betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Periodicities of small regular jet deviations in SS433 and their origin

Abstract

Based on the results of spectroscopic observations of SS433 conducted with the 2.5-m telescope at the Caucasian Mountain Observatory between 2020 and 2026, we study the deviations of the moving hydrogen and helium emission lines from their positions as predicted by the kinematic model of the jets' precessional motion. In these deviations, in addition to the previously known periodicities of 13d.0813^d.08, 11d.2711^d.27, 6d.296^d.29, and 5d.835^d.83, a new period of 3d.083^d.08 is identified. All observed periodicities are explained by a model in which the jet offsets occur in a fixed direction relative to the star-disk axis r\bf r, and the magnitude of the offset is a function a(μ)a(μ), where μμ is the cosine of the angle between r\bf r and the direction of each jet. The odd terms of the power series expansion of a(μ)a(μ) in μμ yield periodicities of 6d.296^d.29, 5d.835^d.83, and 3d.083^d.08, with the jets shifting in opposite directions while remaining parallel. The even powers yield periodicities of 13d.0813^d.08, 11d.2711^d.27, and 4d.144^d.14 (the latter is not observed), with both jets shifting in the same direction, which was previously misinterpreted as a change in the jets' total velocity ββ. With the exception of the 6d.296^d.29 periodicity, all other displacements occur at an angle of ≈120∘\approx120^\circ to r\bf r. Superimposed on the regular variability are random deviations (jitter) in the jet directions, independent for the two jets, with σ≲1. ⁣ ⁣∘5σ\lesssim1.\!\!^\circ5.

Introduction

The unique object SS433 is the first galactic microquasar to be discovered. It is a massive X-ray binary system at an advanced stage of evolution with a precessing supercritical accretion disk around a black hole and relativistic jets ([9, 18, 15, 8, 10]).

The presence of precession means that the system has two periods: an orbital period (POrb≃13d1P_{\mathrm{Orb}} \simeq13^{\mathrm d}1), which is reliably determined from observations of both primary and secondary eclipses, and a precession period (PPrec≃162d3P_{\mathrm{Prec}} \simeq162^{\mathrm d}3), which is determined both from photometric observations and from spectral observations based on the positions of the moving hydrogen and neutral helium lines. All other reliably identified frequencies in the system are combinations of the orbital frequency ω=2πPOrb−1\omega= 2\pi P_{\mathrm{Orb}}^{-1} and the precession frequency Ω=2πPPrec−1\Omega= 2\pi P_{\mathrm{Prec}}^{-1}: the strongest deviations from the precessional motion occur with a period of 6d296^{\mathrm d}29 (2ω+Ω2\omega+\Omega). These deviations are commonly referred to as nutation and are associated with the star’s tidal action on the disk ([16]). The standard kinematic model ([18]) for spectral line shifts accounts only for precession and nutation variations. This model assumes that both jets move at speeds equal in magnitude but strictly in opposite directions:

z±+1=zPrec±+zNut±;z^{\pm}+1=z_{\mathrm{Prec}}^{\pm}+z_{\mathrm{Nut}}^{\pm};
zPrec±=γ[1±βsin⁡isin⁡θcos⁡ψ(t)±βcos⁡icos⁡θ];z_{\mathrm{Prec}}^{\pm}=\gamma[1\pm\beta\sin i\sin\theta\cos\psi(t)\pm\beta\cos i\cos\theta];
zNut±=±ZNutcos⁡ϕNut(t);z_{\mathrm{Nut}}^{\pm}=\pm Z_{\mathrm{Nut}}\cos\phi_{\mathrm{Nut}}(t);
ψ(t)=2π(t−T3)/PPrec;\psi(t)=2\pi(t-T_3)/P_{\mathrm{Prec}};
ϕNut(t)=2π(t−TNut)/PNut.(1)\phi_{\mathrm{Nut}}(t)=2\pi(t-T_{\mathrm{Nut}})/P_{\mathrm{Nut}}. \tag*{(1)}

Here, z±=λ±/λ0−1z^{\pm}=\lambda^{\pm}/\lambda_0-1 is the observed line shift; zPrec±z_{\mathrm{Prec}}^{\pm} is the component that accounts for the transverse Doppler effect and precession; zNut±z_{\mathrm{Nut}}^{\pm} is a correction accounting for nutation. β=v/c\beta=v/c is the velocity of the material in the jet. ii – the inclination of the precession axis relative to the line of sight. θ\theta – the aperture angle of the precession cone. γ=(1−β2)−0.5\gamma=(1-\beta^2)^{-0.5} – the Lorentz factor. PPrecP_{\mathrm{Prec}} – the precession period, T3T_3 – the initial epoch when the wavelength difference between the moving lines is maximal (without accounting for nutation). ZNutZ_{\mathrm{Nut}} – amplitude of the variation zNutz_{\mathrm{Nut}}, PNutP_{\mathrm{Nut}} – nutation period, TNutT_{\mathrm{Nut}} – initial epoch for describing nutation. However, the moving lines do not strictly follow this model. At long timescales of ∼100d\sim100^{\mathrm d}, fluctuations in the precession phase of ∼±10\sim\pm10 days are noticeable [11]. On shorter timescales, random deviations in the jet direction are observed, with the angle changing independently for each jet [17, 5]. Another periodicity of 5d.85^{\mathrm d}.8 (2ω+3Ω2\omega+ 3\Omega) with a small amplitude is observed [16, 13], which is not explained by the tidal nutation model [16]. Furthermore, variations in β\beta with an orbital period have been reliably established [4, 5, 6, 13, 12, 11], as well as with a period of 11d.2711^{\mathrm d}.27 (ω+2Ω\omega+ 2\Omega) [13].

Most position measurements of the moving lines in previous studies were carried out for Hα\alpha, which is the strongest moving line in the visible range. However, this very feature is also a drawback: Hα\alpha has a noticeable emission decay time, such that even a day later it may leave a bright residual trace. This trace can interfere with the measurement of a more recent component or even lead to its misidentification. Furthermore, Hα\alpha lines can overlap with other lines in the stationary spectrum, making them unsuitable for precise measurements. The primary objective of this work was to enhance the precision of redshift determinations for the moving emission features, with the aim of obtaining a more detailed and statistically sound description of the stochastic deviations in jet orientation. This was accomplished through a simultaneous analysis of multiple H and He lines over an extended and internally consistent dataset of spectral observations.

Observations

The observations were carried out with the TDS spectrograph [19] at the Caucasian Mountain Observatory of the Sternberg Astronomical Institute (SAI), Lomonosov Moscow State University, during 2020 – 2026. The spectrograph’s operating wavelength range is 3550 − 7450 Å, with a resolving power of λ/FWHM∼1000\lambda/\mathrm{FWHM} \sim1000 in the blue part of the spectrum and up to 2400 in the red part. A total of 461 spectra were obtained, each formed by averaging three consecutive exposures of 5 minutes. Atmospheric extinction was corrected using a standard star observed at a similar airmass. For spectra acquired since 2022, this procedure includes telluric correction, which significantly improves the accuracy of measurements of the moving lines, when they overlap with telluric absorption bands. All timestamps and wavelengths were reduced to the barycenter of the Solar System.

Parameters of the kinematic model in 2020 – 2026

The quality of the TDS spectra allows us to measure the redshifts z±z^{\pm} not only for the moving Hα±\alpha^{\pm} lines, but also for higher members of the Balmer series up to Hδ\delta, as well as for the He I lines at 5876, 6678, and 7065 Å. The set of measurable lines varies from spectrum to spectrum, depending on their availability for reliable measurement. The redshifts of all moving lines are consistent with one another to within σz±=1.3×10−3\sigma_{z^{\pm}} = 1.3 \times10^{-3}. Given this level of agreement, we combine and average the measured z±z^{\pm} values. This approach enhances both the accuracy and robustness of the z±z^{\pm} measurements: if some moving lines are blended with other spectral features or fall outside the spectrograph’s wavelength range, z±z^{\pm} can still be determined from the remaining measurable lines.

Building on our previous works [13, 12, 11] on determining the parameters of the kinematic model (Eq. 1), we used the same methods to determine the parameters from the new data, which are compiled in Table 1 and Table 2. The deviations of the observed line positions from the kinematic model with parameters from Table 1 and Table 2 amount to σz±≈5×10−3\sigma_{z^{\pm}} \approx5 \times10^{-3}, which is an order of magnitude greater than the measurement precision. In many cases, the model deviations are so large that they exceed the boundaries of the observed line profile, whose median FWHM is v/c≈6×10−3v/c \approx6 \times10^{-3}.

NJDstart_{\mathrm{start}} – JDend_{\mathrm{end}}, daysβ\betaθ\theta, °ii, °PprecP_{\mathrm{prec}}, daysT3T_3, MJD
158895 – 590440.2655 ± 0.002518.88 ± 0.4778.34 ± 0.24160.903 ± 1.25759096.7 ± 1.2
259081 – 592020.2604 ± 0.002020.04 ± 0.2678.84 ± 0.21166.266 ± 1.81859260.3 ± 1.2
359257 – 595600.2619 ± 0.002519.67 ± 0.3179.50 ± 0.22160.800 ± 0.67159579.0 ± 0.7
459630 – 597950.2625 ± 0.002519.57 ± 0.3478.37 ± 0.23158.372 ± 1.06359895.3 ± 1.2
559840 – 600020.2671 ± 0.001918.27 ± 0.2678.99 ± 0.22158.657 ± 1.18960055.3 ± 1.2
660002 – 602540.2536 ± 0.001620.71 ± 0.2178.73 ± 0.14165.761 ± 0.53160223.1 ± 0.3
760254 – 604970.2563 ± 0.003619.87 ± 0.5179.08 ± 0.34164.932 ± 1.68060387.6 ± 0.8
860496 – 606550.2524 ± 0.002920.29 ± 0.4178.54 ± 0.32166.066 ± 1.46460719.5 ± 1.8
960718 – 608910.2623 ± 0.002618.94 ± 0.3878.17 ± 0.31157.420 ± 1.63860871.0 ± 0.8
1060891 – 610760.2511 ± 0.002422.06 ± 0.4978.72 ± 0.39166.632 ± 1.69061037.9 ± 0.8
1161076 – 612470.2605 ± 0.002619.00 ± 0.3778.65 ± 0.26162.758 ± 1.10161199.1 ± 0.4
All*43688 – 612470.2598 ± 0.000719.60 ± 0.0978.98 ± 0.06162.309 ± 0.00260225.88 ± 0.16

Table 1. Precession model parameters in different times. *Parameters in the last row are based on the full 1978 – 2026 dataset ([12, 11]).

NZNutZ_{\mathrm{Nut}}, 10−3×10^{-3}\timesPNutP_{\mathrm{Nut}}, daysTNutT_{\mathrm{Nut}}, days
18.1 ± 1.16.335 ± 0.02858936.54 ± 0.15
29.2 ± 0.86.314 ± 0.01959125.02 ± 0.12
310.4 ± 1.06.282 ± 0.00859445.48 ± 0.10
47.8 ± 1.16.304 ± 0.01859747.38 ± 0.16
59.7 ± 0.96.346 ± 0.01159936.04 ± 0.09
610.2 ± 0.76.276 ± 0.00660149.72 ± 0.06
711.4 ± 1.66.242 ± 0.01760495.04 ± 0.24
88.5 ± 1.36.312 ± 0.01760495.43 ± 0.20
911.0 ± 1.36.255 ± 0.01960809.61 ± 0.13
106.4 ± 1.16.315 ± 0.03060809.17 ± 0.77
118.8 ± 1.06.232 ± 0.02060813.40 ± 1.29

Table 2. Nutation model parameters.

Deviations from the model

We deliberately divided the entire observed period of 2020 – 2026 into the shortest possible intervals that still allow us to determine the model parameters with acceptable accuracy. As can be seen from Table 1, the precession period exhibits fluctuations. This effect is interpreted as phase noise in the precessional variability, likely caused by fluctuations in the viscous timescale in the disk (see [11]). Using the same methods, we extended the time series of phase shifts from [11] with the new data, see Figure 1. Since the precessional component of the variations has the largest amplitude, all other small-scale deviations will be studied after subtracting the precessional contribution with parameters from Table 1.

Figure 1. The precession phase deviation from the mean ephemeris. The analyzed period is highlighted with larger markers.

Our kinematic model incorporates nutational variability, which in principle could be fitted on a segment-by-segment basis using the parameters listed in Table 2. However, to preserve long-term components that may be physically significant, we deliberately avoid fitting the nutation parameters over short time intervals: such an approach risks suppressing slow variations whose characteristic timescales exceed the length of the individual segments. Instead, the nutational component is determined globally across the entire 2020 – 2026 dataset. This choice ensures that any long-term trends or low-frequency signals are retained in the residuals, which are the primary focus of our analysis. We note, however, that the main results remain consistent even if the nutational contribution is subtracted in advance using the global parameters from Table 2, confirming the robustness of our conclusions.

Periodicities in the jet velocity

The kinematic model Eq. (1) does not account for the variability of the jet velocity β=v/c\beta= v/c. Nevertheless, such variability with an orbital period was detected by K. M. Blundell & M. G. Bowler [5] and has been repeatedly confirmed thereafter by K. M. Blundell et al. [6]; V. V. Davydov et al. [13]; A. M. Cherepashchuk et al. [12, 11]. Since the orbital period is slowly increasing (A. Cherepashchuk et al. [7]), hereafter we adopt its mean value over the 2020 – 2025 interval, POrb=13d08341P_{\mathrm{Orb}} = 13^\mathrm{d}08341, and use the epoch of the primary eclipse at the midpoint of this interval, MJD = 58932.636, to compute the orbital phase.

Assuming that the velocities in both jets are equal in magnitude and strictly opposite in direction, the velocity β\beta can be computed for each individual observation from the transverse Doppler effect:

β=1−(1+z−+z+2)−2.(2)\beta= \sqrt{1 - \left(1 + \frac{z_- + z_+}{2}\right)^{-2}} . \tag*{(2)}

Assuming such β\beta measurements, we detect a period of 13d093±0d00513^\mathrm{d}093 \pm0^\mathrm{d}005, which differs by 0d0090^\mathrm{d}009 from the orbital period. This discrepancy may be attributed to strong contamination of the curve by spurious effects, for example, due to the failure of the strict antiparallel alignment of the jets. This appears to be the primary cause of irregular deviations of the line positions from the model, see § 4.3. For definiteness, we assume that the period in the β\beta variation is exactly equal to the orbital period; the remaining parameters were determined via the least-squares method and are listed in Table 3. The dependence of β\beta on the orbital phase is shown in Figure 2; the velocity maximum occurs at φ=0.334±0.015\varphi= 0.334 \pm0.015. We note that all subsequent conclusions remain valid if we adopt the period of 13d09313^\mathrm{d}093 instead.

PP, daysΔz\Delta z, ×10−3\times10^{-3}Δβ\Delta\beta, ×10−3\times10^{-3}MJD0\mathrm{MJD}_0
13.0831.75±0.181.75\pm0.186.0±0.66.0\pm0.658937.0±0.258937.0\pm0.2
11.2671.32±0.151.32\pm0.154.5±0.54.5\pm0.558895.1±0.258895.1\pm0.2

Table 3. Periodical components in the jet velocity. The mean β=0.2562±0.0004\beta= 0.2562 \pm0.0004.

Figure 2. Variation in the jet velocity with orbital phase.

After removing the orbital component from β\beta, the strongest harmonic in the variability becomes P=11d251±0d004P = 11^\mathrm{d}251 \pm0^\mathrm{d}004, which is close to the expected harmonic 11d26711^\mathrm{d}267 corresponding to the combination frequency (ω+2Ω)(\omega+ 2\Omega). As before, we adopt the theoretically expected period of 11d26711^\mathrm{d}267 for further analysis, although the subsequent results are practically insensitive to this choice. The remaining parameters of this periodicity are listed in Table 3, and the phase curve is shown in Figure 3.

Figure 3. A 11.267-day periodicity in the jet velocity residuals after subtracting the orbital variability from Figure 2.

The periodic components β\beta found in this way were substituted into the kinematic model (Eq. (1)) using the parameters from Table 1, Table 2, and the differences between the model with a variable β\beta and the model with a constant β\beta were calculated. The resulting differences were used to correct the observed z±z^\pm for the periodic variation of the velocity β\beta.

Periodic Changes in Jet Direction

After removing corrections for periodic variations in β\beta from z±z^\pm, all periodic components that are simultaneously present in both jets were sequentially extracted from the data, see Figure 4. In addition to the well-known nutation, the variations contain a period of 5.8342 days, which was also found in papers J. I. Katz et al. [16]; V. V. Davydov et al. [13] and corresponds to the harmonic (2ω+3Ω)(2\omega+3\Omega), and a period of 3.0830 days, not previously mentioned in the literature and corresponding to the harmonic 4ω+3Ω4\omega+3\Omega. The parameters of these periodicities are summarized in Table 4.

PP, daysΔz\Delta z, ×10−3\times10^{-3}T0T_0, MJD
6.2870±0.00036.2870\pm0.00039.0±0.39.0\pm0.360005.14±0.0360005.14\pm0.03
5.8342±0.00085.8342\pm0.00083.2±0.33.2\pm0.360003.98±0.0960003.98\pm0.09
3.0830±0.00033.0830\pm0.00032.0±0.32.0\pm0.360006.72±0.0760006.72\pm0.07

Table 4. Periodic components in the deviations of moving lines from the precession model.

Figure 4. Periodicities in the residual deviations z±z^{\pm}. The precession component and the periodic components β\beta have been subtracted beforehand.

There are other peaks present in the frequency spectra; however, they do not coincide for the red z+z^+ and blue z−z^- jets, nor do they correspond to combinations of known frequencies, so we consider them to be noise.

Aperiodic components

The regular deviations from the precession-nutation model given in Eq. (1), discussed above, account for only a small portion of the total dispersion: after subtracting all periodic components, the dispersion decreases from σz−=5.3×10−3\sigma_{z^-} = 5.3 \times10^{-3} and σz+=6.3×10−3\sigma_{z^+} = 6.3 \times10^{-3} to σz−=5.0×10−3\sigma_{z^-} = 5.0 \times10^{-3} and σz+=5.6×10−3\sigma_{z^+} = 5.6 \times10^{-3}. The residuals Δz±\Delta z^\pm are shown in Figure 5 as functions of z±z^\pm and of each other; in the latter case, a slight elongation of the scatter plot is noticeable, which corresponds to an anticorrelation between Δz±\Delta z^\pm with a correlation coefficient of r=−0.19±0.05r = -0.19 \pm0.05.

Figure 5. Residual deviations Δz±\Delta z^{\pm} after eliminating all periodic components, as a function of the observed z±z^{\pm} and relative to each other.

The diagrams shown narrow down the range of causes that lead to deviations in the lines (J. I. Katz & T. Piran 1982; K. M. Blundell & M. G. Bowler 2005). The observed pattern of variations corresponds to random and independent variations in the directions of the jet and counterjet, see Figure 6. If the deviations occurred only in the total angle, that is, if both jets and the source lay strictly on a single straight line, then Δz±\Delta z^{\pm} would be strictly anticorrelated, and the cloud of points on the diagram Δz−−Δz+\Delta z^{-}-\Delta z^{+} would degenerate into a straight line. With random variations in β\beta independent in each jet, there should be a strong dependence of the deviations Δz±\Delta z^{\pm} on z±z^{\pm}, see Figure 7. Such a dependence is not observed.

Expected correlations

Figure 6. Expected correlations Δz±−z±\Delta z^{\pm}-z^{\pm} and Δz+−Δz−\Delta z^{+}-\Delta z^{-} for random deviations in the directions of each jet with σ=1.5\sigma= 1.5 degrees (diameter of the cone).

Figure 7. Expected correlations Δz±−z±\Delta z^{\pm}-z^{\pm} and Δz+−Δz−\Delta z^{+}-\Delta z^{-} for random velocity variations β\beta of each jet with σ=0.01\sigma=0.01.

Another factor that may lead to deviations from the model is the unknown age of the moving lines. As the emitting gas moves along a ballistic trajectory, it fixes the position of the jet at the moment of its launch, but an unknown time interval separates the moment of launch from the moment of observation. Since the kinematic model is constructed based on the observed lines, it incorporates an average delay, whereas the delays of individual lines will be both shorter and longer than this average delay. If the delays in the jet and counterjet lines are identical, there must be a strict anticorrelation Δz±\Delta z^{\pm}. In the case where the delays in the jets are independent of one another, both diagrams will resemble the observed ones, see Figure 8.

Expected relationships between $\Delta z^{\pm}-z^{\pm}$ and $\Delta z^{+}-\Delta z^{-}$

Figure 8. Expected relationships between Δz±−z±\Delta z^{\pm}-z^{\pm} and Δz+−Δz−\Delta z^{+}-\Delta z^{-} for random changes in delays uniformly distributed over the interval ±1\pm1 day.

Yet another effect that could distort the radial velocity curve of moving lines is the light delay between the receding and approaching jets. However, this effect does not need to be taken into account. The fact is that we

observe the jet not as a continuous stream, but as separate clumps that travel along a ballistic trajectory and carry information about their radial velocity at the moment of launch. Therefore, the only important factors are whether we are observing clumps launched simultaneously and how long ago this occurred.

In our view, the most plausible cause of the deviations is random fluctuations in the directions of each jet. The scatter σz−=5×10−3\sigma_{z^{-}}=5\times10^{-3} corresponds to a spread cone diameter of σ=1.5∘\sigma=1\mathord{.}5^\circ. The slight elongation of the point cloud in the Δz+−Δz−\Delta z^{+}-\Delta z^{-} plot (Figure 5) is due to the uncertainty in the age of the observed moving lines, as well as a possible weak correlation between the angular variations in the jets. Taking into account the contributions of various mechanisms to the total scatter, we can state that the angular fluctuations satisfy σ≲1.5∘\sigma\lesssim1\mathord{.}5^\circ.

Discussion

To interpret the detected periodicities, we need to formalize the basic elements of the system, which is conveniently done in vector form (see Figure 9). The position vector from the star to the disk, lying in the orbital xyxy plane, is given by:

Schematic representation of SS433

Figure 9. Schematic representation of SS433. On the left, a view of the system at φ=90∘\varphi=90^\circ and at an inclination i=79∘i=79^\circ. The disk and jet positions correspond to φ/2π=0.65\varphi/2\pi=0.65 and ψ/2π=0.46\psi/2\pi=0.46. On the right is the top view of the system. The bold dashed line is the intersection line between the disk plane and the orbital plane. The angle between the jet j−\mathbf{j}^{-} and the radius vector r\mathbf{r} connecting the centers of the components is α\alpha; μ−=cos⁡α\mu_{-}=\cos\alpha.

r=−{cos⁡φ,sin⁡φ,0}(3)\mathbf{r}=-\{\cos\varphi,\sin\varphi,0\} \tag*{(3)}

The sign ‘−’ means that φ\varphi is traditionally counted from the moment of eclipse of the disk by the star TOrbT_{\rm Orb}. To calculate φ\varphi, we used the average period for our observation interval (see. A. Cherepashchuk et al. [7] and A. V. Dodin et al. [14]):

φ=ω(t−TOrb),ω=2πPOrb,(4)\varphi=\omega(t-T_{\rm Orb}),\qquad\omega=\frac{2\pi}{P_{\rm Orb}}, \tag*{(4)}
TOrb=58932.636 MJD,POrb=13d08341.T_{\rm Orb}=58932.636\ {\rm MJD},\qquad P_{\rm Orb}=13^{\rm d}08341.

The precessional phase ψ\psi is calculated from the data in Table 1:

ψ=Ω(t−T3),Ω=2πPPrec,(5)\psi=\Omega(t-T_{3}),\qquad\Omega=\frac{2\pi}{P_{\rm Prec}}, \tag*{(5)}
T3=60225.88 MJD,PPrec=162d309.T_{3}=60225.88\ {\rm MJD},\qquad P_{\rm Prec}=162^{\rm d}309.

The disk in SS433 precesses retrogradely with respect to the orbital motion; for convenience, we also measure ψ\psi in the opposite direction to keep Ω\Omega positive.

The jets are precessing around the orbital angular momentum under the angle θ\theta to the zz-axis:

j±=∓{cos⁡ψsin⁡θ,−sin⁡ψsin⁡θ,cos⁡θ}.(6)\mathbf{j}^{\pm}=\mp\{\cos\psi\sin\theta,-\sin\psi\sin\theta,\cos\theta\}. \tag*{(6)}

The sign ‘∓’ correspond to the definition that the phase ψ=0\psi=0 corresponds the maximum disk opening time T3T_{3}. The sign ‘−’ before ‘sin⁡ψ\sin\psi’ reflects the chosen direction of ψ\psi.

The line of sight defines the plane xzxz and is inclined under the angle ii to the orbital angular momentum:

I=−{sin⁡i,0,cos⁡i}.(7)\mathbf{I}=-\{\sin i,0,\cos i\}. \tag*{(7)}

The signs correspond to the definition that radial velocity of receding objects is positive. The radial velocity of the jet is determined by its projection on the line of sight:

η±=j±⋅I=±(cos⁡ψsin⁡θsin⁡i+cos⁡θcos⁡i),(8)\eta^{\pm}=\mathbf{j}^{\pm}\cdot\mathbf{I}=\pm(\cos\psi\sin\theta\sin i+\cos\theta\cos i), \tag*{(8)}

which with account of the relativistic factors yields the precessional part of the kinematic model (Eq. (1)):

z±=γ(1+βη±)−1.(9)z^{\pm}=\gamma(1+\beta\eta^{\pm})-1. \tag*{(9)}

To interpret the deviations of the jet from the precessional motion, we consider the torques acting on the disk due to the star and the gas flows in the system. The dominant flow is the one feeding the disk through the L1 point. The mutual orientation of the gas flows and the precessing disk and star is determined by the coaddition of the orbital and precessional phases, φ+ψ\varphi+\psi. Consequently, the torque on the disk should be a periodic function of φ+ψ\varphi+\psi. The simplest form of such a function is a cosine, generally with some phase offset ψ∗\psi_*: cos⁡(φ+ψ−ψ∗)\cos(\varphi+\psi-\psi_*). It is also natural to assume that the strength of this torque is proportional to the half-angle of the precession cone, i.e., sin⁡(θ)\sin(\theta), as in the absence of precession there would be no deviations, and the gas flow pattern would be static in the frame corotating with the orbital motion. Note that, up to a phase, the product μ=sin⁡(θ)cos⁡(φ+ψ−ψ∗)\mu=\sin(\theta)\cos(\varphi+\psi-\psi_*) is equal to the cosine of the angle between the position vector r\mathbf{r} and the jet direction vectors j±\mathbf{j}^{\pm}:

μ±=r⋅j±=±sin⁡θcos⁡(φ+ψ).(10)\mu_{\pm}=\mathbf{r}\cdot\mathbf{j}^{\pm}=\pm\sin\theta\cos(\varphi+\psi). \tag*{(10)}

In general, the magnitude of the jet’s deviation from the precessional motion may be a nonlinear function a(μ)a(\mu), which remains periodic in φ+ψ\varphi+\psi. Assuming that deviations from linearity are small, we can expand this function as a power series in μ\mu:

a(μ)=a0+a1μ+a2μ2+a3μ3+…(11)a(\mu)=a_0+a_1\mu+a_2\mu^2+a_3\mu^3+\ldots \tag*{(11)}

In practice, truncating the expansion at the quadratic or cubic term often suffices to capture the observed deviations while keeping the model analytically tractable. The quantity a(μ)a(\mu) determines only the amplitude of the deviation; the direction of this deviation can conveniently be characterized by its projection in the orbital plane, offset from the radius vector r\mathbf{r} by a constant angle φ∗\varphi_*:

d=−{cos⁡(φ−φ∗),sin⁡(φ−φ∗),0}.(12)\mathbf{d}=-\{\cos(\varphi-\varphi_*),\sin(\varphi-\varphi_*),0\}. \tag*{(12)}

New direction of the jet is

j′=j+a(μ)d∣j+a(μ)d∣,(13)\mathbf{j}'=\frac{\mathbf{j}+a(\mu)\mathbf{d}}{\lvert\mathbf{j}+a(\mu)\mathbf{d}\rvert}, \tag*{(13)}

hereinafter, we omit the designation ‘±\pm’ for the jet and counterjet. Normalization means that we assume only the direction of the jet changes, while its speed remains unchanged; therefore, the new vector remains an unit vector. However, omitting this normalization does not affect the result, since we assume that the deviation is small and expand the denominator to the term linear in aa. In this approximation, the change in radial velocity will be

Δz=γβa(μ)[(d⋅I)−(j⋅I)(d⋅j)].(14)\Delta z=\gamma\beta a(\mu)[(\mathbf{d}\cdot\mathbf{I})-(\mathbf{j}\cdot\mathbf{I})(\mathbf{d}\cdot\mathbf{j})]. \tag*{(14)}

The last term can also be neglected, since it consists of periodic terms with amplitudes sin⁡2θ≈0.1\sin^2\theta\approx0.1 and sin⁡θcos⁡i≈0.06\sin\theta\cos i\approx0.06 relative to the first term. Thus, the dominant term is

Δz=γβa(μ)d⋅I=γβ∑kakμkcos⁡(φ−φk)sin⁡i.(15)\Delta z=\gamma\beta a(\mu)\mathbf{d}\cdot\mathbf{I}=\gamma\beta\sum_k a_k\mu^k\cos(\varphi-\varphi_k)\sin i. \tag*{(15)}

Consider each term in this expansion separately. For k=0k=0, the jet deviation does not depend on φ+ψ\varphi+\psi, and the velocity variation can occur only with the orbital phase. Since the deviation is independent of the sign of μ\mu, it is the same for the jet and the counterjet and occurs in the same direction; therefore, they cease to be antiparallel. This leads to an apparent variation of β\beta with the orbital period, since its calculation in the kinematic model (see Eq. (2)) is based on the assumption that the jet and counterjet are strictly antiparallel. Indeed, we observe a variation of β\beta with the orbital period (see Figure 2). The orbital motion of the disk around the star should also contribute to the velocity variation with the orbital period at the level of Δz∼2×10−4\Delta z\sim2\times10^{-4}; however, this is comparable to the accuracy with which the amplitude of the orbital variability of zz is determined.

For k=1k=1, the deviation of the radial velocity from the precessional motion takes the form:

Δz1=γβa1μd⋅I=γβa12sin⁡isin⁡θ[cos⁡(ψ+φ1−ψ1)+cos⁡(2φ+ψ−φ1−ψ1)].(16)\Delta z_1=\gamma\beta a_1\mu\mathbf{d}\cdot\mathbf{I}=\gamma\beta\frac{a_1}{2}\sin i\sin\theta[\cos(\psi+\varphi_1-\psi_1)+\cos(2\varphi+\psi-\varphi_1-\psi_1)]. \tag*{(16)}

This law contains two characteristic frequencies: the precession frequency Ω\Omega and the nutation frequency 2ω+Ω2\omega+\Omega. The precessional component is absorbed into the overall precession. Note that the sign of μ\mu is opposite for the jet and counterjet, so their deviations occur in opposite directions, as observed in the nutational component (see the left panels of Figure 4).

For k=2k=2 the deviation of the radial velocity from the precessional motion reads

Δz2=γβa2μ2d⋅I=γβa24sin⁡isin⁡2θ[2cos⁡(φ−φ2)+cos⁡(φ+2ψ+φ2−2ψ2)+cos⁡(3φ+2ψ−φ2−2ψ2)].(17)\Delta z_2=\gamma\beta a_2\mu^2\mathbf{d}\cdot\mathbf{I}=\gamma\beta\frac{a_2}{4}\sin i\sin^2\theta[2\cos(\varphi-\varphi_2)+\cos(\varphi+2\psi+\varphi_2-2\psi_2)+\cos(3\varphi+2\psi-\varphi_2-2\psi_2)]. \tag*{(17)}

This gives the frequencies ω\omega, ω+2Ω\omega+2\Omega, and 3ω+2Ω3\omega+2\Omega, corresponding to periods of 13d.08, 11d.27, and 4d.14, respectively. As in the case of k=0k=0, the sign of μ2\mu^2 does not depend on of whether we consider the jet or the counterjet; therefore, their deflections will be in the same direction, which may lead to an incorrect interpretation of the variability of the total speed β\beta.

Indeed, we observe variability in β\beta with periods of 13d0813^{\mathrm d}08 and 11d2711^{\mathrm d}27 (see Section 4.1 above and Figure 2 and 3). We were unable to identify the 4d144^{\mathrm d}14 period. In this connection, we note that detecting short periodicities is more difficult due to the comparable fading time of the moving lines, which is about 1 day.

For k=3k=3 deviations of the radial velocity from the precessional motion are

Δz3=γβa3μ3d⋅I=γβa38sin⁡isin⁡3θ××[3cos⁡(ψ+φ3−ψ3)+3cos⁡(2φ+ψ−φ3−ψ3)+cos⁡(2φ+3ψ+φ3−3ψ3)+cos⁡(4φ+3ψ−φ3−3ψ3)].(18)\begin{aligned} \Delta z_3 &= \gamma\beta a_3\mu^3\mathbf{d}\cdot\mathbf{I} =\gamma\beta\frac{a_3}{8}\sin i\sin^3\theta\times\\ &\quad\times\left[3\cos(\psi+\varphi_3-\psi_3)+ 3\cos(2\varphi+\psi-\varphi_3-\psi_3)+\right.\\ &\qquad\left.\cos(2\varphi+3\psi+\varphi_3-3\psi_3)+ \cos(4\varphi+3\psi-\varphi_3-3\psi_3)\right]. \tag*{(18)} \end{aligned}

This yields, once again, the precession and nutation frequencies, as well as the frequencies 2ω+3Ω2\omega+3\Omega and 4ω+3Ω4\omega+3\Omega, corresponding to the observed periodicities of 5d835^{\mathrm d}83 and 3d083^{\mathrm d}08, respectively.

The unknown parameters of Eqs. (16)–(18) can be determined from observations (see Table 3 and 4). Substituting φ(T0)\varphi(T_0) and ψ(T0)\psi(T_0) for the initial epochs T0T_0 of each periodicity into the corresponding terms of Eqs. (16)–(18) yields linear equations for φk\varphi_k and ψk\psi_k, while the quantities aka_k are determined from the observed amplitudes Δz\Delta z.

From Eq. (17) for the periods of 13d0813^{\mathrm d}08, 11d2711^{\mathrm d}27 we obtain

φ2/2π=0.334±0.015,ψ2/2π=0.033±0.011+m/2,(19)\begin{aligned} \varphi_2/2\pi&= 0.334 \pm0.015,\\ \psi_2/2\pi&= 0.033 \pm0.011 + m/2, \tag*{(19)} \end{aligned}

where mm is an integer. Note that the phase delay φ2\varphi_2 is directly observed in the periodicity 13d0813^{\mathrm d}08 in Figure 2. Matching the observed amplitudes with Eq. (17) yields a2=0.139±0.014a_2=0.139\pm0.014 for the period 13d0813^{\mathrm d}08, and a2=0.21±0.02a_2=0.21\pm0.02 for the period 11d2711^{\mathrm d}27.

Eq. (18) for the periods of 5d835^{\mathrm d}83 and 3d083^{\mathrm d}08 yields

φ3/2π=0.330±0.013+n/2,ψ3/2π=0.000±0.004+m/6,(20)\begin{aligned} \varphi_3/2\pi&= 0.330 \pm0.013 + n/2,\\ \psi_3/2\pi&= 0.000 \pm0.004 + m/6, \tag*{(20)} \end{aligned}

where n,mn,m are integers. The coefficient a3=3.3±0.3a_3=3.3\pm0.3 and a3=2.1±0.3a_3=2.1\pm0.3, respectively from the amplitudes of 5d835^{\mathrm d}83 and 3d083^{\mathrm d}08 periodicities.

If we set n,m=0n,m=0, the obtained results acquire a clear physical meaning. In this case all four periodicities share a common phase offset φ2,3≈0.33\varphi_{2,3}\approx0.33 and ψ2,3≈0\psi_{2,3}\approx0, meaning that the jet deviations are proportional to the cosine of the angle between the jet and the position vector, μ±\mu^{\pm}.

Both terms k=1k=1 and k=3k=3 contribute to the strongest 6d296^{\mathrm d}29 periodicity. However, it turned out that Eq. (16) for k=1k=1 yields (φ1+ψ1)/2π=0.589±0.005(\varphi_1+\psi_1)/2\pi=0.589\pm0.005, which is inconsistent with the values of φ3\varphi_3 and ψ3\psi_3.

To extract the contribution of μ1\mu^1 from the periodicity 6d296^{\mathrm d}29, the addition formula for cosines with different amplitudes and a phase shift should be used. The resulting equations for the amplitude and phase at a3=2.1÷3.3a_3=2.1\div3.3 and φ3/2π=0.33\varphi_3/2\pi=0.33 yield a1=0.28÷0.33a_1=0.28\div0.33 and (φ1+ψ1)/2π=0.68÷0.71(\varphi_1+\psi_1)/2\pi=0.68\div0.71. The phase difference between linear and non-linear terms may be attributed to the fact that the linear term arises from a mechanism of a different nature than the nonlinear contributions. For example, the tidal influence of the star may dominate the linear term, while the nonlinear components are primarily driven by the effects of gas flows in the system.

The same reasoning can be applied to k=0k=0. The agreement of the phases φ2≈φ3≈0.33\varphi_2\approx\varphi_3\approx0.33 and ψ2≈ψ3≈0\psi_2\approx\psi_3\approx0 implies that the contribution of the k=0k=0 term to the 13d0813^{\mathrm d}08 periodicity is either very small or has φ0=0.33\varphi_0=0.33 as well, since otherwise it would distort the values of φ2\varphi_2 and ψ2\psi_2, and these would not agree with φ3\varphi_3 and ψ3\psi_3. The smallness of a0≈0a_0\approx0 is not surprising, since this term corresponds to a constant displacement of the jets in one direction relative to r, independent of the precessional orientation of the disk.

The same problem can also be solved numerically in a more general form, without the expansion of Eq. (13) in the small parameter a(μ)a(\mu). Using the mean parameters of the kinematic model and the data from Table 3 and 4, we generated artificial observations and fitted them with a model given by Eqs. (3)–(13). We searched for a ψk\psi_k common to all kk and obtained ψk/2π=0.02\psi_k/2\pi=0.02, which is very close to zero and justifies setting ψk=0\psi_k=0. We also searched for a common phase shift φ2,3\varphi_{2,3} for all periodicities except the component from μ1\mu^1. This fit yielded the following values: a1=0.29a_1=0.29, a2=0.13a_2=0.13, a3=2.0a_3=2.0, φ1=0.70\varphi_1=0.70, φ2,3=0.32\varphi_{2,3}=0.32. Using this model, we also estimated the contribution of the precessional term from the odd powers of μ\mu to the parameters of the kinematic model. The only parameter exhibiting a significant change is the angle θ\theta: the standard kinematic model underestimates this angle by approximately 2∘2^\circ relative to the true value. This shift is also accompanied by a delay of about two days in the epoch T3T_3 relative to the model prediction.

Adding to this model the noise in the direction of each jet, as found in § 4.3, does not change the amplitudes of the periodicities. To mimic the uncertainty in the ages of the moving lines, we introduced random deviations in the time stamps, the same for both jets (see the conclusions of § 4.3). Such phase noise reduces the amplitudes of the periodicities, the shorter the period, the stronger the reduction. Possibly for this reason, we see the 11d2711^{\mathrm d}27 periodicity in β\beta but do not detect the 4d144^{\mathrm d}14 periodicity, although their amplitudes should be equal. The same may explain the decrease in the amplitude of the 3d083^{\mathrm d}08 periodicity relative to that of 5d835^{\mathrm d}83. Thus, for Gaussian noise with σ=0d6\sigma= 0^{\mathrm d}6, the observed ratio of the amplitudes of these periodicities can be reproduced, but this requires an increase in a3a_3 to 3.6. The change in a3a_3 also leads to a slight change in a1=0.39a_1 = 0.39 and φ1=0.73\varphi_1 = 0.73.

The observed periodicities do not reflect the change in the angle between the precessional jet direction j\mathbf{j} and its perturbed direction j′\mathbf{j}' itself, but rather the projection of this perturbation onto the line of sight. However, this exact angle has physical meaning and characterizes the net perturbation of the disk by the donor star and gas streams. Expanding the scalar product j⋅j′\mathbf{j} \cdot\mathbf{j}' up to the quadratic term in aa (since the linear terms cancel out), we find that the jet deflection angle is

Δζk=akμk[1+sin⁡2θcos⁡2(φ+ψ−φk)].(21)\Delta\zeta_k = a_k\mu^k[1+\sin^2\theta\cos^2(\varphi+\psi-\varphi_k)]. \tag*{(21)}

That is, to within the accuracy of sin⁡2θ≈0.1\sin^2\theta\approx0.1 the deflection angle is equal to a(μ)a(\mu). Since μ\mu varies with the frequency ω+Ω\omega+\Omega (P=12d1P=12^{\mathrm d}1), the angle varies with the same frequency. Figure 10 shows the total variation of the angle for the even and odd powers of μ\mu for the found values of the amplitudes aka_k.

Figure 10. The jet deflection angle for the odd powers, Δζ1,3\Delta\zeta_{1,3}, which manifests itself as nutation, and for the second power, Δζ2\Delta\zeta_2, which manifests itself as variability of the total jet velocity β\beta. The sign of Δζ1,3\Delta\zeta_{1,3} follows the sign of μ\mu.

Conclusion

In § 4 we confirmed the conclusion of previous works [17, 5] that the jet direction exhibits random angular fluctuations, independent for each jet, with an amplitude of 1′′.51''.5. Against this background, it does not seem surprising that the jet and counterjet may fail to be parallel. Since the method for determining the full velocity assumes strict anti-parallelism of the jets, a deviation from anti-parallelism within such a model biases the full velocity β\beta.

The random deviations are superimposed on the harmonic variability. We confirm the previously detected periods of 13d0813^{\mathrm d}08, 11d2711^{\mathrm d}27, 6d296^{\mathrm d}29 and 5d835^{\mathrm d}83, and have also identified a new 3d083^{\mathrm d}08 period. The kinematic model of the deviations of the jet and counterjet from the direction set by the precession has allowed us to explain all the detected periodicities. In this model, the perturbation amplitude of each jet is a function of the cosine of the angle between this jet and the star–disk radius vector (μ±\boldsymbol{\mu}_{\pm}). The expansion of this function in powers of μ±\mu_{\pm} up to the cubic term yields the observed set of periodicities in the system, as well as a period of 4.14 days, which we do not detect, probably due to its low amplitude (≈1.3×10−3\approx1.3 \times10^{-3}) and the uncertainty in the age of the moving lines, which hinders the search for short periods.

Comparison of the observed phases of the periodicities with the model predictions showed that the deviation of the jet j+\mathbf{j}^{+} occurs in the direction of 120∘120^\circ from the star–disk radius vector, opposite to the orbital motion, for all the periodicities except the nutational one (6d296^{\mathrm d}29).

Thus, the analysis of the spectral observations of the moving lines in SS433, carried out at the Caucasian Mountain Observatory of the Sternberg Astronomical Institute of Lomonosov Moscow State University in 2020–2026, makes it possible to explain the periodic deviations from the kinematic model of the source within the framework of physically justified assumptions about the tidal influence of the optical component and the dynamical interaction of gas streams with the inclined precessing accretion disk. The empirically found regularities are important for understanding the complex physical processes during supercritical accretion onto black holes in Galactic microquasars and onto supermassive black holes in the nuclei of galaxies.

Acknowledgements

This work was carried out as part of the State Assignment of Lomonosov Moscow State University. Observations at the instruments and telescopes of the Caucasian Mountain Observatory are supported by the Development Programme of Lomonosov Moscow State University.

Data Availability

Measurements of z±z^{\pm} are available online.

Author Contributions

All authors contributed equally.

Facilities: CMO:2.5m

Software: astropy ([1, 2, 3])

References

  1. [1]Astropy Collaboration, Robitaille, T. P., Tollérud, E. J., et al. 2013, A&A, 558, A33, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361/201322068
  2. [2]Astropy Collaboration, Price-Whelan, A. M., Sipőcz, B. M., et al. 2018, AJ, 156, 123, doi: 10.3847/1538-3881/aabc4f
  3. [3]Astropy Collaboration, Price-Whelan, A. M., Lim, P. L., et al. 2022, ApJ, 935, 167, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ac7c74DOI
  4. [4]Blundell, K. M., & Bowler, M. G. 2004, ApJL, 616, L159, doi: 10.1086/426542DOI
  5. [5]Blundell, K. M., & Bowler, M. G. 2005, ApJL, 622, L129, doi: 10.1086/429663
  6. [6]Blundell, K. M., Bowler, M. G., & Schmidtobreick, L. 2007, Astron. Astrophys., 474, 903, doi: 10.1051/0004-6361:20077924DOI
  7. [7]Cherepashchuk, A., Belinski, A., Dodin, A., & Postnov, K. 2023, NewA, 103, 102060, doi: 10.1016/j.newast.2023.102060DOI
  8. [8]Cherepashchuk, A., Postnov, K., Molkov, S., Antokhina, E., & Belinski, A. 2020, New Astronomy Reviews, 89, 101542, doi: 10.1016/j.newar.2020.101542DOI
  9. [9]Cherepashchuk, A. M. 1981, MNRAS, 194, 761, doi: 10.1093/mnras/194.3.761DOI
  10. [10]Cherepashchuk, A. M., Dodin, A. V., & Postnov, K. A. 2025, Physics Uspekhi, 68, 1042, doi: 10.3367/UFNe.2025.05.039904DOI
  11. [11]Cherepashchuk, A. M., Dodin, A. V., Postnov, K. A., et al. 2022, Astronomy Reports, 66, 451, doi: 10.1134/S1063772922060026DOI
  12. [12]Cherepashchuk, A. M., Esipov, V. F., Dodin, A. V., Davydov, V. V., & Belinskii, A. A. 2018, Astronomy Reports, 62, 747, doi: 10.1134/S106377291811001XDOI
  13. [13]Davydov, V. V., Esipov, V. F., & Cherepashchuk, A. M. 2008, Astronomy Reports, 52, 487, doi: 10.1134/S1063772908060061DOI
  14. [14]Dodin, A. V., Postnov, K. A., & Cherepashchuk, A. M. 2026, ApJ, 999, 104, doi: 10.3847/1538-4357/ae3ddeDOI
  15. [15]Fabrika, S. 2004, Astrophys. Space Phys. Rev., 12, 1. https://arxiv.org/abs/astro-ph/0603390
  16. [16]Katz, J. I., Anderson, S. F., Margon, B., & Grandi, S. A. 1982, ApJ, 260, 780, doi: 10.1086/160297DOI
  17. [17]Katz, J. I., & Piran, T. 1982, Astrophys. Lett., 23, 11
  18. [18]Margon, B. 1984, Ann. Rev. Astron. and Astrophys., 22, 507, doi: 10.1146/annurev.aa.22.090184.002451DOI
  19. [19]Potanin, S. A., Belinski, A. A., Dodin, A. V., et al. 2020, Astronomy Letters, 46, 836, doi: 10.1134/S1063773720120038DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_9wvk97t6
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 4

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents