betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

What does "instant thermalization" in large-qq SYK models mean?

Abstract

Motivated by the Planckian thermalization rate Γ∼TΓ\sim T observed in the two-body interacting SYK model, we study thermalization in the q/2q/2-body case. Previous studies of such systems have established the notion of instantaneous thermalization to leading order in 1/q1/q. It was conjectured that the thermalization may still be Planckian but with a divergent rate Γ∼TqΓ\sim T q, explaining the ``instantaneous'' part. For an analytically and numerically tractable system, we calculate the effective temperatures after a quench at time t=0t = 0 and indeed find a Planckian rate, albeit with the unexpected decaying behavior Γ∼Tq−1Γ\sim T q^{-1} . This is contrasted with the behavior of the causal Green's function G(t1,t2)\mathcal{G}(t_1, t_2), which instantly acquires a thermal form in the two-time plane block t1,t2>0t_1, t_2 > 0. The resulting picture is that instant thermalization is a meaningful concept only for this block, while the off-diagonal blocks t1⋅t2<0t_1 \cdot t_2 < 0 are inherently non-thermal at any qq. Since the effective temperature is obtained from correlations spanning all blocks, it inherits a finite rate set by the off-diagonal. We illustrate this directly by studying the non-thermal correlations' time dependence.

Introduction

Understanding thermalization in strongly interacting quantum systems remains a central problem in nonequilibrium many-body physics. The Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev (SYK) model [1, 2, 3] provides a particularly useful setting, as it combines solvability with features characteristic of chaotic quantum matter. As such, the problem has been studied extensively [4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 11, 12]. Often one focuses on q/2q/2-body SYK type interactions, since the model is exactly solvable at leading order in 1/q1/q. In equilibrium, both finite-qq and large-qq versions of the model exhibit similar thermodynamic [13, 14, 15] and transport properties [16, 17], including saturating the Planckian bounds on chaos [18].

Out of equilibrium, however, the connection between finite-qq and large-qq dynamics is less understood. Especially for quenches the two cases seem to fall into completely different classes of thermalization. It is known that the standard q=4q=4 SYK model thermalizes at a Planckian (universal and linear in temperature) rate Γ∼kBTf/ℏ\Gamma\sim k_{\mathrm{B}}T_f/\hbar [4] for low final temperatures TfT_f. This rate also associated with black hole equilibration [19, 20, 21, 22]. Specifically, this rate was seen in the relaxation of the effective temperature defined via a non-equilibrium (NEQ) fluctuation dissipation relation. Further, taking q→∞q\to\infty one can analytically show that to leading order in 1/q1/q, the post-quench two-point correlation functions immediately satisfy a KMS relation. In this way the system is said to obey instant thermalization [4, 5]. To our knowledge, the SYK model is the only known model to exhibit this behavior.

It was conjectured in [4] that these two regimes may be connected through a diverging rate of the form Γ∝qTf\Gamma\propto qT_f. Such a scaling appears natural if one interprets qq as the effective connectivity of the system, following the perspective of [23]. A direct distance measure to equilibrium provides a lower bound on thermalization rate [24] which indeed grows with qq. The full bound unfortunately tends to zero in the thermodynamic limit; thus, it is not applicable to our SYK system where this limit is taken. The typical random Haar evolution rate is again found to be Planckian [23]. This Planckian rate is the so-called bound on chaos and was initially shown to be the maximal decay rate of out-of-time-order correlation (OTOC) functions [18]. Later it was also demonstrated to be a bound on the decay rate for thermal two-point correlation functions Geq(τ)G_{\mathrm{eq}}(\tau) [25]. It is not however proven to be an upper bound on the thermalization rate.

Against the backdrop of these results, a more detailed analysis is needed that contrasts different concepts of thermalization and specifically the notion of instant thermalization. In this paper, we therefore focus on two established indicators: (i) the equilibration of Green’s functions, (ii) the relaxation of effective temperatures. Concretely, we consider quenches between multiple non-commuting q/2q/2-body SYK Hamiltonians. Our setup is tractable both numerically and analytically allowing for an in-depth analysis. The analytic results are demonstrated in a companion paper [26]. Specifically, we can even provide analytical solutions for the inherently non-thermal off-diagonal time-blocks (t1t2<0t_1t_2<0) where operators evolve under different Hamiltonians across the quench occurring at t=0t=0. This distinguishes it from the quenches in [4, 5] for which only the thermal blocks are known in closed form, and have not been directly connected to another. The present approach provides access to the entire time plane, as sketched in Figure 1, enabling a more complete picture of the relaxation process, and hence a structured comparison between different thermalization scenarios.

Image not extracted

Figure 1. The four blocks of the two-time plane, labelled by the pair of Hamiltonians (s1,s2)(s_1,s_2) under which the two operators are evolved, with 0 and 1 denoting pre- and post-quench. The two diagonal time-blocks (0,0)(0,0) and (1,1)(1,1) are thermal, at TiT_i and at TfT_f respectively, the latter to leading order in 1/q1/q and, at finite qq, up to corrections of order 1/q21/q^2 (Figure 3), whereas the off-diagonal time-blocks (1,0)(1,0) and (0,1)(0,1) are inherently non-thermal at any qq. Also shown are the Wigner coordinates (τ,tavg)(\tau,t_{\mathrm{avg}}) [5]. We include two tilted rectangles used for performing the Fourier transform with respect to τ=t1−t2\tau=t_1-t_2.

We proceed as follows: in Sec. III A we find that up to order 1/q21/q^2 the finite-qq Green’s functions reproduce the large-qq solution over the whole two-time plane, which would be consistent with a diverging rate Γ\Gamma. In Sec. III B we find the opposite Γ∼Tfq−1\Gamma\sim T_fq^{-1}. Sec. III C shows both to hold, since the two measure distance to different reference states: the former compares finite qq against large qq, the latter against thermality, which the large-qq solution obeys only in the diagonal time-blocks. Extracting a rate from the off-diagonal blocks directly yields a third answer, 2π/τ2\pi/\tau, set by the relative time τ≡t1−t2\tau\equiv t_1-t_2 probed rather than by TfT_f or qq. As such each notion of thermalization carries its own rate, and “instant thermalization” is to be read as a statement about the diagonal time-blocks alone.

Model and Setup

We consider a single SYK dot of NN spinless complex fermions subject to two mutually non-commuting q/2q/2-body interactions with time-dependent strengths,

H(t)=∑i=12∑{ν}1q/2Zμ(i)(t)c^μ1†⋯c^μq/2†c^νq/2⋯c^ν1,(1)H(t)=\sum_{i=1}^{2}\sum_{\{\nu\}_{1}^{q/2}} Z_{\mu}^{(i)}(t)\hat{c}_{\mu_1}^{\dagger}\cdots\hat{c}_{\mu_{q/2}}^{\dagger}\hat{c}_{\nu_{q/2}}\cdots\hat{c}_{\nu_1}, \tag*{(1)}

where {ν}1q/2≡1≤ν1<⋯<νq/2≤N\{\nu\}_{1}^{q/2}\equiv1\leq\nu_1<\cdots<\nu_{q/2}\leq N, and c^α†,c^α\hat{c}_{\alpha}^{\dagger},\hat{c}_{\alpha} create and annihilate a fermion of flavor α\alpha. The couplings Zμ(i)(t)Z_{\mu}^{(i)}(t) are independent Gaussian random variables with zero mean and variance ∣Z(i)∣2=(N/2)1−q[(q/2)!J(i)/q]2\lvert Z^{(i)}\rvert^2=(N/2)^{1-q}[(q/2)!J^{(i)}/q]^2, drawn independently for each ii. This setup can also be used to describe a uniform chain with a q/2q/2-body transport term [17, 27]. Our protocol can be summarized by grouping the effective coupling strengths into the vector

J⃗(t)=(J(1),J(2))=(J,J+JγΘ(t)),(2)\vec{J}(t)=\left(J^{(1)},J^{(2)}\right)=\left(J,J+J\gamma\Theta(t)\right), \tag*{(2)}

i.e., we only change the second Hamiltonian over the quench at time t=0t=0. Without loss of generality, we will set J=2J=2 throughout this work which just sets an overall energy scale. The parameter γ\gamma however tunes the strength of the quench. Intuitively larger γ\gamma should result in a higher final temperature. The results are qualitatively independent of γ\gamma; so we simply set γ=1/2\gamma=1/2.

Remarkably in the thermodynamic limit (N→∞N\to\infty) the SYK model is solvable in the sense that one may obtain the exact self-energy

Σ(t1,t2)=−2J⃗(t1)⋅J⃗(t2)q[4G(t1,t2)G(t2,t1)]q/2−1G(t1,t2).(3)\Sigma(t_1,t_2)=-\frac{2\vec{J}(t_1)\cdot\vec{J}(t_2)}{q}\left[4G(t_1,t_2)G(t_2,t_1)\right]^{q/2-1}G(t_1,t_2). \tag*{(3)}

The fact that the two Hamiltonians are non-commuting is reflected in the lack of factorization in J⃗(t1)⋅J⃗(t2)≠∑iJ(i)(t1)∑jJ(j)(t2)\vec{J}(t_1)\cdot\vec{J}(t_2)\ne\sum_i\mathcal{J}^{(i)}(t_1)\sum_j\mathcal{J}^{(j)}(t_2). In the case of a single SYK Hamiltonian, only trivial “quenches” (the factorizing type) can be considered, since the time-dependent coupling merely amounts to a change in energy scale rather than any change in the system.

The self-energy (3) corresponds to a multitude of SYK Hamiltonians under specific conditions. The important feature shared among all interpretations is that it consists of two or more non-commuting q/2q/2-body SYK interacting terms. As such, a quench of one coupling actually yields

non-trivial physics. This contrasts with the setup where a commuting term is quenched, for instance, the mass term or the case with a single SYK term with a time-dependent coupling constant. The latter is merely related to a change in units; hence it leaves equilibrium physics undisturbed.

We study the quench dynamics of the system by focusing on the NEQ (time ordered or causal) Green’s functions G(t1,t2)≡−ι⟨Tc^(t1)c^†(t2)⟩G(t_1,t_2)\equiv-\iota\langle\mathcal{T}\hat{c}(t_1)\hat{c}^{\dagger}(t_2)\rangle averaged over all NN fermionic flavors. This can be explicitly written in terms of the lesser and greater components

G(t1,t2)=Θ(t1−t2)G>(t1,t2)+Θ(t2−t1)G<(t1,t2)=Gret(t1,t2)+G<(t1,t2).(4)\begin{aligned} G(t_1,t_2)=\Theta(t_1-t_2)G^{>}(t_1,t_2)+\Theta(t_2-t_1)G^{<}(t_1,t_2) \\ &=G^{\mathrm{ret}}(t_1,t_2)+G^{<}(t_1,t_2). \tag*{(4)} \end{aligned}

For t1>t2t_1>t_2, this is equivalent to G>(t1,t2)G^{>}(t_1,t_2) by means of the identity Gret(t1,t2)=Θ(t1−t2)(G>(t1,t2)−G<(t1,t2))G^{\mathrm{ret}}(t_1,t_2)=\Theta(t_1-t_2)\left(G^{>}(t_1,t_2)-G^{<}(t_1,t_2)\right). With the SYK set-up as described above, one is able to solve for the thermal pre-quench (t1,t2<0)(t_1,t_2<0) and post-quench time-block (t1,t2>0)(t_1,t_2>0) [4, 5]. What one also needs is access to the blocks (t1<0,t2>0)(t_1<0,t_2>0) and (t1>0,t2<0)(t_1>0,t_2<0), which are inherently NEQ since the operators there are evolved under two different Hamiltonians, namely the pre-quench and post-quench ones. We denote the pre- and post-quench quantities with subscripts 0 (or ii) and 1 (or ff) respectively, as indicated in Figure 1. We make use of a novel solution to these off-diagonal time-blocks, derived in the companion paper [26], partially restated in App. § 1.2.2.

Thermalization Measures

Green’s functions in equilibrium satisfy a KMS relation—a periodicity β\beta in imaginary time—meaning the frequency sets the temperature 1/β=T1/\beta=T. Consequently, observables typically carry characteristic dependencies on temperature, even beyond equilibrium. However, in our specific zero-dimensional system, the only meaningful observables we have access to are conserved quantities: the energy and the number density. Therefore, we will turn our attention to the Green’s function itself. Full numerical solutions for Green’s functions with the self-energy (3) and varying values of qq have been obtained using the NESSi library [28]. For our quench setup, we consider two natural measures to monitor the thermalization process: The first is to have some measure of how far away the Green’s functions are from a thermal state [23], and the second is the change of an effective temperature [4].

Real-Time Green's function

In the following, we study the distance of the nonequilibrium Green’s functions away from the analytical large-qq prediction G(ana)G^{(\mathrm{ana})} directly in the two-time plane, meaning over all four time-blocks. Note that G(ana)G^{(\mathrm{ana})} is instantaneously thermal only in its diagonal time-blocks; in the off-diagonal ones it is the inherently non-thermal solution of App. B. Our solution is derived under a 1/q1/q expansion which is re-summed such that it overlaps with the finite-qq low temperature conformal solution as well as the standard large-qq solution discussed more in App. C. It is this low-temperature regime that is our main regime of interest. We focus on the Green’s functions as a function of time difference and time average

τ=t1−t2tavg=(t1+t2)/2,(5)\tau= t_1 - t_2 \qquad t_{\mathrm{avg}} = (t_1 + t_2)/2, \tag*{(5)}

corresponding to Wigner coordinates. While the conformal solution is valid at all qq, it is only strictly correct at late time differences τ\tau. As such, we expect deviations from the numerical result at intermediate τ\tau even if we formally take the zero temperature limit.

Focusing on the Green’s function at times close to the quench, we plot real and imaginary parts of its full numerical solution G(t1,t2)G(t_1,t_2) and of the instantaneous thermal prediction G(ana)(t1,t2)G^{(\mathrm{ana})}(t_1,t_2) from the large-qq result in Figure 2. Importantly, we observe that the numerical solution is close to the large-qq prediction even directly after the quench. Note that the Green’s functions overlap almost perfectly at q=16q = 16. In other words, the difference between the full numerical solution and the analytical prediction tends to zero as we increase qq. This may be expected given that the analytic solution is derived under a 1/q1/q expansion.

Image not extracted

Figure 2. The real and imaginary parts of the NEQ time ordered Green’s function (4) as a function of relative time τ\tau directly after the quench (sharp ramp tavg=10−3t_{\mathrm{avg}} = 10^{-3}). The data is for Ti=0.1T_i = 0.1 and various connectivities qq. The dashed-dotted line corresponds to the numerical results, while the analytical prediction G(ana)G^{(\mathrm{ana})} is given by the solid line of the same color.. Since τ>0\tau> 0, the data used here is that of G>(t1,t2)G^{>} (t_1,t_2).

For a more quantitative assessment, following Ref. [23], we choose a distance measure between the full numerical NEQ Green’s function and the analytical result

d(q)=max⁡t1,t2∣G(t1,t2)−G(ana)(t1,t2)∣,(6)d(q) = \max_{t_1,t_2} \left|G(t_1,t_2) - G^{(\mathrm{ana})}(t_1,t_2)\right|, \tag*{(6)}

as a function of qq. In Figure 3, we directly compare the two solutions by considering the difference measure (6) multiplied by q2q^2 for various temperatures TT. The temperatures are chosen to be small enough such that we are in

Image not extracted

Figure 3. Maximum difference between Green’s functions (6) multiplied by q2q^2 as a function of the connectivity qq for three different initial temperatures T0T_0.

the Planckian range, T≲J/2T \lesssim\mathcal{J}/2, i.e., where the Lyapunov exponent is close to maximal.

The data in Figure 3 strongly suggests that q2d(q)q^2d(q) tends to a constant as q→∞q \to\infty, which implies that deviations between the numerical solution of the Green’s function and the large-qq theory are of the order 1/q21/q^2. This is the typical behavior for all temperatures in the Planckian range, e.g., those temperatures considered in Figure 3. As a consequence, even the exact finite-qq Green’s functions are reproduced by the large-qq solution at order 1/q1/q, and are therefore instantaneously thermal at that order wherever the large-qq solution is, namely in the diagonal time-blocks.

In summary, the finite-qq Green’s functions overlap strongly with the large-qq solution not only at large qq, but significantly so already at q=4q = 4. Naively this can lead one to conclude that Γ\Gamma lies beyond any finite scale, so that the conjecture Γ∝qTf\Gamma\propto qT_f of Ref. [4] would be an understatement rather than an overstatement. We next contrast the above with a second indicator.

Effective Temperature

We now contrast the real-time picture in Sec. III A with a spectral indicator of thermalization: Effective temperatures TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}} are defined on the basis of the fluctuation-dissipation theorem for correlations in equilibrium. The equilibrium spectral function A(ω)=G<(ω)(1+e−βω)A(\omega) = G^{<}(\omega)(1 + e^{-\beta\omega}) and the Keldysh Green’s function in Keldysh space, GK(ω)=G>(ω)+G<(ω)G^{\mathrm{K}}(\omega) = G^{>}(\omega) + G^{<}(\omega) combine to

iGK(ω)/A(ω)=tanh⁡(βω/2)≃βω/2,(7)iG^{\mathrm{K}}(\omega)/A(\omega) = \tanh(\beta\omega/2) \simeq\beta\omega/2, \tag*{(7)}

where the last statement holds for βω/2≪1\beta\omega/2 \ll1. Following the work by Eberlein et al. [4], we also calculate this ratio for Green’s function out of equilibrium, formulated with Wigner time coordinates (5). We evaluate the above mentioned ratio of the resulting nonequilibrium Green’s functions G(tavg,ω)G(t_{\mathrm{avg}},\omega) and fit an effective temperature from its low-frequency behavior. A detailed discussion of our data processing and sources of error can be found in Appendix § 1.2.1. Figure 4(a) and (Figure 4b) exemplarily show results of this procedure both for the full numerical solution and for the analytical large-qq theory. Since the large-qq theory reaches thermal equilibrium instantaneously in the diagonal block, one might assume the curve would need to be a step function. However, we find that neither analytic nor numerical solutions behave like a step function. A reason for this is that the off-diagonal time blocks t1⋅t2<0t_1 \cdot t_2 < 0, which we have not discussed in detail before, carry memory of the pre-quench dynamics and contribute to the low-frequency behavior of the Green’s function. Note that this is unavoidable by construction: Teff(tavg)T_{\mathrm{eff}}(t_{\mathrm{avg}}) is read off from the transform along the whole line t1,2=tavg±τ/2t_{1,2} = t_{\mathrm{avg}} \pm\tau/2, which leaves the post-quench time-block as soon as ∣τ∣>2tavg|\tau| > 2t_{\mathrm{avg}}, and the low-frequency fit weights precisely the largest τ\tau.

Image not extracted

Figure 4. (a,b) Effective temperatures from the numerical solution (dashed lines) and from the large-qq theory (solid lines) for two different initial temperatures Ti=0.04,0.08T_i = 0.04, 0.08 and for q=4,8q = 4, 8. (c) Thermalization rates Γ\Gamma extracted from the effective temperatures of the numerical solution (circles, dashed) and of the large-qq theory (squares, solid). The lowest considered initial temperatures are Ti=0.04T_i = 0.04 for the numerical solution and Ti=0.01T_i = 0.01 for the large-qq solution.

We find that the overall shapes of the effective temperature curves obtained with the two approaches (numerical and analytical) coincide well and indicate a finite thermalization rate. We further note that the large-qq theory, especially for q=4q = 4, underestimates the final temperature established after the quench. We can, however, see that this underestimation appears to decrease as we increase qq, as expected from Figure 3.

Thermalization rates at late average times after the quench are extracted using an ansatz

Teff(tavg)=Tf+αe−Γtavg.(8)T_{\mathrm{eff}}(t_{\mathrm{avg}}) = T_f + \alpha e^{-\Gamma t_{\mathrm{avg}}}. \tag*{(8)}

In Figure 4(c) we present the extracted thermalization rates for the full numerical (q=4,6,8q = 4, 6, 8) and for the large-qq solution, for which we can more easily cover larger values of qq. In both cases, the rates depend linearly on the final

temperature TfT_f in agreement with the Planckian rates observed in [4] for q=4q = 4. The low-temperature end point of the curve is set by the lowest possible final temperature Tfmin⁡T_f^{\min}, which corresponds to the temperature obtained after quenching from an initial state with temperature zero. Tfmin⁡T_f^{\min} moves to lower values as qq increases. The data also clearly shows that the linear-in-TfT_f parts of the thermalization rates obtained from the full and large-qq solutions become increasingly similar at larger values of qq. Since the smallest initial temperature TiT_i used for our full numerical solution is Ti=0.04T_i = 0.04, the low-temperature end points of the data cannot be directly compared. However, comparing data points with the same value of TiT_i, we can also find that they approach each other as qq increases. Looking at the values of the rates Γ\Gamma, they clearly seem to decay with qq, which is in stark contrast to the hypothesized diverging-in-qq rates discussed in [4]. For a more quantitative analysis, we split the thermalization rate Γ\Gamma into a constant part Γ0\Gamma_0, depending only on Tfmin⁡T_f^{\min}, and a part Γ1\Gamma_1 describing the linear dependence on the final temperature:

Γ=Γ0[Tfmin⁡]+Γ1⋅(Tf−Tfmin⁡).(9)\Gamma= \Gamma_0[T_f^{\min}] + \Gamma_1 \cdot(T_f - T_f^{\min}). \tag*{(9)}

Figure 5 shows the extracted rates obtained within large-qq theory as a function of 1/q1/q down to q=50q = 50. Γ1\Gamma_1 is evaluated for quenches with an initial temperature Ti=0.01T_i = 0.01. The solid straight lines are fitted from the data and provide a guide to the eye. However, since this linear extrapolation of the data would predict slightly negative, unphysical limit values of Γi\Gamma_i as q→∞q \to\infty, we cannot make a reliable statement about these precise values within the accuracy of our approach. Nevertheless, this discussion based on effective temperatures very clearly does not support instant thermalization in the sense of increasing the thermalization rate as q→∞q \to\infty.

Image not extracted

Figure 5. Dependence of the large-qq thermalization rates Γ0,Γ1\Gamma_0,\Gamma_1 (as defined in (9)) on qq. The plotted thermalization rate Γ1\Gamma_1 is evaluated at the smallest considered temperature Ti=0.01T_i = 0.01. The solid lines are a linear fit to the data and provide a guide to the eye showing that the data scales roughly linearly with 1/q1/q.

Relaxation in the off-diagonal time-blocks

The two subsections above measure different notions of thermality. The measure (6) of Sec. III A shows that the finite-qq solution is faithfully captured by the large-qq one over the whole two-time plane. The thermal distance however appears only in G(ana)\mathcal{G}^{(\mathrm{ana})} restricted to the diagonal time-blocks of Figure 1. The effective temperature of Sec. III B, by contrast, measures the distance from thermality via a non-equilibrium fluctuation dissipation relation, which necessarily includes the off-diagonal time-blocks. In order to shed more light on the role of the off-diagonal time blocks, we discuss a third focused measure: the difference of the full numerical solution G(t1,t1−τ)\mathcal{G}(t_1,t_1-\tau) and its late-time asymptotic (thermal) solutions Geq(τ)\mathcal{G}_{\mathrm{eq}}(\tau). Figure 6 shows results for this difference obtained from our numerical solution in the two-time plane for q=4q = 4. One can see that the closer one stays to the time diagonal (small τ\tau), the more step-like the change of the Green’s function becomes. For further analysis, we use a sigmoid function ansatz over tavg=t1−τ/2t_{\mathrm{avg}} = t_1-\tau/2 to describe the time ordered Green’s functions’ (4) differences as a function of t1t_1,

Image not extracted

Figure 6. Plot of the time ordered Green’s functions’ (4) difference (10), scaled (note the ∝\propto symbol in the vertical label) such that the maximum falls onto 1. The typical behavior is that of a sigmoid, shown here given here for T=0.5T = 0.5 and q=4q = 4 and various relative times τ\tau. The numerical data is given in the dots, while the corresponding fit is drawn with dashed lines of the same color.

∣G(t1,t1−τ)−Geq(τ)∣∝11+ektavg.(10)\left|\mathcal{G}(t_1,t_1-\tau)-\mathcal{G}_{\mathrm{eq}}(\tau)\right| \propto\frac{1}{1+e^{k t_{\mathrm{avg}}}}. \tag*{(10)}

The slope parameter kk is extracted from a fit to the data and shown in Figure 7. At small τ\tau, but non-zero τ\tau, the data is consistent with a near-universal rate

Image not extracted

Figure 7. The behavior of the rate kk (11) for different sets of numerical data. Note the insensitivity to T,qT,q.

k=2πτ[1+O(10−1)],(11)k = \frac{2\pi}{\tau}\left[1+\mathcal{O}(10^{-1})\right], \tag*{(11)}

where the non-universal corrections in O(10−1)\mathcal{O}(10^{-1}) are an order of magnitude smaller. Note that strictly in the limit as τ→0\tau\to0, we are left subtracting two boundary terms from another G(t1,t1)=−τ/2\mathcal{G}(t_1,t_1) = -\tau/2 and Geq(0)=−τ/2\mathcal{G}_{\mathrm{eq}}(0) = -\tau/2. As such any sigmoid fit in this limit is meaningless. This is further seen by observing that the time arguments (t1,t2=t1−τ)(t_1,t_2=t_1-\tau) lie in the two-time plane block (1,0)(1,0) (cf. Figure 1) on a line of width τ\tau. The rate (11) is of a different nature to the one considered in Sec. III B. It is inversely proportional to τ\tau at which the correlator is probed and seemingly only weakly dependent on qq and TT.

Conclusion

In this work we have tested the notion of “instantaneous thermalization” by considering quenches of SYK models involving only q/2q/2-body interactions. We solve the problem numerically for a range of finite qq values. We compared this to the recent analytical solution, which solves for the entire time plane to leading order in 1/q1/q [26]. The latter shows instantaneous post-quench thermalization to leading order. Seemingly paradoxically, we saw a decaying thermalization rate Γ∝1/q\Gamma\propto1/q. We confirmed that the analytical results from [26] faithfully represent the numerical correlation for all times. This leads one to ask: what is really meant by “instantaneous thermalization”?

Our findings provide insights via a time-block-resolved picture. While the diagonal time-block correlations, and thus the post-quench (those in block (1,1)(1,1)) Green’s functions, remain thermal, any measure requiring information over the connecting ((1,0)((1,0) or (0,1))(0,1)) blocks inherits a finite rate from inherently non-thermal off-diagonal block correlations. This means that there will always be contributions that require a finite time to relax. Hence, the effective temperature does not change instantaneously during the quench. We made this quantitative in Sec. III C, where the off-diagonal Green’s functions were found to cross over on the line tavg=0t_{\mathrm{avg}}=0 with a width τ/2π\tau/2\pi set by the relative time alone, independently of both TT and qq.

The three measures we have considered therefore return three different answers: a vanishing difference to the large-qq theory in Sec. III A, a Planckian Γ∼Tq−1\Gamma\sim Tq^{-1} in Sec. III B, and a probe-dependent kk trending as 2π/τ2\pi/\tau in Sec. III C. We have studied effective temperatures for the non-equilibrium Green’s function in the standard Wigner coordinates, following the work by Eberlein [4]. However, if one chooses to perform the Fourier transform to frequency space with respect to a different choice of coordinates (e.g. only forward in time for τ\tau), one can also expect different effective temperatures and rates. A closer inspection of possible Fourier transforms (and their physical relevance) could be an interesting direction of further study.

In summary, the question of our title therefore admits no unique answer: the rate one obtains is set by the notion of thermalization one adopts. Nevertheless, our analysis helps to bridge the gap between finite and infinite-qq dynamics. Future directions could consider whether these results can be extended to other quench protocols or transport applications. Our model also opens the door to further analytical investigations of the out-of-equilibrium dynamics, especially from quenching local operators in local generalizations of our model [29]. Lastly, assuming the thermalization rates in Figure 5 go to zero as q→∞q \to\infty, what would this imply in terms of capturing thermalization? Does it imply a diverging memory effect? To address this, one could solve for the effective temperature analytically. Then one could also assess if (and in what sense) the 1/q1/q scaling is a trivial result.

Acknowledgments

A.O. and J.C.L. acknowledge helpful discussions with Stefan Kehrein. J.C.L. was employed at the Max Planck Institute of Quantum Optics and, held a teaching appointment at the Faculty of Physics of Ludwig Maximilian University of Munich during the main course of this work. J.C.L. acknowledges funding by the Max Planck Society and by the Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (DFG, German Research Foundation) under Germany’s Excellence Strategy, EXC-2111 - 390814868. A.O. was employed at Jožef Stefan Institute during the main course of this work. A.O. acknowledges support from No. P1-0044 of the Slovenian Research Agency (ARIS).

References

Numerical extraction of effective temperatures

In the following, we will provide more information on our data processing and a discussion of how the thermalization rates were extracted from the Green’s function data generated via NESSi [28]. The first step is to Fourier-transform the real-time Green’s function with respect to the relative time τ=trel:=t1−t2\tau= t_{\mathrm{rel}} := t_{1} - t_{2}. As the remaining real

time argument we choose the orthogonal average time tavg=(t1+t2)/2t_{\mathrm{avg}} = (t_{1} + t_{2})/2, giving rise to Wigner coordinates. Our numerical solutions for the Green’s function G(t1,t2)G(t_{1},t_{2}) are obtained for a fixed rectangle in the t1t_{1}-t2t_{2} plane such that one needs to define a tilted rectangle, which is used for a consistent transformation to time-frequency coordinates (tavg,ω)(t_{\mathrm{avg}},\omega). Such a selection is sketched in Figure 8. Since effective temperatures TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}} are fitted from the low-frequency behavior of the Green’s functions, one needs to make sure that sufficiently long relative times are available for the Fourier transform, while still being able to access the relevant tavgt_{\mathrm{avg}}-range.

Image not extracted

Figure 8. Sketch of the discrete two-time blocks used for the calculations in this paper. We exemplarily show two tilted rectangles that could be used for performing the Fourier transform with respect to τ=trel\tau= t_{\mathrm{rel}}.

In addition, the extraction of the effective temperature is susceptible to the choice of the frequency range over which the fit is performed. At average times far away from the quench at tavg=0t_{\mathrm{avg}} = 0, we typically find that the ratio iGK(tavg,ω)/A(tavg,ω)iG^{K}(t_{\mathrm{avg}},\omega)/A(t_{\mathrm{avg}},\omega) coincides well with a thermal distribution function, justifying the concept of a thermalization rate of effective temperatures. Close to the quench, the distribution functions are clearly nonthermal, as can be seen in Figure 9 for both the full numerical solution and the large-qq theory. We therefore only use a few frequency points around ω=0\omega= 0 for the fit to iGK(tavg,ω)/A(tavg,ω)!=tanh⁡(βω/2)≃βω/2iG^{K}(t_{\mathrm{avg}},\omega)/A(t_{\mathrm{avg}},\omega) \mathrel{!=} \tanh(\beta\omega/2) \simeq\beta\omega/2.

Image not extracted

Figure 9. Exemplary fits of the effective temperature from the ratio of Keldysh Green’s function and spectral function

As a quality indicator for all these choices, we make sure that the initial and expected final temperatures are correctly reproduced. Figure 10 demonstrates that, while final temperatures typically do not deviate much, the obtained initial temperatures at large values of qq may depend on numerical details like the width of the frequency window over which the temperatures are fitted. In such cases, we make sure to work with data sets in which the numerically obtained initial temperature coincides with the expected one.

Image not extracted

Figure 10. Exemplary dependence of the numerically extracted effective temperature TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}} on the choice of the fitting range: we fit the temperature from a number of ww frequency points with a spacing of Δω=2⋅10−3\Delta\omega= 2 \cdot10^{-3} around ω=0\omega= 0. large-qq, q=16q = 16.

Lastly, thermalization rates Γ\Gamma need to be extracted from the effective temperature data. In order to be able to compare rates obtained from different data sets, we establish a procedure how to extract the rates: Taking the value span ΔTeff=Teff(tavg→∞)−Teff(tavg=0)\Delta T_{\mathrm{eff}} = T_{\mathrm{eff}}(t_{\mathrm{avg}} \to\infty) - T_{\mathrm{eff}}(t_{\mathrm{avg}} = 0) of TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}} from average time tavg=0t_{\mathrm{avg}} = 0 to the latest accessible average time in our simulations, we take a fraction ϵ\epsilon of this range and fit an exponential decay

Teff(tavg)=Tf+αe−Γtavg.(12)T_{\mathrm{eff}}(t_{\mathrm{avg}}) = T_{\mathrm{f}} + \alpha e^{-\Gamma t_{\mathrm{avg}}}. \tag*{(12)}

in the value range [(1−ϵ)ΔTeff,ΔTeff][(1-\epsilon)\Delta T_{\mathrm{eff}}, \Delta T_{\mathrm{eff}}]. This is demonstrated exemplarily in Figure 11. We did not notice a strong dependence of the extracted rates on ϵ\epsilon if ϵ≤0.05\epsilon\le0.05. For the plots in the main text we used ϵ=0.01\epsilon= 0.01.

Image not extracted

Figure 11. Procedure to determine the thermalization rate Γ\Gamma from the effective temperature data. The dashed orange line indicates 95% (ϵ=0.05\epsilon= 0.05) of the TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}}-range between the largest (final) value of TeffT_{\mathrm{eff}} and the value at tavg=0t_{\mathrm{avg}} = 0.

Full quench solution

In this appendix we restate the novel SYK solution derived in the companion paper [26], namely the full

Green’s function solution for all four time blocks over the quench we consider

J⃗(t)=(2,2+2γΘ(t)),J(t)=∥J⃗(t)∥(13)\vec{\mathcal{J}}(t) = (2, 2 + 2\gamma\Theta(t)), \qquad\mathcal{J}(t) = \lVert\vec{\mathcal{J}}(t)\rVert \tag*{(13)}

where we keep J\mathcal{J} explicit, since it is needed to track the overall energy scale in App. B 1. For the quench we consider, and the system at half filling, the general solution is given by G>(t1,t2)=−ieg(t1,t2)/q/2G^{>}(t_{1},t_{2}) = -\mathrm{i}e^{g(t_{1},t_{2})/q}/2, where for the instantaneous thermal regions t1,t2>0t_{1},t_{2} > 0 ((1, 1) block) or t1,t2<0t_{1},t_{2} < 0 ((0, 0) block), we have the standard large qq solutions

egb(t)/2=cos⁡(πvb/2)cos⁡(πvb/2−iλL,bt/2)(14)e^{g_{b}(t)/2} = \frac{\cos(\pi v_{b}/2)}{\cos(\pi v_{b}/2-\mathrm{i}\lambda_{L,b}t/2)} \tag*{(14)}

with s∈{i,f}⟷{0,1}s \in\{i,f\} \longleftrightarrow\{0,1\} and

λL,b=2πvbTb,Tb=Jbcos⁡(πvb/2)πvb(15)\lambda_{L,b} = 2\pi v_{b}T_{b}, \qquad T_{b} = \frac{\mathcal{J}_{b}\cos(\pi v_{b}/2)}{\pi v_{b}} \tag*{(15)}

where we have defined J⃗0≡J⃗(0−)\vec{\mathcal{J}}_{0} \equiv\vec{\mathcal{J}}(0^{-}) and J⃗1≡J⃗(0+)\vec{\mathcal{J}}_{1} \equiv\vec{\mathcal{J}}(0^{+}) and their norms denoted without the arrow. The temperatures can be related by noting the relationship between post-/pre-quench Lyapunov exponents related via the expression

vf=2πsin⁡−1[c01sin⁡(πvi/2)](16)v_{f} = \frac{2}{\pi}\sin^{-1}\left[c_{01}\sin(\pi v_{i}/2)\right] \tag*{(16)}

where we have defined

c01≡J⃗0⋅J⃗1J0J1=2+γ2(2+2γ+γ2).(17)c_{01} \equiv\frac{\vec{\mathcal{J}}_{0}\cdot\vec{\mathcal{J}}_{1}}{\mathcal{J}_{0}\mathcal{J}_{1}} = \frac{2+\gamma}{\sqrt{2(2+2\gamma+\gamma^{2})}}. \tag*{(17)}

The off-diagonal block t1<0,t2>0t_{1}<0,t_{2}>0, is inherently NEQ

gneq(t1,t2)=g1∗(t2)+g0(t1)−2ln⁡[1+c01V0(t1)V1(−t2)](18)g_{\mathrm{neq}}(t_{1},t_{2}) = g_{1}^{*}(t_{2}) + g_{0}(t_{1}) - 2\ln\left[1+c_{01}V_{0}(t_{1})V_{1}(-t_{2})\right] \tag*{(18)}

where

Vb(t)≡2JbλL,bcoth⁡(λL,bt/2)+2iJbsin⁡(πvb/2).(19)V_b(t) \equiv\frac{2\mathcal{J}_b}{\lambda_{L,b}\coth(\lambda_{L,b}t/2)+2\mathrm{i}\mathcal{J}_b\sin(\pi v_b/2)}. \tag*{(19)}

The remaining block t2<0<t1t_2<0<t_1, the (1,0)(1,0) block probed in Sec. III C, follows from the conjugation relation g(t2,t1)∗=g(t1,t2)g(t_2,t_1)^*=g(t_1,t_2).

Smallest final temperature

Consider the protocol (B1) so that the ratio controlling (B4) is c01c_{01} as defined in (B5). We wish to find the smallest final temperature

Tf=J1cos⁡(πvf/2)πvf.(20)T_f=\frac{\mathcal{J}_1\cos(\pi v_f/2)}{\pi v_f}. \tag*{(20)}

attainable from a quench of strength γ\gamma, assuming a small initial temperature TiT_i. For this the initial Lyapunov exponent is

vi=1−2TiJ0+O(Ti2).(21)v_i=1-\frac{2T_i}{\mathcal{J}_0}+O(T_i^2). \tag*{(21)}

Using (B4), the final temperature is given by

Tf∼Tf(Ti=0)+Tf(Ti=0)⋅π2(γ+2)2(Ti/J)2(γ/2+2Tf(Ti=0)/J+1)2γ2T_f\sim T_f(T_i=0)+T_f(T_i=0)\cdot\frac{\pi^2(\gamma+2)^2(T_i/\mathcal{J})^2(\gamma/2+\sqrt{2T_f(T_i=0)/\mathcal{J}}+1)}{2\gamma^2}

where

Tf(Ti=0)=J11−c0122sin⁡−1[c01].(22)T_f(T_i=0)=\frac{\mathcal{J}_1\sqrt{1-c_{01}^2}}{2\sin^{-1}[c_{01}]}. \tag*{(22)}

Re-summation of the large-qq solution

In this appendix we discuss the effect of a mild rescaling of time in the analytic large-qq solution for the Green’s function discussed in App. § 1.2.2, and demonstrate that this modification does not change the order of the comparison between the analytic and numerical results.

When comparing large qq derived results with finite qq, it is useful to consider some renormalized quantities that change variables at higher order in 1/q1/q. Like this, the result at leading order remains the same, but higher-order terms reflect the finite qq results better. For instance we make the ansatz that the Green’s functions can be written as (at half filling)

G(t1,t2)=−isgn⁡(t1−t2)eg(t1,t2)/q/2.(23)G(t_1,t_2)=-\mathrm{i}\operatorname{sgn}(t_1-t_2)e^{g(t_1,t_2)/q}/2. \tag*{(23)}

Note that in the above we have an expression formally to all order in 1/q1/q. This should be seen as a resummation of the finite qq Green’s functions which works particularly well at low temperatures. The reason for this is that together with a renormalized coupling constant J′\mathcal{J}'

J′=J(1−2q)tan⁡(π/q)π/q(24)\mathcal{J}'=\frac{\mathcal{J}}{\sqrt{\left(1-\frac{2}{q}\right)\frac{\tan(\pi/q)}{\pi/q}}} \tag*{(24)}

the solution would then exactly match the low temperature conformal result at all qq [30]. This solution is however only for late time and low temperature, as such, we will still find deviations at any finite qq at early times even if we formally took the zero temperature limit.

In our case we wish to show that the difference between the full numerical Green’s function at finite qq, and the analytical prediction using a 1/q1/q expansion Geq(ana)(t1,t2)G_{\mathrm{eq}}^{(\mathrm{ana})}(t_1,t_2) are equal up to order 1/q21/q^2. In other words, we wish to show that the measure

d(q)=max⁡t1,t2∣G(t1,t2)−Geq(ana)(t1,t2)∣=O(1/q2)(25)d(q)=\max_{t_1,t_2}\left|\mathcal{G}(t_1,t_2)-\mathcal{G}_{\mathrm{eq}}^{(\mathrm{ana})}(t_1,t_2)\right|=O(1/q^2) \tag*{(25)}

while recognizing that at moderate qq this equivalence is often obscured by finite-size effects in the numerics. Now we already know that all time dependence in Geq(ana)\mathcal{G}_{\mathrm{eq}}^{(\mathrm{ana})} is of order 1/q1/q.

We find that these finite-size distortions are significantly reduced if, instead of directly comparing G\mathcal{G} and G(ana)\mathcal{G}^{(\mathrm{ana})}, we introduce a rescaled analytic correlator

Gr(ana)(t1,t2)≡G(ana)(t1r,t2r;q),r=1−6q2.(26)\mathcal{G}_r^{(\mathrm{ana})}(t_1,t_2)\equiv\mathcal{G}^{(\mathrm{ana})}\left(\frac{t_1}{r},\frac{t_2}{r};q\right),\qquad r=1-\frac{6}{q^2}. \tag*{(26)}

To assess the formal impact of this rescaling, we expand 1/r=1+6/q2+O(1/q4)1/r=1+6/q^2+O(1/q^4). Therefore, the rescaling-induced correction satisfies

Gr(ana)−G(ana)=O(t/q3),(27)\mathcal{G}_r^{(\mathrm{ana})}-\mathcal{G}^{(\mathrm{ana})}=O(t/q^3), \tag*{(27)}

where tt denotes a characteristic time scale in the correlator. For time arguments in the standard large-qq validity regime 1≪Jt≪q1\ll\mathcal{J}t\ll q, these two are thus asymptotically equivalent.

Hence, the rescaling in Eq. (26) does not alter the equivalence between G\mathcal{G} and G(ana)\mathcal{G}^{(\mathrm{ana})} up to order 1/q1/q; it only reorganizes higher-order O(1/q3)O(1/q^3) contributions.

Practically, applying the rescaling of Eq. (26) leads to a pronounced suppression of finite-size artifacts at moderate qq. After this adjustment, the scaled deviation still satisfies (C3), and also exhibits a clean exponential decay in qq, revealing the expected asymptotic behavior and confirming that the analytic and numerical Green’s functions coincide up to order 1/q1/q.

This rescaling can be viewed as an infinitesimal time reparametrization, consistent with the subleading corrections that appear in large-qq analyses of the SYK model. It effectively removes small O(1/q3)O(1/q^3) distortions without modifying the leading-order structure.

References

  1. [1]S. Sachdev and J. Ye, Gapless spin-fluid ground state in a random quantum Heisenberg magnet, Phys. Rev. Lett. 70, 3339 (1993).DOI
  2. [2]A. Kitaev, A simple model of quantum holography, Talks at the KITP program Entanglement in Strongly-Correlated Quantum Matter, (part 1) and (part 2) (2015).
  3. [3]D. Chowdhury, A. Georges, O. Parcollet, and S. Sachdev, Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models and beyond: Window into non-Fermi liquids, Rev. Mod. Phys. 94, 035004 (2022).
  4. [4]A. Eberlein, V. Kasper, S. Sachdev, and J. Steinberg, Quantum quench of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, Phys. Rev. B 96, 205123 (2017).
  5. [5]J. C. Louw and S. Kehrein, Thermalization of many many-body interacting Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev models, Phys. Rev. B 105, 075117 (2022).DOI
  6. [6]A. Almheiri, A. Milekhin, and B. Swingle, Universal constraints on energy flow and SYK thermalization, J. High Energy Phys. 2024 (8), 34.arxiv.org/abs/1912.04912
  7. [7]R. Sohal, L. Nie, X.-Q. Sun, and E. Fradkin, Thermalization of randomly coupled SYK models, J. Stat. Mech.: Theory Exp. 2022 (1), 013103.DOI
  8. [8]S. M. H. Halataei, Eigenstate thermalization in the two-site SYK and SYK chain models, Phys. Rev. D 112, 026016 (2025).DOI
  9. [9]S. Jaramillo, R. Jha, and S. Kehrein, Thermalization of a closed Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev system in the thermodynamic limit, Phys. Rev. B 111, 195153 (2025).
  10. [10]R. Perugu, A. Haldar, and S. Banerjee, Universal nonequilibrium dynamics of pure states and density-dependent thermalization in the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, Phys. Rev. B 112, 184301 (2025).
  11. [11]R. Bhattacharya, D. P. Jatkar, and N. Sorokhaibam, Quantum quenches and thermalization in SYK models, J. High Energy Phys. 2019 (7), 66.DOI
  12. [12]S. Bandyopadhyay, P. Uhrich, A. Paviglianiti, and P. Hauke, Universal equilibration dynamics of the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, Quantum 7, 1022 (2023).DOI
  13. [13]T. Azeyanagi, F. Ferrari, and F. I. S. Massolo, Phase Diagram of Planar Matrix Quantum Mechanics, Tensor, and Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev Models, Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 061602 (2018).
  14. [14]F. Ferrari and F. I. Schaposnik Massolo, Phases of melonic quantum mechanics, Phys. Rev. D 100, 026007 (2019).DOI
  15. [15]J. C. Louw and S. Kehrein, Shared universality of charged black holes and the complex large-q Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, Phys. Rev. B 107, 075132 (2023).DOI
  16. [16]C. Zanoci and B. Swingle, Energy transport in Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev networks coupled to thermal baths, Phys. Rev. Res. 4, 023001 (2022).arxiv.org/abs/2109.03268
  17. [17]R. Jha, S. Kehrein, and J. C. Louw, Current correlations and conductivity in SYK-like systems: An analytical study, Phys. Rev. B 111, 045111 (2025).DOI
  18. [18]J. Maldacena, S. H. Shenker, and D. Stanford, A bound on chaos, J. High Energy Phys. 2016 (8), 1.DOI
  19. [19]Y.-Q. Lei and X.-H. Ge, Circular motion of charged particles near a charged black hole, Phys. Rev. D 105, 084011 (2022).DOI
  20. [20]C. V. Vishveshwara, Scattering of Gravitational Radiation by a Schwarzschild Black-hole, Nature 227, 936 (1970).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16058209
  21. [21]G. Carullo, D. Laghi, J. Veitch, and W. Del Pozzo, Bekenstein-Hod Universal Bound on Information Emission Rate Is Obeyed by LIGO-Virgo Binary Black Hole Remnants, Phys. Rev. Lett. 126, 161102 (2021).DOI
  22. [22]J. C. Louw, S. Cao, and X.-H. Ge, Matching partition functions of deformed Jackiw-Teitelboim gravity and the complex SYK model, Phys. Rev. D 108, 086014 (2023).DOI
  23. [23]S. Goldstein, T. Hara, and H. Tasaki, Extremely quick thermalization in a macroscopic quantum system for a typical nonequilibrium subspace, New J. Phys. 17, 045002 (2015).DOI
  24. [24]D. Nickelsen and M. Kastner, Classical Lieb-Robinson Bound for Estimating Equilibration Timescales of Isolated Quantum Systems, Phys. Rev. Lett. 122, 180602 (2019).DOI
  25. [25]S. Pappalardi, L. Foini, and J. Kurchan, Quantum bounds and fluctuation-dissipation relations, SciPost Phys. 12, 130 (2022).DOI
  26. [26]J. C. Louw, Analytical solutions to the non-equilibrium Green’s functions in large-q SYK models (2026), companion paper, posted on arXiv concurrently with the present work.arxiv.org/abs/2609.16438
  27. [27]R. Jha and J. C. Louw, Dynamics and charge fluctuations in large-q Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev lattices, Phys. Rev. B 107, 235114 (2023).DOI
  28. [28]M. Schü ler, D. Golež, Y. Murakami, N. Bittner, A. Hermann, H. U. Strand, P. Werner, and M. Eckstein, Nessi: The non-equilibrium systems simulation package, Comp. Phys. Comm. 257, 107484 (2020).DOI
  29. [29]X.-Y. Song, C.-M. Jian, and L. Balents, Strongly Correlated Mat. Built from Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev Models, Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 216601 (2017).DOI
  30. [30]J. Maldacena and D. Stanford, Remarks on the Sachdev-Ye-Kitaev model, Phys. Rev. D 94, 106002 (2016).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_92smt73p
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents