betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Stable and causal frames for BDNK hydrodynamics

Abstract

We establish the existence of families of linearly stable and causal Bemfica-Disconzi-Noronha-Kovtun (BDNK) frames for arbitrary equation of state and set of physical transport coefficients. By developing a method based on simplification of Routh-Hurwitz criteria and telegrapher factorisation of polynomials, we provide six concrete examples of such families, three of which admit conformal limits, for both neutral and charged fluids. These frames have adjustable characteristic speeds and can serve as a starting point for numerical implementations of relativistic hydrodynamics in various settings. In the process we uncover a map between stable and causal frames in neutral fluids and stable and causal frames in charged fluids. We also develop an AI research protocol that can be used to search for such frames in any hydrodynamic theory.

Overview

Relativistic hydrodynamics describes the long-wavelength evolution of conserved energy, momentum and charge. Its applications in nuclear physics and astrophysics require a consistent treatment of dissipation. However, constitutive relations truncated at first order in gradients need not define stable and causal evolution equations when treated as an exact system [1]. This matters in numerical simulations, which also probe wavelengths outside the hydrodynamic regime: an instability there can prevent the extraction of long-wavelength observables.

Müller-Israel-Stewart (MIS) theories address this problem by promoting dissipative stresses and currents to additional variables with relaxation equations [2, 3]. Another approach is the density frame formulation [4], in which conserved densities define the hydrodynamic variables on a chosen time foliation. Its linearized theory is stable, and boost symmetry is recovered to the retained order in the derivative expansion. This diffusive formulation provides an alternative organization of relativistic hydrodynamics, without requiring the truncated equations to be an exactly causal hyperbolic system.

The Bemfica-Disconzi-Noronha-Kovtun (BDNK) formulation instead uses hydrodynamic frame freedom to obtain causal and stable evolution while retaining covariant constitutive relations in temperature, chemical potential and velocity [5, 6, 7, 8, 9]. Time derivatives in the first-order constitutive relations produce second-order conservation equations and additional nonhydrodynamic modes. Suitable frame choices give causal, linearly stable systems, with local well-posedness established for several constitutive classes.

Numerical studies provide encouraging tests of this formulation. Stable, convergent evolutions of smooth plane-symmetric conformal flows have been compared with MIS [10], and conservative finite-volume methods have been developed for multidimensional flows [11]. Nonconformal ideal-gas calculations include heat flow and shock profiles [12], while holographically initialized evolutions test hydrodynamics against microscopic relaxation [13]. Spherically symmetric neutron-star calculations in the Cowling approximation also exhibit stable evolution within a restricted parameter range [14]. These developments motivate further tests of BDNK as an effective classical description.

The main obstacle to BDNK hydrodynamics is finding linearly stable and causal frames for a given equation of state and physical transport coefficients.1 General conditions for causality and stability are available, including charged constructions [8, 9], necessary and sufficient conditions for generic charged frames, including non-thermodynamic choices [24],2 and a strongly hyperbolic class with a first-order corrected charge current, constraints on the equation of state, and large frame parameters [27]. General criteria characterize admissible coefficients, but using them still requires solving complicated inequalities for a given equation of state and set of physical transport coefficients.

In this work we provide a concrete strategy for finding such frames for any equation of state (EoS) and physical transport coefficients. We take the point of view that, within BDNK theory, the EoS and physical transport coefficients are the properties that characterise the fluid microscopically and can be obtained from e.g. kinetic theory or holography. The remaining BDNK coefficients can be freely chosen [19]. With this in mind, we brute-force the reduction of the Routh-Hurwitz stability criteria in order to find analytically tractable solutions and brute-force the factorisation of the longitudinal (sound) polynomial to simplify the analysis and find concrete families of frames that are general enough to accommodate all EoS and physical transport coefficients.3

In § 1.1 we provide the constitutive relations and basic thermodynamic properties of the fluids considered here. In § 1.2 we explain the construction method, allowing both thermodynamic and non-thermodynamic frames. In sections 1.3 and 1.4 we provide six families of frames and their properties for both neutral and charged fluids while in § 1.7 we conclude with a summary and open questions. In Appendix § 3 we give various derivations, checks, and proofs. Appendix § 4 compares these constructions with existing neutral and ideal-current charged frames.

Constitutive relations and physical data

To begin with, we consider a parity-even fluid with one conserved U(1)U(1) current and no external electromagnetic field following mostly the conventions of [8]. We introduce the timelike fluid velocity uμu^\mu normalised such that u2=−1u^2=-1, and define the operators Δμν=gμν+uμuν\Delta^{\mu\nu}=g^{\mu\nu}+u^\mu u^\nu, D=uμ∇μD=u^\mu\nabla_\mu, Θ=∇μuμ\Theta=\nabla_\mu u^\mu, aμ=Duμa^\mu=Du^\mu, ∇⊥μ=Δμν∇ν\nabla_\perp^\mu=\Delta^{\mu\nu}\nabla_\nu, and α=μ/T\alpha=\mu/T as well as the shear tensor

σμν=2ΔμρΔνλ∇(ρuλ)−23ΔμνΘ.(1)\sigma^{\mu\nu}=2\Delta^{\mu\rho}\Delta^{\nu\lambda}\nabla_{(\rho}u_{\lambda)}-\frac{2}{3}\Delta^{\mu\nu}\Theta. \tag*{(1)}

The conservation equations determining the evolution of the fluid variables are ∇μTμν=0\nabla_\mu T^{\mu\nu}=0 and ∇μJμ=0\nabla_\mu J^\mu=0, where the most general stress tensor and charge current under the above assumptions are, respectively

Tμν=(ϵ+E)uμuν+(p+P)Δμν+2u(μQν)−ησμν,(2)T^{\mu\nu}=(\epsilon+\mathcal{E})u^\mu u^\nu+(p+\mathcal{P})\Delta^{\mu\nu}+2u^{(\mu}Q^{\nu)}-\eta\sigma^{\mu\nu}, \tag*{(2)}
Jμ=(n+N)uμ+Jμ,(3)J^\mu=(n+\mathcal{N})u^\mu+\mathcal{J}^\mu, \tag*{(3)}
\begin{pmatrix} \mathcal{E}\\ \mathcal{P}\\ \mathcal{N} \end{pmatrix} = \begin{pmatrix} \epsilon_1 & \epsilon_2 & \epsilon_3\\ \pi_1 & \pi_2 & \pi_3\\ \nu_1 & \nu_2 & \nu_3 \end{pmatrix} \begin{pmatrix} D\ln T\\ \Theta\\ D\alpha \end{pmatrix}, \tag*{(4)}\end{pmatrix}
Qμ=θ1aμ+θ2∇⊥μln⁡T+θ3∇⊥μα,(5)Q^\mu=\theta_1a^\mu+\theta_2\nabla_\perp^\mu\ln T+\theta_3\nabla_\perp^\mu\alpha, \tag*{(5)}
Jμ=γ1aμ+γ2∇⊥μln⁡T+γ3∇⊥μα.(6)\mathcal{J}^\mu=\gamma_1a^\mu+\gamma_2\nabla_\perp^\mu\ln T+\gamma_3\nabla_\perp^\mu\alpha. \tag*{(6)}

All transport coefficients are functions of the temperature TT and chemical potential μ\mu. In the case of neutral fluids they are functions of TT only and six non-trivial coefficients, ϵ1,2\epsilon_{1,2}, π1,2\pi_{1,2}, θ1,2\theta_{1,2}, remain while the others vanish. In contrast to the thermodynamic-frame choices used in Refs. [5, 6, 7, 8, 9], we do not impose θ1=θ2\theta_1=\theta_2 or, for charged fluids, γ1=γ2\gamma_1=\gamma_2. We allow these vector coefficients to differ, subject to the entropy constraint stated below. This enlarges the frame choices without changing the equilibrium equation of state.

We are only interested in thermodynamically consistent equations of state (EoS) defined via the pressure p(T,μ)p(T,\mu) satisfying ϵ=−p+TpT+μpμ\epsilon=-p+Tp_T+\mu p_\mu where we introduced the charge density n=pμ=∂p/∂μn=p_\mu=\partial p/\partial\mu, the entropy density s=pT=∂p/∂Ts=p_T=\partial p/\partial T and the energy density ϵ\epsilon. To specify the constraints that some of these functions must obey, it is useful to define

r=nw,A=∂p∂ϵ∣n,TB=∂p∂n∣ϵ,x=cs2=A+rTB,(7)r=\frac{n}{w},\qquad A=\left.\frac{\partial p}{\partial\epsilon}\right|_n,\qquad TB=\left.\frac{\partial p}{\partial n}\right|_\epsilon,\qquad x=c_s^2=A+rTB, \tag*{(7)}

where w=ϵ+pw=\epsilon+p is the enthalpy and xx is the square of the sound speed. We also introduce

E=∂Tϵ∣α,F=∂αϵ∣T,N=∂Tn∣α,H=∂αn∣T,E=\left.\partial_T\epsilon\right|_\alpha,\qquad F=\left.\partial_\alpha\epsilon\right|_T,\qquad N=\left.\partial_T n\right|_\alpha,\qquad H=\left.\partial_\alpha n\right|_T,
ΔJ=EH−FN=T(ϵTnμ−ϵμnT),qT=N−rE,qα=H−rF,(8)\Delta_J=EH-FN=T(\epsilon_Tn_\mu-\epsilon_\mu n_T),\qquad q_T=N-rE,\qquad q_\alpha=H-rF, \tag*{(8)}

where the subscript TT (or μ\mu) denotes a thermodynamic derivative with respect to TT (or μ\mu). Given these functions, we work on a regular and causal thermodynamic domain T>0T>0 and w>0w>0 with the constraints

T>0,w>0,ΔJ>0,0<x<1,T>0,\qquad w>0,\qquad\Delta_J>0,\qquad0<x<1,
nμ≥0,E≥0,A+nμw(TB)2≥rTB,nμ≥n2wx.(9)n_\mu\geq0,\qquad E\geq0,\qquad A+\frac{n_\mu}{w}(TB)^2\geq rTB,\qquad n_\mu\geq\frac{n^2}{wx}. \tag*{(9)}

The strict inequality in Δj\Delta_j and xx avoid singular susceptibilities and degenerate or luminal sound speeds. Five of these conditions follow from equilibrium fluctuation positivity [8] and their derivation is recalled in Appendix § 3.2.1. In addition, the second law of thermodynamics enforces [8]

η,ζ,D≥0,γ2−γ1=r(θ2−θ1),(10)\eta,\zeta,\mathcal{D} \ge0,\qquad\gamma_2-\gamma_1=r(\theta_2-\theta_1), \tag*{(10)}

as we re-derive in Section A.2.2, where η\eta is the shear viscosity, ζ\zeta is the bulk viscosity and D\mathcal{D} the conductivity defined as

ζ=−π2−ϵ1A2−Tν3B2+A(ϵ2+π1)+B(π3+Tν2)−AB(ϵ3+Tν1),DT=r(θ3−rTθ1)+rTγ1−γ3.(11)\begin{aligned} \zeta&= -\pi_2-\epsilon_1 A^2-T\nu_3 B^2+A(\epsilon_2+\pi_1)+B(\pi_3+T\nu_2)-AB(\epsilon_3+T\nu_1),\\ \mathcal{D}T &= r(\theta_3-rT\theta_1)+rT\gamma_1-\gamma_3. \tag*{(11)} \end{aligned}

We consider the EoS p(T,μ)p(T,\mu) and the transport coefficients η,ζ,D\eta,\zeta,\mathcal{D} as the physical data characterising the fluid, and derivable for instance via kinetic theory, holography, or any kind of microscopic model. Our goal is to find families of frames, i.e. choices of the remaining coefficients, in terms of this physical data, satisfying (9)–(10) but otherwise generic, that render the BDNK theory linearly causal and stable following the strategy described in the next subsection.

Frame construction strategy

We begin by linearising the conservation equations ∇μTμν=0\nabla_\mu T^{\mu\nu}=0 and ∇μJμ=0\nabla_\mu J^\mu=0 in 3+13+1 dimensions around a uniform equilibrium state T→T+δTT\to T+\delta T, μ→μ+δμ\mu\to\mu+\delta\mu and uμ→uμ+δuμu^\mu\to u^\mu+\delta u^\mu in flat space gμν=ημνg_{\mu\nu}=\eta_{\mu\nu} using plane-wave perturbations of the form e−iωt+ik⋅xe^{-i\omega t+i\mathbf{k}\cdot\mathbf{x}} where ω\omega is the frequency and k\mathbf{k} the wavevector. The frequencies are given by the roots of a dispersion polynomial P(ς,k;v)P(\varsigma,\mathbf{k};\mathbf{v}). Up to a nonzero normalization, rotational symmetry in the fluid rest frame and boost invariance [6, 8] gives

P(ς,k;v)∝PT(ς,k;v)2PL(ς,k;v)=0,ς=−iω.(12)P(\varsigma,\mathbf{k};\mathbf{v})\propto P_T(\varsigma,\mathbf{k};\mathbf{v})^2P_L(\varsigma,\mathbf{k};\mathbf{v})=0,\qquad\varsigma=-i\omega. \tag*{(12)}

Here v\mathbf{v} is the equilibrium spatial fluid velocity which can be generated by a boost from the rest state, ς\varsigma is the growth rate, PTP_T is the polynomial factor for each of the two transverse velocity polarizations, and PLP_L describes the longitudinal velocity that couples to temperature and, for charged fluids, to the chemical potential. Our goal is to find dispersion relations ωa(k)\omega_a(\mathbf{k}) that are linearly stable and causal as we now explain.

What the roots must satisfy

For every root ωa\omega_a, every real wavevector, and every uniform velocity ∣v∣<1|\mathbf{v}|<1, linear spectral stability requires

Im⁡ωa(k;v)=Re⁡ςa(k;v)≤0.(13)\operatorname{Im}\omega_a(\mathbf{k};\mathbf{v})=\operatorname{Re}\varsigma_a(\mathbf{k};\mathbf{v})\le0. \tag*{(13)}

References

  1. [1]W. A. Hiscock and L. Lindblom, Generic instabilities in first-order dissipative relativistic fluid theories, Phys. Rev. D 31 (1985) 725–733, doi:10.1103/PhysRevD.31.725.DOI
  2. [2]I. Müller, Zum Paradoxon der Wärmeleitungstheorie, Z. Phys. 198 (1967) 329, doi:10.1007/BF01326412.
  3. [3]W. Israel and J. M. Stewart, Transient relativistic thermodynamics and kinetic theory, Ann. Phys. 118 (1979) 341, doi:10.1016/0003-4916(79)90130-1.DOI
  4. [4]J. Armas and A. Jain, Effective field theory for hydrodynamics without boosts, SciPost Phys. 11 (2021) 054, arXiv:2010.15782.DOI
  5. [5]F. S. Bemfica, M. M. Disconzi and J. Noronha, Causality and existence of solutions of relativistic viscous fluid dynamics with gravity, Phys. Rev. D 98 (2018) 104064, arXiv:1708.06255.DOI
  6. [6]P. Kovtun, First-order relativistic hydrodynamics is stable, JHEP 10 (2019) 034, arXiv:1907.08191.DOI
  7. [7]F. S. Bemfica, M. M. Disconzi and J. Noronha, Nonlinear causality of general first-order relativistic viscous hydrodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 100 (2019) 104020, arXiv:1907.12695.DOI
  8. [8]R. E. Hoult and P. Kovtun, Stable and causal relativistic Navier–Stokes equations, JHEP 06 (2020) 067, arXiv:2004.04102.DOI
  9. [9]F. S. Bemfica, M. M. Disconzi and J. Noronha, First-Order General-Relativistic Viscous Fluid Dynamics, Phys. Rev. X 12 (2022) 021044, arXiv:2009.11388.arxiv.org/abs/2009.11388
  10. [10]A. Pandya and F. Pretorius, A numerical exploration of first-order relativistic hydrodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 104 (2021) 023015, arXiv:2104.00804.DOI
  11. [11]A. Pandya, E. R. Most and F. Pretorius, Conservative finite volume scheme for first-order viscous relativistic hydrodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 105 (2022) 123001, arXiv:2201.12317.DOI
  12. [12]A. Pandya, E. R. Most and F. Pretorius, Causal, stable first-order viscous relativistic hydrodynamics with ideal gas microphysics, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 123036, arXiv:2209.09265.DOI
  13. [13]H. Bantilan, Y. Bea and P. Figueras, Evolutions in first-order viscous hydrodynamics, JHEP 08 (2022) 298, arXiv:2201.13359.DOI
  14. [14]H. L. H. Shum, F. Abalos, Y. Bea, M. Bezares, P. Figueras and C. Palenzuela, Neutron star evolution with the Bemfica-Disconzi-Noronha-Kovtun viscous hydrodynamics framework, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026) 084029, arXiv:2509.15303.DOI
  15. [19]R. E. Hoult and P. Kovtun, Causal first-order hydrodynamics from kinetic theory and holography, Phys. Rev. D 106 (2022) 066023, arXiv:2112.14042.DOI
  16. [20]R. E. Hoult and P. Kovtun, Causality and classical dispersion relations, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) 046018, arXiv:2309.11703.DOI
  17. [21]L. Gavassino, M. M. Disconzi and J. Noronha, Dispersion relations alone cannot guarantee causality, Phys. Rev. Lett. 132 (2024) 162301, arXiv:2307.05987.DOI
  18. [22]L. Gavassino, Can we make sense of dissipation without causality?, Phys. Rev. X 12 (2022) 041001, arXiv:2111.05254.DOI
  19. [23]D.-L. Wang and S. Pu, Stability and causality criteria in linear mode analysis: stability means causality, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) L031504, arXiv:2309.11708.arxiv.org/abs/2309.11708
  20. [24]N. Abboud, E. Speranza and J. Noronha, Causal and stable first-order chiral hydrodynamics, Phys. Rev. D 109 (2024) 094007, arXiv:2308.02928.DOI
  21. [25]J. Armas, E. Have and G.-P. Nicosia, Null matter and the ultrarelativistic origin of hydrodynamics at zero temperature, arXiv:2509.25320.arxiv.org/abs/2509.25320
  22. [26]J. Armas, E. Have and G.-P. Nicosia, Null fluid/gravity correspondence, JHEP 08 (2026) 220, arXiv:2602.20268.DOI
  23. [27]F. Schianchi and F. Abalos, A strongly hyperbolic viscous relativistic hydrodynamics theory with first-order charge current, arXiv:2602.20254v3.arxiv.org/abs/2602.20254
  24. [28]M. M. Disconzi, On the existence of solutions and causality for relativistic viscous conformal fluids, Commun. Pure Appl. Anal. 18 (2019) 1567, arXiv:1708.06572.DOI
  25. [29]F. S. Bemfica, M. M. Disconzi and P. J. Graber, Local well-posedness in Sobolev spaces for first-order barotropic causal relativistic viscous hydrodynamics, Commun. Pure Appl. Anal. 20 (2021) 2885, arXiv:2009.01621.arxiv.org/abs/2009.01621
  26. [30]J. Armas and F. Camilloni, A stable and causal model of magnetohydrodynamics, JCAP 10 (2022) 039, arXiv:2201.06847.DOI
  27. [31]R. Lier, J. Armas and O. Porth, Finite-volume scheme for first-order viscoresistive relativistic magnetohydrodynamics, arXiv:2606.22691.arxiv.org/abs/2606.22691
  28. [32]Y. Bea and P. Figueras, Field redefinitions and evolutions in relativistic Navier–Stokes, JHEP 11 (2024) 110, arXiv:2312.16671.arxiv.org/abs/2312.16671
  29. [33]J. Bhambure, A. Mazeliauskas, J.-F. Paquet, R. Singh, M. Singh, D. Teaney and F. Zhou, Relativistic viscous hydrodynamics in the density frame: Numerical tests and comparisons, Phys. Rev. C 111 (2025) 064910, arXiv:2412.10303.arxiv.org/abs/2412.10303
  30. [34]D. Fantini and M. E. Rubio, Constraint evolution in first-order viscous relativistic fluids, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 063038, arXiv:2506.06430.DOI
  31. [35]N. Clarisse, E. O. Pinho, T. Patel, F. S. Bemfica, M. Hippert and J. Noronha, Flux-conservative Bemfica–Disconzi–Noronha–Kovtun hydrodynamics and shock regularization, Phys. Rev. D 113 (2026) 024051, arXiv:2510.16603.
  32. [36]R. E. Hoult and P. Kovtun, Causality in dissipative relativistic magnetohydrodynamics, JHEP 04 (2025) 009, arXiv:2411.04966.arxiv.org/abs/2411.04966
  33. [37]R. Lier, A. Jain, J. Armas and O. Porth, Resistive relativistic magnetohydrodynamics without Ampère’s law, Phys. Rev. D 112 (2025) 083059, arXiv:2501.04638.DOI
  34. [38]R. E. Hoult and A. Shukla, Causal and stable superfluid hydrodynamics, JHEP 04 (2025) 172, arXiv:2410.22855.DOI

Paper details

vlnc:W_ajrvhum7
Version
v2 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

OpenAI Codex Astra 6 Pro

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents