betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Compatibility of recent S=−2{\cal S}=-2 emulsion events

Abstract

We question the compatibility of recent S=−2{\cal S}=-2 hypernuclear assignments of J-PARC E07 Ξ−Ξ^--capture emulsion events with assignments deduced from other experiments.

Implications of the J-PARC E05 12C(K−,K+)12Be^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^-,K^+)^{12}\mathrm{Be} spectrum

J-PARC E05 published recently a 12C(K−,K+)12Be^{12}\mathrm{C}(K^-,K^+)^{12}\mathrm{Be} spectrum that indicates a nuclear Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s}–11B^{11}\mathrm{B} state bound by BΞ−=8.9±1.4−3.1+3.8B_{\Xi^-} = 8.9 \pm1.4^{+3.8}_{-3.1} MeV [1]. A natural question to ask is whether this Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s} assignment is compatible with nuclear Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s}–14N^{14}\mathrm{N} assignments of Ξ−\Xi^--capture emulsion events shown in Figure 1. Indeed, expecting BΞ−B_{\Xi^-} to increase with AA, it is puzzling to have a Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s}–11B^{11}\mathrm{B} binding energy larger than a Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s}–14N^{14}\mathrm{N} binding energy of 6.27±0.276.27 \pm0.27 MeV (E07 event IRRAWADDY, Figure 1). It would require an abnormally strong repulsive ΞNN\Xi NN three-body force to accommodate both [3]. A likely resolution of such incompatibility is that the 14N^{14}\mathrm{N} Ξ1s−\Xi^-_{1s}-assigned capture events stand for Ξ1p0\Xi^0_{1p}–14C^{14}\mathrm{C} nuclear states [4] briefly discussed below.

Figure 1. Ξ−−14N\Xi^- - ^{14}\mathrm{N} spectrum deduced from Ξ−\Xi^- capture events identified by their twin-Λ\Lambda hypernuclear decays in KEK-PS E373 and J-PARC E07 emulsion experiments. Figure adapted from Ref. [2].

[1] K. Nakazawa, et. al., Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2015, 033D02 (2015), E. Hiyama and K. Nakazawa, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 68, 131 (2018).

[2] S. Hayakawa, et. al., Phy. Rev. Lett., 126, 062501 (2021).

[3] M. Yoshimoto, et. al., Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2021, 073D02 (2021). Ξ−\Xi^{-} atomic cascade in light (C,N,O) emulsion nuclei normally terminates with atomic 3D→2P3D \to2P radiative E1E1 transitions [5]. Indeed, Ξ−\Xi^{-} capture events identified during the last three decades at KEK and J-PARC provide evidence, as discussed in Ref. [6], for Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p} nuclear states bound by ≈1\approx1 MeV in 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} and 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N}. The formed Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p} Coulomb-assisted nuclear states undergo Ξ−p→ΛΛ\Xi^{-}p \to\Lambda\Lambda strong-interaction conversion. Forming radiatively Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s} nuclear bound states is suppressed by almost two orders of magnitude [7, 8]. Hence, recent Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s} assignments of capture events in 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} by J-PARC E07 [2] are questionable. Ref. [4] demonstrates how radiative E1E1 de-excitation of the atomic Ξ3D−−14N\Xi^{-}_{3D} - {}^{14}\mathrm{N} state populates comparably both Ξ1p−−14N\Xi^{-}_{1p} - {}^{14}\mathrm{N} and Ξ1p0−14C\Xi^{0}_{1p} - {}^{14}\mathrm{C} states that are separated by about 5 MeV, see Figure 2, in spite of their rather small mixing by a residual two-body ΞN\Xi N interaction of order 0.5 MeV. This small mixing gets compensated by a roughly six times larger E1E1 transition energy from Ξ3D−−14N\Xi^{-}_{3D} - {}^{14}\mathrm{N} to Ξ1p0−14C\Xi^{0}_{1p} - {}^{14}\mathrm{C} than to Ξ1p−−14N\Xi^{-}_{1p} - {}^{14}\mathrm{N}, resulting in two orders of magnitude enhancement of the E1E1 transition rate to Ξ1p0−14C\Xi^{0}_{1p} - {}^{14}\mathrm{C} which compensates for the roughly 1% mixing strength. Such mechanism does not work for the carbon or oxygen nuclear constituents of the (C,N,O) emulsion.

Figure 2. Ξ1s−−14N\Xi^{-}_{1s} - {}^{14}\mathrm{N} IRRAWADDY reinterpreted as Ξ1p0−14C\Xi^{0}_{1p} - {}^{14}\mathrm{C}. Figure adapted from Ref. [4].

In conclusion, the only remaining Ξ1s−\Xi^{-}_{1s} nuclear candidate is the J-PARC E05 Ξ1s−−11B\Xi^{-}_{1s} - {}^{11}\mathrm{B} state bound by BΞ−=8.9±1.4−3.1+3.8B_{\Xi^{-}} = 8.9 \pm1.4^{+3.8}_{-3.1} MeV [1]. It is compatible with Ξ1p−\Xi^{-}_{1p} Coulomb-assisted states bound by ≈1\approx1 MeV in 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} and 14N{}^{14}\mathrm{N} upon using a Pauli-corrected density-dependent Ξ\Xi-nuclear attractive potential of ≈21\approx21 MeV depth at nuclear-matter density ρ0=0.17 fm−3\rho_{0} = 0.17\ \mathrm{fm}^{-3} [3]. Such a potential depth is within the range of values 17±617 \pm6 MeV derived in Ref. [9] from a K+K^{+} quasi-free spectrum measured by BNL-AGS E906 in (K−,K+)(K^{-}, K^{+}) on 9Be{}^{9}\mathrm{Be} [10] covering also lower values than ours deduced from KEK-E224 [11] and BNL-AGS E885 [12] (K−,K+)(K^{-}, K^{+}) experiments on 12C{}^{12}\mathrm{C} targets. However, a depth value of 21 MeV is considerably larger than reported in recent theoretical evaluations, e.g., HAL-QCD [13]: 4 MeV; χ\chiEFT@NLO [14]: 9 MeV; SU(6) [15]: 6 MeV. A notable exception is provided by versions ESC16*(A,B) of the latest Nijmegen extended-soft-core ΞN\Xi N interaction model [16] where Ξ\Xi-nuclear potential depths larger than 20 MeV are derived, but then reduced substantially by ΞNN\Xi NN three-body contributions within the same ESC16* model.

Implications of a recent J-PARC E07 ΛΛ13B^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B} event

J-PARC E07 published recently a new Ξ−\Xi^- capture emulsion event identified as production and decay of ΛΛ13B^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B} [17] specified by the following three vertices (see Figure 3):

Photo of the new E07 event and a schematic drawing of the production and weak-decay vertices

Figure 3. Photo of the new E07 event [17] along with a schematic drawing of the ΛΛ13B^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B} production vertex A and weak-decay vertices B and C; see text.

  • A: Ξ−+14N→ΛΛ13B(#1)+p(#3)+n\Xi^- + {}^{14}\mathrm{N} \rightarrow{}^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B}(\#1) + p(\#3) + n

  • B: ΛΛ13B→Λ5He(#2)+t(#4)+3He(#5)+2n{}^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B} \rightarrow{}^{5}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{He}(\#2) + t(\#4) + {}^{3}\mathrm{He}(\#5) + 2n

  • C: Λ5He→4He(#6)+π−(#7)+p(#8){}^{5}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{He} \rightarrow{}^{4}\mathrm{He}(\#6) + \pi^-(\#7) + p(\#8)

We note that momentum and energy balance in both ΛΛ13B^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B} production vertex A and weak-decay vertex B require unobserved neutrons. Vertex A yields BΛΛ(ΛΛ13B)=25.57±1.18±0.07B_{\Lambda\Lambda}(^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B}) = 25.57 \pm1.18 \pm0.07 MeV, assuming here too that Ξ−\Xi^- capture occurs from a 14N 3D{}^{14}\mathrm{N}\ 3D atomic state. Using BΛ(Λ12Bg.s.)=11.37B_{\Lambda}(^{12}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{B}_{\mathrm{g.s.}})=11.37 MeV, the ΛΛ\Lambda\Lambda interaction strength in ΛΛ13B^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B} assumes the value

ΔBΛΛ=BΛΛ(ΛΛ13B)−2BΛ(Λ12B)=2.83±1.18±0.14 MeV.(1)\Delta B_{\Lambda\Lambda} = B_{\Lambda\Lambda}(^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B}) - 2B_{\Lambda}(^{12}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{B}) = 2.83 \pm1.18 \pm0.14\ \mathrm{MeV}. \tag*{(1)}

Introducing the (2J+1)(2J+1) averaged BΛB_{\Lambda} for the (1−,2−)(1^-, 2^-) g.s. doublet levels instead of that for just the 1−1^- g.s. has a small effect of changing 2.83 MeV to 2.97 MeV, which is disregarded here. The value of ΔBΛΛ\Delta B_{\Lambda\Lambda} in Eq. (1) is considerably larger, by 2σ2\sigma, than the value 0.67±0.170.67 \pm0.17 MeV derived from the KEK-PS E373 ΛΛ6He{}^{6}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{He} NAGARA event [18, 19].

J-PARC’s E07 value of BΛΛ(ΛΛ13B)B_{\Lambda\Lambda}(^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B}) disagrees with a value deduced by KEK-E176 [20] from a Ξ−\Xi^- capture event marked # 15-03-37 in terms of a possible ΛΛ13B^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B} production as follows:

  • A: Ξ−+14N→ΛΛ13B+p+n\Xi^- + {}^{14}\mathrm{N} \rightarrow{}^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B} + p + n

  • B: ΛΛ13B→Λ13C∗+π−{}^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B} \rightarrow{}^{13}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{C}^{*} + \pi^-

  • C: Λ13C→4He+4He+3He+2n{}^{13}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{C} \rightarrow{}^{4}\mathrm{He} + {}^{4}\mathrm{He} + {}^{3}\mathrm{He} + 2n

Here Λ13C∗{}^{13}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{C}^{*} stands for Λ13C{}^{13}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{C} first excited doublet levels Jπ=(3/2+,5/2+)J^\pi= (3/2^+, 5/2^+) at Ex≈4.9E_x \approx4.9 MeV. Vertex B then leads to BΛΛ(ΛΛ13B)=23.6±0.8B_{\Lambda\Lambda}(^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B}) = 23.6 \pm0.8 MeV for BΛ(Λ13C)=12.0B_{\Lambda}(^{13}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{C}) = 12.0 MeV [21], so that

ΔBΛΛ=BΛΛ(ΛΛ13B)−2BΛ(Λ12B)=0.9±0.8 MeV,(2)\Delta B_{\Lambda\Lambda} = B_{\Lambda\Lambda}(^{13}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{B}) - 2B_{\Lambda}(^{12}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{B}) = 0.9 \pm0.8\ \mathrm{MeV}, \tag*{(2)}

consistently with the NAGARA event value. Vertex A confirms this result, but within a considerably larger uncertainty.

Regarding the NAGARA event [18, 19] we note that (i) none of its vertices A and B

  • A: Ξ−+12C→ΛΛ6He+3H+4He\Xi^- + {}^{12}\mathrm{C} \to{}^{6}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{He} + {}^{3}\mathrm{H} + {}^{4}\mathrm{He}

  • B: ΛΛ6He→Λ5He+p+π−{}^{6}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{He} \to{}^{5}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{He} + p + \pi^-

  • C: Λ5He→p+d+2n{}^{5}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{He} \to p + d + 2n

requires unobserved neutrons; and (ii) neither ΛΛ6He{}^{6}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{He} nor Λ5He{}^{5}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{He} have particle-stable excited states that could modify ΔBΛΛ=0.67±0.17\Delta B_{\Lambda\Lambda} = 0.67 \pm0.17 MeV. This makes NAGARA a unique event.

A second-best case is ΛΛ10Be{}^{10}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{Be} with two observed events involving excited states. One event involves a Ξ−\Xi^--capture formation of ΛΛ10Be2+∗{}^{10}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{Be}^{*}_{2^+} (3 MeV) [22], whereas in the other event ΛΛ10Beg.s.{}^{10}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{Be}_{\mathrm{g.s.}} is formed, decaying weakly to Λ9Be∗{}^{9}_{\Lambda}\mathrm{Be}^{*} (3 MeV) by emitting a π−\pi^- meson [23, 24]. No unobserved neutrons need to be invoked. Both derived values of ΔBΛΛ\Delta B_{\Lambda\Lambda} agree within experimental uncertainties, and also with the NAGARA value. Any different choice of excited-state pairs would lead to a substantial disagreement between the two values of ΔBΛΛ\Delta B_{\Lambda\Lambda} that follow from such a choice. No other ΛΛ\Lambda\Lambda hypernuclear candidate beyond ΛΛ6He{}^{6}_{\Lambda\Lambda}\mathrm{He} offers this kind of unique determination of ΔBΛΛ\Delta B_{\Lambda\Lambda}. This is also evident in both cluster-model calculations [25, 26] and shell-model calculations [27, 28].

Acknowledgments

Special thanks are due to Eliahu Friedman with whom I coauthored most of the works reviewed here in the first section. I would like also to thank the organizers of HYP2025 for their remarkable hospitality during the conference.

References

  1. [1]Y. Ichikawa, et al. (J-PARC E05): Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2024 (2024) 091D01.
  2. [2]M. Yoshimoto, et al. (J-PARC E07): Prog. Theor. Exp. Phys. 2021 (2021) 073D02.
  3. [3]E. Friedman and A. Gal: Phys. Lett. B 868 (2025) 139728.
  4. [4]E. Friedman and A. Gal: Phys. Lett. B 837 (2023) 137640.
  5. [5]C.J. Batty, E. Friedman, and A. Gal: Phys. Rev. C 59 (1999) 295.
  6. [6]E. Friedman and A. Gal: Phys. Lett. B 820 (2021) 136555.
  7. [7]D. Zhu, C.B. Dover, A. Gal, and M. May: Phys. Rev. Lett. 67 (1991) 2268.
  8. [8]T. Koike: JPS Conf. Proc. 17 (2017) 033011.
  9. [9]T. Harada and Y. Hirabayashi: Phys. Rev. C 103 (2021) 024605.
  10. [10]J.K. Ahn, et al. (BNL-AGS E906): Phys. Rev. Lett. 87 (2001) 132504.
  11. [11]T. Fukuda, et al. (KEK E224): Phys. Rev. C 58 (1998) 1306.
  12. [12]P. Khaustov, et al. (BNL-AGS E885): Phys. Rev. C 61 (2000) 054603.
  13. [13]T. Inoue (for the HAL-QCD Collaboration): AIP Conf. Proc. 2130 (2019) 020002.
  14. [14]M. Kohno: Phys. Rev. C 100 (2019) 024313.
  15. [15]T. Gaitanos and A. Chorozidou: Nucl. Phys. A 1008 (2021) 122153.
  16. [16]M.M. Nagels, Th.A. Rijken, and Y. Yamamoto: Phys. Rev. C 102 (2020) 054003.
  17. [17]Y. He, et al.: Nature Communications (2025) 16 (2025) 11084.
  18. [18]H. Takahashi, et al.: Phys. Rev. Lett. 87 (2001) 212505.
  19. [19]J.K. Ahn, et al. (KEK-PS E373): Phys. Rev. C 88 (2013) 014003.
  20. [20]S. Aoki, et al. (KEK E176): Nucl. Phys. A 828 (2009) 191.
  21. [21]A. Gal, E.V. Hungerford, and D.J. Millener: Rev. Mod. Phys. 88 (2016) 035004.
  22. [22]J.K. Ahn, et al. (KEK-E373): AIP Conf. Proc. 594 (2001) 180.
  23. [23]M. Danysz, et al.: Phys. Rev. Lett. 11 (1963) 29, Nucl. Phys. 49 (1963) 121.
  24. [24]R.H. Dalitz, D.H. Davis, P.H. Fowler, A. Montwill, J. Piniewski, and J. Zakrzewski: Proc. R. Soc. London A 426 (1989) 198.
  25. [25]E. Hiyama, M. Kamimura, T. Motoba, T. Yamada, and Y. Yamamoto: Phys. Rev. C 66 (2002) 024007.
  26. [26]E. Hiyama, M. Kamimura, Y. Yamamoto, and T. Motoba: Phys. Rev. Lett. 104 (2010) 212502.
  27. [27]A. Gal and D.J. Millener: Phys. Lett. B 701 (2011) 342.
  28. [28]A. Gal and D.J. Millener: Hyp. Int. 210 (2012) 77.

Paper details

vlnc:W_8ubpa29q
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 2

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents