nos. 12575088, 11675080, 11775118 and 11535005.
References
- [1]R. L. Jaffe, Phys. Rev. D 15, 267 (1977)
- [2]R. L. Jaffe, Phys. Rev. D 15, 281 (1977)
- [3]S. K. Choi et al. [Belle], Phys. Rev. Lett. 91, 262001 (2003)
- [4]B. Aubert et al. [BaBar], Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 242001 (2003)
- [5]M. Ablikim et al. [BESIII], Phys. Rev. Lett. 110, 252001 (2013)
- [6]R. Aaij et al. [LHCb], Phys. Rev. Lett. 125, 242001 (2020)
- [7]I. Caprini, G. Colangelo and H. Leutwyler, Phys. Rev. Lett. 96, 132001 (2006)
- [8]J. Ruiz de Elvira, R. Garcia Martin, R. Kaminski and J. R. Pelaez, AIP Conf. Proc. 1343, 302-304 (2011)
- [9]S. S. Agaev, K. Azizi and H. Sundu, Phys. Lett. B 781, 279-282 (2018)
- [10]J. D. Weinstein and N. Isgur, Phys. Rev. D 27, 588 (1983)
- [11]C. Amsler et al. [Crystal Barrel], Phys. Lett. B 355, 425-432 (1995)
- [12]M. Ablikim et al. [BES], Phys. Lett. B 607, 243-253 (2005)
- [13]J. Turnau [STAR], EPJ Web Conf. 37, 06010 (2012)
- [14]S. Navas et al. [Particle Data Group], Phys. Rev. D 110, no.3, 030001 (2024)
- [15]C. Liu, Eur. Phys. J. C 53, 413-419 (2008)
- [16]Y. H. Wu, X. Jin, H. X. Huang, J. L. Ping, and X. M. Zhu, Phys. Rev. C 106, 025204 (2022).
- [17]J. L. Ping, F. Wang and J. T. Goldman, Nucl. Phys. A 657, 95-109 (1999)
- [18]J. T. Goldman, K. Maltman, G. J. Stephenson, Jr., K. E. Schmidt and F. Wang, Phys. Rev. C 39, 1889-1895 (1989)
- [19]M. Oka and K. Yazaki, Phys. Lett. B 90, 41-44 (1980)
- [20]K. Maltman, Nucl. Phys. A 438, 669-684 (1985)
- [21]X. Q. Yuan, Z. Y. Zhang, Y. W. Yu and P. N. Shen, Phys. Rev. C 60, 045203 (1999)
- [22]H. R. Ping, J. L. Ping, F. Wang and J. T. Goldman, Phys. Rev. C 65, 014003 (2002)
- [23]A. Valcarce, H. Garcilazo, F. Fernandez and P. Gonzalez, Rept. Prog. Phys. 68, 965-1042 (2005)
- [24]H. Huang, J. Ping and F. Wang, Phys. Rev. C 89, no.3, 034001 (2014)
- [25]A. Gal, Phys. Lett. B 769, 436-440 (2017)
- [26]M. Bashkanov, C. Bargholtz, M. Berłowski, D. Bogoslawski, H. Calen, H. Clement, L. Demiroers, E. Doroshkevich, D. Duniec and C. Ekstrom, et al. Phys. Rev. Lett. 102, 052301 (2009)
- [27]P. Adlarson et al. [WASA-at-COSY], Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 242302 (2011)
- [28]P. Adlarson et al. [WASA-at-COSY], Phys. Rev. C 90, no.3, 035204 (2014)
- [29]F. Wang, G. H. Wu, L. J. Teng and T. Goldman, Phys. Rev. Lett. 69, 2901 (1992).
- [30]F. Wang, J. L. Ping, G. H. Wu, L. J. Teng, and T. Goldman, Phys. Rev. C 51, 3411 (1995); J. L. Ping, H. R. Pang, F. Wang, and T. Goldman, Phys. Rev. C 65, 044003 (2002); J. L. Ping, F. Wang, and T. Goldman, Nucl. Phys. A 657, 95 (1999); J. L. Ping, F. Wang, and T. Goldman, Nucl. Phys. A 688, 871 (2001).
- [31]Y. Y. Xue, X. Jin, H. X. Huang, J. L. Ping, and F. Wang, Phys. Rev. D 103, 054010 (2021).
- [32]R. Molina, D. Nicmorus and E. Oset, Phys. Rev. D 78, 114018 (2008)
- [33]L. S. Geng and E. Oset, Phys. Rev. D 79, 074009 (2009)
- [34]D. Gülmez, U. G. Meißner and J. A. Oller, Eur. Phys. J. C 77, no.7, 460 (2017)
- [35]M. L. Du, D. Gülmez, F. K. Guo, U. G. Meißner and Q. Wang, Eur. Phys. J. C 78 (2018) no.12, 988
- [36]J. L. Ping, H. X. Huang, H. R. Pang, F. Wang and C. W. Wong, Phys. Rev. C 79, 024001 (2009)