betaFeedback

WorksPhysics and Astronomy

Optimized Bragg Grating Liquid Crystal Solar Sail

Abstract

We have designed a thin 3-layer sun-facing diffractive Bragg reflector comprised of a chiral polymeric liquid crystal film. Using Rigorous Coupled-Wave Analysis (RCWA), the stack was optimized to maximize the transverse radiation pressure force across the wavelength band 0.47 - 1.67 micrometers. The optimized structure operates on a single polarization state of light. A two structure stack, each operating on a different state of polarization, is predicted to provide a transverse momentum transfer efficiency of 51%. This study demonstrates how a wavelength selective Bragg grating may be used both as a sunshade to scatter sunlight away from the Earth, and as a solar sail for maintaining a prescribed orbit (such as the Earth-Sun L1 point) owing to the momentum transfer efficiency.

Introduction

Solar radiation pressure has been a subject of interest since the early work of Kepler in 1619, who proposed it as an explanation for comet tails [1]. With the development of electromagnetic theory, it was established that light carries momentum and can exert pressure on matter, forming the physical basis of solar sailing. Unlike conventional propulsion systems, solar sails require no onboard propellant, relying instead on the continuous momentum transfer of scattered light which affords continuous acceleration and high ΔV\Delta V missions [2, 3, 4, 5]. Harnessing solar radiation pressure for in-space propulsion remains a highly active area of research [6]. Conventional mirrored reflective solar sails generate radiation pressure primarily normal to the surface, thereby requiring tilting away from the sun to achieve a significant component of force transverse to the sun line. When simultaneously used as a sunshade, a tilted mirrored sail decreases the amount of insolation. What is more, navigation by tilting a large area sail can impose structural and control difficulties. Diffractive solar sails have emerged as a promising alternative in which propulsion is achieved through engineered diffraction rather than specular reflection [7, 8, 9].

As illustrated in Figure 1, by scattering light via Bragg reflection, these thin films can generate significant transverse radiation pressure force FxF_x while maintaining a sun-facing orientation. Bragg gratings (also called tilted volume hologram) achieve extraordinarily large diffraction efficiencies over a modest wavelength bandwidth owing to simultaneously satisfying both the grating equation, the law of reflection from tilted periodically modulated refractive index structures, and constructive interference of reflected waves. The Pancharatnam phase [10] in anisotropic materials such as cholesteric liquid crystal polymers affords large refractive index modulations that self-align [11, 12]. Other methods of scattering light from a sun-facing film include metallic-coated diffraction gratings and hybrid reflection/transmission designs [13, 14]. However, liquid-crystal-based diffractive optics are particularly promising owing to their thin, robust yet flexible properties as well as scalable manufacturability [15, 16].

A sun-facing polarization Bragg grating solar sail

Figure 1. A sun-facing polarization Bragg grating solar sail having incident wave vectors k⃗i\vec{k}_i (for one polarization state) reflects wavelengths near the Bragg condition (k⃗r\vec{k}_r) and transmits others (k⃗t\vec{k}_t), resulting in a net radiation pressure force F⃗\vec{F}. The transverse component FxF_x is primarily important for navigation in a solar orbit. The periodic structure is characterized by the Bragg period ΛB\Lambda_B, and resulting transverse and longitudinal periods Λx\Lambda_x and Λz\Lambda_z, respectively. The structure has a thickness L>ΛzL > \Lambda_z. The reflection scattering angle θr\theta_r satisfies the grating equation ∣sin⁡θr∣=λ/Λx\lvert\sin\theta_r\rvert= \lambda/\Lambda_x.

Polarization gratings and polarization volume gratings provide engineering latitude for controlling light [17, 18, 19, 20, 21]. In particular, polarization volume gratings (PVGs) can achieve near-unity diffraction efficiency and large diffraction angles under Bragg conditions [22], while advanced diffractive waveplate designs allow polarization-independent operation and enhanced control of diffraction behavior [23]. Bragg polarization gratings have also been demonstrated to provide high efficiency over wide angular bandwidths, making them attractive for high-performance optical redirection systems [24].

Accurate modeling of these complex periodic and anisotropic structures requires rigorous electromagnetic methods. Rigorous coupled-wave analysis (RCWA) provides an efficient and exact framework for solving diffraction from periodic gratings, including anisotropic and multilayer configurations [25]. Extensions of RCWA to liquid crystal polarization gratings enable detailed analysis of diffraction efficiency, polarization response, and transitions between Raman–Nath and Bragg regimes [26]. Combined with transfer-matrix approaches for birefringent media [27, 28], these methods provide essential tools for designing and optimizing high-efficiency diffractive optical systems.

In this work, we investigate a multilayer diffractive solar sail based on Bragg reflection using chiral liquid crystal structures. The proposed design employs stacked birefringent layers to achieve broadband spectral coverage while maximizing transverse momentum transfer efficiency. By combining polarization grating concepts with Bragg-type multilayer architectures, the structure enables efficient light redirection without requiring mechanical tilting. We determine diffraction efficiencies using the RCWA method for an anisotropic material, and then calculate the radiation pressure force expected from a solar blackbody. Our results demonstrate that optimized multilayer liquid crystal diffractive structures can achieve high transverse radiation pressure while maintaining a Sun-facing orientation, offering a promising pathway toward advanced solar sail propulsion systems that can also function as wavelength selective sunshades.

Theoretical Framework and Methodology

The Bragg Condition

The fundamental structure of a Bragg grating is illustrated in Figure 2 which shows titled lines of modulated refractive index at the angle ϕ\phi with respect to the incident surface normal. For convenience we depict the grating embedded in an index matched homogeneous medium having refractive index neffn_{\mathrm{eff}}. According to Snell’s law, a ray refracts from the angle θin′\theta_{\mathrm{in}}' in vacuum to the angle θin\theta_{\mathrm{in}} in the matched medium (i.e., sin⁡θin′=neffsin⁡θin\sin\theta_{\mathrm{in}}' = n_{\mathrm{eff}} \sin\theta_{\mathrm{in}}). Owing to the periodicity of the grating one may expect multiple diffraction orders mm to be reflected and transmitted. The m=0m = 0 modes correspond to reflection and transmission of an unmodulated structure. The m=−1m = -1 reflection order corresponds to the law of reflection from the tilted modulation lines. When such reflections constructively add, the net reflected electric field approaches that of the incident field. That net electric field refracts back into the vacuum at the angle θ−1,r\theta_{-1,r}, θ−1,r′\theta_{-1,r}'. As described below the transverse momentum transfer efficiency approaches 100% when both the reflection into the vacuum approaches 100% and ∣θ−1,r∣\lvert\theta_{-1,r}\rvert approaches 90∘90^\circ. To optimize these two parameters for sunlight the grating must account for the momentum (or energy) irradiance distribution of the incident light. Below we assume a blackbody distribution.

Modulated refractive index structure and diffraction orders

Figure 2. Modulated refractive index structure, tilted at the angle ϕ\phi, embedded into an index-matched host material (gray). Incident sunlight at angle θin′\theta_{\mathrm{in}}' is refracted into the host at θin\theta_{\mathrm{in}} and scattered into reflected and transmitted diffraction orders. Those orders refract back into the vacuum.

The Bragg condition relates the modulation period ΛB\Lambda_B with the slant angle ϕ\phi, design wavelength λb\lambda_b, incidence angle θ\theta, and, refractive index neffn_{\mathrm{eff}}:

ΛB=λb2⋅neff⋅cos⁡(ϕ+θin)(1)\Lambda_B = \frac{\lambda_b}{2 \cdot n_{\mathrm{eff}} \cdot\cos(\phi+ \theta_{\mathrm{in}})} \tag*{(1)}

For a uniaxial liquid crystal the effective refractive index is given by

neff=ne2+2no23(2)n_{\mathrm{eff}} = \sqrt{\frac{n_e^2 + 2n_o^2}{3}} \tag*{(2)}

where non_o and nen_e are respectively the ordinary and extraordinary refractive indexes of the liquid crystal [23]. The grating wave vector of magnitude KB=2π/ΛBK_B = 2\pi/\Lambda_B may be expressed as components of magnitude 2π/Λx2\pi/\Lambda_x and 2π/Λz2\pi/\Lambda_z, resulting in respective transverse and longitudinal periods Λx=ΛB/sin⁡ϕ\Lambda_x = \Lambda_B/\sin\phi and Λz=ΛB/cos⁡ϕ\Lambda_z = \Lambda_B/\cos\phi.

Solar Blackbody Irradiance Frequency Distribution

The transverse radiation pressure force exerted on a solar sail may be optimized by accounting for the peak of the solar frequency distribution, which may be estimated by the blackbody irradiance IνI_\nu at the temperature T=5778T = 5778 K, which according to Planck’s law may be expressed at a distance rr from the Sun:

Iν=(RSr)22πhν3c21ehν/(kBT)−1(3)I_\nu= \left(\frac{R_S}{r}\right)^2 \frac{2\pi h\nu^3}{c^2} \frac{1}{e^{h\nu/(k_B T)} - 1} \tag*{(3)}

where ν=c/λ\nu= c/\lambda is the optical frequency, cc is the speed of light, hh is the Planck constant, kBk_B is the Boltzmann constant, and RSR_S is the radius of the Sun. The peak of this distribution occurs at νpeak=340\nu_{\mathrm{peak}} = 340 THz. Note: the corresponding wavelength λpeak=883\lambda_{\mathrm{peak}} = 883 nm differs from the peak of the wavelength-dependent distribution (502 nm) because dν=−(c/λ2)dλd\nu= -(c/\lambda^2)d\lambda. An optimized Bragg solar sail should therefore be optimized in the vicinity of λb=883\lambda_b = 883 nm, or equivalently νb=c/λb=340\nu_b = c/\lambda_b = 340 THz. As described below, multiple Bragg gratings may be stacked, with each optimized at a different region of the blackbody spectrum. Such stacking can be achieved simply by changing the tilt angle ϕ\phi and the design wavelength λb\lambda_b for each layer, or by continuously chirping the structure. To demonstrate underlying principles, the former procedure is adopted in this report by use of three stacked Bragg gratings, each comprised of the same material. For numerical stability our optimization range covers 180 to 640 THz (or equivalently 1.67 to 0.47 μ\mum), encompassing 69.6% of the total blackbody energy flux of Isun=1367I_{\mathrm{sun}} = 1367 W/m2^2.

at 1 AU from the sun. The momentum transfer efficiency of the sail may be benchmarked using either the irradiance per polarization, (1/2)Isun=683.5(1/2)I_{\mathrm{sun}} = 683.5 W/m2^{2} or the full solar constant, IsunI_{\mathrm{sun}}.

RCWA Modeling and Momentum Transfer

A common numerical method of solving for optical diffraction from a periodic structure is Rigorous Coupled-Wave Analysis (RCWA) [25]. In our case the structure is comprised of a chiral liquid crystal polymer which has advantages such as high index contrast (birefringence), flexible mechanical properties, and ease of large area fabrication. Each polarization state diffracts independently of the other. For example, a well designed grating diffracts right hand circularly polarized light (RHCP) when the Bragg condition is satisfied, but the left circularly polarized state remains unaffected. Various methods may be used to diffract both polarization states, but this is beyond the scope of this report.

For a given incident frequency of a given circular polarization state, CP, the RCWA code outputs reflection and transmission values at diffraction orders mm, Rν,m(CP)R_{\nu,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})} and Tν,m(CP)T_{\nu,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})}, respectively. This allows the determination of the reflected and transmitted spectral irradiance values Iν,r,m(CP)=12Rν,m(CP)IνI_{\nu,r,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})} = \frac{1}{2}R_{\nu,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})} I_\nu and Iν,t,m(CP)=12Tν,m(CP)IνI_{\nu,t,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})} = \frac{1}{2}T_{\nu,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})} I_\nu, respectively.

Momentum Transfer Efficiency

The grating equation provides the diffracted scattering angles within the host material:

sin⁡θm=sin⁡θin−mλneffΛx(4)\sin\theta_m = \sin\theta_{\mathrm{in}} - \frac{m\lambda}{n_{\mathrm{eff}}\Lambda_x} \tag*{(4)}

Applying Snell’s law, the diffracted scattering angles in vacuum are given by

sin⁡θm′=neffsin⁡θm=sin⁡θin′−mλΛx(5)\sin\theta'_m = n_{\mathrm{eff}}\sin\theta_m = \sin\theta'_{\mathrm{in}} - \frac{m\lambda}{\Lambda_x} \tag*{(5)}

Care must be taken for the angle definitions when multiple gratings are stacked. For example, the output angle from one layer becomes the incident angle for the next layer.

The momentum transfer efficiency distribution across frequency may be expressed for the reflection and transmission modes

η⃗(CP)(ν)=∑mIν,r,m(CP)(k⃗in′−k⃗m′(r))I(ν)k′+∑mIν,t,m(CP)(k⃗in′−k⃗m′(t))I(ν)k′=∑m12Rν,m(CP)k⃗in′−k⃗m′(r)k′+∑m12Tν,m(CP)k⃗in′−k⃗m′(t)k′(6)\begin{aligned} \vec{\eta}^{(\mathrm{CP})}(\nu) &= \sum_m \frac{I_{\nu,r,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})}\left(\vec{k}'_{\mathrm{in}}-\vec{k}'_m{}^{(r)}\right)}{I(\nu)k'} + \sum_m \frac{I_{\nu,t,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})}\left(\vec{k}'_{\mathrm{in}}-\vec{k}'_m{}^{(t)}\right)}{I(\nu)k'} \\ &= \sum_m \frac{1}{2}R_{\nu,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})}\frac{\vec{k}'_{\mathrm{in}}-\vec{k}'_m{}^{(r)}}{k'} + \sum_m \frac{1}{2}T_{\nu,m}^{(\mathrm{CP})}\frac{\vec{k}'_{\mathrm{in}}-\vec{k}'_m{}^{(t)}}{k'} \tag*{(6)} \end{aligned}

where k⃗in′\vec{k}^{\prime}_{\mathrm{in}} is the incident wave vector measured in vacuum, k⃗m′(r,t)\vec{k}^{\prime(r,t)}_{m} is the mthm^{\mathrm{th}} order scattered wave vector measured in vacuum, and k′=∣k⃗in′∣=∣k⃗m′(r,t)∣=2π/λk' = \lvert\vec{k}'_{\mathrm{in}}\rvert= \lvert\vec{k}^{\prime(r,t)}_{m}\rvert= 2\pi/\lambda is the magnitude of the wave vectors in vacuum, where λ=c/ν\lambda= c/\nu is the vacuum wavelength. The summations in (6) apply only over the orders satisfying the cut-off condition

∣sin⁡θin′−mλ/Λx∣<1(7)\left\lvert\sin\theta'_{\mathrm{in}}-m\lambda/\Lambda_x\right\rvert< 1 \tag*{(7)}

The wave vectors may be decomposed into transverse and longitudinal components:

k⃗in′=k′(sin⁡θin′ x^+cos⁡θin′ z^)(8)\vec{k}'_{\mathrm{in}}=k'\left(\sin\theta'_{\mathrm{in}}\,\hat{x}+\cos\theta'_{\mathrm{in}}\,\hat{z}\right) \tag*{(8)}
k⃗m′(r)=k′(sin⁡θm′ x^−cos⁡θm′ z^)(9)\vec{k}^{\prime(r)}_{m}=k'\left(\sin\theta'_{m}\,\hat{x}-\cos\theta'_{m}\,\hat{z}\right) \tag*{(9)}
k⃗m′(t)=k′(sin⁡θm′ x^+cos⁡θm′ z^)(10)\vec{k}^{\prime(t)}_{m}=k'\left(\sin\theta'_{m}\,\hat{x}+\cos\theta'_{m}\,\hat{z}\right) \tag*{(10)}

where cos⁡θm′=1−sin⁡2θm′\cos\theta'_{m}=\sqrt{1-\sin^2\theta'_{m}} and cos⁡θin′=1−sin⁡2θin′\cos\theta'_{\mathrm{in}}=\sqrt{1-\sin^2\theta'_{\mathrm{in}}}. The transverse and longitudinal efficiency distributions may then be expressed (for a sail operating on a single polarization of unpolarized light)

ηx(CP)(ν)=∑m12Rν,m(CP)(sin⁡θin′−sin⁡θm′)+∑m12Tν,m(CP)(sin⁡θin′−sin⁡θm′)(11)\eta^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{x}(\nu)=\sum_m\frac{1}{2}R^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{\nu,m}\left(\sin\theta'_{\mathrm{in}}-\sin\theta'_{m}\right)+\sum_m\frac{1}{2}T^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{\nu,m}\left(\sin\theta'_{\mathrm{in}}-\sin\theta'_{m}\right) \tag*{(11)}
ηz(CP)(ν)=∑m12Rν,m(CP)(cos⁡θin′+cos⁡θm′)+∑m12Tν,m(CP)(cos⁡θin′−cos⁡θm′)(12)\eta^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{z}(\nu)=\sum_m\frac{1}{2}R^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{\nu,m}\left(\cos\theta'_{\mathrm{in}}+\cos\theta'_{m}\right)+\sum_m\frac{1}{2}T^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{\nu,m}\left(\cos\theta'_{\mathrm{in}}-\cos\theta'_{m}\right) \tag*{(12)}

Finally we integrate to obtain the net momentum transfer across a band of frequencies from νmin⁡\nu_{\min} to νmax⁡\nu_{\max}:

ηˉx(CP)=∫νmin⁡νmax⁡I(ν) ηx(CP)(ν) dν/Isun(13)\bar{\eta}^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{x}=\int_{\nu_{\min}}^{\nu_{\max}} I(\nu)\,\eta^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{x}(\nu)\,\mathrm{d}\nu\mathbin{/}I_{\mathrm{sun}} \tag*{(13)}
ηˉz(CP)=∫νmin⁡νmax⁡I(ν) ηz(CP)(ν) dν/Isun(14)\bar{\eta}^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{z}=\int_{\nu_{\min}}^{\nu_{\max}} I(\nu)\,\eta^{(\mathrm{CP})}_{z}(\nu)\,\mathrm{d}\nu\mathbin{/}I_{\mathrm{sun}} \tag*{(14)}

where Isun=∫0∞I(ν) dν=1367 W/m2I_{\mathrm{sun}}=\int_{0}^{\infty}I(\nu)\,\mathrm{d}\nu=1367\ \mathrm{W}/\mathrm{m}^{2}. In principle the frequency integration limits would be set to 0 and ∞\infty but numerical integration requires bounds. Hence we set νmin⁡=180 THz\nu_{\min}=180\ \mathrm{THz} and νmax⁡=640 THz\nu_{\max}=640\ \mathrm{THz}.

Optimization Strategy

To optimize Bragg diffraction for a given polarization state for the purpose of navigating in a solar orbit, e.g., a station keeping at the Earth-Sun L1 point, we seek the parameters such as ΛB\Lambda_B, ϕ\phi, and λb\lambda_b that produce the greatest component of force perpendicular to the sun line Fx=Isunnˉx(RCP)/cF_x = I_{\mathrm{sun}}\bar{n}_x^{(\mathrm{RCP})}/c. Here we have arbitrarily selected the right circularly polarized state (RCP).

Birefringence and Bandwidth

The bandwidth of Bragg reflection is known to increase with increasing birefringence Δn=∣ne−no∣\Delta n = \lvert n_e - n_o\rvert, as illustrated in Fig.s 3 and 4 for the case of normal incidence θin′=0\theta_{\mathrm{in}}^{\prime} = 0, with slant angle ϕ=17.5∘\phi= 17.5^\circ and Bragg period ΛB=296\Lambda_B = 296 nm (the Bragg wavelength λb\lambda_b and effective index neffn_{\mathrm{eff}} vary with birefringence). In this case we numerically obtain a linear relation through the origin: Δν=(220 THz)Δn\Delta\nu= (220\ \mathrm{THz})\Delta n. Below we assume a feasibly achievable birefringence [29] of Δn=0.5\Delta n = 0.5 with no=1.7n_o = 1.7 and ne=1.2n_e = 1.2 and neff=1.55n_{\mathrm{eff}} = 1.55. These and other refractive index parameters are listed in Table 1.

PropertyValue
Ordinary Index (non_o)1.7
Extraordinary Index (nen_e)1.2
Birefringence (Δn\Delta n)0.5
Effective Host Index (neff=nhostn_{\mathrm{eff}} = n_{\mathrm{host}})1.55
External Index (nvacuumn_{\mathrm{vacuum}})1.0

Table 1. Refractive indices used for the optical simulation and material modeling.

Frequency dependent Bragg reflection coefficient showing increasing bandwidth with increasing birefringence

Figure 3. Frequency dependent Bragg reflection coefficient Rν,−1(RCP)R_{\nu,-1}^{(\mathrm{RCP})} depicting increasing bandwidth with increasing birefringence Δn\Delta n.

Bandwidth as a function of birefringence

Figure 4. Full bandwidth Δν\Delta\nu at the Rν,−1(RCP)=0.5R_{\nu,-1}^{(RCP)} = 0.5 value assuming normal incidence, slant angle ϕ=17.5∘\phi= 17.5^\circ, and Bragg period ΛB=0.296μm\Lambda_B = 0.296\mu\mathrm{m}. A straight line fit (solid black line) provides Δν=(220THz)Δn\Delta\nu= (220\mathrm{THz})\Delta n.

Three-Layer Bragg Grating Stack

At Δn=0.5\Delta n = 0.5 the grating bandwidth of ∼115\sim115 THz is small in comparison to the ∼500\sim500 THz bandwidth of the solar spectrum, and thus, we propose stacking multiple Bragg gratings, each optimized for a different region of the solar spectrum. These bands may be placed adjacent to each other (as described below), or spectral gaps may be engineered to allow for the transmission of unscattered light (as may be desired for sunshades that affect neither photosynthesis nor photovoltaic power generation). The layers are arranged such that the incident solar flux interacts with the highest-frequency grating first, as depicted in Figure 5.

Three-layer Bragg grating stack

Figure 5. Three-layer Bragg grating stack. Layers 1 (blue) scatters short wavelength light. Layer 2 (green) and Layer 3 (orange) scatter mid and long wavelength light, respectively. Distances between layer is exaggerated to aid the eye.

We assume right circularly polarized light is normally incident upon Layer 1 (θin=0\theta_{\mathrm{in}} = 0), whereupon light is either primarily reflected into the m=−1m = -1 order, or transmitted into the m=0m = 0 order. The polarization is unchanged upon reflection and transmission. Layer 2 receives the transmitted field from Layer 1, with the dominant incident mode also at normal incidence upon Layer 2. Again light is either primarily reflected into the m=−1m = -1 order, or transmitted into the m=0m = 0 order. Light reflected from Layer 2 does not satisfy the Bragg condition of Layer 1, and thus it is assumed to pass through Layer 1 unimpeded.

A similar process occurs for Layer 3. The dominant reflected waves therefore refract into the vacuum at angles satisfying the grating equation for each each layer:

sin⁡θ−1′(j)=λ/Λx(j)(15)\sin\theta_{-1}^{\prime(j)} = \lambda/ \Lambda_x^{(j)} \tag*{(15)}

For example, if sin⁡ϕ(j)=17∘\sin\phi^{(j)} = 17^\circ for j=1,2,3j = 1, 2, 3, and Λx(j)=(0.69,0.98,1.45) μm\Lambda_x^{(j)} = (0.69, 0.98, 1.45)\,\mu\mathrm{m}, ΛB(j)=(0.201,0.296,0.437) μm\Lambda_B^{(j)} = (0.201, 0.296, 0.437)\,\mu\mathrm{m}, and λb(j)=(0.60,0.87,1.29) μm\lambda_b^{(j)} = (0.60, 0.87, 1.29)\,\mu\mathrm{m}, then at λ=λb(j)\lambda= \lambda_b^{(j)} we obtain θ−1=(60.5∘,62.5∘,62.9∘)\theta^{-1} = (60.5^\circ, 62.5^\circ, 62.9^\circ), which are significantly large scattering angles.

Optimization Algorithm

The sequential optical response of the cascaded layers introduces severe non-linearities and inter-layer electromagnetic coupling. Because the spectrum transmitted by Layer 1 dictates the incident field for Layer 2, traditional gradient-descent algorithms are highly susceptible to becoming trapped in local minima. With the birefringence for each layer constrained, the search space for the three-layer stack spans 9 continuous dimensions: the slant angles ϕ(j)\phi^{(j)}, the cutoff frequencies νc(j)=c/Λx(j)\nu_c^{(j)} = c/\Lambda_x^{(j)}, and the thicknesses L(j)L^{(j)}. The layer thicknesses are individually tailored to minimize the mass of the Bragg sail.

To robustly navigate the remaining parameter space, a Differential Evolution stochastic global optimization algorithm is employed. For a given parameter vector [ϕ1,νc1,ϕ2,νc2,ϕ3,νc3][\phi_1, \nu_{c1}, \phi_2, \nu_{c2}, \phi_3, \nu_{c3}], the objective function evaluates the negative of the total momentum transfer efficiency computed via the RCWA pipeline. By evaluating parallel populations and utilizing mutations and crossovers, the optimizer iteratively isolates the configuration that maximizes the efficiency.

The DE algorithm was configured with a population size of 40, 100 maximum iterations, and a spectral resolution of 500 frequency samples linearly spaced between 180 THz and 640 THz. To ensure full spectral coverage across the target bandwidth without excessive inter-layer redundancy, the frequency search bounds are deliberately staggered. Each of these parameters are tuned within the given search space as summarized in Table 2.

LayerSlant angle ϕ\phi boundsCutoff Frequency (νc\nu_c) boundsCutoff Wavelength (λc\lambda_c) bounds
1[15∘,22∘][15^\circ, 22^\circ][350,550][350, 550] THz[0.86,0.54][0.86, 0.54] μ\mum
2[15∘,22∘][15^\circ, 22^\circ][200,400][200, 400] THz[1.50,0.75][1.50, 0.75] μ\mum
3[15∘,22∘][15^\circ, 22^\circ][100,250][100, 250] THz[3.00,1.20][3.00, 1.20] μ\mum

Table 2. Search space bounds for the three-layer optimization.

The simulation environment is governed by a set of global solver parameters listed in Table 3. The incident solar flux is evaluated across a selected spectral domain. The optical properties of the liquid crystal medium and the surrounding environmental index bounds are held constant throughout the optimization process. The guiding optimization performance metric is the magnitude of the transverse radiation pressure force owing to the scattering of the blackbody solar spectrum. To evaluate this, the RCWA algorithm was executed until the optimized parameters (listed in Table 4) were determined, assuming normal incidence upon each layer. Our numerical approach tracks the cascading transformations of the optical field from layer to layer. That is, the spectral irradiance reaching Layer 2 is reduced by the reflectance of Layer 1, and the irradiance reaching Layer 3 is reduced by the combined reflectance of the preceding two layers.

ParameterValue
RCWA Frequency Sweep180 THz − 640 THz
Frequency Resolution500 steps
Retained Harmonics (MM)2 (Total 5 modes: -2, -1, 0, 1, 2)

Table 3. Global frequency and RCWA solver parameters utilized for the simulation.

LayerThickness LLSlant Angle ϕ\phiCutoff Frequency νc\nu_cCutoff Wavelength λc=Λx\lambda_c = \Lambda_x
11.5 μm\mu\mathrm{m}17.0°435 THz0.69 μm\mu\mathrm{m}
22.0 μm\mu\mathrm{m}17.5°305 THz0.98 μm\mu\mathrm{m}
32.0 μm\mu\mathrm{m}17.5°206.5 THz1.45 μm\mu\mathrm{m}

Table 4. Optimized primary design parameters for the three-layer Bragg stack.

Results

A Differential Evolution (DE) optimization algorithm was employed to simultaneously tune the slant angle ϕ\phi and cutoff frequency νc\nu_c for each layer.

The finalized primary design parameters are summarized in Table 4. Associated parameters for each layer include the transverse period Λx=c/νc=λc\Lambda_x = c/\nu_c = \lambda_c, Bragg period ΛB=Λxsin⁡ϕ\Lambda_B = \Lambda_x \sin\phi, longitudinal period Λz=ΛB/cos⁡ϕ\Lambda_z = \Lambda_B/\cos\phi, and Bragg design wavelength λb=2ΛBneffcos⁡ϕ\lambda_b = 2\Lambda_B n_{\mathrm{eff}}\cos\phi. These values are listed in Table 5 along with the selected thickness values. As expected the thickness of each layer is several times greater than the respective longitudinal period. One of the advantages of Bragg gratings using high birefringent cholesteric liquid crystal polymer is the the ability to achieve high efficiency in thin films. Here the total film thickness is 5.5 μm\mu\mathrm{m}, which is remarkably thin for a three-layer diffractive solar sail.

LayerΛx\Lambda_x (μm\mu\mathrm{m})Λz\Lambda_z (μm\mu\mathrm{m})ΛB\Lambda_B (μm\mu\mathrm{m})λb\lambda_b (μm\mu\mathrm{m})νb\nu_b (THz)
10.690.210.2010.60500
20.980.310.2960.87344
31.450.460.4371.29233

Table 5. Related parameters derived from optimized values of ϕ\phi and νc\nu_c.

The reflectance spectra of the individual layers superimposed over the incident solar blackbody curve, shown in Figure 6 for order m=−1m = -1, clearly shows high efficiency scattering across three adjacent frequency bands, resulting in net broadband reflection nearly equal to the full width half maximum blackbody spectrum.

Bragg reflection coefficients for Layers 1, 2, and 3 with the solar blackbody frequency spectrum

Figure 6. Bragg reflection coefficients Rν,−1(RCP)R_{\nu,-1}^{(RCP)} for Layer 1 (blue line), Layer 2 (green line), and Layer 3 (orange line), with the solar blackbody frequency spectrum (black line).

The momentum transfer efficiency components are numerically calculated from the RCWA output, assuming right circularly polarized (RCP) incident light, according to Eqs. 10a and 10b, resulting in ηˉx(RCP)=25.6%\bar{\eta}_{x}^{(\mathrm{RCP})} = 25.6\% and ηˉz(RCP)=99.9%\bar{\eta}_{z}^{(\mathrm{RCP})} = 99.9\%. Although this value of transverse efficiency may be sufficient for station keeping at the Earth-Sun L1 point, as suggested for a specular reflective sail at a 7° tilt in [30], a second layer would be needed to scatter both polarizations away from the Earth for sun shading applications. In the latter case the combined efficiency doubles to ηˉx(RCP)+(LCP)=51.2%\bar{\eta}_{x}^{(RCP)+(LCP)} = 51.2\%. Greater or lesser values of efficiency may be engineered by increasing or decreasing the net Bragg grating bandwidth. What is more, the above design procedure may be readily adapted for a Bragg grating sail/sunshade that transmits to Earth selective spectral bands that are important for photosynthesis (e.g., 600-680 nm or 440-500 THz) and photovoltaic power generation (e.g., 700-900 nm or 330 - 430 THz); for example, by eliminating Layer 2 in the above design depicted in Figure 6.

Further work, which is beyond the scope of this report, will require specific sailcraft mass values and orbital optimization studies. Advantages of sun-facing diffractive sails over canted specular reflection sails includes reduced complexity for attitude and navigation control. A simple roll-control maneuver (without changing the sun-facing attitude) provides navigational authority of a diffractive sail [31].

Finally we note that the radiation pressure force exerted upon our sun-facing Bragg grating sail A=100 m2A = 100\ \mathrm{m}^{2} would provide (for a single polarization state) a transverse force of Fx=IsunAηˉx(RCP)/c=0.012NF_x = I_{\mathrm{sun}} A\bar{\eta}_{x}^{(RCP)}/c = 0.012N and a longitudinal force of Fz=IsunAηˉz(RCP)/c=0.023NF_z = I_{\mathrm{sun}} A\bar{\eta}_{z}^{(RCP)}/c = 0.023N. These values would double for a two-stack film that scatters both polarization states.

Conclusion

We theoretically designed and optimized a sun-facing Bragg grating solar sail comprised of a chiral liquid crystal polymer. Using the Rigorous Coupled-Wave Analysis framework, we designed a three-layer Bragg reflector that scatters nearly 50% of the solar blackbody spectrum, thereby providing a sufficient radiation pressure force for some space missions. The designed grating operates on and primarily scatters into a single state of polarization. We suggest stacking two such Bragg gratings to achieve a useful radiation pressure force for missions such as sunshades at the Earth-Sun L1 point. As with all transportation systems, it is wise to engineer the vehicle for specific tasks. Future work is therefore required to jointly optimize the Bragg grating sail with a specific sailcraft mission in mind.

Acknowledgments

We thank the scientists and engineers at BEAM Engineering for Advanced Measurements Co. (Orlando, FL), particularly Aaron Becker for his assistance with our conversion of his anisotropic RCWA code from MATLAB to Python, and Nelson Tabiryan, Anna Tabiryan, and David Roberts for technical discussions related to fourth generation liquid crystal optics. We also thank Amber Dubill (Johns Hopkins Applied Physics Lab, Baltimore, MD) for technical discussions related to diffractive solar sails. This work was supported by BEAM Co. via DARPA (award number 140D0423C0091/SUB-23682-01) and JHU/APL via NASA (award number 80MSFC22F0165/JHU APL 177864).

References

  1. [1]J. Kepler, Harmonices Mundi, Unknown, 1619.
  2. [2]C. R. McInnes, Solar Sailing: Technology, Dynamics and Mission Applications, Springer, 1999.DOI
  3. [3]G. Vulpett i, L. Johnson, G. L. Matloff, Solar Sails: A Novel Approach to Interplanetary Travel, Springer, 2014.
  4. [4]L. Friedman, Human spaceflight: from Mars to the Stars, University of Arizona Press, 2015.
  5. [5]L. Johnson, N. Barnes, M. Ceriotti, T. Y. Chen, A. Davoyan, L. Fried-man, D. Garber, R. Kezerashvili, K. Kobayashi, G. Matloff, et al., Solar sail propulsion by 2050: An enabling capability for heliophysics missions, arXiv preprint arXiv:2301.01297 (2023).arxiv.org/abs/2301.01297
  6. [6]L. Johnson, Solar photon sails roadmap (2025).
  7. [7]G. A. Swartzlander, Radiation pressure on a diffractive sailcraft, Jour-nal of the Optical Society of America B 34 (6) (2017) C25–C30. doi:10.1364/JOSAB.34.0000C25.DOI
  8. [8]G. A. Swartzlander Jr, Flying on a rainbow: A solar-driven diffractive sailcraft, arXiv preprint arXiv:1805.05864 (2018).arxiv.org/abs/1805.05864
  9. [9]G. A. Swartzlander, Theory of radiation pressure on a diffractive solar sail, Journal of the Optical Society of America B 39 (9) (2022) 2556–2563.DOI
  10. [10]S. Pancharatnam, On the phenomenological theory of light propa-gation in optically active crystals, Proceedings of the Indian Academy of Sciences-Section A 43 (4) (1956) 247–252.DOI
  11. [11]W. S. John, W. Fritz, Z. Lu, D.-K. Yang, Bragg reflection from cholesteric liquid crystals, Physical Review E 51 (2) (1995) 1191.
  12. [12]R. Sutherland, V. Tondiglia, L. Natarajan, J. Wofford, S. Siwecki, G. Cook, D. Evans, P. Lloyd, T. Bunning, Liquid crystal bragg grat-ings: Dynamic optical elements for spatial light modulators, in: Emerg-ing Liquid Crystal Technologies II, Vol. 6487, SPIE, 2007, pp. 189–202.
  13. [13]R. Crum, G. A. Swartzlander, Metallic coated diffraction grating for solar sailing, in: International Optical Design Conference, Vol. 12798, 2023, pp. 209–210.DOI
  14. [14]R. M. Crum, P. R. Srivastava, Q. X. Wang, T. R. M. Sales, G. A. Swartzlander, Hybrid reflection/transmission diffraction grating solar sail, Photonics 12 (10) (2024) 972.
  15. [15]D. E. Roberts, N. V. Tabiryan, Ultralight planar diffractive optics for solar radiation control and space applications, Advanced Optical Mate-rials (2023).
  16. [16]N. V. Tabiryan, D. Roberts, G. A. Swartzlander, E. Serabyn, J. Slagle, M. McConney, T. J. Bunning, Ultralight planar optics and photonics systems for space applications, in: Emerging Liquid Crystal Technologies XX, Vol. 13387 of Proc. SPIE, 2025, p. 133870B.DOI
  17. [17]F. Gori, Measuring stokes parameters by means of a polarization grating, Optics Letters 24 (9) (1999) 584–586.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/18073790
  18. [18]H. Lajunen, J. Tervo, J. Turunen, High-efficiency broadband diffractive elements based on polarization gratings, Optics Letters 29 (8) (2004) 803–805.pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/15119383
  19. [19]C. Oh, M. J. Escuti, Achromatic diffraction from polarization gratings with high efficiency, Optics Letters 33 (20) (2008) 2287–2289.
  20. [20]N. V. Tabiryan, S. Serak, X. Dai, T. J. Bunning, Liquid crystal polarization gratings, Optics Express 13 (19) (2005) 7442–7447.
  21. [21]D. E. Roberts, N. V. Tabiryan, Advanced liquid crystal diffractive optical elements, Optical Materials Express (2019).
  22. [22]Y. Weng, D. Xu, Y. Zhang, X. Li, S.-T. Wu, Polarization volume grating with high efficiency and large diffraction angle, Optics Express 24 (16) (2016) 17746–17750.DOI
  23. [23]D. Roberts, S. Kaim, N. V. Tabiryan, M. McConney, T. J. Bunning, Polarization-independent diffractive waveplate optics, in: IEEE Conference Proceedings, 2018, pp. 1–11.DOI
  24. [24]X. Xiang, J. Kim, M. J. Escuti, Bragg polarization gratings for wide angular bandwidth and high efficiency at steep deflection angles, Scientific Reports 8 (2018) 7202. doi:10.1038/s41598-018-25535-0.DOI
  25. [25]M. G. Moharam, T. K. Gaylord, Rigorous coupled-wave analysis of planar-grating diffraction, Journal of the Optical Society of America 71 (7) (1981) 811–818.DOI
  26. [26]J. Xiong, S.-T. Wu, Rigorous coupled-wave analysis of liquid crystal polarization gratings, Optics Express 28 (24) (2020) 35960–35970.DOI
  27. [27]P. Yeh, Electromagnetic propagation in birefringent layered media, Journal of the Optical Society of America 69 (5) (1979) 742–756.DOI
  28. [28]K. Rokushima, J. Yamakita, Analysis of anisotropic dielectric gratings, Journal of the Optical Society of America 73 (7) (1983) 901–908.DOI
  29. [29]S. Gauza, C. Wen, S. Wu, R. Dabrowski, C.-S. Hsu, C. Catanescu, L. Chien, High birefringence liquid crystals for photonic applications, in: Liquid Crystals: Optics and Applications, Vol. 5947, SPIE, 2005, pp. 51–64.DOI
  30. [30]M. Coco, C. L. Matonti, C. Cappelletti, B. Chesley, C. Fuglesang, G. Governale, N. Pushparaj, M. Romano, G. Tibert, L. Wilk, Planetary sunshade for solar geoengineering: Preliminary design of a precursor system and mission, Acta Astronautica 235 (2025) 452–462.
  31. [31]A. Dubill, Attitude control for circumnavigating the sun with diffractive solar sails, Rochester Institute of Technology, 2020.

Paper details

vlnc:W_atajhqj5
Version
v1 · latest
Published
Fresh — added to the Hub within the last 30 days
Added
License
CC BY 4.0
Usage

views · 0

downloads · 0

A view counts once per browser per day, a download each time the PDF is requested.

  • Physics and Astronomy

Not recorded for this paper

View statement
Looking for related papers…
Contents