WorksPhysics and Astronomy
Impact of heat treatments on the performance of low-frequency superconducting quarter-wave resonators at 4.3 K
Abstract
We applied heat treatments to 80.5 MHz quarter-wave resonators made from bulk niobium and prepared with buffered chemical polishing BCP. We evaluated their performance at 4.3 K. We found that a 48 hour, 120 C bake-out ("low-temperature bake out") reduces the surface resistance by a factor of 2 to 3, stemming from a reduction in the Bardeen-Cooper-Schrieffer contribution, consistent with previous findings. This decrease leads to a 38% decrease on average in the medium-field Q-slope when compared to cavities which had only BCP. Mechanisms for the change in quality factor with low-temperature baking have been explored. We observed no improvement in cavity performance after a 3-hour bake-out at 350 C ("medium-temperature bake out"), in contrast to observations for higher-frequency cavities.
Introduction
The Facility for Rare Isotope Beams (FRIB) began user operations in May 2022 [1, 2]. The driver linear accelerator (linac) consists of 324 superconducting radio-frequency (SRF) cavities to accelerate light and heavy ions (up to 200 MeV per nucleon in the case of uranium ions). Four different cavity types are needed, two quarter-wave resonator (QWR) types and two half-wave resonator (HWR) types [3]. The second cavity type is a QWR optimized for acceleration of low-velocity beams (, 80.5 MHz). The linac includes 92 such cavities in 12 cryomodules. Figure 1 shows the field distributions for the accelerating mode calculated with CST Microwave Studio [4].
Figure 1. Intensity maps of the magnitude of the electric field (left) and magnetic field (right) for the FRIB QWR. The field amplitudes are normalized to a stored energy of Joule.
The quality factor and surface resistance of an SRF cavity are related via [5]
where is the stored energy, is the cavity resonant frequency, is the power dissipation in the cavity, and is the geometry factor; is the average RF surface resistance of the cavity (weighted according to the distribution of the square of the surface magnetic field ). The left equation is generally valid, but the right equation is strictly correct only when there are no additional loss mechanisms in the cavity, such as field emission or multipacting [6, 7]. In the absence of additional loss mechanisms, is proportional to , so reducing decreases , and therefore decreases the load to the cryogenic plant. As such, there has been a sustained effort in the SRF community to reduce and mitigate the -slope (decrease in as accelerating gradient increases). Imperfections, foreign particles, and contaminants on the inner surface of the cavity can produce an increase in and may lead to field emission or early thermal breakdown. Hence careful surface preparation is needed for a high-performance cavity to remove the damage layer from cavity forming and produce the best possible surface. Standard practice is to remove via buffered chemical polishing (BCP). Electro-polishing (EP) is an alternative to BCP which generally produces lower surface roughness [8, 9, 10, 11, 12].
Baking for hours at 120°C has been shown to mitigate high-field -slope at 2 K for electropolished elliptical cavities over a range of frequencies [13, 14, 15]. This low-temperature baking (LTB) has hence been incorporated as a standard preparation step for the International Linear Collider [16] and the European X-ray Free Electron Laser facility [17].
Other treatments have been shown to produce higher and thus improve the cavity performance. For cavities with frequencies GHz, nitrogen doping has been found to be an attractive treatment. Briefly stated, the cavity is heat treated in an ultra-high vacuum (UHV) furnace, nitrogen is introduced into the furnace during the treatment, and then harmful surface nitrides are removed via light EP [18, 19, 20]. At GHz frequencies, N-doping results in an increase in as a function of (“anti--slope”). This anti- slope has been shown to have a frequency dependence, and has not been observed in sub-GHz cavities after N-doping, even though improves [21, 22].
Recently, heat treatment at 300 to 350°C for 3 hours (medium-temperature bake, MTB) has been shown to increase and produce anti--slope for 1.3 GHz TeSLA-style cavities at 2 K [23, 24, 25, 26]. For medium-frequency cavities (500 MHz to 1 GHz), MTB results in higher at 2 K, in line with N-doping effects for such cavities [22, 27].
For low- cavities operating at 4.3 K, LTB is often used and is considered helpful to soften multipacting barriers. For example, LTB was applied for all of the QWRs for SPIRAL2 [28, 29, 30] and was incorporated for ISAC-II at TRIUMF [31]. Both groups observed a lessening of the -slope at K with LTB.
Recent studies at TRIUMF on multi-mode coaxial resonators prepared with BCP have shown that the effectiveness of MTB and LTB has a frequency dependence [32, 33]. At 4.3 K, was reduced by MTB for higher-frequency modes ( MHz), while MTB did not improve the performance for low-frequency modes (220 MHz, 390 MHz). Their work focused on the relationship between the effectiveness of different heat treatments and the frequency of the electromagnetic mode excited in two different coaxial resonators. In our studies, we sought to understand the cause of the improvement in medium-field -slope for many low-frequency quarter-wave resonators due to LTB as well as explore the effect of MTB on a FRIB production resonator.
Originally, it was planned to operate the FRIB QWRs at 2 K, co-habiting with superconducting solenoids at 4.3 K in the same cryomodules. Hence, during FRIB cavity production, LTB was not included as a routine preparation step, as it was not found to be beneficial for 2 K operation [34] (as can be seen in Figure 2). However, during linac commissioning, we found that the QWRs could be stably operated at 4.3 K, which allowed for simpler cryogenic operation of the linac. (Though the 322 MHz FRIB HWR cryomodules still operate with cavities at 2 K and solenoids at 4.3 K.) For the present FRIB operation configuration, LTB would provide improved performance for QWRs, so an LTB step is now included for spare and refurbished QWR cryomodules. As can be seen in Figure 2, there is a clear performance improvement for FRIB QWRs at 4.3 K due to LTB.
Figure 2. Cavity intrinsic quality factor () as a function of accelerating gradient () for several QWRs after BCP (black) or BCP+LTB (red) at 4.3 K (solid lines) and 2 K (dashed lines). The peak surface magnetic field () is also shown. The star represents the FRIB 2 K cryomodule goal.
Cavity Preparation
FRIB cavities were formed from high-purity niobium sheet by deep drawing and electron beam welding. The residual resistivity ratio (RRR) requirement for the Nb sheet was . Production cavities were fabricated and jacketed by industrial suppliers and delivered to FRIB for surface preparation and certification testing. Production cavities received a 120 bulk BCP treatment in the FRIB BCP facility. A 600°C hydrogen degassing treatment in an ultra-high vacuum (UHV) furnace at FRIB was done after bulk BCP. Final steps were light BCP and in-clean-room high-pressure water rinsing [35].
The SRF infrastructure at FRIB [36] allows for exploration of different treatments to gauge their effect on cavity performance. A recent addition is an EP facility [37], which has been used for FRIB HWRs [38] and prototype elliptical cavities for the proposed FRIB energy upgrade [39]. The available access ports for the FRIB QWRs make EP treatment impractical for them with the present EP system, thus we did not explore the effect of EP with heat treatments in this work.
The FRIB UHV furnace can be used for other heat treatments such as LTB and MTB. An in-situ bakeout of FRIB cavities after clean-room assembly is also possible using an electric blanket and warm gas flow through the helium vessel. As FRIB QWRs include an indium gasket, in-situ baking of QWRs cannot be done above about 120°C. Figure 3 shows the furnace and in-situ baking setups. A schematic of the QWR RF seal can be seen in Figure 4. We note that cavities that undergo LTB in the UHV furnace have the RF surface subsequently exposed to air, while cavities that undergo in-situ LTB do not.
Figure 3. FRIB QWR in the UHV furnace (top) and undergoing in-situ LTB (bottom).
Figure 4. Isometric view of the FRIB QWR and schematic of the RF and vacuum seals with a double indium gasket. Image originally published in Ref. [34].
Surface Resistance
The RF surface resistance of a superconductor can be written as the sum of two terms, a term predicted by the Bardeen-Cooper-Schriefler (BCS) theory of superconductivity, dependent on the temperature and the RF frequency , and a temperature-independent residual resistance [5]:
The BCS term can be expressed to a good approximation
by [5]:
where is the critical temperature of the superconductor (Nb in our case); and are coefficients predicted by the BCS theory that are dependent on the London penetration depth and superconducting energy gap . More practically, and can be obtained by fitting experimental data. The coefficient relates to the RRR of the niobium as well. The RRR is correlated with the Nb purity and thermal conductivity which is in turn dependent on the mean-free-path of the electrons in the material; relates to the superconducting energy gap , which in turn relates to the coherence length of Cooper pairs in the superconductor. A value of was used in accordance with findings from Ref. [14] for niobium after LTB.
Magnetic flux trapped during the transition from the normal state to the superconducting state can contribute to the residual resistance [40, 41, 42]. External magnetic field cancellation coils and shielding can be used to try to reduce residual magnetic flux trapping. However, if the cavity and helium jacket are made of different materials, the thermo-electric effect can produce current loops if there are temperature gradients during the during cavity cool-down. The magnetic fields associated with these current loops can be a source of additional trapped flux [43, 44]. Other loss mechanisms, including surface impurities, may contribute to as well. Since it is difficult to describe in analytical form, our approach is to evaluate from at low temperatures where the term is negligible, per Eq. (3), as has been done in previous studies [21, 41].
Methodology
We obtain and from RF power measurements in continuous-wave mode. We can then calculate from using Eq. (1) and the value calculated with CST. Since for the FRIB QWRs, we expect at 2 K for our case. This allows us to infer the BCS and residual terms of for different treatments. An example is shown in Figure 5: at 4.3 K (red), the BCS and residual terms both contribute to . At 2 K (blue), the BCS term is negligible, so the 2 K is approximately equal to the residual resistance . Hence the BCS term at 4.3 K can be inferred approximately by subtracting the measured at 2 K from the measured at 4.3 K (purple).
Figure 5. Inferring as a function of field: at 4.3 K (red), at 2 K (blue), and difference (purple). Results for several FRIB QWRs that underwent BCP + LTB are included.
In Figure 5, we plot the surface resistance as a function of the peak surface magnetic field ; is proportional to , but only represents one location in the cavity. In this sense, using represents the peak Ohmic losses per unit area on the cavity walls [5].
It is clear from Figure 2 that the biggest difference in at 4.3 K between unbaked and baked cavities is in the range of to 7 MV/m, which corresponds to a range of about 25 to 87 mT. This is within the so-called medium field range of 15 to 95 mT. The operating goal for FRIB QWRs is mT ( MV/m), and thus this medium field range is relevant for FRIB linac operation. Hence we will constrain our analysis to this medium field region when comparing differences in cavity preparation.
Measurements and Analysis
Low-field Measurements vs Temperature
Basic information about BCS and residual resistances can be obtained by measuring at constant field as the cavity is cooled from 4.3 K to 2 K. As the temperature decreases, the BCS term decreases until the residual term becomes dominant. An example is shown in Figure 6. Equation (2) and Equation (3) can be used to fit the experimental data and obtain , , and . The measurements are taken at a low field, typically MV/m ( mT) to minimize the field-dependent contribution to .
Figure 6. Measured surface resistance at low field as a function of for QWRs after BCP only (black) or BCP + LTB (red).
We see from Figure 6 that, at high temperatures such as 4.3 K, decreases after LTB; at low temperature, the values are
similar before and after LTB. Thus, at low fields, LTB decreases the BCS term, but not the residual term.
From fitting coefficients , and the final temperature, we can calculate the low-field value for the BCS resistance at 2 K, . Figure 7 shows the resulting , , and values. It is clear that the LTB cavities (red) tend to have lower than to BCP’ed cavities (black), with the latter showing more spread.
Figure 7. Histograms of (left), (middle), and (right) for cavities that underwent BCP/BCP + MTB and those that underwent BCP + 120° C baking.
We note that some extrinsic variables may impact the measured values and may contribute to the scatter seen in Figure 7. It was found that the seating of the indium gasket can affect [34]. Since this seating does not depend on temperature, imperfect RF contact can contribute to the . Re-torquing of the bottom flange is done before cooling down to mitigate creep in the indium, but there may be some cavity-to-cavity variation due to the joint. As mentioned above, another contribution to is the residual magnetostatic field, which may be trapped when the cavity transitions from normal conducting to superconducting. Additionally, all of the cold tests are done after helium jacketing and thus thermo-electric currents (discussed in § 3) can be generated, leading to flux trapping. There may be variations from one test to another, as we do not carefully control the cool-down rate near for QWR certification tests.
Measurements vs Field
Surface resistance data from a number of QWR cold tests were collected and surveyed; some results are shown in Figure 8. The improvement in high-field performance at 4.3 K with LTB (red circles, blue triangles) relative to BCP alone (black crosses) and BCP + MTB (orange squares) can be seen clearly. The values of at 4.3 K (Figure 8, bottom) are obtained by subtracting the values at 2 K from the values at 4.3 K data, as described above.
Figure 8. Measured surface resistance (top) and calculated (bottom) at 4.3 K as a function of peak surface magnetic field for several QWR tests.
Alternative Heat Treatments
At high field, the BCS resistance is on average 2 to 3 times lower in cavities that underwent BCP + LTB relative to BCP only. Additionally, we see that the BCP only cavities have more spread at high fields than cavities that underwent BCP + LTB. Some additional cases are included in Figure 8: we can see that the method of LTB does not affect the outcome, as the 2 furnace LTB cavities (blue triangles) fall soundly alongside the in-situ LTB cavities (red circles). This shows that the performance improvement is not affected by venting after furnace heat treatment. On the other hand, we see that BCP + MTB (orange squares) provides no improvement in , performing alongside the standard BCP’ed cavities (black crosses). From the consistency between in-situ LTB and furnace LTB, we can rule out the MTB result being due to a problem with the furnace treatment.
Thermal Feedback Model
When considering possible causes for the reduction in the BCS term with LTB for BCP’ed cavities, one candidate is the thermal feedback (TFB) model [14, 45, 46, 47, 48]. This model considers the impact on the due to heat transfer through the cavity walls and from the cavity wall to the liquid helium bath. The model predicts
where is the low-field value of the surface resistance, is the thermodynamic critical field ( mT), and is the slope defined for temperature as [14, 46]:
In this formulation, is dependent on the low-field BCS resistance , the thermal conductivity , the Kapitza thermal impedance , cavity wall thickness , and the superconducting energy gap , Boltzmann’s constant , and the steady-state helium bath temperature . In this formulation, we treat as a constant and should therefore be a linear function of .
Figure 9 shows as a function of the square of the normalized peak surface magnetic field for each of the cases. We can do a linear fit for each cavity and compare the fitted lines to the data. The average of the fitted lines for the BCP and BCP + LTB cases are included in Figure 9 and the fitted parameters are shown in Table 1. We note that the measured values tend to increase faster than expected for a linear dependence on .
Figure 9. Measured total surface resistance at 4.3 K as a function of . Dashed lines: linear fits to the TFB model for the two major groups.
| Preparation | [n] | |
| BCP/BCP+MTB | ||
| BCP+LTB |
Table 1. Fitted parameters for the TFB model: averages for the two major groups of FRIB QWRs.
It is clear that all unbaked and baked cavities have similar low-field surface resistance values (). We have already
demonstrated that LTB reduces the BCS contribution and increases the residual component. However, the sum of the low field components is similar for both cases. This is seen in the fitted values (Table 1) and histogram values of (Figure 7, right).
Discussion
Q-Slope Mitigation Mechanism
In Table 1, the slope decreases by 62% upon low-temperature baking. We now discuss the means by which the slope might be changed by LTB.
Leading Hypotheses
In the TFB model, there are two likely suspects: the bulk thermal conductivity and the Kapitza resistance. Per Eq. (5), the slope is proportional to the sum of the thermal impedance of the bulk niobium () and the Kapitza resistance . The thermal conductivity (with the thermal impedance being proportional to its inverse) of Nb can be changed by high-temperature processes such as annealing and degassing [49], but we do not expect a change due to LTB.
The Kapitza resistance is the thermal impedance at the liquid helium-niobium interface. A reduction in would lead to a decrease in [14]. However, if the improvement with LTB was due to a decrease in Kapitza resistance, we would expect no change in cavity performance after repeating light BCP on the inner surface of the cavity, since the outer surface (in contact with the helium bath during the cold test) is not etched.
Tests
Measurements to test the Kapitza Resistance Change hypothesis on a QWR via different surface preparation steps are shown in Figure 10. The performance is improved after each of the two LTB steps, but is worse when light BCP (20 m) is applied after the first LTB. The second LTB produces results consistent with the first LTB. This suggests that the improvement in slope from LTB is not associated with a reduction in the Kapitza resistance.
Figure 10. Calculated BCS resistance at 4.3 K as a function of after different surface preparation steps. The legend shows the steps preceding each cold test in chronological order.
Alternative Hypothesis
Though we have ruled out 2 likely suspects, the thermal conductivity and Kapitza resistance, we note that the TFB model stipulates that the slope is directly proportional to the low-field value of the BCS resistance [14, 45, 47], as seen in Eq. (5). This coefficient comes from the derivative of with respect to . We saw that LTB reduces , which should lead to a reduction in . Furthermore, this relationship may help to explain the deviation from linearity we see in Figure 9. Our initial assumption was that is constant, but as we increase the field amplitude, the cavity wall temperature increases due to the RF wall losses, which leads to an increase in . Thus, we expect an increase in at high field, which is qualitatively consistent with the measurements.
Mean Free Path
Our finding that LTB reduces the zero-field value of may be explained by the Mattis-Bardeen theory and the mean free path. The dependence of the BCS resistance on the mean free path of the normal electrons () is calculated by the SRIMP code [50]. Some results from SRIMP are shown in Figure 11. For
Figure 11. Low-field BCS resistance as a function of the mean free path of normal electrons predicted by SRIMP for an 80.5 MHz cavity at 4.3 K.
these calculations, the temperature, London penetration depth and the Cooper-pair coherence length are kept constant and only the electron mean free path is varied. The and values from Ciovati, Kneisel, and Myneni [14] were used. We see that, if we increase the mean free path starting with nm, the BCS resistance first decreases and then increases. Baking can allow diffusion of impurities from the surface into the near-surface region where the RF magnetic field penetrates from the inner surface of the cavity wall. This effect has been studied and documented for higher frequency cavities, but the role of specific contaminants is still under study [18, 51, 52, 53]. These impurities can reduce the electron mean free path, leading to reduced low-field BCS resistance and thus reduced slope at 4.3 K.
Conclusion
We have observed that a low-temperature bake-out (120 C for 48 hours) improves the high-field quality factor of low-frequency FRIB quarter-wave resonators at 4.3 K by lessening the -slope. In-situ baking after clean-room assembly and furnace low-temperature baking prior to high-pressure water rinsing produce similar results. The increase in at the design field by about a factor of 2 after LTB is consistent with studies of other low- QWRs such as those of ISAC-II and SPIRAL2.
On the other hand, we found that a medium-temperature bake ( C for 3 hours) does not improve the quality factor at 4.3 K. This is consistent with low-frequency results from TRIUMF’s multi-mode coaxial cavity studies. Cycles of baking and light etching indicate that the improvement from the low-temperature baking is not due to changes in the Kapitza thermal resistance. The improvement with baking is shown to be a result of reduced BCS resistance, which can be explained as a decrease in the mean free path in the framework of the Mattis-Bardeen theory.
Acknowledgments
This material is based upon work supported by the U.S Department of Energy, Office of Science (DOE-SC), Office of Nuclear Physics and used resources of the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams Operations, which is a DOE-SC User Facility, under Award Number DE-SC0023633. Additional support was provided by DOE-SC, Office of High Energy Physics, under Award Number DE-SC0018362.
References
- [1]J. Wei, et al., Accelerator commissioning and rare isotope identification at the Facility for Rare Isotope Beams, Mod. Phys. Lett. A 37 (2022) 2230006. doi:10.1142/S0217732322300063.DOI
- [2]J. Wei, et al., FRIB transition to user operations, power ramp up, and upgrade perspectives, in: Proc. SRF 2023: 21st Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, Grand Rapids, MI, USA, JACoW, 2023, pp. 1–8. doi:10.18429/JACoW-SRF2023-MOIAA01.
- [3]T. Xu, et al., Progress of FRIB SRF production, in: Proc. SRF 2017: 18th Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, Lanzhou, China, JACoW, 2017, pp. 345–352. doi:10.18429/JACoW-SRF2017-TUXAA03.DOI
- [4]U. Becker, CST’s commercial beam-physics codes, 2006. URL: https://jacow.org/icap06/TALKS/THM2IS03_TALK.PDF, presented at ICAP 2006: 9th Int. Computational Accelerator Physics Conference, Chamonix Mont-Blanc, France, Talk THM2IS03.
- [5]H. Padamsee, J. Knobloch, T. Hays, RF Superconductivity for Accelerators, 2nd ed., Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, 2008.
- [6]J. Graber, C. Crawford, J. Kirchgessner, H. Padamsee, D. Rubin, P. Schmuesser, Reduction of field emission in superconducting cavities with high power pulsed RF, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 350 (1994) 572–581. doi:10.1016/0168-9002(94)91260-2.DOI
- [7]H. Padamsee, The science and technology of superconducting cavities for accelerators, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 14 (2001) R28. doi:10.1088/0953-2048/14/4/202.DOI
- [8]K. W. Shepard, C. H. Scheibelhut, R. Benaroya, L. M. Bollinger, Split ring resonator for the Argonne superconducting heavy ion booster, IEEE Trans. Nucl. Sci. 24 (1977) 1147–1149. doi:10.1109/TNS.1977.4328877.DOI
- [9]T. Furuya, Preparation and handling of superconducting RF cavities, in: Proc. SRF 1989: 4th Workshop RF Supercond., Tsukuba, Japan, JACoW, 1989, pp. 305–327. URL: https://www.jacow.org/proceedings/SRF89/papers/srf89d02.pdf.
- [10]H. Tian, S. Corcoran, C. E. Reece, M. J. Kelley, The mechanism of electropolishing of niobium in hydrofluoric-sulfuric acid electrolyte, J. Electrochem. Soc. 155 (2008) D563. doi:10.1149/1.2945913.
- [11]M. Kelly, T. Reid, Surface processing for bulk niobium SRF cavities, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 30 (2017) 043001. doi:10.1088/1361-6668/aa569a.
- [12]L. Zhao, C. Reece, M. Kelley, Genesis of topography in buffered chemical polishing of niobium for application to superconducting radio-frequency accelerator cavities, in: Proc. SRF 2017: 18th Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, Lanzhou, China, JACoW, 2017, pp. 651–654. doi:10.18429/JACoW-SRF2017-TUPB108.DOI
- [13]P. Kneisel, Preliminary experience with “in-situ” baking of niobium cavities, in: Proc. SRF 1999: 9th Int. Workshop RF Superconductivity, Santa Fe, NM, USA, JACoW, 1999, pp. 328–335. URL: https://jacow.org/SRF99/papers/TUP044.pdf.
- [14]G. Ciovati, Effect of low-temperature baking on the radio-frequency properties of niobium superconducting cavities for particle accelerators, J. Appl. Phys. 96 (2004) 1591–1600. doi:10.1063/1.1767295.DOI
- [15]G. Ciovati, G. Myneni, F. Stevie, P. Maheshwari, D. Griffis, High field Q slope and the baking effect: Review of recent experimental results and new data on Nb heat treatments, Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 13 (2010) 022002. doi:10.1103/PhysRevSTAB.13.022002.DOI
- [16]N. Phinney, ILC reference design report: Accelerator executive summary, ICFA Beam Dyn. Newslett. 42 (2007) 7–29.
- [17]R. Abela, et al., XFEL: The European X-Ray Free-Electron Laser. Technical design report, Technical Report DESY-06-097, DESY, 2006. doi:10.3204/DESY_06-097.DOI
- [18]A. Grassellino, A. Romanenko, D. Sergatskov, O. Melnychuk, Y. Trenikhim, A. Crawford, A. Rowe, M. Wong, T. Khabiboulline, F. Barkov, Nitrogen and argon doping of niobium for superconducting radio frequency cavities: a pathway to highly efficient accelerating structures, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 26 (2013) 102001. doi:10.1088/0953-2048/26/10/102001.DOI
- [19]P. Dhakal, S. Chetri, S. Balachandran, P. J. Lee, G. Ciovati, Effect of low temperature baking in nitrogen on the performance of a niobium superconducting radio frequency cavity, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 21 (2018) 032001. doi:10.1103/PhysRevAccelBeams.21.032001.DOI
- [20]P. Dhakal, Nitrogen doping and infusion in SRF cavities: A review, Physics Open 5 (2020) 100034. doi:10.1016/j.jphys.2020.100034.arxiv.org/abs/2005.03149
- [21]M. Martinello, M. Checchin, A. Romanenko, A. Grassellino, S. Aderhold, S. K. Chandrasekaran, O. Melnychuk, S. Posen, D. A. Sergatskov, Field-enhanced superconductivity in high-frequency niobium accelerating cavities, Phys. Rev. Lett. 121 (2018) 224801. doi:10.1103/PhysRevLett.121.224801.DOI
- [22]K. McGee, S. Kim, K. Elliott, A. Ganshyn, W. Hartung, P. Ostroumov, A. Taylor, T. Xu, M. Martinello, G. Eremeev, A. Netepenko, F. Furuta, O. Melnychuk, M. Kelly, B. Guilfoyle, T. Reid, Advanced surface treatments for medium-velocity superconducting cavities for high-accelerating gradient continuous-wave operation, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 1059 (2024) 168985. doi:10.1016/j.nima.2023.168985.DOI
- [23]S. Posen, A. Romanenko, A. Grassellino, O. Melnychuk, D. Sergatskov, Ultralow surface resistance via vacuum heat treatment of superconducting radio-frequency cavities, Phys. Rev. Appl. 13 (2020) 014024. doi:10.1103/PhysRevApplied.13.014024.DOI
- [24]H. Ito, H. Arakio, K. Takahashio, K. Umemorio, Systematic investigation of mid-T furnace baking for high-Q performance, in: Proc. SRF 2021: 20th Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, JACoW, 2021, pp. 881–884. doi:10.18429/JACoW-SRF2021-FROFDV01.
- [25]F. He, W. Pan, P. Sha, J. Zhai, Z. Mi, X. Dai, S. Jin, Z. Zhang, C. Dong, B. Liu, H. Zhao, R. Ge, J. Zhao, Z. Mu, L. Du, L. Sun, L. Zhang, C. Yang, X. Zhang, Medium-temperature furnace baking of 1.3 GHz 9-cell superconducting cavities at IHEP, Supercond. Sci. Technol. 34 (2021) 095005. doi:10.1088/1361-6668/ac1657.DOI
- [26]Z. Yang, J. Hao, S. Quan, L. Lin, F. Wang, F. Jiao, K. Liu, Effective medium temperature baking of 1.3 GHz single cell SRF cavities, Physica C 599 (2022) 1354092. doi:10.1016/j.physc.2022.1354092.DOI
- [27]G. Wu, S. K. Chandrasekaran, V. Chouhan, G. Eremeev, F. Furuta, K. McGee, A. Murthy, A. Netepenko, J. Ozelis, H. Park, S. Posen, Medium temperature furnace baking of low-beta 650 MHz five-cell cavities, in: Proc. SRF 2023: 21st Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, Grand Rapids, MI, USA, JACoW, 2023, pp. 158–161. doi:10.18429/JACoW-SRF2023-MOPMB030.DOI
- [28]D. Longuevergne, Etude et test d’un module accélérateur supraconducteur pour le projet SPIRAL2, Ph.D. thesis, Université Paris Sud - Paris XI, 2009. URL: https://theses.hal.science/tel-00448271.
- [29]C. Marchand, P.-E. Bernaudin, P. Bosland, G. Devanz, R. Ferdinand, Y. Gómez Martínez, D. Longuevergne, G. Olry, O. Piquet, Performances of SPIRAL2 low and high beta cryomodules, in: Proc. SRF 2015: Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, Whistler, BC, Canada, JACoW, 2015, pp. 967–972. URL: https://accelconf.web.cern.ch/SRF2015/papers/weba04.pdf.DOI
- [30]D. Longuevergne, Review of heat treatments for low beta cavities: What’s so different from elliptical cavities, in: Proc. SRF 2017: 18th Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, Lanzhou, China, JACoW, 2017, pp. 708–714. doi:10.18429/JACoW-SRF2017-THXA08.DOI
- [31]Z. Y. Yao, P. Kolb, R. E. Laxdal, Medium field Q-slope in low beta resonators, 2015. URL: https://accelconf.web.cern.ch/SRF2015/talks/wea1a03_talk.pdf, presented at SRF 2015: Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, Whistler, BC, Canada, WEA1A03.
- [32]P. Kolb, Z. Yao, T. Junginger, B. Dury, A. Fothergill, M. Vanderbanck, R. Laxdal, Coaxial multimode cavities for fundamental superconducting rf research in an unprecedented parameter space, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 23 (2020) 122001. doi:10.1103/PhysRevAccelBeams.23.122001.DOI
- [33]P. Kolb, Z. Yao, A. Blackburn, R. Blackburn, D. Hedji, M. McMullin, T. McMullin, R. Laxdal, Mid-T heat treatments on BCP’ed coaxial cavities at TRIUMF, Front. Electron. Mater. 3 (2023) 1244126. doi:10.3389/femat.2023.1244126.
- [34]C. Zhang, W. Hartung, J. Popielarski, K. Saito, S. Kim, W. Chang, T. Xu, Certification testing of production superconducting quarter-wave and half-wave resonators for FRIB, Nucl. Instrum. Methods Phys. Res. A 1014 (2021) 165675. doi:10.1016/j.nima.2021.165675.DOI
- [35]L. Popielarski, F. Casagrande, C. Compton, T. Elkin, A. Fila, P. Gibson, M. Leitner, I. Malloch, C. Nguyen, R. Oweiss, J. Ozelis, J. Popielarski, C. Thornson, D. Victory, T. Xu, SRF highbay technical infrastructure for FRIB production at Michigan State University, in: Proc. Linac 2014: 27th Int. Linear Accel. Conf., Geneva, Switzerland, JACoW, 2014, pp. 954–956. URL: https://jacow.org/LINAC2014/papers/THPP046.pdf.
- [36]L. Popielarski, C. Compton, L. Dubbs, K. Elliot, A. Facco, L. Harle, I. Malloch, R. Oweiss, J. Ozelis, J. Popielarski, K. Saito, Process developments for superconducting RF low beta resonators for the ReA3 linac and Facility for Rare Isotope Beams, in: Proc. Linac 2012: 26th Int. Linear Accel. Conf., Tel Aviv, Israel, JACoW, 2012, pp. 342–344. URL: https://jacow.org/LINAC2012/papers/MOPB071.pdf.
- [37]E. Metzgar, B. Barker, K. Elliot, J. Hulbert, C. Knowles, L. Nguyen, A. Nunham, L. Popielarski, A. Taylor, T. Xu, Summary of the FRIB electropolishing facility design and commissioning, cavity processing, and cavity test results, in: Proc. SRF 2023: 21st Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, Grand Rapids, MI, USA, JACoW, 2023, pp. 419–424. doi:10.18429/JACoW-SRF2023-TUPTB016.DOI
- [38]K. Saito, C. Compton, W. Chang, K. Elliot, T. Konomi, S.-H. Kim, W. Hartung, E. Metzgar, S. Miller, L. Popielarski, A. Taylor, T. Xu, Development of transformative cavity processing—superiority of electropolishing on high gradient performance over buffered chemical polishing at low frequency (322 MHz), in: Proc. SRF 2023: 21st Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, Grand Rapids, MI, USA, JACoW, 2023, pp. 145–150. doi:10.18429/JACoW-SRF2023-MOPMB026.DOI
- [39]K. McGee, S. Kim, K. Elliott, A. Ganshyn, W. Hartung, E. Metzgar, P. Ostroumov, L. Popielarski, J. Popielarski, A. Taylor, T. Xu, M. P. Kelly, B. Guilfoyle, T. Reid, Medium-velocity superconducting cavity for high accelerating gradient continuous-wave hadron linear accelerators, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 24 (2021) 112003. doi:10.1103/PhysRevAccelBeams.24.112003.DOI
- [40]C. Vallet, M. Boloré, B. Bonin, J. P. Charrier, B. Daillant, J. Gratadour, F. Koechlin, H. Safa, Flux trapping in superconducting cavities, in: Proc. EPAC 1992: 3rd European Part. Accel. Conf., Berlin, Germany, JACoW, 1992, pp. 1295–1298. URL: https://www.jacow.org/proceedings/e92/PDF/EPAC1992_1295.PDF.
- [41]A. Romanenko, A. Grassellino, O. Melnychuk, D. A. Sergatskov, Dependence of the residual surface resistance of superconducting radio frequency cavities on the cooling dynamics around T_c, J. Appl. Phys. 115 (2014) 184903. doi:10.1063/1.4875655.DOI
- [42]D. Gonnella, J. Kaufman, P. Koufalis, M. Liepe, RF losses from trapped flux in SRF cavities, in: Proc. IPAC 2016: 7th Int. Part. Accel. Conf., Busan, Korea, JACoW, 2016, pp. 2327–2330. doi:10.18429/JACoW-IPAC2016-WEPMR026.DOI
- [43]O. Kugeler, A. Neumann, S. Voronенко, W. Anders, J. Knobloch, M. Schuster, A. Frahm, S. Klauke, D. Pflückhahn, S. Rotterdam, Manipulating the intrinsic quality factor by thermal cycling and magnetic fields, in: Proc. SRF 2009: 14th Int. Conf. RF Supercond., Berlin, Germany, JACoW, 2009, pp. 352–354. URL: https://jacow.org/SRF2009/papers/TUPP0053.pdf.
- [44]J.-M. Vogt, O. Kugeler, J. Knobloch, Impact of cool-down conditions at T_c on the superconducting rf cavity quality factor, Phys. Rev. ST Accel. Beams 16 (2013) 102002. doi:10.1103/PhysRevSTAB.16.102002.DOI
- [45]J. Halbritter, RF residual losses, high electric and magnetic RF fields in superconducting cavities, in: Proc. 38th Workshop INFN Eloisatron Project, Erice, Italy, 1999, pp. 59–79.
- [46]J. Vines, Y. Xie, H. Padamsee, Systematic trends for the medium field Q-slope, in: Proc. SRF 2007: 13th Int. Workshop RF Superconductivity, Beijing, China, JA-CoW, 2007, pp. 178–191. URL: https://jacow.org/srf2007/papers/TUP27.pdf.
- [47]H. Padamsee, RF Superconductivity: Science, Technology, and Applications, Wiley-VCH Verlag GmbH, 2009.DOI
- [48]M. McMullin, P. Kolb, Z. Yao, R. Laxdal, T. Junginger, Thermal feedback in coaxial superconducting radio frequency cavities, Phys. Rev. Accel. Beams 27 (2024) 092001. doi:10.1103/PhysRevAccelBeams.27.092001.DOI
- [49]M. Fouaidy, Thermal conductivity of niobium and thermally sprayed copper at cryogenic temperature, IOP Conf. Ser.: Mater. Sci. Eng. 1241 (2022) 012012. doi:10.1088/1757-899X/1241/1/012012.DOI
- [50]J. Halbritter, FORTRAN-Program for the Computation of the Surface Impedance of Superconductors, Technical Report, Institut für Experimentelle Kernphysik, Kernforschungszentrum Karlsruhe, Karlsruhe, West Germany, 1970. URL: https://www.osti.gov/biblio/4102575.DOI
- [51]M. Martinello, A. Grassellino, M. Checchin, A. Romanenko, O. Melnychuk, D. Sergatskov, S. Posen, J. Zasadzinski, Effect of interstitial impurities on the field dependent microwave surface resistance of niobium, Appl. Phys. Lett. 109 (2016) 026201. doi:10.1063/1.4960801.
- [52]D. Bafia, A. Grassellino, A. Romanenko, The role of oxygen concentration in enabling high gradients in niobium SRF cavities, in: Proc. SRF 2021: 20th Int. Conf. RF Superconductivity, JACoW, 2022, pp. 871–875. doi:10.18429/JACoW-SRF2021-THPTEV016.DOI
- [53]H. Hu, D. Bafia, Y. Kim, Decoupling of nitrogen and oxygen impurities in nitrogen doped SRF cavities, in: Proc. IPAC 2024: 15th Int. Part. Accel. Conf., Nashville, TN, USA, JACoW, 2024, pp. 2825–2828. doi:10.18429/JACoW-IPAC2024-WEPS58.