betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Thermalized buckling of isotropically compressed thin sheets

Abstract

The buckling of thin elastic sheets is a classic mechanical instability that occurs over a wide range of scales. In the extreme limit of atomically thin membranes like graphene, thermal fluctuations can dramatically modify such mechanical instabilities. We investigate here the delicate interplay of boundary conditions, nonlinear mechanics and thermal fluctuations in controlling buckling of confined thin sheets under isotropic compression. We identify two inequivalent mechanical ensembles based on the boundaries at constant strain (isometric) or at constant stress (isotensional) conditions.Remarkably, in the isometric ensemble, boundary conditions induce a novel long-ranged nonlinear interaction between the local tilt of the surface at distant points. This interaction combined with a spontaneously generated thermal tension leads to a renormalization group description of two distinct universality classes for thermalized buckling, realizing a mechanical variant of Fisher-renormalized critical exponents. We formulate a complete scaling theory of buckling as an unusual phase transition with a size dependent critical point, and discuss experimental ramifications for the mechanical manipulation of ultrathin nanomaterials.

Introduction

Thin sheets with a resistance to shear can accommodate compressive stresses through an array of mechanical instabilities, including buckling [1, 2], wrinkling [3, 4, 5], folding [6, 7] and crumpling [8, 9], all controlled essentially by geometry. Although once disregarded as undesirable modes of failure, instabilities now play a central role in the design of mechanical metamaterials [10, 11] as they combine complex morphologies with mechanical functionality. In recent years, rapid miniaturization has driven intense research efforts in developing similar metamaterials on a much smaller scale [12, 13]. In this regard, atomically thin two dimensional (2D) materials such as graphene, MoS2\mathrm{MoS}_2 or BN [14, 15] are particularly promising and offer unprecedented opportunities to study classical elasticity and mechanics in the ultimate limit in thin sheets, where thermal fluctuations can play a dominant role [15, 16].

In such ultrathin flexible materials thermal fluctuations can dramatically renormalize the mechanical properties in a scale-dependent fashion [17]. Out of plane (flexural) deformations allow tensionless solid membranes to exhibit a remarkable thermally wrinkled, yet flat phase with a scale-dependent bending rigidity and strongly softened elastic moduli [16, 18]. While thin sheets favour bending over energetically expensive stretching, geometry links the two as any bending-induced Gaussian curvature inevitably causes stretching as well. This basic feature underlies many of the impressive finite temperature properties. Nanoindentation measurements in graphene [19] and MoS2\mathrm{MoS}_2 [20] monolayers yield exceptionally high Young’s moduli on the nanoscale as expected from strong covalent bonding. Yet on larger scales ∼10 μm\sim10\,\mu\mathrm{m}, recent experiments with freely suspended graphene have demonstrated a ∼4000\sim4000 fold enhancement of the bending rigidity [12] and a factor ∼20\sim20 reduction in the in-plane stiffness [21], due to a combination of thermally generated and static ripples [22, 23, 24], highlighting the importance of flexural fluctuations.

While the anomalous mechanics of thermalized membranes has been extensively explored, the role of confinement and boundaries is much less appreciated. Supported or clamped edges are one of the most commonly encountered boundary conditions, in electromechanical resonators [25, 26], multistable switches [27] and in nanomechanical devices [12, 21]. Geometric confinement at the boundary can induce prestrains in the sample that can cause large scale instabilities such as wrinkling [28]. As a result, in recent years, exploring the influence of external stresses on the mechanics of fluctuating membranes has been a topic of prime interest [29]. While there has been some theoretical work, both old [30] and new [31, 32, 33, 34], complemented by more recent large scale numerical simulations [35, 36, 37, 38, 39, 40], elucidating the role of boundaries in controlling the nonlinear mechanics and buckling of thermalized sheets, particularly for compressions which attempt to impose a nonzero Gaussian curvature, remains a challenging problem.

Motivated by the above, in this paper, we pose and answer the following question - what is the finite temperature version of the buckling transition in an isotropically compressed thin sheet? Euler buckling represents the simplest mechanical instability a thin elastic body can undergo and it provides an attractive setting to investigate the interplay of thermal fluctuations and boundary conditions along with the geometric nonlinearities inherent to thin plate mechanics. In particular, we focus on the universal aspects of the transition such as critical scaling exponents that are independent of microscopic details. By combining a full renormalization group analysis along with a general scaling theory, we provide a complete description of thermalized buckling as a genuine phase transition that exhibits critical scaling along with more unusual features such as a sensitive dependence on system size and the choice of boundary conditions. Apart from new statistical mechanical results, the scaling framework we propose also yields key predictions that have important ramifications for experiments that we highlight below.

In the rest of the introduction, we summarize our main results and outline the structure of the paper.

Results and outline

A key outcome of our work is a renormalization group analysis, augmented by a scaling description of buckling in isotropically compressed thermalized thin sheets. There are two main reasons why finite temperature buckling, when viewed as a phase transition, is distinct from conventional critical phenomena. The first is that buckling is strongly size dependent, even at zero temperature by virtue of it being a long-wavelength instability [1]. The second is the remarkable fact that freely fluctuating elastic sheets exhibit a flat phase [17] with critical fluctuations over an extended range of temperatures. Both these features are characteristic of thin sheets, arising from an interplay of geometry and mechanics, and form the basis of our results below.

Ensemble inequivalence & Fisher renormalization

Thin sheets can be loaded in-plane either by prescribing the external strain (isometric) or the external stress (isotensional) at the boundary (see Figure 1 for an illustration). These constitute dual mechanical ensembles, in analogy with thermodynamic ensembles [42]. While it is well known that boundary conditions can modify nonuniversal quantities such as the buckling threshold [1], we discover that universal scaling exponents (defined in § 5) can also exhibit a remarkable sensitivity to boundary conditions! We demonstrate this fact explicitly within a systematic ε=4−D\varepsilon= 4 - D expansion for a general DD-dimensional solid embedded in d>Dd > D dimensional space (discussed in § 10 and § 11 with details relegated to Appendix C) along with a simpler, but uncontrolled, one-loop calculation performed directly in the physical dimensions of D=2D = 2 and d=3d = 3 in Appendix § 18. Our calculations show that buckling in the two mechanical ensembles is in fact controlled by two distinct fixed points, with different scaling exponents that are summarized in Table I. This remarkable departure from conventional wisdom demonstrates the nonequivalence of mechanical ensembles in thermally fluctuating thin sheets and highlights the subtle nature of membrane statistical mechanics. Thus, in the simplest setting of isotropic compression, we find thermalized plate buckling is described by two distinct critical points characterizing the isometric and isotensional universality classes that are distinguished simply by the boundary conditions imposed.

Figure 1. A sketch showing a possible realization of the two mechanical ensembles, for example, in an atomically thin sheet of graphene. (a) In the isotensional ensemble, a constant inward external stress σ0\sigma_0 is applied to the membrane, while the boundary displacement fluctuates. This set-up might be realized in the same fashion as in single molecule experiments, by using feedback-controlled multiplexed optical tweezers to actuate under constant force conditions, similar to experiments recently used to probe the mechanical response of red blood cells [41]. (b) The isometric ensemble instead corresponds to a clamped boundary with the external load imposed via a global strain ε\varepsilon. While, current experiments with graphene typically suspend monolayers across fixed size holes [21], a variable aperture size tuned by a camera shutter mechanism could be used to tune the strain isotropically. An external symmetry breaking field E\mathcal{E} perpendicular to average plane of the sheet can also be applied in either ensemble to bias the direction of buckling.

ExponentRelationIsotensional ensembleIsometric ensemble
D=2D = 2, d=3†d = 3^{\dagger}D=4−εD = 4 - \varepsilon, d=D+dcd = D + d_cD=2D = 2, d=3†d = 3^{\dagger}D=4−εD = 4 - \varepsilon, d=D+dcd = D + d_c
η,η′\eta, \eta'η′=η\eta' = \eta0.82112ε24+dc\frac{12\varepsilon}{24 + d_c}0.82112ε24+dc\frac{12\varepsilon}{24 + d_c}
ηu,ηu′\eta_u, \eta'_u2η+ηu=4−D2\eta+ \eta_u = 4 - D<br>2η′+ηu′=4−D2\eta' + \eta'_u = 4 - D0.358dcε24+dc\frac{d_c\varepsilon}{24 + d_c}0.358dcε24+dc\frac{d_c\varepsilon}{24 + d_c}
ν,ν′\nu, \nu'ν=1/(2−η)\nu= 1/(2 - \eta)<br>ν′=ν/(Dν−1)\nu' = \nu/(D\nu- 1)0.84812+3ε24+dc\frac{1}{2} + \frac{3\varepsilon}{24 + d_c}1.21812+(12+dc)ε96+4dc\frac{1}{2} + \frac{(12 + d_c)\varepsilon}{96 + 4d_c}
β,β′\beta, \beta'β=ν(1−η/2)\beta= \nu(1 - \eta/2)<br>β′=ν′(1−η′/2)\beta' = \nu'(1 - \eta'/2)12\frac{1}{2}12\frac{1}{2}0.71812+dcε96+4dc\frac{1}{2} + \frac{d_c\varepsilon}{96 + 4d_c}
γ,γ′\gamma, \gamma'γ=ν(2−η)=2β\gamma= \nu(2 - \eta) = 2\beta<br>γ′=ν′(2−η′)=2β′\gamma' = \nu'(2 - \eta') = 2\beta'111.4361+dcε48+2dc1 + \frac{d_c\varepsilon}{48 + 2d_c}
δ,δ′\delta, \delta'δβ=γ+β\delta\beta= \gamma+ \beta<br>δ′β′=γ′+β′\delta'\beta' = \gamma' + \beta'3333
θ,θ′\theta, \theta'θ=1/(νD−1)\theta= 1/(\nu D - 1)<br>θ′=ν′D−1, θ′=θ\theta' = \nu'D - 1,\ \theta' = \theta1.4361+dcε48+2dc1 + \frac{d_c\varepsilon}{48 + 2d_c}1.4361+dcε48+2dc1 + \frac{d_c\varepsilon}{48 + 2d_c}
ϕ,ϕ′\phi, \phi'ϕ=ν(4+D−η)/2\phi= \nu(4 + D - \eta)/2<br>ϕ′=ν′(4+D−η′)/2\phi' = \nu'(4 + D - \eta')/22.1962+(12−dc)ε96+4dc2 + \frac{(12 - d_c)\varepsilon}{96 + 4d_c}3.1552+3(4+dc)ε4(24+dc)2 + \frac{3(4 + d_c)\varepsilon}{4(24 + d_c)}

Table I. The two buckling universality classes. We list all the scaling exponents along with the relevant scaling identities for the isotensional (unprimed exponents) and isometric (primed exponents) ensembles. The exponents are obtained within an ε\varepsilon-expansion (D=4−εD = 4 - \varepsilon, d=D+dcd = D + d_c), accurate to O(ε)O(\varepsilon) and also in physical dimensions (D=2D = 2, d=3d = 3) using the best self-consistent estimates for η\eta [60]. Only β=1/2\beta= 1/2, γ=1\gamma= 1 (isotensional) and δ=δ′=3\delta= \delta' = 3 (both ensembles) are exact to all orders and independent of dimensionality.

Although surprising, the inequivalence of ensembles has precedence in critical phenomena. A critical point engenders fluctuations on all scales which under appropriate conditions can result in scaling exponents that change upon switching to a dual or constrained ensemble. This is known as Fisher renormalization [43]. In our case, however, by tuning to the buckling threshold, we approach the flat phase of a free-standing membrane which characterizes an entire low temperature critical phase with scale invariant fluctuations! Furthermore, we find that the imposition of a fixed strain (in contrast to a fixed stress) boundary condition induces a novel long-ranged nonlinearity that couples the local tilt of the surface at far away points, which we derive in Sec. 3 and Appendix A through a careful consideration of zero modes and boundary conditions. This nonlocal term, which can also be important far from the buckling transition, softly enforces the geometric constraint of global inextensibility, which simultaneously shifts the buckling threshold by a spontaneously generated thermal tension and modifies the critical exponents via a mechanical variant of Fisher renormalization.

Size-dependent scaling theory

The long-wavelength nature of the buckling instability endows it with both a system size dependent threshold and a macroscopic mechanical response [1], features that are retained even at finite temperature. This size dependence is unusual though, from the point of view of critical phenomena, and behaves as a dangerously irrelevant variable [44] that modifies scaling exponents in nontrivial ways. As a result, we derive new exponent identities in § 12 that relate different scaling exponents in both ensembles, mirroring classic results from conventional critical phenomena [45]. Many of these relations are also summarized in Table I. By combining scaling with general thermodynamic arguments, we also explicitly demonstrate how buckling physics in both ensembles is a mechanical variant of Fisher renormalization. Note that, the construction of a consistent scaling theory for thermalized buckling is a significant achievement as it not only clarifies previous confounding results [30, 32] by correctly accounting for nontrivial system size dependence and ensemble inequivalence, but it also yields a unified framework that incorporates experimentally relevant boundary conditions and symmetry breaking fields.

Experimental consequences

Our work illustrates the spectacular ways in which geometry, boundary effects and thermal fluctuations can conspire to produce unexpected phenomena, and suggests that extending thin body mechanics to finite temperature is a rich and challenging enterprise, requiring great care. Given the ubiquity and ease of manipulating strain rather than stress in experiments, our results have important implications for the rational design of strain engineered nanodevices and interpretation of mechanical measurements in ultrathin materials in the presence of thermal fluctuations.

A common setup to probe the mechanical properties of graphene involves measuring the force-displacement curve for a clamped monolayers that is deformed by the application of stresses or external fields. As a simple example, we shall focus here on a simple circular geometry

with sheets draped across holes and deflected by a normal electric field (E\mathcal{E}) as employed in recent experiments [21, 46] (see inset in Figure 2 for a sketch). Other geometries including ribbons cantilevered at an edge [12] or suspended across trenches [25, 26, 28] are also possible, but we don’t address them here. A crucial ingredient in the interpretation of force response measurements in these devices is a mechanical “equation of state” that relates the externally applied field E\mathcal{E} and the in-plane tension Δσ\Delta\sigma to the magnitude of the average deflection of the sheet ⟨h⟩\langle h \rangle. A zero-temperature mean-field description following classical elasticity (detailed in § 8) gives

Figure 2. Experimentally measured height response curve of a clamped graphene sheet suspended over a circular hole of radius 6.2 μm\mu\mathrm{m} in a cryostat at two different temperatures, T=78T = 78 K (blue dots) and T=297T = 297 K (red dots). The data is reproduced from [46]. The electrically integrated graphene devices are capacitively actuated out of the plane using an electrostatic force E∝Vg2\mathcal{E} \propto V_g^2 (VgV_g is the gate voltage) and the average deflection ⟨h⟩\langle h \rangle of the sheet is measured using laser interferometry, see inset for a sketch of the setup and [46] for further details. The red and blue lines are guides to the eye showing the exponent of the nonlinear force response. While the T=297T = 297 K data (red dots) shows a strong cubic dependence on the height, the T=78T = 78 K data (blue dots) shows a smaller slope that matches well with our theoretical prediction using the isometric ensemble exponent 3−1/β′≈1.6073 - 1/\beta' \approx1.607. Note that, this slope is significantly different from a slope of unity (black line), as would be predicted in both the isotsensional ensemble and within mean field theory.

E=c1ΔσR2⟨h⟩+c2YR4⟨h⟩3,(1)\mathcal{E} = c_1 \frac{\Delta\sigma}{R^2}\langle h \rangle+ c_2 \frac{Y}{R^4}\langle h \rangle^3 , \tag*{(1)}

where c1,2c_{1,2} are calculable numerical constants, YY is the sought after 2D Young’s modulus and RR is the size of the sheet. Importantly, when the sheet is constrained at fixed stress Δσ\Delta\sigma, i.e., the isotsensional ensemble, Eq. (1) applies exactly even at finite temperature upon simply replacing YY by its scale dependent renormalized value (see § 12 for details). However, nearly all the force measurement experiments are instead conducted with fixed strain and clamped boundary conditions, i.e., in the isometric ensemble. Our general scaling theory and renormalization group analysis provides a different equation

E=c1ΔσR2(YR2)1−12β′⟨h⟩3−1β′+c2YR4⟨h⟩3(2)\mathcal{E}=c_1\frac{\Delta\sigma}{R^2}\left(\frac{Y}{R^2}\right)^{1-\frac{1}{2\beta'}}\langle h\rangle^{3-\frac{1}{\beta'}}+c_2\frac{Y}{R^4}\langle h\rangle^3 \tag*{(2)}

where the tension Δσ=BΔϵ\Delta\sigma=B\Delta\epsilon is now given by the 2D bulk modulus BB and the imposed in-plane strain Δϵ\Delta\epsilon. Strikingly, Eq. (2) involves a new order parameter exponent β′≈0.718\beta' \approx0.718 that controls the asymptotic nonlinear force response. The difference between Eq. (1) and Eq. (2) makes it clear that using Eq. (1) for clamped sheets, as is conventionally done, can lead to significantly wrong results. In fact, recent experimental measurements [46] on graphene drumheads match well with our theoretical predictions, see Figure 2. The strain in the sample increases upon lowering temperature [26, 46], notwithstanding the theoretically expected negative thermal expansion coefficient of graphene [28, 32], presumably due to surface contaminants. As a result, while the classical cubic response dominates at higher temperature with weak tension (red dots in Figure 2), the anomalous nonlinear response with E∝⟨h⟩1.607\mathcal{E}\propto\langle h\rangle^{1.607} (blue dots in Figure 2) emerges for higher strains at lower temperature. A systematic analysis exploring how this nonlinear response affects the extraction of the Young’s modulus is left for future work.

This result highlights the direct relevance of our work to the correct interpretation of mechanical measurements in graphene devices, not only for the circular geometries studied here, but also cantilevers and doubly clamped ribbons. We believe that recognizing the fundamental distinction between the isotensional and the isometric ensembles is essential to such endeavours. While Figure 2 depicts a static example, a dynamical extension of Eq. (2) including dissipation and inertia along with a time-varying field E(t)\mathcal{E}(t) provides a simple description of periodically driven electromechanical oscillators [47]. Although a full dynamical analysis is beyond the scope of this current work, we can already appreciate the presence of a strong nonlinear response (Eq. (2)) in the small deflection limit, which allows for higher quality factors and bistability [47] even for a weak drive. Note that, such an anomalous response is only elicited in the isometric ensemble, emphasizing once again the importance of boundary conditions.

Although we focus on isotropic compression, we expect suitable extensions of this framework to be applicable to recent numerical simulations [39, 40] and experiments [12, 24, 28] on compressed ribbons that have begun addressing the anomalous mechanics of anisotropic buckling in constrained sheets. While much of our discussion has been based on atomic crystals, we emphasize our results are generic and also apply to organic 2D polymers, such as naturally occurring DNA kinetoplasts [48], the spectrin cytoskeleton [49] and reconstituted spider silk [50], or synthetic molecular crystals [51] and possibly polymerosomes [52] with very large radii. In § 13, we conclude with a brief discussion of the broader significance of our results to experiments on atomically thin crystalline membranes and possible future directions.

Thin Plate Elasticity

Here, we focus on the physically relevant continuum elastic description of a thin 2D sheet fluctuating in 3D space (a generalization for a DD-dimensional solid embedded in dd-dimensional (d>Dd>D) Euclidean space, useful for certain applications, is provided in Appendix C). The deformation of a thin flat sheet is parametrized in the Monge gauge using a 2D in-plane displacement vector u\mathbf{u} and a height field hh. The total elastic energy of the sheet involves both stretching and bending contributions and is given by [1]

References

  1. [1]Lev D Landau and EM Lifshitz, Theory of Elasticity,, Vol. 3 (Elsevier, New York, 1986) p. 109.
  2. [2]Warner Tjardus Koiter, On the stability of elastic equilibrium, Vol. 833 (National Aeronautics and Space Administration, 1967).
  3. [3]E. Cerda, K. Ravi-Chandar, and L. Mahadevan, “Thin films - wrinkling of an elastic sheet under tension,” Nature 419, 579–580 (2002); E. Cerda and L. Mahadevan, “Geometry and physics of wrinkling,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 90, 074302 (2003).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12374968
  4. [4]Benny Davidovitch, Robert D Schroll, Dominic Vella, Mokhtar Adda-Bedia, and Enrique A Cerda, “Prototypical model for tensional wrinkling in thin sheets,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 108, 18227–18232 (2011).DOI
  5. [5]H. Vanparys, M. Piñeïrua, F. Brau, B. Roman, J. Bico, C. Gay, W. Bao, C. N. Lau, P. M. Reis, and P. Dammann, “Wrinkling hierarchy in constrained thin sheets from suspended graphene to curtains,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 106, 242301 (2011).
  6. [6]Luka Pocivavsek, Robert Dellsy, Andrew Kern, Sebastián Johnson, Binhua Lin, Ka Yee C Lee, and Enrique Cerda, “Stress and fold localization in thin elastic membranes,” Science 320, 912–916 (2008).DOI
  7. [7]Haim Diamant and Thomas A Witten, “Compression induced folding of a sheet: An integrable system,” Physical review letters 107, 164302 (2011).DOI
  8. [8]M. Ben Amar and Y. Pomeau, “Crumpled paper,” Proc. R. Soc. A 453, 729–755 (1997); E. Cerda and L. Mahadevan, “Conical surfaces and crescent singularities in crumpled sheets,” Phys. Rev. Lett. 80, 2358–2361 (1998); Enrique Cerda, Sahraoui Chaieb, Francisco Melo, and L Mahadevan, “Conical dislocations in crumpling,” Nature 401, 46 (1999).DOI
  9. [9]Thomas A Witten, “Stress focusing in elastic sheets,” Reviews of Modern Physics 79, 643 (2007).DOI
  10. [10]Kim Krieger, “Buckling down,” Nature 488, 146 (2012).
  11. [11]Katia Bertoldi, Vincenzo Vitelli, Johan Christensen, and Martin van Hecke, “Flexible mechanical metamaterials,” Nature Reviews Materials 2, 17066 (2017).DOI
  12. [12]Melina K Blees, Arthur W Barnard, Peter A Rose, Samantha P Roberts, Kathryn L McGill, Pinshane Y Huang, Alexander R Ruyack, Joshua W Kevek, Bryce Kobrin, David A Muller, et al., “Graphene kirigami,” Nature 524, 204 (2015).DOI
  13. [13]John Rogers, Yonggang Huang, Oliver G Schmidt, and David H Gracias, “Origami mems and nems,” Mrs Bulletin 41, 123–129 (2016); Weinan Xu, Zhao Qin, Chun-Teh Chen, Hye Rin Kwag, Qinli Ma, Anjishnu Sarkar, Markus J Buehler, and David H Gracias, “Ultrathin thermoresponsive self-folding 3d graphene,” Science advances 3, e1701084 (2017); Marc Z Miskin, Kyle J Dorsey, Baris Bircan, Yimo Han, David A Muller, Paul L McEuen, and Itai Cohen, “Graphene-based bimorphs for micron-sized, autonomous origami machines,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 115, 466–470 (2018); Michael F Reynolds, Kathryn L McGill, Maritha A Wang, Hui Gao, Fauzia Mujid, Kibum Kang, Jiwoong Park, Marc Z Miskin, Itai Cohen, and Paul L McEuen, “Capillary origami with atomically thin membranes,” Nano Letters 19, 6221–6226 (2019); Bastien Grosso and Eugene Mele, “Graphene gets bent two-dimensional nanomaterials are bending the rules of the papercraft known as kirigami,” Physics today 73, 46–52 (2020).DOI
  14. [14]Kostya S Novoselov, D Jiang, F Schedin, TJ Booth, VV Khotkevich, SV Morozov, and Andre K Geim, “Two-dimensional atomic crystals,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 102, 10451–10453 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/16027370
  15. [15]Mikhail I Katsnelson, Graphene: carbon in two dimensions (Cambridge university press, 2012).
  16. [16]David R Nelson, Tsvi Piran, and Steven Weinberg, Statistical mechanics of membranes and surfaces (World Scientific, 2004).DOI
  17. [17]DR Nelson and L Peliti, “Fluctuations in membranes with crystalline and hexatic order,” Journal de physique 48, 1085–1092 (1987).DOI
  18. [18]Mark J Bowick and Alex Travesset, “The statistical mechanics of membranes,” Physics Reports 344, 255–308 (2001).DOI
  19. [19]Changgu Lee, Xiaoding Wei, Jeffrey W Kysar, and James Hone, “Measurement of the elastic properties and intrinsic strength of monolayer graphene,” science 321, 385–388 (2008).
  20. [20]Simone Bertolazzi, Jacopo Brivio, and Andras Kis, “Stretching and breaking of ultrathin MoS₂,” ACS nano 5, 9703–9709 (2011).DOI
  21. [21]Ryan JT Nicholl, Hiram J Conley, Nickolay V Lavrik, Ivan Vlassiouk, Yevgeny S Puzeyrev, Vijayashree Parsi Sreenivas, Sokrates T Pantelides, and Kirill I Bolotin, “The effect of intrinsic crumpling on the mechanics of free-standing graphene,” Nature communications 6, 1–7 (2015); Ryan JT Nicholl, Nickolay V Lavrik, Ivan Vlassiouk, Bernadeta R Srijanto, and Kirill I Bolotin, “Hidden area and mechanical nonlinearities in freestanding graphene,” Physical review letters 118, 266101 (2017).DOI
  22. [22]Jannik C Meyer, Andre K Geim, Mikhail I Katsnelson, Konstantin S Novoselov, Tim J Booth, and Siegmar Roth, “The structure of suspended graphene sheets,” Nature 446, 60–63 (2007).DOI
  23. [23]Andrej Košmrjl and David R Nelson, “Mechanical properties of warped membranes,” Physical Review E 88, 012136 (2013).
  24. [24]P Xu, M Neek-Amal, SD Barber, JK Schoelz, ML Ackerman, PM Thibado, A Sadeghi, and FM Peeters, “Unusual ultra-low-frequency fluctuations in freestanding graphene,” Nature communications 5, 1–7 (2014).
  25. [25]J Scott Bunch, Arend M Van Der Zande, Scott S Verbridge, Ian W Frank, David M Tanenbaum, Jeevak M Parpia, Harold G Craighead, and Paul L McEuen, “Electromechanical resonators from graphene sheets,” Science 315, 490–493 (2007).
  26. [26]Changyao Chen, Sami Rosenblatt, Kirill I Bolotin, William Kalb, Philip Kim, Ioannis Kymissis, Horst L Stormer, Tony F Heinz, and James Hone, “Performance of monolayer graphene nanomechanical resonators with electrical readout,” Nature nanotechnology 4, 861–867 (2009).DOI
  27. [27]Owen Y Loh and Horacio D Espinosa, “Nanoelectromechanical contact switches,” Nature nanotechnology 7, 283 (2012).DOI
  28. [28]Wenzhong Bao, Feng Miao, Zhen Chen, Hang Zhang, Wanyoung Jang, Chris Dames, and Chun Ning Lau, “Controlled ripple texturing of suspended graphene and ultrathin graphite membranes,” Nature nanotechnology 4, 562–566 (2009).DOI
  29. [29]Bruno Amorim, Alberto Cortijo, F De Juan, AG Grushin, F Guinea, A Gutiérrez-Rubio, H Ochoa, V Parente, Rafael Roldán, Pablo San-Jose, et al., “Novel effects of strains in graphene and other two dimensional materials,” Physics Reports 617, 1–54 (2016).DOI
  30. [30]E Guitter, F David, S Leibler, and L Peliti, “Crumpling and buckling transitions in polymerized membranes,” Physical review letters 61, 2949 (1988); “Thermodynamical behavior of polymerized membranes,” Journal de Physique 50, 1787–1819 (1989).
  31. [31]Rafael Roldán, Annalisa Fasolino, Kostyantyn V Zakharchenko, and Mikhail I Katsnelson, “Suppression of anharmonicities in crystalline membranes by external strain,” Physical Review B 83, 174104 (2011).DOI
  32. [32]Andrej Košmrlj and David R Nelson, “Response of thermalized ribbons to pulling and bending,” Physical Review B 93, 125431 (2016).DOI
  33. [33]LL Bonilla and M Ruiz-Garcia, “Critical radius and temperature for buckling in graphene,” Physical Review B 93, 115407 (2016).DOI
  34. [34]IS Burmistrov, IV Gornyi, V Yu Kachorovskii, MI Katsnelson, JH Los, and AD Mirlin, “Stress-controlled poisson ratio of a crystalline membrane: Application to graphene,” Physical Review B 97, 125402 (2018); IS Burmistrov, V Yu Kachorovskii, IV Gornyi, and AD Mirlin, “Differential poisson’s ratio of a crystalline two-dimensional membrane,” Annals of Physics 396, 119–136 (2018); DR Saykin, IV Gornyi, V Yu Kachorovskii, and IS Burmistrov, “Absolute poisson’s ratio and the bending rigidity exponent of a crystalline two-dimensional membrane,” 414, 168108 (2020).DOI
  35. [35]Jin Wu Jiang, “The buckling of single-layer MoS₂ under uniaxial compression,” Nanotechnology 25, 355402 (2014).DOI
  36. [36]Mark J Bowick, Andrej Košmrlj, David R Nelson, and Rastko Sknepnek, “Non-hookean statistical mechanics of clamped graphene ribbons,” Physical Review B 95, 104109 (2017).DOI
  37. [37]Duanduan Wan, David R Nelson, and Mark J Bowick, “Thermal stiffening of clamped elastic ribbons,” Physical Review B 96, 014106 (2017).DOI
  38. [38]AP Sgouros, G Kalosakas, K Papagelis, and C Galiotis, “Compressive response and buckling of graphene nanoribbons,” Scientific reports 8, 1–13 (2018).DOI
  39. [39]Ali Morshedifard, Miguel Ruiz-García, Mohammad Javad Abdolhosseini Qomi, and Andrej Košmrlj, “Buckling of thermalized elastic sheets,” Journal of the Mechanics and Physics of Solids , 104296 (2021).
  40. [40]Paul Z Hanakata, Sourav S Bhabesh, Mark J Bowick, David R Nelson, and David Yllanes, “Thermal buckling and symmetry breaking in thin ribbons under compression,” Extreme Mechanics Letters , 101270 (2021).
  41. [41]Hervé Turlier, Dmitry A Fedosov, Basile Audoly, Thorsten Auth, Nir S Gov, Cécile Sykes, J-F Joanny, Gerhard Gompper, and Timo Betz, “Equilibrium physics breakdown reveals the active nature of red blood cell flickering,” Nature Physics 12, 513–519 (2016).
  42. [42]Josiah Willard Gibbs, Elementary principles in statistical mechanics: developed with special reference to the rational foundations of thermodynamics (C. Scribner’s sons, 1902).
  43. [43]Michael E Fisher, “Renormalization of critical exponents by hidden variables,” Physical Review 176, 257 (1968); BJ Lipa and MJ Buckingham, “Critical exponent values at λ-transitions,” Physics Letters A 26, 643–644 (1968); Michael E Fisher and Paul E Scesney, “Visibility of critical-exponent renormalization,” Physical Review A 2, 825 (1970).DOI
  44. [44]Daniel J Amit and Luca Peliti, “On dangerous irrelevant operators,” Annals of Physics 140, 207–231 (1982); M. E. Fisher in, “Renormalization group in critical phenomena and quantum field theory ; edited by J. Gunton and M. S. Green, Temple University, May 29-31, 1973,” (1973); see also David R. Nelson, “Coexistence-curve singularities in isotropic ferromagnets,” Physical Review B 13, 2222 (1976).DOI
  45. [45]Nigel Goldenfeld, Lectures on phase transitions and the renormalization group (CRC Press, 2018).DOI
  46. [46]Isaac R Storch, Roberto De Alba, Vivekananda P Adiga, TS Abhilash, Robert A Barton, Harold G Craighead, Jeevak M Parpia, and Paul L McEuen, “Young’s modulus and thermal expansion of tensioned graphene membranes,” Physical Review B 98, 085408 (2018).DOI
  47. [47]Ron Lifshitz and MC Cross, “Nonlinear dynamics of nanomechanical and micromechanical resonators,” Reviews of nonlinear dynamics and complexity 1, 1–52 (2008).DOI
  48. [48]Alexander R Klotz, Beatrice W Soh, and Patrick S Doyle, “Equilibrium structure and deformation response of 2d kinetoplast sheets,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 117, 121–127 (2020).
  49. [49]Christoph F Schmidt, Karel Svoboda, Ning Lei, Irena B Petsche, Lonny E Berman, Cyrus R Safinya, and Gary S Grest, “Existence of a flat phase in red cell membrane skeletons,” Science 259, 952–955 (1993).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/8438153
  50. [50]Kevin D Hermanson, Daniel Huemmerich, Thomas Scheibel, and Andreas R Bausch, “Engineered microcapsules fabricated from reconstituted spider silk,” Advanced Materials 19, 1810–1815 (2007).DOI
  51. [51]Marco Servalli, Hans Christian Ötting­er, and A Dieter Schlüter, “Synthesizing molecular fishing nets,” Physics Today 71, 40–47 (2018); Payam Payamyar, Benjamin T King, Hans Christian Öttinger, and A Dieter Schlüter, “Two-dimensional polymers: concepts and per- spectives,” Chemical Communications 52, 18–34 (2016).DOI
  52. [52]Ho Cheung Shum, Jin-Woong Kim, and David A Weitz, “Microfluidic fabrication of monodisperse biocompatible and biodegradable polymersomes with controlled permeability,” Journal of the American Chemical Society 130, 9543–9549 (2008).DOI
  53. [53]Basile Audoly and Yves Pomeau, Elasticity and geometry: from hair curls to the non-linear response of shells (Oxford university press, 2010).
  54. [54]J Sak, “Critical behavior of compressible magnets,” Physical Review B 10, 3957 (1974).DOI
  55. [55]DJ Bergman and BI Halperin, “Critical behavior of an Ising model on a cubic compressible lattice,” Physical Review B 13, 2145 (1976).DOI
  56. [56]Marco A de Moura, TC Lubensky, Yoseph Imry, and Amnon Aharony, “Coupling to anisotropic elastic media: Magnetic and liquid-crystal phase transitions,” Physical Review B 13, 2176 (1976).DOI
  57. [57]J Rudnick, DJ Bergman, and Y Imry, “Renormalization group analysis of a constrained Ising model,” Physics Letters A 46, 449–450 (1974).DOI
  58. [58]Thanu Padmanabhan, “Statistical mechanics of gravitating systems,” Physics Reports 188, 285–362 (1990).
  59. [59]Julien Barré, David Mukamel, and Stefano Ruffo, “Inequivalence of ensembles in a system with long-range interactions,” Physical Review Letters 87, 030601 (2001).
  60. [60]Pierre Le Doussal and Leo Radzihovsky, “Self-consistent theory of polymerized membranes,” Physical review letters 69, 1209 (1992); “Anomalous elasticity, fluctuations and disorder in elastic membranes,” Annals of Physics 392, 340–410 (2018).
  61. [61]François David and E Guitter, “Crumpling transition in elastic membranes: renormalization group treatment,” EPL (Europhysics Letters) 5, 709 (1988).DOI
  62. [62]Joseph A Aronovitz and Tom C Lubensky, “Fluctuations of solid membranes,” Physical review letters 60, 2634 (1988); Joseph Aronovitz, Leonardo Golubovic, and TC Lubensky, “Fluctuations and lower critical dimensions of crystalline membranes,” Journal de Physique 50, 609–631 (1989).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10038409
  63. [63]Mark J Bowick, Simon M Catterall, Marco Falcioni, Gudmar Thorleifsson, and Konstantinos N Anagnostopoulos, “The flat phase of crystalline membranes,” Journal de Physique I 6, 1321–1345 (1996).DOI
  64. [64]Boris Grigoryevich Galerkin, “Series solution of some problems of elastic equilibrium of rods and plates,” Vestnik inzhenerov i tekhnikov 19, 897–908 (1915).
  65. [65]Yacov Kantor and David R Nelson, “Phase transitions in flexible polymeric surfaces,” Physical Review A 36, 4020 (1987).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/9899342
  66. [66]As we have set d_c = 1 here, both the height h and the symmetry breaking field ε are scalars here.
  67. [67]Note that we define the Poisson ratio simply using the elastic moduli, as is usually done [16, 60]. Alternate, yet related, definitions are possible that can yield different results, see Ref. [34] for instance.
  68. [68]Marco Falcioni, Mark J Bowick, Emmanuel Guitter, and Gudmar Thorleifsson, “The poisson ratio of crystalline surfaces,” EPL (Europhysics Letters) 38, 67 (1997); Mark Bowick, Angelo Cacciuto, G Thorleifsson, and A Travesset, “Universal negative poisson ratio of self-avoiding fixed-connectivity membranes,” Physical Review Letters 87, 148103 (2001).
  69. [69]Rodolfo Cuerno, R Gallardo Caballero, A Gordillo-Guerrero, Pedro Monroy, and JJ Ruiz-Lorenzo, “Universal behavior of crystalline membranes: Crumpling transition and poisson ratio of the flat phase,” Physical Review E 93, 022111 (2016).DOI
  70. [70]There are other interacting fixed points present, including two that correspond to a fluid membrane (with a vanishing shear modulus μ = 0) and a physically unrealizable one (B = 0 but ν ≠ 0), that are not relevant for us.
  71. [71]JH Los, Mikhail I Katsnelson, OV Yazyev, KV Zakharchenko, and Annalisa Fasolino, “Scaling properties of flexible membranes from atomistic simulations: application to graphene,” Physical Review B 80, 121405 (2009).DOI
  72. [72]See, e.g., Joseph Rudnick and David R Nelson, “Equations of state and renormalization-group recursion relations,” Physical Review B 13, 2208 (1976).DOI
  73. [73]J-P Kownacki and Dominique Mouhanna, “Crumpling transition and flat phase of polymerized phantom membranes,” Physical Review E 79, 040101 (2009).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/19518156
  74. [74]Note that σ_c(T) is in general size dependent in a finite sheet, due to the zero temperature buckling threshold ∝ 1/R^2, see Sec. 5. In addition, fluctuation effects will lead to a shift in the buckling threshold ∝ 1/R^{1/ν} as per standard finite size scaling arguments [75], which we expect to dominate over the zero temperature threshold in a large sheet. A similar argument holds in the isometric ensemble as well.
  75. [75]Daniel J Amit and Victor Martin-Mayor, Field theory, the renormalization group, and critical phenomena: graphs to computers (World Scientific Publishing Company, 2005).
  76. [76]Paul M Chaikin, Tom C Lubensky, and Thomas A Witten, Principles of condensed matter physics, Vol. 10 (Cambridge university press Cambridge, 1995).
  77. [77]The free energy densities also have nonsingular terms that need to be properly accounted for. In the limit Δσ → 0 and Δε → 0, we have the following expansions for the respective free energy densities: F_σ = a_0 + a_1Δσ + a_2|Δσ|^{1+1/θ} + O(Δσ^2) and F_ε = b_0 + b_1Δε + b_2|Δε|^{1+θ} + O(Δε^2), where a_0,1,2 and b_0,1,2 are constants.
  78. [78]E Guitter, S Leibler, AC Maggs, and F David, “Stretching and buckling of polymerized membranes: a monte carlo study,” Journal de Physique 51, 1055–1060 (1990).DOI
  79. [79]Theo Odijk, “Microfibrillar buckling within fibers under compression,” The Journal of chemical physics 108, 6923–6928 (1998); Per Lyngs Hansen, Daniel Svensén, V Adrian Parsegian, and Rudi Podgornik, “Buckling, fluctuations, and collapse in semiflexible polyelectrolytes,” Physical Review E 60, 1956 (1999); Krzysztof Baczynski, Reinhard Lipowsky, and Jan Kierfeld, “Stretching of buckled filaments by thermal fluctuations,” 76, 061914 (2007); Marc Emanuel, Hervé Mohrbach, Mehmet Sayar, Helmut Schiessel, and Igor M Kulić, “Buckling of stiff polymers: Influence of thermal fluctuations,” 76, 061907 (2007); Deshpreet Singh Bedi and Xiaoming Mao, “Finite-temperature buckling of an extensible rod,” 92, 062141 (2015); Simon Stuij, Jan Maarten van Doorn, Thomas Kodger, Joris Sprakel, Corentin Coulais, and Peter Schall, “Stochastic buckling of self-assembled colloidal structures,” Physical Review Research 1, 023033 (2019).DOI
  80. [80]David K Lubensky and David R Nelson, “Single molecule statistics and the polynucleotide unzipping transition,” Physical Review E 65, 031917 (2002).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/11909119
  81. [81]David Keller, David Swigon, and Carlos Bustamante, “Relating single-molecule measurements to thermodynamics,” Biophysical Journal 84, 733–738 (2003); Supurna Sinha and Joseph Samuel, “Inequivalence of statistical ensembles in single molecule measurements,” Physical Review E 71, 021104 (2005).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/12547757
  82. [82]Vitor M Pereira, AH Castro Neto, HY Liang, and L Mahadevan, “Geometry, mechanics, and electronics of singular structures and wrinkles in graphene,” Physical review letters 105, 156603 (2010); Francisco Guinea, MI Katsnelson, and AK Geim, “Energy gaps and a zero-field quantum hall effect in graphene by strain engineering,” Nature Physics 6, 30–33 (2010).DOI
  83. [83]Pierre Le Doussal and Leo Radzihovsky, “Thermal buckling transition of crystalline membranes,” arXiv preprint arXiv:2102.08970 (2021).
  84. [84]Robert D Schroll, Eleni Katifori, and Benny Davidovitch, “Elastic building blocks for confined sheets,” Physical review letters 106, 074301 (2011).pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/21405518
  85. [85]Alexander E Lobkovsky and TA Witten, “Properties of ridges in elastic membranes,” Physical Review E 55, 1577 (1997); Enrique Cerda, Lakshminarayanan Mahadevan, and José Miguel Pasini, “The elements of draping,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 101, 1806–1810 (2004); Thomas Barois, Loïc Tadrist, Catherine Quilliet, and Yoël Forterre, “How a curved elastic strip opens,” Physical review letters 113, 243101 (2014).DOI
  86. [86]L Mahadevan, A Vaziri, and Moumita Das, “Persistence of a pinch in a pipe,” EPL (Europhysics Letters) 77, 40003 (2007); Christian D Santangelo, “Nambu-goldstone modes and diffuse deformations in elastic shells,” Soft Matter 9, 8246–8251 (2013).
  87. [87]Ashkan Vaziri and L Mahadevan, “Localized and extended deformations of elastic shells,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 105, 7913–7918 (2008); Arthur A Evans, Basanta Bhaduri, Gabriel Popescu, and Alex J Levine, “Geometric localization of thermal fluctuations in red blood cells,” 114, 2865–2870 (2017).DOI
  88. [88]Jayson Paulose, Gerard A Vliegenthart, Gerhard Gompper, and David R Nelson, “Fluctuating shells under pressure,” Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 109, 19551–19556 (2012); Andrej Košmrlj and David R Nelson, “Statistical mechanics of thin spherical shells,” Physical Review X 7, 011002 (2017).
  89. [89]Michael Gomez, Derek E Moulton, and Dominic Vella, “Critical slowing down in purely elastic ‘snap-through’ instabilities,” Nature Physics 13, 142–145 (2017).DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_ah94kjdv
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents