betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

First detection of suprathermal CH+^+ rotational emissions from chemical pumping: JWST/MIRI observations of the HH 168 molecular shock

Abstract

The methylidyne cation forms in warm or shocked interstellar gas through the endothermic reaction C+^+ + H2_2 -> CH+^+ + H. Because C+^+, which is common in irradiated and shocked gas, reacts with H2_2 only when the reactants supply > 0.4 eV, CH+^+ traces energy deposition in molecular gas. JWST/MIRI observations of HH 168 reveal the pure rotational lines R(17)-R(31) of CH+^+ at 13.7-21.3 micron, from upper levels J = 18-32 (0.57-1.65 eV). Eleven lines exceed 5 sigma in both of the two fields that we observed and match the hot H2_2 in radial velocity and spatial distribution. Because collisional excitation is negligible, each ion entering the v = 0 ladder emits one photon in every R(J) line below its entry level, so the line intensities provide the first measured rotational distribution of the ground-state products. The photon intensity falls almost linearly with increasing J, as expected for formation at a similar rate into every level up to J ~ 33; formation in J = 32 requires > 2 eV of reactant energy. The line positions, up to 150 km/s redward of ExoMol predictions, provide the first measurement of the CH+^+ rotational intervals above J = 16. A Boltzmann distribution at ϕTϕT ~ 6200 K, where ϕϕ is the fraction of the available energy appearing in rotation, fits slightly better, implying reactant energies equivalent to several thousand kelvin. These lines probe the dynamics of a prototypical interstellar ion-molecule reaction.

Introduction

The methylidyne cation was among the first interstellar molecules to be identified ([11]), and its abundance in diffuse clouds has posed a long-standing puzzle, because its only efficient formation route,

C++H2→CH++H,ΔE=+0.40 eV,(1)\mathrm{C}^{+} + \mathrm{H}_{2} \to\mathrm{CH}^{+} + \mathrm{H}, \qquad\Delta E = +0.40\,\mathrm{eV}, \tag*{(1)}

is endothermic by 0.40 eV and cannot proceed in cold gas ([14]). The proposed solutions, shocks ([14, 13, 33]), turbulent dissipation ([18, 15]) and, in dense photodissociation regions, vibrationally excited H2_2 ([1, 26]), all supply the energy of reaction (1) from the relative motion of C+^{+} and H2_2 or from the internal energy of H2_2.

Pure rotational emission of CH+^{+} was first detected with ISO in the planetary nebula NGC 7027 ([6]) and has since been observed with the far-infrared Herschel Space Observatory in the Orion Bar, in lines up to J=6→5J = 6 \to5 ([26]) and in maps of the J=3→2J = 3 \to2 line ([31]). The excitation of those lines already required “chemical pumping”: because the reaction deposits CH+^{+} in excited levels and the ion is destroyed by H, H2_2 and electrons before it can thermalize, the level populations of the observed molecules retain a memory of the formation process ([17 Faure et al.] 2017). The same chemical pumping accounts for the vibrational emission of CH+^{+} in NGC 7027, where the v=1→0v = 1 \to0 band observed in the near infrared arises from ions formed vibrationally excited by reaction (1) with vibrationally excited H2_2 (Neufeld et al. 2021; see also Changala et al. 2021, and Sil et al. 2026 for the effect of chemical pumping on the level populations). A close analogue is the suprathermal (“prompt”) emission of OH from rotational levels up to N=44N = 44–4646, which traces the nascent distribution of the OH produced by photodissociation of H2_2O ([39, 38, 42, 29]); there the excess excitation comes from a photodissociation, here from a chemical reaction.

The product state distribution of reaction (1) itself has never been measured for the ground electronic state of CH+^{+}. Chemiluminescence experiments have determined the rotational and vibrational distributions of the electronically excited A 1Π^{1}\Pi product at collision energies of 3–8 eV ([24]), and quantum calculations of state-to-state rate coefficients exist for the ground state at thermal energies ([41, 16, 19]), but not at the collision energies of 1–3 eV found in shocks.

Here we report JWST/MIRI observations of the Herbig-Haro object HH 168 in which the pure rotational lines of CH+^{+} are detected from levels as high as J=32J = 32, more than 19,000 K above the ground state. The emission is suprathermal. With radiative decay rates of 40–180 s−1^{-1}, collisions at the densities of the shocked gas cannot maintain significant populations in these levels, which are instead fed by the formation of CH+^{+} in highly excited states. We show that these lines are the radiative cascade of the newly formed ions and that their intensities therefore measure the nascent rotational distribution of the reaction products, which is well described by a Boltzmann distribution at a formation temperature of ≈ 6200 K.

Observations and data reduction

The bright Herbig-Haro object HH 168 lies in Cepheus A West, ≈ 700 pc away ([25]). Our spectra come from JWST GO program 7084 (PI: J. D. Green; “Measuring the Thickness of a J-Shock in Cep A West”), which used the MIRI Medium Resolution Spectrometer (MRS; [40, 4]) to cover the full 4.9–27.9 µm range with resolving power R≈1300R \approx1300–37003700. On 2026 August 1, observations 1 and 2 mapped two fields, G and C (named after the shock knots in [22]), along the shock, each with a five-pointing mosaic and the 4-point dither in every grating setting. Exposures used FASTR1 readout with 57 groups and two integrations per exposure (319 s), giving 6383 s per setting, and observation 3 provided a separate background field, at a single pointing, taken with identical settings. We processed the calibrated exposures retrieved from MAST (pipeline version 2.0.1) through stage 3 with JWST pipeline version 3.0.0 and Calibration Reference Data System context jwst_1535.pmap, subtracting the background exposures at the calibrated-exposure stage, ahead of cube building. The data can be retrieved from MAST at doi:10.17909/6wh2-6424.

All line fluxes are measured in maps brought to the angular resolution of the MRS at 23 µm (0.87″ FWHM). For each line we fitted, spaxel by spaxel, a Gaussian whose center and width were fixed (the latter at the width measured in each MIRI sub-band from free fits to the brightest unblended lines, corresponding to resolving powers of 3000–3200 in channel 3 and 2100–2300 in channel 4, higher in channel 4 than the in-flight values of Argyriou et al. [4], as also found by Pontoppidan et al. [35]), plus a quadratic baseline, with neighboring lines included as additional components where necessary (Section 3); for the bright H2_2 v=0v = 0 lines the center and width were free.

Each line map was convolved with a Gaussian whose FWHM is the quadrature difference between the 23 µm beam and the beam at the line wavelength, reddened to a common 0.35″ grid, and summed over a contiguous region of 3.06 arcsec2^{2} chosen, in each field, to have the highest convolved H2_2 S(7) intensity (outlined on the S(6) maps of Figure 2). All lines are therefore measured in the same effective beam, and no aperture correction need be applied. Uncertainties follow from the residuals of the same fit to the aperture spectrum of the convolved cube.

Figure 2. Maps of H₂ S(6) observed in second order in MIRI channel 3A (left; this image carries 1.5% of the first-order S(6) flux, Neufeld [27], and is shown without further convolution, since its native resolution, ≈ 0.86′′0.86^{\prime\prime}, already matches the 0.87′′0.87^{\prime\prime} of the CH⁺ maps) and of the sum of seven CH⁺ lines in channel 3, R(22), R(23), R(24), R(25), R(27), R(28) and R(30) (right), for fields G (top) and C (bottom), at a common angular resolution. The outlines on the S(6) maps mark the 3.06 arcsec23.06\ \mathrm{arcsec}^{2} apertures, chosen on the convolved S(7) maps (§ 2), from which the line fluxes were extracted. The contours drawn over the CH⁺ maps mark 20%, 40%, 60% and 80% of the S(6) peak, and rr is the correlation coefficient between the stacked CH⁺ and the first-order S(6) map from channel 1 (not shown), computed pixel by pixel wherever the stacked CH⁺ exceeds 3σ3\sigma within the channel 1 field. Offsets are relative to α=22h56m04.73s\alpha= 22^{\mathrm{h}}56^{\mathrm{m}}04.73^{\mathrm{s}}, δ=+62∘02′15.6′′\delta= +62^\circ02^\prime15.6^{\prime\prime} (G) and 22h56m02.83s22^{\mathrm{h}}56^{\mathrm{m}}02.83^{\mathrm{s}}, +62∘02′10.5′′+62^\circ02^\prime10.5^{\prime\prime} (C) (J2000).

Extinction corrections, AV=3.0A_V = 3.0 (G) and 4.1 mag (C), were derived from the H2_2 rotational lines, fitted with two temperature components as in Neufeld et al. [29], with the KP5 extinction curve ([8, 34]), and applied to all the CH+^{+} line intensities below.

Results

Detection and identification

Among the hitherto unidentified emission lines in the HH 168 spectra, a family of lines at 20.28, 19.41, 18.64, 17.31, 16.74, 16.23 and 15.76 µm stood out by their common spatial distribution, which follows the hot H2_2 emission. Their wavenumbers form a smooth sequence with spacings decreasing from 22.0 to 18.4 cm−1^{-1}, as expected for the R branch of a diatomic rotor. Spacings this large require a rotational constant B≳11B \gtrsim11 cm−1^{-1} and hence, for any plausible bond length, a reduced mass below 1.5 amu: the carrier had to be a hydride. The uniform and rapid decrease of the spacings pointed to strong centrifugal distortion, as expected for a rotor this light at high JJ. A fit of a rotational series ν=2B(J+1)−4D(J+1)3+6H(J+1)5\nu= 2B(J+1)-4D(J+1)^3+6H(J+1)^5 to these lines gives B=13.93 cm−1B=13.93\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} and reproduces the laboratory J=1→0J=1\to0 transition of CH+\mathrm{CH}^{+} at 27.857 cm−127.857\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} (Amano [2]; Doménech et al. [10]) to within 0.006 cm−10.006\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1}. We know of no other diatomic or light polyatomic species with a compatible rotational constant and distortion. The identification was confirmed by the subsequent detection of the predicted neighboring members of the ladder, and the full set of line positions is analyzed in § 3.2.

Table 1 lists the R(JJ) lines of CH+\mathrm{CH}^{+} from Jup=17J_{\rm up}=17 to 32, with their fluxes in the two fields, and Figure 1 shows the spectra of the twelve lines detected at more than 5σ5\sigma in at least one field (eleven of them in both), with the R(23) line at 16.745 μm16.745\ \mu\mathrm{m} the most significant (25 and 16σ16\sigma). R(16) is only tentative (≈2σ\approx2\sigma in each field), and the ladder is continuous from Jup=18J_{\rm up}=18 to 32 except for R(21) at 17.94 μm17.94\ \mu\mathrm{m}, which is hidden by [Fe ii] 17.936 μm17.936\ \mu\mathrm{m}; the next line, R(32) at 13.45 μm13.45\ \mu\mathrm{m} (Jup=33J_{\rm up}=33), is blended with a stronger unrelated line ≈75 km s−1\approx75\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} to its red; the lines R(0)–R(12), at λ>28 μm\lambda>28\ \mu\mathrm{m}, fall outside the MRS range, and R(13) and R(14), at 26.6 and 25.0 μm25.0\ \mu\mathrm{m} where the spectra are noisier, are not detected (<3σ<3\sigma; upper limits in Table 1); R(15), at 23.59 μm23.59\ \mu\mathrm{m}, is blended with an unrelated line of similar strength. Einstein AA coefficients and level energies are taken from the ExoMol PYT line list (Pearce et al. [32]); the AA values, 4040–180 s−1180\ \mathrm{s}^{-1}, are large because of the large dipole moment of CH+\mathrm{CH}^{+} (1.68 D1.68\ \mathrm{D}; Cheng et al. [9]), eight to eleven orders of magnitude larger than those of the H2\mathrm{H}_{2} rotational lines, and are insensitive to the small uncertainties in the computed level energies discussed below.

Transitionλ\lambda (µm)a^{a}AA (s−1^{-1})Eu/kE_u/k (K)FGF_GFCF_CΔvGb\Delta v_G^{b}ΔvCb\Delta v_C^{b}
R(13)f^{f}26.6491234123<26<26<38<38⋯\cdots⋯\cdots
R(14)f^{f}25.0427284698<10<10<12<12⋯\cdots⋯\cdots
R(15)g^{g}23.5997335308⋯\cdots⋯\cdots⋯\cdots⋯\cdots
R(16)22.3484c^{c}3959524.9±2.64.9 \pm2.67.0±3.07.0 \pm3.0⋯\cdots⋯\cdots
R(17)21.25244666297.8±0.77.8 \pm0.77.2±1.47.2 \pm1.4+8±8+8 \pm8−4±12-4 \pm12
R(18)20.280953733910.0±0.910.0 \pm0.99.3±1.39.3 \pm1.3+20±5+20 \pm5+11±8+11 \pm8
R(19)19.41496080809.0±0.79.0 \pm0.76.2±0.76.2 \pm0.7+24±7+24 \pm7+41±9+41 \pm9
R(20)18.63906888527.3±1.07.3 \pm1.05.7±0.95.7 \pm0.9+28±8+28 \pm8+45±11+45 \pm11
R(21)g^{g}17.9394769653⋯\cdots⋯\cdots⋯\cdots⋯\cdots
R(22)17.313785104856.0±0.76.0 \pm0.74.3±0.44.3 \pm0.4+51±6+51 \pm6+61±4+61 \pm4
R(23)16.744695113445.6±0.25.6 \pm0.24.9±0.34.9 \pm0.3+59±3+59 \pm3+60±2+60 \pm2
R(24)16.2291104122314.7±0.34.7 \pm0.33.9±0.33.9 \pm0.3+74±6+74 \pm6+68±6+68 \pm6
R(25)15.7598114131445.5±0.45.5 \pm0.44.8±0.54.8 \pm0.5+68±6+68 \pm6+64±6+64 \pm6
R(26)d^{d}15.3341124140834.9±0.94.9 \pm0.94.3±0.84.3 \pm0.8+90±8+90 \pm8+94±10+94 \pm10
R(27)14.9450134150463.0±0.33.0 \pm0.32.2±0.42.2 \pm0.4+97±5+97 \pm5+95±7+95 \pm7
R(28)e^{e}14.5900145160322.2±0.72.2 \pm0.72.0±0.52.0 \pm0.5+105±12+105 \pm12+102±8+102 \pm8
R(29)e^{e}14.2666155170413.1±0.53.1 \pm0.52.9±0.62.9 \pm0.6+123±6+123 \pm6+125±10+125 \pm10
R(30)13.9707166180723.7±0.53.7 \pm0.53.0±0.43.0 \pm0.4+127±6+127 \pm6+138±5+138 \pm5
R(31)e^{e}13.7006176191221.7±0.41.7 \pm0.41.2±0.41.2 \pm0.4+133±18+133 \pm18+162±18+162 \pm18
R(32)g^{g}13.45518720191⋯\cdots⋯\cdots⋯\cdots⋯\cdots
R(33)h^{h}13.22919721281<2.3<2.3<1.6<1.6⋯\cdots⋯\cdots

Table 1. CH+^{+} R(JJ) lines in HH 168.

Figure 1. Continuum-subtracted spectra of the CH+ R(J)R(J) lines detected at more than 5 σ in at least one field, in fields G (left) and C (right), offset vertically, against velocity relative to the mean velocity of the hot H2_2 lines S(5)–S(8) in each field, with the rest wavelengths of Table 1. Gray: Gaussian fits of fixed instrumental width and free center, with a linear baseline (the fluxes of Table 1 are from fixed-center fits); for R(19)R(19) the HD R(5)R(5) line at 19.431 µm, and for R(26)R(26) and R(29)R(29) the neighboring lines of Table 1 (notes d and e), are fitted as additional components (dashed: the CH+ component alone). R(21)R(21), at 17.94 µm, is omitted because it lies under [Fe ii] 17.936 µm (Table 1).

The CH+\mathrm{CH}^{+} lines are at the velocity of the H2\mathrm{H}_{2} emission. Relative to the mean velocity of the hot H2\mathrm{H}_{2} lines S(5)–S(8), the line centroids measured in the two fields agree within their uncertainties (Table 1); the H2\mathrm{H}_{2} lines S(1) and S(2), which fall in channel 3 with most of the CH+\mathrm{CH}^{+} lines, are 5 km s−15\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} (G) and 10 km s−110\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} (C) redder than S(5)–S(8), a measure of the uncertainty in the MIRI wavelength calibration between channels, and referring the offsets to them instead would shift them by those amounts, with the two fields still agreeing (ΔvG−C=+3±2 km s−1\Delta v_{\rm G-C}=+3\pm2\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1}).

The velocity-integrated line maps (Figure 2), stacked over seven lines that fall in MIRI channel 3, follow the H2\mathrm{H}_{2} S(6) emission with a pixel-by-pixel correlation coefficient of 0.87 (G) and 0.92 (C). The S(6) map shown in Figure 2 is the second-order image of the line that a spectral leak admits into channel 3A, which covers the same field as the CH+\mathrm{CH}^{+} lines; the correlation coefficients are computed instead with the first-order S(6) map from channel 1, over the part of the field that it covers (the second-order image gives 0.74 and 0.80).

Line positions and the CH+ energy levels

The measured line positions lie systematically to the red of the ExoMol positions, by an amount that grows with JJ: +5±7 km s−1+5\pm7\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} for R(17), +18±4+18\pm4 for R(18), +60±2+60\pm2 for R(23), +96±4+96\pm4 for R(27), +134±4+134\pm4 for R(30) and +148±13 km s−1+148\pm13\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} for R(31) (Table 1), i.e., ≈10 km s−1\approx10\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} per unit JJ above J≈20J\approx20. The H2\mathrm{H}_{2} and HD lines in the same spectra show no such offsets, so the shifts are not kinematic. The ExoMol energies of the CH+\mathrm{CH}^{+} levels above J=16J=16 are not constrained by laboratory data; they are computed from a potential energy curve and carry quoted uncertainties of 33–11 cm−111\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} for the observed levels (Pearce et al. [32]), whereas the cumulative offset we measure corresponds to a level error of only ≈2 cm−1\approx2\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} at J=31J=31 (relative to J=17J=17).

The only high-resolution laboratory measurements involving these levels are the A–X photofragment lines of Sarre et al. [36], from which the combination differences E(v=1,J=35)−E(v=1,J=33)E(v=1,J=35)-E(v=1,J=33) and E(1,34)−E(1,32)E(1,34)-E(1,32) can be formed; they are smaller than the ExoMol values by 0.91 and 0.77 cm−10.77\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1}, i.e., the true rotational intervals near J=34J=34 in v=1v=1 are 160–190 km s−1\mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} short of the ExoMol predictions, consistent in sign and magnitude with the trend of our v=0v=0 offsets. The wavelengths in Table 1 therefore provide the first measurement of the rotational intervals of CH+ X 1Σ+\mathrm{CH}^{+}\ X\ ^1\Sigma^+ above J=16J=16, with uncertainties of 0.010.01–0.03 cm−10.03\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} for the strongest lines (including the calibration systematic). Referencing each line instead to the H2\mathrm{H}_{2} or HD lines in its own MIRI sub-band, where such lines are available, changes the offsets by at most ∼10 km s−1\sim10\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1}, comparable to the uncertainty of the MIRI wavelength calibration and much less than the trend with JJ.

A fit of ν=2BJ−4DJ3+6HJ5−8LJ7\nu=2BJ-4DJ^3+6HJ^5-8LJ^7 (J=JupJ=J_{\rm up}; level energies BX−DX2+HX3−LX4BX-DX^2+HX^3-LX^4 with X=J(J+1)X=J(J+1)) to the 14 measured positions, with the calibration systematic of 10 km s−110\ \mathrm{km\ s}^{-1} added in quadrature to the statistical errors, gives B=13.936±0.004B=13.936\pm0.004, D=(1.392±0.011)×10−3D=(1.392\pm0.011)\times10^{-3}, H=(1.20±0.12)×10−7H=(1.20\pm0.12)\times10^{-7} and L=(1.4±0.4)×10−11 cm−1L=(1.4\pm0.4)\times10^{-11}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} (χ2=2.2\chi^2=2.2 for 10 degrees of freedom); BB and DD agree within 1.5σ1.5\sigma with the laboratory values (B0=13.9314B_0=13.9314 and D0=1.383×10−3 cm−1D_0=1.383\times10^{-3}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1}, Doménech et al. [10]; D0=1.376×10−3 cm−1D_0=1.376\times10^{-3}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} from

a^{a}Measured rest wavelength (vacuum) in the frame of the hot H2_2 emission, from the weighted mean of the two fields; statistical uncertainties 0.0001–0.0005 µm (2–7 km s−1^{-1}), or 0.0006 µm (12 km s−1^{-1}) for the weak R(31), to which the MIRI wavelength calibration adds ∼10\sim10 km s−1^{-1} systematically. Measured positions are +5 (R(17)), +18 (R(18)), +30, +33, +58, +60 (R(23)), +71, +66, +92, +96 (R(27)), +103, +124, +134 and +148 km s−1^{-1} (R(31)) to the red of the ExoMol PYT positions ([32]).

b^{b}Offset of the line centroid from the ExoMol PYT position in each field, in km s−1^{-1}, relative to the mean velocity of the hot H2_2 lines S(5)–S(8) of that field; statistical uncertainties only (the MIRI wavelength calibration adds ∼10\sim10 km s−1^{-1} between channels).

c^{c}Position predicted by the rotational fit of § 3.1, at which the flux is measured; this line is too weak for a centroid measurement. This position, close to the peak of the emission, lies 0.08 cm−1^{-1} (54 km s−1^{-1}) to the red of that calculated from the laboratory constants of Hakalla et al. [20], whose data extend to J=17J = 17. The ExoMol position differs from Hakalla’s by +0.6 cm−1^{-1}, reflecting the transition between empirical (MARVEL) and calculated levels at J=16J = 16–17.

d^{d}OH 15.314 µm and a second line ≈350\approx350 km s−1^{-1} to the blue of R(26) are fitted as one additional component.

e^{e}A line ≈260\approx260 km s−1^{-1} to the red of R(29) and R(31), and an unidentified line ≈175\approx175 km s−1^{-1} to the red of R(28), are fitted as additional components.

f^{f}ExoMol PYT position; 3σ3\sigma upper limits on the flux.

g^{g}Blended (see below); no flux is given. R(15) and R(21) at their ExoMol positions, R(32) from the fit of § 3.2.

h^{h}Position extrapolated from the trend of the offsets with JJ (Table note a); 3σ3\sigma upper limits.

**Note—**A values and upper-level energies from the ExoMol PYT line list ([32]). FGF_G, FCF_C: observed (not extinction-corrected) line fluxes integrated over the ≈3\approx3 arcsec2^2 apertures of Section 2, in units of 10−1710^{-17} erg cm−2^{-2} s−1^{-1}, from fits of fixed center and width (the width measured in each sub-band; statistical uncertainties). R(15) at 23.59 µm is blended with an unrelated line of similar strength, R(21) at 17.94 µm lies under [Fe II] 17.936 µm and R(32) at 13.455 µm (from the fit of § 3.2) is blended with a stronger line ≈75\approx75 km s−1^{-1} to its red; these three are listed without fluxes.

levels J≤17J \le17, Hakalla et al. [20], which confirms that the lines arise in v=0v = 0 (B1=13.44 cm−1B_1 = 13.44\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1}; Pearce et al. [32]). HH agrees with H0=1.10×10−7 cm−1H_0 = 1.10 \times10^{-7}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} (Hakalla et al. [20]) but is about half the H0=2.2×10−7 cm−1H_0 = 2.2 \times10^{-7}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-1} of Doménech et al. [10], which was constrained by the high-JJ lines (Cernicharo et al. [6]) in a fit without an LL term, so the measured lines are consistent with the low-JJ v=0v = 0 laboratory data once a higher-order distortion term is included.

The radiative cascade and the nascent distribution

In the X 1Σ+^{1}\Sigma^{+} ground state, which has no electronic angular momentum, rotational transitions obey ΔJ=±1\Delta J = \pm1, so the only radiative decay of level JJ is the R(J−1J-1) transition to J−1J - 1. With A=40A = 40–180 s−1180\ \mathrm{s}^{-1}, the radiative lifetimes of the observed levels are 6–26 ms, and collisional excitation or de-excitation is negligible unless the density exceeds A/k∼4×1010A/k \sim4 \times10^{10}–2×1011 cm−32 \times10^{11}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} for H₂ and 4×10114 \times10^{11}–2×1012 cm−32 \times10^{12}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} for H, where k∼10−9k \sim10^{-9} and 10−10 cm3s−110^{-10}\ \mathrm{cm}^{3}\mathrm{s}^{-1} are the rate coefficients for rotational transitions in collisions with H₂ (of order the Langevin rate) and H ([16, 19]), respectively; such densities are several orders of magnitude larger than is plausible for the molecular gas in HH 168. Electron collisions are faster for a polar ion (ke≈3×10−7 cm3 s−1k_{\mathrm e} \approx3 \times10^{-7}\,\mathrm{cm}^{3}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1} for J=1→0J=1 \to0 at 2000–3000 K, from calculations that extend to J=11J=11; Hamilton et al. [21]; Faure et al. [16]), but the corresponding critical electron densities, 10810^{8}–109 cm−310^{9}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3}, far exceed any plausible electron density in the shocked gas. The main destruction route of CH+^{+}, the reverse of reaction (1) with H atoms, has a rate coefficient of (4(4–8)×10−10 cm3 s−18) \times10^{-10}\,\mathrm{cm}^{3}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1} at 1000–3000 K (Faure et al. [16]) and is likewise slow compared with the radiative decay for n(H)≪1010 cm−3n(\mathrm H) \ll10^{10}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-3}.

Each CH+^{+} ion formed in level JfJ_{\mathrm f} therefore emits exactly one photon in every R(JJ) line with J<JfJ<J_{\mathrm f} on its way to the ground state. The photon intensity of the R(J−1J-1) line, IJ=FJ/(hνJΩ)I_J=F_J/(h\nu_J\Omega), is thus the rate per unit area and solid angle at which CH+^{+} is formed in levels ≥J\geq J,

IJ=14π∑J′≥JP(J′),(2)I_J=\frac{1}{4\pi}\sum_{J'\geq J}P(J'), \tag*{(2)}

where P(J′)P(J') is the formation rate per unit area into level J′J', and the nascent distribution follows from differences of successive lines, P(J)=4π(IJ−IJ+1)P(J)=4\pi(I_J-I_{J+1}). No excitation model is required.

Figure 3 shows IJI_J for the two fields, corrected for extinction. It falls almost linearly with increasing JJ, from (1.1(1.1–1.8)×1071.8) \times10^{7} photons cm−2 s−1 sr−1\mathrm{cm}^{-2}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}\,\mathrm{sr}^{-1} at J=18J=18–20 to (1.6(1.6–2.1)×1062.1) \times10^{6} at J=32J=32; the two fields agree in shape and within 15% in normalization. By equation (2), a linear decline is expected if CH+^{+} is formed at a similar rate into every level up to some Jmax⁡J_{\max} and then cascades radiatively (ΔJ=−1\Delta J=-1) to lower JJ, for then IJ∝Jmax⁡−J+1I_J\propto J_{\max}-J+1. A fit of this form (Figure 3, dashed) gives Jmax⁡=33.1±0.5J_{\max}=33.1\pm0.5 (G) and 33.7±0.633.7\pm0.6 (C) and matches most lines to within 30%; χ2/dof\chi^{2}/\mathrm{dof} falls from 3.6 and 2.9 to 1.9 and 1.9 when a 10% systematic uncertainty is added to each line.

Figure 3. Mean photon intensity of the CH+^{+} R(J−1)R(J-1) lines against the upper level JJ, in fields G (top) and C (bottom), corrected for extinction. Points: lines detected at more than 2.5σ2.5\sigma (the detections shown in Figure 1 are those above 5σ5\sigma; the fits use all measured intensities with their errors), with 1σ1\sigma error bars; arrows: 3σ3\sigma upper limits. R(21)R(21) (J=22J=22), which lies under [Fe ii] 17.936 μ\mum, and R(15)R(15) (J=16J=16), blended with an unrelated line, are omitted. By equation (2) each point is the rate at which CH+^{+} is formed in levels ≥J\ge J. Dashed line: the cascade expected if CH+^{+} were formed at the same rate pp into every level up to Jmax⁡J_{\max} (with no statistical-weight factor), so that IJ=p(Jmax⁡−J+1)I_J=p\left(J_{\max}-J+1\right), fitted to all measured values including the non-detections: Jmax⁡=33.1±0.5J_{\max}=33.1\pm0.5, p=(0.85±0.05)×106p=(0.85\pm0.05)\times10^{6} photons cm−2^{-2} s−1^{-1} sr−1^{-1} per level, χ2=47\chi^2=47 for 13 degrees of freedom (G); Jmax⁡=33.7±0.6J_{\max}=33.7\pm0.6, p=(0.70±0.06)×106p=(0.70\pm0.06)\times10^{6}, χ2=38\chi^2=38 (C), with statistical errors only; with a 10% systematic uncertainty added to each line, χ2=24\chi^2=24 for 13 degrees of freedom in both fields. Dotted curve: the cascade from a Boltzmann nascent distribution at the formation temperature Tf=ϕTT_f=\phi T, fitted in the same way: Tf=6400T_f=6400 K, χ2=35\chi^2=35 (G) and 6300 K, χ2=30\chi^2=30 (C) with statistical errors only, and Tf=6300T_f=6300 and 6100 K, χ2=19\chi^2=19 for 13 degrees of freedom in both fields, with the 10% systematic uncertainty.

The nascent distribution is therefore broad, with roughly uniform formation, (0.70(0.70–0.85)×1060.85) \times10^{6} photons cm−2 s−1 sr−1\mathrm{cm}^{-2}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1}\,\mathrm{sr}^{-1} per level, from J≲17J\lesssim17 to J≈33J\approx33; the largest departure is an excess of 30–60% at J=19J=19, in R(18). Formation into levels below J=17J=17, whose lines lie beyond the range used here, is not constrained1, and the J=17J=17 line is only tentative (≈2σ\approx2\sigma). The total formation rate into J≥18J\geq18 is 4πI18≈1.8×108 cm−2 s−14\pi I_{18}\approx1.8\times10^{8}\,\mathrm{cm}^{-2}\,\mathrm{s}^{-1} in both fields. A rotation diagram of the same lines, which is the conventional presentation, gives a “rotational temperature” of ≈3300\approx3300 K; this temperature has

no physical meaning here, since the populations are not set by collisions.

A physically motivated alternative is a thermal nascent distribution. If the energy available above the reaction threshold is distributed roughly exponentially, as it is for reactants with a Maxwellian distribution of collision energies at a temperature TT, and a fixed fraction ϕ\phi of it appears in product rotation, the new ions follow a Boltzmann distribution, P(J)∝(2J+1)exp⁡(−EJ/kTf)P(J)\propto(2J+1)\exp(-E_J/kT_{\mathrm f}), at a formation temperature Tf=ϕTT_{\mathrm f}=\phi T; only the product ϕT\phi T is constrained. Equation (2) with this distribution fits the data slightly better than uniform formation (χ2\chi^{2} lower by 5–6 in each field for the same number of free parameters; an improvement this large would arise by chance in ≈1%\approx1\% of cases if formation were uniform) (Figure 3, dotted): Tf=6300±550T_{\mathrm f}=6300\pm550 K (G) and 6100±6506100\pm650 K (C), with χ2/dof=1.4\chi^{2}/\mathrm{dof}=1.4 in both G and C when a 10% systematic uncertainty is included (2.7 and 2.3 with statistical errors alone). The mean rotational energy of the new ions is then ≈0.57\approx0.57 eV. Even if all the available energy appeared in rotation, this would require reactant energies equivalent to T≳6000T\gtrsim6000 K; for ϕ≈2/3\phi\approx2/3, as quantum calculations suggest at lower energies (Faure et al. [16]), T≈9300T\approx9300 K. This distribution would place about half of the formation in levels below J=17J=17, which our data do not constrain. Both descriptions rest on simplified and idealized assumptions: uniform formation is an empirical description, adopted because it fits the data rather than derived from the reaction dynamics, and the Boltzmann form assumes a Maxwellian distribution of collision energies with a fixed fraction ϕ\phi of the available energy appearing in rotation. A quantitative understanding will require state-to-state calculations of reaction (1) at collision energies above 1 eV, extending those of González-Lenaza et al. (2026, see § 4).

At the energies involved, some CH+^{+} may also be formed vibrationally excited, or in the lowest excited electronic state, a 3Π^{3}\Pi, about 1.2 eV above the ground state (Amitay et al. [3]). In v=1v=1, the rotational decay rates within the vibrational level (54–140 s−1\mathrm{s}^{-1} for J=20J=20–30) exceed the vibrational decay rates to v=0v=0 (9–15 s−1\mathrm{s}^{-1}; Pearce et al. [32]), so an ion formed in v=1v=1 emits a rotational line of v=1v=1 at most steps, but has a 10–15% chance at each step of decaying to v=0v=0 with ΔJ=±1\Delta J=\pm1, thereby entering the v=0v=0 ladder at a similar JJ. Ions formed in a 3Π^{3}\Pi, which has no spin-allowed decay to the ground state, survive for several seconds (Amitay et al. [3]), still short compared with their destruction time, before decaying to X 1Σ+^{1}\Sigma^{+}; they too can enter the v=0v=0 ladder only indirectly. The v=0v=0 cascade therefore measures the rate at which ions enter the

v=0v = 0 ladder at each JJ, directly or through such decays, rather than the full nascent distribution. The v=1v = 1 rotational lines themselves are not detected: stacked at the positions predicted from the ExoMol v=1v = 1 levels with the offset law of the v=0v = 0 lines, they give 2.5 σ2.5\,\sigma (G) and 2.0 σ2.0\,\sigma (C), and a flux ratio F(v=1)/F(v=0)<0.31F(v=1)/F(v=0) < 0.31 in both fields (3 σ3\,\sigma), so that most of the observed emission comes from ions formed in v=0v = 0. This limit applies only to the high-JJ levels that MIRI observes. Formation into v≥1v \ge1 at low JJ remains possible: reaction (1) with vibrationally excited H2_2 is exothermic, and much of the reactant vibrational energy may appear as product vibration, just as H2_2O photodissociated in its first absorption band yields OH that is vibrationally hot but rotationally cold ([38]). Ions formed in this way would emit only far-infrared rotational lines and the v=1→0v = 1 \to0 band at 3.53.5–4.1 μm4.1\,\mu\mathrm{m}, observed in NGC 7027 ([28]), so the v=0v = 0 cascade gives a lower limit to the total formation rate.

The highest level detected, J=32J = 32 at E/k=19,100E/k = 19{,}100 K, places a lower limit on the energy available in reaction (1). Since the products must carry away the endothermicity as well as the rotational energy, the reactants must supply at least 1.65+0.40=2.051.65 + 0.40 = 2.05 eV. This is the sum of the center-of-mass collision energy and the internal energy of the H2_2, which can be substantial; the reaction is exothermic for vibrationally excited H2_2, and also for H2_2 in v=0v = 0 with J≥8J \ge8 ([16]). If the H2_2 were in low levels, the collision energy alone would need to reach 2.052.05 eV, which for ions drifting through H2_2 in a C-type shock requires a drift speed of at least 1515 km s−1^{-1} (reduced mass 1.731.73 amu), and for thermal collisions requires the tail of the Maxwellian beyond ∼2\sim2 eV, i.e., T≳7000T \gtrsim7000 K; reactions with excited H2_2 relax these limits. For comparison, the H2_2 rotational excitation temperatures in the two fields rise from 700700–900900 K (S(1)–S(3)) to 11001100–15001500 K (S(5)–S(8)); these approximate the kinetic temperatures of the H2_2-emitting gas if its levels are close to equilibrium, and at such temperatures only a few per cent of the H2_2 is in levels with J≥8J \ge8. These temperatures, far below 70007000 K, are typical of C-type shocks, in which the energy for reaction (1) comes from ion-neutral drift rather than from the gas temperature. They would also be consistent with a J-type shock if the gas spans a range of temperatures, since the H2_2 emission would then come mostly from gas cooler than that in which the highest CH+^+ levels form. The drift speed cannot be measured directly, because the MIRI line profiles do not resolve it, but the required ≳15\gtrsim15 km s−1^{-1} is plausible in C-type shocks, in which the ion-neutral drift speed can be a substantial fraction of the shock speed ([12]). The lines detected at J=29J = 29–3232 follow the extrapolation of the J=21J = 21–2828 decline to within 0.30.3 dex, and no clear turnover is seen, although these lines are detected at only 33–8 σ8\,\sigma: the distribution may well extend beyond the highest level we can measure.

Discussion

The high-JJ CH+^+ lines open an unusual observational window. In laboratory ion-beam experiments the product state distribution of reaction (1) has been measured only for the electronically excited A 1Π^1\Pi product, through its chemiluminescence ([24]); the ground-state product distribution, which determines the chemical pumping invoked to explain CH+^+ excitation throughout most of the interstellar medium ((Godard & Cernicharo 2013; Faure et al. 2017; but see Oka et al. 2013 for radiative pumping toward Herschel 36)), has been accessible only through theory. The HH 168 spectrum provides it directly, albeit averaged over the collision energies of the shock: formation at a roughly uniform rate per level from J≲17J \lesssim17 to J≈33J \approx33, or a Boltzmann distribution at ϕT≈6200\phi T \approx6200 K. The situation parallels that of the suprathermal OH lines, whose intensities map the rotational distribution of OH emerging from H2_2O photodissociation ([39, 38, 42, 29]); here the process is a bimolecular reaction rather than a photodissociation. A quantum or statistical calculation of reaction (1) on the ground-state CH2+_2^+ surface at collision energies of 11–33 eV, such as those performed by Zanchet et al. [41] and González-Lezana et al. [19] at lower energies, would be tested by these data.

The lines also constrain the CH+^+ budget of the shock. CH+^+ is destroyed rapidly by reactions with H, H2_2 and electrons, so the line intensities measure the rate of reaction (1) rather than the abundance of CH+^+: the observed formation rate into J≥18J \ge18, 1.8×1081.8 \times10^8 ions cm−2^{-2} s−1^{-1}, is the product of the C+^+ abundance, the density of reactive H2_2 and the rate coefficient, integrated through the emitting layer. Carbon nuclei enter the shock at a rate xCnHvs=108x−4n5v7x_{\mathrm{C}} n_{\mathrm{H}} v_{\mathrm{s}} = 10^8 x_{-4} n_5 v_7 cm−2^{-2} s−1^{-1}, where xC=10−4x−4x_{\mathrm{C}} = 10^{-4} x_{-4} is the gas-phase carbon abundance per H nucleus, nH=105n5n_{\mathrm{H}} = 10^5 n_5 cm−3^{-3} the preshock density and vs=100v7v_{\mathrm{s}} = 100 v_7 km s−1^{-1} the shock speed. For a shock surface viewed face-on, each carbon nucleus must therefore form ≈1.8/(x−4n5v7)\approx1.8/(x_{-4} n_5 v_7) CH+^+ ions in levels J≥18J \ge18, or ≈5/(x−4n5v7)\approx5/(x_{-4} n_5 v_7) in all levels if the Boltzmann distribution is extrapolated to low JJ. The observations therefore require Ncycx−4n5v7≳2N_{\mathrm{cyc}} x_{-4} n_5 v_7 \gtrsim2–55, where NcycN_{\mathrm{cyc}} is the number of times each carbon nucleus forms CH+^+. Because the reaction of CH+^+ with H returns the carbon to C+^+ within the hot layer, Ncyc>1N_{\mathrm{cyc}} > 1 is expected, and the data do not distinguish a large preshock mass flux from repeated cycling. Models of C- and J-type shocks that follow the formation, excitation and destruction of CH+^{+} will be presented in a future paper.

Finally, these lines should be present wherever H2_2 is heated to a few thousand kelvin with little infrared radiation to confuse the spectrum. These lines are detected in at least one other protostellar shock observed with MIRI, associated with HOPS 78, as we will report separately (S. Lee, PhD thesis in preparation; S. Lee et al., ApJ, in preparation). In HH 168, the lines are not blended with any strong feature in the 13.7–21.3 μ\mum range except R(21); R(19), R(26), R(28), R(29) and R(31) are fitted with neighboring lines as extra components. Where the formation energy comes from ion-neutral drift rather than thermal collisions, the shape of the cascade should differ, and the two can be told apart.

Conclusions

  1. We have detected the pure rotational lines R(17)–R(31) of CH+^{+}, from levels J=18J = 18–32 up to 19,100 K above the ground state, toward HH 168 with JWST/MIRI; twelve lines in one field and eleven in the other exceed 5σ5\sigma, and their velocities and maps match those of the hot H2_2.

  1. The measured line positions are up to 150 km s−1^{-1} redward of the ExoMol predictions, the offset increasing with JJ, and constitute the first measurement of the CH+^{+} rotational intervals above J=16J = 16.

  1. Because the lines are the radiative cascade of newly formed ions, their photon intensities give the nascent rotational distribution of the C+^{+} + H2_2 reaction products entering the v=0v = 0 ladder: roughly uniform formation per level from J≲17J \lesssim17 (lower levels are not constrained) to J≈33J \approx33, which requires at least 2 eV of reactant energy. The formation rate into J≥18J \ge18 is 1.8 ×108\times10^{8} ions cm−2^{-2} s−1^{-1}.

  1. The cascade is fitted slightly better (χ2\chi^{2} lower by 5–6 in each field, for the same number of free parameters) by a Boltzmann nascent distribution at a formation temperature ϕT=6100\phi T = 6100–6300 K, where ϕ\phi is the fraction of the available energy that appears in product rotation, than by uniform formation per level, although neither is excluded. This requires reactant energies equivalent to T≳6000T \gtrsim6000 K, or ≈9300\approx9300 K if ϕ≈2/3\phi\approx2/3.

This work is based on observations made with the NASA/ESA/CSA James Webb Space Telescope. The data were obtained from the Mikulski Archive for Space Telescopes at the Space Telescope Science Institute, which is operated by the Association of Universities for Research in Astronomy, Inc., under NASA contract NAS 5-03127 for JWST. These observations are associated with program #7084. Support for program #7084 was provided by NASA through grant JWST-GO-07084 from the Space Telescope Science Institute. D.A.N. was supported in part by JWST Theory grant JWST-AR-06829, “Understanding the rich molecular spectra observed with NIRSpec and MIRI/MRS toward protostellar outflows.”

Use of generative AI: Anthropic’s Claude (Opus 5.5 and Fable 5.1, accessed through Claude Code) was used for data analysis, coding, generating the figures from the data using Matplotlib, and drafting and revising the manuscript text. OpenAI’s Codex was used to write the initial line-fitting and mapping code. The authors take full responsibility for the content of this paper.

Facility: JWST (MIRI)

Software: Matplotlib [23]

References

  1. [1]Agúndez, M., Goicoechea, J. R., Cernicharo, J., Faure, A., & Roueff, E. 2010, ApJ, 713, 662, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/713/1/662DOI
  2. [2]Amano, T. 2010, ApJL, 716, L1, doi: 10.1088/2041-8205/716/1/L1DOI
  3. [3]Amitay, Z., Zajfman, D., Forck, P., et al. 1996, PhRvA, 54, 4032, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevA.54.4032DOI
  4. [4]Argyriou, I., Glasse, A., Law, D. R., et al. 2023, A&A, 675, A111, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/202346489DOI
  5. [5]Bradford, C. M., Kogut, A. J., Fixsen, D., et al. 2025, J. Astron. Telesc. Instrum. Syst., 11, 031627, doi: 10.1117/1.JATIS.11.3.031627DOI
  6. [6]Cernicharo, J., Liu, X.-W., González-Alfonso, E., et al. 1997, ApJL, 483, L65, doi: 10.1086/310729DOI
  7. [8]Chapman, N. L., Mundy, L. G., Lai, S.-P., & Evans, II, N. J. 2009, ApJ, 690, 496, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/690/1/496DOI
  8. [9]Cheng, M., Brown, J. M., Rosmus, P., et al. 2007, PhRvA, 75, 012502, doi: 10.1103/PhysRevA.75.012502DOI
  9. [10]Doménech, J. L., Jusko, P., Schlemmer, S., & Asvany, O. 2018, ApJ, 857, 61, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/aab36aDOI
  10. [11]Douglas, A. E., & Herzberg, G. 1941, ApJ, 94, 381, doi: 10.1086/144342DOI
  11. [12]Draine, B. T. 1980, ApJ, 241, 1021, doi: 10.1086/158416DOI
  12. [13]Draine, B. T., & Katz, N. 1986, ApJ, 310, 392, doi: 10.1086/164693DOI
  13. [14]Elitzur, M., & Watson, W. D. 1978, ApJL, 222, L141, doi: 10.1086/182711DOI
  14. [15]Falgarone, E., Godard, B., Cernicharo, J., et al. 2010, A&A, 521, L15, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201015109DOI
  15. [16]Faure, A., Halvick, P., Stoecklin, T., et al. 2017, MNRAS, 469, 612, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stx892DOI
  16. [17]Godard, B., & Cernicharo, J. 2013, A&A, 550, A8, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201220151DOI
  17. [18]Godard, B., Falgarone, E., & Pineau des Forêts, G. 2009, A&A, 495, 847, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361:200810803DOI
  18. [19]González-Lezana, T., Konings, M., Loreau, J., et al. 2026, Physical Chemistry Chemical Physics, 28, 4065, doi: 10.1039/D5CP04254B
  19. [20]Hakalla, R., Kępa, R., Szajna, W., & Zachwieja, M. 2006, European Physical Journal D, 38, 481, doi: 10.1140/epjd/e2006-00063-9DOI
  20. [21]Hamilton, J. R., Faure, A., & Tennyson, J. 2016, MNRAS, 455, 3281, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stv2429DOI
  21. [22]Hartigan, P., Morse, J. A., & Bally, J. 2000, AJ, 120, 1436, doi: 10.1086/301522DOI
  22. [23]Hunter, J. D. 2007, Computing in Science and Engineering, 9, 90, doi: 10.1109/MCSE.2007.55
  23. [24]Kusunoki, I., & Ottinger, C. 1979, JChPh, 71, 4227, doi: 10.1063/1.438230DOI
  24. [25]Moscadelli, L., Reid, M. J., Menten, K. M., et al. 2009, ApJ, 693, 406, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/693/1/406DOI
  25. [26]Nagy, Z., Van der Tak, F. F. S., Ossenkopf, V., et al. 2013, A&A, 550, A96, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201220519DOI
  26. [27]Neufeld, D. A. 2026, Research Notes of the American Astronomical Society, 10, 282, doi: 10.3847/2515-5172/aeae30
  27. [28]Neufeld, D. A., Godard, B., Changala, P. B., Faure, A., et al. 2021, ApJ, 917, 15, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ac05c9DOI
  28. [29]Neufeld, D. A., Manoj, P., Tyagi, H., et al. 2024, ApJL, 966, L22, doi: 10.3847/2041-8213/ad3d48DOI
  29. [31]Parikka, A., Habart, E., Bernard-Salas, J., et al. 2017, A&A, 599, A20, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201629445DOI
  30. [32]Pearce, O., Yurchenko, S. N., & Tennyson, J. 2024, MNRAS, 527, 10726, doi: 10.1093/mnras/stad3909DOI
  31. [33]Pineau des Forêts, G., Flower, D. R., Hartquist, T. W., & Dalgarno, A. 1986, MNRAS, 220, 801, doi: 10.1093/mnras/220.4.801DOI
  32. [34]Pontoppidan, K. M., Evans, N., Bergner, J., & Yang, Y.-L. 2024a, Research Notes of the American Astronomical Society, 8, 68, doi: 10.3847/2515-5172/ad303f
  33. [35]Pontoppidan, K. M., Salyk, C., Banzatti, A., et al. 2024b, ApJ, 963, 158, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ad20f0DOI
  34. [36]Sarre, P. J., Walmsley, J. M., & Whitham, C. J. 1986, Journal of the Chemical Society, Faraday Transactions 2, 82, 1243, doi: 10.1039/f29868201243DOI
  35. [38]Tabone, B., van Hemert, M. C., van Dishoeck, E. F., & Black, J. H. 2021, A&A, 650, A192, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/202039549DOI
  36. [39]Tappe, A., Lada, C. J., Black, J. H., & Muench, A. A. 2008, ApJL, 680, L117, doi: 10.1086/589998DOI
  37. [40]Wells, M., Pel, J.-W., Glasse, A., et al. 2015, PASP, 127, 646, doi: 10.1086/682281DOI
  38. [41]Zanchet, A., Godard, B., Bulut, N., et al. 2013, ApJ, 766, 80, doi: 10.1088/0004-637X/766/2/80DOI
  39. [42]Zannese, M., Tabone, B., Habart, E., et al. 2024, Nature Astronomy, 8, 577, doi: 10.1038/s41550-024-02203-0DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_8nzz227y
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents