WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Field Theory of the Fermi Function
Abstract
The Fermi function accounts for QED corrections to beta decays that are enhanced at either small electron velocity or large nuclear charge . For precision applications, the Fermi function must be combined with other radiative corrections and with scale- and scheme-dependent hadronic matrix elements. We formulate the Fermi function as a field theory object and present a new factorization formula for QED radiative corrections to beta decays. We provide new results for the anomalous dimension of the corresponding effective operator complete through three loops, and resum perturbative logarithms and -enhancements with renormalization group methods. Our results are important for tests of fundamental physics with precision beta decay and related processes.
Introduction. Many precision measurements and new physics searches involve charged leptons interacting with nucleons or nuclei. Examples include neutrino scattering to obtain fundamental neutrino parameters [1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6]; muon-to-electron conversion to search for charged lepton flavor violation [7, 8, 9, 10]; and beta decay to measure fundamental constants [11, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20, 21, 22, 23] and search for new physics [24, 25, 26] [27, 28, 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34]. It is important to control radiative corrections to these processes [35–40]. The precision demands of superallowed nuclear beta decays are particularly stringent. As a consequence of Conserved Vector Current (CVC) relations, hadron and nuclear structure enter as small corrections. Experimental and nuclear uncertainties are being pushed to the level of 100 ppm [21] [41], providing the best determination of the fundamental Cabibbo-Kobayashi-Maskawa (CKM) quark mixing parameter , and the most stringent low-energy constraint on scalar currents beyond the Standard Model [21]. In this Letter we present new results for long-distance QED corrections to beta decay [42–44], and discuss implications for the CKM unitarity discrepancy [21] and New Physics constraints.
QED corrections are dramatically enhanced relative to naive power counting in the fine structure constant for large- nuclei and for small- leptons ( denotes the nuclear charge, and the lepton velocity). The Fermi function [45] in beta decay describes the enhancement (suppression) for negatively (positively) charged leptons propagating in a nuclear Coulomb field. For a nuclear charge and electron energy it is traditionally defined by solving the Dirac equation in a point-like Coulomb field. The result is then given as [45, 46]:
where , , and is the electron mass. The quantity denotes a short distance regulator identified approximately as the nuclear size [47]. Several questions arise in the application of to physical processes: 1) What is the scale and how does it relate to conventional renormalization in quantum field theory? 2) How can other radiative corrections be included systematically? 3) What is the relation between the Fermi function with and the radiative correction to neutron beta decay? Answering these questions is important for the interpretation of precision beta decay experiments. For example, corrections at order must be included at the current precision () of extractions [21]. These corrections require a theoretically self-consistent treatment of both the Fermi function and other radiative corrections, but have previously been treated only in a heuristic ansatz [38, 48]. To answer these questions, we re-formulate the Fermi function in effective field theory (EFT), and study its interplay with subleading radiative corrections.
Factorization and all-orders matching
Factorization arises from the separation of different energy scales involved in a physical process [49–51]. Nuclear beta decays involve physics at the weak scale GeV, the hadronic scale GeV, the scale of nuclear structure MeV, and the kinematic scales relevant for beta decay MeV. The methods of EFT allow for each scale to be treated separately, and facilitate the calculation of higher order radiative corrections. In a sequence of EFTs, the components of a factorization formula are identified with a corresponding sequence of matching coefficients, and a final low-energy matrix element. In the context of nuclear beta decays, the long-distance (or outer) radiative corrections can be computed in the low-energy effective theory, while structure dependent and short-distance (or inner) radiative corrections are absorbed into the Wilson coefficient. Real radiation is straightforwardly included [52].
Consider the corrections to a tree-level contact interaction with a relativistic electron in the final state. Ladder diagrams from a Coulomb potential with source charge correct the tree level amplitude, , with explicit loop integrals given by (see Ref. [43] for more details)
Integrals are evaluated in dimensional regularization with dimensions, and we have included a photon mass, , to regulate infrared divergences [53].
In contrast to the non-relativistic problem [54], the relativistic expression (2) is UV divergent beginning at two-loop order, indicating sensitivity to short-distance structure. The factorization theorem reads [43]
counting and where denotes the scale of hadronic and nuclear structure. We retain separate factorization scales and for clarity; conventional single scale matrix elements are obtained by setting . After MS renormalization, to all orders in , the soft function is given by [55, 56]. Our result for the hard function is new [43], and is given (again to all orders in ) by [57]
where , is a Dirac matrix, and is the Euler constant.
The leading-in- radiative correction to unpolarized observables from the soft and hard functions is given by
where we define . The angle brackets denote contraction with lepton spinors, , sum over final state spins, and division by the same expression in the absence of Coulomb corrections. Note that there is a finite multiplicative correction relating the MS hard function to .
Effective operators and anomalous dimension.
The structure-dependent factor appearing in Eq. (3) depends on the process of interest. Important examples are beta decay transitions or . Superallowed beta decays are governed by an EFT consisting of QED for electrons, and heavy charged scalar fields [58–61],
where denotes a heavy scalar with electric charge whose momentum fluctuations are expanded about , with in the nuclear rest frame.
For neutron decay, the EFT involves spin-1/2 heavy fields [58–61],
where and denote spin-1/2 heavy fields with electric charge 1 and 0, respectively. Matching to the EFT represented by Eqs. (6) or (7), we identify the components of (3) in terms of operator coefficients and matrix elements: is proportional to (a linear combination of) , while and give the hard and soft contributions to the EFT matrix element. In , at each order in , the leading power of is given by the explicit expression (4), obtained from the amplitudes (2). In particular, the leading-in- anomalous dimension is obtained from the dependence of Eq. (4), cf. Eq. (9) below.
We may proceed to analyze the renormalization group properties of weak-current operators in the EFT. Radiative corrections enhanced by large logarithms, , are determined by the anomalous dimensions of the operators in (6) and (7), which are spin-structure independent, i.e., . Writing
we note several interesting all-orders properties:
Powers of greater than the power of do not appear [62].
The leading series involving sums to
This result is obtained by differentiating Eq. (4) with respect to .
At each order in perturbation theory, the leading and first subleading powers of are related [63],
When , the problem reduces to a heavy-light current operator. Using our new result for [42] and property (10), the complete result through three-loop order at arbitrary is
where , , are known from the heavy quark literature [64]. Our result for disagrees with Ref. [39], which did not include the full set of relevant diagrams at [42]. Note that properties (9) and (10) also determine the anomalous dimension at order and .
Renormalization group analysis
An important advantage of identifying the Fermi function as a field theory object is the ability to resum large logarithms, , at high perturbative orders using renormalization group methods. Consider the solution to the renormalization group equation
where is the QED coupling (for one dynamical electron flavor) and [66]. Expanding and in powers of and , then integrating, we obtain a systematic expansion for the ratio of the renormalized operator coefficient at different scales, . Setting and , we thus resum large logarithms [67]. Since the convergence of the series in is influenced by , let us consider several regimes of :
Large asymptotics.
Consider a large nucleus, counting and . For example we may consider beta decays of or . Through ,
where , , and . Consider separately the terms in with odd and even powers of . Using Eq. (10),
The corresponding decay rate corrections involve (less the known correction) [68]
The even series, , is determined through three loop order by Eq. (11).
Intermediate .
Consider a medium nucleus, counting . This is relevant for superallowed beta decays contributing to extraction, which range from () to (). Through , the scale dependence is
where and the square brackets account for effects at order , , , etc.
Achieving permille precision demands proper treatment of terms through resummed order . This result (16) replaces (and disagrees with) logarithmically enhanced contributions at order in the “heuristic estimate” of Sirlin and Zucchini[69]. Using our new result for [42] we compare to this heuristic estimate, and investigate the convergence of perturbation theory in Figure 1. Here we fix , and compute the product of and the squared operator matrix element at , varying as an estimate of perturbative uncertainty [70]. Normalizing to the leading Fermi function (known analytically to all orders) this quantity corresponds to the outer radiative correction appearing in the beta decay literature, (cf. Eq. (11) of Supplemental Material). We note that Eq. (11) is in fact sufficient for a resummation of through , although for practical applications one would also need currently unknown operator matrix elements at [71].
Figure 1. Radiative correction to the beta decay rate as a function of nuclear charge, normalized to leading Fermi function. RC denotes the outer radiative correction, , computed for fixed electron energy, cf. Eq. (11) of Supplemental Material. Red, blue and green curves show results correct through resummed order , and respectively. The black curve represents the central value for Sirlin’s heuristic estimate as implemented in Ref. [21]. Illustrative values , , are used for the electron energy, maximum electron energy (which enters the one-loop matrix element [35]), and renormalization scale , respectively. The width of the curves is given by varying . Analytic expressions can be obtained using Eq. (16) [65].
Neutron beta decay.
Neutron beta decay corresponds to the case (in our convention); we therefore define . Again counting , the resummation is [72]
where the first term is of order , and the second term is of order . The complete result, correct through order , is obtained using (17) together with the one-loop low-energy matrix element.
Even after resumming logarithms in the ratio of hadronic and electron mass scales, , large coefficients remain in the perturbative expansion of the hard matrix element. While the class of amplitudes summed in the Fermi function are enhanced at small and large , neither limit holds for neutron beta decay [73]. The large coefficients can instead be traced to an analytic continuation of the decay amplitude from spacelike to timelike values of momentum transfers. The enhancements are systematically resummed by renormalization of the hard factor in the factorization formula (3) from negative to positive values of (cf. Refs. [74, 75]), with the result [44]
where and is free of -enhancements. This analysis systematically resums -enhanced contributions, and does not rely on a non-relativistic approximation.
Discussion
At the outset of our discussion we posed three questions, which are now answered: 1) The scale appearing in the Fermi function (1) is unambiguously related to a conventional subtraction point, cf. Eq. (5). 2) The Fermi function is identified as the leading-in- contribution to the matrix element from the effective Lagrangian (6). Other radiative corrections are systematically computed using the same Lagrangian. 3) Numerically enhanced contributions in neutron beta decay arise from perturbative logarithms , and can be resummed to all orders. The result (18) differs from the nonrelativistic Fermi function ansatz [37, 76] beginning at two loop order.
Our EFT analysis allows us to systematically resum large perturbative logarithms, and to incorporate corrections that are suppressed by or . New results include:
New coefficients in the expansion of the anomalous dimension for beta decay operators. We have computed the order coefficient for the first time [77], and found a new symmetry linking leading- and subleading- terms in the perturbative expansion. Using our new result, and the existing HQET literature, we show that the first unknown coefficient occurs at four loops, at order [42].
New results for the large- asymptotics of QED radiative corrections to beta decay. We supply the infinite series of terms of order , replacing Wilkinson’s ansatz [78], and present a new result for the term of order , replacing Sirlin’s heuristic estimate [38]. We provide the EFT matrix element to all orders in and clarify its relation to the historically employed Fermi function [43].
An all-orders resummation of “-enhanced” terms in neutron beta decay, replacing the Fermi function ansatz. This substantially improves the convergence of perturbation theory, and is important for modern applications to neutron beta decay [44].
Each of these results has important implications for ongoing and near-term precision beta decay programs [13, 16, 22] [79, 80, 81, 82, 83, 84, 85, 86, 87, 88, 89, 90, 91, 92, 93, 94]. Detailed computations are presented elsewhere [42–44]. Related work on new eikonal identities for charged current processes is presented in Ref. [95]. The same formalism applies to any situation involving charged leptons and nuclei, provided the lepton energy is small compared to the inverse nuclear radius.
An immediate conclusion of our study is that the existing estimate for corrections is incorrect. Focusing on the dominant logarithmically enhanced terms, the coefficient “a” in Sirlin’s heuristic estimate [38, 39], changes. For the 9 transitions with smallest uncertainty (at or below permille level), this leads to shifts ranging from for to for [96], i.e., an order of magnitude larger than the estimated uncertainty on the outer radiative correction [21]. We observe that these shifts are comparable in magnitude to the CKM discrepancy, [21], and with a sign that goes in the direction of resolving the discrepancy. Accounting for these strongly -dependent corrections should also impact New Physics constraints such as on scalar currents beyond the Standard Model [21]. A complete determination of the long-distance radiative corrections at the level will require revisiting the matrix element in the point-like EFT considered here; this work is ongoing. Future work will address factorization at subleading power, and investigate the impact on phenomenology including hadronic [12] [40] and nuclear [15] [97] matching uncertainties.
Acknowledgments
We thank Susan Gardner and Oleksandr Tomalak for useful discussions regarding radiative corrections for beta decays, and Peter Vander Griend for collaboration on Ref. [44]. RP thanks the Institute for Nuclear Theory at the University of Washington for its kind hospitality and stimulating research environment during program INT 23-1B. This research was supported in part by the INT’s U.S. Department of Energy grant No. DE-FG02-00ER41132. This work was supported by the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of High Energy Physics, under Award DE-SC0019095. Fermilab is operated by Fermi Research Alliance, LLC under Contract No. DE-AC02-07CH11359 with the United States Department of Energy. RP is supported by the Neutrino Theory Network under Award Number DEAC02-07CH11359, the U.S. Department of Energy, Office of Science, Office of High Energy Physics, under Award Number DE-SC0011632, and by the Walter Burke Institute for Theoretical Physics. RJH gratefully acknowledges support from the Institute for Advanced Study, where a part of this work was completed.
Supplemental material
Factorization
Consider the Lagrangian (Eq. (6) and Eq. (7) of the main text) describing physics below hadronic and nuclear scales:
where in the nuclear rest frame. For the superallowed beta decay case we have scalar heavy particle fields , , and Dirac structures and . For the neutron beta decay case we have fermionic heavy particle fields , , and Dirac structures and . Coefficients , and are determined by matching the effective theory (19) to the quark-level Standard Model Lagrangian. Feynman rules corresponding to this Lagrangian are shown in Figure 2.
Figure 2. Feynman rules for the hard-scale Lagrangian (19), with gauge parameter and photon mass
For physics below the electron mass scale, electrons of a given four velocity (plus soft radiation) are described by a Lagrangian where the electron is also represented by a heavy-particle field [98],
Feynman rules corresponding to this Lagrangian are shown in Figure 3. It is readily seen that the heavy particle effective theory Feynman rules ensure that the most general Dirac structure is given by the square bracket in Eq. (20) (note that we have ). From the soft Lagrangian (20) we may read off the complete amplitude in the factorized form, Eq. (3) of the main text. Writing the complete amplitude as
Figure 3. Feynman rules for the soft-scale Lagrangian (20) involving the heavy electron field.
we identify
and the soft matrix element is given by
Real radiation
Real photon radiation does not contribute to the leading-in- radiative correction described by the Fermi function (cf. Eq. [1] of the main text), but does contribute at subleading orders. The Lagrangian (19) describes physics below hadronic and nuclear scales, including arbitrary photon radiation. In particular, the solution to the renormalization group equation, Eq. (12) of the main text (cf. Eqs. (13), [16] of the main text), applies to both processes with and without real radiation, and systematically resums large logarithms .
To demonstrate the application of (19) to real photon radiation, let us consider the leading, order , correction, computed from the diagrams shown in Figure 4. Let us write
Figure 4. Feynman diagrams for first order corrections to neutron beta decay rate computed from Eq. (19). Wavefunction renormalization is not shown.
The virtual and real soft contributions are given by Feynman diagrams in the soft theory, cf. [20] and Figure 3:
where real photons of energy smaller than are included (we may take ). The remaining hard contributions are
where is the nuclear energy difference, equal to the maximum possible electron energy. It is readily seen that the dependence on the photon mass regulator cancels in the sum of and , and the soft photon threshold cancels in the sum of and . Further, the dependence on the arbitrary factorization scale cancels between and , and the dependence on cancels between and . For the latter cancellation, we observe that , using Eq. (11) of the main text (at corresponding to neutron beta decay).
The expression (24) corresponds to the well-known result of Sirlin [35]. In particular, upon setting ( the proton mass) and omitting the term in our , the sum gives in Eq. (20) from Ref. [35] up to a conventional constant ( in Eq. (26) for MS vs. in Ref. [35], cf. Ref. [12]). In Ref. [35], the additional term is included in a Fermi function factor, cf. Eq. [1] of the main text at . In comparing with we have used that .
Numerical impact of radiative corrections
Our analysis determines new contributions to structure-independent radiative corrections to superallowed nuclear beta decay rates. These corrections directly impact the associated extraction of . In the notation of Ref. [21] we have
where is the effective operator matrix element and denotes integration over (electron/positron, neutrino and real photon) phase space and sum over lepton spin states [99]. The product of denominators in Eq. (29) extracts the conventional integrated Fermi function prefactor appearing in traditional rate formulas [21]. Here, as in the main text, the short distance regulator in is identified as . Taking and , the round bracket in Eq. (29) is free of large logarithms . Further, because we have divided by the leading-in- expression, the perturbative expansion contains only terms with . In the “intermediate ” power counting discussed in the main text, the relevant terms are at order [35] (cf. Eq. (24)) and at order . The order matrix element has been considered using a different regulator scheme in Ref. [38]. Further discussion of this matrix element will be presented elsewhere [44].
Logarithmic enhancements are contained in the square bracket in Eq. (29). Our results for the resummed coefficient, Eq. (16) of the main text, yield
expressed in terms of the onshell coupling . The terms at order and at order have been included as part of the order [35] and order [38] corrections. The term at order is a correction to the two-loop Fermi function, and has been included in Ref. [38]. The term at order corresponds to and corrects a previous result in the literature, as noted in the main text. The remaining terms have not to our knowledge been included in analyses of nuclear beta decay: the term at order involves the two-loop anomalous dimension ; the terms at order and are higher-order corrections that involve the one-loop anomalous dimension ; the term at order is a higher order correction induced by the contribution (involving ); and the term at order involves the interference of the two loop Fermi function and one loop anomalous dimension, and .
Let us focus on the correction and determine the numerical impact of our new calculation compared to the Jaus-Rasche estimate of the anomalous dimension. We use the updated value from their 1987 paper [39], which determines the coefficient in Sirlin’s heuristic estimate of (i.e., as written in Footnote 10 of Ref. [48]). We find instead . We define . To estimate the size of the logarithm we set with and taken from Ref. [100].
| transition | |
Table 1. Shift in the outer radiative correction at order , for the 9 transitions with smallest uncertainty in Ref. [21].
In the convention we follow in the main text, the two nuclei involved in the transition have charge and . The superallowed transitions that are important for extractions are of the form and for simplicity we will always choose transitions with a positron in the final state. This means that will always correspond to the daughter nucleus. For the transitions with relatively small errors [21] we find the results in Table I [101]. In each case, the shift is larger than the error currently ascribed to . A definitive statement at an accuracy on the order of 100 ppm will require a renewed scrutiny of the matrix element at in the point-like effective theory.
References
the correction.
[70] We include the full matrix element [35] (translated to in heavy particle effective theory). For this comparison we include only the scale-dependent logarithm, , in the matrix element [38].
[71] These matrix elements have been calculated in Ref. [38], but not in the point-like effective theory studied here.
[72] The two-loop anomalous dimension and other subleading two-loop corrections were omitted in the leading-logarithm analysis of Ref. [109]. Ref. [76] included in the RG flow between nucleon and electron-mass scales.
[?] At tree level, less than 0.1% of the total decay rate involves electron velocity , and less than 10% of the rate involves .
[?] V. Ahrens, T. Becher, M. Neubert, and L. L. Yang, Phys. Rev. D 79, 033013 (2009), arXiv:0808.3008 [hep-ph].
[?] V. Ahrens, T. Becher, M. Neubert, and L. L. Yang, Eur. Phys. J. C 62, 333 (2009), arXiv:0809.4283 [hep-ph].
[?] V. Cirigliano, W. Dekens, E. Mereghetti, and O. Tomalak, (2023), arXiv:2306.03138 [hep-ph].
[77] Existing order calculations [36] included only a subset of diagrams and are therefore incomplete estimates.
[?] D. Wilkinson, Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment 401, 275 (1997).
[?] M. A. P. Brown et al. (UCNA), Phys. Rev. C 97, 035505 (2018), arXiv:1712.00884 [nucl-ex].
[?] P. D. Shidling et al., Phys. Rev. C 90, 032501 (2014), arXiv:1407.1742 [nucl-ex].
[?] M. Eibach et al., Phys. Rev. C 92, 045502 (2015).
[?] M. G. Sternberg et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 115, 182501 (2015).
[?] K. Gulyuz et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 116, 012501 (2016).
[?] B. Fenker et al., New J. Phys. 18, 073028 (2016), arXiv:1602.04526 [physics.atom-ph].
[?] J. Long et al., Phys. Rev. C 96, 015502 (2017).
[?] B. Fenker et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 120, 062502 (2018), arXiv:1706.00414 [nucl-ex].
[?] M. Brodeur, J. Kelly, J. Long, C. Nicoloff, and B. Schultz, Nucl. Instrum. Meth. B 376, 281 (2016).
[?] P. D. Shidling et al., Phys. Rev. C 98, 015502 (2018).
[?] A. A. Valverde et al., Phys. Rev. C 97, 035503 (2018).
[?] P. D. O’Malley et al., Nucl. Instrum. Meth. B 463, 488 (2020).
[?] D. P. Burdette et al., Phys. Rev. C 101, 055504 (2020).
[?] J. Long et al., Phys. Rev. C 101, 015501 (2020).
[?] P. Müller et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 129, 182502 (2022), arXiv:2206.00742 [nucl-ex].
[?] J. Long et al., Phys. Rev. C 106, 045501 (2022).
[?] R. Plestid, (2024), arXiv:2402.14769 [hep-ph].
[?] See Supplemental Material [URL-HERE] for a discussion of how these numerical shifts are computed.
[?] M. Gennari et al., “Standard model corrections to fermi transitions in light nuclei,” (2023), INT PROGRAM 23-1B, New physics searches at the precision frontier.
[98] Recall that we are counting as order unity. Since the electron is pointlike there is no further restriction on , unlike the case for the decay of heavy mesons with internal structure [102].
[99] Remaining radiative corrections, denoted by in Ref. [21], are identified (up to a prefactor involving ) with the matching coefficient in the effective Lagrangian (19).
[?] J. C. Hardy and I. S. Towner, Phys. Rev. C 71, 055501 (2005), arXiv:nucl-th/0412056.
[101] The Table lists transitions for which the total uncertainty is ; cf. Figure 4 of Ref. [21].
[?] N. Isgur and M. B. Wise, Phys. Lett. B 237, 527 (1990).
[?] M. A. B. Beg, J. Bernstein, and A. Sirlin, Phys. Rev. Lett. 23, 270 (1969).
[?] X.-D. Ji and M. J. Musolf, Phys. Lett. B 257, 409 (1991).
[?] K. G. Chetyrkin and A. G. Grozin, Nucl. Phys. B 666, 289 (2003), arXiv:hep-ph/0303113.
[?] P. A. Baikov, K. G. Chetyrkin, J. H. Kühn, and J. Rittinger, JHEP 07, 017 (2012), arXiv:1206.1284 [hep-ph].
[?] F. Herzog et al., JHEP 02, 090 (2017), arXiv:1701.01404 [hep-ph].
[?] R. J. Hill, Phys. Rev. D 95, 013001 (2017), arXiv:1605.02613 [hep-ph].
[?] A. Czarnecki, W. J. Marciano, and A. Sirlin, Phys. Rev. D70, 093006 (2004), arXiv:hep-ph/0406324.
References
- [1]H. Nunokawa, S. J. Parke, and J. W. F. Valle, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 60, 338 (2008), arXiv:0710.0554 [hep-ph].DOI
- [2]K. Abe et al. (Hyper-Kamiokande Working Group) (2014) arXiv:1412.4673 [physics.ins-det].arxiv.org/abs/1412.4673
- [3]M. V. Diwan, V. Galymov, X. Qian, and A. Rubbia, Ann. Rev. Nucl. Part. Sci. 66, 47 (2016), arXiv:1608.06237 [hep-ex].DOI
- [4]M. A. Acero et al. (NOvA), Phys. Rev. D 106, 032004 (2022), arXiv:2108.08219 [hep-ex].DOI
- [5]K. Abe et al. (T2K), Phys. Rev. D 103, 112008 (2021), arXiv:2101.03779 [hep-ex].DOI
- [6]B. Abi et al. (DUNE), Eur. Phys. J. C 80, 978 (2020), arXiv:2006.16043 [hep-ex].DOI
- [7]A. de Gouvea and P. Vogel, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 71, 75 (2013), arXiv:1303.4097 [hep-ph].DOI
- [8]R. H. Bernstein and P. S. Cooper, Phys. Rept. 532, 27 (2013), arXiv:1307.5787 [hep-ex].DOI
- [9]M. Lee, Front. in Phys. 6 (2018), 10.3389/fphy.2018.00133.
- [10]R. H. Bernstein (Mu2e), Front. in Phys. 7, 1 (2019), arXiv:1901.11099 [physics.ins-det].DOI
- [11]P. Bopp, D. Dubbers, L. Hornig, E. Klemt, J. Last, H. Schutze, S. J. Freedman, and O. Scharpf, Phys. Rev. Lett. 56, 919 (1986), [Erratum: Phys.Rev.Lett. 57, 1192 (1986)].
- [12]S. Ando, H. W. Fearing, V. P. Gudkov, K. Kubodera, F. Myhrer, S. Nakamura, and T. Sato, Phys. Lett. B 595, 250 (2004), arXiv:nucl-th/0402100.
- [13]G. Darius et al., Phys. Rev. Lett. 119, 042502 (2017).
- [14]C.-Y. Seng, M. Gorchtein, H. H. Patel, and M. J. Ramsey-Musolf, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121, 241804 (2018), arXiv:1807.10197 [hep-ph].DOI
- [15]C. Y. Seng, M. Gorchtein, and M. J. Ramsey-Musolf, Phys. Rev. D 100, 013001 (2019), arXiv:1812.03352 [nucl-th].DOI
- [16]J. Fry et al., EPJ Web Conf. 219, 04002 (2019), arXiv:1811.10047 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [17]A. Czarnecki, W. J. Marciano, and A. Sirlin, Phys. Rev. D 100, 073008 (2019), arXiv:1907.06737 [hep-ph].DOI
- [18]L. Hayen, Phys. Rev. D 103, 113001 (2021), arXiv:2010.07262 [hep-ph].DOI
- [19]C.-Y. Seng, X. Feng, M. Gorchtein, and L.-C. Jin, Phys. Rev. D 101, 111301 (2020), arXiv:2003.11264 [hep-ph].DOI
- [20]M. Gorchtein and C.-Y. Seng, JHEP 10, 053 (2021), arXiv:2106.09185 [hep-ph].DOI
- [21]J. C. Hardy and I. S. Towner, Phys. Rev. C 102, 045501 (2020).
- [22]F. M. Gonzalez et al. (UCNτ), Phys. Rev. Lett. 127, 162501 (2021), arXiv:2106.10375 [nucl-ex].DOI
- [23]K. Shiells, P. G. Blunden, and W. Melnitchouk, Phys. Rev. D 104, 033003 (2021), arXiv:2021.01580 [hep-ph].
- [24]V. Cirigliano, S. Gardner, and B. Holstein, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 71, 93 (2013), arXiv:1303.6953 [hep-ph].DOI
- [25]A. Glick-Magid, Y. Mishnayot, I. Mukul, M. Hass, S. Vaintraub, G. Ron, and D. Gazit, Phys. Lett. B 767, 285 (2017), arXiv:1609.03268 [nucl-ex].
- [26]M. González-Alonso, O. Naviliat-Cuncic, and N. Severijns, Prog. Part. Nucl. Phys. 104, 165 (2019), arXiv:1803.08732 [hep-ph].

