betaFeedback

WorksMathematics

Weak λλ-sets and almost-normal Isbell-Mrówka spaces

Abstract

We determine the least cardinality of a set of reals that is not a weak λλ-set, proving that it is max⁡{b,s}\max\{\mathfrak b,\mathfrak s\}, where b\mathfrak b and s\mathfrak s are the bounding and splitting numbers. We prove that if s<b\mathfrak s<\mathfrak b, then every first countable weak λλ-space is a λλ-space. We also show, relative to the consistency of ZFC\mathsf{ZFC}, that the existence of a weak λλ-set that is not a λλ-set is independent of ZFC+b=s\mathsf{ZFC}+\mathfrak b=\mathfrak s. In particular, we show that in the model obtained by adding ω2ω_2 Cohen reals over a model of CH\mathsf{CH}, every weak λλ-set is a λλ-set. Finally, we construct an almost-normal MAD family under CH\mathsf{CH} and show that no such family exists under OCAT+ap>ω1\mathsf{OCA}_{\mathrm T}+\mathfrak{ap}>ω_1. Thus, the existence of an almost-normal MAD family is independent of ZFC\mathsf{ZFC}.

Introduction

The study of special subsets of the real line is a classical topic at the intersection of topology and set theory. Such sets are defined by properties concerning descriptive complexity, Baire category and measure theoretic notions. For example, a λ\lambda-set is a set in which every countable subset is a relative GδG_\delta, a σ\sigma-set is one in which every GδG_\delta subset is a relative FσF_\sigma, and a QQ-set is one in which every subset is a relative GδG_\delta. The possible cardinalities of these sets and the relationships between them are closely tied to cardinal characteristics of the continuum and to additional set-theoretic assumptions. We refer to [16] for an overview of this field of research.

These classes are also deeply connected to the study of separation properties of topological spaces, such as normality. This connection led to the introduction of weak λ\lambda-sets in [20], a weakening of λ\lambda-sets, while studying separation properties of Isbell–Mrówka spaces.

Definition 1.1. A topological space XX is a weak λ\lambda-space if, whenever A,B⊆XA, B \subseteq X are disjoint and countable, there is a set H⊆XH \subseteq X which is both FσF_\sigma and GδG_\delta in XX such that A⊆HA \subseteq H and B⊆X∖HB \subseteq X \setminus H. A separable metrizable weak λ\lambda-space is called a weak λ\lambda-set.

Every λ\lambda-set is a weak λ\lambda-set. Rodrigues, Ronchim and Szeptycki asked whether the converse can consistently fail [20 Question 4.6].

An almost disjoint family is a collection A⊆[ω]ω\mathcal{A} \subseteq[\omega]^\omega whose distinct members have finite intersection. Given such a family, the Isbell–Mrówka space Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) is obtained by adjoining to the discrete space ω\omega one point for each member of A\mathcal{A}. A basic neighborhood of a∈Aa \in\mathcal{A} is of the form {a}∪(a∖F)\{a\} \cup(a \setminus F) for some finite F⊆aF \subseteq a. The space Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) is Hausdorff, separable, scattered, zero-dimensional, first countable, locally compact and regular. Its topological properties are often related to combinatorial properties of the underlying almost disjoint family A\mathcal{A}: for instance, Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) is pseudocompact if and only if A\mathcal{A} is maximal, and Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) is metrizable if and only if A\mathcal{A} is countable. An infinite almost disjoint family A\mathcal{A} is maximal (a MAD family) if every infinite subset of ω\omega meets some member of A\mathcal{A} infinitely. For background on Isbell–Mrówka spaces, see [9, 11].

Since A\mathcal{A} is closed and discrete, Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) is not countably compact when A\mathcal{A} is infinite [9, 11]. A normal pseudocompact space is countably compact, so Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) is not normal when A\mathcal{A} is MAD. Also, Jones’ Lemma shows that Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) is not normal whenever ∣A∣=c|\mathcal{A}| = \mathfrak{c}. Moreover, in ZFC, there exist almost disjoint families of cardinality ω1\omega_1 which are not normal, e.g., Luzin families (see, e.g., [11 Sections 3.1–3.2]). Nevertheless, it is consistent with ZFC that there are uncountable almost disjoint families A\mathcal{A} for which Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) is normal [22].

Several weakenings of normality for Ψ\Psi-spaces have been studied, such as almost-normality, quasi-normality, partly-normality, and mild normality [6]. In this paper, we focus on almost-normality. A space is almost-normal if any two disjoint closed sets, one of which is regular closed, have disjoint open neighborhoods.

For X⊆2ωX \subseteq2^\omega, let AX\mathcal{A}_X consist of the branches {x↾n:n∈ω}\{x \mathbin{\upharpoonright} n : n \in\omega\}, for x∈Xx \in X. The space Ψ(AX)\Psi(\mathcal{A}_X) is normal if and only if XX is a QQ-set, almost-normal if and only if XX is a σ\sigma-set, and pseudonormal if and only if XX is a λ\lambda-set [20 Corollary 2.3, Theorem 2.9 and Proposition 3.3].

Another separation property related to Isbell–Mrówka spaces is strong ℵ0\aleph_0-separation. We say that A\mathcal{A} is strongly ℵ0\aleph_0-separated if any two disjoint countable closed subsets of Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) can be separated by clopen sets. For AX\mathcal{A}_X as above, this is equivalent to XX being a weak λ\lambda-set [20 Proposition 4.3].

For a class of spaces P\mathcal{P}, write non⁡(P)\operatorname{non}(\mathcal{P}) for the least cardinality of a separable metrizable space outside P\mathcal{P}. Let b\mathfrak{b} and s\mathfrak{s} denote the bounding and splitting numbers, respectively (for their definitions, see § 2). It is well-known that non⁡(λ)=non⁡(σ)=b\operatorname{non}(\lambda) = \operatorname{non}(\sigma) = \mathfrak{b} [25 Theorem 9.1]. We also write q=non⁡(Q)\mathfrak{q} = \operatorname{non}(Q) for the least cardinality of a set of reals that is not a QQ-set [3 p. 13]. The least cardinality of a set of reals that is not a weak λ\lambda-set, that is, non⁡(wλ)\operatorname{non}(w\lambda), was left open [20]. In this paper, we settle this question by proving that non⁡(wλ)=max⁡{b,s}\operatorname{non}(w\lambda) = \max\{\mathfrak{b}, \mathfrak{s}\}.

Theorem A. non⁡(wλ)=max⁡{b,s}\operatorname{non}(w\lambda) = \max\{\mathfrak{b}, \mathfrak{s}\}.

The following diagram summarizes these relationships for families of branches.

Figure 1. Special sets of reals and separation properties of their families of branches. The top row gives the least cardinality of a set of reals outside each class. Horizontal arrows denote implications and vertical arrows denote equivalences.

Rodrigues, Ronchim and Szeptycki asked whether there is, at least consistently, a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set [20 Question 4.6]. The preceding theorem, together with non⁡(λ)=b\operatorname{non}(\lambda)=\mathfrak{b}, gives a positive answer when b<s\mathfrak{b}<\mathfrak{s}. Since each of the inequalities b<s\mathfrak{b}<\mathfrak{s} and s<b\mathfrak{s}<\mathfrak{b} is consistent relative to ZFC, the observation above and the following theorem show that the existence of a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set is independent of ZFC, relative to its consistency.

Theorem B. If s<b\mathfrak{s}<\mathfrak{b}, then every weak λ\lambda-set is a λ\lambda-set.

The remaining question is whether there exists a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set if s=b\mathfrak{s}=\mathfrak{b}. In the model obtained by adding ω2\omega_2 Cohen reals over a model of CH, we have s=b=ℵ1\mathfrak{s}=\mathfrak{b}=\aleph_1 [2 Section 11.3]. Let Cω2\mathbb{C}_{\omega_2} denote the forcing for adding ω2\omega_2 Cohen reals. We prove the following.

Theorem C. Assume CH. Then Cω2⊩\mathbb{C}_{\omega_2}\Vdash every weak λ\lambda-set is a λ\lambda-set.

On the other hand, we show that if p=c\mathfrak{p}=\mathfrak{c}, then there is a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set, where p\mathfrak{p} is the pseudointersection number (for its definition, see § 2). This hypothesis implies s=b=c\mathfrak{s}=\mathfrak{b}=\mathfrak{c}. Under this assumption, we obtain a positive answer to the question above. This result was also obtained independently by Osipov and Lipin [18 Theorem 1.1].

Theorem D. If p=c\mathfrak{p}=\mathfrak{c}, then there is a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set.

Together, these results show that, relative to the consistency of ZFC, the existence of a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set is independent of ZFC +s=b+\mathfrak{s}=\mathfrak{b}.

We now turn to almost-normal MAD families. As noted above, a MAD family cannot be normal. García-Balan and Szeptycki asked whether there is an almost-normal MAD family [6 Question 4.3]. The second and third authors used forcing to construct an almost-normal almost disjoint family which is not normal [19]. The first author showed that CH implies the existence of an almost-normal almost disjoint family which is not normal, and that the Proper Forcing Axiom implies that no MAD family is almost-normal [4]. An earlier version of the first author’s work claimed the existence of an almost-normal MAD family under CH, but the argument contained a gap [5 Theorem 2.7]. In § 7, we obtain the following result.

Theorem E. Assuming CH, there exists an almost-normal MAD family.

For the opposite direction, we use Todorčević’s Open Coloring Axiom OCAT\mathrm{OCA}_{\mathrm{T}} and the cardinal characteristic of the continuum ap\mathfrak{ap} [3 p. 14]. In § 8, we recall the definition of ap\mathfrak{ap} and strengthen the first author’s result by proving the following.

Theorem F. Assume OCAT+ap>ω1\mathrm{OCA}_{T}+\mathfrak{a}_{p}>\omega_{1}. Then almost-normal MAD families do not exist.

Together, the last two theorems stated above show that the existence of an almost-normal MAD family is independent of ZFC.

The paper is organized as follows.

  • Section 2: we introduce the notation and preliminary results used throughout the paper.

  • Section 3: we prove Theorem A, proving that non⁡(wλ)=max⁡{b,s}\operatorname{non}(\mathrm{w}\lambda)=\max\{\mathfrak{b},\mathfrak{s}\}, and obtain as a corollary a consistent example of a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set under b<s\mathfrak{b}<\mathfrak{s}.

  • Section 4: we prove Theorem D, constructing a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set under p=c\mathfrak{p}=\mathfrak{c}. This result was also obtained independently by Osipov and Lipin [18 Theorem 1.1] using similar techniques before the announcement of the present work.

  • Section 5: we prove a strengthening of Theorem B, showing that s<b\mathfrak{s}<\mathfrak{b} implies that every first countable weak λ\lambda-space is a λ\lambda-space. This shows that the existence of a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set is independent of ZFC.

  • Section 6: we prove Theorem C, showing that every weak λ\lambda-set is a λ\lambda-set in the Cohen model. Together with Theorem D, this yields that the existence of a weak λ\lambda-set which is not a λ\lambda-set is independent of ZFC +s=b+\mathfrak{s}=\mathfrak{b}.

  • Section 7: we prove Theorem E, constructing an almost-normal MAD family under CH.

  • Section 8: we prove Theorem F showing that no almost-normal MAD family exists under OCAT+ap>ω1\mathrm{OCA}_{T}+\mathfrak{a}_{p}>\omega_{1} as a consequence of known results from the literature. Together with Theorem E, this implies that the existence of an almost-normal MAD family is independent of ZFC.

Preliminaries

Our terminology is mainly standard: given two sets a,ba,b, we write a⊆∗ba\subseteq^{*}b when a∖ba\setminus b is finite and a=∗ba=^{*}b when a△ba\mathbin{\triangle}b is finite, where a△ba\mathbin{\triangle}b denotes the symmetric difference of aa and $b. We denote by P(X)\mathcal{P}(X) the power set of XX, by [X]κ[X]^{\kappa} the set of all subsets of XX with cardinality κ\kappa, and [X]<κ=⋃η<κ[X]η[X]^{<\kappa}=\bigcup_{\eta<\kappa}[X]^{\eta}.

For an almost disjoint family over a countably infinite set NN, we use Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) for the space defined in the introduction, with NN in place of ω\omega. When forming N∪AN\cup\mathcal{A}, we assume N∩[N]ω=∅N\cap[N]^{\omega}=\varnothing.

We will use the following shorthand.

Definition 2.1. We say that A\mathcal{A} satisfies the topological property PP if the space Ψ(A)\Psi(\mathcal{A}) satisfies PP.

Given L,R⊆P(ω)\mathcal{L},\mathcal{R}\subseteq\mathcal{P}(\omega), we write L⊥R\mathcal{L}\perp\mathcal{R} if ∣L∩R∣<ω|L\cap R|<\omega for every L∈LL\in\mathcal{L} and R∈RR\in\mathcal{R}. In this case, we say that L\mathcal{L} and R\mathcal{R} are orthogonal.

Definition 2.2. Let L,R⊆P(ω)\mathcal{L},\mathcal{R}\subseteq\mathcal{P}(\omega). A separator for L\mathcal{L} and R\mathcal{R} is a set D⊆ωD\subseteq\omega such that

L⊆∗D(∀L∈L)and∣R∩D∣<ω(∀R∈R).L\subseteq^{*}D\quad(\forall L\in\mathcal{L})\qquad\text{and}\qquad|R\cap D|<\omega\quad(\forall R\in\mathcal{R}).

If DD is a separator for L\mathcal{L} and R\mathcal{R}, we say that DD separates L\mathcal{L} from R\mathcal{R}.

Notice that if DD separates L\mathcal{L} from R\mathcal{R}, then L⊥R\mathcal{L} \perp\mathcal{R}. Note that this concept is not symmetric. However, if DD separates L\mathcal{L} from R\mathcal{R}, then its complement separates R\mathcal{R} from L\mathcal{L}. It is well known that countable orthogonal families can be separated. We include its proof for the convenience of the reader.

Lemma 2.3. Let L,R⊆P(ω)\mathcal{L},\mathcal{R} \subseteq\mathcal{P}(\omega) be countable collections such that L⊥R\mathcal{L} \perp\mathcal{R}, and let C∈LC \in\mathcal{L}. Then there exists a separator D⊇CD \supseteq C for L\mathcal{L} and R\mathcal{R}.

Proof. If R=∅\mathcal{R} = \varnothing, take D=ωD = \omega. Otherwise, enumerate both collections with repetitions if needed as L={Ln:n<ω}\mathcal{L} = \{L_n : n < \omega\} and R={Rn:n<ω}\mathcal{R} = \{R_n : n < \omega\}. Let

D=C∪⋃n<ω(Ln∖⋃j≤nRj).D = C \cup\bigcup_{n<\omega}\left(L_n \setminus\bigcup_{j\leq n} R_j\right).

For every n∈ωn \in\omega, Ln∖D⊆⋃j≤n(Ln∩Rj)L_n \setminus D \subseteq\bigcup_{j\leq n}(L_n \cap R_j), so Ln⊆∗DL_n \subseteq^* D. On the other hand, for each m∈ωm \in\omega,

Rm∩D⊆Rm∩C∪⋃n<m(Rm∩Ln).R_m \cap D \subseteq R_m \cap C \cup\bigcup_{n<m}(R_m \cap L_n).

The right-hand side is finite, so ∣Rm∩D∣<ω|R_m \cap D| < \omega. Thus DD is a separator for L\mathcal{L} and R\mathcal{R}. □\square

A separator that separates an almost disjoint family A\mathcal{A} into two orthogonal subfamilies is called a partitioner for A\mathcal{A}.

Definition 2.4. Let A\mathcal{A} be an almost disjoint family.

(1) A set D⊆ωD \subseteq\omega is a partitioner for A\mathcal{A} if it separates some subfamily B⊆A\mathcal{B} \subseteq\mathcal{A} from A∖B\mathcal{A} \setminus\mathcal{B}.

(2) For C⊆ωC \subseteq\omega, let AC={a∈A:∣a∩C∣=ω}\mathcal{A}_C = \{a \in\mathcal{A} : |a \cap C| = \omega\}.

References

  1. [1]Murray G. Bell. On the combinatorial principle P(c). Fundamenta Mathematicae, 114(2):149–157, 1981. doi:10.4064/fm-114-2-149-157.DOI
  2. [2]Andreas Blass. Combinatorial cardinal characteristics of the continuum, 2003. Preprint, November 24, 2003. URL: https://sites.lsa.umich.edu/ablass/wp-content/uploads/sites/1471/2025/10/hbk.pdf.
  3. [3]Jörg Brendle. Dow’s principle and Q-sets. Canadian Mathematical Bulletin, 42(1):13–24, 1999. doi:10.4153/CMB-1999-002-2.
  4. [4]César Corral. Madness and weak forms of normality. Acta Mathematica Hungarica, 165(2):291–307, 2021. doi:10.1007/s10474-021-01186-y.DOI
  5. [5]César Corral. Madness and (weak) normality, 2021. arXiv:2101.01829v3. arXiv: 2101.01829, doi:10.48550/arXiv.2101.01829.DOI
  6. [6]Sergio A. Garcia-Balan and Paul J. Szeptycki. Weak normality properties in Ψ-spaces. Fundamenta Mathematicae, 258(2):137–151, 2022. doi:10.4064/fm935-11-2021.
  7. [7]Martin Goldstern. Tools for your forcing construction. In Haim Judah, editor, Set Theory of the Reals, volume 6 of Israel Mathematical Conference Proceedings, pages 305–360. Bar-Ilan University, Ramat Gan, 1993. URL: https://dmg.tuwien.ac.at/goldstern/www/papers/tools.pdf.
  8. [8]Osvaldo Guzmán, Michael Hrušák, and Piotr Koszmider. Almost disjoint families and the geometry of nonseparable spheres. Journal of Functional Analysis, 285(11):110149, 2023. Paper No. 110149, 49 pp. doi:10.1016/j.jfa.2023.110149.DOI
  9. [9]Fernando Hernández-Hernández and Michael Hrušák. Topology of Mrówka–Isbell spaces. In Michael Hrušák, Ángel Tamariz-Mascarúa, and Mikhail Tkachenko, editors, Pseudocompact Topological Spaces: A Survey of Classic and New Results with Open Problems, volume 55 of Developments in Mathematics, pages 253–289. Springer, Cham, 2018. doi:10.1007/978-3-319-91680-4_8.
  10. [10]Neil Hindman. Finite sums from sequences within cells of a partition of ℕ. Journal of Combinatorial Theory, Series A, 17(1):1–11, 1974. doi:10.1016/0097-3165(74)90023-5.DOI
  11. [11]Michael Hrušák. Almost disjoint families and topology. In Klaas Pieter Hart, Jan van Mill, and Petr Simon, editors, Recent Progress in General Topology III, pages 601–638. Atlantis Press, Paris, 2014. doi:10.2991/978-94-6239-024-9_14.DOI
  12. [12]Michael Hrušák and Osvaldo Guzmán. n-luzin gaps. Topology and its Applications, 160(12):1364–1374, 2013. doi:10.1016/j.topol.2013.05.015.DOI
  13. [13]Anastasis Kamburelis and Bogdan Węglorz. Splittings. Archive for Mathematical Logic, 35(4):263–277, 1996. doi:10.1007/s001530050044.DOI
  14. [14]Kenneth Kunen. Set Theory, volume 34 of Studies in Logic. College Publications, London, 2011.
  15. [15]Arnold W. Miller. Mapping a set of reals onto the reals. The Journal of Symbolic Logic, 48(3):575–584, 1983. URL: https://people.math.wisc.edu/~awmillel/res/map.pdf, doi:10.2307/2273449.DOI
  16. [16]Arnold W. Miller. Special sets of reals. In Haim Judah, editor, Set Theory of the Reals, volume 6 of Israel Mathematical Conference Proceedings, pages 415–432. American Mathematical Society, 1993. URL: https://people.math.wisc.edu/~awmiller/res/survey.pdf.
  17. [17]Arnold W. Miller. On λ-sets. Topology Proceedings, 28(1):179–187, 2004. URL: https://topology.nipissingu.ca/tp/reprints/v28/tp28112.pdf.
  18. [18]Alexander V. Osipov and Anton E. Lipin. A weak λ-set that is not a λ-set under p = c, 2026. URL: https://arxiv.org/abs/2611.06312, arXiv:2611.06312.
  19. [19]Vinicius de Oliveira Rodrigues and Victor dos Santos Ronchim. Almost-normality of Isbell–Mrówka spaces. Topology and its Applications, 288:107470, 2021. Paper No. 107470, 13 pp. doi:10.1016/j.topol.2020.107470.
  20. [20]Vinicius de Oliveira Rodrigues, Victor dos Santos Ronchim, and Paul J. Szeptycki. Special sets of reals and weak forms of normality on Isbell–Mrówka spaces. Commentationes Mathematicae Universitatis Carolinae, 64(1):109–126, 2023. doi: 10.14712/1213-7243.2023.014.
  21. [21]Fritz Rothberger. Sur un ensemble toujours de première catégorie qui est dépourvu de la propriété λ. Fundamenta Mathematicae, 32(1):294–300, 1939. doi:10.4064/fm-32-1-294-300.DOI
  22. [22]Franklin D. Tall. Set-theoretic consistency results and topological theorems concerning the normal Moore space conjecture and related problems. Dissertationes Mathematicae, 148:1–53, 1977.
  23. [23]Stevo Todorčević. Partition Problems in Topology, volume 84 of Contemporary Mathematics. American Mathematical Society, Providence, RI, 1989. doi:10.1090/conm/084.
  24. [24]Stevo Todorčević. Analytic gaps. Fundamenta Mathematicae, 150(1):55–66, 1996. doi:10.4064/fm-150-1-55-66.
  25. [25]Eric K. van Douwen. The integers and topology. In Kenneth Kunen and Jerry E. Vaughan, editors, Handbook of Set-Theoretic Topology, pages 111–167. North-Holland, Amsterdam, 1984. doi:10.1016/B978-0-444-86580-9.50006-9.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_a8x7zbvc
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 2

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Mathematics

OpenAI’s GPT-6 Astra, OpenAI’s GPT-6.1 Sol, OpenAI’s GPT-6.1 Terra

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents