betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

The Highly Disordered Zintl Phase Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 – New Example of a p-type Semiconductor with Remarkable Thermoelectric Properties

Abstract

Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 is a new Zintl phase with a large unit cell volume (~2500 Å3) and a very complex, disordered structure, which can drive the realization of ultralow thermal conductivity in this material. The measured Seebeck coefficient, αα, for single-crystalline Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 approaches 350 μμV/K at 600 K. The experimentally determined electrical resistivity of Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 is very low, leading to a remarkably high-power factor PF of 23.2 μμW/cm.K2^2 at 460 K. The extraordinary PF value in this material, higher than those of the currently known state-of-the-art materials within the same temperature range, suggests that the Ca10_{10}RECdSb9_9 material system (RE = rare earth metal) could serve as a viable playground to harnessing new efficient thermoelectric generators.

Introduction

The onerous task of mitigating the devastating effects of global warming on our planet lies in the ability to significantly cut down the amount of greenhouse gasses emitted from burning fossil fuels and channel a pathway to cleaner energy sources. In this wise, thermoelectric materials that provide for the conversion of waste energy in the form of heat back to reusable energy find relevance. Such a material does not only provide a sustainable source of clean energy but also helps to meet up with the ever-increasing global energy demands. In recent years, several areas of applications of thermoelectric materials such as automobiles, electronic devices, deep space probes, etc., are already being explored. Owing to the useful technological applications of these materials, many research endeavors are thus now focused on identifying suitable candidate materials and developing several techniques and tools to optimize the performance of the few known ones[1, 2, 3].

In our day-to-day life, expressions such as disorderly conduct and complex behavior are often considered negative and generally disadvantageous. The human mind is generally attuned to a good and smooth life, while the converse is never desirable. However, it turns out that certain physical and chemical systems ride on the prevalence of these seemingly undesirable conditions to give rise to novel properties of interest[4]. Such is the scenario in frustrated magnetic systems[5, 6], where the frustration of the magnetic spins produces competing interactions that cannot be simultaneously satisfied and can thus birth exotic states of matter at sufficiently low temperatures. Similarly, the presence of intricate atomic bonding and highly complex structural motifs have been found to be beneficial in achieving enhanced thermoelectric performance in candidate materials[7, 8, 9]. Here, the complex nature of the crystal structure acts as effective phonon scattering centers, thus leading to very low thermal conductivity, which in combination with high Seebeck coefficient and electrical conductivity can achieve an optimal thermoelectric figure of merit, zT=α2σκe+κlzT = \frac{\alpha^{2}\sigma}{\kappa_{\mathrm{e}} + \kappa_{\mathrm{l}}} at a given operating temperature TT, where α\alpha, σ\sigma, κe\kappa_{\mathrm{e}} and κl\kappa_{\mathrm{l}} are the Seebeck coefficient, electrical conductivity, electronic thermal conductivity, and lattice thermal conductivity, respectively.

Zintl phases that combine the features of narrow bandgap, complex atomic bonding, and highly disordered atomic sites are promising candidates to explore for new thermoelectric materials[7]. As demonstrated in several earlier reports[10, 11], Zintl phases present the relevant electronic and transport environments that favor excellent thermoelectric performance. In the recent past, some members of the Ca11InSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{11}\mathrm{In}\mathrm{Sb}_{9} structural series (“11–1–9” compounds)[12], such as Yb11TrSb9\mathrm{Yb}_{11}\mathrm{Tr}\mathrm{Sb}_{9} (Tr=Tr = Ga, In)[13, 14, 15] have been reported and studied for possible thermoelectric applications. These phases feature low κl∼0.6\kappa_l \sim0.6 W/m·K near 1000 K, as well as a small magnitude of α\alpha. The small magnitude of α\alpha here is thought to be associated with the disadvantageous compensated carrier-type present in both materials. Although the low κl\kappa_l observed is most desirable, appropriate doping that will favor a particular dominant carrier concentration is necessary to enhance both phases’ thermoelectric properties.

Subsequently, Wang et al.[16] reported on the Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_9 and Yb10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Yb}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_9, thereafter referred to as the “10–1–1–9” phases, being structural variants of the “11–1–9” family of compounds. The “10–1–1–9” phases crystallize in the centrosymmetric space group of Ibam\mathit{Ibam} (No. 72), different from the non-centrosymmetric space group of Iba2\mathit{Iba2} (No. 45) of the typical compounds with the Ca11InSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{11}\mathrm{In}\mathrm{Sb}_9 structure type[12]. The initial study on Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_9 and Yb10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Yb}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_9 communicates an idea of doping studies that may be beneficial for tuning the nature of the dominant charge carriers and concentrations. Such studies also come with an additional thermoelectric flavor of further reduction in κl\kappa_l. True to this fact, an ultra-low κl∼0.29\kappa_l \sim0.29 W/m·K is reported in Yb10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Yb}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_9 at 875 K. Albeit, similar to the Yb11GaSb9\mathrm{Yb}_{11}\mathrm{Ga}\mathrm{Sb}_9 and Yb11InSb9\mathrm{Yb}_{11}\mathrm{In}\mathrm{Sb}_9 phases, the “10–1–1–9” materials reported by Wang et al.[16] also manifest a small magnitude of α\alpha, thereby placing a constraint on the magnitude of their zTzT. Keynotes from these studies are the available window of opportunity to achieve a low κl\kappa_l as well as their high-temperature stability, which are desired for high-temperature thermoelectric generators. A recent report on related “10–1–9” materials with the simplified formulae Ca10MSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}M\mathrm{Sb}_9 (M=Mn,Zn,Ga,InM = \mathrm{Mn}, \mathrm{Zn}, \mathrm{Ga}, \mathrm{In})[9] have shown heavy structural disorder in them, and a concomitant feature of ultralow κl\kappa_l and enhanced Seebeck coefficient. These works further demonstrate the role of disorder in achieving much-improved thermoelectric zTzT.

Here, we push the experimental boundaries forward and present new results on efforts geared towards enhancing thermoelectric performance in the “10–1–1–9” phases. We report the thermoelectric properties of the Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{Gd}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_9 and Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_9 Zintl phases. While the crystal structure of Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_9 is known[16], that of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{Gd}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_9 is presented for the first time. We demonstrate the promising thermoelectric properties resident in these phases and their potentials for use as efficient thermoelectric generators.

Experimental

Synthesis

The elements were used as purchased from Sigma-Aldrich and Alfa-Aesar with typical purity of ≥99.9\ge99.9 wt.%. Single crystals of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{Gd}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_{9} and Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_{9} were synthesized serendipitously via a Sn-flux reaction designed to synthesize the yet unknown Ca9−xRExCd4Sb9\mathrm{Ca}_{9-x}\mathrm{RE}_{x}\mathrm{Cd}_{4}\mathrm{Sb}_{9} (RERE = rare earth metal; x≈1x \approx1) phases, which were conceived as analogs of the previously published Ca9−xRExMn4Sb9\mathrm{Ca}_{9-x}\mathrm{RE}_{x}\mathrm{Mn}_{4}\mathrm{Sb}_{9} (RERE = rare earth metal; x≈1x \approx1)[17]. The synthesis procedure involves weighing the elements Ca:Gd:Cd:Sb:Sn in the 8:1:4:9:23 ratio, respectively, inside an Ar-filled glovebox. The elemental mixtures were loaded into alumina crucibles and encased in a fused silica ampoules packed between two balls of quartz wool. The ampoules were subsequently evacuated and flame-sealed under a vacuum. The ampoules were then transferred into muffle furnaces (while kept in an upright manner), heated first to 773 K at the rate of 100 K h−1^{-1} and kept for 6 h. This was followed by heating to 1223 K and homogenization at this temperature for 96 h. Then, slowly lowered the temperature to 873 K at the rate of 5 K h−1^{-1} after which the fused-silica tubes were quickly removed from the furnace, flipped, and spun in a centrifuge at high speed to remove excess molten Sn. The tubes were then taken to the Ar-filled glove box to extract the crystals. The products of these reactions were typically multiphase; in the case of Gd, the mixture of several phases included Ca2CdSb2\mathrm{Ca}_{2}\mathrm{CdSb}_{2}[18], Ca14−xGdxCdSb11\mathrm{Ca}_{14-x}\mathrm{Gd}_{x}\mathrm{CdSb}_{11} (x≈1x \approx1)[19] and the title phase Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{Gd}\mathrm{CdSb}_{9}. The crystals obtained from such reaction were only of micron sizes and therefore only suitable for structural elucidation based on single crystal data.

Further attempts aimed at synthesizing the original targeted phase of Ca9−xRExCd4Sb9\mathrm{Ca}_{9-x}\mathrm{RE}_{x}\mathrm{Cd}_{4}\mathrm{Sb}_{9} (RERE = rare earth metal; x≈1x \approx1) involved loading starting elements Ca:RE:Cd:Sb:Sn as during previous experiments following the elemental 8:1:12:9:70 ratio (notice the excess Cd). These reactions too did not produce the target phases. The only reactions where this approach succeeded, so far, were with RERE = La (5–7 mm single crystals of Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{CdSb}_{9}), and RERE = Gd (~1 mm single crystals of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}. We note that a slight modification to the reaction profile which involves a slower cooling rate of 2 K h−1^{-1} from 1223 K to 873 K yield larger crystals (2–3 mm) of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}. All reported structural work and property measurements presented here were conducted on such flux grown crystals. Experiments under different metal fluxes, as well as attempts to make Ca10RECdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}RE\mathrm{CdSb}_{9} by direct fusion of the respective elements were also done, but it is noted these efforts were not successful to date, and that future results from the ongoing work will be published elsewhere.

Powder X-Ray diffraction

Powder X-ray diffraction (PXRD) measurements were conducted at room temperature on a Rigaku Miniflex diffractometer (filtered Cu Kα\alpha radiation, λ=1.5418\lambda= 1.5418 Å), operated inside a nitrogen-filled glovebox. Small portions of the obtained single crystals were ground inside an argon-filled glove box using agate mortars and pestles. Data were collected between 5 and 75° in 2θ2\theta with a step size of 0.05° and 2 s per step counting time. PXRD measurements before and after exposure to air indicate that that both phases are stable in air over a period of up to 3 weeks. The PXRD patterns for Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} and Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} are presented in Figure S1 in supporting information. The powder diffraction patterns for the samples can be matched with the theoretically generated patterns based on the crystal structures elucidated from single-crystal X-ray diffraction methods.

EDS histograms and PXRD patterns of Ca10LaCdSb9 and Ca10GdCdSb9

Figure S1. (a) Representative histogram from the EDS analysis of Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} under high magnification SEM image shown in the inset with compositions comparable to that refined from single crystal data. (b) Powder XRD (PXRD) pattern of Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} together with the calculated pattern based on single crystal XRD structural elucidation. The inset are the single crystals of Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} (c) The EDS analysis of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} with the SEM image shown as inset. (d) PXRD pattern of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} together with the calculated pattern. Single crystals of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} are shown in the inset.

Single-crystal X-Ray diffraction

Single-crystal X-ray diffraction (SCXRD) studies were performed on a Bruker Photon III diffractometer equipped with a Mo Kα\alpha radiation (λ=0.71073\lambda= 0.71073 Å) source. Single crystals prepared by flux reactions were immersed in Paratone-N oil and cut into suitable dimensions. The selected single crystal was placed onto a low-background plastic loop, quickly moved to the goniometer maintained at 200 K for the whole period of data collection. Measurements were carried out in batch runs with a frame width of 0.8° in ω\omega with data collections using a Bruker software. SADABS software was used for multi-scan absorption correction. Structure solution and refinements were carried out using ShelXT[20] and ShelXL[21] (integrated into Olex2[22] graphical user interface), respectively. STRUTURE TIDY[23] software was used to standardize the atomic coordinates. Table 1 gives selected crystallographic parameters. The fractional coordinates of the atoms for Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}, are provided in Table S1; crystallographic parameters for Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9}, which mirror closely those from the earlier investigation,[16] are given in Table S2 and S3 respectively. Selected interatomic distances for both phases are shown in Table S4 and S5 respectively.

refined formulaCa10.43(1)_{10.43(1)}Cd1.25(1)_{1.25(1)}Gd0.59_{0.59}Sb9.01(1)_{9.01(1)}
formula weight1747.57
crystal systemorthorhombic
space groupIbam (No. 72), Z=4Z = 4
aa/Å11.8281(5)
bb/Å12.4315(6)
cc/Å16.7562(8)
VV/Å3^32463.8(2)
ρcalc\rho_{\mathrm{calc}}/g cm−3^{-3}4.71
μ\mu/cm−1^{-1}144.7
R1R_1 (I≥2σII \ge2\sigma_I)a^{a}0.0341
wR2 (I≥2σII \ge2\sigma_I)a^{a}0.0565
R1R_1 (all data)0.0417
wR2_2 (all data)0.0588
Largest difference peak and hole2.59; −2.16

Table 1. Table 1: Selected crystallographic data of Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 measured at 200(2) K with Mo Kα\alpha radiation λ=0.71073\lambda= 0.71073 Å.

AtomWyckoffxxyyzzUeqU_{\mathrm{eq}}
Sb1a16k16k0.15483(14)0.1460(2)0.31139(8)0.0132(4)
Sb2b16k16k0.17147(18)0.1776(3)0.31877(10)0.0138(4)
Sb3c8j8j0.03611(4)0.39128(4)00.0123(2)
Sb48j8j0.13676(4)0.11946(5)00.0168(2)
Sb5d8j8j0.3728(11)0.0295(11)00.023(4)
Sb64b4b1/21/201/41/40.0108(2)
Cd1e8h8h000.11371(7)0.0176(2)
Cd2f4a4a001/41/40.014(10)
Ca1/Gd1g16k16k0.08129(7)0.27333(7)0.15809(5)0.0145(3)
Ca2h16k16k0.2767(18)0.0695(16)0.1676(14)0.009(6)
Ca3/Gd2i16k16k0.31490(9)0.05743(9)0.12939(8)0.0166(4)
Ca4/Gd3j8j8j0.33799(12)0.32707(12)00.0179(5)
Ca5k8h8h000.1747(3)0.016(1)

Table S1. Fractional Atomic Coordinates and Equivalent Isotropic Displacement Parameters (UeqU_{\mathrm{eq}} /Å2^2) Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9. UeqU_{\mathrm{eq}} is defined as 1/3 of the trace of the orthogonalized UijU_{ij} tensor. Site occupancies: aSb1 = 0.598(9); bSb2 = 0.402(8); cSb3 = 0.959(3); dSb5 = 0.044(3); eCd1 = 0.6128; fCd2 = 0.025(4); gCa1/Gd1 = 0.901(2)Ca1 + 0.099Gd1; hCa2 = 0.053(6); iCa3/Gd2 = 0.972(2)Ca3 + 0.028(2)Gd2; jCa4/Gd3 = 0.959(3)Ca4 + 0.041(3)Gd3; kCa5 = 0.403(7)

refined formulaCa9.93(1)Cd1.31(1)La0.78Sb9.01(1)\mathrm{Ca}_{9.93(1)}\mathrm{Cd}_{1.31(1)}\mathrm{La}_{0.78}\mathrm{Sb}_{9.01(1)}
formula weight1751.12
crystal systemorthorhombic
a/A˚a/\mathring{\mathrm{A}}11.873(6)
b/A˚b/\mathring{\mathrm{A}}12.472(6)
c/A˚c/\mathring{\mathrm{A}}16.872(8)
V/A˚3V/\mathring{\mathrm{A}}^{3}2499(2)
ρcalc/g cm−3\rho_{\mathrm{calc}}/\mathrm{g\ cm}^{-3}4.66
μ/cm−1\mu/\mathrm{cm}^{-1}139.9
R1R_{1} (I≥2σII \ge2\sigma_{I})a0.0310
wR2\mathrm{w}R_{2} (I≥2σII \ge2\sigma_{I})a0.0471
R1R_{1} (all data)0.0401
wR2\mathrm{w}R_{2} (all data)0.0488
Largest difference peak and hole1.23; −0.91-0.91

Table S2. Selected crystallographic data of Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} measured at 200(2) K, space group IbamIbam, Z=4Z = 4, Mo Kα\alpha radiation λ=0.71073A˚\lambda= 0.71073\mathring{\mathrm{A}}.

Atom pairsDistance/Å
Sb6\mathrm{Sb}_{6} Ca1\mathrm{Ca}_{1}3.3521(9)×33.3521(9) \times3
Sb6\mathrm{Sb}_{6} Ca3/Gd2\mathrm{Ca}_{3}/\mathrm{Gd}_{2}3.064(1)×43.064(1) \times4
Sb4\mathrm{Sb}_{4} Ca3/Gd2\mathrm{Ca}_{3}/\mathrm{Gd}_{2}3.120(1)×23.120(1) \times2
Sb6\mathrm{Sb}_{6} Ca2\mathrm{Ca}_{2}3.10(2)×43.10(2) \times4
Sb3\mathrm{Sb}_{3} Sb3\mathrm{Sb}_{3}2.835(1)2.835(1)
Sb3\mathrm{Sb}_{3} Ca1/Gd1\mathrm{Ca}_{1}/\mathrm{Gd}_{1}3.0746(9)×23.0746(9) \times2
Sb4\mathrm{Sb}_{4} Cd1\mathrm{Cd}_{1}2.9073(8)×22.9073(8) \times2
Sb4\mathrm{Sb}_{4} Ca1\mathrm{Ca}_{1}3.3327(9)×23.3327(9) \times2
Sb4\mathrm{Sb}_{4} Sb5\mathrm{Sb}_{5}3.01(1)3.01(1)
Sb1\mathrm{Sb}_{1} Cd1\mathrm{Cd}_{1}2.868(2)2.868(2)
Sb1\mathrm{Sb}_{1} Ca1\mathrm{Ca}_{1}3.251(1)3.251(1)
Sb1\mathrm{Sb}_{1} Ca1/Gd1\mathrm{Ca}_{1}/\mathrm{Gd}_{1}3.140(1)3.140(1)
Sb1\mathrm{Sb}_{1} Ca1\mathrm{Ca}_{1}3.318(3)3.318(3)
Sb1\mathrm{Sb}_{1} Ca4\mathrm{Ca}_{4}3.179(2)3.179(2)
Sb1\mathrm{Sb}_{1} Ca3\mathrm{Ca}_{3}3.313(2)3.313(2)
Sb3\mathrm{Sb}_{3} Ca3/Gd2\mathrm{Ca}_{3}/\mathrm{Gd}_{2}3.475(1)×23.475(1) \times2
Sb3\mathrm{Sb}_{3} Ca3/Gd2\mathrm{Ca}_{3}/\mathrm{Gd}_{2}3.457(1)×23.457(1) \times2
Cd1\mathrm{Cd}_{1} Sb2\mathrm{Sb}_{2}3.204(3)×23.204(3) \times2
Cd2\mathrm{Cd}_{2} Sb2\mathrm{Sb}_{2}3.212(4)×43.212(4) \times4
Cd1\mathrm{Cd}_{1} Ca2\mathrm{Ca}_{2}3.50(2)×23.50(2) \times2
Sb2\mathrm{Sb}_{2} Ca4/Gd3\mathrm{Ca}_{4}/\mathrm{Gd}_{3}3.039(2)×23.039(2) \times2
Sb5\mathrm{Sb}_{5} Sb5\mathrm{Sb}_{5}3.10(3)3.10(3)
Sb5\mathrm{Sb}_{5} Ca2\mathrm{Ca}_{2}3.07(3)×23.07(3) \times2
Ca5\mathrm{Ca}_{5} Sb2\mathrm{Sb}_{2}3.000(4)×23.000(4) \times2
Sb4\mathrm{Sb}_{4} Ca4\mathrm{Ca}_{4}3.511(2)3.511(2)
Sb4\mathrm{Sb}_{4} Ca4\mathrm{Ca}_{4}3.596(2)3.596(2)
Sb4\mathrm{Sb}_{4} Ca2\mathrm{Ca}_{2}3.32(2)×23.32(2) \times2

Table S4. Selected distances (Å) for Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}.

CCDC 2162688 and 2162689 contain the full supplementary crystallographic data for the compounds discussed in this paper. CIF files can be obtained free of charge via www.ccdc.cam.ac.uk/data_request/cif, or by emailing [email protected], or by contacting The Cambridge Crystallographic Data Centre, 12 Union Road, Cambridge CB2 1EZ, U.K., fax +44 1223 336033.

Elemental analysis

Analyses were conducted to verify the elemental composition by means of X-ray energy dispersive (EDX) spectrometry. Selected single crystals were mounted on a carbon tape glued to an aluminum holder. The analyses were performed on Auriga 60 Cross Beam Scanning Electron Microscope equipped with Oxford Synergy X-MAX80 electron backscattering diffraction EDX detector. The beam current was 10 μA10\ \mu\mathrm{A} at 20 kV20\ \mathrm{kV} accelerating potential. Data were collected over several spots. See Figure S1 for the EDS results.

Transport properties measurements

Seebeck coefficient measurements were carried out using the integral method, and a constantan wire used as a reference on an SB-100 module MMR Tech. instrument. Appropriate geometry of the sample was mounted on the platform using a high-purity silver conductive paint and interfaced with the probe using the same silver conductive paint. Data were collected for temperatures between 300 and 600 K under high vacuum, with the sample exposed to a limited amount of air throughout the whole process.

High-temperature resistivity was measured within a temperature window of 300–460 K using a H-50 module sourced from MMR Tech. Measurements were made through the four-probe Van der Pauw method on samples utilizing four platinum wires and high-purity silver paint to make contacts. The same temperature variable chamber was used, and a vacuum environment was maintained throughout the experiment.

We also ensured that the various measurements were carried out a couple of times and on different crystals to confirm the reproducibility of the results.

Thermal analysis

Thermogravimetric/differential scanning calorimetry (TG/DSC) experiments were carried out using a TA Instruments SDT Q600. Analysis was conducted on ca. 10–20 mg single-crystalline sample of Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} and Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}, which were loaded into high purity alumina pans and capped with lids. An inert atmosphere was maintained throughout the measurement by a constant flow (100 mL/min) of high-purity argon (Grade 5.0) gas. Following a brief equilibration period at 373 K, the samples were heated to 850 K at the rate of 200 K h−1^{-1}. The TG/DSC results are presented in Figure S2. These results show lack of any thermal events up to a temperature of 850 K, indicating the samples’ stability.

Plots of TG/DSC of $\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}$

Figure S2. Plots of TG/DSC of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}. The weight (wt.%) is represented by a black line while the heat flow (W/g) is represented by a blue line.

Results and discussions

Crystal structure

The “10–1–1–9” structure is a derivative of the known “11–1–9” Ca11InSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{11}\mathrm{InSb}_{9} type structure.[12] At the outset, it should be mentioned that although related to the structure of Ca11InSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{11}\mathrm{InSb}_{9} (space group Iba2; No. 45), Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} crystallizes with the centrosymmetric orthorhombic space group Ibam (No. 72) and the atoms are in an overall different arrangement. The same crystallographic setup has been reported for Yb10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Yb}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} and Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9}.[16] Another important observation with regard to the crystal structure, which ought to be specifically pointed out here, is the fact that Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} and Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9}, although formally isostructural, feature slightly different crystallographic disorder; the chemical bonding in Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} is even more intricate.

The average Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} structure features 13 unique atomic positions—two Ca sites, three mixed Ca/Gd sites, two Cd sites, and six Sb sites as shown in Table 2. Not all of them are fully occupied as some sites are introduced to model the disorder. The polyanionic sub-lattice, as emphasized in Figure 1(a) contains [CdSb4]\left[\mathrm{CdSb}_{4}\right] tetrahedra, diborane-like [Cd2Sb6]\left[\mathrm{Cd}_{2}\mathrm{Sb}_{6}\right] fragments made up of edge-shared [CdSb4]\left[\mathrm{CdSb}_{4}\right] tetrahedra, [Sb2]\left[\mathrm{Sb}_{2}\right]-dimers, and of course, isolated Sb3−\mathrm{Sb}^{3-} anions. The most significant difference between the Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} and Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} structures is the presence of positional disorder involving the terminal Sb atoms from the [Cd2Sb6]\left[\mathrm{Cd}_{2}\mathrm{Sb}_{6}\right] fragments (labeled as Sb1 and Sb2) in the former. Sb1 and Sb2 atoms, which are both occupying 16k16k Wyckoff positions are mutually “exclusive”, meaning that a CdSb4\mathrm{CdSb}_{4} tetrahedron is formed by either two Sb4 and two Sb1 or by two Sb4 and two Sb2 atoms, as shown in Figure 1(b). The additional disorder in Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} may be contributed from the larger size-mismatch between Ca2+\mathrm{Ca}^{2+} and Gd3+\mathrm{Gd}^{3+} (ionic radii 1.12 Å and 1.053 Å, respectively)[24] as compared to Ca2+\mathrm{Ca}^{2+} and La3+\mathrm{La}^{3+} that are very close in size (ionic radii 1.12 Å and 1.16 Å, respectively), and in which case, the polyanionic sub-lattice does not need to compensate for the occupational cation disorder. Figure 1(c) presents the anionic substructure observed in Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} as compared to that of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}.

Crystal structures of disordered Ca10GdCdSb9 and Ca10LaCdSb9

Figure 1. (a) Crystal structure of disordered Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 viewed down the cc-axis showing the Ca/Ga as well as Sb1 and Sb2 sites disorders. (b) The [Cd2_2Sb6_6]14−^{14-} anions in Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9. Selected bond distances are presented in Table S3. (b) The [Cd2_2Sb6_6]14−^{14-} anions found in Ca10_{10}LaCdSb9_9 with disorder free Sb. Some atoms such as Ca and Ca/Gd have been omitted for clarity.

TT (K)α\alpha (µV/K)η\etam∗m^* (mem_e)rHr_H
300175.20.516.841.12
460271.3−0.9915.541.16

Table 2. Selected transport properties of Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 at 300 and 460 K.

The Ca atoms are octahedrally coordinated by Sb atoms, while the three sites co-occupied by Ca/Gd atoms exhibit coordination by six, seven, and eight Sb atoms, respectively, as presented in Figure S3. We therefore note that the observed heavy disorder in Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} will prove to be invaluable in phonon scattering and with an attendant effect of very low and thermal conductivity. In Table S3 selected interatomic distanced are presented.

AtomWyckoffxxyyzzUeqU_{\mathrm{eq}}
Sb1a\mathrm{Sb1}^{\mathrm{a}}16k16k0.1554(3)0.1554(3)0.1466(4)0.1466(4)0.31155(16)0.31155(16)0.0144(5)0.0144(5)
Sb2b\mathrm{Sb2}^{\mathrm{b}}16k16k0.1718(4)0.1718(4)0.1756(7)0.1756(7)0.3185(2)0.3185(2)0.0158(6)0.0158(6)
Sb3c\mathrm{Sb3}^{\mathrm{c}}8j8j0.03608(4)0.03608(4)0.39123(4)0.39123(4)000.01502(14)0.01502(14)
Sb48j8j0.13652(4)0.13652(4)0.11885(4)0.11885(4)000.01792(13)0.01792(13)
Sb5d\mathrm{Sb5}^{\mathrm{d}}8j8j0.3750(19)0.3750(19)0.0270(30)0.0270(30)000.032(10)0.032(10)
Sb64b4b1/21/2001/41/40.0110(14)0.0110(14)
Cd1e\mathrm{Cd1}^{\mathrm{e}}8h8h00000.11583(5)0.11583(5)0.0222(2)0.0222(2)
Cd2f\mathrm{Cd2}^{\mathrm{f}}4a4a1/21/21/21/23/43/40.022(10)0.022(10)
Ca116k16k0.08186(8)0.08186(8)0.27380(8)0.27380(8)0.15879(5)0.15879(5)0.0162(2)0.0162(2)
Ca2/La1g\mathrm{Ca2/La1}^{\mathrm{g}}16k16k0.31343(6)0.31343(6)0.05852(7)0.05852(7)0.13091(5)0.13091(5)0.0198(3)0.0198(3)
Ca3/La2h\mathrm{Ca3/La2}^{\mathrm{h}}8j8j0.33885(9)0.33885(9)0.32802(8)0.32802(8)000.0178(3)0.0178(3)
Ca4i\mathrm{Ca4}^{\mathrm{i}}8h8h00000.1749(3)0.1749(3)0.0222(2)0.0222(2)

Table S3. Fractional Atomic Coordinates and Equivalent Isotropic Displacement Parameters (A˚2\mathring{\mathrm{A}}^2) Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_9. UeqU_{\mathrm{eq}} is defined as 1/31/3 of the trace of the orthogonalized UijU_{ij} tensor. Site occupancies: aSb1=0.617(18)^{\mathrm{a}}\mathrm{Sb1} = 0.617(18); bSb2=0.385(18)^{\mathrm{b}}\mathrm{Sb2} = 0.385(18); cSb3=0.981(2)^{\mathrm{c}}\mathrm{Sb3} = 0.981(2); dSb5=0.020(2)^{\mathrm{d}}\mathrm{Sb5} = 0.020(2); eCd1=0.6453(19)^{\mathrm{e}}\mathrm{Cd1} = 0.6453(19); fCd2=0.024(3)^{\mathrm{f}}\mathrm{Cd2} = 0.024(3); gCa2/La1=0.883(2)Ca2+0.117(2)La1^{\mathrm{g}}\mathrm{Ca2/La1} = 0.883(2)\mathrm{Ca2} + 0.117(2)\mathrm{La1}; hCa3/La2=0.844(3)Ca3+0.156(3)La2^{\mathrm{h}}\mathrm{Ca3/La2} = 0.844(3)\mathrm{Ca3} + 0.156(3)\mathrm{La2}; iCa4=0.3547(19)^{\mathrm{i}}\mathrm{Ca4} = 0.3547(19).

Coordination environment of Ca and Ca/Gd sites of Ca10GdCdSb9

Figure S3. (a) and (b) Coordination environment of Ca and Ca/Gd sites of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}, respectively.

Transport Properties

The temperature dependence of Seebeck coefficient α(T)\alpha(T) of the two phases investigated in the temperature window of 300 to 600 K is presented in Figure 2(a). α(T)\alpha(T) of both phases is positive within the temperature range studied, indicating of a p-type material behavior with dominant hole carriers. α(T)\alpha(T) of Ca10_{10}LaCdSb9_9 at room temperature is only about 16.7 µV/K which is nearly 50% lower than the reported value in Yb10_{10}LaCdSb9_9[16] around the same temperature. However, α(T)\alpha(T) of Ca10_{10}LaCdSb9_9 shows a strong temperature dependence upon heating with an increase in magnitude of a significant factor of ca. 17 between 300 and 600 K, with the value at 600 K being 286.2 µV/K. This value is far higher than even what is recorded for Yb10_{10}LaCdSb9_9 at 1023 K and also superior to those reported in the typical “11–1–9” phases[13] and several others with excellent thermoelectric properties such as Yb21_{21}Mn4_4Sb18_{18} (~290 µV/K at 650 K)[11], YbZn2−x_{2-x}Mnx_xSb2_2(~165 µV/K at 750 K)[25], Yb9_9Mn4.2_{4.2}Sb9_9 (~190 µV/K at 950 K)[26], and Yb14_{14}MnSb11_{11}(~185 µV/K at 1275 K)[27]. Furthermore, α(T)\alpha(T) of Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 presents an even more interesting scenario whereby the value of 175.2 µV/K achieved at room temperature is significantly high and which increases to about 345 µV/K at 600 K. With this observation, it is plausible to infer that the density of states effective masses for both compounds are very high. This notion is further supported by the single parabolic band (SPB) model presented vide infra. It is noted that at 600 K, α(T)\alpha(T) of both phases still shows a strong temperature dependence with no sign of the excitation of the minority carriers or features of mixed conduction. In Yb10_{10}LaCdSb9_9 and Yb11_{11}TrSb9_9 (Tr = Ga, In)[13], features of mixed conduction sets in at elevated temperatures, and it is likely that the title phases too would manifest features of mixed conduction near 1000 K. Regardless, the additional features discussed below strongly supports the realization of excellent thermoelectric properties in these phases.

Temperature dependence of Seebeck coefficient and electrical resistivity

Figure 2. (a) Temperature dependence of Seebeck coefficient α(T)\alpha(T). (b) Temperature dependence of electrical resistivity ρ(T)\rho(T) of Ca10_{10}RECdSb9_9 (RERE = La, Gd).

In Figure 2(b), the temperature dependence of electrical resistivity ρ(T)\rho(T) of both phases are presented in the temperature range of 300 to 460 K. ρ(T)\rho(T) of Ca10_{10}LaCdSb9_9 presented on the right axis decreases upon heating in a semiconducting manner. We note that this feature is in line with the observation in Yb10_{10}LaCdSb9_9[16], albeit the magnitude of ρ(T)\rho(T) in Ca10_{10}LaCdSb9_9 (41.8 mΩ⋅\Omega\cdotcm at 300 K) is about an order of magnitude higher. Although the origin of such a relatively higher value is not immediately apparent, the evolution of ρ(T)\rho(T) in a semiconducting manner can result in significantly high ρ(T)\rho(T) values. Conversely, ρ(T)\rho(T) of Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 shown on the left axis evolves in a metallic manner and features relatively low values that vary from about 2.94 to 3.5 mΩ⋅\Omega\cdotcm at 300 and 460 K, respectively. The metallic nature of ρ(T)\rho(T) and the linear temperature dependence of α(T)\alpha(T) indicate a heavily doped, degenerate p-type semiconducting material that reminiscence several excellent thermoelectric materials. The thermoelectric transport properties of this phase, namely the enhance α(T)\alpha(T) magnitude, relatively low ρ(T)\rho(T) values and the inherent low thermal conductivity, would prove invaluable in achieving an excellent zTzT.

Figure 3 presents results from Hall effect RHR_{\mathrm{H}} measurements on Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 and are further analyzed using the single parabolic band (SPB) model. These results confirm a p-type material and indicate a room temperature value of Hall carrier concentration nH=5.1×1020n_{\mathrm{H}} = 5.1 \times10^{20} cm−3^{-3}, which is calculated from Hall coefficient: RH=1/nHeR_{\mathrm{H}} = 1/n_{\mathrm{H}}e, where ee is the electric charge. The Hall mobility μH\mu_{\mathrm{H}} on the other hand, is calculated from RHR_{\mathrm{H}} and ρ\rho as μH=RH/ρ\mu_{\mathrm{H}} = R_{\mathrm{H}}/\rho. The temperature dependence of nHn_{\mathrm{H}} and μH\mu_{\mathrm{H}} are presented in Figure 3(a) and (b), respectively. nHn_{\mathrm{H}} steadily increases with temperature and attains a value 9.7×1020 cm−39.7 \times10^{20}\ \mathrm{cm}^{-3} at 460 K. μH\mu_{\mathrm{H}} on the other hand, is observed to decrease with an increasing temperature with a relatively small room temperature value of ca. 5.0 cm2/V⋅s5.0\ \mathrm{cm}^{2}/\mathrm{V}\cdot\mathrm{s}, a feature which is a reminiscence of heavily doped semiconductors. A power law models the temperature dependence of μH\mu_{\mathrm{H}}: μH∝T−p\mu_{\mathrm{H}} \propto T^{-p}, within a single scattering limit. The solid line in the plot is the fit to this expression with p<1.5p < 1.5. The small μH\mu_{\mathrm{H}} observed can be associated with the heavy carrier mass near the Fermi level in Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}. We provide additional support to this as follows. nHn_{\mathrm{H}} is related to the chemical carrier concentration nn by:

Plots of Hall concentration, Hall mobility, carrier concentration variation of thermopower, and mobility

Figure 3. (a) The temperature dependence of Hall concentration and (b) Hall mobility. The solid line is a least-square fit to μH∝T−p\mu_{\mathrm{H}} \propto T^{-p}, with p<1.5p < 1.5. (c) Carrier concentration variation of α(T)\alpha(T) based on Pisarenko plot (d) Carrier concentration variation of mobility of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} using the SPB model.

n=rHnH(1)n = r_{\mathrm{H}}n_{\mathrm{H}} \tag*{(1)}

where rHr_{\mathrm{H}} is the Hall factor and it is expressed as[28]:

rH=32F1/2(η)(12+2λ)F2λ−1/2(η)(1+λ)2Fλ2(η)(2)r_{\mathrm{H}} = \frac{3}{2}F_{1/2}(\eta)\frac{\left(\frac{1}{2}+2\lambda\right)F_{2\lambda-1/2}(\eta)}{(1+\lambda){}^{2}F_{\lambda}^{2}(\eta)} \tag*{(2)}

λ\lambda relates to energy dependence of the carrier relaxation time τ\tau: τ=τ0ϵλ−1/2\tau= \tau_{0}\epsilon^{\lambda-1/2}, which determines the scattering exponent. Fj(η)F_j(\eta) is the Fermi integral defined as:

Fj(η)=∫0∞ζj dζ1+e(ζ−η)(3)F_j(\eta) = \int_{0}^{\infty}\frac{\zeta^j\,d\zeta}{1+e^{(\zeta-\eta)}} \tag*{(3)}

where η\eta and ζ\zeta are the reduced electrochemical potentials and reduced carrier energy, respectively. To determine rHr_{\mathrm{H}} from on the above set of equations, one would need to first determine the value of η\eta based on the analysis of the experimentally observed Seebeck coefficient α\alpha according to the equation:

α=±kBe((2+λ)F(1+λ)(η)(1+λ)Fλ(η)−η)(4)\alpha= \pm\frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}}{e}\left(\frac{(2+\lambda)F_{(1+\lambda)}(\eta)}{(1+\lambda)F_{\lambda}(\eta)}-\eta\right) \tag*{(4)}

where kBk_{\mathrm{B}} and ee are the Boltzmann constant and electric charge, respectively. Under the assumption that the charge carriers are limited by acoustic phonons (λ=0\lambda= 0), the thermoelectric properties obtained at room temperature are tabulated in Table 2. Here the magnitude of the calculated effective mass m∗m^{*} at room temperature is ca. 6.84me6.84m_{\mathrm{e}}, where mem_{\mathrm{e}} is the rest mass of an electron, which is significantly high and is in support of the high α(T)\alpha(T) observed at this temperature. It is also noted that m∗m^{*} increases with temperature and achieves a magnitude of 15.54me15.54m_{\mathrm{e}} at 460 K. Such a feature can be associated with the temperature dependence of the bandgap. Also, the observed rHr_{\mathrm{H}} of 1.16 at 460 K is comparable to the value of 1.18 for acoustic phonons scattering mechanism[28].

In Figure 3(c), The Pisarenko plot of α\alpha against nn for m∗=15.54mem^* = 15.54m_e at 460 K assuming an acoustic phonon scattering mechanism in SPB is presented based on the following expression[29]:

n=4π(2m∗kBTh2)3/2F1/2(η)rH,(5)n = 4\pi\left(\frac{2m^* k_B T}{h^2}\right)^{3/2} \frac{F_{1/2}(\eta)}{r_H}, \tag*{(5)}

where hh is the Planck constant. The Pisarenko relation is shown as a dashed line and the experimentally determined α\alpha is also shown. Also based on the same model, μH\mu_H can be written as:

μH=μ0(1/2+2λ)F2λ−1/2(η)(1+λ)Fλ(η),(6)\mu_H = \mu_0 \frac{(1/2 + 2\lambda) F_{2\lambda-1/2}(\eta)}{(1+\lambda) F_{\lambda}(\eta)}, \tag*{(6)}

where μ0\mu_0 relates to τ0\tau_0: μ0=eτ0/m∗\mu_0 = e\tau_0/m^*. A plot of μH\mu_H as a function of nn is shown in Figure 3(d).

–

The nature of the intricate bonding of the constituent atoms in this structure is known to mediate robust phonon scatterings, which can lead to low thermal conductivity κ\kappa. Also, since the title phase is isostructural to Yb10_{10}LaCdSb9_9, with similar structural bonding and unit cell volume, their κ\kappa are expected to be comparable. Figure S4 presents an extrapolated κTot(T)\kappa_{\mathrm{Tot}}(T) data from Yb10_{10}LaCdSb9_9[16] in the temperature range of 300 to 460 K. The data feature low values for the total thermal conductivity κTot\kappa_{\mathrm{Tot}} which varies from the room temperature value of ca. 0.90 to 0.84 W/m·K at 460 K. Also shown in the same panel is the lattice thermal conductivity κLatt\kappa_{\mathrm{Latt}} which is deconfined from κTot\kappa_{\mathrm{Tot}} as κLatt=κTot−κElec\kappa_{\mathrm{Latt}} = \kappa_{\mathrm{Tot}} - \kappa_{\mathrm{Elec}}. Where κElec\kappa_{\mathrm{Elec}} is the electronic contribution to the thermal conductivity, which is given by the Wiedemann-Franz relation[30]:

Temperature dependence of total and lattice thermal conductivity and temperature variation of Lorentz number

Figure S4. (a) Temperature dependence of total and lattice thermal conductivity κ(T)\kappa(T) extrapolated from Yb10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Yb}_{10}\mathrm{La}\mathrm{Cd}\mathrm{Sb}_{9}[16]. (b) Temperature variation of Lorentz number L(T)L(T).

κElec=L0Tρ,(7)\kappa_{\mathrm{Elec}} = \frac{L_0 T}{\rho}, \tag*{(7)}

where L0L_0 is the Lorentz number given by π2kB2/3e2=2.45×10−8 WΩ/K2\pi^2 k_{\mathrm{B}}^2/3e^2 = 2.45 \times10^{-8}\ \mathrm{W}\Omega/\mathrm{K}^2 and ρ\rho is the electrical resistivity of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_9 shown in Figure 2(b). The estimated κLatt\kappa_{\mathrm{Latt}} varies between ca. 0.71 and 0.62 W/m·K at 300 to 460 K, respectively. While the estimation of κLatt\kappa_{\mathrm{Latt}} by the above method may be valid at room temperature, it is unsuitable for certain metallic and degenerate semiconductors where the chemical potential is strongly temperature dependent. Also, the Lorentz number LL is directly proportional to η\eta and for several degenerate semiconductors, they are found to be much smaller than L0L_0 at high temperatures. The Lorentz number LL as a function of η\eta using the SPB model is given as:

L=kB2e2(1+λ)(3+λ)Fλ(η)Fλ+2(η)−(2+λ)2Fλ+1(η)2(1+λ)2Fλ(η).(8)L = \frac{k_{\mathrm{B}}^2}{e^2}\frac{(1+\lambda)(3+\lambda)F_{\lambda}(\eta)F_{\lambda+2}(\eta)-(2+\lambda)^2F_{\lambda+1}(\eta)^2}{(1+\lambda)^2F_{\lambda}(\eta)}. \tag*{(8)}

For a carrier mobility limited by acoustic scattering (λ=0\lambda= 0) and the value of η\eta from the analysis of α(T)\alpha(T), the obtained values of LL are presented in Figure S4. LL decreases with increasing temperature, with values that are much lower than L0L_0 in line with findings in several thermoelectric materials[28, 29].

Thermoelectric efficiency

The temperature dependence of thermoelectric power factor PFPF (=α2/ρ=\alpha^2/\rho) and dimensionless thermoelectric figure of merit zTzT calculated from the experimental results of α(T)\alpha(T), ρ(T)\rho(T) and κ(T)\kappa(T) are presented in Figure 4(a) and Figure S5, respectively. The determined PFPF ranges from 11.1 μW/cm·K2^2 at 300 K to 23.2 μW/cm·K2^2 at 460 K. To put the magnitude of the observed PFPF into perspectives, a plot of PFPF of the title phase Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_9 and those of selected Zintl phases such as Ca10InSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{InSb}_9, Yb10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Yb}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_9[16], Yb14MnSb11\mathrm{Yb}_{14}\mathrm{MnSb}_{11}[27], YbCd2−xZnxSb2\mathrm{YbCd}_{2-x}\mathrm{Zn}_x\mathrm{Sb}_2 (x=0.4x = 0.4)[31], and EuZn2−xCdxSb2\mathrm{EuZn}_{2-x}\mathrm{Cd}_x\mathrm{Sb}_2 ($x =0.1)= 0.1)[32] is presented in Figure 4(b). The magnitude of PFPF of the title phase at 460 K is higher than those of the other phases and with features that suggest a further increase in its value with increasing temperature. These observations along with the putative low thermal conductivity in this phase present an interesting scenario where intricate atomic bonding and a large unit-cell volume conspires with a narrow bandgap in a material to produce remarkable thermoelectric properties. At room temperature, Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} achieves a zTzT of 0.47 and reaches a remarkably high value of 1.73 at 460 K (see Figure S5). Such value is comparable to that of state-of-the-art material PbTe\mathrm{PbTe}[33] with zT>1.5zT > 1.5 at 773 K and much enhanced than Yb14MnSb11\mathrm{Yb}_{14}\mathrm{MnSb}_{11}[27] with a zT∼1zT \sim1 at 1223 K. Although the estimation of zTzT is limited to 300–460 K, the temperature dependence of the various thermoelectric parameters is in favor of a much-enhanced value for T>460T > 460 K. In addition, a theoretical zTzT and PFPF can be calculated based on the SPB model. For such theoretical calculations, the relevant parameters are defined as:

Figure 4. (a) The temperature dependence thermoelectric power factor PFPF of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9}, (b) PFPF of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} together with those of other Zintl phases. The y-axis is presented on a log scale for clarity.

Temperature dependence of dimensionless thermoelectric figure of merit $zT$

Figure S5. Temperature dependence of dimensionless thermoelectric figure of merit zTzT of Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} based on experimental data.

zT=α2L+(ψβ)−1,(9)zT = \frac{\alpha^{2}}{L + (\psi\beta)^{-1}}, \tag*{(9)}

where

ψ=8πe3(2mekBh2)3/2(1+λ)Fλ(η),(10)\psi= \frac{8\pi e}{3}\left(\frac{2m_{e}k_{\mathrm{B}}}{h^{2}}\right)^{3/2}(1+\lambda)F_{\lambda}(\eta), \tag*{(10)}

and

β=μ0(m∗/me)3/2T5/2κLatt.(11)\beta= \frac{\mu_{0}(m^{*}/m_{e})^{3/2}T^{5/2}}{\kappa_{\mathrm{Latt}}}. \tag*{(11)}

The calculated zTzT based on the SPB model in the temperature range of 300 to 460 K is presented in Figure S6. Here zTzT values varies from the room temperature value of ca. 0.41 to a peak value of ca. 0.7 at 380 K. Here, the calculated values clearly underestimate the experimentally observed zTzT. The observed deviation may likely be an indication of the complex band structure in Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} which may be associated with the presence of multiple degenerate bands close to the conduction band edge. In such an instance, the determination of m∗m^{*}, LL and κLatt\kappa_{\mathrm{Latt}} might be prone to errors and consequently impact on the calculated zTzT and optimal nn[34]. Although the theoretical calculation using the SPB model seems to underestimate zTzT and PFPF, such calculation still provide support for the excellent thermoelectric properties in the title compounds and relevant insight into the tuning of nn near the Fermi energy.

Temperature dependence of $zT$ of Ca$_{10}$GdCdSb$_9$ based on the SPB model

Figure S6. Temperature dependence of zTzT of Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 based on the SPB model.

Conclusions

This report presents two highly disordered and complex Zintl phases Ca10RECdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}RE\mathrm{CdSb}_{9} (RE=LaRE = \mathrm{La}, Gd\mathrm{Gd}) with the orthorhombic Ibam space group, which can be harnessed and developed into an efficient material for use in thermoelectric energy generation. These compounds feature large α\alpha (286.2 μV/K\mu\mathrm{V/K} and 345 μV/K\mu\mathrm{V/K} at 600 K for La and Gd phases, respectively) driven by a large density of states effective mass near the Fermi level. ρ(T)\rho(T) of Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9} is semiconducting with relatively large magnitudes, while Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9 is reminiscent of heavily doped semiconductors with low ρ(T)\rho(T) values that translate into large electrical conductivity. In addition, these phases are known to feature low intrinsic κLatt\kappa_{\mathrm{Latt}} (~ 0.71 W/m·K), which is attributed to factors such as their complex atomic bonding and large unit cell volumes which determine the number of phonons states within the first Brillouin zone[35]. The experimentally determined PFPF of 23.2 μ\muW/cm·K2^2 at 460 K is remarkably high.

Theoretical calculations employing the SPB model were further carried out to provide additional perspective into the thermoelectric properties of Ca10_{10}GdCdSb9_9. These calculations gave support to the high density of state effective mass as well as the realization of high zTzT value. Albeit the calculated zTzT and PFPF lags that of the experimentally determined values. We posit that these discrepancies lie in the complex nature of the band structure with multiple degenerate bands close to the conduction band maximum which can result in a non-precise determination of the various transport parameters. Future studies on these materials will benefit from the determination of their electronic band structure, which will require high computational cost considering the nature of the disorder as well the large unit cell volume.

Conflicts of interest

There are no conflicts to declare.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Basic Energy Sciences through grant DE-SC0008885.

The Highly Disordered Zintl Phase Ca10GdCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{GdCdSb}_{9} – New Example of a pp-type Semiconductor with Remarkable Thermoelectric Properties

Michael O. Ogunbunmi; Svilen Bobev

R1=∑∣∣Fo∣−∣Fc∣∣∑∣Fo∣;wR2=[∑[w(Fo2−Fc2)2]∑[w(Fo2)2]]1/2, where w=1[σ2Fo2+(0.0093P)2+(22.2781P)], and P=Fo2+2Fc23.R_{1}=\frac{\sum\left|\left|F_{\mathrm{o}}\right|-\left|F_{\mathrm{c}}\right|\right|}{\sum\left|F_{\mathrm{o}}\right|};\quad\mathrm{w}R_{2}=\left[\frac{\sum\left[\mathrm{w}\left(F_{\mathrm{o}}^{2}-F_{\mathrm{c}}^{2}\right)^{2}\right]}{\sum\left[\mathrm{w}\left(F_{\mathrm{o}}^{2}\right)^{2}\right]}\right]^{1/2},\ \text{where }\mathrm{w}=\frac{1}{\left[\sigma^{2}F_{\mathrm{o}}^{2}+(0.0093P)^{2}+(22.2781P)\right]},\ \text{and }P=\frac{F_{\mathrm{o}}^{2}+2F_{\mathrm{c}}^{2}}{3}.
Atom pairsDistance/Å
Sb6 Ca13.357(1)×43.357(1) \times4
Sb6 Ca2/La23.078(1)×43.078(1) \times4
Sb3 Sb32.845(1)2.845(1)
Sb3 Ca13.101(1)×23.101(1) \times2
Sb3 Ca33.680(2)3.680(2)
Sb3 Ca3/La33.600(2)3.600(2)
Sb3 Ca23.501(1)×23.501(1) \times2
Sb3 Ca2/La23.525(1)×23.525(1) \times2
Sb4 Cd12.940(1)×22.940(1) \times2
Sb4 Ca13.366(2)×43.366(2) \times4
Sb4 Ca33.596(2)3.596(2)
Sb4 Ca33.546(2)3.546(2)
Sb4 Ca23.139(1)×23.139(1) \times2
Sb4 Sb53.06(2)3.06(2)
Sb1 Ca33.196(3)3.196(3)
Sb1 Ca23.318(3)3.318(3)
Sb1 Ca23.744(3)3.744(3)
Sb1 Ca43.473(7)3.473(7)
Cd1 Ca33.479(1)×23.479(1) \times2
Cd1 Ca43.531(5)3.531(5)
Cd1 Sb23.192(8)×43.192(8) \times4
Ca1 Sb23.016(7)3.016(7)
Ca1 Sb23.274(3)3.274(3)
Ca1 Sb23.146(3)3.146(3)
Ca3 Sb23.066(4)×23.066(4) \times2
Ca3 Sb53.55(3)3.55(3)
Ca2/La2 Sb23.428(9)3.428(9)
Ca2 Sb23.477(5)3.477(5)
Ca4 Sb22.996(9)×22.996(9) \times2
Sb2 Cd23.209(9)3.209(9)
Sb5 Sb53.04(5)3.04(5)

Table S5. Selected distances (Å) for Ca10LaCdSb9\mathrm{Ca}_{10}\mathrm{LaCdSb}_{9}.

References

  1. [1]L. Yang, Z. Chen, M. S. Dargusch and J. Zou, Adv. Energy Mater., 2018, 8, 1701797.
  2. [2]X. F. Zheng, C. X. Liu, Y. Y. Yan and Q. Wang, Renew. Sustain. Energy Rev., 2014, 32, 486–503.
  3. [3]T. M. Tritt, Annu. Rev. Mater. Res., 2011, 41, 433–448.
  4. [4]E. Dagotto, Science (80- .), 2005, 309, 257–262.
  5. [5]M. O. Ogunbunmi and A. M. Strydom, Mater. Today Phys., 2021, 21, 100552.
  6. [6]K. Karube, J. S. White, D. Morikawa, C. D. Dewhurst, R. Cubitt, A. Kikkawa, X. Yu, Y. Tokunaga, T. Arima, H. M. Rønnow, Y. Tokura and Y. Taguchi, Sci. Adv., 2018, 4, eaar7043.
  7. [7]G. J. Snyder and E. S. Toberer, Nat. Mater., 2008, 7, 105–114.
  8. [8]M. O. Ogunbunmi, S. Baranets and S. Bobev, Chem. Mater., 2021, 33, 9382–9392.
  9. [9]A. Ovchinnikov, S. Chanakian, A. Zevalkink and S. Bobev, Chem. Mater., 2021, 33, 3172–3186.
  10. [10]H. Tamaki, H. K. Sato and T. Kanno, Adv. Mater., 2016, 28, 10182–10187.
  11. [11]A. He, S. K. Bux, Y. Hu, D. Uhl, L. Li, D. Donadio and S. M. Kauzlarich, Chem. Mater., 2019, 31, 8076–8086.
  12. [12]G. Cordier, H. Schäfer and M. Stelter, Z. Naturforsch. B, 1985, 40, 868–871.
  13. [13]T. Yi, C. A. Cox, E. S. Toberer, G. J. Snyder and S. M. Kauzlarich, Chem. Mater., 2010, 22, 935–941.
  14. [14]S. Bobev, V. Fritsch, J. D. Thompson, J. L. Sarrao, B. Eck, R. Dronkowski and S. M. Kauzlarich, J. Solid State Chem., 2005, 178, 1071–1079.
  15. [15]S.-Q. Xia, J. Hullmann, S. Bobev, A. Ozbay, E. R. Nowak and V. Fritsch, J. Solid State Chem., 2007, 180, 2088–2094.
  16. [16]J. Wang, S.-Q. Xia and X.-T. Tao, Chem. - An Asian J., 2013, 8, 251–257.
  17. [17]Y. Wang and S. Bobev, Chem. Mater., 2018, 30, 3518–3527.
  18. [18]S.-Q. Xia and S. Bobev, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2007, 129, 4049–4057.
  19. [19]S. Baranets, L. Voss, S. Stoyko and S. Bobev, J. Appl. Phys., 2019, 125, 245101.
  20. [20]G. M. Sheldrick, Acta Crystallogr. A, 2015, 71, 3–8.
  21. [21]G. M. Sheldrick, Acta Crystallogr. C, 2015, 71, 3–8.
  22. [22]O. V. Dolomanov, L. J. Bourhis, R. J. Gildea, J. A. K. Howard and H. Puschmann, J. Appl. Crystallogr., 2009, 42, 339–341.
  23. [23]L. M. Gelato and E. Parthé, J. Appl. Crystallogr., 1987, 20, 139–143.
  24. [24]R. D. Shannon, Acta Crystallogr. Sect. A, 1976, 32, 751–767.
  25. [25]C. Yu, T. J. Zhu, S. N. Zhang, X. B. Zhao, J. He, Z. Su and T. M. Tritt, J. Appl. Phys., 2008, 104, 013705.
  26. [26]S. K. Bux, A. Zevalkink, O. Janka, D. Uhl, S. M. Kauzlarich, G. J. Snyder and J.-P. Fleurial, J. Mater. Chem. A, 2014, 2, 215–220.
  27. [27]S. R. Brown, S. M. Kauzlarich, F. Gascoin, and G. J. Snyder, Chem. Mater., 2006, 18, 1873–1877.
  28. [28]A. F. May, E. S. Toberer, A. Saramat and G. J. Snyder, Phys. Rev. B, 2009, 80, 125205.
  29. [29]L.-D. Zhao, S.-H. Lo, J. He, H. Li, K. Biswas, J. Androulakis, C.-I. Wu, T. P. Hogan, D.-Y. Chung, V. P. Dravid and M. G. Kanatzidis, J. Am. Chem. Soc., 2011, 133, 20476–20487.
  30. [30]C. Kittel, Introduction to Solid State Physics, Wiley, New York, 8th edn., 2018.
  31. [31]X.-J. Wang, M.-B. Tang, H.-H. Chen, X.-X. Yang, J.-T. Zhao, U. Burkhardt and Y. Grin, Appl. Phys. Lett., 2009, 94, 092106.
  32. [32]H. Zhang, M. Baitinger, M.-B. Tang, Z.-Y. Man, H.-H. Chen, X.-X. Yang, Y. Liu, L. Chen, Y. Grin and J.-T. Zhao, Dalton Trans., 2010, 39, 1101–1104.
  33. [33]J. P. Heremans, V. Jovovic, E. S. Toberer, A. Saramat, K. Kurosaki, A. Charoenphakdee, S. Yamanaka and G. J. Snyder, Science (80-. )., 2008, 321, 554–557.
  34. [34]H. Naithani and T. Dasgupta, ACS Appl. Energy Mater., 2020, 3, 2200–2213.
  35. [35]E. S. Toberer, A. F. May and G. J. Snyder, Chem. Mater., 2009, 22, 624–634.

Paper details

vlnc:W_9fmjzs6u
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents