betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

BESIII X(3790)X(3790) enhancement as a reflection of higher charmed mesons

Abstract

In this work, we show that the X(3790)X(3790) reported by the BESIII Collaboration is unlikely to be a genuine resonance, a conclusion that follows from the incompleteness of the BESIII experimental analysis. Although BESIII included the established charmed mesons that couple to DπDπ, as listed by the Particle Data Group, and incorporated their reflections in the D0D−D^0D^- invariant mass spectrum, this fit to the experimental data does not exhaust the charmed mesons that can contribute to the D0D−D^0D^- invariant mass spectrum through reflections, as can be explicitly seen from a theoretical charmed-meson spectroscopy. We find that a predicted charmed meson, either D(3 3S1)D(3\,{}^3S_1) or D(2 3D1)D(2\,{}^3D_1), can play a crucial role in mimicking the X(3790)X(3790) structure through the corresponding reflection. This warrants caution in interpreting the X(3790)X(3790) as a genuine resonance. Moreover, such an interpretation is not supported by most theoretical studies of DDˉD\bar{D} hadronic molecules and compact ccˉduˉc\bar{c}d\bar{u} tetraquarks currently available.

Introduction

Electron–positron annihilation into open-charm final states is an ideal platform to probe hadron spectroscopy [1, 2]. Very recently, a charged charmoniumlike enhancement, denoted as X(3790)X(3790), was reported by the BESIII Collaboration in e+e−→D0D−π+e^{+}e^{-}\to D^{0}D^{-}\pi^{+}, based on an analysis of a data sample of 1667 pb−1^{-1} collected at the collision energy W=4.682W=4.682 GeV [3]. Since its mass measured by a Flatté parameterization [4] is 3794.7±6.0±8.73794.7\pm6.0\pm8.7 MeV and its quantum numbers are determined to be JP=1−J^{P}=1^{-}, it is natural to conjecture whether this enhancement could be an exotic hidden-charm hadronic state. In fact, such an assignment is not supported by current theoretical studies of DDˉD\bar{D} molecular states and compact ccˉddˉc\bar{c}d\bar{d} tetraquarks [5, 6, 7, 8]. The reported X(3790)X(3790) is hard to assign to exotic hadronic states like a molecular or tetraquark state.

Faced with this situation, we should reexamine the details of the analysis performed by BESIII. In their analysis, they considered several excited charmed meson contributions (e.g., D1∗(2600)D_{1}^{*}(2600), D1∗(2760)D_{1}^{*}(2760), and D3∗(2750)D_{3}^{*}(2750)) in the DπD\pi invariant mass spectrum and evaluated their kinematic reflections into the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} invariant mass spectrum [3]. BESIII found that the enhancement near 3790 MeV in the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} invariant mass spectrum cannot be described by these reflections alone. Thus, they introduced an additional X(3790)X(3790) contribution in their fit. This is the logic behind the announcement of this new observation.

The experimental charmed meson spectrum remains incomplete [9], so a reflection test should also examine the higher excitations predicted by spectroscopy [10, 11].

In fact, the Lanzhou group noticed this effect in their studies of the reported charmoniumlike structures Zc(3885)Z_{c}(3885) and Zc(4025)Z_{c}(4025). They used reflections to describe these enhancements, with the off-shell D1(2420)D_{1}(2420) contributing to DDˉ∗πD\bar{D}^{*}\pi and D∗Dˉ∗πD^{*}\bar{D}^{*}\pi, including interference with a nonpeaking amplitude [12]. Moreover, the dependence of these enhancements on collision energy follows from the position of the resonance band relative to the Dalitz plot boundary [13]. The same approach was applied to Zcs(3985)Z_{cs}(3985) via the chain Y(4660)→Ds∗−Ds2∗(2573)+→Ds∗−D0K+Y(4660)\to D_{s}^{*-}D_{s2}^{*}(2573)^{+}\to D_{s}^{*-}D^{0}K^{+}, where a combined description of the kaon recoil spectra at five energies gives a pronounced enhancement near the Ds∗Ds2∗(2573)D_{s}^{*}D_{s2}^{*}(2573) threshold [14].

In this work, we propose that the reported X(3790)X(3790) enhancement can be due to an incomplete experimental analysis. Therefore, the X(3790)X(3790) is unlikely to be a genuine resonance. To illustrate this point, we first present the whole spectroscopy of charmed mesons obtained from a potential model and compare it with the charmed mesons collected by the Particle Data Group (PDG) [10]. This comparison shows that the charmed mesons adopted in the BESIII analysis are only a subset of the predicted charmed mesons allowed to couple to DπD\pi. When the 3 3S13\,{}^{3}S_{1} and 2 3D12\,{}^{3}D_{1} charmed-meson states (in the n 2S+1LJn\,{}^{2S+1}L_{J} notation, both with JP=1−J^{P}=1^{-}), which are not included in the BESIII analysis, are taken into account, we find that their reflections can play a crucial role in mimicking the X(3790)X(3790) enhancement in the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} invariant mass spectrum. Detailed analyses are presented in the following sections.

This paper is organized as follows. After the introduction, we present the complete charmed meson spectrum and illustrate how to select the allowed charmed mesons that contribute to the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} invariant mass spectrum through reflections (see Sec. II). In § 3, we introduce the analysis framework and present the final fit results for the three invariant mass spectra of e+e−→D0D−π+e^{+}e^{-}\to D^{0}D^{-}\pi^{+}. This study supports the scenario that the X(3790)X(3790) is not a genuine resonance. Finally, we end with a short summary.

Charmed meson spectroscopy and selection of charmed mesons for the analysis

To understand whether reflections can account for X(3790)X(3790), we first need a sufficiently complete picture of the charmed mesons that may contribute to e+e−→D0D−π+e^+e^- \to D^0D^-\pi^+. Their masses and decay properties determine which DπD\pi contributions should be considered and how they may affect the D0D−D^0D^- invariant mass spectrum. This motivates a study of the excited charmed meson spectrum beyond the established states already included in the experimental analysis.

StateMMΓsel±\Gamma_{\mathrm{sel}}^{\pm}Γsel0\Gamma_{\mathrm{sel}}^{0}BDπ±B_{D\pi}^{\pm}BDπ0B_{D\pi}^{0}
1S0^{1}S_{0}2021.020.090.09100.00100.00
3P2^{3}P_{2}2468.1811.8111.8169.3269.32
3D3^{3}D_{3}2778.9517.0317.0345.0345.01
3D1^{3}D_{1}2761.79367.80367.9621.4821.47
2S1^{2}S_{1}2592.9543.1043.1321.3721.36
3S1⋆^{3}S_{1}^{\star}3014.8289.0089.0812.6412.63
2D1⋆^{2}D_{1}^{\star}3130.59325.43325.4811.5011.50
3D3^{3}D_{3}3129.5044.3444.357.237.22
3F2^{3}F_{2}3053.48401.40401.785.865.86

Table 1. Theoretical masses MM and summed two-body widths Γsel\Gamma_{\mathrm{sel}} (MeV), and inclusive DπD\pi branching fractions BDπB_{D\pi} (%). Superscripts ±\pm and 00 denote charged and neutral parents, respectively; charge-conjugate states have equal values. Stars mark the additional states used in the fits. Calculation details are given in Appendix A.

We therefore calculate radial and orbital charmed meson excitations with the Modified Godfrey–Isgur (MGI) model [11, 15]. As shown in Figure 1, the model gives a good overall description of the masses of established charmed mesons and predicts additional states that have not yet been established experimentally [10, 11]. We then calculate their two-body strong decays using the MGI radial wave functions and the Quark Pair Creation (QPC) model, restricting the channels to those allowed by the Okubo–Zweig–Iizuka (OZI) rule [11, 16, 17, 18]. The model inputs and conventions are given in Appendix § 3.1. Together, these calculations allow us to assess which additional states may contribute to the measured DπD\pi invariant mass spectrum.

Figure 1. Theoretical charmed meson mass spectrum for J≤3J \le3. Blue and orange lines denote states that can decay to DπD\pi, with and without adopted PDG counterparts, respectively; purple and green lines denote the corresponding states for which this decay is forbidden [10]. Circles mark the five families included by BESIII [3], and stars indicate the two additional candidates considered here (Table I). The spectroscopic labels give the dominant n2S+1LJn^{2S+1}L_J component. †: a 0+0^+ state can decay to DπD\pi but cannot be produced with a pseudoscalar DD from a 1−1^- source.

Figure 1 shows that experimental information on the charmed meson spectrum remains sparse above about 2.8 GeV. BESIII has included the established D∗D^*, D2∗(2460)D_2^*(2460), D1∗(2600)D_1^*(2600), D1∗(2760)D_1^*(2760), and D3∗(2750)D_3^*(2750) states, and their charge partners [3], but further states predicted by the model can also couple to DπD\pi. Their possible reflections should therefore be examined. At W=4.682W = 4.682 GeV, the largest accessible DπD\pi mass is W−mD≃2.81W - m_D \simeq2.81–2.822.82 GeV, where mDm_D is the spectator mass. The predicted excitations around 3.0–3.2 GeV lie above these endpoints, so any contribution from them enters through off-shell tails. These tails can interfere with the lower-state and non-resonant amplitudes and thereby affect the D0D−D^0D^- distribution. Whether they can account for the near-threshold enhancement must be tested with the full coherent amplitude.

We next consider which of these states are most promising, taking into account their quantum numbers, DπD\pi branching fractions, and production partial waves. A state that decays to DπD\pi and is produced with a pseudoscalar DD from a 1−1^- source must have natural parity and J≥1J \ge1 [19, 20]. Table I lists the masses and widths of the leading allowed candidates in order of their inclusive DπD\pi branching fractions. The five families included by BESIII occupy the first five places for both charges, supporting the experimental choice. Among the additional states listed, 33S13^{3}S_{1} and 23D12^{3}D_{1} have the largest DπD\pi branching fractions, approximately 12.64% and 11.50%, respectively. Their JP=1−J^{P}=1^{-} also allows them to be produced with the spectator DD in a relative PP-wave. In comparison, 23D32^{3}D_{3} and 13F21^{3}F_{2} have smaller DπD\pi branching fractions and require relative FF-wave and DD-wave production, respectively, with higher centrifugal barriers. These considerations favor 33S13^{3}S_{1} and 23D12^{3}D_{1} as the first additional states to investigate.

The preceding spectroscopy and decay analysis, together with the absence of an I=1I=1, JP=1−J^{P}=1^{-} charged hidden-charm candidate compatible with X(3790)X(3790) in the molecular and compact tetraquark calculations considered here [5, 6, 7, 8], motivates a further test of the reflection mechanism. Table II summarizes the three fit schemes, including nonresonant (NR) production.1 In the next section, we construct the corresponding amplitudes and fit the D0D−D^{0}D^{-}, D0π+D^{0}\pi^{+}, and D−π+D^{-}\pi^{+} spectra simultaneously. This allows us to test whether the additional contributions can explain X(3790)X(3790) through reflections without introducing an additional resonance in the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} channel.

SchemeCommon contributionsAdded state
Scheme I13S11^{3}S_{1}, 13P21^{3}P_{2}, 23S12^{3}S_{1}, 13D11^{3}D_{1}, 13D31^{3}D_{3}, NR33S13^{3}S_{1}
Scheme II13S11^{3}S_{1}, 13P21^{3}P_{2}, 23S12^{3}S_{1}, 13D11^{3}D_{1}, 13D31^{3}D_{3}, NR23D12^{3}D_{1}
Scheme III13S11^{3}S_{1}, 13P21^{3}P_{2}, 23S12^{3}S_{1}, 13D11^{3}D_{1}, 13D31^{3}D_{3}, NRX(3790)X(3790)

Table II. Fit schemes. Common contributions are identical in all three schemes. Charmed meson masses and widths are from Table I; mXm_X, gXg_X, and JPJ^P are from BESIII [3], while cXc_X is fitted.

Reflection Mechanism and Phenomenological Analysis

The framework of analysis

For D0(p1)D−(p2)π+(p3)D^{0}(p_{1})D^{-}(p_{2})\pi^{+}(p_{3}), let s=(p1+p2)2s=(p_{1}+p_{2})^{2}, t=(p1+p3)2t=(p_{1}+p_{3})^{2}, and u=(p2+p3)2u=(p_{2}+p_{3})^{2}, with s+t+u=W2+∑imi2s+t+u=W^{2}+\sum_i m_i^{2}, where mim_i are the final-state masses. For the selected R→DπR\to D\pi states, the DR+D R^{+} and D0Rˉ0D^{0}\bar R^{0} chains interfere coherently. Angular momentum and parity conservation select natural-parity J≥1J\ge1 states with Lprod=ℓdec=JL_{\rm prod}=\ell_{\rm dec}=J [19, 20]. We write the amplitude for a vector source as

AM=ϵM⋅(p1×p2)G(s,t,u),\mathcal{A}_{M}=\epsilon_{M}\cdot(p_{1}\times p_{2})G(s,t,u),
G(s,t,u)=cNR+∑RcR[fR,+(s,t)+fR,0ˉ(s,u)].(1)G(s,t,u)=c_{\rm NR}+\sum_{R}c_{R}[f_{R,+}(s,t)+f_{R,\bar{0}}(s,u)]. \tag*{(1)}

where ϵM\epsilon_M is the source polarization and momenta are in the overall center-of-mass frame. The vector product is the center-of-mass reduction of the parity-conserving Levi-Civita structure [21]. The fitted coefficients contain production strengths and strong phases; cNRc_{\rm NR} is constant. Sharing cRc_R between charge channels implements BESIII’s isospin constraint [3]. The plus sign follows our chain phase convention with a common normal vector.

Factoring out this common vector product gives our reduced spin-JJ amplitude,

fR,c(s,xc)=(pcqc)J−1PJ′(zc)BJ(pc)BJ(qc)xc−MR,c2+iMR,cΓR,c(xc).(2)f_{R,c}(s,x_c)=\frac{(p_cq_c)^{J-1}P'_J(z_c)\mathcal{B}_J(p_c)\mathcal{B}_J(q_c)}{x_c-M_{R,c}^{2}+iM_{R,c}\Gamma_{R,c}(\sqrt{x_c})}. \tag*{(2)}

where x+=tx_+=t and x0=ux_0=u. The momenta pcp_c and qcq_c describe production in the overall center-of-mass frame and decay in the resonance frame, respectively; zcz_c is the daughter-spectator angle cosine in the latter, and PJ′P'_J is a Legendre polynomial derivative. The barrier forms and radius rBr_B follow Refs. [22, 23, 24]. We use BJ(0)=1\mathcal{B}_J(0)=1, absorbing the constants from both vertices, and put the normalization and the JJ-dependent helicity sign into cRc_R [19, 20]. QPC partial widths determine ΓR(m)\Gamma_R(m) through Eq. (8).

Three-body phase space projection gives the spectra; for D0D−D^{0}D^{-} [10],

dσdm(D0D−)∝2m(D0D−)∫tmin⁡(s)tmax⁡(s)dt ∣p1×p2∣2∣G(s,t,u)∣2,(3)\frac{d\sigma}{dm(D^{0}D^{-})}\propto2m(D^{0}D^{-})\int_{t_{\min}(s)}^{t_{\max}(s)}dt\,|p_{1}\times p_{2}|^{2}|G(s,t,u)|^{2}, \tag*{(3)}

with analogous expressions for DπD\pi. The physical tt and uu intervals at each ss allow off-shell DπD\pi contributions to produce a reflected enhancement through interference. All projections include m(D0π+)>2.04m(D^{0}\pi^{+})>2.04 GeV.

In Scheme III, Eq. (1) includes cXfX(s)c_Xf_X(s), with [3, 4]

fX(s)=B1(pX)B1(qX)s−mX2+igXmXqX/s,(4)f_X(s)=\frac{\mathcal{B}_1(p_X)\mathcal{B}_1(q_X)}{s-m_X^2+ig_Xm_Xq_X/\sqrt{s}}, \tag*{(4)}

where pXp_X and qXq_X are the production and decay momenta in the overall center-of-mass and D0D−D^{0}D^{-} frames, respectively, and B1(k)=[1+(krB)2]−1/2\mathcal{B}_1(k)=[1+(kr_B)^2]^{-1/2}. We adopt BESIII’s Flatté form rather than the charged meson Breit–Wigner denominator [3].

All fits use the Npt=238N_{\rm pt}=238 points shown in the published spectra and fixed backgrounds. Shared complex coefficients and three independent spectrum normalizations leave 15 real parameters after fixing the overall amplitude scale and phase.

We compare the fits using the original experimental errors:

χI2=∑i∈I(Nipred−Niobsσiexp)2,(5)\chi_I^2=\sum_{i\in I}\left(\frac{N_i^{\rm pred}-N_i^{\rm obs}}{\sigma_i^{\rm exp}}\right)^2, \tag*{(5)}

where σiexp\sigma_i^{\rm exp} averages the reported upper and lower errors, and NipredN_i^{\rm pred} includes background. The sets Ifull\mathcal{I}_{\rm full} (all 79 D0D−D^{0}D^{-} points) and Iloc\mathcal{I}_{\rm loc} (13 points in 3.73≤m(D0D−)≤3.863.73\le m(D^{0}D^{-})\le3.86 GeV) define χfull2\chi_{\rm full}^{2} and χloc2\chi_{\rm loc}^{2}. Both are evaluated from the simultaneous fits, without refitting. The total χtot2=∑a=13χa2\chi_{\rm tot}^{2}=\sum_{a=1}^{3}\chi_a^{2} sums the three spectra, with χ12=χfull2\chi_1^{2}=\chi_{\rm full}^{2}.

The fitting results

Figure 2 shows that Schemes I and II reproduce the near-threshold enhancement while also describing the two DπD\pi spectra. Table III compares these results with Scheme III. The fitted coefficients are given in Appendix § 3.2.

Figure 2. Simultaneous fits to the D0D−D^{0}D^{-}, D0π+D^{0}\pi^{+}, and D−π+D^{-}\pi^{+} spectra (columns) in Scheme I (top row) and Scheme II (bottom row), defined in Table II. Blue curves show our fits including background; black points are the data. Red dashed curves show the BESIII fit with X(3790)X(3790), and gray areas indicate the experimental background [3].

Schemeχfull2\chi^2_{\mathrm{full}}χtot2\chi^2_{\mathrm{tot}}χloc2\chi^2_{\mathrm{loc}}
Scheme I140.64478.7038.04
Scheme II150.75483.0556.21
Scheme III139.96463.6545.01

Table III.

Table III. Comparison of χfull2\chi^2_{\mathrm{full}}, χtot2\chi^2_{\mathrm{tot}}, and χloc2\chi^2_{\mathrm{loc}} for the full D0D−D^{0}D^{-} spectrum (79 points), all three spectra (238 points), and the near-threshold interval shown in Figure 3 (13 points), respectively. All values use the original experimental errors. All three schemes include the five lower states and NR.

Figure 3. Comparison of the fits in the near-threshold D0D−D^{0}D^{-} region, including background. Blue, orange, and green curves show Schemes I, II, and III, respectively, and the red dotted curve is the BESIII fit [3]. Black points are the data with the reported errors.

The comparison in Table III shows that Schemes I and II give χfull2\chi^2_{\mathrm{full}} values close to that of Scheme III for the full D0D−D^{0}D^{-} spectrum. Their χtot2\chi^2_{\mathrm{tot}} values are somewhat larger when all three spectra are considered. All three fits have the same number of free parameters. The comparison indicates that the reflection mechanism can reproduce the enhancement while also describing the accompanying DπD\pi spectra. Figure 3 shows the near-threshold region in greater detail. Scheme I gives a smaller χloc2\chi^2_{\mathrm{loc}} than Scheme III, while Scheme II gives a somewhat larger value. In particular, the agreement in the near-threshold region obtained in Scheme I supports the possibility that coherent DπD\pi reflections can account for the reported line shape without an additional D0D−D^{0}D^{-} resonance.

These results support a reflection interpretation of X(3790)X(3790) based on the more complete theoretical charmed meson spectrum. Within this description, the off-shell DπD\pi contributions and their interference account for the enhancement without introducing an additional resonance in the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} channel. The comparable descriptions of the mass spectra motivate a comparison of angular distributions. We use the three fitted amplitudes to identify angular features that could distinguish the reflection and resonance interpretations in future measurements. We label the D0D−D^{0}D^{-}, D0π+D^{0}\pi^{+}, and D−π+D^{-}\pi^{+} rest frames by a=1,2,3a=1,2,3, respectively, and define θ1≡θD0D−\theta_1\equiv\theta_{D^{0}D^{-}}, θ2≡θD0π+\theta_2\equiv\theta_{D^{0}\pi^{+}}, and θ3≡θD−D0\theta_3\equiv\theta_{D^{-}D^{0}}. Here θAB\theta_{AB} is the angle between particles A and B in the corresponding frame. With the coefficients determined by the fits to the mass spectra, the angular distributions are [10, 25, 26]

Fa(z)=∫DdΦ3∣AM∣2δ(z−za)∫DdΦ3∣AM∣2,(6)F_a(z)=\frac{\int_{\mathcal{D}} \mathrm{d}\Phi_3 \lvert\mathcal{A}_M\rvert^2 \delta(z-z_a)}{\int_{\mathcal{D}} \mathrm{d}\Phi_3 \lvert\mathcal{A}_M\rvert^2}, \tag*{(6)}

where za=cos⁡θaz_a=\cos\theta_a, and the bar denotes the average over initial

spin states. The integration covers the full accessible phase space D\mathcal{D} subject to m(D0π+)>2.04m(D^{0}\pi^{+}) > 2.04 GeV. Each distribution Fa(z)=Nsig−1dNsig/dzF_a(z) = N_{\mathrm{sig}}^{-1}dN_{\mathrm{sig}}/dz is normalized to the total coherent signal, so that ∫−11Fa(z)dz=1\int_{-1}^{1} F_a(z)dz = 1. The calculation includes the five lower states, NR, the additional contribution, and all interference terms, but not the experimental background or detector acceptance.

The three schemes give similar angular distributions in Figure 4, with modest differences in the central region. In the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} frame, the distributions are approximately symmetric: Scheme I has the deepest central dip, Scheme II is flatter, and the distribution in Scheme III lies between them near cos⁡θπ+D0=0\cos\theta_{\pi^{+}D^{0}} = 0. Differences also appear in the DπD\pi frames. Resolving these features will require larger event samples and careful control of detector acceptance. Such measurements could help distinguish the reflection and resonance interpretations and complement the comparison of the mass spectra.

Figure 4. Normalized angular distributions obtained from the full coherent amplitudes of Schemes I, II, and III, with m(D0π+)>2.04m(D^{0}\pi^{+}) > 2.04 GeV. The panels correspond to the D0D−D^{0}D^{-}, D0π+D^{0}\pi^{+}, and D−π+D^{-}\pi^{+} rest frames. Colors follow Figure 3. Experimental background and detector acceptance are not included.

Measurements at different center-of-mass energies offer a complementary test, as suggested by earlier studies of ZcZ_c reflections [12, 13]. A change in collision energy shifts the Dalitz plot boundaries and changes the kinematic region contributing to the projection. The reflected line shape can therefore change with energy. An energy scan may help clarify the origin of X(3790)X(3790), while measurements in different DπD\pi mass intervals could further test the role of the crossed-channel contributions.

Summary

BESIII reported a charged X(3790)X(3790) enhancement in the spectrum of e+e−→D0D−π+e^{+}e^{-} \to D^{0}D^{-}\pi^{+} [3], but the molecular and compact tetraquark studies discussed above do not predict a compatible I=1I = 1, JP=1−J^{P} = 1^{-} candidate [5, 6, 7, 8]. The experimental fit introduced an X(3790)X(3790) resonance only after the reflections from the PDG-listed charmed mesons included in the fit failed to describe the enhancement [3]. This restricted set of charmed mesons omits higher excitations that can couple to DπD\pi [10, 11]. Together with earlier ZcZ_c and ZcsZ_{cs} reflection studies [12, 13, 14], these considerations motivate us to test whether a more complete charmed meson spectrum can explain the enhancement without an additional D0D−D^{0}D^{-} resonance.

To this end, we first constructed the charmed meson spectrum within a potential model and compared it with the states collected by the Particle Data Group [10]. This comparison shows that the charmed mesons adopted in the BESIII analysis constitute only a subset of the predicted charmed mesons allowed to couple to DπD\pi. In particular, the 3 3S13\,{}^{3}S_{1} and 2 3D12\,{}^{3}D_{1} states, both carrying JP=1−J^{P} = 1^{-} and both absent from the BESIII fit, can contribute to the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} invariant mass spectrum through their reflections.

Including these two states in the analysis framework, we performed a combined fit to the three invariant mass spectra of e+e−→D0D−π+e^{+}e^{-} \to D^{0}D^{-}\pi^{+} measured by BESIII [3]. The fit shows that the reflections of the 3 3S13\,{}^{3}S_{1} and 2 3D12\,{}^{3}D_{1} charmed mesons can play a crucial role in mimicking the X(3790)X(3790) enhancement in the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} invariant mass spectrum, without invoking an additional resonance. The resulting description of the data is consistent with the measured spectra, and the detailed fit results are presented in § 3.

These results warrant caution in interpreting the X(3790)X(3790) as a genuine resonance. The enhancement can be attributed to an incomplete experimental analysis, in which the restricted set of charmed mesons leaves out higher excitations that couple to DπD\pi and whose reflections populate the D0D−D^{0}D^{-} invariant mass spectrum. This conclusion is further supported by the fact that most theoretical studies of DDˉD\bar{D} hadronic molecules and compact ccˉqqˉc\bar{c}q\bar{q} tetraquarks do not predict a compatible candidate for the X(3790)X(3790) [5, 6, 7, 8]. A more complete charmed meson spectrum, as predicted by spectroscopy, should therefore be taken into account in future experimental analyses of this and similar enhancement structures.

Acknowledgments

This work is supported by the Natural Science Foundation of Gansu Province (Nos. 26JRCKA012 and 25JRRA799), the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant Nos. 12335001 and 12247101, the “111 Center” under Grant No. B20063, the Fundamental Research Funds for the Central Universities (lzujbky-2023-stlt01), and Lanzhou City High-Level Talent Funding. T.-L. G. is supported by the Gansu Province Postgraduate Innovation Star Program under Grant No. 2026CXZX-042. The authors used ChatGPT for language editing and for assistance with the numerical code, reviewed the output, and take responsibility for the content.

Model and decay inputs

Spectroscopic inputs

The MGI Hamiltonian, smearing and spin interactions follow Refs. [11, 15, 18], with the inputs in Table IV. Alternative MGI and GI parameter sets are discussed in Refs. [27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32]. We retain the 1LJ{}^{1}L_{J}–3LJ{}^{3}L_{J} spin-orbit mixing for J=LJ=L.

ParameterValueParameterValue
mu,dm_{u,d}0.22msm_s0.419
mcm_c1.628bb0.18 GeV2^2
cc−0.253μ\mu0.03
σ0\sigma_01.80s0s_01.55
ϵc\epsilon_c−0.168ϵt\epsilon_t0.025
ϵso(v)\epsilon_{\mathrm{so(v)}}−0.035ϵso(s)\epsilon_{\mathrm{so(s)}}0.055

Table IV. MGI parameters (GeV units where dimensional), with μ=0.03\mu=0.03 for DD and 0.02 for DsD_s [11, 18].

Screening describes unquenched effects phenomenologically, without explicit self-energy corrections from meson loops [2]. The mass calculation supplies the individual MGI eigenfunctions used for parent and heavy daughter mesons in the decay amplitudes. Their radial and orbital structure is retained in the spatial overlaps, keeping the masses and widths in Table I consistent with the adopted spectroscopy inputs.

The remaining inputs are (α1,α2,α3)=(0.25,0.15,0.20)(\alpha_1,\alpha_2,\alpha_3)=(0.25,0.15,0.20) and (γ1,γ2,γ3)=(1/2,10/2,1000/2)(\gamma_1,\gamma_2,\gamma_3)=(1/2,\sqrt{10}/2,\sqrt{1000}/2) GeV. Spatial overlaps use numerical MGI wave functions for DD and DsD_s. Light mesons use simple harmonic oscillator (SHO) wave functions with βeff=⟨p2⟩1S/3\beta_{\mathrm{eff}}=\sqrt{\langle p^2\rangle_{1S}/3} from GI momentum moments at μ=0\mu=0 [11, 15]; the nonstrange pseudoscalar and vector values are 0.77 and 0.45 GeV. Strong decays use theoretical heavy-meson masses and measured light-meson masses; the three-body fits use measured D0D^0, D−D^-, π+\pi^+ masses [10].

Strong decay widths

We use the QPC normalization of Refs. [11, 16, 17, 33], with γ=8.70\gamma=8.70, charge multiplicities and a rate factor 1/31/3 for ssˉs\bar{s} creation. The partial waves give

Γ(A→BC)=π2qMA2∑ℓ,S∣MℓS(q)∣2(7)\Gamma(A\to BC)=\frac{\pi^2q}{M_A^2}\sum_{\ell,S}\left|\mathcal{M}^{\ell S}(q)\right|^2 \tag*{(7)}

where qq is the two-body momentum and ℓ,S\ell,S are the daughter orbital angular momentum and total spin. Distinct partial waves add incoherently; mixed-state component amplitudes are combined before squaring.

All charge-conserving, OZI-allowed Da(π,η,η′,ρ,ω)D_a(\pi,\eta,\eta',\rho,\omega) and Ds,aK(∗)D_{s,a}K^{(*)} channels open at the theoretical parent mass are included, with MGI heavy daughters and all waves allowed by angular momentum and parity. Electromagnetic and multibody modes and broad-daughter convolutions are omitted.

For charge channels and partial waves labeled by α\alpha, let ΓR,c;α(0)\Gamma_{R,c;\alpha}^{(0)} be the QPC width at MR,cM_{R,c} and qα0=qα(MR,c)q_{\alpha0}=q_\alpha(M_{R,c}). Their sum is Γsel\Gamma_{\mathrm{sel}}; the inclusive DπD\pi branching fraction is the sum of the two DπD\pi charge-channel widths divided by Γsel\Gamma_{\mathrm{sel}}. We extrapolate using

ΓR,c(m)=∑αΓR,c;α(0)MR,cm[qα(m)qα0]2ℓα+1Bℓα2[qα(m)]Bℓα2(qα0)Θ(m−mα1−mα2),(8)\Gamma_{R,c}(m)=\sum_{\alpha}\Gamma_{R,c;\alpha}^{(0)}\frac{M_{R,c}}{m}\left[\frac{q_\alpha(m)}{q_{\alpha0}}\right]^{2\ell_\alpha+1}\frac{\mathcal{B}_{\ell_\alpha}^{2}[q_\alpha(m)]}{\mathcal{B}_{\ell_\alpha}^{2}(q_{\alpha0})}\Theta(m-m_{\alpha1}-m_{\alpha2}), \tag*{(8)}

where mα1,2m_{\alpha1,2} are daughter masses. Only phase space and barriers are continued: overlaps are not recalculated off shell, and this is not a complete unitary coupled-channel amplitude.

Fitted coefficients

Table V gives the coefficients for Schemes I–III. Here cRc_R is the cRc_R of Eq. (1) in the BJ(0)=1\mathcal{B}_J(0)=1 convention; the NR and X(3790)X(3790) coefficients are unaffected by the barrier rescaling. The overall amplitude scale and phase are conventional, and each spectrum has an independent normalization.

Contribution∣c∣|c|ϕ\phi (deg)Unit
Scheme I
1 3S11\,{}^{3}S_10.10−11.41GeV2^2
1 3P21\,{}^{3}P_21.252.251
2 3S12\,{}^{3}S_10.2193.90GeV2^2
1 3D11\,{}^{3}D_13.97122.42GeV2^2
1 3D31\,{}^{3}D_34.49−89.25GeV2^2
2 3S12\,{}^{3}S_111.4918.41GeV2^2
NR0.92119.601
Scheme II
1 3S11\,{}^{3}S_10.1031.33GeV2^2
1 3P21\,{}^{3}P_21.250.711
2 3S12\,{}^{3}S_10.2921.13GeV2^2
1 3D11\,{}^{3}D_19.80−69.51GeV2^2
1 3D31\,{}^{3}D_34.7646.76GeV2^2
2 3D12\,{}^{3}D_123.05172.26GeV2^2
NR0.72−157.851
Scheme III
1 3S11\,{}^{3}S_10.1080.44GeV2^2
1 3P21\,{}^{3}P_21.266.021
2 3S12\,{}^{3}S_10.4417.55GeV2^2
1 3D11\,{}^{3}D_18.80−83.47GeV2^2
1 3D31\,{}^{3}D_31.0240.97GeV2^2
X(3790)X(3790)8.0052.64GeV2^2
NR0.61−98.931

Table V. Coefficient moduli and phases ϕ=arg⁡c~\phi=\arg\tilde{c} (degrees), rounded to two decimal places. Unit 1 denotes dimensionless coefficients.

References

  1. [1]X.-F. Wang, X. Liu, and Y.-N. Gao, Colloquium: Hadron production in open-charm meson pairs at e⁺e⁻ colliders, Rev. Mod. Phys. 98, 021001 (2026).DOI
  2. [2]Z.-Y. Bai, D.-Y. Chen, Q. Huang, X. Liu, S.-Q. Luo, and J.-Z. Wang, Unquenched charmonium and beyond, Phys. Rept. 1204, 1 (2027).DOI
  3. [3]M. Ablikim et al. (BESIII), Observation of a Charged Charmoniumlike Structure in e⁺e⁻ → D⁰D⁻π⁺ + c.c. (2026), arXiv:2607.29138 [hep-ex].arxiv.org/abs/2607.29138
  4. [4]S. M. Flatté, Coupled-channel analysis of the ηπ and K\bar{K} systems near K\bar{K} threshold, Phys. Lett. B 63, 224 (1976).
  5. [5]J.-L. Lu, M. Song, P. Wang, J.-Y. Guo, G. Li, and X. Luo, The bound and resonant states of D⁽*⁾⁽±⁾ and D̄⁽*⁾⁽±⁾ with the complex scaling method, Eur. Phys. J. C 85, 920 (2025).
  6. [6]D. Ebert, R. N. Faustov, and V. O. Galkin, Excited heavy tetraquarks with hidden charm, Eur. Phys. J. C 58, 399 (2008).
  7. [7]Z.-G. Wang, Ground states and first radial excitations of vector tetraquark states with explicit P-waves via QCD sum rules, Chin. Phys. C 48, 103103 (2024).DOI
  8. [8]Z.-G. Wang, Analysis of the vector hidden-charm tetraquark states without explicit P-waves via the QCD sum rules, Nucl. Phys. B 973, 115592 (2021).DOI
  9. [9]H.-X. Chen, W. Chen, X. Liu, Y.-R. Liu, and S.-L. Zhu, A review of the open charm and open bottom systems, Rept. Prog. Phys. 80, 076201 (2017).DOI
  10. [10]S. Navas et al. (Particle Data Group), Review of particle physics, Phys. Rev. D 110, 030001 (2024).
  11. [11]Q.-T. Song, D.-Y. Chen, X. Liu, and T. Matsuki, Higher radial and orbital excitations in the charmed meson family, Phys. Rev. D 92, 074011 (2015).DOI
  12. [12]J.-Z. Wang, D.-Y. Chen, X. Liu, and T. Matsuki, Universal non-resonant explanation for charmoniumlike structures Zc(3885) and Zc(4025), Eur. Phys. J. C 80, 1040 (2020).
  13. [13]J.-Z. Wang, D.-Y. Chen, X. Liu, and T. Matsuki, Mapping a new cluster of charmoniumlike structures at e⁺e⁻ collisions, Phys. Lett. B 817, 136345 (2021).DOI
  14. [14]J.-Z. Wang, Q.-S. Zhou, X. Liu, and T. Matsuki, Toward charged Zcs(3985) structure under a reflection mechanism, Eur. Phys. J. C 81, 51 (2021).DOI
  15. [15]S. Godfrey and N. Isgur, Mesons in a Relativized Quark Model with Chromodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 32, 189 (1985).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9955999
  16. [16]A. Le Yaouanc, L. Oliver, O. Pene, and J. C. Raynal, Naive quark pair creation model of strong interaction vertices, Phys. Rev. D 8, 2223 (1973).
  17. [17]A. Le Yaouanc, L. Oliver, O. Pene, and J. C. Raynal, Naive quark pair creation model and baryon decays, Phys. Rev. D 9, 1415 (1974).
  18. [18]Q.-T. Song, D.-Y. Chen, X. Liu, and T. Matsuki, Charmed-strange mesons revisited: mass spectra and strong decays, Phys. Rev. D 91, 054031 (2015).
  19. [19]M. Jacob and G. C. Wick, On the General Theory of Collisions for Particles with Spin, Annals Phys. 7, 404 (1959).
  20. [20]S. U. Chung, A General formulation of covariant helicity coupling amplitudes, Phys. Rev. D 57, 431 (1998).DOI
  21. [21]M. Albaladejo et al. (JPAC), ω → 3π and ωπ⁰ transition form factor revisited, Eur. Phys. J. C 80, 1107 (2020).
  22. [22]F. Von Hippel and C. Quigg, Centrifugal-barrier effects in resonance partial decay widths, shapes, and production amplitudes, Phys. Rev. D 5, 624 (1972).
  23. [23]R. Aaij et al. (LHCb), Amplitude analysis of B⁻ → D⁺π⁺π⁻ decays, Phys. Rev. D 94, 072001 (2016).
  24. [24]M. Ablikim et al. (BESIII), Partial wave analysis of ψ(3686) → K⁺K⁻ηπ⁰, Phys. Rev. D 101, 032008 (2020).
  25. [25]S.-i. Nam and J. K. Ahn, Three-body decay ϕ → π⁺π⁻π⁰ with Omnès-type final-state interactions, Phys. Rev. D 114, 014022 (2026).DOI
  26. [26]C. S. Kim, S. C. Park, and D. Sahoo, Angular distribution as an effective probe of new physics in semihadronic three-body meson decays, Phys. Rev. D 100, 015005 (2019).DOI
  27. [27]J.-Z. Wang, D.-Y. Chen, X. Liu, and T. Matsuki, Constructing J/ψ family with updated data of charmoniumlike Y states, Phys. Rev. D 99, 114003 (2019).DOI
  28. [28]J.-Z. Wang, R.-Q. Qian, X. Liu, and T. Matsuki, Are the Y states around 4.6 GeV from e⁺e⁻ annihilation higher charmonia?, Phys. Rev. D 101, 034001 (2020).DOI
  29. [29]C.-X. Liu, Z.-L. Man, T.-L. Gao, and X. Liu, Prospects for observing the missing 2D and 1F charmonium states around 4 GeV, Phys. Rev. D 113, 074009 (2026).arxiv.org/abs/2411.15689
  30. [30]C.-X. Liu, J.-Z. Wang, and X. Liu, Exploring charmonia ηc(6S, 7S) in the Λc⁺Λ̄c⁻ invariant mass spectrum of B⁰ → K⁰_SΛc⁺Λ̄c⁻, Phys. Rev. D 114, 074050 (2026).
  31. [31]X.-J. Li, Y.-S. Li, F.-L. Wang, and X. Liu, Spectroscopic survey of higher-lying states of Bc meson family, Eur. Phys. J. C 83, 1080 (2023).DOI
  32. [32]P.-Y. Sun, T.-L. Gao, Z.-L. Man, and X. Liu, Proposed mixing between 2P and 1F wave charmonia, Phys. Rev. D 114, 034011 (2026).DOI
  33. [33]L. Micu, Decay rates of meson resonances in a quark model, Nucl. Phys. B 10, 521 (1969).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_9stfwrnb
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC0-1.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

ChatGPT

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents