In this paper
AbstractIntroductionProblem, positioning, and guiding obstructionWhat is inherited from shape optimization and what is new hereRelation with the preceding papersComparison with recent workTheorem hierarchy and main resultPotential applicationsMethodological conventions and reproducibilityScope and nonclaimsGeometric and variational setupThe class Energy and Euler–Lagrange equationRigidity of a smooth large- limitSelected spherical reference states: preparatory reductionExact-volume chart and smooth PDE dependenceExact volume preservationSmooth dependence of the state and fluxAdapted Lyapunov–Schmidt constructionInversion of the higher spherical modesDesingularized translation equationOpenness of Coordinate transfer from the selected sphere to the coreFréchet differentiability of the return mapDifferentials of the graph slope and normalConsistency with the PDE-generated deformationCombined main theoremPDE boundary-layer interpretationBenchmarks and checksRadial benchmarkPerturbative nonradial exampleReproducible nonradial computational protocolMode separationDiscussion and open problemsWhat has been provedWhat remains openConclusionConsistency with the PDE-generated deformationReferencesWorksMathematics
Perimeter-Regularized Critical Shapes in the Class : Core-Normal Transfer and First-Order Return-Map Response
Abstract
Let be a compact strictly convex core and denote the class of domains whose outer boundary is a global outward normal graph over and whose inward boundary normals return to the interior of . We study volume-constrained critical domains of the Dirichlet-perimeter functional: in the large-perimeter regime . We give an adapted Lyapunov–Schmidt construction near translated spheres to extract the first physical shape coefficient of scale . We then prove that is open under small thickness perturbations and establish a quantitative coordinate-transfer theorem to a unique core-normal thickness. Finally, we prove that the forward return-map operator is Fréchet between Hölder spaces and provide its explicit derivative. This yields a shape-to-dynamics sensitivity theorem for : a perimeter-regularized PDE-constrained critical deformation produces an explicitly controlled first-order deformation of the return dynamics. A nonradial example confirms that the response coefficient is generically nonzero.
Introduction
Problem, positioning, and guiding obstruction
Let , , be a compact strictly convex body. The class , originating in the geometric normal-property framework of Barkatou, consists here of domains surrounding whose outer boundary is a global normal graph over and whose inward outer-boundary normals return to ; see [3, 5, 7]. The geometry carries a return map
obtained by moving first along the outward core normal to the outer boundary and then back to the core along the inward normal of that outer boundary. We study the interaction of this return geometry with the volume-constrained Dirichlet-perimeter functional
where solves
and denotes the outward unit normal. We impose
The source is fixed in physical space.
The large- regime is dominated by perimeter. A necessary-limit argument shows that any connected smooth limit of critical domains with uniformly bounded boundary flux must have constant mean curvature and is therefore spherical. Thus the correct reference object is a selected ball of volume , not an arbitrary nonspherical core. The convex core remains essential in a different role: it provides the global normal coordinates and the return geometry through which the critical branch is represented and observed.
What is inherited from shape optimization and what is new here
The translated-ball existence mechanism itself is not new. Hayouni and Novruzi [13] used the implicit-function theorem to construct regular critical points for a two-dimensional Dirichlet-perimeter free-boundary problem for large perimeter weight. Novruzi [16] subsequently developed existence theory for a broader class of shape functionals, explicitly separating translations from genuine shape deformations and using nondegeneracy of the reduced translated-ball energy. Related free-boundary work by Barkatou, Seck and Ly [4] treated an interior electromagnetic-casting problem through shape optimization and curvature boundary conditions.
Accordingly, the Lyapunov–Schmidt construction in § 3–§ 5 is included as a self-contained preparatory layer adapted to the present notation and to the first-order coefficient required later. The principal new results begin when this classical branch is connected to :
(N1) a -openness theorem for the geometric normal-return class (Theorem 6.1);
(N2) a quantitative coordinate transfer from a translated spherical graph to a unique core-normal thickness, including the joint contribution of center drift and higher spherical modes (Theorem 7.2);
(N3) Fréchet differentiability of the forward return operator , with an explicit derivative obtained from the first-hit equation (Theorem 8.2).
The paper therefore does not claim a new general existence theory for perimeter-regularized critical shapes. Its novelty is the shape-to-return-dynamics sensitivity theory in the class .
Relation with the preceding papers
The present paper is the next step in a sequence with a progressively changing object of study. The first return-map paper [5] established the exact normal geometry of , the fixed-point/critical-point relation, and the spatial linearization at fixed points. The inverse paper [6] studies the opposite direction, reconstructing thickness information from a given return map through an exact nonlinear transport system and its linearized compatibility structure. The elliptic superlevel-set paper [7] keeps the PDE domain fixed and studies one distinguished deformation path
generated by small Dirichlet superlevels.
The present problem is complementary to all three. The domain itself is varied by an Euler–Lagrange condition, and the main forward object is now the operator
Theorem Theorem 8.2 differentiates this operator with respect to an arbitrary thickness perturbation. Hence the earlier PDE coefficient becomes one special direction of a general Fréchet shape derivative, while the inverse-paper compatibility system becomes a natural target for a future range characterization of .
Comparison with recent work
Recent shape-optimization literature emphasizes several complementary questions. Buttazzo–Maiale–Mazzoleni–Tortone–Velichkov [8] develop free-boundary regularity for broad PDE-dependent integral shape functionals. Celentano–Nitsch–Trombetti [10] use overdetermined elliptic systems to characterize critical shapes under volume constraints. Caubet–Dambrine–Darde [9] show that perimeter penalization can improve stability in a Dirichlet inverse-obstacle shape problem. Plotnikov–Sokolowski [17] study geometric gradient-flow frameworks for regularized inverse and free-boundary shape problems, and Amato–Nitsch–Trombetti–Villone [2] give recent local stability results for functionals combining Dirichlet spectral/torsional quantities with perimeter constraints.
These works concern existence, regularity, stability, symmetry, or optimization dynamics of the shape itself. The question addressed here is different: once a smooth critical-shape branch is available, how does an additional geometric observable—the normal return map attached to a convex core—change with the shape? The new object is therefore a response operator from boundary deformation to discrete return dynamics rather than a shape Hessian or a gradient-flow generator.
Two adjacent theories should be distinguished from this claim. In classical Poincaré/first-impact theory, transversality of a flow with a section yields differentiability of the return time and hence of the first-return map by an implicit-function argument; see, for example, Immler–Traut [15]. Thus the projection that removes the component generated by variation of the hitting time is not, by itself, new. In shape calculus, Feppon–Allaire–Dapogny [12] study shape derivatives of geometric constraints involving signed distance and integration along normal rays. Their normal-ray computations are closely related to our equations (8)–(53), but they do not address return maps.
Theorem hierarchy and main result
To make the novelty hierarchy explicit, we distinguish one preparatory theorem from the principal geometric results.
| Work | Main issue | Relation to the present paper |
| Hayouni–Novruzi (2002); Novruzi [16] | Large-perimeter critical/optimal domains; translation versus pure deformation | Classical existence mechanism used as preparatory background; no return response |
| Barkatou–Seck–Ly (2006) | Curvature free-boundary condition and electromagnetic casting | Motivates the PDE-perimeter model and applications; no normal-return sensitivity |
| Buttazzo et al. [8] | Regularity of PDE-dependent optimal sets | Global/free-boundary regularity, complementary to our local smooth branch |
| Caubet–Dambrine–Darde (2026) | Perimeter regularization in inverse obstacle optimization | Shows current relevance of perimeter stabilization; different observable and inverse problem |
| Earlier papers | Geometry, inverse reconstruction, and one PDE-generated deformation of | Supply the exact return geometry; the present work differentiates the full forward operator |
| Present paper | Core-normal transfer and first-order return-map response | Fréchet response operator and combined critical-shape-to-dynamics theorem |
Table 1. Position of the present results relative to closely related work.
Preparatory selected-ball branch. We adapt the classical translated-ball implicit-function/Lyapunov–Schmidt framework and extract the physical coefficient
openness and transfer. Small thickness perturbations preserve , and a nearby translated spherical graph has a unique core-normal representation.
Principal response theorem. The forward return operator is Fréchet , with an explicit derivative .
Combined shape-to-dynamics theorem. Along the critical branch,
No theorem below uses numerical evidence. Exact geometric identities are established before asymptotic expansions; every asymptotic statement is labelled by its topology and small parameter.
Potential applications
The applications are secondary to the geometric analysis, but the theorem chain has several natural interpretations. First, Dirichlet-perimeter free-boundary conditions arise historically in electromagnetic casting and shaping, where curvature regularization competes with a PDE-generated boundary pressure; see [13, 4]. Second, perimeter penalties remain active in contemporary inverse-shape problems because they can improve stability and numerical regularity [9]. Third, the new operator provides a sensitivity map from boundary design variables to a geometric observable. This can be relevant whenever an interface is probed or controlled through normal incidence/return information, for example in inverse geometry, geometric metrology, or PDE-constrained interface design. We do not claim an application-specific sensing model here; the contribution is the mathematical response operator that such models could use.
Methodological conventions and reproducibility
Several conventions are fixed globally to avoid ambiguities that are particularly damaging in normal-return problems. We use
so that a convex core has and for every outward thickness . Outward and inward normals are denoted by and , respectively. Exact identities, first-order expansions, and heuristic interpretations are kept separate. The analytical benchmark in § 11 is exact. A computational protocol is stated there for a nonradial test, but no numerical result is used as evidence for any theorem.
Scope and nonclaims
The results are local. We construct constrained critical domains; we do not claim global minimality. The existence of a selected nondegenerate center and of a containing reference sphere of the prescribed volume is assumed (see Remark 9.2). We do not claim that equals the full compatibility space of the linearized inverse problem; a precise conjecture is stated in § 12. Finally, the preparatory large-perimeter branch is presented as an adaptation of established shape-optimization machinery, not as a new general existence theorem.
Geometric and variational setup
The class
Let
and let be the outward unit normal. We adopt the convention
For a convex hypersurface the eigenvalues of are , hence .
For define
and
Definition 2.1 (The class ). A domain with and belongs to if every inward normal ray issued from intersects .
The global normal-graph property is already built into (6). Set
The exact outward and inward unit normals are
These formulas are exact and are the starting point for all later differentiations; compare [7].
Energy and Euler–Lagrange equation
Fix
For each smooth domain containing , let solve (2).
For a smooth deformation with normal velocity , the Hadamard formula (see, e.g., [11, 14, 18]) gives
With the convention , the perimeter and volume derivatives are
Thus a smooth volume-constrained critical domain satisfies
Set
Then
Rigidity of a smooth large- limit
Proposition 2.2 (CMC obstruction). Let be smooth volume-constrained critical domains for (1), with . Assume
and
Then has constant mean curvature.
Proof. Subtract the surface average from (11):
The flux bound implies
The convergence gives uniform convergence of the mean curvatures, so is constant.
Remark 2.3. In the compact connected embedded setting relevant here, a closed constant-mean-curvature hypersurface is spherical by Alexandrov’s theorem [1]. Proposition 2.2 is only a necessary-limit statement; it does not by itself provide compactness or existence of a large- branch.
Selected spherical reference states: preparatory reduction
Fix by
Let be a neighborhood of a point such that
for some .
For , let solve
Define the translated-ball reduced energy
Lemma 3.1 (Gradient of the reduced energy). Let
Then
Proof. Translate the ball in the direction . The normal velocity is . The Hadamard formula (10) gives
which is equivalent to (17). □
Assumption 3.2 (Selected nondegenerate center). There exists such that
The nondegeneracy is the finite-dimensional hypothesis needed to resolve the translation kernel of the spherical Jacobi operator.
Exact-volume chart and smooth PDE dependence
Let . Define
Exact volume preservation
For and , consider
Lemma 4.1 (Exact volume chart). There is a neighborhood of in and a unique smooth scalar function such that the domain bounded by (20) has volume . Moreover
and
Proof. The enclosed volume is
At ,
The implicit-function theorem gives . Since has zero mean,
so . Differentiating twice gives
which yields (22).
Smooth dependence of the state and flux
Lemma 4.2 (Smooth state and flux map). Under (9)–[15], after shrinking and the neighborhood of in if necessary, the solution of
depends -smoothly on after pullback to . The pulled-back boundary flux
is a map into .
Proof. Choose a smooth radial cutoff equal to on and near . Define on a fixed neighborhood of the origin and, writing outside that neighborhood,
Because the two formulas agree where , this gives a globally map on . For small it is a diffeomorphism from onto .
Put
and define
with
Then
is : determinant and matrix inversion are smooth on the uniformly invertible coefficient set, the composition is because , and multiplication/divergence have the required Hölder mapping properties. Moreover,
is a uniformly elliptic Dirichlet isomorphism by Schauder theory. The Banach-space implicit-function theorem therefore yields a map .
Finally,
and the outer normal of depends -smoothly on . The trace map is bounded. Hence the pulled-back flux (24) is into .
Adapted Lyapunov–Schmidt construction
Let denote the mean curvature of pulled back to . It is independent of by translation invariance. Define
Equation (13) holds for some scalar exactly when the nonconstant part of vanishes. Let
be the translation space, let be the projection onto , and let be the projection onto the orthogonal complement of constants and .
Lemma 5.1 (Smooth mean-curvature map). For in a sufficiently small neighborhood of in , the pulled-back mean-curvature map
is from to . Its differential at the sphere is
Proof. The metric, second fundamental form, inverse metric and unit normal of a radial graph depend smoothly on , and as long as stays positive. Since is smooth, the resulting mean curvature is a smooth quasilinear second-order operator from to . The standard first-variation formula for mean curvature at a sphere gives the displayed Jacobi operator with the convention .
Inversion of the higher spherical modes
At ,
The linearized mean-curvature operator is
On degree- spherical harmonics,
Thus constants form the volume mode, degree one is the translation kernel, and is positive and invertible on all degrees .
Proposition 5.2 (Higher-mode equation). There is a neighborhood of and a unique map
such that
Moreover
where .
Proof. The derivative of with respect to at is restricted to , which is an isomorphism onto by (27). The implicit-function theorem gives (28). Differentiating in at gives (29).
Desingularized translation equation
Define
Since for every , the direct -linearization is singular. Define for
Lemma 5.3 (Desingularization). The map extends to a map at , with
More precisely,
Proof. Because is and ,
which extends to . At ,
The first term belongs to and has zero translation projection, which gives (31). Since
Lemma 3.1 yields (32).
Theorem 5.4 (Preparatory large-perimeter branch near a selected ball). Assume Assumption 3.2. Then there exists and a unique curve
such that, with
the exact-volume domain is a constrained critical domain of (1) for every sufficiently small positive . There exist and such that
and
The center coefficient is determined by the differentiated reduced equation:
The scaled Lagrange multiplier satisfies
Equivalently,
Proof. By (33), the derivative is invertible exactly when is invertible. The finite-dimensional implicit-function theorem therefore gives solving
Together with Proposition 5.2, all nonconstant components of vanish. The remaining constant component is absorbed by a scalar , so (13) holds.
Since , one has , hence
and (35) follows from (29). Differentiating at gives (36). The expansion of is obtained by averaging (13); the average of vanishes because has zero mean. Multiplying by yields (38).
Remark 5.5 (Correct scale). The generic shape scale is . A scale would require an additional degeneracy causing the linear restoring term to vanish in the relevant mode; it is not the generic large-perimeter regime treated here.
Openness of
Theorem 6.1 (-openness of ). Let be positive and assume .
Then there exists such that every positive satisfying
obeys
Moreover, for in this neighborhood the first-return time and return map satisfy
and the first return remains uniformly transverse.
Proof. The global graph property is automatic for positive , since strict convexity gives unique exterior normal coordinates. It remains to prove persistence of the inward-normal penetration.
From (7)–(8), the maps and are locally Lipschitz from to :
Let
be the first return. Since , the same ray continues into . Convexity implies
To justify the compactness step, let be the signed distance to and write
At the first entrance point,
The parameter-dependent implicit-function theorem therefore gives and hence continuity of . Compactness now yields a uniform constant such that
Let be the signed distance to , negative in . Uniform transversality gives a and such that
for all . For nearby , define
Then
For sufficiently small (39), for every , so every perturbed inward normal ray reaches the interior. Hence .
The quantitative estimates and persistence of transversality follow by applying the implicit-function theorem uniformly to
near . This produces, for each nearby , a unique transverse zero in a fixed neighborhood of . It remains to identify that zero with the first entrance time. Since is convex and the ray contains the later interior point , the set of ray parameters for which it lies in is a nonempty compact interval. The transverse zero has points immediately before it outside and points immediately after it inside . Hence it is the entering endpoint of that interval, so no earlier intersection can occur and . The same uniform implicit-function estimates then give (40).
Coordinate transfer from the selected sphere to the core
Assume now
Every core-normal ray meets exactly once. Let be defined by
Set
Then uniformly.
Proposition 7.1 (The selected sphere belongs to ). Under (41), the sphere is an element of . More precisely, each outward core-normal ray meets exactly once and the inward sphere normal reaches .
Proof. Fix and consider
Since , one has , while as . The product of the two roots of this quadratic equals , so exactly one root is positive. This gives the unique outer intersection and hence the thickness . At the intersection point the inward sphere normal points along the segment toward , which lies in ; therefore the inward normal ray enters the core.
Moreover, taking the scalar product of
with gives
Compactness yields a positive uniform lower bound. In fact, by the exact normal-graph formula,
Theorem 7.2 (Coordinate transfer). For sufficiently close to in , the hypersurface is a unique normal graph over :
with . The map
is , and
Its derivative at is
Proof. For near define
and the defining function
Then precisely on . Define
With one derivative of regularity in reserve, is from
Indeed, after restricting to a fixed neighborhood of , the maps and are smooth uniformly for near . The Hölder composition map is from to on this neighborhood (this is a standard consequence of the Hölder algebra property and the chain rule; see for instance [7 Lemma A.1] for the precise statement adapted to the present setting), while is affine into . This is the reason for retaining one derivative beyond the target regularity. At the reference state, , and
Since is bounded away from zero, multiplication by is an isomorphism on . The implicit-function theorem gives and (44). Since on the compact manifold , shrinking the neighborhood if necessary also gives .
For a strictly convex core, the exterior normal-coordinate map is one-to-one for . Hence the positive graph is an embedded hypersurface. Its image is open and closed in the connected hypersurface , hence equals it. Uniqueness follows from the same global exterior normal coordinates.
Finally, differentiate . At the reference state,
because . Therefore
which is (45).
Corollary 7.3 (Core-normal expansion of the critical branch). Let and be the branch of Theorem 5.4. Then
where
Consequently
Remark 7.4. The translation coefficient contributes at the same order as the genuine higher-mode deformation . The shorthand is correct only in the special case .
Fréchet differentiability of the return map
Let with . By Theorem 6.1, all nearby thicknesses remain admissible. Write
where is the first entrance time into .
Differentials of the graph slope and normal
For a perturbation ,
Differentiating (8) gives
Lemma 8.1 (Banach-space first-hit). Let with . There are neighborhoods of and of such that
is . Moreover,
is an isomorphism of .
Proof. Choose a tubular neighborhood of on which the signed distance is smooth with the regularity supplied by . Shrink and so that
pointwise for every . The map is affine from to . Since
and (because and ), the inverse is uniformly bounded by in operator norm on ; the Hölder algebra property and smoothness of matrix inversion then imply that and are from to , with derivative continuous in the operator norm . Consequently
is into . Composition with the fixed smooth function is on maps with image in , which proves the asserted mapping property of .
At the reference state, the chain rule gives
By Theorem 6.1, first-return transversality is uniform: . The multiplier belongs to , as does its reciprocal. Multiplication by it is therefore a bounded isomorphism of .
Theorem 8.2 (Principal return-response theorem). There is a neighborhood of in such that
is in the Fréchet sense, with derivative continuous in the operator norm . For define
Then
Equivalently,
where
In particular,
Proof. By Lemma 8.1, the implicit-function theorem gives a unique map
near such that and . We must still verify that this local root is the geometric first entrance time. Fix and , and set . By the first-hit claim, there is a unique transverse zero in a fixed neighborhood of , with
by Theorem 6.1 (uniform transversality). Consequently and for some ; by compactness of and continuity of in the topology, can be chosen uniform in . Thus, immediately before the ray is outside , and immediately after it is inside .
Since is convex and every inward normal ray reaches (Theorem 6.1), the set of parameters for which is a nonempty compact interval . Since , the point is a transverse crossing, not an endpoint of the interval; and because changes sign from positive to negative at , we must have . Hence for every , so is as a map from to .
Since and have the corresponding regularity, (49) also shows directly that is .
Differentiate the first-hit identity. Since ,
Thus
Differentiating (49) gives (53). The projected form (54) follows from (51). Equation (56) follows by taking the scalar product with .
Remark 8.3 (Link with the inverse-paper compatibility system). The nonlinear transport system of [6] can be written in the present notation as , where encodes the geometric compatibility between the thickness and its return map . The differential along is an isomorphism by uniform transversality, hence
In other words, is exactly the linearization of the inverse-paper transport system along the solution , solved for the variation of . This identification will be used in future work to address the range characterization stated in Conjecture 12.1.
Corollary 8.4 (First return-map response of the critical branch). Under the assumptions of Theorems 5.4, 6.1, 7.2, and 8.2,
Proof. Combine (48) with the Fréchet expansion of at .
Consistency with the PDE-generated deformation
The superlevel-set paper [7] obtained
For the direction , (50) becomes
Substitution into (51) and (54) gives exactly the return-map first-variation coefficient derived in [7]; the calculation is reproduced in Appendix § 14 to make the identification explicit. Thus
This identity provides an independent sign and projection check for Theorem 8.2.
Combined main theorem
Theorem 9.1 (Main shape-to-dynamics theorem in ). Let be compact and strictly convex with . Assume:
, , ;
is fixed by ;
there is such that ;
is a nondegenerate critical point of the translated-ball energy , i.e.
Then, for all sufficiently large , there exists a volume-constrained critical domain of (1) such that
Let be the core-normal thickness of and its return map. Then
where
is uniquely determined by
and the first center correction is explicitly characterized by
Finally,
with given explicitly by (56).
Proof. Theorem 5.4 gives the selected critical branch in spherical coordinates, parametrized by . Theorem 7.2 converts the branch to a core-normal thickness and yields (61)–(60). Since $d_\mu \to d_0$ in $C^1$, Theorem 6.1 implies $\Omega_\mu \in \mathcal{O}_C$ for large $\mu$. Theorem {xref}8.2 then gives {xref}(63)`. □
Remark 9.2 (On assumption (H3)). Assumption (H3) is structural: it ensures that the selected sphere belongs to (Proposition 7.1) and that uniformly (equation (44)). It is not a consequence of (H4). Two regimes are relevant. If is the center of the minimal ball containing (or more generally a point for which holds by construction), then (H3) is satisfied automatically and (H4) becomes a condition on through the reduced energy . A concrete non-spherical instance is obtained by taking to be an ellipsoid with center and radial about with sufficiently small non-radial perturbations; then remains a nondegenerate critical point of (see the perturbative example in § 11) and (H3)–(H4) hold simultaneously. If instead is off-center relative to , (H3) imposes a geometric relation between , and that is not generic. Theorem 9.1 should therefore be read as conditional on (H3)–(H4) jointly; the existence question for a non-spherical pair satisfying both is addressed perturbatively in § 11 and left open in full generality in § 12(ii).
PDE boundary-layer interpretation
The preceding theorem concerns optimization, not superlevel motion. Nevertheless, the first-order forcing can be expressed through a quantity already identified in [7].
Suppose the reference sphere is represented over the core by , and let
For the small superlevel domains of the fixed reference PDE problem, [7] gives
Since ,
Under the stronger smoothness hypotheses of the present paper, the same boundary-flux formula gives , so is an admissible direction for Theorem 8.2. Thus the PDE level-set speed does not equal the optimization direction. Instead, it determines the optimization forcing after inversion and projection:
The two deformations therefore encode different geometric responses to the same boundary flux.
Benchmarks and checks
Radial benchmark
Take
and assume is radial about . Then is constant on , so
and hence
The Euler–Lagrange equation is constant on the sphere for every , with the multiplier absorbing both the curvature and flux terms. Thus the sphere is an exact critical shape. Moreover
and
Rotational symmetry makes the reduced translated-ball energy radial about , and the uniqueness of the local reduced branch implies ; hence . Together with , formula (49) gives . The first return-map response therefore vanishes, consistently with (59).
Perturbative nonradial example
We now exhibit a nonradial setting in which to first order, confirming that Theorem 9.1 is not vacuous. Work in with
and choose a source of the form
where is radial about , (a degree-2 spherical harmonic in ), and is a nonnegative radial cutoff equal to on . Then and , so (H1) holds for all sufficiently small .
Nondegeneracy of at . The reduced energy depends smoothly on ; at it equals the radial energy , which satisfies with (the radial case is a strict maximum of the reduced energy, by the same computation as in the radial benchmark). Since is continuous, remains invertible for with . Also for every because is even under , so is even. Hence (H4) holds at for .
Center correction. Because is odd under for this symmetric perturbation, , hence by (36).
Shape coefficient. The flux splits as , where is the constant radial flux. Therefore
For a generic cutoff , the degree-2 component of is nonzero (it is the trace of on under the Dirichlet problem, which is nonzero by elliptic regularity and unique continuation), so . Hence
where acts on the degree-2 mode via (27). Since , formula (49) gives
Thus to first order in , and consequently generically (the kernel of is conjecturally trivial modulo volume; see Conjecture 12.1). This confirms that the first-order response is nonzero in a genuinely nonradial, nondegenerate situation satisfying (H1)–(H4).
Reproducible nonradial computational protocol
No numerical result is asserted in this draft, but the first-order theorem is directly testable. A reproducible two-dimensional protocol is:
(P1) choose a circular core and a smooth compactly supported nonradial source inside , for example a sum of two unequal bumps;
(P2) for the prescribed area , compute the reduced translated-ball energy on a neighborhood of a candidate center, locate a critical point , and verify numerically that is nonsingular;
(P3) solve the Dirichlet problem on , compute the boundary flux , project onto Fourier modes, and solve the diagonal Jacobi equation for ;
(P4) compute the center coefficient from the desingularized finite-dimensional equation, transfer to the core-normal coefficient , and evaluate the explicit derivative ;
(P5) for a sequence , solve the constrained Euler–Lagrange system numerically and compare the normalized errors
in the norms predicted by Theorem 9.1.
A numerical section should report meshes, nonlinear tolerances, projection resolution, center-search tolerance, and the measured convergence rates. Until such data are produced, the protocol is illustrative rather than evidential.
Mode separation
For a nonradial source, the first correction is obtained by decomposing into spherical harmonics. Its constant component changes the multiplier, its degree-one component determines the center drift via the desingularized equation (36) (and does not contribute to the shape deformation ), and only degrees deform the shape via
On such a mode,
This gives a direct spectral interpretation of the first-order smoothing effect of perimeter regularization.
Discussion and open problems
What has been proved
The large- branch is used as a preparatory input rather than claimed as a new general existence mechanism. The new geometric content begins when that branch is transferred to the normal-return class . In particular, the return map is promoted from a pointwise geometric construction to a Fréchet-differentiable shape observable. The large- problem itself is a singular perturbation around the finite-dimensional manifold of balls of fixed volume. The translation kernel is not an obstruction to be removed by an artificial coercivity assumption; it is resolved by the reduced center equation. The higher modes are governed by the invertible part of the spherical Jacobi operator. The resulting branch can be transferred to an arbitrary strictly convex coordinate core, remains inside , and induces a first-order return-map response, which is generically nonzero by the perturbative example of § 11.2.
What remains open
Several questions are not addressed here.
(i) Minimality and Morse index. The branch consists of critical domains. Determining its local minimizing or saddle character requires the constrained second variation of the full functional along the branch.
(ii) Existence of a selected center. The theorem assumes a nondegenerate critical point of inside the admissible center set. Genericity of (H4) alone follows from Sard’s lemma applied to for generic ; the open question is the joint compatibility with (H3) for non-spherical cores. The perturbative example of § 11.2 provides one non-spherical instance, but a systematic existence theory is open.
(iii) Second-order expansion. The implicit identity (36) determines , but an explicit formula for it in terms of PDE data, together with a shape/return expansion, requires the next-order reduced equation and the second derivative of the return operator.
(iv) Range characterization. Theorem 8.2 establishes the derivative of the forward return map. Whether its range equals the full affine compatibility space of the linearized inverse problem is a separate question, stated precisely in Conjecture 12.1 below.
(v) Nonspherical large- reference states. For Euclidean perimeter, the leading-order reference is spherical. Nonspherical reference states would require a modified leading geometric energy, for example anisotropic perimeter.
Conjecture 12.1 (Range). Let with . Then is injective on (modulo the volume mode already absorbed by the chart (20)) but not surjective. Its image is a closed subspace of of codimension at most , corresponding to the modes (multiplier) and (translations) absorbed by the reduced center equation and the Lagrange multiplier. Generically, the codimension equals .
Remark 12.2. The conjecture is consistent with the structure of the first-hit equation: the return map is determined by through a scalar equation, so one expects injectivity; and the admissible return maps must be compatible with the geometry of , which excludes at least the directions corresponding to the volume mode and to translations. The identification of the range with the compatibility space of [6] is the natural next step.
Conclusion
The classical Dirichlet-perimeter theory provides a local critical-shape branch near a nondegenerately selected ball when the perimeter weight is large. The contribution of the present paper is to place such a branch inside the geometric normal-return framework of and to determine how its discrete return dynamics responds.
Three geometric steps are essential. First, admissibility in is open under small thickness perturbations. Second, the translated spherical branch admits a unique core-normal representation whose first coefficient contains both center drift and genuine shape deformation. Third, the forward return operator is Fréchet and has an explicit derivative determined by the first-hit equation. Their combination yields the first-order shape-to-dynamics law
The perturbative nonradial example of § 11.2 shows that the response coefficient is generically nonzero, confirming that the theorem is not vacuous.
This response formula is the main new result. It complements earlier work on the fixed return map, inverse reconstruction, and PDE-generated superlevel deformations by providing the general forward sensitivity operator with respect to boundary shape.
The next mathematical questions are consequently sharper than a generic shape-optimization extension: characterize the range and possible loss of rank of , obtain second-order return sensitivities, and determine how these operators interact with the affine/holonomy compatibility structure of the inverse problem. Numerical validation of the nonradial protocol in § 11 is also left for subsequent work.
Consistency with the PDE-generated deformation
We verify identity (60) in detail. Let , where is the level-set speed of [7], related to by (66). We compute the three terms in (56) and compare with the coefficient of [7].
Term 1: . This is the direct boundary displacement.
Hence
Term 3: projection. The projection removes the component along at , and is exactly the projection used in [7 equation for A_0] (the normal direction at the return point is , and the tangent space at is ).
Combining the three terms,
This is exactly the expression for derived in [7 Section 8], up to the identification (66) of with the boundary flux. The sign is consistent with the convention (the superlevel deformation moves inward, whereas is computed for an outward perturbation; the two signs cancel in the projection). This establishes (60).
References
References
- [1]A. D. Alexandrov, A characteristic property of spheres, Ann. Mat. Pura Appl. 58 (1962), 303–315.DOI
- [2]V. Amato, C. Nitsch, C. Trombetti, and F. Villone, On some functionals involving torsional rigidity, principal eigenvalue and perimeter, Potential Analysis 65 (2026), article 25. doi:10.1007/s11118-026-10328-2.DOI
- [3]M. Barkatou, Some geometric properties for a class of non-Lipschitz domains, New York J. Math. 8 (2002), 189–213.
- [4]M. Barkatou, D. Seck, and I. Ly, An existence result for an interior electromagnetic casting problem, Cent. Eur. J. Math. 4 (2006), no. 4, 573–584. doi:10.2478/s11533-006-0026-5.DOI
- [5]M. Barkatou and M. El Morsalani, The return map in the class O_C: geometry, dynamics, and thickness regularity, Journal of Nonlinear Dynamics and Applications 2 (2026), no. 3, 192–216. doi:10.62762/JNDA.2026.569839.DOI
- [6]M. El Morsalani and M. Barkatou, Inverse problems for the return map in the class O_C: reconstruction and identifiability, preprint (2026), arXiv:2604.24915.arxiv.org/abs/2604.24915
- [7]M. El Morsalani and M. Barkatou, Elliptic superlevel sets in the class O_C: boundary-layer geometry and stability of the return map, preprint (2026), arXiv:2607.16912.arxiv.org/abs/2607.16912
- [8]G. Buttazzo, F. P. Maiale, D. Mazzoleni, G. Tortone, and B. Velichkov, Regularity of the optimal sets for a class of integral shape functionals, Arch. Ration. Mech. Anal. 248 (2024), article 44. doi:10.1007/s00205-024-01984-y.DOI
- [9]F. Caubet, M. Dambrine, and J. Darde, On the penalization by the perimeter in shape optimization applied to Dirichlet inverse obstacle problem, ESAIM Control Optim. Calc. Var. 32 (2026), article 7. doi:10.1051/cocv/2025093.DOI
- [10]A. Celentano, C. Nitsch, and C. Trombetti, On a Serrin type overdetermined problem, Milan J. Math. 92 (2024), 579–590. doi:10.1007/s00032-024-00405-9.
- [11]M. C. Delfour and J.-P. Zolesio, Shapes and Geometries: Metrics, Analysis, Differential Calculus, and Optimization, SIAM, Philadelphia, 2001.
- [12]F. Feppon, G. Allaire, and C. Dapogny, A variational formulation for computing shape derivatives of geometric constraints along rays, ESAIM Math. Model. Numer. Anal. 54 (2020), no. 1, 181–228. doi:10.1051/m2an/2019056.DOI
- [13]M. Hayouni and A. Novruzi, Sufficient condition for the existence of solutions of a free boundary problem, Quart. Appl. Math. 60 (2002), no. 3, 425–435. doi:10.1090/qam/1914434.DOI
- [14]A. Henrot and M. Pierre, Variation et optimisation de formes: une analyse géométrique, Springer, Berlin, 2005.
- [15]F. Immler and C. Traut, The flow of ODEs: formalization of variational equation and Poincaré map, J. Autom. Reason. 62 (2019), 215–236. doi:10.1007/s10817-018-9449-5.DOI
- [16]A. Novruzi, C^{2,α} existence result for a class of shape optimization problems, SIAM J. Control Optim. 43 (2004), no. 1, 174–193. doi:10.1137/S0363012902382401.DOI
- [17]P. I. Plotnikov and J. Sokolowski, Geometric framework for gradient flow in shape optimization, Uspekhi Mat. Nauk 81 (2026), no. 3, 51–150. doi:10.4213/rm10296.DOI
- [18]J. Sokolowski and J.-P. Zolesio, Introduction to Shape Optimization: Shape Sensitivity Analysis, Springer, Berlin, 1992.