betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Stafford's conjecture on cyclicity of torsion modules

Abstract

We prove that over a Weyl algebra over a field of characteristic zero An(k)A_n(k), every nonzero d∈An(k)d\in A_n(k) admits F,R,S∈An(k)F,R,S\in A_n(k) such that 1=dR+FdS1=dR+FdS, a conjecture Stafford proposed in 1978. As a consequence, every finitely generated torsion right An(k)A_n(k)-module is cyclic. The proof maps dd, by a symplectic change of variables, to a normal form d~\tilde d and shows that the cyclic module Q=An(k)/(d~An(k)+x1Nd~An(k))Q=A_n(k)/(\tilde dA_n(k)+x_1^N\tilde dA_n(k)) vanishes. We first show that right multiplication by x1x_1 is surjective on QQ. A comparison of lengths of localized modules over the associated graded ring then gives gr⁡Q=x1gr⁡Q\operatorname{gr}Q=x_1\operatorname{gr}Q, so that the characteristic variety of QQ is disjoint from the hyperplane {x1=0}\{x_1=0\}. Finally, Gabber's involutivity theorem together with an argument about conormal directions at infinity from algebraic geometry shows that such a characteristic variety must be empty and therefore, Q=0Q = 0.

Introduction

Let kk be a field of characteristic zero, and let

An(k)=k⟨x1,…,xn,∂1,…,∂n⟩A_n(k)=k\langle x_1,\ldots,x_n,\partial_1,\ldots,\partial_n\rangle

be the nnth Weyl algebra, with [∂i,xj]=δij[\partial_i,x_j]=\delta_{ij} and [∂i,∂j]=[xi,xj]=0[\partial_i,\partial_j]=[x_i,x_j]=0. Stafford’s Conjecture 3.8 in [1] asks whether every nonzero d∈An(k)d\in A_n(k) admits F∈An(k)F\in A_n(k) with An(k)=dAn(k)+FdAn(k)A_n(k)=dA_n(k)+FdA_n(k) [1 p. 438]. Stafford shows that this formulation implies stable cyclicity for all finitely generated torsion right Weyl-algebra modules [1 pp. 437–438]. We prove Stafford’s conjecture:

Theorem 1.1 For every field of characteristic zero kk, every n≥0n \ge0, and every nonzero d∈An(k)d \in A_n(k), there exists an F∈An(k)F \in A_n(k) such that

An(k)=dAn(k)+FdAn(k),A_n(k) = dA_n(k) + FdA_n(k),

or equivalently, there exist F,S,R∈An(k)F,S,R \in A_n(k) such that

1=dR+FdS.1 = dR + FdS.

Moreover, if n≥1n \ge1, one may choose F=Φg−1(x1)deg⁡BdF = \Phi_g^{-1}(x_1)^{\deg_B d} for a linear ω\omega-preserving automorphism gg as in § 3.

Proof sketch: We state some preliminaries in § 2, then start in § 3 by defining a map Φg\Phi_g sending any chosen dd of Bernstein degree NN to a monic normal form d~\widetilde{d} with order symbol PP using Bernstein and order filtrations of An(k)A_n(k). For d~\widetilde{d}, we prove in § 4–§ 6 that the module Q=An(k)/(d~An(k)+x1Nd~An(k))Q = A_n(k)/(\widetilde{d}A_n(k) + x_1^N\widetilde{d}A_n(k)) vanishes, and find the final form of Theorem 1.1 by applying the inverse map Φg−1\Phi_g^{-1} to dAn(k)+x1Nd~An(k)dA_n(k) + x_1^N\widetilde{d}A_n(k). The main components of the proof are the following: in § 4, we show that Q=Qx1Q = Q_{x_1} using the extended euclidean algorithm, and gr⁡Q=x1gr⁡Q\operatorname{gr} Q = x_1\operatorname{gr} Q, through two contradictory length estimations of localized modules. In section 5, using mainly results from algebraic geometry, we show that a set WW fulfilling certain criteria (Zariski closed over an algebraically closed field of characteristic zero, fibre-conical, involutive, there exists a polynomial with P(1,0,…,0)≠0P(1,0,\ldots,0) \ne0 vanishing on WW, and WW does not contain points with x1=0x_1 = 0) must always be empty (Theorem 5.8). Finally, we show in § 6 that by defining WW to be the characteristic variety of the closed-field pendant to QQ, the results of § 4 as well as the definition of PP in § 3 ensure that WW fulfils all criteria and must thus be empty. We conclude that therefore, also QQ itself must be zero, from which Theorem 1.1 follows directly. Lastly, we provide the proof by Stafford [1] that hence, every finitely generated torsion module is stably cyclic (Corollary 6.3).

Related literature

Dixmier showed that over the first Weyl algebra A1(k)A_1(k) with kk having characteristic zero, any right ideal can be generated by at most two elements [2]. In a seminal paper in 1978, Stafford extended this result to all An(k)A_n(k) and moreover showed, that any finitely generated left torsion An(k)A_n(k)-module is a homomorphic image of a projective left ideal, and as such can also be (stably) generated by at most two elements [1 Theorem 3.7]. Hillebrand and Schmale [3], as well as Leykin [4] give an algorithm to find the two generators of left ideals, also valid for rational coefficient algebras Bn(k)B_n(k). Caro and Levéovitz [5] generalize the result for both left and right ideals to formal and to convergent Laurent series, and Quadrat and Robertz [6] provide a constructive proof method to calculate the two generators of torsion modules over the Weyl algebras, as well as rings with rational coefficients, formal or convergent Laurent series, and, for ordinary differential operators, with formal or locally convergent power series coefficients.

In the same paper [1], Stafford states the Conjecture 3.8 (our Theorem 1.1), and shows that this conjecture implies that any finitely generated right torsion module can be stably generated by one element, i.e. is stably cyclic (Corollary 6.3). He shows that cyclicity is true if n=1n = 1 (since A1(k)A_1(k) has the restricted minimum condition which makes torsion modules Artinian and he proves that Artinian modules are cyclic) and also states that the conjecture is true if dd is monomial, but provides, as far as the authors are aware, no proof of this. This case is also contained in our proof. For holonomic modules over “simple rings such that they do not have finite length over themselves as left modules” (which all Weyl algebras are), Leykin [4] proved cyclicity constructively, and attributed the proof method to Stafford. However, torsion modules need not be holonomic: for n≥2n \ge2, Stafford constructed quotients An(k)/dAn(k)A_n(k)/dA_n(k) of Gelfand–Kirillov dimension 2n−12n-1 as counterexamples [7], so the question about cyclicity remained open for non-holonomic torsion modules. A paper by Bellamy in 2026 states this explicitly ([8] Conjecture 3.4).

We base our proof on the Weyl algebra and on filtrations and characteristic varieties of An(k)A_n(k)-modules as treated in the textbooks [9, 10, 11, 12, 13], on the involutivity of the characteristic variety due to Gabber [14, 15, 16], on commutative algebra, in particular localization, length, valuation rings, Kähler differentials and completions [17, 18, 19], field theory and bilinear forms [20] and spectral sequences [21], and on algebraic geometry, mostly based on [22].

Formal verification with Lean

Theorem 1.1 and Corollary 6.3 are proved in Lean 4 [23] with Mathlib [24] and AlgebraicAnalysis v0.3.3 [25]. The proofs use only Lean’s three standard axioms: propositional extensionality (propext), the axiom of choice (Classical.choice) and soundness of quotient types (Quot.sound). Every intermediate result is proved in Lean as well, including Gabber’s involutivity theorem for cyclic An(k)A_n(k)-modules. The proof in Sections 3–6 follows the formal proof step by step. The main theorem is registered in Palomar [26], and the Lean sources are archived [27]. Tooling and the role of AI assistance are described in Appendix § 9. Section 7 states further consequences proved in Lean and two generalizations, to rings of differential operators on smooth affine varieties and to simple filtered algebras. The supplementary material [28] shows each formalized statement of this paper next to its Lean version and proof. It can be browsed at https://itpplasma.github.io/stafford38-supplementary/.

Preliminaries

Throughout, kk is a field of characteristic zero and for the nn-th Weyl algebra over kk, we write

An(k)=k⟨x1,…,xn,∂1,…,∂n⟩,[∂i,xj]=δij,[xi,xj]=[∂i,∂j]=0.A_n(k) = k\langle x_1,\ldots,x_n,\partial_1,\ldots,\partial_n\rangle,\quad[\partial_i,x_j] = \delta_{ij},\quad[x_i,x_j] = [\partial_i,\partial_j] = 0.

All ideals are right ideals and all modules are right modules unless the contrary is said explicitly.

Definition 2.1 (e.g. [9]) Let MM be a right An(k)A_n(k)-module. We say MM is torsion if for every m∈Mm \in M there exists 0≠d∈An(k)0 \ne d \in A_n(k) with md=0md = 0, and cyclic if M=mAn(k)M = mA_n(k) for some mm.

Notation 2.2 We single out the first Weyl pair (x1,∂1)(x_1,\partial_1) and write

p:=∂1,C:=An−1(k)[x1],An(k)=C[p;δ],p := \partial_1,\qquad C := A_{n-1}(k)[x_1],\qquad A_n(k) = C[p;\delta],

Here δ(x1)=1\delta(x_1) = 1 and δ\delta vanishes on An−1(k)A_{n-1}(k), so that x1x_1 is central in CC, [p,x1]=1[p,x_1] = 1, and the transverse algebra An−1(k)=k⟨xi,∂i:i≥2⟩A_{n-1}(k) = k\langle x_i,\partial_i:i \ge2\rangle commutes with x1x_1 and pp. Every element of An(k)A_n(k) can uniquely be written as ∑jpjcj\sum_j p^j c_j with cj∈Cc_j \in C. [9 Prop. 1.2.1]

References

  1. [1]Stafford, J.T.: Module structure of Weyl algebras. Journal of the London Mathematical Society. Second Series 18(3), 429–442 (1978) https://doi.org/10.1112/jlms/s2-18.3.429
  2. [2]Dixmier, J.: Sur les algèbres de Weyl. Bulletin de la Société mathématique de France 96, 209–242 (1968)DOI
  3. [3]Hillebrand, A., Schmale, W.: Towards an effective version of a theorem of Stafford. Journal of Symbolic Computation 32(6), 699–716 (2001) https://doi.org/10.1006/jsco.2001.0491
  4. [4]Leykin, A.: Algorithmic proofs of two theorems of Stafford. Journal of Symbolic Computation 38(6), 1535–1550 (2004) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jsc.2004.07.003 arXiv:math/024303
  5. [5]Caro, N., Levcovitz, D.: On a theorem of Stafford. Cadernos de Matemática 11, 63–70 (2010). Preprint at https://arxiv.org/abs/1005.4427
  6. [6]Quadrat, A., Robertz, D.: A constructive study of the module structure of rings of partial differential operators. Acta Applicandae Mathematicae 133(1), 187–234 (2014) https://doi.org/10.1007/s10440-013-9864-x
  7. [7]Stafford, J.T.: Non-holonomic modules over Weyl algebras and enveloping algebras. Inventiones Mathematicae 79, 619–638 (1985) https://doi.org/10.1007/BF01388528
  8. [8]Bellamy, G.: Module structure of Weyl algebras. Journal of the London Mathematical Society 113(1), 7073 (2026) https://doi.org/10.1112/jlms.7073 arXiv:2510.19344
  9. [9]Coutinho, S.C.: A Primer of Algebraic D-modules vol. 33. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1995)DOI
  10. [10]Björk, J.-E.: Rings of Differential Operators. North-Holland Mathematical Library, vol. 21. North-Holland, Amsterdam (1979)
  11. [11]Hotta, R., Takeuchi, K., Tanisaki, T.: D-modules, Perverse Sheaves, and Representation Theory. Progress in Mathematics, vol. 236. Birkhäuser, Boston (2008). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-0-8176-4523-6
  12. [12]McConnell, J.C., Robson, J.C.: Noncommutative Noetherian Rings. Graduate Studies in Mathematics, vol. 30. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI (2001). 1st edition published by Wiley, Chichester, 1987; reprinted with corrections 2001
  13. [13]Schnell, C.: D-modules. Lecture notes (2019). https://www.math.stonybrook.edu/%7Eschnell/pdf/notes/d-modules.pdf
  14. [14]Gabber, O.: The integrability of the characteristic variety. American Journal of Mathematics 103(3), 445–468 (1981) https://doi.org/10.2307/2374101
  15. [15]Gabber, O.: The integrability of the characteristic variety: erratum. American Journal of Mathematics 104(5), 1125 (1982) https://doi.org/10.2307/2374086
  16. [16]Singh, J., Kumar, S.D.: On the involutivity of the characteristic variety. Communications in Algebra 42(8), 3607–3618 (2014) https://doi.org/10.1080/00927872.2013.790393
  17. [17]Atiyah, M.F., Macdonald, I.G.: Introduction to Commutative Algebra. Addison-Wesley, Reading, MA (1969)
  18. [18]Matsumura, H.: Commutative Ring Theory. Cambridge Studies in Advanced Mathematics, vol. 8. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1986). Translated from the Japanese by M. ReidDOI
  19. [19]The Stacks Project Authors: Stacks Project (2026). https://stacks.math.columbia.edu
  20. [20]Lang, S.: Algebra. Springer, New York (2012)
  21. [21]Weibel, C.A.: An Introduction to Homological Algebra vol. 38. Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (1994)DOI
  22. [22]Hartshorne, R.: Algebraic Geometry. Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 52. Springer, New York (1977)
  23. [23]Moura, L., Ullrich, S.: The Lean 4 theorem prover and programming language. In: Automated Deduction – CADE 28. Lecture Notes in Computer Science, vol. 12699, pp. 625–635. Springer, Cham (2021). https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-79876-5_37
  24. [24]The mathlib Community: The Lean mathematical library. In: Proceedings of the 9th ACM SIGPLAN International Conference on Certified Programs and Proofs, pp. 367–381. ACM, New York (2020). https://doi.org/10.1145/3372885.3373824
  25. [25]Albert, C.: AlgebraicAnalysis v0.3.3. Zenodo software release v0.3.3. Source revision bbbbf3fc358ca8100b158cec4cf47f336ab70163 (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.23104842
  26. [26]Albert, C.: Stafford 3.8. Palomar registry, entry PALOMAR-2026-09-05-000007, version 4 (2026). https://palomar-registry.org/entry?id=PALOMAR-2026-09-05-000007&version=4
  27. [27]Albert, C.: Stafford’s Conjecture 3.8 for Weyl algebras: Lean 4 formalization v1.4.0. Zenodo software release v1.4.0 (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24140371
  28. [28]Albert, C.: Stafford’s Conjecture 3.8: paper and Lean proof comparison v0.3.3. Zenodo supplementary release v0.3.3 (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.24192780
  29. [29]Da Silva, A.C.: Lectures on Symplectic Geometry. Lecture Notes in Mathematics, vol. 1764. Springer, Berlin (2004)
  30. [30]Stafford, J.: Weyl algebras are stably free. Journal of Algebra 48(2), 297–304 (1977)DOI
  31. [31]Cohn, P.M.: Algebra vol. 1, 2nd edn. John Wiley & Sons, Chichester (1982)
  32. [32]Vasconcelos, W.V.: Injective endomorphisms of finitely generated modules. In: Proc. Amer. Math. Soc, vol. 25, pp. 900–901 (1970)
  33. [33]Nakayama, T.: A remark on finitely generated modules. Nagoya Mathematical Journal 3, 139–140 (1951) https://doi.org/10.1017/S00277630000012265
  34. [34]Albert, C.: Global Stafford. Palomar registry, entry PALOMAR-2026-09-09-000001, version 2 (2026). https://palomar-registry.org/entry?id=PALOMAR-2026-09-09-000001&version=2
  35. [35]Albert, C.: Global Stafford: Lean 4 formalization v1.0.6. Zenodo software release v1.0.6 (2026). https://doi.org/10.5281/zenodo.22669444
  36. [36]Albert, C.: Same-divisor identities for simple filtered algebras. In preparation (2026)
  37. [37]LeanProver contributors: Comparator: statement and proof comparison for Lean. Project-pinned commit 575674928e239f5bc452aab72d1dd7b0f1326494. Source: https://github.com/leanprover/comparator/tree/575674928e239f5bc452aab72d1dd7b0f1326494
  38. [38]NanoDa: an independent kernel checker for Lean. Project-pinned commit 68d5ca9db226849b41a6fff59d796ff19d0a8840. Source: https://github.com/ammkrn/nanoda_lib/tree/68d5ca9db226849b41a6fff59d796ff19d0a8840
  39. [39]Palomar Registry: About the Palomar registry. Official documentation, accessed 2026-09-30: https://palomar-registry.org/about.html

Paper details

vlnc:W_a6na5bgr
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents