betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

High-precision measurement of the atomic mass of 84^{84}Sr and implications to isotope shift studies

Abstract

The absolute mass of 84^{84}Sr was determined using the phase-imaging ion-cyclotron-resonance technique with the JYFLTRAP double Penning trap mass spectrometer. A more precise value for the mass of 84^{84}Sr is essential for providing potential indications of physics beyond the Standard Model through high-precision isotope shift measurements of Sr atomic transition frequencies. The mass excess of 84^{84}Sr was refined to be -80649.229(37) keV/c2^2 from high-precision cyclotron-frequency-ratio measurements with a relative precision of 4.8×\times10−10^{-10}. The obtained mass-excess value is in agreement with the adopted value in the Atomic Mass Evaluation 2020, but is 30 times more precise. With this new value, we confirm the previously observed nonlinearity in the study of the isotope shift of strontium. Moreover, the double-beta (2β+2β^{+}) decay QQ value of 84^{84}Sr was directly determined to be 1790.115(37) keV, and the precision was improved by a factor of 30.

Introduction

Isotope shifts in atomic transition frequencies arise from differences in neutron numbers between isotopes sharing the same atomic number. The isotopic shifts in the frequency of an atomic transition show an approximately linear correlation with the isotope shift observed in a second transition. These shifts reveal contributions from field and mass shifts [1], originating from the differing nuclear masses of isotopes and variations in their nuclear charge distribution. Isotopic shifts can be systematically studied using a King plot analysis. In this analysis, the isotope shifts in two electronic transitions within the same isotopes are correlated. To perform the King plot analysis, one measures the energies of two transitions for three or more isotopes of a specific element. The King plot is expected to exhibit linearity [1, 2], with the experimentally determined slope serving as a reliable benchmark for theoretical predictions [3]. Deviations from linearity are crucial for refining atomic structure calculations [4, 5, 6]. Recent theoretical proposals suggest that the observed nonlinearity in King plots could be used to impose constraints on higher-order effects on field isotope shift within the Standard Model (SM) or a possibility of a new interaction mediated by a boson beyond SM [7, 8, 9]. SM contributions to field isotope shift, which include quadratic field shift, relativistic effects, and effects of nuclear deformation, are proposed to account for nonlinearities of the King plot [10]. In Refs. [9, 11], nuclear polarization has also been considered as a non-negligible contribution to the nonlinearity.

Motivated by this, a recent surge in efforts [12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23] has significantly advanced the precision of isotope shift measurements. Essential to placing constraints on proposed electron-neutron interactions and other novel physics through King’s linearity is a two-fold requirement. First, experimental data in the form of precision optical spectroscopy and atomic mass measurements are needed to empirically constrain the potential size of the nonlinearity. Second, if a nonlinearity is observed, precise atomic and nuclear theory is necessary to calculate beyond-first-order SM sources of nonlinearity [7, 8, 9, 24]. A natural inquiry emerges regarding the potential for the King plot to maintain its linearity at an enhanced level of experimental precision. Recent experiments conducted with strontium and ytterbium ions [12, 18] have provided initial indications that this linearity is, in fact, disrupted at a magnitude of several standard deviations. Strontium presents favorable properties for studying isotope shifts, boasting an abundance of stable isotopes and very narrow optical transitions [25]. Earlier theoretical work has also proposed the measurement of strontium isotope shifts as a promising probe for new physics [7, 8, 26]. Alkaline-earth element strontium features four stable isotopes: three bosons (84,86,88Sr^{84,86,88}\mathrm{Sr}) and one fermion (87Sr^{87}\mathrm{Sr}). Precise and accurate determination of the atomic mass of the stable Sr isotopes is crucial for probing potential causes for such nonlinearities.

Atomic masses of 86−88Sr^{86-88}\mathrm{Sr} have been measured at the FSU Penning trap [27] with high precision (uncertainty of ≤6\leq6 eV/c2c^2) as adopted in the most recent Atomic Mass Evaluation 2020 (AME2020) [28, 29]. The atomic mass uncertainty for 84Sr^{84}\mathrm{Sr}, the least abundant naturally occurring isotope of strontium, is however notably higher at 1.2 keV/c2c^{2}. For investigating fundamental physics and exploring phenomena beyond the SM via high-precision King-plot tests with strontium, it is critical to measure the atomic mass of 84Sr^{84}\mathrm{Sr} directly with high precision. In this article, we report on the most precise absolute mass value of 84Sr^{84}\mathrm{Sr} to date, achieved via high-precision cyclotron-frequency-ratio measurements with the JYFLTRAP double Penning trap mass spectrometer (PTMS). We employ this refined mass value in an updated King plot analysis for two transitions of strontium.

Experimental method

The experiment was performed at the Ion Guide Isotope Separator On-Line facility (IGISOL) using the JYFLTRAP double PTMS [30, 31], at the University of Jyväskylä [32]. Stable 84Sr+^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} ions were generated using an offline glow-discharge ion source [33]. For a precise mass measurement of 84Sr^{84}\mathrm{Sr}, reference ions of 84Kr+^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+} with a well-known mass value (uncertainty of 4 eV/c2c^{2}[28]) were concurrently produced from the same ion source. As illustrated in Figure 1(a), the gas cell comprising the glow-discharge ion source hosts two sharp electrodes, with one composed of naturally abundant strontium. By introducing a gas containing natural krypton, it facilitates the simultaneous generation of stable ions for both strontium and krypton.

Schematic view of ion production and mass measurements using the PI-ICR technique at IGISOL

Figure 1. (Color online). Schematic view of ion production and mass measurements using the PI-ICR technique at IGISOL. Stable 84Kr+^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+} and 84Sr+^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} ions were generated using an offline glow-discharge ion source (a). Ions having mass number of 84 were selected with a dipole magnet and transported to the JYFLTRAP PTMS for final ion species selection in the preparation trap (b) by means of a buffer-gas cooling technique and cyclotron frequency determination using the phase-imaging technique in the measurement trap (c). A position-sensitive MCP detector (d) was used to register the images of the motion phases. (e) An illustration of the radial-motion (“magnetron”, “cyclotron”, and “center”) projection of the 84Sr+^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} ions onto the position-sensitive MCP detector. Each pixel’s color corresponds to a different number of ions.

The generated ions of 84Sr+^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} and 84Kr+^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+} were extracted using helium gas flow and electric fields facilitated by a sextupole ion guide (SPIG) [34]. Following acceleration over an electric potential of ≈30\approx30 kV, the ions with mass number of A=84A = 84 were mass-separated using a 55∘55^\circ dipole magnet with a mass resolving power of M/ΔM≈500M/\Delta M \approx500. Post isobaric separation, the ion beam passed through a pulsed electrostatic kicker, which functioned as a beam gate to regulate the ion rate. The chopped ions, controlled by the beam gate, were directed to a radiofrequency-quadrupole cooler-buncher (RFQ-CB) [35], where they were accumulated, cooled, and bunched.

The ion bunches from the RFQ-CB were injected to the JYFLTRAP double PTMS, consisting of two cylindrical Penning traps equipped with a 7-T superconducting solenoid. The first trap, functioning as a purification trap, is filled with buffer gas and is employed for isobaric purification using the sideband buffer-gas cooling technique [36]. This technique alone achieves mass purification with a resolving power of approximately 10510^{5} by selectively converting ion motion from magnetron to reduced cyclotron motion.

In the purification trap, all cooled and centered ions (84Sr+^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} and 84Kr+^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+}) were initially excited to a large orbit of revolution by applying a dipole excitation at the magnetron motion frequency ν−\nu_{-} for approximately 11 ms. Subsequently, a quadrupole excitation was applied at the cyclotron frequency of the ions of interest (only 84Sr+^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} or 84Kr+^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+}) for about 100 ms, to center them through collisions with buffer gas. This technique alone can provide sufficient cleaning for 84Sr+^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} or 84Kr+^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+}. A even higher resolving power selecting method, the Ramsey cleaning technique, was additionally employed with a resolving power better than 10610^{6} [37] right after the sideband buffer-gas cooling to ensure no leaking events of contaminants. In this method, the ions extracted through a 1.5-mm diaphragm to the second trap (measurement trap) undergo an additional cleaning step utilizing a dipolar excitation with time-separated oscillatory fields at the mass-dependent reduced cyclotron frequency (ν+\nu_{+}), which selectively increases the cyclotron radius of the contaminants. The contaminants were implanted on the diaphragm after subsequent transfer back to the first trap. A purified sample of either 84Sr+^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} or 84Kr+^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+} ions was prepared after selection and cleaning using the aforementioned techniques. Finally, these ions were centered again in the first trap and transferred to the second trap for measuring the actual cyclotron frequency.

In the second trap, the phase-imaging ion-cyclotron-resonance (PI-ICR) method [38, 39] was employed to measure the cyclotron frequency, νc=qB/(2πm)\nu_c=qB/(2\pi m), where BB is the magnetic field strength, qq is the charge state, and mm is the mass of the stored ion. The scheme of the PI-ICR technique [39, 38, 40, 41] at JYFLTRAP relies on direct measurements of the cyclotron motion and magnetron motion simultaneously by projecting the radial ion motion onto a position-sensitive MCP detector. To determine the phases of the radial motions, the center has to be determined for the ion spots on the detector. This is done by storing the ions for a few milliseconds without exciting their cyclotron motion, after which the ions are directly extracted from the trap and projected onto the MCP detector. Two patterns, as detailed in [38, 39], are utilized to measure the magnetron or cyclotron motion phases, respectively. The angle between two phase images of the projected radial motions with respect to the center spot is αc=α+−α−\alpha_c=\alpha_+-\alpha_-, where α+\alpha_+ and α−\alpha_- are the polar angles of the cyclotron and magnetron motion phases. The cyclotron frequency νc\nu_c is derived from:

νc=αc+2πnc2πtacc(1)\nu_c=\frac{\alpha_c+2\pi n_c}{2\pi t_{\mathrm{acc}}} \tag*{(1)}

where ncn_c is the sum of the numbers of full revolutions in the two patterns of the measured ions during the phase accumulation time tacct_{\mathrm{acc}}. A few different accumulation times for 84Sr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} and 84Kr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+} were used to confirm unambiguously the cyclotron frequency. A fixed accumulation time of 400 ms was employed for the actual measurements to determine the final νc\nu_c. A measurement with "cyclotron" and "magnetron" phase spots collected with respect to the center spot is schematically shown in Figure 1(e). A representative measurement of the magnetron and cyclotron phase spots relative to the center spot is shown in the left and right panels of Figure 2, respectively.

Figure 2. (Color online). Ion spots (magnetron phase, cyclotron phase, and center) of 84Sr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} on the 2-dimensional position-sensitive MCP detector after a typical PI-ICR excitation pattern with an accumulation time of 400 ms. The magnetron phase spot is shown on the left side and the cyclotron phase spot on the right. By analyzing the angle difference between the two phase spots relative to the center spot, αc=α+−α−\alpha_c=\alpha_+-\alpha_-, the cyclotron frequency of the measured ion species can be deduced. Color bars indicate the number of ions in each pixel.

The atomic mass M(84Sr)M({}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}) was derived from the measured cyclotron frequency ratio (R=νc(84Kr+)/νc(84Sr+))(R=\nu_c({}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+})/\nu_c({}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+})) measurements of singly charged ions of the decay pair 84Sr{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}–84Kr{}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}:

M(84Sr)=R(M(84Kr)−qme)+qme+(R⋅B(84Kr)−B(84Sr))/c2(2)M({}^{84}\mathrm{Sr})=R\left(M({}^{84}\mathrm{Kr})-qm_e\right)+qm_e+\left(R\cdot B({}^{84}\mathrm{Kr})-B({}^{84}\mathrm{Sr})\right)/c^2 \tag*{(2)}

Here, M(84Sr)M({}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}) and M(84Kr)M({}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}) represent the respective masses of the decay parent and daughter atoms and qq denotes the charge state for singly charged ions (q=1q=1). mem_e and cc correspond to the mass of an electron and the speed of light in vacuum. The electron binding energies, B(84Sr)B({}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}) and B(84Kr)B({}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}), are 5.69486745(12) eV and 13.9996055(20) eV, respectively, as obtained from [42]. The QQ value for the double-beta decay of 84Sr{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr} can be determined from the mass difference: Q2β+=(M(84Sr)−M(84Kr))c2Q_{2\beta^+}=(M({}^{84}\mathrm{Sr})-M({}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}))c^2.

Results and discussion

Mass and QQ-value determination

A full scanning measurement (one cycle) of the magnetron phase, cyclotron phase, and center spot in sequence was completed in less than 3 minutes for each ion species of 84Kr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+} and 84Sr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+}. In the analysis, the position of each spot within 5σ5\sigma of the ion distribution, was fit using the maximum likelihood method [43, 44]. Maximum-likelihood estimation with a Gaussian distribution was used for the parameter adjustment. Every four cycles were summed to ensure reasonable counts for fitting before determining the exact position of each spot. The phase angles were calculated accordingly based on the determined positions of the spots to deduce the cyclotron frequencies of each ion species. The cyclotron frequency νc\nu_c of the daughter ion 84Kr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+} was used as a reference and was linearly interpolated to the time of the measurement of the parent 84Sr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} (ion of interest) to deduce the cyclotron frequency ratio RR. Bunches with less than five detected ions per bunch were considered in the data analysis to reduce a possible cyclotron frequency shift due to ion-ion interactions [45, 46]. Up to 5 detected ions per bunch were taken into account for the analysis, and no count-rate related frequency shifts were observed in the analysis. The temporal fluctuation of the magnetic field for JYFLTRAP was measured to be δB(νc)/νc=Δt×2.01(25)×10−12/min\delta B(\nu_c)/\nu_c=\Delta t\times2.01(25)\times10^{-12}/\mathrm{min} [39], where Δt\Delta t is the time interval between two consecutive reference measurements. The contribution of temporal fluctuations of the magnetic field to the final frequency ratio uncertainty was less than 10−1010^{-10} since the 84Kr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+}-84Sr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} measurements were interleaved with Δt<10\Delta t < 10 minutes. To minimize the systematic uncertainty arising from the conversion of cyclotron motion to magnetron motion and potential distortion of the ion-motion projection onto the detector, the positions of the magnetron-motion and cyclotron-motion phase spots were deliberately chosen. The angle αc\alpha_{\mathrm{c}} between them was kept to less than 10 degrees, effectively reducing this uncertainty to a level well below 10−1010^{-10} [40]. Moreover, the commencement of the initial dipolar excitation with frequency ν+\nu_{+} was systematically scanned across one magnetron period (6 points), and the extraction was scanned over one cyclotron period (6 points) to mitigate any lingering effects of residual magnetron and cyclotron motion that might influence the distinct spots. The measurements were conducted in eight separate time slots, each lasting around 4 hours to ensure a consistent ion rate with a median value of 1-2 counts per bunch. For each slot of measurement, a weighted mean ratio R4hR_{4\mathrm{h}} was calculated, and the maximum of internal and external errors [47] was selected. The final ratio R‾\overline{R} was then obtained as a weighted mean ratio of all R4hR_{4\mathrm{h}} sets, taking into account the maximum of internal and external errors. The ions of the 84Kr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+} and 84Sr+{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+} were measured under similar conditions to minimize potential systematic shifts in the frequency ratio due to imperfections in the measurement trap. Mass-dependent systematic effects are negligible compared to the statistical uncertainty for mass doublets. No further systematic uncertainties were introduced, and these were confirmed through our previous measurements, as outlined in references [39, 43, 48, 49]. The final frequency ratio RR with its uncertainty, as well as the corresponding Q2β+Q_{2\beta^{+}} and mass-excess values, are 1.000 022 902 36(48), 1790.115(37) keV, and -80649.229(37) keV/c2c^{2} respectively.

In Figure 3, the analysis results, which include all data sets, are compared to literature values. A comparison of these results to the literature values are also tabulated in Table 1.

R‾\overline{R}Q2β+Q_{2\beta^+}ME
This Work1.000 022 902 36(48)1790.115(37)-80649.229(37)
AME20201789.8(12)-80649.6(12)

Table 1. The resulting Q2β+Q_{2\beta^+} and mass-excess values of 84{}^{84}Sr determined in this work based on the weighted mean of the cyclotron frequency ratio R‾\overline{R}. The frequency ratio R‾\overline{R}, Q2β+Q_{2\beta^+} values (in keV), and the mass excess (ME, in keV/c2c^2) of the parent, as determined in this work, are provided alongside the corresponding value from AME2020 [28] for comparison.

Deviation of individually measured cyclotron frequency ratios and mass-excess values

Figure 3. (Color online). The deviation (left axis) of the individually measured cyclotron frequency ratios R4hR_{4\mathrm{h}} (νc(84Kr+)/νc(84Sr+)\nu_{\mathrm{c}}({}^{84}\mathrm{Kr}^{+})/\nu_{\mathrm{c}}({}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}^{+})) from the final ratio value R‾\overline{R} and (right axis) mass-excess values in this work compared to values adopted from AME2020 [50, 28]. The red points, accompanied by uncertainties, represent individual data obtained with the PI-ICR method in eight distinct time slots. The solid red line illustrates the weighted average value from this work, R‾=1.000\overline{R}=1.000 022 902 36(48), and its 1σ1\sigma uncertainty band is shaded in red. The dashed blue line represents the difference between the new value in this work and the one referred to in AME2020, with its 1σ1\sigma uncertainty area shaded in blue.

The mass excess (-80649.229(37) keV/c2c^{2}) and Q2β+Q_{2\beta^{+}} (1790.115(37) keV) from this work are both a factor of ≈30\approx30 more precise than those derived from the evaluated masses in AME2020 [50, 28], but both agree well with the values documented in AME2020. The mass-excess value in AME2020 is derived primarily from two PTMS experiments [51, 52] with an influence of 88.8%. A slight contribution of 6.8% is from endpoint energy measurements of 84Rb(β−)84Sr{}^{84}\mathrm{Rb}(\beta^{-}){}^{84}\mathrm{Sr} [53] and the smallest influence of 2.1% is related to a nuclear reaction experiment 84Sr(d,p)85Sr{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}(\mathrm{d},\mathrm{p}){}^{85}\mathrm{Sr} [54].

King plot analysis

The isotope shift between two isotopes with mass numbers A1A_{1} and A2A_{2}, (νiA1A2)(\nu_{i}^{A_{1}A_{2}}) is defined as the difference in transition frequencies: νiA1A2=νiA1−νiA2\nu_{i}^{A_{1}A_{2}}=\nu_{i}^{A_{1}}-\nu_{i}^{A_{2}}. The primary contributions to the isotope shift arise from the mass shift (MS) and field shift (FS). The MS results from the mass difference of isotopes A1A_{1} and A2A_{2} and is expressed as an electronic coefficient kik_{i} multiplied by the isotope-dependent inverse mass factor, given by: μA1A2=1/mA2−1/mA1\mu^{A_{1}A_{2}}=1/m_{A_{2}}-1/m_{A_{1}}. The FS originates from the differing volumes of the two isotopes, factorized into an electronic, isotope-independent coefficient FiF_{i} and the charge radius variance δ⟨r2⟩A1A2=⟨rA12⟩−⟨rA22⟩\delta\langle r^{2}\rangle_{A_{1}A_{2}}=\langle r_{A_{1}}^{2}\rangle-\langle r_{A_{2}}^{2}\rangle. The isotope shift composition

of a transition ii in terms of electronic and nuclear quantities factorizes into the total isotope shift equation: νiA1A2=kiμA1A2+\nu_{i}^{A_{1}A_{2}}=k_{i}\mu^{A_{1}A_{2}}+ Fiδ⟨r2⟩A1A2+…F_i\delta\langle r^2\rangle_{A_1A_2}+\ldots, where the first term represents the MS, and the second term represents the FS [1, 56], with the dots denoting potential higher-order corrections and new physics contributions. The frequency shifts are commonly normalized by the inverse mass factor μA1A2\mu^{A_1A_2} to obtain the modified isotope shift, νiA1A2/μA1A2\nu_i^{A_1A_2}/\mu^{A_1A_2} [57]. Consequently, the MS (the sum of the normal MS and specific MS) reduces to the electronic factor kik_i, while the FS factor FiF_i is multiplied by the modified charge radius variance, δ⟨r2⟩A1A2/μA1A2\delta\langle r^2\rangle_{A_1A_2}/\mu^{A_1A_2}, establishing a linear dependence between the two sets of modified frequency shifts known as the King linearity [56]. If the isotope shifts are measured for more than one transition (ii and jj), one could eliminate the typically poorly known difference of the mean squared nuclear charge radii δ⟨r2⟩A1A2\delta\langle r^2\rangle_{A_1A_2} and to write the so-called King relation [56]: νiA1A2/μA1A2=Ki−Fi/Fj⋅Kj+Fi/Fj⋅νjA1A2/μA1A2\nu_i^{A_1A_2}/\mu^{A_1A_2}=K_i-F_i/F_j\cdot K_j+F_i/F_j\cdot\nu_j^{A_1A_2}/\mu^{A_1A_2}. To quantify the observed linearity, a measure of nonlinearity is defined [3, 8]. A King plot analysis can be used to systematically quantify and visually examine isotope shifts in various atomic transitions referenced to the same isotope.

The refined mass-excess value obtained for 84^{84}Sr was employed to carry out an updated King plot analysis for two transitions at 689 nm and 698 nm, as detailed in [12, 55]. Figure 4 displays the King plot featuring both the literature mass values from AME2020 and our updated mass value. The main uncertainties in the plot are from the frequency shifts measurements in the transitions between 84^{84}Sr, 86^{86}Sr, and 87^{87}Sr relative to 88^{88}Sr as adopted from [12]. The transition of 87^{87}Sr-88^{88}Sr at 698 nm is from [55] which has a better precision than that of [12]. The observed nonlinearity from [12], achieved through our new mass value for 84^{84}Sr is evident, and the reduced mass uncertainty will enhance the possible precision of isotope-shift data, overcoming previous limitations imposed by 84^{84}Sr. Given that the uncertainty in the mass contributes to the calculation of the modified isotope shifts in similar ways, the impact on the linearity of the King plot is preserved due to the agreement of our result with the literature value.

King plot of the strontium isotope shifts

Figure 4. (Color online). King plot of the strontium isotope shifts in α\alpha (689 nm) and β\beta (698 nm) transitions as reported in [12, 55]. The implication of the mass value of 84Sr{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr} from this work compared to values adopted from AME2020 [50, 28] can be observed. Black data points and their accompanying error bars in black are obtained using the literature mass values, while the red data point with error bars is obtained with the new mass value from this work. Error bars and the difference between the 84Sr{}^{84}\mathrm{Sr}-88Sr{}^{88}\mathrm{Sr} points derived from our measurement and from [12, 55, 50, 28] are not visible at the scale being used due to a good agreement of this work with the AME2020. Linear fits were conducted for the set with literature data (black) and the new mass value (red), with a zoomed-in inset demonstrating a rather small change in the linear fit and no significant change in nonlinearity.

A linear orthogonal distance regression analysis [58] that provides unified standard error estimates for the uncertainties implanted in xx and yy directions, was conducted to determine the slope and intercept. The resulting slope and intercept from the fit to the AME2020 mass values and the updated mass value are 0.98148(51) and 8578(326) MHz·amu, respectively. Our results align well with the fitting values of 0.981(5) and 8560(3450) MHz·amu, reported in [12], offering smaller uncertainties. These results confirm the nonlinearity announced in [12], using the nonlinearity measure defined in [3, 8]. The uncertainty from the mass values now allows for potential future precision measurements of atomic transitions using optical spectroscopy to reach a relative precision by more than three orders of magnitude, thus potentially leading to an unprecedented sensitivity for new physics. This will achieve the spectroscopic precision necessary to attain new limits on a spin-independent fifth force interaction, as current calculations place the required uncertainty at <1< 1 Hz [59, 8]. Such experiments require a measurement of the optical atomic transitions with a relative precision of 10−1510^{-15} or lower, a challenging requirement feasible currently at a few optical clock laboratories [59].

Conclusion and outlook

In summary, we have performed direct high-precision mass and double-beta decay QQ value measurements of 84^{84}Sr using the PI-ICR technique with the JYFLTRAP double PTMS. The newly refined mass and QQ values for 84^{84}Sr were in agreement with the adopted values in AME2020, while a precision approximately 30 times higher than those adopted in AME2020 were achieved. The new mass value was utilized to conduct an updated King plot analysis for transitions at 689 nm and 698 nm for 84,86,87^{84,86,87}Sr in relation to 88^{88}Sr. Our results reveal a nonlinear King plot, consistent with prior research and featuring reduced uncertainties. The current contribution of the mass uncertainty to the King plot analysis enables future precision enhancements by several orders of magnitude in optical spectroscopy, mitigating statistical and systematic errors in both transitions. This potential advancement in both transitions could lead to unparalleled sensitivity to new physics. More precise isotope shift measurements of Sr isotopes, providing stringent experimental constraints on King linearity, are highly required. Performing such a measurement with a radioactive isotope, e.g., 90^{90}Sr, to avoid complications due to hyperfine structure, is feasible at the IGISOL facility. In conjunction with additional measurements of isotope shifts in elements such as calcium, this will contribute to testing the predictions from atomic theory and imposing constraints on new physics.

We acknowledge the staff of the Accelerator Laboratory of University of Jyväskylä (JYFL-ACCLAB) for providing stable online beam. We thank the support by the Academy of Finland under the Finnish Centre of Excellence Programme 2012-2017 (Nuclear and Accelerator Based Physics Research at JYFL) and projects No. 306980, No. 312544, No. 275389, No. 284516, No. 295207, No. 314733, No. 315179, No. 327629, No. 320062, No. 354589 and 345869. The support by the EU Horizon 2020 research and innovation program under grant No. 771036 (ERC CoG MAIDEN) is acknowledged. We express gratitude for the productive results stemming from conversations with R. de Groote and X. F. Yang.

References

  1. [1]W. H. King. Isotope Shifts in Atomic Spectra. Plenum, New York, 1984.DOI
  2. [2]Michail Athanasis-Kaklamanakis, Shane G. Wilkins, Alexander A. Breier, and Gerda Neyens. King-plot analysis of isotope shifts in simple diatomic molecules. Phys. Rev. X, 13:101105, Feb 2023.
  3. [3]V. V. Flambaum, A. J. Geddes, and A. V. Viatkina. Isotope shift, nonlinearity of king plots, and the search for new particles. Phys. Rev. A, 97:032510, Mar 2018.DOI
  4. [4]U. Dammalapati, S. De, K. Jungmann, et al. Isotope shifts of ⁶⁵S3d3-6s6p1p1 transitions in neutral barium. Eur. Phys. J. D, 53:1–8, 2009.
  5. [5]C. Shi, F. Gebert, C. Gorges, et al. Unexpectedly large difference of the electron density at the nucleus in the fine-structure doublet of ca. Appl. Phys. B, 123:2, 2017.
  6. [6]C. Nazé, J. G. Li, and M. Godefroid. Theoretical isotope shifts in neutral barium. Phys. Rev. A, 91:032511, Mar 2015.DOI
  7. [7]Claudia Fruguiele, Elina Fuchs, Gilad Perez, and Matthias Schlaffer. Constraining new physics models with isotope shift spectroscopy. Phys. Rev. D, 96:015011, Jul 2017.
  8. [8]Julian C. Berengut, Dmitry Budker, Cédric Delaunay, Victor V. Flambaum, Claudia Fruguiele, Elina Fuchs, Christophe Grojean, Roni Harnik, Roee Ozeri, Gilad Perez, and Yotam Soreq. Probing new long-range interactions by isotope shift spectroscopy. Phys. Rev. Lett., 120:091801, Feb 2018.
  9. [9]V. V. Flambaum, A. J. Geddes, and A. V. Viatkina. Isotope shift, nonlinearity of king plots, and the search for new particles. Phys. Rev. A, 97:032510, Mar 2018.DOI
  10. [10]P. Munro-Laylim, V. A. Dzuba, and V. V. Flambaum. Nuclear polarization and the contributions of relativistic effects to king plot nonlinearity. Phys. Rev. A, 105:042814, Apr 2022.
  11. [11]V. V. Flambaum, I. B. Samsonov, H. B. Tran Tan, and A. V. Viatkina. Nuclear polarization effects in atoms and ions. Phys. Rev. A, 103:032811, Mar 2021.DOI
  12. [12]Hirokazu Miyake, Neal C. Pisenti, Peter K. Elgee, Ananya Sitaram, and Gretchen K. Campbell. Isotope-shift spectroscopy of the ¹S₀ → ³P₁ and ¹S₀ → ³P₀ transitions in strontium. Phys. Rev. Res., 1:033119, Nov 2019.
  13. [13]Tom Manovitz, Ravid Shaniv, Yotam Shapira, Roee Ozeri, and Nitzan Akerman. Precision measurement of atomic isotope shifts using a two-isotope entangled state. Phys. Rev. Lett., 123:203001, Nov 2019.DOI
  14. [14]Felix W. Knollmann, Ashay N. Patel, and S. Charles Doret. Part-per-billion measurement of the ⁴²S₁/₂ → ³²D₅/₂ electric-quadrupole-transition isotope shifts between ⁴²,⁴⁴,⁴⁸Ca⁺ and ⁴⁰Ca⁺. Phys. Rev. A, 100:022514, Aug 2019.
  15. [15]Ian Counts, Joonseok Hur, Diana P. L. Aude Craik, Honggi Jeon, Calvin Leung, Julian C. Berengut, Amy Geddes, Akio Kawasaki, Wonho Jhe, and Vladan Vuletić. Evidence for nonlinear isotope shift in yb⁺ search for new boson. Phys. Rev. Lett., 125:123002, Sep 2020.DOI
  16. [16]Cyrille Solaro, Steffen Meyer, Karin Fisher, Julian C. Berengut, Elina Fuchs, and Michael Drewsen. Improved isotope-shift-based bounds on bosons beyond the standard model through measurements of the ²D₃/₂ − ²D₅/₂ interval in ca⁺. Phys. Rev. Lett., 125:123003, Sep 2020.DOI
  17. [17]D.A. Nesterenko, R.P. de Groot, T. Eronen, Z. Ge, M. Hukkanen, A. Jokinen, and A. Kankainen. High-precision mass measurement of 168Yb for verification of nonlinear isotope shift. International Journal of Mass Spectrometry, 458:116435, 2020.
  18. [18]Ian Counts, Joonseok Hur, Diana P. L. Aude Craik, Honggi Jeon, Calvin Leung, Julian C. Berengut, Amy Geddes, Akio Kawasaki, Wonho Jhe, and Vladan Vuletić. Evidence for nonlinear isotope shift in yb⁺ search for new boson. Phys. Rev. Lett., 125:123002, Sep 2020.DOI
  19. [19]Nils-Holger Rehbehn, Michael K. Rosner, Hendrik Bekker, Julian C. Berengut, Piet O. Schmidt, Steven A. King, Peter Micke, Ming Feng Gu, Robert Müller, Andrey Surzhykov, and José R. Crespo López-Urrutia. Sensitivity to new physics of isotope-shift studies using the coronal lines of highly charged calcium ions. Phys. Rev. A, 103:L040801, Apr 2021.
  20. [20]Robert A. Müller, Vladimir A. Yerokhin, Anton N. Artemyev, and Andrey Surzhykov. Nonlinearities of king’s plot and their dependence on nuclear radii. Phys. Rev. A, 104:L020802, Aug 2021.DOI
  21. [21]Joonseok Hur, Diana P. L. Aude Craik, Ian Counts, Eugene Knyazev, Luke Caldwell, Calvin Leung, Swadha Pandey, Julian C. Berengut, Amy Geddes, Witold Nazarewicz, Paul-Gerhard Reinhard, Akio Kawasaki, Honggi Jeon, Wonho Jhe, and Vladan Vuletić. Evidence of two-source king plot nonlinearity in spectroscopic search for new boson. Phys. Rev. Lett., 128:163201, Apr 2022.DOI
  22. [22]N. L. Figueroa, J. C. Berengut, V. A. Dzuba, V. V. Flambaum, D. Budker, and D. Antypas. Precision determination of isotope shifts in ytterbium and implications for new physics. Phys. Rev. Lett., 128:073001, Feb 2022.DOI
  23. [23]Koki Ono, Yugo Saito, Taiki Ishiyama, Toshiya Higomoto, Tetsushi Takano, Yosuke Takasu, Yasuhiro Yamamoto, Minoru Tanaka, and Yoshiro Takahashi. Observation of non-linearity of generalized king plot in the search for new boson. Phys. Rev. X, 12:021033, May 2022.DOI
  24. [24]Cédric Delaunay, Roee Ozeri, Gilad Perez, and Yotam Soreq. Probing atomic higgs-like forces at the precision frontier. Phys. Rev. D, 96:093001, Nov 2017.DOI
  25. [25]S. Stellmer, F. Schreck, and T. C. Killian. Annual review of cold atoms and molecules. In K. W. Madison, K. Bongs, L. D. Carr, A. M. Rey, and H. Zhai, editors, Annual Review of Cold Atoms and Molecules, volume 2, Singapore, 2014. World Scientific.
  26. [26]Julian C. Berengut, Cédric Delaunay, Amy Geddes, and Yotam Soreq. Generalized king linearity and new physics searches with isotope shifts. Phys. Rev. Res., 2:043444, Dec 2020.DOI
  27. [27]Raman Rana, Martin Höcker, and Edmund G. Myers. Atomic masses of strontium and ytterbium. Phys. Rev. A, 86:050502, Nov 2012.DOI
  28. [28]Meng Wang, W.J. Huang, F.G. Kondev, G. Audi, and S. Naimi. The AME 2020 atomic mass evaluation (II). tables, graphs and references*. Chinese Physics C, 45(3):030003, mar 2021.
  29. [29]F.G. Kondev, M. Wang, W.J. Huang, S. Naimi, and G. Audi. The NUBASE2020 evaluation of nuclear physics properties. Chinese Physics C, 45(3):030001, mar 2021.DOI
  30. [30]T. Eronen, V. S. Kolhinen, V. V. Elomaa, D. Gorelov, U. Hager, J. Hakala, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, P. Karvonen, S. Kopecky, I. D. Moore, H. Penttilä, S. Rahaman, S. Rinta-Antila, J. Rissanen, A. Saastamoinen, J. Szerypo, C. Weber, and J. Äystö. JFLTRAP: A Penning trap for precision mass spectroscopy and isobaric purification. European Physical Journal A, 48(4):1–21, apr 2012.
  31. [31]Tommi Eronen, Anu Kankainen, and Juha Äystö. Ion traps in nuclear physics—Recent results and achievements. Progress in Particle and Nuclear Physics, 91:259–293, nov 2016.DOI
  32. [32]I. D. Moore, T. Eronen, D. Gorelov, J. Hakala, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, V. S. Kolhinen, J. Koponen, H. Penttilä, I. Pohjalainen, M. Reponen, J. Rissanen, A. Saastamoinen, S. Rinta-Antila, V. Sonnenschein, and J. Äystö. Towards commissioning the new ISOLTRAP facility. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, Section B: 33. M. Vilén, L. Canete, B. Cheal, A. Giat­zoglou, R. de Groote, A. de Roubin, T. Eronen, S. Geldhof, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, I. D. Moore, D. A. Nesterenko, H. Penttilä, I. Pohjalainen, M. Reponen, and S. Rinta-Antila. A new off-line ion source facility at IGISOL. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms, 463(April 2019):382–383, 2020.
  33. [34]P. Karvonen, I. D. Moore, T. Sonoda, T. Kessler, H. Penttilä, K. Peräjärvi, P. Ronkanen, and J. Äystö. A sextupole ion beam guide to improve the efficiency and beam quality at IGISOL. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, Section B: Beam Interactions with Materials and Atoms, 266(21):4794–4807, nov 2008.
  34. [35]A. Nieminen, J. Huikari, A. Jokinen, J. Äystö, P. Campbell, and E. C.A. Cochrane. Beam cooler for low-energy radioactive ions. Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research, Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 469(2):244–253, aug 2001.
  35. [36]G. Savard, St Becker, G. Bollen, H. J. Kluge, R. B. Moore, Th Otto, L. Schweikhard, H. Stolzenberg, and U. Wiess. A new cooling technique for heavy ions in a Penning trap. Physics Letters A, 158(5):247–252, sep 1991.DOI
  36. [37]T. Eronen, V. V. Elomaa, U. Hager, J. Hakala, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, S. Rahaman, J. Rissanen, C. Weber, and J. Äystö. JYFLTRAP: Mass spectrometry and isomerically clean beams. Acta Physica Polonica B, 39(2):445–455, 2008.
  37. [38]D. A. Nesterenko, T. Eronen, A. Kankainen, L. Canete, A. Jokinen, I. D. Moore, H. Penttilä, S. Rinta-Antila, A. de Roubin, and M. Vilen. Phase-Imaging Ion-Cyclotron-Resonance technique at the JYFLTRAP double Penning trap mass spectrometer. European Physical Journal A, 54(9):0–13, sep 2018.DOI
  38. [39]D. A. Nesterenko, T. Eronen, Z. Ge, A. Kankainen, and M. Vilen. Study of radial motion phase advance during motion excitations in a penning trap and accuracy of jyfltrap mass spectrometer. Eur. J. A, 57:302, 2021.DOI
  39. [40]S. Eliseev, K. Blaum, M. Block, A. Dörr, C. Droese, T. Eronen, M. Goncharov, M. Höcker, J. Ketter, E.Minaya Minaya Ramirez, D. A. Nesterenko, Yu.N. N. Novikov, and L. Schweikhard. A phase-imaging technique for cyclotron-frequency measurements. Applied Physics B: Lasers and Optics, 114(1-2):107–128, 2014.DOI
  40. [41]S. Eliseev, K. Blaum, M. Block, C. Droese, M. Goncharov, E. Minaya Ramirez, D. A. Nesterenko, Yu N. Novikov, and L. Schweikhard. Phase-imaging ion-cyclotron-resonance measurements for short-lived nuclides. Physical Review Letters, 110(8):82501, feb 2013.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/23473137
  41. [42]A. Kramida, Yu. Ralchenko, J. Reader, and and NIST ASD Team. NIST Atomic Spectra Database (ver. 5.8), [Online]. Available: https://physics.nist.gov/asd [2021, January 19]. National Institute of Standards and Technology, Gaithersburg, MD., 2020.
  42. [43]D. A. Nesterenko, R. P. de Groote, T. Eronen, Z. Ge, M. Hukkanen, A. Jokinen, and A. Kankainen. High-precision mass measurement of 168Yb for verification of nonlinear isotope shift. International Journal of Mass Spectrometry, 458:1–4, 2020.DOI
  43. [44]Z. Ge, T. Eronen, A. de Roubin, D. A. Nesterenko, M. Hukkanen, O. Beliuskina, R. de Groote, S. Geldhof, W. Gins, A. Kankainen, Á. Koszorús, J. Kotila, J. Kosten­salo, I. D. Moore, A. Raggio, S. Rinta-Antila, J. Suhonen, V. Virtanen, A. P. Weaver, A. Zadvornaya, and A. Jokinen. Direct measurement of the mass difference of 72As-72Ge rules out 72As as a promising β-decay candidate to determine the neutrino mass. Phys. Rev. C, 103:065502, Jun 2021.
  44. [45]A. Kellerbauer, K. Blaum, G. Bollen, F. Herfurth, H. J. Kluge, M. Kuckein, E. Sauvan, C. Scheidenberger, and L. Schweikhard. From direct to absolute mass measurements: A study of the accuracy of ISOLTRAP. European Physical Journal D, 22(1):53–64, jan 2003.DOI
  45. [46]Christian Roux, Klaus Blaum, Michael Block, Christian Droese, Sergey Eliseev, Mikhail Goncharov, Frank Herfurth, Enrique Minaya Ramirez, Dmitry Alexan­drovich Nesterenko, Yuri Nikolaevich Novikov, and Lutz Schweikhard. Data analysis of Q-value measurements for double-electron capture with SHIPTRAP. The European Physical Journal D, 67(7):1–9, 2013.DOI
  46. [47]Raymond T. Birge. The calculation of errors by the method of least squares. Physical Review, 40(2):207–227, apr 1932.DOI
  47. [48]D. A. Nesterenko, L. Jokiniemi, J. Kotila, A. Kankainen, Z. Ge, T. Eronen, S. Rinta-Antila, and J. Suhonen. High-precision q-value measurement and nuclear matrix element calculations for the double-β decay of 98Mo. The European Physical Journal A, 58(3):44, 2022.
  48. [49]M. Ramalho, Z. Ge, T. Eronen, D. A. Nesterenko, J. Jaatinen, A. Jokinen, A. Kankainen, J. Kostensalo, J. Kotila, M. I. Krivoruchenko, J. Suhonen, K. S. Tyrin, and V. Virtanen. Observation of an ultralow-q-value electron-capture channel decaying to 75As via a high-precision mass measurement. Phys. Rev. C, 106:015501, Jul 2022.DOI
  49. [50]W.J. Huang, Meng Wang, F.G. Kondev, G. Audi, and S. Naimi. The AME 2020 atomic mass evaluation (I). evaluation of input data, and adjustment procedures*. Chinese Physics C, 45(3):030002, mar 2021.DOI
  50. [51]A. Kellerbauer, G. Audi, D. Beck, K. Blaum, G. Bollen, C. Güenaut, F. Herfurth, A. Herlert, H.-J. Kluge, D. Lunney, S. Schwarz, L. Schweikhard, C. Weber, and C. Yazid­jian. High-precision masses of neutron-deficient rubidium isotopes using a penning trap mass spectrometer. Phys. Rev. C, 76:045504, Oct 2007.DOI
  51. [52]E. Haettner, D. Ackermann, G. Audi, K. Blaum, M. Block, S. Eliseev, T. Fleckenstein, F. Herfurth, F. P. Heßberger, S. Hofmann, J. Ketelaer, J. Ketter, H.-J. Kluge, G. Marx, M. Mazzocco, Yu. N. Novikov, W. R. Plaß, S. Rahaman, T. Rauscher, D. Rodríguez, H. Schatz, C. Scheidenberger, L. Schweikhard, B. Sun, P. G. Thirolf, G. Vorobjev, M. Wang, and C. Weber. Mass measurements of very neutron-deficient mo and tc isotopes and their impact on rp process nucleosynthesis. Phys. Rev. Lett., 106:122501, Mar 2011.DOI
  52. [53]H.M.W. Booij, E.A. Van Hoek, H. Van Der Molen, W.F. Slot, and J. Blok. Shapes of the non-unique and unique first-forbidden β-spectra of ⁸⁴Rb, ⁷⁴As and ¹²⁴I. Nuclear Physics A, 160(2):337–350, 1971.DOI
  53. [54]J.M. Morton, W.G. Davies, W. Mclatchie, Darcey W., and J.E. Kitching. The level structures of ⁸⁵, ⁸⁷Sr from (d, p) reactions. Nuclear Physics A, 161(1):228–240, 1971.DOI
  54. [55]Tetsushi Takano, Ray Mizushima, and Hidetoshi Katori. Precise determination of the isotope shift of ⁸⁸Sr–⁸⁷Sr optical lattice clock by sharing perturbations. Applied Physics Express, 10(7):072801, jun 2017.DOI
  55. [56]W. H. King. Comments on the article “peculiarities of the isotope shift in the samarium spectrum”. J. Opt. Soc. Am., 53(5):638–639, May 1963.DOI
  56. [57]A. V. Viatkina, V. A. Yerokhin, and A. Surzhykov. Calculation of isotope shifts and king-plot nonlinearities in ca⁺. Phys. Rev. A, 108:022802, Aug 2023.DOI
  57. [58]Derek York, Norman M. Evensen, Margarita López Martinez, and Jonás De Basabe Delgado. Unified equations for the slope, intercept, and standard errors of the best straight line. American Journal of Physics, 72:367–375, 03 2004.DOI
  58. [59]Andrew D. Ludlow, Martin M. Boyd, Jun Ye, E. Peik, and P. O. Schmidt. Optical atomic clocks. Rev. Mod. Phys., 87:637–701, Jun 2015.arxiv.org/abs/1407.3493

Paper details

vlnc:W_9brq4gsq
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents