WorksMathematics
Generic finiteness of rotating relative equilibria in the planar -vortex problem
Abstract
For every , we prove that Zariski-generic nonzero real circulations, with any prescribed signs, admit at most labeled, collision-free rotating relative equilibria modulo translations, rotations in , and positive scaling. The excluded parameters lie in an explicit finite union of quadratic hypersurfaces. The proof combines a logarithmic-residue obstruction to positive-dimensional complex solution sets with Bézout degree bounds.
Introduction
We consider the following planar -vortex problem. Fix and . A labeled, collision-free configuration in is a rotating relative equilibrium if there are and such that
The sign convention is fixed by this equation. We identify configurations under translations, rotations in , and positive dilations.
For , write . Put
Theorem 1.1. The set is a proper algebraic subset of , defined over . For every , the set of labeled, collision-free rotating relative equilibria satisfying (1), modulo translations, rotations and positive scaling, is finite and has at most elements. The conclusion also applies when .
For each prescribed sign vector , the allowed parameters form a nonempty Zariski-open intersection with
This intersection is open, dense, and of full Lebesgue measure in .
Corollary 1.2 (Zero total circulation). Let
Then is a proper algebraic subset of . Consequently, the same bound holds for relatively Zariski-generic nonzero real circulations on . The good set is relatively open, dense, and of full -dimensional Lebesgue measure in every nonempty intersection .
The generic assumption is necessary. An example with a continuum of relative equilibria can be found in [9].
Literature review
The finiteness problem for planar Newtonian central configurations is a longstanding question in celestial mechanics and appears on Smale’s list of problems for the twenty-first century [10 Problem 6]. A related finiteness problem arises for planar point vortices, whose interaction Hamiltonian is logarithmic [2 Introduction]. The logarithmic interaction comes from the fundamental solution of the planar Laplacian. Logarithmic interactions also occur in the plasma analogy for the Laughlin wave function in the fractional quantum Hall effect [1 Section 3.1.2].
Palmore announced almost-everywhere finiteness for positive circulations [5 Corollary 5.2]; his note does not supply a proof of the generic nondegeneracy theorem used to obtain it. No part of the proof below depends on that assertion. O’Neil’s general- work treats static equilibria, translations, and collinear relative equilibria [3]; the scope is summarized in [2 Introduction]. It should not be read as a theorem about all planar rotating configurations with arbitrary signs.
For four vortices, Xiang Yu proves finiteness of rotating relative equilibria for arbitrary nonzero real circulations [8]. For five vortices, Xiang Yu–Shuqiang Zhu obtain finiteness outside a codimension-two algebraic exceptional set, and finiteness for every same-sign circulation vector [9 Theorems 1.2 and 1.4]. O’Neil’s more recent generic theorem applies for arbitrary under a mirror-symmetry restriction, with at most six vortices off the symmetry line, together with a special eight-vortex case [4]. The point of the present argument is the unrestricted number of vortices and the direct signed extension of the full complex-fiber finiteness statement.
Acknowledgment
The author is supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (Grant No. 12271285, 11790273), and by the New Cornerstone Investigator program and Xiaomi Foundation. Moreover, the author is a member of IAS supported by the Shiing-Shen Chern Member Fund this semester.
AI declaration: The work is done with the help of ChatGPT 6.1. The author was inspired by [1 Section 3.1.2] and suggested GPT the method of complexification which is specially adapted to the current problem and utilize the fact that the log potential is the plane Green function. GPT found the key argument, in particular the residue argument, and also assisted in writing.
A normalization that retains both rotation signs
Put , and . Pairing the terms indexed by and gives
For (1), translating the rotation center to 0 therefore gives
If , then ; if , the first identity imposes . The actual rotation data are unique:
For fixed , define the complex fiber by
with
Here are independent complex variables. The unsliced equations are invariant under , , and meets each orbit exactly once.
Lemma 2.1. For , physical similarity classes satisfying (1), with either sign of , are in bijection with
Proof. Represent by . The force equations become
For , set
Then
and
For a similarity , , one has
Conversely,
so the map is injective on similarity classes. Finally, any point in the stated locus satisfies
which is (1) with positions , center 0 and angular parameter . □
Isolation and the Bézout bound
We first prove an isolation criterion by logarithmic residues, then bound the number of isolated solutions by Bézout and use the same estimate to obtain an explicit finite union of exceptional quadratic hypersurfaces.
Eliminate by . The remaining coordinates are
we continue to abbreviate such a point by , with understood in every formula. All vortex indices range from to ; an empty product equals . For , define
Clearing the nonzero denominators in (5) gives
An isolated solution means an isolated point of in the complex Euclidean topology. Since is an open subset of the algebraic set , its isolated points are precisely the zero-dimensional irreducible components of that satisfy all the inequalities . An algebraic set has finitely many irreducible components; thus, if every solution is isolated, is finite. All counts below concern distinct points; no Jacobian nondegeneracy is assumed.
Isolation by logarithmic residues
Proposition 3.1. Fix . If has a nonisolated point, then there exists
Consequently, if the numbers , , are linearly independent over , every point of is isolated.
Proof. Let be nonisolated, and let be a positive-dimensional irreducible component of containing . Put .
*An algebraic curve through Let denote the projective closure of in complex projective space , with identified with its usual affine coordinate chart. If , take . If , choose projective hyperplanes
successively through , each containing no irreducible component of the preceding intersection. Such choices exist because every component at that stage is positive-dimensional, and the hyperplanes through containing it form a proper closed subset of the hyperplane space. Each intersection has pure dimension one less than the preceding one. Choose a reduced irreducible component through of
For , this intersection means itself. Since ,
is a nonempty open subset of , with finite complement. Thus is algebraic by construction. errs_mid=1
Let be its normalization: is a nonsingular projective curve, and has finite fibers and is an isomorphism away from the finitely many singular points of [7 I, Proposition 6.8 and Corollary 6.11]. Over , is a compact connected Riemann surface. We use the same symbols , , for their pullbacks to meromorphic functions on . The force equations (5) hold as identities of meromorphic functions, and , , are not identically zero for .
We next claim that there is at least one that is non constant on .
Proof of the claim. Suppose all are constant. They are nonzero on . Put
For ,
where are the roots of this quadratic. The identity theorem implies that one of the two factors vanishes identically. Hence
Thus every is constant, and
All affine coordinates of would be constant, contradicting . Hence at least one is nonconstant. □
The residue relation. Pairing with in the force equations gives
Since the circulations are fixed, differentiation on yields
Choose a nonconstant . It has a pole : otherwise it would be holomorphic on the compact Riemann surface , hence constant by the maximum principle. Choose a local holomorphic coordinate with . For any nonzero meromorphic function near , write
The order is positive at a zero and negative at a pole. The residue of a meromorphic differential is the coefficient of in its local expansion. Thus
Taking the residue of (13) at this fixed point yields
The vector is nonzero because the chosen has a pole at . Rational linear independence of the pair products rules out (15), proving the isolation assertion. □
Bézout: the number of isolated solutions
For an irreducible projective algebraic set of dimension , its degree is the number of points of , counted with multiplicity, where is a general linear subspace of dimension [6 Definition 18.1(iii), p. 225]. For an irreducible affine algebraic set , set , where is its projective closure under . In particular, a point has degree 1. All sums below run over irreducible components of all dimensions; an empty sum is zero. The degree of a polynomial is its total degree.
Lemma 3.2. Let be an algebraic set and a polynomial of degree at most an integer . Let be the irreducible components of , and those of . Then
The same inequality holds for a projective algebraic set cut by a homogeneous polynomial. In particular, for every , if are the irreducible components of , then
Proof. Consider one component . If vanishes identically on , its degree remains unchanged and . If does not vanish identically and either or is a nonzero constant, the intersection is empty. In the remaining case, homogenize and apply projective Bézout [7 I, Theorem 7.7]. Discarding intersection multiplicities and components at infinity gives
where runs over the irreducible components of . Summing over proves the inequality; discarding repeated components or components contained in others can only decrease the sum. The same argument applies to projective intersections. Since , apply the inequality successively to the polynomials in (9), starting with , of degree 1. This gives (16). □
Proposition 3.3. For every ,
This counts isolated points even when also has positive-dimensional components. In particular, if every point of is isolated, then .
Proof. Let be the irreducible components of . Since is open in , each isolated point of is a zero-dimensional component of . Hence
Bounding the residue coefficients
The same degree estimate bounds the integers in the residue obstruction. This reduces the possible relations to the finite list in (2) and proves finiteness outside .
Corollary 3.4. For every , every point of is isolated and
Proof. Suppose has a nonisolated point. Take the component , the curve with normalization , and the pole used to construct the residue vector in the proof of Proposition 3.1. Applying Lemma 3.2 with at each hyperplane intersection in (11) gives
Consider a coordinate difference or with , as a meromorphic function on . If is constant, it is nonzero, and . Otherwise choose avoiding the finite values of at the finitely many points of mapped by to singular points or points at infinity of . Every zero of then lies over a smooth affine point of . Its order is the local intersection multiplicity with the hyperplane . Bézout therefore gives
For any nonzero meromorphic function on , the residue theorem and (14) give
only finitely many terms are nonzero. Since and have the same poles with the same orders,
Thus in both the constant and nonconstant cases. The order of a product is the sum of the orders, so
Together with (15), this gives
contrary to . Thus every point is isolated; Proposition 3.3 gives the count. □
Proof of Theorem 1.1 and Corollary 1.2. The monomials , , are distinct, so for every . Since the index set in (2) is finite, the polynomial
is nonzero and has integer coefficients. Thus is a proper algebraic subset of , defined over .
On , substitute . Then
If this polynomial vanished identically, the square coefficients would first give for ; the remaining mixed coefficients would then give for . This contradicts $k\ne 0.
Each factor, and hence , therefore remains nonzero after the substitution. In particular, is a proper subset of .
The zero set of a nonzero real polynomial is closed, has empty interior, and has Lebesgue measure zero. Apply this fact to on and to the substituted polynomial in the linear coordinates on . This proves the asserted nonemptiness, openness, density and full measure in each and each nonempty , with relative topology and measure on . The condition also gives the Zariski-open intersections and relative genericity.
Finally, for , Lemma 2.1 and Corollary 3.4 give
The correspondence in Lemma 2.1 includes both signs of and is valid also when . □
References
Rm 305, Wenbei Building, New Cornerstone Sciences Laboratory, Department of Mathematics Sciences, Tsinghua University, 100084
Email address: [email protected]
References
- [1]D. Tong, The Quantum Hall Effect, TIFR Infosys Lectures, 2016. https://www.damtp.cam.ac.uk/user/tong/qhe/qhe.pdf.
- [2]M. Hampton and R. Moeckel, Finiteness of stationary configurations of the four-vortex problem, Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 361 (2009), 1317–1332. doi:10.1090/S0002-9947-08-04685-0.DOI
- [3]K. A. O’Neil, Stationary configurations of point vortices, Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 302 (1987), 383–425.
- [4]K. A. O’Neil, Finiteness of mirror-symmetric relative equilibria of point vortices, Physica D: Nonlinear Phenomena 481 (2025), 134823. doi:10.1016/j.physd.2025.134823.DOI
- [5]J. I. Palmore, Relative equilibria of vortices in two dimensions, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the USA 79 (1982), 716–718. doi:10.1073/pnas.79.2.716.DOI
- [6]J. Harris, Algebraic Geometry: A First Course, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 133, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1992. doi:10.1007/978-1-4757-2189-8.DOI
- [7]R. Hartshorne, Algebraic Geometry, Graduate Texts in Mathematics, vol. 52, Springer-Verlag, New York, 1977. doi:10.1007/978-1-4757-3849-0.DOI
- [8]X. Yu, Finiteness of stationary configurations of the planar four-vortex problem, Advances in Mathematics 435 (2023), 109378. doi:10.1016/j.aim.2023.109378.DOI
- [9]X. Yu and S. Zhu, On finiteness of stationary configurations of the planar five-vortex problem, Mathematische Annalen 392 (2025), 4023–4069. doi:10.1007/s00208-025-03183-w.DOI
- [10]S. Smale, Mathematical problems for the next century, The Mathematical Intelligencer 20 (1998), no. 2, 7–15. doi:10.1007/BF03025291.DOI