betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Phonon Dispersion Relation in Weakly Coupled Bose Gas Beyond Bogoliubov Approximation

Abstract

We study the quasiparticle dispersion relation for a homogeneous Bose gas in a large cubic box with periodic boundary conditions at zero temperature. Inspired by the Bogoliubov method, we rearrange the usual Bose gas Hamiltonian in a form adapted to perturbation theory in the weak-coupling regime, both in the canonical and grand-canonical setting. We compute the first non-trivial corrections to the dispersion relation in both settings. We show that for small momenta they are linear in the absolute value of the momentum. Thus, in this approximation phonons have a well-defined velocity, which we compute.

Introduction

Modern developments in the theory of Bose gases largely depend on the original argument proposed by Bogoliubov in 1947 [8]. Within his approach, the Bose gas is approximated by a gas of non-interacting quasiparticles, whose dispersion relation is given by the famous formula1

ωbg(k)≡ωbg(k,ν):=∣k∣44+v^(k)v^(0)∣k∣2.(1)\omega_{\mathrm{bg}}(\mathbf{k}) \equiv\omega_{\mathrm{bg}}(\mathbf{k},\nu) := \sqrt{\frac{|\mathbf{k}|^4}{4}+\frac{\widehat{v}(\mathbf{k})}{\widehat{v}(0)}|\mathbf{k}|^2}. \tag*{(1)}

Here, v^(k)\widehat{v}(\mathbf{k}) is the Fourier transform of the interaction potential v(x)v(\mathbf{x}) and ν\nu is the parameter involved in the so-called “c-number substitution”. (1) predicts a linear dispersion relation for phonons, quasiparticles with low momentum ∣k∣|\mathbf{k}|. For larger momenta, for some shapes of v^\widehat{v}, we have a local maximum and next a local minimum—traditionally the corresponding quasiparticles are called maxons, resp. rotons. It is remarkable that this picture, at least qualitatively, is validated by experiments with 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} [31, 13] and alkali gases [53]. Neutron scattering (for larger momenta) and sound propagation (for small momenta) in 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} allow us to measure its quasiparticle dispersion relation, which turns out to be a rather well-defined curve similar to its theoretical prediction. Experiments show that this relation is remarkably sharp. In 4He{}^{4}\mathrm{He} we even see maxons and rotons; in alkali gases they are typically absent.

In the strict Bogoliubov approximation the quasiparticle dispersion relation has a precise mathematical meaning: the Bogoliubov Hamiltonian can be understood as a system of independent harmonic oscillators with energy described by (1). The Bogoliubov Hamiltonian has a well-defined thermodynamic limit, and in this limit k↦ωbg(k)\mathbf{k} \mapsto\omega_{\mathrm{bg}}(\mathbf{k}) describes a singular shell in the energy-momentum spectrum.

Clearly, the dispersion relation (1) is only an approximation to the true one. Mathematically, this is due to two factors:

  1. To obtain the Bogoliubov Hamiltonian one needs to discard various terms from the full Hamiltonian.

  2. It is not obvious how to fix the parameter ν\nu, which appears in the Bogoliubov dispersion relation.

In our paper we compute leading corrections to the dispersion relation for weak potentials. More precisely, we replace vv with κv\kappa v, obtaining a perturbative expansion of the energy correction with the small parameter κ\sqrt{\kappa}. We compute the lowest order correction, which has the order κ1/4\kappa^{1/4}. We prove that for low momenta this correction is asymptotically linear. Thus in this approximation phonons have a well defined velocity, which we compute.

The first problem that we encounter is the definition of the dispersion relation itself. For the full system in finite volume it is ill defined—it is expected to emerge only in thermodynamic limit. Unfortunately, we do not know how to interpret the full NN-body Hamiltonian in thermodynamic limit if we keep the density positive. In the traditional approach of theoretical physics this problem is resolved by considering the Hamiltonian in a finite box of size LL with periodic boundary conditions. Then one considers its Green functions (time-ordered correlation functions of some observables) and takes their limit as L→∞L \to\infty. One expects to see the quasiparticle dispersion relation in singularities of the Green functions analytically continued in energy-momentum. This approach was pioneered by Beliaev [1, 2], who computed the correction to the dispersion relation in the dilute limit.

In our paper we do not introduce Green functions. Instead, we consider the lowest order perturbation theory for one-quasiparticle states in fixed momentum sectors in thermodynamic limit. As explained in [23], this is consistent with the approach based on Green functions.

Already in the lowest nontrivial order of perturbation theory the shift in the dispersion relation has a small nonzero imaginary contribution. Thus quasiparticles are unstable, and the measured dispersion relation should have a nonzero breadth. The imaginary shift of the dispersion relation was first computed by Beliaev in [2], and recently confirmed by one of the authors (JD), Napiórkowski and Ben Li [21].

In this paper we are interested in the real part of the shift of dispersion relation. We will consider it in two settings: canonical and grand-canonical. We will treat the canonical setting as the main one of our paper, even though computations in the grand-canonical setting seem to be cleaner. However, interestingly, the final result is simpler in the canonical setting.

In the canonical formalism, we fix the density nn and we consider a sequence of systems with n=lim⁡L→∞NLdn = \lim_{L \to\infty} \frac{N}{L^d}, where N=N(L)N = N(L) is the number of particles and LdL^d is the volume of the box with periodic boundary conditions. The parameter in the initial Bogoliubov approximation is taken to be

ν=κnv^(0)=κlim⁡L→+∞Nv^(0)Ld.(2)\nu= \kappa n \hat{v}(0) = \kappa\lim_{L \to+\infty} \frac{N\hat{v}(0)}{L^d}. \tag*{(2)}

In the grand canonical formalism, the number operator NLN^L is not a constant times the identity, and the main parameter is μ\mu, the chemical potential. In the Bogoliubov Hamiltonian the role of the parameter ν\nu is taken by μ0\mu_0 defined as

μ0=κn0,bgv^(0)=κ⟨N0Ld⟩bgv^(0),(3)\mu_0 = \kappa n_{0,\mathrm{bg}}\hat{v}(0) = \kappa\left\langle\frac{N_0}{L^d} \right\rangle_{\mathrm{bg}} \hat{v}(0), \tag*{(3)}

where ⟨⋅⟩bg\langle\cdot\rangle_{\mathrm{bg}} is the mean value in the Bogoliubov vacuum and N0N_0 is the zero-mode number operator. In order to compare the two approaches we use the identification

ν=κnbgv^(0)=κ⟨NLLd⟩bgv^(0).(4)\nu= \kappa n_{\mathrm{bg}}\hat{v}(0) = \kappa\left\langle\frac{N^L}{L^d} \right\rangle_{\mathrm{bg}} \hat{v}(0). \tag*{(4)}

The chemical potential μ\mu can be approximately computed from μ0\mu_0. Thus we have three distinct parameters: ν\nu, μ\mu, μ0\mu_0: they have the same leading value, but differ by a term of order κ\kappa.

One of the essential ingredients in Bogoliubov’s paper is the following idea. When we decompose the total number of particles into the zero-mode and excited modes

NL=N0+N>,N>=∑p≠0ap∗ap,N^L = N_0 + N^{>} , \qquad N^{>} = \sum_{p \ne0} a_p^* a_p,

we expect that N0N_0 is macroscopic, whereas N>N^{>} is of lower order. Following the paper of Bogoliubov, this is usually implemented by using the c-number substitution, where the zero-mode operators a0a_0, a0∗a_0^* are replaced by the operator N0\sqrt{N_0}, which is then taken to be approximately constant. This procedure is based on the idea that, if the gas is in a condensate state, the zero-mode should be macroscopically occupied, and commutators involving a0a_0, a0∗a_0^* should be negligible in the thermodynamic limit N,Ld→+∞N, L^d \to+\infty. In our paper we never use a direct cc-number substitution. Instead, we treat the Bogoliubov Hamiltonian as the unperturbed part of the full Hamiltonian. This is done in a different way in the canonical and grand-canonical settings.

In our analysis we impose appropriate regularity hypotheses on the interaction potential vv and the parameter ν\nu, see Assumptions 2.1 and 3.1. Besides, when we justify discarding some terms from the Hamiltonian in the canonical setting we assume the positivity of the condensate density n0,bg>0n_{0,\mathrm{bg}}>0, (which holds automatically for a small coupling constant κ\kappa) see Assumption 2.3.

Let us sketch our computations of the correction to the dispersion relation in the canonical setting.

  1. First we embed the physical space with exactly NN particles in a larger space where the zero-mode is allowed to take negative values. This trick goes back to Arnowitt and Girardeau [29]; see also Takano [52]. By separating the zero-mode, one identifies the NN-particle space with a truncated Fock space of excitations. This approach was used by Dereziński and Napíorkowski [22], and in a closely related form by Lewin, Nam, Serfaty, and Solovej [39]. It allows us to use the formalism of 2nd quantization and Fock spaces.

  1. We decompose the finite-volume interaction into its diagonal and off-diagonal parts, VdiagV_{\mathrm{diag}} and VoffV_{\mathrm{off}}; see § 2.3 and § 2.5. The diagonal part depends on the zero mode only through N0N_0, whereas the off-diagonal part contains a0a_0 and a0∗a_0^* separately. We treat the latter using the extended-space formalism of § 2.4, obtaining

HL=HbgL+κH3L+κH2L+κ∑i=13H4,iL+κκH3,xL(5)H^L=H_{\mathrm{bg}}^L+\sqrt{\kappa}H_3^L+\kappa H_2^L+\kappa\sum_{i=1}^{3}H_{4,i}^L+\kappa\sqrt{\kappa}H_{3,x}^L \tag*{(5)}
+κR4,1L+κR4,2L.(6)+\kappa R_{4,1}^L+\kappa R_{4,2}^L. \tag*{(6)}

Here κ\kappa is introduced by rescaling v^→κv^\hat v\to\kappa\hat v while keeping ν\nu fixed. The operators HbgLH_{\mathrm{bg}}^L, H2LH_2^L, H3LH_3^L, and H4,iLH_{4,i}^L are independent of κ\kappa; H3,xLH_{3,x}^L retains a further κ\kappa-dependence. Apart from the remainders R4,iLR_{4,i}^L, these operators act on the excitation Fock space, made over the space of nonzero modes.

  1. A Bogoliubov transformation diagonalizes the quadratic Bogoliubov Hamiltonian HbgLH_{\mathrm{bg}}^L. Its ground state is Ωbg\Omega_{\mathrm{bg}}, and its one-quasiparticle states bk∗Ωbgb_k^*\Omega_{\mathrm{bg}} have excitation energy ωbg(k)\omega_{\mathrm{bg}}(\mathbf{k}).

We use HbgLH_{\mathrm{bg}}^L as the unperturbed Hamiltonian in the Rayleigh–Schrödinger perturbation theory [49 Chap. XII]. At the first nontrivial order, κ\kappa, the dispersion correction consists of two contributions: The quartic terms gives the Hellmann–Feynman term

δ4can,L(k,ν,v^):=(bk∗Ωbg∣H4Lbk∗Ωbg)−(Ωbg∣H4LΩbg)=(Ωbg∣[bk,[H4L,bk∗]]∣Ωbg).(7)\begin{aligned} \delta_4^{\mathrm{can},L}(\mathbf{k},\nu,\hat v):=(b_k^*\Omega_{\mathrm{bg}}|H_4^L b_k^*\Omega_{\mathrm{bg}})-(\Omega_{\mathrm{bg}}|H_4^L\Omega_{\mathrm{bg}}) \\ &=(\Omega_{\mathrm{bg}}|[b_k,[H_4^L,b_k^*]]|\Omega_{\mathrm{bg}}). \tag*{(7)} \end{aligned}

Subtracting the ground-state correction removes the common extensive contribution. In the thermodynamic limit, we set

δ4can(k,ν,v^):=lim⁡L→+∞δ4can,L(k,ν,v^).(8)\delta_4^{\mathrm{can}}(\mathbf{k},\nu,\hat v):=\lim_{L\to+\infty}\delta_4^{\mathrm{can},L}(\mathbf{k},\nu,\hat v). \tag*{(8)}

The cubic term yields the Fermi golden rule contribution. It has a real and imaginary part. Its imaginary part was computed in [23]; here we study

δ3can(k,ν,v^):=lim⁡ϵ↓0lim⁡L→∞δ3can,L(k,ν,v^,ϵ),(9)\delta^{\mathrm{can}}_3(\mathbf{k},\nu,\hat{v}) := \lim_{\epsilon\downarrow0}\lim_{L\to\infty}\delta^{\mathrm{can},L}_3(\mathbf{k},\nu,\hat{v},\epsilon), \tag*{(9)}

References

  1. [1]Beliaev, S. T., Application of the methods of quantum field theory to a system of bosons. Sov. Phys. JETP 7, 289–299 (1958) [Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 34, 417–432 (1958)].
  2. [2]Beliaev, S. T., Energy-spectrum of a non-ideal Bose gas. Sov. Phys. JETP 7, 299–307 (1958) [Zh. Eksp. Teor. Fiz. 34, 433–446 (1958)].
  3. [3]Benfatto, G., Renormalization group approach to zero temperature Bose condensation. In Rivasseau, V. (ed.), Constructive Physics: Results in Field Theory, Statistical Mechanics and Condensed Matter Physics, Lecture Notes in Physics 446, 219–247. Springer (1995).DOI
  4. [4]Benfatto, G., Renormalization group approach to zero temperature Bose condensation. Math. Phys. Electron. J. 2, 3 (1996).
  5. [5]Benfatto, G., Gallavotti, G., Renormalization Group. Physics Notes, Princeton Univ. Press (1995).
  6. [6]Boccato, C., Brennecke, C., Cenatiempo, S., Schlein, B., Bogoliubov theory in the Gross–Pitaevskii limit. Acta Math. 222, 219–335 (2019).arxiv.org/abs/1801.01389
  7. [8]Bogoliubov, N. N., On the theory of superfluidity. J. Phys. (USSR) 11, 23–32 (1947).
  8. [9]Boßmann, L., Petrat, S., Seiringer, R., Asymptotic expansion of low-energy excitations for weakly interacting bosons. Forum Math. Sigma 9, e28 (2021).
  9. [10]Brennecke, C., Caporaletti, M., Schlein, B., Excitation spectrum of Bose gases beyond the Gross–Pitaevskii regime. Rev. Math. Phys. 34, 2250027 (2022).DOI
  10. [11]Brennecke, C., Schlein, B., Schraven, S., Bogoliubov theory for trapped bosons in the Gross–Pitaevskii regime. Ann. Henri Poincaré 23, 1583–1658 (2022).
  11. [13]Bryan, M. S., Sokol, P. E., Maxon and roton measurements in nanoconfined 4He. Phys. Rev. B 97, 184511 (2018).DOI
  12. [14]Buchholz, D., The resolvent algebra of non-relativistic Bose fields: sectors, morphisms, fields and dynamics. Commun. Math. Phys. 375, 1159–1199 (2020).arxiv.org/abs/1807.07885
  13. [15]Buchholz, D., Yngvason, J., Many-body physics and resolvent algebras. J. Math. Phys. 66, 051902 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2411.04737
  14. [16]Caraci, C., Olgiati, A., Saint Aubin, D., Schlein, B., Third order corrections to the ground state energy of a Bose gas in the Gross–Pitaevskii regime. Commun. Math. Phys. 406, 153 (2025).DOI
  15. [17]Cornean, H. D., Dereziński, J., Ziń, P., On the infimum of the energy–momentum spectrum of a homogeneous Bose gas. J. Math. Phys. 50, 062103 (2009).arxiv.org/abs/math-ph/0511007
  16. [21]Dereziński, J., Li, B., Napiórkowski, M., Beliaev damping in Bose gas. J. Stat. Phys. 191, 110 (2024).DOI
  17. [22]Dereziński, J., Napiórkowski, M., Excitation spectrum of interacting bosons in the mean-field infinite-volume limit. Ann. Henri Poincaré 15, 2409–2439 (2014).DOI
  18. [23]Dereziński, J., Pettinari, L., Damping of phonons in Bose gas at low temperatures. arXiv:2602.07701 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2602.07701
  19. [25]Galanda, S., Pinamonti, N., Equilibrium states for non relativistic Bose gases with condensation. arXiv:2509.25101 (2025).arxiv.org/abs/2509.25101
  20. [26]Galanda, S., Pinamonti, N., Equilibrium states for non relativistic Bose gases and the Gross–Pitaevskii limit. arXiv:2606.25775 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2606.25775
  21. [27]Gavoret, J., Nozières, P., Structure of the perturbation expansion for the Bose liquid at zero temperature. Ann. Phys. 28, 349–399 (1964).DOI
  22. [29]Girardeau, M., Arnowitt, R., Theory of many-boson systems: pair theory. Phys. Rev. 113, 755–761 (1959).DOI
  23. [30]L. Erdős, B. Schlein and H.-T. Yau, Ground-state energy of a low-density Bose gas: A second-order upper bound, Phys. Rev. A 78, 053627 (2008).DOI
  24. [31]Godfrin, H., Beauvois, K., Sultan, A., Krotscheck, E., Dawidowski, J., Fåk, B., Ollivier, J., Dispersion relation of Landau elementary excitations and thermodynamic properties of superfluid 4He. Phys. Rev. B 103, 104516 (2021).DOI
  25. [32]Grech, P., Seiringer, R., The excitation spectrum for weakly interacting bosons in a trap. Commun. Math. Phys. 322, 559–591 (2013).DOI
  26. [35]Hugenholtz, N. M., Pines, D., Ground-state energy and excitation spectrum of a system of interacting bosons. Phys. Rev. 116, 489–506 (1959).DOI
  27. [38]Lee, T. D., Yang, C. N., Low-temperature behavior of a dilute Bose system of hard spheres. I. Equilibrium properties. Phys. Rev. 112, 1419–1429 (1958).
  28. [39]Lewin, M., Nam, P. T., Serfaty, S., Solovej, J. P., Bogoliubov spectrum of interacting Bose gases. Commun. Pure Appl. Math. 68, 413–471 (2015).arxiv.org/abs/1211.2778
  29. [42]Mohling, F., Morita, M., Temperature dependence of the low-momentum excitations in a Bose gas of hard spheres. Phys. Rev. 120, 681–688 (1960).
  30. [43]Mohling, F., Sirlin, A., Low-lying excitations in a Bose gas of hard spheres. Phys. Rev. 118, 370–378 (1960).DOI
  31. [44]Nam, P. T., Napiórkowski, M., Norm approximation for many-body quantum dynamics and Bogoliubov theory. In Michelangeli, A., Dell’Antonio, G. (eds.), Advances in Quantum Mechanics: Contemporary Trends and Open Problems, Springer INdAM Series 18, 223–238. Springer (2017).arxiv.org/abs/1611.03961
  32. [46]Nam, P. T., Seiringer, R., Collective excitations of Bose gases in the mean-field regime. Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 215, 381–417 (2015).arxiv.org/abs/1402.1153
  33. [47]Nam, P. T., Triay, A., Bogoliubov excitation spectrum of trapped Bose gases in the Gross–Pitaevskii regime. J. Math. Pures Appl. 176, 18–101 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2106.11949
  34. [49]Reed, M., Simon, B., Methods of Modern Mathematical Physics, Vol. IV: Analysis of Operators. Academic Press (1978).
  35. [50]Seiringer, R., The excitation spectrum for weakly interacting bosons. Commun. Math. Phys. 306, 565–578 (2011).
  36. [51]Shi, H., Griffin, A., Finite-temperature excitations in a dilute Bose-condensed gas. Phys. Rep. 304, 1–87 (1998).DOI
  37. [52]Takano, F., Excitation spectrum in many-boson systems. Phys. Rev. 123, 699–705 (1961).DOI
  38. [53]Vogels, J. M., Xu, K., Raman, C., Abo-Shaeer, J. R., Ketterle, W., Experimental observation of the Bogoliubov transformation for a Bose–Einstein condensated gas. Phys. Rev. Lett. 88, 060402 (2002).
  39. [54]Wu, T. T., Ground state of a Bose system of hard spheres. Phys. Rev. 115, 1390–1404 (1959).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_9s7rjq3n
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 1

downloads · 2

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents