WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Isospin splitting of the Dirac mass probed by the relativistic Brueckner-Hartree-Fock theory in the full Dirac space
Abstract
The isospin splitting of the Dirac mass obtained with the relativistic Brueckner-Hartree-Fock (RBHF) theory is thoroughly investigated. From the perspective in the full Dirac space, the long-standing controversy between the momentum-independence approximation (MIA) method and the projection method on the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass in asymmetric nuclear matter (ANM) is analyzed in detail. We find that, the assumption procedure of the MIA method, which assumes that the single-particle potentials are momentum independent, is not a sufficient condition that directly leads to the wrong sign of the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass, while the extraction procedure of the MIA method, which extracts the single-particle potentials from the single-particle potential energy, leads to the wrong sign. By approximately solving the set of equations involved in the extraction procedure, a formal expression of the Dirac mass is obtained. The wrong isospin splitting of the Dirac mass is mainly caused by that the extraction procedure forcely assumes the momentum dependence of the single-particle potential energy to be a quadratic form where the strength is solely determined by the constant scalar potential.
It is still a challenging task to understand the properties of nuclear many-body system starting from the realistic nucleon-nucleon () interaction. The repulsive core of the realistic interaction causes a strong correlation for the many-body wave function and requires advanced many-body methods that go beyond mean field [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]. The Brueckner-Hartree-Fock (BHF) theory [7] is one of the representative nuclear many-body methods, which is characteristic for its capacity to soften the realistic interaction to an effective matrix in nuclear medium. The BHF theory can be derived as the two-hole-line truncation to the general Bethe-Brueckner-Goldstone expansion theory [1, 8], where the ground-state properties of the nuclear many-body system are calculated order by order according to the number of independent hole lines contained in the expansion diagrams [8]. Dating back to the 1960s, it is found that the saturation points of symmetric nuclear matter (SNM) calculated by the BHF theory with different two-body interactions are located on a so-called Coester line [9], which deviates systematically from the empirical values. Within the nonrelativistic framework, a way out of this dilemma is to introduce three-body forces [10, 11, 12, 13, 14, 15].
In 1980, major modification of the saturation properties of SNM is obtained by including a relativistic description of the nucleon motion [16]. With this pioneering work, much attention has been paid to developing the relativistic Brueckner-Hartree-Fock (RBHF) theory [17, 18, 19, 20]. Starting from the Bonn potential [21], the saturation points of SNM obtained by the RBHF theory have been shifted remarkably close towards the empirical values, without introducing explicit three-body forces. The success of the RBHF theory has been understood by the fact that, relativistic effects contribute a particular part of the three-body force [12, 14, 22] through virtual nucleon-antinucleon excitations in the intermediate states (the so-called diagrams) [23, 24].
One of the essential points of the RBHF theory is using the Dirac equation to describe the single-nucleon motion in the mean field, i.e., the so-called single-particle potentials (SPPs). The SPP operator is generally divided into a scalar and a vector component [25]. They can be obtained in a self-consistent way from the effective matrix. In principle, the calculations of SPPs and the matrix should be performed in the full Dirac space, where both the positive-energy states (PESs) and negative-energy states (NESs) are included. However, due to the complexity of these procedures, RBHF calculations have been usually performed without NESs, by invoking approximate methods to accomplish the Hartree-Fock calculation, such as the momentum-independence approximation (MIA) method [22, 26, 27, 28, 29, 30]. and the projection method [20, 31, 32, 34, 35] [33].
The MIA method assumes that the SPPs are independent of the momentum, and extracts the SPPs from the single-particle potential energies calculated at two selected momenta. In the projection method, the matrix elements are projected onto a complete set of Lorentz invariant amplitudes [19], from which the SPPs are calculated. Since the matrix coupled to the NESs is not considered, the SPPs obtained with these two methods are both suffered from ambiguities [31, 36, 37]. Moreover, two methods deviate significantly for the isovector properties in asymmetric nuclear matter (ANM), especially for the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass [38, 39] [33]. The MIA method leads to , while the projection method obtains the opposite sign .
Recently, self-consistent RBHF calculations in the full Dirac space have been achieved [37, 40, 41], which avoid the ambiguities suffered from the RBHF calculations without NESs. In ANM, the full solution predicts the sign [41] and clarifies the longstanding controversy between the MIA method and the projection method on the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass. The RBHF theory in the full Dirac space has also been applied to study the nonrelativistic effective mass in nuclear matter [42], the properties of with a liquid droplet model [43], and the neutron star properties [44, 45, 46]. In this work, we aim to thoroughly study the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass obtained with the RBHF calculations, especially for the performance of the MIA method, from the perspective in the full Dirac space.
In the RBHF theory, the single-particle motion for a nucleon inside the infinite nuclear matter is described by the Dirac equation
Here and are the Dirac matrices, is the nucleon mass, and are the momentum and single-particle energy, denotes the spin, and denotes neutron and proton . The symbol in Eq. (1) represents the positive-energy Dirac spinor, while the negative-energy Dirac spinor is obtained by . The SPP operator can be decomposed into the scalar potential , the timelike and spacelike parts of the vector potential and [25] as
Here is the unit vector parallel to the momentum . By calculating the matrix elements of on the basis expanded by the PESs and NESs, i.e., , , and , the momentum dependent SPPs can be determined uniquely through [37, 44]
Here the plus and minus signs in the superscripts denote the PESs and NESs, respectively. The effective quantities in Eq. (3) are defined as , , and . The effective mass is also known as the Dirac mass .
The quantities , , and in Eq. (3) are calculated by summing up the effective matrix elements with all the nucleons inside the Fermi sea
Here is the antisymmetrized matrix, is the Fermi momentum, and the starting energy is denoted by . The additional factors in Eq. (4) arise due to the normalization of the Dirac spinors, i.e., , . The effective interaction matrix is the solution of the in-medium Thompson equation [26] which describes the two-body scattering
The labels of PESs and NESs have been suppressed. In this work, the realistic interaction is chosen as the Bonn potential [21]. Here and are the center-of-mass and the relative momenta of the two interacting nucleons with momenta and . The initial, intermediate, and final relative momenta of the two nucleons are , , and , respectively. The scattering in the nuclear medium is restricted with the Pauli operator .
Equations (1), (3), (4), and (5) constitute a coupled system that has to be solved in a self-consistent way. After the convergence of SPPs, the single-particle and bulk properties of nuclear matter can be calculated straightforwardly [29, 32, 47].
In SNM, the Dirac masses for nucleon calculated by the MIA method and the projection method are both quantitatively close to the results obtained in the full Dirac space [41]. However, the situation changes dramatically in ANM. Figure 1 depicts the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass calculated with the RBHF theory as a function of the asymmetry parameter . The projection method finds that in ANM there is , while the MIA method leads to the opposite sign . This contradiction, which is well known since 1997 [38], has been clarified recently by considering the PESs and the NESs simultaneously in Ref. [41]. Comparing to the RBHF results calculated in the full Dirac space as also shown in Figure 1, the projection method obtains a qualitatively consistent isospin dependence of the Dirac mass with overestimated amplitudes, while the MIA method gives a wrong sign.

Figure 1. (Color online) The isospin splittings of Dirac masses as functions of the asymmetry parameter obtained by the RBHF theory in the full Dirac space (red solid), the projection method (olive dashed), and the MIA method (blue dotted). The density is fixed at the normal nuclear saturation density . The interaction Bonn A is used.
It is still unclear why the MIA method succeeds in SNM but fails in ANM. To reach the answer, we notice that this method has two essential procedures. The first procedure can be called as the assumption procedure, which assumes that the scalar potential and the timelike part of the vector potential are momentum independent and the spacelike part of the vector potential is negligible, i.e.,
The second procedure can be called as the extraction procedure, which extracts the two constants and from the single-particle potential energy at two momenta
The quantity in Eq. (7) is calculated as .
The RBHF calculations in the full Dirac space provide us an opportunity to analyze in detail the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass. In the following, we try to study further by testing separately the two procedures of the MIA method from the perspective in the full Dirac space.
Firstly, we apply the assumption procedure (6) in the full Dirac space, i.e., the quantities in Eq. (3a) and in Eq. (3b) are assumed to be momentum independent and are calculated at the Fermi momentum , while in Eq. (3c) is set as zero. The newly obtained quantities and will be used to update the Dirac spinors and matrix for next iteration. After the convergence of SPPs, we calculate the binding energies per nucleon for SNM and pure neutron matter (PNM). As can be seen in Figure 2, the for SNM and PNM are very close to those obtained by the RBHF theory in the full Dirac space. This indicates that the assumption procedure is reasonable for describing the bulk properties of nuclear matter.

Figure 2. (Color online) Binding energies per nucleon of SNM and PNM as functions of the nucleon density calculated in the full Dirac space with the assumption procedure. For comparison, the self-consistent results obtained by the RBHF theory in the full Dirac space are also shown.
In Figure 3(b), we show the Dirac masses of the neutron and proton obtained in the full Dirac space with the assumption procedure. The density is fixed at . The relation of is found, which is consistent with the result obtained by the RBHF theory in the full Dirac space, as shown in Figure 3(a). This indicates that the assumption procedure is not a sufficient condition that directly leads to the wrong sign when one calculates the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass in ANM.

Figure 3. (Color online) Dirac masses for neutron (solid lines) and proton (dashed lines) as functions of the asymmetric parameter at density calculated by the RBHF theory (a) in the full Dirac space, (b) with the assumption procedure, and (c) with the extraction procedure. Details can be found in the text.
Secondly, we test the influence of the extraction procedure (7) from the perspective in the full Dirac space. Starting from the converged obtained by the RBHF theory in the full Dirac space, we extract the two constants and by using Eq. (7) with two selected momenta and then calculate the Dirac mass. The resulting isospin splitting of the Dirac mass is shown in Figure 3(c). It is seen that is obtained for the entire region of the asymmetry parameter , which is opposite to results obtained in the full Dirac space (Figure 3(a)). This shows that it is the extraction procedure (7) that leads to the wrong sign of the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass.
To further investigate how the wrong isospin dependence of the Dirac mass emerges from the extraction procedure, it is insightful to solve Eq. (7) to get a formal expression of the Dirac mass. We start from the case of SNM and suppress the isospin indexes for moment. For , , and , one notices that the typical choice and leads to , . This allows one to expand the square root in Eq. (7) to the first order,
which indicates a quadratic form of the single-particle potential energy . With Eq. (13) it is straightforward to find the difference between and as
For simplicity, we consider the limit that two momenta and are very close and denote them as . In this case Eq. (14) can be written as a quadratic equation for
where the dimensionless function is defined as
The derivative describes the momentum dependence of the single-particle potential energy .
In Figure 4(a), the single-particle potential energy obtained in the full Dirac space for SNM and also ANM with and is shown as a function of momentum . It is found that is a monotonic function of the . Therefore, the function is positive definite and the solution of Eq. (15) is

Figure 4. (Color online) (a) The single-particle potential energy obtained in the full Dirac space as a function of momentum . The cases for SNM and ANM with and are shown. The momenta and are highlighted with empty dots and solid squares respectively. (b) The Dirac mass as a functional of dimensionless quantity in Eq. (17). (c) The dimensionless function (16) obtained in the full Dirac space as a function of momentum . The notation for lines and symbols is the same as panel (a).
From Figure 4(b), the Dirac mass is decreasing with increasing . Therefore, the sign of is opposite to that of , i.e.,
In Figure 4(c), the function for nucleon obtained in the full Dirac space is shown. It is found that is decreasing with the increasing . Besides, generally there is for . This indicates that the momentum dependence of is weaker than that of .
In practice, one usually chooses and [29, 41]. For ANM with , the Fermi momentum for neutron is larger than the of proton, i.e., . As shown by the symbols in panels (a) and (c) in Figure 4, this choice leads to and . Specifically, starting from the self-consistent obtained in the full Dirac space, the choices for neutron and for proton lead to and . According to the analysis in Eq. (18), the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass emerges. This explains the reason why the MIA method leads to the wrong isospin splitting of the Dirac mass in ANM.
Come back to Eq. (13), one can see that the extraction procedure forcely assumes that the momentum dependence of the single-particle potential energy to be a quadratic form, where the strength is solely determined by the scalar potential . In ANM, the momentum dependence of is generally weaker than that of , as shown in Figure 4(c). It is exactly this fact that leads to and the wrong sign of the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass .
In summary, the relativistic Brueckner-Hartree-Fock (RBHF) theory plays an important role in deriving the nuclear many-body properties from the realistic nucleon-nucleon interactions. In comparison to the results obtained self-consistently in the full Dirac space, the momentum-independence approximation (MIA) method leads to wrong isospin splitting of the Dirac mass in asymmetric nuclear matter (ANM). The performance of this method is explored in detail from the perspective in the full Dirac space. The assumption procedure of the MIA method, which assumes that the single-particle potentials are momentum independent, is not a sufficient condition that directly leads to the wrong sign of the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass, while the extraction procedure of the MIA method, which extracts the single-particle potentials from the single-particle potential energy, is found to be responsible for the wrong isospin splitting of the Dirac mass. By approximately solving the set of equations involved in the extraction procedure, a formal expression of the Dirac mass is obtained. With the typical choice of momenta adopted in practical MIA calculations, the wrong isospin splitting of the Dirac mass is found. We conclude that the wrong isospin splitting of the Dirac mass emerges from the fact that the extraction procedure forcibly assumes the momentum dependence of the single-particle potential energy to be a quadratic form where the strength is solely determined by the constant scalar potential. This work improves greatly our understanding on the isospin splitting of the Dirac mass with the RBHF theory.
Acknowledgments
The authors thank the discussion with Professor Peter Ring. This work was supported in part by the China Postdoctoral Science Foundation under Grant No. 2021M700610, the National Natural Science Foundation of China (NSFC) under Grants No. 12205030, the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities under Grants No. 2020CDJQYZ003 and No. 2021CDJZYJH-003, and the Institute for Basic Science under Grant No. IBS-R031-D1. Part of this work was achieved by using the supercomputer OCTOPUS at the Cybermedia Center, Osaka University under the support of Research Center for Nuclear Physics of Osaka University and the High Performance Computing Resources in the Research Solution Center, Institute for Basic Science.
References
References
- [1]M. Baldo and C. Maieron, Journal of Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics 34, R243 (2007).
- [2]B. R. Barrett, P. Navratil, and J. P. Vary, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 69, 131 (2013).
- [3]G. Hagen, T. Papenbrock, M. Hjorth-Jensen, and D. J. Dean, Rep. Prog. Phys. 77, 096302 (2014).
- [4]J. Carlson, S. Gandolfi, F. Pederiva, S. C. Pieper, R. Schiavilla, K. E. Schmidt, and R. B. Wiringa, Rev. Mod. Phys. 87, 1067 (2015).
- [5]H. Hergert, S. Bogner, T. Morris, A. Schwenk, and K. Tsukiyama, Phys. Rep. 621, 165 (2016).
- [6]S. Shen, H. Liang, W. Long, J. Meng, and P. Ring, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 109, 103713 (2019).
- [7]K. A. Brueckner, C. A. Levinson, and H. M. Mahmoud, Phys. Rev. 95, 217 (1954).
- [8]B. D. Day, Reviews of Modern Physics 39, 719 (1967).
- [9]F. Coester, S. Cohen, B. Day, and C. M. Vincent, Physical Review C 1, 769 (1970).
- [10]P. Grangé, A. Lejeune, M. Martzolff, and J.-F. Mathiot, Phys. Rev. C 40, 1040 (1989).
- [11]M. Baldo, I. Bombaci, and G. F. Burgio, Astron. Astrophys. 328, 274 (1997).
- [12]W. Zuo, A. Lejeune, U. Lombardo, and J. Mathiot, Nuclear Physics A 706, 418 (2002).
- [13]X. R. Zhou, G. F. Burgio, U. Lombardo, H.-J. Schulze, and W. Zuo, Phys. Rev. C 69, 018801 (2004).
- [14]Z. H. Li, U. Lombardo, H.-J. Schulze, W. Zuo, L. W. Chen, and H. R. Ma, Phys. Rev. C 74, 047304 (2006).
- [15]Z. H. Li, U. Lombardo, H.-J. Schulze, and W. Zuo, Phys. Rev. C 77, 034316 (2008).
- [16]M. R. Anastasio, L. S. Celenza, and C. M. Shakin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 45, 2096 (1980).
- [17]M. R. Anastasio, L. S. Celenza, and C. M. Shakin, Phys. Rev. C 23, 2273 (1981).
- [18]R. Brockmann and R. Machleidt, Physics Letters B 149, 283 (1984).
- [19]C. J. Horowitz and B. D. Serot, Nucl. Phys. A 464, 613 (1987).
- [20]B. ter Haar and R. Malfliet, Physical Review Letters 59, 1652 (1987).
- [21]R. Machleidt, Adv. Nucl. Phys. 19, 189 (1989).
- [22]F. Sammarruca, B. Chen, L. Coraggio, N. Itaco, and R. Machleidt, Phys. Rev. C 86, 054317 (2012).
- [23]T. Jaroszewicz and S. J. Brodsky, Phys. Rev. C 43, 1946 (1991).
- [24]G. E. Brown, Physica Scripta 36, 209 (1987).
- [25]B. D. Serot and J. D. Walecka, Adv. Nucl. Phys. 16, 1 (1986).
- [26]R. Brockmann and R. Machleidt, Phys. Rev. C 42, 1965 (1990).
- [27]G. Q. Li, R. Machleidt, and R. Brockmann, Phys. Rev. C 45, 2782 (1992).
- [28]D. Alonso and F. Sammarruca, Physical Review C 67, 054301 (2003).
- [29]H. Tong, X.-L. Ren, P. Ring, S.-H. Shen, S.-B. Wang, and J. Meng, Phys. Rev. C 98, 054302 (2018).
- [30]C. Wang, J. Hu, Y. Zhang, and H. Shen, Journal of Physics G: Nuclear and Particle Physics 47, 105108 (202
- [31]T. Gross-Boelting, C. Fuchs, and A. Faessler, Nuclear Physics A 648, 105 (1999).
- [32]E. N. E. van Dalen, C. Fuchs, and A. Faessler, Nuclear Physics A 744, 227 (2004). E. N. E. van Dalen, C. Fuchs, and A. Faessler, Physical Review Letters 95, 022302 (2005).
- [34]E. N. E. van Dalen, C. Fuchs, and A. Faessler, Phys. Rev. C 72, 065803 (2005).
- [35]E. N. E. van Dalen, C. Fuchs, and A. Faessler, The European Physical Journal A 31, 29 (2007).
- [36]C. Nuppenau, Y. Lee, and A. MacKellar, Nuclear Physics A 504, 839 (1989).
- [37]S. Wang, Q. Zhao, P. Ring, and J. Meng, Phys. Rev. C 103, 054319 (2021).
- [38]S. Ulrych and H. Müther, Phys. Rev. C 56, 1788 (1997).
- [39]N. Van Giai, B. V. Carlson, Z. Ma, and H. Wolter, J. Phys. G 37, 064043 (2010).
- [40]S. Wang, H. Tong, and C. Wang, Phys. Rev. C 105, 054309 (2022).
- [41]S. Wang, H. Tong, Q. Zhao, C. Wang, P. Ring, and J. Meng, Phys. Rev. C 106, L021305 (2022).
- [42]S. Wang, H. Tong, Q. Zhao, C. Wang, P. Ring, and J. Meng, Phys. Rev. C 108, L031303 (2023).
- [43]H. Tong, J. Gao, C. Wang, and S. Wang, Phys. Rev. C 107, 034302 (2023).
- [44]H. Tong, C. Wang, and S. Wang, The Astrophysical Journal 930, 137 (2022).
- [45]S. Wang, C. Wang, and H. Tong, Phys. Rev. C 106, 045804 (2022).
- [46]X. Qu, H. Tong, C. Wang, and S. Wang, Sci. China-Phys. Mech. Astron. 66, 242011 (2023).
- [47]T. Katayama and K. Saito, Phys. Rev. C 88, 035805 (2013), 1307.2067.