betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

What Does Precision Spectroscopy Actually Constrain about X17 Couplings?

Abstract

Can precision spectroscopy disentangle the individual couplings of the X17 boson? Within a leading one-body model, we combine electronic and muonic spectroscopy of hydrogen, deuterium and helium with lepton magnetic moments. We show that hydrogen-deuterium comparisons can lose neutron sensitivity through cancellations, while the combined observables restore generic local identifiability without guaranteeing finite individual bounds. The unrestricted fit admits formally unbounded nucleon-coupling directions, some of which violate the assumptions underlying the physical model. Finite-coupling tests nevertheless reveal statistically compatible solutions, with bounds dependent on nuclear responses and physical assumptions. Our results establish what precision measurements genuinely constrain and what additional information is required to extract meaningful limits on X17 couplings.

Introduction

Precision atomic spectroscopy tests new interactions through small shifts of transition frequencies [1, 2]. Electronic and muonic atoms probe different spatial scales because their bound leptons have different masses. Isotope comparisons change the nuclear proton–neutron content while retaining a common electronic structure. They therefore add sensitivity to neutron couplings [3, 4].

X17X_{17} provides a concrete application. This proposed boson was introduced to explain electron–positron excesses in beryllium [5], followed by anomalies in helium and carbon [6, 7]. Vector interpretations allow distinct electron, muon, proton and neutron couplings [8, 9]; Ref. [10] reviews their phenomenology. Nuclear-transition and production searches test this hypothesis independently [11, 12]. Spectroscopy instead probes virtual exchange and the resulting bound-state energy shifts.

Interpreting these shifts requires care. Spectroscopy measures frequencies, whereas nuclear radii are inferred using a theoretical description. Muonic hydrogen established the proton-radius puzzle [13, 14], subsequently tested by electronic measurements [15, 16, 17]. A short-range interaction can mimic a nuclear-size contribution [18]. Radii extracted within the Standard Model (SM) can thus absorb part of the new signal. A comparison of electronic and muonic radii must propagate the interaction through both extractions.

Existing methods address different pieces of the problem. Pohl and collaborators analyze hydrogen–deuterium and helium spectra and derive constraints on lepton–nucleon coupling products [19, 20]. Effective-field-theory treatments connect atomic responses to mediator mass and spin [21], while finite-source calculations refine muonic responses [22, 23]. Delaunay and collaborators emphasize that adjusted constants and new interactions should be inferred together rather than treated as independent inputs [24, 25]. These studies provide the spectroscopic framework; they should not be confused with a demonstration that every individual coupling can be bounded. Previous X17X_{17} phenomenology combined magnetic moments with muonic Lamb shifts [26, 27], and separate electron and muon couplings were investigated in Ref. [28].

Complementary precision strategies have also been proposed for nonlocal electromagnetic effects [29], dark-sector geometric phases [30], scalar-field interferometry [31], photon–axion phases [32], and axion-mediated neutron forces [33, 34]. These involve different operators and are not imported as likelihood constraints here.

The remaining inference question is precise: which combinations does spectroscopy constrain, and when do they imply finite bounds on individual X17X_{17} couplings? Products alone do not fix a lepton normalization, and the proton and neutron contributions can cancel in certain response directions. Additional observables may remove an infinitesimal degeneracy without excluding distant parameter sequences. In particular, full rank of a local sensitivity matrix is not a statement about the size of a global confidence region. Conversely, a mathematical sequence that requires a large change of the nuclear binding potential cannot automatically be interpreted within an atomic model that keeps its nuclear sources fixed.

Here we retain four independent signed vector couplings, derive electronic and muonic radius responses, and combine two independent isotope comparisons with both lepton anomalous magnetic moments. Relative to existing light-atom analyses, our focus is explicitly the rank and global geometry of the four-parameter inference problem, including the distinction between removable local degeneracies, unbounded formal profiles, and nuclear-source validity. We additionally evaluate finite-coupling profiles under labelled nuclear-potential stress thresholds rather than presenting those thresholds as experimental exclusions. This distinction is essential because the nuclear many-body response to the new interaction has not been fitted. We use published radius summaries and do not claim to replace a global fit of raw transition frequencies, adjusted constants and nuclear theory errors.

The paper is organized as follows. Section 2 introduces the physical model and derives the relevant spectroscopic and magnetic-moment responses. Section 3 presents the numerical analysis, investigating coupling combinations, parameter identifiability, and the robustness of the results under different physical assumptions. Finally, Section 4 summarizes our main findings and conclusions.

Physical Model

We assume mediator mass mX=16.88 MeVm_X = 16.88\ \mathrm{MeV} [35]. We use ℏ=c=1\hbar= c = 1, where ℏ\hbar is the reduced Planck constant and cc is the speed of light; numerically, ℏc=197.326980459 MeV fm\hbar c = 197.326980459\ \mathrm{MeV\,fm}. The vector interaction is

LX=eXλ∑f=e,μ,p,nϵffˉγλf.(1)\mathcal{L}_X = e X_\lambda\sum_{f=e,\mu,p,n} \epsilon_f \bar{f}\gamma^\lambda f. \tag*{(1)}

Here LX\mathcal{L}_X is the Lagrangian density, XλX_\lambda the mediator field, and ff a fermion field with Dirac adjoint fˉ=f†γ0\bar{f}=f^\dagger\gamma^0. The γλ\gamma^\lambda are Dirac matrices; λ\lambda is a contracted Lorentz index. The elementary charge e>0e>0 defines the fine-structure constant α=e2/(4π)\alpha=e^2/(4\pi). Real dimensionless couplings ϵf\epsilon_f have independent signs; e,μ,p,ne,\mu,p,n label electrons, muons, protons and neutrons.

For lepton ℓ=e,μ\ell=e,\mu and nucleus AA with proton and neutron numbers Z,NZ,N, the momentum-space potential is

V~X(q)=4παϵℓ[ZϵpFp(q)+NϵnFn(q)]q2+mX2,ϵA=Zϵp+Nϵn.(2)\widetilde{V}_X(\mathbf{q})=\frac{4\pi\alpha\epsilon_\ell[Z\epsilon_pF_p(q)+N\epsilon_nF_n(q)]}{q^2+m_X^2},\qquad\epsilon_A=Z\epsilon_p+N\epsilon_n. \tag*{(2)}

Here q=∣q∣q=|\mathbf{q}| is the transferred momentum magnitude, Fp,FnF_p,F_n are proton and neutron current form factors normalized to unity at q=0q=0, and ϵA\epsilon_A is the nuclear vector charge. Point sources give VX(r)=αϵℓϵAe−mXr/rV_X(r)=\alpha\epsilon_\ell\epsilon_A e^{-m_Xr}/r at lepton–nucleus separation rr. Equal-sign charges repel. Factoring out ϵA\epsilon_A requires Fp=FnF_p=F_n; otherwise ϵA=0\epsilon_A=0 need not cancel the potential. Electromagnetic-like profiles are assumptions.

Let mℓ,MAm_\ell,M_A be the lepton and nuclear masses. Define the reduced mass μℓA=mℓMA/(mℓ+MA)\mu_{\ell A}=m_\ell M_A/(m_\ell+M_A) and Coulomb length aℓA=(ZαμℓA)−1a_{\ell A}=(Z\alpha\mu_{\ell A})^{-1}. The point-source muonic response and our reference dipole form factor are

KApoint=αaμAmX22(1+aμAmX),Fdip(q)=(1+q2RA212)−2.(3)K_A^{\mathrm{point}}=\frac{\alpha a_{\mu A}m_X^2}{2(1+a_{\mu A}m_X)},\qquad F_{\mathrm{dip}}(q)=\left(1+\frac{q^2R_A^2}{12}\right)^{-2}. \tag*{(3)}

Here KAK_A is the positive 2S−2P2S-2P shift per unit ϵμϵA\epsilon_\mu\epsilon_A; S,PS,P denote orbital angular momenta zero and one. The fixed source radius RAR_A is its root-mean-square radius. Dipole sources and point-Coulomb wave functions give Table 1.

Nucleus AAHD3He{}^{3}\mathrm{He}4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He}
RAR_A [fm]0.840602.127581.970071.6786
CAC_A [meV fm−2^{-2}]−5.2259−6.1074−103.383−106.209
KAK_A [meV]3627.5514199.96029937.84730679.725

Table 1. Reference source radii, SM field coefficients [36], and dipole muonic responses. H and D denote hydrogen and deuterium.

The conventional Lamb shift LA=E2P−E2SL_A=E_{2P}-E_{2S}, with level energies E2P,E2SE_{2P},E_{2S}, obeys

LAobs=LA0+CArA,true2−KAϵμϵA,rA,SM2=rA,true2+bAϵμϵA,bA=KA/∣CA∣.(4)L_A^{\mathrm{obs}}=L_A^0+C_A r_{A,\mathrm{true}}^2-K_A\epsilon_\mu\epsilon_A,\qquad r_{A,\mathrm{SM}}^2=r_{A,\mathrm{true}}^2+b_A\epsilon_\mu\epsilon_A,\qquad b_A=K_A/|C_A|. \tag*{(4)}

Here LA0L_A^0 contains radius-independent SM terms, CA<0C_A<0 is the field coefficient, and rA,truer_{A,\mathrm{true}} and rA,SMr_{A,\mathrm{SM}} are physical and SM-extracted charge radii.

For electronic H and D, write the new-force 1S−2S1S-2S frequency shift as δνA=−K21,AϵℓϵA/h\delta\nu_A=-K_{21,A}\epsilon_\ell\epsilon_A/h, with Planck constant h=2πℏh=2\pi\hbar. The dipole responses are K21,H=0.00463608847 meVK_{21,H}=0.00463608847\ \mathrm{meV} and K21,D=0.00463985102 meVK_{21,D}=0.00463985102\ \mathrm{meV}. The isotope convention νD−νH\nu_D-\nu_H gives CHD=−1369.5 kHz fm−2C_{HD}=-1369.5\ \mathrm{kHz\,fm^{-2}} [20, 37]. Define dH=rH,SM2−(rH2−rp2)d_H=r_{H,\mathrm{SM}}^2-(r_H^2-r_p^2), where rp,rDr_p,r_D are proton and deuteron charge radii. Define dHed_{\mathrm{He}} analogously using r32−r42r_3^2-r_4^2, with r3,r4r_3,r_4 denoting helium isotopes. Their predicted new-force contributions are

PHD=ϵμ(Aμϵp+Bμϵn)−ϵe(Aeϵp+Beϵn),(5)P_{HD}=\epsilon_\mu(A_\mu\epsilon_p+B_\mu\epsilon_n)-\epsilon_e(A_e\epsilon_p+B_e\epsilon_n), \tag*{(5)}
PHe=ϵμ(Aμ,Heϵp+Bμ,Heϵn)+Be,Heϵeϵn.(6)P_{\mathrm{He}}=\epsilon_\mu(A_{\mu,\mathrm{He}}\epsilon_p+B_{\mu,\mathrm{He}}\epsilon_n)+B_{e,\mathrm{He}}\epsilon_e\epsilon_n. \tag*{(6)}

The response coefficients, all in fm2\mathrm{fm}^2, are

(Aμ,Bμ)=(bD−bH,bD)=(−6.4649,687.6838),(Ae,Be)=(K21,D−K21,H,K21,D)/(h∣CHD∣)=(0.6650,819.2121),(Aμ,He,Bμ,He,Be,He)=(2(b3−b4),b3−2b4,3(ℏc/mX)2)=(1.4402,−288.1417,409.9674).(7)\begin{aligned} (A_\mu,B_\mu)&=(b_D-b_H,b_D)=(-6.4649,687.6838),\\ (A_e,B_e)&=(K_{21,D}-K_{21,H},K_{21,D})/(h|C_{HD}|)=(0.6650,819.2121),\\ (A_{\mu,\mathrm{He}},B_{\mu,\mathrm{He}},B_{e,\mathrm{He}})&=(2(b_3-b_4),b_3-2b_4,3(\hbar c/m_X)^2)=(1.4402,-288.1417,409.9674). \tag*{(7)} \end{aligned}

(7) uses consistent energy–frequency units. For electronic helium, the contact approximation gives δEX/(∂E/∂rA2)=6ϵeϵA/(ZmX2)\delta E_X/(\partial E/\partial r_A^2)=6\epsilon_e\epsilon_A/(Z m_X^2), where EE is the transition energy and δEX\delta E_X its new-force shift. (6) assumes isotope-independent electronic densities, neglecting finite-range, recoil and higher field-shift corrections. The electron–electron term cancels at infinite nuclear mass; its recoil remainder is omitted.

Define n=(ϵp,ϵn)T\boldsymbol{n}=(\epsilon_p,\epsilon_n)^T and P=(PHD,PHe)T\boldsymbol{P}=(P_{HD},P_{He})^T, where TT denotes transposition. The response matrices are

U=(AμBμAμ,HeBμ,He),E=(Ae−Be0−Be,He),P=(ϵμU−ϵeE)n.(8)U=\begin{pmatrix} A_\mu& B_\mu\\ A_{\mu,He} & B_{\mu,He} \end{pmatrix},\qquad E=\begin{pmatrix} A_e & -B_e \\ 0 & -B_{e,He} \end{pmatrix},\qquad P=(\epsilon_\mu U-\epsilon_e E)\boldsymbol{n}. \tag*{(8)}

Rows label H–D and helium; columns label protons and neutrons. Entries have units fm2^2. For fixed one-body responses, spectroscopy is invariant under (ϵe,ϵμ,ϵp,ϵn)↦(ϵe/s,ϵμ/s,sϵp,sϵn)(\epsilon_e,\epsilon_\mu,\epsilon_p,\epsilon_n)\mapsto(\epsilon_e/s,\epsilon_\mu/s,s\epsilon_p,s\epsilon_n) for any dimensionless scale s>0s>0.

For lepton ℓ\ell, define the magnetic anomaly aℓ=(gℓ−2)/2a_\ell=(g_\ell-2)/2, where gℓg_\ell is the gyromagnetic factor. The one-loop vector contribution is [38, 39]

ΔaℓX=Cℓϵℓ2,Cℓ=α2π∫01dz 2z(1−z)2(1−z)2+z(mX/mℓ)2,Ce=6.999208×10−7,Cμ=7.899579×10−4.(9)\Delta a_\ell^X=C_\ell\epsilon_\ell^2,\qquad C_\ell=\frac{\alpha}{2\pi}\int_0^1\mathrm{d}z\,\frac{2z(1-z)^2}{(1-z)^2+z(m_X/m_\ell)^2},\qquad C_e=6.999208\times10^{-7},\quad C_\mu=7.899579\times10^{-4}. \tag*{(9)}

Here zz is dimensionless and Cℓ>0C_\ell>0 is the loop coefficient. Magnetic moments leave coupling signs undetermined. This leading-order treatment assumes small shifts, perturbative lepton interactions and controlled nuclear sources. The usual condition αϵf2≪1\alpha\epsilon_f^2\ll1 is not by itself sufficient for a fixed-nucleus treatment: a mediator exchange between nucleons can change the nuclear wave function even when lepton loops remain weak. Nuclear polarization induced by XX, relativistic, radiative and mixed photon–vector corrections are omitted. We quantify a necessary consistency diagnostic in § 3.4.

Numerical Analysis

The numerical study proceeds in four steps. We first construct a conditional likelihood from published electronic and muonic isotope-radius differences and lepton magnetic moments. We then establish which coupling products are tested by the isotope comparisons, including a direction in which the hydrogen–deuterium neutron response cancels. Next, we distinguish the local sensitivity of all four observables from the global behaviour of the likelihood when the nucleon couplings are unrestricted. Finally, we repeat the profiling with explicit, illustrative restrictions on the additional nucleon–nucleon potential. Keeping these steps separate is essential: a preference for a coupling product, an invertible local response matrix, and a physically meaningful individual-coupling bound are different statements.

Experimental inputs and conditional likelihood

We adopt Gaussian errors and fixed SM inputs. Muonic H and D radii [14, 40] and the electronic isotope shift [41] give squared-radius differences 3.8200(31) and 3.8207(3) fm2^2 [36, 37]. Parentheses denote one-standard-deviation errors on the last digits. Hence dHD=(−0.0007±0.003114)d_{HD}=(-0.0007\pm0.003114) fm2^2, including correlated nuclear corrections. The muonic helium difference [42, 43] is 1.0626(29) fm2^2, with correlated nuclear errors [44]. Electronic alternatives (Table 2) are analyzed separately: Cancio Pastor with updated isotope theory [20, 45, 46]; singlet–triplet with revised recoil terms [47, 48] replacing the earlier smaller error [49]; Wen with corrected helium-4 postselection and the same helium-3 input as Cancio Pastor [50].

Electronic inputδre,He2\delta r_{e,He}^2 [fm2^2]χmin⁡2\chi_{\min}^2Tension
Steinbach [47]1.0676(10)2.5211.59
Cancio Pastor [45]1.0690(30)2.3441.53
Wen [50]1.0733(21)8.3212.88

Table 2. Electronic helium radius differences δre,He2=(r32−r42)e,SM\delta r_{e,He}^2=(r_3^2-r_4^2)_{e,\mathrm{SM}} and H–D compatibility at ϵe=ϵp=0\epsilon_e=\epsilon_p=0. Tension is χmin⁡2\sqrt{\chi_{\min}^2} for independent inputs.

Table 2 illustrates why the choice of electronic helium input must be stated rather than averaged away. The three determinations enter the same observable, dHe=(r32−r42)μ,SM−(r32−r42)e,SMd_{He}=(r_3^2-r_4^2)_{\mu,\mathrm{SM}}-(r_3^2-r_4^2)_{e,\mathrm{SM}}, but lead to different residual central values and uncertainties. In the table, the displayed χmin⁡2\chi_{\min}^2 is obtained only on the restricted slice ϵe=ϵp=0\epsilon_e=\epsilon_p=0, where both isotope comparisons test a single neutron-coupling product; it does not describe the minimum of the unrestricted four-coupling model. This distinction will be central below.

The data vector d=(dHD,dHe)T\boldsymbol{d}=(d_{HD},d_{He})^T has reference covariance V0=diag⁡(σHD2,σHe2)V_0=\operatorname{diag}(\sigma_{HD}^2,\sigma_{He}^2), where σHD,σHe\sigma_{HD},\sigma_{He} combine published errors in quadrature. We set V=V0V=V_0 for the baseline statistic χspec2=(P−d)TV−1(P−d)\chi^2_{\mathrm{spec}}=(\boldsymbol{P}-\boldsymbol{d})^TV^{-1}(\boldsymbol{P}-\boldsymbol{d}). This is a conditional four-input compressed likelihood, not a global refit of the underlying transition frequencies: the two isotope residuals share theory ingredients and may have an unreported cross-covariance. We do not assign an empirical value to that covariance.

Define residual νℓ=aℓexp−aℓSM\nu_\ell=a_\ell^{\mathrm{exp}}-a_\ell^{\mathrm{SM}} and error σℓ\sigma_\ell. Muon measurements and the lattice-based SM prediction give yμ=(38.5±63.673)×10−11y_\mu=(38.5\pm63.673)\times10^{-11} [51, 52, 53]. This 0.605-standard-deviation residual does not establish a nonzero coupling. Earlier dispersive predictions give different residuals.

The electron measurement [54] is combined separately with cesium (Cs) and rubidium (Rb) recoil values of α\alpha [55, 56]. SM coefficients [57] and Volkov’s five-loop result [58] give yeCs=(−95.92±26.29)×10−14y_e^{\mathrm{Cs}} = (-95.92 \pm26.29) \times10^{-14} and yeRb=(39.27±16.03)×10−14y_e^{\mathrm{Rb}} = (39.27 \pm16.03) \times10^{-14}. The alternative calculation [59] changes either by 0.145×10−140.145 \times10^{-14}. A positive vector contribution cannot explain Cs; Rb favors it at 2.45 standard deviations. Recoil-derived α\alpha remains external. We use

χ2=χspec2+χg−22,χg−22=∑ℓ=e,μ(Cℓϵℓ2−yℓ)2/σℓ2.(10)\chi^2 = \chi^2_{\mathrm{spec}} + \chi^2_{g-2}, \qquad\chi^2_{g-2} = \sum_{\ell=e,\mu} (C_\ell\epsilon_\ell^2 - y_\ell)^2/\sigma_\ell^2. \tag*{(10)}

The first term compares two measured isotope residuals with the two predictions PHDP_{\mathrm{HD}} and PHeP_{\mathrm{He}} from Eqs. (5) and (6). The second term fixes the preferred magnitudes of the lepton couplings through Cℓϵℓ2C_\ell\epsilon_\ell^2 without selecting their signs. It therefore supplies information unavailable to spectroscopy alone, but does not directly measure either nucleon coupling. A small total χ2\chi^2 is agreement within this specified compressed model, not evidence for X17X_{17} in isolation.

Experimental and SM errors add in quadrature, and Cs and Rb are always treated as alternatives. Because signs, boundaries, singular parameter points and theory uncertainties violate the regular assumptions behind simple asymptotic likelihood-ratio tests, we label the reported Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 sublevel sets as mathematical profiles rather than nominally calibrated confidence regions.

Reference inputs also affect the summaries. Write the isotope frequency νiso=ν0(η)+Cδrtrue2+DStrue+δνX\nu_{\mathrm{iso}} = \nu_0(\eta) + C\delta r^2_{\mathrm{true}} + D S_{\mathrm{true}} + \delta\nu_X. Here ν0\nu_0 is the radius-independent prediction with SM inputs η\eta; CC, DD are field coefficients and δνX\delta\nu_X the new-force shift. For isotope charge radii r1,r2r_1,r_2, define δr2=r12−r22\delta r^2 = r_1^2 - r_2^2 and S=r12+r22S = r_1^2 + r_2^2. The measured residual dd and predicted response PP satisfy

d=P+R,R=ν0(ηref)−ν0(ηtrue)C+DC(Sref−Strue).(11)d = P + \mathcal{R}, \qquad\mathcal{R} = \frac{\nu_0(\eta_{\mathrm{ref}}) - \nu_0(\eta_{\mathrm{true}})}{C} + \frac{D}{C}(S_{\mathrm{ref}} - S_{\mathrm{true}}). \tag*{(11)}

Here R\mathcal{R} is the reference-input correction; “ref” and “true” label adopted and physical values. The baseline sets R=0\mathcal{R} = 0 and therefore conditions on the reference inputs. Physically, the same measured transition frequency can produce a different reported radius difference if the reference Standard-Model constants or the charge-radius sum are changed. The compressed residual dd is thus not an independent, theory-free observable. Were a justified Gaussian nuisance covariance SRS_{\mathcal{R}} available, analytical marginalization of the additive nuisance would replace V0V_0 by V0+SRV_0 + S_{\mathcal{R}} (with a covariance normalization when the covariance is parameter-dependent). Such a covariance cannot be inferred from the summary measurements supplied here, so we do not manufacture one. Instead we test illustrative residual correlations ρ=±0.5\rho= \pm0.5 and keep the helium experiments separate. Helium singlet–triplet coefficients are (C,D)=(−214.758,0.017) kHz fm−2(C,D) = (-214.758, 0.017)\,\mathrm{kHz\,fm^{-2}} [47, 48]. A muonic reference sum shifts helium muonic coefficients by (−0.0916,−0.0687) fm2(-0.0916,-0.0687)\,\mathrm{fm^2}; unequal electronic field coefficients add (−0.1298,−0.0974) fm2(-0.1298,-0.0974)\,\mathrm{fm^2} to the helium row of EE. These modifications illustrate a reference dependence and are not fitted nuisance shifts.

Isotope compatibility, neutron cancellation and source sensitivity

A useful first diagnostic is to switch off the electronic and proton couplings, leaving the single product x=ϵμϵnx = \epsilon_\mu\epsilon_n. This is a deliberately restricted test of whether the two isotope measurements favour a consistent response, not an assumption imposed in the full fit. On ϵe=ϵp=0\epsilon_e = \epsilon_p = 0, both spectra measure x=ϵμϵnx = \epsilon_\mu\epsilon_n. For i=HD,Hei = \mathrm{HD},\mathrm{He}, define xi=di/Bix_i = d_i/B_i and si=σi/∣Bi∣s_i = \sigma_i/|B_i|, with BHD=BμB_{\mathrm{HD}} = B_\mu, BHe=BμμHeB_{\mathrm{He}} = B_\mu\mu_{\mathrm{He}}. The minimum χmin⁡2=(xHD−xHe)2/(sHD2+sHe2)\chi^2_{\min} = (x_{\mathrm{HD}} - x_{\mathrm{He}})^2/(s_{\mathrm{HD}}^2 + s_{\mathrm{He}}^2) has one degree of freedom, provided the two input errors are independent. Hydrogen–deuterium gives xHD=(−1.018±4.529)×10−6x_{\mathrm{HD}} = (-1.018 \pm4.529) \times10^{-6}. With the Steinebach input, the conditional compatibility tension is 1.588 standard deviations; the two-sided Wen alternative gives 2.885 standard deviations (probability 0.00392) and joint product x=(3.46±4.26)×10−6x = (3.46 \pm4.26) \times10^{-6}, consistent with zero. A residual correlation ρ\rho contributes +2ρsHDsHe+2\rho s_{\mathrm{HD}}s_{\mathrm{He}} to the variance of the difference because BHDBHe<0B_{\mathrm{HD}}B_{\mathrm{He}} < 0. Assumed ρ=(−0.5,0,+0.5)\rho= (-0.5,0,+0.5) changes the Steinebach tension to (1.99,1.59,1.36)(1.99,1.59,1.36) standard deviations and the Wen tension to (3.50,2.88,2.51)(3.50,2.88,2.51). These are sensitivity scenarios, not measured correlations. Consequently, the larger Wen tension in Table 2 should be read as input-dependent incompatibility within this one-product slice, not as a model-independent anomaly or a detection of the mediator. Once both lepton and both nucleon couplings vary, the two isotope central values can generally be fitted simultaneously; the question then becomes whether the required couplings are uniquely and physically determined.

For ϵμ≠0\epsilon_\mu\ne0, define the lepton ratio rℓ=ϵe/ϵμr_\ell= \epsilon_e/\epsilon_\mu. Then PHD=ϵμ(cpϵp+cnϵn)P_{\mathrm{HD}} = \epsilon_\mu(c_p\epsilon_p + c_n\epsilon_n), with proton and neutron coefficients

cp=Aμ−rℓAe=(−6.4649−0.6650rℓ) fm2,cn=Bμ−rℓBe=(687.6838−819.2121rℓ) fm2.(12)c_p = A_\mu- r_\ell A_e = (-6.4649 - 0.6650r_\ell)\,\mathrm{fm^2}, \qquad c_n = B_\mu- r_\ell B_e = (687.6838 - 819.2121r_\ell)\,\mathrm{fm^2}. \tag*{(12)}

At rℓ=0.839445r_\ell= 0.839445, cn=0c_n = 0 while cp=−7.0231 fm2c_p = -7.0231\,\mathrm{fm^2}; 0.830879<rℓ<0.8480250.830879 < r_\ell< 0.848025 gives ∣cp∣>∣cn∣|c_p| > |c_n| (Figure 1a). Physical neutron dominance requires ∣cnϵn∣>∣cpϵp∣|c_n\epsilon_n| > |c_p\epsilon_p|. Relative to the independent-lepton minimum, cancellation costs Δχg−22=0.1264\Delta\chi^2_{g-2} = 0.1264 for Rb at ∣ϵμ∣=8.6781×10−4|\epsilon_\mu| = 8.6781 \times10^{-4}, and 0.3656 for Cs in the zero-lepton limit. Thus hydrogen–deuterium supplies no universal neutron bound. Equation (5) remains regular at ϵμ=0\epsilon_\mu= 0.

Figure 1. Spectroscopic sensitivity and the formally unrestricted profile. (a) Normalized H–D proton and neutron coefficients as functions of rℓ=ϵe/ϵμr_\ell= \epsilon_e/\epsilon_\mu; shading marks ∣cp∣>∣cn∣|c_p| > |c_n|, and the dashed vertical line marks cn=0c_n = 0. The plotted coefficients do not include the unknown nucleon couplings. (b) Profile Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 after exact fitting of both isotope central values away from singular ratios and minimizing over the lepton magnitude, for alternative Rb/Cs inputs; dotted lines mark det⁡W=0\det W = 0. Limits approached at these lines need not equal values at the singular points. (c) Divergence of ∣ϵp∣|\epsilon_p| and ∣ϵn∣|\epsilon_n| for the Rb–Wen exact-spectra sequence approaching r−r_- from above. The horizontal line αϵf2=1\alpha\epsilon_f^2 = 1 is a perturbative warning, not an experimental limit.

Figure 1(a) makes the cancellation transparent by plotting cp/∣c∣c_p/|c| and cn/∣c∣c_n/|c| against the signed lepton-coupling ratio, where ∣c∣=(cp2+cn2)1/2|c| = (c_p^2 + c_n^2)^{1/2}. The neutron coefficient crosses zero at the dashed line, whereas the proton coefficient remains finite. The shaded interval denotes the region where the coefficient of the proton coupling has a larger absolute magnitude than that of the neutron coupling. It does not establish that the proton term dominates the measured isotope shift, because the actual contributions also contain ϵp\epsilon_p and ϵn\epsilon_n. The physical consequence is narrower, but important: even highly accurate hydrogen–deuterium spectroscopy cannot supply a ratio-independent constraint on ϵn\epsilon_n when the electronic and muonic responses are allowed to cancel.

Table 3 compares sources, including the Gaussian form factor FG(q)=exp⁡(−q2RA2/6)F_G(q) = \exp(-q^2 R_A^2/6). Extended electromagnetic (EM) wave functions reduce muonic responses by 0.018–0.24%, but change the small H–D and helium proton differences by 10.5% and 24.7%. Independent ±10%\pm10\% source-radius variations give Aμ∈[−6.616,−6.323]A_\mu\in[-6.616,-6.323] and Aμ,He∈[1.094,1.782] fm2A_{\mu,\mathrm{He}} \in[1.094,1.782]\,\mathrm{fm}^2. These test sensitivity, not vector-current uncertainty. The relatively small changes in the large neutron coefficients BμB_\mu and Bμ,HeB_{\mu,\mathrm{He}} should not obscure the more substantial fractional changes in the proton combinations AμA_\mu and Aμ,HeA_{\mu,\mathrm{He}}: the latter are differences of larger atomic responses and are therefore particularly susceptible to changes in the source prescription. This matters for the location and conditioning of the cancellations, rather than establishing a new statistical uncertainty distribution. Coordinate- and momentum-space evaluations agree within 2×10−82 \times10^{-8} relatively, checking integration accuracy only.

PrescriptionAμA_\muBμB_\muAμ,HeA_{\mu,\mathrm{He}}Bμ,HeB_{\mu,\mathrm{He}}
Point source−5.9133-5.9133688.3368688.33681.70771.7077−288.3866-288.3866
Dipole source−6.4649-6.4649687.6838687.68381.44021.4402−288.1417-288.1417
Gaussian source−6.4711-6.4711687.6771687.67711.43631.4363−288.1403-288.1403
Extended EM−7.1424-7.1424686.8794686.87941.08421.0842−287.8011-287.8011

Table 3. Muonic response coefficients in fm2\mathrm{fm}^2. The first three rows use point-Coulomb wave functions; the last uses an extended dipole electromagnetic (EM) potential. Electronic coefficients remain fixed.

Identifiability and formal likelihood directions

The cancellation of a particular isotope coefficient is not the same as a failure to determine all four couplings locally. To test the latter, consider the full map from the four signed couplings to the two isotope residuals and the two magnetic-moment shifts. Let f=(PH,PHe,Ce2,Cμ2)\mathbf{f}=(P_H,P_{He},C_e^2,C_\mu^2) be the observable vector and ϵ=(ϵe,ϵμ,ϵp,ϵn)\boldsymbol{\epsilon}=(\epsilon_e,\epsilon_\mu,\epsilon_p,\epsilon_n) the parameter vector. The Jacobian Jij=∂fi/∂ϵjJ_{ij}=\partial f_i/\partial\epsilon_j, with component indices i,j=1,…,4i,j=1,\ldots,4, satisfies

det⁡J=4CeCμϵeϵμdet⁡(ϵμU−ϵeE).(13)\det J = 4C_e C_\mu\epsilon_e \epsilon_\mu\det(\epsilon_\mu U-\epsilon_e E). \tag*{(13)}

For nonzero lepton couplings and spectral determinant, the rank is four. H–D plus both moments has rank three; spectroscopy alone has rank two. Helium restores generic local identifiability. Zero-lepton points are nongeneric; sign ambiguities persist. Full rank here means that sufficiently small parameter displacements generically produce distinguishable changes in the four predictions. It does not bound the parameter space far from the expansion point, and it does not eliminate the discrete sign branches of the lepton couplings. This is why the rank test must be supplemented by a global profile analysis.

Define W(rℓ)=U−rℓEW(r_\ell)=U-r_\ell E. Away from its singularities and from ϵμ=0\epsilon_\mu=0, the nucleon solution that fits both spectral central values is

n^=ϵμ−1W(rℓ)−1d,det⁡W(rℓ)/fm4=872.4086−1278.9509rℓ−272.6372rℓ2.(14)\hat{\mathbf{n}}=\epsilon_\mu^{-1}W(r_\ell)^{-1}\mathbf{d},\qquad\det W(r_\ell)/\mathrm{fm}^4=872.4086-1278.9509r_\ell-272.6372r_\ell^2. \tag*{(14)}

For nonsingular WW, profiling (minimizing) over nucleon couplings removes spectral residuals. Conditional tensions do not exclude the unrestricted model. At determinant roots r+=0.60429r_+=0.60429 and r−=−5.29532r_-=-5.29532, spectral directions align, but every adopted data vector lies outside the column space. Approaching either root gives divergent n^\hat{\mathbf{n}} and exact fits. At the root a residual remains, so the limiting infimum differs from the value there. Geometrically, the proton and neutron response columns become linearly dependent at each root. On approaching a root, increasingly large proton and neutron contributions can nearly cancel while leaving the two predicted isotope shifts fixed. Thus the divergence is a property of the inverse response map, not an indication that spectroscopy favours a physically large nucleon coupling.

Both roots remain simple and real with extended EM wave functions (0.647, −7.43-7.43) or helium reference corrections (0.606, −9.28-9.28). As an additional purely algebraic stress test, independently changing the four entries of the muonic-response matrix UU by ±5%\pm5\% in all 16 sign combinations preserves two real roots, with the negative root ranging from −6.06-6.06 to −4.50-4.50 and the positive root from 0.480 to 0.702. This establishes stability against those response-coefficient perturbations; it is not a calculation of separate proton and neutron form factors, their correlations or nuclear structure. Varying mXm_X over 16.83–16.93 MeV changes dominant coefficients by about 0.6%. Full nuclear-current robustness is not established.

At fixed rℓr_\ell, minimize over the squared muon coupling u=ϵμ2≥0u = \epsilon_\mu^2 \ge0:

u^(rℓ)=max⁡[0,Cμyμ/σμ2+Cerℓ2ye/σe2Cμ2/σμ2+Ce2rℓ2/σe2].(15)\hat{u}(r_\ell) = \max\left[0, \frac{C_\mu y_\mu/\sigma_\mu^2 + C_e r_\ell^2 y_e/\sigma_e^2}{C_\mu^2/\sigma_\mu^2 + C_e^2 r_\ell^2/\sigma_e^2}\right]. \tag*{(15)}

For Rb, root limits lie Δχ2=0.3362\Delta\chi^2 = 0.3362 at r−r_- and 1.0555 at r+r_+ above the global infimum. The formal set Δχ2≤1\Delta\chi^2 \le1 is unbounded (Figure 1b,Figure 1c), without an assigned confidence level. For Cs, vanishing leptons at fixed nonsingular ratio preserve exact fits under coupling rescaling, at limiting cost 0.3656. Rb instead diverges through response alignment; its zero-lepton penalty is about 6.37. Exact nonzero lepton magnitudes away from the roots would fix nucleon couplings on each sign branch.

Figures 1(b) and 1(c) display two aspects of this global result. In panel (b), the ratio-dependent profile is obtained by fitting both isotope central values exactly whenever W(rℓ)W(r_\ell) is invertible and then minimizing the magnetic-moment contribution over the lepton magnitude. The horizontal axis is the signed ratio rℓr_\ell, not the magnitude of an individual coupling, while the vertical axis is the increase in χ2\chi^2 relative to the unrestricted minimum. The Rb and Cs curves differ because a positive vector contribution can accommodate the Rb electron residual but not the negative Cs residual. The dotted vertical lines mark the singular ratios of WW; the plotted values approached near them are limiting profile values and need not equal the value at exact singularity.

Panel (c) isolates the approach to the negative root, plotting the absolute proton and neutron couplings of an Rb fit to the H–D and Wen helium central values against the positive distance rℓ−r−r_\ell-r_-. Both couplings increase without bound as this distance tends to zero, even though the isotope residuals remain exactly fitted along the sequence. The dashed horizontal reference corresponds to αϵf2=1\alpha\epsilon_f^2 = 1, indicating where the assumed perturbative expansion is plainly unreliable; the fixed nuclear-source description can fail even earlier. Panels (b) and (c) therefore establish formal unboundedness of the compressed profile, not a physically permitted infinite-coupling region or a calibrated confidence interval.

The divergent sequences eventually violate the controlled-source and perturbative assumptions of Sec. 2. A finite-coupling domain can regularize these mathematical tails, but imposing a numerical ceiling without stating its physical origin would turn a model assumption into a spurious experimental exclusion. We therefore make the assumed ceiling explicit in the following diagnostic. Complementary probes include hyperfine splittings [23, 60], pion and kaon decays [61, 62], and NA64, KLOE and NA48/2 searches [63, 64, 65]. Translating production and decay searches into this four-coupling space requires additional quark and neutrino couplings, branching ratios and lifetimes; none are silently folded into Eq. (10).

Finite-coupling stress tests and physical interpretation

A weak lepton interaction need not imply a negligible change of nuclear binding. To make this point quantitative without pretending to perform a nuclear many-body fit, consider the tree-level Yukawa potential of the same vector mediator between two nucleons i,j∈{p,n}i,j \in\{p,n\} at a reference separation r0r_0:

∣Vij(r0)∣=α∣ϵiϵj∣ℏcr0exp⁡(−mXr0ℏc),∣Vij(1 fm)∣=1.32191∣ϵiϵj∣ MeV.(16)|V_{ij}(r_0)| = \alpha|\epsilon_i\epsilon_j| \frac{\hbar c}{r_0}\exp\left(-\frac{m_X r_0}{\hbar c}\right), \qquad|V_{ij}(1\,\mathrm{fm})| = 1.32191|\epsilon_i\epsilon_j|\,\mathrm{MeV}. \tag*{(16)}

The source profile and short-distance nuclear dynamics have been suppressed in this deliberately simple diagnostic. Imposing the illustrative requirement max⁡i,j∣Vij(r0)∣≤ΛN\max_{i,j}|V_{ij}(r_0)| \le\Lambda_N at r0=1 fmr_0 = 1\,\mathrm{fm} is equivalent, for these point potentials, to max⁡(∣ϵp∣,∣ϵn∣)≤[ΛN/(1.32191 MeV)]1/2\max(|\epsilon_p|,|\epsilon_n|) \le[\Lambda_N/(1.32191\,\mathrm{MeV})]^{1/2}. We use ΛN=0.1\Lambda_N = 0.1 and 1 MeV as stress thresholds, not as nuclear-theory errors, experimental exclusions or confidence limits. Controlling this one-distance proxy is neither necessary nor sufficient for a reliable many-body calculation; the physical potential changes nuclear wave functions and finite nuclear currents, effects omitted from the atomic response.

For illustration, the Rb central value of aea_e, central aμa_\mu and the Steinebach and H–D radius central values admit an exact fit of the compressed one-body equations with (ϵe,ϵμ)=(7.49,6.98)×10−4(\epsilon_e,\epsilon_\mu) = (7.49,6.98)\times10^{-4} and (ϵp,ϵn)=(1.87,−0.0649)(\epsilon_p,\epsilon_n) = (1.87,-0.0649). In this unrestricted solution, the point-proton potential has magnitude ∣Vpp(1 fm)∣=4.63|V_{pp}(1\,\mathrm{fm})| = 4.63 MeV. This is a warning about the fixed-source approximation, not proof that the solution is excluded by nuclear data.

To study the sensitivity to finite nuclear couplings, we minimize Eq. (10) with ∣ϵp∣,∣ϵn∣≤ϵNmax⁡|\epsilon_p|,|\epsilon_n| \le\epsilon_N^{\max}, solving the two-dimensional bounded linear spectral least-squares problem for every lepton-coupling pair, then minimizing the remaining nonnegative objective. The reference results, for zero residual cross-covariance, are in Table 4. Each entry gives the minimized total χ2\chi^2; the unrestricted Rb fit has infimum zero for each helium selection. An assumed ΛN=0.1 MeV\Lambda_N = 0.1\,\mathrm{MeV} still permits a Steinebach fit at χ2≃0.107\chi^2 \simeq0.107, with ϵp≃0.275\epsilon_p \simeq0.275 and ϵn≃−0.100\epsilon_n \simeq-0.100; thus excluding the large-coupling central-value solution does not exclude good alternate fits. The change in minimum is a numerical likelihood cost, not a calibrated statistical significance. Table 4 also shows that relaxing the stress threshold from 0.10.1 to 1 MeV1\,\mathrm{MeV} decreases the minimum χ2\chi^2 for both helium alternatives, as expected when the allowed parameter domain becomes larger. Small conditional fit penalties should not, however, be confused with a proof that the corresponding nuclear wave functions and source responses remain unchanged.

ΛN\Lambda_N [MeV]ϵNmax⁡\epsilon_N^{\max}min⁡χ2\min\chi^2 (Steinebach)min⁡χ2\min\chi^2 (Wen)
0.10.2750.1070.117
1.00.8700.0450.085
Unrestricted—0 (infimum)0 (infimum)

Table 4. Conditional Rb minima under point-potential diagnostics at r0=1 fmr_0 = 1\,\mathrm{fm}. Thresholds are illustrative assumptions, not nuclear limits or confidence bounds. Electronic helium inputs are alternatives, never combined.

Figure 2(a) compares the ratio-dependent profile in the unrestricted model (dashed curve) with profiles obtained after imposing the two illustrative finite-coupling ceilings. For each chosen rℓr_\ell, the muon-coupling magnitude and the bounded proton and neutron couplings are re-optimized. The vertical quantity is the total χ2\chi^2 minus the unconstrained minimum of the g−2g-2 contribution, so these curves are neither likelihood-ratio confidence contours nor directly comparable to a universal Δχ2\Delta\chi^2 critical value. Near response-alignment regions, finite couplings can no longer compensate freely for nearly dependent isotope responses, and the restricted curves rise relative to the formal profile. Elsewhere, good fits remain possible despite the imposed ceilings. The dotted vertical lines indicate r±r_{\pm}, not experimental exclusions.

Figure 2. Finite-coupling diagnostics for the Rb electron input and Steinebach helium input. (a) Total χ2\chi^2 at fixed signed lepton ratio, minimized over the remaining couplings; the dashed curve is unrestricted and the solid curves impose max⁡i,j∣Vij(1 fm)∣≤0.1\max_{i,j}|V_{ij}(1\,\mathrm{fm})| \leq0.1 or 1 MeV1\,\mathrm{MeV} in the point-potential proxy. All curves subtract the unrestricted g−2g-2 minimum, rather than a calibrated confidence threshold. Dotted vertical lines mark det⁡W=0\det W = 0. (b) pp–pp Yukawa-potential magnitude at 1 fm1\,\mathrm{fm} versus ∣ϵp∣|\epsilon_p|; horizontal dashed levels and vertical dotted lines indicate the assumed 0.10.1 and 1 MeV1\,\mathrm{MeV} diagnostic cutoffs. The cross marks the unrestricted exact-central-value fit. Neither threshold represents an empirical nuclear exclusion.

Figure 2(b) shows the origin and numerical scale of these ceilings for the illustrative proton–proton channel. The solid curve is the quadratic relation ∣Vpp(1 fm)∣=1.32191 MeV ∣ϵp∣2|V_{pp}(1\,\mathrm{fm})| = 1.32191\,\mathrm{MeV}\,|\epsilon_p|^2, while the horizontal dashed lines at 0.10.1 and 1 MeV1\,\mathrm{MeV} and their corresponding vertical dotted lines identify the chosen proxy cutoffs ∣ϵp∣=0.275|\epsilon_p| = 0.275 and 0.8700.870. The cross marks the unrestricted exact-central-value fit, ∣ϵp∣≃1.87|\epsilon_p| \simeq1.87, for which ∣Vpp(1 fm)∣≃4.63 MeV|V_{pp}(1\,\mathrm{fm})| \simeq4.63\,\mathrm{MeV}. Its location illustrates why an excellent atomic fit need not be consistent with an unchanged nuclear source. The full restricted optimization bounds both ϵp\epsilon_p and ϵn\epsilon_n, whereas this panel depicts only the pp–pp contribution; no microscopic nuclear exclusion is inferred from the plot.

The cancellation of H–D neutron sensitivity and the generic Jacobian rank are properties of the specified response coefficients. Their numerical cancellation ratios move if proton and neutron form factors change separately; neither the ±5%\pm5\% response test nor the finite-coupling exercise supplies a self-consistent calculation of Fp(q)F_p(q) and Fn(q)F_n(q). We therefore do not quote model-independent individual limits on ϵp\epsilon_p or ϵn\epsilon_n. Such limits require a nuclear response calculation, justified priors or supplementary observables and, for frequentist confidence statements, coverage studies. Gaussian profiling alone is insufficient near the nonregular lepton-zero boundaries and singular ratios.

Conclusions

Precision atomic spectroscopy represents one of the most sensitive approaches to investigating light mediators and possible deviations from the Standard Model. However, the interpretation of increasingly precise measurements requires a careful distinction between the quantities directly probed by experiments and the fundamental parameters one aims to constrain. In this work, we have investigated this distinction for the hypothetical X17X_{17} vector boson, considering four independent electron, muon, proton, and neutron couplings. By combining electronic and muonic spectroscopy of hydrogen, deuterium, and helium with the anomalous magnetic moments of charged leptons, we have established the structure of the coupling combinations accessible to these complementary observables and identified the conditions under which individual parameters can be inferred.

A first important result concerns the sensitivity of isotope comparisons to the neutron coupling. Although hydrogen–deuterium spectroscopy is particularly attractive for probing interactions with neutrons, we have demonstrated that its sensitivity is not universal. For specific relations between electron and muon couplings, the corresponding neutron contributions can cancel, leaving the observable predominantly sensitive to the proton sector. This effect does not require the neutron interaction itself to vanish, but follows from the interplay between electronic and muonic responses. The inclusion of helium isotope measurements introduces a complementary nuclear response, while the electron and muon anomalous magnetic moments provide independent information on the leptonic coupling magnitudes. We have shown that their combination generically restores local identifiability of the four couplings, demonstrating the importance of combining observables with different physical sensitivities.

The most significant result of our analysis is that this local identifiability does not necessarily translate into finite constraints on individual couplings. Despite the generic full rank of the combined sensitivity matrix, the unrestricted statistical model admits parameter directions along which nucleon couplings become arbitrarily large without a corresponding deterioration sufficient to exclude them from selected profile-likelihood regions. We have identified the response configurations responsible for this behavior and examined their stability under different atomic and nuclear prescriptions. These findings demonstrate that the removal of local parameter degeneracies is not equivalent to the global determination of the underlying interaction strengths. Consequently, the number and precision of available observables alone do not guarantee that all fundamental couplings can be independently bounded.

An essential aspect of this result is its physical interpretation. The divergent directions emerging from the unrestricted analysis cannot be extrapolated indefinitely within a model that assumes fixed nuclear sources and treats the new interaction perturbatively. To investigate this limitation, we have introduced explicit finite-coupling stress tests based on the additional nucleon–nucleon potential generated by X17X_{17} exchange. Our numerical results show that exact reproduction of the central spectroscopic values can require sizeable modifications of the nuclear interaction, whereas solutions involving substantially smaller nucleon couplings can remain statistically competitive. This establishes that the appearance of formally unbounded directions does not imply either the physical existence of arbitrarily strong interactions or the incompatibility of X17X_{17} with the considered measurements. Rather, the extraction of finite individual bounds necessarily depends on the physical domain adopted for the model. The thresholds explored here serve as diagnostics of this dependence and should not be interpreted as model-independent experimental exclusions.

We have also found that the quantitative interpretation of spectroscopic tensions depends on the adopted helium measurements, nuclear response prescriptions, and assumptions concerning correlations between experimental inputs. These dependencies emphasize the importance of treating spectroscopic observables, nuclear charge-radius extractions, and Standard Model reference quantities consistently. A more complete determination of X17X_{17} couplings will therefore require the combined analysis of individual transition frequencies, correlated theoretical uncertainties, and nuclear responses, together with complementary particle-physics constraints. Such an approach would allow the formal parameter degeneracies identified here to be distinguished from physically admissible regions of the coupling space.

Overall, our findings establish that the sensitivity of precision spectroscopy to new physics must not be confused with its ability to uniquely determine the parameters of a new interaction. Beyond the specific X17X_{17} scenario, this distinction is relevant to the interpretation of precision measurements in models involving multiple independently coupled particle species. The results presented here therefore provide a basis for assessing which additional measurements and theoretical developments are needed to transform increasingly accurate atomic spectroscopy into reliable constraints on physics beyond the Standard Model.

Data and code availability. Published input values, reproducible numerical scripts, source audits and validation outputs are included in the supplementary project archive. These scripts reproduce the compressed one-body analysis, not the primary spectroscopy datasets or a nuclear many-body calculation.

References

  1. [1]J. Jaeckel and S. Roy, Spectroscopy as a test of Coulomb’s law: A Probe of the hidden sector, Phys. Rev. D 82, 125020 (2010).DOI
  2. [2]S. G. Karshenboim, Precision physics of simple atoms and constraints on a light boson with ultraweak coupling, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 220406 (2010).DOI
  3. [3]C. Delaunay et al., Probing Atomic Higgs-like Forces at the Precision Frontier, Phys. Rev. D 96, 093001 (2017).DOI
  4. [4]J. C. Berengut et al., Probing New Long-Range Interactions by Isotope Shift Spectroscopy, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 091801 (2018).
  5. [5]A. J. Krasznahorkay et al., Observation of Anomalous Internal Pair Creation in Be8 : A Possible Indication of a Light, Neutral Boson, Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 042501 (2016).DOI
  6. [6]A. J. Krasznahorkay et al., New anomaly observed in He4 supports the existence of the hypothetical X17 particle, Phys. Rev. C 104, 044003 (2021).DOI
  7. [7]A. J. Krasznahorkay et al., New anomaly observed in C12 supports the existence and the vector character of the hypothetical X17 boson, Phys. Rev. C 106, L061601 (2022).DOI
  8. [8]J. L. Feng et al., Protophobic Fifth-Force Interpretation of the Observed Anomaly in 8Be Nuclear Transitions, Phys. Rev. Lett. 117, 071803 (2016).DOI
  9. [9]J. L. Feng et al., Particle physics models for the 17 MeV anomaly in beryllium nuclear decays, Phys. Rev. D 95, 035017 (2017).DOI
  10. [10]R. Serao, A. Quaranta and A. Capolupo, The X17 Anomaly: Experimental Evidence and Theoretical Interpretations, arXiv:2606.20423 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2606.20423
  11. [11]K. Afanaciev et al. (MEG II), Search for the X17 particle in 7Li(p,e+e−)8Be processes with the MEG II detector, Eur. Phys. J. C 85, 763 (2025).
  12. [12]F. Bossi et al. (PADME), Search for a new 17 MeV resonance via e+e− annihilation with the PADME experiment, JHEP 11, 007 (2025).DOI
  13. [13]R. Pohl et al., The Size of the Proton, Nature 466, 213–216 (2010).
  14. [14]A. Antognini et al., Proton Structure from the Measurement of 2S–2P Transition Frequencies of Muonic Hydrogen, Science 339, 417–420 (2013).DOI
  15. [15]A. Beyer et al., The Rydberg constant and proton size from atomic hydrogen, Science 358, 79–85 (2017).
  16. [16]N. Bezginov et al., A measurement of the atomic hydrogen Lamb shift and the proton charge radius, Science 365, 1007–1012 (2019).DOI
  17. [17]A. Grinin et al., Two-photon frequency comb spectroscopy of atomic hydrogen, Science 370, abc7776 (2020).
  18. [18]U. D. Jentschura and I. Nándori, Atomic Physics Constraints on the X Boson, Phys. Rev. A 97, 042502 (2018).
  19. [19]R. M. Potvliege et al., Deuterium spectroscopy for enhanced bounds on physics beyond the standard model, Phys. Rev. A 108, 052825 (2023).DOI
  20. [20]R. M. Potvliege, Spectroscopy of Light Atoms and Bounds on Physics beyond the Standard Model, New J. Phys. 27, 045002 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2412.16315
  21. [21]C. Frugiele and C. Peset, Muonic vs electronic dark forces: a complete EFT treatment for atomic spectroscopy, JHEP 05, 002 (2022).
  22. [22]C.-C. Huang and L.-B. Wang, Constraints on Yukawa-type New Forces from the Lamb Shift in Muonic Hydrogen and Deuterium, arXiv:2607.05917 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2607.05917
  23. [23]X. Lin et al., Probing a Fifth Force in Muonic Atoms through Lamb Shifts and Hyperfine Structure, arXiv:2603.01429 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2603.01429
  24. [24]C. Delaunay et al., Self-Consistent Extraction of Spectroscopic Bounds on Light New Physics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 121801 (2023); [Erratum: Phys.Rev.Lett. 134, 119901 (2025)].DOI
  25. [25]C. Delaunay et al., Self-Consistent Extraction of Spectroscopic Bounds on Light New Physics, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 121801 (2023); [Erratum: Phys.Rev.Lett. 134, 119901 (2025)].DOI
  26. [26]A. Capolupo, A. Quaranta and R. Serao, The impact of the X17 boson on particle physics anomalies: Muon anomalous magnetic moment, Lamb shift and W mass, Phys. Dark Univ. 47, 101748 (2025).DOI
  27. [27]R. Serao, A. Quaranta and A. Capolupo, Addressing Standard Model Tensions via X17 Vector Boson, Int. J. Mod. Phys. A 41, 2646010 (2026).
  28. [28]R. Serao and A. Capolupo, Electron and Muon g − 2 Constraints on Light Vector Bosons: Dark Photons and the X17 Boson, arXiv:2608.24677 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2608.24677
  29. [29]A. Capolupo, G. Lambiase and A. Quaranta, Muon g − 2 anomaly and non-locality, Phys. Lett. B 829, 137128 (2022).DOI
  30. [30]A. Capolupo, G. Pisacane and R. Serao, Geometric Phases as Probes of Dark Sectors and Fundamental Symmetries, Particles 9, 71 (2026).DOI
  31. [31]A. Capolupo et al., Single arm interferometry to probe the scalar field dark matter, Phys. Rev. D 113, 055027 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2505.13574
  32. [32]A. Capolupo, G. Lambiase and G. Vitiello, Probing Mixing of Photons and Axion-Like Particles by Geometric Phase, Adv. High Energy Phys. 2015, 826051 (2015).DOI
  33. [33]A. Capolupo, S. M. Giampaolo and A. Quaranta, Neutron interferometry, fifth force and axion like particles, Eur. Phys. J. C 81, 1116 (2021).
  34. [34]A. Capolupo et al., Probing axion mediated fermion–fermion interaction by means of entanglement, Phys. Lett. B 804, 135407 (2020).DOI
  35. [35]F. Arias-Aragón et al., Combined evidence for the X17 boson after PADME results on resonant production in positron annihilation, Eur. Phys. J. C 86, 378 (2026).DOI
  36. [36]K. Pachucki et al., Comprehensive theory of the Lamb shift in light muonic atoms, Rev. Mod. Phys. 96, 015001 (2024).DOI
  37. [37]K. Pachucki, V. Patkós and V. A. Yerokhin, Three-photon exchange nuclear structure correction in hydrogenic systems, Phys. Rev. A 97, 062511 (2018).DOI
  38. [38]J. P. Leveille, The Second Order Weak Correction to (G-2) of the Muon in Arbitrary Gauge Models, Nucl. Phys. B 137, 63–76 (1978).
  39. [39]M. Pospelov, Secluded U(1) below the weak scale, Phys. Rev. D 80, 095002 (2009).DOI
  40. [40]R. Pohl et al. (CREMA), Laser spectroscopy of muonic deuterium, Science 353, 669–673 (2016).
  41. [41]C. G. Parthey et al., Precision Measurement of the Hydrogen–Deuterium 1S–2S Isotope Shift, Phys. Rev. Lett. 104, 233001 (2010).
  42. [42]J. J. Krauth et al., Measuring the α-particle charge radius with muonic helium-4 ions, Nature 589, 527–531 (2021); [Erratum: Nature 591, E18 (2021)].DOI
  43. [43]K. Schuhmann et al. (CREMA), The helion charge radius from laser spectroscopy of muonic helium-3 ions, Science 388, adj2610 (2025).DOI
  44. [44]S. S. Li, M. T. R. Richardson and S. Bacca, Revisiting the Helium Isotope-Shift Puzzle with Improved Uncertainties from Nuclear Structure Corrections, Phys. Rev. Lett. 134, 032502 (2025).
  45. [45]P. C. Pastor et al., Frequency metrology of helium around 1083 nm and determination of the nuclear charge radius, Phys. Rev. Lett. 108, 143001 (2012).DOI
  46. [46]K. Pachucki, V. Patkós and V. Yerokhin, Testing fundamental interactions on the helium atom, Phys. Rev. A 95, 062510 (2017).DOI
  47. [47]K. Steinbach et al., Spectroscopy of ⁴He at 0.25 ppt Uncertainty and Improved Alpha-Helion Charge-Radius Difference Determination, Phys. Rev. Lett. 136, 243001 (2026).
  48. [48]K. Pachucki, V. Patkós and V. A. Yerokhin, QED nuclear recoil effect in helium isotope shift, (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2512.04623
  49. [49]K. Pachucki, V. Patkós and V. A. Yerokhin, Second-order hyperfine correction to H, D, and He3 energy levels, Phys. Rev. A 110, 062806 (2024).
  50. [50]J.-L. Wen et al., Postselection shifts the transition frequency of helium in an atomic beam, Sci. Adv. 11, eadu9796 (2025).DOI
  51. [51]D. P. Aguillard et al. (Muon g-2), Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment to 127 ppb, Phys. Rev. Lett. 135, 101802 (2025).
  52. [52]D. P. Aguillard et al. (Muon g−2), Final Report on the Measurement of the Positive Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment at Fermilab to 127 ppb, arXiv:2606.17323 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2606.17323
  53. [53]R. Aliberti et al., The anomalous magnetic moment of the muon in the Standard Model: an update, Phys. Rept. 1143, 1–158 (2025).
  54. [54]X. Fan et al., Measurement of the Electron Magnetic Moment, Phys. Rev. Lett. 130, 071801 (2023).DOI
  55. [55]R. H. Parker et al., Measurement of the fine-structure constant as a test of the Standard Model, Science 360, 191 (2018).DOI
  56. [56]L. Morel et al., Determination of the fine-structure constant with an accuracy of 81 parts per trillion, Nature 588, 61–65 (2020).DOI
  57. [57]P. J. Mohr et al., CODATA recommended values of the fundamental physical constants: 2022*, Rev. Mod. Phys. 97, 025002 (2025).
  58. [58]S. Volkov, Calculation of the total 10th order QED contribution to the electron magnetic moment, Phys. Rev. D 110, 036001 (2024).
  59. [59]T. Aoyama et al., Verification of the tenth-order QED contribution to the anomalous magnetic moment of the electron from diagrams without fermion loops, Phys. Rev. D 111, L031902 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2412.06473
  60. [60]J. Chen et al., Fifth Force and Hyperfine Splitting in Muonic Atoms, arXiv:2312.13060 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2312.13060
  61. [61]M. Hostert and M. Pospelov, Pion decay constraints on exotic 17 MeV vector bosons, Phys. Rev. D 108, 055011 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2306.15077
  62. [62]M. Hostert, M. Pospelov and A. Thompson, Kaon decay constraints on vector bosons coupled to nonconserved currents, Phys. Rev. D 113, 115003 (2026).DOI
  63. [63]D. Banerjee et al. (NA64), Improved limits on a hypothetical X(16.7) boson and a dark photon decaying into e⁺e⁻ pairs, Phys. Rev. D 101, 071101 (2020).DOI
  64. [64]A. Anastasi et al., Limit on the production of a low-mass vector boson in e⁺e⁻ → Uγ, U → e⁺e⁻ with the KLOE experiment, Phys. Lett. B 750, 633–637 (2015).DOI
  65. [65]J. R. Bratley et al. (NA48/2), Search for the dark photon in π⁰ decays, Phys. Lett. B 746, 178–185 (2015).

Paper details

vlnc:W_8w8a8h75
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents