WorksMathematics
Braid monodromy and the Cartwright–Steger surface
Abstract
Building on the Livne-like construction of Cartwright, Koziarz and Yeung, we construct a closed smooth 4-manifold with a map to the two-sphere whose generic fiber has genus 109 and whose four exceptional fibers are determined by explicit braid and permutation data. A pencil of four-pointed spheres realizes the same global braid monodromy and makes the covering holomorphic. We show that the contraction of its thirty-six exceptional curves is the Cartwright-Steger surface, hence our smooth construction gives a topological description of this complex surface.
Introduction
The Cartwright–Steger surface is a smooth compact quotient of the complex two-ball with Euler number 3 and first Betti number [4]. Three is the smallest Euler number of a smooth surface of general type. Among the surfaces attaining it, the fake projective planes and the Cartwright–Steger surface, the latter is the unique example with nonzero first Betti number and the unique one admitting a real structure [10, 4, 7, 1]. Cartwright–Koziarz–Yeung constructed on a thirty-six-fold blow-up of this surface a Livné-like fibration whose generic fiber is a 288-fold branched cover of a four-pointed sphere and has genus 109 [3].
In Section 2 we construct a genus-109 fibration from an explicit braid representation and a finite permutation tuple. Section 3 realizes the same global braid representation by a rational pencil, constructs the holomorphic cover, and identifies its blow-down with the Cartwright–Steger surface by a canonical-divisor calculation.
In more concrete terms, using braid monodromy techniques we construct a four-manifold together with a map
where denotes the complement of the four points with and the following properties:
Theorem 1.1. The bundle extends over the four missing values to a closed smooth 4-manifold with a smooth map , with the following properties.
(1) Over it is a fiber bundle with fiber a closed orientable surface of genus 109.
(2) Over each of the fiber has multiplicity 2, with smooth reduction of genus 55.
(3) Over 0 the fiber has four components whose normalizations have genera 4, 4, 10, 10. Their branches meet at three points, at each of which eight
branches cross pairwise transversally. The Euler characteristic of this fiber is .
(4) The Euler characteristic of the closed four-manifold is .
(5) There are thirty-six disjoint smoothly embedded spheres , each of self-intersection . Blowing the spheres down gives a closed smooth -manifold with .
In Section 3 we provide an alternative construction which makes the fibration of Theorem 1.1 holomorphic and identifies its blow-down with the Cartwright–Steger surface. The input is an explicit rational family of four-pointed spheres: In with coordinates let
so that is a cuspidal cubic, is the pencil of lines through , and is the line through the three points at which a line of the pencil is tangent to . On each mark the point , which we distinguish, together with the three points of .
Theorem 1.2. The four marked points of are distinct precisely for . At , two cubic intersection points meet at the cusp with local behavior . At each of , a tangency occurs on . With suitable fiber marking and meridian paths, the global braid representation is exactly the representation used in the proof of Theorem 1.1.
The 288-fold branched cover appearing in the smooth construction now can be applied in the holomorphic setting (with appropriately chosen branch curves), providing a smooth complex surface with the following properties:
Theorem 1.3.
(1) Taking in each fiber of the pencil of Equation (1) a suitable 288-fold branched cover, and completing over , produces a smooth compact complex surface with a holomorphic map .
(2) is fiber-preservingly diffeomorphic to the fibration of Theorem 1.1.
(3) Complex conjugation preserves the covering monodromy class and therefore lifts to an antiholomorphic involution of covering on the base. It preserves the collection of thirty-six disjoint -spheres of Theorem 1.1(5) and hence descends to a real structure on their blow-down . Exactly four of the thirty-six contracted spheres are invariant, each with nonempty real locus, and
The real structure on and above then allows us to identify the blow-down surface (and hence ) with the Cartwright–Steger surface. It also shows that the real structure on is holomorphically conjugate to the one constructed by Borisov–Yeung [1]. More precisely:
Theorem 1.4. The blow-down is biholomorphic to the Cartwright–Steger surface . A biholomorphism may be chosen to identify its real structure with the Borisov–Yeung real structure on the Cartwright–Steger surface .
Acknowledgments
The first author was supported by ERC Advanced Grant KnotSurf4d. The second author was partially supported by the Simons Grant New Structures in Low-Dimensional Topology. We thank İnanç Baykur for helpful conversations. LLM’s were used in the preparation of this paper; in particular, we used Python programs written by AI tools to check identities regarding representations. LLM’s were also used to help in typesetting and language editing. All mathematical content has been checked by the authors, who take full responsibility for it.
The smooth construction
The construction of the bundle with generic fiber the four-punctured sphere
Let be the 2-dimensional sphere with one distinguished marked point and three further marked points , , . First we consider an -bundle (each fiber coming with four marked points) over .
Write for the group of orientation-preserving diffeomorphisms of that fix and preserve setwise, modulo isotopy through such diffeomorphisms. Removing from identifies
the mapping class group of a disc with three marked points modulo rotation of the boundary. Write for the half-twists, and , so that ; under , one has and .
Lemma 2.1. Consider the elements
Then .
Proof. Since , , and in , so the product is .
Since of the four-punctured sphere is the free group generated by three of the four loops, with the product of all four trivial, Lemma 2.1 defines a homomorphism
hence a smooth bundle over with fiber , one distinguished section corresponding to , and an unordered three-point multisection corresponding to .
The branched cover of the four-punctured sphere
Next we describe a 288-fold branched cover of the 2-dimensional sphere . Fix the four marked points , , , as before, and let denote their complement .
In the following we will use the convention that permutations act on the left and are composed right to left: . A finite group with a subgroup acts on the set of left cosets by left multiplication, (), and with the above composition convention is a homomorphism ; the stabilizer of the base coset is itself.
Now take the simple group , of order 6048 [5] (see also a short recollection in the appendix), with its ATLAS standard generators , so that
where stands for the order of . Put , of order seven, choose an element of order three with , and set , of order 21. In the appendix we provide one such choice.
Turning back to the branched cover of : fix the local monodromies at the four marked points coming from the images of five elements in the symmetric group with
and write for the permutations that induce on . (The elements are given in terms of the ATLAS generators in the appendix.) The monodromy sends the peripheral loops at , taken in that order and multiplying to 1, to . Their cycle types are , so the covering is branched with index 2 over and index 4 over each .
Let denote the 288-fold branched cover of , branched along the four points with monodromy representation given above by the permutations around the four distinguished points, respectively. As generate , the subgroup of generated by these four elements acts transitively on . Consequently, the branched cover provides a connected surface, implying that , so the surface has genus 109.
Remark 2.2. As a toy example, a simpler construction can be carried out by taking the double branched cover of branched in the given four marked points; the resulting surface is easily seen to be a torus. We will follow the constructions with this toy example as well.
Lifting the monodromy to
Let be the branched covering above and let have monodromy tuple . We use a right Hurwitz action:
Equivalently, for the corresponding automorphisms of the fundamental group. The two positive half-twists interchange and , respectively.
Lemma 2.3. For there is a unique such that . More explicitly,
and both have order three.
Proof. Evaluating the words for provided in the appendix gives
Only three entries in each row need separate verification. For example, if fixes and carries to , then conjugating gives , where ; comparison with yields . The other row is similar. Applying the homomorphism proves the required identities.
The generators also satisfy
and consequently
The subgroup is self-normalizing. Thus the centralizer of this transitive coset action has
Two simultaneous conjugators differ by an element of this centralizer, proving uniqueness. Finally the nontrivial coset action of the simple group is faithful, so has the same order as .
The Hurwitz action commutes with simultaneous conjugation. Hence every has a unique conjugator with , and our right-action convention gives
This homomorphism is defined on . Its value on the central full twist is nontrivial, as the next corollary records.
Corollary 2.4. The braid fixes . If , then , so is of order four.
Proof. The first assertion follows from . The full twist fixes and conjugates by their product . Uniqueness therefore gives . Thus and .
Choose representatives of the marked mapping classes that are complex linear in oriented local coordinates near the marked points. Such representatives are obtained by local isotopy; the bundle over can be built with transitions of this form. The covering-space lifting criterion applies to these representatives: on the pullback monodromy is conjugate to , and the lift extends across the ramification points smoothly. Indeed, in the local model , a transition lifts to with . The lift is unique because the deck group of is the centralizer in (3). Lifts of isotopies are unique as well. In particular, a genuine order-two representative of lifts to a diffeomorphism whose square is a deck transformation and hence is the identity. This geometric lift and the based sheet conjugator are different objects: the latter includes the transport used to compare the chosen sheet labels.
Theorem 2.5. The fiberwise coverings assemble into a smooth fiber bundle with fiber . It is unique as a covering of the given four-pointed sphere bundle.
Proof. Choose local trivializations of the marked sphere bundle. Each transition diffeomorphism lifts by the preceding criterion. On a triple overlap the two compositions cover the same transition diffeomorphism and differ by a deck transformation of the whole fiber covering, so they agree. The lifts therefore satisfy the cocycle condition. The same uniqueness identifies any two such lifted bundles.
Extension over
In the next two subsections we extend the bundle (defined over ) to a singular fibration over . Consider first the monodromy and its conjugates: these are involutions in the mapping class group of the four-punctured sphere, which fix and one of the ’s (and interchange the other two). We start with a local parity observation:
Lemma 2.6. Let be an oriented branched covering of connected surfaces, and suppose that nontrivial orientation preserving involutions
satisfy . If is fixed by , then is fixed by . If has local degree at , then is odd.
Proof. It is obvious that . Choose small invariant discs around and . On their boundary circles, both involutions are nontrivial and orientation-preserving, therefore after parametrizing the circles by , both are given by
The restriction of to the boundary circles is an orientation-preserving covering of degree . Let be a lift of this circle covering, so that . Equivariance gives
for some integer ; the integer is independent of by continuity. Applying this identity twice gives
Comparing this with , we obtain , thus is odd.
Theorem 2.7. Let be the order-two representative of that fixes and one of the points , say , and interchanges and . Then lifts uniquely to a diffeomorphism
The lift satisfies , acts freely, and has genus 55.
Proof. The Hurwitz action of carries to a simultaneously conjugate tuple. Consequently, the pullback of by has the same monodromy as , up to relabeling of the sheets. The classification of covering spaces over the complement of the marked points therefore gives a lift satisfying . Because the peripheral monodromies have the same cycle types, this lift extends uniquely across the ramification points.
Any two such lifts differ by a deck transformation of . The deck group is trivial, so the lift is unique. Since ,
Thus is a deck transformation of , and therefore .
It remains to prove that is free. A fixed point would lie above one of the two fixed points of . Every point above has local degree 2, as has cycle type . Every point above has local degree 4, because the corresponding peripheral permutation has cycle type . Thus, in either case, the local degree of at would be even, contradicting Lemma 2.6. Hence and the quotient map is an unbranched double covering, the quotient having genus 55 as claimed.
The above result then implies the following:
Corollary 2.8. The bundle extends smoothly over each of . Explicitly, let act on by ; the action is free because is free, so the quotient is a smooth 4-manifold, and descends to a smooth map to whose monodromy is and whose central fiber is with multiplicity 2.
Remark 2.9. In our toy example (where the generic fiber is the double branched cover of , hence is a torus, see Remark 2.2) the monodromies around the three points are all conjugate to (where and are two Dehn twists along simple closed curves in the torus intersecting each other in one transverse point). This monodromy is identical to the monodromy of the -fiber in Kodaira’s classification; topologically such a fiber is the union of two spheres with self-intersection intersecting each other tangentially in one point.
Extension over 0
The extension of the bundle is rather more complicated over 0; this will be discussed in the present subsection. After conjugating the marked fiber, choose a disc containing the two colliding points with peripheral permutations , and put for the covering . The local braid is the positive cube of the half twist interchanging these points. A lift of the single half twist need not be supported on : its sheet conjugator is , of order three and cycle type . The cube has trivial sheet conjugator, however, and its lift has a representative equal to the identity on . We construct its filling directly from an explicit local branched cover.
Proposition 2.10. The subgroup has order 96 and acts regularly on three orbits of size 96. Thus has three connected components, each a degree-96 branched cover of . Each component has genus 21, eight boundary circles, and Euler characteristic . The boundary monodromy is , of cycle type , and every boundary circle maps to with degree 12.
Proof. These orbit and cycle calculations are obtained from the generators and words in the appendix: enumerate , form its left cosets of , and apply by left multiplication. On each orbit, both and have twenty-four cycles of length four and has eight cycles of length twelve. Consequently . Since has eight boundary components, its genus is 21.
Using the above result, an explicit description of the extension can be given.
Lemma 2.11. Put
and
The map
is the degree-96 quotient by . Its branch divisor, in target coordinates , is , with ramification index four along its smooth part. With suitable
peripheral paths and sheet labels, its two cusp meridians have the same permutation action as , on each orbit of Proposition 2.10.
Proof. The two polynomials are invariant under , , and direct calculation gives, with ,
The projective action of on is the octahedral group of order 24. A scalar preserves both polynomials, so and hence . Conversely, . Thus the scalar kernel is exactly and .
The two invariants have no common nonzero zero. Indeed, the left expression of Equation (4) would imply ; on or one has , and on one has . Hence is finite of degree . It factors through , and the induced finite map to has degree one. Since the target is normal, this map is an isomorphism. The two expressions of Equation (4) identify the branch divisor and its ramification index.
Evaluate from their printed words in the 28-point generators, and enumerate products in and in simultaneously. Both enumerations have 96 elements, and every repeated matrix word gives the same permutation word. This verifies an isomorphism sending to and to .
We also check the geometric meridians. On , the path
maps under from to . By Equation (4) its image is real and has no interior critical point, so it parametrizes that interval monotonically. The endpoints and lie on the fixed lines of and , respectively. The transverse eigenvalue of each reflection is . Thus positive meridians based along this interval lift to the local transformations on a common sheet. Deck-labeled sheets give the right regular action. To use the left regular convention of this paper, compose inversion of the labels with the automorphism , ; this automorphism is induced by the semilinear map . The resulting left regular permutations agree with .
Theorem 2.12. Each component of , with the local monodromy , is the Milnor fiber of an ordinary eightfold point, with its positive monodromy. Gluing three copies of this local fibration extends smoothly over . The central fiber is reduced and has four irreducible components whose normalizations have genera and degrees over the capped downstairs sphere. It has three ordinary eightfold points, with incidence matrix
Rows correspond to singular points, columns to irreducible components, and entries count local branches. Its Euler characteristic is .
Proof. Project the cusp family to the -disc. Its two branch points are , so a positive turn around gives the positive cube of a half twist. Lemma 2.11 identifies the prescribed cover on each local orbit with , and the lifted projection is simply . This polynomial has eight distinct linear factors: the two roots of , with , are distinct and nonzero. Thus its zero fiber is an ordinary eightfold point in a smooth surface, and its nearby compact fibers are the corresponding Milnor fibers [8].
This comparison also fixes the relative-boundary monodromy used in gluing. Choose an outside basepoint on the boundary of the -disc. Its loop around the -disc bounds a disc disjoint from the branch curve, so its sheet transport is the identity, as for . The coverings therefore agree on the punctured neighborhood with this marking, and their collar identifications glue to the identity on . There is no need to choose a periodic representative fixing the boundary: the relative-boundary monodromy is supplied by the Milnor fibration itself.
Topologically the central fiber is obtained by collapsing each of the three components of to a point. Its four irreducible components correspond to the orbits of , of sizes 36, 36, 108, 108. The branches at the three singular points are the -cycles assigned to their local and complementary orbits; this gives the displayed incidence matrix. On a complementary orbit of degree , the capped cover has branch indices 2, 4, 12, and hence
The normalization of the central fiber therefore has Euler characteristic . Identifying eight preimages to one point at each of the three singular points gives .
Remark 2.13. In the local model, scalar multiplication by is a periodic representative of the monodromy on the Milnor fiber, allowing its boundary circles to rotate. The representative fixing the boundary pointwise differs by a collar adjustment; its eighth power is the product of the boundary Dehn twists. These are two representatives of the same geometric monodromy with different boundary conventions. The Milnor fillings kill every homology class carried by , as is also clear from the contractible local total space.
Remark 2.14. In the torus toy model the lifted monodromy is , the monodromy of the -fiber in Kodaira’s classification.
Let be the closed four-manifold obtained from by these four fillings over .
Corollary 2.15. , and there are no further singular fibers.
Proof. The regular fiber has Euler characteristic , the fiber over 0 has Euler characteristic , and each reduced multiple fiber has Euler characteristic $-108. Thus
Over the map is a fiber bundle, so no other singular fibers occur.
The thirty-six spheres
Every braid in the image of fixes the marked point , so for such a braid the first entry of is itself; since , the conjugator centralizes and therefore permutes the 144 points of lying over , which are the cycles of .
Lemma 2.16. The sheet conjugator at is trivial. On the 288 sheets, the three conjugators at satisfy
and generate the quaternion group with center . On the 144 cycles of this action factors through and is free. Hence the multisection monodromy has 36 orbits, all of size four.
Proof. Work in , with the right Hurwitz action and its homomorphism , and put
The braid representatives of the four monodromies are , , and . The identity gives
The full twist conjugates by and fixes , so uniqueness of the sheet conjugator gives . Corollary 2.4 gives . Applying the homomorphism to the displayed identity proves ; likewise each .
The element commutes with the . Since , one has , and hence . These are the quaternion relations. They give , because any proper quotient of kills its central involution, whereas .
On the cycles of the center acts trivially. No can preserve one such two-element cycle setwise: its restriction to that cycle would have square equal to the identity, whereas interchanges the two elements. Thus all three nonidentity elements of the quotient are fixed-point-free, and its orbits have size four. There are of them.
Theorem 2.17. The 144 points sweep out a multisection of with 36 connected components . Each is a smoothly embedded sphere, they are pairwise disjoint, and each meets every regular fiber transversally in four points, all four intersections being positive; in particular .
Proof. The components correspond to the orbits of Lemma 2.16, so there are 36 of them, each a degree 4 cover of the base. It is the regular -cover branched over , and at each of those the monodromy is a fixed point free involution, hence two points of ramification index 2; so and the component is a sphere.
For embeddedness we look at the two local models. Over the disc at the monodromy is trivial, and the 144 points lie over , which is not one of the two colliding marked points, so they avoid the region of § 2.5; the multisection is therefore four disjoint discs there, away from the three singular points of the fiber. Over the disc at , in the local model of Corollary 2.8, a pair gives the embedded disc , mapping to the base by a double branched cover; distinct pairs give disjoint discs because is free. Distinct components are disjoint because they are disjoint in every fiber. Finally, meets a regular fiber in the four points of one orbit. Over the projection is a covering map, so at each of these four points with the tangent plane of maps isomorphically to the tangent plane of the base and is therefore complementary to the tangent plane of the fiber: the intersections are transverse. Orient by the orientations of the fiber and of the base, in that order, and orient by pulling back the orientation of the base. Then at each of the four points the splitting is orientation preserving, so every intersection counts positively and . □
Proposition 2.18. Each sphere found in the previous theorem has self-intersection , so these are exceptional spheres of blow-ups.
Proof. For the map give the base the orbifold structure
with order-two points at ; the point is ordinary. The downstairs family extends over each order-two point in the form
where is the half-turn fixing and one of the . In an orientation-compatible complex coordinate centered at this identification is . At , use the standard positive cusp-braid model for , with the two colliding -points away from . In particular the sphere family and its distinguished section extend smoothly near at . These are auxiliary downstairs local models; they agree near with the local fillings already used to construct . Let denote the oriented normal line of this distinguished section, regarded as a complex orbifold line bundle over .
Choose smoothly varying conformal structures on the sphere fibers, agreeing with the standard structures in these local models. Such a choice can be made using fiberwise metrics, averaged under the finite local actions. Locally choose an affine uniformizing coordinate on a sphere with at infinity, and let be the coordinates of the other three marked points. Put
The expression is symmetric in the three points, so their ordering is not important. After changing affine coordinate to , with , one has
Consequently is a well-defined section of . It is nowhere zero while the three -points are distinct. In a uniformizing chart at an order-two point all three are distinct, and the section extends there without a zero; the isotropy on is trivial. At we may take the colliding pair to be and the third point to stay away from . Hence, in a local trivialization,
Equivalently, the positive braid gives discriminant winding number . Thus the section of has just one zero, with topological index three. The Euler-number formula for an oriented line bundle, applied on orbifold charts, gives
The degree-four map is an unramified orbifold covering : its two ordinary ramification points over each cone point have index two, exactly cancelling the order-two isotropy. Near a point over the fiberwise branched covering has local form . Its leading quadratic term therefore identifies the complex normal lines by
This is an identification coming from the quadratic term, not from the ordinary differential, which vanishes in the normal direction. It also holds at the ramification points of : in the uniformizing base coordinate , the local map is into the downstairs orbifold chart above. At it extends because the section is disjoint from the cusp-filling region. Taking degrees, with the orientations already fixed in the proof, gives
It follows that for every .
Proof of Theorem 1.1. Theorem 2.5 gives the regular genus-109 bundle. Corollary 2.8 supplies the three multiplicity-two fibers, and Theorem 2.12 supplies the remaining fiber, including its normalization genera, branch incidences, and Euler characteristic. Corollary 2.15 gives . Finally Theorem 2.17 and Proposition 2.18 give the thirty-six disjoint exceptional spheres and their positive degree-four intersections with every regular fiber. Contracting them decreases the Euler characteristic by 36, so .
The holomorphic model
We construct the complex surface directly from the pencil (1) of the Introduction.
The marked pencil
Recall that the cubic, the pencil, the point and the line are given as
The normalization of the cuspidal cubic is parametrized by . The induced map to the pencil parameter and its derivative are
The exceptional parameters are . The line passes through the cusp , whereas is tangent to the cubic at . The line contains these three tangency points and misses . At exactly two of the cubic intersection points approach the cusp; the third tends to , corresponding to , where the map is unramified. The three poles of are simple, and the four marked points are distinct at .
Blow up , and then blow up twice at each tangency point to separate the cubic from the tangent fiber. Denote the resulting surface by . Over each tangency parameter its fiber is a chain
Contract the six disjoint curves , and write
The surface has six rational double points of type and a map to with three fibers of multiplicity two. Let denote the images of the strict transforms of the cubic and . The distinguished point of a regular fiber is its intersection with ; the three further marked points are its intersections with . The exceptional curve over is a different section and carries no marked point. For a fixed (finite) parameter , use the affine fiber coordinate on the fiber over
The distinguished point is , and the three cubic intersections satisfy
Lemma 3.1. The local marked-sphere monodromy at is the positive cube of a half twist. At each of it is an involution fixing the distinguished point and one cubic intersection, and exchanging the other two. After a quadratic base change at a tangency, the marked family extends with four distinct points.
Proof. Near the cusp put , , . Then
The analytic fiber coordinate , with the root equal to one at the origin, satisfies on the branch curve. A positive turn of therefore turns the two colliding points through .
At a tangency put , make the base change , and set . Dividing (3.1) by gives
In the projective -coordinate, the four points at are and ; they are all distinct. The base-change involution is , whose central action has the stated effect. The map is unramified at all three tangencies. □
Theorem 3.2. With a suitable marking and distinguished meridian paths, the monodromies of the marked-sphere family are exactly those of Lemma 2.1.
Proof. Put , send to infinity by , and put . Equation (3.1) becomes
The double cover branched over the four marked points consequently has Weierstrass equation
Its invariant is
The moduli orbifold of a sphere with one distinguished point and three unordered further points has underlying space a sphere with one point removed, two cone points of orders two and three, and one cusp. In the coordinate , its cusp is , its point of order two is , and its point of order three is . Choose peripheral generators
Equation (6) identifies the moduli map, and Lemma 3.1 fixes the local sign and the order-two stabilizer. The pullback has cusp width three at zero; at infinity its local degree three removes the order-three stabilizer. Choose the meridian paths from the three lifted sectors in cyclic order. The corresponding generators of the index-three subgroup are
Their product is . These are precisely the four elements in Lemma 2.1. Changing the marking or the paths changes the representation by the corresponding simultaneous conjugation or Hurwitz move. □
Proof of Theorem 1.2. The parametrization of the cubic identifies the four exceptional values and shows that the marked points are otherwise distinct. Lemma 3.1 gives the local behavior, and Theorem 3.2 identifies the global marked monodromy. □
The normalized parameter
Normalize a regular marked sphere so that its distinguished point is , two of the other points are , , and the third is . The six choices of ordering of the cubic intersections give the six possible normalizations.
Theorem 3.3. The parameters satisfy
This is a map of degree six. Its fibers over are, respectively,
with ramification indices , , and .
Proof. The transformation sends the normalized configuration to , where . The Legendre formula gives
Comparing with (6) proves the formula. Its numerator and denominator are relatively prime and have degree six. The identity
gives the fiber over one, including its point at infinity. The displayed ramification contributes , so there is no further ramification. □
The holomorphic cover and its completion
We use the following uniqueness principle throughout. An automorphism of the base of a connected finite cover has at most one lift when the deck group is trivial. A lift exists if its action preserves the monodromy class. Relations among such base automorphisms hold for their lifts. In our families, lifts over base trivializations agree on overlaps because their restrictions to each fiber are unique. Holomorphic or antiholomorphic lifts extend to the finite normalization.
Proof of Theorem 1.3(1)–(2). Let . The tuple determines the connected degree- covers of the marked fibers over . Their ramification indices are . By Theorem 3.2 and Lemma 2.3, their monodromy class is preserved by transport. The deck group is trivial by (3), so the local holomorphic covers glue uniquely to a cover over . Equivalently, apply Riemann existence to the finite cover of the branch complement and then normalize. Normalizing in this cover gives a finite normal compact cover
We check its smoothness at the exceptional fibers.
At a tangency, the quadratic base change of Lemma 3.1 gives four distinct marked points, hence a smooth family of genus-109 curves. The involution lifts uniquely. Its square is the identity. On the central curve its only possible fixed points lie over the two fixed points of , where the local degrees are two and four. Lemma 2.6 excludes these fixed points. The action on the total space is therefore free, and its quotient is smooth, with a double fiber whose reduction has genus 55. The downstairs quotient has two points and minimal resolution , so this is the normalization over the corresponding neighborhood in . The holomorphic family need not be a product; an averaged smooth connection nevertheless gives the equivariant smooth trivialization used in Corollary 2.8.
At the cusp use the quotient of Lemma 2.11. The actual pencil parameter lifts to
Choose the analytic eighth root near the origin and put . Its derivative at the origin is a nonzero scalar, and homogeneity gives exactly . Thus the normalization is smooth, and the three local orbits give the three ordinary eightfold points of Theorem 2.12.
These models cover every point of . Over the covering is the one used to construct . At the exceptional values we have identified the same quotient and polynomial fillings, with their coverings on punctured neighborhoods. The unique covering identifications glue to a fiber-preserving diffeomorphism . This proves both assertions. □
The exceptional curves and the canonical divisor
Use the exceptional classes on , where labels the tangencies and the second index records the order of the two blowups. If denotes the hyperplane class in , in this orthogonal basis we have
Here is the class of a regular fiber, and primes denote strict transforms. The rational pullbacks of the branch divisors are
The coefficients follow by intersecting with each contracted curve, which has square .
Proposition 3.4. The distinguished section has rational self-intersection .
Proof. The line meets the cubic transversally at the tangencies and does not pass through the second infinitely near centers. Thus . It meets each once and is disjoint from the . Equation (7) then gives .
Theorem 3.5. Under the diffeomorphism of Theorem 1.3(2), the thirty-six spheres are disjoint holomorphic rational curves of self-intersection . Their simultaneous contraction is a smooth compact complex surface .
Proof. The components of are the same thirty-six packets used in Theorem 2.17, hence are the smooth rational curves . Since the ramification index along is two,
Each component maps to with degree four. The projection formula and disjointness give
The curves can therefore be contracted holomorphically. Denote the contraction by .
Proposition 3.6. The surfaces and are projective. The surface is minimal of general type, and
Proof. First observe that there are two effective anticanonical divisors with no common irreducible component:
where is a generic fiber. For any irreducible curve, at least one of these divisors omits it; their intersection is therefore nonnegative. Hence is nef, and its square makes it big.
For completeness this also proves projectivity of the intermediate contraction. The divisor is nef and big, as is . By the base-point-free theorem [6 Theorem 3.3], a multiple of defines a projective contraction. Its contracted curves are exactly the six : a horizontal curve has positive intersection with , while among the fiber components these six are precisely the ones of anticanonical degree zero. The contraction is therefore . Its finite cover is projective, as is the blow-down .
The ramification formula in codimension one gives
There is no further divisorial ramification. Using (7) we obtain
Since , the exceptional divisor subtracts precisely . Consequently
Thus is nef and big. It follows that is of general type; nefness excludes any further -curve. Moreover
by Corollary 2.15. Noether’s formula gives .
The real involution
We collect the finite data needed for the real structure. These statements refer to the printed left coset action, independently of an identification of with any previously known surface.
Lemma 3.7. (1) There is a unique permutation satisfying
It has cycle type , and
(2) On the thirty-six four-element packets of -cycles, has type . Each fixed packet contains two fixed -cycles and two fixed sheets.
(3) Put . The tuple is a Hurwitz transform and satisfies . The three -orbits are invariant under . Its action on the twenty-four -cycles has type , with 0, 4, 4 fixed cycles on the three local orbits.
Proof. Consider given in Equation (A.1) in the appendix. Direct computation checks the properties of this choice of listed in the statement. Uniqueness follows directly from (3); the square of centralizes the tuple and is therefore the identity. The identities with , check compatibility with transport. Finally, places its cycles in the complementary -orbits as well, so the last count is compatible with the global central fiber.
Lemma 3.8. Complex conjugation induces an antiholomorphic involution of covering and preserving the branch divisors. It preserves the fibers at zero and one and exchanges those at .
Proof. The equations of the cubic, line and pencil are real. The centers , and the tangent direction at are real; the other centers and their infinitely near centers form conjugate pairs. Conjugation therefore lifts to , permutes its six contracted curves, and descends to .
Theorem 3.9. The involution lifts uniquely to an antiholomorphic involution of . It permutes the exceptional curves and descends to a real structure on . Exactly four of the exceptional curves have real points, and
Proof. Choose the real normalization
where the letters also indicate the corresponding peripheral permutations. Conjugation reverses the peripheral orientations and exchanges the points at , . Its action on the tuple is therefore . The first part of Lemma 3.7 gives its lift and its compatibility with base transport. Fiberwise uniqueness glues these lifts over the regular base, and normality extends the lift antiholomorphically over the finite cover. Its square is the identity by uniqueness. Since it preserves , it descends through the contraction to .
We compute the real Euler characteristic directly from . Theorem 3.3 gives in the chosen normalization. As , the points coalesce in this coordinate, and the complementary vanishing region of the original cubic cusp contains the points with meridians . The Hurwitz move to places those meridians together. Its three local orbits are invariant under , and their boundary cycles have fixed elements. Thus all three singular points are real, with eight individually real branches in total.
The real locus of the normalization of the central curve is a disjoint union of circles, possibly empty. Gluing the branches removes eight real normalization points and adds three real singular points. Hence
Every other real fiber has real locus a union of circles, including the reduction of the double fiber over one. Additivity of Euler characteristic for the proper real-algebraic map to now gives .
The packet action has four fixed packets, each containing fixed points. The corresponding invariant rational curves therefore have real circles. Contracting each circle increases the real Euler characteristic by one; the remaining sixteen conjugate pairs do not change the real locus. Thus . □
Completion of the proof of Theorem 1.3. Theorem 3.9 proves assertion (3), completing the proof. □
Proof of Theorem 1.4. Proposition 3.6 proves that is minimal of general type with . Equality in the Miyaoka–Yau inequality makes it a smooth ball quotient [9, 13]. The classification of surfaces of general type of Euler number three leaves the fake projective planes and the Cartwright–Steger surface [10, 4, 1]. Fake projective planes admit no real structure [7]; Theorem 3.9 therefore identifies with the Cartwright–Steger surface .
Consequently is its blow-up at the thirty-six images of the curves . We henceforth write and under this identification. It transports to a real structure on . To compare it with the Borisov–Yeung involution , use [3 Main Theorem (e)]. Any other real involution is for . Conjugation by acts on either trivially or by inversion. In the first case forces . In the second, choose with ; then . Thus the real structures agree up to a holomorphic automorphism of . □
Lemma 3.10. The automorphism lifts uniquely to a holomorphic automorphism of covering . It has order three and descends to a generator of . Moreover
Proof. The projective automorphism preserves the pencil, the branch divisors and all blowup centers as sets. Its cyclic motion of the three cubic intersections preserves the covering class by Lemma 2.3. The same fiberwise uniqueness and normalization argument used for conjugation gives the holomorphic lift. Its cube covers the identity of , so it is a deck transformation and is the identity. The lift is nontrivial because it moves the base. It permutes the exceptional curves and hence descends to a nontrivial order-three automorphism of ; by [3 Main Theorem (e)], this generates its automorphism group. Conjugation takes the downstairs multiplier to , and uniqueness of lifting gives both displayed relations. □
Remark 3.11. The sheet conjugator for the braid has order six, since . This is consistent with : a based braid includes the transport used to compare two fibers, whereas is an automorphism of the entire covering family.
Note that the identification of (and so ) with the Cartwright-Steger surface implies that
Group theoretic properties of
The simple unitary group . Let be the quadratic extension of and let be its nontrivial Galois automorphism. On the vector space , fix a nondegenerate Hermitian form, for example
The full and special unitary groups are
Their projective images are denoted by and . For general one has
Consequently,
Since , the center of is trivial. Moreover, has order . Thus in this particular case the natural projective map gives
After making this natural identification, the common abstract group is often written or . The general simplicity theorem for projective special unitary groups implies that is nonabelian simple; the exceptional nonsimple case in rank 2 is [2, 11].
The isotropic one-dimensional subspaces of form the Hermitian curve
For a Hermitian curve over the number of isotropic points is ; hence . The group acts faithfully and doubly transitively on these points. A point stabilizer has order .
Generators and presentations of . The ATLAS standard generators are elements satisfying
Thus is a quotient of the hyperbolic triangle group
where hyperbolicity follows from . The three order conditions alone do not characterize the finite quotient. A presentation on the standard pair is
where [12].
A particularly useful concrete realization is the following primitive permutation representation on 28 points:
Direct calculation gives
Since is simple, every nontrivial permutation action is faithful. The displayed degree-28 action is a convenient faithful model for finite calculations.
The elements used in the representations defining the branched covers can be explicitly described in the ATLAS presentation of : writing and using , the five elements of Equation (2) are
and are their images under . The element of Lemma 3.7 can be given in this presentation as follows. Define the following permutation of the 28-point set:
The action on a coset is then given by
Direct calculation then verifies the claims of Lemma 3.7.
Matrix representations. These elements can then be represented by matrices over the field of 9 elements as follows. Let
Thus , the element has multiplicative order 8, and the nontrivial automorphism of is .
Let the matrices correspond to the generators of the group ; with this notation
These are the standard generators in the natural, absolutely irreducible 3-dimensional ATLAS representation over . A direct calculation gives
Moreover, direct enumeration gives
Since and , it follows that . For later reference, the product of order 7 is
References
HUN-REN Rényi Institute of Mathematics, H-1053 Budapest, Réaltanoda utca 13–15, Hungary
Email address: [email protected]
Department of Mathematics, Princeton University, Princeton, NJ, 08544
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]L. A. Borisov and S.-K. Yeung, Explicit equations of the Cartwright–Steger surface, Épijournal de Géométrie Algébrique 4 (2020), article 10.DOI
- [2]R. W. Carter, Simple Groups of Lie Type, John Wiley & Sons, London–New York–Sydney, 1972.
- [3]D. I. Cartwright, V. Koziarz and S.-K. Yeung, On the Cartwright–Steger surface, J. Algebraic Geom. 26 (2017), 655–689; longer version arXiv:1412.4137v1.arxiv.org/abs/1412.4137
- [4]D. I. Cartwright and T. Steger, Enumeration of the 50 fake projective planes, C. R. Math. Acad. Sci. Paris 348 (2010), 11–13.DOI
- [5]J. H. Conway, R. T. Curtis, S. P. Norton, R. A. Parker and R. A. Wilson, Atlas of finite groups, Oxford University Press, 1985.
- [6]J. Kollár and S. Mori, Birational Geometry of Algebraic Varieties, Cambridge Tracts in Mathematics, vol. 134, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 1998.DOI
- [7]Vik. S. Kulikov and V. M. Kharlamov, On real structures on rigid surfaces, Izv. Math. 66 (2002), no. 1, 133–150.DOI
- [8]J. Milnor, Singular points of complex hypersurfaces, Annals of Mathematics Studies, vol. 61, Princeton University Press, 1968.
- [9]Y. Miyaoka, On the Chern numbers of surfaces of general type, Invent. Math. 42 (1977), 225–237.
- [10]G. Prasad and S.-K. Yeung, Fake projective planes, Invent. Math. 168 (2007), 321–370.
- [11]D. E. Taylor, The Geometry of the Classical Groups, Sigma Series in Pure Mathematics 9, Heldermann Verlag, Berlin, 1992.
- [12]R. A. Wilson, R. A. Parker, J. N. Bray, and collaborators, ATLAS of Finite Group Representations: U3(3).
- [13]S.-T. Yau, Calabi’s conjecture and some new results in algebraic geometry, Proc. Nat. Acad. Sci. U.S.A. 74 (1977), 1798–1799.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16592394