betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Population structure of the velocity distribution in normal shock waves: Gaussian representations, Mach-number similarity, and prediction

Abstract

Normal shock waves are commonly described as mixtures of upstream and downstream Maxwellians. Discrete-velocity solutions of three relaxation models up to Mach 12 and direct simulation Monte Carlo (DSMC) of hard-sphere and variable-hard-sphere gases up to Mach 25 are used to examine the population structure, Mach-number similarity and upstream precursor of their velocity distributions. Three anisotropic Gaussian populations reproduce the streamwise reduced distributions of the Bhatnagar–Gross–Krook (BGK) model and of DSMC to within 4% up to Mach 12, and of DSMC to within 6% at Mach 25, whereas two Maxwellians incur errors up to 50% (BGK) and 37% (DSMC). Collision histories identify the hard-sphere beam with unscattered stream molecules, which carry half of the peak viscous stress; the other populations are effective descriptions, not collision classes. Above Mach 5, Rankine–Hugoniot-scaled distributions are nearly Mach-independent, with corrections linear in 1/M21/M^2, consistent with the scaled kinetic equation. At equal normalised density, Mach 8 and 12 give the heat flux and stress at Mach 25 within 1%, comparable to the accuracy of the reference; with one moment equation for position, physical-space profiles follow within 5%. Comparing three prediction methods shows that the accuracy comes from the scaling; the Gaussian form adds compactness. Ahead of the shock, the mass of upstream-moving molecules decays as a stretched exponential with effective exponent 0.68–0.87. Collisions regenerate upstream-moving molecules, which explains a decay slower than free-flight survival; a linear cascade model with a downstream-Maxwellian source and no input from the shock interior reproduces the decay rates within 1.2%.

main.pdf

Introduction

Rarefied gas simulations contain information at two levels. The first is macroscopic: density, mean velocity, and temperature. The second is kinetic: the asymmetry and anisotropy of the velocity distribution function (VDF), heat flux, stress, skewness, and fourth-order content. In a transitional or rarefied flow, agreement in ρ\rho, uu, and TT is not sufficient, because distributions with nearly identical primary fields can transport different momentum and energy. Odd, mixed, and high-order velocity moments measure the departure from local equilibrium and expose errors that are nearly invisible in conserved variables ((Bird, 1994; Cercignani, 2000; Sone, 2007; Roohi & Stefanov, 2016; Aklaghli et al., 2023)).

The normal shock is the simplest flow in which this distinction matters. Mott-Smith described its distribution as a combination of the upstream and downstream Maxwellians (Mott-Smith, [3]), and measurements in argon and helium shocks confirmed the bimodal character of the distribution in strong shocks ((Muntz & Harnett, 1969; Holtz & Muntz, 1983; Pham-Van-Diep et al., 1989)), which DSMC reproduces in detail ((Bird, 1970; Erwin et al., 1991)). The two-Maxwellian picture nevertheless leaves part of the distribution undescribed. Salwen, Grosch, and Ziering gave a method for adding terms to the Mott-Smith distribution and computed shock thicknesses for Maxwell molecules with three terms (Salwen et al., 1964), and Segal and Ferziger constructed a model equation with a trimodal gain function (Segal & Ferziger, 1972). Monte Carlo simulations showed that the bimodal ansatz is reasonably accurate for the shock thickness but not for the distribution function (Bird, 1970; Cercignani et al., 1999). Vilquin, Boudet, and Kellay found that velocity distributions measured in shocks in granular gases are not strictly bimodal and proposed a trimodal description in which the intermediate population consists of particles that have undergone one collision between the supersonic and subsonic streams; they showed that the same description fits distributions measured in argon and helium shocks and computed by molecular dynamics, at two positions for each of three Mach numbers (Vilquin et al., 2016). The bimodal distribution has also been used to close the moment equations of strong shocks (Solovchuk & Sheu, 2011). The direct numerical solution of the Boltzmann equation for hard spheres by Ohwada, up to Mach 3, agrees with the Mott-Smith profiles of density, velocity, and temperature but shows a distinct difference in the distribution function (Ohwada, 1993), and in the limit of infinite Mach number the distribution separates into the upstream beam and a remainder that is singular at the beam velocity (Grad, 1969; Cercignani et al., 1999; Takata et al., 2000; Pomeau & Tran, 2019). For hard spheres, this remainder first appears next to the beam velocity and then develops a central maximum, so that it has two maxima inside the shock (Takata et al., 2000). For the BGK model, Liepmann, Narasimha, and Chahine obtained shock profiles from the integral form of the kinetic equation (Liepmann et al., 1962).

For a weak shock and a relaxation model with constant collision time, Lyubarskii found that ahead of the shock the density, velocity, and temperature approach their limits like exp⁡(−C∣x∣2/3)\exp(-C|x|^{2/3}) and not exponentially, and attributed this to fast particles that penetrate far from the front almost without collisions, so that the structure far from the front depends on how the collision time varies with velocity at large velocities (Lyubarskii, 1961). Narasimha obtained the distribution of these molecules by matched asymptotic expansions: on the cold side they form a precursor of the hot side, the downstream Maxwellian attenuated as in a molecular beam whose free path is proportional to the molecular speed. A heuristic extension to inverse-power potentials gave exp⁡(−∣x∣l)\exp(-|x|^{l}) with l=λ/(λ+2)l=\lambda/(\lambda+2) for a potential proportional to r−λr^{-\lambda}, that is, 2/32/3 for Maxwell molecules and unity for hard spheres (Narasimha, 1968). These results concern weak shocks, in which the slow decay is reached only far upstream. For strong shocks, Liepmann, Narasimha, and Chahine noted a long upstream tail in their numerical solutions of the BGK equation and expected the model to exaggerate it except for Maxwell molecules (Liepmann et al., 1965); Narasimha’s later account of that work (Narasimha, 2014) recalls that the tail is the more pronounced the higher the order of the moment, and that such tails have since been found in solutions of the Boltzmann equation. Rigorous analyses of weak shock profiles have recently obtained sub-exponential remainders with the same exponent (Duan et al., 2026; Albritton et al., 2026). To our knowledge, the decay law has not been measured in kinetic solutions of strong shocks. The estimates with which such solutions can be compared, the precursor distribution of Narasimha and its extension to other collision laws (Eqs. (23) and (25) below), take a molecule to leave the upstream-moving group at its first collision. This is exact for a relaxation model. In a gas a collision redistributes both partners, as the collision operators of the Boltzmann and Landau equations treated in the rigorous analyses do, and the consequence of this redistribution for the decay ahead of a strong shock has not been examined. Likewise, a three-population description exists (Salwen et al., 1964; Vilquin et al., 2016), so that the number three is not new; what has not been determined is where in the shock and from what Mach number each population is required, what each contributes to the transport, whether the populations of a fit are sets of molecules with a common collision history, and how the answers depend on the collision law. A tool for the question of history exists for confined rarefied flows: Stefanov and co-workers divided the DSMC solution into a ballistic part, the molecules that have not collided since they left a wall, and a collision part, and obtained the contribution of each to the flow rate, the temperature, and the heat flux (Vargas et al., 2014; Tatsios et al., 2015; Akhlaghi et al., 2018). It is applied here to the shock, with the incoming stream in the place of the wall, and extended by a record of how recently a scattered molecule or its partners belonged to the stream.

A second line of work concerns compact representations of kinetic solutions. A deterministic discrete velocity method (DVM) stores a distribution on the tensor product of a physical grid and a velocity grid, so that even a one-dimensional shock with three velocity coordinates contains hundreds of millions of values. Gaussian kernels are a natural localised basis for such data. Alekseenko, Grandilli, and Wood developed an ultra-sparse isotropic-Gaussian approximation for spatially homogeneous distributions (Alekseenko et al., 2020), Gaussian-mixture compression has been applied to plasma distribution functions (Hu et al., 2025), and Shenoy and Frankel fitted Gaussian primitives to snapshots of turbulent velocity fields and evaluated derivative-sensitive quantities (Shenoy & Frankel, 2026). Gaussian primitives are also prominent in continuous scene and signal representations (Kerbl et al., 2023; Sitzmann et al., 2020), while reduced-order fluid modelling has long relied on proper orthogonal decomposition and projection methods (Sirovich, 1987; Berkooz et al., 1993; Benner et al., 2015). Dynamical low-rank and tensor methods, reduced-order models of the BGK equation, and neural sparse representations reduce the cost of evolving phase-space solutions (Einkemmer & Lubich, 2018; Bernard et al., 2018; Li et al., 2024), learned collision operators target the collision step (Miller et al., 2022; Xiao & Frank, 2021, 2023), and operator-learning and physics-informed approaches map problem inputs to solutions [4, 4, 4] (Brunton et al. 2020; Lu et al. 2021; Li et al. 2021; Lou et al. 2021; De Florio et al. 2022; Tucny et al. 2024; Tucny et al. 2025). An earlier preprint introduced positive Gaussian phase-space representations of shock distributions [4], and a second preprint examined their accuracy in the transport moments and their range of validity for normal shocks and lid-driven cavities [4]. The 512-kernel representation summarised in § 5.3 and reproduced in the supplementary material is taken from the latter, restricted to the shocks: its fits at Mach 3 and 5, the comparison at equal storage, and the Mach-conditioned models with their range check are the results reported there, and the reference BGK solutions are the same. It is included here as the reference against which the few-population description and the predictions in scaled variables are judged. The reduced distributions, the DSMC, the population analysis, the collision histories, the similarity and the prediction, and the analysis of the precursor (§ 2.2–§ 5.2) are new.

These two lines of work lead to the three questions of this paper, which are taken in this order. First, what does the distribution inside a shock consist of: how many Gaussian populations does it contain, where in the shock does each one matter, what does each contribute to the transport, to what sets of molecules do they correspond, and which of these properties belong to the gas rather than to the kinetic model? Second, how does the distribution depend on shock strength, and can this dependence be used to predict a shock at a Mach number for which no solution exists, including Mach numbers beyond those available? Third, by what mechanism do upstream-moving molecules penetrate ahead of the shock, and how does their decay depend on the collision law? A compact Gaussian representation of the whole phase-space function, with several hundred kernels in physical variables, is carried through the paper as a reference for the second question: it shows what a general-purpose representation achieves for a given shock and where it stops being valid when the shock strength changes. The two approaches differ in more than the choice of variables, and they are compared as whole descriptions (§ 5.3).

Figure 1 shows the answer to the first question for a hard-sphere gas at Mach 8, and the three terms used throughout the paper. They are suggested by the kinetic equation. Followed along a molecular path, the distribution at any position is the sum of the molecules of the upstream flow that have arrived there without a collision and of the molecules emitted by collisions on the way; for the relaxation models this is Eq. (14). The first part is the upstream Maxwellian, attenuated but with its velocity u1u_1 and temperature T1T_1 unchanged: this is the beam. Far downstream the gas is in equilibrium, so that the scattered molecules approach the Maxwellian of the downstream state: this is the hot population. These are the two terms of Mott-Smith. Inside the shock, however, the scattered molecules are not in equilibrium. Those that left the stream recently retain part of its momentum, and the distribution of the scattered molecules is skewed towards u1u_1, which a Maxwellian centred near u2u_2 does not reproduce. The third term, the intermediate population, is a Gaussian centred between u2u_2 and u1u_1 that represents this part; it stands where Salwen et al. (1964) added a third term to the Mott-Smith distribution and where the gain function of Segal & Ferziger (1972) has its third maximum. Each population has its own streamwise and transverse temperatures, because molecules scattered between two streams are spread differently along and across the flow. The fit of Figure 1 is consistent with this reading: on the upstream half of the shock the beam is centred at u1u_1 to within 0.001 (u1−u2)(u_1-u_2) and has the width of the upstream Maxwellian to within 8%, and the hot population has the width of the downstream Maxwellian to within 6% throughout, although none of these values is imposed. That three terms are sufficient, and what molecules each of them contains, are not assumed: the first is established by the number of populations required at each position and Mach number (§ 3), and the second by the collision records (§ 4.1.2).

Figure 1. The three populations of a hard-sphere shock at Mach 8. (a) Number density through the shock from DSMC (line) and its division among the beam, the intermediate population, and the hot population of the three-population fit (shaded); the flow is from left to right and xcx_c is the position at which n∗=0.5n^* = 0.5. (b)–(d) Streamwise reduced distribution gg at the three positions marked in (a), from DSMC (line), with the three fitted Gaussians (shaded); u1u_1 and u2u_2 are the upstream and downstream velocities. The beam holds 67%, 22%, and 7% of the mass at the three positions and the intermediate population 11%, 13%, and 7%; the sum of the three reproduces gg to within 1.1% throughout the shock.

The contributions follow the same order. (i) The reference solutions are verified through their conserved fluxes and through the integral form of the kinetic equation, and the DSMC through refinement and through two published direct solutions of the Boltzmann equation. (ii) The reduced distributions are decomposed into at most four anisotropic Gaussian populations between Mach 1.5 and 12; the number required at each position and Mach number and the contribution of each population to the heat flux and stress are determined. The stability of the decomposition is tested with independent data, random restarts, and a changed fit criterion, its physical content with collision histories recorded in DSMC, which also divide the viscous stress and the heat flux between the unscattered stream and the scattered molecules, and its accuracy beyond the fitted reduced distributions with the transverse fourth moment. (iii) The same analysis is applied to Shakhov and ellipsoidal-statistical (ES-BGK) solutions and to DSMC velocity distributions of hard-sphere and variable-hard-sphere gases between Mach 2 and 25, which separates properties of the gas from properties of the BGK model. (iv) The distribution is shown to be nearly independent of Mach number in variables scaled with the Rankine–Hugoniot states, and this similarity, closed with one moment equation, is used to predict the distribution and the profile of shocks at Mach numbers between and beyond those used. Three ways of using the similarity are compared (three populations, the scaled distributions themselves, and the scaled distributions with the beam treated separately), which shows what the Gaussian form contributes; the conserved fluxes of the predictions, their errors in physical space, and the range of source Mach numbers over which each method applies are reported. (v) The upstream precursor is analysed with the integral form of the kinetic equation for the relaxation models and compared with the asymptotic theory of Lyubarskii and Narasimha; for the gas, the composition of the precursor is obtained from collision histories, a linear cascade model without adjustable parameters is compared with the simulations, and the decay exponent is determined with its statistical uncertainty and its dependence on the fit window and the domain length. (vi) A positive mixture of 512 Gaussians is fitted to log⁡f(x,ξ)\log f(x,\xi) for Mach-3 and Mach-5 BGK shocks and conditioned on Mach number over nine shock strengths; tests at withheld positions and with withheld complete solutions, a comparison with regular grids having the same number of coefficients, and a check of the fitted Mach-number interval determine where this representation is valid.

Section 2 describes the kinetic solutions, the DSMC, and their verification. Sections 3 and 4 establish the departure from two Maxwellians and the population decomposition for the BGK model, and Secs. 5 and 6 show what changes with the kinetic model and in the gas, and what the populations are. Sections 7 and 8 give the similarity across Mach number and the prediction built on it. Section 9 treats the upstream precursor, first for the relaxation models and then for the gas. Section 10 summarises, for comparison, the many-kernel phase-space representation of Roohi [4]. The details of the population fits and of the collision record and the cascade model are given in the appendices, and the complete account of the many-kernel study in the supplementary material.

Kinetic reference problems

BGK and Shakhov models and discrete velocity moments

All reference solutions were computed by the author with graphics-processing-unit (GPU) discrete-velocity solvers. The errors reported for the Gaussian descriptions are measured against the DVM distributions and their quadrature moments. The normal shocks use the BGK relaxation model,

∂f∂t+ξ⋅∇xf=fS−fτ,(1)\frac{\partial f}{\partial t}+\boldsymbol{\xi}\cdot\nabla_x f=\frac{f^{S}-f}{\tau}, \tag*{(1)}

with fS=fMf^{S}=f^{M} in the shock calculations. Here f=f(x,ξ,t)f=f(x,\xi,t) is the molecular velocity distribution, xx is physical position, ξ\xi is molecular velocity, tt is time, and τ\tau is the relaxation time. In the shock solver, time is measured in units of the upstream relaxation time, and the relaxation time is the same constant in every cell,

τshock=1,fn+1=fM+(f∗−fM)exp⁡(−Δt/τshock)=fM+(f∗−fM)exp⁡(−Δt),(2)\begin{aligned} \tau_{\mathrm{shock}} &= 1,\\ f^{n+1} &= f^{M} + (f^\ast- f^{M})\exp\left(-\Delta t/\tau_{\mathrm{shock}}\right)\\ &= f^{M} + (f^\ast- f^{M})\exp\left(-\Delta t\right), \tag*{(2)} \end{aligned}

where f∗f^\ast is the distribution after the transport step. The relaxation factor in each time step is thus exp⁡(−Δt)\exp(-\Delta t), and the relaxation time does not depend on temperature. The local Maxwellian is

fM=ρ(2πT)3/2exp⁡(−∣c∣22T).(3)f^{M} = \frac{\rho}{(2\pi T)^{3/2}}\exp\left(-\frac{\lvert c\rvert^2}{2T}\right). \tag*{(3)}

The Shakhov solutions used for the model comparison of § 3.2 instead use the target

fS=fM[1+(1−Pr)c⋅q5pT(∣c∣2T−5)].(4)f^{S} = f^{M}\left[1+(1-\mathrm{Pr})\frac{\boldsymbol{c}\cdot\boldsymbol{q}}{5pT}\left(\frac{\lvert c\rvert^2}{T}-5\right)\right]. \tag*{(4)}

with Prandtl number Pr=2/3\mathrm{Pr}=2/3. In these expressions ρ\rho, u\boldsymbol{u}, and TT are the density, bulk velocity, and temperature, c=ξ−u\boldsymbol{c}=\boldsymbol{\xi}-\boldsymbol{u} is the peculiar velocity, p=ρTp=\rho T is the pressure, and q\boldsymbol{q} is the heat flux. The relaxation coefficient in Eq. (2) was verified directly in the shock solver. The shock solutions are therefore solutions of the BGK model with constant τ\tau and Pr=1\mathrm{Pr}=1, and the Shakhov solutions have Pr=2/3\mathrm{Pr}=2/3 (Bhatnagar et al., 1954; Shakhov, 1968; Mieussens, 2000; Xu & Huang, 2010).

Let {(ξn,wn)}n=1Nv\{(\boldsymbol{\xi}_n,w_n)\}_{n=1}^{N_v} denote the discrete velocity nodes and quadrature weights, and let fn=f(ξn)f_n=f(\boldsymbol{\xi}_n). The macroscopic fields are

ρ=∑n=1Nvfnwn,ρui=∑n=1Nvξi,nfnwn.(5)\rho= \sum_{n=1}^{N_v} f_n w_n,\qquad\rho u_i = \sum_{n=1}^{N_v}\xi_{i,n}f_nw_n. \tag*{(5)}
3ρT=∑n=1Nv∣cn∣2fnwn,cn=ξn−u.(6)3\rho T = \sum_{n=1}^{N_v}\lvert c_n\rvert^2 f_nw_n,\qquad c_n=\xi_n-u. \tag*{(6)}

The temperature and the peculiar velocity in Eq. (6) are defined with the bulk velocity of Eq. (5), and all higher moments below are taken about the same velocity. The transport and higher-order observables used throughout the paper are

σij=∑n=1Nvci,ncj,nfnwn−ρTδij,(7)\sigma_{ij}=\sum_{n=1}^{N_v}c_{i,n}c_{j,n}f_nw_n-\rho T\delta_{ij}, \tag*{(7)}
qi=12∑n=1Nv∣cn∣2ci,nfnwn,(8)q_i=\frac{1}{2}\sum_{n=1}^{N_v}\lvert c_n\rvert^2c_{i,n}f_nw_n, \tag*{(8)}
M300neq=∑n=1Nvcx,n3fnwn,(9)M_{300}^{\mathrm{neq}}=\sum_{n=1}^{N_v}c_{x,n}^{3}f_nw_n, \tag*{(9)}
M400neq=∑n=1Nvcx,n4fnwn−3ρT2.(10)M_{400}^{\mathrm{neq}}=\sum_{n=1}^{N_v}c_{x,n}^{4}f_nw_n-3\rho T^2. \tag*{(10)}

Here ii and jj denote Cartesian components and δij\delta_{ij} is the Kronecker delta. Equation (7) is the traceless part of the pressure tensor, Eq. (8) the heat flux, and Eq. (9) the streamwise skewness. In Eq. (10) the equilibrium value 3ρT23\rho T^2 is subtracted, so that errors of the fourth moment are measured against its nonequilibrium part.

Normal shocks

The reference problem is the stationary monatomic normal shock, computed at nine upstream Mach numbers between 1.5 and 12. The single-state tests of the 512-kernel representation in § 5.3 use Mach 3 (M3) and Mach 5 (M5). Shock variables are nondimensionalised by the upstream state, denoted by subscript 1; velocities are scaled by the upstream thermal speed c1=T1c_1 = \sqrt{T_1}, so heat flux, stress, and the third- and fourth-order moments are reported in units of ρ1c13\rho_1 c_1^3, ρ1c12\rho_1 c_1^2, ρ1c13\rho_1 c_1^3, and ρ1c14\rho_1 c_1^4, respectively. The plotted coordinate is x/λ1=x∗/Kneffx/\lambda_1 = x^*/\mathrm{Kn}_{\mathrm{eff}}, where x∗∈[−1/2,1/2]x^* \in[-1/2,1/2] is the solver coordinate, λ1\lambda_1 is the upstream mean free path, and Kneff=λ1/L\mathrm{Kn}_{\mathrm{eff}} = \lambda_1/L is the effective Knudsen number based on the domain length LL. Rankine–Hugoniot (RH) states are imposed at the domain boundaries. The M3 reference contains 1800 grid points in xx and 64,009 velocity nodes arranged as 121×23×23121 \times23 \times23; the M5 reference contains 2200 grid points in xx and 102,789 velocity nodes arranged as 141×27×27141 \times27 \times27. Their distributions contain approximately 1.15×1081.15 \times10^8 and 2.26×1082.26 \times10^8 scalar values.

The two shocks differ in scale: the M3 transition is narrower, and the M5 profiles have larger ranges of downstream temperature and of the fourth moment. The reconstructions of both are summarised in § 5.3 and given in the supplementary material.

The parametric study uses nine independently converged BGK-DVM shocks at M=1.5M = 1.5, 2, 2.5, 3, 4, 5, 6, 8, and 12. Their physical grids contain 1400–4200 points and their velocity grids contain 35,017–270,725 nodes. Together the nine distributions contain 2.59×1092.59 \times10^9 values (10.36 GB in single precision). In each test one Mach number is withheld, and the model is fitted to the other eight solutions and evaluated on all nine. M3 and Mach 6 (M6) are interpolation tests, because the fitted Mach numbers lie on both sides of them; Mach 12 (M12) is an extrapolation test, because withholding it reduces the fitted interval from [1.5, 12] to [1.5, 8].

Convergence and internal verification

As summarised in Table 1, direct recomputation of ρ\rho, uxu_x, TT, qxq_x, and σxx\sigma_{xx} from the stored M3 and M5 distributions reproduces the archived profiles with maximum relative L2L_2 discrepancies below 1.4×10−61.4 \times10^{-6} and 9.4×10−79.4 \times10^{-7}, respectively.

References

  1. [2]Levermore, C. D. 1996 Moment closure hierarchies for kinetic theories. J. Stat. Phys. 83, 1021–1065. doi:10.1007/BF02179552.DOI
  2. [3]Mott-Smith, H. M. 1951 The solution of the Boltzmann equation for a shock wave. Phys. Rev. 82, 885–892. doi:10.1103/PhysRev.82.885.DOI
  3. [4]Roohi, E. 2026 Transport fidelity and domain of validity of compact Gaussian kinetic representations for rarefied flows. arXiv:2609.04606. arXivDOI:10.48550/arXiv.2609.04606.DOI
  4. [5]Torrilhon, M. & Struchtrup, H. 2004 Regularized 13-moment equations: Shock structure calculations and comparison to Burnett models. J. Fluid Mech. 513, 171–198. doi:10.1017/S0022112004009917.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_9jy536yn
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents